Latest / Office Hours with Fexingo: Daily Career Q&A, Workplace Questions, and Professional Advice / How to Ask for a Raise When Your Manager Is New
Transcript
- Lucas: Today's question comes from a listener we'll call Maya. She's been at her company for three years, consistently rated top-tier, but her manager left two months ago, and the new manager just started. She wants to ask for a raise but feels like she's starting from zero. Anyone who's been through this knows that sinking feeling. So how do you handle it? Luna: Yeah, it's a common problem. The new manager doesn't have the benefit of seeing your past contributions. They only know what's in the file or what they've heard — which might be nothing. Lucas: Exactly. And the new manager is also under pressure to learn the team quickly, so they're not going to dig into your three-year history on day one. You have to make it easy for them. Luna: So what's the first step? Do you just schedule a meeting and wing it? Lucas: No, that's a disaster waiting to happen. The first step is to create a one-page performance summary. Think of it as a cheat sheet for your new manager. It should include your top three projects from the past year, quantified results — like 'increased efficiency by 20 percent' or 'saved $50,000 in vendor costs' — and how those align with the team's current goals. Luna: I love that. It's not a brag document; it's a context document. You're essentially doing the research they don't have time to do. Lucas: Right. And you frame it as a way to help them get up to speed. You say something like, 'I put together a brief overview of my projects so you have a quick reference. I'd love to walk through it and see how I can best support you going forward.' That sets a collaborative tone, not a demanding one. Luna: Then when do you bring up the raise itself? Do you do it in the same meeting? Lucas: Generally, no. Use the first meeting to build rapport and share the summary. Let them absorb it. Then, about a week later, schedule a follow-up conversation with a specific agenda. Call it 'Career Growth Discussion' or 'Future Role Alignment.' That's where you can say, 'Based on my contributions and the market, I'd like to discuss adjusting my compensation to reflect the value I bring.' By then, they have the context. Luna: So the key is patience — you're letting them get comfortable with your record before making an ask. What about timing? Should they wait a certain number of weeks into the new manager's tenure? Lucas: I'd say within the first 30 to 60 days. Too early and they'll feel blindsided. Too late and you risk being overlooked. And avoid the first week — the manager is drowning in onboarding. But once they've had a few one-on-ones with the team, that's your window. Luna: Makes sense. Also, if the manager came from outside the company, they might have a market-rate perspective that's actually higher than your current salary. That could work in your favor. Lucas: That's a great point. An external manager often brings awareness of what top talent costs. So you're not fighting against a 'we've always paid this' mentality. They might be more open to market adjustments. Luna: But what about the fear that the new manager will think you're just trying to cash in on their arrival? Lucas: That's real. That's why you anchor the conversation in the value you've delivered, not your tenure. You say, 'Over the past three years, I've consistently delivered X, Y, Z. As you settle in, I want to ensure my compensation reflects the level of contribution I'm making.' It's about alignment, not entitlement. Luna: And you have to be ready for them to say, 'I need time to evaluate.' How do you handle that? Lucas: First, acknowledge their position. Say, 'I understand you need to see me in action. How about we set a check-in in 60 days? I'll deliver on these two priorities, and we can revisit then.' That gives them a concrete plan and shows you're committed to proving yourself under their leadership. Luna: So you're not just asking; you're also making a commitment. That builds trust. Lucas: Exactly. And in the meantime, make sure you have a written record of everything you accomplish. Send a monthly one-pager to your new manager summarizing wins. When the 60-day mark comes, your case is already documented. Luna: One thing that helps is referencing external benchmarks. If you can point to market data — like 'the median salary for this role in our city is $X' — it takes the onus off you and puts it on the market. Lucas: Great addition. And if your company has a formal compensation philosophy, all the better. You can frame your ask as consistent with that philosophy: 'I'm at the low end of the band for my role given my experience.' That's hard to argue with. Luna: Let's go back to Maya for a second. Say she does all this — creates the summary, has the first meeting, then the follow-up. What's the actual script for that follow-up? Lucas: It can sound like: 'Thanks for taking the time to review my background. As I mentioned, I'm really excited to work together. I wanted to discuss my compensation because I believe my contributions have put me in a position where a market adjustment is warranted. Here's a quick look at what I've delivered and some market data. I'd love your support on this.' Make it a conversation, not a demand. Luna: I'd also add that the new manager might appreciate if you offer to help them understand the team dynamics or historical context. That generosity builds goodwill. Lucas: Absolutely. You're essentially becoming a resource for them. That makes them want to champion you. Luna: So the whole approach is about empathy and preparation. You're not just asking for money; you're helping your new manager succeed. Lucas: Right. And that mindset shift is everything. You go from 'I need to get mine' to 'Let's make this work for both of us.' It's a much easier sell. Luna: Before we wrap, I want to mention something practical. If you've gotten value from episodes like this, and you want to help us keep the podcast ad-free, listener support is what makes it possible. A small monthly contribution at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo genuinely goes a long way. We don't run ads, so it's listener-powered. Lucas: Yeah, it's that simple. A couple of dollars a month keeps the lights on and episodes like this coming. No pressure — just if it's made a difference for you. Luna: Alright, back to Maya. One last tip: when you finally have the raise conversation, avoid the word 'deserve.' It puts people on the defensive. Instead, use 'market value' or 'contribution.' Lucas: Great advice. And remember, the goal isn't to win an argument. It's to turn your new manager into an ally. If they see your success as their success, you've already won. Luna: Exactly. So to sum up: build context, time it right, frame it as collaboration, and follow up. That's the playbook for a raise with a new manager. Lucas: Thanks for the great question, Maya. Good luck out there.