Latest / For the Missing: Missing Persons, Families & the Search for Answers / Who Put Bella in the Wych Elm? The Tree That Hid a Secret | For the Missing
Transcript
- It was just an ordinary Tuesday in April, until a boy climbed into a tree and found a skull staring back at him. For eighty years, that hollow trunk has held its breath, waiting for someone to finally ask the question written on the walls: Who put Bella in the wych elm? Let’s set the scene. It’s the middle of the Second World War. The air is thick with tension, and everyone is holding their breath, waiting for the next bomb or the next letter from the front. But out on the outskirts of Hagley, in Worcestershire, life feels quieter. Four local boys—Robert Hart, Thomas Willetts, Bob Farmer, and Fred Payne—are wandering through Hagley Wood. They’re not there for anything serious. Maybe they’re poaching, maybe they’re looking for birds’ nests. It’s one of those carefree afternoons that feel like they’ll last forever. They come across a large wych elm. It’s old, sturdy, and full of secrets. Farmer, being the boldest of the bunch, decides to climb it. He wants to see if there’s a nest up high. As he climbs, his eyes drift downward into the hollow trunk of the tree. And that’s when he sees it. At first, his brain tries to protect him. He thinks it’s an animal skull. Just a deer, or a fox. But then he looks closer. He sees human hair. He sees teeth. His heart must have hammered against his ribs so hard he thought the others could hear it. He’s scared. He’s on land that doesn’t belong to them, and he’s found something that changes everything. So, he does what any terrified child would do. He puts the skull back. He climbs down. He walks away. None of them say a word as they head home. They bury the secret under layers of silence, thinking that if they don’t speak of it, it won’t become real. But the eldest boy, Willetts, can’t let it go. That unease sits in his chest like a stone. He knows they did the wrong thing by leaving it. So, when he gets home, he tells his parents. And just like that, the quiet of Hagley Wood is shattered. When the police arrive, they don’t just find a skull. They find an almost complete skeleton nestled deep inside the hollow of the tree. It’s a picture frozen in time, dressed in the clothes she wore on her final journey. A striped cardigan. A mustard-colored skirt. And on her feet, blue crêpe-soled shoes, size five and a half. There’s also a gold wedding ring, resting quietly among the bones, a small circle of metal that once meant something very important. But here is where the mystery deepens. The body wasn’t just dumped there. Forensic examination reveals that the woman had been placed in the tree still warm. The measurements of the trunk show it was too narrow for the body to fit once rigor mortis—the stiffening of the muscles—had set in. This means someone carried her there, while she was still soft, still vulnerable, and hidden her away before the cold reality of death had fully set in. The pathologist, James Webster, works quickly. He establishes that she has been dead for at least eighteen months. If we count back from April 1943, that places her death in or before October 1941. She was likely between twenty-five and forty years old, about five feet tall. And the cause of death? Webster finds a section of taffeta fabric wedged in her mouth. Suffocation. She didn’t just die; she was silenced. Every detail of that discovery paints a portrait of a violent end, hidden away in the dark, waiting for spring to reveal it. In a normal year, this might be solvable. You look at the dental records. You check the missing persons reports. But this is 1943. Britain is at war. Thousands of people have moved, disappeared, or been lost in the chaos of evacuation and bombing. The records are a mountain of paper, impossible to sift through completely. The police cross-reference every detail—the height, the age, the distinctive dental pattern, the style of the shoes—but nothing fits perfectly. Too many blanks, too many gaps. They contact dentists across the region, hoping for a match. The dental work is quite distinctive, which should help. But without a name, without a family coming forward to claim her, the evidence remains cold. The blue shoes tell us something specific: they couldn’t have been made before 1940. So she died recently, relatively speaking, but long enough ago that the clues have faded. This is the tragedy of the unknown victim. We know what she looked like. We know what she wore. We know how she died. But we don’t know who she was. Was she a wife? A mother? A daughter? That gold ring suggests a commitment, a promise made to someone. Now, it rests in a police evidence box, a silent witness to a life cut short. The system is overwhelmed. The world is burning, and in the smoke, one woman’s identity vanishes. The search doesn’t end until they’re home, but right now, she has no home to return to. As the investigation stalls, something strange begins to happen in the streets nearby. In 1944, graffiti starts to appear. It’s chalked onto walls, scrawled on buildings. The first message reads: 'Who put Luebella down the wych elm?' Found on Haden Hill Road in Old Hill. Then, in March 1944, another phrase appears on an empty building in Birmingham: 'Who put Bella down the wych elm - Hagley Wood?' Two days later, 'Hagley Wood Bella' shows up on Pershore Street. The handwriting is consistent. Police believe it’s the same person writing these messages. Why? Is it a taunt? A confession? Or perhaps the cry of someone who knows more than they’re saying? The spelling of 'wych' is unusual, leading investigators to suspect the writer might be a countryman, someone familiar with the rural dialect, perhaps visiting the local market. These words spread like ink in water. For decades, sporadic versions of the phrase continue to appear, even on the Hagley Obelisk near where the body was found. By 1999, it’s changed slightly to 'Who put Bella in the witch elm?', hinting at darker, folkloric theories. But in 1944, those chalk marks were fresh wounds. They reminded everyone that the case was open, that the answer was out there, hiding in plain sight. The community felt it. The mystery wasn’t just a police file; it was a ghost haunting the walls of their towns. Years pass. The war ends. The graffiti fades from the walls, replaced by new worries, new headlines. But the tree remains. The case remains. For decades, the remains are kept in the Birmingham City Police’s 'black museum' at their Tally Ho! training center. It’s a place of forgotten things, where evidence sits in drawers, slowly deteriorating. Until the late 1960s or early 1970s, no one seems to revisit the physical proof. The file gathers dust. In 2014, West Mercia Police conduct a formal review of the case. They look at the old notes, the old photos, the old hypotheses. And they close the review. Not because they solved it, but because the trail has gone cold. The hope fades, but it doesn’t disappear. Because some mysteries refuse to stay buried. Then, in 2018, a television program called Nazi Murder Mysteries brings the case back into the light. They commission a forensic facial reconstruction from Liverpool John Moores University’s 'Face Lab.' Using photographs of the skull, they create an image of what Bella might have looked like. It’s a face brought back from the dead, staring out at us, demanding to be recognized. It’s a powerful moment. It reminds us that behind the bones is a person. Behind the mystery is a heartbeat that stopped too soon. We are living in a new era of truth. In May 2023, the BBC launches an appeal. They aren’t just asking for tips; they are asking museums and archives to help track down the victim’s remains. Why? To carry out DNA analysis. Modern science offers tools that weren’t available in 1943. We can now match genetic markers, trace lineages, and perhaps finally give Bella her name back. This isn’t just about solving a crime. It’s about restoring dignity. It’s about acknowledging that she existed, that she mattered, and that her story deserves to be told correctly. The podcast The Body in the Tree accompanies this appeal, weaving together the history, the science, and the human element. It invites listeners to hold that thought with me: that every unsolved case is a wound in our collective conscience. We don’t know who killed her. We don’t know why she was chosen. But we know she was loved, or at least claimed, by someone who left a ring with her. We know she was afraid, or trapped, or silenced. And we know that eight decades later, we are still listening. Still searching. Still refusing to let her vanish into the void. The search doesn’t end until they’re home. And for Bella, home is knowing her name. Thank you for sitting with me today. Thank you for listening to the silence between the facts, and for honoring the memory of a woman who has waited so long to be known. Let’s remember who they were. This story is drawn from public records and widely reported accounts. Our thoughts are with everyone affected.