Latest / Manager Mondays with Fexingo: People Management, Team Leadership, and First-Time Managers / How to Manage the Employee Who Always Says It's on My List
Transcript
- Lucas: So we get a question from a listener named Priya, who manages a team of four at a mid-size marketing agency. She says one of her direct reports, Kevin, is bright and well-intentioned — but every time she asks about a task, Kevin says 'It's on my list.' And then the task stays on the list. Sometimes for weeks. Luna: I've met that guy. Maybe I've been that guy at some point. The phrase is a brilliant shield — it sounds productive without requiring any progress. Lucas: Exactly. Kevin's not saying no, he's not saying he's too busy, he's not even saying he forgot. He's acknowledging the ask — which makes it harder to call him out. Priya's instinct is to get frustrated, but she wants to handle it constructively, not by nagging. Luna: So what's really going on under 'it's on my list'? Is it a time management problem, or is it something else? Lucas: It can be a few things. One, the employee is genuinely overwhelmed — they've said yes to so many things that their list is a graveyard of good intentions. Two, they're avoiding a task because it's ambiguous, unpleasant, or outside their comfort zone. And three — and this is the tricky one — they may feel that saying 'it's on my list' is a sufficient update, because no one has taught them what a real update looks like. Luna: That third one is interesting. Kevin might genuinely believe he's communicating progress. We've all worked in cultures where sending a status report with the same items week after week is tolerated. Lucas: Right. So Priya's first step is to diagnose which flavor she's dealing with. She can do that in a one-on-one by asking a simple question: 'What's the one thing on your list this week that you're most likely to push to next week?' Kevin's answer — and his body language — will tell her a lot. Luna: And if he says 'nothing, it's all manageable' when clearly it's not, then it's a coaching moment about self-awareness. Lucas: Right. But the deeper issue is that Priya needs to shift from asking 'Is it on your list?' to asking 'What's your next step on this, and when will it be done?' She needs to move from a binary check to a conversation about sequence and deadlines. Luna: Yeah, the 'next step' question is gold. It forces Kevin to visualize the actual work, not just the item. Lucas: And that's something we talk about a lot on this show — how small tweaks in how we ask questions can change behavior without confrontation. You know, it's conversations like these that keep me coming back to this work, and I know our listeners appreciate that too. Luna: Absolutely. And if today's episode helps you handle a 'Kevin' on your team — or even if you see a bit of Kevin in yourself — that's the kind of practical takeaway we're after. If you find value in that, the way this show stays ad-free and focused is listener support. Lucas: Yeah, if this helps you be a better manager, you can find us at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. No pressure, just a way to keep these conversations going. Luna: And now back to Kevin's list. So we've got the diagnosis — but what's the actual intervention? Lucas: I think the most effective thing Priya can do is institute something I call the 'Monday micro-deadline.' Every Monday, Kevin picks his top three priorities for the week — not thirty items, three. And he commits to a specific output for each by Friday. That list becomes the focus. Everything else is a bonus. Luna: That forces prioritization and makes the list more honest. If something's really a priority, it'll be in the top three. If it's not, maybe it wasn't that urgent. Lucas: Exactly. And it also gives Priya a clear way to follow up: 'How did the three go?' Not 'Did you finish everything on your list?' That's a much easier conversation. Luna: But what about tasks that aren't weekly priorities but still need to get done — like quarterly reports or compliance stuff? Lucas: Those get a different treatment. I'd recommend a 'visibility audit' — once a month, Priya and Kevin look at his full list together and ask: 'Is this still relevant? Does it need to be done by me? Is there a block I can help remove?' Often, items stay on lists because they've become orphans — no one ever checks if they still matter. Luna: That's a great way to clean house. And it also gives Kevin permission to deprioritize or delegate, which is a skill many managers don't teach. Lucas: Right. The 'list addiction' is often a symptom of a culture where people feel they have to appear busy. Priya can model healthy prioritization by sharing her own top three and sometimes saying 'I'm dropping this because it's not critical right now.' Luna: That builds trust. Kevin sees that it's okay to be realistic, and he stops using the list as a shield. Lucas: And here's something counterintuitive: sometimes the employee who says 'it's on my list' is actually a high performer in disguise. They say yes to everything because they want to be helpful. The corrective isn't discipline — it's helping them build a better system for triage. Luna: That's a generous frame. But what if Kevin is using the list to avoid something he genuinely doesn't want to do? Like, he hates doing the weekly social media report, so it stays at the bottom forever? Lucas: Then that's a conversation about role alignment. Maybe the report can be automated, or reassigned, or Kevin needs to learn why it matters. But if it's truly a core part of his job, then it's a performance issue — and the 'list' becomes a symptom of a mismatch. The manager has to address it directly: 'Kevin, this task has been on your list for six weeks. What's the block? And if it's not something you can do, we need to talk about that.' Luna: That's where a lot of managers get uncomfortable — they'd rather accept the 'it's on my list' than have a tough conversation. But that hurts everyone in the long run. Lucas: It does. And the irony is, the employee often wants the conversation too. They know they're stuck, but they don't know how to ask for help. So the manager who says 'Let's look at your list together' is offering a lifeline, not a lecture. Luna: So to summarize for Priya: first, diagnose the reason — overwhelm, avoidance, or lack of update norms. Then use the Monday micro-deadline to focus on a few key outcomes. Do a monthly visibility audit to clear out dead items. And have the honest conversation when a task keeps getting deferred. Lucas: I'd add one more: celebrate completion. When Kevin actually finishes something that's been lurking on his list for ages, acknowledge it. A simple 'Hey, I noticed you closed out the Q3 analysis — thanks for getting that across the line' reinforces the behavior you want to see. Luna: Positive reinforcement works better than negative follow-up. And it makes 'it's on my list' less attractive as a default response. Lucas: Right. Because eventually, Kevin will realize that saying 'It's done' feels a lot better than saying 'It's on my list.' And that shift is the real win for both the manager and the employee. Luna: Any other favorite tactics for our listeners who are dealing with a chronic list-er? Lucas: One last thing: when you're assigning a new task, don't just say 'Can you put this on your list?' Say 'When do you think you can start on this, and what will the first step be?' That sets the expectation that the conversation is about action, not storage. Luna: That's a perfect close. For Priya — and for all of us — sometimes the smallest tweak in language can turn a list into a roadmap. Lucas: And on that note, we'll see you next week. Until then, keep managing better.