Latest / The Vegan Report / Vegans Fighting Back Discrimination/Vegaphobia. With Tamara Bedić | Ep. 13
Transcript
- 0:00Hello everyone, my name is Ryan and you're listening to The Vegan Report.
- 0:05If you're vegan for the animals and you care to do more for animal rights, but you're not sure
- 0:12where to start, then this podcast is for you. Every week, let yourself fall in love with
- 0:18passionate animal rights leaders who will inspire you to find your voice, your own special
- 0:25contribution to the animal rights movement, however small or big it is. Today is a very
- 0:32special episode because we are going to talk about discrimination against vegans. And did you know
- 0:39that there was a word for that? It is called a vegaphobia and it is a very important issue to
- 0:46address because a world where vegans are marginalized and excluded is a world where it is much harder to
- 0:54fight for animal rights. In order to shed more light on this problem, I'm excited to announce
- 1:01a partnership with the New York City chapter of the National Lawyers Guild. You see, they are
- 1:08organizing a webinar on Tuesday, October 17. It is called Expanding Vegan Rights and it will feature
- 1:16vegans from all over the world who are the victim of discrimination and who decided to fight back
- 1:23against this injustice. For the very first time ever, they will meet each other and share stories
- 1:31of what they went through. I invite all of you to register for the webinar, follow the link in the
- 1:38description and don't miss out on that amazing conversation. So this week and the next, I will
- 1:46be extensively covering this topic. Next Tuesday, I will be joined for an exclusive interview with
- 1:52Astrid. Astrid is a participant of the webinar and she is in the middle of an epic legal fight
- 2:00against the French Board of Dietitians. Tune in next week for more details. But this week,
- 2:07I'm joined with the organizer of the event. Tamara received her master's degree from New York
- 2:13University and her law degree from the University of Virginia. She has been a member of the National
- 2:19Lawyers Guild, the New York City chapter for 10 years. She's a chair of the New York City Animal
- 2:26Rights Comedy and a member of the Guild's Executive Comedy. Tamara has successfully represented animal
- 2:33rescue groups pro bono. As an employment attorney, Tamara champions women in the workplace under Title
- 2:417, the Family and Medical Leave Act and the Age Discrimination in Employment Act. Her special focus
- 2:48is sexual harassment and retaliation claims. Tamara, welcome to the podcast. Thank you so
- 2:54much for being here. Hi, thank you so much for having me, Ryan. It's a pleasure. So let me start
- 3:01with this question. Why did you decide to devote your career to fighting discrimination? Well,
- 3:08when I was 9, 10, 11 years old, I was the victim of a bully in school. And it wasn't just me who
- 3:18was being victimized. My best friend Dawn was being victimized and my other very good friend,
- 3:23Tara. So all three of us were suffering. And the bullying was not just ridicule, but it escalated
- 3:31to theft and physical physical intimidation. And it just felt so horrible. It just felt awful. I
- 3:41dreaded every single day as did my friends. And I decided very early on that it was not something
- 3:50I wanted to tolerate and that when I grew up, I would do something about it. So I did. Amazing.
- 3:56Amazing. And we're happy for that. We're not happy that you had that experience,
- 4:02which I also had. It is horrible. And we don't often talk about how negatively it impacts even
- 4:11adults. You know, when you grow up, you still have some of that, you know, fear or some of those
- 4:18psychological hurtfulness. It still with you in some cases. Yeah.
- 4:27Yeah. Yeah, absolutely. That just that terror that you feel every day, you know, and hating
- 4:35school and hating particularly after school because you knew the bully would be waiting for you. But
- 4:40in my case, I think I was lucky in a way because I watched how it impacted other people and
- 4:48subsequently found out that the bully herself came from a very troubled background and a troubled
- 4:54home. And so really early on, I got a very broad picture of how violence and the threat of violence
- 5:06and those kind of injustices work. It wasn't just me and it didn't it did have its own source. And
- 5:17that source was an older brother who was a firm dealer. So this was a very troubled single parent
- 5:21family. And I learned about all of that in its complexity, you know, before being a teenager.
- 5:29So, yeah. And did you ever just by curiosity, did you ever receive apologies from your bully?
- 5:39No, no. Years later, I saw her pushing a stroller. I said hello, she did a double take. She said
- 5:48hello. And that was it. That was it. I, you know, I hope she's okay, wherever she is.
- 5:54Yes. So how did you find your way to the National Lawyers Guild, the New York City chapter? Why did
- 6:02you decide to start volunteering for the organization? And what attracted you to this institution?
- 6:10Wow. Well, okay. I really, I really thought that law was a wonderful tool to fight for injustice.
- 6:22I had graduated from a great school, took the bar exam, passed the bar. Bar exam is a three day
- 6:29examination in New York. It's just horrific. It's two days and then there's an additional ethics
- 6:36section that you could take previously. But in any event, it's an enormous kind of rite of passage.
- 6:43And having done all of that and having gotten myself six figures in debt,
- 6:47I was on my way up Broadway to a Toys R Us to purchase gifts for a baby shower. And apparently
- 6:56there was a protest going on to the left of me. I was unaware of the protest. I wasn't part of the
- 7:02protest. I had no connection with the protest whatsoever. And suddenly there was a loud noise.
- 7:10It was raining. I was carrying my umbrella. I looked to my left and I saw a white man.
- 7:15I looked to my left and there was a stampede of people running at me. And I just kind of froze
- 7:22in the middle of the street and I was arrested. I was arrested because the police were chasing
- 7:29all of these protesters who were running away. They had apparently been given multiple warnings
- 7:34to disperse. But of course I was none the wiser. I wasn't part of the protest. I was going northward.
- 7:40And suddenly I found myself in a van with other people who were part of this protest. And I was
- 7:45like, what is happening? Why am I being arrested? Who are you? What were you protesting?
- 7:52And it was the worst possible time because having put in so much time, effort, energy,
- 8:00and money into getting this degree, I was now staring at a character in fitness interview,
- 8:07which is sort of the last box to check before you're sworn in. So I was staring at this
- 8:13character in fitness interview and I had just gotten arrested. I was besides myself.
- 8:18And the National Lawyers Guild came in and they represented me pro bono and my case got dismissed.
- 8:29And I went ahead and told my interviewer about it. And he was a little nonplussed, but I swore that
- 8:39if I became a lawyer, I would turn around and volunteer for this organization that had stepped
- 8:45in and helped me in this moment of crisis. And I got sworn in and I looked them up and I began to
- 8:56volunteer. And my initial activities within the National Lawyers Guild were as a legal observer.
- 9:02Legal observers are lawyers, law students, paralegals who go to protests as neutral
- 9:10observers and they're just watching the police and how the police are handling the protests in
- 9:15the crowd. Because we've seen in the past and historically whenever there are large social
- 9:20justice movements that the police can be unnecessarily brutal against protesters. And so
- 9:26we keep tabs on that and we call the police to account if and when that happens.
- 9:32This is a crazy story.
- 9:38You asked.
- 9:40I mean, it's also an inspiring one. But what was the protest about?
- 9:48Turns out that we had just started bombing a Middle Eastern state. I think it was Iraq
- 9:54under the first President Bush. And that's what they were protesting. I distinctly remember
- 10:01two protesters. One was a Columbia professor of Middle Eastern art and the other was a 70-year-old
- 10:10or 80-year-old woman who had somehow fallen while people were running away. And she was complaining
- 10:16in the holding cell how much her knee was swelling up. She was an elderly person and the fact that she
- 10:22had been arrested and was in this holding tank with the other women, we had been segregated from
- 10:27the men. It was just dystopic. I mean, I had never been arrested obviously in my life and
- 10:36there I was and it was just a really, I don't know, it was a bewildering experience.
- 10:42So what is the National Lawyers Guild exactly? Why they got interested in your case? What is their
- 10:52goal?
- 10:55Oh, okay. Well, the National Lawyers Guild began in the 1930s and it began as a splinter group
- 11:03from the American Bar Association. And here's why. By the 1930s, there were particular law schools
- 11:09that were accepting women applicants and that were accepting people of color. So there were
- 11:15African-Americans as well as women who were going to law school and more importantly, graduating
- 11:20from law school. And once graduated, they wanted to join a professional organization that was a
- 11:25national professional organization. Unfortunately, there was one, the American Bar Association. But
- 11:32unfortunately, the ABA, American Bar Association, in its infinite wisdom decided that women and
- 11:37people of color were not qualified to join the national professional lawyers organization.
- 11:46Well, within the ABA, there were progressive white men who had been lawyers who were already
- 11:52members and who were saying, hey, these women are completely qualified as are these people of
- 11:57color. What is going on here? And there began to be sort of an internal struggle within the American
- 12:03Bar Association and the leadership would not relent and the progressives eventually split off
- 12:10and formed the National Lawyers Guild. So that's how the guild started. And of course, the first
- 12:14thing they did was embrace the applicants who were of a different gender and of a different race.
- 12:21So the guild began in the late 30s. It was relatively small, but it really expanded in the
- 12:2750s and 60s because in the 50s, 60s and 70s, we had large social justice movements, first the
- 12:35civil rights movement and subsequently the movement against Vietnam, the anti-war movement,
- 12:44the war resistors, and many, many, many protests related to both of those social justice movements.
- 12:51And in the course of these protests, lawyers from the National Lawyers Guild were watching
- 12:58an incredible amount of police brutality to sort of suppress the social justice movements. Why was
- 13:03this happening? We had water cannons used against protesters. We had police dogs, you know, let loose
- 13:10on protesters. We had people shot at Kent University. We had all kinds of, you know,
- 13:16authoritarian repression in a country that prides itself on First Amendment rights. So as lawyers,
- 13:25what were we going to do about this? We couldn't just sit back and watch it. Right? And that's how
- 13:30legal observation began. We needed to be out there. We needed to be able to take the police,
- 13:36you know, to account because what happens when a policeman beats the heck out of you is six or eight
- 13:41months later, you're in front of a judge and you're saying, yeah, this is what he did. And
- 13:46the judge is saying, did you do that? And the police officer can say, no, I didn't do that. I
- 13:50never saw this man before in my life. And it's the police officer who's going to be believed,
- 13:56unless there's an officer of the court who was also present and who also saw it and who has
- 14:02contemporaneous notes. That's what legal observers do. So we stand back from a protest. We're not
- 14:10part of the protest action, but we're watching and we're taking notes. And those notes at
- 14:14contemporaneous to what's happening. And then, excuse me, and then if we should see police
- 14:21brutality and there is a court case down the road, yeah, we can come in and testify. And we are
- 14:28officers of the court. So our word is going to be taken very, very seriously by the judge.
- 14:34Of course. And that's amazing. Now, the National Lawyers Guild has got, became interested in
- 14:43the animal rights movement. And we're getting back to this. But first, I'm curious about,
- 14:51you know, you're vegan. I'm curious about what has been your vegan journey so far. And why did you
- 14:57decide to get involved in the space of animal rights?
- 15:03Well, I had been involved. I don't really have a progressive vegan journey. I hated milk,
- 15:15even as an infant. You know, I don't remember six months old, but there are stories how at six
- 15:22months old, I was already rejecting milk and milk byproducts, you know, dairy byproducts. And my
- 15:29grandparents at the time who were caring for me had no idea what to do with this infant who just
- 15:36screamed and maybe I was lactose intolerant. I don't know. But I didn't give up meat until I was
- 15:4318. And that was because of Peter Singer's book, Animal Liberation. So I don't really have a, you
- 15:51know, classic vegan journey. But my animal rights journey also sort of sporadic. I would go to
- 16:04for a free Friday protests after Thanksgiving. I would shout at Macy's for having a first salon.
- 16:11I hated the fact that animals were tortured in laboratories. So I was on the very fringe of
- 16:19stop hunting to an animal cruelty. So I would go to occasional protests. But contemporaneous with
- 16:29this, I had been an animal rescuer and I had started rescuing animals in imitation of my dad,
- 16:35who would see an injured bird or a bird that was caught in bad weather. And he would bring the bird
- 16:44home and the bird would sort of rest and recuperate in our bathroom, free flying, until the weather
- 16:51was better or until the bird recuperated. And then we would release the bird from the bathroom
- 16:56window. It would just kind of leave on its own. Obviously, some, most of these birds were pigeons.
- 17:03Some were sparrows. A few starlings came through our house. If the bird was really in need of
- 17:09assistance, we would find an avian vet. There were very few who would want to handle a wild bird.
- 17:16But that all changed with the Wild Bird Fund. God bless them. They are on 565 Columbus Avenue and
- 17:24they are a free avian hospital. Did I say they were free? They are free. So if you are in New York
- 17:32and if you spot an injured bird, please take it to the Wild Bird Fund. They will treat that bird
- 17:40for free and release it in Central Park. And now is an especially sensitive time for birds. Why?
- 17:47Because it's the autumn migration. And thousands of them are hitting the glass of our various
- 17:53skyscrapers and are falling to the ground. And if the glass strike in the fall don't hit them,
- 18:00don't kill them, please put them in a brown paper bag and bring them to the Wild Bird Fund.
- 18:08Besides birds, I also rescued cats and the occasional dog. And it was when I rescued my second
- 18:17dog, a pit bull that displayed all kinds of weird behavior. I ended up learning through her
- 18:28about dog fighting. I had never in my wildest thought about dog, like the people did that,
- 18:35but apparently they do. And then I also heard about bully bans, laws that say you can't have
- 18:45a certain kind of dog. So it was in 2007 when I found Honey and could not rehome her and decided
- 18:56to be her companion myself. That was when my sustained animal rights effort started. So it
- 19:05had been sporadic previously. The animal rescuing was actually quite consistent, but the animal
- 19:16rights was, especially the protesting was sporadic until 2007. When I found Honey and when I realized
- 19:23what was happening to pit bulls especially, and this was thanks to a great friend, John Moore,
- 19:28when I found that out, then I was just like, okay, no, no, no, no, no, no, we don't want this. We
- 19:34don't want particular breeds to be banned just because some individual dogs are aggressive.
- 19:43And that was when the sustained effort started. And what do you say to vegans who want to do more,
- 19:50but are on the fence or they don't really know how to engage, how to contribute? What would be
- 19:59your message to those people, to those listeners? Well, I think that everyone can contribute.
- 20:06You mentioned yourself that you're an introvert, but you're contributing in a way that you can,
- 20:12but you're contributing in a way that you can and that is comfortable to you. There are millions of
- 20:20examples of how people can get involved or get more involved if they want to. Certainly they can
- 20:29listen in to our webinars. We do a free webinar bimonthly. In October, you mentioned the webinar
- 20:35about vegan discrimination and how vegans are fighting back, but we deep dive different
- 20:42intersections of animal rights in the law about every two months. And I mentioned that because
- 20:48when vegans become aware of the wide variety of animal rights campaigns that are out there,
- 20:57then they can really hook into something that is particularly important to them. So that's what I
- 21:06would say, keep exposing yourself to the wide variety of work that's happening and make sure
- 21:13that the work suits your temperament and feeds your passion. Whether that's a passion for fish
- 21:20or for pit bulls or for laboratory animals or circus animals, there is space for you and you
- 21:28will be welcome. Keep listening to the podcast. Keep listening to this podcast. Yes. Okay. So
- 21:36this is a great segue for talking about the webinar. The webinar is at the intersection
- 21:44of two of your passions for fighting discrimination and fighting for animal rights. Now,
- 21:54when was the first time you heard about vegans being discriminated against?
- 22:00Okay. Well, I read, oh, sorry, go ahead. Yes. And what was your reaction?
- 22:04Well, I read Jory Kasimichana's success story in 2020. I think it was January. I think I might
- 22:17have read about it the previous month. He was in front of the tribunal and it was amazing that he
- 22:28won. And I was elated that he won, but subsequently I discovered that there were some cases in America
- 22:35where the vegans were not so fortunate, like Jerry Friedman's case against Kaiser Permanente.
- 22:42And I also found out that there were cases that were pending. For example, Astrid's case,
- 22:48Astrid Prevost's case in France and Martinez's case in Switzerland. And of course, there's Adam
- 22:55Knopf's case in Canada. So these cases are in different stages. And as a discrimination attorney,
- 23:05it kind of makes sense because whenever there is a social justice movement, there's going to be
- 23:10pushback. And now as vegans and vegetarians are coming to be 2%, 3% of the population in some
- 23:19countries, they're 5% of the population, there is an inevitable pushback. And some of that pushback
- 23:26is just out of ignorance, fear, and of strangeness. Some of that pushback might be quite deliberate
- 23:34by the overwhelmingly wealthy dairy industry and meat industry who are watching
- 23:43milk alternatives inch up to 7%, 8%, and 9% in various supermarkets. And so there are all of these
- 23:52sort of cases throughout Europe about whether or not you can use the name or label milk, whether or
- 24:00not you can use the label butter. Who has exclusive rights to these nouns in the English language?
- 24:08And those are the kinds of arguments that are being heard on an industrial level, right? Where
- 24:17you have an industrial giant on the one hand fighting for a monopoly on a particular word.
- 24:24Simultaneously, you have individual discrimination cases that are moving forward because vegans are
- 24:31being discriminated against at work, at school, in divorce proceedings, and in the
- 24:37court proceedings in detention. Well, let's give some concrete examples to listeners.
- 24:45Sure. Well, all right, I'll start sort of sequentially with the US and Jerry Friedman's
- 24:51case. So Jerry Friedman was at the time a computer, he was a computer repair person for Kaiser
- 25:00Permanente, which is a very large hospital chain, and he was working for a pharmaceutical company
- 25:08repairing their computers, and they were very happy with his work, and they offered him a
- 25:14full-time permanent position, which he was very happy to accept, or as happy as a vegan in a
- 25:22pharmaceutical company could be. But he did accept the position, and then they told him that he must
- 25:31be vaccinated and take the MMR vaccine. And Jerry said, you know, this vaccine is cultured from
- 25:40chicken embryos, and I don't feel comfortable taking it. Perhaps we can keep me in the
- 25:50computer repair shop away from anyone who might be a patient and, you know, accommodate me that way.
- 26:01And they said no, and they rescinded the job offer, the full-time job offer, and they stopped
- 26:08using his services as a contractor. So they backpedaled quite a bit, and he was horrified,
- 26:16horrified, and he took them to task on it. Jordi Casamidiana's case, about 20 years later,
- 26:2518 years later, came about because he was working for League Against Cruel Sports,
- 26:33and as an ethical vegan, he was curious as to where his pension fund was going. So
- 26:38pension fund, investing in a pension fund became mandatory, I think, in 2015 in the UK.
- 26:43So everyone at LACS had a pension fund, and he was just curious as to what he was investing in.
- 26:53He found out, much to his horror, that he was investing in tobacco, oil, and big pharma that
- 27:00tested on animals. So he raised this with his managers. They appeared equally horrified.
- 27:07They told him they would change the pension fund, but in fact they didn't, and despite nudging them
- 27:15for over a year, they didn't. And in the course of that year, he begged them to at least stop
- 27:23investing his own money so that it wasn't like his own pension was contributing to animal testing.
- 27:30It turns out they didn't even do that. So he found a mechanism to change his own pension fund to
- 27:40something more ethical, and he changed his own pension fund, his own monetary stream,
- 27:48to something more ethical, and he told his colleagues at LACS about it, and LACS fired him.
- 27:55Astrid Prevost is an aspiring dietitian in France. To get her dietitian's license,
- 28:04there was a mandatory cooking class. I don't know why there was a mandatory cooking class,
- 28:12but there was. They insisted that she use animal ingredients. She requested
- 28:18to be able to substitute the animal ingredients with vegan alternatives. She even got a doctor's
- 28:24note. They said no, and that she would risk failing the cooking class and thereby not being
- 28:31able to pursue her dietitian's degree unless she used animal products. So there are other kinds of
- 28:42cases as well. There are cases in detention or in hospitals where a person in detention is not
- 28:49getting vegan food despite the fact that they are quite clear about what it is they eat.
- 28:57We're hoping that Representative Congressman Ro Khanna opens the webinar. We're waiting for
- 29:04his staff to give us the green light and we're hoping that they will be able to give us the
- 29:09green light. Congressman Khanna is very involved in making sure that American servicemen and women
- 29:15have plant-based and vegan options in the military.
- 29:21And the congressman of which state?
- 29:25California.
- 29:27So there are many, many different examples where
- 29:32vegans are. I'll give you a sort of divorce example. Imagine if you will, you have two people
- 29:42divorcing. One is not vegan. One is vegan. The not vegan claims that the vegan is jeopardizing
- 29:50the health of their child and should therefore be the parent that gets custody.
- 29:55Now in some places they may or may not be laughed at because we know that it's entirely possible
- 30:02to have a child that's on a vegan diet and have that child be extremely healthy. But in some
- 30:09places that's quite a strong argument. And there are some places in the world where to be
- 30:16is not a good argument. And so we're hoping that there will be a way to make sure that
- 30:23where to be vegan is to be openly vegan is to be scared of retaliation where vegans are called
- 30:30terrorists. There's a Italian politician who wants vegan parents to go to jail. Go to jail.
- 30:41Vegan parents to go to jail because they're jeopardizing the health of their child.
- 30:48So depending on where you are in the world, your discrimination is going to be different
- 30:54and more or less severe. When I hear about those cases, my blood starts to boil. It's just the
- 31:02feeling of injustice is so great. And I want to get back to the case of Jerry and also the case of
- 31:12and also the case of Jordi, who are kind of like the flagships of this whole fighting back against
- 31:20discrimination because they decided to sue their employers that decided to seek justice. So what
- 31:31happened in both their cases? Well, both of these cases, as you rightly point out, are in the
- 31:38employment context. And in Jerry's case, he argued that his veganism, his ethical veganism,
- 31:52should be protected the way any secular but deeply held belief system should be protected.
- 32:02And the American courts that tend to recognize monotheistic religions where there is a central
- 32:10deity, they were uncomfortable in recognizing ethical veganism as a religion, if you will,
- 32:22quotes around that word religion. The reason was because they indicated that there wasn't an
- 32:30other worldly element. There didn't seem to be religious holidays. There didn't seem to be any
- 32:39kind of priesthood or clergy as if those things are all necessary indicators of a deeply held
- 32:51philosophy. And of course, they're not. And examples of religions that are recognized in law,
- 33:01but do not have a central invisible patriarch are Confucianism and Buddhism. Both of those are
- 33:11recognized religions in the law. You can't discriminate against someone for being Buddhist.
- 33:16And if you can't, and since you can't, why can you discriminate against someone who is an ethical
- 33:21vegan? There's a case from 1965 called US versus Seeger. In that case, you had conscientious
- 33:30objectors to the Vietnam War. Some of those men were, there were three, were atheists.
- 33:37So there was no other worldly component. There was no clergy and there were no religious holidays.
- 33:43And yet Supreme Court of the United States said, no, these people are deeply convinced
- 33:51that war is an evil. Despite being atheists, what's at issue is their conviction.
- 33:59And the military had to accommodate them in non-combat situations, which is the accommodation
- 34:11that they, that they had requested. And if I think about the case of Jerry, it reminds me of
- 34:21Jehovah's Witnesses who refuse to receive blood, I think, if I'm right, but this is, this should be
- 34:31considered like, we should be considered like the Jehovah's Witnesses because they're making a
- 34:38judgment on our beliefs. That's the thing they're saying, okay, this is a judgment on our beliefs.
- 34:44This is not valid. This is not comparable to other beliefs when they should be making a judgment about
- 34:53are we truly holding on those beliefs? Do we truly, do we have convictions in those principles?
- 35:03I don't know if you also have, you know, noticed that nuance or maybe I'm not sure, but I think
- 35:12that nuance or maybe I'm wrong in my observation. No, no, you're absolutely right. And fortunately
- 35:20in Great Britain, that was the major question. You know, the question was how deeply did Jordy
- 35:29believe in ethical veganism? And he submitted over a thousand pages, I think, of evidence and
- 35:38testimony that described his ethical veganism straight down to being careful about taking
- 35:45public transportation because it would kill insects along the way, not eating figs because
- 35:51there's a relationship between figs and wasps, I believe. Certainly diet, but well beyond diet.
- 36:00Leather of fur products, obviously down. Jordy's position is one of very deep and thoughtful
- 36:14concern about every living creature. And fortunately he was able to document that concern
- 36:22and to sway the tribunal in 2020. His lawyer at the time was Peter Daly.
- 36:28So together they, or I should say his solicitor at the time was Peter Daly. They were successful
- 36:35in a way that we in America were not or have yet to be successful.
- 36:41Now this is America and you have two guests that do not come from America, Adam Knopf
- 36:49and Astrid Prevot. Now this podcast will have Astrid on as a guest next week. But in the case
- 37:01of Adam, he's Canadian. So I shared that in common with him. Can you talk about his story,
- 37:10what he had to face in more details maybe?
- 37:14Well, unfortunately I'm rather gagged at the moment. Adam has decided that given the
- 37:24sensitivity, because mind you, he had his hearing with Wade Pozianka several Tuesdays ago and they
- 37:31are awaiting a decision. So Adam has carefully decided not to participate in the webinar and
- 37:41instead we have a gentleman from Switzerland whose name or pseudonym is Matthias and he will be
- 37:50participating in Adam's stead. His case is related to an animal rights activist who was detained,
- 38:01who was wiretapped illegally, who ended up in detention before he was convicted and that
- 38:12detention lasted for 11 months, during most of which he ate bread and very few other things
- 38:20because his veganism was not recognized despite multiple appeals to the prison management system.
- 38:31He is being represented and his case is in Switzerland and potentially will move up to the
- 38:38European Court of Justice because it is such a horrible transgression of human rights.
- 38:50And I'm planning on talking with Astrid about his case because I think he's an acquaintance of...
- 38:57Okay, yeah and about Adam, it's interesting because if it was not for you Tamara,
- 39:04I would not have known about these different cases, these different instances of discrimination
- 39:13against vegans. Why is it the case that it's not more popular even among vegan circles and
- 39:22then why is it important to talk about this? Okay, well, litigation... My experience when I look at
- 39:33my clients who have gone through the litigation process, it's a challenging process. It's...
- 39:43Even if you're completely righteous in your claim,
- 39:45it's just so psychologically difficult to put that in public.
- 39:55And I think that many people feel awkward about complaining. Many people
- 40:04just wish the problem would go away. Many people will suffer and I deal and I have for a long time
- 40:11with women who have experienced sexual harassment. Many women are just so embarrassed
- 40:17that they don't want to talk about this, much less go to human resources and then
- 40:25point fingers and take notes of various instances, dates and times and specifics.
- 40:34They don't want to tell their boyfriend or husband because they may be concerned that
- 40:38the men who love them will step in and become agitated and that it will make a bad situation worse.
- 40:49Many, many vegans are trying to find alternative means of getting what they want, including
- 41:00declaring themselves to be religions that they're not. Like, I'm a vegan, I'm a vegan,
- 41:07like, I'm Buddhist, please accommodate my child and don't give them milk
- 41:14in the nursery school or at school. Or, I'm Buddhist, my child shouldn't have to dissect a frog.
- 41:25So I've heard stories of vegans doing all kinds of contortions just so that they would fit in
- 41:33and make as few waves as possible. And that's why it was very, very hard to find
- 41:41panelists for October 17th's webinar. And that's why the panelists who are coming forward
- 41:50are exceptionally brave and really deserve to be commended because they're the ones that are
- 41:57opening the doors for others. They're the ones that are taking the heat for others. Astrid is
- 42:05not alone in her fight. There are silent people in Poland and Estonia, Lithuania, Belarus, Russia,
- 42:16Croatia, who in hearing her story, if they don't find the courage to equally step up, then at least
- 42:29they will have the sense that they are not alone. There are hundreds of people who feel like they are
- 42:37alone and hated and they're afraid. There are vegans who have won their court cases, but refuse to
- 42:50speak out, refuse to be named, insist on remaining anonymous and applaud what we're doing, but cannot
- 43:01raise their voice in their communities. We want to make more and more people vegan. And that way,
- 43:09we want to advance the cause of animal rights and stop the exploitation of animals. Now, how can we
- 43:18reach our goal if being vegan is so hard? You're punished for being vegan in society.
- 43:27And so yeah, it is a big detriment to our fight for animal rights.
- 43:39It's definitely a second wave, meaning the first wave is getting people to be vegan,
- 43:47but there has to be some backup and some support once that happens. You can't just get people to
- 43:55transition and then, whoop, great, gone, because it's an ongoing struggle. And I have been reaching
- 44:05out to vegan personalities and asking them what they think about this and can they support this
- 44:15webinar and can they promote this webinar? Can they participate in this webinar from the audience?
- 44:20Because it's lovely that they've helped hundreds, if not thousands of people transition.
- 44:30But this is what some of those people are experiencing having transitioned. What do you
- 44:37do now? You abandoned them. No, you have to step forward. I always hear about people transitioning
- 44:45to a vegan diet, but that is not the key data here. What is the key data is how many people
- 44:54stay vegan after transitioning to veganism. And the studies we have show that not that many people,
- 45:02in fact, the vast majority, leave the lifestyle. And I was talking to vegan conservatives in one
- 45:12of my past episodes and they were talking about how if there was more social support around
- 45:24being vegan, they would have seen more conservatives become vegan. That is the
- 45:31number one thing that stops a lot of conservatives who accept the vegan arguments to become vegan.
- 45:38And I think it applies to other people from other parts of the political spectrum. But
- 45:49yeah, it is. I don't know. Do you want to add something about this?
- 45:54Yes, Earthling Ed, if you're listening to this podcast, you have to reach out and you have to
- 45:59help these people after they've transitioned. My email is Tamara underscore bettick at yahoo.com.
- 46:07Let me know. The fight doesn't stop. The fight does not stop. The more vegans,
- 46:15the more vegan discrimination. Yeah, very true. Very true. And the trauma,
- 46:25because part of me wants to talk with some of those ex vegans and understand why they decided
- 46:34to leave the lifestyle. Now, I don't know if it is my place to do so. Maybe not. But maybe someone,
- 46:42you know, maybe a listener wants to take that task into their hands. Because we need to understand
- 46:51what is happening and we need to understand what kind of trauma, what kind of bad experiences
- 46:58those vegans went through that made them leave the lifestyle and the movement for animal rights.
- 47:08Right. Right. Yeah. And I think that the rubber really hits the road with diet.
- 47:14Ethical veganism is far, far broader than just diet. But I think that the most common, that the
- 47:21nexus and the nucleus of that conflict really with one's family, with one's friends, with one's,
- 47:28with the crumbling social circle, with the inability to fit in, with having to find new friends,
- 47:33with having arguments with your significant other, all that kind of revolves around what's on your
- 47:39plate. Yes. But you know, the detail that truly triggers me personally, it's the fact that many
- 47:47of those ex vegans don't become vegetarian after a few months or a few years of being vegan. It's
- 47:56not like they're leaving veganism to become vegetarian. They're leaving everything behind.
- 48:04Right. And you know, when you asked me earlier, like, what was my vegan journey? And I said,
- 48:09well, it's kind of scattered. I stopped eating meat. I mean, I always hated milk. So I had my
- 48:17coffee black, sometimes with sugar, sometimes without. But when I stopped eating meat, I was
- 48:25unaware of the term vegetarian. So when people would say, oh, you want to have a hamburger? I'd
- 48:32be like, no, I'm boycotting meat. So in my head, the word was always boycotting meat, boycotting
- 48:40the meat industry. So I didn't, I didn't, I was unaware of the words vegetarian. I certainly was
- 48:46unaware of the word vegan. I just knew on the one hand, what I hated and did not want to put it,
- 48:51you know, did not want to drink or have anything to do with. And I also understood that what was
- 48:57happening behind slaughterhouse doors was something that I was not going to invest a penny in. And I
- 49:05was boycotting them for as long as I needed to boycott. I mean, there was never going to be a
- 49:10time that I was going to say, okay, yeah, this is fine. No, it's not all fine. It's not fine.
- 49:15It's never going to be fine. It's never going to be fine. I don't need a label. I don't need to
- 49:20call myself anything. It's never going to be fine.
- 49:22Yes. And yeah, you know, going back to my point, it might be hard to be vegan in terms of dieting,
- 49:31but it is much, much, much easier to be vegetarian. So why do we not have, you know, those
- 49:37ex vegans becoming just vegetarian or just, you know, saying I'm, I'm going to reduce
- 49:44considerably my intake of meat, something like that. Anyway, it is, you know, doing this podcast,
- 49:53you realize how much work still has to be done in this field. So, yes. So what is your goal with
- 50:04this webinar? We talked about raising awareness. So did you have other goals? Well, for starters,
- 50:15one of the things that concerns me is that we don't, my opinion is that we don't really have
- 50:20a umbrella animal rights movement. We have a million and one campaigns. We have a campaign
- 50:28to end this, a campaign for this purpose. We care about various different things, and then we sort
- 50:35of silo ourselves into these different areas. And one of the reasons that the webinars keep
- 50:43changing their subject matter so drastically, for example, the last webinar was on ventilation
- 50:50shutdown in America's farms. The next webinar might be about, you know, how do we get rid of
- 50:58rhinoceros horn? These are all very interconnected issues. And if we want to build a movement,
- 51:05we really need to think globally, and we need to think about the various campaigns and how to
- 51:11bring people together. So the overarching issue of the entire webinar series, the reason that we do
- 51:18these webinars at all is to allow people to see both the diversity and to encourage people to
- 51:25come together under one umbrella. And similarly, the people that will be speaking on October 17th,
- 51:34they don't necessarily know each other. Jerry and Jordi just met at a podcast that I organized
- 51:41with Corinne Hardglass. But there's a growing family of vegan, ethical vegan litigants.
- 51:51I want those people to meet each other, have each other's email addresses, talk about how to pay
- 51:57their lawyers, talk about crowdfunding strategies, talk about just talk, they need to connect with
- 52:07each other. And other people need to see them connect. Vegans who are still in the shadows.
- 52:16Yeah. And also, you know, the industry we're going against is well organized, it is global,
- 52:21it is well funded. And they are aware of what animal rights activists are doing. And they're
- 52:31doing their best to counter attack our advocacy work. And to shut us down. Yeah. And to take down
- 52:40our leadership. For example, right now, the Sonoma trial with DXC, Wayne Shen wasn't even part
- 52:47of the particular rescue that they're prosecuting him for. Why are they prosecuting a man who wasn't
- 52:53on the scene? Because he's a leader. And because if they take him down, and Priya, and other leaders
- 53:00of the DXC movement. And by the way, Wayne stepped away from DXC over a year ago. So he's doing
- 53:07something else now it's called Simple Heart. And they're prosecuting him, because they want to tear
- 53:14down a movement, just like they did with the Stop Huntington animal cruelty. I mean, once we become
- 53:23large enough, and vocal enough, there's an enormous organized opposition against us.
- 53:30And by the way, the goal is not so much, you know, to destroy that industry, but to really
- 53:39make it our own in a way. And by that, I mean, you know, one of my favorite mock cheese brand
- 53:49is Silk. I love them. Their mozzarella, mozzarella cheese is just amazing. For me,
- 53:56mozzarella cheese is just amazing. Forget about Daya. And Silk is owned by, I think, I think they're
- 54:06called Danone, or, but they're this big dairy industry company. And I'm glad, I'm glad that
- 54:17the animal industry is turning into something more plant based, oriented, and vegan friendly.
- 54:27Why not let's convert them to our cause. So it doesn't have to be, you know, antagonistic.
- 54:34It's more of like a show of force and an influencing campaign. Do you agree with that?
- 54:41I think it's all about money. And I think that we have a system called capitalism that makes it all
- 54:48about money. So the people who are going to be successful in a system called capitalism are the
- 54:54people that make it all about money. There are ways to oppose what it is that they are doing.
- 55:04And those ways are fairly secondary and tertiary, like protesting outside,
- 55:10protesting outside the slaughterhouse, like voting for politicians who are more sympathetic to animal
- 55:19rights. But ultimately what's happening behind the slaughterhouse doors is about money. And if you
- 55:24could make it more expensive for them to continue as is, then to transition, they will continue as
- 55:33is. For example, in this, again, this, this Sonoma trial, they have an army of attorneys
- 55:42prosecuting these DXE rescuers, an army. Each of those attorneys is charging several hundred dollars
- 55:50an hour, some possibly 500, some possibly 700, some possibly a thousand dollars an hour.
- 55:56It's cheaper for these particular people to pay those attorneys than it is for them to change
- 56:08their way of doing business. And once it becomes clear that their way of doing business is not
- 56:18supported by their shareholders, then they will change. So long as they are making money and so
- 56:26long as they are distributing that money and dividends, and so long as shareholders are silent
- 56:33about where their money is coming from and the exploitation that undergirds that money, they will
- 56:40continue on. It's just like a criminal enterprise. A criminal syndicate will trade drugs, illegal arms,
- 56:51tigers, sex workers, children. The commodity is just the commodity, but there's a system of
- 57:00trading these items because there's a huge black market demand for all of them, whether you're a
- 57:08tiger cub or a surface to air rocket. I agree. I agree. But I worry that it's going to transform
- 57:17into, you know, the tobacco industry situation where they still exist, which is crazy. After all
- 57:25that advocacy, after all the health studies out there, we still let them market their product,
- 57:33put it on the shelves and do their dirty work. Well, let's learn by what they did. I mean,
- 57:39look at what they did and how that's affecting the argument around climate change. What tobacco did
- 57:46in the 60s and 70s is they decided that they were going to market doubt, doubt in the medical
- 57:57studies, doubt that tobacco and its additives increased the rates of cancer. There's a famous
- 58:06memo about the American tobacco industry deciding that the tobacco industry is going to market
- 58:15their product, their product, their product, their product. And they did. And they did. And
- 58:22they got alternative science. And climate change is using that same blueprint. And, you know,
- 58:32recently I found out that the tobacco industry, one of their headquarters here in Montreal,
- 58:41for their Canadian business. And I found out that they were looking for someone in the
- 58:48fundraising world. And I'm a professional fundraiser. And it was interesting because
- 58:56you're looking for someone to distribute grants to small nonprofits across Quebec and Canada.
- 59:05And also for that person to communicate what they're doing, you know, their good work to
- 59:13their employees. So, you know, they have that inner communication going on, which makes competition
- 59:25to the messaging outside. So the employees are actually in an echo chamber. They're creating an
- 59:35echo chamber around their employees, talking about tobacco as something good, look at all the great
- 59:44stuff, the positive impact we're making in the community and things like that. And I guess for
- 59:50an employee who already feels, you know, a bit maybe marginalized for being part of this industry
- 59:59that is recognized universally as being evil, prefers to believe the lies that their employers
- 1:00:09are telling, then confront the truth that is out there. And yeah, it goes back to something I said
- 1:00:18in the past episode. I want to see vegan activists doing some work targeting employees of
- 1:00:29slaughterhouses and tizen and the big, I'm not talking about the poor immigrant employees
- 1:00:35working as meat bankers. I'm talking about the executives, you know, the people in the offices,
- 1:00:41who we need to reach them to break that echo chamber they're in and show, to demonstrate why
- 1:00:51we're right and they're wrong in their thinking. So yeah.
- 1:00:54I absolutely agree with you. And, you know, it reminds me very much about who gets caught
- 1:01:00and who gets the grunt work. We had a webinar on elephant ivory. And for the elephant ivory webinar,
- 1:01:08we invited prosecutors from six different East African countries to come to the webinar and to
- 1:01:15talk about their prosecutorial styles and their prosecutorial methods. And of course, there was a
- 1:01:22lot of overlap between Tanzania and Malawi, South Africa, Uganda, Kenya. There was a lot of overlap
- 1:01:28because same problem, same mechanisms. However, one of the shared complaints of all of these
- 1:01:38prosecutors was that they were constantly finding and sentencing and convicting their own people
- 1:01:47who were carrying a piece of luggage, not knowing what was in it from point A to point B on their
- 1:01:57bicycle. And they were earning five bucks or some amount of money that was considerable to
- 1:02:10a bicycle runner in Uganda. And they had no idea that there was a tusk in there. They just knew
- 1:02:17that they had to take this from point A to point B on their bicycle. That was the person who was
- 1:02:23getting caught. That was the person who was getting sentenced to six months, for example.
- 1:02:32The middle level people and certainly the people who were higher level traders,
- 1:02:39you never got them. Mostly because they're offshore. They're not even in Africa. They're in Asia.
- 1:02:47You can't reach them. So you're prosecuting your own people. You're taking fathers from their kids.
- 1:02:55You're sentencing them to jail time and you're never really getting the heads of these syndicates.
- 1:03:04I'm thinking now about the Sackler's family. I think that's their name. There was a documentary
- 1:03:12on that medication. I forget the name. Oxycontin?
- 1:03:17Oxycontin, yes. And the addictions that it created, how it destroyed so many families across
- 1:03:23North America in the US, of course. And now their name, the Sackler's family, is synonymous with
- 1:03:34that, with the harm they have made on this world. And I think that's the reason why they're
- 1:03:40on this world. And I want to know who are the big families behind the animal industry who are
- 1:03:49profiting from the exploitation of animals who have blood money. I mean, it's the definition
- 1:03:56of blood money. You're profiting from the death of sentient beings. So yeah, why don't we know
- 1:04:05their names? Well, we do in the case of the animal industry. For example, you had Crystal Heath.
- 1:04:14You interviewed Crystal and she will be the first to tell you that the very people who are
- 1:04:21extracting large figures from animal exploitation are investing a fraction of their money
- 1:04:31in things like conferences for veterinarians, in things like laboratories at vet schools.
- 1:04:41So you'll walk into a laboratory as a vet student and you'll see on the wall a plaque
- 1:04:47that this particular laboratory was paid for by Cargill or was paid for by XYZ laboratory.
- 1:04:55Yes. Charles River, right? And these are the folks who are paying for large conference halls
- 1:05:03where veterinarians can sort of get together and continue to support either explicitly or be
- 1:05:11complicit with some hideous forms of animal cruelty like ventilation shutdown in the US.
- 1:05:19Yeah, I think it should turn into a Sackler's family situation and hopefully maybe there will
- 1:05:27be a documentary produced around those people. So Tamara, before we end this conversation,
- 1:05:37I would like to ask you, did you have anything more to add?
- 1:05:41No, I think you were very, very thorough.
- 1:05:44But it was lovely chatting with you and I really appreciate your time today and your patience with
- 1:05:50my early morning escape artist. I'm referring now to my cat who made it his business to, you know,
- 1:06:01ruin my Wednesday morning. But fortunately, he's now satiated and napping, continuing to
- 1:06:08somewhere as cats will. Well, that's life for you. I mean, you should meet my cat. She's a demon. I
- 1:06:16mean, she's old and all and I love her. But oh my gosh, you need lots of patience with her. And
- 1:06:26her name is Misha. Misha. Excellent. Yeah.
- 1:06:31Yeah, she's a real princess. So Tamara, it was a pleasure. Thank you so much for having accepted
- 1:06:40my invitation and for all of your good work. And yeah, thank you.
- 1:06:47Thank you, Ryan. Thanks for having me today. Bye now.
- 1:06:51Thank you, everyone for listening. Let me read you a little bit about your life.
- 1:06:56Let me remind you that the webinar will be happening on October 17th.
- 1:07:02There is a link in the description for registration and more details.
- 1:07:07Thank you to the National Lawyers Guild for hosting the event.
- 1:07:10As always, please tell your friends about the show and why you love it so much.
- 1:07:16Let's inspire more people to take action.
- 1:07:19If you're listening to this on Apple dolls, please subscribe.
- 1:07:23If you're listening to this on Apple Podcasts, please leave me a good review.
- 1:07:29And finally, you can always reach out to me on Instagram at veganreportpodcast.
- 1:07:36Thank you again for listening, take care and see you next Tuesday for an exclusive interview
- 1:07:42with the Brave Astrid.