Latest / Tech IPO Conversations with Fexingo: Public Software Companies and Capital Markets / How Post-IPO Companies Use Stock Buybacks as a Liquidity Tool
Transcript
- Lucas: Meta announced a fifty-billion-dollar buyback authorization back in February, and the market has basically been cheering ever since. The stock is up over nine percent just in the last five days, closing yesterday at six hundred fifty-nine. Luna: That's a huge number. But is it really about signaling confidence, or is there a more operational reason a company like Meta would lean so hard into buybacks? Lucas: Great question. The traditional view is that buybacks say 'we think our stock is undervalued.' And that's part of it. But for post ipo companies—especially ones that went public five, six years ago—there's a liquidity angle that often gets overlooked. Luna: Because employees and early investors have a lot of stock they want to sell, but the market might not have enough natural buyers? Lucas: Exactly. When a company does a buyback, it becomes a buyer itself. That creates a liquidity backstop. So when an employee exercises options or an insider sells shares as part of a 10b5-1 plan, the company's repurchase program can absorb that supply without tanking the stock. Luna: So it's almost like market making, but from the corporate treasury side. Lucas: Right. And Meta is a perfect example. They've got a massive float, but they also have a lot of insider holdings from the IPO era. A fifty-billion-dollar authorization gives the treasurer room to buy on down days, smoothing out the volatility that would otherwise come from insider sales. Luna: But not every company can do that. Shopify, for instance—it's up five and a half percent this week, but its buyback program is much more modest. Why the difference? Lucas: Shopify's market cap is about a hundred sixty billion, versus Meta's one point seven trillion. So the scale is different. But also, Shopify's free cash flow is still recovering from the post-pandemic slowdown. They generated about two billion in FCF last year—healthy, but not enough to fund a massive buyback and still invest in growth. So they're being more surgical. Luna: Surgical how? Lucas: They're using an accelerated share repurchase program—basically a contract with a bank to buy back a fixed dollar amount of stock over a short period. The bank does the buying, and Shopify gets the shares retired immediately. It's efficient, but it doesn't provide the ongoing liquidity support that a standing open-market program does. Luna: And then you have a company like Rivian, up almost five percent this week but still burning cash. They haven't authorized a buyback at all. Makes sense—they need every dollar for production. Lucas: Right. Buybacks when you're fcf negative would be irresponsible. But it shows how the tool is only available to companies that have reached a certain financial maturity. For post ipo companies that are profitable, buybacks become a strategic liquidity lever. Luna: And there's a timing element too. Companies often announce buybacks right after earnings, when they have the most information. But they can't just buy whenever they want because of insider trading rules. Lucas: That's where Rule 10b5-1 plans come in. A company can set up a pre-arranged trading plan that buys shares on a schedule or at a price target, even during blackout periods. It removes the discretion—and the legal risk. Most of the big tech buybacks you see are executed through these plans. Luna: So the buyback isn't just a signal—it's an actual market mechanism that keeps the stock liquid for everyone involved. Lucas: Exactly. And if this kind of practical breakdown of post ipo strategy is useful for what you're building or running, that's exactly why we do this. The way these stay ad-free is listener support—buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. Luna: Yeah, it's a small way to keep the conversations going without any sponsor interruptions. Lucas: So back to the mechanics—one interesting detail is how companies decide the size of the authorization. Meta's fifty billion was about three percent of its market cap at the time. That's actually on the smaller side relative to some financial firms that authorize five or ten percent. Luna: Why would a tech company keep it lower? Lucas: Flexibility. A large authorization can be seen as a commitment, and if the business hits a rough patch, you don't want to be on the hook to keep buying. So they authorize what they're comfortable deploying over the next couple of years, then renew it. Luna: That makes sense. And then the actual execution is often done through a mix of open-market purchases and ASRs, depending on market conditions. Lucas: Right. And here's where it gets interesting for post ipo companies: the buyback can also be used to offset dilution from employee stock compensation. Meta, for example, issues about ten billion dollars in stock-based compensation annually. If they didn't buy back shares, the float would keep expanding, diluting existing shareholders. Luna: So the buyback is partly a way to neutralize that dilution. Lucas: Exactly. For a lot of tech companies, the buyback program is really a capital allocation tool to manage the shareholder base. And when you look at the data, companies that consistently buy back tend to have lower volatility and tighter bid-ask spreads. Luna: But there's a critique that buybacks can be used to prop up the stock artificially, especially when insiders are selling. Lucas: That's the other side. And regulators have looked at it. But as long as the buyback is disclosed and executed under a 10b5-1 plan, it's legal. The question is whether it's always in the long-term interest of the company. Some argue that money spent on buybacks could go into R&D or acquisitions. Luna: Especially for younger post ipo companies that still have room to grow. Lucas: Right. That's why you see a company like Shopify being cautious. They're investing heavily in their merchant services and international expansion. They're not yet at the stage where returning cash to shareholders is the priority. Meta, on the other hand, is a cash machine—they generated over seventy billion in FCF last year. So fifty billion in buybacks is well within their capacity. Luna: And Meta's stock price reflects that confidence. Up nine percent this week, as we said. Lucas: It's a virtuous cycle. The buyback signals confidence, the market rewards the stock, and then the higher stock price makes the remaining authorization go further. But it can also work in reverse—if earnings disappoint, a buyback can seem like a desperation move. Luna: Like when a company announces a buyback right after a big drop, trying to stop the bleeding. Lucas: Exactly. That's usually a red flag. The most credible buybacks are the ones that are consistent and predictable, not reactive. And that's what investors look for. Luna: So for a post ipo company thinking about starting a buyback program, what's the first step? Lucas: They need to have a sustainable free cash flow and a clear capital allocation policy. Then they need to set up a 10b5-1 plan and decide on the authorization size. And they should communicate it clearly—not just the dollar amount, but the rationale. The best buyback stories are the ones where management explains how it fits into the broader strategy. Luna: And for investors, what should they watch? Lucas: Look at the buyback yield—the total buybacks as a percentage of market cap. Compare it to the company's free cash flow yield. If the buyback yield exceeds the FCF yield, they're probably borrowing to buy back stock, which is riskier. Also watch insider selling patterns. If insiders are selling while the company is aggressively buying, that's a potential red flag. Luna: All good things to keep in mind as more tech companies mature into buyback territory. Lucas: Absolutely. It's a sign of the lifecycle of a public company—from growth spender to cash returner. And for listeners building or investing in these companies, understanding that transition is key.