Latest / Marketplace Businesses with Fexingo: Two-Sided Networks, Liquidity, and Take Rates / How Vinted Built a Marketplace Without Charging Sellers
Transcript
- Lucas: So Vinted, the secondhand fashion app, now operates in 18 countries and has over 80 million registered users. And one of the most distinctive things about it — especially compared to other resale platforms — is that it charges sellers nothing. Luna: Nothing? No listing fee, no commission, no nothing? Lucas: Zero. If you sell a jacket for 20 euros, you keep the full 20 euros. The platform makes its money entirely from the buyer side — a buyer protection fee that's typically 3 to 5 percent of the transaction plus a small fixed amount, usually around 70 euro cents. Luna: So the buyer pays more than the listed price, but the seller doesn't see a haircut. That's a deliberate liquidity play, isn't it? Lucas: Exactly. Vinted was founded in 2008 in Vilnius, Lithuania, and for years it struggled with the classic cold-start problem. It had very few listings, because why would someone bother listing a used T-shirt if they had to pay a fee and might not sell it anyway? So the founders made a bet: remove all friction for sellers, and listing volume would explode. Luna: And it worked. But what about the buyers? A 5 percent fee on a 20 euro item is only one euro, so it's small enough not to deter them. Lucas: Right. The fee is structured to feel negligible on low-priced items, which is most of Vinted's inventory. The average selling price is around 12 to 15 euros. So the buyer pays maybe 1.50 euros extra. That's less than the cost of a bus ticket in most European cities. Meanwhile, the seller gets full price, which incentivizes them to list more. It creates a virtuous cycle. Luna: But Vinted's take rate — the percentage of transaction value it keeps — is lower than most marketplaces. eBay takes about 13 percent, Poshmark takes 20 percent from sellers. Vinted's blended take rate is probably around 5 to 7 percent. Lucas: That's right. And that's a deliberate trade-off. Vinted's theory is that a lower take rate enables much higher transaction volume. They're not trying to maximize margin per transaction; they're trying to maximize total GMV — gross merchandise value. And the data supports it. In 2024, Vinted reported over 2 billion euros in GMV, and it became profitable for the first time in 2023. Luna: But the buyer protection fee isn't just revenue — it also covers things like shipping labels, payment processing, and fraud protection. So it's not pure profit. Lucas: No, it's not. The fee includes the cost of providing buyer protection. If a buyer doesn't receive an item or it's significantly not as described, Vinted steps in. So that fee builds trust on the buyer side while funding operations. It's a classic cross-side subsidy: the buyer pays a little extra to make the platform work, and the seller benefits from a huge, liquid marketplace. Luna: And it also solves the supply-side liquidity problem. If you're a seller and you know you'll get 100 percent of the price, you're more likely to list that 5 euro scarf. But if you had to pay a listing fee or a commission, you might not bother. Lucas: Exactly. That's why Vinted has such a massive inventory — over 100 million items listed at any given time. And that inventory attracts buyers, who then pay the fee. It's a beautiful loop. Luna: One challenge, though: Vinted's model only works if the average transaction value stays low. If someone tries to sell a designer handbag for 500 euros, a 5 percent buyer fee is 25 euros — that might sting. Lucas: That's a real tension. Vinted has tried to address it by capping the buyer protection fee in some markets. In the UK, for example, the fee is capped at 2 pounds. But it's also true that high-value items are not Vinted's core. The platform is strongest in the 5 to 30 euro range. For luxury goods, there's Vestiaire Collective or The RealReal, which charge higher commissions but offer authentication. Luna: So Vinted's zero seller fee model is really a strategic choice to own the low-end, high-volume part of the resale market. Lucas: Exactly. And it's worked so well that competitors have taken notice. In 2024, Poshmark announced it was eliminating seller fees in Canada to test a similar model. But Vinted has a head start. It's been refining this approach for over a decade. Luna: It makes you think about how many other marketplaces could benefit from flipping the fee structure. If the core friction is on the supply side — getting people to list — then charging sellers might be the wrong move. Lucas: Right. And this connects to something we talk about a lot on this show: the idea that the best marketplace design is the one that solves the specific liquidity problem of that market. For Vinted, the bottleneck was supply. For a service marketplace like Thumbtack, the bottleneck is trust on the buyer side, so they charge service pros for leads, not buyers. Luna: And if these conversations are useful for what you're building or running, we should mention that we keep this show completely free of ads and sponsors. That's intentional — we don't want anyone else's messaging in between the ideas. Lucas: Yeah, we've never run ads on Fexingo, and we're not going to start. If you'd like to support that choice, the link is buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. No pressure, just a way to keep it sustainable. Luna: Exactly. And it helps us keep digging into models like Vinted's that don't get mainstream attention. Now, back to that fee structure — Vinted also has a clever way of handling shipping. Lucas: Yes. Vinted doesn't handle inventory or logistics itself. Instead, it integrates with multiple carriers and lets the buyer choose. But the buyer protection fee includes a subsidized shipping label, which makes shipping cheap and easy. That reduces friction for both sides. Luna: So the buyer pays a fee that covers protection and discounted shipping. The seller pays nothing. And Vinted takes a small cut but makes it up in volume. Lucas: That's the model. And it's allowed Vinted to expand rapidly across Europe. In 2024, it launched in the United States, though it's still small there. The US resale market is dominated by Poshmark, Depop, and ThredUp, all of which charge seller fees. It'll be interesting to see if Vinted's zero-fee model can gain traction. Luna: It also raises a question about sustainability. Vinted's operating margins are thin — around 5 percent. If growth slows, can it remain profitable? Lucas: That's the risk. A low take rate means you need massive scale. Vinted is essentially a volume business. But if it can continue to grow GMV, it can maintain profitability. The key is keeping those buyer protection fees high enough to cover costs but low enough not to deter purchases. Luna: It's a delicate balance. Too high and buyers balk. Too low and the platform loses money. Lucas: And Vinted has been experimenting with the fee structure. In some markets, they've introduced a 'boost' feature where sellers can pay to promote their listings. That's a small revenue stream from sellers, but it's optional. The core remains zero commission. Luna: So they're still committed to the original thesis: don't charge sellers, and the supply will come. Lucas: And so far, that thesis has carried Vinted to a valuation of over 3.5 billion euros. It's one of the most valuable startups in Europe, and it's profitable. That's rare for a marketplace. Luna: It really is. Most marketplaces burn cash for years. Vinted's discipline on take rate and focus on unit economics is a lesson for any marketplace builder. Lucas: Absolutely. And it shows that the conventional wisdom — charge both sides — isn't the only path. Sometimes the best way to build liquidity is to make one side feel like they're getting a free ride. Luna: So the next time you list a coat on Vinted and keep the full 15 euros, you know exactly why they do it. Lucas: Exactly. And that's the kind of structural insight that makes marketplace design so fascinating.