Latest / The Events of 1848, Especially in Their Relation to Great Britain / Part 3
Transcript
- 0:00Section three of the Events of eighteen forty eight, especially in their relation to
- 0:06Great Britain, by Richard Mukton Mills. This LibriVox recording is in the public
- 0:11domain Part three. Without representation, public opinion is unknown to rulers. Without
- 0:21a fair representation, it is distorted, and public opinion is the visible sign
- 0:26of that real consent without which all governments are insecure. The King of Prussia,
- 0:33having attempted for several years to decipher the public opinion of his country without
- 0:37representation, so that he might adapt to constitution to its desires and requirements,
- 0:43at last was compelled to summon a parliament, whose proceedings, though merged in
- 0:49the tumult of the last months, were most wise and effective, and must
- 0:53have frequently since suggested to the thoughtful Prussians how much anxiety and embarrassment must have
- 1:00been saved, not only to their country, but to Germany if that assembly
- 1:04had been established long enough to have taken root in the country and to have
- 1:10become the firm trunk out of which other freedoms might naturally grow. Had the
- 1:17King summoned his people about him when he ascended the throne, there can be
- 1:22little doubt that the political position of Prussia would at this time have been the
- 1:26object of admiration to the other states of Germany and the firmest support of the
- 1:33Common Fatherland. This is not the place to discuss the relation that the newly
- 1:38proposed central government at Frankfort should bear to the other powers in Germany. But
- 1:44as far as England is concerned, it may assuredly be stated that as long
- 1:49as the arrangement be amicable, and the pretensions not enforced beyond the free consent
- 1:53of the parties concerned, our interference must be unnecessary. The arrangement of Germany
- 2:01in eighteen fifteen was made with the advice of England, and such advice,
- 2:06in a friendly spirit, might no doubt be tended again. But as long
- 2:10as there is nothing aggressive in the claims of this consented authority, even council
- 2:15would be superfluous. If, however, as has lamentably occurred, the very
- 2:22convocation assembled for the express declaration of the principle of German nationality shows itself contemptuous
- 2:29of the same right in other nations, ridiculing the notion of an Italian league
- 2:32at the moment it is demanding a German one and insisting on the retention of
- 2:38Lombardy as a military frontier of fortresses, while it calls on Denmark and Holland
- 2:44to surrender to the Confederation every portion of their populations. That as any pretense
- 2:49to Germanism, it cannot expect to be looked on without suspicion. And as
- 2:54it is above all things desirable that Germany should possess the greatest amount of defensive
- 3:00power, both against France and Russia, so we should be urgent that the
- 3:05new foundation may be just in order that it may be secure, for it
- 3:10will most assuredly be a source of mere weakness and distraction if it does not
- 3:15combine a deference for the spirit of independence abroad with a yearning after unity at
- 3:23home. There need be little fear but that things will soon end well in
- 3:28Northern Germany, either with the King of Prussia or without him, better if
- 3:34with him, for he is a good and generous man, and may be
- 3:37the means of impressing upon the people that princes have their worth too. The
- 3:43separation of Austria from Germany is unhappily no longer a matter of form, and
- 3:49this not from any differences of abstract opinion or even of modes of government.
- 3:53But because late events have so developed the Slavonian element and given it so clearer
- 4:00predominance, that its interests and its inclinations have alike ceased to be German.
- 4:06The once loyal and affectionate city has been bombarded by a Slavonian army, and
- 4:13many hundred German lives, with the expiation for one madly taken the numerous aristocracy,
- 4:20which was the rampart between Europe and the Turk, and whose oath Maria
- 4:26mouproreggi nostro Maria Theresa saved, Austria lies crushed under the Slavonian heel. The
- 4:32three generals who exercise a military authority that reminds one of the latter days of
- 4:38the Roman Empire, are of Slavonian blood and name, and have shown the
- 4:43will as they have the power to prevent the revival of the superiority, which,
- 4:47as the representative of a higher civilization. The German minority has hitheroto always
- 4:54exercised over the Slavonian majority of numbers. With this remarkable alteration in the prospects
- 5:01of Austria, England can immediately have little right or reason to interfere the independence
- 5:09of Germany. Was no doubt one of the main objects of the Treaty of
- 5:13Vienna, and nothing was less contemplated than the subjection of the German provinces and
- 5:18German capital to Slavonian force. But if this change is brought about by a
- 5:24civil war without foreign interference, we have nothing to offer but our earnest sorrow
- 5:30at so sad a consequence of former misgovernment. If a Russian soldier crosses the
- 5:36frontier, the question, of course assumes a different aspect. And it is
- 5:42in the encouragement which Slavonian sympathies would give to such an intervention, and in
- 5:46the probability that sooner or later the community of Teutonic Race will inflame other portions
- 5:53of Germany to rise in defense of their subject brethren, that we are deeply
- 5:59interested, not only as friends of humanity, but as inevitable sufferers in the
- 6:05case of a European war. Apart from this consideration, England can have no
- 6:12abstract objection to the growth of this new power in Europe. In the case
- 6:16of the Turks abandoning that portion of Europe in which, after so many years
- 6:21of conquest they are still only encamped, there is no other power to which
- 6:28Constantinople and the mouths of the Danube could be entrusted with so little danger to
- 6:32the comity of nations. Slavoni and Austria, extending its influences and conquests towards
- 6:40the east, might not only afford a most wholesome counterpoise to the weight of
- 6:45Russia, but might really advance the cause of civilization and self government. But
- 6:50then she must choose between the two destinies, or she may end by losing
- 6:56both. She cannot grasp with one hand at the Dardanelles and with the other
- 7:02retain her hold of Lombardy. If she will let Italy go free and give
- 7:08large federal rights to the German provinces, the rest of the world is open
- 7:13to her energies. But if she will remain in Western Europe as a conqueror,
- 7:18Europe will soon regard her as an enemy. No more striking anticipation of
- 7:26public events than has been offered by Count Valerian Krasinski's work on Pan Slavism and
- 7:31Germanism, published in the beginning of last year English Public Opinion, which ignores
- 7:38all such influences and looks on at Jelachich and Windisgrats as policemen putting down a
- 7:45mob would learn much from the study of this book, and besides the matter
- 7:49it contains, might find an interest in tracing the deep Slavonic sympathies of the
- 7:55writer himself, an exile from Slavonic persecution. Thus two the executioners of Bloom,
- 8:01the implacable German, spared Froebel, who had written or spoken favorably of
- 8:07Slavonic Austria. The settlement of the Italian question is essential to the stable peace
- 8:16of Europe. If the conflicts and difficulties to which it is exposed were limited
- 8:20by the Alps and the Sea, if no foreign element entered into the discussion,
- 8:26even then the confusion of this great peninsula would compromise the tranquility of other
- 8:31nations. There would be dynastic relations, popular sympathies, religious associations, pretensions
- 8:37and claims, all provoking and some demanding interference. And how greatly are these
- 8:45dangers aggravated by the retention of the north of Italy by a power of Central
- 8:50Europe, in which the element that has least in common with the civilization of
- 8:54the modern world had no historical relation whatever to Italy has become undeniably predominant.
- 9:03Suppose for a moment that Austria does confine herself scrupulously within the limits of eighteen
- 9:11fifteen, regardless of the tumult of feelings that is raging on the other side
- 9:16of the pole. Will the rest of the Italians remain passive spectators of this
- 9:22noble province held as a Slavonian fortress. Then if the other Italian states provoked
- 9:30the conflict and are defeated, as they probably will be, what is to
- 9:33hold back the victorious power from again occupying Tuscany or Rome or Naples. France
- 9:43under any administration can hardly permit the invasion, and England would be loath to
- 9:50admit the retention of the capitals and ports of Italy by Austria. And yet,
- 9:56if fairly won by force of arms from an insulting a enemy, it
- 10:01is hard to say by what right either power can afterwards interfere. If we
- 10:07do nothing to prevent this otherwise inevitable contest, we shall scarcely be justified in
- 10:13violently impeding its natural result. It is said to be the intention of the
- 10:20Austrian government to make the Lombardo Venetian Kingdom a second Poland, to acquire the
- 10:28affections of the peasantry by confiscating the estates of many of the nobility, and
- 10:33to destroy the power of the middle class by reducing them, as far as
- 10:37possible to the lowest level. It is hoped that thus Northern Italy may in
- 10:43time be denationalized, and that a race will grow up without passions and without
- 10:50memory. A savage and cruel process, but perhaps the only one possible,
- 10:56if this abhorred authority is to be maintained. But the analogy is not sufficiently
- 11:03exact to render the experiment even as hopeful as that of the prototype. Poland
- 11:11is surrounded by enemies, animated with all the bitterness of conscious injustice. Lombardy
- 11:18by compassionate, if not devoted friends. The Poles have only found sympathy among
- 11:24men strange to their race, their language, their habits. Lombardy finds sympathy
- 11:31with cognate nations, to which she is bound by a common literature and common
- 11:37customs. Poland, to the greater part of European travelers, remains but a
- 11:41name. Lombardy is a familiar face to thousands of strangers, a highway of
- 11:48civilized Europe, and a delightful sojourn to the lovers of what is beautiful in
- 11:54nature, in art, and in classic tradition and France. Whatever be her
- 12:01adventures in government, will not easily have so dulled her imagination or quenched her
- 12:07enthusiasm as to be unmoved by appeals to the deeds of Marengo and of Loadi,
- 12:13and to suffer an expiring nation at her very door, to cry in
- 12:16vain for help and protection, not against the restraints of an orderly authority,
- 12:22but against fierce and renewed invaders intent on her absolute destruction. Arvedi ruendo ad
- 12:31libertatum in servitutum di laps sunter can hardly be the final record of northern Italy.
- 12:39Libata verticando chesikara commesarchi per les vita refuta hum purgatorio i. How extravagant
- 12:50is the comparison between Dante's ideal of a beneficent, protecting emperor as preferable to
- 12:56the papal rule and the German occupation of Lombardy, cried the old poet,
- 13:03whose name has lately been taken in vain by Lord Braun, against the country
- 13:07he loved so well. And they can know little of Italian nature, who
- 13:11believe that she can, under any circumstances fall back again into the luxurious apathy
- 13:18in which before these events she seemed to lie. The only question is how
- 13:24this excitement is to be directed, how this passion is to be spent.
- 13:31The idea of Italian unity, which till now remained in the representation of one
- 13:35great common literature and in the visions of theoretical politicians, has seized the Italian
- 13:41imagination from the Alpster Calabria. From the point of view of the moment,
- 13:48it seems to have done so most unfortunately for the establishment of the constitutional liberties
- 13:54of the several states, and to have grievously increased the difficulties and dangers of
- 13:58the time. But for this notion, the success of the generous policy of
- 14:05the Grand Duke of Tuscany would have been complete, and that spectacle of peaceful
- 14:09political ardor and national well being would have been productive of the highest good.
- 14:16As it is, an element of discontent always remains, which at any moment
- 14:22may ferment into confusion. But for this notion, the reforms of Pope Pious
- 14:28the Ninth, though inspired by no higher sentiment than a humane desire to see
- 14:35his people improving and contented would have laid the basis of a good government.
- 14:39And although there may be something in the constitution of the Ecclesiastical Republic repugnant to
- 14:45the wants and feelings of present Italy, yet at any rate, the melancholy
- 14:50example would have been avoided of so painful a desertion from the cause of hopeful
- 14:56progress, and of the sudden lapse of so fair a name from the lofty
- 15:01series of the benefactors of mankind. Yet it may well be suggested whether the
- 15:07temporary inconvenience of this notion is not compensated by its own grandeur and worth.
- 15:13If beneath its influence the petty jealousies and envies of separate states, the reciprocal
- 15:20ridicule of peculiarities of manner and speech, and the ready reproach of inferiority pass
- 15:26away or even diminished. If the value of the common literature, intelligible and
- 15:33open to all, be fully recognized and improved, Who will be bold enough
- 15:37to say that the incorporation of the Italian states into one federation is impractical or
- 15:43even far distant. Let them one sacrifice wealth and life for one another's freedom
- 15:50and fraternity cannot be far off. The cohesion may be just as strong under
- 15:58monarchical forms as under republican and probably more manageable. And comparing the difficulties that
- 16:03surround and United Italy with those that attend and United Germany, the balance is
- 16:11strongly against the German. The contrasts of national position, the discrepancies of commercial
- 16:18interests, the distinctions of manners and modes of thought are much less on the
- 16:22side of Italy, and the differences of dialect about the same. These last
- 16:29have indeed been much exaggerated. A Genoese would understand the Neapolitan quite as easily
- 16:36as a Cornishman would a Yorkshire presidant, and in a federal Italian assembly there
- 16:40would arise none of the impediments to which the Austrian dieties exposed. Nor can
- 16:47the traditionary talent of the Italians for political life be altogether left out of consideration.
- 16:53Amidst the stormy republican excitements of the Middle Ages. They combine what at
- 16:59this distance looks nearly as confused as social state as the present one of South
- 17:03America, with all the grace and pleasure of existence with the Summit of Art
- 17:10and the flower of literature. The diplomacy of European nations was almost exclusively in
- 17:15their hands, and the policy of which Machiavelli was the organ and the representative,
- 17:21has always predominated in the Italian spirit over that of chivalry and Christian scruple.
- 17:27It was this political aptitude probably which made Napoleon, who had no taste
- 17:33for sentimental nationalities, always maintained the possibility of reconstituting in Italy, and direct
- 17:40his policy to that end as far as his other schemes permitted. With such
- 17:45a spirit, it is unlikely that she would have remained cantonized in chance principalities
- 17:52even if these general movements had not taken place, And now the restoration of
- 17:57the old scheme is frankly in possible. It will be of no ultimate disadvantage
- 18:03to the arrogant and boastful tendency of that people, if many checks require many
- 18:08efforts, and if they be made strongly to feel that so great a gift
- 18:14as independent nationality and self government is worth the lifeblood of a generation. To
- 18:21England, the peaceful consolidation of Italy would bring nothing but advantage. It would
- 18:26open to our manufactures and mark it all but closed against us by high tariffs
- 18:33and annoying restrictions of every kind. The exportation of corn of the best quality
- 18:41would be quadrupled by good and quiet cultivation, and that of silk and oil
- 18:47considerably increased. Her naval and commercial power commanding the two coasts would stand in
- 18:53the way of all monopoly of force in the Mediterranean and tend to preserve the
- 18:59liber of the sea. At the same time, the completion of the Lion's
- 19:04railroad will facilitate the access of travelers and bring her within a week's easy journey.
- 19:11The pleasure hunter should desire the true preservation of order in Italy by pacific
- 19:15means, as well as the advocate of liberty or humanity. In the meantime,
- 19:21Russia stands like a mute shadow, watching all, and her attitude commands
- 19:26at one's respect and fear, respect from those who at a distance seeing it
- 19:33a passive dignity and fear, and those who believe it to be the vigilance
- 19:37of power gathering itself together for a favorable opportunity. It is only by residing
- 19:45some time in Germany that one can understand the political terror of Russia. That
- 19:51overhangs the popular mind. The calm Neibur himself, in his latter days,
- 19:59was burdened with the thought that a new era of intellectual darkness and brute force
- 20:04was at hand for Europe. Napoleon said in fifty years Europe would be Cossack
- 20:11or Republican. The family alliance between Prussia and Russia has gone far to alienate
- 20:17the nation from the House of horn Zollen. The Poles, though inimicable by
- 20:22race and uncongenial by character, were objects not only of pity but of respect
- 20:29in northern Germany, and even the Cabinet of Vienna showed no hostility to the
- 20:33Polish Revolution. These feelings have little to do with the personal character of the
- 20:40emperor, whose efforts, however unsuccessful, to reform the administrative corruption of his
- 20:45huge dominions, have won the admiration of a people whose functionaries, however unenlightened,
- 20:52are notable for personal honesty. The antagonism has a far deeper route and
- 20:59a larger meaning. It is felt that Russia not only is, but must
- 21:03be, the irreconcilable enemy of liberal institutions in Germany. She cannot keep her
- 21:11people from the infection of a spirit so near at hand, and the infection
- 21:15acting on a body totally unprepared to receive it, can hardly produce anything but
- 21:22evil. It is the very worse misfortune of the political condition of Russia that
- 21:26influences in themselves good can only injure her peace and weaken her stability. The
- 21:34patriarchal system is disturbed, and nothing is substituted. Government from above is discredited
- 21:41and self government not insured. For where the Czar is still divine, rebellion
- 21:48against him assumes the impotence of blasphemy and the traitor sins against the public conscience.
- 21:55The long process of the feudal system to which Europe has been subjected and
- 22:00out of which she has elaborated her liberties is there unknown, and the sense
- 22:06of responsibility has yet to be developed out of the municipal nucleus common to the
- 22:11east of the world. And yet how near is Breslau to Warsaw, how
- 22:15accessible Koenigsberg from Saint Petersburg. The fear of the consequences of this contact is
- 22:22most just on both sides, and it is an interesting point in diplomatic history
- 22:27to observe how unwilling the European states have been to recognize Russia as a substantive
- 22:33European power till the commencement of the French Revolution. Her attempts to procure an
- 22:40influence in the domestic affairs of the German Empire were without success, the German
- 22:45States having encountered with determined opposition the pretensions of Russia to the title of guarantee
- 22:52of the Treaty of Westphalia, which she claimed by a forced interpretation of a
- 22:56passage in the Treaty of Tesshen. It is in the memory of the present
- 23:03generation with what courteous disregard the proposals of mediation in the agitations of Europe from
- 23:10the young and enthusiastic Emperor Alexander were received by the Allies, and how it
- 23:15required all the insanity of Napoleon's ambition to bring the Russian army to the gates
- 23:21of Paris. But from that time Russia took her undisputed seat in the councils
- 23:26of Europe, and cannot be expected to resume an isolation offensive to her pride,
- 23:33however beneficial to her own true interests and those of the civilized world.
- 23:40The future of Slavonic Austria will no doubt multiply the points of contact, and
- 23:45the far sighted politician would probably fix on the circumstances connected with that relation as
- 23:52the main source of peril to the tranquil advancement of Europe. The good under
- 24:00standing between Russia and England runs little chance of being disturbed by any of the
- 24:04above considerations. And yet it is to Russian agents, unrecognized or disowned,
- 24:12that we owe the disasters of Afghanistan and the seizure of Constantinople is, with
- 24:18the exception of the stoppage of communication with India through Egypt, the single act
- 24:23of political aggression in the range of probability which would compel us under any administration
- 24:30to an immediate declaration of war. As long as the present emperor lives.
- 24:37The former event is unlikely to occur, but the hope of it is fixed
- 24:41in the heart of the Russian nation, and it is and will long be
- 24:47the business of Russian rulers to restrain, rather than excite, the ardor of
- 24:52their subjects. The great devastations and injuries of the world have been committed rather
- 24:59by excited mass than by individual passion. The invading moguls rather led than followed
- 25:07Genghis Khan, and France rather demanded than answered the ambition of Napoleon. It
- 25:14is assuredly a fact of much significance that the country whose relations with our own
- 25:19give cause for the least anxiety, should be the very one of which we
- 25:25had at one time come to believe, as Cromwell said of Spain, that
- 25:30God had made her our enemy, and man could not make her our friend.
- 25:36While the other nations of Europe cried to France, citoi quipu nouarmi lu
- 25:41charbon sou la leevre trois qui nusean fiotrn leuvernard de ta fievre, neu za
- 25:48febois au font de tonveron chante, leuvan de L'Esperance a dolla liberte barbier.
- 25:57England has rather learnt to appreciate the value of what she already possesses, and
- 26:02with no vain pride, has contemplated the security derived from a blameless, sovereign,
- 26:07an inoppressive church, and a parliament on the whole obedient to the desires
- 26:11of the people. This feeling has no doubt been heightened by the consciousness that
- 26:17it is to the want of this principle of ministerial responsibility. Hereso firmly established,
- 26:22though not without many a constitutional struggle. That the success of the late
- 26:26subversive movement in France is to be mainly ascribed. A true constitutional throne has
- 26:33barriers about it to preserve the sovereign from falling, which cannot elsewhere exist.
- 26:40I am not blind to the difficulty of establishing a monarchy on the ground of
- 26:45high expediency in a country where it has not historically grown up, and it
- 26:48must be owned that hitherto too, the experiments in France have signally failed.
- 26:55There. The inviolability of the crown has been like the ring in the common
- 27:00fairy tale, which possessed a remarkable quality that from whatever height the wearer happened
- 27:04to fall, the duel remained uninjured. Louis the sixteenth was inviolable by the
- 27:11Constitution at the moment of his execution. Charles the tenth and Louis Philippe when
- 27:18they were exiled. Why establish a principle, it may be said, to
- 27:22which neither side will adhere Lurrois Louvoulee was the excuse of the ordinances, and
- 27:29the king fell mori fujendo a disfiorando iljiglio lurrois regna e guvne was the cry
- 27:37of the opposition, and Louis Philippe fled assuredly. The English people would not
- 27:44thus have punished any desire of family aggrandizement, and that family honest, amiable
- 27:49and patriotic, which wore at least the color of the firm establishment of a
- 27:55constitutional dynasty. And if an unscrupulous and unjust juice was made of the enormous
- 28:00patronage of which the government was the disposer, the proper remedy would have lain
- 28:06in some diminution of the means of favor. To expect that any executive should
- 28:11hold that machinery of influence in its hand and not use it for political purposes
- 28:18argues more faith and less sagacity than the French people usually possess. When it
- 28:23is singular that up to the present moment, no serious attempt seems to be
- 28:29in contemplation to diminish this inevitable source of corruption to the nation and demoralization to
- 28:37the government. The Constitutional Party in France has always remained a fraction, both
- 28:44in the chambers and in the country, although composed of such men as Detaueville
- 28:48and de Beaumont, and has never commanded the influence. Its purity of character
- 28:52and eminence of talent would have justified. There was perhaps hardly an act of
- 28:57the personal government of the king which the majority of the nation did not approve
- 29:03of. And it seems as if every French ruler was tempted on to the
- 29:07exercise of unconstitutional authority, and then he is the terroristic motto clamored in his
- 29:12ear larresponsibility sell The more it is needless to say that such a disposition is
- 29:22utterly at variance with the hereditary principle as exercised in a free state. And
- 29:26the question must have lately forced itself on the mind of many an Englishman whether
- 29:32constitutional monarchy in France is possible if such offenses as those committed by Louis Philippe
- 29:37were deemed worthy of the banishment of himself and his family. This apparent contradiction
- 29:44is in some measure diminished when we remember that in France a minority has always
- 29:48made the revolutions. But it is the minority congregated in towns, active,
- 29:55intelligent, bold in theory, brave in practice. The real mind of the
- 30:00nation, on the other side, is the majority of Frenchmen, tranquil,
- 30:06frugal, domestic material in their objects, in a large part of the country,
- 30:12religious and in all patient and unpolitical. This is the France which submits
- 30:19to revolution, though it once resisted in Lavon day, while the other France
- 30:26will always hold the ultimate destiny of the country in its hands, and the
- 30:30difficulty will always lie in the conciliation of the two. This was the great
- 30:37achievement of the Empire, which gave to the masses tranquility, justice and order,
- 30:42to the ambitious, the possibility of every man becoming great, rich and
- 30:48glorious, and to the republican communist and equality under the sword, accompanied by
- 30:55a sort of political pantheism, absorbing each individual into the state. End of
- 31:03section three read by BRN. Roberts Kings, Winford, October twenty twenty three.