Latest / eMotors: Electric Revolution / Cicero’s Chariot: Stoic Luxury in the Electric Age
Transcript
- 0:10OK, I want everyone to just take a deep breath, clear your mind.
- 0:14We are going to do something a little different today.
- 0:16I want you to picture a scene. It's 2026.
- 0:20You're the top salesperson at the most exclusive high end
- 0:24electric vehicle dealership in the city.
- 0:26You know the floors are marble, the espresso machine cost more
- 0:29than a Honda Civic, and the silence is expensive.
- 0:33It's a high pressure environment.
- 0:34Extremely. And you're waiting for your
- 0:36100AM appointment, but when the doors slide open, it's not a
- 0:39tech billionaire and a hoodie. He's not a venture capitalist.
- 0:42It's an elderly man. He's draped in a toga that, I
- 0:45mean, somehow manages to look more dignified than a three
- 0:48piece suit. He has the weight of the entire
- 0:50Roman Republic on his shoulders. And he's probably judging your
- 0:53architectural choices. Oh, absolutely, ladies and
- 0:56gentlemen. Or a difficult client today is
- 0:58Marcus Tillius Cicero, the legendary Roman statesman,
- 1:01orator and philosopher. A man who has been dead for over
- 1:052000 years and yet here we are trying to get his credit score.
- 1:08Here we are. And look, we have to be clear
- 1:10about the mission today. This is a game of fantasy.
- 1:13We are taking a stack of very real sources, Cicero's own heavy
- 1:17hitting texts like the officies, his letters, academic papers on
- 1:21his real estate habits, and a fascinating Italian analysis
- 1:25that links Cicero specifically to the philosophy of modern EVs.
- 1:29It sounds like a bizarre combination, I know, but when
- 1:32you dig into the texts, the connection is shockingly
- 1:35logical. That's the goal.
- 1:37We're going to play this game, this Gioco de Fantasia, to
- 1:40figure out definitively which modern car Cicero would drive
- 1:44off the lot. I'm ready to sell.
- 1:46And I'm ready to make sure you don't violate his philosophical
- 1:48principles in the process. Because selling to Cicero isn't
- 1:51about features or horsepower. It's about virtue.
- 1:54Right. So let's profile the client,
- 1:56because I started reading the source material, specifically
- 1:59Cicero, about luxury, and I have to be honest, this guy seems
- 2:02like a total buzzkill. He certainly has that
- 2:04reputation. I mean, he is harsh.
- 2:07He writes about luxuria luxury like it's a disease.
- 2:10He lumps it in with avaricious. So greed, libido, lust and
- 2:15decidia idleness. He's practically shouting get
- 2:18off my lawn with your fancy Chariots.
- 2:20He advocates for the simple life, frugality, dignity.
- 2:24You know, he sounds like a minimalist.
- 2:25Exactly. But then, and here's where I got
- 2:28confused, you look at his actual life.
- 2:30The guy was a real estate mogul. He had a massive house on the
- 2:33Palatine Hill in Rome. He had villas in Tusculum,
- 2:36Formia, Pompeii. He wasn't exactly living in a
- 2:40barrel like Diogenes. No, he was not, and that is the
- 2:43paradox of character that historians have argued about for
- 2:46centuries. Is he a hypocrite?
- 2:48Is he preaching water and drinking wine?
- 2:50It feels that way. It feels like a modern
- 2:52politician tweeting about climate change from a private
- 2:54jet. It does feel familiar, but here
- 2:56is the nuance we need to nail down if we want to sell him a
- 2:58car. It comes down to the Roman
- 3:00distinction between the private person and the public person,
- 3:03right? So what's the excuse?
- 3:05The excuse, or the justification really, is status.
- 3:09The argument is that if a private individual bathes in
- 3:12luxury just for pleasure, that is hedonism, that is weak.
- 3:16But a state person, a public figure like Cicero, requires
- 3:20representative housing. Representative Housing.
- 3:23Yes, he needs a place that reflects his social standing.
- 3:26Think about it this way. If the President of the United
- 3:28States showed up to AG7 Summit driving a rusted out 1998
- 3:33hatchback, what does that say? Says the country is broke.
- 3:37It looks weak. Exactly.
- 3:38IT projects instability. Cicero's defense is that his
- 3:41mansions, his art and yes, his transport aren't for him.
- 3:45They are props for the character he plays, the consul, the
- 3:48senator, the father of the fatherland.
- 3:50So the luxury is a uniform. Precisely.
- 3:52It's about maintaining the dignity of the office, and that
- 3:55is the first rule for our sales pitch.
- 3:57This car cannot be a party car. It can't be a bright red
- 4:00convertible bot just so he can feel the wind in his hair.
- 4:03That would be libido. It has to be a tool.
- 4:06A tool of Dignitas. If he buys a car, he needs to be
- 4:09able to argue to the Senate that this vehicle helps him serve the
- 4:11Republic better. Got it.
- 4:13So we need something impressive but serious.
- 4:17But before we get to the specific models, we have to talk
- 4:20about the owner's manual. We have to talk about D
- 4:22officies. D officies or on duties.
- 4:25This is the book he wrote for his son Marcus, and if we don't
- 4:28understand the core conflict in book three, we are never going
- 4:32to close this deal. This is the battle between
- 4:34Honestam and Utila, which again sounds like a high end law firm.
- 4:39It does. Honestam is moral virtue.
- 4:42What is inherently right utila is expediency.
- 4:46What is useful or advantageous to you?
- 4:48OK, so normally we think those two things are enemies.
- 4:51Like if I'm running late for a meeting, the UTL thing, the
- 4:54useful thing is to speed drive 100 mph, but that's illegal and
- 4:58dangerous, so it's not honest to him.
- 5:00I have to pick one. Right, that's how we think.
- 5:01It's a trade off. You can be good or you can be
- 5:03successful, Cicero says. Absolutely not.
- 5:06He thinks you can have it all. He goes further.
- 5:08He argues that if an action is immoral, it cannot actually be
- 5:11useful in the long run. If you cheat to get ahead, you
- 5:14haven't actually succeeded. You've damaged Imagine your
- 5:16soul, which is your most valuable asset.
- 5:18So applying this to the car dealership.
- 5:21It means the car must be useful. It has to get him to the Senate
- 5:24efficiently. That's util.
- 5:26But to be truly good, it must also be honest.
- 5:29It cannot be obtained through corruption.
- 5:32It cannot be ostentatious to the point of moral decay, and
- 5:36honestly, the supply chain probably matters to them too.
- 5:38So if I try to sell them a car that's fast but known for being
- 5:42unreliable or ethically shady, he's going to walk out.
- 5:45He's going to lecture you on virtue and then he's going to
- 5:47walk out. OK, so we need a car that is
- 5:49practical and morally sound. Now I want to throw a curveball
- 5:53here. We're talking about a stoic.
- 5:54We're talking about a guy who preaches against greed.
- 5:56So why don't I just take him to the used lot and sell him a a
- 5:59Toyota Prius? A Prius.
- 6:01Yeah, it's reliable, it's efficient, it's humble.
- 6:04It it seems like the perfect stoic car.
- 6:06Why spend 6 figures on an EV when a used Prius does the job?
- 6:10That is a very rational thought, but it fails the test of.
- 6:14Decorum, decorum. OK, that's the concept from the
- 6:16thesis. There's no I in team.
- 6:18Break that down. Why does the Prius fail?
- 6:20Because of the two masks, Cicero uses this theatrical analogy.
- 6:25He says we all wear 2 masks. The first mask is universal.
- 6:28It's our shared human reason. We all have that.
- 6:30And the second mask. The second mask is our
- 6:32individual role, the unique traits and station that make you
- 6:36you. Decorum happens when there is
- 6:38harmony between your character and your actions.
- 6:40So the car has to match the specific mask he is wearing.
- 6:43Exactly. Cicero is a senior senator.
- 6:46He's an elder statesman if he rolls up to the Roman Forum in a
- 6:50dented Prius. It doesn't match the mask.
- 6:52It's unseemly. It lacks gravitas.
- 6:55It might be virtuous in a vacuum, but for Cicero
- 6:57specifically, it's an insult to his office.
- 7:00A Prius says I am an Uber driver.
- 7:02It doesn't say I am saving the Republic.
- 7:04So the sensible choice is actually the wrong choice
- 7:07because it damages his brand. That is a very specific, very
- 7:11Roman kind of vanity. It's not.
- 7:13Vanity to him, it's propriety decorum requires him to be
- 7:16visually above the crowd. OK, so the Prius is out.
- 7:19The monster truck is definitely out.
- 7:20We need high end. We need dignified.
- 7:22This brings us to the engine. Our sources are convinced he
- 7:26would go electric. Why?
- 7:28This comes from the Cicerone source, the Italian analysis.
- 7:31It focuses on the sensory experience of Rome.
- 7:34Let's paint that picture because we think of Rome as white marble
- 7:37statues. But it wasn't like that, was it?
- 7:39God, no. It was loud.
- 7:41It was chaotic. Think about iron wheels grinding
- 7:44on stone paving, drivers shouting, the smell of thousands
- 7:48of horses, the dust. Cicero was an intellectual.
- 7:52He was a man who needed to think.
- 7:54He needed to compose complicated rhetoric in his head.
- 7:57He found the noise and the smell of travel physically exhausting.
- 8:01So enter the modern EV. Enter the silence.
- 8:03The source suggests Cicero would be obsessed with the acoustic
- 8:07isolation of a high end EV. It aligns perfectly with stoic
- 8:11calm. It allows him to turn the
- 8:12vehicle into a mobile study. The source calls it invisible
- 8:16luxury. I love that term.
- 8:18It's advanced technology, but it's discreet.
- 8:20It's not a roaring V8 engine drawing attention to itself with
- 8:23noise. It's stealth.
- 8:24Wealth. And don't forget the practical
- 8:26side. The source mentions acceleration
- 8:28for many a lightning acceleration.
- 8:30Which sounds fun, but remember, no fun allowed.
- 8:33Well, not fun for fun's sake, but think about his commute.
- 8:36He's going back and forth between Rome and his villa in
- 8:39Pasi, constantly getting there in half the time, without the
- 8:43sweat, without the horse manure that is pure.
- 8:45You too, OK. We have the profile.
- 8:49Silent, efficient, powerful but discreet.
- 8:52Dignified enough for a console but rational enough for a
- 8:55philosopher. We are ready for the showroom
- 8:57showdown. Let's see the inventory.
- 8:59I have two cars pulled around the front contender #1 the Lucid
- 9:04Air. Interesting choice.
- 9:05The Cicerone source specifically calls this one out.
- 9:08It mentions a range of up to 512 miles and over 1200 horsepower.
- 9:13That range is the killer feature.
- 9:15Exactly. Cicero spent a huge amount of
- 9:17his life on the road. 512 miles means you can go from Rome to
- 9:20Tusculum, then down to Formia, maybe even flee to the coast of
- 9:24Marc Anthony's chasing him, all without stopping to charge.
- 9:27It is the ultimate expression of efficiency.
- 9:30It's a car that prioritizes technology and logic over pure
- 9:33bling. It appeals to the part of him
- 9:35that wrote D Officious the practical management of duties.
- 9:38It gets the job done better than anything else on the market.
- 9:41I have a concern which is it's a prestigious enough Lucid is a
- 9:45startup, it's new tech, Does it carry the gravitas of the Roman
- 9:49Republic? That is the risk.
- 9:51It might be too Silicon Valley for a traditionalist like
- 9:54Cicero. Which brings us to contender #2
- 9:57the Rolls Royce Specter. Now we're talking about
- 10:00Dignitas. This is the electric version of
- 10:03the ultimate status symbol. The source describes it as ultra
- 10:07exclusive, silent and prestigious.
- 10:10This is the state person car. Remember the loophole?
- 10:12He is allowed to have representative housing.
- 10:15This is representative transport.
- 10:16When he pulls up to the Curia in a Rolls Royce Specter, nobody
- 10:19questions who is in charge. But I'm worried it's too much.
- 10:22I'm worried it's Luxuria. It's walking a fine line.
- 10:25I mean, look at it. It's massive.
- 10:26It's opulent. Honestly, it smells a little bit
- 10:29like libido. It smells like indulgence.
- 10:31If I'm his political enemy, if I'm Caesar, I'm looking at that
- 10:34car and saying look at Cicero bathing in hand stitch leather
- 10:37while the people starve. That is a very real danger.
- 10:40But counterpoint, the Specter is also a fortress.
- 10:44It is the quietest car in the world.
- 10:46It is a bank vault on wheels. So you think you can justify it?
- 10:50I think the Lucid Air is the choice of the private Cicero,
- 10:54the philosopher who wants logic, but the public Cicero, the man
- 10:58who has to intimidate his rivals.
- 11:00He can't step out of a spaceship.
- 11:01He needs a throne. So we're torn.
- 11:04The lucid for the man, the roles for the legend if.
- 11:07He has to pick one. Which mask does he wear most
- 11:10often? He wears the mask of the orator,
- 11:13the public figure. Then I think the sources push us
- 11:16toward the Rolls Royce. But, and there is a massive butt
- 11:20here, he would only accept it if he uses it with performative
- 11:23sobriety. Performative sobriety.
- 11:25I like that. He can't drive it like a
- 11:26teenager. He can't wrap it in gold Chrome.
- 11:29He has to drive it with a stern look on his face.
- 11:31He has to tell everyone. I take no pleasure in these
- 11:33lamb's wool carpet citizens. I only endure them because the
- 11:37soundproofing helps me draft laws for your benefit.
- 11:40I am suffering in this massage seat for the good of the
- 11:42Republic. Exactly.
- 11:43It's the perfect Ciceronian compromise.
- 11:46He gets the luxury, but he frames it as a burden of his
- 11:49office. I think we have a winner.
- 11:51Yeah, we are leasing him the Rolls Royce Specter, black on
- 11:54black, no rims. But before he signs the
- 11:57paperwork, I want to take a deeper dive into the price tag
- 12:01because this is a $400,000 car and there is a really
- 12:05interesting point in the thesis about property rights that
- 12:08connects to this. Yes, this is crucial.
- 12:10It connects back to his politics.
- 12:12Cicero was a staunch defender of private property.
- 12:15The sources mentioned he opposed something called novae tabulae.
- 12:19What is that? Novae tabulae literally means
- 12:21new tablets. It was a euphemism for debt
- 12:24cancellation. Wiping the slate clean A.
- 12:27Jubilee. Right.
- 12:28The popular airs, the populist politicians like Caesar and
- 12:31Cataline often promised this to the masses.
- 12:33Vote for me and I'll wipe out your debts.
- 12:36And Cicero hated that. He despised it.
- 12:38He believed the state's primary job was to protect private
- 12:41property. She believed that if you earn
- 12:43something through your merit and your labor, the state had no
- 12:46right to take it away or devalue it.
- 12:48So in a weird way, him buying this incredibly expensive
- 12:51electric vehicle is a political statement.
- 12:54It is. It's a defense of his
- 12:55philosophy. He is enjoying the fruits of his
- 12:58merit. He's saying I earn this status,
- 13:01I earn this wealth, and the state protects my right to buy
- 13:03this spectrum. It's not just a car, it's a
- 13:06symbol of the system working. If the state starts saying you
- 13:09can't have a Rolls Royce, or if they start wiping out debt so
- 13:13that money becomes meaningless, the Republic falls.
- 13:16Precisely, the thesis notes that for Cicero, the protection of
- 13:19private property is an extension of natural justice, so driving
- 13:23this car is an act of justice in his eyes.
- 13:26That is the best rationalization for buying a luxury car I have
- 13:29ever heard. Honey, I didn't buy the sports
- 13:31car for me. I bought it for justice.
- 13:33Try that with your spouse and let me know how it goes.
- 13:35But for Cicero it works. There's one last paradox I want
- 13:39to touch on, from the Paradox of Stocorum.
- 13:41The Sage alone is free. Yes, only the wise are free.
- 13:45Every fool is a slave. How does that apply to the car?
- 13:49Because usually we think of cars as freedom, the open road,
- 13:52right? But cars also trap us Payments,
- 13:54maintenance, traffic. Well, think about the
- 13:56technology. The source mentions that modern
- 13:59EVs, with their climate control, autopilot features and smooth
- 14:03ride, free the driver from the physical fatigue of travel.
- 14:07That's good. In a chariot, you are a slave to
- 14:10the elements. You are a slave to the horse's
- 14:12mood. You arrive exhausted.
- 14:14In the EV, the technology handles the physical burden.
- 14:18This frees your mind. So the car frees him to be a
- 14:21philosopher. Exactly.
- 14:22It allows his mind to work on rhetoric and logic rather than
- 14:25worrying about a broken wheel or a lame horse.
- 14:28The technology facilitates his wisdom, therefore the car makes
- 14:32him freer. Unless of course the battery
- 14:34dies in the middle of nowhere. Then he's just philosopher stuck
- 14:37on the side of the Appian Way, waiting for a tow truck.
- 14:39Well, that's why he has his assistance.
- 14:40A true statesman never charges his own vehicle.
- 14:43True. So we've successfully sold
- 14:46Marcus Tilia Cicero a Rolls Royce Specter, justified it as a
- 14:49tool of the state, aligned it with his views on private
- 14:52property, and framed it as a vessel for stoic freedom.
- 14:56Not bad for a day's work. I think he'd be the most
- 14:58difficult customer we've ever had, but eventually the logic
- 15:01holds up. It really does.
- 15:03And look, I want to say a huge thank you to everyone listening
- 15:06for going along with this. This was a true Joko de
- 15:09Fantasia, a game of fantasy. It's a fun exercise.
- 15:13Taking these ancient minds and dropping them into our modern
- 15:15problems helps us see both sides a little clearer.
- 15:18Absolutely. But before we hand over the
- 15:20keys, there is one final lingering thought from the
- 15:23Paradox Astoria Quorum that I think we need to leave the
- 15:26listener with It's. The warning.
- 15:28Cicero says all fools are mad and every fool is in exile.
- 15:34He talks about how people become slaves to their possessions.
- 15:36They become owned by their things.
- 15:38Right. We just spent all this time
- 15:40justifying Cicero buying a $400,000 car, but the danger is
- 15:44always there. If we are constantly upgrading,
- 15:47if we are obsessed with the next model year, if we are taking on
- 15:50massive debt just to look the part of the state person, are we
- 15:55actually free? Or are we the fools Cicero
- 15:57warned about? Are we driving the machine or is
- 16:00the machine driving us? That is the question.
- 16:03And if Cicero were here, I think he'd tell us that the car is
- 16:05fine as long as you're willing to walk away from it without
- 16:08looking back. A little something to Mull over
- 16:10while you're stuck in traffic today.
- 16:12Indeed. Thanks for participating in the
- 16:14game. Thanks for joining us on the
- 16:16deep dive. Drive safe, watch out for
- 16:18Chariots, and we'll catch you next time.