Latest / Jewish History Uncensored / 29 | Rabbinic Letters
Transcript
- 0:06Speaker 1: Welcome to Jewish History Uncensored with Mark Shapiro. This is
- 0:09Speaker 1: season sixteenth, episode twenty nine.
- 0:30Speaker 2: I just I feel it's appropriate to mention we lost
- 0:34Speaker 2: another giant this week. That's you see his picture there
- 0:38Speaker 2: of Goadalia Dove Schwartz. I mentioned also because, as I said,
- 0:43Speaker 2: one of his grandsons has been a longtime listener. Just
- 0:49Speaker 2: a couple of things I'll say about him. You can
- 0:53Speaker 2: know well, first of all, hold on me, stop sharing.
- 0:57Speaker 2: You can read about him on very good article reb Intense.
- 1:03Speaker 2: I thing it is in intense Intense tank Ritensky whatever
- 1:06Speaker 2: I don't know from Chicago on the the Larehouse. Although
- 1:09Speaker 2: I do have to point out that he says, hold
- 1:13Speaker 2: on a second, I'll get it. He says in the
- 1:16Speaker 2: article I'll read you the exact words here that Rabbi
- 1:21Speaker 2: Kadali Dov Schortz is the first second generation American Tomkchum
- 1:25Speaker 2: to publish goduche Tora. That's that's clearly not correct. Rabbi
- 1:31Speaker 2: Gadali Dov Schwartz did publish a safe Fair in nineteen
- 1:34Speaker 2: fifty nine, but we had plenty of American tell me
- 1:38Speaker 2: I'm in publishing red Tor beforehand. By Gifter, for instance,
- 1:42Speaker 2: and I think it's ninety forty four in the tapio
- 1:46Speaker 2: he's publishing, and we have many others if you look
- 1:48Speaker 2: in Paradise, so then you might want to say, well,
- 1:51Speaker 2: maybe he's the first to publish a safe their first
- 1:55Speaker 2: that is American born. I don't know why this language
- 1:58Speaker 2: at a use second generation American. Now he means American born.
- 2:03Speaker 2: That's not true at all either. I'm going to show
- 2:05Speaker 2: you now what I believe is the first Safer ever
- 2:09Speaker 2: published by an American born Towers scholar. And I know
- 2:15Speaker 2: we have many scholars of all sorts of areas. Listen
- 2:18Speaker 2: to us. Correct me if I'm wrong, but I believe,
- 2:22Speaker 2: I believe this is it. It's called Osarasota. It's a
- 2:27Speaker 2: commentary on the laws of Helasota and the Rama's Mission
- 2:29Speaker 2: of Torah, written by none other than ELIZARDSP. Revel. That's
- 2:33Speaker 2: Bernard Revel's son. And this was published in nineteen forty one.
- 2:37Speaker 2: I believe this is the first Safer ever published. He
- 2:40Speaker 2: published all this for him as well, but this was
- 2:42Speaker 2: his first. This is after his father passed away. His
- 2:45Speaker 2: father died young el Revel also he died. I think
- 2:50Speaker 2: in his fifties. Also never married.
- 2:52Speaker 3: Dove.
- 2:52Speaker 2: Bernard Revel has no descendants, and I believe so the
- 2:57Speaker 2: bibliographers with us can correct me if I'm wrong. This
- 2:59Speaker 2: is the first stay forever published by an Americans in
- 3:05Speaker 2: terms of rabbi the value go Schwartz's work. You can see. Actually,
- 3:13Speaker 2: we have so many things I want to show you.
- 3:14Speaker 2: I'm going to delete this for now. You can see
- 3:19Speaker 2: this this work, it's called the Charredula. It's a collection
- 3:23Speaker 2: first of all of hollfic things the answers he gave.
- 3:28Speaker 2: But even more than that, and which is most interesting
- 3:31Speaker 2: is the first half of it. It's a historical overview
- 3:34Speaker 2: of American Orthodoxy. Anyone who wants well, we have histories
- 3:38Speaker 2: of American Orthodoxy. We have one in particular, this one
- 3:40Speaker 2: of Jeffrey Gurak. What this is more of a social history.
- 3:45Speaker 2: If you want to know the harmonic literature, literature from
- 3:49Speaker 2: the nineteenth century before let's say nineteen World War two,
- 3:53Speaker 2: great rabbis were here in far funk places from Bangor,
- 3:57Speaker 2: Maine to Mapuli or Vermont to Omaha, Nebraska. You had
- 4:02Speaker 2: real first quaess. Tell me to who, for financial reasons
- 4:05Speaker 2: were first to come to America. And they were all
- 4:08Speaker 2: over the United States, and a published story. And if
- 4:12Speaker 2: you want to do a history of the way, I
- 4:15Speaker 2: would do it of you know, the history of Orthodoxy.
- 4:19Speaker 2: Looking at the rabbinic urture halaha, Rabbi Schwartz's first hundred well,
- 4:25Speaker 2: actually it goes up to uh two hundred pages, two
- 4:29Speaker 2: thirty one. Well, they skid the first part of this
- 4:32Speaker 2: dealing a biographical skitch, so about one hundred and eighty
- 4:34Speaker 2: pages dealing with castrous and mc close and conversion. Very
- 4:39Speaker 2: very nice. His grandson. Well, first, let me show you
- 4:47Speaker 2: a picture that they have in this book, because we've
- 4:49Speaker 2: been we've mentioned this idea a lot already here. It
- 4:52Speaker 2: is so when he received an honorary degree from yu
- 4:55Speaker 2: Is there he is. He's in his his gown, cappin gown.
- 4:59Speaker 2: I showed you last week from the MTJ boys, a
- 5:01Speaker 2: few of them. I didn't mention instantly last week that
- 5:06Speaker 2: MTJ that that big book I have gives oglist of
- 5:10Speaker 2: all the rabbis serving at the well. This was when
- 5:13Speaker 2: it came out about ten years ago. As rabbis in
- 5:16Speaker 2: American communities in Israel, she was et cetera, very impressive.
- 5:20Speaker 2: I had no idea that there were so many musmaching
- 5:25Speaker 2: distinguished musmaching from mt J. One more thing I just
- 5:28Speaker 2: want to show you so I thank Rabbi Godalia Dove,
- 5:32Speaker 2: Schwartz's grandson who gave this to me and I wrote
- 5:35Speaker 2: about this last year. The rove wrote a letter which
- 5:45Speaker 2: about the It appeared in the book About in Nattie
- 5:51Speaker 2: Helscott's book Community, Covenant and Commitment, and before that it
- 5:57Speaker 2: appeared in let me show you that I don't know
- 5:59Speaker 2: the title page here The Sanctity of the Synagogue. However,
- 6:04Speaker 2: the original letter of the Rove was found in the
- 6:08Speaker 2: archives of Rabbi Gadaliudolf Schwartz as in his house. You
- 6:12Speaker 2: can see it on top here confidential members or a
- 6:14Speaker 2: bit of a council only. And it actually and this
- 6:17Speaker 2: might be the only copy that survives from the fifties
- 6:22Speaker 2: and Rabbi Schwartz's grandson sent it to me. It has
- 6:24Speaker 2: a very interesting point in it which anyone who wants
- 6:27Speaker 2: to write about the Rove needs to know about, because
- 6:31Speaker 2: he has a couple of paragraphs here. You can go
- 6:32Speaker 2: to the Sparing blog in November of twenty eighteen and
- 6:36Speaker 2: you can I included those paragraphs which he speaks about
- 6:40Speaker 2: how sometimes you can't just you can't give an answer
- 6:45Speaker 2: that people want. He says, Taku is a very prominent
- 6:48Speaker 2: and characteristic, featured persha welpa. We members of the local
- 6:51Speaker 2: Commission are not partners in a contracting firm whose task
- 6:54Speaker 2: it is to provide every member of the Brineral Council
- 6:57Speaker 2: of America with a queer cut answer to his problems.
- 7:00Speaker 2: Why often the solution will lose us. We are beset
- 7:02Speaker 2: by grave doubts. We face many alternatives, not knowing which
- 7:07Speaker 2: to choose, which to choose, since each is supported by
- 7:10Speaker 2: sound logical reasoning. We cannot be guided in our decisions
- 7:14Speaker 2: by emotional factors or pragmatic arbitrariness, et cetera, et cetera.
- 7:18Speaker 2: And then he says that the decision sometimes seem to
- 7:21Speaker 2: inconvenience some of our members. And uh so this is
- 7:24Speaker 2: a very important passage by devalued of Shorts, by the way,
- 7:29Speaker 2: served as a Rabbi of the as the basin of
- 7:34Speaker 2: the r Senate. Okay, let us move on a couple
- 7:38Speaker 2: more things. We're gonna get to next week. We'll get
- 7:40Speaker 2: to the issue I want to deal with. Uh oh, yeah,
- 7:49Speaker 2: saying God's name that Mosha asked at the end of
- 7:51Speaker 2: last class, can you say God's name? We'll get to that.
- 7:54Speaker 2: Just too much to do today. Oh okay, two more things,
- 8:00Speaker 2: dreamer things. Actually this will take it's probably totenov uh.
- 8:03Speaker 2: Do you know this book? I just want to clarify
- 8:07Speaker 2: last week. This is Daniel Sperber's great the volume five
- 8:10Speaker 2: of his study of Minhagime. I know a lot of
- 8:13Speaker 2: people were surprised about last class what I said about
- 8:17Speaker 2: the minoga, and then I said to the implication of
- 8:19Speaker 2: the schoch also, so let me show you what I'm
- 8:22Speaker 2: talking about. Then it's in Jena Diomo. If you look
- 8:25Speaker 2: in the Tour sim On six seventy three. What the
- 8:29Speaker 2: tour says is that when you write down the ariskonika,
- 8:34Speaker 2: you don't make a sake that is with other lights. Therefore,
- 8:37Speaker 2: he says the last one, the okarone, is not for knica.
- 8:44Speaker 2: So there, what is it for? The tour says it
- 8:47Speaker 2: is for the light. So if you use it, you're
- 8:50Speaker 2: using a light, You're not using a minoa. And then
- 8:52Speaker 2: the tour says that ain't shame shamashall of we do
- 8:57Speaker 2: not call this hand all the shamas while light because
- 9:01Speaker 2: khama who am, because we already used the shamash to
- 9:06Speaker 2: light the manoa. So we see from the tour they
- 9:09Speaker 2: had two lights. Now, if you look in the s
- 9:12Speaker 2: what does he say here? He says as follows. He's
- 9:15Speaker 2: not so clear his language. He's quoting the tour, but
- 9:18Speaker 2: he's not one hundred percent clear. He says vanoa gami
- 9:21Speaker 2: near no suff He says, we're accustomed to light an
- 9:24Speaker 2: additional naire, additional candle kadesh englisha yell or no suff shot.
- 9:34Speaker 2: He says that, so that if you use it, you'll
- 9:37Speaker 2: you're not using the manoa. Now, what's not clear about
- 9:40Speaker 2: the shoa here is because uh, he's actually referring here
- 9:46Speaker 2: to the second light, not the shamas. He's referring to
- 9:50Speaker 2: the one you like. Afterwards, you see that if you
- 9:52Speaker 2: read the door and that the Ramo says, say, oh
- 9:56Speaker 2: that is in Poland and safe rock manasa. It's on
- 10:00Speaker 2: a shamash. So there must says in our lands, we
- 10:03Speaker 2: don't have this separate can't look light candle. We just
- 10:08Speaker 2: have the shamash. So we see that the chaufrone even
- 10:11Speaker 2: and what's the reason, Well, the reason is there's too
- 10:13Speaker 2: there's the one you light it with, and then there's
- 10:15Speaker 2: the one, the one that you use so that you
- 10:18Speaker 2: don't get benefit from the light of the Manoah, and
- 10:22Speaker 2: we use the shamash for that. But you see, that's
- 10:24Speaker 2: what I meant when I said to chafe the chauf.
- 10:27Speaker 2: He sort of abridges it so it's not really clear,
- 10:30Speaker 2: but he's voting the tour that's the Roma understands them.
- 10:33Speaker 2: And when he says to no near no stuff, that's
- 10:36Speaker 2: after lighting the candles. Uh, that's referring to the second
- 10:42Speaker 2: the second one you're light You like two things before
- 10:49Speaker 2: we get to big question last week, which I think
- 10:54Speaker 2: you will find of interest, is Susannah with us? If not,
- 10:58Speaker 2: I'm going to hold off till she is with us
- 11:00Speaker 2: because a show like this, if she doesn't write it,
- 11:03Speaker 2: I'm gonna hold off till next week, uh for Susannah,
- 11:08Speaker 2: And that way we won't I'm here, Oh, Susanna is here. Okay.
- 11:12Speaker 2: So Susannah made a very good point last week about
- 11:15Speaker 2: how sometimes even in Taanacha, you have things that don't go,
- 11:20Speaker 2: don't go in accordance with the rules. So I want
- 11:22Speaker 2: to show you a couple of things here delete this,
- 11:26Speaker 2: here's to uh to hell him some of these telling
- 11:30Speaker 2: we know very well lamitvove you'd babs. What does it
- 11:34Speaker 2: say here screen up here? Alta vote amy rego gaval
- 11:42Speaker 2: let not the foot of pride overtake me the al
- 11:46Speaker 2: timy daney and let not the hand of the week
- 11:48Speaker 2: could drive me away. What is this word al to
- 11:51Speaker 2: vote amy. It's a very strange word.
- 11:53Speaker 3: Uh.
- 11:54Speaker 2: You would expect to say ta voili. We don't have
- 11:57Speaker 2: the new mude ending in a case like that. But
- 12:01Speaker 2: this it rhymes, you see the no ending to the
- 12:04Speaker 2: day to d tenny dainty. So you have TiVo ani.
- 12:09Speaker 2: Another example, look over here, this is uh number man
- 12:17Speaker 2: look at zion. Let's talking about the different sacrifices, and
- 12:21Speaker 2: it says, oh of the hatah alta burnt offering and
- 12:25Speaker 2: sent offering, hast thou not required. Wouldn't your hata? It
- 12:29Speaker 2: should be hata. But again the rhyming o the rata.
- 12:35Speaker 2: Here we go Another example into hill looking gimmel amri
- 12:42Speaker 2: Leloheim saying to God man no ra masaka, that's a
- 12:47Speaker 2: man no ram saca. Uh, that's that's not unusual. You
- 12:52Speaker 2: would like you would assume it would be man poro
- 12:54Speaker 2: no ra no rhin. Perhaps is there another one I
- 12:58Speaker 2: want to show you? So look at the here five
- 13:05Speaker 2: vers five. Looking at verse five no verse eight, the
- 13:11Speaker 2: Ani bors bar lining by a tech it's strange. You'd
- 13:25Speaker 2: expect maybe berra. Yes, I mean that's not grammatical per se,
- 13:28Speaker 2: but it's just unusual. Okay. So now where where do
- 13:32Speaker 2: I get all these examples from? And there's many, many
- 13:34Speaker 2: more examples I can give you. I get it from
- 13:36Speaker 2: this book. Actually this book. I found a very interesting
- 13:41Speaker 2: book years ago called Parijamlitza The Safer Tailor by uh
- 13:46Speaker 2: Lithuanian who went there to sorrow wrotesfari men and he
- 13:49Speaker 2: came to America William Grossman's in English in Hebrew Zev
- 13:53Speaker 2: Grossman book. The book has an approbation by William Chomsky.
- 13:57Speaker 2: William Chomsky, who's a great Grimmerian, is the father of
- 14:02Speaker 2: none other than Noah Chompsky. I don't think William Chomsky,
- 14:08Speaker 2: who was one of the leading scholars of Hebrew, as
- 14:11Speaker 2: far as I know, he was an anti Zionist. So
- 14:13Speaker 2: Broceman wrote this book, and uh, he points out something
- 14:17Speaker 2: which I find really interesting. He says his follows. You
- 14:23Speaker 2: don't just speak about to Hilen. He gives an example here.
- 14:26Speaker 2: Look in now this is Parahuftest thirty five. What does
- 14:31Speaker 2: it say here the Asila Aronovanov? And thus show you
- 14:35Speaker 2: do to Aaron and his sons? Sorry an khola short cvc.
- 14:41Speaker 2: All that I have commanded osaka is about why have
- 14:46Speaker 2: you ever seen this word osaker? You never say it?
- 14:49Speaker 2: See that, but notice it's it's for the rhyme, the
- 14:54Speaker 2: csila aronovka cohola sht cvc osaka. That there's an example
- 15:01Speaker 2: where even in toward itself, we see variations from what
- 15:06Speaker 2: we'd expect normal grammar when it quote should be in
- 15:10Speaker 2: order for the rhyme. I was looking in this book.
- 15:13Speaker 2: It's so interesting the because at the end it gives
- 15:17Speaker 2: his books and lo and behold he published this book
- 15:20Speaker 2: initially where he published it then in the forties, the
- 15:25Speaker 2: forties or fifties here no fifty four, yes fifty four,
- 15:28Speaker 2: so he has the last pages. Look at this Timuno Speakadolia.
- 15:34Speaker 2: He sold pictures of the great rabbis Rashi Rambam, Joseph Kara,
- 15:38Speaker 2: the Rama, the provisions Almond of readers, collars sure the
- 15:42Speaker 2: kitzky and on a card, and that you could put
- 15:45Speaker 2: him on the uh this is the put him on
- 15:47Speaker 2: the you're the wall of the school or the base madris.
- 15:51Speaker 2: So this is the rabbi cards. We all know about
- 15:54Speaker 2: rabbi cards, right. I used to collect them. Ze's ellis
- 15:58Speaker 2: the indefatigable zev He has an article came out a
- 16:03Speaker 2: few years ago, Godolan cards and the commodification of rabbis things.
- 16:09Speaker 2: I used to collect these cards.
- 16:12Speaker 4: At My.
- 16:15Speaker 2: Brother also did that. My brother's bar mitza for the
- 16:17Speaker 2: tables of the seating instead of like one, two three,
- 16:22Speaker 2: it was different. Adobi So had the beni skai and
- 16:25Speaker 2: this and that, and then we had some giant ones
- 16:28Speaker 2: hanging on the ceiling. One of them looked like this.
- 16:32Speaker 2: This is of course the famous of Verbuhona Las. I
- 16:34Speaker 2: took this. It's a huge it was like three feet
- 16:38Speaker 2: and I brought it to JC where I was a student,
- 16:40Speaker 2: and I hung it on the wall of our classroom.
- 16:43Speaker 2: And I come back a day or two later and
- 16:45Speaker 2: it's not there, And people told me that Rabbi tights
- 16:47Speaker 2: took it off. So I didn't understand. Why would Rabbi
- 16:49Speaker 2: tights take off the poster of Verbohonen. I know, I
- 16:54Speaker 2: didn't know then, and Rohana was controversial in some of
- 16:56Speaker 2: his views, but it's still not a reason to take
- 16:58Speaker 2: him off. I went to Rubbi tights and he said
- 17:01Speaker 2: that the room that was my classroom, they use it
- 17:04Speaker 2: since we use it for Dovini Minha. You can't have
- 17:07Speaker 2: a picture even of a godl on it because it's used.
- 17:12Speaker 2: You could say someone could like that in that direction,
- 17:14Speaker 2: whatever he says, in a show, you don't have pictures
- 17:17Speaker 2: of Godoba. I guess not bolthough, in if you go
- 17:21Speaker 2: into that room I showed you two weeks ago, the
- 17:23Speaker 2: small not the big show. But like the base minors
- 17:26Speaker 2: in Tunis, they have pictures of the great Tunisian rabbis
- 17:30Speaker 2: in the actual show itself. And don't get me started
- 17:34Speaker 2: by Ahabad. Obviously they have a picture of the Rebbe. Okay,
- 17:38Speaker 2: the last thing I want to do now is I
- 17:46Speaker 2: want to give an introduction for a minute, and then
- 17:49Speaker 2: we'll get to the question and this will take us
- 17:51Speaker 2: like five more minutes or so. We spoke about poetry
- 17:57Speaker 2: a bit. We spoke about how it doesn't have to
- 18:01Speaker 2: always be in accordant with grammatical rules, Ashkenazim. For instance,
- 18:08Speaker 2: if you read the Aloc's poetry, it's in accordance with
- 18:11Speaker 2: and Tchernikowski. It rhymes Ashkenazi. So it's not that the
- 18:15Speaker 2: Alok is row. That's how the Ashkenazim pronounce it. Not
- 18:19Speaker 2: in to reading. I'm talking about poems. The the best
- 18:23Speaker 2: example of this, which you all know, even if you
- 18:26Speaker 2: don't realize. You know it is a tikvah a tikfa,
- 18:31Speaker 2: which uh we all know, and how it sungs. But
- 18:34Speaker 2: also they say the meter not so good at meter
- 18:36Speaker 2: is the same thing, but it's Ashkenazic. The whole thing
- 18:39Speaker 2: is Ashkenazik. And it's strange because Israelis today all recite it,
- 18:45Speaker 2: but it's not done. For example, we don't say odo
- 18:50Speaker 2: av da tik it's old lo avda ha tikva, not
- 18:56Speaker 2: a tik va. Uh, it's Leo the not Leotai, Ceo,
- 19:04Speaker 2: not Coo. And that's okay because again that's uh, it's
- 19:09Speaker 2: written and it's sung by Ashkenazi. Now why do I
- 19:12Speaker 2: give this as an introduction? I give this as an
- 19:15Speaker 2: introduction for the following reason. Last class I read as
- 19:22Speaker 2: follows and show you what I read. I was reading
- 19:30Speaker 2: aDNA ram, we are pronouncing it. And I said, uh,
- 19:37Speaker 2: the second bottom line there das Ara and Mel pointed
- 19:45Speaker 2: out to me, and then we had a correspondence and
- 19:49Speaker 2: gave me permission to cite him that when I said
- 19:52Speaker 2: the Ira, it actually is incorrect. It should be the
- 19:57Speaker 2: era because look you see though I'm right there, just
- 20:00Speaker 2: like over here Bira. And then he said that, uh,
- 20:06Speaker 2: it's the only reason we say the chan valira is
- 20:09Speaker 2: because of because of the tune the song. And he said,
- 20:14Speaker 2: points out look above here we say the second line,
- 20:18Speaker 2: what do we say as I'm melech. We don't say melech.
- 20:21Speaker 2: We say as I'm melech with the accent on the end.
- 20:24Speaker 3: And his point is and I.
- 20:26Speaker 2: Said to him, I'll speak about this next week. And
- 20:28Speaker 2: Mel says he doesn't know what's there to discuss. The
- 20:31Speaker 2: correct stress is clearly marked in the sitter. And you
- 20:35Speaker 2: do see the line there in the art under Melach
- 20:38Speaker 2: under our era. Bye, someone is I hear someone? So
- 20:43Speaker 2: someone has to be muted.
- 20:46Speaker 5: This line.
- 20:47Speaker 2: We know it's the meteg in the tower, we call
- 20:49Speaker 2: it in the hummush, we'll call it a guy you here,
- 20:51Speaker 2: it's a metic By the way, the don't always rely
- 20:55Speaker 2: necessarily that the metics correct. For instance, I found that
- 21:00Speaker 2: art Stroll gets in the bekosa shakra. Arts Throw gets
- 21:03Speaker 2: it right in the morning, it's we have a broth
- 21:07Speaker 2: called Sarki. He has sorry uh to make sure I
- 21:13Speaker 2: don't confuse the two dispute. Actually that word the last word,
- 21:20Speaker 2: it's sky. But as arts Grow gets it right, Koran
- 21:24Speaker 2: gets it wrong. Koran has sa sali. It's definitely it's
- 21:29Speaker 2: a meal l for the reasons that we spoke about.
- 21:32Speaker 2: But Korn gets the first brough right. Sure, Nassan v Na,
- 21:39Speaker 2: art Stroll gets it wrong. We know that it's a
- 21:41Speaker 2: it's a pusslen In art Scow even tells you it's
- 21:45Speaker 2: an eel. So it's not exactly. But this is Mell's point.
- 21:51Speaker 2: Every sinner I checked, I checked all the sea during
- 21:53Speaker 2: they all put the the dash there Mell Ira Ira.
- 21:59Speaker 2: So they all agree, and yet I'm gonna tell you
- 22:01Speaker 2: now that in my opinion, they're all wrong. And therefore,
- 22:05Speaker 2: although mel says that he wonders what they're discussed, the
- 22:08Speaker 2: correct stress is currently marked on the citter. I tell
- 22:10Speaker 2: you right now, the correct stress is not marked on
- 22:13Speaker 2: the sitter, and all these see Duriam are wrong for
- 22:16Speaker 2: the reason I'm going to explain. Now, Yes, the word
- 22:18Speaker 2: melick is to be written if you just have the
- 22:22Speaker 2: word melic. We know that whenever there's a three two segles,
- 22:26Speaker 2: it's the first syllable. So, for example, the word you
- 22:30Speaker 2: don't say, which incidentally in Benching Benching is an example
- 22:35Speaker 2: of where the song does mess it up. Who knows
- 22:40Speaker 2: saying lastmas are we pronounce it when it should be lessen.
- 22:44Speaker 2: But okay, so that's with a song you can, uh,
- 22:48Speaker 2: I guess be incorrect. But my point is that this
- 22:51Speaker 2: is not even incorrect. And let me explain to you.
- 22:53Speaker 2: And I'm going to prove this to you in two
- 22:55Speaker 2: ways and then mel and the rest. You'll either accept
- 22:58Speaker 2: it or you won't accept it. Let me explain to
- 23:00Speaker 2: you why. Because if a poem is written from the
- 23:04Speaker 2: beginning to be pronounced a certain way, even if it
- 23:08Speaker 2: doesn't fit in with we call grammar, then it is
- 23:12Speaker 2: that's the way to do. So when Nel says that
- 23:14Speaker 2: there are people in his shoel who go against the
- 23:17Speaker 2: tune and put the stresses on the correct syllables, I say, no,
- 23:20Speaker 2: they're putting this stresses on the room syllable because you
- 23:23Speaker 2: can't argue with the author. And let me explain to
- 23:27Speaker 2: you what I mean. Now, the author intended it to
- 23:29Speaker 2: be written in a certain way, and in poetry doesn't
- 23:33Speaker 2: need to be guided. So for example, here you can
- 23:36Speaker 2: see I don't know. Let me just read you the
- 23:39Speaker 2: first two lines. How this works. It goes as follows.
- 23:44Speaker 2: You have eight syllables, and it goes no stress stress,
- 23:49Speaker 2: no stress, stress, no stress. So it goes uh, don't
- 23:52Speaker 2: oh lum a share ma lah the tenm call yeah,
- 23:59Speaker 2: sear nivra let a nasa the tref so call zai
- 24:08Speaker 2: me chef mo kru. So you see very clearly that
- 24:13Speaker 2: the way the poem is set up. But we don't
- 24:15Speaker 2: know who they wrote this poem. It's a medieval apparently
- 24:18Speaker 2: in Spain. We don't know wrote You see very clearly
- 24:20Speaker 2: that the way it's designed to be read, it's not Melach.
- 24:25Speaker 2: And if someone recites the song and tries to make
- 24:28Speaker 2: it as I melf instead of Melas, he's going against
- 24:32Speaker 2: the intent of the author. And the author is entitled
- 24:34Speaker 2: to create a poem the way he wants. And as
- 24:36Speaker 2: for how I recited the end of the line value
- 24:39Speaker 2: rah not val Ira. Just look at how they are
- 24:43Speaker 2: the Manasco Cibo makr the a s Schanva, a e
- 24:50Speaker 2: ra Hashemi, the low e ro. It is obviously designed
- 24:54Speaker 2: to be read that way, despite the fact that if
- 24:58Speaker 2: you take the word itself the era, it should be
- 25:04Speaker 2: the era. But that's not how it's supposed to end.
- 25:07Speaker 2: So now, if you're still not convinced, I will convince
- 25:12Speaker 2: you now for the simple reason that a lot of
- 25:16Speaker 2: people were thinking that this is the Ashka Nazi. We
- 25:19Speaker 2: like to use tunes that don't go on a chord
- 25:21Speaker 2: with grammar. But obviously the sardine they get it right.
- 25:25Speaker 2: They'll get it right. Let me play you how the
- 25:27Speaker 2: Fardim read this, and you will see they all read
- 25:31Speaker 2: it the way I just said, for the simple reason
- 25:33Speaker 2: that this is how you're supposed to read it. So,
- 25:36Speaker 2: although so those Fahamim telling you the tune is wrong,
- 25:39Speaker 2: the tune is right. And how do I know this? Well,
- 25:42Speaker 2: let me play you just a couple I could do more.
- 25:45Speaker 2: I found online. What you can find today is amazing.
- 25:48Speaker 3: Here is.
- 25:51Speaker 2: This comes from Central Asia. The caucus is just read
- 25:56Speaker 2: how they I'm not gonna be able to read them
- 25:59Speaker 2: all with for all of you. But listen to all
- 26:01Speaker 2: these different sward and how they read it. And listen,
- 26:05Speaker 2: let me make it loud so you can hear a
- 26:14Speaker 2: bit go.
- 26:19Speaker 1: Uh.
- 26:23Speaker 2: Okay, So here you have in the middle of Asia.
- 26:26Speaker 2: They read it properly. And then this isn't because of
- 26:29Speaker 2: some tune and some Ashkenazi invented in Germany. How about
- 26:33Speaker 2: the end? Let me get it to U the closer
- 26:40Speaker 2: to the end here?
- 26:42Speaker 3: Well is it?
- 26:44Speaker 2: Oh my, no, same man that goes oh manica ver uh.
- 26:55Speaker 5: Uh uh.
- 27:07Speaker 2: They had stored him have extra verses in it. So
- 27:10Speaker 2: there you see it here do we have up here's
- 27:12Speaker 2: North Africans. Look how the North Africans recited.
- 27:19Speaker 5: Oh sam la me? Did him cold?
- 27:24Speaker 6: Yes?
- 27:25Speaker 5: Your name? Uh me? Not so cool as I may shame.
- 27:33Speaker 2: Okay, there you go again. Let me show you another
- 27:38Speaker 2: one here we oh, actually, let me show you. I
- 27:46Speaker 2: think I have one more I want to show here. Oh,
- 27:48Speaker 2: here's two miss I want to show you at the
- 27:52Speaker 2: end here two thirty two. I made a mark here.
- 27:58Speaker 2: Listen how the last lines are.
- 28:02Speaker 5: Be we sov we.
- 28:11Speaker 2: Actually sorry that was the wrong one. We're a different
- 28:13Speaker 2: one now okay? Whatever, Well I have here I'll play
- 28:19Speaker 2: from the beginning. This is to tunis oh.
- 28:25Speaker 6: Man be the ram go'sly it nash.
- 28:38Speaker 5: The stoke gold as I mean.
- 28:45Speaker 2: Man laugh mal laugh uh. And if I can find
- 28:49Speaker 2: it quickly here these are preserving the traditional tunes.
- 28:53Speaker 5: We sov we be they.
- 29:09Speaker 6: And we uh I mean.
- 29:14Speaker 2: And finally, oh, actually one more thing I want to
- 29:19Speaker 2: show you, and then we'll be done for today. But
- 29:22Speaker 2: I think you'll find those interesting because those are traditional tunes.
- 29:27Speaker 2: There's a yem night wine also.
- 29:30Speaker 3: Mhm, not back any co.
- 29:45Speaker 2: Yeah, I'm going home.
- 29:47Speaker 3: I'm not sure looking back any con yet not.
- 29:54Speaker 5: Every talk I tell him here, let me.
- 29:58Speaker 2: Get down, and then uh, just to play you at
- 30:02Speaker 2: the end, Oh.
- 30:09Speaker 3: Is it not? Is it not?
- 30:16Speaker 4: Here?
- 30:17Speaker 3: I don't arget it all.
- 30:24Speaker 2: I era not a era. And the last thing I
- 30:28Speaker 2: want to show you in this is I found on
- 30:33Speaker 2: that very site they have a sitter from sixteen sixteen
- 30:39Speaker 2: in Germany. And look how they market at the end
- 30:42Speaker 2: here at the bottom here, look how they divide it
- 30:45Speaker 2: the ecra the era. They divide all the endings there
- 30:51Speaker 2: bit's Sarah, so that you know they're separated. So that's that.
- 30:58Speaker 2: It says at the top here it says shear me
- 30:59Speaker 2: at he to stay to new oak, stay to new oak.
- 31:03Speaker 2: That's it's not exactly it's it doesn't always have that.
- 31:06Speaker 2: But what this means is that the a tade is,
- 31:10Speaker 2: for example, the shava or the that's the first, yeah,
- 31:16Speaker 2: odd dome, that's the first thing, and then straight to
- 31:19Speaker 2: oh uh you see the set and how that follows
- 31:23Speaker 2: the model share the the tade is the first, the chava,
- 31:30Speaker 2: followed by the next syllable, and then the new oat
- 31:34Speaker 2: ma la. Then you go remco yeah see her. That's
- 31:41Speaker 2: not every verse does that, but uh, most of the
- 31:45Speaker 2: verses do that. So I rest my place that the
- 31:48Speaker 2: way it should be pronounced is malech, even though that's
- 31:51Speaker 2: not the grammatical, but that's how the poet intended it.
- 31:54Speaker 2: He intended it to be ira rah because he wrote it,
- 31:59Speaker 2: and he intended us to recite it that way, and
- 32:01Speaker 2: if you look, Jews all over the world recite it
- 32:04Speaker 2: this way. This is some Ashkenazic sort of uh thing.
- 32:10Speaker 2: I see, we say, I'll get back to you that
- 32:11Speaker 2: now about that, So I I that's that's my point.
- 32:18Speaker 2: Very good. Let us move on now. But I think
- 32:23Speaker 2: I made my case there that this isn't a. We
- 32:26Speaker 2: had plenty of examples of pronunciation mistakes that uh that
- 32:30Speaker 2: there were tunes go against the grammatical rules because we
- 32:35Speaker 2: just invented the two. But here's an example where the
- 32:38Speaker 2: author of the poem wanted you to say fade a
- 32:41Speaker 2: certain way, and as I showed you the first two lines,
- 32:44Speaker 2: it has to be melef because it goes unaccented, accented,
- 32:47Speaker 2: unaccent accent, et cetera. Okay, my friends, we now turn
- 32:55Speaker 2: to the safer. We went longer than I ever went,
- 32:57Speaker 2: but I thought this was as you know, those who
- 33:00Speaker 2: with me for many years' we don't actually we just
- 33:03Speaker 2: keep going like what is it rebby tarphone? Uh you
- 33:06Speaker 2: know we we says it in Turkey of us that
- 33:09Speaker 2: we're not going to be able to finish everything and
- 33:11Speaker 2: uh a fatha fothball. Also, you can say, because I
- 33:17Speaker 2: put on the YouTube, I give a little description of
- 33:20Speaker 2: what we talked about. But someone emailed me the other
- 33:22Speaker 2: day that all I mentioned was the actual things in
- 33:26Speaker 2: the book we speak about it, and I don't even
- 33:28Speaker 2: speak about all the other things. But okay, we returned
- 33:32Speaker 2: to the safer. I'm in the middle of the letter.
- 33:33Speaker 2: This is page two thirty seven in the letter to
- 33:36Speaker 2: Rabbi Mazu's Simon Puffi Dowd and as I mentioned that
- 33:42Speaker 2: I would write him, I would save up a lot
- 33:47Speaker 2: of questions or comments and then send them them. So
- 33:50Speaker 2: this has maybe ten different things. The next thing is
- 33:53Speaker 2: as fathers he said in he comes out, you know
- 33:59Speaker 2: with this weekly rashets. So in one of them he
- 34:01Speaker 2: said his follows. He quoted the Rumbumb. First of all,
- 34:05Speaker 2: we all know, or we should know, that if someone
- 34:09Speaker 2: says eat this non kosher food or I'll kill you,
- 34:12Speaker 2: you're not supposed to be killed. You're supposed to eat it.
- 34:17Speaker 2: The only exception would be if the person was doing
- 34:20Speaker 2: that in a way that's say, to cause you to
- 34:23Speaker 2: destroy it, wasn't doing it for his own benefit, but
- 34:26Speaker 2: to destroy Judaism, something like that. But leave that aside.
- 34:30Speaker 2: From now, we'll get back to that. But generally we
- 34:31Speaker 2: all know that except for the three big things, a
- 34:34Speaker 2: vote asara shistamin, killing someone someone says kill this person
- 34:40Speaker 2: or I'll kill you, or certain sexual moralities, martyrdom is required.
- 34:46Speaker 2: And Rabbi Mazous said quotes the that the the Rumbumb's
- 34:53Speaker 2: position that there's there's no, the rum mom doesn't just
- 34:58Speaker 2: say you don't up your life. Let's say, if someone
- 35:01Speaker 2: says eating non kosher, the Rumam says you're you have
- 35:03Speaker 2: the status of a suicide. If someone comes up to
- 35:05Speaker 2: you with it, puts a gun to your head and
- 35:06Speaker 2: says eat on young Pipper or I'll kill you, and
- 35:09Speaker 2: you say, well, I'm going to be pious. I'd rather
- 35:10Speaker 2: be killed. The rumbus lush on is horaisingki. It's like
- 35:16Speaker 2: you're a suicide because, after all, the Torah tells us
- 35:18Speaker 2: when to give up our life and when not to.
- 35:20Speaker 2: And it's not your life. It's not your life to
- 35:23Speaker 2: decide what you're gonna do with it, just like we
- 35:25Speaker 2: all know it's not our bodies. We can't just do
- 35:28Speaker 2: what we want. We can't decide that I want to
- 35:29Speaker 2: give up life now I'm going to just commit suicide
- 35:33Speaker 2: or something. Well, you can't say I'm just gonna you know,
- 35:36Speaker 2: I don't. I can't eat non kosher, I can't eat
- 35:38Speaker 2: on young Pipper and therefore kill me. The Rumm's very
- 35:42Speaker 2: harsh about however, this on earth, they so safe. It's
- 35:47Speaker 2: troubled him. He didn't agree with this, and he said
- 35:54Speaker 2: straining him Rabbi. He says, many great people disagree with
- 35:57Speaker 2: the Rambam that if you choose you, you it's like
- 36:01Speaker 2: super irrogatory. If you miss a din, if someone says
- 36:04Speaker 2: I'll kill you unless you eat or something, uh, then
- 36:09Speaker 2: you and you decide to be martyred, you're considered pious
- 36:12Speaker 2: and holy. And so we're gonna get back to this
- 36:17Speaker 2: in a second. So we have a dispute here. The
- 36:19Speaker 2: rum says you can't Chochnard quotes people who say you can.
- 36:22Speaker 2: Ravan Mazous explain, what does it mean?
- 36:26Speaker 3: What is the the.
- 36:27Speaker 2: Chan i should say mean when he says that if
- 36:31Speaker 2: you are killed and didn't violated, it's considered a great action.
- 36:36Speaker 2: Ramazou says he did amidst of a godola the keys
- 36:39Speaker 2: Hashem and he uh and Raban Maszoos writes he sanctified.
- 36:46Speaker 2: And how does he say Hashem? He says, hey with
- 36:48Speaker 2: a dash? So I wrote to Ramazous, is this a typo?
- 36:54Speaker 2: Hey with a dash? Because the word it should be
- 36:58Speaker 2: hashen hey shin man, the sanctify God's name? Where does
- 37:05Speaker 2: this come from? This whole idea? It comes from this
- 37:07Speaker 2: puzzle right here. Let's see we got the puzzle here Vayikra. No,
- 37:17Speaker 2: it's not that here kra Peric twenty two, verse thirty two.
- 37:22Speaker 2: What does it say? It says, you shall not profane
- 37:24Speaker 2: my holy name as shame cud she's got I you
- 37:32Speaker 2: should not profane my holy name, and uh, you should
- 37:36Speaker 2: sanctify me. But the word here is shame. You see,
- 37:41Speaker 2: that's where you get the idea of hello Hashem, because
- 37:46Speaker 2: the it's not it's not as in God. That's my point.
- 37:51Speaker 2: So if you say k hsham, it should be uh,
- 37:56Speaker 2: you should just use hey, because when we use hey
- 37:58Speaker 2: with a dash that refers to God. I also have
- 38:03Speaker 2: another pet peeve that here. You see here people write
- 38:08Speaker 2: as follows hilo hashim. That's the word hashem. That's how
- 38:12Speaker 2: we write God, hushm God. That's not the name. If
- 38:17Speaker 2: when you say hashm, it's and look here, look at
- 38:21Speaker 2: the in the article. Why is kiddish is and hillo
- 38:25Speaker 2: there lowercase and hashem hashem as in God God.
- 38:29Speaker 3: But it's not.
- 38:30Speaker 2: It's not God. It's not Kiddish of God. And the
- 38:33Speaker 2: author here knows is not Kiddish of God, but he
- 38:35Speaker 2: still writes hushim capital age. If anything, it should be
- 38:38Speaker 2: small h a dash capital s if you want a GM,
- 38:43Speaker 2: but not hushim, So I asked ram Azous. Though Mazus
- 38:47Speaker 2: he knows everything, he writes hey, kiddish hey, and so
- 38:55Speaker 2: he replieses me it really is the same thing, because
- 39:00Speaker 2: he doesn't really answer the question. He says, uh, look
- 39:02Speaker 2: in the pussle here vidash de bot in Israel, I
- 39:09Speaker 2: will be sanctified. So he says that when you are
- 39:13Speaker 2: sanctified God's name, you sanctify God. So therefore it's okay
- 39:18Speaker 2: to write hey with the dash. Okay, leave it there.
- 39:21Speaker 2: I still don't like it because people when they see husham,
- 39:24Speaker 2: just the hey and the dash, they assume it means,
- 39:27Speaker 2: you know, sanctification of God when it's not. But the
- 39:32Speaker 2: bigger question is as follows, and this is when I
- 39:35Speaker 2: this gets us into a very very important issue here.
- 39:39Speaker 2: As I said, the Rambam holds it. If you say,
- 39:41Speaker 2: if you would martyr yourself when you're not supposed to be,
- 39:44Speaker 2: you're a suicide. However, the problem is that this is
- 39:48Speaker 2: the position of the Rambam in the Missionta. But the
- 39:50Speaker 2: ROBM has another word. It's called agherrisha shamad. The Garisha
- 39:54Speaker 2: Shamad was written the Rambam. You had this the rise
- 39:57Speaker 2: of this radical Islamic group called the Almaha. Yes, they
- 40:01Speaker 2: were the Hamas or the Islami Jihad of medieval times. Now,
- 40:05Speaker 2: the typical Muslim approach is as it says in the Quran,
- 40:09Speaker 2: is there is no compulsion in religion. But there's all
- 40:12Speaker 2: sorts of interpretations over what that meant. The mainstream interpretation
- 40:15Speaker 2: was that for people of the book, that is Jews
- 40:18Speaker 2: and Christians, you couldn't force them to convert. All you
- 40:22Speaker 2: could do is keep them in like in a second
- 40:24Speaker 2: class status. Dim me but Pagans, of course we're having
- 40:28Speaker 2: a choice conversion or death. But there were the others
- 40:31Speaker 2: who interpreted that first in a different way. And the
- 40:33Speaker 2: Almohads they had a notion of conversion or death. They
- 40:40Speaker 2: came into Spain and they gave people this choice conversion
- 40:43Speaker 2: or death or the Rambam and his family fled to
- 40:45Speaker 2: North Africa. They would then make their way to or
- 40:49Speaker 2: to throw and then Egypt. Now the Ramum was asked
- 40:52Speaker 2: the question because the people in Spain and in Morocco,
- 40:57Speaker 2: what most of them did not all the die in
- 41:00Speaker 2: the Fez, for instance, was burnt at the steak were
- 41:02Speaker 2: told because he refused to convert. But what most of
- 41:05Speaker 2: them did was convert to Islam outwardly. What does it
- 41:09Speaker 2: mean to convert to Islam. It's not it's not so
- 41:11Speaker 2: complicated like in Judaism. There's no meal or anything that's required.
- 41:15Speaker 2: What's required is you say the shad. If you say
- 41:18Speaker 2: it once with meaning there is no God but God.
- 41:23Speaker 2: Not there's no God but Allah. There's no good Allah
- 41:25Speaker 2: as God. There's no God but God. And Mohammad is
- 41:27Speaker 2: is propheted. You say at one time with meaning, you're
- 41:29Speaker 2: a Muslim. All you have to do is say that.
- 41:32Speaker 2: And that's and most of the Jews, but the overwhelming
- 41:35Speaker 2: majority of Jews, that's what they did. And they lived
- 41:38Speaker 2: as secret Jews, but outwardly as Muslims. In fact, that
- 41:43Speaker 2: Irma tells us that the Muslims knew that the Jews
- 41:46Speaker 2: were not living privately as Muslims. I guess they figured
- 41:49Speaker 2: over time they would become a Muslim. The question did
- 41:55Speaker 2: the Rambam live as a Muslim? It's an interesting historical question,
- 42:00Speaker 2: as he says that all of us have to live
- 42:02Speaker 2: like a Muslim. So was he speaking the royal we
- 42:05Speaker 2: or was he referring to himself, and he says that
- 42:07Speaker 2: we all have to do this. Now, it's not a
- 42:09Speaker 2: problem quote religious problem, because the rom I's going to
- 42:12Speaker 2: tell you that's what you should do. But this was
- 42:14Speaker 2: the biggest it's a big historical issue that the Rama
- 42:16Speaker 2: himself has to live as a Muslim. Okay, so the Rombum.
- 42:21Speaker 2: The problem was these Jews were challenged by this scholar.
- 42:24Speaker 2: We don't know who this scholar was. The ram treats
- 42:27Speaker 2: him as if he's nobody. But he couldn't have been
- 42:29Speaker 2: a nobody because when he issued his ruling that all
- 42:32Speaker 2: these Jews are basically i at the status of idolators
- 42:35Speaker 2: because they're living as a Muslim, the Jewish community was
- 42:38Speaker 2: thrown into a quandary. If he was some nobody, they
- 42:39Speaker 2: wouldn't have cared. So when this unknown scholar issues this ruling,
- 42:43Speaker 2: they write to the Rambum, and the Rambum issues this
- 42:46Speaker 2: marvelous work the Garrison Shamad, which is the defense of
- 42:49Speaker 2: the Jewish community under siege, explaining that what you're doing
- 42:53Speaker 2: is absolutely correct. There's no obligation to marry yourself because
- 42:56Speaker 2: Islam is not idolatry. Uh, there's a big difference between
- 43:01Speaker 2: the response in the Christian lands when you were obligated
- 43:04Speaker 2: tomorrow to yourself. That doesn't mean that the people who
- 43:08Speaker 2: are not strong enough to allow themselves to be killed,
- 43:12Speaker 2: as many Jews in France and Germany did, but in Spain,
- 43:15Speaker 2: for instance, in Portugal, well Spain, let's spit to Spain now,
- 43:19Speaker 2: most of them did not. It seems the majority converted
- 43:22Speaker 2: from thirteen ninety one to fourteen ninety two, and many
- 43:25Speaker 2: of them later then tried and fled to North Africa
- 43:27Speaker 2: or the land of Israel. The difference is that they
- 43:31Speaker 2: although they were not treated as evil, but there was
- 43:33Speaker 2: understood there was a sin, and they were given various
- 43:35Speaker 2: penances chuva to do. But in what Arama was saying
- 43:39Speaker 2: is that what you're doing is absolutely correct. There's nothing
- 43:41Speaker 2: wrong with because it's not idolatry Islam, and therefore all
- 43:45Speaker 2: they want us to do is make a statement that
- 43:48Speaker 2: you know, God is God and Mohammas's prophet to save
- 43:51Speaker 2: our lives. We make a statement. According to Rama, there's
- 43:53Speaker 2: no mass said, no action of idolatry. Incidentally, this position
- 44:00Speaker 2: a rumbam, which seems to make a lot of sense,
- 44:03Speaker 2: was subject to dispute the writs of a the baas,
- 44:07Speaker 2: because you get into a big one should discussion here
- 44:11Speaker 2: has I'll say that for these, for given a choice,
- 44:13Speaker 2: you a votera zara or death, you have to choose death.
- 44:16Speaker 2: What's the what's the real issue here? The rom Bomb
- 44:20Speaker 2: holds that the issue is you can't do an action
- 44:22Speaker 2: of a votazara. The action of a vota azara is
- 44:24Speaker 2: so terrible that you have to the harvilov, you have
- 44:28Speaker 2: to accept martyrdom. So with his mom there's no action
- 44:32Speaker 2: of vota zara. It's a monotheistic religion, so of course
- 44:35Speaker 2: you don't marty yourself. However, the rit of Va criticizes
- 44:40Speaker 2: the ram Bomb, and then the rabbas and others, and
- 44:42Speaker 2: the rivas says the things the Rambam's wrong. He says,
- 44:45Speaker 2: the real problem is not the action of idolatry, bowing
- 44:48Speaker 2: down to the cross or whatever, to the idol of Zeus.
- 44:52Speaker 2: The issue is rejection of the Torah. That's the capital offense,
- 44:56Speaker 2: denial of the Torah. When Hazau looking for an example
- 45:01Speaker 2: of denial of the Torah, the example was obviously bowing
- 45:05Speaker 2: down to an idol kraza in the days a rassal,
- 45:07Speaker 2: there wasn't a conception of a religion that's monotheistic. Every
- 45:10Speaker 2: religion was idolatris. So when rassal speak about you know,
- 45:14Speaker 2: an action of idolatry, that's showing rejection of the Torah.
- 45:19Speaker 2: But now with Thesam, the rich Vuff, for instance, says,
- 45:23Speaker 2: we have to get the essence. The essence is denial
- 45:25Speaker 2: of the Torah. And when you accept a psalm, by definition,
- 45:29Speaker 2: you're rejecting the Torah because Islam teaches that the Torah
- 45:32Speaker 2: has been fraudulently written. We've we've altered it. The real
- 45:36Speaker 2: authentic text is preserved in the Quran, the authentic teaching,
- 45:40Speaker 2: and therefore, by accepting Islam, you reject the Torah. The
- 45:44Speaker 2: rich Vas says, and this is what Shati says in
- 45:46Speaker 2: the Gamara, that is the actually not just the d fathers,
- 45:50Speaker 2: they all. That is the capital offense, denying the Torah.
- 45:54Speaker 2: So if it's denying the Torah, if that's the capital offense,
- 45:57Speaker 2: well then if you're giving the choice virtual Islam or death,
- 46:01Speaker 2: you have to accept offurse. That's a big mahaukus mungery
- 46:05Speaker 2: shown me. Is it the action of a votasara the Masa,
- 46:08Speaker 2: which like the Ramam holds, or the the rejection of
- 46:12Speaker 2: the toa. Let's leave this aside for now, because in
- 46:16Speaker 2: the Garrisa Shmad, although the Ramam strongly defends this position
- 46:20Speaker 2: of his that it's it's only if it's if it's
- 46:22Speaker 2: no action of the motazaari, you don't eat some word
- 46:24Speaker 2: of yourself. The Rambam also says, but if you want
- 46:26Speaker 2: to be piss and you want to be holy, and
- 46:29Speaker 2: you allow yourself to be martyred, you're kuddash, you're holy,
- 46:34Speaker 2: You've you've reached a great height. So he leaves it
- 46:36Speaker 2: as an option, which he does not leave in the
- 46:40Speaker 2: Mission of Tower, where he says that if it's if
- 46:42Speaker 2: you're not obligated to and you aie yourself to be killed,
- 46:45Speaker 2: it's as if you're a suicide. So Rabbi Kaf, the
- 46:47Speaker 2: great Rabbi Kafe, we've spoken about already, he already deals
- 46:51Speaker 2: with this in his note on his edition of the
- 46:53Speaker 2: Rambam's letters, and he says the Ramam changes mind. When
- 46:57Speaker 2: the Ramam wrote the Agreta Schmad, he was young. Later
- 47:00Speaker 2: on he changed his mind and he didn't accept this
- 47:02Speaker 2: idea that you can be pious and volunteer voluntary martyrdom.
- 47:06Speaker 2: I guess you can call it. He rejects it. Rab
- 47:11Speaker 2: I mean sorry. Rabbi Shane Lot in this work, his
- 47:14Speaker 2: Important Edition of the Letters, he has a different approach
- 47:18Speaker 2: to explain this contradiction. He says that, first of all,
- 47:25Speaker 2: he points out that we're dealing with an unusual case anyway,
- 47:29Speaker 2: because in a time of chamad, in a time of persecution,
- 47:33Speaker 2: you're supposed to give up your life for anything. If
- 47:35Speaker 2: Romo says, you don't have to, Sir Chatte wants to
- 47:38Speaker 2: argue that this is maybe not a real schamad because
- 47:42Speaker 2: the Muslims themselves knew that the Jews it was just
- 47:44Speaker 2: for show on the outside, and that privately they were
- 47:47Speaker 2: still being Jewish. He he has a whole different approach.
- 47:50Speaker 2: He rejects he doesn't accept a Rabbi u Kaffer's idea.
- 47:55Speaker 2: He says that he says, in the case of where
- 48:04Speaker 2: it's a shmad aha shmad, then the ram bomb would
- 48:08Speaker 2: allow you to be a public martyr, a voluntary martyr,
- 48:13Speaker 2: but not in other cases. So he tries to make
- 48:15Speaker 2: that argument. It's it's not clear if there's a contradiction,
- 48:20Speaker 2: how to explain it. Robby Mazou says he thinks the
- 48:23Speaker 2: simplest answer is as follows. He says, the ram Bum's
- 48:27Speaker 2: position is and always is that it's it's forbidden to
- 48:32Speaker 2: be a martyr, a voluntary marder. However, if you go
- 48:35Speaker 2: ahead and do it anyway with the avada. But if
- 48:43Speaker 2: you go ahead and do it anyway and you have
- 48:45Speaker 2: good intentions, we're not going to treat you like a
- 48:47Speaker 2: suicide you regarded ex post facto. This is like someone
- 48:52Speaker 2: had you asked the question, we would have said not to,
- 48:54Speaker 2: but if you went ahead and did it, we regard
- 48:56Speaker 2: you as holy. Interestingly, this is the exact position of
- 48:59Speaker 2: Crime Solvation. I saw his new volume, third volume. I
- 49:02Speaker 2: have to get a essays came out from my favorite
- 49:04Speaker 2: press Litman library. But that's his That's how Time Salvation
- 49:08Speaker 2: understands what was going on, because you have a strange phenomenon.
- 49:11Speaker 2: You have people in ashdie ass not just committing suicide,
- 49:15Speaker 2: killing their children. How can you kill your children? There's
- 49:18Speaker 2: no source? So what are we gonna call them all heretics?
- 49:21Speaker 2: So are we gonna call them evil murderers? Not bury
- 49:24Speaker 2: them in Jews cemetery? He said, that was impossible. Even
- 49:28Speaker 2: the Rabbis who assume what they do is absolutely wrong,
- 49:31Speaker 2: understood they did it because they thought it was the
- 49:34Speaker 2: proper thing. And therefore, although we will never tell anyone
- 49:37Speaker 2: to do that ex post facto, we have to regard
- 49:40Speaker 2: them as kdoshi. And that's how I'm Salvation reads the
- 49:43Speaker 2: all they are, all the discussions as like ex post facto.
- 49:46Speaker 2: And that's what Rebamazu says. The rama's position is that
- 49:49Speaker 2: when the Rama says you're holy, it means that if
- 49:52Speaker 2: you will, a simple person decides to like just think
- 49:55Speaker 2: we're back in Germany or in Spain or something like that,
- 49:59Speaker 2: and ann juk and says, eat this non kosher and
- 50:02Speaker 2: someone says, no, I will never do that. I would
- 50:04Speaker 2: rather die than meet that. Uh are we going to
- 50:07Speaker 2: assume that? And and he's martyr and a were going
- 50:09Speaker 2: to regard him as a suicide. It's supposed to. Yes,
- 50:11Speaker 2: the ra mom gives the hawaha. But in the real world,
- 50:14Speaker 2: if the person intended proper, proper you know, chuva or whatever,
- 50:21Speaker 2: if he intended to do this, uh to serve God,
- 50:24Speaker 2: we're not going to regard him as a suicide. Although
- 50:27Speaker 2: then what's the realm I'm talking about. Then in a
- 50:29Speaker 2: mission Tarr when he says you were a suicide, it's
- 50:33Speaker 2: a problem. That's why says he changed his mind. By
- 50:36Speaker 2: Massous thinks no, Ramazous thinks that that's the Missionaris like
- 50:40Speaker 2: the theoretical that this is the halaka and you tell
- 50:43Speaker 2: anyone you understand as the suicide, but expost facto will
- 50:47Speaker 2: regard the person as a coddas. I'm not sure if
- 50:50Speaker 2: this is the best answer either, but this is uh
- 50:53Speaker 2: so we have three approaches to how to deal with
- 50:55Speaker 2: this very unusual apparently change in the Ramum's position. Is
- 50:59Speaker 2: there some notion of voluntary martyrs in medieval Ashkena's voluntary
- 51:03Speaker 2: modern martine was taken for granted, and there's all sorts
- 51:06Speaker 2: of Gothic sources you can cite about people like the
- 51:09Speaker 2: village young people jumped off the boat and martyr themselves
- 51:12Speaker 2: so they wouldn't be taken back to Rome, and all
- 51:14Speaker 2: sorts of other examples. But the Rumbum is opposed to
- 51:18Speaker 2: voluntary martyrdom. Then it makes perfect sense. It's not our bodies.
- 51:21Speaker 2: We can't decide on our own what to do the
- 51:26Speaker 2: next part of the letter, it's also I think of interest.
- 51:30Speaker 2: Rabbi Mazus in his weekly Tora Journal newsletter set as
- 51:37Speaker 2: follows that if you're sending letter, there's a city in
- 51:40Speaker 2: Israel called Bytel, it's a I was there. I was
- 51:44Speaker 2: there last summer. No, not last summer, least January a
- 51:48Speaker 2: year ago almost. I was in Betel. First time ever
- 51:51Speaker 2: was in Baytel. Went to Sham. That was interesting. First
- 51:54Speaker 2: time I went to see. The Samaritans have a museum there.
- 51:57Speaker 2: It's it's really very interesting if you get over the
- 52:00Speaker 2: fact that we were stopped in a traffic jam right
- 52:02Speaker 2: in the middle of an Arab village and my wife
- 52:04Speaker 2: is thinking we're all going to be killed and everything.
- 52:07Speaker 2: But the driver showed us is gone. But still but
- 52:09Speaker 2: that was. But if you ever to Baydown, it's it's
- 52:13Speaker 2: it's it's worth seeing. And I went to where is
- 52:20Speaker 2: a Eliezer, Mohammed Harbor, all those places. Okay that Bethdel
- 52:26Speaker 2: is a big city. I mean it has lots of
- 52:28Speaker 2: people there seven their lives. They have a winery as well.
- 52:35Speaker 2: We'll see if the wine from Bakedel beginning in January,
- 52:39Speaker 2: if it can still be labeled from Israel or has
- 52:42Speaker 2: to go back to hertors so here, So what is
- 52:46Speaker 2: this Bakedeal? Is this a hall we name? Can you?
- 52:50Speaker 2: Can you say the name Maydeal? Can you write? Can
- 52:52Speaker 2: you send them letter to Bakedell? In Hebrew? You send letters,
- 52:56Speaker 2: So whenever I send lyterst Israel, I used the Hebrew
- 52:58Speaker 2: and I just wade in English as it'll get there.
- 53:01Speaker 2: Raby A Zou says that if you send a letter
- 53:05Speaker 2: to Beatedale, you should write it as one word Bethel
- 53:09Speaker 2: or make a line between the Aliph and the Lhama.
- 53:12Speaker 2: So Bethdale. Because you're not l is one of the
- 53:16Speaker 2: names of God, You're not supposed to write it. We're
- 53:20Speaker 2: gonna get to the names. I just said the name. Well,
- 53:23Speaker 2: we'll get to about next week about using the name
- 53:25Speaker 2: of God other than the tetragrammaton in Tora study. I
- 53:29Speaker 2: think most of her sending me stuff, and I found
- 53:31Speaker 2: some good stuff. What I know Aroumzus's follows. I understand that,
- 53:35Speaker 2: and that's not the men. No one does that. But
- 53:37Speaker 2: I said to him, first of all, the bek safe,
- 53:41Speaker 2: the bear ko safe is the da I'm your azubi
- 53:47Speaker 2: just commentary, and he brings different opinions. The question is
- 53:50Speaker 2: that the word Beatedeale appears in Tora, first appears in
- 53:55Speaker 2: brac She's let me show you this isn't a new city,
- 54:01Speaker 2: you see. Hold on seconds here if you look in
- 54:10Speaker 2: here somewhere I believe, Oh yes, here, So look in
- 54:14Speaker 2: plus eight. Uh, this is at the way beginning where
- 54:18Speaker 2: it says that Avraham moved to the east of Baydale.
- 54:23Speaker 2: So apparently already you see that there's a Bagdale in
- 54:25Speaker 2: the days of Avraham. Well, if there's a Bagdale in
- 54:28Speaker 2: the days of Avraha, then the words it's obviously not
- 54:32Speaker 2: a god's name. It's just the name of the city beforehand.
- 54:36Speaker 5: Uh.
- 54:37Speaker 2: The problem is we have later in Racis where Yakov
- 54:39Speaker 2: names the place is Baydale, and some people even say,
- 54:42Speaker 2: some commentaries that the Beaydale we just saw with Avraham
- 54:45Speaker 2: is named in anticipation of what Yakov's gonna do. So
- 54:48Speaker 2: what's the other issue? Is is it when we say Bakedale,
- 54:53Speaker 2: do you mean house of God? Or is this just
- 54:54Speaker 2: the name of a city. If it's just name of
- 54:56Speaker 2: the city, it doesn't matter what originally it was. And
- 54:59Speaker 2: I when you get out in my letter, is that
- 55:01Speaker 2: the after after I mentioned the dog quotes opinions in
- 55:05Speaker 2: both ways. The hustom Sofur says that this word bagdale
- 55:08Speaker 2: that we see in Torah is not holy. You have
- 55:12Speaker 2: all these names, if they're holy names, the sofa has
- 55:15Speaker 2: to have a special kravana. I think, and I think
- 55:19Speaker 2: he even recites it's us thinking he recites it's a
- 55:21Speaker 2: holy name. Sometimes it will go to mechfield before maybe
- 55:26Speaker 2: even today, before writing it.
- 55:27Speaker 3: Uh.
- 55:28Speaker 2: And then there's letters that are on holy even though
- 55:30Speaker 2: named Eloheim Elohimahirim that sound in Yeshiva, we'd always say
- 55:34Speaker 2: l Mariam and the red uf el Us. No, no, there,
- 55:36Speaker 2: it's Elohima Irim because it's foreign gods. That's not a
- 55:39Speaker 2: holy name. The hustom sources is not holy and therefore
- 55:43Speaker 2: the soufiing are not the kadish that name. And what's
- 55:47Speaker 2: the hustom Sofur's proof. Take a look at unculus Uncles
- 55:51Speaker 2: does not translate bakedale based bagda oha. What is he right?
- 55:56Speaker 2: He doesn't translate it the house of God, the word
- 55:59Speaker 2: he would use if it's holy. He just writes bedel.
- 56:02Speaker 2: So it's just a city name, that's all. So I
- 56:05Speaker 2: said to Rabbi Bazoums. I don't know why it's so
- 56:08Speaker 2: simple to you that with selfer and the positions of that,
- 56:15Speaker 2: it's it's not a holy name. Why do you feel
- 56:17Speaker 2: that when you write it you should have the line?
- 56:20Speaker 2: I said, do you really both think that the meaning
- 56:22Speaker 2: of Beakedeal was bagda lha house of God? And then
- 56:27Speaker 2: I said, there regal, there are many synagogues in America
- 56:31Speaker 2: that are called Bethel. And I said, but with regarding
- 56:34Speaker 2: these synagogues, there's no question that when they say hell,
- 56:36Speaker 2: they refer to God. Every synagogue and an Orthodox synagogues
- 56:40Speaker 2: too are called Bethel. And yet when they use the word,
- 56:43Speaker 2: are they not naming it after a city they intended
- 56:46Speaker 2: to mean house of God. Well, if that's the case,
- 56:49Speaker 2: I said, I don't know why the rabbi is never
- 56:51Speaker 2: rebuked the ballabat Dame that you should call a synagogue
- 56:54Speaker 2: Bethel because when you write the name Bethel, then you
- 56:57Speaker 2: are really writing God's name, because they ended the mean
- 57:00Speaker 2: house of God. So these are the two questions I
- 57:03Speaker 2: have for of Mazus. One, I guess with Kula that
- 57:05Speaker 2: we should be able to say Daytel, we're send the
- 57:07Speaker 2: lighter to Daytel, because Sofur and others and others that
- 57:11Speaker 2: what about all these shows, including Orthodox goals that I
- 57:15Speaker 2: think in Newton, isn't it where where where you can
- 57:17Speaker 2: type it in where they're our shows are at Bethel.
- 57:20Speaker 2: They're definitely in Brooklyn. I think you even have the
- 57:22Speaker 2: Bethel people can write it in where they know of
- 57:26Speaker 2: Bethel Orthodox synagogues. And that's I said, that's a problem.
- 57:29Speaker 2: How do we allow synagogues that have the name Bethel
- 57:34Speaker 2: if it's God's name? So I see we're already at
- 57:38Speaker 2: the end. So we will will get the answers next week,
- 57:42Speaker 2: and we'll also actually it's a good time to then
- 57:44Speaker 2: speak about this whole issue of saying God's name. We're
- 57:46Speaker 2: gonna see it dispute between Ashkenazim and swardin Spardin don't
- 57:50Speaker 2: even believe in saying things like kale et cetera. Oh
- 57:53Speaker 2: there you go, brokeerk. That's right, young Isrobetho. That's where
- 57:55Speaker 2: I spoke it. That was the I spoke last year.
- 57:58Speaker 2: Burrough who was there, it was with us. Fact Borah
- 58:00Speaker 2: who's with us. He will testify next week we speak
- 58:03Speaker 2: about sotmore or what he's where he brought me. So
- 58:07Speaker 2: you see my Sotner connections. But uh, I think I
- 58:10Speaker 2: guess that fell and young Is are different synagogues namerge.
- 58:12Speaker 2: How do the rabbis allow us to call synagogues bethel?
- 58:16Speaker 2: So we will get to the questions. We'll get to
- 58:18Speaker 2: Rabbi Mazu's answer next week. A couple other interesting things
- 58:22Speaker 2: we'll see from Rabbi Mazou's trump, how to understand the
- 58:27Speaker 2: meaning of sooking based on the trump? And are we
- 58:30Speaker 2: down to the truck? We'll see that next week. And
- 58:32Speaker 2: Rabbi doctors wait to hear the Kannai the extremist Mark Shapiro,
- 58:36Speaker 2: what he says about rabbi doctors and how Rabbi Mazus
- 58:39Speaker 2: speaking as one myself. But but how Rabbi Mazous defends
- 58:43Speaker 2: the Rabbi doctors because after all the reshow name uh,
- 58:47Speaker 2: We'll get to that, and then we'll move into the
- 58:49Speaker 2: into sotmore. What is Mark Shapiro doing with one of
- 58:53Speaker 2: the greatest sotmer tell me and my relationship to Sotmar
- 58:59Speaker 2: and sot Mar. We're going to criticize him, no question,
- 59:02Speaker 2: but they really get a bad rap. There is so
- 59:04Speaker 2: much good and sot mare which people don't usually see.
- 59:08Speaker 2: And we will get to that next class. Time flies
- 59:13Speaker 2: oh when when we remign Jool, we'll hear that I
- 59:17Speaker 2: will be here next week before I get to the questions,
- 59:19Speaker 2: but double next week because Nichol Christmas Eve I we're
- 59:22Speaker 2: getting a special talk, special class on shouldn't we be
- 59:26Speaker 2: studying Torah on that night? And we'll get to that. Yes, okay,
- 59:32Speaker 2: Rob Matanki, that was the name of the rabbi, so
- 59:33Speaker 2: anyone's interested. Rob Daliodov Schwartz h really a great time
- 59:37Speaker 2: of fuckholm the based and not just in Chicago but
- 59:39Speaker 2: the RCA. You can read what he wrote in their house.
- 59:42Speaker 2: And Daniel Chill says Schwartz's first job was in a
- 59:45Speaker 2: rabbi in Providence. In fact, in the yeah, well this
- 59:54Speaker 2: actually the Safer is written when I believe when he say, uh,
- 1:00:01Speaker 2: let me pull it up for you to show you
- 1:00:02Speaker 2: when he was a rabbi. Then he was an English town.
- 1:00:08Speaker 2: He has a haskama there from Varro and Cutler in
- 1:00:11Speaker 2: the Safer Ravarron Cutler was yeah, the same first called
- 1:00:16Speaker 2: I'm looking at it now, Devray Reggash. Now this is
- 1:00:19Speaker 2: fifty nine. This is after he was in Providence. This
- 1:00:21Speaker 2: is he was an English town, New Jersey. He was
- 1:00:25Speaker 2: also in problem he was. He was not a student
- 1:00:28Speaker 2: of the ROV by the way, Schwartz. Of course anyone
- 1:00:31Speaker 2: who was at Yeshiva College Ushan had relationships with the
- 1:00:35Speaker 2: Rov R six year, but he was not. He was
- 1:00:37Speaker 2: uh the palao. I think also romotion, shots, kiss and
- 1:00:43Speaker 2: in other words, who were the lift shuts. But the
- 1:00:47Speaker 2: Rove was not like you think of people who are
- 1:00:50Speaker 2: went through yu with the ROV. That was not his
- 1:00:53Speaker 2: main rebby. I don't even know if he was ever
- 1:00:55Speaker 2: even in the sheer. Larry says, I wonder if this
- 1:01:02Speaker 2: has to do with what they were using for light.
- 1:01:04Speaker 2: When I used to use candles, I use the shamash
- 1:01:06Speaker 2: both for the lighting and afterwards to be the youthful light.
- 1:01:09Speaker 2: But now that I use oil, I have one oil
- 1:01:11Speaker 2: light used to serve as a youthful light, but I
- 1:01:13Speaker 2: light the other lights with a flame starter. I wonder, okay,
- 1:01:18Speaker 2: what they use nair, we use this candle. They don't
- 1:01:21Speaker 2: mean candle, they mean and when the when the Gamarra
- 1:01:26Speaker 2: speaks about neare, it means a what's the what's the
- 1:01:30Speaker 2: word I'm looking for? Not a not a jug but
- 1:01:34Speaker 2: a lamp? There, thank you Ellen, And that's that's the shot.
- 1:01:41Speaker 2: Of when you're learning on Friday night. You can't learn
- 1:01:46Speaker 2: next to the nare because you'll tilt it. I mean
- 1:01:48Speaker 2: you'll tilt it if it's a candle, you know't uh.
- 1:01:50Speaker 2: But but because though the oil starts going out, so
- 1:01:53Speaker 2: you move it so that the oil then continues and
- 1:01:56Speaker 2: you can so I don't know. I don't think so.
- 1:01:59Speaker 2: I don't think it has to do with that. What
- 1:02:02Speaker 2: you suggest. And you wonder why you light the useful
- 1:02:05Speaker 2: light last, it seems that you should light it first.
- 1:02:07Speaker 2: There's no time you would be making use of the
- 1:02:09Speaker 2: sacred lights. You have to look in the tour. The
- 1:02:12Speaker 2: tour has asked this question. He said, you make the braha,
- 1:02:15Speaker 2: then you light everything, and then afterwards then you light
- 1:02:19Speaker 2: the other light. If you light it, I guess you
- 1:02:22Speaker 2: could light it. Let me read you what the tour says.
- 1:02:28Speaker 2: You could light it. I guess beforehand. But that wasn't
- 1:02:32Speaker 2: the practice because I probably the reason is because the
- 1:02:35Speaker 2: first thing you're supposed to do, the mitza the midst
- 1:02:38Speaker 2: is the first thing you do, then you do the
- 1:02:39Speaker 2: other thing. If you do that, that's what I'm thinking.
- 1:02:41Speaker 2: You just stop. On the top of my head. It's
- 1:02:42Speaker 2: not the midso, so you wouldn't do that, And uh
- 1:02:49Speaker 2: Mel says, are poetic forms of words, This says kuma
- 1:02:51Speaker 2: azer cicero, which is a better form of coom. Yes, well,
- 1:02:54Speaker 2: that we have all the time. That's called the cordative.
- 1:02:57Speaker 2: That's the technical term in uh in Biblical Hebrews cohertative.
- 1:03:02Speaker 2: And there's another type like eschmerah, whyesmore schabat eschmera, I
- 1:03:08Speaker 2: shall indeed.
- 1:03:10Speaker 3: You have that.
- 1:03:11Speaker 2: That's not the cordative. I forget what that's called. In English.
- 1:03:13Speaker 2: The coherdative is like let us niche marahab let us
- 1:03:18Speaker 2: observe shabat versus eschmerah, or I will indeed observe shaba.
- 1:03:23Speaker 2: I don't know really. If you look in the grammars,
- 1:03:25Speaker 2: they always say that hey, at the ending, when it's
- 1:03:27Speaker 2: not the coerdative, when it's the other term which I
- 1:03:29Speaker 2: can't remember these fancy terms, that it's uh emphatic. But
- 1:03:34Speaker 2: I don't think so. I think that's correct, that it's
- 1:03:36Speaker 2: more poetic. David says another rhymnistics partials. When you promises
- 1:03:42Speaker 2: his father toak that involve at the end of both
- 1:03:50Speaker 2: of them, which interesting is a brilliant rhetorical tool to
- 1:03:52Speaker 2: win over the argument with Yako for using to bring
- 1:03:55Speaker 2: down the young by Huda using Yako's own words he
- 1:03:57Speaker 2: had used, Uh, I mean uh if I'm pronouncing you right,
- 1:04:03Speaker 2: very nice, Okay. The difference is, though, that what I
- 1:04:06Speaker 2: showed you osa osaka is that that's not a normal form.
- 1:04:13Speaker 2: That's not even a regular form. That's just like a
- 1:04:15Speaker 2: form used just to rhyme with the kaka osa uh.
- 1:04:19Speaker 2: And that that was pointed out by Grossman in his book.
- 1:04:22Speaker 2: I had never known that or thought of that. So
- 1:04:24Speaker 2: it's a you can see on hebrewbooks dot org. It's
- 1:04:26Speaker 2: a nice if you're interested in these sort of things.
- 1:04:28Speaker 2: It's a nice book.
- 1:04:29Speaker 3: Uh.
- 1:04:30Speaker 2: Helthic's in English. And one says that the Central Asian singing,
- 1:04:37Speaker 2: the accents weren't as you said. I'll have to listen
- 1:04:40Speaker 2: to it again, I said, certainly, mouth was I thought.
- 1:04:44Speaker 3: Uh.
- 1:04:45Speaker 2: Someone privately says that if you listen to ben O
- 1:04:47Speaker 2: Weis's rendition of Adonolum, which is said out a loud
- 1:04:49Speaker 2: and no shoes will keep menshnas all our milerra everything
- 1:04:54Speaker 2: is include melech and also a ira. You may also
- 1:05:00Speaker 2: find it I'm a home mauritious ashkna site. I tried
- 1:05:03Speaker 2: to get for the renditions of ben Oies there in Dartmouth,
- 1:05:07Speaker 2: but so far they haven't yet given me permission. And
- 1:05:12Speaker 2: then you say the fact that it's not set out
- 1:05:14Speaker 2: out of being a dobbining for all to hear the tradition,
- 1:05:17Speaker 2: and for all to hear the tradition from this pronunciation
- 1:05:20Speaker 2: is lost. That's right, we don't say it anymore. Incidentally,
- 1:05:22Speaker 2: the it seems that it was originally supposed to be
- 1:05:29Speaker 2: said at night. I don't know, or if not at night,
- 1:05:32Speaker 2: first thing in the morning, because remember ishan va ai
- 1:05:35Speaker 2: rah so uh, I shouldn't say at night in the morning,
- 1:05:38Speaker 2: that's the original place to say it, right when you
- 1:05:40Speaker 2: get up, because you said I gave my soul to God.
- 1:05:43Speaker 2: And now that I get up he as, I.
- 1:05:46Speaker 5: Had the privilege of learning a don't a long word
- 1:05:48Speaker 5: for word.
- 1:05:48Speaker 4: We're a broyer, and I asked the question why the
- 1:05:52Speaker 4: many shoes not say it? He said, it's about because
- 1:05:54Speaker 4: it's all a couple of amshumyam, and you should everyone
- 1:05:58Speaker 4: should be studying dobbining with I don't alone.
- 1:06:01Speaker 2: Okay, thank you for that, Howard, I don't know why
- 1:06:05Speaker 2: we don't say it the usual Susanna says, the usual
- 1:06:08Speaker 2: truth for the is like that also accents in the
- 1:06:11Speaker 2: wrong place. Yeah, And I think my point basically that
- 1:06:13Speaker 2: the sum up is that we have plenty of examples
- 1:06:16Speaker 2: in the dobbining that the accents are in the wrong.
- 1:06:18Speaker 2: They really are in the wrong, but it's not such
- 1:06:20Speaker 2: a big deal because it's a song, so songs we
- 1:06:23Speaker 2: can it doesn't really change the meaning unless it's of
- 1:06:26Speaker 2: perfect and it's above. But my point with I don't
- 1:06:29Speaker 2: know m is it's not, you know, wrong, because the
- 1:06:31Speaker 2: python himself wanted you to sing it that way. That's
- 1:06:35Speaker 2: how he wrote it. Oh yes, Barry says, rebegation siegull showl,
- 1:06:42Speaker 2: that's Bethel. Yes, that's what I was thinking of. What
- 1:06:45Speaker 2: about g DSD rather than go o D. That's the dispute.
- 1:06:50Speaker 2: There are some who say it's there's no reason to
- 1:06:52Speaker 2: do that, and others say no, that God's name, even
- 1:06:55Speaker 2: in non Hebrew languages, also has to have uh shouldn't
- 1:07:01Speaker 2: be written, It shouldn't be raced. I should say there
- 1:07:04Speaker 2: also shouldn't be written.
- 1:07:05Speaker 5: Some would say yeah, uh.
- 1:07:08Speaker 2: Ah, so then I didn't really I forgot this. I
- 1:07:10Speaker 2: read this. Yeah. Bark says that Regalia of Schwartz was
- 1:07:13Speaker 2: the young rabbi, the youngest all Borough Park years ago,
- 1:07:16Speaker 2: the one we've been speaking about. He gave the he
- 1:07:19Speaker 2: took over the daff Yomi in Burrough Park, I believe
- 1:07:22Speaker 2: after by Schmulkommen Mursky who took it over. And then
- 1:07:26Speaker 2: I think, uh, that that was the big duff yon
- 1:07:29Speaker 2: me I when I ask, can I make my article
- 1:07:34Speaker 2: on little available to participants? Well, they are. The talk
- 1:07:38Speaker 2: is going to have new stuff, lots of good new stuff.
- 1:07:41Speaker 2: But if I make it available beforehand, no one's gonna
- 1:07:44Speaker 2: want to come and hear me. So I will, uh,
- 1:07:47Speaker 2: And we do have there's an earlier version that we
- 1:07:49Speaker 2: put online, but this is before YouTube and it was
- 1:07:51Speaker 2: nine years ago. So Rabbi Kellman things putting on one
- 1:07:54Speaker 2: more time so everyone could hear it and go on YouTube.
- 1:07:58Speaker 2: And uh, who remembers it. I'm like you who listens
- 1:08:00Speaker 2: to it every year. Most people don't remember it. And finally,
- 1:08:06Speaker 2: rab Mel says my Rabbi quota of Ramone's new Safer
- 1:08:09Speaker 2: and a shiro Tonight. Ramone says one can like either
- 1:08:13Speaker 2: before or after the other candles. Well, Normally we think
- 1:08:19Speaker 2: of the shamash as the one you used to light
- 1:08:21Speaker 2: the candles. The problem is, if you have one of
- 1:08:24Speaker 2: these oil lambs, you have a shamash, but you can't
- 1:08:25Speaker 2: really use it to light, and so they use another candle.
- 1:08:28Speaker 2: When you like the shamash, you don't need the shamash.
- 1:08:30Speaker 2: Shamash is not uh, you know, it's not how almost
- 1:08:33Speaker 2: we've seen now you're in the gamara. But but if
- 1:08:35Speaker 2: you do have it, you can't have it. On the
- 1:08:36Speaker 2: same line things like that, Daniel says the anymology of
- 1:08:41Speaker 2: doctors from the Latin meaning teacher rabbi means teacher rabbi
- 1:08:44Speaker 2: doctor is redundant. No, I would disagree, because doctor is
- 1:08:48Speaker 2: telling you you haven't You've been awarded based on nontover knowledge.
- 1:08:52Speaker 2: That's why you're given doctor the rabbi. Although the whole
- 1:08:56Speaker 2: idea of smich as began in the astronautic world might
- 1:08:59Speaker 2: be bag stun what they were doing at the universities,
- 1:09:02Speaker 2: at least that's what the critics said. But doctor is
- 1:09:04Speaker 2: not for totra knowledge. It's doctor is for either quasi
- 1:09:09Speaker 2: tower knowledge or secular But doctor is important, and I
- 1:09:13Speaker 2: believe Joe Biden should be given her title. She worked
- 1:09:15Speaker 2: for it. And if you don't know what I'm talking about,
- 1:09:18Speaker 2: just google doctor Joe Biden. The blogosphere and the news
- 1:09:21Speaker 2: is going wild about someone who dissed doctor Jill Biden.
- 1:09:30Speaker 1: This series was originally recorded in twenty twenty and twenty
- 1:09:33Speaker 1: twenty one as part of an ongoing lecture series. To
- 1:09:36Speaker 1: sign up to attend the lecture on Zoom, please visit
- 1:09:38Speaker 1: torahmotion dot org. Please rate and review us in your
- 1:09:41Speaker 1: favorite podcast app, or even better, tell a friend to
- 1:09:43Speaker 1: give the podcast to listen