Latest / Friendship Project: Friendship, community & belonging / How to Guide Without Taking Over: The Art of Mentoring a Friend | Friendship Project
Transcript
- I watched her struggle with a problem I had solved ten years ago, and for the first time in my life, I wanted to reach across the table and fix it myself. But if I did, I would rob her of the very thing she needed most: her own messy, beautiful process of figuring it out. Let’s sit with that for a second. That impulse to rescue is so strong, isn’t it? Especially when you care about someone. I remember sitting in a coffee shop last month with Maya, who is twenty-four and brilliant, but currently drowning in the early stages of her career. She was talking about a project that wasn’t working, her voice tight with that specific kind of exhaustion that comes from trying too hard to be perfect. And I knew exactly what she should do. I had written a letter to my boss five years ago that solved a nearly identical issue. I had the script. I had the template. I could have handed it to her right then and there, and her stress would have vanished instantly. But I didn’t. Instead, I felt this physical ache in my chest, this tension between my desire to help and my knowledge that helping in that way might actually harm us. It’s a strange place to be, watching someone you love trip over something you already know how to navigate. We’ve all been there. Maybe it’s your younger sister struggling with a relationship pattern you swore you’d never repeat. Maybe it’s a junior colleague at work who looks to you like you’re holding the map to success, even though you’re just as lost as they are, just further down the road. The complexity here isn’t really about giving advice. It’s about resisting the ego’s need to be the hero. We tend to think mentoring is about transmission. Like we’re passing a torch, or handing over a set of keys. But real connection doesn’t work like that. When we step into the role of mentor for a friend, especially a younger one, we often fall into the trap of assuming our path is the only valid one. Or worse, we assume that because we suffered through a certain lesson, they must suffer through the exact same thing to learn it. That is where the overstepping happens. That is where we start parenting our friends instead of walking beside them. I used to do this constantly. Early on in my organizing days, I would see a young volunteer making a mistake, and I would swoop in, correct them, and take over. I thought I was being efficient. I thought I was protecting them from failure. But looking back, I realize I was robbing them of their agency. I was telling them, implicitly, that their judgment wasn’t trustworthy. That their intuition wasn’t worth listening to. And that creates a dynamic where the younger person stops trusting themselves. They start waiting for permission. They start looking for approval rather than looking for truth. And the friendship changes. It becomes hierarchical. It becomes heavy. And honestly, it becomes boring for both of us. Because growth requires friction, and I was smoothing out all the bumps before they could feel them. So how do we hold space without taking the wheel? It starts with a shift in language. It starts with moving from statements to questions. Instead of saying, 'You should talk to him,' which closes the door, try asking, 'What do you think is happening when he says that?' It feels small, but it’s massive. It returns the power to her. It signals that I believe she has the capacity to analyze her own life. Tell me more about why that matters to you. I use that phrase often now, not just as a podcast host, but as a friend. When Maya started venting about her project again, instead of offering the solution, I asked her, 'What part of this feels most unfair to you?' And she paused. She really stopped. She hadn’t realized that her anger wasn’t about the deadline; it was about feeling unheard by her team. By asking that question, I helped her find the root cause herself. If I had given her the solution, she would have fixed the symptom, but she wouldn’t have understood the pattern. And next time, she would have made the same mistake. Mentoring isn’t about fixing the present moment; it’s about equipping her for the next one. It’s about building her internal compass, not carrying her around in ours. This brings us to the hardest part: respecting her timeline. Our brains are wired to want efficiency. We want the problem solved, the conflict resolved, the anxiety gone. But healing and learning are not linear. They are messy loops. A younger friend might bring up the same fear three times in three weeks. And it can be tempting to say, 'Aren’t we past this yet?' or 'Did you try what I suggested?' But that is dismissive. That is toxic positivity disguised as helpfulness. We have to trust that her pace is hers alone. Just because I figured out my boundaries two years earlier doesn’t mean her journey is behind schedule. It means her context is different. Her resilience is built differently. There is a sacredness in showing up consistently for people, even when they aren’t moving at the speed we wish they would. It requires a quiet confidence. It requires believing that she will get there, even if she stumbles, even if she takes the long way around. Sometimes the best thing we can offer is simply, 'I’m here. Take your time.' No agenda. No expectation. Just presence. That safety allows her to slow down enough to actually hear herself. And we must also admit our own limits. This is where the vulnerability comes in. We cannot mentor someone from a place of superiority. We have to acknowledge that we don’t have all the answers. In fact, we probably have fewer answers than we think. I share my failures with my friends not to teach them how to succeed, but to show them that I am still learning too. When I tell Maya about the times I messed up, when I spoke too harshly or stayed too long or left too soon, I am dismantling the pedestal. I am showing her that wisdom isn’t a destination you arrive at; it’s a practice you keep doing. If we pretend we have it all together, we create an impossible standard. We make our friends feel inadequate for struggling. But if we are open about our mess, we give them permission to be human. We create a space where mistakes are data, not disasters. This shifts the dynamic from teacher-student to fellow travelers. And that is so much lighter. That is so much more honest. We are all just figuring it out as we go. Saying that out loud is one of the greatest gifts we can give to someone who looks up to us. Ultimately, mentoring is less about guidance and more about witnessing. It is about seeing someone clearly, exactly as they are, without trying to mold them into a version of yourself. It is about celebrating their unique strengths, even if those strengths look nothing like yours. Maybe she is more impulsive than you were. Maybe she asks for help sooner. Maybe she forgives faster. Those aren’t flaws to correct; they are features to honor. When we stop trying to fix our friends, we start truly knowing them. We move from surface-level advice to deep relational intimacy. We become safe harbors. And in a world that is increasingly transactional and performance-based, that kind of unconditional witness is revolutionary. It tells our younger friends that they are valued not for what they achieve, but for who they are. That is the legacy we leave. Not a list of instructions, but a memory of being seen. So the next time you feel that urge to rescue, to fix, to steer… take a breath. Sit with it. Trust her. Trust yourself. And let her find her own way home. Thank you for letting me into your day. Thank you for trusting me with your attention. I’m Rhiannon, and I’ll be right here next week, keeping the light on for you. Until then, be gentle with yourself. You’re doing better than you think. Bye for now.