Latest / Inner Work With MaryAnn Walker: Life Coach for People Pleasers / 189: Scapegoat vs Golden Child: How Family Role Shape Identity and People Pleasing With Elle Boone
Transcript
- 0:21MaryAnn Walker: Well, hello and welcome back.
- 0:23MaryAnn Walker: This is Inner Work with MaryAnn Walker, where I help recovering people, pleasers, identify the roles that are holding them back.
- 0:30MaryAnn Walker: And as part of that, I want to welcome Elle Boone to the show.
- 0:33MaryAnn Walker: So welcome Elle.
- 0:34MaryAnn Walker: So happy to have you.
- 0:35Elle Boone: Thank you so much.
- 0:37Elle Boone: I'm so happy to be here.
- 0:38Elle Boone: I'm very, very excited to have this conversation with you today, Marianne.
- 0:41Elle Boone: Thank you for inviting me.
- 0:42Elle Boone: Yeah.
- 0:43MaryAnn Walker: Yeah.
- 0:43MaryAnn Walker: And L is launching a brand new podcast that really works with a very specific role that holds a lot of people back.
- 0:50MaryAnn Walker: Do you wanna tell us a bit about that?
- 0:52Elle Boone: Yes, so the title of the show, which will launch somewhere between the end, uh, sorry, the middle and the end of October, is titled The Family Scapegoat Chronicles.
- 1:03Elle Boone: And.
- 1:04Elle Boone: The name Scape Family Scapegoat, um, would indicate that the host is probably from that tribe of family scapegoats.
- 1:12Elle Boone: Um, so yes, I have a lot of experience on that topic and I wanted to create something that didn't exist when I figured out that I was the family scapegoat and all the dynamics that.
- 1:25Elle Boone: Would allow people not just to learn more about it, but also to come on the show and express their feelings about it and share their story so that others can be heard and seen and validated and, and find community as well.
- 1:38Elle Boone: So I'm excited about that.
- 1:41Elle Boone: Yes, I, I hope that many come and, and, and get benefit and value out of it.
- 1:47Elle Boone: For sure.
- 1:48Elle Boone: Yeah.
- 1:49MaryAnn Walker: So for those that are unfamiliar with the term scapegoat, can you tell us a bit about what that looks like, especially in a family dynamic?
- 1:55Elle Boone: Yes, yes.
- 1:56Elle Boone: So typically in a family dynamic, it's, I, I wanna preface it by saying a dysfunctional family dynamic because it is, it's very much, um, a dysfunction.
- 2:09Elle Boone: And the scapegoat role is one that is assigned, um, to a child within a family system, and it can be out of a dysfunctional family system.
- 2:23Elle Boone: A narcissistic family system or a combination of the two, if that makes sense.
- 2:29Elle Boone: Um, so one person is singled out to carry the blame and the shame of the family, and not just the current generation, but previous generations as well.
- 2:40Elle Boone: It's passed down a little bit like China
- 2:43MaryAnn Walker: Hmm.
- 2:43Elle Boone: family heirloom.
- 2:45Elle Boone: Um, and so the.
- 2:48Elle Boone: The dysfunction of the family is projected on the family scapegoat,
- 2:52MaryAnn Walker: Mm-hmm.
- 2:53Elle Boone: and that person is carrying the wounds of, of the, the family, um, so that the people who are doing the projection don't have to deal with the issues
- 3:04MaryAnn Walker: That just sounds like such a huge burden.
- 3:06MaryAnn Walker: I mean, to carry the blame and the shame of the family.
- 3:09MaryAnn Walker: Um, can you give us an example of what that might look like?
- 3:12MaryAnn Walker: I'm sure it's probably something that's harder to identify when you are the one being scapegoated.
- 3:17Elle Boone: Yeah, the one thing that comes to mind in terms of blame,'cause there are three, three components that are really important.
- 3:23Elle Boone: There's blame, shame, and rejection.
- 3:25Elle Boone: So the blame might look like everything is your fault.
- 3:30Elle Boone: In the family dynamic, I used to say.
- 3:33Elle Boone: When I, before I started to figure this out, I was living in New York when nine 11 happened, and I used to joke that it was my fault.
- 3:40Elle Boone: My family blamed me for that because I was living there.
- 3:43Elle Boone: So all jokes aside, the blame and the shame coupled with the rejection can really wear down the scapegoat, which is the point.
- 3:54Elle Boone: If the scapegoat is contained.
- 3:57Elle Boone: Minimized, reduced, then they're not so much of a threat as they are if they are free to be the truth teller that they are.
- 4:07Elle Boone: And I will say too, that the person who's chosen to be the scapegoat is typically the empath, the highly sensitive person, the truth teller, the one who's not afraid to call out what's happening in the fam, the family dynamic.
- 4:22Elle Boone: So it's, targeted.
- 4:25Elle Boone: And sometimes it's deliberate and conscious and sometimes it's not conscious.
- 4:30Elle Boone: The family can be in a, state of denial in terms of the dysfunction, and not be fully conscious of what they're doing and how they're behaving.
- 4:39Elle Boone: So that adds another layer.
- 4:41Elle Boone: But the rejection, I think is, at least for me, has been the hardest part.
- 4:46Elle Boone: There is something called.
- 4:47Elle Boone: Family mobbing.
- 4:48Elle Boone: Have you heard that term before?
- 4:50Elle Boone: No,
- 4:51MaryAnn Walker: family mopping?
- 4:52Elle Boone: So family mobbing, it's no picnic.
- 4:54Elle Boone: Let me just say that.
- 4:56Elle Boone: It's when the dysfunctional family unit gangs up against the chosen scapegoat.
- 5:04Elle Boone: So for example, if something goes wrong in the family, the scapegoat person who is blamed for that issue or event, everybody comes together and it's the narcissist at the head of, those events that rallies the siblings, for example,, and pits the group against the scapegoat.
- 5:27Elle Boone: So it creates this really isolating, lonely, dark sensation for the scapegoat that's very confusing.
- 5:37Elle Boone: And it takes time to figure this out.
- 5:39Elle Boone: And so again, I'm really glad you're doing this episode because there isn't enough content out there on this topic, in my opinion, being a scapegoat, it took a while for me to figure it out.
- 5:51Elle Boone: I'm only five years into my healing, and i'm still at the beginning in many ways to recover from this dynamic because there's so much isolation that comes out of, the family mobbing, you don't have any allies.
- 6:06Elle Boone: Your siblings become your enemies on purpose.
- 6:11Elle Boone: And so where do you go?
- 6:13Elle Boone: And when you go to someone in the family, you're typically being gaslighted with your concerns.
- 6:19Elle Boone: That's not what they said.
- 6:20Elle Boone: I didn't say that.
- 6:21Elle Boone: That's not true.
- 6:22Elle Boone: You're making things up.
- 6:24Elle Boone: You are too dramatic.
- 6:26Elle Boone: Why are you so sensitive?
- 6:28Elle Boone: These are clues for anyone listening.
- 6:31Elle Boone: If you've been told those things in your family dynamic, chances are you are probably the scapegoat in the family.
- 6:38MaryAnn Walker: So when you're being told those things that, oh no, you're misremembering, you're being too sensitive, are the other family members that are participating in it, is this something that they're consciously doing is trying to blame and shame, or how does that show up?
- 6:52Elle Boone: Yeah, that's a great question.
- 6:54Elle Boone: I think it's yes and no.
- 6:55Elle Boone: I think that when it starts, when this dysfunction starts early on, when the kids are really young, I think as a safety and coping mechanism, the siblings will side with the parent because it's safer.
- 7:11Elle Boone: If you side with the scapegoat, you could be scapegoated too.
- 7:15Elle Boone: And nobody wants to be scapegoated.
- 7:18Elle Boone: So I think it's a little bit of both.
- 7:19Elle Boone: And a lot of us are in this denial state where we just don't see things the way they really are.
- 7:26Elle Boone: So we come up with coping mechanisms and catchphrases that minimize the situation and deflect so that we don't have to really dig in and do the work and confront the pain.
- 7:39MaryAnn Walker: Yeah.
- 7:40MaryAnn Walker: And that's fascinating'cause as you describe it that way, it has me thinking that yes, I can see how this could be, you know, with a narcissistic parent, but also it sounds like a significant amount of emotional immaturity.
- 7:51MaryAnn Walker: And as you talk about how it's usually the highly sensitive and the empathic people that are scapegoated, I almost wonder if it's because they're more aware of emotions and aware of everybody else's emotions and maybe those that are less emotionally mature.
- 8:05MaryAnn Walker: It's, it's always easier to blame somebody else than to take accountability, isn't it?
- 8:09Elle Boone: Yes.
- 8:10Elle Boone: Yeah.
- 8:11Elle Boone: Always.
- 8:11Elle Boone: Yes, always.
- 8:13Elle Boone: Um, and, and I wanna say too that the, the scapegoat role can rotate in the family.
- 8:19Elle Boone: So.
- 8:20Elle Boone: The golden child could become the scapegoat and vice versa.
- 8:24Elle Boone: So I've been in, in both roles, uh, this
- 8:27MaryAnn Walker: confusing.
- 8:28MaryAnn Walker: Can you tell more about that?
- 8:30MaryAnn Walker: So, first, describe the golden Child and the scapegoat, and what are the differences in those roles.
- 8:35MaryAnn Walker: But then I really wanna hear how they can switch.
- 8:37MaryAnn Walker: That's
- 8:37Elle Boone: Yeah.
- 8:38Elle Boone: How they're reassigned.
- 8:39Elle Boone: Mm-hmm.
- 8:40Elle Boone: Yes.
- 8:41Elle Boone: So the golden child is the one who is more enmeshed with the narcissistic.
- 8:48Elle Boone: I'm gonna use the narcissistic dynamic in this explanation because while you can be scapegoated in, in a dysfunctional family that doesn't have the narcissistic element.
- 9:00MaryAnn Walker: Mm-hmm.
- 9:00Elle Boone: It's more common in my experience to have both the narcissism and the dysfunction.
- 9:07Elle Boone: So the, the narcissist also assigns the golden child, the one who's gonna be more compliant, who's more like them, who's not going to resist the programming as I call it.
- 9:20Elle Boone: And it's a very unhealthy dynamic and it can turn into such enmeshment that I've heard it called, emotional incest, which is big, a big phrase.
- 9:31Elle Boone: Um, yeah.
- 9:33Elle Boone: So, but let's say the scapegoat does something wonderful and gets more attention for any length of time.
- 9:44Elle Boone: They can be sort of reassigned as the golden child.
- 9:48Elle Boone: In that moment and then someone else has to become the scapegoat.
- 9:52Elle Boone: They have to have a scapegoat in the system so those two roles can switch.
- 9:57Elle Boone: In my experience, it was temporary.
- 10:00Elle Boone: So back to the scapegoat role, I went and because of my personality, I'm sensitive, but I'm also very vocal and a truth teller and I call it the way I see it, and that rocks the boat.
- 10:14Elle Boone: So hence the family mobbing.
- 10:16Elle Boone: Also, the silent treatment is a, another dynamic in this dysfunction, where if you do something.
- 10:26Elle Boone: That they think is wrong or not in compliance with the family dysfunctional rules, then you can be given the silent treatment and stonewalled, which furthers the isolation and rejection emotions in the scapegoat and can later show up, as, in my case, as complex PTSD.
- 10:48Elle Boone: It's unresolved unprocessed trauma.
- 10:51Elle Boone: Emotions and they show up.
- 10:54Elle Boone: We filter every experience through all of our past experiences.
- 10:59Elle Boone: So, yeah, so the way I figured this out, it was just before the pandemic, and I talk about this in my first episode that we'll launch in October.
- 11:10Elle Boone: I'm so excited.
- 11:11Elle Boone: Someone I was working with suggested that I look at my patterns and behaviors.
- 11:19Elle Boone: And I said, what, why, what's wrong with my patterns?
- 11:24Elle Boone: And he said, well, I hear your stories and I feel like the patterns that you've developed that you're not really aware of are coping mechanisms and you're filtering life through them.
- 11:37Elle Boone: So let's say you get an opportunity, in your career and in that opportunity and that experience, something triggers inside of you and you're operating with your behavior through that trigger and it ruins the opportunity because you're reading it wrong.
- 11:58Elle Boone: So, yeah, so IW that was when I was like, okay, and a few other things took place and I thought, he's right.
- 12:05Elle Boone: I need to look at my patterns.
- 12:07Elle Boone: And that's one of the tips that I wanna give at the end when we, when we talk about tips and resources, because if you can, and people pleasing too, um, is, is a big pattern of being scapegoated,
- 12:20MaryAnn Walker: I'm also really curious, like I found it so interesting as you talked about how you could switch back and forth and how you personally, that was your experience between being scapegoated and being the golden child and.
- 12:31MaryAnn Walker: Number one, how disorienting, but also the sporadic reinforcement of hoping to be the golden child and thinking, well, if I can just do the right thing, I can totally see how that would lead into those people pleasing tendencies, because you want to not be scapegoated anymore.
- 12:47MaryAnn Walker: You want to be the golden child.
- 12:49MaryAnn Walker: You want to be the special one, but knowing that you're gonna get knocked off of that role at any moment, that must be extremely upsetting to the nervous system.
- 12:58MaryAnn Walker: And, and speaking to that, I'm wondering if you can share with us some of the signs and symptoms, of being scapegoated.
- 13:04MaryAnn Walker: You said some of the signs and symptoms are, it's always your fault.
- 13:08MaryAnn Walker: Like you joked about that nine 11 was your fault.
- 13:10MaryAnn Walker: So even things not related to you at all, you kind of just knew it was always gonna be your fault.
- 13:14MaryAnn Walker: Silent treatment, stonewalling.
- 13:18MaryAnn Walker: What are some of the other symptoms and, and signs of scapegoating?
- 13:22Elle Boone: In, in terms of trying to figure out if you've been scapegoated in your family.
- 13:26MaryAnn Walker: Yeah.
- 13:26MaryAnn Walker: I guess I'm really curious, like, how did you, how did you put it together?
- 13:30MaryAnn Walker: Like what, what brought it into your awareness?
- 13:32MaryAnn Walker: It sounds like it's something that it's often hard to see that you're experiencing it, so how did you figure it out?
- 13:38Elle Boone: So it was, there were th two other events that took place in terms of identifying my own behaviors and some of that included, anxiety and people pleasing.
- 13:51MaryAnn Walker: Hmm.
- 13:52Elle Boone: Um, and when my, friend suggested that I start looking at my patterns.
- 13:55Elle Boone: I went to YouTube and I started looking up as many videos and books that I could find, on the subject of narcissism, family dysfunction, and all of those things.
- 14:07Elle Boone: And that's when I started to identify with, oh, silent treatment.
- 14:12Elle Boone: That's, oh, gaslighting.
- 14:14Elle Boone: There's a whole list of, nomenclature is, is a term I use, like it's the vocabulary for this.
- 14:21Elle Boone: So I started looking into all of those different elements in, that dysfunction, and first identified with the experiences that I had under that lens.
- 14:34Elle Boone: And then just looking for, information.
- 14:37Elle Boone: And when I finally got to the point where I, found what I was looking for, it was about two or three years in from that first event and I was on.
- 14:48Elle Boone: During the pandemic when we all had a lot of time, I was on a Facebook, group page about narcissism, I'm sure, and I was reading comments.
- 14:58Elle Boone: And in the comments someone suggested a book
- 15:01MaryAnn Walker: Mm-hmm.
- 15:02Elle Boone: that was written by Rebecca c Mandeville.
- 15:07Elle Boone: This is one of my, tips at the end for references and resources.
- 15:11Elle Boone: I wanna get the name of the book right, so I have to look it up.
- 15:14Elle Boone: Blamed, shamed, and Reject.
- 15:17Elle Boone: No, rejected, blamed and Shamed.
- 15:21Elle Boone: I sometimes get those backwards.
- 15:22Elle Boone: I'm so sorry.
- 15:24MaryAnn Walker: Oh, it's just fine.
- 15:25MaryAnn Walker: And I'll link that in the show notes for everybody too.
- 15:28Elle Boone: Rejected, shamed, and Blamed.
- 15:29Elle Boone: Yes.
- 15:30Elle Boone: So she wrote this book.
- 15:31Elle Boone: She is a licensed family therapist and a life coach, and she wrote this book that describes my entire experience
- 15:42MaryAnn Walker: Wow.
- 15:43Elle Boone: on family scapegoating.
- 15:44Elle Boone: She's coined the term family scapegoating abuse and has a peer review study out and another one in the making, which is important because that gives this.
- 15:55Elle Boone: Dynamic, more exposure and more people, with opportunities to learn about what they might have been through.
- 16:02Elle Boone: Because for me it was, I just walked around with a chip on my shoulder and this anxiety thinking, oh, this is just who I am.
- 16:09Elle Boone: No, it's, it was my programming and my conditioning and my upbringing.
- 16:13Elle Boone: So once I got the vocabulary down, I knew what to look for.
- 16:19Elle Boone: Not just in information, but also my behaviors and my patterns, so I could start to break those cycles within my own family.
- 16:27Elle Boone: Yeah, Did that answer your question?
- 16:30MaryAnn Walker: that does answer my question beautifully.
- 16:32MaryAnn Walker: And I'm also curious, I'm going back again to the switching back and forth between the scapegoat and the golden child.
- 16:39MaryAnn Walker: If, from your experience, was that often, like, I wonder if that was even weaponized, like comparison with why can't you be like them?
- 16:47MaryAnn Walker: Is that another symptom of being scapegoated, or what was your experience there?
- 16:51Elle Boone: It can be, yes.
- 16:52Elle Boone: It wasn't my experience.
- 16:54Elle Boone: Um, I will say though, that.
- 16:57Elle Boone: Especially in the narcissistic dynamic, the narcissist is very interested in and protective of image, the family
- 17:06MaryAnn Walker: Hmm.
- 17:08Elle Boone: And I thought about this earlier today in, anticipation of meeting with you, and I feel like in, my upbringing there was a a lot of lack financially.
- 17:19Elle Boone: And, and I, so maybe that's why I didn't experience it.
- 17:22Elle Boone: And I feel like families that are more affluent might have more to be concerned about in terms of image.
- 17:31Elle Boone: So, yeah, that's, that was my take earlier today.
- 17:34Elle Boone: When I thought about it, there we didn't have a lot to be concerned about in terms of public facing personas.
- 17:40Elle Boone: So, So, no.
- 17:42Elle Boone: Um, and the, and when the roles switched, it wasn't necessarily scapegoat to golden child and back.
- 17:50Elle Boone: Sometimes it's the scapegoat to the lost child.
- 17:56Elle Boone: Which is another element, gets if the scapegoat leaves and goes, no contact.
- 18:02Elle Boone: That's a term that's really popular right now.
- 18:05Elle Boone: Um, someone else has to take that role on.
- 18:10Elle Boone: So it can be reassigned in that way to another sibling.
- 18:14Elle Boone: And it's not typically the golden child in my experience.
- 18:17Elle Boone: It's the lost child or, someone else in the system that's, not already been the golden child.
- 18:23Elle Boone: Because that rearing from my experience, started at a very young age.
- 18:27Elle Boone: The golden child is conditioned and programmed, from a very, very young age, and I see it more with a mother and son
- 18:35MaryAnn Walker: Mm-hmm.
- 18:36Elle Boone: than a mother and daughter dynamic in terms of the golden child, so, mm-hmm.
- 18:43Elle Boone: Yeah.
- 18:43MaryAnn Walker: can you kind of give us a little bit more information about, who is the lost child?
- 18:47MaryAnn Walker: Like how would you describe the lost child?
- 18:50Elle Boone: Uh, it's in my experience, it's, it's someone who's been, sort of ignored in the sense that they weren't given opportunities that other kids are dynamic in that sy that system.
- 19:05Elle Boone: Maybe they didn't excel in school as much.
- 19:07Elle Boone: So they just kind of get washed into the background.
- 19:11Elle Boone: Um, and not, given what, what, definitely not what they needed for sure.
- 19:16Elle Boone: So they just kind of become quiet and voiceless.
- 19:21Elle Boone: My experience.
- 19:22Elle Boone: Yeah.
- 19:23MaryAnn Walker: Okay, and so tell me if I'm understanding this correctly.
- 19:26MaryAnn Walker: So then both the golden child and the scapegoat are getting a lot of attention, though different kinds of attention.
- 19:32MaryAnn Walker: And then the lost child is, the one that's kind of ignored and neglected.
- 19:37MaryAnn Walker: And then those roles kind of can rotate and shift around depending on.
- 19:40Elle Boone: Mm-hmm.
- 19:41MaryAnn Walker: What is gonna put forth the best image in the moment it sounds like.
- 19:45Elle Boone: And protect the denial system that is such, has such a stronghold on especially the, the dysfunctional families.
- 19:53Elle Boone: And what I mean by dysfunction is unresolved trauma of their own.
- 19:58Elle Boone: It can be alcoholism, drug addiction.
- 20:00Elle Boone: All of those things are under that dysfunctional umbrella.
- 20:03Elle Boone: When I say dysfunctional.
- 20:05Elle Boone: Yeah.
- 20:06Elle Boone: So there's, there's a lot of.
- 20:08Elle Boone: I think in every role, including the narcissist and maybe especially a lot of unprocessed trauma.
- 20:16MaryAnn Walker: Yeah, sounds like it.
- 20:18Elle Boone: There are a couple of other things that I have in my notes that in terms of people trying to identify whether they've been scapegoated, That I think are important.
- 20:29Elle Boone: If I can just take a quick glance here.
- 20:32Elle Boone: Okay.
- 20:32Elle Boone: So here, here are a few things.
- 20:34Elle Boone: That are really common, that a scapegoat, a family scapegoat can experience.
- 20:40Elle Boone: They're, like I said earlier, they're blamed for everything.
- 20:43Elle Boone: When anything goes wrong, it's their fault.
- 20:47Elle Boone: Ironically, your successes are minimized.
- 20:51Elle Boone: they're ignored or downplayed.
- 20:54Elle Boone: They don't wanna put you on a pedestal.
- 20:56Elle Boone: That role is taken in this movie.
- 21:00Elle Boone: Right.
- 21:01Elle Boone: And I'll say too that, you know, once you start to identify the theatrics, for lack of better term, in, in the behaviors from the dysfunctional family members to onto the scapegoat, you'll stop buying tickets to the show.
- 21:19Elle Boone: Once you see the performative and the cosmetics of it.
- 21:24Elle Boone: So being criticized is another, you know, sort of backhanded way of keeping, keeping you in your place, so to speak.
- 21:32Elle Boone: And the same rules don't apply to every family member.
- 21:36Elle Boone: So the golden child gets special treatment, the scapegoat gets the silent treatment.
- 21:42Elle Boone: Yeah.
- 21:44Elle Boone: you're kind of a dumping ground.
- 21:46MaryAnn Walker: Yeah.
- 21:46MaryAnn Walker: And'cause as you list off those things, so just to kind of recap those qualities that you shared, it has me thinking that we've been talking about this in the family dynamic, but really these symptoms you can also see in individual relationships, you know, the, the blame, the shame successes are minimized.
- 22:03MaryAnn Walker: Um, you're maybe ignored.
- 22:05MaryAnn Walker: You're downplayed backhanded criticism.
- 22:08MaryAnn Walker: They're holding other people to a different standard than they're holding you to, that they don't wanna put you back on.
- 22:13MaryAnn Walker: They don't wanna put you on a pedestal'cause you don't belong there.
- 22:15MaryAnn Walker: So they have to knock you down.
- 22:17MaryAnn Walker: And, and I love how you said that once you identify the theatrics, then you'll stop buying tickets to the show.
- 22:22MaryAnn Walker: And I think that's where like the people pleasing comes in, is we keep thinking if I can be good enough, then they'll treat me well.
- 22:28Elle Boone: it's a good one.
- 22:29Elle Boone: It's, we wanna be perceived as a good one.
- 22:32Elle Boone: Yeah.
- 22:33Elle Boone: And, and it's about control really, and not in an evil control freak kind of way, but you are manipulating.
- 22:42Elle Boone: The situation to protect yourself.
- 22:44Elle Boone: It's, it's a coping and protective mechanism that, can be learned, can be inherited.
- 22:51Elle Boone: And, you know, we wanna feel safe.
- 22:54Elle Boone: So if the person we're having this relationship with makes us feel unsafe, we have to create circumstances, imaginary or otherwise that allow us to feel safe so we can continue to function really.
- 23:08Elle Boone: And protect your nervous system as well.
- 23:10Elle Boone: 'cause sometimes it's, it's hard to confront that someone who you have loved for so long and is supposed to give that back to you, It is not working in your best interest.
- 23:22Elle Boone: They're manipulating you.
- 23:24Elle Boone: And it makes us shrink.
- 23:25Elle Boone: And then so we think, oh, how would do, how do we get out of the smallness?
- 23:30Elle Boone: Well, I'll just buy more things for them.
- 23:32Elle Boone: I'll do more things for them.
- 23:34Elle Boone: And.
- 23:35Elle Boone: It's just a spiral.
- 23:37Elle Boone: And so once you start to recognize the patterns, this is one of the things that I wanna suggest.
- 23:42MaryAnn Walker: Mm-hmm.
- 23:43Elle Boone: Look at your patterns.
- 23:44Elle Boone: Look at how many times you apologize For, for things that you know aren't your fault or, watch the behavior of other people.
- 23:56Elle Boone: When you go to lunch with friends or when you're at work, just notice.
- 24:01Elle Boone: How people behave.
- 24:02Elle Boone: You don't have to tell them you're surveying them, but you know, just look at how many times they apologize or, do they have patterns in them that you're recognizing in yourself as a way to get some sort of like reverse engineer mirroring.
- 24:17Elle Boone: Because I think watching other people's behaviors can be really informative for, for our own,
- 24:24MaryAnn Walker: tell me more about that.
- 24:25MaryAnn Walker: How has observing other people helped you?
- 24:27MaryAnn Walker: Because that's interesting'cause there is that self-reflective piece.
- 24:30MaryAnn Walker: But when you are observing other people, what else are you observing besides how often they're apologizing compared to you?
- 24:36MaryAnn Walker: Like, what are the other things that, kind of struck you as, oh, that's different.
- 24:41Elle Boone: Yeah.
- 24:41Elle Boone: So some, things that may not relate to family scapegoating specifically, but just, um, thinking about some of my friends who do over apologize.
- 24:50Elle Boone: There's also overgiving.
- 24:51Elle Boone: That's the behavior that I've noticed, in others and myself.
- 24:56Elle Boone: That's part of the people pleasing dynamic.
- 24:59Elle Boone: If I give enough, I'll be considered the good one and I won't be attacked today.
- 25:04Elle Boone: And I can, get through work at least.
- 25:07Elle Boone: Some of the other behaviors that I have noticed in people is the denial behavior.
- 25:13Elle Boone: I've had conversations with friends where, you know, they're in bad relationships and I'll gently say, oh,, I think, you know, have you looked at this?
- 25:22Elle Boone: No, no, no, no, no.
- 25:23Elle Boone: It's, they minimize the issues.
- 25:26Elle Boone: That's, that's another behavior pattern that I've noticed, and it's not that I think it's more that they're, again, they're protecting their own nervous system because if we pull the curtain all the way back at once, it's too much.
- 25:42Elle Boone: That's what I did when I first started to figure this out, MaryAnn, I thought I could YouTube my way out of this problem in six months.
- 25:52Elle Boone: No.
- 25:53Elle Boone: It's deeper than that.
- 25:54Elle Boone: There's so many layers.
- 25:55Elle Boone: Yeah, tho those are just a few of the behaviors and it's, it's interesting to watch even films, you know, ask yourself how are these characters behaving in this film?
- 26:07Elle Boone: Am I like them?
- 26:08Elle Boone: Do, do I wanna be more like them?
- 26:10Elle Boone: Do I wanna be le have less of their, those behaviors.
- 26:13Elle Boone: Films are a really good way to learn about behaviors, especially.
- 26:17Elle Boone: Specific films that are geared toward trauma.
- 26:21Elle Boone: There's actually a film, that I wanna recommend at the end.
- 26:24Elle Boone: I'm gonna save it for the end.
- 26:26Elle Boone: Don't lemme forget.
- 26:27MaryAnn Walker: Okay.
- 26:28Elle Boone: Yeah.
- 26:30MaryAnn Walker: Yeah.
- 26:30MaryAnn Walker: Well, and that's so interesting because I, I like say how you said to watch films because I do know specifically people in narcissistic relationships, they're, they have a very easy time identifying who's the narcissist.
- 26:42Elle Boone: Right.
- 26:43MaryAnn Walker: But to zoom out a little and see if you can identify, okay, who's the golden child, who's the scapegoat, who's the lost child?
- 26:50MaryAnn Walker: To see if you can identify those other roles.
- 26:53MaryAnn Walker: Once you've identified that, okay, this is a familiar thing, instead of it, it's our tendency to just focus on the other person.
- 26:58MaryAnn Walker: Right?
- 26:59MaryAnn Walker: But I like he said, okay, well look for how it's showing up in other roles so that you can identify those parts of self, I think could be very helpful.
- 27:07Elle Boone: And I think it's easier too than sitting down and dissecting your own personality.
- 27:12Elle Boone: So for me, when, when I started to figure out the people pleasing dynamic in myself, going through all these videos and learning the, the vocabulary, the nomenclature, I thought, oh yes, I do that and, and that.
- 27:26Elle Boone: And I kept coming back to people pleasing.
- 27:28Elle Boone: And it took me a couple of years.
- 27:31Elle Boone: To really dismantle that part of my personality because it had become such a protective energy, in my family dynamic and, and being an empath and a highly sensitive person.
- 27:45Elle Boone: I feel tomorrow's feelings, you know, if we feel everything, but it's, it's a tough role and, The people pleasing for me was the biggest pattern that I really started to dismantle and rebuild, and so I had to ask myself often, am I really that nice?
- 28:05MaryAnn Walker: Hmm.
- 28:06Elle Boone: I really that kind?
- 28:08Elle Boone: Am I really that generous?
- 28:10Elle Boone: And I have always, and I still, because I am a generous person, I finally figured it out.
- 28:15Elle Boone: Yes, I am kind.
- 28:16Elle Boone: I'm not evil.
- 28:17Elle Boone: I am not what they said I was.
- 28:19Elle Boone: So there's this identity crisis, I think that happens in the scapegoat role.
- 28:25Elle Boone: I'm actually working on a course, about rebuilding or, or healing the identity wound and rebuilding a new identity.
- 28:32Elle Boone: Without the dysfunction because we don't know who we are outside of the dysfunction until we start to rebuild that.
- 28:39Elle Boone: So people pleasing for me was the first pattern to go, and I still to this day wanna help people.
- 28:45Elle Boone: If I see someone stranded on the side of the road, my impulse says, pull over.
- 28:52Elle Boone: And then my safety voice says, what are you thinking?
- 28:57Elle Boone: And then I have to remember, oh, that might be a people pleasing energy.
- 29:03Elle Boone: that is coming up from my past, but now I can stop it and not over give.
- 29:09Elle Boone: Which is a huge part of my people pleasing problem.
- 29:13Elle Boone: And then I let you know I give so much and then I don't get anything back, and then I'm upset.
- 29:17Elle Boone: I'm like, but you're supposed to reciprocate.
- 29:21Elle Boone: I'm supposed to not give so much.
- 29:23Elle Boone: That's really the dynamic I.
- 29:26Elle Boone: You don't, don't give as much.
- 29:28Elle Boone: Um, and it's hard for someone who's been a people pleaser for a long time to suddenly stop pleasing.
- 29:34MaryAnn Walker: For sure.
- 29:35MaryAnn Walker: And to untangle that of trying to think through.
- 29:37MaryAnn Walker: 'cause it's when love has been conditional for so long.
- 29:41Elle Boone: Mm-hmm.
- 29:41MaryAnn Walker: It's easy to think, okay, well now that I've broken free, now that I see it, now I can have this.
- 29:47MaryAnn Walker: And then still trying to figure out, okay, well what does it look like to create balance?
- 29:51MaryAnn Walker: 'cause like you said, sometimes we are overgiving thinking that then they'll see our value and come to us, but then we end up burned out and resentful and like, okay, well maybe I need to pull back a little so they can have the opportunity.
- 30:03MaryAnn Walker: And maybe they will and maybe they won't and but it is interesting.
- 30:07MaryAnn Walker: And then especially like you said, when you're going through that identity crisis.
- 30:11MaryAnn Walker: That just adds another layer where it's like, well, I don't quite know who I am.
- 30:14MaryAnn Walker: Am I a nice person?
- 30:16MaryAnn Walker: I think that that's gonna be really impactful for a lot of people.
- 30:18MaryAnn Walker: 'cause I know a lot of the people pleasers I've worked with, they think, well, if I'm not a people pleaser, I'm gonna be mean.
- 30:25MaryAnn Walker: It's like, no, you're not a mean person.
- 30:28MaryAnn Walker: You, you're just not going to over accommodate anymore.
- 30:30MaryAnn Walker: You're going to make sure that your own cup is filled and you're not mean, and you're not evil.
- 30:35MaryAnn Walker: You're not the things that they've told you that you are, but allowing that identity to shed so that you can live more authentically.
- 30:43Elle Boone: And you said something really beautiful in a podcast that I watched this week on the Fear of abandonment.
- 30:51MaryAnn Walker: Hmm
- 30:51Elle Boone: It's, that's true for both scapegoats and others who have people pleasing tendencies but weren't scapegoated.
- 31:01Elle Boone: It, it can be, it can be on, on both sides.
- 31:04Elle Boone: The fear of rejection, abandonment, loss, that's where that all comes from.
- 31:10Elle Boone: And yeah, it does.
- 31:12MaryAnn Walker: to recap that, that yeah, that, that having that fear of abandonment leads to that self abandonment, which I think is what you were just describing, is I don't know who I am anymore, because I've abandoned myself in an effort to please, and
- 31:26Elle Boone: And survive.
- 31:27MaryAnn Walker: losing people that Yeah.
- 31:28MaryAnn Walker: That we abandoned ourself.
- 31:29Elle Boone: Yeah, that is so well said.
- 31:32Elle Boone: We really do.
- 31:33Elle Boone: And, and then we're lost and confused and depressed and, and not functioning at our full capacity.
- 31:40Elle Boone: So it does take some, like you said earlier, some untangling and the, biggest thing I want everyone listening to take away from this, especially if you're just figuring out uhoh, she said something that makes me possibly be the scapegoat.
- 31:59Elle Boone: Just take your healing really slowly and be intentional about your healing.
- 32:06Elle Boone: Don't do what I did during the pandemic and over consume to the point of panic attacks and mass confusion like.
- 32:15Elle Boone: And find community and support that, is rooted in, scapegoating or people pleasing because they can, they can be different.
- 32:22Elle Boone: And I do wanna talk about the difference, a little bit of people pleasing versus codependency.
- 32:30Elle Boone: Is this something that you've explored on your show?
- 32:33MaryAnn Walker: I don't know if I've said it explicitly, so yeah, share more about that.
- 32:37Elle Boone: Okay, let me, find my notes because.
- 32:40Elle Boone: Scapegoating, and people pleasing, they go together.
- 32:43Elle Boone: But I don't, think that in everyone who's a people pleaser has been scapegoated.
- 32:48Elle Boone: People pleasing.
- 32:49Elle Boone: Like we said, it comes out of the fear of abandonment and wanting to protect and not lose and keep the status quo and keep the peace.
- 32:58Elle Boone: With codependency, it's more of a, survival technique.
- 33:05Elle Boone: Where I've got to find this note because I wrote this out and it was so perfect.
- 33:10Elle Boone: The codependent person is enmeshed with the narcissist, to the point where, especially with the golden child, there is a lack of individuality.
- 33:22Elle Boone: They're so enmeshed they're, kind of one person And so, it's sort of like codependency is like people pleasing on steroids.
- 33:31MaryAnn Walker: Mm-hmm.
- 33:32Elle Boone: You're, super enmeshed.
- 33:34Elle Boone: It's a survival mechanism rather than seeking approval.
- 33:39Elle Boone: That's one of the big differences, if that makes sense.
- 33:42Elle Boone: And I know you talk about people pleasing a lot on your show.
- 33:46Elle Boone: That's the main focus, right?
- 33:48MaryAnn Walker: yeah.
- 33:48Elle Boone: And have you come across any scapegoat people in your practice so far?
- 33:55Elle Boone: Is this newer to your ears?
- 33:57MaryAnn Walker: Well, it's interesting because I was getting requests on YouTube to talk about this, and that was right when I met you and, so it has been interesting to see how it's showing up, but to be able to put words on the experience, you know, as you've talked about it, I can see more.
- 34:12MaryAnn Walker: Okay.
- 34:12MaryAnn Walker: I can see that.
- 34:13MaryAnn Walker: Many of my clients are going to fit into this role.
- 34:16MaryAnn Walker: But it's, very interesting to actually put a name on it, I think can help to bring so much clarity and it helps you to feel not as alone when you've talked about the isolation that can come with it.
- 34:26MaryAnn Walker: Just putting a word on it can help you to feel not so alone and not so crazy that, well, what, what's wrong with me?
- 34:32MaryAnn Walker: Something must be wrong with me because they've always been telling you that something's wrong with you.
- 34:36MaryAnn Walker: Right?
- 34:37MaryAnn Walker: So it's easy to believe that, but to give it a name and see, oh, it's not me really.
- 34:42MaryAnn Walker: I think it's just so valuable.
- 34:44Elle Boone: Yeah.
- 34:45Elle Boone: Yeah.
- 34:46MaryAnn Walker: So I think that we've te Oh, go ahead.
- 34:48Elle Boone: no, no, no, no.
- 34:49Elle Boone: You're good.
- 34:49Elle Boone: You're fine.
- 34:50Elle Boone: Go ahead.
- 34:50MaryAnn Walker: Okay.
- 34:51MaryAnn Walker: So I was gonna say, I think that we've teased them enough and I would love to get a list of your resources and what supports now that they're probably identifying that, oh, that might be me.
- 35:01MaryAnn Walker: Tell us more about what supports you have found helpful.
- 35:04Elle Boone: So, as I mentioned earlier, the book by Rebecca Rejected, shamed, and Blamed.
- 35:10Elle Boone: There's an audible version as well and a hard copy Amazon, wherever you get your books.
- 35:16Elle Boone: I highly recommend that.
- 35:18Elle Boone: She's also got a pretty strong presence on, Substack, if you're familiar with that.
- 35:25Elle Boone: And, that book alone has, done more for me than.
- 35:30Elle Boone: Than any other research that I've done, Including all of the YouTube videos that I've watched., There aren't a lot specifically on the scapegoat role.
- 35:39Elle Boone: And the same for podcasts.
- 35:41Elle Boone: There just aren't many out there unfortunately.
- 35:44Elle Boone: The film I wanna suggest is a documentary by Gabor Mate.
- 35:50Elle Boone: I know I mentioned him the first time we met.
- 35:53Elle Boone: Lemme get the titles.
- 35:54Elle Boone: So I don't mess it up.
- 35:56Elle Boone: He's also, what I consider, this is my own term, sort of the godfather of trauma.
- 36:01Elle Boone: And he has a number of books out.
- 36:04Elle Boone: And this movie I watched sometime during the pandemic, it's called The Wisdom of Trauma,
- 36:11MaryAnn Walker: The wisdom of trauma.
- 36:13MaryAnn Walker: Fascinating.
- 36:14Elle Boone: It is.
- 36:15Elle Boone: Yeah, it was for me, it was sort of at the peak of, increasing my compassion for those who had scapegoated me in my family, which is a tough one, and we can call it forgiveness or compassion, radical acceptance.
- 36:33Elle Boone: But that comes later.
- 36:36Elle Boone: Like first step, identify your patterns, your behaviors,.
- 36:43Elle Boone: Make sure that you know, you, you were the family scapegoat by that checklist that we went through and do your own research.
- 36:50Elle Boone: Um, there's another film.
- 36:52Elle Boone: And it's not necessarily on scapegoating, it was done by a group of people at the uk and if I can't find it real quick, I will send it to you so you can include it in the show notes.
- 37:07Elle Boone: Um, it was more about narcissism and, it's on YouTube.
- 37:13Elle Boone: That's what it is.
- 37:14Elle Boone: I think it was free.
- 37:15Elle Boone: The Gabor Mate film was a donation based, watch.
- 37:19Elle Boone: Um, so yeah, I'm not finding it, but I will, I will find it and I will send it to you.
- 37:25Elle Boone: Um, for those who are interested in learning about the relationship, it's not a family dynamic.
- 37:30Elle Boone: It was about two people dating and, it was really eyeopening because like I said, scapegoating can come with narcissism or without it.
- 37:41Elle Boone: So it's important to understand both and take your healing slowly.
- 37:46Elle Boone: I have a couple of other tips that I think would help listeners, look at your patterns.
- 37:53Elle Boone: Take your healing slowly, and start to think about your identity because this really is an identity crisis in the middle of it, there's a lot of chaos and confusion that goes with this role.
- 38:09Elle Boone: But once you start to figure out your own patterns, then you can start to rebuild your future based on healthier patterns.
- 38:19Elle Boone: That create a life that is more enjoyable, That invites less, narcissism and scapegoating'cause that can happen in any dynamic in any group.
- 38:30Elle Boone: And we talked about this earlier, people pleasers tend to be a little bit more vulnerable and open and generous.
- 38:35Elle Boone: So we can be targets for that kind of energy.
- 38:39Elle Boone: Yeah.
- 38:39Elle Boone: Mm-hmm.
- 38:40MaryAnn Walker: And I can see how just taking that time to even think about your own identity and how do I see myself, could be so helpful when you're being told that you're something else.
- 38:49MaryAnn Walker: And of course that's going to create an identity crisis because it's kind of gaslighting, right?
- 38:53MaryAnn Walker: Saying, no, you are this horrible being.
- 38:56MaryAnn Walker: It's like, wait, what?
- 38:56MaryAnn Walker: Who am I?
- 38:57MaryAnn Walker: What did I say that?
- 38:58MaryAnn Walker: Did I do that?
- 38:59MaryAnn Walker: So I love those tips.
- 39:00MaryAnn Walker: So you said first identify your patterns and behaviors.
- 39:03MaryAnn Walker: Second, take your healing slowly, and third, start to think about your personal identity to help to untangle all of that.
- 39:10Elle Boone: Yeah, and a quote, I, I tried to find where this came from.
- 39:14Elle Boone: I've seen it a number of times, but it's has stuck and I can't find the original author, but it stuck with me for years, and that is to be careful of what you tolerate because you are teaching people how to treat you so good.
- 39:29Elle Boone: Boundaries, right.
- 39:30Elle Boone: Yeah.
- 39:31Elle Boone: but, and noticing your own patterns, will help you identify, oh, this person's giving me breadcrumbs.
- 39:37MaryAnn Walker: Mm-hmm.
- 39:38Elle Boone: Hmm.
- 39:38Elle Boone: What am I doing to allow that?
- 39:40Elle Boone: I want the whole loaf.
- 39:42Elle Boone: I don't want just the crumbs.
- 39:43Elle Boone: I deserve more.
- 39:45Elle Boone: But first is the awakening.
- 39:46Elle Boone: You have to figure out, what your behavior patterns are.
- 39:50Elle Boone: And just be really easy on yourself.
- 39:52Elle Boone: Just take your time, take it as slow as you can.
- 39:56Elle Boone: Be intentional with your healing because don't do what I did over consume and like the doom scrolling, and then get stuck on a new influencer on TikTok or whatever that's giving you new information about the narcissism in your family.
- 40:11Elle Boone: Like maybe schedule your, intake, the consumption of the information so that you're rested and fed and feeling good and you're of sound mind when you're learning about it, so that you don't get really reactive and over emotional and go into a spiral like I did.
- 40:29Elle Boone: Yeah.
- 40:30MaryAnn Walker: Such good advice.
- 40:31MaryAnn Walker: Yeah.
- 40:31MaryAnn Walker: So what words of encouragement do you have for those that are at the beginning of this journey?
- 40:37Elle Boone: You know, I would say you, you were never the problem.
- 40:41Elle Boone: You are, it's not your fault.
- 40:43Elle Boone: You have hidden talents and, and, parts of you that you've yet to discover that are buried under this identity that you have been given, that's been forced upon you, and that you've adopted out of necessity, out of survival.
- 40:58Elle Boone: And just recognize that some, some of that's in the past now, hopefully most of it, and that there is a way out and that you can heal from this.
- 41:06Elle Boone: But be careful, with your, over consumption and find community that understand this dynamic that can support you and listen to your story so you can feel seen and heard and validated and be a contributing member of society rather than reclusive in your home, In the pantry, if you will.
- 41:28MaryAnn Walker: Yeah.
- 41:28Elle Boone: Yeah.
- 41:30MaryAnn Walker: Well, that is beautiful.
- 41:31MaryAnn Walker: Elle, thank you so much for being here.
- 41:33MaryAnn Walker: This has been
- 41:33Elle Boone: you.
- 41:33MaryAnn Walker: an amazing conversation.
- 41:36MaryAnn Walker: And tell everybody again, where can they find you?
- 41:39MaryAnn Walker: Tell'em the name of your podcast.
- 41:40MaryAnn Walker: I'm gonna make sure that this drops about the same time so they can jump over and follow you and subscribe.
- 41:45MaryAnn Walker: 'cause like you said, there's so few resources for those that have been scapegoated, and I think that your channel is going to be an extremely valuable resource.
- 41:53MaryAnn Walker: So tell us more about how they can find you.
- 41:56Elle Boone: Thank you.
- 41:56Elle Boone: Yes.
- 41:56Elle Boone: I'm also on Substack.
- 41:58Elle Boone: I don't, engage quite as much as I will after the launch.
- 42:01Elle Boone: And both that and the podcast can be found.
- 42:04Elle Boone: Uh, there is a trailer out right now, I will say not on Apple because strategically I wanna get as many, uh, reviews to get us into a higher ranking so we have more visibility and can reach more people.
- 42:16Elle Boone: But once that launches, it will go straight to Apple and it's called the Family Scapegoat Chronicles.
- 42:22Elle Boone: And if, if anyone listening is unfortunately the scapegoat in your family and you wanna come on the show, that's gonna be a huge part of the format where we interview either anonymously, or like this on, on camera where people can come and share their story in a safe space and find community.
- 42:41MaryAnn Walker: That's beautiful because I'm sure that finding your voice and giving voice to the ways that you've been wronged can just be so healing for people.
- 42:48MaryAnn Walker: And not only that, but hearing those stories and knowing you're not alone, I, think that's just gonna be beautiful.
- 42:53Elle Boone: Yeah.
- 42:53Elle Boone: And critical, I think for healing as well.
- 42:55Elle Boone: And hopefully I can be a, a part of that for many people, because already I have like 12 or 13 different countries that have listened to the trailer.
- 43:05Elle Boone: So it's a global issue.
- 43:07Elle Boone: It's not, you know, just one or two families.
- 43:09Elle Boone: It's a thing.
- 43:10Elle Boone: So I'm so grateful that you invited me here today because we're just getting started and you're kicking it off, so thank you.
- 43:19Elle Boone: Yeah.
- 43:19MaryAnn Walker: thank you so much and yeah, thank you for all of the healing that you're bringing into the world.
- 43:23MaryAnn Walker: It's beautiful to witness.
- 43:24Elle Boone: Thank you.
- 43:24Elle Boone: Likewise.
- 43:25Elle Boone: I love your show.
- 43:26Elle Boone: I love your show.
- 43:27Elle Boone: I can't wait to dig in more.
- 43:29Elle Boone: So,
- 43:29MaryAnn Walker: Oh good.
- 43:30MaryAnn Walker: Well, thank you so much.
- 43:31MaryAnn Walker: I'm glad that we were able to connect.
- 43:32Elle Boone: yes.
- 43:33Elle Boone: And maybe you can come on our show and share your story and, and expertise.
- 43:38Elle Boone: I think that would be amazing.
- 43:40Elle Boone: Yeah.
- 43:41MaryAnn Walker: I'd love to.
- 43:42MaryAnn Walker: All right.
- 43:42MaryAnn Walker: Well, thank you so much everybody for being here.
- 43:44MaryAnn Walker: And as a reminder, you can find all of the resources that Elle talked about here on the show.
- 43:48MaryAnn Walker: I will link all of them in the show notes so that you can find support, community, and healing.
- 43:53MaryAnn Walker: So thank you so much and I'll see you next week.
- 43:56Elle Boone: Thank you.
- 43:56Elle Boone: Take care.
- 43:57Elle Boone: Bye everyone.