Latest / Newcomer Pod / Substack's Index Fund of Culture (with Chris Best and Hamish McKenzie)
Transcript
- 0:01Hey, it's Eric newcomer. We've got a great episode for
- 0:03you this week. I went to sub Sachs offices to
- 0:06interview subjects, CEO, Chris fast, and co-founder Hamish
- 0:09McKenzie had a really fun conversation.
- 0:12The company has released notes which is a basically a Twitter
- 0:16copycat though. I'm sure they wouldn't want to
- 0:18frame it that way but micros social messaging platform which
- 0:22sort of moves them further Beyond just publishing
- 0:25newsletters like my own. I recently invested five
- 0:29thousand dollars. Is in sub Stacks Community
- 0:32round, I publish on sub stack. So this is the rare and
- 0:36hopefully just singular case where I don't have to editorial
- 0:40Independence. I think that said you can see, I
- 0:42can't help myself but ask probing questions, we talked
- 0:45about the fight with Elon Musk and Twitter and of course, Chris
- 0:49past was on the verge is podcast.
- 0:52I think by Chris's own estimation flubbed the interview
- 0:56with him about how subsequent handle racism on its Form.
- 1:00So we get into that. So a fun and timely interview
- 1:03with a company that I think a ton about so I think you'll
- 1:07enjoy it before we get to the episode.
- 1:09I want to thank our sponsor vanta who has been such a great
- 1:13supporter of the newcomer podcast newcomers brought to you
- 1:17by vanta to close and grow customers.
- 1:19You have to earn trust, but demonstrating your security and
- 1:22compliance can be time. Consuming tedious and expensive
- 1:26until you use vanta Fanta automates up to 90% of the work.
- 1:29For the most sought-after, security and privacy standards,
- 1:33save time and money on compliance with vant has
- 1:36enterprise-ready. Trust management platform for a
- 1:39limited time. Newcomer listeners.
- 1:40Get $1000 off vanta. Go to VA, NT.
- 1:44A.com newcomer to get started and I really am deeply
- 1:49appreciative to vanta for sponsoring this podcast and
- 1:52would love if you would check them out, VA en t, a.com slash
- 1:56newcomer All right. Now my interview with Chris past
- 2:01and Hamish McKenzie co-founders of sub sack at their offices in
- 2:05San Francisco. Give it a listen.
- 2:08Thanks, I'm in subjects offices. This is the most compromised
- 2:12episode I could ever have. I've donated, you know, we're
- 2:15invested just write what the do invested five thousand dollars
- 2:21and obviously, you know, we're closely with your platform, but
- 2:24thanks for having me into the office and great to talk to you
- 2:26both. Thank you.
- 2:28Yeah, yeah. Yeah there's so much to talk
- 2:30about right now but notes is obviously sort of the new
- 2:33exciting future so I'm curious. Yeah.
- 2:37What What sort of your view on how the notes rollout has gone
- 2:41so far? We're really pleased with it.
- 2:43We're pleased with how the feature Works.
- 2:45We've been really pleased with how writers have received it.
- 2:49The launch itself. Got a little bit more attention
- 2:52than we expected. Is that good or bad?
- 2:54Most isn't this supposed to be? Yes, I think on the whole I
- 2:56think on the whole that it's good.
- 2:58I think it's on the whole a good thing was a little bit of chaos
- 3:01but we don't mind a little Cass. What was chaotic about it?
- 3:05The problem we had Tessa pated. Having was kind of like Getting
- 3:08everyone to pay attention to this thing you are doing and we
- 3:11sort of had the reverse problem where all of a sudden everybody
- 3:13was paying super close attention to it.
- 3:15Everybody was heralding. It is this very exciting thing
- 3:18that was going on which on the whole is great.
- 3:20It is very exciting by them and it is very exciting.
- 3:23We just we just we were anticipating having to convince
- 3:26people of that, right? And then it just worked out a
- 3:28different way, right? Well, I appreciate that.
- 3:31You're coming back on a podcast after you're on a podcast before
- 3:34and getting grilled over, like the edge case of moderation.
- 3:38Ocean right after launching like sort of a new fish social
- 3:41product so I'm glad you're back in front of the microphone.
- 3:44Yeah, my view on the moderation things, it's a lot for you guys
- 3:48are gonna have to like solve this sort of overtime.
- 3:50Do you see yourself as a totally different company?
- 3:52Now, I guess, having a notes thing, been somewhat resistant
- 3:56to like social or like, how much does it change?
- 3:59How you guys think about the company with this sort of
- 4:01pseudo, social media platform? Now, I think it's an extension
- 4:06philosophically. A lot of the things that we have
- 4:09already been doing, right? One of the things we've been
- 4:11working on for a while is building up the sub stack
- 4:14Network right? The idea that on sub stack, your
- 4:17independent you and your connection with your audience
- 4:19but also you get the benefit of being part of this network being
- 4:23part of this like subscription Network people.
- 4:25Thank you. Mandarin J is pragmatic
- 4:26engineer. So, recommend alert, right,
- 4:31right? So recommendations, are a great
- 4:33example of a feature that works in the network where it's like,
- 4:35hey, you know, writers are recommending other writers,
- 4:39they're sort of, you've got this network feature, but the humans
- 4:42are in charge of how it works and we see notes as sort of an
- 4:46extension of that, right? It works the same way, people
- 4:48are allowed to, you can share short thoughts, you can share a
- 4:51piece of writing you can share quotes.
- 4:52You can recommend stuff. Yeah.
- 4:53But it is it's sort of like this multiplayer piece of the subs
- 4:57deck Universe. It definitely means that we have
- 4:59to update our sort of approach on how some of the stuff works
- 5:03but it doesn't change the sort of philosophically what we're
- 5:05doing. Yeah, we're you guys, totally.
- 5:08Both on undoing Adder, was it? We argue for years.
- 5:11Now, this now we've been such a status of Stack, we thought in
- 5:15wanted to make it a network, not just a tool, but the tool is
- 5:19something you have to start with.
- 5:20But the big game for us as always been how can we make this
- 5:23a network? How can we give people the
- 5:25superpowers of the internet Beyond, just a simple and
- 5:29elegant and beautiful publishing system, the right to collect
- 5:32money easily. And so notes is a natural
- 5:35extension for us writers want to Post short things and share,
- 5:39casual content, and publish them stuff that they don't
- 5:42necessarily want to email to all the subscribers, right?
- 5:44And think readers and I'm both of these people, right?
- 5:47I'm a writer and a reader this way readers want to sometimes
- 5:50snack on stuff from their favorite writers, rather than
- 5:53just being these fully immersed experiences with a long form
- 5:56post or a podcast episode. So, notice in The Sweet Spot for
- 6:00both of those use cases. So far, you know, these social
- 6:03networks are very much defined with how they're designed by,
- 6:06who's on them. And I feel like, Like early on
- 6:09it's like, oh, it's all writers. So it's a fun little, you know,
- 6:12I like nerds the vibe at the moment I mean, that's sort of
- 6:15which funny with the like line of questioning about, you know,
- 6:19the level of moderation. When right now, you have sort of
- 6:22almost like overly polite. Like it's too nice.
- 6:24Yeah. But I mean, I'm going to get
- 6:27into the moderation question, but I want to set it up a
- 6:29different way. I mean, it's sort of funny like,
- 6:33You're almost, you're coming into this, like, oh my God, I
- 6:35almost went to Big like, don't you want it to be as big as
- 6:38possible? And really, like, don't you want
- 6:41to, like, present some sack as like this Foyle to Twitter or
- 6:44like, isn't this a moment where it's like, you're starting to
- 6:47compete with Twitter? Are you not willing to lean into
- 6:49the like direct competition with Twitter?
- 6:52So I say there's a way that we do want to draw that contrast.
- 6:57Yeah like we see this as almost like a battle of competing
- 7:01philosophies or Items like the big vision of what we think of
- 7:05sub stack as, is this new economic engine for culture,
- 7:10right? We're like okay, there was this
- 7:11old class. The first generation of social
- 7:13media companies got built on this one model.
- 7:15Everything had to be free. There's this big land, grab for
- 7:18attention. Yeah.
- 7:19And these giant sort of attention monster money
- 7:22printing, add fueled set of companies grew up in this age
- 7:27and we're tremendously wildly successful at what I did.
- 7:31And You know, I think in retrospect that had certain
- 7:34consequences, it destroyed a lot of the business model, for sort
- 7:40of, written culture, and smart content, without adequately,
- 7:43replacing it, with something, it created a bunch of incentive
- 7:47systems that pull in a certain direction, no matter what your
- 7:50intention is. If the way you make money as
- 7:53maximizing time spent and engagement, cause you're selling
- 7:56ads, the things that you end up optimizing for pull in a certain
- 7:59direction, it has certain consequences.
- 8:01We see sub stack as A whole as being created kind of in
- 8:06opposition to that Trend and kind of in the vacuum that's
- 8:09created by the evolution of that whole ecosystem.
- 8:12Like, the way I think of this as everybody sort of having to
- 8:14become Tick-Tock, right? Right.
- 8:16Like the natural perfect version of the super attention monster
- 8:21social media, people what they want, give the people what they
- 8:23say, and what they want, but what they want in what way,
- 8:26right, what they want in their bassist in their lizard brain,
- 8:29right? And the thing that's, you know,
- 8:30the old version of us, you had to click on it, the new version.
- 8:32A you just don't even have to click on it and just like it's
- 8:34just there you're sort of staring at it.
- 8:36Mesmerised you go there, thinking it's going to take
- 8:39three seconds and you spend five hours.
- 8:41It's the perfect, it's The Logical.
- 8:43Conclusion of that, whole business model of that way of
- 8:48interacting with the audience. We think that there's like this
- 8:50tremendous thing that's working there and it's going to pull
- 8:54everything that's in that mode of working in that same
- 8:57direction, you know, Instagrams. Going to have to become more
- 9:00like Tech talk Twitter's going to become more like Right?
- 9:02And if you as a reader want, something else you're going to
- 9:07feel increasingly ill-served. And so there's going to be this
- 9:10new space where you say, what if I want to go somewhere where I
- 9:15can use my attention wisely, where it's giving me, what I
- 9:18want. Not in sort of the back of my
- 9:21lizard brain of, like, what will I not click a head-on.
- 9:23But what are the things that I value?
- 9:25One of the things that I might choose to, you know, sit back
- 9:29and subscribe to on a Sunday when I'm thinking of how I I
- 9:32want to stay well, informed or what do I actually want to pay
- 9:34the money supply? Almost be aspirational?
- 9:36Or it's like this is the stuff I want to support like people are
- 9:39supporting them and it's also yet sort of a reason like this
- 9:43is, yeah, like we're you know, we're helping you.
- 9:46Ideally we're helping you construct for yourself.
- 9:50The media diet that you want, we're helping you put the things
- 9:53in your mind that you aspire to put there to become more.
- 9:56The person you want to be as opposed to kind of like eroding
- 10:00your defenses to turn you into the person that Basement self.
- 10:03Once those are different things. So in that grand Battle of ideas
- 10:08then yeah, I think sub stack is an anti Twitter.
- 10:10I think it is an anti Tech talk. I think it is an anti, it's a
- 10:13different idea. To all those things sub stack as
- 10:16a whole is built on this different economic system where
- 10:20we don't need to keep you glued to the thing.
- 10:22We want to find you, things that you decide you care about enough
- 10:26to pay for, that's not just a different way to make money from
- 10:28the same stuff. It's the kind of things that you
- 10:30make, as you know, When you're trying to succeed in that system
- 10:34are just different and better better by, you know, who says
- 10:37better, I say better, I think it's better.
- 10:39So it is different in that way. The other way that you could
- 10:41construe it though is and the way that I think a lot of people
- 10:44wanted to construe it is, it's like, oh, like we are mad at
- 10:48Twitter, right? This is a new thing.
- 10:51This is the new Twitter, right? Everyone's going to leave
- 10:53Twitter and come here and that's how it's going to work.
- 10:56And I just that story to me, doesn't ring true, right?
- 10:59That's not the thing that we're building.
- 11:02I saw. Think of it as even if we could
- 11:04do that, we wouldn't want to because that's not the thing we
- 11:07set out to build. But I also don't think that
- 11:09that's how these things work. Basically there's so much to
- 11:12tease a I mean in some ways you were the Free Speech arguing for
- 11:17free speech before you had like the musk Ilan coming in and
- 11:21making Twitter Pro, free speech. So then there's like in terms of
- 11:25like The Branding of the platform and the openness
- 11:29they're sort of like a complicated Ting moment for us.
- 11:34Free speech has never been out. Branding is just something I
- 11:36really like Taylor Stakes. There was, there was a point
- 11:39though, like we're a lot of the conversation around sub-sect was
- 11:42about. Like, people are used to be able
- 11:44to focus on a lot and we are proud to defend Free Speech but
- 11:48we don't we're not like Rumble in which we come out and say we
- 11:52are the free speech platform. Yeah.
- 11:54We're a platform where free speech is protected and defended
- 11:56and that's important. But that's just table Stakes for
- 11:59a good ecosystem, for conversation for Course and
- 12:03we're willing to stick up for it in a pinch as we've shown but
- 12:06it's not kind of, you know, we see it as necessary, but not
- 12:10sufficient to making something great.
- 12:12Where is the brand? Is just like the writers, or
- 12:14what is the first thing you want people to think about?
- 12:17When you talk about sub-sect, I do think it's the writers.
- 12:19I mean, nobody comes to sub stack because they want to get
- 12:25more email, right? Right, not a problem.
- 12:29People have right. Nobody comes to sub stack
- 12:31because Cuz they don't have enough stuff to read because
- 12:34they're it really is, you know, first and foremost.
- 12:36It's what's going to appeal to the writers?
- 12:38The deal we can offer to writers is luck.
- 12:40You're going to be independent, you can have editorial Freedom.
- 12:44Yeah you can have ownership of what you're doing.
- 12:46You have a direct connection with your audience.
- 12:48Yes you're going to have free speech.
- 12:49You're going to be able to write the things you want to write but
- 12:51it's this package of things that's like you're going to be
- 12:54able to do the work that you believe in and if you do a good
- 12:57job, you're going to be able to make a living, may be a fortune
- 13:00doing this thing. And the Independence of that
- 13:03buys, makes it very compelling for readers, because the thing
- 13:07that readers are looking for, is not a theoretical platform with
- 13:11X, Y Zed. It's like, where am I going to
- 13:12get the smartest best, most trustworthy, the things that I
- 13:15value, as I decide to Value them, right?
- 13:18Yeah. We set it up, like before we
- 13:20settled on a new economic engine, for culture, as the
- 13:23mission, which is an updated Mission, we sort of shopped
- 13:27around or satellite that we're trying to build a better future
- 13:29for writing so that system that can help.
- 13:32Typewriters pursue the work that they really think is important
- 13:35and be able to fly like support it by making money from Rita
- 13:38subscriptions it's Central to way.
- 13:40We built sub stacking to can see it in every post that we've
- 13:43written in the history of our amazing blog on subset of a
- 13:47subset of your own, my newsletter promoting yours, and
- 13:50that's the subject. Rewrite should also check out
- 13:53music, you come. And you need to sell the actual
- 13:57newsletter better. In this podcast.
- 13:58Yeah, please make sure you use mansions and all the cost
- 14:00posting features would be accomplished.
- 14:02What is it? Has put aside as podcast guest
- 14:05in the UI. We love that.
- 14:06Are you trying to move Beyond writing?
- 14:08I mean, obviously, you just put in a video embedding feature.
- 14:11You know, this podcast is published through subject but
- 14:13like, is it truly like video and well yeah, sorry, little writing
- 14:17already way you host a bunch of people who are not expressly.
- 14:21Just writers were writing, will always and writers always be
- 14:23part of the DNA of sub stack and will always be Central to our
- 14:27identity, but we're starting to see more and more writers and
- 14:31creators or culture makers generally because some people
- 14:33aren't sub stack. And they think of themselves as
- 14:35podcasters primarily or video makers primarily, or they're
- 14:39sort of shepherds of a community.
- 14:41And I think we think there's there's room for that to expand
- 14:44over time. And so I personally have a broad
- 14:47definition of writers. I think a podcaster is a racer.
- 14:49I think a Movie Maker as a racer, but we want to have an
- 14:53expansive tent that people can see themselves as part of, and
- 14:57we think the subset model can support all these kinds of
- 15:00creators. Yeah.
- 15:01Alright so back to Switch, I'm super interested in.
- 15:04I've been giving all my feedback and like totally iterate it to
- 15:07me. I think I made I made a note at
- 15:10one point. Basically being like you should
- 15:11give things that like help writers that get the pain
- 15:15audience, right? Or I think one of the
- 15:16complication of notes is this idea that we want the subset
- 15:19platform to reward people who are writing stuff that like
- 15:24people are willing to pay for but then on notes you don't want
- 15:27to just I don't know handicap any new writer and stop them
- 15:31from being able to build a following.
- 15:32Because I happen to be earlier than them.
- 15:34How do you think about using the actual like money as a signal on
- 15:39notes while still keeping it sort of a platform that's
- 15:42appealing to other people right? Chris base question.
- 15:46You've thought about this right? This is certainly something we
- 15:48think we do think that the the money is this important signal
- 15:53and for example you know we have bestseller badges on sub stack
- 15:58where if you're have a certain number of paid subscribers you
- 16:00get a little thing or the purple badge which Is 10,000 paid is
- 16:03almost like more of an incentive to get to 10,000.
- 16:06Maybe I want the money, I'll get the money.
- 16:12All right, that thing works really well, and I think that
- 16:22there's a lot that we can do. You know, when we show
- 16:24leaderboards of one of the top sub Stacks in this category, we
- 16:29rank it by pain. That's a deliberate thing,
- 16:30right? We actually way back.
- 16:32In the day, we had one that was ranked by like how many people
- 16:35liked it and then there's instantly.
- 16:36There. Was people gaming it, right?
- 16:37You're someone that coming in and doing fake stuff and putting
- 16:40fake sign ups on their email list and the beautiful thing
- 16:42about the paid subscriptions is like yet.
- 16:44Go ahead game. It like figure out how to get to
- 16:47the top of this leaderboard, right?
- 16:48Whatever you do. That thing is pretty good.
- 16:51The thing that we don't need to do is sort of like treat that as
- 16:55you know, it's not like having a lot of paid subscriptions gives
- 16:59you this magical superpower that.
- 17:02You know, you get this amplifier where no one else is ever
- 17:05knowing heard, right? The people who have the big
- 17:07subscriptions already have large committed audiences and that's
- 17:11the thing that matters we wanted both of you a place where you
- 17:15sort of get credit for that, where you can have those signals
- 17:18of this is where I'm on something.
- 17:20Like this is all these things but also where, if you're
- 17:22someone who's just getting started, you know, you're not
- 17:24shut out from right, what? I guess to me, I don't have a
- 17:27Content moderation problem on my sub sack because people pay for
- 17:31it if they like it and like, I'm responsive to what readers want.
- 17:34And like, the reason I'm successful in some way is that
- 17:36it's not like unbearably crass, like it goes beyond what any
- 17:39platform would reasonably moderate, right?
- 17:41It's like oh, you have to be proactively good and if healing.
- 17:45So I guess the question is like, are there pieces of what make
- 17:49like sub sack work and sort of Self moderating in a way that
- 17:52you can bring to notes or if you like when you're pushing with
- 17:55the like I don't know. It's a free-for-all and I like
- 17:58on every Edge case I'm going to defend what people can say on.
- 18:02It's you, are you like embracing like the writer piece of it?
- 18:07Yeah, you know you know I'm saying there?
- 18:10Yeah I think maybe you're pointing at, there's a
- 18:11difference between sort of taking a stance in favor of free
- 18:17speech and a free press and not wanting to have like a
- 18:20centralized sort of like censorship system.
- 18:24There's a difference between that and saying, anybody can say
- 18:27everything in any circumstance and that's going to be fine,
- 18:30right? Right?
- 18:31Because that lat Either one is going to lead to a thing.
- 18:34That sucks, right? Like you have a comment section.
- 18:37You're such that you can limited to paid subscriber, you can kick
- 18:39people out, you can set rules, eat on whatever.
- 18:41And there's a little bit of like it's your house, it's your
- 18:43rules. Right?
- 18:44To me, that is not only consistent with the sort of free
- 18:47speech principles actually think it's like a necessary the to
- 18:50have to go together. If you're gonna have a thing
- 18:52that says, we're going to have a place where you can say what you
- 18:54want. Part of that freedom is to say,
- 18:56I'm going to be able to set the Norms in my space with my
- 18:59community and we're going to be able to have a space.
- 19:01That's not only You know, as you said prevents the things that
- 19:04like everybody everywhere agrees we don't want, but I can set the
- 19:07rules in my house to be very strict and therefore the people
- 19:12that come to your comment section can choose to be part of
- 19:15the community. That's got this like very
- 19:18specific norms and values and that is actually very valuable
- 19:22that actually does a better job of creating a space that people
- 19:25want to be. Then if sub stack said,
- 19:27everybody has to be polite to whatever that the global
- 19:30substance that it is because nobody wants to listen.
- 19:32Some company. But it's like, okay, we can
- 19:34organize around like a Creator or exactly.
- 19:36Like the, you know, if we wanted to set up in and set the rules
- 19:39of politeness in your comment section, the best we could do is
- 19:42kind of take an average of what everybody's upset.
- 19:44Once, I'll tell you from experience, the result of that
- 19:47is you will you will please nobody right.
- 19:49And the best you can hope for is to have people that are equally
- 19:51mad on kind of every Side of Everything.
- 19:53Whereas if we say look, you're going to be able to set the
- 19:55rules and you know now not everybody in your audience will
- 19:59be perfectly happy with that but it's your house, you can do it
- 20:01and people can choose to be a part.
- 20:02That and you can create something, and somebody else can
- 20:04have a different space that has different norms.
- 20:07And that's good. Not only is it, okay?
- 20:09It's actively good. Now, the challenge with
- 20:12something like notes exactly how it was.
- 20:14My next, we're sort of we're like, okay, so now there's two
- 20:17writers, interacting with each other.
- 20:19Right. How does that work?
- 20:20Right? There's places where people are
- 20:22allowed to publish your thing. Like how does that work, right?
- 20:24And the approach that we take with this is we want to figure
- 20:28out how to take the parts of that former system that work and
- 20:32apply them to this new world. We want to leave the case where
- 20:35the writers and the readers are in control and this leads to
- 20:39things that are actually dramatically different than what
- 20:41other networks have done. For example, when you do a post
- 20:45on notes, it's your space. You set the rules.
- 20:48The same way, people commenting on your posts, right?
- 20:51Works the same way as if they're commenting on your newsletter
- 20:54post, right? You can go and delete people who
- 20:57comment on your post, you can delete the comment, you can
- 20:59block them, you can ban them, you can, you know, you can have.
- 21:02Of this level of control where you say, this is my space and
- 21:06within my space, we're going to kind of go by these rules and
- 21:10we're still figuring out all of the like there's a lot of, you
- 21:14know, different parts that go into that and what does it mean
- 21:15over here? And what does it mean, if
- 21:17somebody does this and that, but in general, that's the principal
- 21:20were applying. We're kind of trying to say,
- 21:22look, we want you to be able to set your sort of Rules of
- 21:25Engagement, like, who do I want to see, who do I want?
- 21:29How do I want to be able to interact with people?
- 21:30And we want that to make kind of like, A force field that
- 21:33governs, your experience on sub stack and that can be much more
- 21:37specific to the kinds of things you want to do.
- 21:40Like, it's not just like, whatever.
- 21:42Don't call me names, you might say, hey, I want everything to
- 21:44be really productive, which is a kind of standard that would be
- 21:47untenable to have as like, a global rule to be clear.
- 21:51What I want from my notes, I want it to be like, you know, an
- 21:54Ender's Game where, you know, Valentine and like Peter wig in
- 21:58our writing, I like the global forum.
- 21:59This is like, you know, you don't want to come to the Rock.
- 22:02I want to be able to take advantage of the fact.
- 22:03Okay, I have a pretty successful tech one like but now, do I get
- 22:07to I get to argue about like, politics or whatever with the
- 22:09other, you know? I feel like that's the dream and
- 22:12so to me, you think you should become the hegemon.
- 22:14Yeah, exactly right. Exactly.
- 22:15Just for having such great writing and it's Jimmy.
- 22:19That means that it's like a pretty like buttoned up.
- 22:23I mean they're not boring but that it's you know I that's what
- 22:26that's why the when you hear like it's going to be totally
- 22:28unmoderated, it sounds like the opposite of what most of the
- 22:31writers. Is want, which is they want to
- 22:33be in a place where they're like, taking super seriously and
- 22:36like influencing the culture, you know what I mean?
- 22:39Yeah, I mean, I think there's a difference between being able to
- 22:42set norms and participating communities that have very
- 22:44strong norms and the idea that the way to get there is
- 22:48centralized censorship. Yeah, and I think we've come
- 22:51from an era where those two things have been kind of
- 22:53conflated and people think that the only way to get a platform
- 22:57to have a certain characteristic is to have a really strong sort
- 23:00of like centralized set of like Here's the governing rules that
- 23:03affect everybody. We just don't think that's
- 23:05worked very well. We think there's something
- 23:08better that can be made here. So, you know, you got sort of
- 23:10pounded, on the racism, on the platform question, or has your
- 23:14answer at all? Change to when you lay asked
- 23:16about, will you do about sort of a racist incident on the
- 23:19platform know, it's basically the same answer.
- 23:21I mean, I think I did a very bad job in that interview, but I
- 23:24think the answer is look, we do have a Content policy, it's by
- 23:28Design, like it allows a lot of stuff that we don't like it.
- 23:32It bans, only very like extreme things.
- 23:35If people are putting things that are against the overall
- 23:37content policy, they get taken down by us.
- 23:40However, that allows a lot of things that we find very
- 23:42objectionable. And then we try to build a
- 23:44system that puts people in control of what they see and who
- 23:46they interact with image. You and you worked with Ilan,
- 23:50right? You're at test you interact with
- 23:52him personally or yep? Yeah, he hired me.
- 23:55Yeah. So what's it like you guys can
- 23:58decide whether you want to be total foils to him or not?
- 24:01Or like what's it like to be in a pseudo competitive situation
- 24:05with him at the moment? I try to think about you Lon as
- 24:07little as possible. I'm thinking about self stack
- 24:11all the time and what we're trying to do here is not build
- 24:15the anti Twitter or build the ante Instagram or anything like
- 24:18that. We're trying to build the first
- 24:19sub stack and the vision for what we think it can become is
- 24:23an amazing beautiful thing and It's bigger and more important
- 24:28than social media, like a social media for text or social media
- 24:32for pictures or social media for video.
- 24:35I spend all my time thinking about how to make that thing a
- 24:38reality and it's hard just thinking about that.
- 24:40It's hard just to get to year 5 of a network that let's write as
- 24:46publish directly to the audiences and serves so far,
- 24:49mostly just writers. So I don't ya.
- 24:53I'm not thinking. I'm not gonna be totally, ignore
- 24:55the know. Not thinking about them because
- 24:57I mean an awkward thing about the argument of the moment, is
- 25:00it like Twitter in some ways is trying to switch to like just
- 25:04charging people instead of attention, arguably Twitter's
- 25:08trying to kill subset. Yeah, I mean, what do you make
- 25:11like the Blue strategy to me? I mean, it's paying the company
- 25:15rather than a writer or like how would you distinguish like the
- 25:18Blue strategy from your approach and like how that plays out sort
- 25:22of differently in the product? Either of you can answer this
- 25:25strategy? All's totally different.
- 25:27It's like medium on Netflix. Yeah, it's like, you're paying
- 25:31for the platform. I do think in general anything
- 25:34where we're setting writers up to make money from what they're
- 25:39doing, we are in favor of this is you know very important piece
- 25:42of what subject does. It's not the only thing that
- 25:45subject does and this is something that you know we've
- 25:46had people try to copy sub stack in various ways over the years
- 25:53and often what happens is the look at one piece of the A pie
- 25:56and think that that's what it is.
- 25:58So, we went through a wave where a bunch of people looked at some
- 26:00stack and said email newsletters, right?
- 26:03That's what's going on over there.
- 26:04Email newsletters are so good. Facebook, did this Twitter
- 26:07bought a different company? A bunch of the Atlantic design.
- 26:09There's like can use letters. We're going to cut, we're going
- 26:12to make a newsletter thing and that's going to be it in.
- 26:14The newsletter is very important.
- 26:16It's a big part of what a sub stack is, but it's not the whole
- 26:19thing, right? The whole thing is, it's your
- 26:22publication. You own the connection with your
- 26:25audience. Hey you directly you have this
- 26:27independent site that you can do.
- 26:29You can leave some stack with your audience you can bring your
- 26:32audience to sub stack. This piece of that is a huge
- 26:35ship on control I really I can't underline enough it's easy for
- 26:39people to abstract away but the fact that you know I could walk
- 26:42away is key to the relationship working.
- 26:44Well you know. Yeah.
- 26:45It's the difference between me saying, come on, trust us and me
- 26:49saying okay, trust us like we know we know we have to keep
- 26:53entering your trust because you can't leave They're just
- 26:56different relationships to be under with a platform it is
- 26:59fundamentally different and so you know I think with blue it's
- 27:03not really even the same thing at all.
- 27:05There's others some other monetization tools that Twitter
- 27:07is testing that we're excited that they're doing that.
- 27:10I think it helps to be paid but it's still not the same thing
- 27:13right now. They're trying to create crater,
- 27:16do you part of your delicate dance with Twitter is, is it
- 27:20that you think writers your subset Riders are still
- 27:23dependent on Twitter for audience?
- 27:26I don't think they're dependent on it for audience, but I think
- 27:29they are dependent on it in other ways.
- 27:32Let me put it this way. A lot of writers are just heavy
- 27:36Twitter. You can just like it, right?
- 27:38It takes up a lot of their mind, share.
- 27:40A lot of our customers are all. They use it a lot in spite of,
- 27:42not like we use a lot in spite of not liking it or they
- 27:45convince themselves that they need to use it and then because
- 27:48they want to use it a lot. And even though like if you look
- 27:53at exactly the traffic stats like how much traffic is Coming
- 27:56from Twitter, it's really not that much.
- 27:58I don't know if it's that, if if you see this in your neighbors
- 28:01but like, five maybe for me, I mean, obviously my actual
- 28:03newsletter people underestimate just what a large percentage, it
- 28:07is because you're sending it to everybody every time.
- 28:09So yeah emails. Um, and then right and then
- 28:11direct and obviously, Google searches actually becoming a
- 28:15better one over until searches over what I mean that, you know,
- 28:17we've added a bunch of network features that are an order of
- 28:20magnitude more than the actual traffic.
- 28:22But all of that said, it's still a major place where people are
- 28:25spending a lot of time. It's still like a
- 28:26quality-of-life Thing If It just like it just sucks.
- 28:29It sucks. When you can't embed your Tweet
- 28:31and your sub S letter. Like that should just work,
- 28:33right? It sucks that I can't.
- 28:35It doesn't sometimes it messes with my link when I share it
- 28:37it's just hard links working for, what's your view?
- 28:40What's your sense of how throttled it is?
- 28:43I do think that there is some throttle and going on.
- 28:45I think the previews are not being enrolled in some cases and
- 28:49I think in some cases, it's the distribution is different, you
- 28:53know, Andreessen Horowitz is a major sub Wester in a Twitter
- 28:57investor, have you tried to ask them to Broach a piece or
- 29:01anything like that? I mean we've been talking to
- 29:03them about the stuff. We're very much in favor of a
- 29:06piece. We didn't start any of this, we
- 29:08don't think that it makes any sense.
- 29:10Frankly for Twitter to be feuding with sub stack we'd love
- 29:13to not have any of this, not any of his annoying bugs for writers
- 29:19but at the same time it is kind of out of our control.
- 29:21Just today. I like coming into this like
- 29:23Tucker Carlson saying he's going on Twitter.
- 29:26And there's still like this sort of, you know, platforms are
- 29:30identified with the like huge craters on top of them.
- 29:33What sort of sub Stacks view right now in terms of like
- 29:37cording writers, this is going to lead us to the financials
- 29:40that you disclose, what's the view on?
- 29:42Sort of handpicking writers, unlike the strengths and
- 29:45weaknesses of that. For like your strategy, we have
- 29:48always taken an approach of Going in like recruiting
- 29:55specific writers right from the start of some stack, when we've
- 29:59always had, you know, the same way that readers don't come to
- 30:02sub stack because of sub stack, they come to sub stack because
- 30:04of writers, I think the same is true of writers in general.
- 30:08Like there's every kind of pocket of people.
- 30:11The people that come to some stack come because of other
- 30:15people who are on the platform and we've gotten to the point.
- 30:17Now, I think used to worry a lot in the early days about getting
- 30:20identified with some Particular slice.
- 30:22Like you get a pocket of this type of people, and then it's
- 30:25like, well, all of this people are on substract all that people
- 30:27in such tag. I think we successfully got to
- 30:29the point where it, it really does feel like, sort of an index
- 30:33fund of culture. Like you have a bunch of
- 30:35different slices from all across the map.
- 30:37People still have these opinions often hear someone say, oh some
- 30:39stack. That's where, you know, that's
- 30:41all the people of X, Y Zed, but that's just their world.
- 30:43They just happen to know, all those people, and it's one of
- 30:45many world, right? So, I think, you know,
- 30:47recruiting writers, helping them come to some stack, helping them
- 30:50succeed remains a core. Of what we do the piece, where
- 30:55it's something that has changed over time is in the past.
- 30:57We've experimented with using money, as a way to help
- 31:01accelerate that. Yeah, we do something that we
- 31:03did, pretty extensively a couple of years ago, I think with great
- 31:06success, but we no longer have to do basically, since abstract,
- 31:10was not a big believer in you. Come, you guys were willing to
- 31:12give me advance, but you were not like, oh, we're going to
- 31:15break. It might have been sort of tale
- 31:16as the particular timing of that vitamin B.
- 31:19Yeah, but I did it anyway, but you You what we, what we did in
- 31:23the lot of those cases was trying to push people to not
- 31:26take right in advance because the deal is better if you don't
- 31:29the deal, was you keep 90% of your right, right?
- 31:31- this is on the record being very happy.
- 31:37But yeah, but yeah, but you made a smarter Choice by comparison,
- 31:40right? Well, the thing to remember with
- 31:41all of those glaciers everybody, it reverted to the normal
- 31:44substrate. Also, it's not like an ongoing
- 31:46thing, but there was sort of like a moment where, like, let
- 31:48us help you get the start. So that this thing, Turnover,
- 31:52you can see it working. We've done enough of that.
- 31:54The people see it working now and I don't think we have to do
- 31:57that anymore but you're out certain still recruiting writers
- 32:00to come on. It's just not Financial or,
- 32:03yeah. We are always trying to sort of
- 32:05unlock new pockets of writers and look for people who sort of
- 32:09fit the characteristics of whom, I succeed on self stack.
- 32:12But we're not paying advances and partly, that's because the
- 32:16market has changed, and we've been more cautious with our
- 32:18resources and partly it's because the network has been
- 32:21boots. Trap.
- 32:22Now things have their own momentum and we have Network
- 32:25effects that add as much benefit for people as, you know,
- 32:28upfront, cash mine. So like 20% of paid
- 32:31subscriptions across sub, stat come directly from the subset
- 32:34Network. Now it's a, it's a huge benefit.
- 32:37You get just either you don't need all that much more
- 32:40encouragement to come. So, you know, you did this
- 32:42community fundraise. How much did you end up?
- 32:45Getting the maximum? You can do through a community
- 32:48around, is five million dollars? Yeah, do you have the money?
- 32:52I don't even know. I think we're actually not
- 32:54supposed to talk about the specifics of it yet because of
- 32:57like it's not officially closed and it's a police unit the right
- 33:01at first. There was like oh we're just
- 33:02sort of rethinking but there are lots of sort of language games
- 33:06going on and not specific to you.
- 33:09Which is how just wait. Yeah.
- 33:10How do you play nicely with you? See.
- 33:13I think we I think I expect we'll be able to but in the
- 33:15meantime you can go to the page. You can see the things, you can
- 33:17see the thing we're being very careful to like follow the rules
- 33:20basically in Anyone, you had negative Revenue because - yeah
- 33:24- Revenue, which is different, by the way than, that's not just
- 33:28a loss. That's technically, the revenue
- 33:30itself was negative because the way we can try something, right.
- 33:33That's why if you like, look at it without thinking very much,
- 33:36it seems absurd like people who want to criticize your business.
- 33:39It's easy to be like - Revenue that, you know, even the top
- 33:43light. But I mean, you know, the story
- 33:45of that was, we were spending money to bootstrap this network.
- 33:48We publish a bunch of numbers around, how that's gone.
- 33:50What that's meant for people. Or it's pretty clear that it it
- 33:54worked. It's the you were sort of taking
- 33:57a loss on these like advances to writers and those come ahead of
- 34:01Revenue and so then you lose money totally there and whereas
- 34:04if it was after in 2021 is an especially frothy year as well
- 34:07in the end as a market. So it may be in a typical year
- 34:11Ben Thompson, who I'm sure you guys read sort of.
- 34:14I should have reread it before. But like, I mean, she seems to
- 34:17really like racial. Like, me are like suckers for
- 34:20investing in this round, right? He was pretty - he is sort of a
- 34:23complicated subject View and that on the one hand I feel like
- 34:26he wants you guys to actually control the list and thinks you
- 34:29should be sort of more controlled or I don't know any
- 34:32response to been Thompson's riding on sub-sect.
- 34:36I'll tell you what will work really hard to make sure that it
- 34:39goes your way. We can definitely that and we I
- 34:42have tremendous respect for been like, we looked at him as one of
- 34:47the examples that made us think that starting substantially be
- 34:49worth while we talk to him and their early days of I think a
- 34:52lot of his thinking on this stuff is good but he's wrong
- 34:56about this one. He can sometimes have this sort
- 34:58of like I mean he was so successful so early and it's
- 35:02like he he's the one that, you know, the made it, I don't know.
- 35:07And like I can be skeptical about the weather.
- 35:10How big of a trend it will be broadly or whether he sort of
- 35:13set up a somewhat unique situation and he's belts and
- 35:16he's built some cool tools and this rest as well.
- 35:19Like he's right he I think he was now just trying to be He's
- 35:22trying to be a good faith critic, and a good faith,
- 35:24analysts and Beyond some things, we agree with him.
- 35:27Fervently on and some things we just disagree with them on,
- 35:30right? One thing I'm thinking about
- 35:32more is building like a publication on top of sub stack.
- 35:35Like obviously Barry waist is like much further on that
- 35:38Journey. There's like what the ball work
- 35:41is sort of a publication Yang Claire's.
- 35:42Another one? Yeah.
- 35:44Well ER we gotta you gotta have the in front of the name.
- 35:46You gotta do this. Oh yeah.
- 35:47I might not might not make it that the new killer had back.
- 35:53Yeah, which I mean what's the pitch to The Publications?
- 35:56And like, how much? I mean there's sort of a
- 35:58contradiction, right? And I have find this sort of
- 36:00recruiting writers at the moment that I'm having to explain its
- 36:03like come to a sub stack, which I'm doing partially for my
- 36:07Independence but then like you're joining a publication or
- 36:10like how do you think about publications on subsequent a lot
- 36:13of the pitches every person sort of on their own as their own
- 36:18business? I think I look at this through
- 36:22the lens of Institutions and I think especially in the early
- 36:27days of sub stack, a lot of what was happening was, people felt
- 36:31like the especially the writers felt ill-served by the existing
- 36:35institutions either. They weren't aligned with how
- 36:37they wanted operate, or those institutions were struggling and
- 36:40it felt like there wasn't space in the existing institutions for
- 36:43what they wanted to do. And the option was to sort of
- 36:47like go outside and start. Your own thing and like be
- 36:50independent and you know, create this sort of like external
- 36:54pressure and I think that's wonderful and necessary and then
- 36:58the other piece that I'm very excited about that can come from
- 37:01that is the opportunity to build new institutions.
- 37:04And I think you're seeing this the seeds of this with some of
- 37:07the people not every some people on some stack get very
- 37:10successful and make a ton of money and I like this is great,
- 37:12like, right? This is my perfect life.
- 37:14I don't want to be anybody's boss.
- 37:16I don't want to do with this other stuff.
- 37:17I totally understand that. And I, you know, we will, your
- 37:20life could be so easy. Eric, if you just don't invite
- 37:23the others in, we will, you know, we will make sure that sub
- 37:25stack is great for those people because I think that's a
- 37:27wonderful thing. But there are other people who
- 37:30say this actually might be the seed of something new that I
- 37:34could start. I could start a new kind of
- 37:36institution that's grown up in this new world that lives by
- 37:39different rules. And I can build something larger
- 37:42than myself, and I can give an opportunity to other people to
- 37:45come and be a part of it. And we're really excited about
- 37:48that. And we want to make Make sure
- 37:49that you can keep doing that on some stack basically
- 37:52indefinitely. And we've got a bunch of work
- 37:54into you know some of the features that help you with
- 37:57this. We think of it as sort of like
- 37:59media Empire mode. It's something that we're
- 38:01actively building. So the more you build that come
- 38:03and talk to us we'd love to help you make it, wonderful, right.
- 38:07You're not against all institutions just just the bat
- 38:09that's just the ones that don't use some stack yet.
- 38:12Part of what's going on is like you know the high-profile
- 38:14writers get to put themselves on top of these media institutions
- 38:18in the way that they were. Buried under management.
- 38:21Yeah, it's really interesting as a like, right at from the bias.
- 38:24Right? A perspective to see, right has
- 38:26become owners and set the agenda is themselves.
- 38:28I think that's really exciting. Dynamic, this developing you
- 38:31can't even look at it sort of, by analogy with what happened in
- 38:33Tech where it used to be the norm that the people that built
- 38:37the tech were sort of underlings.
- 38:40And at some point that Dynamic kind of flipped and I said, wait
- 38:42a minute, like these should be our company's, right?
- 38:46You know, if this was 40 years ago, I probably wouldn't run.
- 38:49Sub stack, I'm going to be like the whatever.
- 38:51I'd need some boss. Wearing a suit to tell me what
- 38:53to do and it just turns out when you let the inmates running the
- 38:56Asylum, you get more interesting results.
- 38:58I think the same is going to be true in me, I had never thought
- 39:01about it that way, but that is super interesting.
- 39:03It's like okay the becomes much easier to build the actual
- 39:06company. So the core yet product skills
- 39:09are enough to become like a company.
- 39:11The business friction, the admin fresh in the tech friction.
- 39:14The design friction is removed so you can just sort of focus on
- 39:17the journalism itself or the In itself, it opens up new
- 39:20opportunities. How much is like sub sack the
- 39:23company growing or you know, I wish I'd seen 2022 revenue and
- 39:27like, what metrics can you share any of my own free list growing
- 39:31a lot? Obviously, I'm just one
- 39:32business, you know, will like some of my Revenue growth is off
- 39:35sub SEC. You know, sponsorships like
- 39:38events and like that's net. Probably good for you because
- 39:41I'm hiring another writer who's going to write more posts.
- 39:43It'll probably translate into subscribers, but like how sub
- 39:47stack the business. Doing it the moment it's doing
- 39:50well, the numbers that we shared our two million paid
- 39:54subscriptions. Now top 10 Publishers, make more
- 39:58than 25 million dollars, a year of paid three hundred million
- 40:01dollars out to writers over the course of subsets lifetime
- 40:05readers have paid writers that should say.
- 40:08I think we crossed borders at 30 million active subscriptions,
- 40:11135 million monthly active subscriptions.
- 40:15There's the best kind of growth. Indicators we can give,
- 40:17obviously, there are so many lever, your Unemployed at the
- 40:19moment. Is there like more writers?
- 40:22It's the existing writers monetizing more.
- 40:24It's like readers coming on. Its readers, subscribing to a
- 40:29second publication or like, obviously these are all like,
- 40:31yes. Well these, yes.
- 40:33Yes, sir. Give me a top of those like.
- 40:35Is there one that's sort of at the top of your mind at the
- 40:38moment, basically your listing, all of the ones that are part of
- 40:41sort of the core growth equation for sub stack.
- 40:44And I would say the story of the past year.
- 40:47Let's say has Has been, we took a really hard.
- 40:51Look at writers, coming to sub stack like, how are we going to
- 40:55get more and more writers coming and being able to start and
- 40:57succeed and kind of the readers, getting their second
- 41:03subscription like growth from the sub stack Network, the place
- 41:05where I'm already reader who scrubs one subject do, I
- 41:08subscribe to a second and a third and how does that happen?
- 41:11And we've made huge gains in both of those over the past year
- 41:14and you can see this with the growth of the steps of network
- 41:1720% of paid. There's across the number come
- 41:20from the network now. Yeah, a year ago, he's going to
- 41:23say 8% before that, it was zero percent and so that piece of the
- 41:28thing has started working really, really well.
- 41:31So I think we're going to keep doubling down on those areas and
- 41:35then the other one, that's very interesting.
- 41:36Of course, is always just like the Top Line growth.
- 41:38Like how are we letting you bring in readers from
- 41:41everywhere, the right and you have a sense of like how
- 41:43penetrated our newsletters right now, have you tried to say,
- 41:47well, assess what the Total addressable market for
- 41:50newsletters is I mean, I would imagine another great Chris,
- 41:53this question. Yeah, I imagine like thinking
- 41:56about podcasts and video more. I mean, one sort of negative way
- 42:01to read that. Is that you think?
- 42:02Well, there's only so many people love to read and pay for
- 42:05reading and like, people love to watch TV like is there a sort of
- 42:08a limit? This doesn't affect my business
- 42:10because I feel like they're plenty more Elites like to chase
- 42:12into. But for the big big pie is there
- 42:15just like a limit of how many people will pay for newsletters.
- 42:19I think in the long run, is there a limit to how many people
- 42:24will pay? I think of it as like, how many
- 42:25people will pay for culture that they care about will pay for
- 42:29things that they value? I think there is a limit to that
- 42:32it's not going to be everybody in the whole world.
- 42:35I do think that the limit is going to be sort of hilariously
- 42:39large. Basically what you're saying
- 42:41Beyond reading you're saying also for for watching and
- 42:45listening. Yeah but I think within that
- 42:47market reading is actually a very large looks like a big
- 42:51piece of that like if you're looking at not just like
- 42:54everybody you can see with media but who are the people who are
- 42:56going to pay for things that are more valuable.
- 42:58They're much more likely to be readers are much more likely to
- 43:01be in that Universe. The thing that we keep finding
- 43:03is that there are new pockets of things that we maybe never even
- 43:11would have thought of or guessed that they exist that start to
- 43:15work on sub stack and so they'll be no.
- 43:17It was like there was you know, the person Pushing like some
- 43:20book past its copyright. What was that?
- 43:22Was it like Dracula, Dracula, daily.
- 43:24Yeah, but what any other it was a human Jesus moment on.
- 43:28Yeah. Well, I even had the Cox
- 43:30Richardson is the number one aurangzeb stack is, she's a
- 43:33history Professor who was publishing books through the
- 43:35Academic Press at? I think it Princeton the
- 43:38something, but she wasn't like high-flying journalist or author
- 43:43before she was on some stack but now she's the number-one earner.
- 43:47Its new energy that's been unlocked only Is it, you know,
- 43:50the 2017 version of this question, we got was how many
- 43:53other been Thompson's do you think there are in the world?
- 43:55How many other Bill Bishops? There are enrolled.
- 43:58The question we never got was, do you think there's a history
- 44:00professor at a college whose potential has been unreal?
- 44:03Aced. Right.
- 44:05So yeah, we think it's a massive energy.
- 44:07Unlocker know what's the most successful like non-writing sub.
- 44:12So there's actually quite a few of the top sub Stacks that
- 44:17either have a podcast as The vet or are a podcast like single has
- 44:22like a podcast or yeah, blocked and reported the fifth column is
- 44:26unsub stack. Andrew Sullivan has a podcast,
- 44:28that's very good. Michael shellenberger, who does
- 44:31public is doing more and more video which is quite good.
- 44:34Josh barro is going to come up here because there's actually
- 44:37there's actually quite a lot. I'm just probably not because we
- 44:40could make it a little bit that we've got the best podcast
- 44:45platform for this kind of thing, right?
- 44:47Really your meeting with patreon.
- 44:48Everybody wants to talk. About Twitter.
- 44:49But no, I mean I just I think a patreon is once being the best
- 44:53monetization models. I would be remiss.
- 44:55If I didn't say I miss my guess if you're thinking about doing a
- 44:57podcast, you should definitely do it on subtag.
- 45:00Get the emails charge, paid subscriptions.
- 45:02It's a tremendous place to build a community around a table.
- 45:05Pay whining. I don't pay well and you podcast
- 45:07right now because why is it? This is where you know, I want
- 45:10like a YouTube channel or like and in part to bring it back to
- 45:13the Twitter question, there is like you want some platform
- 45:17diversity as a Creator and like Like Oak, Twitter's going to
- 45:20die. Then I probably want to be on
- 45:21YouTube. Also, YouTube is just so good at
- 45:24like, total rows as much as you guys are, you know, we would
- 45:27encourage you to be on YouTube. We encourage, you know, if you
- 45:30publish your podcast on sub, s goes to all the podcast goes to
- 45:32our robot guys, goes to Spotify. You should take clips and put it
- 45:35on YouTube. You should take clips and put it
- 45:37on Tick-Tock. We want you to put it
- 45:38everywhere. I just as you want to put it
- 45:39everywhere because it becomes the sort of top of funnel for
- 45:42the thing you're making. And if you do monetize it with
- 45:44paid subscriptions in the cool feature on sub stack, which
- 45:47allows you to put a like an Yo pay wall into the episodes, send
- 45:51it out. Still goes out to all your main
- 45:53listeners and then at 20 minutes and they might get you
- 45:56interrupting them saying, hey this is supported by
- 45:59subscribers. It's the only reason this
- 46:00exists. If you want to subscribe, you
- 46:02don't have to. But some people are, we are
- 46:05building the tools to let you do so and they're working real.
- 46:08It's a secret killer feature that we haven't marketed.
- 46:10Well, there are no that some scale, I will right now.
- 46:13I just like want to grow it and like, you know, I don't want
- 46:15some subscribers to subscribe out of the goodness of their
- 46:18heart as you know, Hey, every subscriber the paid.
- 46:20So, I mean, I believe in Bay walls, honestly like my readers
- 46:23convert when they hit up a wall, like I surveyed them and I
- 46:27thought a larger percentage would say, oh, it's like the
- 46:29goodness of my heart, like, I believe in you, but in there
- 46:33like, no, it's like, I believe I want this stuff and like when
- 46:35you deliver the stuff, I like pay for it, actually for getting
- 46:38your company to pay for it. It's easier to justify.
- 46:40If some of the stuff is pay, one kind of like a business expense.
- 46:43How ideological are you guys on ads right now?
- 46:45I feel the temperature changing on your views on ads as that.
- 46:49Wrong or where are you on Advertising right now?
- 46:51I'll give you my view on this, which I would go back to that
- 46:56kind of like Grand Battle of Empires picture that I painted
- 47:00at the start of this to meet one of the big reasons I wanted to
- 47:02work on subsequent, I think, is fundamentally different on sub
- 47:05stack. Is that when you do advertising
- 47:08in the way that the big social media platforms did, when you
- 47:12say, okay, our business model is we're going to aggregate a bunch
- 47:15of eyeballs and then we're going to sell off those eyeballs as a
- 47:18commodity. So that the way that you're
- 47:20selling the ads are based on who the person is that's watching it
- 47:25not based on what they came here.
- 47:26For those things are totally disjoint.
- 47:29It fundamentally undermines the value of the content that you
- 47:35have on the platform because the only value of it to the platform
- 47:37is that people are there. And so, if you make something
- 47:41that's as cheaply as addictive as possible, like that's how you
- 47:44win, that's how that Dynamic gets created.
- 47:46And so, that's the thing that sub stack is kind of Of created
- 47:50in direct opposition to write the whole thing we want is that
- 47:53when you come to some stack, we're not valuing you based off
- 47:56of the time you spend, we're not trying to get you to trick you
- 48:00in to clicking on them. So that you do an ad impression
- 48:03than that goes into money somewhere.
- 48:06Where subscriptions are very aligned with this where you're
- 48:08saying hey we want to find you something that you value enough
- 48:12to pay for right. Right.
- 48:13And you're very much in conscious control of who I
- 48:15sometimes joke that people will hate read things but they won't
- 48:18hate pay for it. The question that feels
- 48:20interesting to me is, is there something that aligns with that
- 48:25Universe, right? That's me.
- 48:27Feels like a more of an open question.
- 48:29This seems like a long way to say, we're no longer.
- 48:32Totally opposed. I'm not, I'm not even trying to
- 48:34bait you to some degree, like as a Creator like or whatever.
- 48:38I am selling like ads independently because our super
- 48:41tailored to my newsletter is like fine.
- 48:43I'm not necessarily begging. You guys to get in it, but it
- 48:46does feel just like looking from a businesslike.
- 48:49Hybrid, you want Sub saker's, make more money because then
- 48:53they're more likely to do it. And like, hybrid businesses are
- 48:55better than pure subscription businesses.
- 49:00It's not totally clear that that's true but I think the
- 49:03thing you're pointing out here is like, ultimately, what do we
- 49:05want? We want writers to succeed, and
- 49:08we want them to Succeed In an ecosystem that supports them
- 49:11doing their best work. And that aligns the inside times
- 49:13makes, it people are consuming at the customer.
- 49:15That's why subscriptions have been such a strong match and
- 49:18that's kind of like the north star that will keep following
- 49:21its sub sack at a point where it could survive without more
- 49:25Venture funding or like, yes. But I mean, do you think You
- 49:30will raise more Venture funding. I think the best place for a
- 49:33company like sub stack to be is the place where in which is
- 49:36we're like look we have everything, we need not just to
- 49:40keep going but to win without further outside capital.
- 49:44And should we find ourselves in a position where it makes sense
- 49:48to take more investment to accelerate that be a great
- 49:51option to have? If not, we've got everything we
- 49:53need. That's kind of where we're happy
- 49:55to be. Are you guys like personally
- 49:57close to many, like consumer Founders?
- 49:59Or it feels like it's been Been a sort of brutal period for like
- 50:03the consumer startup and obviously got no friends really
- 50:07like, you know, I like the clubhouse guys.
- 50:09Like, rose so hot, we just, I think Paparazzi just shut down.
- 50:12There was like a sense that, you know, team Noah paper.
- 50:15I see is a neighborhood of it was like, one of the, I think
- 50:17there's a bench, mark, you know, is like, one of the sort of it
- 50:20was a teen photo. As, you know, there have been
- 50:23several. I think be real, as easily as
- 50:25like, past its peak, you know, I mean subject was always a Mia.
- 50:30Yeah, yeah exactly. I mean to some degree you know,
- 50:33subject has been sort of a tool for creators and so hasn't been
- 50:38always been a pure consumer company though.
- 50:40Now, with notes, it's more hard to argue that, I think that
- 50:43somebody makes it different. The money makes it slower to
- 50:47build, but also more enduring, it's not the same as kind of
- 50:51like a, you know, a social media app, where everybody kind of
- 50:55like hops into it. And says this is fun and then
- 50:57kind of bounces it's like, you know, it's you First of all, you
- 51:00can't build a subscription business as quickly as that as
- 51:03as you probably know it can be, can be fast, but it's not going
- 51:06to be. You're not going to get a
- 51:06million subscribers overnight, but then once you have it, it's
- 51:09you've got something that people deeply value.
- 51:12We think of it as a subscription Network.
- 51:14It's a different kind of thing that a lot of the sort of free
- 51:18consumer studies. Okay, payments.
- 51:21Thank you so much for coming on. Thanks very much for having us.
- 51:24Yeah, / coming to visit us. That was our episode.
- 51:27I'm Eric newcomer, there's the newcomer podcast.
- 51:30Thank you so much for listening. Thanks to vanta sponsoring the
- 51:33episode. Shout out Tommy Heron, our audio
- 51:36editor, Riley Consulting my chief of staff and young Chomsky
- 51:40for the wonderful music. Check out our YouTube channel,
- 51:43Apple podcast and of course, here to the sub stack newcomer
- 51:47dotco. Thanks so much for listening.
- 51:49See you next week, goodbye, goodbye.
- 51:52Goodbye, goodbye, goodbye.