Latest / Jew York Times / Zohran's Antisemitism plan, Israel Plane Hijacking and Israel Election Update/Ultra Orthodox Rundown
Transcript
- Eitan: Welcome to the New York Times. On today's episode, it is another edition of 120 Angry C C lead up to the Israeli election. I am joined by Shani Reichman from the Israel Policy Forum. We be talking about election updates. Plus, we're going to be talking about the Mamdani anti-Semitism campaign effort commission that's been set up. To try and fight anti-Semitism on a municipal basis. Also, we'll be talking about the Fly Dubai Tel Aviv hijacking. like I said on my Instagram, someone learned that that it's not a good idea to try to hijack a plane full of 175 Mossad agents. all of those stories and more on today's episode. Sha'em, sing it with me. Yay da-da-da-da-da-da. Shanie: No. Eitan: New York Times, baby. Shanie: Wait, Aton Aton, we said I said that I realize now that the next time we record, I should come to your studio. Studio in quotations because it's your living room. Eitan: Yes. Shanie: but but we didn't do that. We should do that. Eitan: Listen, a Tucker Carlson records in his living room. I'm basically the Tucker Carlson of the Jewish media universe, as a lot of people say. I know I do. Shanie: You've a nice, you've a nice hook setup. It's like what is that, a Hasidish guy riding a Vespa and playing baseball and dunking? Eitan: It's a slam dunk. Do you know what these are? Do you know what what this is? Shanie: Is it your own baseball cards? Eitan: These are my own baseball cards, but this is the this is the funny thing about them though, is that so I'm in I'm in tops trading cards. Like literally, if you open up I think what's called version two or or update number two from last year, if you open up packs, you could pull an A Ton Levine, which it's actually Shanie: Sec. Eitan: funny because I bet there's a bunch of kids out there that spent their like allowance and then pulled an Aton Levine, and we're like, what the hell? This is you kidding me? Shanie: They're listening right now. Eitan: but they had me sign 200 of the cards, right? So 10 of them have a special Lahayam alt signature. So 10 of them say the word La Chayam on it. And I've been finding them on eBay. So I've actually been buying back my special Lahayam inserts of the top trading cards. Which is a Shanie: That's so cute. I love that. That's adorable. Eitan: this is a pretty cool. And then this is my Guinness record for setting the thing. Shani, how you doing? How this episode, by the way, Shanie: Yes, I'm fabulous. Eitan: we're moving next week. We're not even shooting this episode in the space. Do you know where we're shooting next episode? Shanie: No idea. Eitan: On a on a fly Dubai flight going to Tel Aviv. We gotta start with this. Obviously, this is the big news. More and more keeps on coming out every minute. But this morning there was an attempted hijacking, it seems. And I want to say also that everyone is learning more information every minute by this. But apparently there was a hijacking on a fly Dubai flight where the co pilot tried to stab the other pilot. the door was somehow opened. At that point, a bunch of Israelis came in and were able to subdue the the the hijacker. they also apparently hogtied him with in. flight headphone cords, which I thought was very, very funny. Shanie: Innovative. Eitan: very, very creative. the other thing was that apparently it dropped the plane dropped a ton, and I was reading, and once again, we're in the Reddit part of this story where everyone Shanie: Okay. Eitan: is getting their information off of screenshots. Some of us from Reddit, but apparently the fact that they had dropped as fast as they did and as low as they did, but pulled up, and the plane didn't like snap off the back. Is a miracle. And I say that because Shanie: Mm. Eitan: apparently the interview that BB Netanyahu got with the one of the the people that stopped the hijacking, he said that he learned how to pull the plane up because there's a very popular TV show called May Day. and he was able to figure out how to pull the plane up out of the spiral that was happening in order to stop the plane from crashing. So Absolutely crazy story. the pilot is being heralded as a hero. the Israelis who stopped it are being heralded as heroes. after the plane landed in Tel Aviv, one of the Israelis who had subdued the hijackers, covered in blood, was brought over to meet with Bibi Netanyahu immediately. and then he got to tell Bibi Netanyahu the story. it was actually pretty funny because I feel like some of the politics maybe did melt away a little bit because Bibi was like, and then what happened? Cool. And Shanie: Yeah. Eitan: then and then what? no way. Like there was that element to it. But I gotta ask, you know, what is BB gonna be able to use this in order to get some political headwind from it? Do you see this at all affecting the campaigns coming up? And then I also gotta ask about the conspiracy theory side of this all, but let's talk about that first thing first. he was a little bit starstruck I I I gotta go I gotta ask the question though do you see this as having any political repercussions is BB gonna be able to use this to get any political headwind do you see this at all mattering in the election coming up Shanie: I don't I mean it's a nice photo op. And but Netzanyao is already starting to do a little bit better than he was before, unfortunately. So I don't know that like this is making I mean it's a nice photo op again, but like it's not gonna make or break things. If it, you know, if it escalates, right? If there's if somehow there becomes like more security threats. When things are bad for Israel, they tend to be good for Bibi Netzanyao. And so that's kind of like the way things go. Right. Like the more Israelis feel isolated. So again, less about like the photo op and more about how do Israelis broadly feel? Do they feel isolated and alone and afraid and threatened? Cause that can sometimes lead to to folks moving to the right in general. and I will say the the recent polling is putting Eisenblock and the Nestaniao block Eitan: The Eisenblock. Shanie: without the ROM parties. It's putting them very close together, very head to head right now. Eitan: So this could be the kind of thing where like any little bit matters, but this probably won't matter, but it will matter a little bit, which won't matter that much, but may matter a little bit. Shanie: Yeah, they're they're fight they're fighting over like two percent of the voters. And as I told you in the last episode, it'll all have like the main thing that's gonna decide if they're going to another election or if Isenko can actually build a coalition is whether or not the like reservists, like whether the three right-wing parties all make it above the threshold. Right now, Amha Israel and the reservists, I'm now looking at them hovering around four. So Eitan: Okay. Shanie: that's actually high the reservists were not making it in polls I'd seen previously. Now you Now I'm looking at like four very right wing parties, but hovering around four is like you're not gonna make it. You're very hovering around four is like you're very unlikely to make it in. So I'm not that optimistic. but that would like change the whole would change everything, right? Like that changes all the all the math that you do. Eitan: Before we go back into the election side of this, I gotta ask you it's on the fly Dubai incident side of things. Conspiracy theories? Here we come. Do you Shanie: No no no Eitan: think BB did this? How do you Shanie: No Eitan: think BB smuggled the axe into the cockpit? Is BB secretly an Omani national? This is what I want. Shanie: What deranged what deranged side of the internet are you on? Is this Reddit? What where is this from? Eitan: I get this, I get hoof cleaning videos. This is it. It's but okay, here's the thing though. Very real. Let's talk about how there's a couple things that can come from this. One, Shanie: Okay. Eitan: you're obviously gonna get the conspiracy theories out there. There's obviously we are gonna be in this next part. I in my mind, the cycle is gonna be we're gonna get small justifications of hijacking an Israeli plane. You know that is coming. Shanie: Naturally. Eitan: You know that there's gonna be an instant con think pieces that are like how hijacking planes is actually an act of liberation or anything like that. Shanie: Of course, Israelis aren't aren't humans, so it's fine. Anything goes Eitan: And you're gonna, you know, you're gonna get the the whole batch of the internet that's saying that this is a conspiracy theory because, you know, BB somehow is able to finagle this into a point or two, like, you know, everyone always thinks that BB and the Mossad are doing BB and the Mossad things. Shene, I just gotta ask, you know, out there, what is the likelihood that there was some sort of conspiracy element to this? And if you had to pick your most likely conspiracy, what would it be? Shanie: I'm very anti-conspiracy. I think conspiracy is ultimately Eitan: Obviously. Shanie: when people talk about like weird contr people control small groups of people controlling this or controlling that, it's like always the Jews, and then the Jews get killed. So I will not be contributing to any conspiracy theory dissemination here. Okay. I think that there's no chance that this is true, and I'm not gonna entertain it unless without actual evidence. Eitan: Did Overwinter do it? Shanie: No. Eitan: Okay, good. Wow. She's holding the line. I l All I'm Shanie: But Eitan: saying is that this is obviously I don't think that any of this is true, but at the same time, like it's so undeniable that the stuff does get tossed around a ton. Like we are going to go through a Shanie: Totally, totally. Eitan: news cycle where it is going to be like, wow, this is convenient. You know, Israel wants to get like some positive will out of this. Also, we got lucky by the fact that there's a Saudi Arabia tie in the fact that the plane landed in Saudi Arabia. And no one freaked out. No one was like, this is Shanie: Yeah. Eitan: bad. You know, like that's a big thing when it comes to the Abraham Accords and it comes to justifying some of the movements that you know BB has taken. Like he does like there is it's a net positive thing. Obviously, it's net negative because of how crazy it was and and the fact that someone got injured and the fact that you have a plane full of people that are, you know, reeling from something, but also it can totally be looked at as like a positive thing on the Israeli side of things. Shanie: Yeah. What's interesting now is that like Israel has great relations with fewer countries than ever than like it has in a very long time, but it has normal relations with more countries than it ever has, right? So in a time Eitan: Yes. Shanie: where like its biggest allies are like, let's be acquaintances, it has gained a lot of acquaintances. So, which means like ultimately he i Israel has fewer enemies than it's ever had, unless you count like, you know, Spain as its enemy. But like it's had fewer actual enemies than it's ever had, which is great. And It's downgraded a lot of a lot of besties to like friends and friends to acquaintances at the same time. So it's like when people ask me if Israel's in a better or worse position, I think overall worse, because I think it's going to get worse if we go down this, continue on this path. But right now, like it actually, the fact that you can land in Saudi Arabia and not be worried is amazing. And there is Eitan: Yeah. Shanie: something there. I also want to say Jordan Tilchin posted this, and she is so right, which is that we all have to do Chuva for being like I am such a I am so horrible to Israelis on planes. I hate them so much. I am so angry. I like try not to fly LL. I try to fly to Israel on Shabbat specifically. Like I do not, I don't like Israelis Eitan: No. Shanie: on planes. and I think we can, that's like something that all American Jews can like unify on. And but you know what? What? What video? No. no, maybe I did. Fine, do your bit. Do you have a bit on this? Eitan: Did you not watch my video? The one that I did on this. Shainee, I watch all your videos. This was me, this wasn't Jordan Tilkin. Shanie: She wrote she posted it today. Eitan: I did all I did also. I made the same point. Shanie: No, saying that we all need to say sor that we all need to say sorry to the to like Israelis because they like at the end of the day, they got you covered if like shit's hitting the fan. Eitan: Let me just say that Jews and Israelis get a ton, people shit on us a ton for the way that we act on planes. And that is. Shanie: No wee. I'm perfect I know plane etiquette. I'm great on a plane. Go on. Eitan: You are your brother's keeper, Shiny. Okay? This is what we've learned here when it comes to this stuff. Jews and Israelis were not known for our plane etiquette. But also, people keep on hijacking us. So at the end of the day, maybe we would be a little bit nicer on planes, a little bit less uppity and a little bit less, you know, try to be comfortable and and try to, you know, keep space for us if people didn't try to keep on crashing our planes, huh? It's a one Shanie: True. Eitan: for one here. If you want us to behave better, then you guys also gotta start. being a little bit nicer to us is what I would say out there over yeah. Shanie: you know you know what, Aitan, ju I'm asking you a Jewish or anti-Semitic, standing up on a plane before the plane is stopped when it's like not your turn to go out. Like just no connecting flight, no connecting flight, just standing up in the aisle the second it lands. Eitan: Can I say not Jewish, not anti Semitic, Hasidic. Okay? Shanie: Yeah. Eitan: There needs to be a third category. I'm not getting up because also there's a Jewish part to it where everyone that gets up is the ones that has to stand up. I'm not standing up at all. Shanie: Wait, another one, another one. Eitan: Go. Shanie: Getting out of the plane before it's your turn. The person in front of you has not yet got yet left their seat and you don't wait for them and you just run out of the plane. Ugh. Then I hate the Jews. Eitan: Jewish. Jewish. Jewish. Jewish, Jewish, Jewish, Jewish, Jewish. Okay? Jewish. I mean, listen, I get it, but also Jewish. That's how it works. We have to behave how we behave, okay? Shanie: they're so anxious. Eitan: If we if we don't behave the way that we behave, the people are gonna trounce us as we've learned at every given thing. Also, I wanna say what is the funniest things about it? It's been the videos that came out from the from the the From the plane as it was landing, and people are like singing and cheering and stuff like that. If this was ever a lesson here, it is don't if you're a hijacker, just keep in mind if you try to hijack an Israeli plane, there is a good chance that you're gonna have your face kicked in and then have to listen to Tel Aviv, Ya Khabibi Tel Aviv, just as you're going down to be arrested by Saudi Arabia's, you know, a police department. It's embarrassing. You can't hate Israel Shanie: Samaritan. Eitan: and then get absolutely eviscerated by a bunch of dudes and sandals named Yossi. You gotta, it's embarrassing out there. This guy's gonna go to prison. Eventually he's gonna die. And when he dies, he's gonna go to to wherever. I'm not saying heaven or hell. He's gonna go to whatever's next, and he's got to face some sort of God. And that God, he's gonna have to admit to the time where he effed up this thing and gave Jews a good week of PR. Anyways, I want to move on before we talk about the election thing. I just have one more thing that I want to kind of flag, and that is with the Mamdani administration. This week, the Mamdani administration announced an act, announced a commission, announced an effort to fight anti-Semitism. It is a municipal effort. Apparently, it's the first in the nation to have a codified anti-Semitism fighting effort. here's the the the rub of this thing. One, it frees up a lot of money for safety for synagogues, which is great. I think a lot of people don't realize how much money synagogues have to pay when it comes to safety, especially around high holidays. you know, I've in the billions from from what I saw across the nation. Second thing that they are doing is that they are investing more in Jewish cultural initiatives. They are spending some money on the Holocaust Museum. They are putting some Jewish heritage stuff up in the link NYC things. They're just putting more money, investing more money into Jewish heritage stuff in the city, which is incredibly Shanie: Mm-hmm. Eitan: important. Those are the two things that I really like. Here is what I don't like about it, it does not really address the central cause of anti-Semitism and anti-Jewish hate that is currently happening in New York. And that is that yes, the right wing, obviously, the conspiracy theories they they hate and they will hate the Jews and all that stuff. But it just happens to be statistically, the hate that is leveled at Jews nowadays in New York frequently comes from in New York. Shanie: In New York, not everywhere. Eitan: I'm just saying I'm talking about specifically New York. The hate that is leveled at Jews oftentimes is based in anti-Zionism or hating Israel that oversteps into a place that is just hating Jews, targeting Jews, becomes completely inappropriate. The documents of the way that they're talking about this stuff and the speech that that Zoran did on Instagram, they don't address this central cause. And because the mayor has a very awkward relationship with Israel in general. I think that it is on him to at some point come out and label the hate as stemming from anti-Israel spaces. And there is a way for him to go out there and say, I don't like Bibi, I don't like the war. If he wants to say genocide, apartheid, occupation, he can say all of that stuff. But he also has to admit how the Israeli component is screwing the Jews in New York. On top of that, Jews in New York have some sort of relationship. To Israel. Just is what it is. I want to be able to say, I visited my sister in Israel. I went to this Israeli restaurant. I saw this Israeli movie. I want to be able to say that on a subway and not have to look over my back or hush my tone when I say it. I don't know if the act or this commission or you know, whatever they're calling this, I don't know if this helps that specific cause. And that specific cause, elephant in the room, is where a lot of the Jewish conversations around synagogues and you know and and Shabbat tables, that is where the the the fear is. The fear is anti-Israel hate that crosses its line into anti-Jewish hate. I don't think that this commission really touches that yet. And the last thing I'll say is that this is a first step. They've made that very clear that this is the first step of what they consider will be many steps, but that was kind of my overall take on it. Shani, what are your kind of thoughts? Shanie: Yeah. I mean, I I think that maybe you were hoping for a little too much because I it's hard for me to imagine a world where Mamdani is willing to connect the dots between anti-Semitism and anti-Zionism when he's himself, you know, really part of the anti-Zionist community. These are his voters, these are his people. the activists that supported him brought him into office, and for him to say your rhetoric, even when I even though I agree with your rhetoric, your rhetoric is feeling anti-Semitism. It's gonna be pretty hard for him to do. But yes, I agree. It's pretty in New York. People are not that concerned Eitan: We should do the hard thing. Shanie: about white nationalism. Obviously, white nationalism gets Jews killed all over the country in the world. It's not in New York really the case. here we're dealing with something else entirely, and Israel's central to that. And also, I should add, like, ultra Orthodox Jews in Brooklyn are the primary target of anti-Semitism in New York. Eitan: Mm-hmm. Shanie: so I would like to also see something that's like targeting their. I mean, he has like a good relationship with some of those folks because they some of them are anti-Zionist and non-Zionist, but like I don't. I I do think it's important to say like that's where that's where people are actually getting beaten in the streets. right. Eitan: I I will say that I think that his relationship with the with the Hasidim in New York, he has what I would consider to be one of the more healthy relationships they have the the most healthy relationship with him because they have recognized that safety and their tax credits and bike lanes and you know and food stamps and stuff are pretty important. They're willing to swallow the Israel element. They don't see Israel the same way that the modern Orthodox community sees Israel, not in an anti Zionism side, just in a I think that that is kind of like the vibe that they have with it. But the Orthodox communities and the modern sorry, what? Shanie: Good segue. I said that'll be a great segue for when we talk what we're talking about today. Eitan: absolut a hundred percent. The Haredi issues. my god. But I I do think that he had they have like a pretty like normalized relation with him. I just I think that at some point Zoran just has to like stand with like a couple of Israelis, like eat a falafel and just like be normal about it. I you know, i i he released that Russia Shana video. Shanie: Yeah. Like if you would go to an Israeli Israelis for peace rally where like those are people who Eitan: Yeah. Shanie: are, you know, they're really lefties, but they're they still have the word like Israelis. I feel like it would be meaning wonder if that's in the works. We should talk to some people. Cause like to nor to humanize Eitan: That's but that's what I'm saying. It's like there's ways to s Shanie: Israelis. I I I don't like it because like, these are the good Israelis as opposed to all the rest, but but still I think that something like that, if he could like do something of that nature would be nice. Not to say that he doesn't ever get pictured with Israelis, you there are some like anti-occupation Israelis who make the rounds and Or sometimes, you know, near him and whatnot. Eitan: But even then I'm like, just it it needs to be normal. Like it needs to be the big thing that needs to happen is that Israelis and J and Judaism in New York, in order for this to be effective, have to be removed from the the war in Gaza. Like that is the only way at this point to to to Shanie: Well, I don't y yes, but I don't think what he's doing is trying to conflate Jews in New York from Israel and Gaza. I think he's actually trying to separate Eitan: No. Shanie: them to like it's it's in his best interest to separate them because he doesn't want to be seen as an anti-Semite. And I'm not calling him one, but I'm saying like he wants those to be viewed as separate. Eitan: Yeah, but the only way for him to do that is to acknowledge like this thing that he's not acknowledging because he can't. Like he the only way for him to to to separate the two effectively would be to say, I am pro-Israeli culture and I am anti-Israel or the government. Like he's not he hasn't done the step Shanie: Yeah. Eitan: to embrace Israeli culture. And because he's not embracing like Israel as a people, it prevents him from it prevents him being able to make that like that that that separation. And Shanie: You're saying separate Israel from Israelis, the state from the people and the idea of a Jewish state. Yes, agreed. That Eitan: Yeah. Shanie: is like the core issue that everybody is struggling to do and doing a terrible job of like kind of across the board. Is it's not to Eitan: Yeah. Shanie: separate Israel from Jews, it's to separate Israelis and a Jew the notion of Jewish statehood from the Israeli governments. That's the problem. Totally. Eitan: Yeah. Like I just want him to say, like, yeah, I got an Israeli f like this is an Israeli guy that came over to the beggar's house the other like he just I just need him Shanie: Mm. Eitan: to say it. I need him to not be weird around it. And I don't think that this you know, I I don't think that this helps it. I mean like and I will say this also, I I in speaking Shanie: You want you thought he was gonna invest in his really cultural center in Brooklyn? Eitan: I thought he was gonna be opening up a Taeim in the Shanie: Ha ha ha. Eitan: r right next to Gracie Mansion. you know, Shanie: Ha ha ha. Eitan: I I I d that being said, I do think that some of the initiatives that they're funding when it comes to like Jewish heritage stuff, i i it's impossible for them to delete the Israel connection just on like a culture side. Shanie: Mm-hmm. Eitan: I I'm pretty sure that that is gonna be that there is Israeli components that are gonna be highlighted and pushed as part of the money that is being spent on the heritage side. I just think that Until he does that one thing. I you know, I I I it's effective, but it could be way more effective. You know. Shanie: Yeah. Eitan: Anyways, that's why Chanie, that's why I am endorsing you for mayor, okay? You're I I'm Shanie: Ha ha ha. Eitan: running on the Chenille ticket next time. The eisenblock is gonna make their way. Shanie: That's a safe bet. Ugh the Eitan: And with that, I want to move into the 120 Angry Seats section of this episode. we are a little bit under a month away from the Israel elections. October 27th is still the date on where the election is going to start. where are we at polling wise? I know we kind of like talked a little bit about it earlier. Shanie: Yeah. Eitan: walk me through where we are on the polling. Shanie: So the Eisenblock without the ROM party, the Arab Party, average of the last three polls during like the last week or so, Eisenblock 53, Netanyahu block 51, but that's including like eight seats that are really on the verge. so that's important to say. on the right, sorry, on Eitan: On what side? Okay. Shanie: the right, like that includes in in this poll that it's calculating, it's it is is assuming that the reservists and Ampre Istrail are both getting into the Knesset. but by four, like just clearing it. So it's I mean it's really that's Netanyahu really a 47 if I'm being honest. and the RAM party is like if you include that it put it puts eisen eisen caught a little bit higher, five seats higher. that said, it is like getting closer. You can see like you can see an Esanya block getting a little bit closer. but I I don't know. It Eitan: So talk to me about that. Shanie: it's it no longer looks it no longer looks like a clear Well, Landslide's a stretch. Like you I think the most likely scenario is they go to another round of elections, first of all. That's really the most likely scenario. Somebody asked me the other day, was like, the poly like showing you poly market, like BB versus like B BB versus Isengott, and like, that's really not the question. Question is is anyone gonna be able to have a government? And the most likely answer Eitan: Yeah. I mean so just to Shanie: is no. Eitan: just to walk through that specifically, what Shitty's referring to here is that after the first election, if neither side, the opposition and the and the coalition, if neither of them reach 61 seats, then a government is not formed and they have to have the election again. And that process goes Shanie: Yeah. Eitan: over and over and over until eventually one of the sides hits sixty-one. I quick question on that. What happens In the interim. Is there there's an interim government that's put in is that the B B runs that in that government? Shanie: Yeah. He it's called a caretaker government. So basically you can just like stay in power while the elections run. And that's what happened back in like twenty nineteen, twenty twenty, twenty twenty one. Like he just kept well, twenty nineteen, twenty twenty, there were three elections and he just stayed in power. There's actually a really funny music video that I will send you where that like makes a joke about how like with Sarah Netanyahu saying, like, Yeah, we like keep losing, but we just stay in power. So who cares? and that's kind of the Eitan: That's beautiful. Shanie: gist. It's it's feels it's very undemocratic. I mean, not very like th this is the democratic process for Israel, but I don't like it because like four years you're like that's it. Let's go. but you can just stay in power until forever in theory. I don't even know if there's an official time limit because who's gonna run the country otherwise, Eitan: You know, Shanie: right? Eitan: you know this this past week, there was like a little bit of news when it comes to solidifying the Eisenblock. It was the first time that the Shanie: Mm-hmm. Eitan: the leaders of the parties had all sat together and took a very nice picture. I actually you know what I liked about it? It's a really cute Shanie: It was so cute. Eitan: picture. It also is very funny that nine none of them dressed up for the picture. They're all wearing like polo shirts and jeans. except for Bet I think Shanie: Do you not do you not know Israelis? It was is it's Eitan: No, obviously. I be this is you're right. This is Shanie: hilarious. It's all the leaders of the Zionist opposition it having this like bro hang in Yeager Lapide's like basement man cave. It's so funny looking. It's I thought it was so wholesome. I thought it was so wholesome. Yeah. Eitan: They got the they got the they have the Jets game on in the background. There it's a fantasy football draft that happens there. But what's interesting about this meeting was that they solidified the fact that they are all gonna be running on the same side. And when they met, they signed a document. Yes. I was gonna say because they s Shanie: Which is important. Which is important because a Victor Lieberman is to the right and has been like histor historically kind of trying to distance himself from Yah Golan, who's viewed like a real lefty, which is like a little bit funny if you know his politics. and here he's like sitting, you know, in the same picture, which I do think is meaningful. But they didn't say we're all gonna support Gotti Eisencott. Like they did not say that. So I think that's relevant than I would have thought. Eitan: No. I was gonna say what the they signed a pact where they agreed on different topics that they were going to center in the election, and then they also agreed to only attack the opposition. They agreed to not attack each other. They were only going to attack Bibi and the Lee Coud and whoever else is on that side. I I th and they also had agreed on some of like the the the main points that they were gonna run on. and focus on one of those points I thought was interesting was about term limits where they all agreed to like term limits and you just you okay Shani if you guys at home are listening Shanie: That's all I want. All I want for Israel is term limits. Eitan: So I'm saying, was this so this was an interesting thing. It it also, okay, here's what I'm saying. This was interesting because it felt like it was the first time I had seen a non war, non Haredi topic that was kind of like frontline up there. The fact that it made it into this pact that was signed between them, I hadn't known that it was even like something that was that high of a priority. walk me through that specifically. The fact that they all agreed to get rid of term limits. Shanie: I mean, I think it's kind of obvious. Like Netzanyao's been in power for fifteen years, on and off, but mostly on. So, like, we have seen the consequences of not having term limits. It in theory, like you would think there's no need for term I mean, you and we're American, so we believe in term limits, but in theory you would think, like, what's the point? If you can keep winning, so keep winning. But the reality is that as the incumbent, you do have like there's a huge benefit to being the incumbent, especially in Israel, which doesn't have a constitution. You can keep changing the rules of the game till you win. You can make sure you like you can time the elections, like you have so much power in Israel over what happened. Like you can affect you control when the elections are. And so it's you're really at an unfair advantage. In America, I don't think. Even though it's good we have term limits, it's not that because of the structure of the system here, I don't think the incumbent is actually that it's not that Eitan: Yeah, no. Shanie: beneficial to be the incumbent. In Israel, it's hugely beneficial, I think. in a way that it just isn't here. Yeah, I think be like I think you have a lot of you because Eitan: That's interesting. That's an interesting element I ever thought of. Yeah. Shanie: you can change. I mean, I'm sure in America you can do it too, but like for now, I think it's much harder to change the rules of the game in America. whereas in Israel, yeah, no, he's been working on it. It's on the agenda. Eitan: The thing is that Trump's been trying to do it. He keeps on when Trump does it, he yeah, he and he but the thing is that he gets shut down can if it's anything that we've learned is that him trying to finagle and to screw around with the election, he's not able to do it. Like he gets shut down fairly consistently. And I feel like Shanie: He hasn't successfully done it. Yeah, he has not successfully done it. Eitan: and I guess the question is, is it easier to finag it's easier to finagle in Israel if you are an incumbent, is what you're saying. Shanie: I think so. well, you do the Supreme Court. So an example of finagling is that they voted on the Central Elections Committee voted to remove the Rom Party, for example. to and and they actually succeeded, right? Like they voted successfully to remove the Rom Party, Mansur Abbas's party. This is the Arab party that could theoretically join could theoretically join the coalition to remove them. and the Supreme Court's going to almost for sure get like push push back on that and it will be irrelevant. But the point is like you can decide like these guys can't run, for example. so that's like obviously changing how like the rules of the game. There's also like a lot of surveillance questions involved. Like there was a lot of surveillance in in Arab towns in the past and a lot of intimidation tactics, things like that, which I don't think exists Eitan: I just wanna say that I think Shanie: as much here. Eitan: The that Arab parties being blocked from running story. I was surprised at how much press that got in America because of how it wasn't being presented accurately. Like Bernie Sanders put a post about it. Everyone's making it seem like this was a law. Like that Israel had voted that Arabs were not allowed that Arab parties were not allowed to the election Shanie: Right. Yes, correct. Eitan: when that just is not fucking true. It's like it it would be like space laser research dollars being allocated, like by Marjorie Taylor Reen. Like someone else has to vote on. This like thing that had happened. So the the fact that it was yeah. Shanie: Yeah. I I also think we should specify that yes, it targeted Arab parties, but it didn't target every Arab politician. It actually po targeted one Jewish politician on an Arab list, and then it taught targeted the chairperson of one of the Arab parties and then the entire Rom party. and so which was not quite legitimate. But my my point being like it isn't like we're not allowing any Arabs to run, right? And there are obviously Arabs running on Jewish slates, Jewish whatever, like Jewish Zionist party lists. so it's not so clean cut. Obviously, I think it's racist and it's rooted in racism, but it's like it's not as simple as he's making it seem to be. And of course, we know the Supreme Court will overturn it. And by the way, I just read that like in terms of how the math works, if these folks were cut, like Gaudi Eisenko would actually do be doing way better if these outer parties didn't run. So there's no way that Netanyahu actually wants this to happen. Like he wants them to run because if they don't, it actually like helps the opposition just because of how the math works. So Eitan: Would a Zoran Mamdani endorsement of the Rom party lead to any votes? I think that that's not a crazy idea out there for Zoran Mam Dani. 100%. Shanie: You know what? Should we get him involved? Eitan: If he wants to come out there and get involved in Israel politics, then let him get involved. If he wants to arrest Bibi, then he also has to endorse Rom. That is actually my official statement. Shanie: A good rule. Eitan: If you want to go out there and make a big deal about arresting Bibi, then you have to pick an actual party that you support. Shanie: An opposition party that you support and Eitan: dead serious about this. Shanie: you help campaign for. By the way, please, Mamdani, do not endorse any of the other parties. because imagine if Mamdani endorsed it at your goal on, that would be like the worst thing in the whole world for Eitan: Let me just say Mamdani, if he was smart, he would he would endorse the the winter party. Him and and Yosef Haddad doing Krav Maga classes in the Gracie Mansion, Shanie: my god, that would be funny. my god. That'll be so good. Eitan: yeah, what's it called? The the field out there in front, I think would you know, would move some votes. Shanie: Carl Schurz Park, that's my park. Eitan: There it is. anyway, okay. So I I got nothing else on just like the election side. So things are getting Shanie: Mm-hmm. Eitan: like kind of closer. what Shanie: Yeah. Eitan: has it what is attributed to the the this like i i slowly got he's been getting less seats on the week and it seems like B B's been getting yeah. Shanie: That's how it yeah. That's how it goes. Gotti just got onto the scene. Everyone was very excited, hyped him up. He got better over time. First of all, Netanyahu always does a little better than the polling shows historically. So he it it this is generally historically, this is how it's worked, and he's done a little bit better as they get closer to election day. So we'll see what happens. It could be that seeing like these guys all sitting together in the man cave, I actually think that could really help. So We'll see how that goes. I think pe some people will actually appreciate that and be like, okay, I feel better voting for these guys. one more note is that we still have this question. I just want to remind you of will they or won't they include the Rom Party, the Arab Party, in their in in a government if they are to form one, all of these Zionist opposition leaders, because you have a Vitor Lieberman who says he does it he won't do it, and you have Natali Bennett who, you know, he said that once and then he did it anyway. Year five years ago, right? So six years ago. so there that that question is is very top of mind. and there are some ideological differences between Mansur Abbas, especially what he's like willing to or not willing to do and say. so we'll see how that goes. Yeah. Eitan: Interesting. Interesting. you know, one of the bigger through lines throughout this election has been the concept of the Haredi parties. How's that for a transition? The ultra orthodox Yeah. Yeah. Shanie: Ultra Orthodox. That was a great transition. No, because we talked about the ultra-orthodox in Brooklyn and how they are kind of like single issue. They care a lot about welfare and education systems and like more localized issues. And the ultra Orthodox are very similar, although you need to add in like the question of the IDF draft. But otherwise, like they actually, there are a lot of national questions and issues historically that they don't care so much about. Like they're not running as much on the like question of national security and foreign policy the way that most Israelis are. Eitan: You know what's funny is that we've talked about on this podcast before, whether it was with you or with Margwe, about how the thing that Zoran and BB Shanie: Tweet Do you say Tweetweet? Eitan: Margot Tweetwe. Tweetwa? What how do you pronounce her last name? Margot. Margot explains Shanie: I believe Tweeto. Eitan: it all. I thought it was Tweetwee. Anyways, we had on Shanie: No way. Eitan: our on that episode, we c you know, we had a conversation about how there's one thing that, you know, Zoran, there's a couple things that Zoran and BB have in common. The first is they are Libras. A lot of people didn't know this. The second is that they both have relationships with ultra-orthodox communities that they leverage in election seasons for the reasons that you had said. You know, the ultra-orthodox community in Brooklyn, they sided with not they I will say that there was the way that it broken up is that there's two voting blocks, the Slonim and the the Aaron. One of them went with Zolron. And then within that that voting block, it was like there's three rabbis or four rabbis. And a couple of them went with Zorwan and then the others went with Cuomo. So they kind of like hedged their bets. They kept a very like normal relationship when it came towards endorsing, you know, when it came to endorsing. They were also, like we said in the earliest episode, they were able do this because they want tax credits and they want child, you know, they want food stamps and they want this biking lane issue by 770 to be six to be fixed, all that stuff. Bibi Natadiahu, similar thing where he has the ultra-orthodox community that they want. food stamps. They want their schools to be funded. They want also you know, to not be drafted in the military, which is not a thing that the Hareda that Shanie: That's a biggie. Eitan: the that that the Hasidic community has here. But anyways, that is the similarities between the two entities, Gracie Mansion and Shanie: Yeah. Eitan: Tel Aviv. Shanie: Exactly. So we have we have two major ultra-orthodox political parties, and they are really important because they're actually like they've been the source of different governments falling over the years, and many people are voting based on this, both in their sector and outside of it. The if if folks are familiar with like the ethnic diversity of Jewish people, there is a Sephardic Mizrahi ultra-orthodox party called Shas. which are basically Jews from the Middle East who are mostly ultra Orthodox, but some are actually not. And then there's the Ashkenazi party, European Jewry. it's called UTJ, United Torah Judaism, which is actually like a merger of two different factions. and these parties are both like ultra Orthodox essentially, and they like Shas gets between like eight and eleven seats, and UTJ gets between like seven to eight seats. So, like together they're pretty substantial. and they're definitely for the For the right wing bloc, they are a they are required for the right wing bloc to function. And they are in this current government, of course. The Svartic Party Shas was founded Rabbi Ovadi Yosef. Did you know that, Ethan? Eitan: I actually did not know that. Huh. That's a random one. Shanie: Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. not so ransom. so so Eitan: I think he dresses like I think he dresses like a salt shaker. I think all those like Swardy rabbis, they all dress like salt shakers. Is and Shanie: You should yeah, you should see pictures from my my cousin's wedding. so Eitan: Yeah. Shanie: their current leader is Ari Dairy, who's like a super I can't wait to tell you about all the corruption he's been involved with. it's also a little bit more working class than the Ashkenazi party, which is just because like Misrahi Jews tend to be more working class compared to Ashkenazi, like they tend to be less wealthy. So they're very intense about like they feel strongly about welfare spending and social conservatism. Those are like their main issues, which makes sense. I actually just read that Rabbi Ovadi Yosef's funeral was the largest in Israeli history. and that 10% of Israelis went. Yeah, like almost a million people. Eitan: Whoa my God. That that's crazy. Shanie: Yeah, it was crazy. but you'll see like Eitan: That's like when Argentina won the World Cup. Shanie: if you okay, but here's the here's a comparison. If you talk to like the average secular Ashkenazi person or like Not non-Hari non-Hareiti Ashkenazi person, they're not gonna like speak that fondly about the people running UTJ's like the Ashkenazi Hari Party. They're not gonna like, wow, love that guy. If you talk to the average like Spartak Eitan: Interesting. Shanie: Mizrahi person in Israel or even here who's not Hareidi, they'll still be like, Ravavadhya said, Ravavadya said. Like there's a lot more respect for him. So it's very different. Like a lot of non-Orthodox Eitan: Yeah. Shanie: people were at that funeral. So it's a little different. Eitan: Are are are the just to compare them over to like the Arab parties, so are the Arab like are are the Arab parties closer than to each other than like the O Orthodox parties are? Like do they No. Okay. Shanie: No, they're very different. No, no, no. I would not compare them because you have like i secular and i Eitan: I'm talking about their relationship to each other. Shanie: yeah. you mean like d how much they like each other or how ideologically similar they are. Eitan: Yeah, like are they yeah, like like is Shas and and U T J like are they in more in cahoots than Okay. Shanie: Okay. They work together. Yeah, they're more in cahoots. And I would also say like the ideological differences in the Arab sector are enormous. You have like communists and you have Islamists and you have secular. Like there's like a lot going on there. So I would say ideologically they're way more dis disparate than like Sephardic and Mizrahi guy. Eitan: Yeah. Yeah, but we yeah, but what if it's pesoch and there's beans in the soup? I can can't be having Shanie: Can't be having beans on Pesach, everyone knows that. Eitan: beans on pesoch. Shanie: Are beans kidny yoked? Eitan: Yeah, are they not? What about corn yeah, that's why you can't have corn, I thought. Yeah, you can't have corn. You didn't know this? I know Shanie: I don't know. I don't I eat kidney. I have no idea. Corn? you know what? I did know that one. I did know that. Because I remember like, I remember you don't have corn syrup in the soda, and that's what makes it pesa soda. I did know that. Eitan: That's right. And then RFK. Do you know about the RFK-ness of this? Shanie: he hates corn syrup. He banned it. Eitan: And that's why all Coca-Cola is now kosher lapazach, because it's not corn syrup. Yeah. Yup, yup, yup. Shanie: Really? That is a fun fact. Eitan: They ended. They don't need to have the yellow caps anymore. Yeah, Shanie: Wow. I love Eitan: yellow cap culture is dead. Shanie: That's a win for the Jews, if there ever was one. Eitan: We've colonized the Coca-Cola. Shanie: So now let me take you now Eitan: There's Coca Cola is a massad psyop. Anyways, continue. Yeah. Shanie: let me take you to like what the Ultra Orthodox parties actually care about. Number one issue, like the most important issue of all time is to not serve in the military. not to get too political, but like obviously no one wants to serve in the military. Like it's not create, like, yeah, like they don't want to fight in the war if they don't have to and they've never had to. So like why would they suddenly want to start doing that? That sounds terrible. Like makes sense, you know, for them if you don't care about like a collectivistic culture and nationalism and all the things. Eitan: Yeah. Shanie: so that's like number one, number one issue that they care about. Number two is government subsidies for yeshivas, like for their religious seminaries, which also like very important to them. other piece, ultra Orthodox families have an average between six and seven children. that's a lot of children. They care a lot about like very generous child allowances, which, you know, makes sense. and they also generally because of that care a lot about welfare because They are generally impoverished, which we'll talk more about, like what that actually looks like and means. They care about that there's like no public transportation on Shabbat, no open businesses on Shabbat. There's like been some drama recently in which a bunch of like there was like a restaurant open on Shabbat like all these Orthodox came to like attack them and harass them. Actually, my parents were living in Jerusalem above the first restaurant in Jerusalem that was ever like stayed open on Shabbat. And all night long, Friday night, there were all these Haredi Eitan: Yeah. Shanie: people like yelling and yelling and yelling. And like my brother was like a baby. My mom always says, so annoying. Like they would spend all Eitan: Mm-hmm. Shanie: night. I was like, You're allowed to do this on Shabbat to like go to a protest. Eitan: I actually have always wondered that also. Are you allowed to go protest these places on Shabbos? Like unlockedly. Shanie: I they do. I don't know. Maybe they I guess they like schlep from wherever. Eitan: You know what they gotta do? They gotta start having these places that are up on Shabbos right outside of the A Riv. Like, make it so Shanie: Mm-hmm. Eitan: that you gotta you can't go with a Talus bag over there. I just don't feel like it's a Shabbos dick thing to do. Like that to me is like crazy. There's no way. Shanie: It's not in the spirit of Shabbat for sure. Not at all. Not at all. but yes, I mom always like now, I mean, growing up, I spent all my summers in Jerusalem growing up and like there were always like we knew which restaur I I always knew which restaurants were open on Shabbat. but it's not it wasn't like that many, but there already were. But this was like thirty five years ago or so, where it was like the first one. It was a big deal. so yeah, this like happened recently. Eitan: You what's funny is I used to, when I was in when I was in Yeshiva for the year, I was at Bait Shemesh and we were like on the border of of Ramath, sorry, we were it was right next to Ramat Beit Shemesh, which is like a ortho orthodox orthodox. And you know, we lived right by one of the the the circles, the key cars, and that was one of those circles where orthodox, ultra orthodox roundabouts, yes. I went to the Shanie: I think it's called a roundabout in English, in case you're wondering. Because no one knows what what circle means. Eitan: circle, roundabout. but yeah, we were with a roundabout that famously was just one of the places where the the Haredi guys would go and just yell at cars on Shabbos. So as you were going to sleep at night, you would just hear Shabbos, Shabbos, just like Shanie: Yeah. Eitan: in the background. there's just this this like chorus in the background, just hear people yelling. And I always thought you're ruining everyone else's Shabboses by yelling, Shanie: Mm-hmm. Eitan: Shabbos, Shabbos at an area where other people are living. Anyways, that's my own personal grave. Anyways, but if you can't beat them, join them. So I spent the second part of my yeshiva just yelling at cars. And that's why I, in Shanie: No, you did not. Eitan: Israel, I go to the coffee shops in Jerusalem and I yell at them. I get hired. You know what the thing Shanie: You sleep outside. Eitan: is? They hire me. It's a real good way to make a dollar. They can't protest on Shabbos. I'll go protest on Shabbos for a couple bucks. I don't care. And that's how I make my money. Protesting coffee shops in Jerusalem on Shabbos. Anyways. Shanie: okay, on to the next. the other thing that they care a lot about is their school system and not teaching boys math and science and English and civics. so we've spoken about this on the podcast before, but like that's a that's a huge piece of the conversation. And when you hear the opposition leaders talking about is talking about the elections, they talk a lot about the necessity for every Israeli child to get a proper education, including math science. Because remember, like Then they graduate, no, graduate, whatever that means. They like finish school, they're adults and they want to go to the workforce and they don't speak any English, which is hard to work. You know, you can't there's very limited in your job if you don't speak any English. Certainly if you don't know any math or science or English or civics, then it's like, you know, it's a little tough if you're illiterate other than in Aramaic. Eitan: I mean it it it seems to be I mean that's the push and pull of this entire thing. You know, like that's the issue in in you know in Williamsburg also or not Williamsburg and Crown Heights and all those places, is that like it it's always a question of like, are they not learning the skills they need as part of the design of their education? Or is it a deliberate we are not giving you the skills so that you don't get out of this like bubble? And I think that that so I so that's the whole thing behind this. Shanie: Deliberate. I think it's deliberate. I feel very strongly that it's deliberate. There's no re Yeah. Eitan: It is a hundred percent deliberate. A thousand percent deliberate. But they're able to go out there and say, Shanie: That's why I think it's abusive. Eitan: it is a hundred percent abusive. I also am this podcast, we don't like this situation at all. I think it's a major problem. I also think that it was really cowardly for the Zoran Mamdani administration not to address these issues. Like I do think that that is a problem. Shanie: To be fair, most New York mayors have not addressed this issue where there are there are New Eitan: None of them have. None of them have. Shanie: York Jewish children of our community who are not getting properly educated, don't speak English. And that means that like you are chained to this community. In theory, yeah, when you turn 18, you can leave, but you don't have any of the tools to actually leave. That's not acceptable. It's by the way, on our Eitan: Mm-hmm. There's no it and it went Shanie: com Jewish community, like it's these are our children. These are the the children of our community too. I don't get me started on this topic. Eitan: No, but there's there's issues because this lack of education, there's there's I'm sorry, but there's abuse problems, there's substance abuse problems, physical abuse problems. There's people, this all comes from the fact that they that the the jobs and the six the situational structure out in these communities doesn't let people go out there and be like working parts of society. And the behavior is very much reinforced over no one says anything. This was another reason. I mean, the reason why it's not enforced and the reason why it's never called out is because that admits That involves admitting that something is wrong. And if you're admitting something is wrong, like I you know, it's there's a million reasons why I think that these things, you know, don't get called out. But I will say though, in that is the Israeli society, one of the big differences here is that, like, yes, in in Hasidic Williamsburg or whatever, not having this education means one thing. In Israeli society, if you're not going into the army and you're not getting this education, you're not able to physically give back to the country in a way that's more necessary than in the US. Shanie: Right. So just a a note on this, Eitan: Right, wrong, yeah. Shanie: because because ev listen, every community has abuse, substance abuse and physical abuse and sexual abuse and all of these things. The the only the difference here is like you never never end up with a crackdown because like there's such a desire to not bring the police, get the police into your community, especially when you might be like evading other laws. And so when you don't want to bring the police in, it creates this culture where like Abusers in positions of power remain in power. Again, we know that this happens across America. It's like a specifically ultra-orthodox thing, Eitan: Yes, yes. Shanie: but the more like authoritarian a community is, the more like into like this is an authority figure, we cannot like speak out against him, the more likely you are to just like have the problem continue and escalate and escalate. So that's really the issue here. Eitan: I'll tell you two points on this. Like, one of the issues I had with Bill de Blasio was during the pandemic, he would call out the Hasidic communities and he wouldn't call out the other communities that were doing all of the unsafe COVID practices. To me, this is very much that. I'm saying Shanie: Mm. Eitan: the Hasidic community is like a billion other ultra-religious communities that have a power structure that is very hard to fight against. Shanie: Okay. Eitan: Like they do what all these other places are doing. I will say also is that, you know, I used to work at the Orthodox Union. And while I was at the Orthodox Union, there was a case where there was this rabbi. you didn't know that? yeah. I was the marketing coordinator for the Orthodox Union. You didn't know that? It was the worst job I ever had. This was in twenty thirteen, twenty fourteen or something. Shanie: What did you do there? wow. No, I'd know what like ten years ago? How long ago? Yeah. Eitan: This was yeah. This I hated it. I was it was this was one of the reasons why I hated it was because there was an incident where there was a rabbi, I think it was in Lakewood. I think his name was Rabbi Kolko. Either Rabbi Kolko did this or is the person that committed the assault. But basically there was a Shanie: I hope you got his name right and are not like smearing the name of some nice rabbi. Eitan: Let me say back in no no, his name is right. This is back in the day. The issue is that Shanie: okay, fine. Good. Eitan: there was a rabbi that that had abused a bunch of kids. A larger rabbi came out and said, How dare you call the cops? You should let the rabbis handle this. Put the families of the abused kids in harem for a little bit, which is like they're Shanie: Exiles them. Eitan: exiled from the rest of the community. And To be honest, that guy was on the OEU's payroll. Not the guy that committed the crime, but Shanie: Yeah. Eitan: the guy that went out there and harassed the family. These power structures are very real. Like when someone decides to shield someone that has done something despicable in the community, it is in very, very, very hard to fight against that, especially knowing that your family's status, you know, is in question. All being able to count in a minion. You know, if you go out there and you tell the cops, That this rabbi abused my kid. He can get kicked out of a menu. He can get kicked out of your social circle. So, you know, these are very, very real issues that are very much structurally based. We don't like it on this podcast. We are anti-that on this podcast. Shanie: We don't we already inside that. okay, going back to the origin story of the ultra orthodox draft, because that's sort of at the heart of this election. And that's what separates the coalition from the opposition in many ways. Like a lot of these the right wing opposition parties and the left wing opposition parties like disagree on a hundred things, but they all agree that ultra orthodox men need to draft. Not all of them, different var varying degrees of like how to do it, why to do it, whatever, but everybody believes in it. This all started in nineteen forty eight and is completely the fault of David Ben Negoryon, Israel's founder and founding prime minister. Because he really wanted the Ultra Orthodox to support him. He was like, I need the Ultra Orthodox to back me in this. there were four hundred yeshiva students and he was like, Fine, like Torah study will be your national service. That we'll count that. Yeah. Eitan: Wait, can I just give a little context more? The country is founded at this point and they need to yeah. Shanie: Country is founded, small, small group. Almost everybody in the country is secular. Okay. The Eitan: Yes. Shanie: country is founded by secular people, labor Zionists, socialists, hippies. Like that's a lot of the people, not all of them, but like that's a lot of what's happening here. Okay. There's only 400 yeshiva students. Okay. Eitan: And at that point, Bengorian, in order to stabilize the country, he needs to start creating all these bridges and all these gaps between Shanie: Totally. Eitan: the communities. He needs to bring everyone in. Very famously, you know, the IDF was a series of different brigades, Lechy and the Palmach, and you know, that all had to be congealed. Shanie: Yeah. Eitan: And yet, all these groups and dynamics need be congealed. And then there was. Shanie: Yeah, they brought all their like little militias, varying types of militias, into one group. And so no, there was the Eitan: And big militia. Shanie: it it there was a lot to do to unify the country. And you didn't want to have these people who are like sitting there at odds. And there was so much fighting. By the way, this like religious all these divides is why Israel has no constitution, because they couldn't agree on anything, Eitan: Yeah. Shanie: which is unfortunate. And so that's what started it. It was 400 exemptions. Now it's, you know, 80,000 exemptions. Eitan: Well wait, but when so Ben Gurion, when he brought in the four hundred, so they they Shanie: Yeah. Eitan: had certain th so they wanted there was a couple of things that they that they got. They basically got to determine the religious identity of the country. It's why there's no Yeah. Shanie: To some degree. If you read the Declaration of Independence, some of it, there's a lot of compromises in there. Okay. I can like pull you some quotes, but there's in some ways Declaration of Independence, actually a very liberal document. Talks a lot about it, but lacks a lot about like really great values, about no discrimination on the basis of all of these things. Like it's actually a very progressive document compared to the American Constitution. But you should note Declaration of Independence in Israel is never actually enshrined in that way. But sorry, as you were. Eitan: No, just saying that they was a couple of the really the buses not running, Bengorian not being open, and kosher food and when it comes to like a conversion and when it comes to intermarriage, like this was all stuff that the rabbis Shanie: Yeah, they control all marriage and divorce. Eitan: so this was all stuff that the rabbis wanted and they got, and then on top of that, they also got the ability to not have to fight in the army. That is and yeah. Shanie: Right. Which didn't feel like a big deal because it wasn't that many of them. Who knew there that they would have this many children? Eitan: I mean to the the c dichotomy back then that it was four hundred people then and the fact that like by twenty thirty I think the number is twenty five percent of Israel is gonna like fall under this category Shanie: Yeah. Eitan: is a pretty seismic shift. Shanie: Yeah. Well I would say, I mean, there was a time, it was a little before this, but like during the Enlightenment, people believed religion would die. Like that that it wouldn't survive science, that it wouldn't survive the Enlightenment. Like nobody would be religious anymore, especially not at this level. So it's actually was is almost shocking to see the demographic trends in the other direction if you look at it historically. but you know, here we are. Eitan: Yeah. Yeah, but they didn't account for the secret lives of Mormon wives. And I think that that has should it okay. Shanie: That is it. So 1948 exemption. Fast forward 50 years, the Supreme Court is finally like, this feels unconstitutional because you know what our constitution says? It says no discrimination. And this is discriminatory. The government says we're gonna ignore the Supreme Court. And then this kind of like back and forth happens a couple times. Then you have like laws passed, the laws are not enforced, the Supreme Court says you can't exempt, you can't do exemption. They never enforce it. No one's ever really arrested for this. But like it goes back and forth. This is basically like a classic, like, who's actually in charge situation? fast forward to 2019. Yeah. This is like 1998 is the first time this happens. Yeah. So it's this is like, this is like 30 Eitan: did these when did sorry, when did these like yeah, I was gonna ask like when interesting. Okay, so ninety eight is when is when people start to question this. Yeah. Shanie: years of like the government's like, we're so sorry, there's nothing we can do. And this court is like, you guys, like, we gotta draft them. This doesn't make any sense. And it just goes on and on and on. Eitan: Was there like was there like an instigating event or anything? Like what like ninety eight? yeah. Shanie: Well, the ultra-orthodox, the ultra-orthodox parties have been trying for years to say, we want a blanket exemption. We want it to say, like, under no circumstances are you going to draft us. Like they want it to be enshrined in law. And it's not enshrined in law in that way. It's just kind of like an agreement. and so that's like that's a huge piece of the problem here, is that even though right now, like in practice, no one is being drafted, in reality, like the if The government decides tomorrow they could arrest 80,000 people. They're not going to. But like in theory, that could happen. And that like gives like a level of insecurity. and so from their perspective, it makes sense that like they want to have this enshrined into law. And at certain point you need to you can get enough power to actually achieve that. Right. Eitan: Yeah. And this has been a little bit of a of a sticking point between BB and UTJ, where UTJ technically I don't know if they're in the coalition right now, but at one point they left the coalition because they w you know, they've they were saying that B B wasn't coming out strong enough to do things like codify this and to make the blanket exemption and to and to make it a little bit more substantial. Shanie: Yeah, technically they quit the coalition, but like there's they're still there because Netanyahu was has was not able to like actually pass a law saying they are exempt. And that's what they want. It's not enough to just like in practice not be drafted. Like it to be fair, like in in their defense, even though like I want them to be drafted, in their defense, like it's hard to be in this position of like really legally you should all be drafted. And if you don't, you should go to jail the same way Tel Aviv leftists who say they don't want to go to the army go to jail, like Theoretically, you should all be two. but they just like don't on a practical level do it. so this happened a couple of times. And then so Netzanyahu has been like trying to Netanyahu has been trying to do this. He's been like making, making attempts at not because he wants to, like his voters also want the ultra orthodox to draft, but he's been attempting to get them exemptions. And the Supreme Court is basically says no. And in 2024, they were like, you need to draft these people. And they basically sent out all these draft notices, tens of thousands of draft notices, okay? Like sixty thousand, seventy thousand. They're sending them out to people saying, like, go to the army. None of them actually go, but theoretically they're like, You all need to go, which is like kind of crazy. I just told you that they sent out draft notices for like 60,000 men. there are like even more that are really realistically eligible. only like 2,000 actually go to the army or actually went to the army in general. That's a very small percentage. And FYI, like the people they are counting as Haredi is like very loose. Like, you know the guys who are raised Haredi and now they're not? They count those. So it's basically Eitan: Mm. Shanie: those people. There's like a couple actually Orthodox soldiers, but a lot of them are like. modern Orthodox or they like were raised highly now they're literally secular like this. Those guys are counted to. Eitan: How do you get so how do you get this exemption? Like when when it comes to getting the exemption, is it just like you approach you like the government, Shanie: Everybody gets the exemption. Eitan: do you need a a letter from a rabbi? Like how are people getting this exemption? Shanie: Okay, that's a good question. I'm not I mean the yeshivas really control it. So like they'll they kind of like negotiate with one of my my friend Uri, who like we should bring him on actually, Uri Kadar, he's great. but he talks a lot about this because he's like, we act like there's all these like deals between like the rabbi and the institutions and the yeshivas and the government. No, like you are an individual. We are treating these people like they are collectives, but actually we're individuals. I, as an individual, have been drafted. I can go to jail. Or I could do like it's not my yeshiva's business. Like the fact that there's negotiations happening, like, hey, yeshiva, you should send this many boys and you decide how many people you send. That doesn't make any sense. Like you we are individual human beings being drafted and they're treating it like this like weird political game, which is fair. so no, but they they do have to like you they do have to officially apply and everything. Like it's there like an official system for getting exempt, and otherwise, like you they would be. Eitan: They make them they make them compete in tolerable. They make them Shanie: They like you ha everybody's receives a draft notice or doesn't receive a draft. Like you receive draft notices in Israel. There's like a population Eitan: Yeah. Shanie: registry. They know who's there. technically you should you're you should like actually be actively learning in the yeshiva. and there's like all kinds at different points in time there have been different rules that have been enforced or not enforced. Like the in the most stringent version, you have to like really actively be learning in yeshiva. But on a practical level, like there are plenty of men who are Haredi who are not learning in yeshiva who are also not going to the army. Eitan: Hmm. Shanie: and that's kind of the nuance there. Like you could hypothetically draft the people who are like le the less the like less religious guys who are not really going to the going to the army, going to the yeshiva anyway. Yeah, like the burnout. Think about not that you want them in the army, but Eitan: The burnouts. The schutzes is what we used to call them. Shanie: we call them Shabab Nikim. Like think about how there's a lot of those. Every family has at least two. Like send them. Eitan: If guess the question, let's say that Israel was to like tomorrow like repeal this thing and and the get rid of the exemption, right? There's gotta be a percentage though of the Haredim that do want to go to the army and do want to take part in regular society. Like, is there you know, is is what would it what would it take or is what is that group like? Is it a significant group? Is it Shanie: I saw something like 15, 20% that like w didn't actively say we hate this idea. It's pretty low, but there is some diversity. there's some diversity of ultra orthodox. So you do have like maybe like 35 to 40 percent who are on the more like modern and nationalist side, which is not nothing because it's a big chunk of people, right? Realistically, if you if you drafted 20% of the eligible Haredi Ben. The IDF would be like that would be enough for the IDF because already a high number. IDF says it's short twelve thousand, twelve thousand men Eitan: Yeah. I heard fifteen. Shanie: right now. It's going up. It's gonna and it's about to go up by quite a bit. So it might end up being around twenty. But Eitan: They also, if I'm not mistaken, there was the age, the IDF age, got raged also, like again. Yeah. Shanie: Yes, they are they are now extending service. They're extending they for like reservists. No, but basic there there's more of a shortage because cause they they changed the parameters. So there's there's like a pretty big shortage. I heard 12,000 as of I think it was like last, like a few months ago. And I know by the end of this year it's supposed to get higher. Not sure by how much. but my point is there are so many ultra orthodox men that like you don't actually have to draft all of them. If you drafted 25%, like it will be it would be hugely helpful. Eitan: Th you know what's funny is actually what my question is that like ninety eight happens and it's really the first time that like this question is is brought forward about trying to, you know, undo this exemption. Over the past couple of years, that conversation has kind of like gotten way hotter, and it seems to be, and maybe I'm wrong, is that we're closer to having this repealed than ever before. Talk to me a little bit about how you just rolled your eyes. Shanie: You think they're gonna no, we're they're not okay. Eitan: Closer than before. It's the fact that it's being talked about as much, the fact that, like, Shanie: Yeah. Eitan: you know, like we are in a position where it seems to be one of the major sticking points that the opposition has, and it seems to be anyone that isn't BB has, is getting rid of this exemption in some capacity. We've seen that there is a Haredi co part, Ultra Orthodox party that had come out that even suggested of there being a percentage of Of the ultra orthodox that have to serve versus a blanket exemption. And that is a newer party that I last I saw or last you said was probably not going to get voted in. But it was the first time that this had kind of been talked about, or this is the first time that it you know taken hold on the conversation a little bit with the larger parties potentially also running, Shanie: Yeah. Eitan: or not potentially, but the larger parties running on this platform of getting Shanie: Yeah, it's a voting issue. Eitan: rid of this exemption. We are probably closer to ever before to having this kind of like taken away. So the question is though, Shanie: I agree. Eitan: is what has led to that change in your opinion over the past couple of years? Shanie: October 7th. before this, you would hear people before October Eitan: What is that? No, I'm sorry. Shanie: 7th, you would hear people say, Yes, we want them to draft, but a lot of people would say, we don't really want them in the army. They're not gonna do well in the army. It's annoying. It means you need women-free bases, it's like all kinds of inconvenient. and then October 7th happened, and like, you know, you and I have friends are doing a hundred, doing 300 days of reserve duty since October 7th. So now, like, it's really affecting the society. You have like 50-year-olds going into reserve duty. You have like Yeah, you're Golan like putting on his uniform. Like it's like old, all these like old men and men with kids. And then you have like then you have the Kharidi community where you have all these 18-year-olds who are not going and it's infuriating to watch. It's infuriating. and then people realize the population. Right now they're 14, 15% of Israeli population. For under 20 year olds, they're like half. Okay. Like they're like very hot. I mean, they're they're they're like doubling their for real. Eitan: The secular Jews gotta start sh dupping more. The what what's happening, secular Jews? Yeah. Shanie: For real. It's crazy. their poverty rate is more than double non-Haredi Jews. So there's also an economic component of like you're, you know, you're putting in, you're getting out so much more than you're putting in. And that obviously also creates an animosity because people are frustrated because remember, it's like it's intentional, like 50%, only 50% of ultra-Orthodox men are employed. And most of them are underemployed. I think only a quarter of them make enough money to pay taxes. Okay. A quarter of them. Eitan: Yeah. And I think the ones that are employed, they're all involved in health Yeah. The ones that are employed are Shanie: Make enough money to pay taxes. Like that's Eitan: also all I was gonna say they're the ones that are employed, they're all employed in healthcare fraud. So it it you know, the numbers really I didn't Shanie: Stop it. Eitan: mean it. But I hear we you yeah. Shanie: Take it back. Eitan: I I agree that I I it's a it's a very s sticky situation. I you know I saw that Khaviv Reta Gore made a point. you know, I like a lot of what he says, some of the stuff is a little bit intense, but he made a point about how like at some point something has got to give within the community. Like I in my mind, you know, they take out so much where they also, if they are taking in so much money over time as Israel goes through this like brain drain and literally, you know, the with the military and stuff like that, eventually like something has got to give and they have to start giving back. Like, you know, at one point they are going to get forced into this when they realize that they can't, you know, support their own infrastructure that they have set up. So it does seem like they i yeah. Shanie: I agree, but I also think like when people talk about on a practical level, what does it mean? Like, what does it mean to arrest? I mean, to me, you have to arrest the rabbis, frankly, because I mean they're they're the source of this. They're the ones saying don't go. The rabbis control, but they have like a tight grip on the population. So they can really change this anytime they want, as far as I'm concerned. Like you need strong political leadership. They they won't, but like in theory, those are the people responsible because you cannot arrest 60,000 people. In theory. Eitan: Yeah. You know what? Shanie: There's like sixty thousand people who should be arrested right now. Eitan: You know, this interesting tie-in here, and just follow with me on this, is that there was news this week about the about the board of the the board of peace is what I think they call the BOP, baby. We're Shanie: Yes. Eitan: all about the BOP on this podcast. The BOP is a BOP, as far as we are concerned here. But the the BOP, you know, they're figuring out like what to do next. But the BOP is what they're there, that's the Gaza board. That is the board of of that Trump has appointed. It was at twenty points and now it's at 15 points, so you know things are going well. but there was a conversation about re about the education system in Gaza and how going forward there was going to be a question about what do we do about the education system here? I don't remember who said this, but someone brought up the point. interesting. And what about the West Bank and about the education system amongst you know Israeli extremists in the West Bank? Now, obviously, it's not a one-to-one out there, but the re-education system and about changing the curriculum, I do think is something that is relevant to the Haredi community. When I was in Israel, one of the professors in Reichman who I was speaking to was talking about how he thinks the biggest thing needs to happen in the Haredi communities is the education system needs to completely change. Right now, they do not view themselves as part of Israeli society. They view themselves as something outside of Israeli society that definitely is being supported by Israeli society, but is not part of Israeli society. That needs to change. Margot Tweetwee was on this podcast and she talked about how these a lot of these communities are not Zionists. Like, and you know, the term obviously is a complicated term to people listening to this podcast. But when we think about Zionists in this context, we think about people that are giving and contributing to this idea of Israel. The Karedi community or a bunch of them don't, you know, agree with this concept and they're willing to kind of just like live in this par in this in this world where they think it's a good idea to send, you know, your kids to protest in the wet cement. out there. So it is interesting where Shanie: Yeah. Eitan: the education system also becomes a major concern here, where you have to have the rabbis changing the curriculum and changing their stance to be, you Shanie: Yeah. Eitan: know, ultra orthodox, be as orthodox as you want to be it, but at the same time, you can't exist in this bubble aside from the community, which is what they currently exist in. Shanie: Yeah, no, I totally agree. Number one change has to be education system. You have to change from the bottom because it you first you need people who feel like they're part of the society and who actually want to be part of the society, want to be part of the state. and never never mind that I I really do believe it's abusive to like not give to not give your child child the tools to be able to leave your community and make choices for themselves. I think it's wrong. I think it's unacceptable. And that's why I think I've mentioned it to you before, but I don't like that if Tali Bennett says, like, fine, if you if you wanna like have your own rules, we won't pay for it. Go raise money, go fundraise for Americans. And actually, no, I don't care who pays for it. It's not about paying for it. I don't want it to exist. It's not, I'm not like trying to save money on Haredi kids. I I'm trying to make sure every child of this country gets an education. That's really important. and it and it's not, it's not right. so but but on a practical level, it's gonna be really hard. The change has to come from the top, and I I c I don't know what it's gonna look like. Like it's very hard to imagine this happening without. literally a civil war. I I don't know on a practical level how you can make it happen. Like you're gonna you can't Eitan: But it there was Shanie: you you can, like, but how many people are you gonna rouse up and throw in jail? I don't know. And remember, they're chanting in the streets, we'll die before you draft us. Like we will we will get killed before we draft. You understand? Like this is how strongly they feel. Eitan: hate to make the comparison, but but Gush Katif, I mean, the idea of pulling people out of those settlements and you know and rehoming them inside of Israel proper whatever the term would be, it's gonna be months of awkwardness. Like those first it let's say the the the the thing Shanie: Yeah, but the protesters th yeah. No, I that's an interesting comparison. That's actually sorry, go on. That's interesting. Eitan: You throw over, but over time it just normalized. Like we know that it's Shanie: Right. Eitan: gonna be months of protest. It's gonna be there's gonna be images that we are gonna hate. There's it's gonna be Hasidic Shanie: Yeah. Interesting. Eitan: men, sorry, Haredi men that are gonna be dragged by their payas to the to you know into prison. And you know what? There's a very good chance that some people are gonna die or get seriously injured during the this, and then their faces are gonna be used weirdly. I'll say this as martyrs. that's crazy that we're using this here, but I'm not inaccurate when I say that. It's gonna be weird for a little bit, but at the same time. A year, two years, three years, five years, ten years down the line, when it's normalized, it's not going to be an issue. There will be a small civil war that needs to happen. I mean, God for you know what it is? I'll say this. God Shanie: God. Eitan: forbid we have a little bit of a civil war. Like I I don't know Shanie: All right. So Eitan: how else to say that. Like yeah. Shanie: I I don't wanna say that like bloodshed is inevitable here, but I I do believe in political imagination. And I believe in that there are so there are a lot of things that exist today that were unfathomable even ten years ago. And so I I mean, I'm hopeful that it doesn't require bloodshed in order to occur, but you're right. Like the fact that I can't f can't envision it happening doesn't mean it won't happen. And I agree that it is in fact a requ necessary, completely necessary, for this for this to happen. So hopefully, you know. Eitan: And can I also let me stand on the Haredi. Can I stand on the Haredi side of this for a second? Shanie: Please. Eitan: as Rabbi Ovadi Yosef. No, let me just say here is that the Israeli government and the IDF do need to step it up when it comes to accommodating this religious identity that the Haredi community or the ultra-orthodox community is gonna be bringing to there, where there are issues with women on army bases and women, you know, as instructors. And what the women's roles are when it comes to talking with you know with with the ultra-orthodox that are coming in there. And I do think that the the Israeli government, that the IDF, there are flaws and there's like issues within that. And I think that it is a hundred percent incumbent on the IDF to make those accommodations. Over the past couple of months, there was a whole conversation with some of the modern Orthodox rabbis who are technically, you know, pro having the the mandatory draft, but also do feel concerned about the religious about about having women, you know, as part of the curricula, about dealing with women. It's a weird Shanie: Yeah. Eitan: thing, but I totally get their side of this, where I grew up, you Shanie: Mm-hmm. Eitan: know, modern Orthodox. So obviously I personally never fell into this category, but I was in the community that did fall in this category. And I do think that if they don't want to have women instructors, then you do unfortunately have to give them the ability to absorb into the army in a way that doesn't make them feel religiously awkward. If they don't want to talk to women, you know, it is not Shanie: Yeah, Eitan: Best, but you do have to give them an opposite. Yeah. Shanie: I am of the belief, I'm of the belief that they have been accommodated quite a bit. and are being like a bit dramatic about some of their needs. Eitan: Yeah. Shanie: but I agree, of course, you have to accommodate people. Like there's there you need to make them comfortable. The army is not a super comfortable place for deeply religious people. their fears are legitimate. And I actually think, frankly, I think that the the rest of Israeli society, like the military specifically, has been quite accommodating. And has built out divisions for them and you know made a lot of progress in terms of welcoming in them into the military. But you know, there's there's always more to do, and there needs to be a lot of collaboration between the Roshea Shiva and and rabbis and the military in order to make this happen. Eitan: Interesting. What a country. I can't imagine if my if Shanie: What I got trade. Eitan: if the my principal from RTMA was also involved in getting government military placement and stuff. I would have been in the front lines. They would have been putting me right in the front lines immediately. Anyways what do we have anything else on the Haredi commun community and the and their voting blocks? Shanie: that's about it for now. It's looking like they're pulling it around. Let's see. I got UTJ at seven or eight. I got Shoss at seven. So that's about fourteen or fifteen seats together. yeah, out of 160. Eitan: Can I I I so then I have a question which my question then is with the you know with this election specifically, it's that seems to be that they are kind of like the and not not to use this term completely inappropriately, like the redheaded stepchildren of this election, where even a c as of a couple of weeks ago, BB was even considering splitting from the from the ultra orthodox community when it comes to having them enlist. It seems to be that it's a very unpopular thing to have that the, you know, to to continue to support them not enlisting in the army. The opposition is definitely against it. Lee could voters, they they're not pro it, but also it seems to be they don't care that much. So I'm just curious, Shanie: Yeah. Eitan: you know, in what is their position in the upcoming election? You know, are they being courted at all? Shanie: Okay, the ultra-orthodox parties are disliked by everyone besides the ultra-orthodox parties. So the split is just the parties who need them, like Netanyahu's likud, and the parties who don't need them, like the opposition. The parties who are willing to give them what they want, hold their nose and give them what they want, and the parties who say, No, we're not gonna do that. Okay, so that's the difference. The you are right to say Netanyahu is trying to distance himself. In the end, he's gonna sit with them just like he always sits with them. But he's distancing himself because he knows none of his voters want him to want the dr Hariti draft. None of the right wing parties, Utsmayu, the Jewish Power Party, Religious Zionism Party, the Amhai Israel, every every right wing party, their people serve in very high numbers. They do not want to sit with the ultra-Orthodox. It's only those who are willing to and have to, and those who are not willing to and don't have to. Nobody actually wants to sit with. Eitan: Who's more popular, the Arab parties or the ultra Orthodox parties? Shanie: Ultra Orthodox. Actually. you mean like if you Eitan: Interesting. Who who do people with you so like Shanie: ask the average Israeli? I don't know, but politically the ultra there's more people comfortable sitting publicly with the ultra Orthodox, I think. Eitan: Injury I I'm but like your average Israeli, like are they you know, are they when it comes to like Rom and U T J, you know, if you're asked like, Hey, who do you who do you like more? Shanie: I think this election is gonna t tell us the answer to that question because people voting for the opposition are know that they're voting for an opposition that is willing to that might be willing to sit with Arab parties, although some maybe are hoping they won't. And then those who vote for the coalition know that they are for sure gonna sit with the ultra-orthodox. So we're gonna find out who's less popular very soon. Eitan: And last question: Zoran Mamdani endorsing UTJ. Do you think that that helps? Do you think that that hurts? Shanie: Calling on Zoran Mamdani to endorse the Arab joint list. Okay. They are ideologically aligned. Eitan: I'm dead serious. Shanie: And he can I bet you he would pull really well in Arab villages in Israel. Let him go do a get-out the vote for his people. Not his people, but like. Eitan: I am dead serious. I think that if he literally should a hundred percent if he wants to go out there and get involved in Israel. Shanie: Is that legal? Wait, is this legal before we endorse this? Is it legal to do that? Eitan: He whatever illegal, not legal. In 2027, what is illegal Shanie: Ha ha ha. Eitan: and not legal? He wanted to arrest BB until a couple months ago somehow. Legal and not legal, it doesn't Shanie: Not legal. Eitan: make a difference. If he wants to go out there and make all these statements, then he should. Because the other thing is that then it would involve him acknowledging that there is a government structure in Israel and that Arabs are in some capacity working, contributing members of society out there. I think that that's why would ultimately would kind of keep him away from it. This is kind of my guess here. Shani. What a rundown that was of the ultra orthodox and Haredi voting blocks. I just need to give a shout out real quickly because someone's podcast launched about a week ago, Disputed Territories with Shinee Reichmann, first episode with Alana Zajik, who I actually will say one time we recorded an episode that we never put up because I got stuck in Israel or something, something happened. We never ended up putting up the episode. But Shanie: Yeah, it was Iran war, I think. Eitan: That's what it was. but Alana was on your first episode. What is what's the podcast Shanie: Yeah. Eitan: about? Like what is your what what's your angle here? Shanie: So, you know, usually when I'm promoting the podcast, I'm talking to people who are used to listening to like really buttoned up podcasts and like formal journalist podcasts. And so I say, my podcast is a much more like casual, less buttoned up, more conversational podcast. But now I'm on your podcast, which is like by far the most casual of any I've ever listened to. And so I can't say that. I have the buttoned up podcast for this audience. But we're talking about Eitan: You're the adult you know Shanie: Israel, Zionism, Jewish community stuff, like all of the things. And like a lot of our favorite people are gonna be on it. So you should listen. It's great. Eitan: Is finally giving a voice to like this middle group of normies. I've been calling them we've been trying, I've Shanie: Yes. Eitan: calling them normy Jews out there. I because the the Shanie: Yes. Eitan: first clip that you shared, or one of the first clips you shared, was about how you know things aren't as polarized and extreme as they seem. But if people don't start talking up more and making a big stink about how there's a moderate group of people in the middle that are very loud, then eventually it will become just extremists. Because if you let all the voices become Shanie: Yeah. Eitan: extreme and take over. then they become the centralized thought. I thought that was a you know a really good point about how we're not Shanie: Totally. Eitan: it there yet, but we are heading there if we don't speak up. Shanie: Totally. And I by the way, like I appreciate a lot of the Israel Focused podcasts, but I do think a lot of them are very like old man heavy, which no shade, love those guys, but a little bit old man heavy. and also like pretty center right, which is okay, but ideal, like if you pulled young American Jews, they are not the center right. Like they are liberals and like on the left. Not that I'm like so far left, but like I think that I'm much more representative of young American Jews, and I'm trying to carve out a space, like an ideological space for those of us who are like very comfortable being openly critical of the Israeli governments, but also believe in the humanization of Israelis and care about the Israeli people and are connected to Israel. Like that's the space that I want to be building out and like flooding the zone with information, as I've told you many times, because like we are the vast majority, but in the media ecosystem, we're actually the minority because all of the moderate normies are like, am I taking up too much space? I don't want to take too much space. Meanwhile, like the extremists don't shut up. So here we are. Eitan: Yeah. I I mean you're it's interesting where I think that Israel's next the Israel and the Jewish community, their next big thing is that they have to figure out how to deal with anti-Zionist, pro-Israel kids who who like think who use terms like apartheid and occupation and genocide and you know ethnic cleansing, but don't have ill will towards Israel or Israelese, but don't want to fuck with the word Zionist and Shanie: Right. Eitan: They are anti-government. And I think that right now the Jewish commun they call themselves this is whether listen, that word has been. Yeah. That word, listen, it means Shanie: They call themselves anti Zionist. Right. It's an important distinction because you said they believe in the Jewish state. So that's you know, it's a fine line here. Eitan: it means more to be an Oakland A's fan than than actual definition of Zion. Actually, that may have been a little bit whatever. I'm saying that there's no de clear definition of the word. So they may identify as anti-Zionist, Shanie: For sure, for sure. Eitan: anti-Zionist, pro-Israel. Thinks it's an occupation, thinks it's an apartheid, calls it a genocide, you know, uses all the buzzwords that they hear online, but also don't hate Israel and aren't calling for the destruction of Israel. That is a huge group, young group of kids that the Jewish community has not figured out how to handle at all. And I do think that lanes like yours are where they come and they get to be, you know, heard. And lanes like this. Normie Jews. We gotta be loud, angry, Shanie: Totally. Normie Jews. Eitan: annoying Jews. Anyways. With that, this has been another episode of the Jew York Times. Make sure to check out disputed territories. Make sure to like, subscribe to the Jew York Times. We have a Patreon. go. Shanie: Disputed territory, not plural. Go on. Eitan: There it is. Disputed territory. It's not the territories. It's not Shanie: No, just territory. Eitan: we're not talking about the Greater Greater Israel project. I thought that your podcast was pro-Greater Israel project, where Israel is not only going to be televived, but it also involves some of Iraq. Yeah. God. Shanie: We wanted all of Jordan. Yeah, some of Iraq. Eitan: You know what? One time one day early on after October 7th, there was the war. There was someone that wrote on Twitter about how if the Israelis really want to punish Gaza, they should implement a Knesset style. political system in Gaza and let them just suffocate themselves like they do in Israel. Anyways, but disputed territory you can check it out the episode is live there's gonna be more episodes coming out soon like I said like Shanie: Weekly. Eitan: subscribe to the Jew York Times here we have a Patreon please start submitting to the Patreon we are trying to build out this a little bit more and you know what if you don't give to this Patreon you don't care about Israel okay yeah I said it you actually Shanie: You're anti Semitic. Eitan: You're anti-Semitic. Yeah, your hate speech, okay? Anyways, you don't have to give if you don't want to give. But if you want to give, we'd love it if you give. and with that, by the way, I'm gonna be tomorrow night, the because this is going up right now. I'm gonna be in JCC of Atlanta. If you're out there and listening, check out JC Atlanta. And of course, October 22nd, the Jew, Jewish or anti-Semitic live is coming back to the 92nd Street. Y Shanie is gonna be there. Shanie is gonna be there. Shanie's gonna be there. Shanie: Shanille's gonna be in DC. But you should go up, especially Eitan: So he's gonna be in DC. Spiritually she'll be there. Shanie: if you live on the Upper East Side. I do feel terrible because it's like seven blocks from my apartment. But it's gonna be sick. Jewish or anti-Semitic is my favorite thing that you do. I like a lot of things you Eitan: Thank you. Shanie: do, but this is my favorite thing you do. Eitan: She bought ten tickets, so just contact Shaanie for one of those tickets, okay? That's what it is. Shanie: Do not contact me. Eitan: October twenty-second, secondary why November fifth, we're gonna be at the Whitesman Museum in Philadelphia doing a Jewish or anti-Semitic. and then December 23rd, actually, we're gonna be back in Philadelphia doing a Christmas show at a next inline comedy. So all of those are on my channels and stuff like that. Go and buy tickets. And we will see you soon, as we always do, in homage to my roommate, Richard Templeton, who my roommate, by the it's a duplex, okay? He's on the other side of the building. But you know, he whatever. Barstool. Shanie: Nice guy, nice guy.