Latest / Energy Voice – Out Loud / EVOL: AR7 winners revealed
Transcript
- 0:00Hello and welcome to Energy Voice Out Loud, the weekly news
- 0:04podcast that keeps you up to date on the hottest stories from
- 0:07the UK energy market. AR 7 results finally revealed.
- 0:13Vieiro is still in a spot of bother and Petrafac updates over
- 0:18Christmas and some into January. I'm Aberdeen features lead Ryan
- 0:22Duff and joining me this week is our news editor, Erica Askland.
- 0:26How are you doing today, Erica? Very good.
- 0:29Thank you for asking. We've also got NW correspondent
- 0:33Floyd March. How you keep him in?
- 0:35All good, glad to be on the podcast.
- 0:36Again, and all the way back from Australia, he's up about the
- 0:41lack of sunshine in Glasgow is reporter Matthew Ferry.
- 0:45How are you doing today, Matt? I'm looking forward to a
- 0:47stonking podcast. Well, you are sharing a
- 0:52sentiment with a fellow Glasgow based person and that's Chris
- 0:57Stark who described Allocation Round 7's results as stonking
- 1:02success, I believe was the words he used after the UK government
- 1:07awarded CFDS for 8.4 gigawatts of offshore wind production on
- 1:14Wednesday morning. Now there's a lot to be
- 1:17discussed here, a lot to be unpacked.
- 1:19You know, we had industry sentiment kind of saying, well
- 1:22this is really great, you know where we've hit the target that
- 1:24we were needing to hit for AR 7, which the the last two
- 1:29allocation rounds at least were very short, especially AR5 when
- 1:33it didn't unlock any. People were saying it sends a
- 1:37good signal to it's a market up here in Scotland.
- 1:40There was maybe a better debate as to whether Scotland had been
- 1:44snubbed. Again, a talking point that was
- 1:46sort of circulating on the build up to the results.
- 1:49Matt, you were keeping an eye on the Scotland commentary in
- 1:52particular. Yeah, well, as you, as you
- 1:54mentioned, it is a pretty decent result for Ed Miliband and Co
- 1:59and Chris Stark described as a stonking result.
- 2:01But if you were RWE probably described it as vunderbar
- 2:04because they came away with a massive chunk of capacity
- 2:08contracts secured or CFD contracts I should say.
- 2:12Yeah, but up in Scotland, I guess it was in some sense, you
- 2:16know, a decent result. It's the first time since 2022
- 2:19that Scottish offshore wind projects have secured CFD
- 2:23contracts. And so a big chunk of that went
- 2:25to Berwick Bank. The SSC renewables contract,
- 2:27which we know has had a bit of a time of it going through the
- 2:30consenting process with the Scottish Government.
- 2:32It's had a lot of opposition from, you know, seabird
- 2:35charities and, and wildlife campaigners, but they secured
- 2:40ACFD for what they're calling phase B of the, the project was
- 2:44about 1.4 gigawatts capacity, which is a decent chunk of the
- 2:48overall 4.1 gigawatts, which, you know, when SAS complete,
- 2:52that's one of the biggest offshore wind projects in the
- 2:54entire world. That's on the development right
- 2:57now. And the other one that Scotland
- 2:59got was the Pentland floating offshore wind farm up north of
- 3:03Caithness, which we saw earlier or end of last year.
- 3:07I keep saying earlier this year, we're in 2026 now, but we saw a
- 3:10big investment, £150 million from GB Energy, the National
- 3:13Wealth Fund and the Scottish National Investment Bank into
- 3:16that project. So, you know, in, in some senses
- 3:19it's a good result for, for Scotland, but it could have been
- 3:22better is what I guess a lot of the politicians and, and
- 3:25industry leaders in Scotland have been saying, you know, you
- 3:27think of the likes of West of Orkney, They're one of the more
- 3:30advanced Scotland projects. They, you know, they've fully
- 3:33consented. They, they've gone through the
- 3:35whole process. They, you know, one of the
- 3:37quickest bulls out of the gate in, in terms of the Scott wind
- 3:41developers. But they were not to be seen in,
- 3:44in AR 7. And obviously we don't know then
- 3:46I'm I'm sure they won't be confirming whether they, they
- 3:49put in a bid, but you, you would expect that they would have and
- 3:54possibly being penalized for how far north they are in the
- 3:57subsequent transition charges that the factor into those,
- 4:01those sorts of projects. You know, we saw Scotland's
- 4:04energy secretary, Gillian Martin calling it a missed opportunity
- 4:07for Scotland. We've saw the likes of Aberdeen
- 4:09Grampian Chamber of Commerce, Russell Bothwick also, you know,
- 4:12feeling a bit disappointed and talking about these projects
- 4:16being at a competitive disadvantage.
- 4:17So, you know, well, overall a very good result and, you know,
- 4:21good geographical spread. We had projects up in the
- 4:23northwest. We had projects in the Celtic
- 4:26Sea, the Erebus. That's the first floating wind
- 4:29project down in the Celtic Sea to get ACFD contract.
- 4:33So you know, those early stage supply chain developments at the
- 4:38ports in the likes of Milford Haven and then Pembrokeshire
- 4:41and, and all around there. They're moving ahead for those
- 4:44bigger GW scale floating wind projects that are likely to come
- 4:47in the future in the Celtic Sea. But you know, as we all know,
- 4:50Scotland's very keen to have a lot more projects moving headed
- 4:53at a quicker pace and I guess eyes are now turning to to AR
- 4:57right to see what more tinkering Ed Miliband and Chris Start will
- 5:01be be doing with these rounds. Well, that's it.
- 5:04There was a lot of talk on the build up to AR 7's results about
- 5:07about Scotland's involvement. There hasn't been a Scott a
- 5:10Scottish offshore when project to receive ACFD since 2022 until
- 5:15yesterday at time of recording. And, you know, we were seeing
- 5:19sort of demand for that sort of transmission discussion ahead of
- 5:23time. Obviously not much came of it.
- 5:25And this is the result. But Maggie McGinley from ETZ was
- 5:29speaking about how things need to change specifically around
- 5:32that head of AR-8, which should take place next year.
- 5:37But I guess, I guess the question really is, you know,
- 5:41the the UK's wind ambitions, there's a lot of, there's a lot
- 5:44of scope for Scotland to to roll out when Scotland's a massive
- 5:48opportunity. But then, yeah, these projects
- 5:50just aren't getting through. Erica, you were speaking about
- 5:54that this morning. I feel like you've got an axe to
- 5:56grind a little bit. Absolutely.
- 5:58You know what I mean? I'll be I was at the a
- 6:00conference hosted by Holy Rood magazine yesterday, which of
- 6:04course you know, just happened to fall on AR 7 day as a happy
- 6:09coincidence. So there was lots of windy chat,
- 6:11as you might have expected on the ground.
- 6:14And so, I mean, ocean winds, you know, was was on there.
- 6:19And of course they're highlighting that, you know, for
- 6:22their wind farms, you know, they've got, you know, Murray
- 6:26East and West, you know, up in probably the most challenging
- 6:30geography in terms of connection charges.
- 6:35You know, they are looking at costs for their wind farms
- 6:40increasing fourfold, You know, which really just changes the
- 6:45competitive landscape entirely. When you're putting together
- 6:50bids, when you're trying to attract investment, when you're
- 6:52trying to sell power back to the UK through the CFD process in a
- 6:59manner that is affordable. Because like, let's not forget,
- 7:03affordability is a major issue when it comes to the CFD process
- 7:08that is essentially a forward contract, you know, on the price
- 7:12of energy. And of course, you know, as
- 7:14they, you know, net 0 haters like to point out the 1.8
- 7:21billion spent on, you know, this year's CFD AR-7 allocation round
- 7:27for offshore wind was twice, you know, what they had initially
- 7:32been planning to spend, Which of course is easily to just say, oh
- 7:37look, it comes back to the bill payer, doesn't it?
- 7:39Now we all know here amongst us, you know, kind of people who are
- 7:45living and breathing, you know, the offshore wind industry and
- 7:49the, you know, real challenges it faces in technologically, you
- 7:55know, kind of planning wise, connecting to the grid and
- 7:59investment wise. I mean, we kind of think that I,
- 8:02I'm for one, you know, love the idea of offshore wind.
- 8:06You know, I want to see it a huge part of the mix.
- 8:08And, you know, the UK is kind of factoring it in, you know,
- 8:10certainly in terms of 20-30, whether or not we'll meet those
- 8:13targets is another thing altogether.
- 8:16But I mean, it's, it's, it's, it's a challenge and it's
- 8:20expensive. I mean, they were sawing
- 8:22yesterday that, you know, the CFD's allocated for offshore
- 8:26wind is less expensive than a new gas plant, although, you
- 8:30know, that's a big question altogether too.
- 8:33But you know, kind of it's, it's a little, it's a weird thing to
- 8:35crow about. Um, so yeah, I don't know, I'd
- 8:39like to see the whole, you know, thing sorted out in Scotland in
- 8:43terms of the connection charging I.
- 8:45Do think, though, that, you know, as much as it pains us
- 8:47sometimes to to give credit to politicians, I do think some
- 8:50credit is, is due. You know, the as a lot of the
- 8:53analysts takes, I saw the coming out after this AR 7 round, You
- 8:57know, it, it basically came in at double what most analysts
- 9:00were expecting. They were thinking 4 to 5
- 9:02gigawatts. They thought 6 gigawatts if it
- 9:03was lucky. And you know, the analysts have
- 9:05basically said this result really does keep those clean
- 9:08power 2030, which a lot of people have been highly
- 9:10skeptical about, you know, thinking it's pie in the sky.
- 9:13It's never going to happen. They've, they've kept that in
- 9:15play, which I think is, is really what, you know, AR 7
- 9:19needed to do and it has, has done that.
- 9:21And I think, you know, we, we heard a lot of the, the
- 9:25tinkering beforehand or the changes.
- 9:27Obviously those changes that they've made have been, have
- 9:29been appealing to developers. And, and you compare that to
- 9:32recent various auctions in Germany and Denmark, which they
- 9:36were having their own AR5 moments, no bids for sites
- 9:38there, no bids for, for contracts in Germany and
- 9:41Denmark. And so you're also seeing
- 9:44companies like Equinor completely pulling out of
- 9:46markets like Australia and, and, and other areas.
- 9:49So I guess the UK is really bucking the trend in the, the
- 9:52offshore wind sector globally where people are actually still
- 9:54keen to invest there. And so I think that, you know,
- 9:57Miliband and Stark deserve a little bit of a pat on the back.
- 10:00And then we can do that for just today.
- 10:01And then we're going to be back into hammering them next week
- 10:04and all the other the problems that still exist.
- 10:06But, you know, I think it's, it's not what we were really
- 10:10expecting from AR 7. So I think they've they've
- 10:13probably got a bit of a smug feeling in Disney's offices this
- 10:19week and we'll, we'll let them have it for today.
- 10:21Let them have the stalking. I think you're absolutely right.
- 10:24Yeah, well, it's a rare opportunity for us to say nice
- 10:27words about the government on this podcast, but stick around
- 10:30because we're not going to be speaking about wind after the
- 10:32break. But Vieiro is still in a spin.
- 10:37International upheaval and uncertainty make one thing
- 10:40clear. Energy security starts at home.
- 10:43So what can Scotland do to leverage its advantages?
- 10:46What are the resources we should be thinking about industry and
- 10:49people to deliver security, affordability and tackle
- 10:52emissions? E Ford will be hosting a special
- 10:55event with Anna Sawa, leader of the Scottish Labour Party in
- 10:57Holy Rood on the 22nd of January.
- 11:00We'll have an on the stage interview with him and then
- 11:01panels drilling into what industry needs and how
- 11:04politicians can deliver. Sign up now for the event on the
- 11:0722nd of January. So Viero has been an interesting
- 11:15company to follow over the past couple of years.
- 11:19And I think I'm going to try to not commit any libel while while
- 11:23saying this is a lot, a lot going on with Francesco
- 11:26Madzagatti, the CEO of the company.
- 11:29And of course the company's dealings in the North Sea couple
- 11:32of years ago, about 18 months ago actually, they signed a deal
- 11:36with Exxon and Shell to buy some southern North Sea gas assets as
- 11:40well as the Bracton gas terminal.
- 11:43But Floyd that went up a Creek without a paddle yesterday
- 11:47didn't. That yeah, we did.
- 11:48And yeah, it was pretty big news yesterday.
- 11:52So obviously Shell decided not to proceed with the sale of of
- 11:56those assets. It's been a long old saga.
- 11:59I think the deal was agreed like 18-19 months ago.
- 12:03Shell wanted the deal done, the other back end of 2025 is
- 12:08obviously eked into 2026 and now we've got a no deal on the
- 12:14table. So obviously the deal would
- 12:16include the 11 gas fields and the back to terminal in Norfolk
- 12:20alongside an exploration prospect.
- 12:22So, you know, huge deal, huge takeover.
- 12:27But yeah, that like I think it's been mentioned like quite a lot.
- 12:30Like it seemed like quite a friendly decision of like, no,
- 12:34like it's see, like both parties seemed to talk about how it was
- 12:37like a mutual agreement, which kind of reminded me of those
- 12:41like early teen relationships where like you get broken up
- 12:44with, but you tell all your mates I was mutual just to try
- 12:47and like to save some face. Are you saying that Francesco
- 12:50Madsagathi was crying into his pillow last night?
- 12:52Is that what we're we're going for?
- 12:54Well, I don't need to come after me, so I'll say no.
- 12:56But I'll, I'll nod on the podcast.
- 13:01You should see what Floyd is signalling.
- 13:04You know that, the listeners. I think Floyd might get shot
- 13:11after that. In all serious though, you know
- 13:16it's a a very, very interesting situation.
- 13:21Situation. I think Shell and Exxon find
- 13:25themselves in. But you know what it it does,
- 13:29Let's not forget that, you know, the North Sea Transition
- 13:33Authority has been really kind of putting up reservations about
- 13:38this transaction in particular, not previous transactions
- 13:42because remember, Vieiro has become a significant North Sea
- 13:47investor and player when it acquired assets of Rock Rose
- 13:51Energy a while ago. So, you know, Vieiro, you know,
- 13:59love it or hate it is, you know, kind of like a significant North
- 14:02Sea investor. But you know what the NSTA said
- 14:08yesterday? You know, they, they were
- 14:10interesting and they said, well, they don't usually comment on
- 14:13transactions. Sure enough.
- 14:15But, you know, the ball actually had indefinitely in Viaro's
- 14:21court. NSTA had come to Viaro and said
- 14:25about this Shell transaction, we need some more information.
- 14:31And I think it's about we don't know quite what the, you know,
- 14:35tenor of this information required was.
- 14:39But, you know, they were still looking for him to fill his
- 14:41paperwork. And Bob was in his court.
- 14:44And, you know, that did not happen.
- 14:45And so Shell finally decided Shell and Axon finally decided
- 14:50to maybe throw in the towel. So what is going to become of
- 14:55this, you know, kind of 1/5 of gas N seas gas producing assets?
- 15:00That's a very good question. Is it going to be wrapped up
- 15:02into a Dura? Are they going to try to find
- 15:05another buyer? Is VRO going to have another go
- 15:08once it fulfills whatever the NSTA wants to see from VRO?
- 15:13But I mean, the question is, is why I was when I was at this
- 15:18conference yesterday, there was this question.
- 15:21It's like, well, what's what's wrong with Vieiro?
- 15:23I mean, you know, you know, why this whiff of brimstone about
- 15:28the company. And you know, of course there
- 15:30are, you know, issues that chief executive of Francesco Matagati
- 15:37has rejected as as baseless. You know, there's issues about
- 15:43funding and his, you know, kind of relationship with that and
- 15:49you know, various appeal courts going on, you know, kind of with
- 15:53regards to, you know, his previous work with Alliance
- 15:58Petrochemical Investments and what not.
- 16:01I mean, you know, there is just maybe some issues.
- 16:04Yeah, uncertainty is always a, a, a strong foundation to form a
- 16:09business deal on, isn't it? And it's, it's an interesting 1,
- 16:12isn't it? Because, you know, that whole or
- 16:14we were needing more information from Vieiro seems to be
- 16:17something that a stick that the, the North Sea Transition
- 16:20Authority is hitting Vieiro with a lot lately.
- 16:24If you look at the, you know, middle of last year, the, you
- 16:28know, Vieiro announced that they were wanting to take over
- 16:30Deltek, A fellow North Sea operator, and that deals are
- 16:36been in doldrums after the NSTA raised concern was the word it
- 16:42used around, you know, lack of details.
- 16:44And it's certain that that deal has been kicked into the weeds a
- 16:48little bit. And we don't really know what's
- 16:50happening with that. Well, yet another one that, you
- 16:54know, is, is ahead of us because I mean, honestly, like the, you
- 16:59know, Floyd was saying 18 months, you know, 18 months to
- 17:03say, oh, we're done a deal with Shell.
- 17:04Hooray, isn't this exciting? And then it's like going, what
- 17:08the hell is going on with this, you know, just going legs and
- 17:11legs and legs and legs. So I mean, I think you're
- 17:13absolutely right, Ryan, you know, kind of like, what are we
- 17:16going to see? What is was it?
- 17:18What is it going to take to get this £7 million deal with the
- 17:22Celtic over the line? Well, and that's the thing.
- 17:24And so if you've got, if you've got that uncertainty there and
- 17:26the NSTA is clearly trying to keep Viero at arm's length maybe
- 17:30through sort of worry about this or international court cases
- 17:35surrounding its CEO. I, I had the thought that this
- 17:38morning of is there also a thought from Shell and Exxon of
- 17:43we don't want to be a total and sell to Prax and then end up
- 17:47having these assets come back in our lap?
- 17:49Well, you know, I mean, this is the issue kind of when, you
- 17:53know, you are working in, you know, the North Sea where merger
- 17:58and acquisition activity is being driven by, you know, kind
- 18:03of petulant flounces like total energies, you know, just kind of
- 18:07wanting to get the hell out of the basin because they don't
- 18:11seem to see eye to eye with the tax man.
- 18:16You know, then selling assets to, you know, people who end up
- 18:20to be completely not up to the job, as was the case with Prax.
- 18:25Of course, Prax, you know, also bought it, made deals to buy,
- 18:30you know, assets West of Shetland that fell through.
- 18:33They were looking to buy the Shetland gas plant.
- 18:36And of course, Floyd, you've been looking at the fallout
- 18:40about, you know, kind of practice, you know, and what
- 18:43happens when they bought Total Energy's Lindsay refinery in
- 18:47Lincolnshire. It's a disaster.
- 18:50It is and I thought I'd get through one podcast without
- 18:52talking about the Lindsay or refinery, but here we are.
- 18:56But I, I guess it, I guess it kind of just shows the the
- 18:59landscape of the energy sector really.
- 19:01But I think the NSTNSTA will probably be pretty glad that the
- 19:05blame's not been put on them. Maybe that's why they made the
- 19:07statement that they did, because obviously they get a lot of
- 19:09stick for decision making across the North Sea.
- 19:12So they'll probably low key be happy that that Shell and Viaro
- 19:17are playing knives with each other and and they can then say
- 19:20that they was waiting For more information.
- 19:22But it just seems strange to me. Like obviously I'm not an expert
- 19:25in in the North Sea and all that stuff, but like I find it
- 19:28strange how like VRO, obviously they have interests in the North
- 19:32Sea already. Like how are they not able to
- 19:35sufficiently give the NSTA like what they need?
- 19:37Like surely they've been like dealing with these guys like all
- 19:40the time. So it seems like a really weird
- 19:42situation. So for all involved, North.
- 19:45Sea a weird situation. You know, I think, I think this
- 19:49is going to be, you know, is this going to be, you know, an
- 19:52energy voice out loud theme for 2026.
- 19:56Well, do you know what? Thinking of weird situations, I
- 19:58guess. Because this deal has fallen
- 20:00through, we've also got to welcome the North Sea's newest
- 20:03player, right? In the form of Shell, who wasn't
- 20:07a player. Last week, but is again now.
- 20:11It'll be interesting to see what happens there.
- 20:12Quite well see see, I was just saying the other day that you
- 20:16know kind of BP's the last super major standing in the North Sea,
- 20:20but you're. Right.
- 20:20Shell's back baby. Is is is Exxon not back as well?
- 20:24Did Exxon not have a bit of a stake in?
- 20:27Exxon return. Yeah, I suppose they're they're
- 20:30maybe a non operated partner in in the asset.
- 20:33But yeah, we've got the US super majors flying in as well.
- 20:36Look at this, 2020, 26 is clearly the year for the North
- 20:40Sea. We're.
- 20:40About on par with Venezuela now. Jeez, and and to be fair, the
- 20:47Super majors are calling us an uninvestable too, so it makes
- 20:50sense. I think Jim, Jim Johnson from
- 20:54Hunting said that Venezuela was more investable than the North
- 20:58Sea this week. So you know.
- 21:00What a great line, yeah. Well, I think that wraps up our
- 21:03Viaro speculation before we do end up getting hauled before the
- 21:07courts or anyone else for that matter.
- 21:10So stick around because after this break we'll be wrapping up
- 21:14by speaking about everyone's favorite Aberdeen based services
- 21:17giant, Petrofac. Hello, I'm Ed Reid, the editor
- 21:22of E Ford. E Forward is a membership
- 21:24community that brings together the entire UK energy supply
- 21:28chain, every hub, every sector, every stage.
- 21:31Our aim is to deliver growth to the energy sector, working with
- 21:34industry and policy makers to unlock the UK's opportunities
- 21:38and advantages. This is the movement to secure
- 21:41increased investment, improve policy making and better
- 21:44collaboration by providing our members with visibility,
- 21:47influence and access. Join me Forward today.
- 21:52So Petrofac, we all know the situation it's found itself in
- 21:56in recent months, the appointed administrators sort of in the
- 22:00third quarter of 2025 and we were uncertain about the future
- 22:06of various business units, namely myself being a little bit
- 22:11filled with hometown pride and maybe being a bit selfish.
- 22:15I was interested in particular in the asset solutions business
- 22:18which is based in the heart of Aberdeen but employs people up
- 22:23and down the UK. And on Christmas Eve there
- 22:27seemed to be a bit of a a bit of happy news, which we haven't
- 22:31heard from Petrofac in a good wee while, which was the
- 22:36American tank. And I think they call themselves
- 22:40fluid containment specialists, but essentially the manufacturer
- 22:44and design tanks. They're called CB and I and they
- 22:50said they'd be buying the the company, the Aberdeen based
- 22:54company, at least the asset solutions business.
- 22:56And while it maintains its North Sea operations until Petrofac
- 23:01goes into administration. That came on Christmas Eve.
- 23:06So a bit of a Christmas present for those Petrofac workers that
- 23:09spent months uncertain about their future, uncertain about
- 23:13what their unemployment status is going to be following the
- 23:17administration process. And today we got a further
- 23:21update. So this is, we're recording
- 23:23this. On Thursday the 15th, Petrovac
- 23:26announced that it's holding a meeting with its creditors,
- 23:30which we knew was going to have to happen to approve the deal
- 23:35that will be taking place at 10 AM UK time on the 30th of
- 23:40January. And the, the Asset Solutions
- 23:44Chief Operating Officer was I, I sorry, giving quite strong words
- 23:50saying, you know, we, we should back this, this is a good deal
- 23:54for Petrovac. It's a good deal for, for the
- 23:57asset solutions business. So that kind of reminded me of a
- 24:03similar situation that's been taking place in terms of another
- 24:08asset solution or another service provider in Aberdeen
- 24:12Wood, because Wood had a recent shareholder vote about its
- 24:16takeover at the hands of Sedara. Now, obviously that vote went
- 24:20through. I, I couldn't, I can't imagine
- 24:23this vote would be rejected. I can't see a reason why it
- 24:27would be. But Erica, I'm not going to say
- 24:30you've been around longer than I have.
- 24:32What I'll say is you're more experienced than I am.
- 24:35Is there a reason why this shouldn't go ahead?
- 24:39Well, no, absolutely not. You know, the the tenor of the
- 24:43announcement made, you know, the eve of Christmas, you know,
- 24:48delivering a miracle for thousands of Petrofac workers,
- 24:54particularly in the North East, applying their trade in the
- 24:57North Sea, you know, kind of suggested it was all in the up
- 25:01and up and everyone was happy. You know, everyone we've spoken
- 25:05to at Petrofac is seems pleased. And I can't imagine there's any
- 25:11reason why creditors, you know, kind of wouldn't actually
- 25:13support this because, I mean, when you're looking at, you
- 25:17know, something in administration, your job or
- 25:21Teneo's job as administrator of Petrofac Limited is to realize
- 25:27as much for debt holders, which could be anyone.
- 25:32It could be, you know, kind of like tax authorities, creditors,
- 25:38you know, customers, you know, who hadn't had their bills paid
- 25:43before the men in the big, you know, kind of black cars drove
- 25:48in and took control. And so, yeah.
- 25:51I mean, you know, yeah, it would be, it would be strange, unusual
- 25:56and extraordinary if, uh, you know, the creditors, uh, you
- 26:00know, decided against, uh, CB and I, uh, you know, coming to
- 26:03the rescue. Umm, So.
- 26:05Yeah. Umm, crazy.
- 26:08Yeah. So essentially this meeting is
- 26:09going to be, uh, to, to agree upon what it's calling a company
- 26:14voluntary agreement. And I, I found one line quite
- 26:17interesting. Umm, in the announcement, which
- 26:21was a company voluntary agreement, they've abbreviated
- 26:23the CVA. They've said the CVA is intended
- 26:27to compromise certain creditor claims to enable the completion
- 26:32of the deal. So clearly some people will be
- 26:34short changed. But is that to be, isn't that
- 26:37just to be expected throughout the the sales process throughout
- 26:41this administration? Never does an administrator end
- 26:45up paying back every single penny that a company's owed.
- 26:48Well, I think, yeah, yeah. I mean, you know, honestly,
- 26:51like, uh, creditors in this position, um, you know, we
- 26:55don't, we haven't had like a, a final deal.
- 26:57Um, but, um, it will, uh, you know, offer them, you know, uh,
- 27:02pence on the pout, uh, that they're owed, uh, which is
- 27:06always a bit of a tough thing for creditors.
- 27:09And ACVA is a is a, is a structure, a legal structure,
- 27:14which is different than, you know, like a Phoenix, which
- 27:17tends to get up people's backsides.
- 27:20Because, you know, a Phoenix company is, you know, the sort
- 27:23of thing that, you know, what you get is directors putting a
- 27:26company into an administration, then starting up, you know, a
- 27:29company the next day buying its assets out of administration,
- 27:32but not having to, you know, pay off its creditors, which again,
- 27:35you can see why that would be really annoying.
- 27:38But, you know, as CVA is, you know, kind of a slightly
- 27:41different structure. So and I see that John Pearson,
- 27:44you know, who seems to be leading, you know, this deal is
- 27:49in a really urging, you know, that everyone to kind of come
- 27:52together, come on and do it. You know it's a.
- 27:54Good deal. Do you want any money at all
- 27:57from Petrofax and maybe approve this deal as kind of the
- 28:00mentality, isn't it? Well, thinking of wanting money
- 28:02from Petrofax, Matt, you've been keeping an eye on Companies
- 28:05House and you've been looking at their list of creditors.
- 28:10How bleak is the situation? Well, we don't have a list of
- 28:12creditors yet. I'm sure that will be becoming,
- 28:16but we've had some creditors reach out to us.
- 28:19We've just had a supply chain firm in the Netherlands inform
- 28:21us that they're at about 140,000 USI believe, which was, you
- 28:25know, for a small company that's not a, a small chunk of change.
- 28:28I'm sure there will be people on the Petrifact list of creditors
- 28:31with with much bigger debts owed than that is in total.
- 28:36Petrifact collapsed. We, we found out earlier was
- 28:39sort of late last last year that it was around about 2 billion
- 28:44U.S. dollars Petrofac was owing across secured debts and
- 28:48unsecured debts. So the secured debts was around
- 28:51$708 million and they're sort of non preferential creditors.
- 28:56So basically these are people that are likely to wind up in in
- 28:59the lurch. That's estimated around 1.4
- 29:01billion US. So there's a lot of money owed
- 29:06basically is the situation. And yeah, I guess they're
- 29:11currently going through the process of, of seeing what
- 29:13assets they can they can sell to get.
- 29:16We've seen Petrofic Asset Solutions potentially being
- 29:19snapped up by CBI, I believe it was.
- 29:23And so, you know, it's nervous time if you're one of these
- 29:28supply chain companies that is waiting for an invoice to be
- 29:31paid. It's back to that old chestnut
- 29:33though. If I owe £10 it's my problem,
- 29:38but if you lend me £10,000,000 it's your problem because you
- 29:44know, it's about, you know, the size of the debt.
- 29:46And of course you know, that's essentially, you know what, you
- 29:51know, Petrofac, you know, as their problem was, you know, too
- 29:56much debt. You know, the deals that they
- 30:00tried to, you know, the pain, you know, of that negotiation
- 30:03that they trying to come to an agreement with, with
- 30:06bondholders, You know, in the run up to pulling the plug and
- 30:10calling the administrators. You know, was a long, storied
- 30:13saga which chronicled quite adequately I'd found on Energy
- 30:19Voice. And it was always like a really
- 30:20popular story with our readers just because, you know, so many
- 30:24people rely on that business. It's a huge employer.
- 30:28It was a huge employer. So Asset Solutions now has found
- 30:32a home for quite a lot of those employees to 3000.
- 30:35Well, I think I've said this before and I think the reason
- 30:37that it's such a popular story among readers is the fact that
- 30:40at least in Aberdeen, I can't speak about other parts of the
- 30:43country. Petrofax, a household name, you
- 30:45know, it's, it's one of those things that, you know, it's a
- 30:48company that would sponsor, you know, school initiatives and go
- 30:51into local primary schools to speak to people about career
- 30:55opportunities or whatever. And, you know, so if you told
- 30:57your your granny that you were, you got a job at Petrofax, she's
- 31:00not going to ask who's that, you know, And so definitely an
- 31:04important, an important employer in this part of the world.
- 31:07So that, that sort of leads quite nicely into the last thing
- 31:10I wanted to, to flag around this deal, Percy B and I said that
- 31:14essentially it would onboard 3000 employees that would save
- 31:173000 jobs if the deal completes. That's, that's interesting
- 31:22because in the sort of build up to the administration and the
- 31:25reaction from the news, a lot of politicians were saying this
- 31:27puts 2000 jobs in Scotland at risk.
- 31:30So it shows that, you know, this the, the wide source, the wide
- 31:34reaching impact of the, the asset solutions business.
- 31:38But I guess the question is what happens to the asset solutions
- 31:42business if it gets brought, brought in under a company with,
- 31:45you know, not any North Sea experience.
- 31:48From my understanding, they've got, they do dealings in energy,
- 31:51but not in, in offshore UK at least.
- 31:55And essentially they've said, well, we'd create a new business
- 31:58division and we'd have CB and I asset solutions and CB and I,
- 32:02what we do now, essentially. So it seems like it would
- 32:05essentially just be allowed to continue as is, which is kind of
- 32:09in line with what the the administrators have been saying.
- 32:12And throughout this process, which is actually the North Sea
- 32:16business was a bit of a jewel in the crown and the in Petrofac.
- 32:20And it was doing, it was doing well, despite claims that the
- 32:24reason Petrofac fell into administration was the windfall
- 32:27tax and stuff from all position politicians.
- 32:29It's just that blatantly not what it was like.
- 32:32The the main. The main lesson to be learned
- 32:35from Petrobras administration is don't get embroiled in fraud
- 32:39cases in the Middle East. Now don't get me wrong that
- 32:43they've never said that. They've never pled guilty to
- 32:46fraud. However, employees from the
- 32:50company from previous years have accepted a rap on the knuckles
- 32:55in court and that caused issues for them.
- 32:58Anyway, that does it for this this week's episode, so I feel
- 33:03like I've probably gotten myself into some legal trouble, either
- 33:07with Francesco Mazzagati or what remains of Petrafac after that
- 33:11comment. Who knows?
- 33:12Nice knowing you mate. Yeah, yeah, skirting danger here
- 33:15on Energy voice out loud every week.
- 33:17Well, if you want to see if the lawyers do get in touch with me,
- 33:20well, you're going to have to see if I show up to next week's
- 33:22episode. So if you stay tuned on your
- 33:25podcast platform of choice, we'll be in the same place, same
- 33:27time next week.