Latest / And Now For Something Completely Machinima / S6 E248 The Movies: Rediscovering a 2006 Machinima Horror Film
Transcript
- Phil Rice 01:00 Hello and welcome to and now for something completely machinima, the podcast about machinima virtual production and related stuff. My name is Phil Rice, and I'm here with my co-hosts Damian Valentine, Damien Valentine 01:12 hello, Phil Rice 01:12 Ricky Grove, and Tracy Harwood. Tracy Harwood 01:15 Hello. Phil Rice 01:17 So this week we are looking at a film from the archive, and that means Ricky Grove. Ricky, why don't you tell us about it? Ricky Grove 01:25 Sure thing. It's I was poking around in the oldarchive.org, which has a massive cinema collection. A good deal of it's not very good, but there's some real nice gems in there. And I came across a film that I'd forgotten about, created by a team of Sherwin Liu and Kate Lee, they were very interesting filmmakers in the early 2000s who tried to take machinima in a more what should I more serious drama, more literary Direction, and one of the things that they did was something called "The Light and the Dust," Part One, Corpus Maum. It was a 2006 film that was shot in a a game that was based on creating movies called the Movies, created by Lionhead, and it was quite the trend for some time. But because you play as a kind of Hollywood mogul, and you set up actors and you create scripts, and it was quite ingenious in how they set up how to make movies, you know, and of course machinima filmmakers flocked to it. It proved to be somewhat short-lived. I only think they did a short sequel, maybe three years, and then it was dropped, and now it's in that sort of kind of vaporware state. You know, you can get copies online if you want, or you can get the old ones. And there have been mods, quite a few mods for it. But anyway, Sherwin and Kate created this story along with a fellow named Lizard, and it's a it's a combination horror film drama film about a man who lost his wife, and then while he's grieving over his wife's grave, a demon takes over his body, and he becomes a kind of mass killer, a tragic mass killer, because he's still aware of what he's doing, it's a really interesting film, and I chose it primarily because it's an example of early machinima trying to create good drama, and a lot of detail and work went into the making of the film, and it succeeds for the most part, given the fact that the limitations of the movies. Quite a bit of the animation in the movies is comic, and it's really hard to get good animation in it, and which is why the version that I watch had quite a few still pictures. But Kate has or Tracy has some ideas about about that and wants to share the fact that that wasn't the original attention. But I really like the editing in the film. I thought the film was well edited. At times, the film tries too hard to be dramatic, especially in the narration of the lead actor. He's overly dramatic, and he's not able to make a convincing case for it being a tragic narration, it's just not believable. But and the plot is a little far fetched. But what I think the movie really succeeds in is the mood of a horror film. It captures the mood with great music composed by Sherwin Liu. It's like I said; it uses still images, which is a smart idea. And I was thinking, gosh, AI would be good for animating some of those still images. But I really liked it a lot, and I thought it was a good example of the kind of films that was made in the movies and the kind of serious drama that filmmakers are trying to do using machinima. So, what are your what's your take on this? Phil Rice 05:28 Yeah, I the the music is what really jumped out to me too because I I also only watched the Tracy will explain this further, but I think her and Damien are the only ones that have watched maybe the film as it was intended to be watched originally, but Ricky and I saw the version that plays for you on on the the archive, and it's very interesting that it's essentially it's two different versions of the film and maybe impact in different ways. But the thing that jumped out to me was the music. Maybe because because it it was a series of stills as as it was presented, I had a lot more time to to fixate on that. You know, the audio the rest of the audio is kind of it's of its era. You know, not the highest fidelity, and nothing was really back then. But the the music style reminded me a lot of something you would hear on this, like Angelo Battlementi, something from the the first season of Twin Peaks, where it was almost continuous throughout the entire episode and and these these I don't even know how to describe it musically, but these these something about the chord progressions and the way that it presented it was it was a very effective mood setter and a mood retainer through it, and I think it really helped the version of the film that I saw with the stills. It helped kind of sew all that together a little bit more. I too felt like it was a little bit heavy-handed, a little bit overly overacted or over dramatic, but I like that there's ambiguity. It's kind of got that right balance of not everything is explained in fine detail. That there's something to be said for that, as we've mentioned so many times on this show. That that leaving room for the story to breathe a bit, for our imaginations to work with it, there's there's there's a lot to be said for that. So, yeah, the main thing that jumped out to me was was the music, obviously, because that's that's my my thing, I guess. But yeah, I'm curious to hear what the rest of you thought. Damien Valentine 07:56 I watched the still version to start with, and because it is still images, and they were they were well done still images. I kind of tuned that out and just listened to the story. So now that I'm aware there's a an actual video version, I watched that as we were getting set up for the show, and I was not listening to three of you getting prepared. I was doing this instead. So what I noticed is, Ricky, you talked about how the movies has very comedic animations, and it's very difficult to get some serious character motion out of it. But they've done that. I watched it, and it's not really over the top. There's a couple of bits where it's a little bit on the silly side, but not in a way that's really distracting. It feels like it fits the tone of the story. Cool, Ricky Grove 08:48 cool, that's great. Damien Valentine 08:49 So I would highly recommend watching that again, just to to see how it compares. Obviously, when I watched it this way, I had the sound off, so I could still listen to when we were getting started. So I haven't. I need to watch it a third time so get the audio and the video together. But what I liked what I saw is emotion. They made good use of the sets that I remember from the game because I really liked that game. I know it was silly and you couldn't do it with it, but it was fun. And I remember the commissioner community got really excited when it came out, and it was interesting to see what people were doing with it, and it's a shame that you know it didn't get a more support than it did, and it didn't get more serious character animations for people to work with. But obviously, Sherwin and Kate they they did a pretty good job with this. I do remember them as filmmakers, and I always enjoyed watching their projects. I don't think I saw this one back in the day, so this is a new one for me. Well, you could always Ricky Grove 09:49 be sure that Sherwin, you and Kate would come up with something that was creative and interesting and well done. Damien Valentine 09:55 Yeah, always. Yeah, because Ricky Grove 09:57 they cared about what they were doing. Damien Valentine 09:59 Yeah, and. They took their time making things as well, so you wouldn't get something every week or something. Yet, you know, a long period of time would go by, and then they'd release their new thing, and you know they'd put a lot of effort into it. And this is one of those films where you can see they spent a lot of time figuring out exactly how to get what they wanted from the movies to to make this film that they wanted to to make, Tracy Harwood 10:25 the movies is that the film is that the game that Alex Chan made, the French Democracy. Yes, yes, yeah, Ricky Grove 10:34 that's it. Yeah, when it first came out, which gave the game quite a boost. Tracy Harwood 10:39 It did, but it came out the most viewed piece of content that was ever streamed through the movies community channels. Because all the one thing about the movies was that it also was very supportive of community content sharing, so it had a very active community, didn't it? But of the 6000 or so shorts that went out through that community, I think the one that everybody talked about the most was the the French democracy. It's a real pity, actually, because I wish I'd have seen this one a lot earlier than than than is now being brought to my attention because I hadn't seen this one before, and it's I think it's a it's a really good film. So let me tell you how I how I came to watch two different versions. I started to watch the the the one that's actually you know headlining lining on the archive, and it got to about three quarters of the way through having you know, watched these very intense images get even more intense, and at about three quarters of the way through, it kind of started to the images didn't make sense in terms of the emphasis of where the story was going, and I and it was at that point that I thought, I think I've got a playback issue here. Either that, or maybe the editing isn't making any sense to me anymore, or I've just lost my concentration in the intricacies of the story because there's a lot of detail in the in the way that the narration is is kind of taking place. Either way, I went at that sort of three quarter mark. I stopped playing it, and I went and did an analysis of what that that particular film was, and whether there was actually a fully animated version of it. Sure enough, the WMV version is a fully animated file. Now, I've watched now both the stills version and the animated version, and the you know the audio the narration still dominates, but actually the the audio the the more animated version begins to make a bit more sense as a story, rather than just these intense stills. So I would I would definitely say look at the look at the WMV version of it and check it out again because I think it will reward you doing that. Ricky Grove 13:20 We should include a link in the notes. I will version so you can download that or stream it. Tracy Harwood 13:26 I definitely will because yeah, I've got some things to say about it anyway. Obviously, but I was it was because it didn't. Well, I lost attention. There was so much detail. I lost attention. That's what led me to think there must. I must be missing something? So yeah, and I was. But what I really liked about this, and what made it so interesting for me, is that effectively what you've got is, you know, this idea of of playing with the fear that your body might no longer belong to you, and I think that makes this a really ambitious kind of gothic psychological horror, where the emotional starting point of the story, which is the the wife's murder, turns into something that's kind of bit more than bereavement, although it's kind of pitched in that way. So this guy, this central character, is basically unable to recover from the death of his his wife, and he kind of then encounters this unnatural force, shall we say, that only really enhances his suffering, or maybe it's inside him. I don't know. There's an awful lot of possible interpretations that you can come to from the way that the story is told. But it's a really, it starts really cleverly, I think. I mean, it kind of moves towards. Questions of bodily possession, of displaced identity, Ricky Grove 15:06 and and the Tracy Harwood 15:06 and the possibility of experiences being worse than death, if ever that could be the case. Corpus miam means my body, which is you know kind of an interesting point in the title, and clearly what they're doing here is sort of making an assertion about ownership under threat of of one's body. Now they identify the Kate and Sherwin and Lizard identify Anne Rice's The Tale of the body thief and the television series Quantum Leap as being inspirations for this, and they also explain that the the narrative deliberately leaves viewers to connect the clues. Now, this is where I think these two versions of this might lead you in different directions, in actual fact, because if you're if you're watching the version which is, in effect, a super slow mo stop mo kind of animation with lots of blanks in between, your interpretation of that I think is going to be very different to the one where it's a fully animated film in front of you, so and I, you know what that you know you've got two for the price of one there. I think that's a super interesting idea if it's delivered. It Ricky Grove 16:30 is, yeah. Tracy Harwood 16:31 I mean that's I've not. Ricky Grove 16:32 I don't think it was delivered. I think it's a technical. Tracy Harwood 16:34 So do I. Napo, but but it's I think it's um it's maybe a fortuitous one where you know you get two for the price of one. I think that's an interesting idea, but you know, obviously, the film's about you know a mystery about what's happened to this character, and and alongside this kind of horror story, you're not really entirely sure what kind of happens next. I mean, my reading of it is that you've got bereavement and possession mirroring each other, and you know this main sort of character. You know, he's I don't know the thing that lost the thing that made his life so meaningful is now you know gone. And is there a is there a sense in which the wife was taken through murder, or you know, some I don't know. There may be, and I'm not I'm not really entirely sure about that. It's left open, isn't it, as to how she actually died, I think. Even though other deaths are more brutal and obviously murder, I don't know. There's something. There's something to me that's got to connect the what happened to his wife with what with how he gets to his end state. I think in the in the film, but you know the the main horror isn't just that loss. It's also about the way he loses his identity through this physical presence that seems to take over his body and makes his existence within himself insecure. And for me that's the real horror in this. Yeah, yeah, it's it's it's a really it's a really cleverly done device. I think. Now you know Kate and Sherwin and Lizard here they're working as decadent pictures, but I know you know you've already commented that Showin wrote the original music score, which is absolutely critical to both versions of the film. I think, but it was after this that they went on to work together as Chapnoir Studios, and they made then shorts called Death in Venice and Incubus, and as as I recall, the latter was presented in Video Forms 2011 machinima program, and that's also a psychological thriller. And I think what you got there, and probably even in the name of the studios themselves, Chatmore, you can see that they they kind of excelled in making this kind of type of type of film. Really, yeah. Now, I think another aspect of this that I was intrigued by was the way that the you know there's this kind of strong again you probably get better sense of this if you watch the video version of it but there's kind of a strong relationship between the sort of domestic collapse that you see this guy go through and and the graveyard and the way. That you know the video pans around the the graveyard and all the all the things that are happening in the graveyard you know the drunk and the druggy you know just sort of popping up out of nowhere kind of thing and it's that kind of sort of descent into collapse in different forms that sort of holds it together at the beginning part of it. Really, I think the cemetery itself becomes the focus for the grief that you you witness, and it's it's it's then through that kind of you know strange contact that this guy has in the graveyard that his existence becomes transformed into something else. It's all you know. It's it. Is it grief overtaking him, or is it something awful happening in that graveyard around him that takes him over? I don't know. It's kind of like I said. It's ambiguous. the The stunning bit is these real close ups of the face, and the you know what that's doing to me is sort of making the identity of the main character really the central the central place point you know the the thing that holds the thing together really, and obviously if you've if you've just watched the sort of the stop mode version of it or the still version of it, it's pretty much the only thing you see is his face. But it's actually very dominant also in the animation side of it. And these faces are, you know, his face there is they're isolated, they're differently lit. Sometimes they're surrounded by darkness, and I think all of that helps to really sort of disorientate you. Tracy Harwood 21:47 And yeah, and you know what you're trying to do here is look look closely at at someone, but actually, it it you know what you what you end up thinking about is who who is it I'm looking at here? Because his face changes, and it's the it is him all the way through. All the all the all the stills that you see are the same character, just him in different states of his his bodily being, and that becomes a little bit easier to follow in the animated version, I think what's fascinating is how the sense of possession is is kind of portrayed, and that you know you use when you see the the images flick between the the younger person and then the hollowed out grayed person. You know, you you kind of you you almost have a sense of a bit Dory and grayish. You know, the sort of the way you know the way the horror is portrayed in that through the through the the the features of what of what you see on the on the character's face, and there's a little bit of that kind of playing in this as well. But even in the animated version, you still get the sense of stillness, and and it it occurred to me really that what what they were conveying is that it's not really, it's not really the animation, but it's the horror of what you see on the face and in and inside that person that conveys the sense of uneasiness about what you're looking at, and it's again that ambiguity that kind of comes through, which I thought was probably why it appealed to you so much, Ricky, because that's one of the things that you know you you often comment about is ambiguity in the in the storytelling. Ricky Grove 23:45 Yeah. Tracy Harwood 23:46 Yeah. I guess the the main sort of critical thing is you know does this animation and the images do they stand up to the you know the way in which you're, you know the emotion is, is is, you know they're trying to build the emotion and the way in which they're trying to convey that emotion, and and is there enough kind of visual evidence in what you're seeing to help you form an interpretation about what is actually going on, and yeah, now this is the tricky bit because I think in the stills version, I'm less certain about that than I am in the animated version. I think you can through the movement and the and the way that the character sort of slumps when some of the things kind of happen around him, you you can definitely feel a connection to the emotion that is is being portrayed, and I think that's harder when it's just the stills to look at. And then another thing that occurred to me is is to do with the treatment of the of the wife, and you know clearly her death. Is what motivates this guy's suffering for the you know for the purposes of the story. A question I had though was: Does she acquire a presence or an identity of her own, or is her main function just to you know just for for John's character to to you know launch his story from, and I had to think about that quite a bit because I'm not sure I could answer that one very well. So maybe maybe you guys have got more thoughts about that. But for lots of reasons, I thought this was really clever on so many levels, and and I you know, I quite like the fact that it exists in two modes. I think that's that's a novelty that we've not. Ricky Grove 25:46 Me too. Yeah, yeah. Tracy Harwood 25:47 Not come about, you know, come come by before. I mean, obviously, I also had to have a think about the Anne Rice and the quantum leap influences, because both of those themes are really about experiencing another person's circumstances from within a body, and in effect, coming to terms with the changes in that body when you don't necessarily have full control over it. And I think that's I think they've done that really well, actually. You know, does the story stand up to the aging look and feel of the environment. Well, yeah, I think it's looking dated, and I do think the low quality nature of it is a little bit problematic. But if the quality were to be improved, would the lowish sort of poly characters need to be replaced to tell this story as effectively. No, I don't think they would really. I think you can get a good sense of what the story is through through the the voice acting. I mean, you could tell it with lots of different engines. Probably, you could probably tell it just as well in parts of GTA or you know, I don't know even StarCraft maybe, but you you could probably tell it in in in any number of different engines and get a very similar kind of feeling at the end of it. Really, do you get a sense of grief from the kind of Lack of movement of the character faces. Yes, I think you do, but that's mainly achieved through the through the the voice acting. Yeah, I think. I mean, I do think it works on on a lot of levels. I mean, it it does look old. Machinima Ricky Grove 27:40 machinima audiences accepted it was like a convention the fact that they we weren't going to have expressive characters but I think more recent in fact the next film that we have is a great example of the fact that the characters have little expression but the filmmaker has given them incredible emotional content. Tracy Harwood 28:03 Absolutely, Ricky Grove 28:03 that limitation creates creative ideas as opposed to just accepting the limitation. Tracy Harwood 28:10 Yeah, I do. Yeah, I can. I completely agree. So you know, for for lots of reasons, yes, it's a it's dated, but I think it still works. It's a good story. Yeah, I Ricky Grove 28:20 think so too. Tracy Harwood 28:20 So yeah, I mean, I haven't really got anything more to say about it. Really, it was a great pick for particularly for Halloween. Damien Valentine 28:26 Something I always think about when I'm watching an old piece of machinima is to not think about this as something that's trying to be photorealistic because it's not going to be. Even if at the time that was the goal. It's not going to be now. So the way to look at it is: this is a piece of stylized animation. Tracy Harwood 28:46 Yes, it is. Yeah. So you don't Damien Valentine 28:48 need to worry too much about it being dated because it's not meant to look like it's not meant to look realistic or highly detailed. It's meant. Well, Ricky Grove 28:57 I think that's a great word, and and we're going to come back to that word when we talk about Phil's pick next week, style. Yes, Tracy Harwood 29:05 indeed. Style is actually a feature this month, I think. Ricky Grove 29:10 Yep. Phil Rice 29:11 Yeah, another one of those coincidences where unplanned we end up picking. We're good at that, Tracy Harwood 29:17 aren't we? Yeah, it's Phil Rice 29:18 funny how that works. Tracy Harwood 29:20 Yeah, great pick though, Ricky. Thank you very much. Ricky Grove 29:22 Oh, you're very welcome. I'm happy. I I was very excited when I came across it. Damien Valentine 29:28 My last thought is, Quantum Leap and Anne Rice are not the two things that you normally associate with each other, but I think it makes sense knowing that now and thinking about this film and the story. Ricky Grove 29:40 Well, that's part of the definition of creativity. You take two separate things and put them together in a creative way. Damien Valentine 29:47 Yeah, of course. Phil Rice 29:49 Yeah, I'd be remiss if I didn't go ahead and give a little plug here. That yes, our own Ricky Grove was actually on an episode. Quantum Leap. Speaker 2 30:01 Oh, I did not Phil Rice 30:03 know that at the time that I saw it. I knew Ricky by that point, but I hadn't poured through his IMDb or whatever. And this is many years ago. I'm just watching Quantum Speaker 3 30:18 Leap Phil Rice 30:19 reruns of Quantum leap, and all of a sudden, there's Ricky. Which, if I remember right, the scenario was there was a big storm or hurricane coming or something like that, and Ricky was refusing to evacuate, and was was was quite obstinate. And it was just, and I'm just pointing at the screen, going, "That's my friend Ricky. That's my friend Ricky. Yeah, yeah. That was a Ricky Grove 30:45 fun episode. I enjoyed doing that. It looked Phil Rice 30:47 like you were having a great time. Ricky Grove 30:49 Yeah, Tracy Harwood 30:49 brilliant. Phil Rice 30:50 Well, audience, what did you think of of Ricky's pick this week? And and more importantly, did you did you watch the stills version or did you click a couple links down and find the the full framed version? Maybe watch them both if you have it, and let us know what you think. You can comment wherever you see this episode, or drop us an email at talk@completelymachinima.com. So my name is Phil Rice, and on behalf of my co hosts Damian, Ricky, and Tracy, we'll see you next time. Tracy Harwood 31:23 Bye bye. Bye Ricky Grove 31:24 bye.