Latest / Crimes and Consequences / EP185: Killer Couple: Alvin and Judith Neelley
Transcript
- 0:00This episode may contain content of a graphic nature, including descriptions of physical and
- 0:05sexual violence against adults, children, and animals. Listener discretion is advised.
- 0:12Hi everyone, I'm Tanya and I'm Talia and we are Crimes and Consequences,
- 0:18a true crime podcast. Hi Taliah, Hi Tania. How are you doing
- 0:39today? Great? Great, wonderful? Doing really great? Thanks for us.
- 0:43Oh that's good to know you know how I'm fucking doing? Why are
- 0:48we playing this? Really? You're not doing well? I'm doing fine.
- 0:51Yeah, you're doing just fine. I have a new episode this week,
- 0:55and before I get into it, I would just like to ask everyone to
- 0:59hit this of scriber follow button on your favorite app that you're listening to us
- 1:03on, and I'm just going to get into the story. Yeah, knock
- 1:07it out. It was early September of nineteen eighty two in Rome, Georgia,
- 1:11at the Regional Youth Development Center. What's that so? I'm going to
- 1:15refer to this as the RYDC. It's a facility for troubled adolescent girls.
- 1:23The phone rang one night and a staff member named Kenneth Dooley. He was
- 1:26the one that answered the phone. On the other line was a woman who
- 1:30claimed to know his wife. During their conversation, she asked for directions to
- 1:34their personal home not like this home. Not thinking much of it, he
- 1:40gave the information and the call ended shortly thereafter. However, his wife,
- 1:47and they had only been married a few months, claimed she had no idea
- 1:49who this woman was. In the end, they just shrugged it off and
- 1:53they really didn't think about it again. That is until the night of September
- 1:57tenth is though, right very weird. On September tenth, a young woman
- 2:02called asking for Kenneth, but he was out. She called back a little
- 2:07bit later, and this time she got him on the line. She waited
- 2:10patiently for him to come to the phone, and when he picked up the
- 2:14receiver, expecting to hear a woman's voice, he was unpleasantly caught off guard
- 2:17because I'm the other lend was an angry mail voice, and the man told
- 2:23him you're gonna pay Oh, So Kenneth was dumbfounded, like he just couldn't
- 2:28understand what what do you mean. Later that night, four shots were fired
- 2:32into his home, two of which penetrated his study. He managed to see
- 2:38a car speeding way and he called the police and no one was hurt.
- 2:40He wasn't sure exactly what he was reporting. Well, that's fucked up.
- 2:45I know, like what, I've never had any shots fired into my No
- 2:50me either, Oh right. He didn't know if the shots were intended for
- 2:53him or someone in his family, but it definitely worried him. He had
- 2:59a new wife, his two children were in the house with him, so
- 3:01there was obvious cause for concern. Are these children wom a different marriage?
- 3:06Yeah, like troom a different marriage. He ended up staying wide awake that
- 3:08night. I know right, I wouldn't be able to sleep either. He
- 3:14soon though, would find out he wasn't the only one being targeted. The
- 3:19following night, another roy DC staff member it was her turn. A homemade
- 3:25molotov cocktail thrown into the home of Kenneth's co worker, Linda A. Dare.
- 3:32Apparently her husband was reported saying that Linda received several phone calls from a
- 3:37young woman just prior to this incident, but when Linda had gone to the
- 3:42phone to take the call, there was no one on the other end of
- 3:44the line. Right after the fire bomb was tossed, a neighbor boy reported
- 3:47seeing a brown car with cream colored stripes speedaway with a man and a woman
- 3:53with long reddish hair inside. When the flames were extinguished, the police examined
- 3:59the ba, which had been constructed with a simple bottle cloth and gasoline like
- 4:02your typical I guess small to contain. Yeah, I mean, I've made
- 4:08cocktails, but not that one. Right. At first, they thought that
- 4:12Linda's arson inspector husband was the target, but they soon discovered that to be
- 4:16untrue. While the police were still in Linda's home, another phone call came
- 4:21into her home again. It was a young woman who this time told Linda
- 4:26that both her and Kenneth Dooley were going to die that very night. Oh
- 4:30wow, it was obvious both of these assaults on the RYDC staff members were
- 4:35intentional and meant for them specifically. This call, along with another one made
- 4:42later to police, proved that these two attacks were linked. The motive behind
- 4:46it was anger and revenge from a woman who refused to give her name in
- 4:50any other information except for the fact that she was a victim of sexual abuse
- 4:56at the hands of the RYDC. Luckily, her call had been recorded,
- 5:01so she called the police told them listen, I did this because I was
- 5:08a victim of sexual abuse. They recorded these calls so that could be used
- 5:12when they were looking into it. Police promptly had Linda take a listen,
- 5:15and while she said the voice sounded similar to the woman who had called her
- 5:18at home, she wasn't able to identify the voice as belonging to anyone she
- 5:24knew from the RYDC, or anyone else that she knew for that matter.
- 5:29The police searched for clues and interviewed people at the RYDC, trying to figure
- 5:32out who exactly might have been responsible for the incidents, and decided whether the
- 5:39allegations of abuse had any substance. Unfortunately, since no one had been harmed
- 5:43in the attacks, and since there were no clear leads, the case went
- 5:46on the back burner. On Saturday, September twenty fifth, nineteen eighty two.
- 5:51So this is a couple weeks later, two young girls were approached on
- 5:55the western side of Rome, Georgia by a woman who wanted to know their
- 5:59names. It turns out this woman, and spoiler alert, it's the woman
- 6:02that made the original call. HERMO was to pretend she knew one of the
- 6:08girls as she approached them, calling the girl by a wrong name intentionally.
- 6:12This is her way like to get information. Okay, once the little name
- 6:16mistake was set straight through naturally conversing, the girl had managed to learn one
- 6:21of the girl's real name and where she lived. After this, the woman
- 6:25would continue to pressure her about going with her to ride, like get in
- 6:29my car, We're going to take a ride, which really sounded odd,
- 6:31but both of these girls managed to avoid her. However, not all were
- 6:35as lucky. Thirteen year old two escape, Yeah, these two escape.
- 6:40Thirteen year old Lisa Anne Milliken was one of the unlucky ones. Lisa was
- 6:46on and outing with five other girls from the Ethel Harps Home for Neglected Girls
- 6:50in Cedartown. You know that really sounds like a sad place. They were
- 6:56visiting the Riverbend Mall, which is the central shop area in Rome, Georgia.
- 7:00At the time, it had a video game arcade for families and teenagers,
- 7:04so the girls like to go there. Lisa wouldn't have known this,
- 7:09but two years earlier, a woman had been robbed at gunpoint at that same
- 7:14mall on the day before Halloween. Interesting enough, the very woman who had
- 7:18been arrested for the robbery and spent a brief time at a juvenile facility.
- 7:24The RYDC was now luring Lisa away from the mall and her friends toward a
- 7:30brown car. One minute, she was with the other girls being told to
- 7:35meet a certain spot, and by the time they were all back together again,
- 7:39Lisa was gone. Three separate searches were made and then the police were
- 7:43called, but Lisa. They didn't find her. The worried social worker who
- 7:46had accompanied the girls on their mall trips said that Lisa had been wearing jeans
- 7:51and a white and black patterned blouse. Several days went by and there still
- 7:56was no sign of Lisa and no leads either. That is until the same
- 8:01female caller made three anonymous phone calls to the police directing them to Alabama's Little
- 8:07River Canyon, which was about thirty five miles away from where Lisa had disappeared
- 8:15the well. These calls were initially received and recorded, but when they checked
- 8:20out the area that the caller told him to go to, they didn't find
- 8:22anything. Then police and Alabama took the next two calls. A call also
- 8:28came into a roam radio station claiming that the police were covering up a murder
- 8:33done by a female juvenile officer. The caller named Lisa Anne Milliken as a
- 8:39victim, so the police thoroughly searched the area once more, following the concise
- 8:43instructions given. The caller said, you know you're going to find her body.
- 8:48Finally, just as dusk was coming on September twenty ninth, they spotted
- 8:54the still figure of a child draped partially over a tree trunk, a child
- 8:58yeah stone on the canyon floor. A pair of jeans hung from a branch
- 9:03nearby. As they got closer, they could see a bullet hole in the
- 9:09victim's back, showing her death wasn't an accident and instead she was murdered.
- 9:13It appeared as though she'd been thrown down from the eighty foot height onto these
- 9:18rocks. I know. As they carefully brought the body up to the top
- 9:22in a basket, a woman who had known Lisa from one of the juvenile
- 9:26facilities positively identified her as Lisa Anne Milliken. She had finally been found.
- 9:33Lisa's autopsy revealed that she had been subjected to a series of brutal attacks and
- 9:41she's only thirteen. If you remember, she had been raped. She was
- 9:45injected in the neck with something that like boiled the fat under her skin,
- 9:52I know, and the county corner described the like under the skin like her
- 9:58flash or fat was consistency of anchovy paste. What. Crime scene investigators also
- 10:05found three plastic syringes near her body, which were sent for fingerprints and further
- 10:09substance analysis. The crime layoub came back stating that the substance found in the
- 10:15syringes had the basic components of like liquid drain. Now, so she had
- 10:20been injected. Oh, yes, she had been injected several times. The
- 10:26jeans, I know, poor Lisa. The jeans that had been found hanging
- 10:31from the tree had red splatches of blood on them, but they turned out
- 10:35not to be Lisa's pants. It which is really strange, and police thought
- 10:39maybe the pants belonged to the killer. Well, they don't know if they're
- 10:43guy's pants, these guys pants, girls pants? Like, what are these
- 10:46pants? I believe they were probably girls pants? Okay. Detective Sergeant Kenneth
- 10:52Kines was assigned to had the investigation into Lisa's murder. The only thing that
- 10:56they had to go on thus far were the call that had been made.
- 11:01Each one had been recorded, so Detective Kinds started their first investigators listened to
- 11:07each of the calls made to the various places regarding Lisa, and some of
- 11:11the investigators agreed that the same woman. It sounded like she'd made all four,
- 11:16especially when the transcripts were typed out. Once everything was in front of
- 11:20them, they realized the clues were and how she talked, like the phrases
- 11:24and in her accent. She sounded fairly young, and many things she said
- 11:30indicated she was familiar with the juvenile justice system. Investigators checked whether Lisa had
- 11:35any enemies. Who's an enemy of this thirteen year right right? While it
- 11:39turned out that she was not popular, there seemed to be no specific grudges
- 11:45that might make someone wish to kill her. The police figured that Lisa's abductor
- 11:50was probably from the Rome area rather than Alabama, since the first calls had
- 11:54been made there, and they interviewed everyone they could think of, from the
- 11:56girls at the home where she had been face, to farmer neighbors, to
- 12:01her destitute father who had allegedly molested her. He interviewed her mother, who
- 12:07had a boyfriend fresh out of prison. Many people were given light detector tests,
- 12:11and some looked pretty good as suspects, but no one emerged as a
- 12:16viable person to continue to investigate. It seemed at Leasta either had friends that
- 12:20no one had known about, or she had been abducted by a stranger.
- 12:26Even as the police were busy with this crime, another one was taking place
- 12:28on the streets of Rome, with another victim targeted for similar treatment. I
- 12:35know, I'm October third cemetery worker John Hancock, which I think is kind
- 12:39of funny. But John Hancock and his fiance Janice K. Chapman accepted an
- 12:46invitation from a complete stranger to go riding around. What like, wow,
- 12:52Like what do you mean? Yeah, We're just hanging out the cemetery and
- 12:54someone's like, hey, you want to go? They're just on the street
- 12:56somewhere, and a young woman in a car who was a complete strangers to
- 13:00them commit them somehow't have some fun. She lurned them into her car by
- 13:03giving them a pitiful story about how she was lonely and she just wanted some
- 13:07company for a while. So I'd be like what the fuck. I know,
- 13:11I'd be like what, I'm busy, I had got shit to do.
- 13:13I'm not happing in the car with you. But this couple got in
- 13:16and as a Christian. John later said he felt obligated to do what he
- 13:20could for her, so he and Janice got in. During the ride,
- 13:24they talked with the woman who showed them her Cobra CB radio and she got
- 13:30into a conversation with someone on the other end called the night Rider stop.
- 13:33I know. The The woman went by Lady's sondown and she acted like she
- 13:39didn't know night Rider. But this would soon prove to be untrue. John
- 13:45and Janice had cbe handles of their own. Oh so, when John noticed
- 13:48the weakness of the frequency that the driver was using to chat with night Rider,
- 13:52he wondered what was going on. After all, this night Rider character
- 13:56seemed to be quite close rather than where he said he was. He communicated
- 14:01with Lady Sundown in a code that was foreign to John. Yeah, I
- 14:05know. So John just relaxed and went along for the ride. But then,
- 14:09to john surprise, the woman took them outside of town. She came
- 14:13to a stop where a rather large man was apparently waiting for them in a
- 14:16red Granada. This man was the mysterious night night Rider. John introduced himself
- 14:22and Janie to night Rider, and night Rider said he wanted to find some
- 14:26alcohol. Then they all drove her way together in two cars to get another
- 14:31spot that was miles away from where they had all come from. Night Rider
- 14:35pretended he was looking for a place to get liquor, but really he was
- 14:37just trying to get them lost, and John lost all sense of directions,
- 14:41so he had no idea where they were to John surprise, he was allowed
- 14:46to get out of the car to pee, but when he did, Lady
- 14:50Sundown walked up to him with a handgun and ordered him into the woods.
- 14:54Well shit, She walked him down a narrow road and then he heard night
- 14:58Rider yelled her like, get it over with, She told John, don't
- 15:01worry about your girlfriend. Night Rider yelled again at her, and then John
- 15:05felt a shot go through his right shoulder and he fell to the ground.
- 15:11Fortunately for him, Lady Sundown was in a hurry and she didn't check to
- 15:13make sure he was alive or not. John was shocked and dazed by what
- 15:18had just happened, but yeah, he was still alive. He knew he
- 15:22needed to act fast, but he had to wait and make sure that the
- 15:26coast was clear before he could get up. After laying there for a bit,
- 15:28he managed to regain his strength, and he ran to the road and
- 15:33he flagged down a truck driver. His girlfriend. She's nowhere near them.
- 15:39I guess it couldn't have done munch to save her anyway, he probably couldn't.
- 15:43The truck driver took him to the hospital, and that's when a nurse
- 15:46called the police. Although John had been shot in the right shoulder, he
- 15:50would recover. He gave police his version of the story, but the police
- 15:54weren't completely convinced. For a few reasons. They initially suspected maybe it was
- 15:58a drug deal gone bad hood since John was saying that a woman had shot
- 16:03him, and he didn't seem to put up any kind of fight. Okay,
- 16:07wasn't making a drug deal? I don't know. And then they just
- 16:10didn't like his mannerisms. I guess. While he talked to them, he
- 16:15was like easygoing, and even though they didn't think he was lying, he
- 16:19seemed oddly unconcerned about his fiance or even about his own attack. It seemed
- 16:26to be a rather strange story anyway, like it is a fu getting into
- 16:30the car with a strange woman you don't know. Even so, there had
- 16:33been a number of reports over the past few days of people being approached by
- 16:37a woman driving around in a brown dodge with white stripes, So at least
- 16:41that lent some credibility to a story. John was able to supply a description
- 16:47of lady Sundown and night riders stop. They gave police a break in all
- 16:52of these recent puzzling cases. However, it didn't come out, and during
- 16:56his interrogation instead, when they were going to give him a polygraph, he
- 17:00overheard Detective Kinds playing the tape of the female caller. He recognized the voice.
- 17:06Yeah, absolutely, He was like, that's the woman who shot me.
- 17:08So he told his story again to Detective Kinds and he offered physical details
- 17:12so that they could do a composite sketch for Detective Kinds. This was a
- 17:17real break in the case. John wanted to help in any way that he
- 17:19could. He even agreed to submit to hypnosis his way to refresh his memory,
- 17:25like maybe there was something but he's missing, that's your subconscious. He
- 17:29was taken to Atlanta to have the sun and he was able to remember one
- 17:33thing, and it was that there was a bumper sticker on one of the
- 17:36cars that he hadn't previously mentioned. He also rode around town with Detective Kinds
- 17:41and an effort to see if anything he saw could jog his memory where he
- 17:47was. Yeah, because he said he was lost. Yeah, he was
- 17:48lost. After Detective Kinds was certain that all of the anonymous calls were made
- 17:55by the same woman, he went back to Linda Adair and Kenneth Dooley,
- 17:57and remember they were the one at the beginning of the story that had their
- 18:00home attacked. So Detective Kinds decided to bring them both in together and he
- 18:06wanted to know from them whether something had occurred at the RYDC to a girl
- 18:11who might now be to yeah exactly. The two both denied that there had
- 18:17been any kind of sexual abuse occurring at the facility, and they said that
- 18:21they didn't even know each other outside of being coworkers. Detective Kinds went over
- 18:26all of the files of the girls who had been sent to the RYDC due
- 18:30to crimes they had committed and narrowed his list of suspects down to five with
- 18:34prior records. Among them was Judith Anne Neelie and chief of the description given
- 18:41by some of the witnesses. In addition, she had been involved with an
- 18:45armed robbery, so they knew she was comfortable using the gun, and they
- 18:48can give her mushot to John. Right. So, after doing some digging
- 18:52and investigating, Detective Kinds discovered that Judith was married to a man named Alvin,
- 18:59and they both had police records. He then placed their photos in a
- 19:03lineup to show John. Absolutely, John hesitantly picked out the Kneelies as his
- 19:07attackers, but he said he'd want to see them in person, Like,
- 19:12but I don't know, he said, you know, it was a long
- 19:15night and the guy, Yeah, it was a long night, John,
- 19:18Yeah, he said. In the guy in the photo, you know,
- 19:21night rider, he had a beard, so it was hard to tell.
- 19:23Ye, I didn't see that. As it turned out, luck was in
- 19:27the police's favor, seeing as Alvin and Judith had been arrested for other crimes,
- 19:33so they were conveniently in custody in Tennessee. Oh so they're literally arrested
- 19:37at that point. Yeah, they arrested at that point. So this is
- 19:41right after what happened to John. Yes, yes, let me tell you
- 19:45a little bit about Judith and Alvin, these two winners. I can't wait.
- 19:49Judith and Neelie was born a loser who was also known by her Cebee
- 19:55handles which were Lady Sundown or Lady Goodyear. And she was went by the
- 20:00bride of Frankenstein. Oh that's love ye. Judith was born in mumps free
- 20:04Borough, Tennessee, in nineteen sixty four. Her father died in a motorcycle
- 20:08accident when she was nine, and after he died, Judith's home life went
- 20:12from bandor's I bet Her mother was arrested for contributing to the delinquency of a
- 20:18teenage boy. And I'm not sure exactly what that doesn't sound good. No.
- 20:22When Judith was fifteen, she met Alvin Neely, who was twelve years
- 20:26her senior. Oh gross, I know, very gross. Although he was
- 20:30larger than most football players, so he's a big dude. He had a
- 20:34face most people thought was sweet to stop it. Born born in Georgia,
- 20:41I don't know, born in Georgia. He was car thief with a friendly
- 20:48demeanor, who was more than car thief with a friendly demeanor. He was
- 20:52more than happy to give Judith a way out of her taxic situation at home.
- 20:56Their chemistry was instantaneous and undeniable. Neither could imagine life without the other.
- 21:03However, Alvin was married at the time, No problem. Yeah,
- 21:07he decided to get a divorce so it could be with his fifteen year old
- 21:11girlfriend basically, and his wife really wasn't all that upset to see him go.
- 21:15And then Alvin and Judith eloped in Georgia in nineteen eighty. Judith so
- 21:21she's like sixteen. Judith fit in easily with Alvin into his life of petty
- 21:26crimes. They were constantly on the move, robbing convenience stores and gas stations
- 21:32from Georgia to Texas in order to finance their on the go lifestyle. As
- 21:37they came into the Riverbend Mall parking lot in Rome, Georgia, they finally
- 21:41made a mistake in nineteen eighty They robbed a woman at gunpoint and were eventually
- 21:45caught trying to cash stolen checks, which led to their arrest. Since Alvin
- 21:49had outstanding warrens in several states, he was sentenced to five years in prison.
- 21:55Judith, on the other hand, ended up at the Ryds. Oh
- 22:00there we go, Ding Ding Ding ding Ding. She was pregnant at the
- 22:03time and gave birth to twins. She's pregnant in twins. She was then
- 22:08transferred to another facility in making Georgia. Judith spent much of her time writing
- 22:12to Alvin, telling him how much she despised the staff at the r y
- 22:17DC, and she claimed that they had sexually abused her. That's just it.
- 22:22Though all of her allegations have been denied by the staff there and police
- 22:26found no evidence to support them, so I can't confirm or deny whether they
- 22:30were true or not. Even so, she managed to get Alvin feeling like
- 22:34he needed some revenge due to these incidents. She got them all riled up,
- 22:38so now they are on this war path. For how long did he
- 22:42do? Uh? It had been less and five, Yeah, it was
- 22:47less than five. It was definitely like a year and a half. Judith
- 22:51was released towards the end of nineteen eighty one, and since she had nowhere
- 22:53else to go, she ended up moving in with Alvin's parents in Tennessee until
- 22:57he was released from prison. But her stint away didn't help much, as
- 23:02she returned right back to her old crime freeways. Surprised, she was arrested
- 23:07again after robbing another convenience store, and I don't know what punishment she got,
- 23:11if any, but Alvin's parents took care of the twins. I wouldn't
- 23:15even know how to rob a convenience store. I don't know. Excuse me?
- 23:19Can you just give me all your money? Yeah? Stick them up,
- 23:22I don't know, stick them up, stick them up. Within six
- 23:25months, Alvin had been granted an early release, so he did all of
- 23:29like a year and a half. So the two picked up where they had
- 23:32left off, leaving their kids behind. They needed money, so they learned
- 23:37how to steal checks from post offices and use their signatures to forge money orders,
- 23:41which became their primary means of supporting their lifestyle. I don't know how
- 23:45you forge money orders, but I don't know. I know this is back
- 23:48in nineteen eighty two, so who knows. To keep track of one another,
- 23:52they installed CBE radios in their respective cars, and Alvin became the night
- 23:57rider in Judith Lady Sundown. Just so cool. They even gave themselves the
- 24:03nicknames of Bony and Claude as a joke about their resemblance to the bank robbing
- 24:10Bonnie and Clyde. It's so stupid, that's so clever, so hysterical clever.
- 24:17Yes. In September nineteen eighty two, they found themselves in Rome,
- 24:21Georgia again and decided to launch an all out attack, which ended up being
- 24:25much of what I've told you earlier about the attacks on Kenneth Dooley and Linda
- 24:27Adair's residences, as well as the kidnapping of Lisa Millican. In this account,
- 24:33I'm gonna tell you about all these crimes came mostly from Judith. Judith
- 24:37described that they abducted Lisa Millican from an arcade and said she looked like Jonie
- 24:41Cunningham from Happy Days. They kept her. This was really sad what they
- 24:47did to her, so buckle up, all right. They kept her captive
- 24:51in two different hotel rooms in Georgia and Alabama for three days. Judith and
- 24:56Alvin had sex with Lisa and kept her handcuffed to a bed, which forced
- 25:00her to sleep on the floor. Then, at alvin distraction, Judith took
- 25:03Lisa to a remote canyon in Alabama and tried to inject her with drink cleaner
- 25:08products they had purchased for this very purpose. Horrible time. I know,
- 25:14I can't even imagine. If it touches your skin, it burns, yes,
- 25:18And but Lisa didn't die like Judith hoped or expected. Lisa was moaning
- 25:26on the ground and complained of being in pain. I mean, obviously,
- 25:29Judith kept shoving the needle into her six times in the neck for more than
- 25:33a half an hour before she accepted the fact that these injections weren't working.
- 25:40Lisa was burning and she was cold, but she wouldn't die. The girl
- 25:44begged Judith to take her back to the Harp's home. That's that girl's home
- 25:48that she was at, but that obviously wasn't going to happen. In the
- 25:52end, Judith decided just to kill the girl quickly, and she used a
- 25:56thirty eight pistol to shoot her three times. One bullet went through Lisa's back
- 26:02and out her left breast, which was the shot that ended up killing her.
- 26:06When Judith was certain she was dead, she shoved her over the edge
- 26:08of the canyon. Judith would later say that Alvin had masturbated as he looked
- 26:14now you know, at the battered corpse grows, but Judith's description of this
- 26:19incident to the police indicated she'd been alone. Alvin too, denied ever being
- 26:23there, so I don't know if this really happened, But Alvin also denied
- 26:29raping Lisa before he finally said that he had indeed had sex with her,
- 26:33but only once. Only once. It was difficult to know what the true
- 26:37story was. He had even tried claiming that Judith had masturbated him into ejaculation
- 26:41and then put the sperm into Lisa stop. Only when the police refused to
- 26:48buy that did he admit to sexual contact with Lisa. And before I tell
- 26:52you more, we're going to take a break. Five days later, Judith
- 26:59went searching for another victim. This is five days after they murdered Lisa.
- 27:04She saw a woman at a pay phone that appeared to be by herself,
- 27:07but Judith was unable to get her into the car like to go riding around
- 27:11with her. That woman would remember later for the police the strange feeling she
- 27:15had when Judith approached her. Fortunately for her, she had called her husband
- 27:21to come get her and therefore didn't need a ride. Soon afterward, Judith
- 27:26spotted twenty two year old Janice Chapman, who was John Hancock's fiance and even
- 27:32though she was with a man, Judith thought, with Alvin's help, they
- 27:36would be able to manage this. After all, they could get rid of
- 27:38the guy and take the girl with them. Judith pulled over invited the couple
- 27:42to go with her. I told you everything that happened the CB and blah
- 27:48blah blah. So remember Janice. I never told you what happened to her
- 27:52after Judith shot John and left him. Yeah, I don't know anything about
- 27:57what happened to Janis. She and Alvin took Janice, who was mentally disabled.
- 28:02I'm not sure how. So they took her to a cheap motel nearby.
- 28:07They raped her repeatedly and then shot her. They drove her body to
- 28:11a wooded area near a creek in Dumpter, and that's what happened I know.
- 28:17So it seems now that they've gotten away with murder twice, you know
- 28:19Lisa and now Janice. So they were ready for another. But they needed
- 28:23money first, so they went into Murfreesborough and probably saying that wrong to pass
- 28:30some of their forged money orders. Thankfully, someone recognized them from a police
- 28:33flyer and they were arrested. So that's why they're sitting in jail in Tennessee.
- 28:37Once in police custody, each began to point the finger at each other
- 28:42at exactly it seemed to be every man for himself. Alvin was quick to
- 28:48lawyer up, effectively shutting down the interrogation, but his attorney urged him to
- 28:52tell police what he knew. Alvin claimed that Judith had instigated the crimes and
- 28:57was responsible for eight murders, and then, oh yeah, he had just
- 29:02gone along with her. Oh wow, that's true. Love hed eight.
- 29:07He said she liked to have power over others, and in that moment he
- 29:11didn't know what else to do. He even went as far as say he
- 29:15was afraid that his wife might kill him. He's like this big dude,
- 29:18right. He made sure to emphasize how dangerous Judith, very dangerous really was.
- 29:25I was scared from my life. Yeah, suck off by the way
- 29:27he raped Yeah, teenagers right. Alvin apparently believed her tales about sexual abuse
- 29:34at the ROYDC and thought she had a good reason to be angry, but
- 29:38he also gave the distinct impression that he didn't want to commit I didn't want
- 29:42to the rape and murders. I absolutely didn't, right, but really this
- 29:48wasn't quite Why don't you just walk away? It's all bullshit. Alvin also
- 29:52claimed that the weapons oblong to Judith and that she had killed the two girls
- 29:56because of some rage that she carried around with her. At first, he
- 30:00do to stop nothing, right In fact one, I'm Almo was in a
- 30:03hotel. Yeah, days exactly with them and they were raped. Yes,
- 30:07yes, absolutely he participated. At first. Judith did accept the blame,
- 30:12exonerating Alvin every step of the way. In her own confession, she described
- 30:18her final moments with Lisa and Janice, and she admitted to the fire bombing
- 30:22and the shooting into Kenneth's house, but she said she did that because Kenneth
- 30:26Duley had raped her and that Linda Adair had set it up. But it
- 30:30didn't matter what either of them said or told police, because the wait,
- 30:33those are the people from the RYDC. Yeah, okay, that's why she
- 30:38was angry with them. It didn't matter what either of them said or told
- 30:42the police, because they would both change their minds and their stories several times.
- 30:47So yeah, not to mention things would change after getting lawyers. In
- 30:52preparing for trial, of course, Alvin told authorities how Judith had killed Janis
- 30:56Chapman and gave directions to where they could find the body. He even drew
- 31:00a map, implicating himself at least as an accomplice it wasn't long before they
- 31:04recovered Janice's decomposing corpse. She had been raped, shot to death, and
- 31:10dumped in a wilderness area, just as he described. So now they had
- 31:15two murders and two suspects. It would seem to be cut and dry,
- 31:18but it wasn't. After all, these crimes, the murder, rape,
- 31:22and assault had all been committed in different counties and in some cases different states.
- 31:26Not to mention, the evidence against Alvin was kind of weak except for
- 31:32the rape. I know they could get him for Janice's murder, but not
- 31:36Lisa's. Okay, well that's one. Yeah. Alvin remained in Tennessee and
- 31:41pled guilty to his part in the kidnap murder of Janis Chapman in exchange for
- 31:45life in prison. Jabith, on the other hand, faced first degree murder
- 31:48charges in Alabama for the murder of Lisa Milliken, and with her confession,
- 31:52they had a good case against her. She was extradited there for trial with
- 31:56possible death penalty hanging over her. Had it. Yeah. Judge Randall Cole
- 32:02presided over the proceedings. Alabama had a three count indictment against her murder,
- 32:08abduction with the intent to harm and abduction with the intent to terrorize. Her
- 32:14defense relied heavily on the insanity plea based on battered woman. I knew it.
- 32:21I knew it. She's not going to say that she went through psychiatric
- 32:23examinations but proved to be competent enough to stand trial. Which there's a difference
- 32:30between being influenced, yes, and being battered, right exactly. Even so,
- 32:35her defense put their bast foot forward and claiming that Judith was a pawn
- 32:38for Alvin and that he had beat her into doing the things he wanted,
- 32:43like capturing and raping young girls. The tree beater, not that I've ever
- 32:47heard. No. The trial began two months later after these arrests in the
- 32:52extradition, and Judith's defense put everything into the fact that Alvin controlled Judith and
- 32:58made her do his dirty. They even brought in Alvin's ex wife to describe
- 33:02her years of alleged abuse in Alvin's hands, and she claimed to have many
- 33:07scars from those days. And that might be true, maybe, but I'm
- 33:09not gonna kidnap some girl, I know, right, I mean I don't
- 33:14know for days and kill her and kill a guy. Yeah, And so
- 33:19now it's Judith's turn to take this. I'd rather just die than do those
- 33:22things. I mean some people, I guess, I don't know, Okay.
- 33:24She was grilled for four days. She went into extravagant detail about being
- 33:30a victim and being definitely afraid of her husband, Alvin. She claimed that
- 33:35if she hadn't done what he wanted, then he would have killed her.
- 33:37It would be true. Maybe. According to her, everything from assault to
- 33:42murder had been done completely under his direction. Apparently he was the master mind
- 33:46behind everything. However, everything Judith was saying contradicted everything she had written to
- 33:52Alvin. And you know what, she's still fucking them like they were still
- 33:57together, making the sweet love right and all that come on. When the
- 34:02prosecution presented their case, John Hancock testified as well as three different girls that
- 34:08Judith tried to pick up but she was unsuccessful in doing so. And all
- 34:13three of these girls said there was no sign of a man anywhere when these
- 34:16incident took place, But that doesn't mean to them control over maybe not to
- 34:21mention. A psychiatrist came on the scene and talked about how Judith had known
- 34:23the difference between right and wrong at the time of the offense, and she
- 34:28had consciously decided to commit murder. Even if she was brainwashed, she still
- 34:31hit a choice, and the psychiatrist stood firm on that statement. It's true,
- 34:36so now both sides closer cases. And the judge gave the instructions to
- 34:39the jury. The jury received the case on March twenty first, nineteen eighty
- 34:44three, fairly late in the afternoon, and by the next morning they had
- 34:46reached a verdict. They found Judith and Neely guilty of the kidnap and murder
- 34:51of Lisa Milliken, and they recommended that she be sentenced to life in prison.
- 34:57I can see that rather than giving her the death penalty right eighteen.
- 35:00By the way, Despite this recommendation, sentencing was up to Judge Cole,
- 35:05and he had written two opinions. Ultimately, he decided that while Judith was
- 35:10young, she was also brazen and cruel. He thought the crimes had been
- 35:15heinous and atrocious beyond which is common to most capital cases, and sentenced turned
- 35:20to death. Holy shit. Yeah. When Judith heard this, she began
- 35:23to cry Wow. He usurped jury that she's going I'm gonna put her in
- 35:30death row, not wanting a second death sentence in another state. Judith ended
- 35:36up leading guilty to the kidnap and murder of Janis Chapman in Tennessee, and
- 35:40she received a life sentence for that crime. Then she got ten years for
- 35:45the shooting of John Hancock. It was her deal with Tennessee that spurred Alvin
- 35:50to finalize his own plea deal. Judith became the youngest woman to have been
- 35:53sentenced to death in Alabama. In a nineteen eighty three prison interview, she
- 35:59reportedly quote, I pray for strength. I don't ask God for me not
- 36:04to be electrocuted. I just asked that if I'm going to be electrocuted,
- 36:07to give me strength to go through it. End quote. Its kind of
- 36:10not going to have a choice, I know. Judith appealed to get a
- 36:15new trial, but in March nineteen eighty seven, the US Supreme Court rejected
- 36:19the appeal. Less than two years later, they let her death sentence stand.
- 36:22She converted to Christianity. While she was in prison. She apparently developed
- 36:28a relationship with another woman who, on May twenty first, nineteen ninety four,
- 36:31was found dead at her home. She had shot herself. What she
- 36:37did this relationship with this other woman and she was found dead. She had
- 36:40shot herself, leaving photographs and a cassette recording of her end Judith's fatal plan.
- 36:47Judith was found in her cell, her wrists slashed with a disposable razor,
- 36:52but she survived. So it's going to be murder suicide or suicide suicide
- 36:57kind of thing. Then there was more news. Alabama Governor Fob James decided
- 37:02that Judith didn't deserve to die for her crimes. Before he left office,
- 37:07he signed an order to commute her sentence to life in prison without the possibility
- 37:13of parole. This decision caused an outcry, so he defended his decision,
- 37:17stating he had given it long consideration and went through many documents, including letters
- 37:22pleading with him to reconsider Judath's case. The jury, he noted, had
- 37:25given her a life sentence, and it was the judge that had held for
- 37:29the death sentence. Governor James said that since the jury who had seen all
- 37:32the evidence, had decided on leniency and they had been chosen as Judith's peers,
- 37:38their recommendation was the proper one to follow. In response to the governor
- 37:43commuting Judith's sentence, lawmakers in two thousand and three passed the law that death
- 37:46row inmates who had their sentences commuted shall not be eligible for parole. Judaths
- 37:52attorney filed the lawsuit challenging the statute in its retroactive application to her case.
- 37:58The law was ruled institutional in March of twenty eighteen, leading to her first
- 38:02parole hearing in May of twenty eighteen, where the Alabama Board of Pardons took
- 38:07only fifty five seconds to deny her parole. However, even if Judith is
- 38:15granted parole, she would likely be arrested by Georgia authorities to serve a time
- 38:19for a consecutive life sentence in the rape and murder of Janis Chapman. All
- 38:22of them. What the fuck? What's the point? I know? She
- 38:24is set to see the parole board again this month May of twenty twenty three.
- 38:29Currently, she is the second longest serving female death row inmate in the
- 38:32country. That sucks in cause you're wondering what happened to Alvin. I would
- 38:37like to know he died in prison in two thousand and five. Oh,
- 38:39how I don't know. He just died. He just died. He wasn't
- 38:44old. No, well, he's twelve years older than her. No,
- 38:46he wasn't the old because at home, Karma's a bitch. Yeah, Kara's
- 38:51a bitch, and so is he. He is a bitch. So that
- 38:57is my awful story of Alvin and Judith Neely. I never heard that.
- 39:02I knew that she was the youngest person to be sentenced to death row.
- 39:06Maybe if i'd like saw our picture, maybe I would know. But I
- 39:09would just like to do what Neely and neal e L L E Y.
- 39:15I would like to ask everyone to hit the subscriber follow button if you haven't.
- 39:19I don't like her, No, I'm just thinking at the pictures.
- 39:22I don't like her. And if you would like to hear more episodes that
- 39:25we have not released to the public, please check out Patreon dot com,
- 39:30slash t n T crimes, or go to our website and there's information there
- 39:34YEP Crimes and Consequences dot com and you would not only get additional episodes,
- 39:39but you would also get our weekly free episodes early release and and free YEP.
- 39:45Absolutely. If you don't want to go there and you are listening on
- 39:47your Apple podcast app iPhone, I mean, you've got so many options.
- 39:52You can just subscribe through the Apple podcast app and you would get the same
- 39:57episodes. Why not just do it? We are on Facebook and Instagram at
- 40:01hardcore true crime, and I think that's probably It's good enough. That's good
- 40:06enough. We have shout outs and I even write them now. No,
- 40:08so we have to do it next time, all right, all right until
- 40:12our next episode, don't kill each other. Bye bye,