Latest / Building Real / He Got Deported. Then Built Airbnb's #1 Culinary Experience | Dhruv Shanker
Transcript
- Arjun Thomas: ⁓ So ⁓ I guess ⁓ a good way to start ⁓ would be if you could just quickly ⁓ kind introduce yourself ⁓ what is it that do. ⁓ Dhruv Shanker: Sure. My name is Dhruv and I'm an entrepreneur based in Singapore. I run two businesses fairly different from each other. ⁓ My first business is an e-commerce enablement firm where I help brands enter Singapore and sell on marketplaces a lot faster and just accelerate their e-commerce journey. My other business is ⁓ in food. I'm a former professional chef and I run a private dining business which also has branches in terms of a cooking class and a catering model as well. Two very different things but still all run by one person. So that's really what I do. I find my businesses crossing over sometimes because I end up selling food on my e-commerce platforms as well. But ⁓ no, they're two separate things that are equally important. Arjun Thomas: So I guess that's a good place to start as any. ⁓ Is it a question of a left brain, right brain? trying to co-exist when you're running two very, very different businesses at the same time. And the reason I ask the question is that most people struggle to just do one thing well, if at all, ⁓ and you've taken up the task of doing two things that have some overlap and we'll probably dig into it a little bit more. ⁓ But why these two things ⁓ over anything else that you could have, should have, might have done? Dhruv Shanker: Right, right. Well, okay. Right brain, left brain is an interesting way of looking at it because I never thought of it that way. I mean, my entire journey with food, right, I'll rewind a bit because I started out as a chef. I went to culinary school, got my degree in the culinary arts, but then was not able to make enough money. Okay. And my story is actually... It's not like I stepped away from the hotel industry because I stopped loving it or anything like that. I loved it, but I just didn't make enough money. So I ended up chasing a paycheck and that's why I started doing different things. I ended up working in a call center for a bit. I worked at Google for some time, eventually ended up as a founding team of an e-commerce company. And throughout this journey, right, I've always thought that I would stop my tech journey or my corporate journey, let me call it that, at some point, and then I'll start a restaurant. The interesting thing that happened, I think this was when I was working at Google ⁓ in the early 2000s, was that I really started liking it. I started liking the corporate side of my life as well. And while I did miss being a chef, I said, look, maybe I can do both of them, right? So I decided at that point that I was going to have some kind of a side hustle in food. Actually, this predates Google as well. When I joined the call center. then that was probably the biggest leap I took because I hated it. I couldn't stand it. I felt like I had sold my soul. was like, dude, Hotel Nashville was expensive, man. It put a big strain to get me through college. And not to mention, like I went from flipping omelets in a balcony in Munnar, which is a lovely hill station in Kerala. You must visit. I'm sure you've been. But I went from doing that to sitting in a cubicle selling computers at Dell. And that felt like a real betrayal to myself. And then I was like, dude. We've got to fix this. So, but I still needed the paycheck. So I'm working in the call center, but I'm also cooking on the side. So my side hustles in food have taken many different forms. So it's been a food blog. It's been sending party snacks, something or the other. Just keep that little flame alive. I think at some point, right, ⁓ this side hustle became a larger part of my life and ⁓ it entered a 50-50. And I think just through... rigorous understanding of my own productivity patterns and just what pays the bills and what keeps me happy You know, I managed to hit that balance of doing these two things. I know it sounds chaotic It is chaotic sometimes but it is a beautiful chaos that I thrive in so for me to balance these two things ⁓ It actually you know, it feels very nice and feels very comfortable because one pays the bills one keeps me happy one keeps and keeps me sane So so I think I'm in a good place that way. Yes ⁓ Is it hard to run two companies? It is. It is. So at some point I actually had to merge some of the efforts. My accountants actually don't like this side of it. But we figured it out. So that's where I am. Arjun Thomas: What do you enjoy about the non-sexy side of the business that you're kind of operating on? So obviously we talked about clearly the love for food exudes out of every pore, if I could use that term. But when it comes to the other non-sexy, pay the bills kind of business, what excites you about that ⁓ beyond just the paycheck? Is there anything that excites you about it? Dhruv Shanker: it. ⁓ ⁓ absolutely, I still think e-commerce is very very fascinating. I think I'm drawn to e-commerce naturally because you know it is at its heart core entrepreneurship. You know I'll give you an example of when I was at Alibaba. So I spent four great years at Alibaba. Everyone said you're gonna hate it, the culture is very aggressive, it's gonna be whatever right. Honestly I loved it. I first worked at Lazada which is their Southeast Asia adventure and then I worked at Daraaz which is the South Asia adventure. And I've got a great understanding of just how this massive engine works. And I had my aha moment in one of the leadership meetings. And the room is packed full of SVPs and above and CEOs there standing and everyone's thumping their chest talking about how we made this happen and we made that happen and we drove this much growth and all of that. And at some point I just stopped and I looked at the slide and I was like, we didn't make any of this happen, man. We made... the engine we made the platform, yes. But ultimately it was that seller, it was that handful of sellers, know, the Pareto principle, right? It was that 20 % of sellers who really figured out how to use this platform and they made this happen. We are hitting our targets, we are going on this fancy offset because they did their bit really well, okay? And at that point, right, I just made that decision that look, I don't want to be the highest paid exec in this room, I don't. I'm not about this ladder anymore. I want to be the most successful seller on this line. That's what I want to do. So even now if you ask me, I'm much more interested by going to a seller summit, where you meet other e-commerce sellers, people who figured out a gap in the market. I went to Amazon seller summit recently and I met this guy who just figured out how to sell that square ⁓ omelet pan, the Japanese omelet that is rectangular. Dude, why? Why did anyone else think of this, right? This is a 32 year old guy who just bought five different pans from Alibaba and then tried to figure out what works and then built a brand around it. And now he's the highest selling omelette pan guy on Amazon US. Now if you think about it, that is fantastic, right? Like you don't need any great degree to go and crack that. But the perseverance, the drive to do that. And everyday people succeed at e-commerce. The entire business is built for that, right? And that's what I find fascinating. So that's why, you know, when a brand comes to me and says that, we're struggling to sell, we're getting, we want to sell faster, we don't know how to do it. I'm like, dude, there are a lot of things you can do. Probably focusing your efforts on the wrong things. So that... you know, clarity that I'm able to bring to the table in terms of saying like, okay, you've got half a million dollars to spend, spend it on these three things, right? Start with something as unsexy as SEO, right? Because that will help your products show up first. Run measured tests, use AI to scale this thing fast and fail fast and then pull out. But don't go and paint like five buses, you know, just to get your brand out there, because it may not work. So those are the kind of things that excite me. ⁓ I'm very selective with the kind of brands that come in. I usually look for a brand that has some amount of PMF. But then after that, you start looking at how you can really help them execute that marketplace strategy better. And that still keeps me quite excited. And I love applying those learnings that I've gotten over the years from the space to new brands and to new products. Arjun Thomas: So maybe then. that's the connective tissue between you being a quote unquote small seller yourself ⁓ and the small sellers on all the pseudo small sellers who actually sell large volumes on e-commerce platforms. Having seen, I'm guessing, a number of them and you seem to have identified those that ⁓ like the Japanese, the egg pan guy, ⁓ what makes a seller good? What do you need to, because it's not the platform, it's not the technology, they are piggybacking off platforms like Lazada to get access. But what makes these sellers different ⁓ than the other 10 sellers who also try to sell the Japanese Omelette SquarePan? Is there something in the way they approach ⁓ communicating with consumers that makes them stand out? Is there a pattern there that you've seen, having witnessed a lot of these ⁓ sellers on these platforms? Dhruv Shanker: Yeah, great question. think the answer varies by country because e-commerce is, you know, it's not a cookie cutter. You know, it's different in every country. your consumers are different, behavior is different. This omelette pan may not work everywhere else. But I'll give you from an Asian perspective and try and somewhat put Southeast Asia in a bucket. ⁓ See, people believe reviews more than any other marketing. So that's the first thing I think brands need to wise up and realize that, let me focus on building trust with the consumers. And how you build that trust is not through a series of brand advertising. ⁓ It is through actual customer feedback and getting your first 100 reviews for a product, super important. Discovery is also something that is very different in Asia. mean, your product gets discovered through video primarily and in so many different formats, right? So you can't just be doing these static listings and hoping that the algorithm will pick you up. And we are also reaching a point where it's actually quite easy to reach that customer if you know exactly who you're selling to. So think a lot of people launch products without really understanding the audience. Map the audience first and understand that they're willing to buy. This omelette pan, sure, it's a Japanese omelette. How many people make Japanese omelettes? Turns out in Singapore quite a lot, okay? Because in Singapore, there is a natural affinity towards Japanese culture. It is one of the top destinations visited by people in Singapore. People love going to Japan. It's super easy and it's not too much of a flight. And if you just look at trends, right? The number of Japanese restaurants. with this product. If I were to take this Japanese omelette pan and probably try and sell it in, I don't know, maybe India, right? I might have to work a little harder for it. Arjun Thomas: Hmm. Dhruv Shanker: So look at trends. I'll give you another great example. Korean hot sauces. There's a brand called Bull Duck that is taking the world by storm right now. But you know which market they launched in before even coming to half of Southeast Asia? It was actually India. And that was because the Korean dramas are so popular in India. Korean culture has become so popular. K-pop and all of the ⁓ bands, the shows, all of that, right? It's a cultural phenomenon. They have a huge footprint already in India. So they went and launched their line of products in India. Amazon and today they're a multi-billion dollar business just in India alone. So if you look at that right that is a clear understanding of the audience first and then deciding where to go and launch. It's very easy a big company here you can go and say okay tomorrow I'm going to go and launch in these five markets but is that the right thing for the business? No. think about that a little more, a little closer, that's what I would say. So coming back to the omelette guy, he's also done the same thing. He may not be sitting on a Hot Sauce Empire or a ramen kingdom, but he's still doing fundamentally the same thing. Is there an audience for this product? Let me size it up. Let me not go and buy a huge amount of it. Let me get a little bit in, let me run a test, and then let me get some customer feedback and use that and use video and use tool. influencers to build that trust around your product and then just go Arjun Thomas: So a lot of this is, again, in a way pattern recognition, right? So the pattern here is consumer behavior and their interests and needs, which in a way, ⁓ using the example that you did about Korean ⁓ hot sauces entering India using K-pop as an avenue, again, not connected to food at all, but again, you need to look at, I guess, cultural phenomenon more broadly to figure out where there are overlaps to kind of piggyback on in that example. ⁓ So how does that, ⁓ is that common enough? trait that you see in small sellers because it takes a fair bit of ⁓ sales savvy, consumer savvy, of ⁓ human psychology in a way, the way people kind of buy in what people like and why they like what they like and to do it more abstractly in a world that is so interconnected. the hot sauce brand started selling in India again, it's a market unless it was an Indian sitting in Korea trying to get into the Indian market. So given all these ⁓ variables, ⁓ Is this more uncommon than it's common? Those individuals that really come at it at the intersection of ⁓ understanding human psychology, buying behaviors, cultural phenomenon, then piggybacking and figuring out a service or product that they can sell into that. In the SME space, in a large organization, there huge departments, I'm sure, but in the context of small businesses and entrepreneurs. Dhruv Shanker: Absolutely. Yeah. Sure, sure. Absolutely, it's not like everyone nails it and there's no formula the omelette guy is going to the he's going to do that for a while and That trend is also going to taper off But he's already got to be thinking about the next one and that is just how it works for everyone like in most e-commerce sellers It's their 10th or 11th product which actually starts taking off you have to try you have to try a lot of them ⁓ Arjun Thomas: Yep. Dhruv Shanker: And again, sometimes it's a cultural phenomenon. This thing with India and the Korean dramas actually where some of the dishes, Tteokbokki for example, became quite popular in one of the dramas and that's how Indian kids got familiar with the product and somebody decided to go jump on that trend. I'll give you another great example. I met somebody who sells pickle ball. rackets and a pickleball racket with a little innovation as well. It's a little clip that just goes in. It's the strap of the pickleball racket but it just goes and clips into the thing and there's accessories basically building around the pickleball you know phenomenon like if you look at it we all know that pickleball is picking up right and people are starting to go that are you know it's a trend but it is a handful of sellers who decide to go and do something about it. Arjun Thomas: Mm-hmm. right. Dhruv Shanker: So observing that trend, I don't think comes to everyone. Yes, it is still reserved to a small number of sellers who display this awareness. ⁓ And again, it is also category specific. Like I don't think somebody who's tracking hot sauces very closely is also going to be tracking pickleball. but that's the beauty of e-commerce. It's so wide, it could be anything really. ⁓ So to answer your question, yes, it is a fairly small number of sellers because once you become the big dog there, right, then you kind of dominate that space. And then the interest for others to come in is somewhat low because you don't want to go and compete because e-commerce platforms are expensive to sell on to begin with. So you're like, okay, fine, I've lost, I missed the bus on this. Let me move on to the next thing. That's usually the thinking behind it. Arjun Thomas: So I'm going to just kind of double click on that. So when you say missed the bus, given that someone spotted a pattern, they looked at an opportunity, they probably on their 10th test and the 11th one worked. In this case, the sauce in India, the pickleball strap. Is it? The way you are articulating it, correct me if I'm wrong, it's almost that the first mover wins the whole market. But is that actually true? what prevents someone else from coming and offering the very same product? Because again, the first person saw an opportunity, figured out the market, got in. Is it so binary? Is it a winner take all, or the first person take all kind of mentality? And why is that so? Dhruv Shanker: Advantage. No, no, definitely not the first mover. Like the first mover has the advantage for sure. But it's not like the number, you just see somebody that's like, you walk away from it. If you can see that you can manufacture cheaper, if you can get this better and you can get it to market quicker, that is always going to be your, your, your, your ticket to win. See, ultimately it is, we, we got to come back to the consumer, right? If you can get this product in front of the consumer fast. Arjun Thomas: Right. Dhruv Shanker: and in the best quality possible, right? They're always gonna choose you over there. And price, price is obviously gonna be it. So it's okay if someone's already started, you see someone selling pickleball rackets and what not, and you're like, okay, fine, I think I can do this better. Take a crack at it for sure. But you have to be able to see that. opportunity that is the second option now. Somebody spotted a trend great but can I do better than that? Sometimes you look at them okay maybe I can do better designs right so that is where you'll have to come in so don't give up completely that's what I tell a seller but most of the time you know people who are seasoned at e-commerce kind of you know will have those bases covered. Depending on the size of the category, then there might be room for 2-3 players as well. But really depends on the product. saying that yeah it's a winner-take-all kind of thing but sorry I also want to double click on this a little bit because see some things are here to stay some people and some products are just fads like today this morning I saw this ⁓ handbag that's gone viral it looks like a like a Chai Fan like a Chinese takeaway food container but the handbag okay it's very cool, it looks exactly like a food container we should pull it up on the screen at some time but that's a fad okay and they're going to sell a lot but they're going to sell a lot just for maybe a month or so so in that case like i don't know if you want to go and say hey can i make a better version of this Maybe you just jump on the trend, right? And try and them on price perhaps. Yeah, that's it. But with something like a hot sauce, that's there to stay. You're always going to want hot sauce. You will always want something to put on top of your ramen. You'll always... So that's a place worth experimenting. That's a place, that's a category worth pursuing. There could be more players in that for sure. Arjun Thomas: See how long you can write it, essentially. And in the context of, again, as a small buyer. ⁓ Where? And you hear lot of these stories again from Amazon where you have ⁓ buyer teams just waiting for SMEs to kind of do all the grunt work, get to the 11th successful product and then kind of copy it. And then they have economies of scale, they can under price you, undercut you, get in front of ⁓ customers a lot cheaper, a lot faster than you potentially can. What worry do SMEs have when they're trying to create these new market segments where you have large brands, again I don't know if I'm ⁓ being too much of a pessimist but you have teams waiting in the wings as it were if this was a movie plot, just waiting for trends and saying hey we've got a small SME that's figured this out, you know we've got enough money to throw at this, let's just undercut and just make a bit of money for as long as we can and then find the next one and go. Is that a very pessimistic view that I have or is that a... Dhruv Shanker: Yeah, yeah, no, definitely. Yeah. that very much happens but very much happens so look I call myself an ecommerce accelerator okay a lot of other people also call themselves that incubators also call themselves accelerators to some extent and these guys will go and incubate an ecommerce brand but then they also have to help them grow and take off so this is a very real thing I have been contacted for numerous surveys ⁓ Arjun Thomas: Hmm. Hmm. Dhruv Shanker: hey, what are you guys doing? But you know that this is a big brand that is shopping for a trend and is sometimes even looking to get ahead of that. See, it's a very real thing. I think the difference between a big brand that's just waiting to swoop in is that sometimes they lack a bit of agility. And that is where a little local scrappy seller can come out ahead of them. Arjun Thomas: Right. Hmm. Dhruv Shanker: It's still very much a thing. Like if it's a big opportunity, yes, a big brand could come for you. But again, yeah, that's when marketplaces are democratic, so it's okay. Maybe you play your game right and then you position yourself as a partner or find a way to get in with that. Because manufacturing and see, big brands struggle with so many things, right? I mean, you won't be able to just get your product into a country so fast. You can, you know, for you to go and start signing deals and procuring and creating, just doing the branding and all of that. Those are things which take time. I'm not saying that they can't do it. There's a good example, actually. There's a company called, I'm sure you know, Himalaya, which is the cosmetics company, big giant from India. They had a really good product called, what was the Hangover? think it was called Party Smart. It was called Party Smart. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Sounds familiar. You seem like somebody who's consumed it. Party Smart, So Party Smart was a great product, okay, but they doing very well in India. And these guys wanted to launch Take It Global because it worked. At the end of the day, was electrolytes and all good stuff for you to make you feel good after the night of party. Arjun Thomas: I'll write it again sounds familiar yes yes yes yes yes yes party smart and ironic name if anything right Dhruv Shanker: But the product was still branded as Himalaya. And Himalaya as a brand was very old school. Let me put it this way. It's a traditional brand, respected brand, but it's associated with good hand creams and things like that and maybe other wellness products. But not party, not a crazy night out in town. So at that time, there was, you Like what do do? You have a great product, rebrand it, rebrand it, call it something cool, right? Put it into a new packaging altogether. You've got the formulation, which is probably the hardest part. But they just never did anything with it. Just never moved on it. And there was so much talk and there would be discussions. And I know a brand agency also who had done some work, but for whatever reason, the opportunity was there. OK, they saw that somebody local had started it. The company called Bounceback now in Singapore that does it, which I think is a cooler name. Arjun Thomas: Hmm. Dhruv Shanker: I think Patti Smart is a nice name too. But if you look at the two products, they are like chalk and cheese. Very very different. They are positioned very differently. Now you can't imagine a Himalaya going and collaborating with cocktail bars. But these guys did it. A brand like Bounceback was able to do it. The product looks cool. very little. discrete black box, which is probably what you wanted because at the end of the day, hangovers are slightly embarrassing, right? So, you know, I think that was a good example of a little brand that just figured out that, hey, I can go and win this space. A big giant that saw that, look, we can come and kill these guys. We can produce more than in one day than they can do in a quarter. But could they execute fast enough? Probably not. ⁓ What probably not? didn't. Bounceback is the market leader now. So. So that for me, I think, I think if I'm not wrong, I think at some point, Amalia did invest in Bounceback as well. But we'll have to check that story out. But yeah, that is some of the stuff that shows the power of someone who's able to execute better and is using agility as their mode. local understanding, go work with influencers. Sure, Himalayas, hundreds of influencers that they work with, there's certain kind of content readers, certain kind of influencers, slightly older perhaps. These guys went out there and did it completely different. Arjun Thomas: So. I think it does, mean, yes, mean, scrappiness is probably the best way to... to look at it. It's also the advantage of, well, the one big advantage that you have as a young, as an early stage kind of startup and entrepreneur is you don't have the baggage of having to ask 10 people before you make a decision, regardless of whether it's a good or bad decision. And you're not as worried about the consequences of the decision going wrong. You can call it being young and stupid. And a lot of entrepreneurs today are not young anymore, but at least the stupidity still stays. I think that that's an important ingredient Dhruv Shanker: Yeah. Arjun Thomas: in being scrappy, ⁓ willing to be stupid and failing miserably and then going again the next day and say, yeah, doesn't matter, I'll be stupid tomorrow, who the hell cares. ⁓ Dhruv Shanker: For sure man, for sure. When I was a groupon, was this... One of the reasons why I loved that time of my life was because I was allowed to be crazy. I was allowed to be stupid. I did... I used to run Easter... I used to run... April Fool's gags every year, know. One year I sold Martian water, one year I sold dinosaur eggs. And they were complete gags, know, fake nonsense, just to get a laugh out of someone, you know. But they did so much for the brand. And yes, out of the, you know, every thousand, we'd sell, we'd cap it at a thousand, you know, vouchers. And then we'd refund the customer the next day. You know, big joke. Yes, one or two people get pissed off with us. And one person actually sued us because they wanted, they got really mad. They were like, I want the dinosaur egg, you know. Arjun Thomas: The Dragon eggs. ⁓ Dhruv Shanker: Okay, that's fine. Arjun Thomas: Maybe they'll make a movie about it like the Pepsi Harrier Jet fiasco where the guy actually accumulated enough. Do you know the story? Yeah, so... Yeah! Dhruv Shanker: Yeah. Yeah, yeah, yeah, the one. He just got too much. He flew like a ridiculous number of times. Yeah, who knows, Yeah, but those are great learning opportunities, I believe. Arjun Thomas: So what else goes into being scrappy? mean, in today's day and age, I want to kind of connect back to what you mentioned a couple of, I guess, maybe 10 minutes ago about using AI, ⁓ which is... ⁓ Is that something that a small business should use to kind of increase their odds in what is essentially an unfair fight with large brands to kind of differentiate? how do you recommend brands, ⁓ small, early stage entrepreneurs, SMEs, let's call them, leverage that ⁓ practically to kind of build their brand presence and kind of sell essentially? Dhruv Shanker: Yeah. Sure. Yeah, absolutely. I think I'm going to say the same thing that a lot of people say about AI. Don't use it to create, use it to elevate. Okay, and that applies to e-commerce as well. You can't just say, these are four products, go write me, write listings for me. No, that doesn't work. You've got to educate your AI on what you want. So a simple thing with us as well. When we launch a new brand, ⁓ And our brands are quite diverse, Like at Cash Counter we sell everything from cooking staples to sustainable swimwear to vitamins, okay. And it's very hard to be in. Arjun Thomas: But before you continue, what the hell is sustainable swimwear? Dhruv Shanker: sustainable swimwear. Sustainable swimwear is swimwear that is made from... It's actually clothing that is made from ocean waste. you know, it's an interesting concept for sure. Heart is in the right place. ⁓ But the point I'm trying to make is it's very hard to find one person who's going to be an expert on all of these three random categories. Not to mention the food staples itself is an entire world. Arjun Thomas: stays on longer. ⁓ Yeah. Right. Dhruv Shanker: But you can get your AI to really build competence on each of these. Another core... ⁓ you know, ticket to win on e-commerce platforms is that in Asia people like to chat with your store. Okay, it's bizarre, but the number of inquiries that come before an order is placed and it could be anything. It's not something simple like expiry dates, because people are getting smarter, right? Your consumers also have access to AI. So usually they come in to you with a complicated question. Like I'll give you an example of somebody asked us about urad dal, okay, which is a black dal. when it has the skin on but when you soak it the thing turns a little shade of green okay now that thing looks very very similar to another lentil which is green moong and when they are soaked they look very very similar the water runoff it's a fairly complicated thing but somebody hit us with that question and ⁓ who's going to answer that right someone's got to research all of this stuff who's going to know every damn thing that exists about dal and be ready with an answer REI is. So both Lazada and Shopee actually allow you to plug in your bots into the chatbot on the store itself. So what we do is we actually educate them, we educate our bots heavily on the product itself. Wellbeing Nutrition is another brand that I run a store for. Wellbeing Nutrition is in the business of with vitamins are a lot of good things for you but you know they can get very specific right when you're talking about bloating or know gut health and things like that so we make sure that our stores are fully equipped with every question that could possibly come their way But how does the store get educated? How does our bot get educated? It is by understanding every single thing that the brand does. So that one time process of just ingesting all the learning material. Like sometimes when we're launching a brand, we will ask them for bizarre questions. We ask them for documentation on the product. They're like, why do you need this? You need the box and you need some images, right? Like, no, I want the is selling. So we get that in. So customer support is taken care of. So that automates so many queries for us. The stores also, so the marketplaces measure a store's, you're given a score based on your response rate as well. So our response rate is always 100 % because we have a bot replying and we have a bot giving you the best quality answer, right? Something that even I would probably have to sit and then Google and search or even the founders would have to do. Arjun Thomas: Hmm. Dhruv Shanker: So that is one thing that we're using AI for. The second thing is building these listings, right? Now you've got to understand the listing. It comes back to my first thing about who am I selling to? So what happens is that we have a team that really figures out how to market a product to the audience that we are going after. And we write that first listing. Okay? We use colloquialisms, we use local languages, we translate heavily into all the languages, which also helps from an SEO standpoint. Arjun Thomas: Mm-hmm. Dhruv Shanker: and we get a really robust listing in place that is checking all the boxes. But we spend a lot of time building that first listing. And then we train our AI to understand that style of writing for that particular brand. Now this is an exercise that you have to do, like initially. And then, because this is the foundation that you're building for the AI to stand on. And then after that, when you come in with a variant of a certain melt or a new flavor or a new... ⁓ Arjun Thomas: Hmm. Yeah. Dhruv Shanker: swimsuit, could be shorts now right. Fundamentally the AI understands how you want to communicate, what are the boxes I need to check. See all these platforms right Lazada, Shopee, Amazon they're all different just as their marketplaces that's the only thing they have in common. Everything including the text limits to the listing to the size of the images everything is different right. So get a machine to do that for you. Arjun Thomas: Hmm. Dhruv Shanker: That is the thing, we built the framework. The Amazon listings have to be written in a certain way. We get our operations sorted out using a lot of chat GPT and plugins like that. So those are tools that are available to everyone. I don't have to be a big business to do this. I just have to know how to use this correctly. deploy them in the right way. So straight off from a discovery standpoint, I know that all the listings that we're going to produce are going to be top class. There's also going to be a uniformity across it. I know that the store is going to respond in a classy professional manner, which is not going to sound like just a parrot because this is material. It's trained. It knows what it's talking about. It's not just saying that, oh, this is your order status, blah, blah. If you have a question about the product, it's going to give you that. So I think these are tools that are available and this is how AI is helping us to go to market a lot faster. And finally, images, right? Images are a big part of it, optimizing those images, changing backgrounds, doing seasonal stuff, all of that, building the storefronts itself, You can use a lot of... ⁓ Arjun Thomas: Yeah. Dhruv Shanker: See, you don't have to be that creative. The platforms don't let you be that much creative. Like marketplaces like Lazada and Shopee, there's only that far you can go with the product image. But you can play with backgrounds, right? You can add little stamps and things like that. You know, you can, like when there's a seasonal campaign coming out. Singles Day is our Super Bowl, right? Like, you know, 11-11. We can go crazy, right? But at that time, am I going to be downloading each image and then adding a watermark or? Arjun Thomas: Great. Dhruv Shanker: We can get the systems to do this for us and do it fast. That's the biggest thing. We do it fast. So I hate to say it, but we don't use graphic designers at all anymore. We don't use copywriters anymore at all. And like, even when we started this business three years ago, there was still some, some users still needed resources for this. They do other stuff now. Arjun Thomas: Is this a skill set that... Dhruv Shanker: Take care of it. Arjun Thomas: most SME small business owners have intuitively. I'd be skeptical if they do. Someone like you with a lot of experience. That's the reason why you set this up in the first place with CashCounter. ⁓ So is the path, and you hit on two things. One is know-how, which is essentially not only understanding the world of e-commerce, that I guess is the secret sauce in your context. Understanding the world of e-commerce and understanding consumer behaviors and essentially how to position what content what audience, in what way in each kind of platform. ⁓ So is the path for a lot of small businesses to work with individuals like you, are you seeing that kind of a trend where smaller... I guess e-commerce accelerators take the place of traditional brand managers or whatever the term is in large organizations and that service is now offered to small businesses that could not have access to it before because it was too expensive to have an entire team doing now what maybe a smaller shop can do with the help of AI. Are you seeing a trend in that direction or do you see SMEs still doing things the way they always did and that isn't changing? Dhruv Shanker: Red. I see SMIs actually getting spotted. ⁓ See there's a massive drive on, you know, I told you about the getting left behind, right? I missed the bus. That is a sentiment that exists very strongly in the seller community. ⁓ man, I could have done this, but I got left behind. Even the bottom telling you about, right? Dude, it's not complicated. I said it's for everyday people to succeed. But you can still miss this bus also, right? Arjun Thomas: Hmm. Dhruv Shanker: So for me, I see more more SMEs upskilling themselves and figuring out this competence in-house. ⁓ For me, as Cash Counter, I think we like to work with larger brands that can do this in-house, but then also we bring in the country complexity, is the regional expertise. Well, there are some brands from India that are performing extremely well on Amazon, but Amazon India is Amazon India. Arjun Thomas: Right. Dhruv Shanker: Lazada and Shopee are different platforms. How do you take that strategy? Take that product from here and then localize it for this market. That is the place where we like to drive value. For me, all of the bells and whistles and all of these things, these are my tools and I'm very open to sharing with them, with everyone, including my clients. You want to do this in-house, go for it. This is our process. We know how to do this, we do it much faster. Again. I think there is a beautiful simplicity to the fact that we're not very high tech. We're platforms that are existing and that are available to everyone. It's just a question of knowing which lever to pull when. ⁓ I'll give you another example. When you launch a product from a new market and you want to go with five influencers, right? It sounds like something you can just go ahead and do. I was at Gulf food last year, sorry, last month, and there were so many brands that just wanted to come and launch their food products on the market. And I said, I want to start selling to Malay population. I want to start selling to Indonesian audiences. Okay, but it's not as simple as just giving the product to that blogger, right? And they're, okay, what do you say? Scripting is such a huge part of it. Use Chagy BT to write your scripts for this audience. What should the influencers say? Those are things where brands can start stepping up and putting a little bit of effort and just giving the product. Getting the product to an influencer is the easiest thing in the world. Getting them to create something meaningful and say what you want them to say without being too pushy. That's the nuance. these things will come in. So I think those are, you know, those are places where we can add value. And we thrive in that space because, you know, with a big brand, they have the assets, they have great product photos, they have great, you know, they've done, they made the ads, they have a vision, they have an ethos, they have like their whole mission. So that translating that into you know for a new audience taking those values pulling out what resonates with the local audience that is the space that Arjun Thomas: I think that's a great segue over to maybe something more. more general than e-commerce, is you've, through your career, you've had the experience of A, working in very, very large corporates across multiple geos. And we can maybe get into a little bit more detail on this bit, which is you've kind of run your own kind of F &B businesses ⁓ in a couple of countries, think Bangladesh as well, so it'd be good to kind of talk about that story. And you also now held other brands in other markets enter new markets. So given that ⁓ you have a fair bit of experience in Southeast Asia and South Asia generally as a region, ⁓ what interesting kind of lessons insights have you cleaned? I know it's probably like 10 days worth of a conversation there to kind of unpack, ⁓ but ⁓ what do you find ⁓ interesting or different about a the way ⁓ Dhruv Shanker: Okay. Arjun Thomas: ⁓ brands think about entering a market, I think you alluded to a little bit about that. How different is that in reality based on your experiences? How big is that gap? Why does that gap exist? People in different countries, you'd assume, think a little differently. Cultural contexts are different. But isn't that something that all people know? When you enter a new market, you assume that, you should assume as a default position that what worked in one country does not work in another. But you hear more and more stories of people expecting exactly that. The example you just quoted. So the question more broadly is that multi-country operations with brands getting into other countries, what interesting stories do you have about that and experiences? Dhruv Shanker: I think cultural advance is something that you can't get by just reading case studies. You do need to have some understanding of local behavior. You either need to have a person or one contact or at least a consultant on the ground who can tell you that, this is not going to fly or this is a value that is respected in this market. You want to double down on this. I think that... foundational step is pretty important. There is a little bit of overconfidence that comes in sometimes when you have really strong product market fit in your home market. You've got great, you know, you've gotten a lot of, you know, it's a good product and people love you and all of that. And then you start feeling like you're on top of the world and you can just go and unlock a new territory, right? It doesn't necessarily work that way. Arjun Thomas: Mm-hmm. Dhruv Shanker: ⁓ I think that humility is something that is a bit lacking. So what happens is you'll have a big brand that will announce a global expansion after raising ⁓ a ton of money. And then you realize that they will come in guns blazing, but the product is not working and then they're getting outgunned by somebody local. And that is, and they don't take that very well, right? Because they will try it. And that's an expensive experiment because you already committed to it. So you do end up seeing a lot of brands that will come in very aggressive and then try to just buy out the market with this saying that, I have this best seller, it's definitely gonna work. And it's a performance marketing, keep pouring money and then I should win. Sometimes you do. and if the product has not, if you haven't achieved PMF locally, it's not going to fly. ⁓ One of the brands we represent actually is very big in men's wellness space, okay? And that's their whole thing. They came in here and it just didn't fly. And we tried everything we could. All of the tricks, all of the levers I told you, Tailor it to the audience. Is there a need for this? Yes, there is a need for it. Translate we did all of that. We even got some social, you know, you know boost for it some validation, but it didn't take off However, another product took off melatonin that these product this company was also selling They didn't expect it to sell and we didn't expect it to sell either but turns out Singapore has a much larger sleeping problem Then you know, I mean that from a I think just a stack ranking, right? I think sleep is way more important Arjun Thomas: Hmm. Dhruv Shanker: we can eat for this. Now it was a bitter pill to swallow, pun intended but you know it was something we managed to you know the brand was able to say after two months that okay let's pull the plug on the men's wellness piece but they had an entire like this is what they were betting their last dollar once like ⁓ we are going to come and be the men's wellness brand in Southeast Asia. Didn't work but we have that humility to pull out after two months of hard data starting in the face saying that, listen man, this is not selling, but this is starting to show some interest. That is something, that's a good story, but I have, there are plenty of examples of brands that have come and just burnt a lot of money and then they blame it on the market saying, oh, the market's not ready. Or like, no, we didn't have a good experience. was too, maybe we didn't spend enough time figuring out if this is the right fit for us. That's what it is. Arjun Thomas: Yeah, you're right. mean PMF is a continuing dialogue with the market, right? Your consumers are never stuck in the same situation. They evolve, they change. Behaviors change, buying patterns change, tastes change. So unless you have a two-way dialogue with the market, ⁓ you really will find yourselves on the back foot to whenever things change, not for your better. ⁓ So want to connect that back to, ⁓ you know, we've been talking a lot about Dhruv Shanker: Yeah. Arjun Thomas: the work that you've been doing for other brands, e-commerce and other startups and food companies and trying to come into the market. How has that thinking influenced ⁓ building your own business in the food space. So maybe we just talk a little bit about that. Like, you know, what exactly are you focusing on right now? And how have those lessons percolated into the way you're trying to reach your current audiences? ⁓ Dhruv Shanker: So I think there's been a lot of learning from my clients. I think with every brand that we launch at Cash Counter, there's something new to learn. Sustainable Swimwear is a great one. while it may not seem like the most exciting product or something that you need very often, there is an audience for it. that... sell to the rodents? What are the pillars that are driving without it? The end of the day, this is a business that's making money and they have a store and everything. Like why are people buying? What is intriguing that customer, right? So that is something that we have also learned, we are also learning. It's an ongoing process. I think we definitely see trends, like we know what Singapore, like with the grocery stores that we run, we definitely know what Singapore eats and we know what they like and have a sense of you know what they're going to buy next so that often feeds the discussion of whenever I meet my account managers at any of the marketplaces right because as an enabler we sit right in the middle between the brands and the marketplaces so the marketplaces also you know we have pretty good a good relationship with them and they're always like okay so you're running all of these stores when you're doing your own thing and and I think just just because I food myself ⁓ I've usually had my account banned as food and things like that they're like dude when are you gonna sell your own product right so I think that is something that is still a work in progress I don't know if I've cracked it a hundred percent but ⁓ dabbling in the space ⁓ I I don't know this is this was exactly the question that you were asking but I get a lot of inspiration sell or at least like guidance and pointers on what to sell or at least what not to sell ⁓ by being in cash counter by running it you know running e-commerce stores for so many people and then thinking that okay fine if I were to sell my own thing maybe this is what it should be so we haven't launched an in-house product yet ⁓ but who knows maybe in the next year or so I don't want to force that decision ⁓ Arjun Thomas: Hmm. Dhruv Shanker: We have a few odds and ends that we have imported here and there that we've sold. But to do a house brand because branding ⁓ is big deal. It's an expensive affair as well. So we'll see. We'll see. ⁓ As of now, think hands are full with the e-commerce business and the private denning business. So I don't know if we'll be launching a new product for e-commerce just yet. Arjun Thomas: Hmm. So maybe let's talk a little bit about the private dining business because again it is closer to your heart than the other business. ⁓ What has surprised you most about the experience? I know you love cooking, you love entertaining, ⁓ you love cracking jokes, you've got a wicked sense of humor, but what has surprised you most ⁓ having done this for the last couple of years? ⁓ Dhruv Shanker: So I think private dining, I didn't expect it to be this fulfilling to do. It's a lot of work. I get physically exhausted at the end of this. Running, turning your balcony or part of your home into a restaurant three or four times a week is not easy work at all. But somehow I find myself energized at the end of these. And it's very, very, it's that crazy combination of doing something you love and then making money as well. Like that little icky guy, I think I found that intersection of what I'm good at, what the world needs, what I can charge some money for. just keep that whole thing going. I'm pretty sure I forgot the last Venn diagram, but you get it. It is that sweet spot. that I discovered through private dining. For me, private dining has evolved and it's opened a lot more doors. Like my private dining started out as a cooking class, okay, just started out with me teaching people how to cook a meal in a very relaxed setting. And that was, was largely, it was something I started when I lost my job actually. So just to give you context, I have always had side hustles in food, but this is one that really came and saved me actually, because I have always gambled with startups. And one thing I actually did after leaving Groupon was I joined a company called O4, which was very well funded, but was not quite OK on the books. And these guys followed it very fast. And we can talk about that company for a long time because. ⁓ but I won't go into the details. Long story short, I got fired ⁓ or the company folded and we all lost our jobs. I got a little more screwed in the process because I also got deported because of an immigration mess up. And I found myself without a source of income. And Singapore being so frightfully expensive, my father was locked into a lease on my apartment. I had bills to pay and I was like, okay, this is, and I wasn't finding a job easily. was the head of marketing there. I was not finding anything. ⁓ Not to mention I was locked out of the country for five months. So I was at rock bottom when private dining actually came and kind of saved me. So I started cooking as a way to get my head back on track, just feel a little better, and then start doing something I love. And then the money started coming because I started selling it. And then I think that piece of monetizing what you love, right? is what clicked in. I started selling a cooking class on Airbnb experiences and that thing really, you know, developed and grew legs and like grew wings and whatnot. And today what I do is, it's a combination, it's a dining, but there's live cooking, lot of things involved. I think what surprises me about this business is the number of forms it can take on. Like what started out as a humble cooking class where I was just teaching people how to make butter chicken and you know, a couple of other things. Arjun Thomas: Hmm. Dhruv Shanker: That today is such a big team bonding experience. I've hosted pretty much every corporate out there. Every team, every company has come and booked me at some point or the other. Like, I mean, I've done. 10,000 guests in the last eight years. like that, that itself, the number itself is staggering. I never thought it could get that big. And for a guy who's been deported to getting, you know, featured in a full page article on straight stems, right? I'm like, ⁓ you like me now, huh? Like, you know, for me, that journey was like pretty crazy. Yeah, like even last year, like I was featured in this thing called SG60, which there was a program on 60 interesting people or something. And I was like, okay. Arjun Thomas: Hero arc, the hero arc as it were. Dhruv Shanker: media cop show and it was great and I loved doing it but for me to to see that all of this has happened on the legs of my little cooking class my boring Indian food workshop is what I call it and that has just opened doors and like you know I've done collaborations I've managed to enter the FNB industry without really entering it I have so many contacts in the FNB space I've collaborated with so many smart wonderful people and I've been able to do good quality work ⁓ I've worked with restaurants, know, built menus. So there is so much more that I have gotten from that business than just a little bit of money, you know. So happiness, brand recognition, collaborations, like so many things have come my way thanks to that little experiment I took. I was like, well, fine, let's try. Big deal, let's open this cooking class. Maybe nobody will come, but if they come, come. And I just focused on having a good time, primarily. I wanted to a good time. I made sure that the guest had a good time as well. And I think that has been my guiding principle till this day. So yeah, so private dining, very surprising ⁓ in terms of how much I have personally gained from it. And yeah, I have a lot of fun with it. That really is. Arjun Thomas: So clearly not boring, clearly not boring, but why boring cooking comes? Dhruv Shanker: Yeah, so that is a little bit of reverse psychology. This is I think where the marketing side of me comes in. In fact, I call it the boring Indian food workshop, the boring Indian barbecue party because I... Arjun Thomas: if it's ending but. Dhruv Shanker: Yeah, but like, you know, in fact, I still remember the first experience I submitted on Airbnb, right? It got rejected because they were like, they reached out to me saying that, look, I don't know if English is your first language, but boring is a negative word. I'm like, dude, dude, hang on, hang on, hang on. I know what I'm doing. This is reverse psychology. And I actually had to appeal and I had to convince Airbnb to let me use boring in my experience name. I said, no, it sets the tone, right? It sets the tone for it to be a little, you know. Arjun Thomas: No! Hahaha! Dhruv Shanker: It doesn't take itself too seriously man and I think that is what my whole philosophy with food is. Don't overthink it, take it easy. ⁓ know food will happen. The first line that I say to people when they walk into any of the hands-on culinary experiences is that look the focus here is on fun. Yes, I will feed you, I will teach you how to make a few things but let's focus on having a grid time. Okay, we'll do that and I give them a drink and then we start. That's the model. It is not a cooking school. Okay. You will learn something, but you will learn it in the format that I tell you and it is centered around fun. So that is, that has been extremely liberating. So that's why, you know, once you call it boring, like it just, you know, raises an eyebrow. If nothing, it'll get you a smile. And this question about why you calling it boring? It gives me the opportunity to tell this damn story. Yeah. So that's what it is. So, and then along the way, I think ⁓ as a marketer, think I, ⁓ Arjun Thomas: You Dhruv Shanker: I know the value of having a brand and some cohesiveness around it. So when I launched my second experience, is the Boring Indian Barbecue Party, I could have called it like, know, Tandoor and Tales of Dhruv or something like that. But no, it was, ⁓ I chose to keep it under the Boring Food umbrella. At some point the business has also reached a point where people don't want to come in, like they come for the experience but they just want one or two of the things. Like my lamb chops for example are legendary, work with, yeah very popular, I work with a local butcher here, I got this really, I thought recipe I cracked in Singapore actually because I use Australian lamb chops and it's an Indian recipe that's been highly adapted to work with. Arjun Thomas: Very popular. Dhruv Shanker: this Australian lamb chop that you get here. for me, it's like, it's a nice one, okay? But a lot of people come to the experience, like they've come for a team offset or whatnot, and then they remember that, dude, I had some amazing lamb chops. So sometimes they just want like 12 lamb chops. They're not gonna book the entire private dining experience, right? And then at that point I was like, this is an opportunity, right? Like if somebody wants lamb chops. Why get it, right? Why do I have to say that, no, you have to come with five friends and then make it an experience. I said, okay, fine, let me open online ordering. Again, I used a very simple platform called Take App, which is a WhatsApp based shop. And so I have a store, I have boringindianfood.com as well, where people can order pretty much everything that's on the menu. And so then that unlocked a catering model of the thing. In fact, I just did one yesterday as well. So the party, the private dining. Private dining doesn't mean just my house, right? Your house is also private. So we either we do the... So I started expanding the model to say that, we can do private dining in your house too. That's fine. A lot of people have lovely houses in Singapore. People have grills as well. What do you need help with? You need help throwing the damn party. You need help grilling. Great. Come, let me take care of them. So out of that... My catering business was born. It's all under the same umbrella. So today if you ask me, I do private dining, yes, at home in my balcony, but I also do private dining in other people's balconies as well. ⁓ We've done so many housewarming parties, anniversaries, birthdays, all of that. Sometimes you want to host in your own space, right? And that model actually works very well because I've also been able to build a team through this. You know, I still... I am amazed at how much talent exists around us, but we don't have access to them. I actually have a team of four elderly ladies. I call them my fiery barbecue aunties. And my fiery barbecue aunties, I've met them through Carousell. And ⁓ it just started from there. I needed help at one of my own barbecues. And I was like, wow, there's 50 people. That's a lot for me. Okay, so 50 people. So then I decided to call in some backup. But then how do you start? Where do you do this? This was, I said, okay, let me try. I posted a job on Carousel, one lady replied. Arjun Thomas: Hmm. Dhruv Shanker: 60s and then as as aunties would be aunties no other aunties and then you know I brought them in and I actually did a cooking like I did a proper teaching course for for them and I trained them on my menu and today I have a team of four elderly Chinese aunties my fiery barbecue aunties who can probably cook my kebabs just as well as me maybe even better. And so I love that. I love that. And they are the ones actually who support me. And then, know, when we do, when we get a catering gig, we take the party to people. I have a bartender who works with me. He'll line up, we send the grill, send the marinated food, and we throw a kick ass party. And is it private dining? It is still private dining. Is it the Boring Indian Food Workshop? It is fundamentally the same thing. But being able to package and repackage this wonderful little experience around food, that's what keeps me excited. Arjun Thomas: So clearly no shortage of excitement in your life. What is the most interesting ⁓ thing that's happened or crazy thing that's happened to one of your cooking classes that you can talk about publicly? Dhruv Shanker: Yeah, so I think one thing that happened when the experience exploded on Airbnb. So Airbnb has played a big role in my life, of really taking this to the next level because Airbnb, I don't know if you know, but they can't run their core business in Singapore. Airbnb homes, their rooms business is not something that they can run in Singapore. Arjun Thomas: Hmm. Dhruv Shanker: despite having a regional headquarter here so it's crazy but they actually reached out to me when I started the cooking class and they said look why don't you host over here we have this platform called experiences I said okay fine and I tried but like I said I kept my focus on just having fun and making sure reviews were good and one fine day I get a message from them saying that hey Dhruv congratulations you just broke a record on Airbnb ⁓ currently as of yesterday last night you have the highest rated culinary experience in the world. I was like wow that is crazy so I had a perfect five star record and I did a hundred reviews and I was like okay that's nice and I thought okay great so like do I get a t-shirt or something like you know what's the thing then yeah they call yeah and so they're like no no no we will we'll actually run a campaign around you ⁓ Arjun Thomas: Something you called me there had better be something behind the phone call Dhruv Shanker: campaign for you. I'm like okay great marketing campaign sounds nice but I wasn't prepared for what they did because they sent a 14 member crew down from LA and they shot a commercial and they did a whole thing on me and while the commercial only aired in a few places I'll send you a link to it on it's on YouTube they gave me a crazy amount of traffic man and I was on the home page and like the and the algorithm really rewarded me so I got two years of bookings in advance Arjun Thomas: Hahaha ⁓ Dhruv Shanker: And Airbnb has travelers coming into the country, they book in advance. So they said, open your calendar. That's what I had to do, And so I said, OK, I'm taking them. I open the calendar. And then they filled the calendar. I think that was a dream, because I couldn't imagine that volume of bookings to ever happen. That really exploded. And then I had some, you know. Arjun Thomas: Wow. Dhruv Shanker: the media picked it up. Of course, COVID came and derailed this whole thing for a bit. But then when Airbnb pivoted to online experiences, I also pivoted along with them. Because by then they'd become a strategic partner for me. I almost thought of Airbnb as my co-founder in this thing. And then the online version exploded as well. So for me, it was a thrilling ride. And I think out of that, when the media exposure came, I started getting some interesting clients as well. ⁓ Some celebrities, you know when you have to sign an NDA and you can't mention that the client has come to your place. I okay, that is interesting. But wait, I'll tell you about, ⁓ forget the celebrity one. I actually had a... Arjun Thomas: You have NDAs, so let's get you in legal water right now. Dhruv Shanker: Yeah I had a lady who came in and she was a chef herself. And after a while, we were chatting and this was a mixed group. I had some people from Argentina and this lady was from Colombia. And so I asked her, what kind of cuisine? And she's like, no, I cook everything. I was like, okay, great. And then I said, do you have a restaurant? And she's like, yeah, no, I'm a private chef. I was like, wow, that's very cool. And then we started chatting. started going on. I said, what are you doing in Singapore? She's like, yeah, I'm actually on a work trip. I said, so you're a private chef on a work trip? And then the story started getting, and she's like, OK, fine. I'm a private chef. She was a private chef for some kind of a drug lord or somebody, OK? And she was traveling with them. And these guys decided to do the Bali leg of their trip alone. She was a private chef for some kind of a drug lord or somebody, OK? And she was traveling with them. And these guys decided to do the Bali leg of their trip alone. And they decided to just let her be in Singapore. no, we don't need a chef because they were staying in some nice place. He said, OK, be useful. ⁓ and learn some Indian cooking. yeah, I'm actually here to learn Indian cooking because my boss's new wife ⁓ really likes Indian And then she takes out her phone and starts showing us pictures of ⁓ her life in their hacienda, Dude, And they decided to just let her be in Singapore. said, no, we don't need a chef because they were staying in some nice place. He said, OK, be useful. Go and learn some Indian cooking. So he said, yeah, I'm actually here to learn Indian cooking because my boss's new wife really likes Indian food. And then she takes out her phone and starts showing us pictures of her life in their hacienda, their house and all that. Dude, like, I mean, this is the stuff. I didn't think it was real, but you know. Arjun Thomas: No! Dhruv Shanker: pet tigers, leopards, fancy cars, guns, all of that shit, I'm like, okay, this is an interesting thing. So I basically, ⁓ trained ⁓ private chef of, I guess, ⁓ kind of ⁓ mafia boss or whatever, she was a very interesting guest that came in. pet tigers, leopards, fancy cars, guns, all of that shit, right? I'm like, okay, this is an interesting thing. So I basically, I trained the private chef of, I guess, some kind of mobster, mafia boss or whatever, right? ⁓ And yeah, she was a very interesting guest that came in. And she had some, and I thought, yeah, yeah, yeah. Arjun Thomas: You better hope you don't get any complaints. You better hope you don't get any complaints coming back. They know where you live. Dhruv Shanker: sure for sure so that was a that was a that was a very interesting fun one I'll tell you another one because this was deeply humbling for me I actually had a blind person come to the cooking class once and I was so surprised man I was so so surprised too because like I was like you can you cook like I mean how are we gonna do this this this there's knives and this there's hot oil and like there's cooking But this gentleman was, you know, just showed that like, he's like, no, my other senses work very well and you just have to go a little slow for me. But I, I've done this before and then I cook and he kept feeling everything. I'm telling you, Arjun, this was like something I never thought I would do and it turned out to be one of the most rewarding experiences because we cooked an entire meal and we didn't skimp or didn't change any step at all. And... I'm just amazed at how he managed to pull that off and how we managed to do that. So yeah, I had one like that ⁓ as well. Great experience. ⁓ I had a corrections officer from Australia who came in and he was running a juvenile home ⁓ and he said, and he had an interesting one as well. The boys in the home would fight about every single thing. Arjun Thomas: Hmm. Dhruv Shanker: But he said food was the one odd thing that they bond on as the only thing that you could probably get them to do together. So he came and then that, you we cooked the meal together, but then we ended up talking about other things and I ended up creating this little menu for him as well that he could go and get the boys to do simpler stuff. like. know, things that, like he was trying to make these troubled youngsters bond over food. And he knew that food was working, but he wasn't a chef himself and he just wanted some help. So, I mean, I've had some fantastic conversations unfold. Some very, very interesting people come in. ⁓ There's a gentleman by the name of Prem Vatsa. You look him up, he's like the Warren Buffet of Canada. His private jet broke down in Singapore and... ⁓ they had to go and get a certain part for it. So he was stuck here for three days and he decided to make a little holiday out of it. But then the crew, his private jet crew actually came to do this and I got to hang out with them and then understand a little bit about this other kind of flying that also happens. I've never been on a private jet, but you know, had... pilots and the stewardess who came in and they just had the greatest stories in the world so I feel like I have met so many interesting people through this like the list goes on this goes on I once had a lady who ⁓ the door and she was nine months pregnant I was like whoa you are I mean I you want to stand and cook she is and I remember she had asked for one very very specific thing to cook she wanted something called Gongura chicken and I was like Gongura chicken because one of the things I put in my listing in the bottom of the listing is that by the way if you're not interested by my boring menu here's my Instagram go and take a look and if you want to cook something from there we'll make it happen Arjun Thomas: Hmm. Dhruv Shanker: I have never had anyone who actually followed through on that, okay? But this lady actually went and like, she like, you said that I can choose from your Instagram. I was like, yeah, nobody does it, but okay. But then she had like, scrolled like five years into my feed and found this Gongura chicken and I was like, wow. Arjun Thomas: Hmm. Dhruv Shanker: Okay, fine. I I guess I've advertised it, right? So I have to do it now. And then she pinged me the night before the class saying that, hey, did you get the gongura? And gongura is like a, it's a leaf, it's a leafy vegetable. It's sorrel leaves. And I was like, yes, I got it. And when she showed up, she was like very, very pregnant. And I was like, okay. Turns out this poor lady had been transferred to Singapore. smack in the middle of her pregnancy and there was a visa issue her husband was you know was having trouble getting in so she was by herself in a lousy guest house okay in some kind of company accommodation and she was craving something that she used to eat as a child or like I think back home order and she even wanted to eat gongura chicken and then but she was so heavily pregnant she couldn't just walk into any Arjun Thomas: Hmm. Dhruv Shanker: restaurant. So she went online and she asked like I'm really craving a gungra chicken and then somebody suggested said you know what there's this crazy guy who does this cooking class he'll probably cook it for you if you ask him to ask him nicely but then she was like how can I just ask this guy to come and just cook food for me right then she found that I have a cooking class so she booked a session with me and then asked for this thing just to have gungra chicken and dude that was one of the most satisfying experiences as well because Arjun Thomas: Just to have gongura chicken. Dhruv Shanker: Not only like, know, did you come and find me and like this suddenly this was not just Gongura Chicken, I had to like really make it. So I said, okay, you know what? He has a big glass of lemonade. You sit down, okay? And we're gonna cook Gongura Chicken. So that's what she did. She had a nice drink and then she helped as well. But we made it a really, really chill, laid back experience. And yeah, she was just, ⁓ we made Gongura Chicken. I packed some to send it back. It actually was such a nice experience because once her husband finally got into the country... ⁓ you know they actually came back and eventually became friends. very rewarding experience. She wanted to give me a gift at the end of the whole thing and ⁓ for me the gift is the review. Usually that's enough. But she also gave me her grandmother's peanut chutney recipe. So yeah and that is something which actually I love because not only is it a fantastic peanut chutney recipe ⁓ but you know it just makes this experience so much more. Arjun Thomas: Hmm. Dhruv Shanker: So even now when we're having dosas and we're thinking about what chutney to make on the side, it's usually like, you want peanut chutney or do you want bindus peanut chutney? Sometimes we make bindus peanut chutney. It's a great recipe. I ended up posting it online. So for me, this is, yes, it is three hours where there's a meal that you've cooked together with somebody. Arjun Thomas: Hmm. Dhruv Shanker: But then it keeps giving, it's a gift that keeps giving. It goes on, every time I cook Bindu's peanut chutney, you know, there's this wonderful memory associated with it. There's so much positivity. And heck, even Gongura Chicken, man, like, you know, I can't, it's my recipe, yes, I cook it a lot. But I can't not think of this guest when I make that dish as well. So, tons of stories that have come out of this business. Arjun Thomas: So I think, I mean, no shortage. I 10,000 people having experienced your classes and clearly a wide range of interesting experiences for you, I guess, front and center. You're also a youngish father of two. How does that? Yeah, youngish. How is that third job? Dhruv Shanker: Yeah. Arjun Thomas: Well, fourth job, you've got twins. So fourth job played into juggling these two balls that you already have up in the air. Dhruv Shanker: Yeah. Yeah, I think ⁓ everything happens in twos, I feel. Like we've got, in my life at least, like I have two dogs, I have two businesses, and now I have two babies. ⁓ It's been great fun. It's a lot of work, but it's also twice the fun. I take immense joy in sharing what I'm doing with the children, like food, like that's big thing. Cooking something new, understanding their palates, ⁓ their twins, but they're very different, fraternal twins, and they're also two very different people, feel like. So, you know, understanding what gets each of them going. So I'm loving fatherhood, thoroughly enjoying it. Yeah, it's a busy life, but I think the entrepreneur life, is also, you this is one of the big benefits of it. I really feel like the biggest plus is the time that I have. E-commerce runs, it's a machine that will run well, it needs to be looked at. And initially when you're starting, you know, when I'm launching a brand on Cash Counter, when I'm launching... Arjun Thomas: Hmm. Dhruv Shanker: whole set of new products, that's a lot of work. But then after that, that tapers off and then the optimization phase comes in and there I have some people. like, know, so that gives me a little bit of flexibility, a little bit of breathing room. With the private dining, that business is as flexible as it gets. I've actually just moved house. I finally outgrew my apartment. I was living there for 12 years. I only moved because I didn't have enough place. So I just moved into a new place and my private dining is now on a very, very limited schedule, but. because that business itself is so flexible, right? I'm still able to do the home delivery, the food ⁓ delivery piece of it. I'm still able to do content and I'm still able to stay at home and look after the kids. So I'm go get them lunch after this. It's good. That flexibility that the entrepreneur life, or it is my entrepreneur life, affords, right? That is something I really... Arjun Thomas: to what's on the menu for the kids today. Dhruv Shanker: They are getting a really nice mutton curry actually. They are going to eat a family recipe, something called Gonda Wala Meat. Gonda is a small town in UP where my great grandfather came from. ⁓ It's a really nice mutton curry with lots of marrow bones because they are going to get lots of, at this age, getting that protein and getting all the good fats into them is important. So they getting a nice hearty ⁓ mutton curry and rice is what they doing. A little bit of veggie on the side because my wife wants it. Arjun Thomas: Mm-hmm. Hmm. Dhruv Shanker: No, but it's ⁓ important. Arjun Thomas: Mum needs the veggies to go in. I can hear mums all around the world echoing the sentiment. Dhruv Shanker: But no, that is their lunch. Little bit of, recipe is nice, little bit of, it's a little heavy on pepper, but you know, given having rainy weather in Singapore, little slap of pepper is a nice thing to have to keep those colds in bay. Arjun Thomas: So, I mean, thanks Dhruv, it's been an amazing conversation. ⁓ Probably one of the few people I can talk to, Roas and Garam Masala in the same conversation and not make it sound very strange at all. ⁓ But, you know, was wonderful. You take the time. ⁓ I'm sure there's a plethora of interesting stories. We'll probably do another one of this somewhere down the road when you've launched your brand, chosen not to launch a brand, pivoted to your fourth business or third business or somewhere in between, and then we can take it from there. Dhruv Shanker: Thank you so much Adrian, I appreciate you reaching out and I really enjoyed the conversation. Always happy to share and thanks for listening to some of the madness, maybe it gives you a sense of what this chaotic life is about. But yeah, thanks, great questions and I really enjoyed the chat. And all the best with this series. I think this is... Creating content is not easy. I've tried and failed it a few times and then started again. It's not easy. Content creation is a journey. But you'll just get better at every one that you do. And that's just how it is. Arjun Thomas: Yeah, I'm starting with the easy bit which is talking to really interesting people. I find that that's less weight on my part. I can figure out the rest. Dhruv Shanker: know, interesting people are interesting when you ask them interesting questions. That's really it. The question can be very boring. talk about that but the questions are really what make the conversation worth having. So thanks a lot and ⁓ yeah I look forward to seeing this. Arjun Thomas: Mm. I will put in your details, I think you're probably already a very very popular person in Singapore, so the two three people that get to watch this would be two three more that we can add to that list. I'd be facetious obviously, but yeah I'll put your details down, people can reach you on guess LinkedIn, on Instagram, on Twitter, you're pretty much on every social platform I would assume at this point. Dhruv Shanker: Yes, I'm called madonionslicer everywhere from Instagram to GitHub. Okay, so that's my thing. Arjun Thomas: Done and done, done and done. Catch up soon man, lovely speaking to you. Cheers, bye. Dhruv Shanker: Thank you so much. Take care, man. Bye.