Latest / eMotors: Electric Revolution / Continuous Power vs. Peak Power: Defining the Homologation Difference in Electric Cars
Transcript
- 0:09Welcome to the deep dive. Today we're tackling something
- 0:13that really puzzles a lot of people about electric cars.
- 0:16It's this power paradox. That's a good way to put it.
- 0:19You drive an EV, maybe for the first time, and it just feels
- 0:23incredibly responsive, right? Absolutely.
- 0:25You touch the pedal and it just goes.
- 0:27Feels really powerful. But then you look at the
- 0:30official registration, the paperwork, you know that that
- 0:33that decides your taxes and. The power number listed there
- 0:35seems, well, almost laughably low sometimes.
- 0:39Exactly. It doesn't seem to match the
- 0:40experience at all. So why?
- 0:43Why does the loss seem to treat these quick electric cars like
- 0:47they're much less powerful? That's our mission today.
- 0:51We're diving into this gap between the power you actually
- 0:53feel behind the wheel and the power number you end up paying
- 0:56taxes on. And to do that, we really need
- 0:58to get clear on two key terms. There's the Potenza amalgata,
- 1:03what's called the homologated or continuous power.
- 1:05Right, the official one. And then there's a Potenza de
- 1:07Pico, the peak power, which is usually much higher.
- 1:10And I understand there's a specific rule behind all this.
- 1:12Yes, the framework for this is largely set by an international
- 1:16standard. It's the European Regulation,
- 1:19UNES 85, that's the rule book that dictates how these power
- 1:23ratings are measured, how they get certified and really
- 1:26crucially, which number actually ends up on the official
- 1:29documents. OK, let's start there then.
- 1:31The official number, the one on the registration document that
- 1:34the government uses continuous power.
- 1:37What exactly is that number measuring?
- 1:39Right. So continuous power or sometimes
- 1:41called net maximum power, it's defined in a very specific way
- 1:44by that regulation. It's the average power the
- 1:47motor, along with its battery and cooling systems, can
- 1:50consistently deliver over a full 30 minute period. 30 minutes
- 1:54while holding the accelerator pedal completely down.
- 1:57That's the test. Full throttle for half an hour
- 2:00straight. Wow.
- 2:01That sounds pretty demanding. It's designed to push the system
- 2:04hard, isn't it? It absolutely is.
- 2:06And here's the critical part, especially for EVs, that 30
- 2:09minute test is essentially a thermal stress test.
- 2:12Thermal. So heat is the limiting factor.
- 2:14Precisely. For an older internal combustion
- 2:17engine, you know it could often run near its peak power for
- 2:20ages. But for an electric vehicle,
- 2:23pulling maximum power generates a lot of heat in the battery, in
- 2:27the motor itself. I see.
- 2:29So the continuous power figure isn't just some arbitrary legal
- 2:33definition, it's actually tied to the car's ability to manage
- 2:37heat. It's a kind of thermal safety
- 2:38rating you've. Got it.
- 2:40That lower number reflects the maximum output the whole system,
- 2:44especially the battery management system.
- 2:45The BMS can sustain without risking overheating, damage, or
- 2:49compromising the battery's long term health or safety.
- 2:52So the car is designed to protect itself, throttling back
- 2:55after an initial burst. Exactly, it pulls back to stay
- 2:58within safe operating temperatures.
- 3:00That continuous power rating is the legally certified maximum
- 3:03for prolonged safe operation. OK, that makes sense for the
- 3:06official cautious number. But what about the power that
- 3:09gives you that acceleration? The fun part?
- 3:13Let's talk peak power. Right, peak power.
- 3:15That's the number that aligns more with what you feel.
- 3:17It's the absolute maximum power the motor can pump out
- 3:20instantaneously. This relies on drawing the
- 3:23maximum possible current from the battery, but, and this is
- 3:27key, only for very short durations.
- 3:29We're talking maybe just a few seconds, so.
- 3:31Perfect for those quick bursts you need, like getting onto the
- 3:34motorway or overtaking someone quickly.
- 3:37Exactly. It's a temporary surge the
- 3:39system can handle because it's not sustained long enough to
- 3:42cause thermal issues. It knows it will dial back
- 3:45quickly to the sustainable continuous level.
- 3:47And crucially, this peak power number, it doesn't show up on
- 3:52the registration, does it? No, absolutely not.
- 3:54That's a really important point for anyone looking into EVs.
- 3:57Peak power is not on the official registration document.
- 4:00You'll typically find that figure, the much higher one
- 4:03buried somewhere in the manufacturer's technical spec
- 4:05sheets. Sometimes it's not even easy to
- 4:07find. OK, so this split personality,
- 4:10the sort of Jekyll and Hyde thing with EV power ratings, Why
- 4:14is this mainly an EV issue? When I think about a traditional
- 4:19petrol or diesel car, we don't usually talk about two different
- 4:23power figures like this. That's a great question.
- 4:25The fundamental difference is in how they deliver power and
- 4:28manage heat. For decades with internal
- 4:31combustion engine vehicles or IC cars, the maximum power figure
- 4:36they advertised, that was pretty much the power the engine could
- 4:39sustain, more or less. You mean if a petrol car said
- 4:42150 horsepower, you could theoretically drive it using
- 4:45close to 150 horsepower for a long time?
- 4:47Generally, yes, within reason of course.
- 4:49You might run out of fuel or eventually hit some mechanical
- 4:51limit, but the advertised peak power was much closer to its
- 4:55continuous capability. So simplifying it for a gas
- 4:59CarMax, power roughly equals continuous power, and that
- 5:02single number went on the paperwork.
- 5:03That's a fair summary, but E VS because of those thermal limits
- 5:06we talked about, they just operate differently.
- 5:09For an electric car, the peak power potential is always
- 5:11significantly higher than its rated continuous power.
- 5:14And that technical difference has big implications.
- 5:17The car uses the High Peak power for performance, for that
- 5:21acceleration feel right. But the legal and tax side of
- 5:24things only cares about the lower continuous power rating,
- 5:28that 30 minute average. Exactly.
- 5:30That's the number used for classification for insurance
- 5:33groups sometimes, and definitely for taxation in many places.
- 5:36Right, this is where it gets really interesting, isn't it?
- 5:38Connecting the engineering back to your wallet?
- 5:40I mean, shouldn't the real performance number be the
- 5:43official one? It almost sounds like
- 5:45manufacturers are maybe legally but still sort of gaming the
- 5:48system. I can see why you'd say that,
- 5:50but you could also see the UNSR 85 regulation differently.
- 5:54It's not really defining performance in the way a driver
- 5:57feels it. It's defining sustainable
- 5:59output. And by setting that official bar
- 6:01based purely on the tough 30 minute continuous test, the
- 6:05regulation actually creates a pretty significant economic
- 6:08advantage for the EV owner. Well, it lets car makers deliver
- 6:12that really satisfying temporary performance, the instant torque,
- 6:16the quick zip off the line without sticking the owner with
- 6:19the higher taxes and potentially higher insurance costs that
- 6:22usually come with a car rated at that higher power level.
- 6:27So it kind of optimizes the car for how people actually use
- 6:29them, especially in cities. Lots of short bursts of
- 6:32acceleration, not many 30 minute flat out runs.
- 6:35And it does that without the financial penalty.
- 6:37Precisely, you get the practical performance benefits without the
- 6:40traditional financial downsides of high horsepower on paper.
- 6:44OK, let's make this really concrete.
- 6:45You mentioned the Renault Twingo Electrica is a good example.
- 6:48Yes, the Twingo EV is a perfect case study for how this works in
- 6:52practice. If you check its official
- 6:54registration documents, the Potenza Continua Amalgada, the
- 6:57continuous power is listed as just 31 kilowatts. 31 kilowatts,
- 7:02OK, converting that, that's around 42 horsepower, right?
- 7:0442 CV. Exactly 42 horsepower, which on
- 7:07paper for a modern car sounds incredibly modest, almost like a
- 7:11small motorbike or a scooter. That's the number the tax
- 7:14authorities are looking at. But if you dig into Renault's
- 7:17technical specifications, you find the Potenza Massima, the
- 7:21peak power figure, and that's 60 kilowatts. 60 kilowatt peak.
- 7:25OK, what's that in horsepower? That translates to about 82 CV
- 7:29or 82 horsepower. So it officially looks like a 42
- 7:33horsepower car, but when you actually accelerate, it's
- 7:35delivering almost double that 82 horsepower.
- 7:38That's it. You're so look at that.
- 7:40The Twingo EV is fiscally rated exactly where the base Fiat 127
- 7:44was decades ago, around 42 CV. But when you put your foot down
- 7:48in the Twingo, you get 82 CV peak.
- 7:51That's significantly more punch than even the sporty Fiat 127
- 7:54had back then. Absolutely.
- 7:56And think about how you got the power in the Fiat 127.
- 7:58You had to Rev the engine high, work the gearbox.
- 8:02It was noisy, maybe a bit vibe, and the power built up
- 8:05gradually. Right, you had to work for.
- 8:06It whereas the Tingo EV, it gives you that 82 horsepower
- 8:09peak pretty much silently and instantly thanks to the electric
- 8:12motors torque. It just scoots away from
- 8:14traffic. Lights, Yeah, when the tax bill
- 8:15comes. You're paying based on the 42 CV
- 8:18continuous rating, the thermal limit number, not the 82 CV you
- 8:22actually use for acceleration. Let's quickly touch on top
- 8:25speed, though, just for fairness.
- 8:27The Fiat 127 could manage maybe 100 and 35140 kilometers per
- 8:31hour. Like.
- 8:32That, yeah. And the Twingo EV, It's top
- 8:34speed is limited to around A130135 kilometers per hour.
- 8:38That's right, and that similarity and top speed is
- 8:41actually quite telling. How so?
- 8:43It shows that ultimate top speed depends on more than just raw
- 8:46horsepower. Aerodynamics, gearing, weight,
- 8:49they all play a huge role, especially in small cars.
- 8:52But the way you get towards that top speed, the acceleration, the
- 8:55ease of driving, that's where the E VS peak power makes a
- 8:58world of difference compared to the old Fiat 127.
- 9:02Even if there are continuous ratings and top speeds look
- 9:04similar on paper, the Twingo gives you that 82 CV burst when
- 9:08needed, making it feel much more capable in normal driving while
- 9:12staying fiscally modest at 42 CV.
- 9:15OK, it's much clearer now. That number on the EVs
- 9:17registration, the 30 minute continuous power figure, it's
- 9:21really just a baseline. It's the legally defined minimum
- 9:23for sustained use, dictated mostly by heat management.
- 9:26Exactly. It was never meant to represent
- 9:28the car's sprinting ability or that immediate feeling of power.
- 9:31And this distinction, this focus on continuous power in the
- 9:34regulations, it seems to perfectly suit the strengths and
- 9:37weaknesses of current EV tech, especially for city cars.
- 9:40It really does. Manufacturers can leverage that
- 9:43Unis R-85 focus on sustained power, something EVs are
- 9:47inherently limited in compared to their peak output, to keep
- 9:50the official taxable power rating low.
- 9:53But at the same time, they can maximize that short burst peak
- 9:56power, which is precisely what makes driving in urban
- 9:59environments feel effortless and responsive.
- 10:02So the regulation itself almost encourages this type of design.
- 10:06Because the rules focus on that 30 minute endurance test,
- 10:09engineers have an incentive to create systems that deliver
- 10:12fantastic temporary power, knowing that this peak
- 10:15performance won't lead to higher taxes or registration costs
- 10:18associated with that higher number.
- 10:20That's a really insightful way to look at it, yes.
- 10:22It raises A fascinating question for the future, doesn't it?
- 10:25How does this specific regulatory approach
- 10:27fundamentally shape how performance is designed, valued
- 10:30and even marketed in modern cars?
- 10:32Because if the legal framework allows for this high feeling of
- 10:35performance while classifying the car officially as low power,
- 10:38it makes the EV an incredibly smart choice for city use.
- 10:41Efficient on paper, efficient for your wallet, and
- 10:43surprisingly zippy on the actual Rd.
- 10:45A brilliant summary. The power you feel versus the
- 10:48power you pay for, the EV power Paradox explained.
- 10:52This has been a fascinating deep dive.