Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / Graham vs Munger⚡️: Has Value Investing Outgrown Its Father? From Cigar-Butt” to Wonderful Companies
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to the deep dive. This is where we take a whole
- 0:02stack of sources and really pull out the key Nuggets for you.
- 0:05That's the plan. Today we're diving into the
- 0:07minds of two absolute legends who, well, they reshaped how we
- 0:12think about markets and value. Benjamin Graham.
- 0:14The father of value investing, you could say.
- 0:16Absolutely. And then Charlie Munger, the
- 0:18architect who built upon that foundation, really creating its
- 0:21modern form. So our mission today is to trace
- 0:24that evolution. How did value investing go from
- 0:28Graham's focus on, you know, tangible stuff, Balance sheet
- 0:31value? Stuff born out of surviving
- 0:33market trashes. Right to Munger's much broader
- 0:36view, thinking about intangible quality, long term business
- 0:39strength, using ideas from all over the place.
- 0:42It's a fascinating shift. We got a great report, Graham
- 0:44versus Munger investing philosophies and some other key
- 0:47pieces to guide us. So Are you ready to figure out
- 0:48if you're buying a discarded cigar butt or maybe investing in
- 0:53an economic castle? Good question.
- 0:55Because by the end, you should have a much clearer idea of what
- 0:58makes a business truly valuable and maybe, just maybe, what kind
- 1:01of investor you want to be. OK, let's dig in.
- 1:04We really have to start with Benjamin Graham.
- 1:06You can't understand his ideas without understanding his world.
- 1:09Exactly, context is everything here.
- 1:11We're talking serious economic turmoil early 20th century.
- 1:15Think about the crash of 19 O 7 and then the big 1/19/29.
- 1:19Devastating. And Graham lived through it,
- 1:21lost a lot of himself. And that experience, maybe more
- 1:23than anything, it just hammered into him this profound need to
- 1:27avoid risk, a deep distrust of speculation.
- 1:30His number one goal became capital preservation rule #1
- 1:34don't lose money rule #2 See a rule #1 pretty much.
- 1:38And it's so important to get this.
- 1:39His system wasn't just academic. It was like an intellectual
- 1:43toolkit for survival. Survival.
- 1:44Yeah. In a world where businesses
- 1:46failed constantly, where mispricings were extreme, where
- 1:49liquidations were common, his focus on liquidation value
- 1:52wasn't random. It was a direct response.
- 1:54Absolutely a logical response to a market that often forced you
- 1:58into liquidation. He built a system to help you
- 2:01survive the absolute worst. So from that fire, Graham gave
- 2:05us these, let's say, 3 core pillars for the intelligent
- 2:09investor. Pillars is a good word.
- 2:11Foundational ideas. The first one, and maybe the
- 2:14most famous story is Mr. Market. We all kind of know him.
- 2:18Really. In a manic depressive business.
- 2:19Partner exactly every day he shows up, offers to buy your
- 2:22share of the business or sell you his.
- 2:24The catch? He's completely nuts.
- 2:26Some days Total Euphoria offers crazy high prices.
- 2:29Other days, total despair, convinced the sky is falling,
- 2:32offers ridiculously low prices. So the big question Graham poses
- 2:35is, what do you do? Right with this unstable
- 2:38partner. And Graham's lesson is well,
- 2:40it's simple in theory, but incredibly hard in practice.
- 2:42Tell me about it. You just ignore him most of the
- 2:44time. You are under no obligation to
- 2:47trade with him. His mood doesn't matter.
- 2:49You use your own analysis. Precisely your analysis of the
- 2:52fundamental value you exploit his moods buy when he's
- 2:55pessimistic and selling cheap. And maybe think about selling
- 2:58when he's wildly optimistic and overpaying.
- 3:01It's the bedrock of contrarian thinking.
- 3:04But the real challenge isn't the logic, it's the emotion.
- 3:07Oh definitely keeping your head when everyone else is losing
- 3:10theirs. Demands huge emotional
- 3:12discipline. It tests your temperament more
- 3:14than your intellect, really. That discipline connects right
- 3:16into the second pillar, and this one's maybe even more famous,
- 3:20the margin of safety. Yes, the three most important
- 3:23words in investing, according to Graham.
- 3:25He was asked for the secret, and that was his answer.
- 3:28But for Graham, this wasn't just, you know, a nice idea.
- 3:31No, it was quantitative. Strict.
- 3:33He meant buying a dollar's worth of assets for $0.50 if your
- 3:36analysis said a company was worth $20 a share.
- 3:39You wouldn't pay $20 or even 18 dollars.
- 3:41Nope. You'd insist on buying it for,
- 3:43say, $15 or less. That $5 gap?
- 3:46That's your cushion. That's your margin of safety and
- 3:48that cushion is everything. Why so critical?
- 3:50It's your buffer, your protection against, well, making
- 3:53mistakes in your analysis, because you will protection
- 3:56against bad luck, unforeseen problems.
- 3:58Or just the market being crazy? Exactly.
- 4:00Market whims. It's Graham admitting we're
- 4:03human, we make errors and the world is unpredictable.
- 4:07It's your insurance. And crucially for Graham, where
- 4:10did that safety come from? Unequivocally, the price you
- 4:12paid, not from how great you thought the business was or its
- 4:15growth prospects. Safety came from the discount.
- 4:18Got it. Price was paramount.
- 4:20Now the third pillar, the business owner mindset.
- 4:24This is fundamental too. He drew a very sharp line.
- 4:26Between investing and speculating, right?
- 4:29He said an investment after a thorough analysis promises
- 4:32safety of principle and a satisfactory return.
- 4:35Anything else? That's speculation.
- 4:37Gambling basically an. Investor sees a stock not as a
- 4:40flickering ticker symbol but is owning a piece of a real
- 4:43business. So.
- 4:43You focus on operations finances returns like you own the whole
- 4:48thing where the. Speculator just sees a piece of
- 4:49paper hoping someone else pays more later.
- 4:51Like a hot potato, it's. A completely different frame of
- 4:54mind, Graham also gave us some practical tools for finding
- 4:56these bargains. One famous term popularized by
- 4:59Buffett was cigar butt investing.
- 5:01Yeah, it's evocative, isn't it? It really.
- 5:04Is what do you? Mean It's exactly what it sounds
- 5:06like. Finding companies that are
- 5:08struggling may be unattractive, beaten down, but creating?
- 5:11So cheaply so. Cheaply that there's likely one
- 5:14last puff of value left in them. Pick it up off the street, get
- 5:18that last free puff and toss it the.
- 5:20Focus is purely on the bargain price, not the business quality
- 5:23long term. Almost entirely yes.
- 5:25And a specific strategy for this was the net, net.
- 5:29Classic Graham Net net. He found this worked
- 5:31consistently for him over a long time.
- 5:33How? Does it work?
- 5:34A net net is a company whose stock price is less than its net
- 5:38current asset value. NCAV, OK.
- 5:41Break that down NCAV you. Take current assets, cash,
- 5:44receivables, inventory, the liquid stuff and subtract all
- 5:48liabilities short term and long term total liabilities so.
- 5:51What's left is basically the working capital.
- 5:54Exactly, and Graham's rule was to buy only if the stock price
- 5:57was 2/3 of that NCAV or even less.
- 5:59Wow, so you're buying the company for less than its
- 6:02working capital? Effectively yes, meaning you get
- 6:05all the long term assets, buildings, equipment, maybe even
- 6:09brands for free. Like finding money on the
- 6:11street, pretty much. It highlights how inefficient
- 6:14markets could be back then. But these were often troubled
- 6:17companies, right? So how did he protect against
- 6:19failures? Crucial point diversification.
- 6:22He called it diversification as a shield.
- 6:25Don't put all your eggs in one broken basket.
- 6:27Precisely, he recommended holding a lot of these cheap
- 6:30stocks, maybe 30 or more, because some would fail.
- 6:33It hedges against individual business risk and also.
- 6:36Also, against your own ignorance, you don't know
- 6:37everything about every company. Diversification protects you
- 6:40from yourself. He.
- 6:41Also advocated for diversifying across asset classes, right?
- 6:44Stocks and bonds, yes. A mix of stocks and high grade
- 6:47bonds typically suggesting holding between 25% and 75% in
- 6:51stocks, adjusting based on market levels.
- 6:53OK. But here's where things get
- 6:54really interesting. A bit of a contradiction maybe?
- 6:57You're talking about GEICO? Exactly.
- 6:59Graham taught this system. Diversified baskets.
- 7:02Mediocre businesses. Cigar butts.
- 7:04But his own personal wealth? More than half of it came from
- 7:07one investment, GEICO, a single concentrated bet.
- 7:11And Jico wasn't a cigar butt. Not even close.
- 7:14No, it was a fantastic business growing fast with a huge
- 7:18competitive advantage. A.
- 7:19Sustainable Moat even back then. So what does that tell us?
- 7:22Well, it strongly suggests Graham New deep down he
- 7:25understood the incredible power, the superior economics of owning
- 7:29a truly wonderful business. Even if he couldn't quite fit it
- 7:32into the strict quantitative system, he taught everyone else,
- 7:35right? Maybe he felt identifying those
- 7:37wonderful businesses was too hard, too subjective for the
- 7:40average person he was writing for.
- 7:42But he saw it. It was a preview of Munger in a
- 7:44way. That's a perfect transition.
- 7:46Let's talk about Charlie Munger. He didn't throw Gram out.
- 7:48Not. At all.
- 7:49He built on that foundation respectfully but significantly,
- 7:52he. Constructed this magnificent
- 7:54intellectual structure on top, really adapted for a more
- 7:57modern, complex market. And at the core of Munger's
- 8:00thinking is worldly wisdom, his famous lattice work of mental
- 8:04models. OK.
- 8:05Lattice work of mental models sounds impressive.
- 8:07What does it mean practically? It means you can't just
- 8:10understand investing by studying finance alone.
- 8:12That's too narrow you. Need broader knowledge?
- 8:14Exactly. You need the big powerful ideas
- 8:16from other disciplines. Psychology, hugely important for
- 8:20Munger. History, math, physics, biology,
- 8:23the core principles. Why?
- 8:25How does knowing physics help you pick stocks?
- 8:28It's not about literal application usually, Munger
- 8:30famously said. To the man with only a hammer,
- 8:33every problem looks like a nail. Right, avoid being the one trick
- 8:36pony. Yes, relying on just one
- 8:39discipline blinds you, Munger believed.
- 8:41If you mastered maybe 80 or 90 of these key models from various
- 8:45fields, 80 or. 90 That sounds like a lot.
- 8:47But he argued you could then handle maybe 90% of the problems
- 8:50you face. You'd see reality much more
- 8:52clearly than any single discipline expert.
- 8:54Because reality isn't siloed into disciplines.
- 8:56Precisely. Things interconnect and vesting
- 8:58is complex, messy. You need multiple lenses to see
- 9:02it properly. This is a huge contrast to
- 9:04Graham's focused quantitative system.
- 9:06And Munger, he's really credited with pushing Warren Buffett and
- 9:10therefore value investing itself in a new direction.
- 9:13Absolutely catalyzing the most significant evolution he.
- 9:16Gave Buffett that legendary advice the.
- 9:18Line that changed everything forget what you know about
- 9:21buying fair businesses at wonderful prices.
- 9:23Instead, buy wonderful businesses at fair prices it.
- 9:26Sounds similar, but it's a world of difference.
- 9:28Oh, it's. A complete paradigm shift.
- 9:30Monumental Munger saw that the real fortunes, the truly massive
- 9:34returns, weren't in the quick flips of cigar butts.
- 9:37They were where? In owning the really great
- 9:40companies, the ones you could buy and just hold for decades as
- 9:44their intrinsic value just compounds and compounds so.
- 9:47The focus shifts dramatically from the.
- 9:50One time bargain price to the long term compounding power of a
- 9:53superior business. It becomes quality centric.
- 9:56What makes this business durable and that?
- 9:58Quality. That durability?
- 9:59Monger called it an economic Moat.
- 10:01Brilliant term, like a castle Moat protecting it from
- 10:03invaders. A.
- 10:04Business Moat protects its profits from competitors.
- 10:07Exactly. And these moats come in
- 10:08different forms. It's not just one thing.
- 10:10Like what? Give us examples.
- 10:12Well, powerful brands are a huge one.
- 10:14Think Coca-Cola, Apple customers pay more.
- 10:17Stay loyal, OK? What else?
- 10:19Network effects where the service gets more valuable is
- 10:23more people use it. Facebook Visa, it's hard for
- 10:26competitors to break in makes sense.
- 10:27Switching costs If it's expensive or a huge hassle for
- 10:31customers to change providers like with specialized enterprise
- 10:33software, they're. Locked in basically to.
- 10:35A degree yes, and finally cost advantages being the lowest cost
- 10:39producer like Walmart through scale or efficiency but.
- 10:42Just finding a Moat isn't enough for monger.
- 10:44Not at all. That's just Step 1.
- 10:46You have to assess is this Moat durable?
- 10:48Will it last? And just as important is
- 10:52management actively widening the Moat.
- 10:53Good stewards of the castle? Exactly.
- 10:55Because if you have a strong widening Moat, the business's
- 10:59value grows so consistently that the exact price you paid
- 11:02initially becomes less critical over, say, 1020 years.
- 11:05It shifts the focus from finding cheapness today to predicting
- 11:08durability tomorrow. You.
- 11:09Nailed it. It's a dynamic view, not static
- 11:12another. Huge piece of Munger is
- 11:13understanding psychology, the psychology of human misjudgment.
- 11:17Oh, absolutely central to his thinking, avoiding what he
- 11:20called standard stupidity. Standard stupidity.
- 11:23I like that he. Meticulously catalogued dozens
- 11:26of cognitive biases. The ways our own brains trick us
- 11:30into making irrational decisions, especially with money
- 11:33and. His favorite tool to fight these
- 11:35biases? Inversion always invert.
- 11:37Invert How does? That work.
- 11:39Instead of asking how do I make this investment succeed, you
- 11:42flip it. You ask what are all the ways
- 11:44this could fail? How could this go to 0 you?
- 11:46Focus on avoiding the bad outcomes first, Yes.
- 11:50Identify all the potential pitfalls, bad management,
- 11:53disruption, leverage, stupidity, and then figure out how to avoid
- 11:56them. By dodging the failures, you
- 11:59drastically increase your odds of success.
- 12:01It's. A powerful risk management
- 12:02technique built on acknowledging potential failure points.
- 12:05Profoundly so forces you to be realistic and confront your own
- 12:08blind spots. Now, given this focus on deep
- 12:10understanding, Munger had some strong views on diversification.
- 12:15Strong is putting it mildly. He was famously critical of
- 12:18broad diversification, at least for investors who truly know
- 12:22what they're doing. Yeah, that quote,
- 12:24diversification is a protection against ignorance.
- 12:27It makes very little sense for those who know what they're
- 12:29doing that. Flies in the face of Graham's
- 12:31shield it. Really does.
- 12:33It's a major point of divergent Munger's logic is if you've done
- 12:38the intense multidisciplinary work to find a small number of
- 12:41truly outstanding businesses that you understand deeply.
- 12:45Businesses within your circle of competence, right?
- 12:47Then why on earth would you dilute your returns by spreading
- 12:50your money across dozens of mediocre companies?
- 12:53You barely understand he. Advocated for concentration.
- 12:56Highly concentrated portfolios, maybe 10 to 15 stocks, sometimes
- 13:00even fewer. Your absolute best ideas held
- 13:03for the very long term that. Requires incredible conviction
- 13:06and humility. Immense discipline and knowing
- 13:09the edge of your own competence. Knowing what you don't know is
- 13:12critical if you're concentrating bets.
- 13:14This also changes the definition of risk, doesn't it?
- 13:16Fundamentally, for Graham, risk was largely about the price paid
- 13:20relative to quantifiable assets. Low price equals low risk.
- 13:24Margin of safety through price for.
- 13:26Munger risk is more about the future.
- 13:28It's the risk that the businesses competitive advantage
- 13:31might erode. It's a qualitative judgement
- 13:33about durability. So paying a fair price for a
- 13:36dominant company like Coke? Munger would argue that's far
- 13:39less risky long term than buying a dying textile mill at a 50%
- 13:43discount to its liquidation value, even.
- 13:45Though the mill looks cheaper on paper.
- 13:47Because Coke's Moat protects its earnings power for decades, the
- 13:50mill is only protected against that one time mispricing.
- 13:54Quality versus cheapness. Let's.
- 13:55Make this concrete the sees candy story.
- 13:57This seems like the turning point it.
- 13:58Absolutely was 1972 Berkshire buys, sees candies for $25
- 14:02million. And from a Graham perspective?
- 14:04Disaster. The price was roughly 3 times
- 14:06its net tangible assets, about $8 million.
- 14:10Buffett himself said Graham would have been horrified.
- 14:12So. Why did they do it?
- 14:13This was Mongers influence right?
- 14:14Huge influence. Buffett was stuck on the high
- 14:16price relative to the tangible book value.
- 14:19Munger, look deeper. Pass the raw financials as you
- 14:21said. Exactly.
- 14:22He saw the intangibles. The incredibly powerful brand,
- 14:26the intense customer loyalty and the key insight untapped pricing
- 14:31power. Pricing power.
- 14:33Meaning CS could raise prices consistently without losing many
- 14:36customers. Because CS wasn't just sugar and
- 14:38chocolate it. Was emotion gifts?
- 14:40Yes. He was associated with holidays
- 14:43affection. That executive quote sees
- 14:45candies means getting kissed. That's brand power you can't
- 14:49easily quantify on a balance sheet so.
- 14:50Munger wasn't asking about book value, he was asking can.
- 14:53We sell that $1.95 box of candy for $2.25 and the answer was
- 14:58yes, and then for $2.50 yes again and again that.
- 15:01Ability to raise prices was the real asset, the Moat.
- 15:04That durable pricing power was the economic Moat, far more
- 15:06valuable than the factories or inventory.
- 15:08And the result? Phenomenal success.
- 15:10That $25 million investment generated well over a billion
- 15:12dollars in profit for Berkshire over the years.
- 15:14It became their model of a dream business.
- 15:16Proof of concept for mongers ideas.
- 15:19Absolutely. But more than that, it.
- 15:20Changed Buffett. Permanently, Buffett famously
- 15:23said. If we hadn't bought C's, we
- 15:25wouldn't have bought Coke. Wow.
- 15:27Sees gave him the real world proof, the intellectual
- 15:30confidence to pay up for truly high quality franchises.
- 15:33Later, it validated Monger's focus on quality over just
- 15:37statistical cheapness. So let's bring this all
- 15:40together. What does this journey from
- 15:41Graham to Monger mean for you, the listener, the investor
- 15:45today? Well.
- 15:46First, despite the strategic differences in how they
- 15:48invested, their core philosophy that required temperament is
- 15:52identical. Rationality.
- 15:54Emotional discipline. Strong aversion to real risk
- 15:56thinking long term, viewing stocks as businesses.
- 15:59They were completely aligned on the foundations.
- 16:01OK. But practically, can you still
- 16:03be a pure Graham investor today finding those net Nets?
- 16:06It's exceptionally hard, maybe impossible at scale.
- 16:09Markets are just much more efficient now.
- 16:10Information is everywhere. Those obvious cigar butts are
- 16:13mostly gone. But.
- 16:14His principles still matter more.
- 16:15Than ever demanding a margin of safety, Controlling your
- 16:18emotions when Mr. Market goes crazy, Treating volatility as
- 16:22opportunity. That's timeless wisdom.
- 16:24Graham is the indispensable starting point, the
- 16:27psychological bedrock. And mongers approach quality
- 16:30focused multidisciplinary that's.
- 16:32Arguably the dominant model for serious long term large scale
- 16:36investing now, but much harder. It demands way more work, broad
- 16:40curiosity across fields and deep humility.
- 16:43Knowing what you don't know, staying in your circle of
- 16:45competence, Munger himself said investing got harder because the
- 16:49simple statistical bargains dried up.
- 16:51You actually have to think deeply about business quality
- 16:53now, so. It's not about choosing Graham
- 16:55or Munger. No, I think the goal is to
- 16:57integrate them. Every serious investor needs to
- 16:59make that intellectual journey. Start with Graham, Build the
- 17:02right mindset, master the margin of safety.
- 17:04Learn to handle Mr. Market. Get the foundation right then.
- 17:07Evolve with Munger, build that lattice work of models, learn to
- 17:11identify truly wonderful companies, and develop the
- 17:13confidence to pay a fair price for them when you find them.
- 17:16It's a progression, not a replacement.
- 17:18The ideal. Approach, then, is combining
- 17:20Graham's price discipline with Munger's quality judgement.
- 17:23Exactly. Use Munger's lens to find the
- 17:26great businesses, but use Graham's discipline to avoid
- 17:29overpaying even for the best and avoid Graham's trap of buying
- 17:33cheap businesses that are just deteriorating.
- 17:36Finding that sweet spot a wonderful business at a fair
- 17:40price. That's the Holy Grail, isn't it?
- 17:42So. Here's the final thought to
- 17:43leave you with In today's world drowning in information, what's
- 17:47actually harder is finding those rare, statistically cheap cigar
- 17:51butts. Or is it doing the deep work to
- 17:54truly understand a wonderful business and having the patience
- 17:56to hold it even when it doesn't look cheap on a basic stock
- 17:59screen? Someone to definitely Mull over
- 18:01on your own investing journey. That's all for this deep dive.
- 18:04We really hope you gain some valuable insights, maybe a few
- 18:07surprising connections. There's a great discussion.
- 18:10Now, as always, a quick reminder, all the analysis here
- 18:12is based on publicly available sources.
- 18:14It's purely for educational purposes.
- 18:16It doesn't constitute investment advice.
- 18:18Always do your own research. Absolutely conduct your own due
- 18:21diligence before making any decisions.
- 18:23If you enjoyed this, please do like and subscribe.
- 18:26You can find the Deep Dive on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, and our
- 18:30YouTube channel. And check the episode
- 18:32description. We've put together a list of key
- 18:34books on value investing related to Graham and Munger.
- 18:36Great point, Definitely check that out.
- 18:38We'll be back soon with another stack of sources to unpack for
- 18:41you.