Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Discovery: Managing Risk
Transcript
- 0:03Welcome to Discovery Managing Risk. I am Lori
- 0:07Krip -Martin, a certified family law specialist
- 0:10and the former vice chair of the HBA's litigation
- 0:13section. I'm delighted to introduce our speaker,
- 0:16Judge Susan L. Greenberg. Judge Greenberg is
- 0:19a mediator, an arbitrator, and a discovery referee
- 0:22with Signature Resolution, where she also serves
- 0:25as a special master and a judge pro temp. She
- 0:29spent 26 years on the San Mateo. County Superior
- 0:32Court with supervising assignments in civil,
- 0:36family law, and probate, and a docket that ranged
- 0:39from jury trials to complex civil matters. During
- 0:42her tenure, Judge Greenberg developed the court's
- 0:45informal discovery conference program, giving
- 0:48her a firsthand view of where discovery stalls
- 0:51and how to keep it moving. She also founded and
- 0:55chaired the court's AI committee and led its
- 0:59ADR programming. Before Assuming the bench, Judge
- 1:03Greenberg served as a deputy district attorney
- 1:05and handled civil litigation and private practice.
- 1:09She was named Judge of the Year by the San Mateo
- 1:12County Trial Lawyers Association in 2024 and
- 1:16has taught at Golden Gate University. And now
- 1:19let's get started. Thank you so much Laurie and
- 1:23welcome everyone. This is part three of the three
- 1:27part series with regard to discovery For those
- 1:30of you who have been with me throughout the entire
- 1:33time. We started part one We're talking about
- 1:36where cases bottleneck which very often is in
- 1:39the discovery phase how to deal with the time
- 1:43constraints regarding discovery. And now we will
- 1:46talk about managing risk in discovery. But for
- 1:49those of you who have been a part of the three
- 1:53-part series, at the end when there's time for
- 1:55questions, feel free to ask about anything that
- 1:58might have been discussed in parts one or two.
- 2:02That's totally fine. Next slide, please. All
- 2:11right, so we've talked about me. Next slide,
- 2:14please. All right, so we're going to start with
- 2:18what high efficiency means and what exactly it
- 2:21is that we're talking about in discovery. And
- 2:24we've discussed this in the previous sessions,
- 2:27but I just want to remind everyone our objectives
- 2:31here are to reduce the cycle time of collection,
- 2:35review, and production, for example, of documents
- 2:38or responses to interrogatories. We're going
- 2:41to reduce reworking the various items that we
- 2:46are producing. We're going to reduce redoing
- 2:48searches, reduce the privilege log issue, and
- 2:52reduce the number of productions and reproductions.
- 2:56It's just very often something that happens.
- 2:59We want to reduce risk, which deals with spoliation,
- 3:02waiver, sanctions, confidentiality breaches.
- 3:06Improve the defensibility. of what we are producing.
- 3:11Make sure that it's repeatable, it's documented,
- 3:15it's auditable, so that if there is a motion
- 3:18to compel and a motion to compel further, you've
- 3:20got some ammunition to say, look, Judge, this
- 3:24is what we did. I can show you exactly how we
- 3:26did it. This is everything that we've got that's
- 3:28discoverable. Setting expectations for this afternoon.
- 3:33Being efficient does not mean cutting corners.
- 3:36It's really front loading decisions and standardizing
- 3:40execution. And I thought about that a lot as
- 3:44we've been going through these three different
- 3:46sessions. And really what it means is putting
- 3:49together as a law firm or as a solo, if you are,
- 3:52a set of business practices that you will use
- 3:55each and every time you're served with a specific
- 3:58type of written discovery. Again, whether interrogatories,
- 4:02requests for production, requests for admission,
- 4:06you need to have an actual process in mind as
- 4:09to how that's going to go, what your time constraints
- 4:13are, who's going to be the person that's going
- 4:16to we have the final say. And we talked about
- 4:19that in sessions one and two, but really it's
- 4:22a business practice issue. And I think the more
- 4:25that your firm or your firms have implemented
- 4:29strong business practices, the better your discovery
- 4:32is going to be. It's going to be more efficient.
- 4:34You're not going to be sanctioned and you're
- 4:37going to be providing what you're required to
- 4:40provide under the law. Next, next slide, please.
- 4:45All right, so we'll start with automating discovery
- 4:48logs. Next slide. We're going to automate the
- 4:53capture and structure. That's what we want to
- 4:58automate. We don't want to have a computer decide
- 5:01judgment calls, like what's privileged and what's
- 5:06not. We don't want to have a computer insert
- 5:08narratives next to a privilege log. So the computer,
- 5:15or whoever you... vendor, whatever vendor you
- 5:18choose to use, if you do it that way, you can
- 5:20automate how you capture the documents that are
- 5:23being requested, what the structure is going
- 5:26to look like, and we'll talk about that in more
- 5:27detail. But keep your attorney judgment for is
- 5:31this privileged? Is it not? If so, what are the
- 5:34codes? What are the narratives? We'll talk about
- 5:36that quite a bit. Our targets today are privilege
- 5:39logs, redaction logs, production indexes, and
- 5:44confidentiality designations. Next slide, please.
- 5:51So what are our standard fields when we want
- 5:53to design a very efficient privilege log? Absolutely
- 5:57Bates Stamp. Have a Bates range for every item
- 6:01that you are producing. I can't tell you how
- 6:05many times, and it's so frustrating in this day
- 6:08and age, how many times that discovery would
- 6:11be produced without bait stamps and you're trying
- 6:14to in a motion to compel you're trying to reference
- 6:18to the judge look this is what was produced there's
- 6:21no bait stamps at the bottom of the page i mean
- 6:23this is simple but please be certain that you
- 6:25put that in your privilege log bait stamp your
- 6:28documents have it in your privilege log in addition
- 6:31to the bait stamp range put the date the author
- 6:36of the recipient the privilege type. Is it personal
- 6:40identifying information? Is it attorney -client
- 6:42privilege? And they're listed. I've listed them
- 6:44for you and given you the code sections that
- 6:47list them. But make sure you put the privilege
- 6:49type, a brief description, any attachments that
- 6:53might be included within the privilege, and who
- 6:56the custodian of that document might be so that
- 6:59you've got a very linear in your spreadsheet,
- 7:03a very linear description of exactly what it
- 7:06is that you are claiming privilege for. Use consistent
- 7:11description taxonomy. For example, it was a request
- 7:15for legal advice regarding a complaint or regarding
- 7:21the breach of contract. And keep that the same.
- 7:25Use it consistently throughout your privilege
- 7:27log. If it's attorney -client privilege, you
- 7:29don't just get to say, oh, attorney -client privilege,
- 7:32Your Honor. Attorney -client privilege regarding
- 7:34a discussion of the breach of contract I think
- 7:38is appropriate. It supports your privilege and
- 7:44description, and it makes it easier for the judge
- 7:47to rule in your favor. We've already talked quite
- 7:50a bit about email threading. Remember that you
- 7:55want to have this log talk about the family thread
- 7:58level where permitted and avoid duplicate entries.
- 8:02And so we know that emails will have the first
- 8:05email that was sent and then the response and
- 8:07then very often the first email is repeated and
- 8:10it becomes this long mushed up. amount of document,
- 8:16number of documents that it's very hard for opposing
- 8:19counsel or for the judge to go through. So make
- 8:22sure you avoid duplicate entries in doing that.
- 8:25You're going to do a lot of quality control because
- 8:29this is going to be computer assisted and especially
- 8:32in the larger cases, a computer assisted item.
- 8:36And so you want to when doing your quality control
- 8:40checks, look for missing fields. And a lot of
- 8:44the fields that could be missing are the metadata
- 8:46fields. We'll talk about what that is in a moment.
- 8:48But there could be inconsistent privilege types
- 8:51and, of course, duplicate entries. Next slide,
- 8:54please. All right. So we are going to talk about
- 9:00redaction and confidentiality logs. Put your
- 9:03redaction reason. It can be a code. It can be
- 9:07PII, personal identifiable information. It could
- 9:12be protected health information. trade secret
- 9:15privilege you are not going to if you're coca
- 9:18-cola you're not going to give up your formula
- 9:20formula in a lawsuit with pepsi right i mean
- 9:23that's just all kind of pretty well known and
- 9:26those are your redaction codes you want to link
- 9:30those redaction codes to your baits and page
- 9:34coordinate references i say where possible but
- 9:37frankly it should be every time you should know
- 9:40exactly why you're claiming a redaction a confidentiality
- 9:45or a privilege and be able to reference it every
- 9:48time you are telling the other side, I'm not
- 9:51producing this, and here's why. Next slide, please.
- 9:58How to automate your workflow. And these are
- 10:00just some examples. So you can review platform
- 10:03tags, for example, and then export the report
- 10:08and have it formatted into a log that's actually
- 10:12in a template. And with that, you can auto -populate
- 10:16the metadata. What is metadata? It is the information
- 10:20that is provided when you look into a file and
- 10:25you can determine when it was first authored,
- 10:29when it was modified. And that's important because
- 10:34you may see a document that purports to be from
- 10:382024. It wasn't created till 2025. So metadata
- 10:42is extremely important and it has to be provided
- 10:46when requested. The attorney will add a narrative
- 10:50on that particular line, for example, on that
- 10:54particular document only when needed. Exception
- 11:01reporting goes to your quality control. So when
- 11:04you're doing your quality control, it could be
- 11:08You could have that you have to have the computer
- 11:10basically go through and say take a look at this
- 11:12document What's missing? Where are there exceptions?
- 11:15Where are there blanks where there shouldn't
- 11:16be? One reason could be it's privileged, but
- 11:19there's no basis listed. No PI and I are PHI.
- 11:22There's no redaction It's redacted, but there's
- 11:25no reason there's no reason code. So those are
- 11:29Automated workflows that you can have a computer
- 11:32do Kind of as a first pass, you're still going
- 11:35to do your own actual quality control, but it'll
- 11:39get you a lot closer to having everything where
- 11:42it should be when you are putting together your
- 11:45responsive documents, for example. Next slide,
- 11:48please. All right, we'll talk about technology
- 11:53assisted review and production controls. Next
- 11:57slide. So when does technology assisted review
- 12:01help the most? really what's where there's a
- 12:04large volume of documents and I'll tell you these
- 12:06days most cases have a large volume of documents
- 12:09because they're kept electronically we've talked
- 12:11about electronically stored information it's
- 12:14so easy to keep that and and people you know
- 12:18it's not like they're destroying any paper so
- 12:20it's all staying on the computer when there's
- 12:23repetitive issues when the issue is something
- 12:27that the computer can easily look for and with
- 12:30the correct prompt find, and when there's tight
- 12:33deadlines. That's when you really want to use
- 12:35your technology assisted review. What are your
- 12:39defensibility pillars? Meaning, what are the
- 12:44things that you can use if you're brought to
- 12:46court to say, look, Judge, I'm defending this
- 12:48on these various pillars. I have a documented
- 12:52workflow. I have a training validation plan.
- 12:56I've done quality control metrics. And your quality
- 13:00control in a 10 ,000 page production isn't going
- 13:04to be looking at one out of every thousand pages.
- 13:07It might be looking at more like one out of 100
- 13:10pages. You're not going to say, yeah, we looked
- 13:13at 10 pages total out of 10 ,000 and they seemed
- 13:16fine. So we did our quality control duty diligence.
- 13:21No. You have to have really appropriate quality
- 13:25control metrics in order to show that you have
- 13:28really met your burden. Transparency spectrum.
- 13:33This is kind of interesting. Are you going to
- 13:37give just like the black box to cooperative technology
- 13:42assisted review? I think you decide that early.
- 13:46I err on the side of cooperative. I think that
- 13:52you need to be more transparent in how you present
- 13:58your documents and what's being redacted, what's
- 14:01being claimed as privilege, because almost always
- 14:05there's going to be a fight about that. And if
- 14:08you're a black box about it, the judge is going
- 14:09to say in my. In my experience, the judge can
- 14:13often say, no, we need more transparency. I really
- 14:17need to know what's going on here. So decide
- 14:20early what you feel is appropriate, but you might
- 14:23not want to be all the way to the side of black
- 14:26box. You're not learning anything. You might
- 14:28want to get somewhere a little bit closer to
- 14:30more transparent as to how you perform the searches
- 14:34and the functions that you did. Next slide, please.
- 14:41All right. So production controls that Prevent
- 14:45disasters. That's what we're talking about preventing
- 14:47here. So your pre -production quality control
- 14:50checklist will include make sure your bait stamps
- 14:53are continuous. We talked about the family integrity
- 14:57in emails. It's also true of texts and correct
- 15:02any confidentiality legends. Make sure that the
- 15:05code that you're using means what you want it
- 15:08to mean. Correct metadata fields. Sometimes the
- 15:13metadata fields are incorrect because of a difference
- 15:16in time zone. So you want to make sure that if
- 15:19that's an issue, that that's pointed out. This
- 15:23says it was produced because on a certain day
- 15:26and time, but it's three hours off because it
- 15:28was in New York and we're here in California
- 15:30and we've got. Attorneys in New York that were
- 15:33working remotely that day whatever you want to
- 15:35make sure that that information is provided correctly.
- 15:39So it doesn't look like you're hiding the ball
- 15:41with regard to text and optical character recognition.
- 15:45If you're using software to do that. It's so
- 15:48good now that I don't think you need to do too
- 15:51much other than show that it's done show what
- 15:55software software you've used and There shouldn't
- 15:58be a problem if there's an incorrect description
- 16:04from like when the when the OCR is reading a
- 16:07page and it gets it wrong, which can happen,
- 16:09although it's getting really good, but it can
- 16:11happen. That's something that can be easily corrected.
- 16:14Natives included where required native is, for
- 16:17example, if your document is native Excel, then
- 16:21you're going to want to produce it in Excel.
- 16:23You're not going to want to produce it as a word
- 16:25document. It's not going to be. manageable or
- 16:29usable by the attorneys that you produce it to.
- 16:34Privilege screen passes. So those are the actual
- 16:37pass codes or passwords that allow the attorney,
- 16:43the computer, whoever is doing this work, getting
- 16:45all the documents set up, for example, it gives
- 16:48them the privilege to get in. You want to redact
- 16:53any burned in verification of that. You don't
- 16:57want that information provided to the other side.
- 17:01And there's, of course, good cause to do that.
- 17:03You don't want them having access to be able
- 17:05to get into your computer. You want a sample
- 17:09for any privilege leak leakage or hot documents.
- 17:13Be certain that that That's the quality control
- 17:17side. Be certain that you do a pretty decent
- 17:20sampling, especially if you feel that your production
- 17:23has a lot of documents that really should be
- 17:27privileged. Your post production controls are
- 17:31going to include a production index with hash
- 17:36values. Hash values are a very specific kind
- 17:39of long number. Letter combination that specifically
- 17:45identifies a document. It's internal within the
- 17:47computer, but it helps to identify a document
- 17:52if there's ever a situation where there's a question
- 17:57about authenticity, for example, and your errata
- 18:00protocol. And again, there's code sections that
- 18:03deal with this, but you i would strongly recommend
- 18:07you stipulate with the other side as to a clawback
- 18:11ability replacement of productions where something
- 18:15was produced that is clearly privileged and i
- 18:20have a notice template have a template saying
- 18:22you know i'm sorry i'm now sending you notice
- 18:25that we. incorrectly gave you document number
- 18:285 ,267 and we are asking to have that clod back
- 18:33pursuant to stipulation. Of course, there are
- 18:36code sections that give you some or give the
- 18:39judge some discretion to do that, but it's so
- 18:42much better if you've stipulated to that in advance
- 18:45so that you don't have to have a motion. We're
- 18:49trying to avoid motion work, particularly in
- 18:51discovery. Next slide, please. All right, so
- 18:58what are our common failure modes? Broken families.
- 19:02Problem, if you've got the beginning of an email
- 19:05at document number 263 and then the next, the
- 19:09reply is at document 1057. You really want to
- 19:14make sure that that doesn't happen that can be
- 19:18Corrected by the instructions given to the technology
- 19:21assisted review for example to not break that
- 19:25up initially Or at all make sure the attachments
- 19:29again are part of that because there are very
- 19:32often attachments that are attached to an Email
- 19:36and you don't want those missing or again broken
- 19:39up and some Weird strange place in the production
- 19:43that you're providing we talked about the wrong
- 19:46time zone metadata issue over redaction can be
- 19:51a problem and it not only Makes the other side
- 19:57think that you're hiding something. It can make
- 20:00the judge feel that way as well. So if you can
- 20:04If you can really be transparent and Only redact
- 20:12what's required and necessary for confidentiality,
- 20:17for privilege. It's very important to do that.
- 20:20And then again, as we said, keep your designations
- 20:24consistent. You don't want inconsistent designations.
- 20:27It's going to be a problem when you're trying
- 20:30to defend what you've done with regard to your
- 20:33production. Next slide, please. All right. So
- 20:39how do we identify and address any deficiencies?
- 20:43efficiently because remember again what we're
- 20:46talking about is efficient discovery. Sometimes
- 20:48those two words shouldn't be used in the same
- 20:50sentence, but they actually really should. It's
- 20:54very hard to do, but it would be wonderful if
- 20:58discovery could become more efficient. Next slide,
- 21:01please. So you're going to categorize whatever
- 21:06is deficient. This is how you triage what the
- 21:10deficiency is. You're going to get a call from
- 21:11the other side and say something's missing. We
- 21:14don't have date ranges. We don't have bait stamps
- 21:17on everything. We're missing the custodians.
- 21:20You want to categorize your deficiency. What's
- 21:23the gap? What's the scope of the gap? Is it just
- 21:27custodians? Is it something more broader than
- 21:31that? And then you want to search that. gap?
- 21:35Is it a search gap because the terms were too
- 21:38narrow? You searched for something that was so
- 21:41very specific over a time frame that was shorter
- 21:44than what you were required to do, for example.
- 21:46That's an example of a term that is too narrow.
- 21:50Has there not been any iterative testing, which
- 21:52means a repetitive request to see if the first
- 21:56time through something was missed, right? So
- 21:59you want to figure out what the scope gap is.
- 22:02figure out what the gap is with regard to the
- 22:04search. Is there an actual production defect
- 22:08in the formatting, in the metadata, in the family
- 22:12issues that we've talked about? And then is there
- 22:15a defect in the privilege log insufficient descriptions,
- 22:19missing entries, the coding is not consistent?
- 22:22And then try to figure out, was that a one off
- 22:24error or is it systemic workflow failure? Because
- 22:27you're going to treat it differently. If it's
- 22:29one off, you can go through, fix it almost kind
- 22:32of by hand in a sense. If it's a systemic workflow
- 22:35failure, you need to kind of go back to your
- 22:38technology assisted review and figure out how
- 22:41can we reprogram this to get the documents that
- 22:45we're supposed to provide and to do it in the
- 22:47way that we need to do it. Next slide, please.
- 22:54So you'll have a one page deficiency chart, which
- 22:57I think makes perfect sense when you meet and
- 22:59confer with opposing counsel. You're going to
- 23:01list your issue. They're going to give you evidence.
- 23:04For example, there's no bait stamps. They're
- 23:07going to say what they want as a requested fix.
- 23:10You'll agree on a deadline and then you'll take
- 23:13the next steps. You need to have concrete examples
- 23:18five to ten documents showing look. This is where
- 23:21there were no bait stamps This is where the metadata
- 23:23wasn't set up appropriately rather than just
- 23:26broad Accusations if they come to do to come
- 23:28to you and say this isn't right. We didn't get
- 23:31everything It's not done correctly. No, that's
- 23:34not sufficient. You need to have a very, very
- 23:38valid meet and confer where you discuss those
- 23:41issues in detail and have your concrete examples
- 23:45and be able to then propose a remediation plan.
- 23:49Is there going to be supplemental collection?
- 23:51Are we going to rerun the searches? Is there
- 23:54going to be a targeted review or a corrected
- 23:57production with a, for example, larger sample
- 24:00size with a larger date range with whatever it
- 24:04is that the complaint is about? And I can tell
- 24:07you from doing so many informal discovery conferences
- 24:11in both regular civil and complex cases, it's
- 24:16a little frustrating for the court when the judge
- 24:19says, I would like you to provide not just two
- 24:25employees, if it's an employment claim, for example,
- 24:28but I want you to give a much broader sample
- 24:31size. Two out of 100 is not a sufficiently statistical.
- 24:36statistical sample size to start with. Let's
- 24:39get 25 % in the day and age of electronically
- 24:43stored information and you can't really as the
- 24:46defense in that, for example, you can't only
- 24:48make the argument that oh, it's going to cost
- 24:50too much. Yeah, it's not going to cost that much
- 24:52more. So it's you know, you need a statistically
- 24:56relevant sample size. You need to make sure that
- 24:59when you meet and confer on these issues that
- 25:02you're coming up with something that A judge
- 25:04would support. Next slide, please. All right.
- 25:11So how are we going to escalate this without
- 25:14wasted motion practice? Like we talked about
- 25:17in the first two seminars, set short deadlines,
- 25:21confirm them in writing, use proportional remedies
- 25:25like targeted sampling and just limited recollection.
- 25:27You don't have to necessarily redo the entire
- 25:31production if there's only certain arenas and
- 25:33certain areas in which there's a problem. Preserve
- 25:38your record keep all letters call notes, right?
- 25:42Make a note every time you talk with opposing
- 25:44counsel what you agree for protocols Hit reports
- 25:49will talk about for a quick second hit reports
- 25:52are not necessarily things that are discoverable
- 25:54to the other side You may get a hit on five thousand
- 25:58documents based on a single word but the rest
- 26:00of the document is completely non -discoverable
- 26:03it has nothing to do at all with that particular
- 26:04case so but preserve those records preserve the
- 26:08hit reports so that when there's a question comes
- 26:13up you can say yeah judge look i had a hit report
- 26:15of five thousand but only one out of the five
- 26:17thousand pertained to the case at hand and so
- 26:20that's why the other four thousand nine hundred
- 26:22and ninety nine are not being um you know produced
- 26:27So make sure that you keep a really like detailed
- 26:32log honestly of all of the things that are on
- 26:35this slide. Next slide, please. Alright, so I
- 26:42want to add just a few things. I don't see any
- 26:44open questions yet. Some things that have happened
- 26:47during my time on the bench and they're a little
- 26:50bit interesting. I've agreed to do them. Perhaps
- 26:52not every judge would, but if you've got a really
- 26:58Difficult privilege log you can ask the judge.
- 27:02Hey, can we give it to you? And can you just
- 27:04look at it in camera and we'll show you the documents
- 27:08not divulge anything to other side and just give
- 27:11us like your take on it. Is it? Is it valid?
- 27:16Is it ridiculous? You know, without going into
- 27:18any specific details. So in lieu of some protracted
- 27:22motion practice on a privilege log, I have done
- 27:25that. And I've said, yeah, I went through this
- 27:27and I actually went through it really carefully
- 27:29a couple of times and said, there's support.
- 27:33You don't want to give too much information,
- 27:35but there's support. You can't say don't make
- 27:36your motion, but you can kind of nip it in the
- 27:38bud in that way in an informal discovery conference.
- 27:41If you look at California Rule of Court 3 .724,
- 27:46it speaks to privilege and in Section 8, it speaks
- 27:50to privilege with regard to electronically stored
- 27:52information and privacy in, that's in 8E and
- 27:57then in 8F, it speaks to privacy. Also importantly,
- 28:02look at CCP 2031 .285 about electronically stored
- 28:08information privileged documents being turned
- 28:12over accidentally. You really want to avoid that
- 28:18happening. Again, the stipulation is your best
- 28:21bet to prevent a problem down the line in lieu
- 28:24of filing a motion and asking the judge to protect
- 28:27you. But in that code section, it does prevent
- 28:31the other side from going. The minute you notify
- 28:33them that there's been a problem, the other side
- 28:35cannot go any farther. in looking at it, producing
- 28:38it to anybody else, it stops everything unless
- 28:42and until you come up with a stipulated agreement
- 28:44or the judge rules on it. And then finally, evidence
- 28:48code section, I wrote this down, read my writing,
- 28:51912, lists a good number of the privileges that
- 28:54you're going to want to be working with. So keep
- 28:57all those in mind. We do have a minute or two
- 28:59if anybody has any questions. I know somebody
- 29:02was asking for the materials. I guess they got
- 29:04it. Does anybody feel free to put it not in the
- 29:09chat, we have a Q &A that you can ask a question
- 29:12or I'll look in the chat just in case. No, the
- 29:16link to the program materials is in there. Yeah.
- 29:19Okay, good. Okay. If there's no questions, thank
- 29:24you all for attending. I love discovery. I think
- 29:28that it is super important. It really helps to
- 29:34Can I view discovery? I'm not sure what that
- 29:37means from Giacomo Russo. Can I view discovery?
- 29:43What does that mean? Do you want to add to your
- 29:46question? Okay, actual privacy. The judge can
- 29:53do that and make a determination. It would be
- 29:57interesting to see how those motions came about.
- 30:01So I think that If there's an issue of privacy
- 30:08that is super important and it outweighs the
- 30:12benefit of whatever document might be provided,
- 30:15then yes, that would be an in -camera issue for
- 30:19the judge. Actual attorney -client privilege,
- 30:22too. Yes, I have done that as well. Again, it's
- 30:24going to depend on who your judge is. But yes,
- 30:28because sometimes you get counsel who honestly
- 30:30don't trust each other. is the bottom line. Most
- 30:33of the time you do, but work product, attorney
- 30:36client, confidentiality, privacy, personal identifying
- 30:42information, personal health information, you
- 30:45know, sometimes it's going to be super relevant.
- 30:47If it's a personal injury case and there's medical
- 30:50records that have to be involved, that could
- 30:52be relevant. If it's tangential, if it's mental
- 30:56health, if there's no mental health claim. Yeah,
- 30:58as a judge, I would go through that and look
- 31:01through it and determine whether or not that
- 31:04was something that should be produced and often
- 31:06err on the side of privacy. Crime fraud exception
- 31:11items depends. I mean, there are certainly crime
- 31:20items that are relevant in a civil case, right?
- 31:23If there's been a felony conviction. So that's
- 31:26a little bit trickier. But yeah, that you guys
- 31:30have good class. Those are good questions. Lots
- 31:32of fun. Okay. I think we're past our time, you
- 31:40guys. Are we okay? Yes, it looks like that's
- 31:46it for questions today. Thank you so much, Judge
- 31:49Greenberg, for an excellent program and an excellent
- 31:51series. Can I answer Rogelio's question, though?
- 31:56That's so sweet. Forgive me. It's not ignorance.
- 32:00In an informal discovery conference, which counsel
- 32:03can ask for, you can just... It's out. It's off
- 32:07the record. It's either in chambers or it's in
- 32:09the courtroom, but without a court reporter and
- 32:12you just say look I'm just not sure about this.
- 32:16Would you mind if we agree that judge you take
- 32:20back the documents before? You know the documents
- 32:23that they claim are privileged and the privilege
- 32:27log and just give us your take on it and That's
- 32:31how I've seen it done and I have done that in
- 32:33several cases over the years Again, can't promise
- 32:36you your judge in your case is going to be willing
- 32:38to do that, but it could certainly just nip in
- 32:42the bud a lot of protracted motion practice.
- 32:45So sorry. I'm so sorry. Go ahead, please. Now
- 32:47I just wanted I really wanted to answer that
- 32:49question. All right. This concludes today's presentation.
- 32:53I'd like to thank Judge Susan Greenberg for an
- 32:56excellent presentation today and an excellent
- 32:58series. And also a lovely thank you to our audience
- 33:01for joining us today. Have a great day, everybody.
- 33:04Thanks, everyone. Bye.