Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Using CCP §998 Offers in Employment Discrimination Cases
Transcript
- 0:03My name is Andi Fields. I'm the chair of the
- 0:06BHBA's employment law section and attorney at
- 0:09the Jeannie Harrison law firm. I am delighted
- 0:12to introduce our speaker today, Sean Novak. Sean
- 0:16is the founding partner of the Novak law firm,
- 0:18PC, where he focuses his practice on representing
- 0:21individuals and employment discrimination and
- 0:23other civil rights matters. A seasoned trial
- 0:26attorney with more than 25 years of experience,
- 0:29Sean has litigated cases throughout California
- 0:31and nationwide, securing over $250 million in
- 0:35verdicts and settlements for his clients. Before
- 0:37dedicating his practice to plaintiff's advocacy,
- 0:40Sean represented entertainment companies, large
- 0:42corporations, and insurers in high exposure defense
- 0:45matters, giving him valuable insight into defense
- 0:48strategies that he now leverages on behalf of
- 0:50employees. And now I'll turn it over to you,
- 0:52Sean. Thank you. Thank you very much and good
- 0:56afternoon everyone and thank you for joining
- 0:58us today. Really appreciate the interest in this
- 1:01topic. I discussed the etiology of this topic.
- 1:07comes from a recent discussion I was having with
- 1:10an opposing counsel on a matter where they said
- 1:12in an employment discrimination matter where
- 1:15they said why do plaintiffs serve 998s anymore
- 1:19in employment discrimination cases and it was
- 1:23a good question and we were you know having a
- 1:26you know nice discussion civil civil discussion
- 1:30a civil litigation matter which is refreshing
- 1:32when it happens and and that became a discussion
- 1:38that I felt was a, let's say, of the moment topic
- 1:43based on the fluctuations in the law that are
- 1:48occurring with regard to Code of Civil Procedures
- 1:52998 in cases involving fee claims or Fair Employment
- 1:57and Housing Act claims, government code sections
- 2:00relating to discrimination, harassment, and retaliation
- 2:03in the workplace. You know, one of the things
- 2:08when we look at the Code of Suba Procedure Section
- 2:10998 as a tool within litigation is that if we
- 2:17look at the lifespan of a lawsuit from inception
- 2:23to the conclusion, it is one of the most important
- 2:30tools that can be used through the litigation
- 2:35process. And so I consider it if we look at the
- 2:39first slide or next slide on this, I think it
- 2:44was fair to put it into one of the three pillars
- 2:47of effective litigation. There's kind of three
- 2:51giant moments in a civil litigation matter. The
- 2:56filing of the lawsuit if you're the plaintiff,
- 2:58the filing of a responsive pleading or series
- 3:01of responsive pleadings depending on you know
- 3:04whether demersed motions to strike judgment on
- 3:06pleadings get granted and that process but the
- 3:10initiating or responding in the initial pleading
- 3:14and then towards the very end one of the biggest
- 3:17milestones and most litigation is the expert
- 3:20designation in that discovery process. The middle
- 3:24section of the entire case is the civil discovery
- 3:27and all the things that happen the tools that
- 3:30are used but It's really file lawsuit, expert
- 3:33discovery, and then you've got the event, which
- 3:35is the trial. But mixed in there, it are significant
- 3:40milestones where CODESU Procedure Section 998
- 3:44offers to compromise are interplaying. And so
- 3:49they come to have significant importance throughout
- 3:54the litigation process because of the burden
- 3:59shifting, because of the cost and fee shifting,
- 4:02all of these consequences of an effective 998
- 4:07that can materially alter the strategy of the
- 4:12case, the decision even to go to trial for settling.
- 4:17And so I think that it does it. It fills in as
- 4:22one of the most significant events within the
- 4:25litigation process, but it's not a specific timing.
- 4:28I mean, within the code, it just needs to be
- 4:32within the last, you know, 10 days before the
- 4:36trial or 30 days or 10 days before trial, whichever
- 4:39happens, the first incense or last, depending
- 4:43on the perspective. But you can use them right
- 4:47up to the edge of trial. Trial isn't deemed to
- 4:50start until a jury is impaneled. So, Sometimes
- 4:53people will make that recognition who probably
- 4:56should have served one or one more and there
- 4:59may be within that last 10 -day window Plus service
- 5:03whether electronic or mail and you're adding
- 5:06a couple of days But because you might not actually
- 5:09impen on the jury for several more days after
- 5:11the quote first date of trial There often can
- 5:15still be time for one last 998 to get in there
- 5:19and so if we We look at the next slide here.
- 5:26Because this is a general audience, and I don't
- 5:30always know specifically the level of experience
- 5:34that everyone attending is going to have, let's
- 5:36start with a quick refresher. What is the Code
- 5:40of Civil Procedure Section 998 offer to compromise?
- 5:44And I'm not going to go into all the history
- 5:46in every single detail. There are thousands of
- 5:50articles on Section 998. And the goal here today
- 5:53is to talk about more practical considerations,
- 5:56practical application, how we can use this. And
- 5:59then within that lens of an employment fee hot
- 6:01case, how you could use the 998 offer to compromise
- 6:06to your best advantage through the course of
- 6:08the litigation. So the code itself, Section 998,
- 6:14has two important functions that it contemplates.
- 6:17One, is the penalty aspect, the shifting of costs
- 6:21if the opponent fails to obtain a better result.
- 6:25And that's really when you look at legislative
- 6:27history, the express language of the section,
- 6:31code section itself, it really is about that.
- 6:34It's establishing, recognizing that there is
- 6:39a good public policy and parties reaching informal
- 6:42resolution. It creates within California a burden
- 6:47shifting shifting costs if an opponent fails
- 6:51to obtain a better result. Now, it can also impact
- 6:56recovery of expert fees, attorney's fees, and
- 6:58interest following trial. But it can impact either
- 7:03side no matter who propounded it. Because if
- 7:06you fail to get a better result, but you are
- 7:08still a technically prevailing party at the conclusion
- 7:13of a trial or arbitration, the failing to obtain
- 7:16a better result can deny expert fees and expert
- 7:20costs and can turn what looked like a win into
- 7:25a loss. So Section 998 is a constant tool within
- 7:31essentially all litigation. There's very few
- 7:35litigation matters where it won't have some use
- 7:40within the case. Looking still at the overview,
- 7:46if we go looking at the next slide, I create
- 7:48a little visual example here or ask the question,
- 7:55well, is the legislative framework for code of
- 7:57civil procedure section 998 fairly balanced for
- 8:00the parties? Generally speaking, as we all know,
- 8:04we have a plaintiff, we have a defendant in a
- 8:06case, we have cross complaints, we have third
- 8:09party beneficiaries, but generally there's plaintiff
- 8:11and a defendant. And when we look at Section
- 8:14998, the question that we can consider is, is
- 8:19the statute fairly balanced between the plaintiff
- 8:23side and the defense side? And if we look at
- 8:27the next slide, starting with language in Section
- 8:32998C, it's applicable to defense offers. And
- 8:37I'm not going to read the whole code section
- 8:39in here. But what we see is it creates that cost
- 8:42shifting risk for a plaintiff to have to consider
- 8:46when receiving one. They come in and as a practical
- 8:52matter, they should always, always, always be
- 8:55shared with the client immediately. There's a
- 8:58number of both ethical and legal reasons to do
- 9:02it. It's good practice. Generally, as soon as
- 9:06it comes in because the offer is going to have
- 9:08a 30 -day window to accept or reject, or it's
- 9:12going to be deemed rejected. And of course, it
- 9:14comes in by electronic or mail. Hello, Sean.
- 9:29It looks like your video cut out for a brief
- 9:31moment. Oh, thank you. I believe you'd mentioned
- 9:35mail. I think that's when it started to cut out.
- 9:38Oh, okay. Sorry. You know, in Manhattan Beach,
- 9:42sometimes the weather can impact Wi -Fi. So,
- 9:45I apologize. Are we good again? Yes. Okay. Thank
- 9:49you. So, you know, whether you're adding two
- 9:53or five days for the mail, electronic or mail,
- 9:57there's a 30 -day window at its basic to communicate.
- 10:03And so, you want to make sure you get that to
- 10:04the client right away because the consequence
- 10:09of not accepting one, it needs to be a discussion
- 10:13that's had with the client without just letting
- 10:15it lapse. All of the risks and benefits should
- 10:18be shared. That's a practical recommendation.
- 10:23And there are, again, there's legal and ethical
- 10:25reasons why it's essential. Hi Sean, it looks
- 10:39like the connection did drop again when you were
- 10:43discussing legal and ethical matters. Hi there.
- 11:11Yes, you were discussing legal and ethical matters.
- 11:15Yes, I'm sorry. I was resisting going to a cellular
- 11:21connection I could use. We've been having good
- 11:24Wi -Fi lately and so the weather seemed clear,
- 11:27but there's some wind. It seems odd, but yeah,
- 11:29Manhattan Beach actually, we have that. But yeah,
- 11:32with regard to ethical matters, it's essential
- 11:35you share the 998 with your client. It is good
- 11:41practice and it's also it's got both the legal
- 11:44and ethical reasons to do it. And then look looking
- 11:47at the section 998C subsection 2B when we're
- 11:55looking at one of what is a relatively recent
- 11:58amendment to the code, the legislature put in
- 12:04an express carve out in response to the decision
- 12:07in Encinitas Plaza Real V. Knight, 209 Calab
- 12:123, 996 expressly stating that attorney's fees
- 12:17awarded to the prevailing party were not cost
- 12:20for purposes of the section, but were part of
- 12:23the judgment. And if we go to the next slide,
- 12:27we can focus at that for a moment. This was very
- 12:30important because in a FIHA case particularly,
- 12:35and not exclusively, a prevailing plaintiff is
- 12:39entitled to attorney's fees. And one of the determinations
- 12:43or analysis prior to the legislature amending
- 12:49Section 998 was the ability to include a recovery
- 12:54of attorney's fees in the judgment to make the
- 12:58determination whether you beat a defense 998
- 13:02offer to compromise. and Encinitas Plaza Real
- 13:07said that that was allowed in order for a plaintiff
- 13:11to determine if they obtained a more favorable
- 13:13result compared to a defense offers compromise.
- 13:18The legislature went back and made an amendment
- 13:21to Section 998 in response to that in order to
- 13:26expressly carve out and state you cannot include
- 13:30your attorney's fees in the judgment as a plaintiff
- 13:33to determine if you be a defense 998 offer to
- 13:37compromise. And so that was a big shift. And
- 13:42we'll get into how that can impact your analysis
- 13:46of your own case based on the fact that the attorney's
- 13:51fees cannot be included in the judgment. So if
- 13:54we look at the next slide. Thank you. Section
- 14:03998D is applicable to plaintiffs and it creates
- 14:08its own burden shifting. And if a plaintiff recovers
- 14:13better than the offer, then the plaintiff broadly
- 14:16can recover additional costs that are not contemplated
- 14:20under the Code of Civil Procedure and Civil Code
- 14:24and also expert fees and costs. And so, generally
- 14:29speaking, so not just in a FIHA case, but looking
- 14:33again at, well, how would this impact a decision
- 14:38in a FIHA case about using a 998 as a plaintiff?
- 14:42When plaintiffs are entitled to recover fees
- 14:45and costs is an important consideration because
- 14:50you would say, well, I don't need a 998 to get
- 14:53my fees and my costs because the government code
- 14:55sections, labor code sections, already call for
- 14:57that. But what we see is that as the law, as
- 15:01courts continuously are interpreting these code
- 15:04sections, some of the certainty about or the
- 15:10insurance that a plaintiff would recover these
- 15:13has been eroded. And so it's important to look
- 15:16back at the foundation of the statute to express
- 15:19language. So then if we look at the next slide,
- 15:25Section 998e has additional language that seems
- 15:30to more clearly favor the defense. Again, we
- 15:34were looking at the statute saying, is this balanced?
- 15:37Is this a tool that can be used equally? And
- 15:43I think when we look at Section 9998e, because
- 15:48it gives this additional language and this additional
- 15:51penalty structure, could be, I think, when I'm
- 15:57suggesting that the 998 more often favors a defense.
- 16:00It's trying to encourage settlement and it's
- 16:03trying to create a pressure on a plaintiff. And
- 16:05it certainly does create penalties on defense
- 16:09if you're a plaintiff using it. But when you
- 16:12look at the overall, because as the plaintiff,
- 16:15it can not only prevent you from recovering at
- 16:18all, but at trial or arbitration, but it can
- 16:21seriously dilute even a win. So it can turn a
- 16:25loss into a win. It can turn a win into a loss.
- 16:28But on its balance, one could make the argument
- 16:32that 998 is more typically advantageous to a
- 16:37defense to use. And again, then as we turn that
- 16:40lens narrower, zooming in on what about the FIHA
- 16:44case where section 998 burden shifting is much
- 16:51more limited the advantage was intended to go
- 16:54more towards the plaintiff. We can see, you know,
- 16:57as we go along some of the changes in the law
- 17:00that make that still an uncertain situation to
- 17:04rely only on the code sections, bringing 998
- 17:07back into a necessary tool to use by the plaintiff
- 17:12also. And so if we look at the next slide, one
- 17:17of the things I want to do is just show the comparison
- 17:19with federal rules. Rule 68 of the Federal Rules
- 17:22of Civil Procedure is, in some ways, closely
- 17:29aligned with Section 998. But one of the key
- 17:32things in a Rule 68 offer of judgment is that
- 17:35only a party defending against the claim may
- 17:39serve it. And so if there's a cross -complaint
- 17:42and you're the cross -defendant, even though
- 17:44you're also the plaintiff, it can be used but
- 17:47only as, typically it's only used in that context,
- 17:50back against the cross complaint. But it's a
- 17:53defense -oriented statute. It's intended to create
- 17:56burdens and penalties in federal court if a plaintiff
- 18:00does not accept an offer under Rule 68. But there
- 18:06is no equivalent in federal rules for a plaintiff.
- 18:10So if we look at to the extent the legislature
- 18:14used Rule 68 in its analysis or creation of Code
- 18:20of Civil Procedure Section 998 where you can
- 18:23see probably or like I said I think it still
- 18:27supports the argument that Section 998 is more
- 18:32advantageous to the defense as a tool a majority
- 18:35of the time. So you say okay if you're doing
- 18:41plaintiff work which I do the vast majority of
- 18:44my work is is plaintiff consumers consumer side,
- 18:47either personal injury or plaintiff representing
- 18:50employees in FIHA claims, discrimination, harassment,
- 18:54retaliation. Say, OK, well, where does the 998
- 18:58still fit into the tools that I'm going to use
- 19:04as representing a plaintiff? And again, going
- 19:07back to the theme here, which is it has a lot
- 19:10of use. And practically speaking, it is very
- 19:12useful. And so if we look To the next slide here,
- 19:17just to give a little outline of these points.
- 19:24Thank you. Why does this matter in employment
- 19:27cases? Well, first off, there's the potential
- 19:30for attorney's fees recovery, which in a lot
- 19:34of employment cases, when you're the plaintiff,
- 19:37the attorney's fees are a significant value risk.
- 19:45To the defense often I did defense for many years.
- 19:50I still do some defense and I defended many in
- 19:53employment claims and defense will say, you know,
- 19:56it's blanket We don't see any value in this case.
- 19:59What's our risk? What's our risk and it's a legitimate
- 20:02response to say well your risk is that maybe
- 20:05the jury doesn't award a substantial amount in
- 20:10actual damages But the attorney's fees to get
- 20:13there are not capped or limited by statute. And
- 20:16so the attorney fees can vastly exceed the value
- 20:21in quotes perceived by the defense as something
- 20:24the defense has to look at. And it's a real discussion
- 20:28that should be had with a client in terms of
- 20:33litigation strategy is to say, well, maybe the
- 20:35plaintiff doesn't have a they didn't work there
- 20:38very long or It was a narrow set of circumstances
- 20:42and say, well, we think we can bottle it or contain
- 20:46it. So what about the attorney's fees and the
- 20:48cost? So under FIHA, the prevailing plaintiff
- 20:53is entitled. Not the prevailing defense unless
- 20:55they can prove it's a frivolous case. And the
- 20:58burden is fairly high on that. Not impossible,
- 21:00but the vast majority of time, the defense is
- 21:04not going to be able to shift. back and try and
- 21:07recover attorney's fees if they defend a case.
- 21:10So even a win on defense can be a loss because
- 21:14they kept the value down but the attorney's fees
- 21:16and costs are substantial or maybe they prevent
- 21:21the plaintiff from a recovery but the client
- 21:23has spent three times the value of the case defending
- 21:27something and they can't recoup any of that from
- 21:29the plaintiff. And same with cost. The FIHA does
- 21:32not shift cost back to a plaintiff. even expert
- 21:36costs. And then when we look in employment cases,
- 21:42there was a window of time that's still open
- 21:47where the legislature and within the case law
- 21:51that's relevant denies a defense any cost, even
- 21:57expert costs, if a plaintiff is not the prevailing
- 22:01party. But as we're going to talk about there
- 22:05are some more recent very recent cases that are
- 22:07seeming to shift the pendulum a little closer
- 22:10back to the defense which again makes the plaintiff
- 22:13have to reevaluate whether to consider a defense
- 22:19998 if it shows up because i say you had about
- 22:21a good six year window of being able to say i'm
- 22:25going to ignore this defense 998 because it doesn't
- 22:27have any real teeth to it but that pendulum is
- 22:30shifting ever so slightly and maybe it shifts
- 22:33more. And so understanding section 998 gives
- 22:38you that additional leverage in negotiations.
- 22:41Understanding the law, the underpinnings, your
- 22:43strategic evaluation of your own case, your damage
- 22:47model allows you to let's say keep the ultimate
- 22:53goal in mind which is to bring the matter to
- 22:55resolution whether by informal or through trial
- 22:59or arbitration and get that recovery for your
- 23:02client. That is the goal. And so, one of the
- 23:08key points we'll look at also is to try everything
- 23:12possible to avoid drafting mistakes. Because
- 23:15an errant word can cost significant fees post
- 23:18-judgment. And I'm going to talk at length about
- 23:22some of the more on the practical side. The law
- 23:27says one thing we all know. The law says one
- 23:29thing. Case law says another and then application
- 23:32of that case law and those statutes to your specific
- 23:35facts depending on the courtroom depending on
- 23:37the judge depending on the venue You know, we
- 23:41can get a wide variety of results and and that
- 23:44keeps you on your toes practicing law But it's
- 23:46the reality is well the law says one thing But
- 23:50well, I mean the job our job is to find exceptions,
- 23:53right? And so sometimes an exception is going
- 23:55to get applied to you that I think you know as
- 23:58Even if you say it hasn't happened yet say never
- 24:01just means not yet. So looking to say how can
- 24:05we mitigate or reduce? Let's just say unpleasant
- 24:10law in motion that was the result of small drafting
- 24:13mistakes that maybe go undetected Ways that you
- 24:18can craft the 998 and customize it to your own
- 24:21case so that Looking down the road when you win
- 24:26gonna win and get that result for your client
- 24:29that you preserve that result. Because there's
- 24:33nothing worse than losing or having it taken
- 24:36away, having that victory snatched out of your
- 24:39hands because of technical issues that could
- 24:45have been spotted and addressed beforehand. If
- 24:53we take a look down to the next slide. One of
- 24:58the things we look at is how does section 998
- 25:01interact with fee? Say well We know fair housing
- 25:05act allows for family plaintiff to recover attorneys
- 25:07fees is expressed and there is ample case law
- 25:11that says that that is one of the important Let's
- 25:17say enforcement mechanisms of the Fair Employment
- 25:20Housing Act is to because of the mismatch or
- 25:24often the economic a disparity between an employer
- 25:28and the employee in the workplace, allowing access
- 25:34to the court and encouraging attorneys to take
- 25:38on these cases and help individuals that are
- 25:44claiming or have been subjected to retaliation,
- 25:47harassment, discrimination, labor code violations,
- 25:50wage hour. violations within the workplace. We
- 25:54won't need a public policy is recognized. We
- 25:56want to see attorneys taking these cases and
- 25:58there is public service in this. A vast majority
- 26:01of my clients are employees and they would not
- 26:04be able to have the means to retain counsel,
- 26:08effective counsel for them without the fee enforcement
- 26:13mechanisms. And so it's one of those things that
- 26:21Often when you're having dialogue with the defense
- 26:24when you're in the plaintiff's side, they don't
- 26:25want to talk about you. Oh, well, you know, they
- 26:28just want to tell you your case has no value.
- 26:30Your case has no value and say, well, you know,
- 26:33we take a look. The FIHA doesn't put any limits
- 26:36on our attorney's fees on the plaintiff's side.
- 26:39So, just like doesn't put any limits on the defense
- 26:41attorney's fees. They're free to bill their client
- 26:43whatever contractually they've agreed to. So,
- 26:48of course, you should track your time. when you're
- 26:51on the plaintiff's side doing FIHA cases, it's
- 26:53a good idea to maintain your time sheets as if
- 26:56it was a billable case because more often than
- 26:59you might expect or hope, you're itemizing that
- 27:03time and it's good to be able to not, you know,
- 27:06to have a good itemized bill is good practice.
- 27:09It's a recommendation. And so, what we look at
- 27:15though, it's not enough to say, well, we get
- 27:18our attorney's fees, we'll just hammer defense
- 27:20with that the whole way because recent case law
- 27:23has shifted to potentially allow defense section
- 27:27998 offers to create limitations on recovery
- 27:31of post offer fees. So for a very long time we
- 27:35go you know go back almost as far as the the
- 27:38government code sections that incorporate or
- 27:41constitute Fair Employment Housing Act. You would
- 27:45see that 998s were used frequently by defense
- 27:49to try to cut off plaintiff attorney's fees at
- 27:54any chance they can get essentially because there
- 27:57was some case law and authority that would support
- 28:01that if a plaintiff did not accept a defense
- 28:05offer to compromise and failed to get a better
- 28:09result at trial, their fees and costs could be
- 28:12cut off from the date of the 998. Then for the
- 28:19law, we have case decisions that evolve and for
- 28:22an extended period of time, the California Supreme
- 28:25Court and Court of Appeals decisions erased that
- 28:29saying, no, the statute is clear. There's an
- 28:32incentivization there for attorneys to take these
- 28:35cases. You can't use a 998 by the defense. Section
- 28:40998 has no language allowing a deprivation of
- 28:45a prevailing plaintiff of the fees and costs.
- 28:48It's expressed by statute. And so, you know,
- 28:53I'd say, you know, the window's been open for
- 28:55a good six years, still open, meaning that the
- 28:59case law is still valid saying, well, defense
- 29:02can't, but we have the new, relatively new decision
- 29:06in Simer's versus Los Angeles Times Communications,
- 29:09LLC, 104, CalAP, 5th, starting at page 940, a
- 29:152024 decision and some case law that's now come
- 29:19from that kind of renewing that view that section
- 29:24998 can create limitations on recovery of post
- 29:30-offer fees in the discretion of the trial court
- 29:33at the moment is how it's phrased and so the
- 29:37trial court would look at whether the 998 was
- 29:39reasonable at the time it was propounded, whether
- 29:43a reasonable plaintiff would have or should have
- 29:45accepted it and could use that determination
- 29:49to limit or reduce the recoverable attorney's
- 29:53fees. Because even though the Fair Employment
- 29:57and Housing Act allows for the recovery of attorney's
- 30:00fees by the prevailing employee plaintiff, it
- 30:04is subject to motion and a determination by the
- 30:07trial court as to reasonableness. And so you
- 30:10can't just put any number down there. It's not,
- 30:12you know, you can't put any rate down there.
- 30:14There's there's if anyone's or I will assume
- 30:17a majority of people have had the experience
- 30:19of doing a fee application. And if you do, you
- 30:22know, you don't always get all your time. Defense
- 30:26also, when they file motions, they don't always
- 30:29get all the time they put down. The court looks
- 30:31at it and makes a determination whether time
- 30:33spent was reasonable. And so it is it is a Let's
- 30:39just say it's a it's a open -ended question what
- 30:42the attorney's fees will be But what we do know
- 30:45is looking at simers and some more recent case
- 30:48decisions There is risk to the plaintiff in a
- 30:52C hot case if they just ignore a 998 from defense
- 30:55And so it still needs to be looked at with all
- 30:59those determinations and I'm going to talk towards
- 31:01the end About a trend. I'm seeing these days
- 31:04in practice for objections to 998s and defense
- 31:11will often serve them making the argument and
- 31:14using recent case law to say the 998 is premature
- 31:17or it's not reasonable or you know just quoting
- 31:21essentially case language but a plaintiff can
- 31:26certainly object to a defense 998 if a defense
- 31:28shoots a 998 across to the plaintiff very early
- 31:33in a case before discovery has really gone underway
- 31:36a decision could be made to send an objection.
- 31:39There's kind of no downside to doing it. Whether
- 31:42or not an objection has any validity would be
- 31:46something to be decided by the trial court at
- 31:48the end of the case anyway and so it's something
- 31:53that is a consideration is that the law is not
- 32:02going to guarantee your fees 100 % and so one
- 32:05has to look at the risk. Because if you ignore
- 32:08a good offer and tell your client I suggest you
- 32:11reject this offer and the client might be inclined
- 32:14to take it Well, you have to understand all those
- 32:18risks and take that into consideration So if
- 32:22we go to the next slide One of the things sorry
- 32:28Yes, thank you So talking about the Cyrus case
- 32:37again, it's an important case that came down
- 32:39and it's relatively recent. The defense is going
- 32:42to come in and try to argue post -offer attorney's
- 32:44fees. And when you're in post -judgment again,
- 32:47you're in that glow of having won and then you're
- 32:49watching your victory chipped away, you know,
- 32:53and so it can be frustrating because you don't
- 32:57have control over that. Your client and you have
- 33:00just gone celebrating and then these post trial
- 33:03motions are the are the zombie aspect of the
- 33:07case after you've secured that very difficult
- 33:09win after the years of protracted litigation
- 33:12that is so common. And that's what we look at.
- 33:16Simon says the court can compare the judgment
- 33:18to the pretrial statutory defense offer and make
- 33:21a determination whether a reasonable plaintiff
- 33:25would have or should have accepted it and use
- 33:27that as a basis to reduce attorney's fees. Because
- 33:30the pendulum was going pretty far towards telling
- 33:34courts that they had to pretty much first stamp
- 33:37a plaintiff fee motion. And so Simers kind of
- 33:43brings that pendulum a little further back towards
- 33:46the middle, if you will, by giving defense stronger
- 33:50arguments to say, okay, even though the plaintiff's
- 33:52entitled under the government code, they're the
- 33:54prevailing party, look, we made a very fair offer
- 33:57and they didn't do better. And so court could
- 34:00then use that. And then again, going to that
- 34:06theme that sometimes and I'm not suggesting that
- 34:11recovery fees should be a driver for litigation.
- 34:15It's something that is a risk benefit analysis
- 34:20for both sides to be using and it is a statutory
- 34:24recovery that is intended but I don't think when
- 34:31I think most people would agree, one shouldn't
- 34:33use attorney's fees to drive cases. Oh, we'll
- 34:35get attorney's fees. Let's keep this thing going.
- 34:37That's not, I think, good practice or good for
- 34:40our system. But when you're looking at the totality
- 34:46of a case and making a determination and working
- 34:50towards getting on the plaintiff's side, working
- 34:51towards getting the best recovery possible for
- 34:54your client and on the defense side, managing
- 34:56risks for your client because that's one of the
- 34:59jobs of defense is to Look out for your client,
- 35:02advise them of the risk, what their exposures
- 35:04could be, and it sometimes can be a bitter pill
- 35:07for an employer to settle a case they feel strongly
- 35:12didn't have value, but make an economic decision
- 35:16that why would you prolong litigation and pay
- 35:21additional attorney's fees and costs when you
- 35:24could informally resolve a case? It's a business
- 35:27decision. It's a practical decision. it's something
- 35:30to be discussed. And so, as I've seen just in
- 35:37that practical aspect, I do see on the plaintiff's
- 35:39side, the pendulum had shifted to a point where
- 35:42people were being fairly strident on the plaintiff's
- 35:45side about recovering attorney's fees and using
- 35:48that to let it drive a case that maybe had, let's
- 35:53just say, factual or evidentiary issues that
- 35:58would make a recovery of trial arbitration challenging
- 36:01and can lead to an overconfidence that won't
- 36:04benefit your client and doesn't benefit the system.
- 36:08So that's, again, like I said, one of the takeaways
- 36:11today on the practical side is never ignore a
- 36:14defense 998. Consider it and make strategic decisions
- 36:20based on what you're seeing. as it comes in,
- 36:24it's not something to just push to the side and
- 36:28assume won't be an issue later. And if we go
- 36:32to the next slide, say one of the things that's
- 36:35a practical point I can suggest is you serve
- 36:38your own 998 in a FIHA employment case early.
- 36:43And the question is why? Well, you know, I've
- 36:45got my points here. It's what creates your benchmark
- 36:47for case value. And one of the things is it's
- 36:52common practice on that side to contact plaintiff
- 36:55lawyer make the introduction at the beginning
- 36:57of the case and make an inquiry as to whether
- 37:00there's any chance to informally resolve the
- 37:03case or ask if the plaintiff has a demand and
- 37:07one of the reasons defense does that is because
- 37:09they have insurance often not always but often
- 37:12they have insurance carriers to report to and
- 37:15part of risk management is seeing what's plaintiff
- 37:17looking for and there isn't enough information
- 37:20on a practical point it's a It's an irritation
- 37:23of mine when I when I get the fence looking at
- 37:26a statement of damages that gets served as part
- 37:29of the the packet of documents after you filed
- 37:32and you send out for service and you and using
- 37:35that as a benchmark for the plainest expectations
- 37:39where the statutory provision for statement of
- 37:43damages is it creates an outside top end for
- 37:47a case of valid. You're advising the court of
- 37:49an outside. So a plaintiff should make that number
- 37:52as giant as possible because it's not a settlement
- 37:54demand and it's not evidentiary but it actually
- 37:57has a statutory reason for existing and it can
- 38:01be very important also if you have to seek a
- 38:03default judgment because you have to serve a
- 38:06statement of damages and if you just put an arbitrarily
- 38:10low number you might be limited in default prove
- 38:13-up to that low number and so a statement of
- 38:17damages is not a settlement demand. And it shouldn't
- 38:19be considered that way. And it shouldn't be considered
- 38:22as the plaintiff's solid evaluation of the case.
- 38:26It's a statutory obligation of a plaintiff to
- 38:31advise the court, essentially, in parties of
- 38:35the potential maximum upside of the case. So
- 38:40defense is going to call and ask for an offer,
- 38:42a demand. At the early stage, there's no downside
- 38:49in creating your own benchmark for the case value.
- 38:52The 998, and we're going to talk about this more,
- 38:56you're not limited to one. And they don't supersede
- 38:59each other or erase each other. The code is very
- 39:02clear and the case law is very clear. They will
- 39:04exist contemporaneously, continuously. And the
- 39:08numbers can be up and down and all over. Now,
- 39:11I think practically, unless there's a big change
- 39:14in the case, they shouldn't go up. but it does
- 39:16happen. But they can go up, they can go down,
- 39:19they can move. There are good reasons sometimes
- 39:22to serve same one repeatedly. And I talked about
- 39:24the objection as one example. If you get an objection
- 39:27to a 998, I suggest if that was really a number
- 39:31you felt was a solid number for the case, serve
- 39:37it again at the end for exactly that number.
- 39:39If that's what you think it's worth and that's
- 39:41the bottom line for your client, because that
- 39:44can eliminate that objection argument. Say, well,
- 39:47it was premature maybe at the week one of the
- 39:50lawsuit but not 10 days before trial. According
- 39:52to defense in that scenario or an objecting party,
- 39:55one could never serve a 998. It's like Zeno's
- 39:58paradox. You'll never catch the turtle, right?
- 40:02As you're trying to approach it. So, I do recommend
- 40:05that. It's an antidote to what I consider often
- 40:09frivolous objections to 998s where defense trying
- 40:12to an insurance company will try and punt on
- 40:15making a decision by simply serving an objection
- 40:19saying what we need to keep investigating and
- 40:21you'll only find out again end of the case whether
- 40:24or not that objection had any significance and
- 40:27so that that's one thing you create a benchmark
- 40:30at the beginning and it's formalized and then
- 40:34it protects against the defense leverage because
- 40:37you've opened up a risk at the very beginning
- 40:41of your case that will progressively increase
- 40:47through the case. You've set a benchmark in the
- 40:51very beginning. You start pre -judgment, interest
- 40:54clocked right there. And again, I won't lament
- 40:57the change of the law, but when you could add
- 41:00your attorney's fees to your judgment, well,
- 41:02it might have been maybe a fairly optimistic.
- 41:06Section 998 offered a compromise one week into
- 41:10the case but by the end and you've got a half
- 41:12million in attorney's fees it might look super
- 41:15reasonable but you know you can't but that's
- 41:18why you have to then look at shouldn't we do
- 41:20the same one again or should we change that number
- 41:22we're going to talk in a moment about not just
- 41:26doing one if you're going to do them and so you
- 41:29know it does showcase confidence I think one
- 41:31of the problems with the 998 is that There's
- 41:34a lot of ways to look at anything, but there's
- 41:37two things you can look at with a 998. Are you
- 41:40doing it as a settlement tool or are you doing
- 41:44it to maximize your cost and fee recovery? Which
- 41:48are both valid uses based on the statutory language.
- 41:52So as a settlement tool, it should be the biggest
- 41:55number you can think that they might pay because
- 41:58it'll start a dialogue or they might accept.
- 42:01But on the cost recovery, analysis, it should
- 42:06be the smallest number you think they won't pay.
- 42:09I would say this as a practical, you should,
- 42:11for purposes of protecting your ability to recover
- 42:14costs and fees, it should be for a dollar more
- 42:18than the lowest amount you think the defense
- 42:20would pay because there's no upside. It's like
- 42:23you're doing the limbo. Why would you raise the
- 42:26bar as low as possible or lower the bar when
- 42:29you could raise it? Why would you make it a number
- 42:31that's really hard to beat? If the case is worth
- 42:34$500 ,000, you shouldn't do a 998 close to trial
- 42:38when there's no chance they're going to pay it
- 42:40for $10 million because you're making your job
- 42:43at trial harder than it needs to be. But, you
- 42:46know, I say you always want to watch. You don't
- 42:48want what I call the crossover where you shoot
- 42:51a demand that's lower than they were willing
- 42:54to pay. And, you know, a good negotiation strategy,
- 42:59you know, art and science along the way but you
- 43:03don't want to do an early 998 that's too low
- 43:06because you're going to set a low bar. And so
- 43:10early on I would say use it as a settlement tool
- 43:13but start creating a benchmark. So I think you
- 43:15just what I would practically suggest is you
- 43:19take it you look at the comparable cases what
- 43:23a jury's going to you know consider the potential
- 43:28value how long the client was working there their
- 43:30emotional distress are there any medical treatment
- 43:33anything like that and then project your attorney's
- 43:36fees project your costs for the life of the case
- 43:40you can get a good idea from when your client
- 43:42comes in how many witnesses you're going to talk
- 43:44to and such and get that number you know as you
- 43:49know up there and then you're going to reevaluate
- 43:52through the course of the case, but it shows
- 43:54a case competence. And if someone asks you early
- 43:57on, your defense attorney, you're talking to
- 43:59insurance adjuster, how did you get that number?
- 44:01Well, this is it. We did the comparables and
- 44:04I'm factoring in the attorney's fees for the
- 44:06life of the case. And now you can have a negotiation
- 44:09because they'll say, well, you haven't incurred
- 44:10those attorney's fees yet because you haven't
- 44:12done all that. You haven't taken the depositions,
- 44:14opposed to summary judgment, started retaining
- 44:17experts, but you're projecting that. because
- 44:20that's reasonable. So it's showcase confidence
- 44:23and again there's no downside. There's no limits
- 44:26on the number you can serve. There's no there's
- 44:35no real penalty for it. The only thing is that
- 44:37you know as we all know from negotiation it gets
- 44:40awkward when numbers are fluctuating and you
- 44:43know one wants to show confidence confidence
- 44:46And professionalism and being a moving target
- 44:49on up and down on settlement demands is a sure
- 44:54way to guarantee you're going to go to trial,
- 44:56and if that's what the case needs. But an opportunity
- 44:59to informally resolve the case and give your
- 45:01client certainty and closure should never be,
- 45:06let's say, overlooked. I mean, it's not about.
- 45:09getting another trial under your belt. I mean,
- 45:11you get as far down the road as I am and I'll
- 45:13give some back. You know, so, you know, it's
- 45:15nice. It's not about getting into a, you know,
- 45:17a boda or another trial organization. It's about,
- 45:21you know, each case, what's what's necessary
- 45:23for your client best interest. So, um, so if
- 45:26we go down to the next slide and a couple of
- 45:30draft and tips, I include the fee language. This
- 45:32is this, I suggest this, um, It's something to
- 45:37be put to the test. But you want to make sure,
- 45:40so the 998, there's some statutory and case law
- 45:44regarding mandatory components. It has to be,
- 45:48you know, it has to be open for the 30 days or
- 45:5110 days before trial. You know, it has to be
- 45:55in writing. It has to have a, it should have,
- 46:00it should have a recommend, sorry. segment where
- 46:06the opposing counsel signs acceptance. But acceptance
- 46:09can be in writing other than signing the 998.
- 46:13But generally speaking in drafting, I recommend
- 46:17you put a nose of acceptance attached to your
- 46:19offer to compromise with language in the offer
- 46:21saying you're going to accept this sign on the
- 46:24next page and it boils down the terms and then
- 46:28if they sign it you've got a case resolved. But
- 46:32you can put in language indicating that free
- 46:38and post -offer costs and fees will be included
- 46:43in determining whether the plaintiff gets more
- 46:47successful result. Because at the end of the
- 46:50day, 998 is a contractual agreement. And so if
- 46:54you put that in there, there is case law. And
- 46:58I cited two cases that are beneficial, Stallman
- 47:01vs Bell, 235 Calab, 3rds at starting at page
- 47:05740, 1991 case and also referencing Simers because
- 47:10Sword and Shield was sometimes something that
- 47:12helps one side helps the other. I mean, you know,
- 47:15that's that's balance in the law. So here I say
- 47:19expressly that the offer includes attorney's
- 47:23fees and costs. So there doesn't need to be a
- 47:26post offer motion to determine that amount. and
- 47:30that if it's not accepted at the conclusion of
- 47:35trial, attorney's fees and costs will be included
- 47:38in the judgment. So it is essentially modifying
- 47:45the terms of the contract to incorporate back
- 47:52what Encinitas, the Encinitas Plaza Real case
- 47:55contemplated. And there is case law that supports
- 47:58that a plaintiff or defense can make that modification.
- 48:02And so again, unfortunately, you're always going
- 48:04to be subject to the post -trial testing of these
- 48:07things. But if you put it in there on its express,
- 48:10there's case law that would support that the
- 48:12court will allow you to add your fees and costs
- 48:15into your judgment to make that determination
- 48:18that you got a more favorable result. So if we
- 48:23look to the next slide. So another thing is be
- 48:27clear and simple. I wouldn't make too many conditions.
- 48:31It's basically you pay this amount, you get a
- 48:36dismissal once it's paid, but it's a judgment
- 48:39entered. And so sometimes you see on the defense
- 48:42can serve one that says instead of it being a
- 48:44judgment, it's a settlement and subject to a
- 48:47release. And those terms have been found to be
- 48:49valid. So if an insurance company is involved
- 48:52and they servant in the defense serves a 998
- 48:56that to a plaintiff that says plaintiff will
- 48:59condition if plaintiff sign a release that can
- 49:05be a valid 998 even though it's not going to
- 49:08be recorded as a judgment so you know the things
- 49:11that i think need you know well the case law
- 49:13and the statutes they should be clear is the
- 49:15total settlement amount whether the first inclusive
- 49:19or exclusive of fees and costs there may be so
- 49:22when you do early one of the things you could
- 49:23do is do a lower number but change your offer
- 49:28so that it says exclusive of fees and costs and
- 49:31those will be subject to a motion and that might
- 49:34bridge a gap for your own client to get a case
- 49:36resolved you could do a 998 for more beatable
- 49:39number at the early stage and then try and capture
- 49:43some fees and costs on the post acceptance law
- 49:48in motion. And so that works. You know, I've
- 49:51given an example that's not fija. In a lemon
- 49:53law case, that can be a good idea. And so, of
- 49:57course, you have to specify method of acceptance,
- 49:59and that's in writing, and the dismissal terms,
- 50:02whether it's going to be recorded judgment or
- 50:04dismissal with prejudice. So, you know, there's
- 50:07my little summary there. Clarity equals greater
- 50:09probability of enforceability, meaning you're
- 50:12only going to find out about the defects that
- 50:14are in your 998 post judgment. And that's just,
- 50:20you know, when you don't want to find out that
- 50:23you didn't have all the necessary pieces in there,
- 50:26because again, it can turn a win into a loss
- 50:29faster than you'd like. And so, yeah. And so
- 50:33if we go to the next slide, one of the other
- 50:39strategic uses is that it can trigger the 10
- 50:42% interest calculation. If plaintiff makes the
- 50:44offer, defendant rejects it, plaintiff beats
- 50:46it at trial. You've got a 10 % interest from
- 50:50the date of the first exceeded offer. So again,
- 50:53you can do more than one. And so along the way,
- 50:55you might not beat your first one. You might
- 50:57not beat your second one. You might beat your
- 51:00third one. And so that will start the interest
- 51:04from that date. So again, they don't supersede.
- 51:07Sometimes you may have fluctuated. You may have
- 51:09a high number. You might go lower and then go
- 51:10high again. That middle one, if you beat it,
- 51:13it wasn't erased by the others. It's not like
- 51:15off route. It's not like a general contract negotiation
- 51:19where the offers and counter offers are erasing
- 51:22each other. Here, each 998 stands on its own.
- 51:25As long as you get a proof of service, which
- 51:27you want to make sure you do, you'll be able
- 51:30to reference them. And of course, if you've shown
- 51:34a cascade down, that's going to be something
- 51:38that a court should consider strongly in your
- 51:41favor. Say, hey, we made several reasonable offers,
- 51:44especially if you beat all of them. And we just
- 51:46blow it out of the water. I mean, of course,
- 51:48you know, that's that's a great result in every
- 51:50way. But one of the things they well turns out
- 51:52that that first 998 way back in the beginning
- 51:54was super reasonable because look what the jury
- 51:57did. So, you know, But one of the one of the
- 52:02actually the strongest reasons for a 998 was
- 52:05my response in my response to the attorney as
- 52:09I said what the ideology of this whole subject
- 52:12is defense attorney saying why why are plaintiffs
- 52:14even bothering to do 998s these days in employment
- 52:17cases. And if we go to the next slide, I want
- 52:20to talk. This is the thing I think is most important.
- 52:23It documents settlement demands because, as we
- 52:26know, mediation discussions are privileged. And
- 52:29even the back and forth informal settlement negotiations
- 52:32can be privileged if the defense or either side
- 52:36puts it under evidence code section 1152 and
- 52:42other. code sections also that hold that settlement
- 52:46communications are privileged and confidential
- 52:48but especially mediation where so many times
- 52:52we've got we go to mediation and the offers and
- 52:57counters are confidential and you can't reference
- 53:01them you're not even supposed to tell the court
- 53:03what happened at mediation and you can't bring
- 53:06in the mediator as a witness to the negotiation
- 53:10so you can guess scenarios where there was settlement
- 53:14discussion and You know, maybe one side's being
- 53:18very reasonable and the other side is not and
- 53:20then trial occurs because that's a good way to
- 53:24show who had a you know Had the more reasonable
- 53:28position one could say or at least it's a way
- 53:30to resolve things is your trial and find out
- 53:33that the offers or the demands were very reasonable,
- 53:37but You can't tell the judge that and you can't
- 53:40say well mediation And then the court, as they're
- 53:44looking at the attorney's fees and costs, maybe
- 53:46feel sympathetic to one side or the other without
- 53:49that information. And that could be a big difference.
- 53:52But again, you can't reference mediation as confidential.
- 53:55You can't bring the mediator, get a declaration
- 53:56from the mediator. And you could get one side
- 53:59saying, I don't know if you're making that demand.
- 54:00Or that wasn't a real demand. Or that wasn't
- 54:02a real offer. That was a maybe. And so a 990
- 54:07is not privileged. It's not confidential. And
- 54:10it can be considered by the court. So, you know,
- 54:13one of the things I recommend is practice pointers.
- 54:15You come out of mediation and you felt very strong
- 54:20about your last demand with your client at that
- 54:23or the last offer. Do a 998 that afternoon, that
- 54:27day, next day, day, two days later. But following
- 54:31that, do a 998 that memorializes the last offer
- 54:35or demand. One of the reasons is Sometimes we
- 54:39find out and it's you know, it's just part of
- 54:42strategy and discussion is sometimes meteors
- 54:44don't communicate the full numbers they're Having
- 54:47discussion dialogue and maybe a number doesn't
- 54:49and you don't find that out until Sometimes maybe
- 54:52even too late. Hopefully not too late, but you
- 54:55don't find out the media never communicated a
- 54:57demand Well the 998 again that takes out any
- 55:01Confusion misunderstanding About what happened
- 55:05to me plaintiffs last number was this amount
- 55:08and we can tell because they served a 998 the
- 55:10next day and so That I think is Alone a good
- 55:18enough reason if you needed one to just one to
- 55:22serve a 998 as a plaintiff in an employment case
- 55:25because it's going to be about the only way that
- 55:27you can prove But you actually offered demanded
- 55:30a specific number and you beat it and when you're
- 55:34fighting over probably be substantial attorneys
- 55:37by the time you finish a lengthy trial and you're
- 55:40an experienced attorney like with a lot of years
- 55:42experience and you say well my rate is x per
- 55:46hour and I spend every minute of it and then
- 55:48judges seeing you in trial they know you must
- 55:50have by that point these things can make a massive
- 55:57difference and I mean I have had It's just a
- 56:03practical I've had situations where the attorney's
- 56:05fees eclipsed the judgment and you know often
- 56:09They kind of match each other but or the judgment
- 56:13you want the judgment to eclipse the attorney's
- 56:15fees But you know, it's expensive litigating
- 56:18in this world. So It is it's a reality that these
- 56:24Points can make an enormous financial difference
- 56:27to your client at the end and so it's, you know,
- 56:33it's worth all of the consideration. Now, if
- 56:36we look at the next slide. So you see, what would
- 56:42be the milestones? We're calling this a third
- 56:43pillar of litigation in between the filing of
- 56:47a lawsuit or responding, responsive pleading,
- 56:49and expert designation almost at the end. You
- 56:52say, well, since you're not limited, I'd say
- 56:54there's three times to do it. and you can just
- 56:58calendar it in you do it early at the beginning
- 57:00within I would say after defense service written
- 57:02discovery you're returning verified responses
- 57:07you're returning to them verified documents that
- 57:11are produced from your client that's a good moment
- 57:13to also serve a 998 along you're nailing that
- 57:18stuff out or emailing it out include a 998 now
- 57:21you've also done you know you've put significant
- 57:23effort in by that point And then after key discovery,
- 57:28that's where you could consider increasing your
- 57:31number. More time has gone by, more work, and
- 57:35maybe something's happened. Witnesses have not
- 57:37come through the way one side or the other expected.
- 57:41And then certainly before Trump. And that's the
- 57:44last one. At that point, you've got a good sense
- 57:47this thing is not settling. You want to benchmark
- 57:50one that you can beat. Like I said, I would do
- 57:53it for $1 more than I know defense won't pay.
- 57:56And if they won't pay a zero, if they say zero,
- 57:59I'd make it for a dollar because you're just
- 58:01trying to beat that to get your, to maximize
- 58:03the probability you get your fees and costs.
- 58:06So you're not limited to one offer. I would incorporate
- 58:10that. And so if we go to the next slide. So,
- 58:18you know, each time you're going to serve one,
- 58:20you'd say, okay, What are the things we want
- 58:22to accomplish here? Is this number defensible?
- 58:24If you think the case is worth $250 ,000, you
- 58:27shouldn't do a demand from $1 .8 million. I mean,
- 58:30you can, but I'm not a big fan of giant numbers
- 58:35for shock value because it's, I just think, inelegant
- 58:40in negotiation where they're offering, they're
- 58:42going in blocks at 10 ,000, and you're moving
- 58:44in blocks of a million because the demand is
- 58:47just so far out of... proportion to what the
- 58:51case value in the particular matter can be. I
- 58:54think knowing what your case is worth is certainly
- 58:56one of the jobs of a professional experienced
- 58:59attorney. Clients are looking to us for guidance.
- 59:03Knowing how to evaluate cases is really one of
- 59:06the key parts of the job at that point. That's
- 59:08what the counselor aspect of our profession.
- 59:12If we don't know what it's worth, how is anybody
- 59:13supposed to? But we have plenty of databases
- 59:16and data and resources that help us evaluate
- 59:20cases and we use precedent as we should and so
- 59:23you get a good idea what your case is worth based
- 59:25on you know each particular type of case medical
- 59:29records and bills in that in an injury case when
- 59:32an employment case longevity of their earnings
- 59:35was a written contract are there penalties for
- 59:39a breach of a written employment contract i mean
- 59:41i can go on with examples but should ask is this
- 59:45is this the right number You're leaving yourself
- 59:48room to negotiate. I don't think you should do
- 59:50a 998 first off the bat for exactly the lowest
- 59:54number your client wants because that creates
- 59:57a box where you're almost guaranteeing a trial
- 59:59because people won't believe that until it's
- 1:00:02too late, in a sense. So the other thing is if
- 1:00:06you're trying to get some dialogue, you have
- 1:00:09to say, are you realistically evaluating your
- 1:00:11exposure? If there's substantial risk in the
- 1:00:16evidence, You don't come out of the box, I think,
- 1:00:18at $20 million demand, where the case is very
- 1:00:21weak, and you knew it from talking to witnesses
- 1:00:23in your own due diligence. You want to evaluate
- 1:00:26and give your client best guidance possible.
- 1:00:29Clients make final decisions, so we know that.
- 1:00:32It's a service industry. But you want to give
- 1:00:35advice, and it'd be reasonable. Someone should
- 1:00:38have the cooler head always. Does the language
- 1:00:43address fees? Again, that's... sometimes it should
- 1:00:46say including sometimes say exclusive of and
- 1:00:49I gave examples of that and really at the end
- 1:00:52of the day you're asking am I prepared to beat
- 1:00:54this number of trial I mean I always say I don't
- 1:00:57my office we don't take a case we won't take
- 1:00:59to trial now doesn't mean that we don't want
- 1:01:03to resolve cases it's just you don't want to
- 1:01:07well I obviously didn't hope it's not a strategy
- 1:01:09And so not every case settles. And I wouldn't
- 1:01:12have all the trials I have if every case settled.
- 1:01:14But statistically, based on the thousands of
- 1:01:17cases I've worked, still about 3 % go to trial.
- 1:01:19A little more of certain types of cases like
- 1:01:21medical malpractice. But still, most resolve
- 1:01:26informally, but not all. And it's not always
- 1:01:29the ones you think that go to trial. Sometimes
- 1:01:32there's practical reasons a case goes to trial
- 1:01:34that have nothing to do with just a number. So
- 1:01:36you have to say, OK, when I'm doing this, Can
- 1:01:39I beat this at trial? And if you say, I don't
- 1:01:41think I can beat this at trial, do another one
- 1:01:43for the number you think you can, because that's
- 1:01:45going to be your trial 998. And you do that at
- 1:01:48the end. So if we go to the next, start to kind
- 1:01:51of get into a bit of a wrap up here. Some things
- 1:01:56that say the common mistakes to avoid in practice.
- 1:01:59Ignoring a defense 998. Don't ignore. Don't serve
- 1:02:02an unrealistic offer. you know maybe strategically
- 1:02:06you want to shock someone but I think that it
- 1:02:08that more shocking number more let's just say
- 1:02:14harms your credibility and then don't forget
- 1:02:18to address attorney's fees if is it inclusive
- 1:02:20or exclusive you don't want to leave that empty
- 1:02:22one way or the other because then it's vague
- 1:02:25and it's maybe neither and you just just don't
- 1:02:28want to get in there you know don't don't make
- 1:02:31it clear use clear language And don't wait too
- 1:02:34long to serve. Don't, you know, when you're six
- 1:02:36days before trial and it's just too late, you
- 1:02:39know, you could have still done one. And as we've
- 1:02:42talked about for all the many reasons, it's a
- 1:02:43good idea for a plaintiff to do one in a FIHA
- 1:02:46case. And there's a good reason for a defense
- 1:02:48to do one as well. And so we go down to the next
- 1:02:52slide. Want to, you know, CODESU procedure section
- 1:02:59998. as I say, it's not just a form. This is
- 1:03:03a very important, very practical, very studied
- 1:03:07and used litigation tool. It's a fee protection
- 1:03:10tool, a settlement leverage tool, an interest
- 1:03:14triggering device, a risk management strategy.
- 1:03:17It can be a knife, it can be a hammer. It's a
- 1:03:20very versatile tool and it's part of your litigation
- 1:03:25strategy as a practicing attorney. Especially
- 1:03:29if you're trial counsel. And so going, we got
- 1:03:32our last slide. We're there. So it's a final
- 1:03:36advice to consider. Just think about it from
- 1:03:38day one. Calender your deadlines as one would
- 1:03:41do, but make sure the 998 deadlines are calendered.
- 1:03:43Last day to serve a 998. Buy mail. Last day to
- 1:03:46serve one. Buy electronic. Last day before trial
- 1:03:50to serve one. Draft it carefully. Use it strategically
- 1:03:55and not reactively. And the summary here is smart
- 1:03:59use is equally protected fees and increased leverage,
- 1:04:02which serves your client, serves our justice
- 1:04:05system. So we've concluded with the slides. Sorry.
- 1:04:25just making sure are we are we over time or are
- 1:04:29we sorry um it looks like we were on the last
- 1:04:33slide um but um or we just concluded at the last
- 1:04:37side we are a little over time but if you'd like
- 1:04:39to stay on we do have some questions for you
- 1:04:41actually yeah no i i thought i had a time sorry
- 1:04:44it's you know travel experience thought i had
- 1:04:46a time to come in um and we and i'm happy to
- 1:04:49stay as long as anyone has questions i just wanted
- 1:04:52to make sure i was um because that wrapped it
- 1:04:54up that last slide in that conclusion. But yeah,
- 1:04:58if anyone has questions. OK, so I'm going through,
- 1:05:08I'm looking, there are a couple of questions.
- 1:05:11OK, now there's one here who says, is any advice
- 1:05:16for a plaintiff to use 998s when there are multiple
- 1:05:19defendants in a FIHA case? And the answer is,
- 1:05:22yeah, do one. Oh, I recommend you do. Well, OK,
- 1:05:28so sorry to answer that specifically plaintiffs
- 1:05:32can serve one on all defendants. But if they're
- 1:05:39all common interest is where you could look at
- 1:05:41it. But if you the problem is then they say,
- 1:05:44well, how do you know if you beat it if three
- 1:05:46defendants are. You know found liable with different
- 1:05:51percentages what I generally recommend in where
- 1:05:55there's multiple defendants is serve one on each
- 1:05:58defendant and Then you have to make a decision.
- 1:06:02It's always that's gonna be fact -dependent.
- 1:06:04Do you do the same number to each defendant and
- 1:06:07You know, then you're setting, you know three
- 1:06:09the bar at the same level for each defendant
- 1:06:12and when in doubt do that I Say to this defendant
- 1:06:16only no other defendant. I always put that in
- 1:06:18there Because you don't want them start going,
- 1:06:19well, they're my agent. So when they settled,
- 1:06:21we settled. It's like, no, it was just that entity
- 1:06:24or that person, you know, and that comes up and
- 1:06:28you start getting into. But yeah, no, from plaintiff
- 1:06:31perspective, I don't recommend you block. Defendants
- 1:06:35can all serve one on plaintiff. That's more clear.
- 1:06:38There's one plaintiff and all the defendants
- 1:06:40say, here's one number. And then, okay, so there
- 1:06:46was a question, doesn't a subsequent 998 offer
- 1:06:48to supersede the prior one? Case law has been
- 1:06:50that it doesn't. And so unless there's, I mean,
- 1:06:52I'm not aware of a newer case, is that there's,
- 1:06:56it's been, you know, we've had this come up and
- 1:06:58it's, it's a, they don't supersede. They each
- 1:07:02exist and you can go back in time. And I've done
- 1:07:05that in post -trial motion and say, well, I didn't
- 1:07:08beat the second last one, but I beat the last
- 1:07:11one. And it's like, well, where I beat the middle
- 1:07:13one. It was one where there was and so. And then
- 1:07:19started we've got one do attorneys fees include
- 1:07:22costs and so that's where we were looking at
- 1:07:24this in a 998 the 998 the amendment to the statute.
- 1:07:32Says no the attorneys fees are not costs because
- 1:07:37you can use your costs to determine if you beat
- 1:07:40it beat the number you can you but. You can't
- 1:07:44use the attorney's fees. They're not considered
- 1:07:45cost in that context for that purpose. And that
- 1:07:49was the reaction from the legislature, if you
- 1:07:54will, to the SMU's case. And then there was a
- 1:08:00question, Christian Burr Garment Company versus
- 1:08:02EEOC case, 4334 US 412. standard bar of defendant's
- 1:08:09recovery costs and attorney's fees. Well, I mean,
- 1:08:11you know, that's a 1978 case and so many things
- 1:08:15have kind of ebbed and flowed from there but
- 1:08:19attorney's fees under the government code section
- 1:08:22and one was cited as 12965C6 is that plaintiffs
- 1:08:27can't be denied a right to attorney's fees. But
- 1:08:31again, the Stimer's case was looking at could
- 1:08:35a judge reduce the attorney's fees and deny attorney's
- 1:08:40fees after a reasonable 998 by defense and the
- 1:08:43Court of Appeal found that they could. And so
- 1:08:47that was the pendulum shifting back because the
- 1:08:49case would say, wait, the statute says prevailing
- 1:08:52plaintiff gets attorney's fees. And then so the
- 1:08:56998, there was a while where you'd say defense
- 1:08:58shouldn't bother with the 998 because they're
- 1:09:00pointless. And then now I would say defense should
- 1:09:03definitely. consider, but it's the same considerations.
- 1:09:08It's not a reasonable 998 based on the case then.
- 1:09:16And then there was a question, if you're in mediation
- 1:09:19and settle for an amount less than 998, does
- 1:09:21it still kick in against you? Well, okay, so
- 1:09:24there is a new case, Madrigal versus Hyundai
- 1:09:28Motor America. And in that, and it's 2025 case.
- 1:09:32And in that case, Settling for less than the
- 1:09:35998 can impact fees and costs if you settled
- 1:09:39At a mediation after a 998 from the defense had
- 1:09:42expired and the terms of the settlement were
- 1:09:45specific number Laws attorneys fees and costs
- 1:09:48subject to motion which sometimes that is the
- 1:09:51settlement term Then they could argue. Well,
- 1:09:54you didn't you didn't accept the 998 you settled
- 1:09:57a mediation for less And therefore, we shouldn't
- 1:09:59get any more attorney's fees and cost than what
- 1:10:01you had accrued up to the point where we did
- 1:10:03the 998. And the Madrigal case had some support
- 1:10:06for that. But that was a very specific circumstance.
- 1:10:11They settled during trial for a number less than
- 1:10:15the 998. And then on the pretrial motion, the
- 1:10:18court was considering whether to award full attorney's
- 1:10:22fees. Oh, I think we got all questions. All right.
- 1:10:31All righty. Well, that concludes today's presentation.
- 1:10:34Thank you so much, Sean, for an excellent presentation.
- 1:10:36And thank you so much to our audience. Have a
- 1:10:38great day, everybody. Absolutely. Thank you.
- 1:10:40I appreciate you guys having us. So thank you.