Latest / The Sperrins: Mining, Power & Community in Northern Ireland / #No.49🎙️ Public Inquiry -New Information Admitted Week 2 Day 3
Transcript
- 0:04All the world's a stage, and all the men and women merely
- 0:07players. They have their exits and their entrances, and one man
- 0:12in his time plays many parts. Now I'm going to skip a few
- 0:16lines, and then the justices in fair round belly, with good cap,
- 0:22unlined with eyes severe and beard of formal cut full of wise
- 0:27saws and modern instances or to translate. And then come the
- 0:32barristers, comfortable, well fed, settled into themselves,
- 0:36sharp eyed, neatly groomed, speaking with authority, full of
- 0:40quotes and opinions and examples, ready with a lesson
- 0:43for everything certain they understand how the world works.
- 0:49Well, the barristers were there in all their glory, and what a
- 0:51day it was. Here's what happened. The first discussion
- 0:55this morning was all about the timetable. Everyone was given an
- 0:59opportunity to speak and make suggestions going forward as to
- 1:02how the public inquiry could be extended, if I may remind you,
- 1:08it's already 24 days long during this week, it became blindingly
- 1:13obvious that everything was moving at a far slower pace than
- 1:17The Pac had anticipated, slowed down by the hugely legitimate
- 1:23concerns of the third parties, the admission of new information
- 1:27that none of us had time to read, much less respond to, the
- 1:30economic appraisals that depend on the Phantom 2016 feasibility
- 1:35study, but even the dfis own economic branch
- 1:39hadn't seen just a
- 1:40spreadsheet version instead, otherwise known as the bespoke
- 1:45model. All calculations are based on this model that no one
- 1:50knew existed, much less have seen. Add into that the lack of
- 1:56habitats, regulation, assessment from Nia, any of these topics
- 2:01alone are controversial, piled together, they become a toxic
- 2:05slag heap of misinformation, frustration, anger and
- 2:10injustice, and ought to be a source of shame for the
- 2:14departments of DFI and Nia. Why so? Because they have actively
- 2:20derailed the timetable as a result of their inaction in the
- 2:24months preceding the inquiry. They had about 17 months to
- 2:28present all the information needed for the public inquiry,
- 2:32but they didn't do it. The information is simply not
- 2:35available to the third parties, effectively muzzling any
- 2:40questions and concerns we might have about financial
- 2:43calculations or ecological destruction. Without it, we are
- 2:48limping along,
- 2:49as Emmett McAleer said, like a wounded animal,
- 2:53to quote Connor Fagan, counsel for fodc, that he had a strong
- 2:57resistance to any
- 2:58further information being admitted
- 3:01at this point and that he was putting a marker down. The
- 3:06commissioner at this point reminded everyone that the
- 3:09inquiry is not the form to process the application. The
- 3:13fodc Council followed up with this remark, having seen the
- 3:18economic concerns, wonder how would play for the topic of
- 3:23ecology, conjecturing that it would be writ large after this
- 3:29was a long discussion about how the applicants arrived at the
- 3:32value of gold as presented by them to the commission. With us,
- 3:37the third party gradually teasing out the truth with
- 3:40probing questions revealing that was actually gold concentrate as
- 3:46opposed to gold ore. Apparently, there is quite a difference in
- 3:51the commodity value, which, of course, would impact the figures
- 3:55in the economic model, and therefore the very glossy
- 3:58projections delradian predicted would be quite different, as
- 4:04Emmett McAleer says, You've heard the gold fever, we seem to
- 4:07be suffering from a surface of concentrate fever. Around this
- 4:13time, Connor Fagan advised the commission be very sure the
- 4:16analysis in front of you before you have confidence in the
- 4:19economics of this project. Might this be a good time to say all
- 4:25that glitters is not gold? Yeah, I know it's a bit enough coming
- 4:29back to the barristers. At some point during the morning, the
- 4:33Commissioner pointed out that the last written submission was
- 4:36made by delraydian, and that none of the third parties had a
- 4:40chance to rebut that in the written evidence, our last
- 4:44submissions were rebuttals to previous information. You
- 4:48remember I spoke about how this happened yesterday in the last
- 4:52podcast. Anyways, the Commissioner queried whether DFI
- 4:58felt this was appropriate ground. To proceed with the
- 5:00inquiry, particularly as dfis economic branch had raised
- 5:05concerns about del radians statement of evidence. Barrister
- 5:09Mackay, counsel for DFI said they were content any issues
- 5:14would be addressed orally within the inquiry. This opened up the
- 5:19possibility of department consultees being allowed to make
- 5:23extra oral submissions where there would be no transcripts,
- 5:28effectively eliminating a paper trail. Pack decided then to
- 5:34break early for lunch to allow Mackay to get some guidance
- 5:37about this. I guess the commissioner thought he would
- 5:42ring someone over lunch, like the minister or senior counsel
- 5:46or the Permanent Secretary after lunch. It appears none of this
- 5:51occurred, and instead, he sent an email to his consultees
- 5:54asking them how long it would take to raise matters orally. As
- 5:59you might imagine, this raised quite a few eyebrows, but he
- 6:03stuck to his line of reasoning, which was oblique to everyone
- 6:06except himself. After this, there were questions asked,
- 6:10wondering whether he even understood the issue. Mary
- 6:15Brawley, solicitor for the third party, pointed out, because of
- 6:19this situation, ie asking consultees to come to the public
- 6:23inquiry and present technical information that the third party
- 6:28have no chance to respond. It is quite literally handing dal
- 6:32raiding a tactical advantage. But the barrister was adamant
- 6:38the consultees will be there, and was up to us to ask them
- 6:40whatever we wished. It looks like we were carrying on
- 6:45regardless, going through the motions of a public inquiry in
- 6:49farcical and ridiculous circumstances. Bad and all as
- 6:54the situation was, it was about to become a whole lot worse, if
- 6:57that's possible. It was around about this time that a
- 7:00protester, not one of the third parties, decided to film
- 7:04proceedings in the auditorium after we had been warned all
- 7:07week that this was not allowed. He was pleading disabled and
- 7:11that he was unable to follow proceedings, and therefore
- 7:13needed to film it. As you might imagine, everything came to a
- 7:17grinding halt. We were all told to leave the auditorium, and the
- 7:21police were called. Some 30 minutes later, we were called
- 7:26back in. The protester had vanished, and the circus
- 7:30continued. Back to business as usual. There was more
- 7:34conversation and questions about front loading, back loading, and
- 7:38the green book being a gold standard. I have to put my hand
- 7:42up and say, By this stage, I'd had enough and stopped taking
- 7:45notes. If I ever do find out what they were talking about,
- 7:48I'll let you know. Sufficient to say, We third parties left this
- 7:54evening with feelings of disbelief,
- 7:57anger and a vague sensation of being shafted. It was all deeply
- 8:01unsatisfactory.
- 8:03There wasn't even an attempt by the
- 8:04departments to conceal their contempt of the process. They
- 8:08had a stunning lack of respect for us,
- 8:11the third parties paying scant
- 8:13attention to what we were saying, sometimes even laughing
- 8:16in our faces, all the while laying the blame firmly with the
- 8:21PAC. Have gone to seek legal advice and advised us to do the
- 8:24same. We wait the commission to get back to tell us how they are
- 8:31going to manage a timetable that is now accepting new oral
- 8:35information and one expected to take twice as long as the
- 8:39original and that brings to a conclusion the end of the second
- 8:44week of the public inquiry.
- 8:48We'll see you all soon. You.