Latest / Inside Commerce: Ecommerce Strategy, CX and Technology Podcast / EP299: SEO For AI Engines - Adapting Your SEO Strategy To Maximise Brand Reach In AI Powered Platforms, With NOVOS MD Sam Hurley
Transcript
- 0:00There is broadly in the agreement that GLSAEOS and all
- 0:03these acronyms are being created.
- 0:05Essentially the tactics that we're doing for SEO, they're
- 0:08very, very similar as what you would do for the AI.
- 0:10There's just slight adaptations. Nobody can name a brand that is
- 0:14really good in the AI overviews that's got really bad SEO.
- 0:17So it's like all of the performance and the overviews is
- 0:20driven from your SEO performance.
- 0:25You listen to Insidecommerce, a weekly ecom strategy, technology
- 0:27and CX focus podcast hosted by experienced digital consultants
- 0:31and re platform specialist James Geddon Paul Rogers.
- 0:33Get insights into ecom strategy leading brands, hear from
- 0:35industry thought leaders and leading tech vendors with
- 0:38practical advice to help you improve your online CX.
- 0:43This episode is sponsored by Shopify.
- 0:45We are talking about how SEO strategies are adapting,
- 0:48evolving to react to the growth in AI agents, LLMS, what other
- 0:54other whatever I can speak other acronym you would like to use
- 0:58because you know, marketing is full of acronyms.
- 1:01But the, the, the context partners before I introduce our
- 1:04highly experienced guests is that AI searches here.
- 1:08It's not, it's not a myth. It might be being hyped up in
- 1:11certain quarters, but it's there.
- 1:12It's growing. And it's important to analyse
- 1:14and understand what the impact is still a really small
- 1:16percentage of traffic from the vast majority sites.
- 1:18So I think in the data I've seen, it's less than a percent
- 1:20for a lot. There will be differences in
- 1:22some, some markets were, but it's growing.
- 1:25And on that basis, we have to understand it and we have to
- 1:27look at whether that means we need to change how we manage or
- 1:31execute SEO strategies in line with this or not and keep an eye
- 1:35on the evolving tools and understand what the change in
- 1:37use of these tools could mean to us, our site, in our content,
- 1:40etcetera. And then it get then we get onto
- 1:43the the convoluted world of tracking when there is lots of
- 1:47new test involved. So we're going to be discussing
- 1:49this and look about what the reality is and what the
- 1:51implications are. And we've got an exceptionally
- 1:53experienced guest today, so warm welcome to Sam Hurley.
- 1:56Hey, Sam, how are you? Hey John, how are you both?
- 2:01Oh good. Before we start getting into the
- 2:04the nitty gritty of this, do you know for those people who might
- 2:07not have come across you and the agency, do you want to give
- 2:10people a bit of flavour for your background, What you do, what
- 2:13the agency? Does yeah, sounds good.
- 2:16So I got into SEO about 2013 or so straight out university.
- 2:22First role was a tiny agency, first in house employee, kind of
- 2:27worked on lots of very dodgy clients, learned so much that
- 2:32got to about 10 people that then sold to another agency.
- 2:36I moved to cost with those clients from that agency.
- 2:39I then went in house to may.com, which is where I met Paul.
- 2:44And then from there after about two and a bit years of scaling
- 2:47then on brand S here by over 20 million, I then set up Novos.
- 2:54And since then, so that was 2019, we sold the company to the
- 2:59staff in 2020 as an employee ownership route.
- 3:03We literally just work on e-commerce, some industry just
- 3:05work on SEO. So we do that full service SEO,
- 3:07which is the tech content and digital PR link building.
- 3:11And then that's kind of like overpinned with strategy.
- 3:14We've got quite a few mutual clients of Paul as well.
- 3:18The small world of e-commerce and Paul and Vivant excellent.
- 3:22So let's let's get some context to this because there's been a
- 3:26lot, a lot of conversations with Paul and others recently.
- 3:29So Paul, you recently to data you, you posted an interesting
- 3:33article on LinkedIn looking at data from clients on traffic
- 3:36from AI agents and LMS. What is the data telling you and
- 3:40your clients? Yeah, absolutely.
- 3:42So I think so I basically did a post, there's a guy in our team
- 3:46who's running a data project now business and we've got a lot of
- 3:49data sick in a data warehouse. So I basically asked him to
- 3:53build a report that showed the growth of traffic from LLMS
- 3:59overtime per client. And basically the takeaways were
- 4:04traffic's increasing really quickly for probably about 50%
- 4:08of the brands. But in general, the traffic is
- 4:10increasing pretty quickly. The volume's still really low.
- 4:14So I think it was basically up to 1% of the traffic.
- 4:17There was one company that was higher than that, but they're
- 4:21very technical. So it's about a technical audio
- 4:25brand. And I think basically when
- 4:28you're kind of anything that's a bit more technical where you're
- 4:31more likely to be doing research because the other brands where
- 4:34there's a slightly higher proportion were kind of
- 4:36technical clothing, more technical kind of athleisure
- 4:40wear, that kind of stuff. So I think they were the types
- 4:44of businesses that were getting more demand or more like traffic
- 4:47through particularly ChatGPT, which is about 98% of all of the
- 4:52referral traffic. So, yeah, so that's kind of
- 4:56where it is really at the moment.
- 4:57So I think, yeah, anywhere from kind of nought .5% to 1% on
- 5:02average per client with those more technical exceptions.
- 5:07But yeah, pretty sure it'll continue to grow.
- 5:10And I would say particularly the last few months, there's been a
- 5:13lot more uplift in traffic coming from Chat 2, Vt in
- 5:17particular. Sam, what are you seeing?
- 5:20You see you work, you've got an agency, you work across lots of
- 5:23different clients and now there's some crossover, but
- 5:25you'll have different business types as well.
- 5:27Is it consistent? Are you seeing a lot of
- 5:30disparity between certain types of businesses and how much
- 5:32impact it's having? Yeah, we are.
- 5:35But I think this, this is the point that kind of a lot of
- 5:39everything that we're discussing will come back to is that I
- 5:42don't really think these channels now are kind of like
- 5:44traffic drivers. So it's that they're not really
- 5:46going to be, that's not how you're going to judge success
- 5:49from them. So if we, if we are looking at
- 5:51purely traffic, the numbers will always be small.
- 5:53And particularly with Google, like you can see, you've seen it
- 5:57on LinkedIn where you can, you've got this kind of like
- 6:00alligator chart that they're calling it in search console
- 6:02while like impressions are going up, clicks coming down.
- 6:06And that that's kind of essentially what AI search is
- 6:09all about. It's getting in the AIO reviews,
- 6:11getting into GPT and the kind of aim of these isn't to link out
- 6:17like it's very hard to find a link within the the results that
- 6:22you get back that will directly refer you to another website.
- 6:26So it's all about brand visibility getting mentioned
- 6:31rather than traffic drivers. So what we've seen is it's kind
- 6:36of like how we split our reporting is like the
- 6:37traditional reporting is all like clicks, revenue, all that
- 6:41side. And the separate part then is
- 6:44the visibility within the platforms and how clients
- 6:48performing there. So we've seen, we've seen a
- 6:50spike the last six to seven months, particularly for our
- 6:54clients at all e-commerce since they launched, since GPT
- 6:58launched shopping. So that's still very, very early
- 7:01days. What they're essentially doing
- 7:04is crawling the website rather than using a feed.
- 7:06Since they started doing that, we have seen a rise in revenue
- 7:11and traffic coming from these platforms.
- 7:14Month a month, they're going like 300, four, 100%.
- 7:17But yeah, like Paul said that the numbers are so small as
- 7:21negligible, the clients still like seeing it.
- 7:23But the more interesting part for us is like that, that new
- 7:26kind of reporting, which is like, how is your brand
- 7:29appearing within these platforms before they've even heard about
- 7:32you? So there's a lot more like brand
- 7:34discovery rather than direct traffic and revenue.
- 7:39I think, I think the reporting one's really interested and so I
- 7:43know there is a question later on on this, I won't go too deep,
- 7:47but I've been playing around. I know you use or you introduced
- 7:50me to profound, I think it is. And I've been playing around
- 7:55with, there's one called Pete, some rushes, new stuff and a
- 7:58couple of others. And I do think it's really
- 8:00interesting because from what I can see, most of that data is
- 8:03basically coming from them submitting queries and then kind
- 8:07of basically measuring sentiment, measuring like
- 8:11volume, trying to understand like what's driving like
- 8:15relevancy. But yeah, I felt like I was kind
- 8:18of underwhelmed by it. But I think it probably like
- 8:21that whole area needs to like mature a bit and maybe ChatGPT
- 8:26in particular need to like allow for more data to be made
- 8:30available again if you agree with that, I think.
- 8:33There's parts like a lot of, I think it's one of your questions
- 8:37coming up, but it's like what basically we're quite, quite a
- 8:41lot of clients ask us is like, why now?
- 8:43Like why is, why are we talking about this so much now when GPT
- 8:46has been out for like what, two to three years or something?
- 8:49It is because Google's always been very good at the bottom of
- 8:52the funnel commercial side of things, top of funnels.
- 8:55OK, but the GBT came out and then that completely transformed
- 8:58top of funnel and almost created an even further up funnel, which
- 9:02then create that that then made Google's top of funnel crap in
- 9:06comparison. But then GBT top of funnel, this
- 9:10chat experience like excellent, but then their commercial side,
- 9:13absolute dog shit. So what's happened this year is
- 9:17GBTS got better at the commercial side and then
- 9:19Google's launched AI mode and AI overviews to combat GBTS like
- 9:23both of them now are set up perfectly to compete.
- 9:27And that's where things have got interesting in the sense of like
- 9:29what GBT has done to search behaviour.
- 9:33So people are searching way longer than they ever have
- 9:36before, which is increasing the quantity of searches in Google,
- 9:39despite everything that you read online by Google dying.
- 9:42It's like people are so used to doing one search or chatting and
- 9:46then doing a follow up and then a follow up.
- 9:49And now what Google's doing with the overviews is keeping
- 9:51everybody within the platform not linking out.
- 9:54So then the trend for SEO's is like zero click searches, which
- 9:58have been around for good five years or so, but this trend has
- 10:02just accelerated recently. And then on top of that is the
- 10:05longer tail searches are now. Yeah.
- 10:08I think the start was like the keywords that include 5X words
- 10:12have like 300% increase or something just because people
- 10:15are just, they're just so used to getting very, very specific
- 10:20results for very, very specific searches.
- 10:25What do Mattel, Victoria, Beckham, Sennheiser and Glossier
- 10:30all have in common? They power their businesses with
- 10:34Shopify. Shopify is the most innovative
- 10:38and scaled commerce platform on the planet.
- 10:41It also happens to have the best converting check out on the
- 10:44planet Shopify Powering the future of enterprise commerce.
- 10:51Find out more at shopify.com/enterprise.
- 10:55One one thing. Sorry, James, I'll, I'll stop
- 10:58ruining the flow of this podcast that soon.
- 11:01I should say before the before we start recording this, I was
- 11:04saying that Josh had done a lot of research and he did a
- 11:06LinkedIn post actually on like the trend between search volume
- 11:10in Google and then uplift in GPT and all of that, which was quite
- 11:15interesting. But then I got him to send over
- 11:19those notes that I talked about and there's some interesting
- 11:24stats in there. So as you say, those zero click
- 11:27searches are driving like loads more time in the results.
- 11:31And I thought this was quite interesting.
- 11:33And so 80% of search users now rely on the AI summaries for 40%
- 11:39of their queries, which is massive.
- 11:42And to be fair, that's probably pretty accurate for me.
- 11:44I reckon 40% of the time when I'm searching, I'm actually
- 11:48using the AI summary. But yeah, I thought that was
- 11:51quite interesting in terms of like how important it is now.
- 11:56Yeah. And the with that, come and see
- 11:58how much do you trust it? Because I'm really sceptical
- 12:01just because there've been plenty of examples where the AI
- 12:04overview is not so accurate and it is.
- 12:07I know it's getting better than how they learn because they have
- 12:09to because in there, if they're going to try and monetize it
- 12:11like USA and Sam, it needs to be accurate and reliable.
- 12:14But it's fascinating. See, that's it.
- 12:16But let's come back to the data point because this is this is an
- 12:18area that I'm I'm really curious about because I haven't spent
- 12:21enough time looking at the pure numbers behind it, more around
- 12:24trends of strategy, the implications.
- 12:26How good is the data? How reliable is it?
- 12:28How accurate? Because you say it's small
- 12:30numbers, but what data points can people get that they should
- 12:33be looking at now? I think your first part of the
- 12:37question, how accurate or like it shows how new this is, is
- 12:41because Google's launched their mode in America, which is live
- 12:46and the AI or AI overviews have been out for a long time, but
- 12:51they've still not given us any form of measurement of those
- 12:54within Google Search Console. So that is something they give
- 12:58to you to measure the performance of your site and
- 13:01they haven't even given those metrics yet.
- 13:02So we're very much relying on 3rd party tools for that side of
- 13:05things. And then GPT hasn't even created
- 13:09a search console equivalent. So until we get those, it's all
- 13:13going to be questionable finger in the air because we're relying
- 13:16so much on 3rd party data, which is so much reliant on the
- 13:19keyword database, which is limited anyway.
- 13:23And even in the old world of search where say keep like even
- 13:27when Google started becoming much more longer tail, our tools
- 13:31struggle to keep up with that kind of long tail, which we're
- 13:33talking about 3 to 4 words. Now we're talking 5-6 plus.
- 13:38It's like feels like impossible. How are you going to track that?
- 13:41Because there's so many nuances about say if we, if we wanted to
- 13:44do a search now, but like are on trainers any good, all three of
- 13:49us would do a completely different variation of that
- 13:52search into GBT. Whereas in the olden days that
- 13:55you could probably just get maybe 4 words to verify and get
- 13:58the same output from that. So in general, the numbers
- 14:01aren't very accurate on very early days.
- 14:05I think it is very interesting with I think because yeah, you
- 14:09mentioned about sentiment and stuff that Paul, I think like
- 14:12what I found really interesting about it is that what you're
- 14:15getting out of it is essentially an aggregate of how your brand
- 14:18is perceived online, which you can't really get that anywhere
- 14:22other like it's like an amalgamation of how the Internet
- 14:25views your brand. So from all of that, I find that
- 14:28really interesting. And then it's kind of things.
- 14:30Then you've got some of our clients products, it's like
- 14:35drugs are really thin for how expensive they are, corners
- 14:39overturn and it's like all of the stuff that is like it's out
- 14:43there and that's how these engines are perceiving a brand
- 14:46was that's the kind of data we've just never had before.
- 14:49I find that part quite interesting.
- 14:52I thought the only other one that I thought was quite
- 14:54interesting when I was going through the reporting, because I
- 14:57guess what I guess they probably don't have at the moment is any
- 15:02real true accurate volume, which is what you'd expect just based
- 15:06on, you know, was having access to Google Analytics or Search
- 15:08Console. But I think what the other one I
- 15:11thought was quite interesting was, so you have sentiment and
- 15:14then the brands you're over indexing with and then like a
- 15:17view of like the sentiment per brand.
- 15:21So if I'm aloe yoga, my I'd be over indexing with Lululemon
- 15:26like 85% of the time. And then the sentiment is better
- 15:29for aloe yoga. So I thought that was quite
- 15:31interesting. But again, I think they probably
- 15:33just need more. It needs to be more proven to be
- 15:36more accurate, and yeah, needs more value.
- 15:41Yeah, it's that prospecting point mentioned about search
- 15:43volume. That was a sticking point, which
- 15:45I think the best tool I found for that, which was literally
- 15:47last week was a head drafts new brand radar part of the site.
- 15:52So that essentially does give you volume and you can do some
- 15:55kind of GBT gap analysis which that with that because yeah,
- 15:59essentially you've got Profound peak Sam Rush, etcetera.
- 16:03The equivalent of rank checking tools from previous about an SEO
- 16:08or do is do a bunch of keyword research and like mask keyword
- 16:11research, hundreds of thousands keywords and then you take the
- 16:14best of them and put them into the rain check tool, but without
- 16:17the visibility, the keyword volume, essentially it was
- 16:21always a guessing game. So our dated guy last week was
- 16:24like trying to play around with GPT to create prompts out of it
- 16:29that we could then use to track our clients.
- 16:31And even that was like he'd get 50 out and only 10 of them were
- 16:35decent. But AHFS brand Radar 1 is
- 16:38probably the best one that I've seen.
- 16:40And in their shows, things like like, again, like brands will
- 16:45find, it's really interesting. It's like somebody searching for
- 16:49our Adidas backpacks. Do they have lifetime warranty
- 16:53or something like that? And then the GPT spits out
- 16:56everything. And then the final paragraph is
- 17:00Adidas doesn't, but if you're thinking about a lifetime
- 17:03warranty, then you should check out brands like Osprey that do
- 17:05have a lifetime value. So it's like, if you like
- 17:08that's, that's ridiculous for a brand like Osprey to get that
- 17:11kind of data and insight into how his LLMS are perceiving it
- 17:17and. Yeah, don't want to drill into
- 17:18the the AI overviews further because I've seen a few my
- 17:24clients people. And then you say that from an
- 17:26upper funnel brand estate point of view.
- 17:28And again, people to associate, I guess credibility, authority,
- 17:33trust signals with your brand when you're answering research
- 17:36questions is really important. And I managed to locked in.
- 17:38I did some, I was doing some checking on, on key on lines
- 17:42like research questions related to the services I provide found
- 17:46that I've got 2 AI overviews and I've got very excited by that
- 17:49until I realised my videos in there were really old branding
- 17:53and look crap. But I guess how important, how
- 17:58important is it to be present in AI overviews now?
- 18:02And is it you? Are we at the point where
- 18:04actually in terms of the way people think about content
- 18:08strategy that things are going to shift again towards creating
- 18:13more like authoritative content? I'm not saying it hasn't always
- 18:16been important, but do you think people will adapt because the
- 18:19value of an AI overview will become more important going
- 18:22forward? Yeah, I think that the AI
- 18:25everything is somewhat society questions almost like is it
- 18:29important to be in search to an extent because that's
- 18:33essentially why it's moving. It's like commercial will.
- 18:35I think it's another part of all of this is Google's launched a
- 18:38new Google Shopping games only in the US for now.
- 18:41But it seems like looking at those two trends, it's like the
- 18:44homepage, Google will eventually just become AI, which is
- 18:47eventually just beat AI overviews.
- 18:50And then the commercial aspect, we get pushed into shopping like
- 18:53the same as like maps and images and everything like that.
- 18:57So then the commercial, you could see the commercial side
- 18:59moving over into Google Shopping.
- 19:01So then essentially the homepage of Google just becomes AI
- 19:04overviews as if if you want to get in front of your clients, in
- 19:08front of your potential customers for a certain point of
- 19:10a journey, then yeah. And Google's still got all the
- 19:14search volumes. So you should want to get into
- 19:16the ARP views for that reason. You could do some kind of like
- 19:21intense research in terms of say you've got loads of blog traffic
- 19:25that you're losing. You could dig into the value of
- 19:28that old blog traffic and try and prioritize because you could
- 19:30say a lot. It's going to take a lot more
- 19:32effort to get into this AI overview.
- 19:33Now was that traffic actually valuable or did we just do it to
- 19:38get more traffic versus like actually trying to help
- 19:41customers? And then you point into cont
- 19:44onto the content side. Yes, but I think it just, it
- 19:49kind of it changes to an extent like the way the way we're
- 19:55saying of the clients, it's like there's like 2 new things. 1 is
- 19:58like situational search, which is a lot more of a currently GPT
- 20:03kind of thing. So it's like this is the current
- 20:04situation that I'm in. Give me products that match
- 20:09this. So as a quick example, it would
- 20:11be like in the olden days. You probably search for
- 20:15something like backpacks for commuting.
- 20:18Whereas now what you're potentially could search for is
- 20:21like one of the most comfortable, stylish backpacks
- 20:23for women in their 30s, commutes by train daily and takes
- 20:25frequent trips to Europe. So that's like such a specific
- 20:28search will that individual. So then you have to make sure
- 20:32that you're like product USPS are getting across on the
- 20:36website. It's like who who is the like
- 20:38target profile that's buying from you.
- 20:41And then you can go as granular as like the different models
- 20:43that you own. So it's like this model is
- 20:46really good for intense travellers, this one's really
- 20:50good for commuters, like getting like really granular like that,
- 20:53like that across your content. Because from everything that I'm
- 20:58looking at is, is that actually the, the principles haven't
- 21:02changed because I think some people are trying to create this
- 21:04narrative that everything in SEO and content is changing as
- 21:07opposed to just the vehicle with which data and information is
- 21:10retrieved is changing. But but fundamentally, there's
- 21:13been a big shift over the last five or so years anyway around
- 21:16authority content, trust signals, good structured data,
- 21:21you know, proper atomized data, whether that's product
- 21:23attributes or concise, well formatted.
- 21:26So it's not just dumps of text. And that my my interpretation
- 21:30would be that that actually it's that this is more important than
- 21:34ever. But the those SOLID principles
- 21:36about how you prepare and structure and create content
- 21:39that's relevant to people useful.
- 21:41But then is tackling specific questions and needs that that
- 21:45hasn't changed? Or am I?
- 21:46Am I oversimplifying it? No, I think that that's the
- 21:50that's the challenge that we got with.
- 21:53So like in the SEO world, like we like all the SE OS are kind
- 21:57of broadening the agreement that GO and all of these AE OS and
- 22:02all these acronyms that are being created.
- 22:04It's kind of just a bit nonsense really because essentially the
- 22:07tactics that we're doing for SEO, they're very, very similar
- 22:10as what you would do for the for the AI.
- 22:12They're just slight adaptations. And then another consensus is
- 22:17like nobody can name a brand that is really good in the AI
- 22:21overviews that's got really bad SEO.
- 22:23So it's like all of the performance and the overviews is
- 22:26driven from your SEO performance.
- 22:28There might be some nuances there.
- 22:30So like you can see it's like, because the overviews are so
- 22:34like narrow fielded in what you can get, like content structure
- 22:37plays an even bigger part than what it used to.
- 22:40But then what we're kind of seeing with client is that
- 22:43you've got to almost hit like both the on site and the off
- 22:45site side of things in parallel. So that's like, if you, if
- 22:48you've got really good content, you've not been investing in
- 22:52links PR brand that's almost giving a reason to not get into
- 22:57the overviews versus somebody else who has been through.
- 22:59We've seen scenarios where particularly some of our smaller
- 23:02brands, like we potentially get ranking #1 before quite long
- 23:06tail searches is loads of traffic to the blog.
- 23:10And then you get an overview and now clients not in it, but some
- 23:15big authoritative brands are in that.
- 23:17And then their content is quite outdated as well as like from
- 23:192023. So like an example, I'm thinking
- 23:22of this paint, it's like we were ranking number one for something
- 23:26around paint colours from north facing walls.
- 23:29AI overview comes in and the Lick paint gets in there even
- 23:31though their contents 3 years old.
- 23:34But it's because it's Lick and it's got the authority within
- 23:37the space of paint. They're just getting put into
- 23:41it, even though they were ranking potentially like sixth
- 23:43before. How we kind of half covered
- 23:48this, but I think the bit that I find interesting, I think the
- 23:52value of being there like. Do you do you think?
- 23:58That because obviously historic value would be #1 of an organic
- 24:02testing would have been pretty high because you're going
- 24:04through to the site and you have the ability to like trade that
- 24:07traffic and like commercialize the experience and like channel
- 24:11people through to PDPS and stuff like that.
- 24:13Whereas in most cases it feels like, as you say, people don't
- 24:17really progress to the site and actually, you know, a lot of the
- 24:21queries more research like like, yeah, I guess what's your,
- 24:25what's your view on that in text?
- 24:29I, I would see it as like I guess just in commerce, I see it
- 24:33as still relatively small, but I guess like due to see that
- 24:37changing as part of like the AI mode stuff.
- 24:43I think it comes back to those metrics of like how you, how you
- 24:46judge success. So one of the posts I've written
- 24:48recently, which I can send you a link to is like, you know, it'd
- 24:54been really hard to prove the value of SEO for like like
- 24:57decades. Not provided came in, killed and
- 25:00then J Fo's come in and killed even more.
- 25:03So say SEO has always been trying to be a performance
- 25:06channel, but in the polls basically line up like how do
- 25:09you measure the success of a brand, brand channel versus a
- 25:12performance channel. And our performance is like
- 25:14revenue, ROI, traffic, all of the stuff that is so hard to get
- 25:18out of SEO, which is going to get even harder or as we view it
- 25:21through the lens of visibility, share, share, voice, brand
- 25:28versus brand, like all of these other like brand LED metrics for
- 25:32that. And for now to where users like
- 25:34SEO is moving from one of the hardest performance channels to
- 25:38measure to becoming one of the easiest and most data-driven
- 25:42brand channels to measure. So an example we used with one
- 25:45of our clients at Rockabill, we pulled all of this last click
- 25:50date of him and like revenue and traffic and things through the
- 25:53roof, crazy ROI. And then one of his points was
- 25:56like around TV. And then how do you discount the
- 25:59value off of TV onto SEO? And then the point I'd make is
- 26:03life or we got your ranking number one for rugs.
- 26:05So you invested in TV. And in the scenario, TV could be
- 26:09meta ads, for example, or any kind of like any kind of
- 26:13equality that you're doing, somebody will get exposed to the
- 26:16ad. But then you're assuming that
- 26:19the customer is remembering the brand and not the product.
- 26:22And not like so many times people remembering the product.
- 26:24So you're creating demand for rugs and later down the line
- 26:28somebody will like where people are always going to end up is
- 26:31search. So then they're going to do a
- 26:33search for rug. So then if they weren't number
- 26:35one and they were where they were before when they hadn't
- 26:37invested in SEO, which was 20th, they wouldn't have been there.
- 26:40So then all of the demand from TV wouldn't have been captured
- 26:44from examples like a demand generating traffic channel
- 26:47versus demand capturing and SEO is still the best demand
- 26:52capturing channel out there. I can't see anything.
- 26:56I think the interesting home of that is like if it's brand.
- 27:00So if you're essentially running top of anal activity, driving
- 27:06more volume around brand, but you can measure that, whereas if
- 27:10you're inadvertently creating non brand volume then it will be
- 27:15a lot. Hard to measure, but then that's
- 27:18where a non brand can become a Discovery Channel.
- 27:20So then an example for me, yes. And he was, I was searching
- 27:24around best linen clothing or something and then a brand came
- 27:30up. I'd never heard of any AI
- 27:32overviews. Check them out.
- 27:34Didn't like the website. OK.
- 27:36And then I was opened in Oxford Street and then I saw the shop.
- 27:39I was like, OK, I never heard of them.
- 27:41I'll check them out. Spend absolute fortune.
- 27:44So then that's where the brand has been.
- 27:46The awareness of the brand has been raised through the non
- 27:49Brandon SO. That's the impossible
- 27:51attribution. Yeah, I guess.
- 27:53You've only been suited by attribution be dead for like
- 27:57such a long time and even I don't even see clients like our
- 28:01clients using their MMM models. And then so many times SEO has
- 28:04expedited anyway, and then you decide it's one of the best
- 28:07traffic drivers out there, but it's always been neglected as a
- 28:13function. Just getting back to something
- 28:16else we talked about earlier because I found the slide from
- 28:18Josh's little deck. It's quite interesting to see.
- 28:20We talked about, I don't know if it was on the podcast or before
- 28:24the podcast, but we talked about Google and how it could cause
- 28:30essentially we were talking about this essentially adding
- 28:33more value to Google, but that requires Google, Google to
- 28:37continue growing at the same rate.
- 28:40And actually it's looking at a graph that Josh has got here,
- 28:44which is from Morgan Stanley research.
- 28:47Essentially, Google's growth has been fairly consistent since
- 28:512016, started to slow maybe in 2022, but still growing.
- 28:57And then now, so the last three years, essentially as volume,
- 29:04search volume is increased, ChatGPT is now taking a pretty
- 29:09big share of it, which is quite interesting.
- 29:13I kind of need to share the image for this to be useful
- 29:15information, but it is impacting.
- 29:17So I think that the next thing over the next couple of years is
- 29:20if ChatGPT in particular do enrich their results and start
- 29:27to cover off more product comparison.
- 29:30Yeah, have more like kind of compete with Google Shopping.
- 29:33I mean, the interesting thing will be video as well, because
- 29:36when you were talking about Google not being top of the
- 29:39funnel, the only thing that's easy to forget is YouTube as
- 29:41well. But it's going to be interesting
- 29:44to see how the mix of usage changes because obviously the
- 29:50other variable is matter for discovery.
- 29:53But, but based on this graph, you would assume that Google
- 29:57would actually see over time less search volume and ChatGPT
- 30:03would continue to grow just because of how aggressively it's
- 30:06growing over the last three years.
- 30:09I realised that's about the tangent to come back to it,
- 30:11because I do think it's an important question.
- 30:15Yeah, I think that's like, and this is the thing that SEO has
- 30:18wanted for like years and years is to have more search engines
- 30:22of it. So the dreams now or the future
- 30:23be you'd have somebody who's like a perplexity SEO specialist
- 30:28and the GPT specialist and all of this stuff, which is very
- 30:32good. I think on that point, it's
- 30:34like, you know, yeah, it depends what what the data is coming
- 30:37from and what what what they're trying to do with it.
- 30:40I just think like this, like the overall, if you just treat
- 30:45search as an overall channel, which includes GPT as well, like
- 30:49that number is definitely increasing because people are
- 30:52searching more. So I go to the poison match
- 30:54about chat. It's like the amount I search in
- 30:57chat, like it's just constant like feeds or just talking.
- 31:01You would never do that research, Yeah.
- 31:04The, so the actual number here, so essentially it's global
- 31:08weekly queries in billions and that number has increased
- 31:12significantly since ChatGPT got bigger, but Google has remained
- 31:18flat. And then the uplift has come as
- 31:21a result of such of ChatGPT. But presumably that will also be
- 31:26that the average user is searching more as well.
- 31:29And one other thing that I thought I'd mention as that's an
- 31:32interesting variable here that's a slight threat to Google.
- 31:36One of the biggest what's that Google has is obviously Chrome.
- 31:40But the other interesting thing will be some that like
- 31:44Perplexities browser looks pretty interesting.
- 31:47There's a couple of people on our team that use the AI
- 31:50browsers now, some of the other AI browsers.
- 31:53And I think the big thing would be if Chrome was to lose some
- 31:57market share, I think that would probably impact this quite a lot
- 32:01as well. Well, and also don't forget
- 32:03there's the ongoing case in the US about whether Ginga would
- 32:06have to divest itself of Chrome because around all these
- 32:11dynamics that could then shift what happens from a browser and
- 32:15a search point of view. But I want to bring this back to
- 32:18so a real tangible question actually, because the bit that I
- 32:21always are, the bit that I always get asked as you will be,
- 32:24is like, OK, what do I need to do about this?
- 32:25So in in my view, the one thing where I'm advising people from a
- 32:30pure E com and a pure data point of view to be better prepared
- 32:34for being able to be part of the answer that an AI agent is
- 32:38pulling in is to think beyond just well structured product
- 32:43data and think more about intents, the different types of
- 32:48intent, and therefore the different types of questions and
- 32:50information needs that people need and build out a wider set
- 32:54of data points around products or other non product content.
- 32:59Exactly. I think you gave that example
- 33:01about, you know, clothing, but the the type of question that's
- 33:04all the bags that could buy it sort of like what you know, you
- 33:07have about good for travel, what's what's, what's good for
- 33:11kids, what's like damage proof? What's damage?
- 33:13Or is it you've got all these additional facets where
- 33:16traditional e-commerce optimization wouldn't get to
- 33:20that level of granularity because the focus is on
- 33:22merchandising and you don't have 700 filters for merchandising
- 33:25because you kill the UX. However, you do in a exponential
- 33:30world of multifaceted AI driven search, have the need for
- 33:34potentially hundreds of attributes around product
- 33:37categories rather than 5 or 10. So that's the bit where I'm
- 33:40advising people to think and put the effort in, especially around
- 33:43re platforming when it's a perfect time and there are tools
- 33:45out there, AI tools are emphasis that can help you add data.
- 33:48It come come to you first. Sam, what is your practical
- 33:52advice where what should people be thinking about and actually
- 33:55action in now beyond working the smart people to understand what
- 33:59the data is telling them and how much this is growing?
- 34:03Yeah. Is it I was going to bring
- 34:05something back to Paul, but Sammy answers your question as
- 34:07well. I was kind of all of this stuff
- 34:10is so new, but like, like you just said, like your numbers are
- 34:12growing like mad and they're only going to continue to grow.
- 34:15So that's get it, Like you say, like found it.
- 34:18My, my, our expectations are higher, but still getting an
- 34:23understanding of how this stuff works and what is working to try
- 34:27and get ahead of competitors because it's obvious that this
- 34:29stuff isn't really going to go anywhere anytime soon.
- 34:33So there's that part which kind of antsy person like
- 34:35understanding how these brands are perceived, how these tools
- 34:38are perceiving your brands and understanding that because other
- 34:41things and how search is shifting the trends, etcetera.
- 34:46But yeah, so I think Jones, the question was like right now kind
- 34:51of in between two different worlds that whole like EA EE AT
- 34:55still a thing. They've added another E for
- 34:58experience, which hits the whole AI contents writing side of
- 35:02things, which we can come back to.
- 35:04But the general elements might do it.
- 35:06Also you got. Sorry Tinto, you sama might be
- 35:11worth you just quickly explaining what they are because
- 35:13I think the average person, myself included, don't fully
- 35:16understand what they are. Yeah, good.
- 35:18So EAT is expertise, authority and trusts that came out around
- 35:222018-2019 and that's the area where kind of once they've
- 35:26released those quality guidelines, SEO hasn't really
- 35:30changed that much since that point.
- 35:32It's always every, every time something happens, it's always
- 35:34like, Oh well, you're EAT. So yeah, expertise, if you're
- 35:37presenting self an expert, authority and trustworthiness.
- 35:41So all of that element comes from your content, your experts
- 35:43you work with. And then the offside promotional
- 35:46link building side of things. They then added expert in with
- 35:53combats AI content. So as an example, the example I
- 35:56gave is like, like both of you, for example, could go into GPT
- 36:01and say, like, write me a blog about SEO.
- 36:04It'll give you something back, which is pretty decent.
- 36:06But then if I went in and I was like, here's my opinions on SEO,
- 36:11few bullet points build, build out from this that that's the
- 36:16level that will differentiate between other generic AI
- 36:18content. So that that's what that's why
- 36:21they brought it in. And then the topic a lot now
- 36:23about effort, which we really hard to measure.
- 36:26We're trying to understand. I guess some things doesn't take
- 36:29much effort to make and it's obviously not going to add that
- 36:33much value, which again is AI content.
- 36:37So that they're the main areas of SEO is your tech content and
- 36:42backlinks or digital PR. So the tech side of things, if
- 36:46anything, GPT is kind of Google from like five years ago.
- 36:51And so it's nowhere near as advanced, still struggles with
- 36:54JavaScript, all those sort of things.
- 36:57Like, yeah, tech side of things, still very important, still
- 37:00making sure you don't block GBT if you don't intend to.
- 37:03Then you've got the content side of things.
- 37:06So that's broadly similar, but it's kind of just tweaking and
- 37:10adapting. So in, in previously, like when
- 37:13we had feature snippets, there'd be a way that you could
- 37:15structure content to optimize for those features and bits,
- 37:19which is all about like heading structures, bullet points,
- 37:23tables, all of this. That makes it a much more easier
- 37:26to digest piece of content, which ties into the user intent.
- 37:30That's slightly adapting. No, no huge amount.
- 37:33It's more on sentence structures of getting your answer out
- 37:36sooner. So it's like, so then when it
- 37:38when, when the AI kind of pulls your content out, it's got the
- 37:41question and the answer like closer to each other.
- 37:43It's like not a huge difference. And then when it comes to
- 37:46content strategy around top funnel stuff, that is why are
- 37:50you just go into that extra level of detail?
- 37:52So one of the clients that we're pitching now has got like A blog
- 37:56which is all about like best waterproof trainers.
- 37:59It's a very good blog. But then now the level of depth
- 38:02needed on that is like best waterproof trainers for
- 38:05commuting, for running, for road running.
- 38:08And then you can go even granular from that, then with
- 38:10running shoes, a psych, Yeah. Best shoes for wide feet are
- 38:14specific branded shoes good for wide feet?
- 38:17And all of this kind of nuanced situational search.
- 38:21It's all about like the actual user.
- 38:25Quick stop. Question on that one, Sam.
- 38:26So I think when you, when you start reading about this stuff
- 38:29and what you're describing that you start to hear about like
- 38:33chunking and the need to like restructure information.
- 38:37So for that as an example, I feel like historically from an
- 38:40SEO perspective, the expectation would be that you'd write could
- 38:44come down and like the semantics behind Google with like add more
- 38:49content. Whereas now it feels like the
- 38:52advice in the industry is the trunk information, more like
- 38:55create like little sub bits of information with like really
- 38:59relevant sub headings to really try and optimise towards how
- 39:04like open AI in particular is like collecting information.
- 39:08What's your view on that? You're going into your nerd SEO
- 39:12blogs now, aren't you? I can't notice if it's basically
- 39:16what it is, is yeah, just making the content as I think there's
- 39:20elements where it kind of, we all think it's like very, very
- 39:24advanced technology, which it is.
- 39:26But then sometimes when you break things down, we're doing
- 39:29it in the office of the day where it's like breaking down
- 39:32where the sources come from, from a specific search.
- 39:35And it was almost like. So what it's essentially doing
- 39:38is just aggregating a bunch of best content and then put in a
- 39:41bit of jazz over it with Reddit. And then it's giving out the
- 39:44answers. And then like you kind of like,
- 39:46oh, this is amazing. But like we break it down.
- 39:48You're like, you're literally just aggregating all of those
- 39:50best pieces out there, which is where it's going to become way
- 39:55more advanced in the future. So like that example is like
- 39:58probably going to work now and it'll be completely fine.
- 40:00But then that might then create very strange content where it's
- 40:03like just constantly just, it almost becomes a list form where
- 40:07it's a bunch of paragraphs. So it's like people will react
- 40:09and they'll adapt and optimize. But surely over time, if this
- 40:12tech is as advanced as what we think it should be, then just
- 40:18right normally and it should be able to pick all of that stuff
- 40:21up. And this, I feel like this is
- 40:25the, this is the conversation we need to pick up in six months
- 40:27and revisit. And it's like how, how has it
- 40:30moved where we're expecting to? Has it has things shifted in a
- 40:33way we hadn't expected and factoring the paid search stuff,
- 40:37because by then that should be a little bit clearer as well.
- 40:39So thanks Sam, thanks for joining us.
- 40:43Anyone listening who wants to, you know, chat to Sam about how
- 40:47you know what what's happening in in more detail and, you know,
- 40:50want to talk to him about potentially supporting you guys
- 40:52and your businesses with helping understand this better than his
- 40:55contact details on the landing page.
- 40:57But hopefully everyone's enjoyed listening this.
- 41:00I think this is something we could end up talking about for
- 41:02hours as it always is. And that yeah, thanks Sam.
- 41:06Always a pleasure listening to to your views on this.
- 41:09Thank you both, thank you very much enjoyed it and you and I
- 41:11could kept going for another two hours.
- 41:14You're listening to the Inside Commerce podcast, hosted by
- 41:16experienced consultants James Gerd and Paul Rogers.
- 41:19Inside Commerce is your fast tracked additional knowledge
- 41:22feature in interviews with leading e-commerce retailers,
- 41:25industry thought leads and the C-Suite key tech companies to
- 41:27explore the latest digital strategy, customer experience
- 41:30and tech. Discover what the latest trends
- 41:32really mean and get practical advice based on experience to
- 41:36help fine tune your E Comm strategy and tech.
- 41:39Follow us on LinkedIn and reach out to James and Paul if you'd
- 41:41like to discuss an e-commerce project.
- 41:44We hope you enjoy the latest episode.