Latest / The Brief / Distress in Affordable Housing
Transcript
- Affordable housing is supposed to be the safety net.
- But what happens when the safety net starts to tear? New Minnesota research suggests that strain is no longer isolated.
- It’s widespread across nearly 26,000 regulated units in 456 properties with distress showing up in vacancies, bad debt, insurance, operating costs, and cash flow.
- And this is the part that should stop people cold: among the 11,408 units with cash-flow data, average cash flow fell to $1,226 per unit below breakeven in 2023.
- At 100% permanent supportive housing properties, it dropped to $1,980 below breakeven.
- The report’s conclusion is blunt: distress is widespread, and many of the drivers are external to providers things like inflation, rising labor and insurance costs, rent non-payment, staffing shortages, and broader social instability.
- Residents feel that distress in real life in safety concerns, strained building conditions, and the wear-and-tear that comes when staff are burned out and service needs keep getting more acute.
- And the financial hit is staggering.
- The quantitative analysis estimates that the decline in cash flow from 2018 to 2023, applied across the full universe of units studied, comes to roughly $49 million.
- So today, we’re asking the hard question: when affordable housing is in distress, who steps in before the damage becomes permanent? Because this isn’t just about buildings.
- It’s about whether safe, stable homes stay that way.
- This is The Brief.
- And today we are covering “Distress in Affordable Housing.”
- You're listening to the Brief, a podcast from the Minnesota Multi-Housing Association.
- Whether you're a property owner, manager, maintenance pro, product/service partner, or just curious about the industry we've got fresh insights, and quick takes, to keep you informed and ahead of the curve.
- No fluff.
- No filler.
- If it affects your residents, your business, or your bottom line.
- You'll hear about it here.
- This industry provides more than buildings.
- It offers Minnesotans a solution for home That solution is multi housing.
- Welcome to MHAs, The Brief.
- This episode of The Brief is proudly sponsored by our founding partner, Citizens State Bank.
- Rooted in the Upper Midwest with a growing presence in Minnesota, Citizens State Bank is deeply committed to supporting the region’s housing providers and small businesses through personalized financial solutions.
- Whether you're financing a new property in the Twin Cities, refinancing in Rochester, or expanding your operations across the state, their experienced team is here to help.
- Citizens State Bank specializes in property management banking solutions tailored to meet the unique needs of Minnesota’s property owners and managers.
- From commercial real estate loans, competitive deposit accounts, and a state-of-the-art business online banking suite, they provide the local insight and resources you need to keep your business moving forward.
- Experience the difference of working with a bank that understands Minnesota communities.
- Visit csbnet.net
- to learn how Citizens State Bank can help you achieve your goals.
- Member FDIC.
- Equal Housing Lender.
- Thanks to Citizens State Bank for backing this podcast and helping us bring valuable industry insights to Minnesota and beyond Week after week.
- Before we go further, it’s worth saying clearly where this comes from.
- Today’s conversation is based on a multi-part research project prepared for the Minnesota Housing Stability Coalition, with analysis by O’Neil Consulting, plus a resident perspectives report prepared for the Coalition.
- The work was commissioned with support from the Family Housing Fund and the Greater Minnesota Housing Fund.
- And this is not just outside analysis dropped in from 30,000 feet the project was built in two phases: first, interviews with housing provider staff and industry professionals, and then a quantitative review of property and organizational data from across Minnesota’s regulated affordable housing system.
- Right so when we say this is grounded in the operators themselves, that is literally how the study was designed.
- The qualitative phase included interviews with housing provider staffers and other industry professionals, and the quantitative phase was built from operating statements, audited financials, public program datasets, and other real-world property information.
- The point was to make the distress housing providers have been describing both visible and measurable.
- And the operator voice here is substantial.
- In the qualitative work, Thomas O’Neil interviewed dozens of people across Minnesota, including staff from affordable housing provider organizations and professionals working as lenders, consultants, vendors, policy analysts, and advocates.
- The provider organizations involved collectively owned roughly 19,000 regulated units at the start of 2024, so this was meant to be a representative sample of the industry, not just a few isolated anecdotes.
- And then the resident side matters too.
- The Coalition also commissioned focus groups with residents living in homes managed by Coalition members, especially in financially or physically distressed buildings.
- That report says residents and providers actually showed an aligned interest in the same thing: safe, welcoming, high-quality homes.
- So what we’re talking about today is not just a balance-sheet story.
- It is also a lived-experience story.
- So with that on the table, let’s get into what the research actually says.
- As we said earlier, the distress is not limited to one property type or one corner of the state.
- The quantitative report’s conclusion is that the pressure is widespread, and that many of the biggest drivers are external to operators inflation, interest rates, labor costs, insurance, rent non-payment, staffing shortages, and broader social instability since the pandemic.
- That point is important because it pushes back on the lazy assumption that distress automatically means mismanagement.
- The reports are pretty direct on this: the sector is dealing with macroeconomic and social pressures that are largely beyond the control of individual property operators.
- In other words, this is a systems problem before it is a blame-the-manager problem.
- And once you understand that, the rest of the findings start to click.
- As we said in the cold open, the cash-flow picture is deeply strained.
- That means owners and parent organizations are having to cover gaps, delay other priorities, or draw down resources just to keep properties stable.
- Affordable housing still has to function every day staff still need to be paid, units still need to be turned, buildings still need maintenance, and residents still need support.
- And the cost side is where this gets brutal.
- The reports show major increases in operating, repair, and maintenance costs, along with huge insurance spikes and rising security expenses in some of the most stressed settings.
- Even before you get into any one subgroup, the pattern is clear: the expense structure changed fast, and revenues did not keep up.
- Security is a good example of how this shows up in the real world.
- In the qualitative interviews, operators talked about negative operational issues that were not one-time events things like crime, vandalism, and the need for third-party security contracts.
- That is not a cosmetic problem.
- That changes the operating model of a property.
- And staffing comes right alongside it.
- The qualitative report flags continual high staff turnover and persistent staffing shortages as indicators of distress.
- Then the resident report gives that finding a human face: residents described feeling the effects when relationships with management fray, when burnout rises, and when staff turnover makes buildings feel less stable and less responsive.
- That resident report is especially powerful because it makes clear that providers are not describing these pressures in a vacuum.
- Residents talked about safety concerns, disruptive behavior connected to unmet service needs, and the strain of trying to live in a building where both neighbors and staff may be stretched beyond capacity.
- The report also says nonprofit providers have been hit by rapid cost increases and revenue reductions that have made it harder to provide the level of maintenance and resident service they expect of themselves.
- Which gets to something the reports keep returning to: service intensity has changed.
- Operators describe residents arriving with more acute needs, while the system has not kept pace with the funding and coordination required to support that reality.
- The resident report says the demands placed on nonprofit housing providers have increased extensively as resident needs have grown more acute.
- And that has ripple effects everywhere.
- Units can take longer to turn.
- Placements can take longer.
- Staff are handling more complicated situations.
- Physical inspections become harder to pass.
- Deferred maintenance becomes harder to tackle.
- None of that means operators do not care.
- In many cases, it means the opposite: they are trying to do more, under worse conditions, with less room for error.
- The preservation angle is huge here too.
- The qualitative report points out that Minnesota has thousands of Li-tech units now reaching ages where rehabilitation needs are real, but resources to recapitalize much of that stock are limited.
- So this is not only about current operating distress.
- It is also about whether the state can preserve affordable housing that already exists.
- That is why these findings matter beyond any one portfolio.
- This is reputable research, but it is also field-based research.
- It comes from providers, their books, their properties, their staff experience, and residents living in these homes.
- And the through-line is pretty unmistakable: the sector is under strain, the causes are bigger than any one operator, and the consequences land first on the people who call these places home.
- So then the question becomes: what do we do with that information? Because these reports are not saying affordable housing is failing.
- They are saying affordable housing is being asked to absorb shocks it was never designed to absorb alone.
- Exactly.
- And that is the key distinction.
- This is not a story about weakness.
- It is a story about overload.
- And if Minnesota wants these homes to remain safe, stable, and truly affordable, then the response has to match the reality the research lays out not just in theory, but in operations, funding, services, and preservation.
- And that is the challenge in front of Minnesota right now: not just building affordable housing, but making sure the housing we already have can stay stable, safe, and financially viable.
- Because once distress sets in, the costs don’t stay contained.
- They show up in operations, in resident experience, and eventually in the long-term health of the entire housing system.
- We’re going to take a quick break.
- When we come back, we’ll shift from the big picture to something practical: if you’re a housing provider who’s new to Section 8 or Housing Choice Vouchers what do you actually need to know before you start accepting them? We’ll ask Mihra to walk us through the basics from inspections and rent reasonableness to the role of your local housing authority, and what can vary depending on where you operate.
- And we’ll also tell you about a unique training opportunity from MHA: a one-day Boiler Exam Preparation Class built specifically as a fast-moving exam prep course for housing professionals who want a focused path into state boiler licensing prep.
- That’s after the break.
- Looking to refresh your flooring without the hassle? Bloomington Carpet One has you covered—with expert guidance, quality products, and solutions tailored for multi housing professionals.
- Whether it’s one unit or an entire building, their team helps you choose flooring that’s stylish, durable, and budget-friendly.
- Visit carpet-one-bloomington.com
- or stop by their Bloomington showroom to see the difference that local expertise and national buying power can make.
- Bloomington Carpet One.
- Beautiful made affordable.
- Power problems don’t wait for convenient timing.
- And in multifamily, neither can you.
- J.
- Becker partners with housing providers to keep communities powered, connected, and operating without interruption.
- From complex electrical upgrades and service troubleshooting to EV charging installations, J.
- Becker handles the heavy electrical work that keeps your properties running.
- We also provide low-voltage systems, security infrastructure, and preventative maintenance— working behind the scenes so your residents never notice a disruption.
- WE understand phased renovations.
- WE understand occupied buildings.
- And we understand that downtime costs MORE than money.
- Whether you're stabilizing an aging asset or planning your next capital improvement, J.
- Becker brings the expertise and responsiveness multifamily demands.
- Visit j becker .com
- to learn more.
- Built for multifamily.
- Ready when YOU are.
- We are, J.
- Becker and Associates.
- Welcome back.
- Before the break, we talked about what happens when affordable housing is under pressure at the system level.
- Now let’s bring it down to something practical.
- It’s time for Ask mira.
- And today’s question is one a lot of providers run into when they’re trying to widen access and fill units: what should I know if I’m new to accepting Housing Choice Vouchers what a lot of people still call Section 8? The first thing to know is that the program is federal, but the experience is local.
- Your local Public Housing Authority, or PHA, administers the voucher, handles the approval process, and walks the tenancy through lease-up.
- HUD’s landlord guidance says the basic flow is: connect with the PHA, screen the applicant using your normal criteria, submit the tenancy approval paperwork, and make sure the unit meets the required inspection standards before move-in.
- So you’re still the landlord.
- You still choose whether an applicant meets your screening criteria.
- But once everyone wants to move forward, the program adds a few extra steps.
- The rent has to be reviewed for reasonableness, the unit has to pass inspection, and then there are two signatures that matter: the lease with the resident, and the HAP contract with the PHA, which sets up the housing assistance payment.
- And that’s really the headline for someone new to vouchers: this is not mysterious, but it is procedural.
- The more familiar you are with your local PHA’s workflow, the smoother it usually goes.
- HUD also notes that PHAs can differ in how they administer parts of the program, so it helps to think of this less as one-size-fits-all and more as learning your local process well.
- Exactly.
- Keep the unit inspection-ready, know your paperwork, and treat the PHA like a program partner.
- That usually puts you in a much better position from the start.
- And while we’re on the subject of practical tools for providers, here’s what’s happening at MHA.
- MHA is offering a Boiler Exam Preparation Class that’s built a little differently.
- Instead of the typical two-day format, MHA worked with St.
- Paul College to condense the material into a one-day course.
- It’s taught by the people who helped create the exam, so the focus is exam prep not a broad boiler operations course.
- And for property teams, especially maintenance techs, that matters.
- Being out of the office for one day is a whole lot easier than being out for two.
- It’s a smart setup: tighter, more targeted, and easier to fit into a busy schedule.
- And that’s where we’ll leave it for today.
- Thanks for listening to The Brief.
- We appreciate you spending part of your day with us.
- We’ll see you next time.
- This has been The Brief, an original podcast produced by the Minnesota Multi Housing Association.
- It is hosted by your two favorite AI voices—me, Denise Wilson… …and me, Logan Garcia.
- Our story editor is Todd Lillgenquist.
- Aubrey Albrecht is our showrunner and managing producer.
- The Brief’s executive producer is Sesil Smith.
- Follow and listen on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, mmha.com,
- and wherever you get your podcasts.
- And one more big thank-you to Citizens State Bank, our founding sponsor.
- Their support powers this podcast—and their team powers smart financial solutions for Minnesota’s housing providers.
- Visit csbnet.net
- to learn more.
- See you next time!