Latest / Legally Speaking with Michael Mulligan / Sugar, Support, and Frankie
Transcript
- 0:28Michael Mulligan: You read that right.
- 0:29Michael Mulligan: Okay.
- 0:30Michael Mulligan: That is uh fortunately not uh part of the I'm sure the uh uh warning labels on a website called Seeking Arrangement, uh which uh is a apparently a website which is intended to connect up sugar babies, a quotes, with sugar daddies slash mamas.
- 0:47Michael Mulligan: Uh and apparently the site works.
- 0:50Michael Mulligan: Uh this particular case uh involved a 23-year-old uh who wound up uh eventually marrying a 77-year-old sugar daddy.
- 1:00Michael Mulligan: They uh managed to find each other uh on that site.
- 1:03Michael Mulligan: Uh probably not surprising to uh many listeners, uh that was not a successful uh not a successful uh marriage, or at least for very long.
- 1:13Michael Mulligan: Uh the uh couple began cohabiting in March of 2021.
- 1:17Michael Mulligan: They that that lasted a while.
- 1:19Michael Mulligan: They they got married uh on April 4th, 2023, uh, but I guess things went downhill seven months later, as of November 2024, they separated permanently, uh, which brings us to the case we're going to talk about first.
- 1:33Michael Mulligan: Okay.
- 1:33Michael Mulligan: And this is an unusual case.
- 1:35Michael Mulligan: It's a BC decision, just came out, uh, and it is uh an application for interim spousal support, which is indeed a thing.
- 1:44Michael Mulligan: Um and uh pursuant to section it's fifteen point two for those uh keeping score at home uh of the divorce act, uh, it sets out uh the uh reasons why uh an interim support order might be made.
- 1:58Michael Mulligan: And I should say an interim support order is to be distinguished from like a final decision following uh a trial, right, about you know how much money should somebody get, a division of property, this sort of thing.
- 2:10Michael Mulligan: Uh and the Divorce Act sets out why we have such things, right?
- 2:15Michael Mulligan: Uh and uh it speaks there about various objectives, including uh recognizing economic advantages and disadvantages arising from marriage or its breakdown, after seven months in this case, uh the desire to apportion financial consequences uh for uh children, there were none happily here, uh, to relieve economic hardship and to finally promote economic self-sufficiency for each spouse with any reasonable period of time.
- 2:43Michael Mulligan: Uh and the idea when one of these uh applications is being made is it's not intended to be a uh you know a long process.
- 2:53Michael Mulligan: Interim orders are supposed to sort of bridge the gap between the time they're being applied for and the trial, which would eventually sort out what's to happen long term.
- 3:02Michael Mulligan: Uh now in this particular uh case, the sugar baby applicant uh was applying for, as you said, some twelve thousand dollars per month uh in interim support.
- 3:15Michael Mulligan: Uh and uh in uh support of that uh application, um she uh alleged that uh the 77-year-old uh soon-to-be ex-husband uh was uh uh should have a substantial uh income imputed to him despite the fact that on his tax returns uh he made very little income.
- 3:38Michael Mulligan: In fact, as the judge pointed out, looking at his tax returns for the previous four years, they were like $22,000 in one year and twenty-nine thousand another year.
- 3:47Michael Mulligan: One year he did uh claim $123,000, but most of it I was pretty modest.
- 3:52Michael Mulligan: Uh and uh her argument was that this uh she said he should have an imputed income of $2.45 million per year.
- 4:02Michael Mulligan: Uh and the argument for that was based on the opulent lifestyle uh that they enjoyed together.
- 4:09Michael Mulligan: Uh and it would appear that it was common ground.
- 4:12Michael Mulligan: They were living a fairly opulent lifestyle, um, uh traveling frequently, giving her expensive gifts, jewelry, handbags, watches, eating at expensive restaurants.
- 4:21Michael Mulligan: They were really living it up.
- 4:23Michael Mulligan: Uh but and this is the other interesting legal issue that arose in this case, uh, his evidence, which again appears to have been just completely accepted by the the judge, it wasn't a case where it's somebody who was like failing to report their income, like making money under the table or cheating on their taxes or something.
- 4:40Michael Mulligan: What was going on for this fellow?
- 4:42Michael Mulligan: Um yeah, his evidence was that he most of his expenses were made by the selling off of capital assets.
- 4:48Michael Mulligan: Interesting.
- 4:49Michael Mulligan: And so he had some uh capital assets uh in a uh corporation, and the corporation owed him a shareholders' loan.
- 4:57Michael Mulligan: It started out back in 22 of some 2.2 million dollars, and by 2024, I guess owing to the handbags purse's expensive lifestyle, it was down to $708,000.
- 5:07Michael Mulligan: So he was just spending his capital, basically.
- 5:10Michael Mulligan: Yeah.
- 5:10Michael Mulligan: Um and there is some conflicting law about well, how does that to be accounted for, right?
- 5:15Michael Mulligan: Because that is genuinely not income, right?
- 5:18Michael Mulligan: If you're just selling stuff and spending it, you haven't made income.
- 5:21Michael Mulligan: Like you don't pay income tax on that, you're just you know selling off your stuff, right?
- 5:25Michael Mulligan: It's like if you sold your house and sold the you've spent all that money over the next few years, you don't have an income, you you've just sold a capital asset.
- 5:33Michael Mulligan: Uh now there are cases that have considered that before, and it's not as clear as just, well, you just look at the income tax returns.
- 5:41Michael Mulligan: Uh and in fact, the way it's to be looked at um is that one of the uh considerations in setting an interim uh order for support is the sort of capacity of the person to pay.
- 5:53Michael Mulligan: And you can take that kind of income into account in a general way uh when deciding whether there should be uh uh an interim support order.
- 6:02Michael Mulligan: So you don't have to just stick with the income tax return, even though those were accurate, right?
- 6:06Michael Mulligan: Uh but then the judge looked a little further at what this uh woman was uh asking for.
- 6:12Michael Mulligan: Uh and she asked for this large amount of money, um, setting out uh various things she claimed to be um sort of necessary expenses, right?
- 6:20Michael Mulligan: And the judge took a look at those things, uh, and uh they uh they would have paid for what the judge I think fairly described as an opulent lifestyle.
- 6:29Michael Mulligan: Um she first of all was asking for the cost of insuring and fueling a Range Rover, which she no longer had.
- 6:35Michael Mulligan: That was part of her monthly expenses.
- 6:37Michael Mulligan: She also wanted tuition for a fashion school.
- 6:40Michael Mulligan: She apparently uh previously was a uh UBC student at the time she hooked up here, but then moved to fashion design, she said, at his urging.
- 6:49Michael Mulligan: Um she wanted $3,000 for rent, even though she wasn't paying any rent.
- 6:52Michael Mulligan: She wanted $500 for toiletries and cosmetics, and then finally she had an item listed there of salon visits.
- 6:58Michael Mulligan: She wanted $850 per month to pay for facials, massages, and eyelashes.
- 7:02Michael Mulligan: There's no breakdown of how much the eyelashes were, but that was her that was her figure there.
- 7:07Michael Mulligan: Uh and conversely, uh the uh husband on this uh uh husband in this uh circumstance, um, his uh view of it was that uh she didn't require any support, that she could uh pay for her expenses by selling the many gifts that he had given her during the relationship, uh that she had a wealthy family, and that she was capable of working, uh, including including by her own admission of previously working and earning income occasionally as a paid escort, probably not a great surprise.
- 7:37Michael Mulligan: Uh, and he therefore are argued that they should be imputing an income of thirty thousand dollars per year for her escorting activities.
- 7:44Michael Mulligan: Well, some of that the judge took into account, uh, but you can't, for example, argue that, well, your wealthy family should uh pick up the slack.
- 7:53Michael Mulligan: That didn't get too far.
- 7:54Michael Mulligan: Uh but the the judge wasn't buying her uh breakdown of why she needed this $12,000 some odd dollars per month, uh including for things like the uh you know wanting uh the cost of her online fashion school being paid for, even though she was separately asking for that under another heading.
- 8:11Michael Mulligan: By the way, she also wanted retroactive payment for the last 11 months.
- 8:14Michael Mulligan: So her initial claim amounted to this uh twelve thousand some odd dollars, but another hundred grand or so representing the last eleven months when she didn't get this cash.
- 8:23Michael Mulligan: Uh the judge, I think, quite sensibly, concluded that uh that was a bit much, uh, and that her needs could be met on a much more modest budget, uh, and so uh ordered uh that uh this fellow pay her four thousand dollars per month, but it'd be retroactive, and so she'd be looking at a uh forty-four thousand dollar uh payment uh retroactively.
- 8:45Michael Mulligan: That didn't end the case, however.
- 8:47Michael Mulligan: There's another element to it, which also is some legal interest, um, which is that she had applied for and obtained what is referred to as an ex parte protection order.
- 8:57Michael Mulligan: And what that means is that the same day she commenced the action asking for this money, she went to court without telling uh the husband, uh, and managed to get a judge to order a protection order claiming that she had been threatened or was in danger.
- 9:12Michael Mulligan: And she got the protection order.
- 9:14Michael Mulligan: Uh, and that wasn't the end of it.
- 9:15Michael Mulligan: She got this order and then she made a report, which the husband claimed was a false report, and I should say ultimately Crown did not approve charges, but she made a complaint that he had tried to contact her through her hairdresser, as as one would.
- 9:29Michael Mulligan: Um, and uh as a result of that, he wound up getting arrested uh and being taken into custody.
- 9:35Michael Mulligan: Um and when he was taken into custody, um she then showed up at the former family residence uh and wound up taking a bunch of things, uh including the dog, Frankie.
- 9:47Michael Mulligan: Uh and so she had the dog.
- 9:50Michael Mulligan: Uh and the husband's complaint was well twofold.
- 9:53Michael Mulligan: One, you know, she never revealed to the judge she was going to take a bunch of expensive things from the home, and she wound up taking like expensive handbags and jewelry and stuff like that, not just, you know, socks and underwear and her passport or whatnot.
- 10:04Michael Mulligan: But then the dog.
- 10:06Michael Mulligan: The dog was spirited away.
- 10:08Michael Mulligan: Uh, and so he was asking to have the protection order set aside on the basis that she had misled the judge uh about what she was going to do and take from the house and the circumstances, and he wanted the dog back.
- 10:19Michael Mulligan: Now, on the application to set aside the protection order, the judge did find, who was hearing this application, that uh there were some things in there that were kind of misleading.
- 10:30Michael Mulligan: Like the judge intentionally had a had a discussion about what it was she wanted to get from the house when she was to attend there on some occasion.
- 10:37Michael Mulligan: Uh, and it was clear that the judge was intended her to be permitted to get personal items like identification or her laptop, not a bunch of uh jewelry and handbags that the husband said were worth in excess of two hundred thousand dollars or scooping them up at the house.
- 10:51Michael Mulligan: Uh, but that wasn't enough in the judge's view to set aside the protection order completely.
- 10:56Michael Mulligan: Um, and so the judge had to then move on to what about Frankie, the dog?
- 11:00Michael Mulligan: Yeah.
- 11:00Michael Mulligan: And we have we have we have the Family Law Act in BC that actually sets out things that are now to be considered when determining who's to be taking care of pets.
- 11:10Michael Mulligan: They're not treated just like the handbag.
- 11:13Michael Mulligan: Uh and so under section ninety seven of the Family Law Act, uh there are a variety of things that a judge must decide when they are to determine who's to keep the pet.
- 11:21Michael Mulligan: And there are things like the circumstances when the companion animal was acquired, the extent to which each person cared for it, a history of family violence, any threats of cruelty, uh whether the uh child had a companion animal.
- 11:35Michael Mulligan: Anyways, all these factors the judge should take into consideration.
- 11:38Michael Mulligan: She, by the way, alleged that uh the dog was for her as a uh support animal, emotional support animal, again, not surprisingly, unsurprising, not surprisingly.
- 11:47Michael Mulligan: Uh, and she alleged that the husband had uh insisted on feeding Frankie inappropriate human food, making him ill, and so that was one of the reasons she wanted to have I guess he's giving the dog table scraps.
- 11:58Michael Mulligan: And so on all of that, those representations, the judge concluded that she got to keep Frankie, at least on an interim basis.
- 12:05Michael Mulligan: And so uh the net result of all of this, on all those considerations about interim orders and lifestyle and all this, was even after only a seven-month marriage, uh, he'll be paying her some four thousand dollars a month until this matter can get to trial to sort out what ought to happen long term.
- 12:22Michael Mulligan: Uh and so really this entire thing should be appended to the the entire decision should be appended to the seeking arrangements website, uh lest any other 77-year-olds think that this might be a great idea uh to uh uh go and uh marry the uh 20-something-year-old uh UBC student uh part-time uh escort.
- 12:43Michael Mulligan: So that's the latest from the DC Supreme Court uh in terms of some very bad matrimonial choices and how interim support works in combination with uh different kinds of income, and of course, who gets the dog on an interim basis?
- 12:57Michael Mulligan: So that's the latest uh on uh sugar babies uh seeking interim support.
- 13:02Adam Stirling: All right.
- 13:03Adam Stirling: Michael Malkenberg Michael is preventing a man from attending a welfare office and appeal for attempting to rely on inadmissible hearts and evidence.
- 13:25Adam Stirling: What happened?
- 13:28Michael Mulligan: Well, I uh the province lost twice despite the fact that this man did not show up at either hearing.
- 13:33Michael Mulligan: So uh credit to the judges involved for carefully looking at it uh without uh this man even being there.
- 13:40Michael Mulligan: And so the the background of this goes back to uh back in 2022 uh in Kelowna when this man showed up apparently at a welfare office there, uh, and according to a report, which we'll come to in a moment, uh did things including uh using intemperate language, whatever that might be, threatening staff and using a large stick to hit the ministry office, not hitting people, apparently just the office with the large stick there.
- 14:04Michael Mulligan: Uh and so the province responded by suing the man.
- 14:09Michael Mulligan: Uh and uh so they started uh uh an action uh and uh served him.
- 14:15Michael Mulligan: Uh and uh then uh come trial, I guess, of this action, the man didn't turn up.
- 14:19Michael Mulligan: Probably not a great big surprise that the person who's alleged to have hit the office with a big stick might not be the most reliable fellow.
- 14:25Michael Mulligan: Yes.
- 14:26Michael Mulligan: But in any case, he doesn't show up, so they get default judgment.
- 14:29Michael Mulligan: Congratulations, the province has won.
- 14:31Michael Mulligan: But they then ask the judge to grant what's referred to as a permanent injunction.
- 14:36Michael Mulligan: And a permanent the permanent injunction they're seeking would have permanently banned this man from attending uh the welfare office without prior authorization or communicating with staff through a third party, and it would last forever.
- 14:50Michael Mulligan: Now, this is going back a bit, but uh some uh movie boss might recall, Oh brother, where art thou with the ban from going to Woolworths.
- 14:58Michael Mulligan: It sort of had a ring of that.
- 14:59Michael Mulligan: Uh I appreciate that maybe a little uh a little dated.
- 15:01Michael Mulligan: But in any case, they wanted this uh permanent ban.
- 15:05Michael Mulligan: And the uh sharp-eyed judge looked at the evidence that the province was relying upon.
- 15:11Michael Mulligan: And the province was trying to rely upon uh this document, which was uh referred to as an IRT document prepared by uh some of the ministry staff at that office.
- 15:23Michael Mulligan: Uh and the province was trying to use that report, which sort of sets out the complaint about what this fellow is alleged to have done, uh, and they were attempting to use that as what's referred to as a business record.
- 15:36Michael Mulligan: And here's what that's about.
- 15:38Michael Mulligan: So in the Evidence Act, and there's both a provincial and federal evidence act that has some of the rules, like some special rules of evidence listed in it, and in British Columbia, one of the sections of that Evidence Act, section 42, and that's the act that would apply to civil cases like this, um, uh, provides that a business record uh can be admissible uh as evidence in a civil case like this.
- 16:01Michael Mulligan: And the idea there with a business record uh is like, let's say, for example, you're trying to prove like um, you know, how much money did somebody charge up on their credit card, for example, right?
- 16:12Michael Mulligan: There's probably no human being you could call in from Visa or wherever to say, yeah, I was keeping an eye on it, and you know, so-and-so put $300 on their credit card, right?
- 16:22Michael Mulligan: That just doesn't exist.
- 16:23Michael Mulligan: It's not a human process.
- 16:24Michael Mulligan: But the idea with that section of that act is that if you have a record which a business record which is made, and this is important, in the ordinary course of business, right?
- 16:35Michael Mulligan: Like things like, you know, till receipts that get printed out, or, you know, bank statements that come out of the computer, things like that, right?
- 16:42Adam Stirling: Yeah.
- 16:42Michael Mulligan: The idea is that if you follow the other requirements to introduce a business record, those things can be introduced to prove what they say.
- 16:51Michael Mulligan: And so that's how you would try to prove like somebody charged $300 on their credit card, right?
- 16:55Michael Mulligan: You'd get that thing and you'd have to prove it was made contemporaneously, and you know, be somebody cut there'd be some evidence about what that thing is and so on, but you can get that in to prove those things, because frankly, it would be very difficult, time consuming, or nay impossible to otherwise prove things like that.
- 17:10Michael Mulligan: But the rub, as pointed out by the judge, the original judge, and now the court of appeal, um, is that that particular thing that the province was trying to use to prove exactly what this man uh did was not really the kind of document produced in the ordinary course of business.
- 17:28Michael Mulligan: And the Sharpie judge, and the Court of Appeal agreed, looked at things like, Well, how is it that that thing gets prepared?
- 17:34Michael Mulligan: Is this just something that gets typed up anytime somebody comes along and hits the ministry office with a stick in some kind of an automated way?
- 17:40Michael Mulligan: Like, oh yeah, let's fill out the uh office was hit today form, uh right?
- 17:44Michael Mulligan: Yeah.
- 17:44Michael Mulligan: It's not.
- 17:45Michael Mulligan: And what the judge looked at was, well, this is a thing that gets filled out when like a supervisor can ask somebody to say, hey, you should make one of these reports.
- 17:54Michael Mulligan: But the problem with that, when it's sort of uh, hey, we've just been hit with a stick, and the supervisor says to the employee, hey, let's fill out one of these reports so we can go to court, it's not really kind of an automatic thing.
- 18:06Michael Mulligan: It's not really the ordinary course of business.
- 18:08Michael Mulligan: And the risk is that, of course, when you know, somebody who quite reasonably doesn't want to work in an office getting hit with large sticks might be inclined to, you know, maybe uh exaggerate something, or, you know, sort of uh express something in a way that might be more favorable to whatever their objective was, like stop this man from coming in and using intemperate language.
- 18:28Michael Mulligan: And so the judge found that well, sorry, this is not a business record, this is just something written up by the staff member when the supervisor asked them to after whatever this guy did uh he did in the in the the the office.
- 18:41Michael Mulligan: And so the judge at trial said, no, you you win, the man hasn't showed up, but you don't get your permanent injunction.
- 18:49Michael Mulligan: And so the province didn't like that.
- 18:51Michael Mulligan: And so they decided to appeal it to the court of appeal, which comes to the which brings us to the decision that just came out.
- 18:57Michael Mulligan: And once again, they duly served this man with the notice of the appeal, but again, not surprisingly given what's alleged here, he was at no-show at the Court of Appeal.
- 19:06Michael Mulligan: But the judge of the Court of Appeal, like the trial judge, were also sharp-eyed and careful and looked at the whole background of this thing.
- 19:13Michael Mulligan: And so uh the argument being made by the province in the Court of Appeal without this guy even being there, is they're saying, oh yeah, the judge made a mistake here, in that the uh judge, they argue, that is to say the province argued, applied this inappropriate extra test to whether this record should be in, suggesting that the judge was trying to determine whether this was reliable or not.
- 19:35Michael Mulligan: And he shouldn't have done that, because they, I guess, want to be able to use this sort of thing in future cases, hence their trip to the Court of Appeal.
- 19:42Michael Mulligan: Uh and uh so the Court of Appeal took the time to carefully look at that section and consider that argument and look carefully at what the judge had done.
- 19:50Michael Mulligan: And indeed, the judge had uh considered issues about whether this might be reliable for the reason I've indicated, because it's like, you know, the employee that just says we were hit with a stick, and the manager says, well, write up this report.
- 20:01Michael Mulligan: And so the Court of Appeal had took the time now to look at, well, what does that section of the Evidence Act mean?
- 20:06Michael Mulligan: And indeed, they found that that language of in the ordinary course of business, and this was referencing a previous decision of uh Justice Hinkson, uh says that there must be some evidence of reliability advanced for each document before it could be admitted under section 42.
- 20:22Michael Mulligan: And so we now have this decision, which is now clear authority, if there was any doubt given that language used by Justice Hinkson in the previous decision that was cited, is that when you refer to that language of in the ordinary course of business, there needs to be some evidence and some basis for a judge to determine uh that this appears to be reliable.
- 20:45Michael Mulligan: Uh and the court talked about the difference between things like the automated uh till receipt that prints out or like the you know the bank's visa statement or something, uh, versus this kind of a document that's kind of written up uh by somebody in this way.
- 20:59Michael Mulligan: And so the province lost uh and the uh trial judge's decision was upheld.
- 21:05Michael Mulligan: And the court of appeal went on to say, and I think this is not inappropriate either, the court of appeal said even if this wasn't was a problem, which it wasn't, analyzing the document in that way, the decision to issue an injunction, a permanent lifetime ban is discretionary.
- 21:20Michael Mulligan: And even if all that evidence was properly admissible, the Court of Appeal added they would not have exercised their discretion to from for a lifetime ban this man from going to the welfare office.
- 21:30Michael Mulligan: Uh and so that's the latest from the Court of Appeal.
- 21:33Michael Mulligan: The prophets got just what they asked for, and now very clear evidence about very clear law about when you can use those business records, and that's uh the latest uh from them.
- 21:42Michael Mulligan: And uh I guess if this fellow wants to go back to the welfare office, he can do so.
- 21:46Michael Mulligan: He just uh shouldn't bring the big stick.
- 21:48Adam Stirling: So that's the latest on business records uh and the Court of Appeal.
- 21:51Adam Stirling: Legally speaking, on T Facts Intevity with Michael Mulligan from Mulligan Defense Lawyers.
- 21:56Adam Stirling: Thank you so much, Michael.
- 21:56Adam Stirling: Pleasure as always.
- 21:58Adam Stirling: Thanks so much.
- 21:58Adam Stirling: Always great to be here.
- 21:59Adam Stirling: All right.
- 22:00Adam Stirling: Quick break news is next.