Latest / Grief and Light™ / Grief Dreams and Continuing Bonds: How Dreams Connect Us to Loved Ones Who Have Died | Dr. Joshua Black
Transcript
- 0:00Dr. Joshua Black: She was in this space.
- 0:00Dr. Joshua Black: She's like, Oh, the space is so amazing.
- 0:02Dr. Joshua Black: I feel so so much love here.
- 0:04Dr. Joshua Black: And the deceased says, Yeah, because the space is love.
- 0:09Dr. Joshua Black: And then she says, But how can I feel this love if I don't love myself?
- 0:15Dr. Joshua Black: And then he says, In this space you do love yourself.
- 0:20Dr. Joshua Black: And then she woke up.
- 0:22Nina Rodriguez: You just lost your loved one.
- 0:23Nina Rodriguez: Now what?
- 0:24Nina Rodriguez: Welcome to the Grief and Life podcast, where we explore this new reality through grief-colored lenses.
- 0:30Nina Rodriguez: Openly, authentically.
- 0:32Nina Rodriguez: I'm your host, Nina Rodriguez.
- 0:35Nina Rodriguez: Let's get started.
- 0:37Nina Rodriguez: Have you ever dreamt of your person in spirit and wondered if that encounter was in any way real?
- 0:43Nina Rodriguez: Today's guest is a renowned grief and bereavement researcher, speaker, and host of the Grief Dreams Podcast.
- 0:50Nina Rodriguez: With a PhD focused on dreams and continuing bonds after loss, including prenatal and pet loss, Dr.
- 0:56Nina Rodriguez: Joshua Black is one of the leading academic experts in the field of grief dreams.
- 1:00Nina Rodriguez: These dreams offer profound insights into the grieving process and continuing connections beyond death.
- 1:08Nina Rodriguez: Currently, Dr.
- 1:09Nina Rodriguez: Black serves as a bereavement initiative manager for the BC Center of Palliative Care, where he leads groundbreaking research in bereavement support.
- 1:18Nina Rodriguez: He is dedicated to raising awareness and providing essential grief support through his extensive work.
- 1:23Nina Rodriguez: And with that, I would like to give a warm welcome to Dr.
- 1:26Nina Rodriguez: Joshua Black.
- 1:27Nina Rodriguez: Welcome to the Brief and Life Podcast.
- 1:30Dr. Joshua Black: Well, thank you for having me.
- 1:31Nina Rodriguez: I'm so excited about this conversation.
- 1:33Nina Rodriguez: It's one of my favorite topics.
- 1:35Nina Rodriguez: And I actually learned about your work through Kathy Wagner.
- 1:39Nina Rodriguez: I was interviewing her.
- 1:40Nina Rodriguez: She's the author of Here With You, and she shared a dream that she had with her son.
- 1:43Nina Rodriguez: You recorded a beautiful episode with her.
- 1:45Nina Rodriguez: I found your podcast and I could not stop listening to the episodes.
- 1:49Nina Rodriguez: They are so fascinating.
- 1:51Nina Rodriguez: So thank you for your work.
- 1:52Nina Rodriguez: Tell us how you even got started in this space.
- 1:55Nina Rodriguez: How do you become a grief dream researcher?
- 2:00Dr. Joshua Black: Good question.
- 2:00Dr. Joshua Black: I think you know, it's really like the lived experience, usually, right, for most people that really drives their their path in life.
- 2:08Dr. Joshua Black: And for me, I didn't set out to do this.
- 2:11Dr. Joshua Black: It wasn't something that was ever on my mind or someone told me this would be a good path.
- 2:15Nina Rodriguez: It wasn't in your painball cards.
- 2:16Nina Rodriguez: Yeah.
- 2:17Dr. Joshua Black: No, it wasn't there.
- 2:18Dr. Joshua Black: I wanted to be an elementary school teacher, and that was sort of my passion for a long time.
- 2:22Dr. Joshua Black: And you know, my parents kind of pushed me that way too.
- 2:25Dr. Joshua Black: And so that was kind of my path.
- 2:26Dr. Joshua Black: And then when I was in undergrad, my dad suddenly died.
- 2:31Dr. Joshua Black: And in that moment, I felt, you know, the deep grief for the first time.
- 2:36Dr. Joshua Black: Uh when it c after like a um someone you care about dies.
- 2:39Dr. Joshua Black: And it kind of transformed my journey in in so many ways.
- 2:43Dr. Joshua Black: And when it comes to the grief dreams aspect, it was such a powerful part of why I'm here today and how I got, I guess, integrated the loss in my life.
- 2:53Dr. Joshua Black: Because the first moments of hearing the news and then going to the funeral, I was a wreck.
- 3:00Dr. Joshua Black: And you know, you'd expect someone to be.
- 3:02Dr. Joshua Black: But for me, I've never really cried like that before.
- 3:05Dr. Joshua Black: It was kind of scary.
- 3:07Dr. Joshua Black: I didn't have the support around me.
- 3:09Dr. Joshua Black: I didn't know what to do.
- 3:10Dr. Joshua Black: I need I needed to go back to school to finish the degree.
- 3:13Dr. Joshua Black: And I need to go back to work.
- 3:15Dr. Joshua Black: And so I just really wanted to get rid of it, to push it away and push it down.
- 3:20Dr. Joshua Black: And I was able to do that, which is kind of amazing that you can.
- 3:24Dr. Joshua Black: But what happened was my whole the color came out of my world.
- 3:28Dr. Joshua Black: And so I was almost like a zombie, just like doing what you need to do.
- 3:32Dr. Joshua Black: You look good, but inside you're you're dead, right?
- 3:34Dr. Joshua Black: Like there's nothing really going on in there.
- 3:36Dr. Joshua Black: And it's like you're just, you know, this black and gray world.
- 3:39Dr. Joshua Black: And it was only three months later that I had this dream of my father kind of changed everything and put the color back into my life.
- 3:45Dr. Joshua Black: And it was a very simple dream, but one of the most profound experiences I've ever had waking or dreaming.
- 3:51Dr. Joshua Black: Just like just in general.
- 3:53Dr. Joshua Black: And so I was sitting in the dream.
- 3:54Dr. Joshua Black: I was sitting on my bed and I look to the left and I see my dad in my room, and he was looking through some of my stuff.
- 4:01Dr. Joshua Black: And then I I get up and I walk to him, and I noticed that he's just there's just a feeling of lightness, and he had a lot of addiction issues in life, a lot of trauma.
- 4:11Dr. Joshua Black: And so he always had this heaviness to him.
- 4:14Dr. Joshua Black: But in the dream, it wasn't if he felt like this lightness to him for the first time I've ever felt that from him, which I thought was very unique.
- 4:22Dr. Joshua Black: So I walked up to him and I said, I'm going to miss you, acknowledging the loss.
- 4:25Dr. Joshua Black: And then I said that I loved him and we hugged, and I woke up.
- 4:30Dr. Joshua Black: And when I woke up, I said like something changed in me because I woke up completely different.
- 4:35Dr. Joshua Black: The grief has wasn't as it once was.
- 4:39Dr. Joshua Black: I could honor him, I could regulate my emotions again, I could feel joy.
- 4:42Dr. Joshua Black: And I remember sitting at the edge of my bed and just thinking, what was that?
- 4:46Dr. Joshua Black: Because I didn't even interpret the dream yet, but I could feel the change within me.
- 4:50Dr. Joshua Black: And so the dream itself changed me from within.
- 4:53Dr. Joshua Black: And I'm just trying to figure out what's going on.
- 4:55Dr. Joshua Black: And so I always sort of held that uh such a beautiful and special experience for me on my journey.
- 5:01Dr. Joshua Black: And I never really thought too much of it.
- 5:03Dr. Joshua Black: Like I knew it changed me.
- 5:04Dr. Joshua Black: I didn't really tell many people about it.
- 5:06Dr. Joshua Black: I didn't ask dreams about other people.
- 5:08Dr. Joshua Black: But just just as my journey went forward, I got into uh had an interview to go to teachers college and just didn't feel right.
- 5:15Dr. Joshua Black: And so I I denied that and I didn't know what it was gonna do, but I knew that wasn't the path anymore.
- 5:20Dr. Joshua Black: And then so I decided to volunteer at a hospice and basically do some briefing groups and one-on-ones with people, and they kept having these questions on dreams, and like I never told them about mine.
- 5:31Dr. Joshua Black: It just like you know, life has a funny way of organically like giving you direction and insights, and so they were asking these questions.
- 5:38Dr. Joshua Black: And for me, I only had these positive ones, but they were asking why I haven't I had a dream, they're asking why am I having these negative dreams?
- 5:44Dr. Joshua Black: What does this dream mean?
- 5:45Dr. Joshua Black: You know, all this sort of stuff.
- 5:46Dr. Joshua Black: And you tell like the questions that they were asking, they were then also complicating their own grief with their own answers on what it could be.
- 5:53Dr. Joshua Black: And so I was like, Oh, like I wonder what the literature says.
- 5:55Dr. Joshua Black: And so when I went back to literature, this really wasn't anything for them to really provide them understanding and comfort.
- 6:01Dr. Joshua Black: And so that's sort of when I said, Now I wonder, I wonder if this is my path.
- 6:05Dr. Joshua Black: I wonder if I could do a master's or even a PhD on this topic.
- 6:09Dr. Joshua Black: And so it was a real challenge, it took a lot of courage because I wasn't trying to be a researcher.
- 6:13Dr. Joshua Black: I never, you know, like everyone like you know has a plan, and some people just love that.
- 6:16Dr. Joshua Black: And for me, it wasn't a it wasn't the plan.
- 6:18Dr. Joshua Black: So I really had to like you know, redevelop my identity and also persevere some great struggles because I was starting in a deficit, I would say, when it comes to a lot of the research methodology, statistics, that sort of stuff.
- 6:30Dr. Joshua Black: Um, I had the grades for it, but just you know, once you do a course, you kind of forget about it if that's not your passion.
- 6:36Dr. Joshua Black: And so um, it took a lot of a lot of work, but you know, here I am.
- 6:40Dr. Joshua Black: I was able to find someone to be able to do my master's with at first, which was amazing.
- 6:45Dr. Joshua Black: And I found someone too that was able to do my PhD with, and I think it was just phenomenal because without them, I wouldn't be doing this for sure.
- 6:51Dr. Joshua Black: Because you need a supervisor that actually will allow you to do a topic that hasn't been looked at, that they haven't looked at.
- 6:58Dr. Joshua Black: And so, you know, like not many people are willing to do that because usually you have to do what your supervisor is doing in the realm.
- 7:04Dr. Joshua Black: Um, so both were interested in dreams, both supervisors, um, but just they had their own experience with these dreams that got them interested in what I was talking about and what I wanted to research.
- 7:16Dr. Joshua Black: It was a beautiful path that kind of opened up a lot of different doors, and I've just been raising awareness ever since.
- 7:22Nina Rodriguez: Well, thank you for answering the call to walk on that path.
- 7:25Nina Rodriguez: Because to my knowledge, are there more dream researchers that you're aware of?
- 7:29Nina Rodriguez: Or are you the only one in this space?
- 7:31Dr. Joshua Black: So there are dream researchers in general, right?
- 7:33Dr. Joshua Black: Um, not many in uh I think there's maybe one or two in Canada.
- 7:36Dr. Joshua Black: But when it comes to this topic, there's very few.
- 7:38Dr. Joshua Black: A lot of people, what they do is they're majoring in a certain other field and they'll touch on the topic and then they go back to the field.
- 7:45Dr. Joshua Black: They have some interest in it, but they'll just do a one-off.
- 7:47Dr. Joshua Black: And so no one's actually pursuing and trying to figure out more and more of this stuff.
- 7:51Dr. Joshua Black: And so there were some small studies here and there.
- 7:54Dr. Joshua Black: Um, now I'm seeing some more studies uh coming out, which is nice.
- 7:57Dr. Joshua Black: I would I would feel I have the most publications uh within this area.
- 8:01Dr. Joshua Black: Um, but that's just because the interest I have, and I have a great passion and love for trying to figure this out because it comes from a personal note, but also I'm really trying to help the bereaved.
- 8:10Dr. Joshua Black: I think that's where a lot of my questions lie in.
- 8:12Dr. Joshua Black: It's like, how can I help the bereaved understand the topic to be able to provide a little more guidance on their brief journey rather than oh, I'm a researcher, this is interesting, I'm gonna touch on this and then I'm gonna move on, or I'm gonna do something else because I'm interested in it.
- 8:23Dr. Joshua Black: I'm really trying to do research that actually will help individuals in waking life.
- 8:29Nina Rodriguez: And thank you for that.
- 8:30Nina Rodriguez: And going back a little bit, I'm sorry for the loss of your father.
- 8:33Nina Rodriguez: And I really like how you use that analogy of the color was sucked out of my life.
- 8:38Nina Rodriguez: Like everything was black and white, yeah, just very gray.
- 8:41Nina Rodriguez: And after the dream, there was some color that came back into your life.
- 8:45Nina Rodriguez: As you know, I've experienced dreams of my own.
- 8:47Nina Rodriguez: And for the listeners and everybody watching, I will be doing a separate interview with uh Dr.
- 8:52Nina Rodriguez: Black on his podcast.
- 8:54Nina Rodriguez: So stay tuned.
- 8:55Nina Rodriguez: Better yet, go to his podcast, subscribe, subscribe to this one as well, and uh stay tuned for the stories because they're amazing.
- 9:01Nina Rodriguez: But it does bring an element of connection, at least it did for me, when it happened, because to have a dream where you get to see them again, there is no other way to see your person again other than in this space.
- 9:14Nina Rodriguez: It is magical.
- 9:15Nina Rodriguez: It can be magical.
- 9:16Nina Rodriguez: It could also be, you know, traumatizing in some cases, depending on the on the nuance of it, which we'll talk about later.
- 9:22Nina Rodriguez: But um, but thank you for answering the call.
- 9:25Nina Rodriguez: Thank you for your research.
- 9:26Nina Rodriguez: Before we get into the nitty-gritty, let's talk broadly.
- 9:29Nina Rodriguez: What is a grief dream?
- 9:31Nina Rodriguez: How do you define that?
- 9:33Dr. Joshua Black: You know, we it's probably better to classify it as like a bereavement dream, but most people didn't know how to what bereavement meant or how to spell it, so we went to grief dream.
- 9:43Dr. Joshua Black: Um, and so it's just basically these dreams that we can have after someone that we care about dies.
- 9:49Dr. Joshua Black: And so there's three different forms that this can take.
- 9:51Dr. Joshua Black: So one can be that the dream reflects the waking life struggles that we're going through.
- 9:57Dr. Joshua Black: And so the deceased isn't in the dream or they're not mentioned.
- 10:00Dr. Joshua Black: So this could be like running by a mountain, the mountain collapses on you, and it just represents the heaviness of waking life and the grief on you.
- 10:07Dr. Joshua Black: Then you have the second form, which is someone mentions the deceased within the imagery.
- 10:13Dr. Joshua Black: It's not that the deceased isn't part of it, um, but or there's reference to the deceased in some way.
- 10:18Dr. Joshua Black: So this could be you're visiting the hospital where they died at, it could be um an angel uh talking to you about the deceased, it could be another character talking to you about the deceased and your loss or your grief.
- 10:28Dr. Joshua Black: And so you can tell it definitely represents the grief in general and what you're going through.
- 10:32Dr. Joshua Black: And then the last one is what most people want to talk about, and that's where most of my research is focused on is the dreams I actually have the deceased present within the imagery.
- 10:40Dr. Joshua Black: And that is where you can have these very beautiful, profound experiences, but also you can have said, like some really terrifying nightmares that really keep people from progressing within their grief journey because it just re-traumatizes them and keeps them uh really being afraid to go to go to sleep for the most part.
- 10:58Dr. Joshua Black: And then sleep deprivation really hinders the grief journey, as you know.
- 11:02Nina Rodriguez: So thank you for making those distinctions because in my initial understanding, the grief dream was really just dreaming about your person.
- 11:08Nina Rodriguez: In most contexts, I've heard of it's usually a positive thing.
- 11:11Nina Rodriguez: So I've haven't heard anybody say, or very few people say, like, oh, it was a negative experience.
- 11:16Nina Rodriguez: Most people generally say it's it's been a good thing.
- 11:18Nina Rodriguez: Deep dive into some of the research.
- 11:20Nina Rodriguez: What have you found?
- 11:22Dr. Joshua Black: Well, the first that we were looking at was you know, is it even common?
- 11:26Dr. Joshua Black: We didn't really even know.
- 11:27Dr. Joshua Black: I had mine, like supervisor had theirs, and like, but like how common actually is it to have a dream of the deceased?
- 11:34Dr. Joshua Black: And so when we looked at that, we looked at different samples.
- 11:36Dr. Joshua Black: So after spells of loss, it was 86% of the individuals had a dream of the deceased within the first year or two.
- 11:44Dr. Joshua Black: Uh after pet loss, it was 78%, and that was within the first six months.
- 11:47Dr. Joshua Black: And then after miscarriage, this is fascinating.
- 11:50Dr. Joshua Black: 57% had a dream of the deceased baby that they never actually met, which I thought was really fascinating.
- 11:56Dr. Joshua Black: That was within the first year.
- 11:58Dr. Joshua Black: And so there has also been another study, not by me, by someone else, but children can also have these experiences.
- 12:03Dr. Joshua Black: And 55% of children within this uh bereavement camp stated they had a dream of the deceased.
- 12:09Dr. Joshua Black: So it's just understanding that that's a significant amount of people that you're gonna run into that are grieving that will have one of these experiences.
- 12:16Dr. Joshua Black: And one would think that as you become further away from the initial death of the individual, you'll have a more likely a chance of dreaming of the deceased as time goes on.
- 12:25Dr. Joshua Black: You know, it's not all the time you get it right away.
- 12:27Dr. Joshua Black: Like mine took three months to have my first one.
- 12:29Dr. Joshua Black: I know people it took a year or two before they had their first one.
- 12:31Dr. Joshua Black: And we're still trying to figure out exactly why is that, like, why are some people having it very soon, other people aren't.
- 12:37Dr. Joshua Black: You know, there's different factors that may go into that, but it's still you know, still very unknown in like the timing of things.
- 12:43Dr. Joshua Black: But the timing seems to be very significant on when these dreams can happen for people.
- 12:48Dr. Joshua Black: And as you said, one of the interesting aspects of these dreams is that we went in, like me and my supervisor, she was a trauma researcher, which is really helpful to me in this area.
- 12:59Dr. Joshua Black: I had a positive dream, she had a negative dream.
- 13:02Dr. Joshua Black: And so we went in thinking that people probably had more negative dreams of the deceased, because Western research basically says that dreams reflect our waking life.
- 13:11Dr. Joshua Black: So, and that's probably like the continuing hypothesis.
- 13:14Dr. Joshua Black: So if you're let's say sad before bed, or you're angry, or you're like frustrated, or you have anxiety, you're gonna have more negative dreams.
- 13:22Dr. Joshua Black: But if you're happy and joyful, you're gonna have more positive dreams, given we're in grief.
- 13:27Dr. Joshua Black: And just typically in general, like we would expect to have more negative dreams.
- 13:32Dr. Joshua Black: And just in the research in general, uh, people typically have more negative dreams, even without grief or whatever, just because life is so hard and we have a lot of anxieties before bed.
- 13:41Dr. Joshua Black: Then after trauma, your dreams become even more consistently negative.
- 13:45Dr. Joshua Black: And so we were expecting something like that when we went in.
- 13:48Dr. Joshua Black: But what we found was actually very shocking, um, is that basically when the deceased is a part of the imagery, those tend to be more positive images and more comforting images, uh, which it goes against typical dream research.
- 14:02Dr. Joshua Black: So there's something else going on within within this.
- 14:05Dr. Joshua Black: So it goes against typical research, which is why I think people can really have these fascinating interpretations of these dreams and it can change them in such a different way.
- 14:14Dr. Joshua Black: Like something else is going on than what we would typically understand from these dreams.
- 14:18Dr. Joshua Black: So some people will say they're visitations, and some people will say maybe it wasn't, but the dream was more vivid and real than they ever had.
- 14:24Dr. Joshua Black: So it's acting differently than what we would expect.
- 14:27Dr. Joshua Black: So in the research, when we asked that all the like the different samples, even after pet loss, as well as the loss, what's fascinating is around 92% of those who dreamt stated that they had a positive dream of the deceased.
- 14:37Dr. Joshua Black: And that could be seeing them healthy or happy, also acting or speaking in a way that's comforting.
- 14:42Dr. Joshua Black: And then when we asked them about negative themes that they had, which is the individual, the deceased dying again, or being dead in the imagery, or acting in ways that was causing them to be upsetting, like chasing them or something, or causing them to have guilt.
- 14:55Dr. Joshua Black: Um, 44%.
- 14:56Dr. Joshua Black: So there's still a big chunk of people who are having these negative dreams.
- 14:59Dr. Joshua Black: But what was interesting is most people who had the negative dreams around 95% also had a positive dream.
- 15:04Dr. Joshua Black: And there seems to be this push for people to dream of the deceased in a positive way.
- 15:10Dr. Joshua Black: And so, which is really fascinating to me.
- 15:12Dr. Joshua Black: So, if you are having negative dreams, what it tells me is you're not gonna always have negative dreams.
- 15:17Dr. Joshua Black: So the question is like, what does that reflect?
- 15:18Dr. Joshua Black: Some people will interpret it as a haunting, right?
- 15:22Dr. Joshua Black: Some people who think of these dreams as visitations will also take the negative dreams as visitations, and you know, based on your culture, whatever, like people can have different rules and understandings on these, but based on Western science, we would expect you to have negative dreams.
- 15:34Dr. Joshua Black: So this may be more to do with your grief, your trauma, a lot of your guilt to regret.
- 15:39Dr. Joshua Black: And that's something that we looked into.
- 15:40Dr. Joshua Black: Like, why are some people having these positive dreams versus negative dreams?
- 15:43Dr. Joshua Black: And you know, as we sort of found, like guilt to regret and trauma were some of the predictors of that.
- 15:48Dr. Joshua Black: Once you work through some of those things, you're more likely for going to have these positive experiences with the deceased.
- 15:54Dr. Joshua Black: And so it's very fascinating to sort of see that and to really understand that for whatever reason, there is this push for us to have these positive experiences, and they don't stop after one is, let's say, done with the acute phases of grief.
- 16:06Dr. Joshua Black: When you've integrated your grief and your loss and you're moving forward and it's not as heavy.
- 16:10Dr. Joshua Black: What's fascinating is the dreams don't stop.
- 16:12Dr. Joshua Black: They may become less common, but a lot of times when you have these significant issues in your life, they can come back again to provide comfort.
- 16:20Dr. Joshua Black: So in the pandemic, we saw a lot of different people um just hanging out with the deceased or getting advice from the deceased.
- 16:25Dr. Joshua Black: Other people through divorce will have these dreams or a breakup where the deceased has come to comfort them in times of anxiety or job loss.
- 16:33Dr. Joshua Black: And then even at the end of life, you'll see these dreams again happen and they'll help with the transition from life to death.
- 16:38Dr. Joshua Black: They provide the comfort to say it's okay to let go or that they're going to be there.
- 16:41Dr. Joshua Black: So it's really fascinating how in the beginning it starts with your grief, but then after that, it really helps you through the rest of your life in very difficult moments.
- 16:49Dr. Joshua Black: And so that's a fascinating part of me.
- 16:51Dr. Joshua Black: I don't know any other dream image that would actually do that.
- 16:54Dr. Joshua Black: And so there is something very unique and kind of mysterious about it, which I kind of love.
- 16:57Dr. Joshua Black: And there's just something beautiful about what can happen during our sleep that can really transform us and change us as we walk in this world.
- 17:06Nina Rodriguez: That is truly, truly fascinating.
- 17:08Nina Rodriguez: We try to make so much meaning out of them.
- 17:10Nina Rodriguez: And, you know, they did this in my dream.
- 17:12Nina Rodriguez: What does that mean?
- 17:12Nina Rodriguez: Are they okay?
- 17:13Nina Rodriguez: Does that mean that they're they haven't made it to heaven?
- 17:15Nina Rodriguez: Or, you know, there's all these questions that pop up.
- 17:18Nina Rodriguez: So thank you for bringing so much context to what they could possibly mean, how they could possibly be interpreted.
- 17:25Nina Rodriguez: Let's say a negative dream doesn't mean that something's bad's happening to them.
- 17:29Nina Rodriguez: There's no data or evidence of that.
- 17:32Nina Rodriguez: It may just be, hey, there is a traumatic element to this and it's showing up in a dream, and or whatever other evolution you see throughout the years.
- 17:40Nina Rodriguez: Like I'm almost five years in, I'm still having those dreams.
- 17:43Nina Rodriguez: But my mom hasn't.
- 17:45Nina Rodriguez: And, you know, they were extremely close.
- 17:47Nina Rodriguez: And she always says, gosh, how do you do it?
- 17:49Nina Rodriguez: And I say, I don't know.
- 17:50Nina Rodriguez: I honestly don't know.
- 17:51Nina Rodriguez: They just happen.
- 17:52Nina Rodriguez: But if I could just give up all my dreams to give them to her, I totally would because I would love for my mom to dream more.
- 17:58Nina Rodriguez: So for somebody who is desperately wanting to dream of their person or try to find a way to prompt these encounters, if you will, or even just have a nice fluffy dream about their person.
- 18:10Nina Rodriguez: Like, how can they do this?
- 18:12Nina Rodriguez: Is there a way to prompt a grief dream, a bereavement dream?
- 18:17Dr. Joshua Black: Good question.
- 18:18Dr. Joshua Black: We've looked into sort of why some people have these dreams of deceased and others don't.
- 18:24Dr. Joshua Black: And what we found was we looked at a lot of different predictors from personality to dream recall to spirituality to a lot of different stuff.
- 18:31Dr. Joshua Black: And what we found was the major predictor in different studies, multiple studies so it got replicated, was dream recall in general.
- 18:38Dr. Joshua Black: And so what it's saying is that the more you remember your dreams, the more likely you're going to remember remember one of these types of dreams with the deceased.
- 18:46Dr. Joshua Black: And so I always question people now when I meet them if they want more dreams or they haven't had a lot of dreams, is just how often do they remember their dreams typically, just in general?
- 18:56Dr. Joshua Black: And what you'll find is they'll say maybe not that often or a little bit, maybe once a week.
- 19:01Dr. Joshua Black: Well, if you only remember one dream a week and you're dreaming throughout the night by seven, eight hours, right?
- 19:06Dr. Joshua Black: Like in REM and non-rem, like the chances of catching that type of dream is seems to be slim.
- 19:11Dr. Joshua Black: And so you can increase your dream recall if that is something you want to do.
- 19:14Dr. Joshua Black: But I always caution people because if you're in grief, yeah, the dreams of the deceased may be positive, more likely positive, but your other dreams without the deceased are probably gonna be really negative because you're still dealing with grief, you know.
- 19:26Dr. Joshua Black: Like, and so you may have to sort of also have the understanding of how to work with those negative dreams that would come from an increase in recall.
- 19:33Dr. Joshua Black: And so, what you can do is just we're really in our Western culture is to value dreams.
- 19:38Dr. Joshua Black: It's something that we're not taught about, we're taught to dismiss them, we're not talked about them in school or anything.
- 19:43Dr. Joshua Black: First time I heard about dreams was actually the first time was in the Bible with Joseph.
- 19:47Dr. Joshua Black: I grew up in a Christian home.
- 19:48Dr. Joshua Black: The second time was uh in my university degree on the sleep course, there was a little section on dreams, and so that's a huge gap, just really understanding it.
- 19:58Dr. Joshua Black: And so, what you can do is just value the dreams, and you're telling your mind that this is something you want to know more about, you want to remember.
- 20:05Dr. Joshua Black: And so, listening to this podcast, talking about your dreams when they happen, reading about dreams, all of that will increase your dreams that you recall.
- 20:13Dr. Joshua Black: So, if you do have a dream, write it down.
- 20:15Dr. Joshua Black: What you're saying is that this is important to me.
- 20:17Dr. Joshua Black: I want to remember it because a lot of dreams happen in a different conscious state, and so by the time we wake up, if we think about something else in the world and we try to go back to it, it's gone because it's it happened in a different uh state of consciousness.
- 20:29Dr. Joshua Black: And so the goal is to write it down, so then you won't forget about it, and then that actually increases your your dream recall rate.
- 20:35Dr. Joshua Black: And I had about, you know, probably one or two dreams a week, and I'm like, oh, I wonder if this would work.
- 20:39Dr. Joshua Black: And so I started doing that, and within a couple months, I was at like three dreams a night because I was writing them all down, but like that's how fast your mind says, Oh, you want to know more?
- 20:50Dr. Joshua Black: Okay, you want to remember more?
- 20:51Dr. Joshua Black: Here you go.
- 20:52Dr. Joshua Black: And so then I was like, I'm getting tired from all waking up from all these dreams, and so I stopped writing them down and only write down the more memorable ones, but then my recall rate had decreased because of it too.
- 21:02Dr. Joshua Black: So you can increase and decrease it based on whatever you want to do.
- 21:06Dr. Joshua Black: And so if you're having a lot of nightmares, it may not be best to write those down or or talk about them with everyone you meet because you're remembering more of them.
- 21:13Dr. Joshua Black: There's other things you can also do when it comes to nightmares that we can talk about to help you reduce the distress from the nightmares.
- 21:18Dr. Joshua Black: Yeah, maybe get some understanding, but just in general, it's understanding that you can change your frequency, and there's gonna be about 10% of the population that doesn't remember dreaming at all.
- 21:27Dr. Joshua Black: So they're not gonna be able to remember any of these dreams.
- 21:30Dr. Joshua Black: And so there are still ways to sort of engage those individuals.
- 21:34Dr. Joshua Black: And I always like to ask at the end of my podcast, but also on my my website, griefdreams.ca, I have a grief dreams worksheet where what you can do is basically create a dream you want to have.
- 21:44Dr. Joshua Black: Like what would be the perfect dream for you uh to have if that was the case, if you could actually manifest something like that.
- 21:52Dr. Joshua Black: And what's interesting about this is that it can provide you a lot of information about what you're longing for, but it also can provide other people around you.
- 21:59Dr. Joshua Black: An opportunity to all talk about the dreams they want to have.
- 22:02Dr. Joshua Black: Because some people are going to have dreams, some people aren't.
- 22:04Dr. Joshua Black: And that's okay.
- 22:05Dr. Joshua Black: We're humans, we're built differently.
- 22:07Dr. Joshua Black: We have you know different reasons and understandings, and you know, the mind is doing different things.
- 22:11Dr. Joshua Black: And so if you're not having a dream, it's okay to ask other people and utilize their dream.
- 22:16Dr. Joshua Black: So if you're l longing for a dream to know that they've quote unquote crossed over or that they're okay or they're watching out for you, if someone else has that dream, well, utilize it and say, Oh, they are okay.
- 22:26Dr. Joshua Black: They're all good.
- 22:27Dr. Joshua Black: Okay, cool.
- 22:27Dr. Joshua Black: That's something you don't have to worry about anymore.
- 22:29Dr. Joshua Black: Yeah, you may want one yourself, but it's okay not to have everything as long as you know that they're safe, right?
- 22:34Dr. Joshua Black: And then hopefully in time you can have that.
- 22:36Dr. Joshua Black: But by talking about even those feelings, it's important because that's part of the grief journey.
- 22:41Dr. Joshua Black: You know, what you're saying is just, I miss them.
- 22:43Dr. Joshua Black: I wish I had another opportunity to see them.
- 22:45Dr. Joshua Black: Yeah, I wish you had that too.
- 22:47Dr. Joshua Black: Um, but that's something that we can't actually manifest.
- 22:51Dr. Joshua Black: We can't actually produce that in people's, you know, sleep yet.
- 22:54Dr. Joshua Black: Maybe one day we can.
- 22:55Dr. Joshua Black: But as of right now, all we can do is honor the process and honor people sharing.
- 22:59Dr. Joshua Black: And at one time or another, you'll probably end up dreaming about them.
- 23:02Dr. Joshua Black: Um, especially if you can remember some of your dreams.
- 23:05Dr. Joshua Black: I remember a person who came on my podcast who never had a dream of her mom.
- 23:09Dr. Joshua Black: Her mom died when she was a child.
- 23:11Dr. Joshua Black: It was, I believe it was an earthquake, and everyone around her was telling her that she was still alive, even though she was dead.
- 23:17Nina Rodriguez: Oh, wow.
- 23:17Dr. Joshua Black: So she went through her life knowing her mother died, but never really wanting it to be true is the best way to put it.
- 23:24Dr. Joshua Black: And so I asked her, you know, did you ever go to the grave site?
- 23:28Dr. Joshua Black: And she's like, no.
- 23:30Dr. Joshua Black: I said, but why not?
- 23:31Dr. Joshua Black: And she's like, Oh, because if I did, it would tell me that it actually happened.
- 23:34Dr. Joshua Black: Like it's it was true.
- 23:35Dr. Joshua Black: I said, Well, maybe that's it.
- 23:36Dr. Joshua Black: Like maybe even if you did dream of decease, you wouldn't want to remember it because it's a reflection that she has died.
- 23:42Dr. Joshua Black: And so maybe when you do go to the grave site, you'll have a dream of your mom soon after.
- 23:47Dr. Joshua Black: And exactly what happened.
- 23:48Dr. Joshua Black: She decided to go visit the grave site.
- 23:49Dr. Joshua Black: And then a couple days later, she had a dream of her mom putting like one of her old necklaces on her, and it was just a beautiful moment.
- 23:56Dr. Joshua Black: And so you sort of see part of it, it could be our readiness um and where we are in a grieving process.
- 24:01Dr. Joshua Black: Some people say they don't want to dream, it'd be too scary, or they have these understandings on what that would make them feel waking up, and they may not be ready for that, and that's okay, you know.
- 24:12Dr. Joshua Black: Um, but it's just like understanding and questioning some of that stuff can be helpful to sort of uh understand where the individual is, like what their dream recall rate, if they even want to dream, um, all that sort of stuff.
- 24:21Dr. Joshua Black: Um, and but at the same time, it's just great to be able to pose a question either way.
- 24:26Dr. Joshua Black: What dream would you want to have tonight if you could?
- 24:28Dr. Joshua Black: And it's amazing the responses that people come up with because it comes from their heart, it comes from their memories or mind.
- 24:33Dr. Joshua Black: And like that's beautiful.
- 24:34Dr. Joshua Black: And I've seen many people do different things with that from paintings and meditations to all sorts of stuff.
- 24:39Dr. Joshua Black: Even if they have a nightmare, they'll remember that dream instead, and that can help, right?
- 24:42Dr. Joshua Black: So there's just different things and tools we can utilize when it comes to this topic.
- 24:46Nina Rodriguez: Thank you for that.
- 24:46Nina Rodriguez: And there's so much to unpack.
- 24:48Nina Rodriguez: I think it's fascinating the fact that the dream recall is malleable in some way for positive dreams and then to slow down the rate of maybe the negative ones.
- 24:57Nina Rodriguez: So for the listeners and anybody watching, take the initiative, just play with it.
- 25:02Nina Rodriguez: Plan what dream you would like to have.
- 25:04Nina Rodriguez: As soon as I wake up in the middle of the night from a dream, I go to the notes section.
- 25:08Nina Rodriguez: It's already open, so I'm still sleepy.
- 25:09Nina Rodriguez: I don't have to fumble on my phone and try to find all these things because what I notice is the more you try to wake up, the quicker the dream vanishes.
- 25:18Nina Rodriguez: What I try to do is stay in like that sleepy state as much as possible.
- 25:21Nina Rodriguez: And sometimes as I'm waking up, it's vanishing very quickly.
- 25:24Nina Rodriguez: So I stop what I'm doing, I close my eyes, try to tune into the feeling of what I dreamt.
- 25:29Nina Rodriguez: And all of a sudden, everything comes flooding back.
- 25:31Nina Rodriguez: Like all the imagery comes flooding back.
- 25:33Nina Rodriguez: That's when I have the best recall.
- 25:34Nina Rodriguez: And then I start typing right away.
- 25:36Nina Rodriguez: And I built a practice out of this just because I didn't want to forget all the dreams.
- 25:40Nina Rodriguez: And I have this log of dreams.
- 25:42Nina Rodriguez: So, for example, my mom, she would like to dream about him more.
- 25:46Nina Rodriguez: She doesn't know how to.
- 25:46Nina Rodriguez: But I tell her every dream and I say, Hey, I had this dream and this happened.
- 25:49Nina Rodriguez: She said, You gave me the answer to the question that I asked yesterday.
- 25:53Nina Rodriguez: It's interesting that you brought up find a way to connect with it, even if it's through somebody else who maybe has the ability to dream more.
- 26:00Nina Rodriguez: So I find this making so much sense to me in my personal life as well.
- 26:03Nina Rodriguez: But if you're listening, I encourage you to play with these ideas, be open-minded, see what happens.
- 26:09Nina Rodriguez: Let's just play with the why not do it for the plot twist.
- 26:12Nina Rodriguez: Now, another topic you touched on was giving meaning.
- 26:16Nina Rodriguez: People have certain beliefs.
- 26:17Nina Rodriguez: It tends to be on the religious or spiritual side.
- 26:20Nina Rodriguez: They have a negative connotation about these dreams.
- 26:22Nina Rodriguez: It's almost like they fear them.
- 26:24Nina Rodriguez: They don't want to have them because that means X, Y, Z about their person.
- 26:28Nina Rodriguez: What advice could you give them to maybe be a little bit more open or interpret them differently?
- 26:34Dr. Joshua Black: I think the first thing is what research can do is just allow you to see it from a different perspective.
- 26:38Dr. Joshua Black: And you're taught in a certain culture and a certain way, and that's fine, right?
- 26:42Dr. Joshua Black: But just understand that there's different ways of seeing the world.
- 26:45Dr. Joshua Black: Research is just another way into the stream.
- 26:48Dr. Joshua Black: And so the positive dreams, those are great for people to have.
- 26:51Dr. Joshua Black: But understanding where the negative dreams may be coming from, I think is very important.
- 26:55Dr. Joshua Black: Well, I grew up in a Christian home and they didn't have any understanding of dreams.
- 26:58Dr. Joshua Black: And so they would just go to the pastor to sort of see whatever's going on with these dreams.
- 27:03Dr. Joshua Black: And so then the pastor would say, Oh, it's the devil is causing you to have these nightmares.
- 27:08Dr. Joshua Black: But now I know I don't think it was the devil, it was just being in an unsafe environment at home.
- 27:13Dr. Joshua Black: I think that was probably it.
- 27:14Dr. Joshua Black: And so I had a lot of like nightmares growing up.
- 27:17Dr. Joshua Black: So when I started doing this work, I realized very similar uh statements when it comes to this topic where there's been people in my some of the speaking gigs I have and just emails and even doing the research where I've had pastors or different other people state that people have told them that these dreams are from the devil, even the very positive ones.
- 27:37Dr. Joshua Black: So they're like the devil's disguise themselves as your deceased person to trick you in a way.
- 27:43Dr. Joshua Black: And I think that's interesting because I and I try to figure that out like what what would cause that?
- 27:47Dr. Joshua Black: And I think it's because they have a belief of where the soul is, and if if the soul is there, it can't be here, right?
- 27:52Dr. Joshua Black: So it's just like there's got to be trickery going on, it must be the devil.
- 27:56Dr. Joshua Black: But what's fascinating is that these people who are making these assumptions about, I guess, the afterlife or even the dreams, haven't actually looked at dreams in general, haven't done their own research in it.
- 28:08Dr. Joshua Black: So they're going off what people have told them in general or their own experiences.
- 28:13Dr. Joshua Black: And so when I do get this sort of question a lot, I think it's okay to say that we don't know.
- 28:19Dr. Joshua Black: And but to sort of jump that these positive dreams are from the devil is actually kind of absurd.
- 28:24Dr. Joshua Black: And I'll just I'll say why, because you know, I don't like like attacking individuals.
- 28:29Dr. Joshua Black: It's just the belief itself is kind of absurd because the research has shown that these dreams can allow people to um believe more in afterlife.
- 28:37Dr. Joshua Black: If it is heaven, believe more in heaven, repair their faith, which all the things that a devil wouldn't want you to do, right?
- 28:42Dr. Joshua Black: They want a devil technically wants you to suffer.
- 28:45Dr. Joshua Black: But what these dreams are doing is providing more love in your life to believe.
- 28:48Dr. Joshua Black: And then a lot of these dreams, I've asked pastors, I said, What about if I dream of Jesus?
- 28:53Dr. Joshua Black: He's dead, you know.
- 28:54Dr. Joshua Black: Like, is that the devil in disguise?
- 28:56Dr. Joshua Black: Like, oh no, that's not.
- 28:57Dr. Joshua Black: I said, Okay, what about Jesus with the deceased?
- 28:59Dr. Joshua Black: Because I've seen a ton of dreams like that.
- 29:01Dr. Joshua Black: And then the question is, well, I don't know.
- 29:03Dr. Joshua Black: Well, I think that's a good point to start.
- 29:05Dr. Joshua Black: If if Jesus can come with the deceased, why can't the deceased come alone?
- 29:08Dr. Joshua Black: Like just like these different things.
- 29:09Dr. Joshua Black: And then I bring up scripture and I say, like, Matthew 12.
- 29:13Dr. Joshua Black: This happened with Jesus uh when he was healing people, and they said, Oh, your healing is from the devil.
- 29:19Dr. Joshua Black: And he's like, Well, that doesn't make any sense.
- 29:20Dr. Joshua Black: Like, why would why would the devil be healing people and like attacking his own kind of thing where it's confusing people to believe more in heaven and more in God?
- 29:30Dr. Joshua Black: Like it doesn't make any sense.
- 29:31Dr. Joshua Black: And so it's the same kind of logic here where it doesn't make sense of who the devil is for it to go this way.
- 29:36Dr. Joshua Black: So then you're at a crossroads.
- 29:38Dr. Joshua Black: Is it a visitation?
- 29:39Dr. Joshua Black: Is that something that one would allow, or is it the mind?
- 29:42Dr. Joshua Black: And I'm in a place that I don't know, it doesn't matter.
- 29:44Dr. Joshua Black: It's more your decision to do, but to try to take something positive and make it negative really complicates people's grief because that's something that either the mind or the visitation is trying to provide comfort to the individual.
- 29:58Dr. Joshua Black: And now you're saying you should be distressed by it, like it's the devil haunting you.
- 30:02Dr. Joshua Black: It's just being understandable what we're saying and how important it is to fact-check some of the stuff just through the research now and through our own understanding.
- 30:09Dr. Joshua Black: Um, so it's very important to do that.
- 30:10Dr. Joshua Black: So there's some Buddhists who can have these very beautiful dreams, and in the beginning they're very powerful and comforting, but after a while they can be very distressing because it's a sign that the soul hasn't reincarnated yet.
- 30:26Dr. Joshua Black: And so for them, there's one paper I read, it was like after two years, some Buddhists believe that's a time frame when souls should be reincarnated.
- 30:33Dr. Joshua Black: And so, if you're continuing to have these dreams, they have these rituals that they do to provide like these merits to try to get them to incarnate faster, kind of thing, which is interesting.
- 30:43Dr. Joshua Black: And so, you know, that is its own story.
- 30:45Dr. Joshua Black: But I've heard other Buddhists will say no, they're enlightened, or no, they can they can incarnate when they when they can.
- 30:50Dr. Joshua Black: And so it's just understanding the rules that people have told us and how that can impact our interpretation.
- 30:56Dr. Joshua Black: And sometimes the rules need to change, you know, and I've seen that many times where these dreams actually help change people's perspectives on their own belief structure, their religion.
- 31:07Dr. Joshua Black: I had atheists now who want to believe, I had people who believe in hell, and then they're um there are persons who should be there because it was a very mean person, was providing forgiveness, was in the afterlife, and they like, well, maybe it isn't as I thought it was.
- 31:21Dr. Joshua Black: I think it's just being flexible with our minds a little bit.
- 31:24Dr. Joshua Black: And with that, it's understanding that when we do talk about these dreams with people in groups or whatever, people are gonna have their own understandings, their own culture is gonna have understandings towards it, and we just have to talk to them and listen and understand like what are the what are their strategies for dealing with these nightmares or if it's a haunting.
- 31:41Dr. Joshua Black: You know, research can help in some circumstances, but if it's a positive dream and then they're concerned about that, well, then let's talk about what that concern means and is.
- 31:49Dr. Joshua Black: And then from there we can sort of see if your culture has any kind of rituals or different things to help moving forward.
- 31:55Dr. Joshua Black: So there was a paper, I think it was Brazil, where uh if you're if you don't get your child baptized at a certain time, they can't go to heaven.
- 32:04Dr. Joshua Black: But what was interesting was these parents were just grieving that because their child wasn't baptized in time.
- 32:10Dr. Joshua Black: And for them in the faith, that's such a horrifying thing.
- 32:13Dr. Joshua Black: But then they had these dreams where the deceased child was telling them they're in heaven, and so all of a sudden that kind of like eliminates that that belief from them, and they're like amazing, and they praise God and whatnot.
- 32:22Dr. Joshua Black: But how those beliefs can change that, and I think it's very important to understand the power of these and alleviating some of the suffering that is caused by different beliefs that you know people have imputed on their the culture or their party or whatever, and to know that it may not be true.
- 32:41Dr. Joshua Black: Like, there's so many different theories of the afterlife, so many different rules and regulations and things that we should follow or understand.
- 32:47Dr. Joshua Black: We don't know, right?
- 32:48Dr. Joshua Black: Like at the end of the day, these are our best guesses based on a human mind.
- 32:51Dr. Joshua Black: Um but I know a lot of these dreams have really helped provide guidance for a lot of people.
- 32:54Dr. Joshua Black: And I would definitely think that if you actually studied these dreams, you probably get a different kind of understanding of maybe what the afterlife is like based on, you know, cross-culturally looking at these dreams.
- 33:04Dr. Joshua Black: Um, because one of the biggest things is a huge, very powerful love that's really within the imagery that a lot of people say they've never really felt before that stays with them.
- 33:13Dr. Joshua Black: Kind of like what happened with my dad.
- 33:14Dr. Joshua Black: There's just this loving energy that I'm like, wow, like I don't know if I've ever felt that.
- 33:18Dr. Joshua Black: I'm always there's always some type of anxiety when I'm awake, right?
- 33:21Dr. Joshua Black: There's always something going on, a worry or a thing about the future or a thing about the past.
- 33:25Dr. Joshua Black: But like in there, it's like you're in the present, and there's this love, and there's like this being there, and you get to talk to them, even acknowledging that death is real, but you're still there, right?
- 33:33Dr. Joshua Black: And there's still not that deep kind of grief, and it's fascinating.
- 33:36Dr. Joshua Black: And you see that across cultures.
- 33:37Dr. Joshua Black: There's a lot of wisdom within these dreams that we can find.
- 33:41Dr. Joshua Black: Like, I don't know if it's a visitation or not, but I can honor it if someone believes it is.
- 33:46Nina Rodriguez: Thank you.
- 33:46Nina Rodriguez: Thank you for that.
- 33:47Nina Rodriguez: I completely agree that there is an influence with, you know, religious beliefs, personal beliefs, cultural beliefs, etc.
- 33:53Nina Rodriguez: My encouragement would be to approach it from a place of curiosity.
- 33:57Nina Rodriguez: If a dream shows up, instead of judging it right away, acknowledge that it happened and start there.
- 34:02Nina Rodriguez: Try not to give it too much meaning.
- 34:04Nina Rodriguez: I try to divide things into is this helpful for me in my grief journey versus not helpful?
- 34:09Nina Rodriguez: The labels are less important than what we get out of these experiences.
- 34:13Nina Rodriguez: And like you said, with your dream with your dad, it sounded very healing, very beautiful.
- 34:17Nina Rodriguez: He looked healthy.
- 34:18Nina Rodriguez: There was that love energy.
- 34:19Nina Rodriguez: Well, that's so beautiful.
- 34:20Nina Rodriguez: That helps you move forward.
- 34:21Nina Rodriguez: So if that's what you take away from it, then great.
- 34:23Nina Rodriguez: If you want to give a different meaning, that's a whole different experience.
- 34:26Nina Rodriguez: And I just invite anybody to uh relax into the experience and not approach it with so much fear.
- 34:32Nina Rodriguez: Instead, switch that fear into curiosity and just lean into that beautiful experience.
- 34:38Nina Rodriguez: I want to pivot to the conversation about continuing bonds.
- 34:42Nina Rodriguez: It is one of my favorite topics.
- 34:43Nina Rodriguez: I did an episode on this called Death Ends a Life, but not a relationship.
- 34:47Nina Rodriguez: It's something you're well versed in.
- 34:49Nina Rodriguez: So talk to us about the evolution of continuing bonds, how it started, where we are now, and how they relate to dreams.
- 34:57Nina Rodriguez: And I know that's a whole dissertation in and of itself, but like very high level.
- 35:02Dr. Joshua Black: It is.
- 35:02Dr. Joshua Black: And this is a lot to talk about.
- 35:04Dr. Joshua Black: Yeah.
- 35:05Dr. Joshua Black: So in the beginning, I wouldn't say in the beginning, um, because indigenous cultures always sort of talked about continuing bonds in their own way.
- 35:12Dr. Joshua Black: Uh, but Freud was the one to talk about the need to relinquish relationships with the deceased.
- 35:18Dr. Joshua Black: Talked about not doing continuing bonds.
- 35:20Dr. Joshua Black: Like, if we do continuing bonds, he said it actually uh hinders us in our the grieving process.
- 35:25Dr. Joshua Black: Like, don't think about deceased, don't talk about them, let it go, move forward without them.
- 35:30Dr. Joshua Black: It's done.
- 35:31Dr. Joshua Black: But that's not how humans grieve.
- 35:33Dr. Joshua Black: So what he was really saying is like push down your feelings.
- 35:36Dr. Joshua Black: And now some of the issue is because of the research that was going on, there was like mixed results on how doing continuing bonds related to grief.
- 35:45Dr. Joshua Black: Uh, there's a correlation there.
- 35:46Dr. Joshua Black: But it could be doing continuing bonds increases our grief.
- 35:50Dr. Joshua Black: Um, or it could be when we're grieving, we're doing our continuing bonds to sort of help cope.
- 35:55Dr. Joshua Black: And so there's new research, you know, mine included, that really showcases that certain types of continuing bonds can be very beneficial to people um in the grieving process.
- 36:04Dr. Joshua Black: And there's really two different types.
- 36:07Dr. Joshua Black: Well, I guess there's a lot, but you can put them into different two different types.
- 36:11Dr. Joshua Black: And the first is these internalized continuing bonds, it's more within us, it's very comforting.
- 36:16Dr. Joshua Black: Um, we have agency, we're choosing to do these, so it's about going to the gravesite or looking at photos or talking about them.
- 36:23Dr. Joshua Black: Like these are all very like internalized continuing bonds, like we're doing it, right?
- 36:28Dr. Joshua Black: And so research shows that those tend to be more comforting for people and to relate to post-traumatic growth, which is amazing.
- 36:34Dr. Joshua Black: And then you have these externalized continuing bonds.
- 36:38Dr. Joshua Black: This could be these waking life experiences that we can have of the deceased, so we could hear them, we can see them, smell them, things like that, or we feel their touch.
- 36:46Dr. Joshua Black: Um, but also be thinking that the deceased is haunting you is a part of that.
- 36:51Dr. Joshua Black: So these negative types of things that we can also feel.
- 36:54Nina Rodriguez: People would refer to as like a paranormal activity.
- 36:57Dr. Joshua Black: It could be, or it could just be inside.
- 36:58Dr. Joshua Black: Like sometimes we think that you know, the our deceased would be proud of us for who we are.
- 37:02Dr. Joshua Black: Uh, one would say, Oh, deceased is sort of ashamed of us.
- 37:04Dr. Joshua Black: And so there's that negative view of what the deceased is doing.
- 37:06Dr. Joshua Black: That's more like the externalized continuing bonds, and they tend to be more negative in the sense of the stress they're causing people.
- 37:13Dr. Joshua Black: But what's interesting is they're also tied to post-sematic growth, but only when they're comforting.
- 37:17Dr. Joshua Black: What we looked at further was okay, you have these two different types looking at attachment and trauma and grief.
- 37:23Dr. Joshua Black: What are people directed towards?
- 37:25Dr. Joshua Black: Like, what's like what are the predictors for that?
- 37:27Dr. Joshua Black: And what we found in multiple studies was that when it comes to these internalized claiming bonds, the ones that we, you know, you typically do at, you know, yeah, like hospices or any kind of breathing programs.
- 37:39Dr. Joshua Black: This is good for people who are anxiously attached or even secure attached will tend to do those.
- 37:44Dr. Joshua Black: People who are avoidant attached don't tend to do those, right?
- 37:46Dr. Joshua Black: Because someone who has an avoidant attachment, they're not going to process their emotions.
- 37:50Dr. Joshua Black: They don't want to go towards their grief, so they're going to avoid that.
- 37:52Dr. Joshua Black: So they don't really do those internalizing types.
- 37:54Dr. Joshua Black: What happens is they have these externalizing continuing bonds.
- 37:58Dr. Joshua Black: So people who are avoiding their grief, right, having the avoidant attachment style, they're having more of these externalized experiences, which is very fascinating to me.
- 38:06Dr. Joshua Black: And so it could be that because we're not choosing in our own way to go towards the grief and we're trying to avoid it, it could be manifesting in front of us, right?
- 38:16Dr. Joshua Black: These externalizing things to help us to process our own grief.
- 38:20Dr. Joshua Black: So that's one theory when it comes to that.
- 38:21Dr. Joshua Black: Uh, the other thing, when you look at grief and trauma, grief in general tends to be predicted more to go to the internalized continuing bonds.
- 38:29Dr. Joshua Black: But people processing traumatic symptoms tends to be uh focused at the externalized.
- 38:34Dr. Joshua Black: So when we look at these externalized continuing bonds, it's still a red flag, even though some people can't take them as comforting, which is great, uh, provide comfort.
- 38:40Dr. Joshua Black: But a lot of times what people are experiencing those, it could represent trauma, it could represent uh avoidant attachment style.
- 38:46Dr. Joshua Black: And those are sort of some things that we keep in mind.
- 38:48Dr. Joshua Black: But because when we look at grief, continuing bonds may be great for certain people, like these internalizing continuing bonds be great for certain people, but not everyone.
- 38:56Dr. Joshua Black: And it's like understanding that people are gonna have different attachment styles.
- 39:00Dr. Joshua Black: And if we try to force someone with an avoidant attachment style into doing something maybe internalized, like looking at photos or doing this or join this grief group, it may not be the best approach for them.
- 39:10Dr. Joshua Black: Research has shown when you look at you know what works best for maybe avoidant attachment styles is more like under getting them to understand their somatic symptoms, their headaches, their thing, how to breathe, and doing more of that body work with them rather than doing this kind of group talk therapy.
- 39:26Dr. Joshua Black: So starting there.
- 39:27Dr. Joshua Black: So it's very interesting to see how these continuing bonds really are there and who utilizes them within their grieving process.
- 39:34Nina Rodriguez: Well, thank you for that distinction because the way that I've always understood continuing bonds has been like in that positive, more internal processing way.
- 39:42Nina Rodriguez: And I always encourage people to develop that on their own, whatever that looks like to them.
- 39:46Nina Rodriguez: But I'm hearing that that depends.
- 39:48Nina Rodriguez: What is their attachment style?
- 39:50Nina Rodriguez: Is it causing more trauma?
- 39:51Nina Rodriguez: So that's very eye-opening as well.
- 39:53Nina Rodriguez: And if you're listening and you could relate to any of this, maybe you could identify then this is a better way for me to move forward versus this other way.
- 40:00Nina Rodriguez: So very fascinating to hold that distinction, like the dreams and the meaning is unique to each person and their experience, their trauma and their joys and all the things.
- 40:08Nina Rodriguez: Uh, I do want to touch on our love for Ram Das and his teachings.
- 40:12Nina Rodriguez: And and I believe if I heard in one of your episodes you've dreamt about him, talk about who Ram Das was, his work, and anything you want to share about your dream.
- 40:23Dr. Joshua Black: Beautiful question.
- 40:24Dr. Joshua Black: Wow.
- 40:25Dr. Joshua Black: Ram Das is a legend.
- 40:27Dr. Joshua Black: Um, and I would say a guide and a great teacher for me on the path.
- 40:31Dr. Joshua Black: So one of the biggest things for me was I've had certain dreams and certain experiences in life, and what a lot of them have taught me is that I didn't love myself.
- 40:42Dr. Joshua Black: And how do you love yourself in this world where you don't really have these role models who also love themselves?
- 40:47Dr. Joshua Black: And how do you deal with your grief, your trauma?
- 40:50Dr. Joshua Black: How do you walk in a world with confidence?
- 40:52Dr. Joshua Black: And growing up and loving psychology, so my PA was in psychology MA PhD, uh, he was a psychology professor at Harvard who was doing studies within psychedelics, like LSD, and he was getting to a state of love utilizing these chemicals.
- 41:09Dr. Joshua Black: He went on this path and he found a guru who basically explained to him that the drug he was using was just a backdoor into what is possible being human, which is you can have great love within yourself.
- 41:20Dr. Joshua Black: And so his journey was him also trying to love himself in his own way and having a guru to showcase how to get there.
- 41:26Dr. Joshua Black: It's just been a beautiful story of my growth and learning from him from his growth.
- 41:32Dr. Joshua Black: And hopefully, as I move forward, I can also be a model for other people moving forward on the importance of focusing on ourselves and understand that there's so much work that needs to be done within ourselves, but also to be compassionate, you know, within our journey.
- 41:47Dr. Joshua Black: Uh, I know I was very hard on myself in many ways.
- 41:49Dr. Joshua Black: Like, I should be further than I am, or I should, you know, why is it taking so long?
- 41:52Dr. Joshua Black: But then you realize, well, I've done 30 years of getting going down the wrong way.
- 41:56Dr. Joshua Black: It takes gonna take some time to come back and build a new approach and model of myself.
- 42:02Dr. Joshua Black: I gotta say, like that was one of the big things for me that I've I learned from him.
- 42:05Dr. Joshua Black: I had never had him on my podcast, but had two other people, his friends on the podcast, who also had the same kind of guru, theme Crowley Baba.
- 42:13Dr. Joshua Black: Uh, and one of my favorite quotes from him is love is the strongest medicine.
- 42:17Dr. Joshua Black: And it's one of the things I've seen through these dreams across culture, really, on how powerful the love could be within these dreams.
- 42:23Dr. Joshua Black: And it's almost like a lighthouse for people to know what's possible.
- 42:27Dr. Joshua Black: Because I always say if it's happens in their dream and you feel it, well, that feeling is possible in waking life too.
- 42:33Dr. Joshua Black: But a lot of times we've never had that experience, and the question is why?
- 42:37Dr. Joshua Black: And it's because of all that other stuff that's going on within our lives that take over that purity of what's already within.
- 42:43Dr. Joshua Black: With that, I I want to sort of share a dream too, not of Ram Doss, but of someone else to give you an idea of just the power of love.
- 42:50Dr. Joshua Black: I had this individual share a dream with me where she was visiting, I believe it was a cousin who died, and she was in this space.
- 42:57Dr. Joshua Black: She's like, Well, the space is so amazing, I feel so so much love here.
- 43:01Dr. Joshua Black: And the deceased says, Yeah, because the space is love.
- 43:06Dr. Joshua Black: And then she says, But how can I feel this love if I don't love myself?
- 43:12Dr. Joshua Black: And then he says, In this space you do love yourself.
- 43:16Dr. Joshua Black: And then she woke up.
- 43:18Dr. Joshua Black: And it's just like, wait, what?
- 43:20Dr. Joshua Black: What?
- 43:22Dr. Joshua Black: And it's just it's just so there's a beauty in that.
- 43:25Dr. Joshua Black: And there's a beauty in this understanding how much love can heal us, and how even looking back on my dream with my father, yes, I got to say goodbye, which I never get a chance to do.
- 43:33Dr. Joshua Black: Yes, I gotta tell him I love them, which I haven't done in like probably 20 years or something, because just wasn't that type of relationship.
- 43:40Dr. Joshua Black: Um, but I believe there was that love in the dream was the profounding change factor within it all.
- 43:44Dr. Joshua Black: He was in the state of love.
- 43:46Dr. Joshua Black: I was in a sort of environment of love, and it helped move something within me.
- 43:50Dr. Joshua Black: And so with the dream of Ramdas um that I had, there's there's a couple I've had, you know, throughout the years.
- 43:57Dr. Joshua Black: I wonder which one that you heard I shared, but one of Was just being at a um one of his lectures, and he just finished the lecture and every and he was like handing out some stuff, and everyone was like trying to get signatures from him and everything.
- 44:10Dr. Joshua Black: And I walked up and I saw the like the crowd, and I just walked past and I went to a corner, and then I saw in the corner there was this book, and top of the book was a picture of you know Neem Crowley Baba, his guru.
- 44:23Dr. Joshua Black: And I just sat there, began to meditate, and he walked over and we had personal time together.
- 44:27Dr. Joshua Black: It was just fascinating because I did the way and I just followed my heart.
- 44:31Dr. Joshua Black: I got a whole moment with him, which is much different.
- 44:34Dr. Joshua Black: Really allowing myself to try new things and to be curious about life, be curious about myself, and curious about what love is because the reality is I'm still learning every day, and every year I look back, I'm like, wow, like I've gained so much that I didn't know was possible before.
- 44:49Dr. Joshua Black: And I think that's what life is.
- 44:50Dr. Joshua Black: Our concept of love is flawed based on what we've seen and what we heard in our own experiences.
- 44:56Dr. Joshua Black: And I think there's a different type of love that as we move forward, it can manifest in front of us.
- 45:00Dr. Joshua Black: And I think that's a very positive thing, that that's something that we can do.
- 45:03Dr. Joshua Black: Like this is not something someone can give us.
- 45:06Dr. Joshua Black: Like, this is a journey that we have to go on.
- 45:07Dr. Joshua Black: And same thing with dreams.
- 45:09Dr. Joshua Black: People can't really interpret your dreams.
- 45:11Dr. Joshua Black: Like you have your own dream language.
- 45:12Dr. Joshua Black: And so when we look at people's dreams, I always say, like, don't go online, don't go on a dream dictionary.
- 45:18Dr. Joshua Black: Like, it's not going to be helpful.
- 45:19Dr. Joshua Black: You're going to be capturing other people's ideas of what those symbols mean.
- 45:23Dr. Joshua Black: You yourself is a unique person, and you have your most unique features about how you see an image, how you feel, who the person is that died, and how it all relates.
- 45:33Dr. Joshua Black: It's not just about the image, it's about the story and the feelings that go along with the dream.
- 45:37Dr. Joshua Black: And I think as you process that, as you talk more about it, you can find those connections.
- 45:42Dr. Joshua Black: You can try to understand a new language that our culture really hasn't been helpful to understand.
- 45:47Dr. Joshua Black: And so it's going to take time.
- 45:48Dr. Joshua Black: But I always tell people if you start at the emotion and reflect it back to waking life, that can really help, especially with those nightmares and any kind of anxiety dreams, to really sort of see okay, where is this maybe talking about that I may be avoiding or I haven't really been processing?
- 46:02Dr. Joshua Black: And that's a good way to start as you learn about your language and your own symbols.
- 46:08Nina Rodriguez: In this space, you know how to love.
- 46:10Nina Rodriguez: Is that the quote that powerful?
- 46:12Nina Rodriguez: If we could just take that, there is a part of us that is in that space, whatever that space is, that knows how to do this.
- 46:18Nina Rodriguez: Apply that to your life what however it benefits you.
- 46:21Nina Rodriguez: I think that's a beautiful message.
- 46:22Nina Rodriguez: And ultimately, these dreams and being able to connect to this energy, even in the trauma, I think there's a message that could ultimately be for our greater good.
- 46:31Nina Rodriguez: It's a matter of be leaning into the curiosity, use your inner wisdom to interpret what that means.
- 46:38Nina Rodriguez: And sometimes it's as simple as, hey, you might need a little extra support in this area.
- 46:43Nina Rodriguez: And other times it's absolutely magical.
- 46:45Nina Rodriguez: And sometimes we don't even have the words to explain what that beautiful message was.
- 46:49Nina Rodriguez: So just stay in that energy.
- 46:50Nina Rodriguez: I think, you know, from personal experience, there are messages that I really don't have words words for, and I don't think I'm supposed to.
- 46:57Nina Rodriguez: I think it's just an energy I'm supposed to live in for a specific moment in time.
- 47:02Nina Rodriguez: So thank you so much.
- 47:04Nina Rodriguez: We're we're at the end here.
- 47:05Nina Rodriguez: I wanted to give you the opportunity to touch on anything that maybe I didn't ask and where they can reach you.
- 47:11Dr. Joshua Black: Right.
- 47:11Dr. Joshua Black: I think we there's enough there.
- 47:12Dr. Joshua Black: You can also learn some more on the my website, griefdreams.ca.
- 47:16Dr. Joshua Black: There's other questions that I answer on there.
- 47:18Dr. Joshua Black: And also listening to the Grief Dreams podcast.
- 47:20Dr. Joshua Black: We have over uh 230 people that have come on, shared their experience.
- 47:25Dr. Joshua Black: And so, like just hearing those stories can give you an idea to like how vast these dreams are and even how they interpret their their own dreams, which is really nice to sort of hear and be a part of almost like a community that you know you can actually hear about this stuff and a in a way.
- 47:39Dr. Joshua Black: I know some people um don't talk about this stuff and don't want to share it because maybe it could be a very beautiful experience, or they just want other people to judge it and put their own interpretations on it.
- 47:48Dr. Joshua Black: And so this is a nice little way for people to sort of see the vastness and also validate something of their own.
- 47:53Dr. Joshua Black: And so you can also find me on Instagram at Grief Dreams, and there's also a Facebook page.
- 47:58Dr. Joshua Black: So just go on the website and you can find everything there.
- 48:00Nina Rodriguez: And what about your research?
- 48:01Nina Rodriguez: Are you actively researching right now?
- 48:03Nina Rodriguez: Is there something that you want to work on in the near future?
- 48:07Dr. Joshua Black: Yes, of course, of course.
- 48:08Dr. Joshua Black: Haven't stopped.
- 48:09Dr. Joshua Black: Um, so one of the things that we're working on right now is a project at the BC Center for Palight Care for bereavement in the context of homelessness.
- 48:17Dr. Joshua Black: And one of the questions we asked within that huge undertaking of the research was their dreams that they had.
- 48:24Dr. Joshua Black: And so we're gonna be uh be writing a paper up on the dreams that they've shared, you know, with that.
- 48:29Dr. Joshua Black: And then we also do want to look at healthcare providers and their grief and their dreams, you'd say too, of when a client passes.
- 48:36Dr. Joshua Black: So I think it's important as one of those disenfranchised griefs that it doesn't get talked about enough of the grief that they sort of hold, you know, when a client passes or patient and the dreams that they can have afterwards.
- 48:47Dr. Joshua Black: There's a couple, there's two people that came on my podcast that shared about dreams that they had of past clients that were very beautiful.
- 48:52Dr. Joshua Black: And so it's something I I really want to sort of capture for the world to really see.
- 48:57Dr. Joshua Black: And you need research for people to validate it to be true in many ways.
- 49:02Dr. Joshua Black: But I think you know, where where we are in our healthcare system, I think it's important for us to do more research when it comes to the grief that is being experienced by the workers there.
- 49:12Nina Rodriguez: Powerful stuff.
- 49:13Nina Rodriguez: And I am looking forward to that, and I'm very curious to see what the differences are and how it affects each individual.
- 49:20Nina Rodriguez: Wow, very powerful.
- 49:21Nina Rodriguez: I look forward to following that and listening to your episodes.
- 49:24Nina Rodriguez: If you are watching or listening, follow the Grief Dreams podcast.
- 49:29Nina Rodriguez: There's a wealth of information there, so many stories and fascinating data.
- 49:34Nina Rodriguez: So, Dr.
- 49:34Nina Rodriguez: Black, thank you so much for your time.
- 49:36Nina Rodriguez: This has been incredibly interesting and selfishly, I just love this information.
- 49:42Nina Rodriguez: I love all this research.
- 49:43Nina Rodriguez: I love these types of conversations, and I thank you for everything you're doing.
- 49:47Nina Rodriguez: As a final thought, what would Dr.
- 49:49Nina Rodriguez: Black say to young Josh embarking on this research journey?
- 49:55Dr. Joshua Black: Keep moving forward, really.
- 49:56Dr. Joshua Black: It's what it is, and and like continue to love yourself.
- 49:59Dr. Joshua Black: I think the goal, or just tell myself, is understand the truth.
- 50:02Dr. Joshua Black: And the truth is you don't love yourself.
- 50:04Dr. Joshua Black: And if you can focus on that, everything else just comes in into focus and your path kind of like falls in place really quickly.
- 50:10Dr. Joshua Black: Until then, you're running around thinking everything else will sort of suffice that need.
- 50:15Dr. Joshua Black: And once I realize that, it's so interesting on how the path kind of opened up, and even how this topic, which one would assume would be so very distressing, and because it's grief, is probably one of the most profound and loving things that one could actually do their studies on because there's so much love in a lot of these images that you wouldn't think.
- 50:35Dr. Joshua Black: And so it's just interesting.
- 50:36Dr. Joshua Black: It's like whatever you direct your mind to, it kind of manifests in like what you're gonna do and who you're gonna meet.
- 50:41Dr. Joshua Black: And so that's what I would tell my younger self just you know, focus on the truth that you just don't love yourself and learn to love yourself.
- 50:48Nina Rodriguez: Beautifully said.
- 50:49Nina Rodriguez: Thank you so much, Dr.
- 50:50Nina Rodriguez: Black.
- 50:50Nina Rodriguez: It's been an honor.
- 50:52Dr. Joshua Black: All right, thank you for having me.
- 50:53Nina Rodriguez: That's it for today's episode.
- 50:55Nina Rodriguez: Be sure to subscribe to the Grief and Light podcast.
- 50:58Nina Rodriguez: I'd also love to connect with you and hear your thoughts and your stories.
- 51:03Nina Rodriguez: Feel free to share them with me via my Instagram page at Grief and Light, or you can also visit griefandlight.com for more information and updates.
- 51:12Nina Rodriguez: Thank you so much for being here, for being you, and always remember you are not alone.