Latest / Eerie Travels / The Harpe Brothers: America's First Serial Killers
Transcript
- 0:45[SPEAKER_00]: Greetings travelers.
- 0:46[SPEAKER_00]: Welcome to another fun ghost story Sunday or Tuesday or Wednesday or whatever day you are listening.
- 0:52[SPEAKER_00]: We just happy you're joining us.
- 0:55[SPEAKER_00]: But today I'm going to start with some history.
- 0:58[SPEAKER_00]: and then we're gonna go right into the ghost story in the second half.
- 1:02[SPEAKER_00]: So this one, I was one I almost did for a full episode with Erica, but I thought you guys might enjoy this one just as a deep dive and a little bit of fun.
- 1:12[SPEAKER_00]: So we're gonna go back into the deep part of Appalachian folklore, a little bit where history and legend of kind of intertwined and where the echoes of violence are kind of just still here.
- 1:27[SPEAKER_00]: the heart brothers.
- 1:28[SPEAKER_00]: Micah, big harp, and wily, little harp.
- 1:32[SPEAKER_00]: They want struck terror in the wilds and Tennessee, Kentucky, and beyond.
- 1:38[SPEAKER_00]: Some people call them America's first serial killers, some others call them the Devil's of Appalachia.
- 1:44[SPEAKER_00]: We're going to follow their trail across wilderness and a little bit later, we're going to tell some ghost stories.
- 1:51[SPEAKER_00]: So sit back and
- 1:54[SPEAKER_00]: enjoy the tales.
- 1:55[SPEAKER_00]: Before we get deep into the realm of the legends, we've got to go into the grim reality of the late 18th century and the American frontier.
- 2:06[SPEAKER_00]: Basically, the heart brothers is full of violence, vengeance, lawlessness, and just everything that haunted the bordelands of our imagination.
- 2:15[SPEAKER_00]: We've kind of pieced this together from court records, some eyewitness accounts, and a lot of oral traditions of the communities that they kind of terrorized.
- 2:24[SPEAKER_00]: So...
- 2:25[SPEAKER_00]: uh... micah our big heart and wiley will harp uh... they were sometimes cousins sometimes brothers known really knows aren't uh... they were born in the years before the american revolution somewhere between seventeen sixty seven seventeen seventy other born in orange county north keralina to scottish immigrant families their fathers were loyalists
- 2:48[SPEAKER_00]: and steadfast narrow agents to the British crown during a time where that's pretty much a death sentence in that area.
- 2:55[SPEAKER_00]: Some accounts said that the heartboys witnessed their parents execution, Patriot neighbors.
- 3:01[SPEAKER_00]: And this is a trauma that may have set them on this path of violence.
- 3:04[SPEAKER_00]: As the revolution rage, young heart brothers joined some Tory gangs that were kind of like bands
- 3:18[SPEAKER_00]: terrible things these gangs had other names that I can't really say on the show pretty bad they would just raid a patriot families and settlements and they fought in several battles as a regulars including the Battle of Kings Mountain in 1780 and then they later joined forces with the Chica Magua Cherokee.
- 3:37[SPEAKER_00]: and there they learned survival and stealth and also a little bit of their brutality.
- 3:43[SPEAKER_00]: And now for over a decade, they lived among the Chika Magwa at Nika Jack, which is kind of near Chattanooga.
- 3:51[SPEAKER_00]: During this period, they kidnapped two women, Susan Wood and Maria Davidson, and they would later become their wives and then companions in crime.
- 4:02[SPEAKER_00]: Now, while he would later marry another lady, Sarah Rice, or Sally Rice, and she was the daughter of a Baptist minister, and I'd be in 1797.
- 4:13[SPEAKER_00]: So by the mid 1790s, the harps had settled near Knoxville, Tennessee on Beaver Creek.
- 4:18[SPEAKER_00]: Outwardly, they appeared to be settling down, raising hogs, selling pork, marrying into local families, but beneath that veneer, they were doing livestock thefts, they were burning barns and many disappearances are plaguing the community.
- 4:33[SPEAKER_00]: So in 1797, they were accused of stealing some horses, and the harps were captured by a posse, but they somehow managed to escape.
- 4:43[SPEAKER_00]: And according to their wives, this was the turning point.
- 4:46[SPEAKER_00]: And that was when they decided to declare war on all mankind.
- 4:51[SPEAKER_00]: And yeah, that was their quote.
- 4:53[SPEAKER_00]: Their first known marker was that of a man named Johnson, whose body was found in the Holston River, and he had been disemboweled and flayed.
- 5:03[SPEAKER_00]: And then his body was filled with stones.
- 5:06[SPEAKER_00]: This is a gruesome signature that they kind of marked many of their victims with.
- 5:12[SPEAKER_00]: So from 1798 to 1799, they fled north, the inner Kentucky buyer, the wilderness road,
- 5:19[SPEAKER_00]: which is kind of this perilous artery right through Cumberland Gap, Daniel Boone, you know, marked it and it was traveled by lots of settlers looking for new lives, but for the harps, this road led to death.
- 5:34[SPEAKER_00]: Their victims included here, Peyton, a peddler murdered for his horse and goods near the Cumberland Gap.
- 5:42[SPEAKER_00]: Bates and Paka, two travelers from Maryland who were shot in Tomahawk in December of 1798,
- 5:49[SPEAKER_00]: Stephen Langford, a young Virginian who paid for the harps breakfast that an in, on to be found dead days later, his body was hidden in a ravine.
- 5:59[SPEAKER_00]: The murders alarmed local authorities and Captain Joseph Ballinger led a posse that captured the harps again and their wives, and this was near Stamford, Kentucky, on Christmas Day in 1798 and they were jailed in Danville and a weighted trial for Langford's
- 6:20[SPEAKER_00]: But frontiers' jails were a little more than log-shacks, right?
- 6:24[SPEAKER_00]: And on the night of March 16th, 1799, big and little harp escaped and left their pregnant wives behind.
- 6:31[SPEAKER_00]: Again, the women were later acquitted, but each gave birth in jail.
- 6:35[SPEAKER_00]: And then eventually they came back and joined them again.
- 6:40[SPEAKER_00]: I don't understand it.
- 6:42[SPEAKER_00]: It happens.
- 6:45[SPEAKER_00]: So, now the harps rampage intensifies at this point.
- 6:49[SPEAKER_00]: in the spring and summer of 1799, their trail of blood stretched from Kentucky to Illinois and back.
- 6:55[SPEAKER_00]: This time, Johnny Trebu, a 13-year-old son of Colonel Daniel Trebu, was murdered for a sack of flour and beans.
- 7:06[SPEAKER_00]: And then again, his body was mutilated and hidden in a sinkhole.
- 7:10[SPEAKER_00]: Frederick Stump, a fisherman on the Baron River was stabbed, disemboweled, filled with rocks,
- 7:18[SPEAKER_00]: Three men camping near the sailing river in Illinois were all shot in cold blood attributed to the harps.
- 7:25[SPEAKER_00]: Now, the harps sought refuge at cave in a rock, which is a notorious den of river pirates, and it was led by Samuel Mason on the Ohio River.
- 7:34[SPEAKER_00]: Even there, among the outlaws, the harps say doesn't was too much.
- 7:38[SPEAKER_00]: They stripped a captive, tied them to a blindfolded horse, and then they chased them both over a cliff for sport.
- 7:45[SPEAKER_00]: So Mason's gang said, no, you got to go.
- 7:47[SPEAKER_00]: You're too crazy for us.
- 7:49[SPEAKER_00]: So after that, we're still summer 1799.
- 7:54[SPEAKER_00]: They returned to Tennessee and Kentucky.
- 7:56[SPEAKER_00]: And again, just kept going.
- 7:59[SPEAKER_00]: Bradbury and Hardin were two farmers near Knoxville.
- 8:02[SPEAKER_00]: They were murdered in July.
- 8:03[SPEAKER_00]: A young boy named coffee was killed for his rifle.
- 8:08[SPEAKER_00]: William Ballard was found disemboweled, filled with rocks and sunk in the Holston River.
- 8:16[SPEAKER_00]: had his throat slashed and they named the mountain their bristles knob after that.
- 8:22[SPEAKER_00]: John Tully, he was murdered near the Tennessee Kentucky border.
- 8:26[SPEAKER_00]: John Graves and his teenage son were bludgeoned with an axe and south central Kentucky, and then the Triswald family, men, women, children, they were slaughtered in her camp near a dearsville Kentucky.
- 8:39[SPEAKER_00]: Now the harps violence spared no one, not even their own children.
- 8:44[SPEAKER_00]: In August 1799, Big Heart killed his infant daughter by bashing her head against a tree because her crying threatened their concealment.
- 8:53[SPEAKER_00]: It was the only murder for which he would later express remorse.
- 8:58[SPEAKER_00]: So, end of their bloody trail, right?
- 9:02[SPEAKER_00]: The final atrocity comes at the home of Moses de Gaulle in Webster County, Kentucky.
- 9:09[SPEAKER_00]: On the night of August 20th, 1799, the harps posed as Methodist preachers were given shelter by Mrs. de Gaulle, and was home with her infant son and a guest, Major William Love.
- 9:22[SPEAKER_00]: That night, the harps murdered love allegedly for snoring too loud, then slit the baby's throat and killed Mrs. Tagal when she screamed about it.
- 9:32[SPEAKER_00]: They burned the cabin to cover their crimes.
- 9:35[SPEAKER_00]: Now when Moses returned and found his family slain, he joined a posse, which was led by John Leipur.
- 9:43[SPEAKER_00]: and they did not let up at this point these men gotta go.
- 9:47[SPEAKER_00]: So on August 24, 1799, they caught up with big harp in Mulberg County and he was shot in the leg and the back.
- 9:54[SPEAKER_00]: Pulled from his horse and as he laid dying, he confessed to at least 20 murders.
- 10:01[SPEAKER_00]: Moses to Gaul seeking vengeance slowly cut off his head with a hunting knife.
- 10:06[SPEAKER_00]: The head was spiked on a pole of crossroads near Stagal cabin
- 10:14[SPEAKER_00]: Now, while he a little harp escaped the posse and returned to the mason gang at Cavener Rock, and he used the alias known as John Setton, but in 1803 he and a fellow outlawed named Pete Alston killed someone named Samuel Mason.
- 10:33[SPEAKER_00]: and cut off his head and tried to claim the bounty on him, but they were recognized as the villains that they were.
- 10:39[SPEAKER_00]: They were arrested and they were hanged in the old Greenville jail of the Mississippi Territory on February 8, 1804.
- 10:48[SPEAKER_00]: Their heads too were displayed on stakes alongside the Natches trace as a warning to other outlets.
- 10:56[SPEAKER_00]: So, what are the women?
- 10:58[SPEAKER_00]: Well,
- 10:59[SPEAKER_00]: After Big Harps' death, Sally Rice, Susan Wood, and Maria Davidson were tried as accomplices, but they were acquitted.
- 11:06[SPEAKER_00]: The courts believed that they had been captives.
- 11:09[SPEAKER_00]: Now, Sally returned to Knoxville, remarried, and moved to Illinois.
- 11:13[SPEAKER_00]: Susan and Maria settled near Russellville, Kentucky.
- 11:16[SPEAKER_00]: Maria later married John Hulfstetter, and moved to Illinois where she lived until the 1860s.
- 11:24[SPEAKER_00]: Now, the harps convert confirmed victims, number at least 39, with some estimates as high as 50.
- 11:32[SPEAKER_00]: The crimes are so senseless in savage that even hardened criminals recoil that on.
- 11:38[SPEAKER_00]: They murdered men, women, children, and infants.
- 11:42[SPEAKER_00]: And sometimes for gain, and seemingly for no reason at all, many times, they're a terror-led to the formation of many vigilante posses
- 11:54[SPEAKER_00]: on the frontier.
- 11:56[SPEAKER_00]: So their story, indoors and places names, harps had rode, is their haunted crossroads and whispered warnings of Appalachian parents to their children, beware of the devils that once walked these woods.
- 12:09[SPEAKER_00]: So we'll be right back with the spookier side.
- 12:34[SPEAKER_00]: So the harp story didn't end with their deaths.
- 12:38[SPEAKER_00]: In the hills and hollows of Appalachia, their spirits are said to linger, restless, vengeful, and forever bound to the places where they spilled blood.
- 12:49[SPEAKER_00]: Now travelers, let's leave the cold facts behind at an enter the where the line between history and haunting blurs.
- 12:58[SPEAKER_00]: They say on certain moonless nights travel the old road south of Dixon, Kentucky.
- 13:05[SPEAKER_00]: You might find yourself at a lonely crossroads.
- 13:08[SPEAKER_00]: Place the locals, still call harps head.
- 13:12[SPEAKER_00]: Two centuries ago, the head of Big Harp was spiked on a pole here,
- 13:19[SPEAKER_00]: but some say the warning was not enough.
- 13:23[SPEAKER_00]: Long after the flesh had rotted and the birds had picked the skull clean, travelers began to whisper of strange happenings at the crossroads.
- 13:32[SPEAKER_00]: Horses would shy and refuse to pass.
- 13:35[SPEAKER_00]: Dogs were whimpering, cower, tails tucked between their legs.
- 13:39[SPEAKER_00]: Some claimed to see a shadowy figure, tall, broad shoulder, with wild black hair standing beneath the trees, his face twisted in a perpetual scale.
- 13:51[SPEAKER_00]: One story tells of a peddler, lost on a stormy night, who saw a shelter beneath the old tree.
- 13:57[SPEAKER_00]: As he dosed, he was awakened by the sound of heavy footsteps, and the cold touch of a hand on his shoulder.
- 14:09[SPEAKER_00]: The peddler fled, abandoning his pack, and was found the next morning, babbling of the devil's ghosts that haunted the crossroads.
- 14:18[SPEAKER_00]: Others say that on the anniversary of Big Harps' death, the spectral head appears at top of the pole.
- 14:24[SPEAKER_00]: It's eyes glowing red, its mouth moving and silent curse.
- 14:28[SPEAKER_00]: The wind carries the echo of his last words.
- 14:38[SPEAKER_00]: for the harpshead spirit is said to hunger for company in the afterlife.
- 14:47[SPEAKER_00]: The wilderness road, once the gateway to Kentucky's Promised Land, is now a ribbon of memory winding through the mountains, but not all who traveled it reached their journey.
- 14:58[SPEAKER_00]: Some say the harpsbrothers still ride the road, their spirits bound to the path of their
- 15:07[SPEAKER_00]: in the trees been low, travelers have reported seeing two writers.
- 15:12[SPEAKER_00]: One large, one slight galloping along the old trace.
- 15:16[SPEAKER_00]: The horses hose make no sound and their faces are as pale as moonlight.
- 15:21[SPEAKER_00]: Sometimes the writers vanish into the mist.
- 15:24[SPEAKER_00]: Other times they stop and stare with hollow eyes as if searching for their next victim.
- 15:29[SPEAKER_00]: Their tails of wagons found abandoned, their driver's missing, and children who woke in the night, sound of laughter and clutter of horses hooves outside their cabins.
- 15:39[SPEAKER_00]: Some say the harps were cursed to ride the wilderness road forever, unable to find rest, doomed to haunt the land they once terrorized.
- 15:48[SPEAKER_00]: And then there's the legend of the Wild Hunt, a spectral cavalcade that sweeps through the mountain, led by the ghosts of the harpsbrothers.
- 15:56[SPEAKER_00]: On all halos Eve, when the veil between the worlds is thin, the hunt rides out, gathering lost souls and striking terror into the hearts of those who hear its approach.
- 16:06[SPEAKER_00]: And if you find yourself on the wilderness road after dark, and hear the thunder of hose behind you, do not look back.
- 16:14[SPEAKER_00]: For if the harps brothers catch you, with their gaze, you may be swept away into the land of the dead.
- 16:24[SPEAKER_00]: So what is it about the heart of brothers that keeps their story alive?
- 16:28[SPEAKER_00]: Is it just the sheer brutality of their crimes or...
- 16:32[SPEAKER_00]: the way their legend is woven itself into the very fabric of Appalachian folklore.
- 16:36[SPEAKER_00]: In the mountains, ghost stories are more than entertainment.
- 16:39[SPEAKER_00]: They're warnings, they're lessons, they're reminders of the darkness that dwells within us.
- 16:44[SPEAKER_00]: And the places can be haunted, wilderness road, cave and rock, carp's head.
- 16:48[SPEAKER_00]: They're not just points on a map, but kind of living landscapes.
- 16:53[SPEAKER_00]: They've got memory, they've got meaning.
- 16:55[SPEAKER_00]: The ghosts of the harps are said to be bound to these places, unable to move on.
- 17:00[SPEAKER_00]: forever replaying the violence and fear they'd sewed.
- 17:03[SPEAKER_00]: Now, in the oral tradition of Appalachia, stories are told with reverence for the dead in a sense of place.
- 17:10[SPEAKER_00]: But the harpsbrothers, that's a cautionary one, or a reminder that evil ones unleashed can echo through generations.
- 17:18[SPEAKER_00]: Thanks for joining me on this eerie travel into America's haunted past, I hope you enjoyed it.
- 17:24[SPEAKER_00]: Be sure to subscribe, leave a review.
- 17:28[SPEAKER_00]: Let us know your own haunted tales and places you'd like me to discuss at eurotravel.com.
- 17:34[SPEAKER_00]: We'd love to hear it and to find yourself on a lonely cross road or hear hoof beats on the old wilderness road.
- 17:44[SPEAKER_00]: You know, share a thought for the souls who never found peace, keep your lanterns lit, and your wits about you, because you never know what shadows may be waiting just beyond
- 17:57[SPEAKER_00]: beware of the devils who walk in the woods, and we'll see you on the other side.