Latest / Film And Whiskey / The Apartment / Bunnahabhain 12
Transcript
- 0:00In 1960 director, Billy Wilder and star Jack Lemmon gave the
- 0:05world a peek into the sleazy world of high class.
- 0:08Manhattan in 2021. We return to the Ila region for
- 0:12a single malt. Scotch the film is the
- 0:15apartment. The whiskey is banana hovind 12
- 0:19and we'll review them both. This is the film and whiskey
- 0:24podcast. Welcome to the film and whiskey
- 0:44podcast, where each week, we review a classic movie and a
- 0:47glass of whiskey. I'm Bob book, I'm Brad G and
- 0:51this week we are looking at the 1960 Best Picture Winner, Billy
- 0:56Wilder's, the apartment Brad. I have been waiting to talk.
- 1:00About this movie for years. And I purposely did not put it
- 1:04in our first few seasons because I you're still a wild card, man.
- 1:08You're such a wild card. I never know what you're going
- 1:10to think of a movie. The way you said that have you
- 1:13just like never spoken of this movie a single time.
- 1:17You've just like watched it and know I've a kylin I've just been
- 1:20running on the journal, your thoughts.
- 1:22I've been running down the street just like shaking people
- 1:24and say have you seen it? Have you seen the other are not
- 1:28know. Honestly Brad this is Is this is
- 1:30one of my favorite films of all time and watching it again.
- 1:33I you know, I haven't washed it since we started doing the
- 1:35podcast because I wanted to wait and watch it with the more
- 1:38critical eye. Again, I can't wait to get into
- 1:40talking about it. I sincerely hope you liked it,
- 1:43but before we get into any of those questions, the most
- 1:46important question, Brad, had you seen had you heard of the
- 1:50movie, the apartment prior to watching it for our podcast,
- 1:53Bro? You've got me on two weeks in a
- 1:55row of movies that I'd never even heard of, man.
- 1:58You know, I'm kind of surprised you.
- 1:59I heard of this one especially since you have been such a big
- 2:02fan of the to Billy Wilder movies that we've done to this
- 2:05point. I thought maybe you would have
- 2:07gone and looked kind of looked through his filmography at some
- 2:09point but bro, know if we win I'm taking minimal effort some
- 2:14sort of cinephile, Didi's, get degrees.
- 2:17That's dude, I gotta say man, is we got the same piece of papers.
- 2:23That's right. All right, so you had not even
- 2:26heard of the apartment. I'm really glad that you went
- 2:29into this kind of old and I am waiting with baited breath to
- 2:32hear what you thought of it. Brad, why don't you just give us
- 2:35kind of initial Impressions on the movie?
- 2:37What do you think of it? I, you know, if All About Eve is
- 2:41one of the most underwhelming Best Picture winners ever.
- 2:44I would have to put the apartment in, probably, like, I
- 2:48don't know the top 20 to 30 percent of Best Picture winners,
- 2:52I've ever seen. There you go, like it's solid.
- 2:55I like, I can 100% understand why this Back best picture.
- 3:01You know, I think if you put it up against some of the other
- 3:03greats, it would, it would clearly lose.
- 3:07But in the year where, you know, obviously I don't know what the
- 3:09heck was going on in cinema in 1960, but in a year where there
- 3:13weren't any other like, massive contenders, this is just I think
- 3:17it's just one of the best films comedic dramas I've ever seen in
- 3:22my life and more emphasis on the drama.
- 3:25You know the comedic elements. Just barely lighten it up enough
- 3:29to make it almost feel like real life.
- 3:32Yeah. More than like a drama.
- 3:33Does that make sense? Absolutely.
- 3:34And Brad I would, I don't want to correct you right off the bat
- 3:36here. But you did have some idea of
- 3:38what was going on in cinema, in the year 1960, because you and I
- 3:42watched Alfred Hitchcock's Psycho just last season and that
- 3:46was the other, you know, kind of really big popular controversial
- 3:49movie that came out in the year 1960.
- 3:52So, you know, this is better than psycho.
- 3:54Just looking at those two movies side-by-side, I really do think
- 3:58that this might be kind of an underrated Needed year for
- 4:00Cinema, in terms of really kind of pushing the medium forward.
- 4:04And talking about things that hadn't been talked about, you
- 4:07know, just from Some Like It Hot to this movie, I feel like Billy
- 4:11Wilder, really took a deep dive into some themes that you, you
- 4:14just didn't see explored in mainstream entertainment in that
- 4:19time period. Yeah, I mean you're jumping in
- 4:21here with like really heavy themes of infidelity of suicide
- 4:27of a man trying to On his way to the top, I guess.
- 4:32And you just see all these things, kind of crashing into
- 4:35one another, you know, all in order to tell a simple love
- 4:39story. But I just can't imagine this
- 4:42coming out in 1960. Honestly, Bob, as I was watching
- 4:44this, I had two main thoughts and I'll get to the second one
- 4:48eventually. But my first, main thought was
- 4:50this, if you have ever watched the TV show, Mad Men, the entire
- 4:56show was based off of this movie.
- 4:59But have you ever watched mad I have?
- 5:01Yeah, yeah I mean tell me that I'm wrong.
- 5:03No, I will show was based off the whole vibe is just it's
- 5:07right here. The blueprint was laid.
- 5:09Yeah. And so I think that what you see
- 5:11here is, I don't want to call it like an expose but I think that
- 5:16what Wilder was doing was just this criticism of like men who
- 5:21are in power and think that they can get whatever they want and
- 5:24he did that by putting this unassuming nice guy kind of a
- 5:29guy. Against them.
- 5:30And in the end, the nice guy wins.
- 5:33Yeah. And he's not a sleaze ball, and
- 5:34he gets the girl, and it's just a really cute unique and
- 5:40surprisingly deep film. Well, before we get any further
- 5:43Brad, because my sneaking suspicion will be that, not many
- 5:46people will have seen this movie coming into listening to this
- 5:49episode, and I already would wholeheartedly say, go watch
- 5:53this movie, you will not be disappointed.
- 5:54I think this is the kind of movie even like you said, Brad
- 5:58that you may not I come away from it, loving it, as much as I
- 6:02do, where I'm ranking it in like my top 10 favorite movies ever.
- 6:05But I don't really know of anyone that would watch this
- 6:08movie and walk away. Not having been entertained.
- 6:12This just seems like a crowd-pleasing kind of movie.
- 6:15Yeah. I, you know, for a movie that
- 6:17deals with like, incredibly deep subjects and honestly is almost
- 6:21gratuitous in the way that it shows it for 4 1960, you know,
- 6:26which really I would say for 1950s Cinema like Like I would
- 6:31say this is one of the more entertaining films we watched in
- 6:33a while. Yeah, well I mean like now it's
- 6:3561 years old and I feel like some of these scenes especially,
- 6:39I mean truly hold up in 2021 and we'll get to a pretty harrowing
- 6:44sequence later on but it reminded me of a movie that is
- 6:48more recent and I think actually this movie may have done it
- 6:51better but before we get into all that it is time for us to
- 6:54talk. Brad explains.
- 6:56This is the part of the podcast, where Brad breaks down the plot
- 6:59of the movie that he Is just seen often for the first time.
- 7:02Obviously that is the case today.
- 7:04Brad. As you know, we have
- 7:05implemented, a strict 60-second timer on Brad explains this
- 7:10year. Can you walk us through the plot
- 7:12of the movie, the apartment in under one minute?
- 7:16Jack Lemmon is a nice guy. Fred MacMurray is Shirley
- 7:20MacLaine is in love with the and he'd ruins her life.
- 7:24She tried to commit suicide. Jack, Lemmon saves her.
- 7:27They fall in love. Whoo!
- 7:29Ooh, all right, you did it in 15 seconds.
- 7:32Now I'm gonna, I'm gonna require you to go a bit deeper because
- 7:37because the one of the big parts of this movie is the kind of
- 7:40like you said, I don't want to expose, or even satire, but the
- 7:44portrayal of corporate America in the late 1950s early 60s.
- 7:50Like, I don't think you can really talk about this movie
- 7:52without talking about the endless rows and rows of desks
- 7:56on this floor, that, that Jack Clemons character Baxter.
- 7:59Works on like the idea of corporate America, and these
- 8:04upper level Executives who think they're entitled to everything
- 8:07really kind of permeates the whole movie.
- 8:10Oh yeah. No II called him a.
- 8:12I thought we all knew that that was just like code for Corporate
- 8:15America and America. Yeah, right on, man.
- 8:17Absolutely, no. I honestly, I think that it, I
- 8:21don't know it as somebody in 2021 watching this film.
- 8:26I feel like it's almost just taken for granted that like
- 8:30High-powered businesses business executives are just like either
- 8:34like average to terrible people. Like I don't know if there's any
- 8:38of them that are really that good.
- 8:40And so there's already such a distrust of corporate America on
- 8:44the average citizens end that I do feel like it dulls the edge
- 8:50of this movie a little bit, but I can appreciate the fact that
- 8:53this is probably one of the first like honest attempts at
- 8:57saying, hey, like this isn't okay.
- 8:59Like all of these people who are working in this company are real
- 9:03people and just because you guys can go and have your Lover's
- 9:07tryst at this dude's apartment because he's a bachelor, doesn't
- 9:11make him worth promoting. It doesn't make you guys get P.
- 9:15Like it's just all bad. All bad all around Brad.
- 9:18As always. You continue to be incredibly
- 9:21eloquent. It bad all bad.
- 9:24It's bad for you bad. All right it's okay.
- 9:28I do want to jump in here and kind of Round out, Brad explains
- 9:30a little bit. So the the essential plot of the
- 9:33movie is that Jack. Lemons character Baxter is kind
- 9:37of a lower level employee working for this giant Insurance
- 9:40firm in New York City and he is climbing the corporate ladder by
- 9:45allowing his superiors. And people in Administration, in
- 9:47this building, to use his apartment to have affairs in.
- 9:51He is lending out his key. And what I really love about the
- 9:55place that the movie starts Brad, is that you can tell from
- 9:59the Beginning of this movie that we are coming into this
- 10:03situation when it's already spiraling out of control, you
- 10:07know what I mean? Like we don't see the first time
- 10:09Jack Lemmon kind of gives his apartment over to somebody.
- 10:11We don't see that slippery slope, we see Jack Lemmon, you
- 10:15know, even though the opening narration where he's talking
- 10:17about how his apartment, so, great for a bachelor and you
- 10:20sound, so chipper, but the way they're framing it with the
- 10:23camera, is this, incredibly lonely?
- 10:26Like there's just an expanse around him and Jack Lemon is
- 10:30just walking down the street with no one around him and you
- 10:33can tell that he is already feeling this intense loneliness
- 10:36and regret for what he's doing with his apartment to the point
- 10:40where, you know, he's basically been kicked out of his own
- 10:42apartment because his boss needs to you know have an affair and
- 10:46he ends up sleeping on a park bench.
- 10:48And I really liked that Wilder allows us as the audience to be
- 10:53dropped right into that situation when it's already
- 10:56falling apart and not have to feel like he needs to walk.
- 10:59Us through and give us, you know, tip us off at every
- 11:03instance like oh, this is bad. You can just tell from the
- 11:06beginning. This guy is in over his head.
- 11:09One might say that he drops us and media rests.
- 11:13That's very true. Boom.
- 11:15Brad learned a Latin phrase today.
- 11:18Hey man, I learned that like a while ago.
- 11:21Now, I love one of my favorite Parts about the opening and
- 11:24ending of this film. I, I love whenever a movie
- 11:27bookends things, right? Yeah.
- 11:29And I love that at the start of this film, you see, Jack Lemmon
- 11:33get the wrong key. You know, the dude leaves the
- 11:35wrong key and it's actually the key to the executive washroom
- 11:39but like he gets this key and it's almost like a symbol of
- 11:42like, well one day I'll have this key and it won't just be
- 11:44accidentally left underneath, you know, my carpet.
- 11:47And at the end of the film, what happens?
- 11:50He gives him the key to the executive washroom back so that
- 11:53he can win his love. Yeah.
- 11:55And I just I loved how they bookended this movie with that,
- 11:58you know, kind of Plot device if you will, Brad, I feel like we
- 12:02are slowly, revealing tidbits of information, about this film to
- 12:05our listeners. And I feel like we should
- 12:08probably just go ahead and completely spoil the whole
- 12:11thing. You know, we do spoilers on this
- 12:12podcast. So, if we haven't already given
- 12:15away enough, we're going to go ahead and just give the whole
- 12:17thing away here. Jack Lemmon is kind of secretly
- 12:20pining for has a crush on the elevator girl played by Shirley
- 12:24MacLaine. Her name is Miss kubelik and
- 12:27unbeknownst to Jack. Lemmon one of the most senior
- 12:31Executives in the building, the guy who's in charge of
- 12:33personnel. Essentially, the HR, you know,
- 12:36vice president of this company is having an affair with Miss
- 12:41cubic and you come to find it out about halfway through the
- 12:44movie. It all kind of clicks into place
- 12:46for Baxter and the second half of the movie is him dealing with
- 12:49the Fallout of before black of a better term, you know, aiding
- 12:53and abetting this affair not just you know the Fallout for
- 12:58himself and his emotions but Fallout in terms of what's
- 13:01happening with with Fran, Miss kubelik internally and by the
- 13:05end of the film, you know, he does he quits the job.
- 13:08He gets the girl like everything gets patched up but Brad you
- 13:12even texted me at one point today and said you were about
- 13:14halfway through the movie and you were right at the scene that
- 13:18I think is maybe the most crucial and pivotal scene of the
- 13:21whole movie and what happens is Jack Lemmon allows his boss to
- 13:26use the apartment for an affair. He finds a little pocket mirror
- 13:29that That has been left behind and he returns it to his boss.
- 13:33Sheldrake played by Fred MacMurray, and a few days after
- 13:36that they're having the office Christmas party.
- 13:38And he shows miscue Bullock his brand new office because he
- 13:43keeps getting promoted miraculously and he's saying a
- 13:47look at this incredible office that I have.
- 13:48And she pulls out this pocket mirror and he recognizes that
- 13:52it's hers because it's cracked down the middle and it all
- 13:55clicks into place for him. He didn't know that she was the
- 13:58one that his boss was. Affair with.
- 14:00She doesn't know that he is the one whose apartment she was in.
- 14:05Yeah, I mean, what we're talking about here, Bob is just an
- 14:08amazing script, right? And, you know, they're talking
- 14:11and he's shown her his office and he sees this and he kind of,
- 14:16you can see his entire tone shift, you know, which once
- 14:20again, one of the signs of a great actor, is their ability to
- 14:23move, like, facially from one emotion to the other.
- 14:26And you see him like, like, Almost audibly shift in this
- 14:31tone to like, sadness and realization.
- 14:34And she kind of asked him. What's wrong?
- 14:36And he tries to catch himself. He goes, oh well, your mirror.
- 14:39It's broken and she goes. Yes, I know.
- 14:44I like it that way, makes me look the way I feel, and it's
- 14:48just little moments like that throughout this film that like,
- 14:53they're not funny. They're like, they're dramatic,
- 14:56like, obviously Wilder is known for his comedy and, you know,
- 14:59something like Could hot. It just cuts to the core.
- 15:02You see the depth of sadness in Franz heart and in her
- 15:07self-image and in her understanding of who she is.
- 15:11And you just feel that desire that Jack Lemmon has to like
- 15:15figure out what the heck is going.
- 15:16Absolutely and and you feel these two different people
- 15:19having two different tensions, right?
- 15:21Because Fran is finding out that her lover and boss is actually
- 15:26just a Serial you know, romanticize Iran has had Add
- 15:29tons of flings and Baxter is finding out that his Crush has
- 15:34been taken in by an older sleaze ball and neither of them know
- 15:38what to do about it. And they awkwardly, leave the
- 15:41room and it just it's just pitch.
- 15:44Perfect. Best scene of the film.
- 15:46You know, I want to touch on a couple things that you said,
- 15:48Brad Pitt. The first thing that keeps
- 15:49coming to my mind is the way that Billy Wilder draws out and
- 15:53really makes clear to the audience, the kind of pervading
- 15:57sense of loneliness in this V and I talked about it with
- 16:01Baxter a little bit. Obviously Fran played by Shirley
- 16:04MacLaine is feeling it as well, but I think that everything in
- 16:09this movie really highlights, the the fact that these are two
- 16:14very lonely people and that by the time that you get to like
- 16:18that big office party scene, he has done such a good job of
- 16:22establishing their motivations that you notice the contrast
- 16:26between everybody outside of Baxter's do off.
- 16:29His door who are having this like raucous, debaucherous
- 16:33party. And the fact that these two
- 16:35people can be standing right next to that and they, and they
- 16:39are still so profoundly alone. I think that Scorsese might have
- 16:44something to say about, you know, that looking like a
- 16:47debaucherous party because for him, this is like the most tame
- 16:50thing. That's very true spread.
- 16:52That's very true. I would like to see this mashed
- 16:55up with Wolf of Wall Street, somehow I was going to say
- 16:57that's an easy easy man. Nothing you could do.
- 17:02Yeah, Brett. I mean I just I was really
- 17:04struck by the cinematography in this movie and it was shot in
- 17:07black and white on purpose at a time when most movies were being
- 17:10shot in color. I think it really does kind of
- 17:12continue to highlight. Like I said, the loneliness of
- 17:15these characters, they went super wide with the widescreen
- 17:18and I think that was intentional as well.
- 17:20I don't know. Brad.
- 17:21Did you find that the photography, you know, the
- 17:23cinematography stuck out to you? I think one of my favorite
- 17:26scenes was literally the very opening one when you you see
- 17:29Baxter working and then you slowly cut from one scene of him
- 17:34and everybody bustling around him to him by himself with empty
- 17:39row after row after row. Like obviously a lot of
- 17:42different movies have used that trick of the Mindless drone and
- 17:46you show you know, row after row of secretaries working or like
- 17:52assembly workers at a factory and you just, you know, show
- 17:55them mindlessly working. But I feel like this was one of
- 17:57the most beautiful ones because it homes Deeply in on Jack
- 18:00Lemmon and just his predicament in life of being a nobody and
- 18:06Brad. I think that we should talk
- 18:07about the three main performances in this movie and
- 18:09since we're already talking about Jack Lemmon let's dive
- 18:12into his performance. Here I have to say Jack Lemmon
- 18:16is one of my favorite actors of all time and and part of that is
- 18:20because for as incredible of an actor is he is he always seems
- 18:25authentically Jack Lemmon I don't know how else to phrase
- 18:28it, it's kind of like Like Tom Hanks where, you know, you will
- 18:32suspend disbelief to watch him be, you know, Captain Sully or
- 18:36Captain Phillips or whoever it might be in these movies that
- 18:39you're watching but at the end of the day you you trust him,
- 18:43you know, him because he is Tom Hanks and you you know, you have
- 18:47this attachment to him. And with Jack Lemmon by all
- 18:50accounts, he was as authentic of a person in real life as he was,
- 18:55you know, playing a character like Baxter and I think that
- 18:58that authenticity A city that earnestness really really helps
- 19:02him here in this performance. Please miss cubic, you gotta
- 19:06promise me. You won't do anything foolish,
- 19:08who care? I would I can't I ever fall in
- 19:18love with somebody nice like you Yeah.
- 19:22Well that's the way crumbles cookie wise Yeah, I mean I think
- 19:29that, you know, we talked we mentioned the script for a
- 19:31minute here that this is like a really witty and sharp script
- 19:34but I don't think that it would go anywhere if it wasn't for the
- 19:38performance of Jack Lemmon like and there's so many little
- 19:42moments throughout the film. But like when he was in his
- 19:45bathroom after Shirley MacLaine has attempted suicide and you
- 19:50see him slowly like grabbing things that she could try and
- 19:54kill herself with. And like hiding them and you see
- 19:57him keep looking back into the room with care and you just feel
- 20:02the seriousness of the situation, you know?
- 20:04And as somebody who has had friends, who have desired to
- 20:08commit suicide and have attempted like, for me in that
- 20:12moment watching him, I like, I understood him.
- 20:15Yeah, understood that motivation of.
- 20:18I just want to care for my friend, and I think that's one
- 20:21of the most important things in this movie is that, is that
- 20:25backs. Really views Fran as a friend
- 20:29and potential love interest and it's not just a love interest.
- 20:34I don't know. Did you get that sense?
- 20:36Yeah, for sure. And Jack Lemmon is one of the
- 20:38few actors that I think can really go from being kind of
- 20:41this lovable. I don't as a clown but you know,
- 20:44there are moments where he's being goofball goofball.
- 20:46Yeah I mean but there are moments where he's being very
- 20:48performative even for the people in the movie like when he's
- 20:52trying to cheer up Shirley MacLaine and he's cooking
- 20:54spaghetti and straining. Get through a tennis racket and
- 20:57you know humming a fake little Italian song.
- 21:00And then there's moments where you know, you watch him in just
- 21:03this state of despondency where he's drinking himself into a
- 21:07stupor in a bar and it's all completely believable.
- 21:11And even from one scene, to the net, like, you know, that scene
- 21:14where he's in the office with Fran cubic and he finds the
- 21:18mirror or, you know, she pulls out the mirror, right before
- 21:20that. He decides he wants to model
- 21:23this dumb hat that he got for himself and it's like It's the
- 21:26best little sight gag in the whole movie because the hat
- 21:28looks horrible, and he stands there with his bowler on his
- 21:32head and he holds it for a beat and she's clearly not into it
- 21:36because she's thinking about how heartbroken she is.
- 21:39And it really highlights, not just how Billy Wilder is able to
- 21:43balance, you know, the comedy in the tragedy.
- 21:45So, so effortlessly, but like you said how much he had to rely
- 21:49on Jack, Lemmon to make those transitions so seamless.
- 21:53Well, I think the best way to To illustrate, this is to contrast
- 21:57it with Some Like It. Hot like the beauty of Some
- 22:00Like, It Hot, is that the comedy steers?
- 22:03Like it just veers right into the Absurd, right?
- 22:06It's just over the top and ridiculous and you have Jack
- 22:10Lemmon at the height of his powers just being flat-out.
- 22:14Funny. And the difference of this movie
- 22:16is that his comedy is always grounded in reality, like tell
- 22:21me that you couldn't imagine some Bachelor using a tennis
- 22:24racket to strain his Getty like it's 100% believable and the way
- 22:29he does, it is charming and relaxed.
- 22:31And you can feel this sense of like, oh, well, like I'm in my
- 22:35element. I'm in my home.
- 22:36I'm caring for a woman that I see as a friend.
- 22:39And as somebody, I kind of like, and I just everything about his
- 22:43performance, kept the core of the movie, which is this drama
- 22:48of, you know, Fran and her desire to find love their
- 22:54everything about His performance keeps that feeling real and if
- 22:59he had veered into the Absurd at all, you know, which credit to
- 23:02Billy Wilder for directing him. Well, that, if he had gone over
- 23:06the top in an instant, I think it would have discredited the
- 23:09entire, like core of the film. Yeah.
- 23:12And countering him, you know, are balancing him out.
- 23:15I guess in some ways, is Shirley MacLaine as Fran, she is 26
- 23:19years old, in this movie, she's only been acting in movies for
- 23:21five years. At this point, she is kind of A
- 23:26really quickly ascending star in Hollywood and watching this
- 23:31movie, this time, Brad, I've probably seen this movie 10
- 23:33times through. I have always always been blown
- 23:35away by Jack, Lemmon watching it this time I was like how did I
- 23:41miss how incredible she is in this movie?
- 23:44Because she is acting in such a naturalistic way that I forgot
- 23:51at many points of the movie that I was watching someone pretend
- 23:55to be be somebody else. She's so perfectly embodies this
- 24:00heartbroken depressed person and every single line reading that
- 24:07she does is so authentic and not only that but she knows to not
- 24:12be showy about any of it and she knows that, you know, Jack
- 24:16Lemmon has the these sillier more showy performance in this
- 24:20movie and so she has to balance him out by being a little more
- 24:23subdued and Sadly, it's not the kind of performance that you
- 24:27really take note of, unless you have seen the movie a few times,
- 24:30I feel like and this time through I'm thinking to myself
- 24:33my gosh this might be one of the best female performances I've
- 24:37ever seen in a movie and I have been overlooking it all these
- 24:41years. I just walked out of me, quit
- 24:45through that, big fat, John right in my face.
- 24:49The nerve. Anyway.
- 25:03I guess that's the way it crumbles.
- 25:06Cookie wise. Are you talking about?
- 25:12I'd spell it out for you only, I can't spell well, you know that
- 25:17was Bob. It's the fact that in a time
- 25:21where it feels like every single movie was trying to make their
- 25:24female leads a Marilyn Monroe, you know?
- 25:28And I say this with all respect because I actually really like,
- 25:31Marilyn Monroe in her movies but they are trying to make their
- 25:34leads ditzy and dumb and not only their leads, but I feel
- 25:38like women were portrayed in a pretty terrible way in general
- 25:41as being just Ridiculously stupid and unaware of men's
- 25:46intentions with them and just buying any lie that they were
- 25:49fed, I think that Shirley MacLaine in this film, portrays
- 25:54a more real woman who was caught up in the lies of a manipulative
- 26:00just jerk. And you get the sense that she's
- 26:03a real girl. You don't ever get the sense
- 26:07that she is faking. Anyway.
- 26:09And I honestly Bob, I've talked about this before on the
- 26:11podcast, Authenticity. I think that's what you're
- 26:15looking for in a lot of different films and in this one
- 26:19you have two characters that just come across so perfectly
- 26:24authentic of being who they are going to be Shirley MacLaine
- 26:28knocks it, out of the freaking Park in this movie.
- 26:31And I really think one of my favorite scenes for her is the
- 26:34very final one, where she comes into Jack Clemons apartment and
- 26:38just matter-of-factly starts playing gin rummy, hmm.
- 26:41And like She's she's kind of playing Coy kind of playing
- 26:45hard-to-get even though he knows for 100% that he has her and
- 26:48when she doesn't answer him when he says that I love you, it's
- 26:53just this like fun playful little acknowledgement of like,
- 26:56yeah, I know you love me. Let's play some Gin Rummy.
- 26:59It's just it's just perfect. Yeah, I mean I was watching
- 27:02little moments like when sheldrake her boss or you know
- 27:06the the executive that she's sleeping with his secretary
- 27:09basically Corners her and confronts her.
- 27:12The information that he's been doing this with girls for years
- 27:14now and that she herself was one of them and watching Shirley
- 27:18MacLaine react is, it's such a like, it was almost cringey.
- 27:23Like, it was like watching those.
- 27:25Those are really hard to watch episodes of the office in some
- 27:27ways because she plays it, so naturally, like, she's trying to
- 27:31laugh it off and she's turning her head away and saying like,
- 27:34you know, you have to excuse me and it's the way she embodies
- 27:38the embarrassment. It's so perfectly done that.
- 27:42You like like I said, I forgot I was watching an actress at some
- 27:45point and that I think is the highest compliment I can
- 27:48possibly give to somebody well. And when you talk about
- 27:52authenticity and disability you know like you said of Shirley
- 27:55MacLaine to just keep the audience drawn in with just how
- 28:00real her performances. I think you have Fred MacMurray
- 28:03as the foil to that of just being the most sleazy over the
- 28:09top villain that I think that this Movie kind of needed like
- 28:14with all of the groundedness of the other characters.
- 28:17I don't think it would have served the film to have a
- 28:20executive who genuinely had a terrible marriage and was like
- 28:24genuinely struggling. All this like it really needed
- 28:27to have a corporate high-powered.
- 28:29Honestly, in a certain sense, no name, nobody who's just out for
- 28:33his own. Well and I thought the Fred
- 28:35MacMurray was great at that. I completely agree and I'm going
- 28:38to say that it's going to sound like an insult Brad, but I hope
- 28:40you understand what I mean when I say this I think it actually
- 28:43benefited the movie to have Fred MacMurray in this role, because
- 28:47he is not as good of an actor as the other two, like, in the late
- 28:5350s, early 60s, you really started to see some of these
- 28:56older actors, who had been, you know, making movies in the 30s
- 28:58and 40s started to be in films with these people that were
- 29:02coming out of the Actors Studio in New York, and we're into
- 29:04method acting and it was like, watching two completely
- 29:07different clashing styles of acting on screen and sometimes
- 29:11it worked and sometimes And it was really obvious, and I think
- 29:14this is one of those times, where, you know, Fred MacMurray
- 29:16is just kind of a wooden actor. He doesn't have a lot of range
- 29:20and I think I thought that works really well in Double Indemnity
- 29:22when he's playing this hard-boiled, kind of guy and
- 29:25here it works really well too. Because, you know, we keep using
- 29:27the word, but he's just a dick and he plays the really, really
- 29:31well, but he doesn't overdo it and I think there are a lot of
- 29:36people who would have either tried to play it to
- 29:38naturalistically, or tried to play it to hammy, and he doesn't
- 29:41do either one. Of those things.
- 29:42And I think the movie really benefits because of that.
- 29:45Honestly, I think one of the scenes that illustrates that
- 29:48movement or that almost the Baton being passed from Fred
- 29:52MacMurray generation on to Jack. Clemons generation is the very
- 29:56final scene between the two of them.
- 29:58When Jack Lemmon quits, there's this one singular moment that I
- 30:02just loved way, where Fred MacMurray goes now.
- 30:07I thought you were a bright man. See, I thought you were, you
- 30:10were understanding your place in this world.
- 30:12See you? You just give me the key right
- 30:15now. You see?
- 30:16And sorry. Mr. Chaudhary What do you mean?
- 30:19Sorry, you're not going to bring anybody to my apartment.
- 30:23I'm not just bringing anybody. I'm bringing this Cube lie.
- 30:25Especially, not miss Cube lie. How's that again?
- 30:28No key. Baxter.
- 30:33I picked you for my team because I thought you were a very bright
- 30:35young man. Do you realize what you're
- 30:38doing? Not to me, but to yourself,
- 30:40normally, it takes years to work your way up to the 27th floor,
- 30:44but it only takes 30 seconds to be out on the street again.
- 30:47You dig? I dig, he looks up into Jack
- 30:52Clemons eyes and obviously, I'm exaggerating some but he goes,
- 30:55You Dig and Jack. Lemmon goes, oh yeah.
- 31:00I dig. And like, it just felt like
- 31:02this, like, symbolic moment of, like, you dig was a terrible,
- 31:08terrible line. And like, jet the way Jack
- 31:11Lemmon just throws it back at him casually.
- 31:14I just felt like that was a moment where I was just like, I
- 31:17just, I loved every second of this.
- 31:19There was a moment in this movie and you know will censor this
- 31:21for the the wide release but patreon you'll get an earful
- 31:25here. There's a moment where I just
- 31:27looked at the screen and I wanted my breath.
- 31:29There's no one else in the room. Oh, just like you mother like I
- 31:34I said it out loud to the screen and it's the moment where a
- 31:38sheldrake Fred MacMurray. And Miss kubelik are in the
- 31:41apartment together for the first time.
- 31:43And she gets him, a Christmas present, and it's a, it's a
- 31:47recording, it's an LP. Of The Pianist in the restaurant
- 31:51that they go to. And the first thing he does is
- 31:53he says, well you know, we better leave that here.
- 31:56Meaning I can't take this home to my wife, I'll have to explain
- 31:58things and she goes, yeah, we better leave it here and then he
- 32:01says well you know II didn't get you anything but here's a
- 32:05hundred dollars and he pulls a hundred dollar bill out of his
- 32:07wallet and the way they frame it Brad they cut back to her on the
- 32:10couch and it is like at eye level with her sitting on the
- 32:13couch. So you basically just see like
- 32:15Fred mcmurray's waste he's and you just see this, huh?
- 32:19Two dollar bill kind of like fall into frame while she's
- 32:22looking at him with this. Look of just utter contempt and
- 32:27and hatred, and it was the most crushing thing to watch him drop
- 32:33this hundred dollar bill at her. It basically has a way of saying
- 32:37like you are nothing but a cheap whore to me and it like that
- 32:40scene and that the way they framed it, visually, I think
- 32:44will forever be burned in my mind, and the way that she
- 32:47stands up and like, takes her It off and and he just goes,
- 32:51although we don't really have any time for that and he and
- 32:54she, I don't remember exactly how she says it, but she
- 32:57basically says, well, if you already paid for it, I figured,
- 33:00I might as well. See ya.
- 33:02And you're just like, oh man, and he just kind of goes on,
- 33:06don't talk like that. Okay, bye, right.
- 33:10Yeah, he's I mean, all three of them are great in this movie,
- 33:13Brad. I don't think we're saying
- 33:14anything, like revolutionary here.
- 33:16There's movies really good, the acting is phenomenal.
- 33:18The script is great. Rate.
- 33:19The direction is fantastic. I think it's time for us to hit
- 33:22pause and drink some whiskey. So what do you say?
- 33:25We sip on some single malt scotch and try this Buna haben
- 33:2812? Yes, let's drink it.
- 34:14Alright, today we are checking out Buna Haven. 12-year Brad.
- 34:18This might be the most fun to say, name of any whiskey we've
- 34:22ever had on this show. I love the Scottish people and
- 34:26their names. And this one Buna haben is one
- 34:30that I'm going to say at least 50 times in this segment.
- 34:32So just prepare yourself. I don't know man.
- 34:35The nectar nectar might have been that might be our best.
- 34:42We probably should run a segment on Instagram with the just the
- 34:45best names of whiskey. That's right time.
- 34:47That's true. I broke logic is right up there,
- 34:50too. That's right, man.
- 34:52All right, so Buna, hob and 12 year is an interesting whiskey
- 34:55Brad. This is an I'll, uh, scotch.
- 34:56And as we know, Ila scotches are usually very heavily peated.
- 35:01Think Laphroaig, but Boone, aha Van Gogh's, an opposite route.
- 35:05They really don't heavily Peach their Scotch at all.
- 35:08In fact, as I know Agnes, I'm not getting many, you know, any
- 35:11Pete at all. So it may be completely
- 35:12unpainted for all. I know, this particular
- 35:16expression of Buna, haben 12 was kind of revamped back in the
- 35:19year 2010, they upped the proof on it to 46.3%.
- 35:25So we're looking at a basically, a 92 and a half proof whiskey
- 35:28here. It's non chill filtered and they
- 35:30have not added any coloration to it.
- 35:32One thing we've really never talked about on this show, is
- 35:34that unlike bourbon with Scotch. They can actually add caramel
- 35:39Alluring to Scotch whisky to make it look darker in the
- 35:42glass, and it doesn't affect anything.
- 35:44They have to put on the label. It's still considered Scotch.
- 35:47So there's actually been a pretty big movement in the
- 35:49scotch world to stop doing that and just present, you know, the
- 35:53whiskey, the way that it's supposed to look in the glass.
- 35:55So it has a much lighter look in the glass, but that's just
- 35:57because they haven't added any coloration to it, dude.
- 36:01They just need to listen to The Beatles, man.
- 36:03Let it be, let it be let it be. That's right.
- 36:06And there's our copyright strike for this episode.
- 36:09Kaboom, you're welcome. Well Brad, let's get into
- 36:12drinking this. I'm really excited.
- 36:13This is the second week in what three weeks now.
- 36:16Brad, that we are drinking Scotch, so I'm excited to get
- 36:19back into drinking some single malt.
- 36:20Scotch whiskey, what are you picking up on the nose of this
- 36:23Buna? Haben?
- 36:2412-year, honestly, I think that you can still get a little bit
- 36:28of that smoke. And it's not, you know, I'm not
- 36:31to calling this a peated scotch, but there's a little bit of that
- 36:33smokiness for me. It's actually coming across a
- 36:36little bit, alcohol forward. There's some hints of saline
- 36:41flowers and a little bit of just generic sweetness.
- 36:46But yeah, it's a nice pleasant. Smelling knows that I'll give a
- 36:517 out of 10. Are you ready for this Brad?
- 36:53Because a couple weeks ago we did a burl our 16 and a burl our
- 36:5718. Mmm.
- 36:58And while I remember yes, and while I liked both of those
- 37:01whiskies, you were much more. What's the word effusive in your
- 37:05praise and I was a little bit more reserved and Brad, I think
- 37:08the tables are To be turned this time because I want ahead and
- 37:11took all my notes on this already.
- 37:13I love this whiskey. I love it.
- 37:16Brad, this nose is beautiful. I mean, if you just kind of, let
- 37:21it air out a little bit in the glass because it's been in our
- 37:23sample bottle for a while, it has layers of butterscotch.
- 37:27And caramel, you can get a little bit of that malt on it,
- 37:30but for me, it was stone fruit. I got a lot of Peach on this.
- 37:33I got dark chocolate notes. Just on the nose of this.
- 37:36I found this to be incredibly complex.
- 37:39It's still very light and you can tell like you said, Brad
- 37:43that there is some alcohol on it.
- 37:44I didn't find it to be offensive.
- 37:46I didn't find it to be alcohol forward.
- 37:47I love this knows. I'm actually going to give us an
- 37:50eight and a half on the nose. Brad.
- 37:52Yeah. That is pretty high up there and
- 37:55a lot of words that you just said, but when I get into the
- 37:58taste, I think that honestly it's kind of at a similar point
- 38:02for me. There's a few hints of vanilla
- 38:04there that are kind of under written by really strong saline.
- 38:07Taste that I'm getting I'm not getting blown away by any one
- 38:12particular note, its kind of vaguely sweet and kind of
- 38:17pleasureful. And so I'll just I'll call it a
- 38:197 out of 10. One thing that I've been doing
- 38:21the last few weeks, Brad, when we're tasting Whiskey's,
- 38:23especially because, you know, sometimes we record right after
- 38:26dinner, we might have some funky taste still on our, on our
- 38:29palettes. I had Chinese food tonight, so I
- 38:31was like, I got to find something to reset my palate
- 38:34here. I have a very standard Bourbon
- 38:37and a very standard sky. Atch that I just take like a
- 38:41thimble full basically just to kind of get acclimated to the
- 38:44flavor of scotch again before I dove into this one.
- 38:47And so for me it's Cutty Sark which is not a very good scotch
- 38:50and you know, it's just, hey, here's alcohol and maltiness.
- 38:53And there you go. And I followed it with this
- 38:56about 10 minutes later. Brad for me, this was very sweet
- 39:01right from the jump. I thought it was sweet with just
- 39:04a hint of of that saline you're talking about.
- 39:06It had a really nice spice on it.
- 39:08When I breathe out afterwards, I had nutmeg and clove, I just
- 39:13really thought that it's not a complex flavor, but there is
- 39:16just layers and layers of richness to this man.
- 39:19Like I got a ton of brown sugar, I got a ton of butterscotch and
- 39:23yet it still stayed very, very light on the palate.
- 39:27This is one of the best scotches I've had on this show and
- 39:30probably two seasons Brad, like I Thinking back, the only ones
- 39:34that really stand out to me that I liked immediately better than
- 39:36this. We're keen to Ruben and
- 39:38Laphroaig lore. I'm going to give this a nine
- 39:41and a half on the palate. Dude.
- 39:44I think you need to start writing some copy for Buna
- 39:46Harbour, hey, this you are all about this stuff.
- 39:49Like I said, I like it's fine. It's just not blowing me away in
- 39:53any way. I think when I get to the Finish
- 39:56it's a little bit nutty, kind of on the finish with a little bit
- 40:00of that floral Aroma coming through it.
- 40:02It's a solid finish. But once again, nothing has
- 40:05blown me away. I'll give it a seven and a half
- 40:06out of ten. Yeah, I think if there is one
- 40:08area where this is not great, it's the Finish.
- 40:12It's a bit more of just kind of a standard scotchie finish Oak.
- 40:16It actually soured for me a little bit on the finish and
- 40:19then I got quite a bit of smoke on the backend Brad.
- 40:21So you're right. It is lightly peated.
- 40:23I think it definitely carries a smokiness with it but overall
- 40:26still Pleasant not alcohol forward.
- 40:29Not harsh. It doesn't dry the mouth.
- 40:31Thought it was definitely. Ring.
- 40:33I thought it was a good finish like you.
- 40:34I'm gonna give it a seven and a half out of ten.
- 40:37Yeah and that brings us to our overall balance.
- 40:39I think this is a well-balanced whiskey.
- 40:42I personally though just feel like there's a need for more
- 40:44complexity here that I was not getting.
- 40:47So I'm just going to stick right where I'm at man.
- 40:49I'm gonna give it a seven out of ten.
- 40:51It's solid it's just not blown me away.
- 40:53I think this is a beautiful whiskey.
- 40:55Like I would not be very often that I would use the word
- 40:58beautiful to describe a whiskey and I think in some ways we have
- 41:01been a little bit Old because a lot of the scotches we've been
- 41:04trying, Brad have been finished in other types of casks to give
- 41:08it a little bit more sweetness, a little bit more maturity.
- 41:11So like I don't know if I would stack this right next to a
- 41:13Glenmorangie Keen to Reuben, because that has a very
- 41:17particular flavor that's been sort of, you know, I don't say
- 41:20added to it, but, you know, infused into it.
- 41:23And if you like this up next to like a regular Glenmorangie,
- 41:27like, I know that's a Highland, not a Nyla.
- 41:29But this thing has so much more depth so much.
- 41:32Our richness. It's very sweet.
- 41:34It's really decadent. I would choose this over like a
- 41:37Glenmorangie 10-year any day of the week, I think it's
- 41:40incredibly well-balanced. I'm gonna give it a 9 out of 10
- 41:44on the balance. I mean, I don't mean to throw
- 41:46you under the bus here but this is double matured and X Bourbon
- 41:50and X Sherry, Cask, quite right. But that is essentially what
- 41:53most scotches do. Like we did that with a burl are
- 41:55a couple weeks ago, X, bourbon, barrels, and X.
- 41:58Sherry, Sherry butts are pretty much the standard for maturing
- 42:02skin. Scotch.
- 42:03Okay. Yeah, I mean I am not, I guess
- 42:07I'm just not getting what you're getting Bob.
- 42:08I just think it's kind of bland Lee.
- 42:10Sweet and has a few interesting notes and it's just okay.
- 42:14And you know, that's when we get to the value, you know, this
- 42:17sells for $55 and confusingly enough 83 cents.
- 42:22Yeah. In the state of Ohio, I don't
- 42:24understand that price could you know use any of the just make a
- 42:2755? No no no 83.
- 42:32I wonder if that works out to be like an even number when they
- 42:34had tax on to it or something. I mean, maybe the like what
- 42:37happens when they change the tax rate?
- 42:39Exactly. Now I just, it's, I love when
- 42:42you find little anomalies like that.
- 42:44But honestly, for me, when you have a world with Keen to Reuben
- 42:48for like five dollars less than this, I just can't consider this
- 42:52a great value. Like it's, it's fine, it's good.
- 42:56I would drink it. If it was offered to me.
- 42:58But at $56, I can only give it a 4 out of Non-value a 4 out of
- 43:0410. Yeah like it's it's just I can't
- 43:08I've said this a million times already Bob, it's just fine.
- 43:11Yeah. Like it's like it's it's good
- 43:13interest but in the world of scotch for me I'm only gonna buy
- 43:17a scotch if I'm just really Blown Away by it and I really
- 43:21like scotch and so you know, even at the fifty, sixty seventy
- 43:25dollar range, unless it's blown me away.
- 43:28I don't want to spend that much money, man.
- 43:30I mean, I will say that. That I think this has a ton more
- 43:34character, a ton more sweetness, a ton more flavor than the
- 43:38aberle. Our 16 that we tried two weeks
- 43:40ago. Like, I'd think this this would
- 43:42stack up if we did these side-by-side again, I actually
- 43:45would venture to say that you might pick this over the a burl,
- 43:48our 16 and again we're comparing different regions of scotch
- 43:52here, speyside to Isla but for me Brad I really do think that
- 43:57at this price point. The only whiskey, the only
- 44:00Scotch I should say. That I think is a better value
- 44:03is the key to Ruben and Ohio has actually raised the price of
- 44:07Buna, haben and lowered the price of keen sir Reuben.
- 44:10So I always say a year ago, you could flip flop.
- 44:13The prices of the to this would have been about five dollars
- 44:15cheaper at least in the Kingdom. Ruben, Brad for me.
- 44:18I think it's a 9 out of 10 on value.
- 44:20This is, this is one of the better scotches that I can think
- 44:22of, for $55 or less and we are going to come out in extremely
- 44:29different places on this whiskey.
- 44:30I'm coming out too. Day, 43 and a half out of 50 on
- 44:34this ya, Baba, I'm coming out to a 32.5 on this.
- 44:39Alright, so that is bringing us out to a 76 out of 100 or a 38
- 44:45out of 50. So, it is over that 35, Mark,
- 44:48where we typically say that it's worth trying, it's worth buying.
- 44:51I actually would say that in the rarest of instances for me,
- 44:55being the Cheapskate that I am, I would recommend both, I think
- 44:58it's worth buying a bottle of this at $55.
- 45:00I would absolutely. We recommend trying it at a bar
- 45:03because it's going to be less than $10 to try this Brad.
- 45:06Where would you come out in terms of recommendations?
- 45:10Yeah, this is true. Yeah, yeah, I mean if you really
- 45:15want to try it that's fine. I don't think it's particularly
- 45:18worth grabbing but go for it if you want to.
- 45:20Would you like, would you recommend someone to try this at
- 45:23a bar? Would you say pass on it all
- 45:24together? I honestly Bob, there's very few
- 45:28whiskies that. I would say, don't try it, got
- 45:30it. But honestly like, you know,
- 45:32there's probably maybe out of all the Whiskey's wherever ever
- 45:35drank. There's probably only 10 to 15
- 45:38that. I'd be like, man.
- 45:39I would even pass on it at the bar.
- 45:41I get that. Yeah, I'd say, go for it.
- 45:43Like, if you enjoy Scotch, if you enjoy especially sweet,
- 45:46Scotch go for it. Yeah.
- 45:47It's solid. It's a good poor.
- 45:50But overall buying a bottle. No, not as much.
- 45:54All right man. So we're divided on that one.
- 45:55Hopefully we're not too divided on our movie of the day.
- 45:58So what do you say we get back into talking about the
- 46:00apartment. Let's get to it.
- 46:44All right. That was Buna.
- 46:46Haben 12, a whiskey. That Bob and I are pretty
- 46:48daggone split on. I don't often come out 11 points
- 46:51away from each other on her whiskeys.
- 46:54Yeah man. I was really shocked to see
- 46:55that. Yeah, you know it was fine is
- 46:58fine but on my gosh yeah it was really good.
- 47:02It was not anything. You say fine, one more time.
- 47:06Hey Brad. I like I just have to double
- 47:08check my notes Here. Was it?
- 47:10Fine? Ah it wasn't, it wasn't fine.
- 47:14It was just fine. You know.
- 47:17Do you remember the episode of How I Met Your Mother?
- 47:19Where robin keeps talking about that painting of Lily's?
- 47:22It's hanging in the, in the coffee shop.
- 47:24He goes, oh, it's really neat. The colors are neat and Ted's
- 47:28like, I'm sorry, just to clarify.
- 47:30Would you say that it's more neat or Neato burrito?
- 47:34Yeah. That's where I'm at.
- 47:35With this Brad. This was, he was Neato burrito.
- 47:38Bob. All right, man, let's get back
- 47:42to talking about the apartment. Dude, I have a burning thought
- 47:46on my mind that's been sitting on me since I was like, I don't
- 47:50know about an hour into the film.
- 47:51Oh, is this a scorching-hot brad G?
- 47:54Take Jim Carrey modeled his whole acting career off of
- 47:59trying to be kind of like Jack. Lemmon oh man, are you Brad
- 48:04listen to me like 100% agreement with you?
- 48:10Like if you listen to the way Jim or Jim Carrey Jack Lemmon.
- 48:14And I mumble some of his lines in this movie, like, when he's
- 48:16depressed, or when he's drunk, it is Jim Carrey's.
- 48:20Whole performance in Eternal Sunshine, but he is trying to do
- 48:24the yes, dude. Yeah, 100%.
- 48:27And like the, the physical characteristics that he has
- 48:30like, when we haven't even talked about this part of the
- 48:34film, and I think it's brilliant.
- 48:35The one time that Baxter tries to get a woman and it's a
- 48:39married woman and he's like you're worried he's about to
- 48:43dive into the vein of Of sleazy high-powered executive that
- 48:47moment he turns on the music and he's kind of dancing around.
- 48:50The apartment, is the moment where I was like, oh it's Jim
- 48:55Carrey. Like the way he was moving
- 48:57around the apartment, I was just immediately, like, oh, it's
- 49:01Liar. Liar, it's Bruce Almighty.
- 49:04It's everything I've ever seen Jim Carrey.
- 49:06And I honestly, like it's this is not a knock on Jim Carrey.
- 49:09I really like him as an actor know, for sure, for sure.
- 49:12I just was struck The comparison and my rated just popped it,
- 49:18dude. I'm going to share, maybe the
- 49:20nerdiest story I can share with you.
- 49:22And when you've seen as many movies, as I've seen, like, my
- 49:25brain constructs, like, pretend remakes of movies.
- 49:30And I think sometimes like if they were ever going to remake
- 49:32this, who would I want to be in it?
- 49:34And we actually played this game a little bit with, I think the
- 49:37Great Escape way back in season one.
- 49:39So when I first saw this movie I was in high school.
- 49:41So it was around 2004 2005 this The movie called The Terminal
- 49:45had just come out with Tom. Hanks, I don't if you've ever
- 49:48seen, it's a Spielberg movie and the lead actors in that movie
- 49:52was Catherine Zeta-Jones and she was playing a flight attendant
- 49:56who was having an affair with, I think a pilot or something like
- 50:00that, you never see the guy in the movie, but she played to a
- 50:04tee, the Shirley MacLaine part of this movie.
- 50:07And I just remember thinking to myself, oh my gosh, like,
- 50:10Catherine Zeta-Jones, might be a few years older than Shirley
- 50:12MacLaine was at this point. But I was like, if they ever
- 50:16wanted to remake the apartment, like, you have Jim Carrey and
- 50:202004 era, Catherine Zeta-Jones, like right there for the taking.
- 50:24And I just, I'm pissed in retrospect that no one read my
- 50:28mind. And made that remake, bro.
- 50:31I'm telling you, man, once we start the film and whiskey
- 50:33Studio, we will just make all of those remakes that we've always
- 50:38order to make. We're just gonna cast them as 65
- 50:41year olds. Yeah, just do it anyway.
- 50:43Yeah, Jim Carrie will be lights out.
- 50:47Wow, I Brad, I'm really happy that you noticed that as well.
- 50:51Because I have been thinking that to myself for like, what 15
- 50:5516 years now is that also what you yell at people on the
- 50:58street, I do I shake them and Isaiah remedy making chip.
- 51:03Carriage we make any Apartments I just have this image of you
- 51:08being George Bailey running down the snowy streets of Akron
- 51:12shaking people. Yeah like when he when he's
- 51:15accosting the pretend version of Mary that's coming out of the
- 51:18library it's like trying to kiss her that's made out of that
- 51:21version. Don't you see Jim Carrey is Jack
- 51:24Lemmon oh man Brad I think this is a good time for us to move
- 51:30into our final scores and I am interested to hear what you have
- 51:34to say here because at the beginning of the episode, Said
- 51:36that you thought it was a really solid movie that it was in the
- 51:39top, you know, 20% kind of a thing.
- 51:42It doesn't sound like you're ready to go, all in, and give it
- 51:44like a nine and a half, or a 10 out of 10.
- 51:46So share your final score with us, but but also, can you
- 51:49enlighten me a little bit on what you think might be some of
- 51:51the flaws or the drawbacks of the movie here?
- 51:55I do think that there are a few points throughout the film,
- 51:57where it drags a little bit like, you know, the moment of
- 52:01the start of the movie, when he's making all these phone
- 52:03calls to the different, guys, to try and And rescheduled dates
- 52:07like it's a gag and it's funny but it kind of drags a little
- 52:11bit and there was just one or two other moments throughout the
- 52:14movie where I just felt myself wanting a little bit faster of a
- 52:19pace and not in a comedic sense just in a genuine like, okay,
- 52:24let's get to the next part. Like what?
- 52:25Like, we need to keep moving. But overall, I really don't have
- 52:29much to complain about this film.
- 52:30I think it's really solid. I'm going to compare to Some
- 52:33Like It Hot again because I gave Some Like It Hot a 10/10.
- 52:37And I think, you know, I'm gonna give the apartment a 9 out of
- 52:4010. I think the reason that it's not
- 52:43getting a 9 and a half, or a 10 out of 10, for me, is the fact
- 52:46that like, in the vein of comedies, I think Some Like It
- 52:50Hot just stands Head and Shoulders above.
- 52:54Most, any comedy ever, written directed and acted filmed like
- 52:58it is so far above that. For me, it's just a 10 out of
- 53:0110, and I honestly think that the apartment might be the
- 53:05better move. Movie overall.
- 53:07But in the end, there are a lot of really beautiful dramas out
- 53:12there that I can compare this to and go.
- 53:15Yeah, this is like one of the better entries in the heartfelt.
- 53:19Meaningful drama Department with a little bit of Comedy thrown
- 53:23in, I don't know. Does that make sense?
- 53:25Yeah, no I totally understand. And I get your critique, you
- 53:29know, when we watch the movies for the podcast you and I both
- 53:31take notes while we're watching a movie and I will freely admit
- 53:33that there were a couple parts of the movie that I It more
- 53:36convenient to take notes during so you're right there probably
- 53:39is and it's not very much like if they trimmed maybe even like
- 53:43three minutes off the run time, I think it would be a little bit
- 53:46tighter but for me it's just like, man, this movie hits a
- 53:50level of emotional depth that I don't think has really been
- 53:55surpassed in some ways by movies that have tried to do it since
- 53:58then. And the scene that I was talking
- 54:00about earlier Brad, that I called a really harrowing
- 54:02sequence is that whole sequence in Jack Clemons apartment after
- 54:06he He discovers that Fran has, you know, tried to overdose on
- 54:10pills, he calls the doctor over and they have to basically keep
- 54:13her from dying the whole night and Wilder just puts us in that
- 54:16apartment and does not shy away from the horrible.
- 54:20After-effects of, you know, the actions of this dick sheldrake,
- 54:25and watching that sequence. I was reminded of a very similar
- 54:29sequence in the movie. Almost Famous, which we're going
- 54:32to be reviewing here in, just a few months.
- 54:33And Brad, you've seen the director's cut of that movie.
- 54:36So, You've at least seen that scene before, but, you know, a
- 54:38main character in that movie tries to commit suicide, they
- 54:41have to pump her stomach out. It's very similar to the
- 54:43apartment and yet that movie Cuts away Way quicker than this
- 54:48one does. And I'm not saying that just,
- 54:50you know, forcing people to watch something harrowing makes
- 54:53it better, but I think that it's really a testament to how well
- 54:58made this movie was that in 60 years.
- 55:02I don't know if that scene has been topped in terms of what
- 55:05they're trying to do. And so, for all those reasons,
- 55:08for the reasons of, you know, it being a comedy and a tragedy,
- 55:12and a romance and working at all, three, it's a nearly
- 55:15perfect movie for me. I'm going to give it a 10 out of
- 55:1810, honestly. Bob, I was worried that you were
- 55:21going to mention Pulp Fiction there when you're talking about
- 55:23overdosing seen. Oh gosh, not that one.
- 55:25Not that one. But honestly, I will say, there
- 55:29is a moment when the doctor was just slapping her.
- 55:32That I was worried that like a Only one viewer might watch that
- 55:38and just think that it's like over the top and, you know,
- 55:41abusive and on, you know, unnecessary and I will say this
- 55:46as somebody who has watched, people had their stomachs pumped
- 55:50and been brought back from the brink of death, you know, after
- 55:53suicide attempts or alcohol poisoning or things like that.
- 55:57Nah dude, that doctor was being gentle.
- 55:59Yeah, like, being 100% honest like that.
- 56:02I mean it was a gruesome scene. It was brutal, it was honest.
- 56:06East. And that's what I really loved
- 56:08about it. Once again, this movie is not
- 56:10shying away from the reality of what's happening.
- 56:14When these, you know, sleaze balls are just taking advantage
- 56:17of women. Well, on that really happy and
- 56:20shiny. And positive note, we would like
- 56:22to hear what you think about this movie.
- 56:24I, I mean, Brad, I assume nine out of ten.
- 56:27You gave it your going to recommend that people should go
- 56:29watch this movie. Oh yeah, dude.
- 56:31I mean, if you can get it at a bar, if you can, you know, just
- 56:34going to shut up. Oh sorry.
- 56:35We're talking about movie. Yeah.
- 56:37Yeah. You should you should totally
- 56:39watch this movie 5. It's it's great.
- 56:42And if you have seen the movie or if you wanted, if we have
- 56:45persuaded you to go watch it. Hit us up after the fact, you
- 56:48can find us on social media on Facebook, Twitter or Instagram
- 56:52at film whiskey. Honestly, Bob, I'm just going to
- 56:55make another pitch. Don't go see All About Eve.
- 56:59I just want to remind everybody that that is not a movie worth
- 57:03watching, whereas the apartment is eminently.
- 57:06We a better film and much more worth watching than All About
- 57:09Eve. So now that, that public service
- 57:11announcement is over. If you want to give us some
- 57:13feedback verbally auditorily, give us a phone call.
- 57:18You can leave us a voicemail on our website which is anchored on
- 57:21FM / film, whiskey, Brad, I am ready for this with every ounce
- 57:27of my being next week. We're coming at you with the
- 57:31only movie to this day to feature a man, free falling and
- 57:34bouncing off a propeller into icy cold water.
- 57:36There's 1997's Best Picture Winner Titanic.
- 57:41I cannot wait. I will see you next week.
- 57:44Brad as we discussed that Masterpiece, but until then, I'm
- 57:47Bob book, I genuinely had no idea what movie you were talking
- 57:52about. If I just said like Happy Feet
- 57:56or like anything else, like the cold Eames?
- 58:00Yes, the Santa Claus has. Oh man, I am bread.
- 58:05G'yahhhh. And guys, I'm so pumped for next
- 58:08week. Titanic should be a great time.
- 58:10We'll see you next week.