Latest / Columbus' Morning News / Is calling someone a racial slur an excuse for violence?
Transcript
- 0:00Speaker 1: He is a First Amendment attorney in the state of Ohio.
- 0:03He is a former Deputy Attorney General of the State
- 0:06of Ohio. He's got a book called a wordsmith Work,
- 0:09and he is on the Legacy Retirement Group dot com
- 0:11phone line. It is Mark Weaver, Mark, good morning, Good
- 0:14to talk to you.
- 0:14Speaker 2: How you ben doing well?
- 0:16Speaker 3: Thanks for inviting me.
- 0:17Speaker 1: Absolutely, you've got an op ed piece in the Cincinnati
- 0:19Inquirer at Cincinnati dot com having to do with his
- 0:22mess in this brawl from what about ten days ago.
- 0:25Speaker 2: I think in Cincinnati.
- 0:28Speaker 1: It's become racial, unfortunately, as so many things become in
- 0:33this day and age.
- 0:34Speaker 2: It's kind of sad. It's a different discussion.
- 0:37Speaker 1: But you've got the alleged victims here, I guess, shouting
- 0:42racial slurs. You've got the alleged suspects here taking offense
- 0:47to that and has beaten the crap out of these people.
- 0:50Speaker 2: We've seen the videos. They're hard to watch. And then
- 0:52you've got.
- 0:53Speaker 1: This Cincinnati Council City Council President Victoria Parks, who went
- 0:57on Facebook and just went full score to earth and
- 1:01said that these victims deserved it, that they were begging
- 1:06for this beat down.
- 1:07Speaker 2: I'll let you take it from here. What's the story.
- 1:10Speaker 3: Yeah, low character behaviors should never be rewarded. If you
- 1:15use a racial slur, that means you've got low character.
- 1:18But the First Amendment's pretty clear. You're not allowed to
- 1:21punch somebody who calls you a name. And this council
- 1:24president you mentioned, Victoria Parks. She claimed falsely that this
- 1:29is somehow a legitimate reason to punch somebody, because if
- 1:35somebody calls you an in, I don't think the woman victim.
- 1:37I think your first name is Holly. I don't think
- 1:39she's been accused of a racial slur. But okay, maybe
- 1:41somebody else has. Either way. You know, when we're kids,
- 1:45our parents, you know, remind us sticks and stones may
- 1:48break my bones, but words will never hurt me. But
- 1:51the First Amendment says is, yeah, if somebody calls you
- 1:54a name, that's bad. But they're allowed to call you
- 1:56a name and you're not allowed to punch them, which
- 1:59is why we're seeing people being charged with the felonious
- 2:02assault and other serious felonies.
- 2:05Speaker 1: Victoria Parks actually used the analogy of you can't run
- 2:09into a crowded theater and scream fire, because that was
- 2:13at one point the exception to the First Amendment.
- 2:16Speaker 2: Is that not true anymore now?
- 2:19Speaker 3: It was not in fact that that was the case
- 2:20in nineteen nineteen where they used that metaphor, and you
- 2:24can't falsely yell fire, is what the justice said, but
- 2:27that was overturned in a case that came out of Cincinnati, Ohio.
- 2:30It's usting that's not the standard anymore, and it hasn't
- 2:34been the standard for decades, but people still love to
- 2:36refer to it. The standard is what's not proper speech
- 2:40is if you say something meant to incite public lawlessness,
- 2:44you actually want to, and then you're likely to, and
- 2:48even then the person is not allowed to punch you.
- 2:50It's just that you could be in trouble yourself for
- 2:53saying something like, let's all go bust those windows. Here's
- 2:56some rocks. Well, that's speech right there. That's probabrobably a
- 3:00crime under that. You know the current standard, but it
- 3:04still doesn't allow someone to punch you. And so in
- 3:07this case, the Supreme Court has been very clear racial
- 3:10slurs are mean, they're offensive, but they're legal to use,
- 3:16including whatever people call hate speech, which is kind of
- 3:18an overused term nowadays, but to the extent that hate
- 3:21speech can even be defined, A unanimous Supreme Court has
- 3:26said it's fully protected by the First Amendment.
- 3:29Speaker 1: Yeah, I never really understood hate crimes or hate speech.
- 3:32I understand the intent there by labeling them as such,
- 3:36but I mean, at the end of the day, they're
- 3:38just crimes. Whatever the motivation behind them is in a
- 3:43lot of instances is inconsequential. Speaking with Mark Weaver, first
- 3:47Amendment attorney in Ohio, so let me play devil's advocate.
- 3:53If I'm a defense attorney from some of these suspects,
- 3:55I'm going to go I'm going to say, well, who
- 3:57wouldn't want to punch someone right in the kisser if
- 3:59they got called, you know, one of the worst possible
- 4:02names you can call somebody involving race. There's got to
- 4:07be some defense there, right, I mean, there's got to be.
- 4:10You know, my client was emotional, they were called a name,
- 4:13and they took action.
- 4:14Speaker 2: They regret it, but that's what happened.
- 4:17Speaker 3: It's not a legal defense, but it's what we call
- 4:19a jury nullification defense. You hope the jury will maybe
- 4:24not find your guy guilty, not because the law says
- 4:27they can, yeah, but because they're kind of angry about it,
- 4:31because the law is rather clear you cannot punch somebody
- 4:34because they said something mean to you. If that were true,
- 4:39there'd be lots of punchings every day all across the
- 4:41country with no legal remedy.
- 4:44Speaker 1: The other issue too, Mark, in this situation, I think
- 4:47there's been four or five. I think five arrests have
- 4:50been made now in this situation, which is fantastic, and
- 4:53I hope that these people will get prosecuted to the
- 4:55full extent of the law. One of the other disturbing
- 4:58parts of this whole story, Mark, is that only one
- 5:01person in a group of you know, sixty seventy eighty
- 5:04people called nine to one one during this fight. Everybody
- 5:07else had their cell phones out, not to call somebody
- 5:10for help, but to video it.
- 5:12Speaker 3: Yeah, this is a vicious time in American history where
- 5:15people would rather become famous by getting the video of
- 5:18an attack than by stepping in and helping somebody. And
- 5:23some of the politicians have called this a fight. This
- 5:25is not a fight. When somebody's on the ground and
- 5:29a crowd swoops in and starts kicking the person on
- 5:32the ground, that's not two people squaring off on a fight.
- 5:35That is a full blown felonious assault. People need to
- 5:38go to prison for doing this. That is not a
- 5:40fair fight, and bystanders need to step in and do
- 5:44responsible things, which is to pull people away who are
- 5:47kicking the skull of somebody on the ground.
- 5:50Speaker 1: So we okay, hate speech, racial slurs, whether you agree
- 5:56with it or not, those are protected under the First Amendment.
- 6:00You know, what about violent speech like you know, I'm
- 6:02going to come over there and I'm going to knock
- 6:04your teeth in as a threat a threatening speech?
- 6:08Speaker 3: Yeah, threat is an exception to the First Amendment. You're
- 6:10not allowed to make threats. You could say, hey, Homer Simpson,
- 6:14I hope somebody beats you up someday. Well, that's not
- 6:17a threat. But hey, Homer Simpson, I'm coming over there
- 6:20with a baseball bat right now. I'm going to bash
- 6:21your head in. That's a threat. That's a crime. So
- 6:24the First Amendment does not protect actual threats.
- 6:28Speaker 1: Interesting, what do you have against Homer Simpson, Mark, that's
- 6:31my question.
- 6:31Speaker 3: I just use him as an example because he's unlikely
- 6:34to assume me. That's why I use Umber Simpson as
- 6:36an example.