Latest / Credit Union Exam Solutions Presents With Flying Colors / NCUA's Net Economic Value (NEV) Framework with Todd Miller
Transcript
- 0:02Treichel: Hey everyone, this is Mark with a special Archive
- 0:05episode of With Flying Colors.
- 0:08I hope you enjoy.
- 0:12Katie: Do you want to maximize your success with NCUA?
- 0:16Join Mark Treichel as he shares with you the insider's view on passing
- 0:19your exam with Flying Colors.
- 0:22The With Flying Colors podcast is sponsored by Credit Union
- 0:25Exam Solutions by Mark Treichel.
- 0:27If you would like to work directly with the Credit Union Exam
- 0:30Solutions team and receive support.
- 0:31Port to optimize your results with NCUA, so you save time and money.
- 0:36Visit us@markttrico.com
- 0:37to find out more.
- 0:45Treichel: Hey, this is Mark TriCal with another episode of With Flying Colors.
- 0:49Today's topic is going to be an update on NNC a's stakeholder forum
- 0:55on interest rate risk supervisory.
- 0:58Framework.
- 0:59This webinar and update from NCOA just happened at 2.
- 1:0330 Eastern on September 15th.
- 1:07I listened to it and one of my team members, Todd Miller, who is Got a
- 1:11great background in this, also listened to it, and we're going to talk through
- 1:16our immediate take on having just heard NCUA's webinar on their changes
- 1:22to Interest Rate Risk Supervisory Framework, which was outlined in
- 1:28letter 22 CU09, issued just this month.
- 1:32Todd, how are you doing today?
- 1:35Miller: I am doing, the weather's a little bit cooler.
- 1:37It's been a lot, a very hot summer out here, but today, weather's nice, doing
- 1:43well, and this is an interesting thing.
- 1:45Been waiting for it since I signed up for it.
- 1:48So listen to it with a great deal of anticipation.
- 1:51Treichel: Yeah, you and I have both been looking forward to this one.
- 1:54We've got some clients we've assisted on interest rate risk over the past few
- 1:58months who have been waiting with a abated breath for the letter to credit unions.
- 2:03And then also for potentially some clarifications with the webinar today.
- 2:08And it's, it's been a few episodes since you and I chatted.
- 2:12We actually did do an, ironically, we did do a net economic value pick.
- 2:17Podcast early on in the history here of with flying colors.
- 2:21I did a follow up on that when rates started going up.
- 2:24And so this will actually be yours and my second discussion on this, but the
- 2:29third actual podcast I've had on this particular topic, but if you could,
- 2:32for people who haven't listened to.
- 2:34Some of the podcasts that you have been on, if you could give a little bit of
- 2:37your background at NC, and then they'll quickly realize why it makes sense to
- 2:42listen to this episode and hear what you have to say relative to this topic.
- 2:46Miller: Like you, Mark, I'm a retired NCUA employee.
- 2:48I was with NCUA from 1987 up to 2021.
- 2:53So 34 years call it during that time I spent most of my time as a problem
- 2:57case officer spent 10 years as a capital market specialist from 2000
- 3:02to 2010 and then from 2010 to 2021 when I retired, I was a director of
- 3:08special actions in the Western region supervising capital market specialist
- 3:12and as well as problem case officers and dealing with troubled credit unions.
- 3:17So in my 10 years as A capital market specialist did a lot of training
- 3:22for NCOA examiners on the review of interest rate risk and liquidity
- 3:28and had a hand in developing some of these tools that they use today.
- 3:32And if I didn't, staff that worked for me certainly did very close to all of these
- 3:37topics, especially over the last 10 years.
- 3:41Treichel: Yeah, yeah, you, as you said, 10 years as a capital market specialist,
- 3:44and then another 10 plus years supervising those capital market specialists and
- 3:49having been in on meetings where NCUA set some of these policies and or provided
- 3:53some input on where NCUA was at in the past, and that's actually might be a
- 3:59good transition on providing, we've given your background a little bit, maybe it'd
- 4:03be good if we kind of walk through for the audience a little bit of history
- 4:06and background on this whole arena.
- 4:09Yeah.
- 4:09with where NCUA has come since the early 2000s and where they're
- 4:14at coming up to today's webinar.
- 4:16Miller: Sure, we can do that.
- 4:18And we did a lot of this background in our NEV podcast, too.
- 4:22If people want to go back and listen to that one.
- 4:24In the early 2000s, NCUA had this thing they called the 17 4 test.
- 4:30It just looked at asset volatility.
- 4:32It was a scope determinant.
- 4:332016 is really when they came out with a policy that they were talking about
- 4:38today and revisions made to that.
- 4:40So we'll talk a little bit about that one.
- 4:42That's when NCUA determined that we were going to use, or the agency
- 4:47was going to use, premiums of one in 4 percent for non maturity shares.
- 4:52You'll have to excuse me if I say we, sometimes I think I'm still with NCUA.
- 4:57I spent so much time.
- 4:57With that family, but that was addressing a problem.
- 5:00There were parties out there that had very large non maturity share premiums.
- 5:05It wasn't a lot of them, but there was a number of them where those premiums
- 5:10would be 15%, 20%, even on occasions, 30%.
- 5:14And in those situations, the credit union could essentially have about
- 5:19a hundred percent of their loans in fixed rate, long term real estate,
- 5:23and the models would say they're fine.
- 5:26So.
- 5:27I would rephrase it as credit unions were using model results to justify what they
- 5:32were doing and not using their models to inform their decision making, so to speak.
- 5:38So, to just alleviate all of that, NCUA came up with the 1 and 4 percent premiums.
- 5:46They did a lot of research.
- 5:48Everyone's models on the asset side of the balance sheet look very much the same.
- 5:53Most of the liability side look very much the same.
- 5:55But then you come to these non maturity shares and results were all
- 5:59over the place and very inconsistent.
- 6:01So NCA said, we'll make this consistent.
- 6:03We'll create some bright lines.
- 6:06It will avoid us from having these discussions with credit unions.
- 6:10It's a one size fits all approach.
- 6:12That works for most of the time, and it did accomplish what the agency wanted in
- 6:18terms of some consistency of measurement and helping them compare risk in one
- 6:24credit unit to another credit unit.
- 6:27It accomplished that very well.
- 6:29Treichel: And they actually, Todd, they actually in the webinar, which we'll,
- 6:32I'll have a link to the actual NCOA webinar in the show notes once they, I
- 6:37may have to go back and add that because we might get our podcast up before NCOA
- 6:40gets their webinar up, although they've been moving those more quickly, lately.
- 6:45But they made a reference to that.
- 6:47Uh, that specific issue that it helps NCUA provide context if we're
- 6:52looking at everybody doing all of their own assumptions on it.
- 6:56And as you said, you could have people going with as a lowest
- 6:584 percent and as high as 30%.
- 7:01The numbers come out so much differently.
- 7:03This provides context to NCUA so they can take their quarterly data and take a look
- 7:08at it and see who those outliers are.
- 7:10So that perhaps they could say, Okay.
- 7:12Because they're outliers here, we might want to send a capital market specialist
- 7:17into those credit unions so that we could see if they have the systems in place and
- 7:22the programs in place to mitigate whatever risks those numbers might show or that
- 7:26there actually might not be any risk.
- 7:28Does that sound right?
- 7:31That
- 7:31Miller: does sound about, and I think it's an accurate statement,
- 7:34but we'll go back and talk a little bit more about the background is.
- 7:37It creates some problems too.
- 7:39Anytime you do a one size fits all approach, you're going to have outliers
- 7:43where that approach just doesn't work.
- 7:45The fact of the matter is credit unions are not all the same balance sheets vary.
- 7:50There's an infinite number of combinations of risk and reward out there.
- 7:56And one size fits all approaches doesn't work for everybody.
- 8:01And in fact, their guidance in 2016 was very inconsistent.
- 8:05from the way they manage other risks.
- 8:07They've always talked about it's examiner judgment.
- 8:10We need to look at a given risk area in light of other risks areas.
- 8:14So we need to aggregate risks together and their approach in 2016 says if
- 8:19you hit this bright line, you're going to get a document or resolution and
- 8:22we're going to ask you to de risk.
- 8:24So, It's like a sledgehammer to a problem that just really needed
- 8:28something as simple as a Dremel tool.
- 8:30They went way overboard with it, and it was very inconsistent with
- 8:34their other examination procedures in that and everything else.
- 8:38Let's look at aggregate risk here.
- 8:40They said, Here's a silo.
- 8:42There's zero examiner judgment.
- 8:44We're going to look at this one factor.
- 8:48We're not going to consider how much credit risk you have.
- 8:50We're not going to consider how much liquidity risk you have.
- 8:53We're not going to consider that accrediting with 2 percent operating
- 8:56expenses can accept a lot more interest rate risk than accrediting with,
- 9:00say, 2 4 percent operating expenses.
- 9:03So from that one aspect, this bright line that they created in 2016
- 9:09was actually not really consistent with the rest of their exam guide
- 9:13and the rest of their processes.
- 9:15And when you really come down to this program update in this new
- 9:19issuance that they issued here last month, and that we talked about
- 9:22today, they really just fix that.
- 9:25And really brought the world back to let's be more consistent with the way
- 9:30we evaluate all these other risk areas.
- 9:33We do evaluate risk in light of other risk areas.
- 9:36We are going to allow a measure of examiner judgment.
- 9:41We are going to go back where this test they use, and they're still going to
- 9:44use the test is a scope determinant and it helps them find outliers.
- 9:49So it's still useful for that.
- 9:50They're going to use it for that.
- 9:52That's.
- 9:53more consistent with the way they examine all the other areas of risk.
- 9:57So in the big scheme of things, I would just say they're maybe
- 10:01fixing a mistake they made in 2016.
- 10:04Other people might not categorize it like that, but the reality is that
- 10:08policy has cost a lot of angst for a lot of credit unions here this year.
- 10:13Treichel: Yeah, it sure has.
- 10:14And I think it went unnoticed until rates went up, right?
- 10:18We didn't have a situation where we saw the results of what it was doing where
- 10:22everybody was getting rated extreme.
- 10:24And if you were extreme, you automatically had to get a document resolution.
- 10:28And as you've so eloquently said, examiner judgment.
- 10:32In every other area determines whether or not you get a document resolution,
- 10:36whether you get an examiner, funny, let me back up setting aside bank secrecy
- 10:40act, where there are some required document resolutions and things like
- 10:44that, based on agreements with other agencies, this really gets this whole
- 10:48interest rate risk topic more aligned with the rest of their exam program, which.
- 10:53Again, comes back to examiner judgment.
- 10:56Todd, one other thing you mentioned is, if someone, if the, if someone
- 11:00has extremely low operating expenses or extremely high net worth, yet
- 11:07they have some issues with their.
- 11:09Uh, interest rate risk calculation here, the ENT or the NEB, whichever, whichever,
- 11:14whichever way you want to call it, if they have a lot of other positives, those
- 11:19can be mitigating factors that may result in the examiner using that judgment
- 11:25and concluding that the credit union does not need a document of resolution.
- 11:30Anything you'd like to expand on relative to the statement I just made?
- 11:34Miller: I think that's absolutely it, and they alluded it to it a little bit
- 11:39in the webinar that you may still find yourself, a criterion may still find
- 11:43itself with a high risk rating for interest rate risk or for sensitivity is
- 11:48the term they use now, it's on the camels.
- 11:51But yes, you can use these mitigating factors now where perhaps you
- 11:55won't get a document or resolution.
- 11:57Yeah.
- 11:59We'll go through maybe the slides a little bit in their presentation and
- 12:04get to the document or resolution.
- 12:06The letter is very specific as to when you'll get a document or resolution.
- 12:10It's more consistent with other practices and that you're going
- 12:14to get a document or resolution if your risk is high enough to cause.
- 12:18Some undue risk to the insurance fund.
- 12:20Our management risk management practices are severely deficient.
- 12:25Now you can have that number, but if your risk management processes
- 12:29are good and you have control of your risks and other areas, you're
- 12:34probably not going to get a door.
- 12:36I'm sure there's still going to be some uncomfortable discussions about your risk
- 12:39position and what is really management doing to recognize that and assessing.
- 12:46If they need to do something with it, pardon on, I thought it was interesting.
- 12:51They had a slide during today's webinar on contributing factors and results.
- 12:56Some of this is because we just had a huge surge in deposits over 2020 and 2021.
- 13:03During the pandemic, they grew over 20%, both of those years.
- 13:06So capital ratios dropped across the industry.
- 13:10So we're starting out at a lower point than perhaps we were
- 13:12when this policy was enacted.
- 13:14It is interesting that growth has slowed tremendously since then.
- 13:18And in fact, from March to June, there's been almost no show share growth, but
- 13:22it's hitting this whole high risk.
- 13:25It's hit a very specific number of credit unions.
- 13:28And they talked a little bit around it during the webinar, but The ones that it's
- 13:32really impacted the most are these credit unions with lower loan to share ratios.
- 13:36So you have a group of credit unions that are relying on their investment
- 13:40portfolio for earnings, not just liquidity management, but they have
- 13:45large investment portfolios that are really serving as their loan portfolio.
- 13:49So they have zero credit risk, but they've taken on duration and extended
- 13:54the maturity of their investments because it's a core piece of their earnings.
- 14:00While the rise in interest rate risks.
- 14:02or interest rates, it's dropped the value of those significantly.
- 14:08And you can see it on the FPR just nationally.
- 14:11I think it's around, they mentioned it during the webinar, 17 percent
- 14:14of net worth is sitting in these unrealized losses and investments.
- 14:17So those criteria have been hit really hard in terms of triggering
- 14:23extreme risk on that supervisory test.
- 14:26But also the parties that have the most mitigating factors, they typically
- 14:30have very low operating expenses.
- 14:33And because they're not making loans, they have almost no credit risk.
- 14:36So they need to be taking on interest rate risk to generate earnings.
- 14:41And it's all reasonable.
- 14:43And Many of these credit unions were just showing up as moderate
- 14:47risk in December, all of a sudden, now they're extreme went from
- 14:50Treichel: moderate to extreme.
- 14:51And now the definition of extreme is, oh, is gone.
- 14:54But that may have led to them already getting a document resolution.
- 14:58Miller: Yeah, so those are the people that have been hit really hard by this policy,
- 15:02and they're the very ones where when you.
- 15:06Assess the risk mitigation.
- 15:07They have the most mitigation.
- 15:09So they're the group that can actually take the most interest rate risk too.
- 15:15Treichel: Fascinating.
- 15:15Fascinating.
- 15:16Yeah.
- 15:16We might want to do a little deeper dive into that, but the other
- 15:20thing too, is it might be best for someone who hasn't seen the letter.
- 15:23If we maybe talk through the highlights of the actual letter to credit
- 15:27unions to, to give a primer on who the letter applies to, et cetera.
- 15:31So what, what are the highlights of the, this recent letter that we.
- 15:35Miller: So I would say there's a couple main highlights in the letter.
- 15:38First off, this applies mostly to credeans over 50 million.
- 15:41So the smaller credeans, it doesn't impact them at all.
- 15:44The letter does a number of things.
- 15:46In the 2016 policy, they created this extreme risk category where
- 15:52there was no ifs, ands, or buts.
- 15:53You were going to get a document of resolution if NCUA supervisory tests
- 15:58determined your risk was extreme.
- 16:00Using their 1 and 4 percent non maturity shares.
- 16:03It does away with that entire extreme risk rating.
- 16:06It's gone.
- 16:06They've just eliminated it.
- 16:07Now we just have low, medium, high.
- 16:09So, they've eliminated that entire risk rating, which was appropriate.
- 16:14Policy in 2016 also took away examiner flexibility.
- 16:18They were not allowed to alter that rating.
- 16:21at all.
- 16:22It was a numerical rating.
- 16:24This new guidance in the letter, it gives the examiner some judgment back.
- 16:29Now, it does say it should be rare for credit unions to lower that
- 16:33risk rating, but it does create an environment where they can.
- 16:38And then, of course, the absolute largest thing it does is the 2016
- 16:42guidance required a document of resolution and a de risking plan.
- 16:47That has done away with.
- 16:49They've created some specific criteria where A document of resolution is still
- 16:55appropriate, but for a lot of credit unions, not for a lot, it's hard to judge.
- 16:59For many credit unions, the document of resolution is probably
- 17:03not going to be appropriate.
- 17:05They laid out conditions for when they might still need a document
- 17:09of resolution, and that's undue risk to the insurance fund.
- 17:12A credit union really hasn't reacted appropriately to
- 17:15these rising interest rates.
- 17:17Risks.
- 17:17It's a big change in risk rating and should be talking about their various
- 17:21loan and investment and pricing strategies and they probably need to
- 17:25change them or at least reassess them.
- 17:28So there's a category of folks that have not done that may still find themselves
- 17:34with the door, even at a high risk rating.
- 17:36And then the third piece, and this has always been a reason for
- 17:39having a document or resolution.
- 17:42It lays out if a criterion has material issues or weaknesses
- 17:46in their governance of risk.
- 17:48And that's always required the door in regardless of the area.
- 17:52So that's really not a new policy.
- 17:54It's just reaffirming a policy that's already existed.
- 17:58But that was the biggest change is they deleted the extreme risk,
- 18:00gave their examiner judgment back.
- 18:03Doors are not automatic.
- 18:04Now they need a safety and soundness reason for giving you a door, basically.
- 18:09Treichel: Got it.
- 18:11You also mentioned as we were chatting before we started, before I hit the record
- 18:16button, that there's a sentence or two in the letter where the NCOA equates the
- 18:22fact of asset growth and complexity and risk, and I know you have some general
- 18:27thoughts on that, on whether or not that's, that, that, is that a truism
- 18:33or is there, is it a little bit more
- 18:36Miller: I'll actually go, I have the letter right in front of
- 18:39me, so I'll read the sentence.
- 18:41There's two sentences and then I'll chat with them about.
- 18:44So the two sentences in the letter says the crediting system has experienced
- 18:48significant growth and complexity over the past two years, with total
- 18:52assets growing by approximately 25%.
- 18:56As the system has grown, concentrations in longer maturity assets have
- 19:00significantly increased sensitivity to changes in interest rates.
- 19:06So, They're talking about assets, and I guess NCUA has been doing this
- 19:11for a long time to justify budget growth, to justify new departments.
- 19:15Assets are growing, so the world is getting more complex.
- 19:19And that's not necessarily the case, and in here, that, those two sentences
- 19:24infer that complexity is increasing.
- 19:27But the fact of the matter is, if you pull down NCUA's call reports for June,
- 19:31uh, This year, long term fixed rate real estate loans have moved from 23.
- 19:402 percent of assets in 2018 to 22.
- 19:4339 percent at June of 2022.
- 19:48So in four years.
- 19:49Exposure to fixed rate real estate loans as a percentage of assets.
- 19:53It's actually come down a little bit.
- 19:55It hasn't gone up.
- 19:56Now, total real estate loans have gone up, but as a percentage
- 19:59of assets, no, it's come down.
- 20:01Another big piece of that is commercial loans because they throw all these
- 20:07commercial loans into long term assets.
- 20:10They went from 4.
- 20:1188 percent of assets in 2018 to 5.
- 20:1488 percent today.
- 20:15It's very much an insignificant change.
- 20:19So it's one of those things, NCU, and they say that a lot,
- 20:22that growth equals complexity.
- 20:24But really when you look at that balance sheet composition and how
- 20:27they're funding those assets, it hasn't really changed, they leave
- 20:31out the funding side of it, which hasn't gotten any more complex either.
- 20:35I just find it interesting.
- 20:37They throw that into all their letters.
- 20:39They use it a lot.
- 20:40Assets are growing.
- 20:41World is getting more complex.
- 20:43Not really.
- 20:43Assets are growing, but complexity is not changing very quickly in
- 20:49aggregate across the industry.
- 20:50There might be individual parties that increased a lot, but across
- 20:54the industry, no, that complexity has not really changed since 2018.
- 21:00Treichel: Got it.
- 21:01No, that's I think that's an interesting point that I didn't pick up on.
- 21:05I'm glad you did a deep dive on the numbers.
- 21:07And like you said, individually, credit unions risk profiles have changed.
- 21:10And we've seen that on some individual situations that
- 21:14that we've been involved with.
- 21:15But that's good to point out.
- 21:17Now, one thought on the whole liquidity Side of this in the webinar, and I might
- 21:24be getting a little bit ahead of myself here, but this just popped into my head.
- 21:28So let's go forward.
- 21:28So in the webinar, there was some discussions about the liquidity, the
- 21:32requirement for liquidity policies and different things like that.
- 21:35And there's, there were also references and you might have the slide in
- 21:39front of you, but references to the upside down nature of the investment
- 21:42portfolios collectively in credit unions, where, where the net worth is.
- 21:47A certain percentage of the net worth is eaten up by the fact that
- 21:51these investments are underwater.
- 21:53And of course, they don't have to recognize that if it's in
- 21:55a whole to maturity category.
- 21:57However, there are some situations where credit unions need to worry
- 22:01about that longer term if that.
- 22:04If they have a big investment portfolio and if that loss keeps going up,
- 22:09that can have some ramifications on their liquidity in different ways.
- 22:12But one of those ways is the relationships that they have for borrowing.
- 22:16I've heard you speak to me on that offline, but can you highlight,
- 22:22highlight that here for our listeners?
- 22:24Miller: So there's lots of pieces to the liquidity piece.
- 22:27And I think this is one of those things where NCOA, they tend to.
- 22:32fall behind on where risk is really going and then it hits them in the face
- 22:36and then they start adjusting policies.
- 22:38In fact, someone asked a question during the webinar today.
- 22:42Is NCUA looking at how it's looking at liquidity and do they
- 22:45have any plans to change it?
- 22:47And they talked around the answer.
- 22:48So somebody is paying attention to what's going on.
- 22:51I think there's a few things going on with liquidity risk and there's a lot
- 22:54of indicators that it's increasing.
- 22:58So, first.
- 23:00A lot of creditors and lenders, they look at your gap equity as
- 23:05opposed to your regulatory equity.
- 23:07And while regulatory equity isn't falling because it doesn't consider
- 23:11these investment losses, gap equity is falling pretty significantly too.
- 23:18It's down a From about 11.
- 23:192 in 2019 to 9.
- 23:2199 today on an aggregate basis, you look at the investment portfolio.
- 23:28Let's see.
- 23:28I have a call report in front of me.
- 23:30I'll get to it here.
- 23:31Fair market value of hold to maturity investments is down
- 23:35to 94 percent of book value.
- 23:37And that unrealized loss on available for sale investments is 7.
- 23:425 percent at June.
- 23:43Credit unions don't like to sell investments.
- 23:47At a loss, one of NCOA's internal models that they used to use years ago, it had
- 23:52an indicator for investment losses greater than 2 percent because just intuitively
- 23:57history shows when you're more than 2 percent underwater, you typically
- 24:01don't want to sell those investments.
- 24:02They're still available to pledge, but that's a secondary source of liquidity
- 24:07and your haircuts are going to get larger, especially if a credit union
- 24:12starts having asset quality problems.
- 24:14Generally, if asset quality is good, they can still use those investments to assess.
- 24:19wholesale funding.
- 24:21A couple of other things going on that they don't talk about
- 24:24behind the scenes is we have these very large inflation numbers.
- 24:30No one really talks about them.
- 24:32But if you go look at deposit growth since March of this year, It's 0.
- 24:402%.
- 24:40Deposit growth is ended.
- 24:42People are struggling to pay bills and I'm sure that has an impact on that whole
- 24:46deposit growth, which is almost nothing.
- 24:49When I looked for March to June across the industry, all your asset
- 24:53growth was from borrowed money.
- 24:55So borrowed money is growing very rapidly and then we have these rising rates.
- 25:00So what is the cost of that borrowed money?
- 25:02Right now it's not showing up in cost of funds yet because all that
- 25:07borrowing is shifting to overnight.
- 25:08Historically, credit unions, they would borrow long term to fund loans.
- 25:12They would borrow long term to hedge interest rate risk.
- 25:15Now you're seeing just an explosive growth in overnight borrowed money.
- 25:20And that's funding growth in the industry, and that's just from March to June.
- 25:24And so those are kind of indicators that, hey, liquidity problems
- 25:27might be coming down the pike for individual credit unions.
- 25:30And so you got a combination and borrowings are going up, investment values
- 25:34are falling, gap net worth is falling.
- 25:38We have these large inflation numbers, which potentially means
- 25:42parts of the economy are slowing down.
- 25:44People are having troubles playing bills.
- 25:46I remember one of our clients, we were having a conversation or
- 25:50they had us look at their credit committee meetings and their cost
- 25:53of fuel oil for that one person, their members tripled from last year.
- 25:58And so they had just a segment of their middle class members are going to
- 26:01struggle just because of the increase.
- 26:03Costs in heating costs this winter.
- 26:05So there's lots of little warning indicators around liquidity.
- 26:09And so they did mention during the podcast today, there is a liquidity
- 26:12regulation, you are supposed to have a contingency funding plan.
- 26:16You do have to have the access to the federal reserve or the
- 26:19CLF, if you're over 250 million.
- 26:22So just as a side note, even though this is a podcast about interest rate risk.
- 26:26The industry would do well to go reassess their liquidity risk at an individual
- 26:31party level and see if strategies about that might need to change as well.
- 26:37Treichel: No, that's a great point.
- 26:38And it's, they're related and an issue I think that's brewing.
- 26:42And as you mentioned, you've got, you didn't miss mentions of specifics, but
- 26:46you've got the corporate credit unions, you've got the federal home loan banks.
- 26:50Of course, you've got the fed and their liquidity borrowing abilities.
- 26:55Can be at one or all of those and of course, obviously, depending on
- 26:59their size, but other factors are potentially painting some credit unions
- 27:03in a corner because of the fact of the value of their portfolios because of
- 27:08the fact that maybe they've already accessed some of their lines and as
- 27:11numbers start to deteriorate, those.
- 27:13Sources tend to look a little bit more closely at the credit union.
- 27:19I think you've said they put, they may start monitoring and put
- 27:22them on some sort of watch list.
- 27:24It's something you definitely want to get ahead of before you end up having
- 27:27some of those things evaporate under you.
- 27:29And as I've heard said before, liquidity doesn't matter until it matters.
- 27:33And when, and then it's the only thing that matters.
- 27:36Miller: Yeah, and I think we're a ways away from it.
- 27:38I don't want to imply that borrowing is bad or credit unions are In totally in
- 27:44trouble because that's not the case at all But that whole borrowing and ability to
- 27:48borrow is there to help serve your members and get you through these Crises and we
- 27:52don't really know how long the economy is going to stay down or how inflation
- 27:58How long inflation will remain elevated and how that will impact consumers.
- 28:03So far, you don't see it on the asset quality side.
- 28:06Delinquency isn't coming up anywhere yet in credit unions.
- 28:10So that's a good thing, but you might start seeing it become elevated and
- 28:15that becomes a watchword with liquidity issues too, is when credit risk
- 28:19starts going up and you start seeing elevated delinquency and elevated
- 28:23charge offs, then the liquidity risk will Really start accelerating.
- 28:28Treichel: Sure.
- 28:28And of course that gets to that inflation that gets to where, where
- 28:32our company's profits at, what do they do relative to unemployment?
- 28:36What's the impact of unemployment on, on, on rates going up to try and control
- 28:41inflation and just listing those things makes my head hurt and there's smarter
- 28:45people out there than me that, that know what all that means, but it does mean that
- 28:49it can create some issues individually for credit unions, individually for people.
- 28:54And what have you, so
- 28:56Miller: I'm sure it's extremely challenging for every credit management
- 29:00team out there and board out there because you have these national
- 29:04trends, but then you have all this localized stuff and I'm sure places
- 29:07where the economy is still very robust.
- 29:09There's places it's slowing down, there's places where their segments are
- 29:13good and other parts are slowing down.
- 29:16It has to be, they're just.
- 29:17The uncertainty is higher, I think, than it has probably been
- 29:22in the last four or five years.
- 29:24And they alluded to that a little bit in this letter.
- 29:26It's, wait, we haven't seen an interest rate risk increase
- 29:30like this in a long time.
- 29:32And so that level of uncertainty, it always creates risk management challenges.
- 29:37So.
- 29:38It's a tough time for management teams and boards of directors.
- 29:41Treichel: Yeah, that's a fact.
- 29:44So we've talked about what the letter highlighted.
- 29:46We talked about the door clarification of what happens
- 29:49relative to not requiring a door.
- 29:52What's what.
- 29:53What might require a door and we both listened to the webinar, maybe we should
- 29:57talk through what we thought the key takeaways were where they provided some
- 30:02context in the webinar on the letter.
- 30:06So what jumps out to you having just listened to it?
- 30:09What do you think we should highlight here?
- 30:10to the webinar if they haven't listened to it themselves.
- 30:13Miller: The person who spoke about this, Jonathan Farrell, he spoke very quickly,
- 30:19but he had a slide on things that would help you avoid getting in the door.
- 30:24And they gave some examples in the actual letter itself of situations that you
- 30:32would not necessarily receive a door.
- 30:35And I think for a lot of credit unions, those need to be one
- 30:42of their takeaway points.
- 30:43What do you have to do to not get a door, even though their supervisory tests
- 30:49might tell you you're very high risk?
- 30:51A lot of that really comes down to, you need to have good risk
- 30:55management practices in place.
- 30:58The words they use during the webinar is your risk management processes need
- 31:02to be commensurate with your risk level.
- 31:04And that's Regulatory language that's been used for decades.
- 31:10Sometimes it's hard for credit needs to put their finger around.
- 31:13What does that actually mean?
- 31:15But many credit use vendors.
- 31:17They have peers.
- 31:18Let's have some discussions with that.
- 31:19Let's have some discussions with your examiners ahead of time
- 31:22of what they might think that.
- 31:25may also mean.
- 31:28They'll pretty much say you won't get a door under two conditions and that's
- 31:33if your risk management processes are acceptable and commensurate or if
- 31:39the crediting has already taken steps to act on their high risk rating so
- 31:43they've noticed their risk has gone up.
- 31:45So They've went back and they've come up with a plan.
- 31:48We're going to change our pricing strategy.
- 31:50We're going to slow the growth of long term assets, whatever that may be.
- 31:54What they're looking for, does the credit union already have a plan to
- 31:57maybe start reining in their risk level or containing it or reducing it?
- 32:02So it's those two pieces are the big takeaways.
- 32:05You're not going to get a door if you have really good risk management.
- 32:09Practices and governance across your credit union are if your risk is
- 32:13elevated, has your management team done something to rein that back in?
- 32:17Do you have a plan to contain this rising risk?
- 32:21So those are the two big takeaways.
- 32:23If you want to avoid a door and get a good risk rating is make
- 32:27sure your risk management processes are Acceptable and consistent.
- 32:31And I think for some of the credit is that already got a door.
- 32:33They did have good risk management processes.
- 32:36I think the examiners were very reluctant to give them a door.
- 32:40They knew one wasn't necessary, but they had this agency policy that says
- 32:44I have to give you a door that has happened to places that have very That
- 32:50have risk management practices that are commensurate with their risk, but the
- 32:54second piece for the smaller, moderate credit unions, and if you haven't
- 32:57got an exam yet, and you are going to hit their new high risk ratings, do
- 33:02make sure and do a self assessment.
- 33:05Have we addressed these issues?
- 33:06Have we paid attention to our rising risk levels?
- 33:09Do we have some discussions in our ALCO committee?
- 33:11What are we going to do about it?
- 33:13Are we going to talk about our earnings challenges?
- 33:17And I really, let's go back and look at everything.
- 33:18Is your credit risk management where it needs to be?
- 33:22Have we assessed how this changing marketplace might impact your liquidity
- 33:26risk and credit risk down the road?
- 33:29So continue doing what you're doing.
- 33:32If you have good practices in place, you should be fine.
- 33:36Treichel: No, that all makes good sense.
- 33:38And you talked about, so someone who's offering fixed rate.
- 33:41Real estate loans.
- 33:42And that may have played a role.
- 33:44You can tweak what you're putting on the books moving forward.
- 33:47Same as tweaking what it is that you're putting on the rest of your assets.
- 33:50You mentioned credit unions that rely heavily on the investment portfolios.
- 33:54You obviously, if they want to hold what they've got to, they've got to let
- 33:57that play out, but they can change what it is they're adding to their book.
- 34:01I know one of the things.
- 34:03You and I, again, have talked about, so one scenario, one of the
- 34:09things that drives this is if your liabilities are mostly in the core
- 34:13deposits, the share, the regular share deposits that have no term.
- 34:18You can try and attract and move that money by creating rates that might help
- 34:23move that money, but it really relies on what your members are willing to do.
- 34:26And then it also has an impact on the bottom line.
- 34:29The other thing you can do is, You can, you can start borrowing
- 34:33longer term to make your numbers come out a little bit better.
- 34:36Any thoughts relative to anything I just threw out on the table there on
- 34:39what might make sense, what doesn't make sense, what thing credit unions
- 34:43could consider when they're looking at different levers that they can pull to.
- 34:48Reduce their
- 34:48Miller: overall risk.
- 34:50You can pull all those levers, just recognizing there's
- 34:53going to be a cost to them.
- 34:54And like I said, one of the things that's somewhat interesting is
- 34:58credeans are getting increasingly competitive for loans, even though
- 35:02interest rates are going up, yield on loans across the industry is coming
- 35:07down because they're just fighting with the banks, credit unions.
- 35:11Internet lenders are fighting with everybody for loan dollars because
- 35:16even though rates are going up, there's still such a big spread
- 35:19between loans and investments.
- 35:21People are fighting for loan dollars.
- 35:23So loan yields are coming down.
- 35:25That's fascinating.
- 35:26You normally, you would think about, okay, we can pay a higher amount
- 35:28of money to borrow, to fund loans.
- 35:31You can pay a higher amount to borrow, but you might not
- 35:34have the loans there to grant.
- 35:36Sure.
- 35:37A positive spread.
- 35:39So there's costs to borrowing money.
- 35:41You can do all of those things.
- 35:42The challenge for credit unions is, and it's kind of contrary to what you
- 35:49might think, is the credit unions with the most non maturity shares, which
- 35:54are in effect the most stable funding, are the ones that are being punished
- 35:59the most under this supervisory test.
- 36:01They have the biggest impact, even though they're, in effect, Have the
- 36:06least risk and the most stable funding.
- 36:08So it's one of those one size fits all approaches is
- 36:12somewhat dangerous to people.
- 36:14I think the credit is, they just have to look at all their levelers and
- 36:17it's a manner of managing earnings.
- 36:20And that is really challenging right now.
- 36:22People doing things to manage those earnings.
- 36:25They're competing for loans.
- 36:26You're seeing more people purchasing loans.
- 36:29They alluded toward the webinar.
- 36:30One of the biggest issues is it's longer duration investments and.
- 36:34That's Cartagena's reaching out there for earnings.
- 36:36It's not there in the loan marketplace because people aren't raising
- 36:41loan rates the way they need to.
- 36:43Consumer loans, the real estate loans are going up because the secondary
- 36:46market does impact those real estate loan rates to a great deal.
- 36:50People want to keep that liquidity available.
- 36:53So people price those to the secondary market.
- 36:56So they do move with treasury rates, all these other consumer loans.
- 37:00And I would suspect we've seen this in the last recession back,
- 37:04In 2006 2007, commercial loans tend to get underpriced, too.
- 37:10And while it's only 5 percent of Cretien's assets, the Cretien's that are in that
- 37:14business, they need to pay attention to their pricing because quite often
- 37:18you see that get underpriced, too.
- 37:19And that has consequences when delinquency starts rising.
- 37:24Later, sure, and see if it starts visiting.
- 37:27I would just throw one last thing out there.
- 37:28And I guess maybe this is a piece of what you asked me about what they can do in
- 37:33terms of funding, but it's go look at your concentration risk levels everywhere.
- 37:39And that's on your share side and on your house that side.
- 37:42I think you're going to see your examiners.
- 37:45They're going to start.
- 37:46Scrutinizing those concentration risk levels a little bit more, and I already
- 37:50elevated it a couple years ago with a letter on concentration risk, but
- 37:55I think you might see an even more enhanced focus on it going forward.
- 38:01Treichel: That's good advice.
- 38:02Very sound advice.
- 38:04So the webinar itself went about went a little over probably about 70 minutes.
- 38:10About half of that was actually the presentation.
- 38:12That's when they got into the question and answers.
- 38:15And there were some good questions.
- 38:17And 1 of the biggest questions that I was interested in hearing how
- 38:21they answered was the timing issue.
- 38:23So.
- 38:24Credit unions, as you and I know, since May, a lot of credit unions have received
- 38:29document resolutions simply because, perhaps simply because the previous
- 38:35guidance required that the examiner give the credit union a document resolution.
- 38:41if they were rated as extreme.
- 38:43So there were a couple different questions relative to, all right,
- 38:46so I got a document resolution.
- 38:48What happens now that I was rated extreme, which required
- 38:52me to get a document resolution?
- 38:54Now extreme doesn't exist.
- 38:56What is NCUA going to do relative to that?
- 38:59Any thoughts relative to the, or could you summarize what you heard as the
- 39:04answers that they gave relative to that?
- 39:05Any thoughts on that?
- 39:07Miller: I can summarize it and then I can tell you what wasn't said
- 39:10too, which is almost as interesting.
- 39:12So they said the region, if you're one of these cruddies that hit extreme risk
- 39:16because of the supervisory testing, you received a door to send in a plant
- 39:19during the webinar, what they said is the region is going to go back and assess
- 39:23those doors and they will contact you.
- 39:26What wasn't said is what criteria are they going to use to assess those
- 39:31doors, and are they going to contact you if your door might be modified,
- 39:37or are they not going to contact you if your door is not modified.
- 39:41So they're going to turn it back over to the regional directors to go through and
- 39:48assess doors that have already been issued and determine what happens with them.
- 39:52And.
- 39:53Like I said, the interesting part of the webinar is they didn't say what
- 39:58criteria the regions will use to do that.
- 40:02In the new guidance, there's a whole set of extra steps for examiners to go
- 40:06through and assess the sources, how that interest, what made that rating change.
- 40:12And you have clients, they went from moderate to extreme in a
- 40:16quarter, even though their balance sheets didn't change, the guidance.
- 40:20Says examiners in the future are going to assess what caused that.
- 40:24I'm just going to surmise that for these credit unions that have already
- 40:28received doors that the regions have to go back and reassess is they'll have
- 40:32their examiners go back and look at that.
- 40:34What caused it?
- 40:35Why did it occur?
- 40:36Was it just a market change?
- 40:38Is the credit unions other?
- 40:40practices.
- 40:41So I think they'll just go back and review those exam reports in light
- 40:44of this new workbook and guidance.
- 40:46That's what I'm going to guess is going to happen.
- 40:49Although I don't know that's speculation on my part.
- 40:51It is speculation.
- 40:52They don't say.
- 40:53And NCUA is short of staffing and they're short of resources.
- 40:58So, you know, this is a big time commitment to go back and how
- 41:02does that play into everything?
- 41:03I don't know.
- 41:04They didn't say that.
- 41:05Treichel: They didn't say they did.
- 41:06They did say that they're going to be training their staff.
- 41:08They're going to be trading, trading, training the states, and perhaps
- 41:13they're still trying to figure out what they're going to do there.
- 41:15And perhaps that will be part of that training.
- 41:18Todd Harper did open up about on the front end, talking about wanting to
- 41:21make sure that credit unions were.
- 41:23Treated consistently that an exact credit union in Region 1 would
- 41:27be treated similar to Region 3.
- 41:29There is this nuance now, though, when you push things back towards
- 41:33judgment, it gets harder and harder to treat everybody fairly because
- 41:36Todd, as you and I know, everybody has a little bit different judgment.
- 41:40Every examiner has a little bit different risk tolerance.
- 41:42Every credit union has a little bit.
- 41:44different risk tolerance.
- 41:46My advice to a credit union, if you had a document resolution and you listen to
- 41:51this webinar, and hopefully you listen to this podcast, I would reach out to
- 41:55your examiner and engage a conversation saying, Hey, we really want to talk
- 41:58to you about the things we've done.
- 42:00You, you, they probably already know it, but highlight to them again,
- 42:03make them aware of the fact that they're going to be reevaluating
- 42:07that and put your best facts forward.
- 42:09Relative to the document of resolution.
- 42:12And some of the reality is some of the things in there you're going to want to
- 42:15do anyway, but whether or not you need that document resolution is something
- 42:18that is definitely up for play here.
- 42:21Miller: A couple of things that kind of segue.
- 42:24Into that as well as Todd Harper.
- 42:26Also, he mentioned that interest rate risk was a supervisory priority in 2022.
- 42:32He said it's going to be on our list again in 2023.
- 42:35And I think it's been on the list.
- 42:36I don't know.
- 42:37I don't remember a year when it wasn't on the list.
- 42:39But then something else they said during the webinar as well is the intensity.
- 42:44of your exam and the review of interest rate risk, it isn't
- 42:47going to change with this letter.
- 42:48We took out an extreme risk rating.
- 42:50We said a door isn't required, but they actually added exam steps to
- 42:55their whole interest rate risk review.
- 42:57And they were very clear the intensity of our interest rate risk review.
- 43:01It's not going down.
- 43:03It's probably going to go up.
- 43:04This is not going to make your life any easier.
- 43:09It might mean you don't get a door, but The examiner's scrutiny of interest
- 43:14rate risk, it's not going to change.
- 43:15It's still going to be elevated.
- 43:18In fact, it's going to go up for a certain group of credit unions that hit that high
- 43:23risk threshold on that supervisory test.
- 43:25They were pretty clear in the webinar that What we're doing isn't going to go down.
- 43:29It's going to go up.
- 43:30You might not get a door, but our review is going to get
- 43:34more thorough and more intense.
- 43:36Treichel: Todd, I think you just hit the biggest highlight of the whole webinar,
- 43:40and it's what you just summarized and what Todd said on the front end.
- 43:44It's a priority now.
- 43:45It's going to be exam priority next year.
- 43:48And you also picked up on the fact that their exam steps have gone up.
- 43:53Todd was sending signals there that he wants to make sure that this Is
- 43:58addressed appropriately by credit unions.
- 44:00But as you said, there's going to be some difficult conversations.
- 44:03They've armed the examiners with some more exam steps that will lead to
- 44:07some more difficult conversations.
- 44:09But when you get to the other side of that, those conversations, hopefully
- 44:12you can demonstrate that you've put good things in place, and then perhaps
- 44:17you'll learn a thing or two from those conversations that can help you guide your
- 44:21own credit union even NCWA is pointing out, but again, you nailed it right there.
- 44:28That this issue isn't going away, and so we will be asking those difficult
- 44:32questions regardless of whether or not guidance requires a door or not.
- 44:37That's a great point.
- 44:39point and again a highlight of the webinar today.
- 44:42Miller: I think there's another piece to it too if you're an accrediting
- 44:47official or just a member of the public who cares about the NCISIF and
- 44:51there's some positives in there too because the other policy when they
- 44:54had it and says you're going to get a door at extreme interest rate risk it
- 44:58caused a lot of examiners to maybe give creditings a break that were at high or
- 45:04moderate in risk management processes weren't what they should have been.
- 45:08Because the examiners didn't have to scrutinize them closely and the
- 45:12simple fact of the matter is, there are probably pretty names out there
- 45:16that might be moderate risk for that supervisory test that they do
- 45:21deserve a door and they probably have.
- 45:25Taking on more risk than they should have.
- 45:28And maybe some of those people will get caught now because the examiners don't
- 45:33get that automatic get out of jail free card where we're going to reduce our
- 45:36scope and level of review just because the numbers are moderate and they'll turn that
- 45:42focus back on governance a little bit.
- 45:45And that's a positive thing.
- 45:48If you really want to see your share insurance fund protected,
- 45:53that goes the other way as well.
- 45:54Treichel: It does.
- 45:55Now that's a, that's, I hadn't thought of it in that way, but that's crystal clear.
- 45:59That makes perfect sense.
- 46:00We've hit a lot of the highlights of the letter and we've hit a highlights
- 46:04and I think you just hit the two key points of what was said today
- 46:07before we wrap this, this episode up, Todd, is there anything else that.
- 46:11Anything I should have asked you or anything that pops into your mind that
- 46:15a credit union might want to take into consideration as they're negotiating
- 46:19these difficult waters of the world today?
- 46:22Miller: I'll just throw one more thing out there and this has always been
- 46:24true and it affects all your clients.
- 46:26It was brought out in the question and answer session.
- 46:29Someone asked a question about if they're already high or extreme risk,
- 46:33should they reach out to the examiner before the examiner calls them?
- 46:37And it's easy to view your examiner as an enemy, but the reality is if you
- 46:42open the door and communicate with them up front, they can become a resource
- 46:47for your credit union and you can smooth a lot of things over and you can
- 46:52reduce a lot of exam anxiety and reduce the difficulty of these questions.
- 47:00If you're communicating with your examiner up front, so pick up the
- 47:03phone, call them occasionally.
- 47:05A lot of this stuff you can get put aside and you create a lot of trust and
- 47:09credibility with them and life can become a lot easier for you if you have open,
- 47:15honest and consistent communications with your examiner and that.
- 47:20Kind of came out during the webinar too in the answering question session.
- 47:24So I would say that's one takeaway.
- 47:26Don't necessarily treat that examiner and COA as an enemy.
- 47:30They're part of the cost of doing business, but you can
- 47:32turn them into a partner if you communicate effectively with them.
- 47:37Treichel: Great point, Todd.
- 47:38And you reminded me of a quote that I have to now get out of my head here.
- 47:42And that so communication breeds familiarity.
- 47:45And there was a quote that that Mark former board member, Mark
- 47:49McWater said that I won't forget.
- 47:50And that was familiarity breeds consent.
- 47:53So you have those communications and you have those dialogues and they start
- 47:58to understand NCWA starts to understand better what it is you're doing.
- 48:02And they're going to do.
- 48:04That's going to create consent.
- 48:06They're going to come towards your direction.
- 48:08If you're building a good program and you're communicating that to them,
- 48:13they're going to be able to better understand what's going on and then use
- 48:19that examiner judgment in a way that is.
- 48:23reasonable in dealing with the credit union.
- 48:25So great point.
- 48:26The communication is always a key.
- 48:28Todd, I really appreciate you.
- 48:29And I've been talking about the letter coming out and then we heard
- 48:32that as soon as the letter came out, they mentioned that the, this
- 48:36webinar was going to be happening.
- 48:37And I'm glad this worked into both of our schedules so that we could
- 48:41listen to what NCUA had to say.
- 48:43We could record this to give our take on it and we can get it
- 48:46out to the listeners real quick.
- 48:48Next week, this will be the episode and thanks again for.
- 48:52Listening to the webinar today and sharing your wisdom with
- 48:54our listeners on the podcast.
- 48:57Miller: Always a pleasure.
- 48:58Treichel: Great.
- 48:58Great.
- 48:59And to those of you listening, we appreciate your time.
- 49:01Thanks for listening to this episode of With Flying Colors, and we hope
- 49:06that you'll listen again soon.
- 49:08And this is Mark Treichel signing off With Flying Colors.
- 49:20Katie: Thank you for joining us on this episode of With Flying Colors.
- 49:23Subscribe on your favorite podcast app to hear future episodes where subject matter
- 49:27experts of all varieties will provide tips on how to achieve success with NCUA.
- 49:32If you would like to learn more about how we assist credit unions, check out
- 49:35our services at mark trickle dot com.