Latest / Escape The Clock: How to Become Financially Free and Have the Option Not to Work / The Family Governance Protocol: Engineering a Legacy That Lasts with John Knowlton, Author of Thinking for Success
Transcript
- 0:00Do you talk openly about money with your children
- 0:02at the dinner table? We're taught that money
- 0:05is a private matter. Don't talk about politics,
- 0:08religion, or your net worth, especially with
- 0:10our children. We hide the numbers thinking we're
- 0:13protecting them from entitlement or burden. But
- 0:16in the corporate world, hiding the P &L from
- 0:18the board of directors would be a fireable offense.
- 0:21According to a TR Price survey, 71 % of parents
- 0:25said they would rather talk to their kids about
- 0:26drugs, smoking, or death and talk about family
- 0:29finances. If you are building generational wealth,
- 0:33your children are the future CEOs of your legacy.
- 0:36So why are we treating them like the interns?
- 0:39Today on Escape the Clock, I'm speaking with
- 0:42the author of the new book, Thinking for Success,
- 0:4452 stories that upgrade your thinking to boost
- 0:47productivity, problem solving, and relationships.
- 0:49He challenges the traditional ways we manage
- 0:52our family fortunes. So stay tuned for an eye
- 0:55-opening conversation that may change the way
- 0:57you think about your legacy going forward. Welcome
- 1:20back to Escape the Clock, the show where we highlight
- 1:22strategies for achieving financial freedom and
- 1:24having the option not to work. I'm your host,
- 1:26Daniel C. Rogers. One of the biggest risks in
- 1:29any long -term project is succession planning.
- 1:32In the wealth world, there's a famous saying,
- 1:34shirt sleeves to shirt sleeves in three generations.
- 1:37The first generation makes it, the second spins
- 1:40it, and the third blows it. Research from the
- 1:43Williams Group found that 70 % of wealthy families
- 1:46lose their wealth by the second generation and
- 1:4890 % lose it by the third. Even the wealthiest
- 1:51suffer from this problem, spending lavishly on
- 1:53off -site family retreats where professional
- 1:55companies help them design a legacy that lasts.
- 1:58Why does that continue to be such a problem for
- 2:01so many? We all understand that we're supposed
- 2:03to name the beneficiaries and transfer the assets,
- 2:06but we rarely transfer the framework that led
- 2:08to our success. We toil, save, and sacrifice.
- 2:12all to earn a comfortable life for our older
- 2:14selves and for our families, yet so many stumble
- 2:17at the finish line when it comes to legacy planning.
- 2:19Not because of any lack of intelligence or willpower,
- 2:22but simply because the way we are taught to behave
- 2:25with money prevents us from setting up our inheritors
- 2:28for success. It's taboo to talk about the family's
- 2:31financial situation and operations at the dinner
- 2:33table, so instead adults find themselves speaking
- 2:35about it in hushes in back rooms when the kids
- 2:37are asleep. We find that we are helping protect
- 2:40them, but indirectly all we're doing is hiding
- 2:42the knowledge and the tools they will eventually
- 2:44need to learn for themselves. So let me ask you
- 2:46this. Is a legacy of money inheritance, without
- 2:49governance, a legacy at all? Well, today my guest
- 2:52says he has engineered a solution to that problem.
- 2:55John Knowlton co -founded a wealth management
- 2:57firm that grew to manage over $1 billion in assets.
- 3:00He sold it in 2020. and retired at the age of
- 3:0351, but instead of just going golfing, he treated
- 3:05his family's future like a business turnaround.
- 3:08He established a family board complete with voting
- 3:10rights, investment committees, and a governance
- 3:13charter that includes his adult children. He's
- 3:15also the author of the newly released book, Thinking
- 3:18for Success, which outlines 52 mental models
- 3:21for better decision -making. John, welcome to
- 3:23Escape the Clock. Daniel, it's a real pleasure
- 3:25to be here with you and your listeners and viewers.
- 3:28Well, thank you so much. I really enjoyed going
- 3:31through your book. I want to start, though, with
- 3:33what led you to deciding to spend your time in
- 3:37the way you are. Like I said, you made it. You
- 3:39had that career. You got to that retirement.
- 3:41You had been spending your career managing billions
- 3:45of dollars for other families. When you sold
- 3:47your firm and you looked at your own family,
- 3:50what was the thing that you were seeing and what
- 3:53were you trying to avoid? Well, that is a key
- 3:57question, really. What am I here for and how
- 4:00am I going to spend my time? And really, everyone
- 4:02needs to grapple with that. And I guess maybe
- 4:05when you start your career, you've got these
- 4:07pressing needs of, gosh, I've got to pay rent
- 4:10or pay a mortgage and pay off my student loans.
- 4:12And so there's kind of this boulder chasing you
- 4:15down the hill that you're running to stay in
- 4:17front of. But at some point, especially for those
- 4:20of us who are able to retire early, then we're
- 4:24faced with these questions. Gosh. How do I spend
- 4:28the next half of my life or however much time
- 4:30I have left? And the book Thinking for Success
- 4:33lays out my definition of success. And it is
- 4:37really like this. It's becoming ever more like.
- 4:40the person you were designed to be. And there's
- 4:43this term from geometry called an asymptote,
- 4:46which is a curve that approaches a line but never
- 4:49touches it. So I could say walk halfway to the
- 4:51wall and walk halfway again, walk halfway again.
- 4:54You could keep getting closer but never quite
- 4:56get there. And so I think it's coming on everyone
- 4:59to really discern what is the thing that I'm
- 5:04uniquely created for or skilled or designed for
- 5:08and then lean into that. And so that led me in
- 5:122021 on a sabbatical. I took an indefinite sabbatical
- 5:17and there was some deferred maintenance on my
- 5:19house and projects like this, but really it was
- 5:22spending time with my wife and in quiet prayer
- 5:26and solitude. What am I doing with the next half
- 5:29of my life? And I stumbled into this thing called
- 5:33C12, which is peer advisory for Christian CEOs
- 5:36and business owners. So for the last... A few
- 5:39years, I've been leading a couple of groups of
- 5:41people in that category, as well as leaning into
- 5:45my family. And so we really want our family to
- 5:49maintain a sense of identity and be a force for
- 5:52good for generations. I was going through the
- 5:56book and I really enjoyed a lot of the balance,
- 5:59but positive messaging. You're kind of positioning
- 6:02who we are and this journey we all take. I also
- 6:05love the selflessness of how you turn a lot of
- 6:08that to wanting to help your family and a broader
- 6:11kind of people that we touch in our lives. And
- 6:15so I want to dive into one of the questions you
- 6:17ask in the book. At one point you say, you really
- 6:20tell your kids how much you make? And you kind
- 6:23of just pose this question, like, do you really
- 6:25do it? Because that's like the crux of so much
- 6:27I think that a lot of us struggle with. There
- 6:29was a study by Merrill Lynch. I found that 52
- 6:32% of parents have never had a comprehensive conversation
- 6:37with their adult children about their net worth,
- 6:40inheritance plans, or anything around that. So
- 6:43there is a large lack of conversations when it
- 6:46comes to something that is so important in so
- 6:49many of our lives. And I think it's not like
- 6:52there's bad intention behind there. I think there's
- 6:54a fear of spoiling kids that will drive a lot
- 6:57of us to silence. So in your book, you argue
- 7:00that authority without information is blind.
- 7:03Why does withholding financial data essentially
- 7:06set them up to fail when they eventually get
- 7:10that inheritance? Yeah, the short answer to your
- 7:13question or my question that I posed is, yes,
- 7:16we opened the kimono. In fact, we were having
- 7:19a family meeting at the end of December. Here
- 7:22we're recording in mid -December and the slides
- 7:25needed to be updated on. How much money did I
- 7:28make in 2024? I guess I was using my last tax
- 7:32return. And what's our current net worth? So
- 7:35updating from the previous discussions. And so,
- 7:38I mean, I keep an Excel chart and we graph it
- 7:41and I share it with them. Absolutely. Now, you
- 7:44can't just dump that on somebody. There has to
- 7:48be some context for them. And so the context
- 7:51begins at the dinner table. when they're little.
- 7:55And my wife and I have practiced the four questions
- 7:58since the beginning of our marriage. And the
- 8:01four questions are these, Daniel, how was your
- 8:03day? How was your day? What do you need tonight?
- 8:06What do you need tonight? It's really just two
- 8:09questions. You only have to remember two. How
- 8:11was your day? What do you need? And the how was
- 8:15your day question gives you the opportunity to
- 8:18talk about how did you interact in the world
- 8:20today? Who did you talk to? What value did you
- 8:23provide? What services did you provide? How did
- 8:25you help a client? How did you talk to an employee?
- 8:28So you're really telling your kids, how do I
- 8:33interact in the world? And how do I function
- 8:36as a person? And they're also learning how do...
- 8:39loving parents talk to each other? How do spouses
- 8:42treat each other? What are the expectations that
- 8:44I should have if I'm a girl of my husband or
- 8:48if I'm a boy of my wife? And so all of the financial
- 8:52education begins right there at the dinner table,
- 8:57kneecap to kneecap, listening to how are we interacting
- 9:00in the world. So I didn't share with my little
- 9:03kids about detailed financial information, but
- 9:07Hey, I'm contemplating building an office building.
- 9:10Here's what I'm thinking about with my partner,
- 9:12Mr. Kehoe, and things like that. And so they
- 9:14would learn through observing our interactions
- 9:18and listening to our conversations. And then
- 9:21as they got a little older. If I was going to
- 9:24buy or sell a business or do some kind of a deal,
- 9:27a real estate transaction, I'd bring my kids
- 9:29with me. My little son, Sam, was my briefcase.
- 9:33He was my bag man. He had my briefcase at a closing.
- 9:36And I don't know, we put a $150 ,000 check in
- 9:39it and he got to carry it to the bank, you know,
- 9:41to deposit the check, things like that. So yes,
- 9:44we're completely open and transparent with our
- 9:46money. And you have to have some context for
- 9:49it, I think. Yeah, I can imagine because you
- 9:52brought your kids along on the journey and you
- 9:54made it such a norm to talk about these things
- 9:57that you didn't have to do too much awkward pushing
- 10:01of specific conversations at specific age points
- 10:04is kind of how I'd imagine it at least. How would
- 10:07you advise a parent who hasn't been doing this,
- 10:09who's just not been talking to their kids about
- 10:12this, but who wants to start? Is there some mental
- 10:15model you would point them to for that? Yeah,
- 10:17it's interesting question. I've asked a number
- 10:20of people. I don't ask them why they don't talk
- 10:22about money with their kids because that's maybe
- 10:24a little too intense for people. But why do you
- 10:26think people don't talk about money with their
- 10:28kids? And the number one reason that I get is
- 10:31shame. They think people feel shameful about
- 10:34decisions they've made, debt they've taken on,
- 10:37things like this. And I would just say, here's
- 10:40the mental model, if you will. Some people say
- 10:43experience is the best teacher, but I would say
- 10:45someone else's experience is the best teacher.
- 10:47Because if I can only learn from my experience,
- 10:51well, that means I've got to stub my toe an awful
- 10:54lot. But if I can learn from Daniel, hey, there's
- 10:57a rock around the corner here. Don't stub your
- 10:59toe on it. Boy, that would be a whole lot better.
- 11:02And so whether your financial picture is awesome
- 11:05or rotten or most likely somewhere in between.
- 11:11I would just encourage you to begin to share,
- 11:13even if you don't share numbers, share your experiences.
- 11:16Oh man, I took out credit card debt when I was
- 11:18in college and it took me years to pay it off.
- 11:20Avoid that stuff like the plague or whatever,
- 11:23but begin to share that stuff. And people are
- 11:26impressed with your success, but they're impacted
- 11:28by your failures. And so if you can share with
- 11:31your family, hey, here's a mistake I made. I
- 11:34hope you don't do that. And here's how I would
- 11:36do it better if I had a chance to go back. That's
- 11:39right, because from experience, if you start
- 11:41with data and spreadsheets and stuff, it's just
- 11:44especially with a young person, their eyes will
- 11:46glaze over. But if you talk about stories, everyone
- 11:50on some level can connect with a good story and
- 11:52it's going to be a very effective way. And it's
- 11:55not like it's easy to talk about the mistakes
- 11:57that we've made and talk about those stories.
- 11:59But when you're coming from a place of love and
- 12:01someone can hear that, yeah, you could move them
- 12:03in the right direction for sure. Well, I want
- 12:06to touch on something that's very unique that
- 12:08I think you do that maybe a lot of us should
- 12:11start considering, which is this idea of a family
- 12:14board. And I was hoping you could walk us through
- 12:16what that is, the actual mechanics of it, and
- 12:20how it's kind of different from like just a normal
- 12:21family meeting, which is probably what a lot
- 12:23of us do. Yeah, and I actually want to back up
- 12:25and start with Simon Sinek's golden triangle.
- 12:28Start with why. Why do we want to do this? And
- 12:32so for me, I've already shared it, but the why
- 12:34is I want a family to maintain its identity and
- 12:38be a force for good for generations rather than
- 12:42every nuclear family starting the cycle over.
- 12:45Hey, let's start not at our own goal line, but
- 12:47let's start somewhere down the field a ways here.
- 12:50So that's the why. How is the next thing? And
- 12:53this is what I think I'm bringing to the conversation
- 12:56that might be a little bit unique. And the how
- 12:58is what I call shared governance. And we can
- 13:01unpack that as we continue talking. And then
- 13:03the what is the assets, the money, investments,
- 13:07portfolio, real estate, family business, et cetera.
- 13:10So why, how, what, why? To make my family persist
- 13:14and be a force for good. How? Shared governance.
- 13:18And so one of the... mechanisms of shared governance
- 13:22is the family meeting or the board meeting. The
- 13:25idea here, Daniel, is contrast with traditional
- 13:28estate planning. Very commonly in estate planning,
- 13:32a family that has some assets will write a trust
- 13:35document that has pretty specific language around
- 13:40when distributions can be made. There might be
- 13:43age requirements. There might even be behavioral
- 13:45requirements. So essentially, we're trying to
- 13:48codify our values in this document and then govern
- 13:53from the grave. The attorneys talk about it or
- 13:56control from the grave. And I think that's way,
- 13:59way, way too late. In other words, if we want
- 14:02to impart good decision making and teach our
- 14:06values, and see those things persist. We need
- 14:09to be living them together with our kids long
- 14:14before we die. And so shared governance is what
- 14:18it sounds like. We share the role, the decision
- 14:21-making with our kids. And so my wife and I have
- 14:25taken our adult kids through an extensive process
- 14:28of discerning our family's mission and vision
- 14:31and values. We've set up a governing structure
- 14:36with a family board. And then there are two committees.
- 14:39One is a philanthropy committee and one is an
- 14:42investment committee. And so I'll just give you
- 14:45an example. The board says, hey, we want to give
- 14:48away this much money this year. Okay, great.
- 14:52The investment committee needs to respond to
- 14:54that by making sure we generate enough cash in
- 14:57order to satisfy the goal. And then the philanthropy
- 15:00committee needs to respond to that by... identifying
- 15:04giving opportunities that are in line with our
- 15:06family's mission and vision and values. And so
- 15:09we're all working together with our own areas
- 15:12of specialization, but together towards the goals
- 15:16to meet the objectives that we've together set
- 15:19as a board. So feel free to ask more details.
- 15:22Awesome. I got a round of lightning questions
- 15:24for you on all this. Okay. I think it's a fascinating
- 15:27model, and I'm sure a lot of people will be.
- 15:29Having some thoughts tickling the brain here.
- 15:31So the first is your family governance charter.
- 15:34Can you talk about what like the top two or three
- 15:37kind of critical rules were for you in that document?
- 15:40Well, who's on the board? That's one thing. And
- 15:43so we've decided on a five person board. And
- 15:47so we're actually keeping a running list of family
- 15:50members. My kids are engaged. So in 2026, we're
- 15:53going to add a couple of people and to the family,
- 15:56but not necessarily to the board. And so we've
- 15:59decided on five. It's good to have a tiebreaker
- 16:02number, if you will. So that was the first thing
- 16:05is who's going to be in the decision making process.
- 16:08And then we've had to go through how does one
- 16:11get on the board? So we just started with the
- 16:14people we had. But what we've decided is that
- 16:17that board should be made up of the chairs of
- 16:20the two committees, philanthropy and investment
- 16:23committee, and that you enter a committee. By
- 16:28spending time on that committee, you can then
- 16:30learn enough through the work of giving money
- 16:34away or investing money. You learn through that
- 16:37process and then could become a member of the
- 16:40board. We're using the committees as workshops
- 16:43or places where people can learn how to manage
- 16:48the money according to the family's approach
- 16:50and values. A lot of people think about investment
- 16:53before philanthropy. and I'm not arguing that's
- 16:56right or wrong, but do you see an either a direct
- 17:00strategy, if you will, or maybe a natural outcome
- 17:05where some of the family members are sitting
- 17:08on an investment committee, learning how to grow
- 17:10money and use money responsibly before going
- 17:12to the philanthropy committee, or maybe you're
- 17:14doing it the other way around, or maybe it doesn't
- 17:16matter. Like, how have you seen members come
- 17:19and go between these committees? Yeah. In my
- 17:22family, they're much, more inclined to be on
- 17:25the philanthropy committee than the investment
- 17:27committee you know dad's been doing this for
- 17:2940 years i started investing at age 11 and i'm
- 17:3256 so i think they're intimidated by trying to
- 17:36get up to speed with me or something i i don't
- 17:40know but uh one of my goals for this meeting
- 17:43that's coming up is to add another member to
- 17:46the investment committee so maybe you and i are
- 17:49more inclined to think about investing but For
- 17:52my kids and my family, they've seen us tithe
- 17:55and we've been committed tithers our entire marriage.
- 17:59So that's natural for them. And as they got allowances,
- 18:04they were taught to tithe. We give at least 10%,
- 18:07the first 10 % away, and then we may give above
- 18:10and beyond that. So it could be different in
- 18:12different families. It sounds like they're happy
- 18:14for dad to make the money and then they can help
- 18:16give it away. That might be true. That's a concern
- 18:21of mine. I'm very gratified. One of my daughters
- 18:24is getting her MBA right now. And when she was
- 18:27in one of the tough finance, in intro finance,
- 18:31but master's level, she was struggling with all
- 18:34these formulas and the, you know, the finance
- 18:36class. There's a lot to it. Yeah, taking them.
- 18:38And I think her professor was very data oriented
- 18:42and not super relational or whatever. She said,
- 18:47do I really need to know these kinds of things?
- 18:49And I said, oh, well, here. And I pulled up a
- 18:52three tab real estate deal analysis spreadsheet
- 18:56that I use. And I'm like. Kind of. Yeah. And
- 18:59so she knuckled down and she came over and wanted
- 19:01to help. I helped her prep for her exam and whatnot.
- 19:05But so I'm gratified she's learning that. I've
- 19:08got another son who's running a general contracting
- 19:10company and he's starting to think like a business
- 19:13person. And so with my help, I sit on his staff
- 19:17meetings and and help guide discussion. So they're
- 19:21learning. It makes me happy. Well, a lot of the
- 19:23way I look at it is we have to. Help push enough
- 19:26information to help them avoid making costly
- 19:28mistakes and then wait for them to come back
- 19:31to us when they're ready to learn some of the
- 19:34bigger picture stuff. At least that's the way
- 19:36I've been experiencing it so far. But then again,
- 19:39my kids aren't fully adults yet, so they're still
- 19:41going. Well, I've seen your spreadsheet, your
- 19:43planning tool, so I know you can get down into
- 19:45some Excel. Yeah, I get a little thorough. I
- 19:49like data. Anyone's listening to the show probably
- 19:51can tell that at this point. But yeah, you know.
- 19:54Imagine at least one of them at some point is
- 19:55going to want to dive deep into some data and
- 19:57I'll have plenty for them. Cool. I am curious
- 19:59about how often you all meet and like how formally
- 20:03do you do that? Is this a dinner table conversation?
- 20:07Are you actually sitting in a meeting room somewhere?
- 20:09What's the environment look like? Yeah. So our
- 20:11end of the year meeting is going to be in person
- 20:14in Florida. We live in Michigan. and soon to
- 20:17be Colorado and Oregon. And so we're spread across
- 20:21time zones. So most of our meetings are 75 minutes
- 20:25on Zoom. So we found that to be the right amount
- 20:29of time. People can stay engaged for that long.
- 20:31And the meeting cadence is approximately six
- 20:36meetings a year. The philanthropy committee has
- 20:39decided that they can make decisions via email.
- 20:42In other words, if someone has a gift or a big
- 20:46quest or idea, there's a form they fill out.
- 20:49And I'm very proud of my daughter who built this
- 20:52form to ensure that it asks the questions about
- 20:55how does this entity measure results? How do
- 20:58their activities align with our mission, vision,
- 21:02values, etc. And so there's pretty much all the
- 21:04information you could need to make a decision
- 21:07contained in the form. So they can work asynchronously.
- 21:10But as a group, we tend to get together every
- 21:13couple of months on a Saturday morning. Gotcha.
- 21:17And how have these gone so far? Have there been
- 21:20any contentious ones? And also, have there been
- 21:23any moments where? Maybe an individual or a committee
- 21:26has come and brought something that just is not
- 21:30really in your mind been a great idea. And how
- 21:34did those things play out? Like, for instance,
- 21:35maybe pushing for a meme stock or something.
- 21:38And you're like, well, no, my experience tells
- 21:41me that's not a good investment. And, you know,
- 21:43being the chair of the investment committee,
- 21:45I mean, I imagine you might have some power to
- 21:47override ideas like that. Have you had situations
- 21:49like that pop up? Yeah. As I said, I'd love to
- 21:52have that. on the investment committee. They're
- 21:55not. But I'll tell you, for example, I was looking
- 21:58at buying a building that had four retail shops
- 22:02and then I think 18 residential units. So it's
- 22:05a three -story building. And my older daughter,
- 22:08who lives in the same town, came on a walkthrough
- 22:11and began to ask questions. We went over the
- 22:16pro forma and the cash flow analysis and all
- 22:18that on the deal. And she met with a couple of
- 22:23guys who were considering a joint venture with
- 22:25us. And so they're getting exposed there. Your
- 22:28question was about contention. So far, we have
- 22:30not. So it's so far just been a pretty tight
- 22:34group that's fairly homogeneous. That's great.
- 22:37Well, I imagine some folks, if they try this,
- 22:39they might not always have the most harmonious
- 22:42situation. But I think the important thing is
- 22:44stay focused on your mission statement. and you
- 22:47know keep looking at the bigger picture i would
- 22:50love to ask you about how you see setting up
- 22:55your children as assessors because i know it
- 22:59sounds like some of them are adults but you know
- 23:02there's a model here that's that you have in
- 23:05mind actually have lots of models in mind as
- 23:07i look through your book um in particular you
- 23:09had a model called the uh push work down pull
- 23:12work down where leaders delegate tasks to the
- 23:16lowest competent level, which I think anyone
- 23:18who's worked in corporations are going to feel
- 23:20very familiar with this. How do you apply this
- 23:23to training your heirs? Are you pushing work
- 23:26down to your children so that they're building
- 23:28confidence before it's too late? Is that kind
- 23:30of the way you think of it? Well, it certainly
- 23:32is. Yeah. So we think about the family wealth
- 23:35as belonging to the family and not to individuals.
- 23:39We're actually. In the process of setting up
- 23:42a family LLC, which can be the sort of holding
- 23:47company, if you will, for real estate, brokerage
- 23:49accounts, etc. And then we would have membership
- 23:53interest in the LLC rather than having assets
- 23:56titled in our own names. And then other business
- 24:00entities can also be members of that family LLC.
- 24:04LLCs are governed by... particular state laws.
- 24:06So I'm not giving legal advice or anything like
- 24:08that and check with a local competent attorney
- 24:11in your jurisdiction. But yes, so the short answer
- 24:14is we really want kids to get on board with making
- 24:18decisions jointly. And that's the whole point
- 24:21of sharing the governance. And as their competence
- 24:23and experience grows, my intention is that my
- 24:29wife and I can begin to be second chair instead
- 24:32of first chair. And ultimately, I expect I'll
- 24:35be spending more time with grandchildren than
- 24:37children and mentoring them, you know, in all
- 24:40the ways that good grandparents would, in addition
- 24:42to mentoring them into the idea that they have
- 24:46a duty to be a productive member of this family.
- 24:51Now, the family wealth that we have is not intended
- 24:55to support the lifestyles of anybody in the family.
- 24:58So one of our core values is self -reliance.
- 25:02And that each of us has a profession or a career
- 25:06of some kind. I mentioned one daughter's getting
- 25:09her MBA. She works for a university right now.
- 25:13Her fiance is a medical doctor. My son runs a
- 25:17general contracting company. He has his grand
- 25:20vision for his company. And so he's... He's going
- 25:24to be doing just fine. Right now, he's partnering
- 25:27with the family, though. We're buying properties
- 25:30that can use value add. His company adds the
- 25:32value. Together, we sell it and share profits,
- 25:35the family and his company. So each of them should
- 25:39learn to be self -reliant. And so that's a way
- 25:42of building skills along the way as well. But
- 25:45they've got a friendly backstop of the family.
- 25:49So we're there to teach, to guide. to give or
- 25:53lend money expertise etc but they they're responsible
- 25:58for their own living expenses and their own family's
- 26:00expenses and the family money is for posterity
- 26:05so when your children were to get married is
- 26:09there significant others and eventually children
- 26:12and all that stuff also included in the in the
- 26:15board and not maybe not the board but at least
- 26:17the committees is there a vetting period that
- 26:19you typically look at how do you extend it so
- 26:22it's outside of your immediate family i'm young
- 26:25enough and new enough at this that we haven't
- 26:27had to worry about divorces or uh you know the
- 26:31the third generation yet that we're contemplating
- 26:34all that and it's it's actually on our discussion
- 26:36list for this year but yes we do invite the committed
- 26:41fiancés into the discussion, I think it's important
- 26:44for them to know what their spouse is committed
- 26:48to, which is our family. And to be clear, don't
- 26:53expect to be enriched when John and Julie die.
- 26:56You have the skills and abilities to earn your
- 26:59living. It's not coming from the family money.
- 27:01That is to be a force for good for generations.
- 27:05Gotcha. And has there ever been a moment where
- 27:08you've had to reject any ideas or have you found
- 27:11that the family typically is usually coming together
- 27:14and finding ways to compromise and always move
- 27:17forward? Or have you been to the point yet where
- 27:20you've had to make a hard rejection on something?
- 27:22Yeah. So raising your kids and being an involved
- 27:25parent, you tend to transfer most of your values.
- 27:28But I will say there are some values differences
- 27:31across the generations. around social issues.
- 27:35You know, younger people tend to be a little
- 27:38more liberal around certain issues than older
- 27:41people, right? It's not universally true, but
- 27:44we do have some differences there. And so we've
- 27:46worked to craft our values in ways that address
- 27:50our commonality and not our differences. A lot
- 27:54of folks listening to this show are chasing financial
- 27:57independence. So, you know, they're looking at
- 27:59trying to get to maybe a number or a certain
- 28:03point milestone in their lives where they work
- 28:06becomes optional. And I think a lot of us, when
- 28:09we think of things like succession planning,
- 28:11I won't speak for everyone, but at least for
- 28:12me, it was part of a checklist thing. I wanted
- 28:15to make sure I had covered my basis. You know,
- 28:18I wasn't going to have done all this work and
- 28:20then just squandered it and not prepared my family
- 28:23well. I'm just curious, as you've gone through
- 28:26all of this, there was one of the other models
- 28:29in your book. You talked about there's such a
- 28:32thing as a bad success. Good success and bad
- 28:35success. Yeah, bad success. And I don't think
- 28:38any of us are purposely working for that. But,
- 28:39you know, you never know, right? Until you get
- 28:41to an outcome. But I was curious how the implementing
- 28:44all of this, the family board and all of your
- 28:47ideas. And I know it's growing, but I can see
- 28:50that it's had a very positive impact on you since
- 28:52your retirement. How has this changed your own
- 28:55sense of purpose in your own life? Well, it really
- 28:58has an unexpected outcome. Daniel is that as
- 29:02we're talking more openly and clearly about money
- 29:06and making it and giving it, it's actually. changed
- 29:10how we talk about everything else so as we're
- 29:13more open about money and it's interesting we
- 29:17call it earning a living right it's part of our
- 29:19life it's maybe our life distilled into a balance
- 29:23sheet as we talk more openly and clearly about
- 29:26that it has given us the opportunity to talk
- 29:29more openly and clearly about other things that
- 29:32are important to us our relationships our personal
- 29:35struggles and things like this. And so I wasn't
- 29:38even aware that that would happen, but it's been
- 29:41a beautiful unintended positive outcome or side
- 29:44effect of that. And so thinking about good at
- 29:47success and bad success, I think having more
- 29:49money without better relationships wouldn't be
- 29:53a good success. In other words, Stephen Covey's
- 29:55language, that would be leaning the ladder up
- 29:57against a tall wall, but it was the wrong wall.
- 30:00I'd rather be poor and have great relationships
- 30:03with my kids. Even better, I'd rather be rich
- 30:05and have great relationships with my kids. Wow.
- 30:08Yeah, I think that's powerful. I mean, I've definitely
- 30:10heard folks say, wow, if I only had this much
- 30:13more money, then everything would be okay. I
- 30:17know for a fact that once you get to that special
- 30:20number that you pick, it's never enough. It doesn't
- 30:23automatically fix your problem. So that's amazing
- 30:25that you've experienced these other things in
- 30:27your life, that you've created a conduit for
- 30:29social connection and relationship building that's
- 30:32not just around the money. It's about the people.
- 30:34Because in the book, I talk about the five big
- 30:37regrets people have at the end of their retirement.
- 30:40And usually one of them is they didn't spend
- 30:42more time on relationships. They spent too much
- 30:44time chasing wealth. Yeah. So I think, you know,
- 30:47some people are probably going to be listening
- 30:48to this and be interested in the book. They're
- 30:49going to be interested in thinking about how
- 30:50do I try this? So two quick questions. One, for
- 30:53someone who might not have a ton of money, I
- 30:57don't know what the number is, but let's just
- 30:58say they're not even to a million. They're working
- 31:00their way up and might feel like they're not
- 31:02quite rich enough for a board. Are they wrong?
- 31:05Should they be doing this now? Or is it better
- 31:08to wait until you have more assets to manage?
- 31:10And then the second part of the question is,
- 31:12what's the first step they should take if they
- 31:13should? Sure. Well, I would say that it's important
- 31:16to be open with your kids about your life. Like
- 31:21I said earlier, even if you've made a mess of
- 31:23things, let them know about the messes so they
- 31:26can avoid those, making the mistakes that led
- 31:28to the mess. And so I'm just highly encouraging
- 31:33of people to be open and clear. Secrecy doesn't
- 31:37lead to good things. So that's my first step
- 31:40is, hey, let's be clear. and honest with our
- 31:43kids. Age appropriate, of course. Little kids
- 31:46shouldn't be worrying about money. That's an
- 31:51adult responsibility is to make sure that we
- 31:53have food, shelter, and all of that. So don't
- 31:56put that on your kids. But if they're old enough
- 31:58to have a job, they're old enough to know about
- 32:01money and how you make it and how you spend it
- 32:04and how you think about it. So I think that's
- 32:07appropriate whether you're... dirt poor or fabulously
- 32:11wealthy or anywhere in between. I think it's
- 32:14great to work your way into this. So you could
- 32:16think about if you don't have a whole bunch of
- 32:20money yet, you still have the ability to make
- 32:22some gifts. to do some giving. And you could
- 32:25invite your kids to make decisions about, hey,
- 32:27we were thinking about the Salvation Army or
- 32:29the Humane Society or the Girl Scouts, whatever.
- 32:33What do you think we should do and why? And now
- 32:36you're starting a values discussion. If they
- 32:38choose Girl Scouts, oh, great. Why the Girl Scouts?
- 32:40And you get to hear from them. And then you can
- 32:43share your heart about it. I just think that's
- 32:45a beautiful conversation. And then you could
- 32:49say, It's time for open enrollment. And that
- 32:54made me think about changing my 401k contribution.
- 32:57Hey, kids, you're a little older. You understand
- 33:00how math works. I was thinking about saving more
- 33:03money in my 401k. That will mean we have a little
- 33:06bit less for vacations or going out to eat or
- 33:09what have you. Let's talk about this trade -off
- 33:11and invite them into a conversation that way.
- 33:15So that's not, you don't have to set up a board.
- 33:17But you can begin to have conversations that
- 33:19provoke your kids and draw them in to thinking
- 33:23like an adult about tradeoffs and about money
- 33:26and about their values. That's amazing. Yeah.
- 33:29So you, I guess it's not too early or too late
- 33:32to start thinking about. those dinner table conversation
- 33:35as little boardrooms until you get to the point
- 33:38where you're ready to start crafting your governance
- 33:40statements and then forming your own little committees,
- 33:43whatever your committees are right for your family.
- 33:45Sure. So Daniel, I'm trying something new at
- 33:48this year's in -person family board meeting.
- 33:50So my parents, my dad was a teacher. My mom stayed
- 33:54home with the boys until we went to. I went to
- 33:57school, had some different corporate jobs, and
- 33:59then together they ran an insurance agency. And
- 34:02then I became their financial advisor and helped
- 34:05them sell their business and then manage their
- 34:07assets until I retired. And I haven't even told
- 34:11them that we do this with our kids. And I just
- 34:15realized that was a miss. I missed that opportunity
- 34:18to mentor up. Not that I'm asking them to do
- 34:22the same with me and my brother, but just for
- 34:25them to hear. As I said, our relationships seem
- 34:28to be getting better as we talk more openly.
- 34:31And so they're invited to our family board meeting
- 34:35this year. It's amazing to imagine the growth
- 34:37that we all have. Even those who established
- 34:39this, we are still growing. It doesn't end. So
- 34:43that's awesome. Well, thank you so much, John,
- 34:45for being here with us today. How can listeners
- 34:46connect with you and get your book? Thank you
- 34:48for success. Daniel, you're a great host and
- 34:51interviewer. And so I've. honestly loved this
- 34:54conversation. And so the book is called Thinking
- 34:57for Success. And the subtitle is 52 stories that
- 35:01upgrade your thinking to boost productivity,
- 35:03problem solving, and relationships. You can get
- 35:06the book anywhere books are sold. And you can
- 35:09go to our website, thinkingforsuccess .com. And
- 35:13there's an insights tab that has lots of short
- 35:15videos and pieces of articles that I've written
- 35:18that are just additional conversations around
- 35:21how do we manage our family? How do we manage
- 35:24our relationships? The favorite one seems to
- 35:27be the ones with my wife. I'm sure she's more
- 35:30attractive than I am. And so you can see some
- 35:32with just me and some with Julie as well. That's
- 35:35awesome. Well, I really appreciate you being
- 35:37here on the show today and helping us think about
- 35:39our families and financial literacy and secession
- 35:43a little differently. I think it's been useful
- 35:45for me. I definitely have a lot of new ideas
- 35:48after we talked about this and after looking
- 35:49at your book. So thanks again for coming on the
- 35:51show. True pleasure. Thanks, Daniel. I hope you
- 36:08enjoyed my conversation with John Knowlton. There
- 36:11were a lot of insightful things he shared in
- 36:13his non -conventional approach to family finances.
- 36:16For example, the profound distinction between
- 36:19good success and bad success. Because it's natural
- 36:23to want the best for our loved ones, but good
- 36:26intentions can result in bad outcomes. But like
- 36:28John said, the best teacher is someone else's
- 36:31experiences. We can use that model to ensure
- 36:34that we're avoiding those sharp rocks and enjoying
- 36:37the walk. John said that authority without information
- 36:40is blind. And as parents, we have the authority,
- 36:44and it can be all too easy to lecture and correct,
- 36:46yet it's hard to learn without the information.
- 36:49Our children might listen to us, but without
- 36:52context, they're blindly wandering forward, especially
- 36:55after we're gone. But like John said, stories
- 36:58are one of the most effective ways to teach.
- 37:00They're easier to listen to. and they're easier
- 37:02to remember. And what better place to tell stories
- 37:05than the kitchen dinner table? Yet the data shows
- 37:08that 52 % of parents have never had a comprehensive
- 37:12conversation about wealth or legacy with their
- 37:14children. Sadly, the norm is to hand the next
- 37:17generation the keys to the kingdom without teaching
- 37:19them how to govern it. John's book, Thinking
- 37:22for Success, goes deep into the mental models
- 37:24to take on these mental challenges. His proposal
- 37:27to stop treating our wealth like a secret and
- 37:29start treating it like a business, gives us a
- 37:32familiar blueprint. It starts with the golden
- 37:35triangle. It's a simple exercise. You define
- 37:38the why, the how, and the what. The why defines
- 37:42your values on paper. This is your mission statement
- 37:45and the thing that can keep you all on the same
- 37:47page and anchored throughout the twists and turns
- 37:50of life. The how is what it sounds like. This
- 37:53is how you'll govern. John touched on a few things
- 37:56that worked for his family. First, they created
- 37:58a family LLC. placing assets into a shared entity.
- 38:02This allowed them to shift the psychology away
- 38:04from individual interests into the common shared
- 38:07interests of the family. Which takes us to the
- 38:10other piece, their shared governance model. All
- 38:13members are decision makers and everyone has
- 38:16a role. They have committees and they have a
- 38:18board, but this is just the constructs that bring
- 38:21them together and keep them united in purpose.
- 38:24The governance model gives them the tools. Voting,
- 38:28debating, growing. Whatever they need to continue
- 38:31to be a positive family force toward their why.
- 38:34And finally, there's the what. This is what most
- 38:37of us think about when it comes to financial
- 38:39freedom. Get more assets. Grow the net worth.
- 38:42But did you notice how John downplayed this part
- 38:45of the triangle? The money isn't the important
- 38:48part. It's a means to an end. And in his case,
- 38:52how much giving him and his family can do. Look.
- 38:57You don't need a boardroom or millions of dollars
- 38:59to add governance to your life. All you need
- 39:02is the intent and a shared space. You could start
- 39:05at a dinner table and bring up the values important
- 39:08to you and your hopes for your family's future.
- 39:11With older kids can come more mature conversations,
- 39:14but it's not too early or too late to start the
- 39:17conversation. For example, John shared his decision
- 39:20to bring his kids into his 401k choice during
- 39:24their open enrollment. In my entire lifetime,
- 39:27it had never once occurred to me that I might
- 39:29ever do this. But why not? My kids will need
- 39:33to make that decision. Wouldn't it have been
- 39:35better if they had had a safe place to practice
- 39:37it? You know, they could have asked me questions.
- 39:40They could have seen what the impact of my decision
- 39:43would be. And maybe later they'd have some understanding
- 39:46about why we're making a sacrifice or doing something
- 39:49that we were doing. This is financial literacy
- 39:52in action. So the challenge for us this week
- 39:55is to break that 52 % statistic. Whether you're
- 39:59setting up a family LLC or just asking your kids,
- 40:02what do you need? I'd love to hear from you.
- 40:05How do you plan to talk to your family about
- 40:07money this week? Would you consider using a formal
- 40:10governance model? Send me an email at contact
- 40:13at escapetheclock .com or leave your comment
- 40:15where you listen. I'm Daniel C. Rogers. Thanks
- 40:19for listening. Best of luck governing your family
- 40:21finances and escaping the clock. I'll catch you
- 40:23next week. Please remember to like and subscribe
- 40:48so you don't miss an episode. Thanks for tuning
- 40:50in and I'll catch you next time.