Latest / I Love You Keep Going with George Haas / The Activation of the Creative Self
Transcript
- 0:01You're listening to the I Love You Keep Going podcast with
- 0:04George Haas. For more information, please
- 0:06visit our website at www.medigroup.org.
- 0:10That's www.n ETTAGROU p.org. So welcome everybody.
- 0:20This is I love you. Keep going.
- 0:21It's Thursday, October 10th, 2024 at 7:35 PM Pacific.
- 0:26I think it's still Daylight. Time means we get up in the dark
- 0:34at this point. And tonight I thought I would
- 0:41talk about activating the creative self or causing the
- 0:47creative sense of self to arise in the attachment lens.
- 0:53Of course, the toggle that we're really talking about is the
- 0:56activation of the attachment system, which causes you to
- 0:59abandon exploration and seek physical proximity to somebody
- 1:05who you feel will protect you and comfort and soothe you.
- 1:10And in order to get the exploration system to turn back
- 1:13on, you need to get the attachment system to turn off.
- 1:17They're they're linked. And then some sense, if you can
- 1:21get the attachment system to turn back on, the exploration
- 1:25systems turned back on. So you have the the capacity
- 1:29then to leave that secure base and adventure out into the world
- 1:35and begin to discover the things that you need to know.
- 1:38But that still isn't quite the same thing as then this creative
- 1:45sense of self that arises when you can pull out of the way all
- 1:52of the obstacles that the mind tends to throw up to prevent you
- 1:56from doing all. All of the sense of self doubt
- 1:59that might come up and the the the sense of preferences that
- 2:05might come up as you discern one thing from another through that
- 2:11lens of meaning. Because of the way that we
- 2:20create the sense of reality and the the process of that
- 2:26unfolding, you have the capacity to send something when it has
- 2:31contact with an object that can be sensed by that capacity, a
- 2:35consciousness of that experience arises.
- 2:39It's still before the self experience.
- 2:43It's evaluated for urgency. Does it need to mediate
- 2:45attention? Does it not matter whether we
- 2:48ever get to it? Is there time for a pleasant
- 2:50experience? And then it's compared to the
- 2:55perceptual database, that storehouse of meaning that we
- 2:59have from the experiences that we've already had.
- 3:04And in that process of attaching meaning, that whole thread of
- 3:07meaning which is really identified by the, the
- 3:11collection of sense experiences or mind moments in, in the
- 3:17present moment. What attaches to that is a whole
- 3:22thread of meaning. And some of those threads go all
- 3:26the way back to the, to the very beginning of, of life.
- 3:34And in that is also the expectation for the outcome of
- 3:42what's going to happen. And we can get into these
- 3:49breaths of conditioning. Samsara is the word where
- 3:55because of our anticipation of the outcome, we don't take
- 3:59certain avenues. It's a kind of an avoidance of
- 4:03the of the anticipated outcome. And then of course, depending on
- 4:10what your attachment conditioning is and how that
- 4:14habit of creation of the present moment unfolds, you have
- 4:20different ways of responding to it.
- 4:23So imagine for a second that your caregivers were sensitively
- 4:27attuned to. They responded to more than 30%
- 4:33of the time in a way that was useful to you, and you developed
- 4:36a secure sense of attachment. Then what likely is to happen
- 4:42there is that you have the expectation that people will be
- 4:46supportive of the things that are interesting to you, have the
- 4:49expectation that people will listen to you as you describe
- 4:52the experience of discovering what's meaningful to you.
- 4:57You have the sense that not only will they listen to you, but
- 5:00they'll be delighted that you've expressed that to them and
- 5:06they'll be encouraging you for you to do more.
- 5:12And in that, that space, that sense of the creative self
- 5:18easily arises because there's a sense of confidence that I can
- 5:24explore. I can discover the things I need
- 5:26to know. I can express them to people
- 5:29that are interested in me, interested in what I found out.
- 5:33And and in that arising of his competent sense of self that can
- 5:39engage in the process of discovery, endure the likelihood
- 5:47that most avenues of discovery won't lead to much.
- 5:50This is one of the great difficulties of exploration is
- 5:55developing sufficient resilience so that you can discover the
- 5:59things that you need to know and that you don't give up before
- 6:05the discovery. And at the same time can
- 6:10carefully discern whether or not an Ave. needs more in the way of
- 6:15pursuit or you can redirect to something else.
- 6:19And in that process of moving from discovery to discovery and
- 6:24the collection of meaning over time, really develop this
- 6:30facility for exploration, which is driven by the sense of reward
- 6:38that you get out of doing it, that making sense Mudit.
- 6:47I think we're, we're still setting up that form of
- 6:51expectation, right? Because we are saying that, oh,
- 6:53if this thing doesn't lead to, that is a form of an expectation
- 7:02from the activity, right from the anticipation of the outcome.
- 7:10I think that we have an expectation of what will happen,
- 7:18and in the way that you say that, it sounds to me like
- 7:23there's a negative association with an expectation, which may
- 7:28not necessarily be there always. If your expectation was that the
- 7:34the exploration would be fruitful and that you would be
- 7:39able to discover the things that you need to know, then the
- 7:41expectation would be 1 of receiving one of being burdened.
- 7:47That makes sense. So what does exploration being
- 7:53fruitful mean exactly? Well, because we're all so
- 7:58unique and our conditioning is also also unique, The thing that
- 8:04really will will be valuable to you is probably going to be very
- 8:12specific to you. And the things that I value are
- 8:16going to be specific to me. And so I often think that it is
- 8:24the actual specifics that are less interesting than the the
- 8:28unfolding of how to discover what you need to know, because
- 8:32you could use the understanding of the process of exploring for
- 8:36your own exploration without having to arrive at the
- 8:40specifics that are meaningful to me.
- 8:44So for instance, if I were to talk about photography a little
- 8:47bit, when I started to take pictures of trees, the initial
- 8:57impetus of that was to make a formal portrait of a tree, but
- 9:02use the constraints of portraiture for humans and apply
- 9:07that to the subject of a tree. And so I began to do that, but
- 9:13in the way that visual art works, of course, is you make a
- 9:17visual representation of something and then you examine
- 9:21the visual representation that you made and and in the
- 9:26exploring that of that, begin to discover, to discover the the
- 9:30parts of it that work for you and the parts that don't work.
- 9:35And then when you go to make the next image, you explode the
- 9:39parts from the creation of the image that did not work and
- 9:43center it more on the aspects of the image that did work.
- 9:48And then in making the next image, examining the image and
- 9:52again understanding the parts of it that work and the parts that
- 9:56have it that don't work. And in this gradual process of
- 10:01distilling what is working, obviously in my experience of
- 10:07what's working you, I find most of the time the subtleties of
- 10:12the, the, the images that really get me going are never mentioned
- 10:16by anybody who looks at them. And really, when they relate
- 10:22their experience of the image, they're relating to the, the,
- 10:27the meaning that they've assigned to it, not that I've
- 10:29given to it. And so every now and then when
- 10:34you find somebody that relates to things in the way that you
- 10:37do, that it's close enough that they might actually be talking
- 10:40about the marvelous things that you've put in there that nobody
- 10:43could see except you. There's a Zing to that, really.
- 10:50But I can tell you that in the beginning, the tree was central.
- 10:55But if you look at the end of that particular series, what
- 10:59really is happening is an interplay between telephone
- 11:03poles, trees and streetlights. Because over and over again, the
- 11:08thing that really zinged for me was in addition to the tree,
- 11:14telephone poles and streetlights.
- 11:17And so the, the whereas the portraits at the beginning of
- 11:21these very sort of straight on pictures of trees, by the end of
- 11:25it, it's this dance between these three elements.
- 11:28And as you move through the landscape looking for what to
- 11:32take a picture of, gradually, as you know what it is that you're
- 11:36actually working with, the locations change.
- 11:40Because not all locations have all of the elements that you
- 11:45want and an absence of the elements that you don't want.
- 11:51This is, you know, a years long process.
- 11:55Vigorous, vigorous exploration on my part.
- 12:00But I'm not sure that you would spend three years photographing
- 12:08trees, looking for a dance between trees and telephone
- 12:14poles and streetlights, you know what I'm saying?
- 12:20Classrooms. Huh.
- 12:23I'm on mushroom. Hard to drive on mushroom,
- 12:29although I don't know, I've never taken Christian.
- 12:38George, do you find that people's like the way they see
- 12:42your art in a way that you didn't see it?
- 12:45They end up. Convincing you or like how does
- 12:49that what do you end up with when when like here's this work,
- 12:55but no one can agree on on what it is about it.
- 13:01No, I don't. I don't know that I'm persuaded
- 13:05to a different point of view. So Buddha talked about this as
- 13:10the jewel of Dharma. Of course, right, The Dharma is
- 13:13the jewel, but there's all these different facets.
- 13:15And as you look through the facet, each different facet, it
- 13:20creates a different perspective on the Dharma, which is actually
- 13:25enriching of the understanding of things.
- 13:29But what is interesting to me is when you you look at a picture
- 13:36and express the meaning of it. So half the series of trees is
- 13:40in color and half the series of the trees is in black and white.
- 13:45And the the black and white images are in a very traditional
- 13:48format and the color pictures are in the the golden ratio.
- 13:53Do you know the golden ratio? It's 1.168 realistically, but
- 14:00the golden ratio is supposed to be the dimensions of sight space
- 14:04really is the origin of it. But then as you look at the at
- 14:08nature, it repeats over and over again.
- 14:12In that sense, one by 1.618. The reason I started to make
- 14:20other pictures is the the dealer I had at the time said that
- 14:24people cannot, younger people cannot look at a black and white
- 14:29photograph without viewing it as a color photograph where the
- 14:33color is muted, which would suggest that it was overcast and
- 14:37Gray and cold and desolate. Because they don't have the
- 14:44visual literacy of black and white images because they grew
- 14:48up in an era of color images. But I grew up in an era of black
- 14:53and white images. And for the longest time, color
- 14:56images were entirely garish and unpleasing because of the
- 15:02intensity of the color. And, and so I haven't lost the,
- 15:07the capacity to view a black and white image with the full range
- 15:10of emotions from a joyfulness all the way to that melancholy.
- 15:15And, and maybe you, you have that or you don't have that, but
- 15:20it's certainly a vocabulary in our culture that has been lost.
- 15:27But now when you're looking at the creation of of the visual
- 15:33world because of the advent of artificial intelligence and all
- 15:39of the tools that are are available for creating and
- 15:45distorting imagery of the generation that's currently
- 15:49coming up is shooting black and white film.
- 15:52Again, because they want analog, because they want to be able to
- 15:56represent something as unaltered, which they think that
- 16:03they can do by using film. I don't know if you know your
- 16:08photographers, but Gary Winogran used to file out the the
- 16:14negative holders so that there would be a black border around
- 16:18the image so that he could demonstrate in the way that he
- 16:22presented it, that he caught the image without cropping, without
- 16:27altering. Which is I always thought of as
- 16:30this ablest view. We, those of us who are very
- 16:37slow visual processors, who can't snap something and get it
- 16:42right, but can spend 45 minutes setting up the camera to take a
- 16:47picture, should we really, you know, the, the genetic
- 16:52advantage, should they be deserving of all of the
- 16:56attention? I would say decidedly they
- 16:58shouldn't. How our culture values those
- 17:03things. It's a it's kind of an
- 17:05athleticism in a way. It's like the the hyper
- 17:10realistic drawings where I can Draw Something as good as a
- 17:13photograph or something. Where the somebody who's
- 17:18autistic who can look at something once and then draw a
- 17:21detailed drawing 6 feet long in, in perfect scale, you know,
- 17:26these kinds of advantages. I suppose I have my own, my own
- 17:34set of, of advantages and we each do.
- 17:40And then some are valued more than others, which is an
- 17:43interesting thing when we were talking about the activation of
- 17:48the, the creative self and, and the, the fitting that expression
- 17:56into the cultural container that we have.
- 18:01There's a lot of pressure in the cultural container to represent
- 18:05the reality of our society in certain ways or the relationship
- 18:10of our societies in a certain way.
- 18:12If you if you take this down a little bit.
- 18:17So culture is the overall container in society are the
- 18:21groups of people that are dependent on one another for for
- 18:26their livelihood and survival, all sorts of different layers of
- 18:36society. You know, living in Los Angeles
- 18:40and I like to live in these really big places where there's
- 18:44a lot of, of different societies that are interacting and living
- 18:49within the same culture. It makes it more vibrant, more
- 18:52interesting. And I like the variation of
- 18:56that. I'm, I'm, I really, the
- 18:59segregated neighborhoods don't really appeal to me because
- 19:02they're too much of the same. And I like the variation.
- 19:12When you activate this creative sense of self, which is really
- 19:16organized around the things that matter to you and the things
- 19:19that you find interesting, and then you go to express them.
- 19:24I really do think that when we talk about this cycle of
- 19:28expression, it is to go out on your own and really go deeply
- 19:34into the things that matter to you and to really understand and
- 19:38integrate the things that matter to you so that you can express
- 19:43them to someone else. And that cycle is really about
- 19:47the gathering of the things, the ingestion of them, and then the
- 19:53expression of them when you move beyond the society that you're
- 20:01really into. A broader picture of that and
- 20:06there is some attention to. How big of a messenger can you
- 20:13be with the expressions that you make?
- 20:16How does it affect actually the thing that you're exploring?
- 20:22So does it become less about that primary interest thing that
- 20:27really matters to you and and turning more into the secondary
- 20:32exploration, which is a gathering of resources, Adam.
- 20:41Thanks, George. A couple of questions.
- 20:43One, how important if at all do you find it to be to know and
- 20:50understand the why of what matters to you, if that makes
- 20:54sense? And, and also the line between
- 21:00what you just said, It's the only reason I have a second
- 21:03question, because it was a compelling for me that I often
- 21:08find that this desire to express on a mass level the things that
- 21:16matter to me isn't so much for those primary resources as it
- 21:23is. Or rather, it's more about the
- 21:29gathering of of monetary resources as opposed to and to
- 21:41be honest, attention. Right seeking social status is
- 21:47also secondary exploration because it provides access to to
- 21:52more resources if you can get a higher social status.
- 21:55Right. And some, you know, for some
- 22:00people, social status actually has more bite to it than
- 22:04actually remuneration or other kinds of resources the the
- 22:08attention of it. So when we when I talk about the
- 22:16activation of the creative self, another way to really talk about
- 22:22it is intermediate and advanced mentalizing.
- 22:25We talk about the basic mentalizing, which really gets
- 22:29you into a place of security where you can you can support
- 22:33the life that you have, and then you can be in relationship to
- 22:35the people that you need to be in, in relationship to.
- 22:39And at the top of the stack of the basic mentalizing is meaning
- 22:44making so that you have a sense of what it is that's meaningful
- 22:48to you. And then as you move into the
- 22:52intermediate range of mentalizing, one of the things
- 22:57that really comes to the fore is the understanding of why you've
- 23:02assigned the meaning to it that you have based on your
- 23:05conditioning, which means that you can reflect on the process
- 23:09of making meaning and understand it.
- 23:13I talk about the 57 T bird. If you heard me talk about that,
- 23:18the that in seeing the light flash off the grill of the 57 T
- 23:26bird, my mind went to a similar flash of light off a Chrome
- 23:32surface. But it wasn't the wasn't a car
- 23:37in the sense of AT bird. It was the light flashing off
- 23:42the the dashboard of my grandmother's car, which was a
- 23:4653 DeSoto, which was, you know, this was before they padded the
- 23:52dashboards. It was like metal, you know,
- 23:55and, and Chrome and the knobs for a child's hand took up the
- 24:00whole hand and the light flashed off a bit.
- 24:04And I was with my grandmother and she was sometimes kind to
- 24:14me. And I, I grew up in a cruel
- 24:17environment. And so I really equated
- 24:22extraordinary value to expressions of kindness and, and
- 24:28that's what came to mind. And so to understand the meaning
- 24:32that you give something is to understand all of the resources
- 24:36that you use to define it so that you could see clearly, for
- 24:39instance, in that example, that it wasn't the car in the present
- 24:43moment turning the corner that provided that sense of richness
- 24:47and and meaning. It was the memory of my
- 24:50grandmother from 40 years earlier that provided that.
- 24:56And so as you move, as you navigate through your
- 25:00exploration and you can mentalize at that level, then
- 25:05you see that more clearly. And as you move then into the
- 25:09advanced mentalizing where you can see the way the system, for
- 25:15instance, of your society, your immediate society relates to the
- 25:20systems of the larger society, which relates then to the system
- 25:23of culture. And that you can carry meaning
- 25:27all the way across that, then, then that's an even richer
- 25:30experience of meaning. And when you can then relate
- 25:35that even beyond the confines of culture to the, the human
- 25:40condition and the spiritual nature of our our life here,
- 25:47then that that carries an even deeper, more profound sense of
- 25:52meaning that you could in your exploration.
- 25:58Then certainly this is true in the meditative side of things,
- 26:01Go deeply into the nature of the understanding of this human
- 26:05condition, this conundrum that we're in, and find a deep sense
- 26:11of meaning in that. And then express that in a way
- 26:15that is then understandable by the people that you're in
- 26:19society with, which would create a richness in the meaning.
- 26:23So that the, the, the, the greater your, your, your
- 26:27capacity at mentalizing these, you know, moving parts really
- 26:36at, at scale, the the richer that that sense is.
- 26:41I think that making sense, Adam. Thank you to help clarify, and
- 26:55this is the meeting I'm assigning to it obviously, but
- 26:58when I, when I you know, I've I've heard you tell that story a
- 27:03few Times Now and it never gets old.
- 27:05Don't get me wrong, but it's. The problem with having a
- 27:09limited life, you have the same stories.
- 27:19What I got out of that is, well, one of many things.
- 27:25It's not the car that is giving you the meaning.
- 27:29So perhaps someone who thought it might be the car who did not
- 27:34have that capacity to mentalize. Right.
- 27:37Buying a car only to realize I never needed the damn car to
- 27:41begin with. Now I.
- 27:42Only to be disappointed. Right, right.
- 27:46OK. Thank you.
- 27:48Yeah, that's it. Thank you.
- 27:52How many avenues have been the wrong Ave. right.
- 27:56Which really brings us back to resilience, right?
- 28:00How resilient are you? How can you go up the wrong Ave.
- 28:04and really have high hopes that it's going to pay out and then
- 28:07it doesn't. But what you gather is that it's
- 28:10a misdirection. And so there must be another
- 28:12direction to go in. So for dismissing people where
- 28:18there's great rigidity, the the resilience is what's missing in
- 28:24the, the the pursuit of a wrong Ave. is a a catastrophe because
- 28:29they can't flex and then move into a different direction.
- 28:35And for preoccupied people, the the problem is that they don't
- 28:40explore very and they don't emotionally regulate independent
- 28:45of other people, So they can't separate from other people to
- 28:49begin to pursue what might be meaningful to them.
- 28:57And as soon as they get dysregulated, of course, the
- 29:01attachment system activates, if they can even get the attachment
- 29:05system to shut down. So the capacity for exploration
- 29:08opens. They then still have to be able
- 29:11to mentalize at a higher rate to get the creative self to arise,
- 29:16to know what to do to to have the confidence to try and do it.
- 29:25Disorganized people, particularly as they get older
- 29:28beyond the 20s, really get into a place of preferring social
- 29:36isolation to the experience of being with other people.
- 29:42And that has a terrible impact on exploration because they
- 29:50don't have the this mostly regulating base to fall back on.
- 29:56So the resilience isn't there. And then also it's so easily
- 30:01turns into auto regulation where it really is just distracting
- 30:06and consuming of the time without actually providing much
- 30:11in the way of meaning. This is also true for dismissing
- 30:15people. But you know, if you, you engage
- 30:19in an activity that's distracting, but it doesn't
- 30:22really lead you to any kind of discovery and you never actually
- 30:27find a need to express it to anyone else.
- 30:30You're really just in a, in an auto regulating loop that that
- 30:34doesn't provide the sense of meaning.
- 30:37It provides a sense of distraction from the lack of
- 30:40meaning, which means every time you stop distracting yourself,
- 30:45the lack of meaning becomes apparent again.
- 30:48And so you have to go back into the process of distraction to
- 30:52get away from it. And you know, you can consume
- 31:03vast want to see yourself, your very short life caught up in
- 31:10auto regulating loops. In fact, the whole life can go
- 31:15by and it won't. It won't pay attention to it.
- 31:24So as we gather around us, these little societies, these little
- 31:28groups of people that really support us, it's really in that
- 31:33intimate container that the these primary explorations could
- 31:37be pursued at a deep level. That's the thing that we
- 31:46organize. And so when you look at the
- 31:48structure of that, what you're, what you really are seeing is
- 31:51that in order to be good at exploring, you have to develop
- 31:57your capacity to mentalize so you can discern what it is
- 32:01you're doing. And you need to develop a
- 32:03capacity to emotionally regulate so that you can go explore.
- 32:08But then you also have to develop a, a safety net, a
- 32:13social safety net, a small group of people that are reliably
- 32:20emotionally regulating that you can show up to and they will
- 32:26help you come back into balance if your exploration just knocks
- 32:31you sideways. If you don't have that, of
- 32:33course, you won't be able to take the risks that you need to
- 32:36know to really find a depth of meaning.
- 32:42And if you can't find the depth of meaning, it affects the
- 32:45resiliency because there's no upside to balance the
- 32:51disappointment of so many directions that don't really
- 32:55carry you where you need to go. Would it?
- 33:01George, can you elaborate on the the disappointment of
- 33:04exploration? If it goes sideways?
- 33:06What? What does that mean exactly?
- 33:09Well. I start playing a music
- 33:16instrument. I don't like it.
- 33:17What's this? What's the?
- 33:27The when you pursue something and it doesn't work, or you
- 33:33attempt to develop something and it doesn't work, there's a
- 33:36quality of disappointment that comes in that have you ever
- 33:42heard the expression the sophomore slump?
- 33:46You know what I mean? It's it's a phrase that means in
- 33:52the beginning when you first start something, the the gains
- 33:57that you make. So for instance, if we were
- 33:59using a musical instruments, the gains of not being able to play
- 34:03at all to being able to play a little bit are fast and exciting
- 34:08and amazing. But to get from the playing a
- 34:12little bit to playing well is a longer path, which is much
- 34:17harder to do. So that the instant rewards of
- 34:22the successes don't come so much.
- 34:25And it's really the resilience to practice well enough to get
- 34:29beyond that, that very slow climb in your ability to do it
- 34:36to a place where you suddenly can do it.
- 34:40An instrument wouldn't be one of the things that I did, but when
- 34:44I was in my 20s, I decided that I would learn to throw pots.
- 34:50And so the first few weeks where you center the clay and you make
- 34:54a little pot and you've got this, this coffee cup that
- 34:57weighs 2 lbs because the walls are so thick.
- 35:01But it looks so beautiful and you're so excited that you could
- 35:05do it. And then hundreds of pots later,
- 35:08hundreds of crappy pots later, you finally get to a place where
- 35:14you could throw a pot. And it's, it's amazing, but it
- 35:17is literally stacking up that that's that enduring that, that
- 35:24unpleasant, disappointing process to get there.
- 35:28And can you do it? That's what I mean by that.
- 35:33Yeah. Making sense?
- 35:35So not being good at it, but I mean, I can be good at something
- 35:39after three years, but then it could be completely meaningless.
- 35:43Right, I can give you another example.
- 35:48I decided that I would use a pyro, which is a, one of the
- 35:54original film processing developers that was developed in
- 35:59the 19th century, at the end of the 19th century.
- 36:02And the reason that I wanted to use pyro is because I live in
- 36:06Los Angeles. It's very contrast to here.
- 36:09It's very easy for the, the, the spectrum of contrast to exceed
- 36:13the, the, the, the capacity of the film to hold contrast.
- 36:17And then when you use pyro, the development is really slow and
- 36:21long. And when you get good at it, the
- 36:25negatives are are amazing because you could take, say,
- 36:28this may be too technical at 13 or 15 zones of contrast and
- 36:32condense them down into the nine that the film can manage.
- 36:36And so when you make a print, it's an amazing range of
- 36:41tonality in a, in a black and white print, which really
- 36:45engages my mind. But it's very tricky.
- 36:49And if you make one mistake, it ruins the negatives or it
- 36:52streaks them, makes them problematic.
- 36:56So it was years of learning how to to get it to work and then
- 37:02just living with the fact that so many of the negatives were
- 37:08disastrous because of it. Every now and then you'd get one
- 37:12that would just work and it would sing.
- 37:14And so that that would carry you forward into the next thing Is
- 37:18that that's sort of making sense.
- 37:20Sorry, one thing I'm realizing is that a lot of it is related
- 37:24with me. Like if it's music instrument or
- 37:28photography, it's it's for me performing for people that
- 37:33really has way more meaning. Is there is that a secondary or
- 37:39is that also primary? I don't know.
- 37:42I think that as we as we resist AI, we're going to be sitting
- 37:47around campfires with guitars, singing folk songs again.
- 37:53And so the ability to be able to play with a group of people
- 37:57would be stunning, right? That would be really meaningful
- 38:01in those moments where it all just sort of comes together in
- 38:04that. That moment would be remarkable,
- 38:08yes, and full of meaning. For the people than me doing it
- 38:12alone doesn't have that much meaning, but if I do it for
- 38:14people then it has that's. Yes, as long as we're not
- 38:20veering off into secondary, there needs to be the the, the
- 38:23sense of personal satisfaction in the engagement.
- 38:27I see. OK, although you can.
- 38:32Social get individual satisfaction from status also so
- 38:36I'm not sure. Right, Henry?
- 38:43Hey, George. I don't think we've met.
- 38:45I'm Henry. Hi.
- 38:47Hey I I had a question, I'm sorry I missed the first couple
- 38:51minutes so let me know if this is off topic or anything.
- 38:55OK. I was wondering I guess 2
- 39:02questions. One is with with avoidant
- 39:07people, are they are people with avoidance style?
- 39:10Are they regulating outside of relationship with other people
- 39:15or distracting? Or can it be some of both?
- 39:18And then just in general for anxious people, like how do we
- 39:23learn to regulate on our own? Like what are good methods for
- 39:26doing that? So in avoided people they tend
- 39:33to be auto regulators and they don't really have much in the
- 39:36way of skill and and something beyond that.
- 39:39So auto regulation is engaging in an external activity that's
- 39:45regulating. So for instance, one of the the
- 39:51main sources of that is competitive physical activity is
- 39:57one of the big ones. Engaging in in activities that
- 40:06require concentration, for instance, avoided people also
- 40:10suppress awareness of their emotions, so they're not so
- 40:13aware that they're dysregulated. And, and they tend to attract
- 40:21people who regulate them so that they don't necessarily have a
- 40:25conscious experience of that. When they move toward earn
- 40:31security and collaboration, they begin to mentalize that and
- 40:34begin to allow into consciousness the awareness of
- 40:37their emotions and then develop the the skill to regulate
- 40:42themselves but also develop the capacity to be in relationships
- 40:47of the people who are regulating.
- 40:50Preoccupied people are dependent on external regulators and the
- 40:57habit is to a mesh into the mind state of the other person and to
- 41:01regulate them. And because the empathetic
- 41:04experience is their primary emotional experience and their
- 41:08own emotional experiences secondary, they feel regulated
- 41:12when they're enmeshed with somebody else who's regulated
- 41:15and they don't feel regulated, they're not.
- 41:18And so the the process then is to turn your attention away from
- 41:23the emeshing and focus on your own emotional states, which then
- 41:29brings your own emotional states into the foreground and and
- 41:33pushes the empathetic experience of the other person into
- 41:37secondary position. And then to examine the
- 41:41emotional regulation skills you may already have or what is more
- 41:46often what, what's required is the development of emotional
- 41:51regulation strategies that you can apply to yourself.
- 41:56But then also begin to pay attention who's regulating for
- 42:00you and to begin to develop your society or social network of
- 42:06regulators so that they're available to you.
- 42:10That making sense. So the, the challenge for
- 42:14preoccupied people is there's more mentalizing that has to be
- 42:21developed and there's more basic emotional regulation skills that
- 42:25need to be developed in order to begin that process.
- 42:32The big also the big hindrance for preoccupied people is the
- 42:37reliance on pretend mode. So there there's also a need to
- 42:42begin to express authentically what your experience is, which
- 42:48also supports the exploration. Because if you can't explore,
- 42:54which is what is affecting most preoccupied people, then the
- 42:59expression of your exploration that you've been making is
- 43:02pretending. You're pretending to explore,
- 43:06and then you're expressing your pretend exploration.
- 43:11And so you have to come into the capacity to express
- 43:15authentically. And then that would mean that
- 43:19you're expressing they don't explore very well in the
- 43:23beginning. And the willingness to do that,
- 43:27which is actually the hardest, I would guess the hardest part of
- 43:30it 'cause if you're used to pretending to explore it,
- 43:34presenting your exploration in a way that gathers a response,
- 43:41even though it's all pretend to move to exploring and then
- 43:47expressing a, a not very capable capacity for exploration.
- 43:55You're not going to elicit necessarily the same response
- 44:00that you might have when you were pretending.
- 44:05And to really see clearly that even though it's not as
- 44:10developed, it's authentic. And that's much preferable to
- 44:13the more elaborated Pretend makes sense.
- 44:22Yeah. Thank you.
- 44:23That's really helpful. You know, one way to talk about
- 44:26it is primary exploration is really the place of the
- 44:32authentic self, the authentic expression of self and pretend
- 44:40exploration is the place of the false self.
- 44:44And a lot of us in our culture in order to fit in, particularly
- 44:47if the depending on the pressures in the family system
- 44:51against your authentic expression, we get really good
- 44:55at the false self. This false self is quite
- 44:59accomplished. But at the back end of all of
- 45:02that is this deficit of meaning, which which is, you know, as
- 45:07over the course of a lifetime becomes a deeper and deeper
- 45:11sense of despair at being alive, which goes away.
- 45:17If you can, if you can move yourself into primary
- 45:21exploration because you're engaged and actually those
- 45:24things that that mean something to you, not necessarily cultural
- 45:33or even across the smaller societies.
- 45:37Is that making sense? All right, why don't we do some
- 45:42meditation and we'll focus on mentalizing a little bit, but do
- 45:47a little bit of concentrations. So go ahead and settle in.
- 45:54All right, let's go of the meditation.
- 46:00How's that Good, huh? So the last piece was
- 46:09interesting. Hey, I thought it was just one
- 46:11event, another event. What's there to notice, say?
- 46:19A little more. Oh, I was just curious, what am
- 46:21I noticing in the last step of the mind?
- 46:24I know there is, yes, attention would move pretty rapidly, but
- 46:31there's only events. I mean, it's hard to say.
- 46:33There's a tension. There's just events and then
- 46:35second event and then third event.
- 46:38Right. Sometimes what you'll notice is
- 46:41that the mind just jumps. Sometimes more than one sense
- 46:46object will appear and then the mind will sort of have some
- 46:50question about where it's going to flow, or it will begin to
- 46:53flow in One Direction and then flow in another.
- 46:55Sometimes there's something that pops and the attention just
- 46:59moves. So that's what you're really
- 47:02beginning to notice. And then the flow of energy is
- 47:07really toward preferred objects. And so when there's more than
- 47:10one at the same time, you can begin to notice that the mind
- 47:14really has a preference of one thing over another.
- 47:18You can see that process of curation as it creates what it's
- 47:22sampling in order to create the experience of reality.
- 47:29One of the sense objects, so like.
- 47:31Right. For me it's like seeing is a lot
- 47:36more and sometimes my eyes are open.
- 47:38There is this day, no daydreaming, but the eyes would
- 47:40get identified with space. Yeah.
- 47:46It's very common with eyes open. Good.
- 47:51Thank you so much. Someone else.
- 47:59All right, so in a couple of weeks we're going to have this
- 48:05half day long on exploration. We're going to go deeply, more
- 48:10deeply into the advanced mentalizing.
- 48:12And then I'm going to try and relate it to the work I've done
- 48:16over my life. And I'll bring some visual
- 48:19examples in for that so that you can you have a visual
- 48:23representation of what I'm talking about rather than these
- 48:26sort of blurred descriptions. And and then we've decided to
- 48:34add 1/2 day long in November, which I'm calling a family
- 48:40archaeology home for the holidays as an attachment
- 48:46exploration so that we could talk about how to go home and
- 48:57watch what's unfolding it as an insight into the nature of your
- 49:01attachment conditioning and how to actually be able to relate to
- 49:04it. So it does, it doesn't just
- 49:06trigger you into a state of non mentalizing.
- 49:13And then we'll come to the end of the year as it goes.
- 49:16So anyway, thanks, thanks a lot for your practice.
- 49:20If you ioffer the teaching freely, if you can make a
- 49:23donation, it's much appreciated. There's a link on the website to
- 49:27do that. Appreciate you being here and I
- 49:31hope to see you soon. Bye.
- 49:34Thank you. Bye.