Latest / I Love You Keep Going with George Haas / Preoccupied People and Exploration
Transcript
- 0:01You're listening to the I Love you Keep Going podcast with
- 0:04George Haas. For more information, please
- 0:06visit our website at www.medigroup.org.
- 0:10That's www.m ETTAGROU p.org. So welcome everybody.
- 0:20This is I Love you. Keep Going.
- 0:21It is Thursday, October 3rd at 7:35 PM Pacific Daylight Time
- 0:26and I talked last time about dismissing people or avoiding
- 0:33people and how with exploration sometimes it their thoughts
- 0:39about exploration are really organized around auto regulating
- 0:43and and distracting themselves from the lack of interaction
- 0:49with other people. And so I thought that I would
- 0:50talk this week about the way that preoccupied people enter
- 0:54into the process of exploration and how that looks for them.
- 1:02Dismissing people or avoiding people do have the capacity to
- 1:05explore, but they tend to Orient themselves around secondary
- 1:08exploration. The gathering of time, energy
- 1:10and resources preoccupied people because they've had so much
- 1:16interference in the, in the, the natural development of their
- 1:20capacity to explore. And because they're dependent on
- 1:24external regulation to feel emotionally settled, they, they
- 1:29tend to swap exploration for proximity so that a lot of the,
- 1:35the, the strategies that they have are organized around
- 1:38maintaining proximity to somebody who's regulating for
- 1:42them. And one of the, the tricks of
- 1:45that process is to assume that the meaningful of meaningfulness
- 1:51of life will come from that relational connection and not
- 1:57from independent exploration. That's really the purpose of
- 2:02which is to discover the meaningfulness of life.
- 2:06And this can work really well in different in different settings.
- 2:11We tend to talk about preoccupation as taking 2
- 2:17distinct paths. 1 is a presentation of helplessness and
- 2:22the other is a presentation of control or controlling a
- 2:27behavior. And sometimes there's a swap
- 2:29that can go on, but we really need to be able to manage our
- 2:40emotional regulation in order to separate to pursue a primary
- 2:45exploration. And if we can't manage that
- 2:48emotional regulation, it really is very impactful on in the way
- 2:54that we're able to explore Christian.
- 3:00This sort of dichotomy that you presented of control or flipping
- 3:05into helplessness, is that do those serve the same purpose or
- 3:11the person you'd like using that strategy?
- 3:14I know it's not like a conscious strategy necessarily.
- 3:17So the controlling behavior tends to emerge in mid
- 3:21childhood, say around 6:00 or so, six or seven when there's a
- 3:26additional brain development that would allow a child to be
- 3:29able to begin to to take on the role.
- 3:35And it's usually in response to the caregiver's presentation as
- 3:39helpless. So in order for the child to
- 3:42manage the caregiver and create the perception that there's an
- 3:49adult managing the household so that they can get the things
- 3:53that they need from from the adult world, they begin to take
- 3:57on a kind of controlling relationship with the caregiver
- 4:01to get them to manage the household.
- 4:06That's where it really comes from.
- 4:09If the caregiver's in charge, of course, and they have the adult
- 4:12level of control that they have, then the child is free to be
- 4:15helpless in a way of eliciting care.
- 4:18Remember, the child is attempting to elicit the care
- 4:22from the caregiver in the family system that they grow up in.
- 4:26And if the caregiver needs the child to appear to be helpless
- 4:30in order for the the caregiver to feel a sense of satisfaction
- 4:34in their caregiving, then the child will produce the sense of
- 4:39helplessness in order to get the proximity and care from the
- 4:45caregiver. Is that making sense?
- 4:48So it's it sounds like maybe there's a little bit of a
- 4:51different goal for each of the behaviors like the helplessness
- 4:56grants closeness for the child and and the controlling actually
- 5:02like sort of puts things in order or like uses the caregiver
- 5:07for a different for like they're.
- 5:09Both attempts to elicit care, OK, just depends on how the the
- 5:15caregiver is presenting. So the child has a choice of
- 5:19what to do. You know, for instance, if the
- 5:22child needs a slip, a sign for school, then they demand of the
- 5:26caregiver that they sign it rather than the caregiver
- 5:29volunteering to sign. And they keep track of those
- 5:32things. If the child needs to have
- 5:34supplies or if the child needs to have food in the house or if
- 5:37the child wants to have dinner on time, often they end up
- 5:41taking over the preparing of the meal.
- 5:44For instance, whatever it is that they need to do, doing the
- 5:48laundry or whatever it is. Often times they'll go into
- 5:54school and they'll perform at a high level because that actually
- 5:57attracts attention to them that they have a hard time getting
- 6:00from somewhere else. And but understand that the the
- 6:07directedness of that is not for primary exploration.
- 6:13They're eliciting proximity and care through that presentation,
- 6:19that making sense. So when we talk about this, in
- 6:22some sense the non mentalizing modes of pretend mode, one of
- 6:27the things about preoccupation is it puts you in a position to
- 6:31pretend to be who it is that you think you need to be in order to
- 6:35elicit the care that you. Because you don't really develop
- 6:45monitoring. If you look at that pattern of
- 6:47preoccupation and and how that develops, you're very
- 6:50spontaneous as a preoccupied person and you're very oriented
- 6:55toward the other and your mind easily and meshes with the mind
- 6:58states of the other person. You're very externally oriented
- 7:02in the world and not so much in touch with what goes on with
- 7:06you. And you're very emotionally
- 7:08oriented and not particularly cognitively oriented, which
- 7:12means you don't monitor what presentation you have to do.
- 7:15You just keep throwing things up, hoping that one of them will
- 7:20be the right one so that people grab onto it and you get the
- 7:23care that you need. And the reason that you do that
- 7:27is because the caregivers are chaotic and they don't
- 7:30consistently respond to you. So there's no point in learning
- 7:34how to elicit care from a chaotic caregiver because they
- 7:38don't respond the same way, though.
- 7:41There's no point in putting energy into developing the
- 7:45capacity to track it. Does that make sense?
- 7:49And so you're really just in the moment, throwing up a
- 7:52presentation and seeing how it does.
- 7:53And if it doesn't do what you want, you throw up something
- 7:57else and see if that does. And eventually you land on
- 8:00something that elicits the care that you want, but you don't
- 8:03really have a sense of what's authentically yours and and you
- 8:09don't develop a ready dialogue with somebody else that's
- 8:14collaborative and and a fair exchange that makes sense.
- 8:21Mudit. Hi, George.
- 8:23So the attention is different from the care right in this
- 8:26case. Well, proximity, remember that
- 8:31we're, we're dependent on our caregivers for emotional
- 8:35regulation in childhood. And so proximity to the
- 8:39caregiver that's available to us enough and their time, interest
- 8:43and attention to help us emotionally regulate with a
- 8:49somebody who grows up to be a disorganized, they don't really
- 8:53have a caregiver who has the capacity for that.
- 8:58And So what they need is to navigate the the proximity
- 9:03mainly in hopes that the proximity itself will be
- 9:07regulating that. Is that making sense?
- 9:10So if you look at that development, we all start out as
- 9:15auto regulators and we, we are all self involved and
- 9:20regulating. And then, you know, three
- 9:22months, five months into life, if we have a caregiver who comes
- 9:26reliably enough, we reorient toward external care.
- 9:31But if the caregiver provides that in an unpredictable way, we
- 9:36get, we, we zoom in and, and mesh with their mind state.
- 9:40And we operate as if the mind state and the emotional state of
- 9:45the caregiver is the primary emotional experience.
- 9:49And our own emotional experience begins to drift into the
- 9:52background where we don't really attend to it.
- 9:57So much so that if we want to feel regulated in proximity to
- 10:02our caregivers, we have to regulate them.
- 10:05And that's where either the control or the helpless comes
- 10:08in. So we can navigate regulating
- 10:10them because the empathetic experience of the caregiver has
- 10:14displaced our own awareness of our own emotional states.
- 10:20And if they are well regulated, because that's our dominant
- 10:23experience, we feel regulated. But it also means we can't
- 10:28separate from them because as soon as we do, we're outside of
- 10:32the empathetic experience of regulation and into our own
- 10:36emotional state, which is often quite dysregulated.
- 10:40Is that making sense? Go ahead.
- 10:46I see it's it's a form of caregiving in some sense.
- 10:50Yes, it's role reversing. The child is put in charge of
- 10:53the care of the caregiver instead of the other way around.
- 10:57But even in in adult relationships it would be the
- 10:59same, right? Well, in adult relationships,
- 11:05caregivers, the caregiving is supposed to be insecure.
- 11:10In insecure dynamic, mutual right, You take care of somebody
- 11:15else the way that they need, and they take care of you in the way
- 11:18that you need. But because preoccupied adults
- 11:22grow up in a family system where that doesn't really happen, they
- 11:25don't have the conditioning to understand those conditions.
- 11:28What they've always known is that they had to take care of
- 11:32the other person and that that the other person did not often
- 11:39reciprocate that. But as long as they did a good
- 11:42job at taking care of the other person.
- 11:43Because the empathetic experience is the dominant
- 11:46emotional experience and the regulated mind state of the
- 11:48other person is the dominant experience.
- 11:51As long as they were doing OK, you felt good, as long as you
- 11:55were in proximity to them. That making sense.
- 12:02But it's not the child who is secure or the child who is
- 12:05dismissing that. It's clinging through the
- 12:08banister and not wanting to go to school.
- 12:11It is the preoccupied child who can't regulate outside of
- 12:14proximity to the caregiver that doesn't want to leave.
- 12:18They don't want to leave because they they're going to be they're
- 12:22going to have a harder time regulating themselves, but they
- 12:24also don't want to have to come back to an adult who's
- 12:27completely dysregulated and then have to figure out how to bring
- 12:31them back into balance. Is that making sense?
- 12:39So who do you hook up with if you're used to taking care of
- 12:43somebody else and you don't demand from them that they
- 12:47reciprocate the care? You hook up with somebody who
- 12:53likes to be taken care of but doesn't think to reciprocate it.
- 12:57And the reason that you do that is because you can tolerate that
- 13:00relational condition when most people can't.
- 13:04And so you have the opportunity for connection there that that
- 13:07other people wouldn't accept really that that makes sense.
- 13:14But you do have to be able to show up well enough that the
- 13:17other person feels taken care of.
- 13:20And you have to be willing to do it without, without
- 13:23reciprocation. So what you find in preoccupied
- 13:28people is they're often burning out in terms of providing so
- 13:32much care without without it being reciprocated so much.
- 13:39Yes, taking care of an addict parent or an addict partner.
- 13:50Addiction is a little bit different.
- 13:55Most people who are who are addicted are disorganized.
- 13:58And so we one of the impediments to an organized preoccupied
- 14:05person having a relationship with a disorganized person is
- 14:08that disorganized people self isolate to emotionally regulated
- 14:12that is counterproductive for the proximity seeking of the
- 14:21preoccupied person. So there's less of that than you
- 14:24might think. It's mostly organized dismissing
- 14:27people with organized preoccupied people, and that can
- 14:31create a fairly stable union where the dismissing person is
- 14:38taken care of by the preoccupied person, but the dismissing
- 14:44person does not reciprocate care particularly.
- 14:48It's transactional, and they're good with stuff dismissing
- 14:51people, but they're not good with intimate emotional care.
- 14:55That makes sense. Now understand that somebody who
- 15:01grows up in a, in A and to be a preoccupied adult is not growing
- 15:07up in a collaborative, intimate environment.
- 15:10So they don't know that either. What they know is a
- 15:13transactional relationship. I do this for you and then you
- 15:17you reciprocate the things that I need, but it's not an
- 15:22emotional, collaborative, intimate experience and it's an
- 15:26exchange. Is that making sense?
- 15:33So what you'll notice is that dismissing people are really
- 15:38good at secondary exploration in the gathering of stuff that they
- 15:42need in order to transact and preoccupied people are really
- 15:46good at supporting somebody else's exploration.
- 15:50So you also have that match in terms of how how exploration
- 15:56goes Preoccupied people are often in a state of
- 16:00dissatisfaction because proximity to somebody else and a
- 16:06an emotional regulation is also not primary exploration, not
- 16:11even really secondary exploration.
- 16:15And so there's a dissatisfaction that comes from a lack of
- 16:19exploration, which the preoccupied person demands of
- 16:24the dismissing person that they fulfill that which the
- 16:29dismissing person, ironically I like to say, interprets it as
- 16:35they have to work for more stuff which is useful to them, right?
- 16:41That's one of the ways that preoccupied people support
- 16:44dismissing people is by demanding that the dismissing
- 16:48person do better. And in that demand they are.
- 16:53They have more energy than to compete in the way that they
- 16:55like to. But it still doesn't provide for
- 17:01the preoccupied person, particularly the sense of
- 17:04meaningfulness and relationships, even functional
- 17:08transactional relationships that are stable and last a long time
- 17:13don't provide that meaning. And it isn't that the person is
- 17:17withholding that, it's that relationships aren't aren't
- 17:22really for that. That's not what happens.
- 17:27A primary exploration is where the activity itself provides a
- 17:31sense of meaningfulness in in your life.
- 17:35And secondary exploration is where you're gathering the
- 17:38resources in order to support your primary exploration.
- 17:43So what is it? What is it that you need to find
- 17:46out about? As Mary Oliver would say, you're
- 17:50one wild and precious life. What do you need to know about
- 17:54it so that it feels fulfilling, it feels meaningful to you.
- 17:59You like to get up out of bed and go do it because it's
- 18:06enriching. Now you're noticing that I'm
- 18:12giving you a handful of superlatives, but no, no actual
- 18:18instructions for an activity to choose.
- 18:23And that is because you can derive meaning from a lot of
- 18:29different things depending on your conditioning.
- 18:33Kayleen, did you have a question?
- 18:35No, I was just clearing my throat, sorry.
- 18:38You're you. You unmuted yourself.
- 18:40That's why. I asked.
- 18:52As it turns out, since this is actually a meditation community,
- 18:55one of the things that people find really meaningful is the
- 18:59spiritual pursuits. You know, the, the quest for
- 19:01enlightenment actually is something that is very
- 19:04meaningful for a lot of people. And it really does produce this
- 19:08rich experience about, about being alive.
- 19:12And it opens up so much, takes you out of that very
- 19:18contractive, limited identification with a sense of
- 19:21self and opens up this vast, you know, cosmic, sacred way of
- 19:30navigating the world, which is fantastic.
- 19:34And so I, I think that that's probably a useful pursuit, but
- 19:39there are certainly others that that also, I mean, but I might
- 19:44also say that a primary exploration is the authentic
- 19:50expression of what matters to you in a way that's commutative
- 19:55to other people. So that it's also an exchange.
- 19:59You go out and find out the things that really matter to
- 20:02you. And then you come back and you
- 20:05express them in an authentic way to the, that small group of
- 20:10people that you've gathered around you that are interested
- 20:13in you and what you find out and you are, you express that in an
- 20:20authentic way that that's open and vulnerable.
- 20:23And then they also do that for you.
- 20:26They. Expressed you the things that
- 20:28they've found out about this human condition that we're in
- 20:36and and that that richness of exchange is the thing that
- 20:43fosters intimacy. You really know somebody based
- 20:48on the things that matter to them, and they really know you
- 20:51based on the things that matter to you that are of interest to
- 20:55you. That making sense, Christian.
- 21:01George, hopefully I can formulate this clearly.
- 21:03Could you comment on maybe maybe this is just a particular way of
- 21:07understanding Buddhist philosophy and maybe it's not
- 21:11true, but that maybe there's kind of a tension between
- 21:16finding meaning out in the world, out in the like the
- 21:18material world versus a spiritual practice where you let
- 21:23go of attachments and you kind of see the emptiness and
- 21:27phenomena. Are those kind of not pointing
- 21:32in maybe different directions somewhat?
- 21:35Well, we have the difficulty of the word attachment and non
- 21:39attachment in the attachment theory sense and in the Buddhist
- 21:43sense and what it actually means.
- 21:47So non attachment means that you don't in the Theravada sense, of
- 21:52course, depending on what what tradition you're in and how it's
- 21:55taught. Also, we're in a in in a in a a
- 22:00word salad trap, but. I guess I I I meant attachment,
- 22:07not in the attachment theory sense.
- 22:11So I would say that non attachment means that you can
- 22:14fixate your your meaning to the sensing experience that you you
- 22:22are having and that you can be non attached to it.
- 22:26So that you're free to attach and non attach to the sensing
- 22:30experience so that you know you have the capacity to sense
- 22:34touching, seeing, hearing, tasting, smelling.
- 22:36You have mind, which does this highly selective curation of the
- 22:40sense mind moments that you're gathering.
- 22:44You put those sense moments, those mind moments, together.
- 22:49You associate meaning to them, and as soon as you associate the
- 22:53meaning, they fixate. That is to say, you attach
- 22:57meaning to the sensing experience and it rolls into a
- 23:02tableau of conceptual reality which you project out into the
- 23:07world and that's what you're inhabiting.
- 23:10But if you recognize that you've misidentified or misassigned
- 23:16meaning, you're free to simply drop that and reassign it.
- 23:20That would be what I would think of as attachment and non
- 23:23attachment. And in each moment, as it ends,
- 23:26you don't cling to it because it's something that you wanted
- 23:30in each moment it arises, and you're not aversive to what is
- 23:34arising in the moment and that you're coming and going from
- 23:38this, a sensing experience into reality.
- 23:44So ultimate reality into conceptual reality.
- 23:47And there's total freedom. And there's no clinging, there's
- 23:52no grasping, there's no grab in anything.
- 23:56It's dense. Which is not to say that you
- 24:03can't fixate anything, which is equally problematic, right?
- 24:07It's the coming and going that that is a is a, a representation
- 24:12of freedom, not either the clinging or the inability to
- 24:17cling. OK, so I guess you're saying
- 24:21that you don't think a spiritual or Buddhist practice will
- 24:25necessarily contradict your wanting to like find meaning out
- 24:35in the world in kind of more material ways or, or that
- 24:40practice isn't kind of dull that I don't know if that's kind of a
- 24:43nihilistic view. I don't think that material, the
- 24:51collection of material things, provides a lot of meaning.
- 24:57How long does new car smell last?
- 25:02I. Get the first scratch that it's
- 25:05a total total loss. I guess maybe I'm being
- 25:09imprecise, maybe just achievements or attainments,
- 25:12things that could be cultural. Tokens.
- 25:14Is that what you mean? Yeah, like if I want to be an
- 25:22artist, then some artistic success.
- 25:27Well, so that's the cultural idea.
- 25:31We if you read the newspaper about art, mostly what they're
- 25:36talking about is how much it's sold for, not what the content
- 25:39of it was, not what the meaning of it.
- 25:44Sometimes if you read reviews of shows of artists, you can have
- 25:51that. But our culture is so confined
- 25:54and media is so constrained and, and with the advent of AI, it's
- 26:01just going to be stripped down to a kind of propagandistic
- 26:05message that supports people in power.
- 26:11That the that is probably unlikely to provide the kind of
- 26:18meaning as an artist that you would be looking for, which is
- 26:21of course, in the discovery of the making of the work.
- 26:26That is, what is the meaningful part of it?
- 26:32Does it matter that your auction, the auction price at on
- 26:36the secondary market is spectacular because you don't
- 26:39make any of that? What does it really matter which
- 26:45is coming back to this idea of the authentic expression of
- 26:51yourself. And in our culture, of course,
- 26:53in art in particular, branded artists do better than
- 26:57experimental artists. So you make a painting and it
- 27:00sells well, and you make another version of the painting and it
- 27:02sells well. Then all of a sudden you've made
- 27:04200 versions of the same painting, or if you're Warhol,
- 27:10900 versions of the flower painting because it, it, it was
- 27:16a popular painting. Is that then primary exploration
- 27:23or does that somehow morph into secondary exploration, which is
- 27:27really the the gathering of cultural tokens, which I don't
- 27:33think is the is the meaning that we're really talking about.
- 27:38OK, who did? Just a quick vocabulary clarity
- 27:48on the definition of helplessness.
- 27:51I know the Christian's comment of Tell me what to do.
- 27:55He just wrote. Is that considered?
- 27:59Would you would you define that as helplessness?
- 28:02Well, helplessness is a presentation.
- 28:04It's not an actual lack of ability, it's a it's a mode of
- 28:11seeking proximity. So to be helpless, you would
- 28:14scan the environment and look for a problem, and then you
- 28:18would present the problem to somebody so that they could
- 28:20solve it for you. But it's usually not the problem
- 28:24that matters to you particularly whether it's solved or not.
- 28:27It's that you get the proximity in the request for the the
- 28:31problem to be solved. So the more unsolvable the
- 28:35problem, the better it is for you, because then the other
- 28:38person doesn't have a chance to solve it and they have to engage
- 28:42in it. And So what I would describe as
- 28:44a helpless loop is you just, you look in the environment,
- 28:48identify a problem you presented to somebody, they offer you a
- 28:51solution, which you reject and then represent the problem.
- 28:55They offer you another solution, which you reject and represent
- 28:59the problem. They offer you another solution
- 29:02and you rejected and represent the problem.
- 29:06And what you'll notice in the person who's trying to solve the
- 29:10pretend problem for somebody is that you're gradually feeling
- 29:13more and more helpless to help because they've already tried
- 29:19everything and nothing has worked.
- 29:24So that's really what the helplessness is.
- 29:28The person themselves is not helpless and most of the time
- 29:32they actually don't need you to solve the problem that they're
- 29:35presenting because it's not about the problem, it's about
- 29:39the proximity. It's a pretend mode request for
- 29:44proximity, which they they they don't make directly that making
- 29:50sense. So the mind state is not
- 29:53actually helpless, it's just the pretension of.
- 29:56Right, they're not helpless and generally they could solve the
- 30:00problem themselves. I'll give you an example.
- 30:05I was when I was working in the rehab of one of the the students
- 30:10at the rehab came up to me and she said, I'm so glad I saw you.
- 30:14You're the perfect person to help with help me with this.
- 30:18And it's really terrible. My whole family is concerned
- 30:22about that. And I said, what's the problem?
- 30:25And she said we can't get a visa for my grandmother to come from
- 30:31a country. I thought to myself, I'm a
- 30:36meditation teacher. I know nothing about
- 30:38immigration. I know nothing about the law.
- 30:40I'm the last person that you would ask to solve a visa
- 30:44problem. And yet it was presented in as a
- 30:50way of me being the perfect person to help with this, right.
- 30:55So you see the, the, the conundrum of it.
- 31:02So how do you get out of a helpless loop?
- 31:04I, I can actually tell you how to do that.
- 31:08You just say, Oh my God, that's a terrible problem.
- 31:10What are you going to do? And then they, then they have
- 31:17to, they have to solve it. Or you sometimes when it seems
- 31:21like they've already solved it, you can say, oh, that was a
- 31:24terrible problem. What did you do?
- 31:26And then they'll just tell you what they did to solve the
- 31:29problem. Is that making sense?
- 31:36When we look at the preoccupation, and particularly
- 31:38when we put it into, say, a work context, because preoccupied
- 31:42people don't explore well. They make very good support
- 31:45people for somebody who does or so you'll notice the, the upper
- 31:49echelon of, of the hierarchical structure of these teams is
- 31:54somebody who can explore and somebody who has an idea of what
- 31:58the exploration could be. And then the next layer down or
- 32:01the next couple of layers down or more preoccupied people who
- 32:05are very good at helping to manifest somebody else's
- 32:10exploration because they don't have to come up with the
- 32:13direction themselves. That making sense.
- 32:20You know, the Peter Principle where you're promoted one level
- 32:23above what you can actually do you, you can't promote a
- 32:29preoccupied person into a position of exploring this.
- 32:32They don't really know how to do it.
- 32:35So they, they, they are better in in that supporting position
- 32:38than they are in the direction position.
- 32:41But they can be quite excellent in that that position.
- 32:48But if you were a preoccupied person, that would continue to
- 32:52lead to the deprivation of not engaging in your own
- 32:59exploration. It's not satisfying ultimately
- 33:03to support somebody else's exploration.
- 33:06We really do have to figure out how to do this for ourselves.
- 33:12And when you look at the core of the difficulty for the
- 33:15preoccupied person, it's the dependence on external emotional
- 33:19regulation, it's the dependence on proximity to a regulator that
- 33:24keeps them confined and unable to explore independently.
- 33:30And so the first part of this process is beginning to develop
- 33:34the capacity to emotionally regulate yourself independent of
- 33:39proximity to a regulator so that you have the space to begin the
- 33:45the journey of exploration. The other, I think of it as a
- 33:51bummer in terms of the nature of these things as you, you're all
- 33:55the way into adulthood and the restrictions on your early
- 34:01exploration have left your capacity to explore without
- 34:06resilience. And one of the other things
- 34:08about people who are good at exploring is the capacity or
- 34:14resilience. And when you really begin to
- 34:18understand the nature of exploration, what you know is
- 34:22that most of the avenues of exploration that you're pursued
- 34:26are fruitless. What does that mean?
- 34:31It means that the, the the depth of meaning that you were looking
- 34:35for in that Ave. of inquiry that you engaged in does not produce
- 34:41the meaning that you want. And if you're a seasoned
- 34:45explorer, you understand that and it's always been like that.
- 34:49And you just take it into the into the process of exploring
- 34:54and you gather the information that you need to know from that
- 34:57Ave. and shift into another Ave. of exploration.
- 35:00Because when you do find that depth of meaning, it's so
- 35:04rewarding. It makes total sense that you
- 35:07would do that. But what you're just starting
- 35:10out and you two or three of these avenues don't pan out and
- 35:15you don't have resilience. It can be quite defeating.
- 35:20And so you with you stop exploring until the, the quality
- 35:25of the deprivation becomes so great you can't bear that
- 35:28anymore. And then you begin another foray
- 35:32into exploration. And if two or three of the
- 35:36avenues don't pan out again, it's too disappointing and you
- 35:39withdraw from the exploration. So part of this is a cognitive
- 35:44understanding of the nature of exploration and that most of the
- 35:48time it doesn't pan out, but that's actually easy to just
- 35:54then move on from the then stopping that making sense.
- 35:59And then really in order to to take the the level of risk that
- 36:06you need to take to really find out the things that you need to
- 36:09know, you need a safety net. Just we're talking some high
- 36:14wire stuff here. Are you free to get onto the
- 36:19high wire and to dance, but with no safety net, then then plunge
- 36:25to your death on the cold ground is inhibiting, right?
- 36:31Whereas if you have a safety net and it doesn't matter whether
- 36:34you fall off the high wire, you can take some extraordinary
- 36:38risks for meaning. And what is the safety net?
- 36:42So what you need to begin to develop is this intimate
- 36:46collection of people around you who will catch you emotionally
- 36:51when you fall. Which means you're going to have
- 36:54to come out of pretend mode and begin to tell people who you
- 37:01really are. Which means you're going to have
- 37:03to develop the capacity to know that, which means you're going
- 37:07to have to come into a higher level of mentalizing that than
- 37:12what you might be used to. Is that all making sense?
- 37:19All of this is doable. I think one of the one of the
- 37:22things that really is important to understand is all of these
- 37:26skills that you need to be able to do all of this.
- 37:29You can learn and you can learn it in a in a basic meditation
- 37:33practice. You don't need some miraculous
- 37:39solution. Who did?
- 37:45How long do you think? I mean, you've worked with a lot
- 37:48of students. How long do you think it's worth
- 37:50exploring one thing? Because I think I also have some
- 37:54sort of black and white thinking when I start something and there
- 37:58has to be meaning. Almost like I'm expecting this
- 38:03feeling of meaning coming in in this next the second session.
- 38:08Right. So in some sense it's it's the
- 38:15fostering of curiosity. The one of the ways that it's
- 38:25often characterized as peak moments, I think is one of the
- 38:30cultural ideas about this. What I think is that really the,
- 38:40the, the orientation is toward doing your very best in
- 38:44everything in every moment, doing the best that you can do,
- 38:50which creates a a sense of meaningfulness in in in the
- 38:55ordinary stuff. The reason for that is so much
- 38:58of life is ordinary, so much of life is repetitious.
- 39:02We, we, we have day long cycles that the older you get, of
- 39:08course the shorter they are in terms of a percentage of the
- 39:14whole just mathematically, but also the experience of the
- 39:18repetition of them. How do you then make all of the
- 39:23stuff meaningful, all of the little stuff meaningful, but
- 39:27deriving some little bit of meaning on it that then supports
- 39:30the the current of, of examining things for meaning so that when
- 39:35you do stumble into something that has the potential for huge
- 39:39insight that you're, you're able to take it.
- 39:44Is that making sense? And it it is not a disregard for
- 39:48things that don't immediately have that intoxicating quality
- 39:51to them and only pursuing the ones that are the the the very
- 39:57intense experiences so that in some sense there's an equanimity
- 40:02to the process and then ease a non attachment is Christian was
- 40:10alluding to we we can attach easily to these peak moments and
- 40:14it in some sense then devalues everything else.
- 40:18Although there's a little bit of meaning that can be skimmed off,
- 40:21pretty much everything that you engage every moment, every
- 40:36moment. Well, when you think about it,
- 40:37every moment in the human condition is a stunning event,
- 40:43even though sometimes it's repetitious.
- 40:48The the quality of sacredness is in every moment.
- 40:51Can you identify that and allow the experience of that?
- 41:01And you see it rushing by at the extraordinary pace it goes.
- 41:10Sometimes Shinzen used to talk about it as as bodhichitta.
- 41:17The heart breaks open and then you become more oriented to
- 41:21people, you become more oriented to the exchange with other
- 41:26people. And I know that in childhoods
- 41:29that produce adverse attachment conditioning, we don't really
- 41:34see other people as this extraordinary benefit to us.
- 41:39In fact, sometimes we we have a reluctance to be in relationship
- 41:45to other people because our experience of other people.
- 41:49And I'm not in any way challenging your perception of
- 41:53this. You're correct.
- 41:53They weren't reliable. They didn't provide well, it
- 41:57wasn't worth it. That doesn't mean all people are
- 42:03like that. That's one of those cognitive
- 42:06pieces. And in order to explore deeply,
- 42:09you have to be able to connect to people who will support you
- 42:12because you can't make it. You can't take the level of risk
- 42:16that you need to if you have no support, because if it goes
- 42:19badly, you won't be able to re regulate yourself and the the
- 42:24periods of dysregulation will be too long and too interruptive.
- 42:29Is that making sense? So with preoccupied people,
- 42:37which maybe I'll wrap this up and then we can do a little bit
- 42:41of practice. What needs to happen is you need
- 42:47to improve your mentalizing enough, which is done through
- 42:51practice that you can begin to emotionally regulate yourself
- 42:56and begin to really see clearly the mind state of the other and
- 43:00your own mind state. And each time you notice that
- 43:04whole of the ameshing mind into the other's mind state, you turn
- 43:08your attention back in to your own emotional state.
- 43:12So that you swap out your own emotional states as the primary
- 43:18experience from the empathetic experience of the other, which
- 43:22has been flipped by the requirement of the caregiver
- 43:27that involved you in their mind states.
- 43:31And then begin to tolerate the the the lack of experience of
- 43:38exploring that you have sometimes a sense of humor about
- 43:43it is good. And sometimes getting people to
- 43:47help you in a way that fosters you and is for the purpose of
- 43:51exploration and not the helplessness of that is really
- 43:56about proximity. So you're really moving in the
- 44:00direction of exploring and then begin to discern simply what
- 44:04means more to you from your engagement in something and
- 44:08directing yourself more and more in the direction of meaning so
- 44:14that you have the agency to fulfill your your own life
- 44:23without being dependent on a vicarious relationship to
- 44:29somebody else's exploration. That making sense.
- 44:36Viva, hi. Thank you for this.
- 44:42I've been wanting to join for a while but haven't been available
- 44:45at this time of day. And just of a curiosity, I, I
- 44:49grew up in a very like conservative, highly like
- 44:55gendered society in terms of conventional gender roles.
- 44:58And I'm curious if there's any sort of distribution of a
- 45:05gendered distribution when it comes to these different types
- 45:09of attachment. Well, because preoccupied people
- 45:14mainly form relationships with dismissing people, they're the
- 45:17same number of of. OK, so if you look at A and it,
- 45:24it's more likely that class has an effect on attachment than it
- 45:29is gender. The the if you grow up in a
- 45:33resource community, it it has a very different effect than if
- 45:37you grow up in a non resource community.
- 45:41But let's say 20% of people are dismissing and 20% of people are
- 45:47preoccupied and there's an even distribution across the sexes.
- 45:53Mainly what you're looking at is you have an 85% chance of having
- 45:57developing the same attachment strategy as your primary
- 46:01caregiver, which means if your mother is dismissing, but
- 46:06doesn't matter what sex you are, you'll develop that strategy,
- 46:10right? So in your household, if you had
- 46:13a preoccupied mother and you grew up to be preoccupied, which
- 46:17is the stereotypical role of a female in our culture, but you
- 46:21had a brother, they would also be preoccupied.
- 46:25I see. So what causes that stereotype
- 46:31like or what contributes to it? Power and the distribution of
- 46:38resources and mainly in the West it's about property and heredity
- 46:49that I think that creates these stereotypes.
- 46:54There is some biological difference between men and women
- 47:01are males and females. You know, if you separate gender
- 47:03from sex, there's biological imperatives that are associated,
- 47:08but it isn't so much around ability or around gender
- 47:13identity. If you look at the the the I'm
- 47:25referencing John Money from John Hopkins when I talk about this
- 47:30and I don't I haven't really found something that I like
- 47:33better than that. But you have in the the
- 47:40development of the sexes Chrome chromosomal sex.
- 47:44Sorry if this is too granular, but.
- 47:47Oh, so it's very interesting to me.
- 47:49Thank. You so XY and XX, there's a
- 47:55hormonal change. So depending on on whether you
- 47:59have a normal range of hormonal receptivity, it will change the
- 48:03characteristics of the physical body.
- 48:05But you also have a brain, all zygotes are female.
- 48:10So everybody starts with a female oriented brain.
- 48:14And there's a process of hormonalization of the brain
- 48:17where if you have XY and you're going to develop into a male,
- 48:22the brain is first defeminized and then masculinized.
- 48:28But in dependent, let's say you you your mother took
- 48:32barbiturates while you were in the third trimester and that
- 48:35interfered with the masculinization or the
- 48:38feminization of the brain. You would you would be born in
- 48:42the genetic sex body, but you would have a different
- 48:44orientation brain wise than you might.
- 48:48Then you're born and you grow up in a family system and depending
- 48:52on the gender role acceptance in the family system, you would
- 48:56learn to be the the gender role that is assigned to you in your
- 49:02family system. Which would hold for most people
- 49:05throughout childhood until puberty.
- 49:08And then when puberty happens, you have the cognitive ability
- 49:13to then make a gender assignment for yourself, which is one of
- 49:16the things that happens in in adolescence now a lot of the
- 49:22times, because there's a greater flexibility in in gender roles.
- 49:33And there's a natural experimentation that happens in
- 49:36that post puberty adolescent phase of trying to understand
- 49:42what what identity you might like to have.
- 49:46And if you had the freedom to explore it, then you could, you
- 49:49could manifest a lot of different versions and then
- 49:53settle into one. But there's also an arbitrary
- 49:57quality to the assignment of capacities based on male and
- 50:02female. For instance, I think that
- 50:05largely the men's movement as we see it now are preoccupied men
- 50:11who identify that as feminine and want to be dismissing
- 50:18because that's been identified as masculine.
- 50:23And it's and it's unbearable when you lock yourself into
- 50:27these rigid identities that are based on cultural and not based
- 50:32on either the family system or the biology of what's really
- 50:36true. So the these stereotypes also
- 50:41create certain pressures. Right to conform.
- 50:45And if you're not good at conforming, of course, it
- 50:47creates the perception that you're not lovable in childhood.
- 50:52Of course, then then it also creates the perception that your
- 50:57authentic expression is not acceptable.
- 51:01Then you begin to hide your authentic expression.
- 51:03And the more you hide your authentic expression, the
- 51:06greater the the experience of deprivation is because you're
- 51:10never really expressing who you are, and that's never being
- 51:14satisfied. And who you are expressing is
- 51:17not who you are. And even if that is satisfied,
- 51:20it's not satisfied. That making sense.
- 51:26And then we also have the heteronormative thing where if
- 51:29you identify as female at Trump's biological sex and if
- 51:35you identify as male at Trump's biological sex, which is to
- 51:42great advantage to to to the male population and great
- 51:46disadvantage to the female population.
- 51:50But it's already extremely disadvantaged to the female
- 51:54population. So why would that bother men?
- 51:57Really? That makes sense.
- 52:00Mm Hmm. OK.
- 52:06There's so many more questions that just came up from you
- 52:10saying what you said, but I'll stay with the curiosity.
- 52:13Thank you. I'm, I'm a big component
- 52:21proponent of androgyny that yeah, you should have a whole
- 52:30spectrum to choose from and choose whatever it feels as a
- 52:36representation of an authentic expression of yourself, right?
- 52:41Yeah, I grew up in one very particular, very gendered and
- 52:46stereotypical society. And now I live in North America
- 52:51and my teenage child is non binary.
- 52:54So I'm definitely like aware of the spectrum.
- 52:58But I think that I was noticing as you were talking particularly
- 53:01about preoccupied. And I've noticed this also in
- 53:04other things I've listened to you say that, you know, as my as
- 53:09I'm listening, my mind will come up with examples that I'm
- 53:12familiar with from my day-to-day life.
- 53:14And they're often female people or in there.
- 53:20It's gendered in that sense. And so I was wondering if that
- 53:22was due to the stereotype and pressures that our society puts
- 53:29on gender or if it's just like what I see if I'm my own.
- 53:33But I was just just curious to hear what you had to say about
- 53:35it. So thank you for that.
- 53:40Do we do a little practice? OK, let go of the meditation.
- 53:54How's that? George The sense of self, when
- 54:07that arises, it's very clear to me every time.
- 54:13But it just takes up. It just takes the whole space,
- 54:19the mind. It's almost like it would just
- 54:22draw so much attention to it and they would stay there.
- 54:29Maybe a part of me doesn't want that.
- 54:34Well, it has a lot of grab. I'm doing this, I'm in charge of
- 54:40this, I'm the author of this, I'm the controller of this
- 54:43compelling. So then the question is, if you
- 54:53restrict the focus to a narrower and narrow portion of each of
- 54:58the sense gates in order to have the self experience, it's a
- 55:02fairly broad focus. You zoom in on one of the sense
- 55:07gates, it's going to be hard to manifest the sense of self in
- 55:10that space. And you would do the self
- 55:13inquiry wherein visual experience is the self, you
- 55:17can't find it, where it's an where an auditory experience is
- 55:21the self and you can't find it. Then you pop pop open to
- 55:29internal thinking and the body emotion and and the purple part
- 55:34of it and that's the self. Fantastic.
- 55:44And, you know, it's, it's meant for Comic Relief mostly.
- 55:55The great organizing principle of all things, the self in our
- 56:03in our limited experience. Although it does look outside
- 56:06the scope of see here feel, for me it sounds like it's a fourth
- 56:09thing. Right, it's well see here feel.
- 56:15It's usually internal visual thinking, internal auditory
- 56:18thinking. Emotion and the physical quality
- 56:22of the body is what creates the perception of self.
- 56:27Feels like something else. What's that?
- 56:31I don't know how to describe it. It's the synthesis of that
- 56:38space. There is a feel out.
- 56:44In there. Yeah, definitely.
- 56:49Bye Christian, I was doing a. Whole great litigation in my
- 57:01head. So I was bouncing between here
- 57:03and feel, but I found it. I found I'd get really lost in
- 57:11the threat of my argumentation and like it'd be hard for me to
- 57:15like keep the noting of here and actually keep the argument
- 57:20going, which may maybe I don't need to keep the argument going,
- 57:24but I kind of, I just noticed that was kind of a hard, hard
- 57:29thing to to both track and kind of stay in the here space.
- 57:35If we talk about it from the mentalizing perspective, it's
- 57:38you're slipping into the spontaneous side and losing the
- 57:42monitoring side. You want to tighten up the
- 57:45brain, tighten up the experience and monitor harder so you don't
- 57:51get swept up into the spontaneity.
- 57:55Yeah, I it seemed like when I could get back to the noting and
- 58:01kind of tighten up, I would I would lose, I would lose that
- 58:04thread, which it's a lot of ruminating, but.
- 58:09That's the balance, right? If you over tighten, of course
- 58:13the spontaneity goes away and so the flow of the internal chatter
- 58:18is it interfered with. So there's a a a balance that
- 58:23was absent. See, I guess I've noticed in my
- 58:29meditating, maintaining that balance in here space seems to
- 58:33be kind of the most difficult 1 for me.
- 58:39More to do everyone OK so really the only thing we have left
- 58:51coming up this year since everything's already started and
- 58:55is chugging along is the exploration half day that's at
- 59:01the end of the month. And we really going to focus on
- 59:07advanced mentalizing is how I like to talk it how in the in
- 59:12the preliminary classes, we really focus on basic
- 59:17mentalizing, which is the development of just a way of
- 59:20relating and all the way up to meaning making and something
- 59:24that you can mentalize. And we talked in the last
- 59:27exploration workshop on the intermediate set of mentalizing.
- 59:32And so in this workshop, we're really going to focus on the
- 59:35advanced set, which is really what you need to go into deep
- 59:39practice, but also in, in a way of reflecting on your, your own
- 59:45authentic expression and, and what that actually means and how
- 59:50you assign meaning to things and, and how it's represented.
- 59:54All of those things are in that advanced set.
- 59:57So we'll talk about that. And then I was also gonna talk
- 1:00:01about how that expression in over the course of a so a
- 1:00:07lifetime of exploring how. That represents in the say, the,
- 1:00:13the youthful explorations of my 20s and later 40s and 50s and
- 1:00:21then what's happening now. You'll see, I think how that
- 1:00:29that capacity to explore, but also the the the, the the lack
- 1:00:34of the more there is a lack of interference with the authentic
- 1:00:41expression, how it represents itself differently in in a
- 1:00:45visual expression of that. So that's the idea of it anyway.
- 1:00:50Take a look at that. Ioffer the teaching freely.
- 1:00:53But I do hope that if you're a resource and you can make a
- 1:00:55donation that you will and help support me and also the work
- 1:00:58that's better group is doing. There's a link on the website to
- 1:01:01do that. Really appreciate your practice.
- 1:01:03Thanks for being here. We will see you soon, I hope,
- 1:01:06somewhere. Bye.