Latest / Psychology In Seattle Podcast / Borderline Abuse (Chapters 10-12)
Transcript
- 0:00Hey, deserved listeners. Love is Blind Season six. Let's see what happens.
- 0:03Okay, So Jimmy and Chelsea are starting a conversation. They're both on
- 0:10their phones a theme this season. For some reason, I thought maybe they
- 0:17would just be done with each other, but no, that wasn't definitive.
- 0:20Okay, So I mean, it doesn't really matter what my prediction is,
- 0:26but it might help to understand what I typically see in real life is that,
- 0:34you know, if both people are in love and dedicated and they don't
- 0:39want to lose the other person, even though all that stuff happened, and
- 0:42even though in the moment and maybe for a time one or both of them
- 0:46were telling themselves that it was over and they hate that person, and it's
- 0:52you know, there's just no way that it's going to recover that. You
- 0:57know, we all need attachments, we all want to have hope for the
- 1:03future. So maybe that's starting to settle in and at least visually, she's
- 1:08the one approaching him right now, and based on the pattern that I see
- 1:15with his couple and in life, my guess is that she will have the
- 1:22tone and some words of apology and halfway taking responsibility, he will stay pretty
- 1:33defended. Eventually he'll warm up. Then she will start to feel more regulated.
- 1:38There'll be a little bit more goodwill between the two because his body language
- 1:42is face. We've never I don't even seen that body language or face before.
- 1:46He seems really just like the walls are up. And once the walls
- 1:53are down, then she'll in acute see way like she has in the past.
- 1:57She'll start sneaking in some of the criticism, like you're a bad communicator,
- 2:02or I don't know, you can't be friends with women or something.
- 2:09I don't know if she'll go that far, but maybe making suggestions like I
- 2:13don't want to be with someone that goes out and drinks, but we'll talk
- 2:15about later, so you know, And he'll maybe push back on a little
- 2:22bit. But it's enough reason for him to believe that maybe she's learned her
- 2:28lesson or changed her ways. But he'll be more skeptical than before because he's
- 2:34been here before. Or they break up, or he's a complete asshole and
- 2:40he reveals himself for who he truly is. I don't know, you know
- 2:44what happens, but I guess I'm there's nothing that there's no way that this
- 2:52is going to be good for either one of them unless there's a couple therapists
- 2:57that is working with them intensely at least weekly to help them navigate this.
- 3:02Even with that for a long time, they would still experience a lot of
- 3:07the same sort of conflict that wouldn't change right away at all. The couples
- 3:10that I work with that are sort of in this category and this is pretty
- 3:14typical. It's the problems they have. It's it's not like some weird,
- 3:17exotic problem. It's it's in the realm of just a little bit more than
- 3:23average, honestly. So it would still take a long time. So unless
- 3:29that begins, yeah, I would say there's zero percent chance that this is
- 3:36that this is going to work too. Went home and we'll watch out for
- 3:44either one of them, saying just some simple solution of I'm just never going
- 3:49to do that again, which is not a viable plan. I had time
- 3:53to sort of clout my thoughts and when I had time to really think about
- 3:59what I wanted and what I wanted out of this experiment was so you know,
- 4:03show you I love you and be there for you and take you home
- 4:09and be proud to call you my wife. And yeah, I'm sure you
- 4:13know where this is headed, but it was a bit of a roller coaster.
- 4:15He started out talking like decided to end things, but then when he
- 4:20says that, it sounds like no, and it's fine. You know,
- 4:24he's free to make his choice. I'm sure there's a lot of ringing of
- 4:29hands while watching this. I'm currently wringing my hands, but you know,
- 4:35each to their own. I just feel like I was a little betrayed the
- 4:40other night, and I mean this morning. My perspective on getting married,
- 4:46I I, you know, decided I didn't want to. I'm on the
- 4:55edge of my seat. That's going back and forth. I don't know why
- 5:01predict my prediction still stands. I think that you know he's in love,
- 5:06and when you're in love, you don't easily throw that away, even when
- 5:13times get tough. So I'm gonna take a guess and say that she'll make
- 5:16up for it somehow and they'll give another try, and then they'll either have
- 5:21another fight and then really break it off or say no to the altar,
- 5:25or they won't have another fight and she'll hold it together for the most part
- 5:29and they won't trigger each other. Maybe he'll even avoid doing anything to trigger
- 5:32her, like he'll never leave her side. They say yes yes to the
- 5:34altar, and then we never hear about anything ever again, and they have
- 5:39whatever life they have behind closed doors and we never find out. So for
- 5:46better or for worse, you know, sort of like with Matt and Colleen.
- 5:49You know, there are a lot of concerns I think, rightfully so
- 5:54about their relationship. And with most of those relationships, like Zennab and Cole,
- 6:00they break up, so they are in our minds no longer involved with
- 6:04each other. Now I know or suspect that the people that have issues will
- 6:10have those issues with other people in the future. Is just not on camera,
- 6:13so it's not like the trouble ends, but that's usually what happens.
- 6:16It's it's kind of rare when we see like big huge red flags and then
- 6:21they get married and then there's just this absence of data. Right, but
- 6:26all these questions and concerns, right, people are worried, So we just
- 6:30have to live with the fact that they're just regular citizens. They're not even
- 6:34really famous people with paparazzi, right, and we'll we'll just never know,
- 6:40so that that could happen to this couple. So you're are you So you're
- 6:45saying no, you told me you didn't think I love you. That statement
- 6:49alone, that heard's my feelings that you don't think I love you. Yeah,
- 6:59he's speaking from the heart, he's being differentiated, and eye statements makes
- 7:03sense, and it sounds like this is an open door for her to suck
- 7:09him back in, i e. Repair that release. I don't know,
- 7:13Yeah, I mean yeah, I don't shy away from a phrase like suck
- 7:17him back in because it will happen again. It will now if she is
- 7:25in therapy now during this time, and or she you know, if they're
- 7:29still together, which I don't know, and she has been in therapy this
- 7:32whole time and she's really working on it, and she occasionally will transgress in
- 7:36that way and be triggered for real and imagined threats. Then you know,
- 7:43he can make his own choice about that. But from the outside, I
- 7:46would say, well, at least there's a pathway that the individual that is
- 7:50transgressing is taking to reduce the chances of transgressing again in the future. But
- 7:57unless that happens, and not on purpose, she's not sucking him back in.
- 8:01She doesn't think that she's going to do it again. But it will
- 8:05happen again. I would put so much money on that, whether it's caught
- 8:11on camera or not. In fact, even with a lot of therapy,
- 8:13it's you know, I can't know for sure, but chances are very very
- 8:18high that the exact thing that we saw will happen with whoever she's with.
- 8:24Like I said, even with a lot of therapy, the kind of things
- 8:26that we're seeing in all likelihood require a long time to recover from, and
- 8:31even when you do recover, you never fully recover because you can't just completely
- 8:39excisee your the neural pathways that were established when you were young and just get
- 8:43rid of all of them. You'd be getting rid of half your brain or
- 8:48more. Not that half your brain is filled with that stuff, but you
- 8:50know it's all interwove anyone. You know what I'm saying. I love you,
- 8:54and I will always fight for the the woman I'll I always have and
- 9:01I always will and I'll fall for you a lot through this experiment. But
- 9:07you're saying that I'm not giving you any love and affection, and I feel
- 9:09like I'm giving you as much as I possibly can give. Okay, So
- 9:13if they're on the road to getting back together. If you're ever in these
- 9:18shoes the pathway, I guess you consider there be kind of two prongs to
- 9:24it. One is that he's I think, seeking an apology and an acknowledgment
- 9:31from her to say, like, I do know that you love me,
- 9:35and I'm sorry that I said that you didn't. I was just really upset
- 9:37something like that, something convincing. So that's one, but that only addresses
- 9:41the moment that that happened. The other issue that is more important is the
- 9:48bigger issue that she's done a lot of things in this category and all the
- 9:52things that I've talked about, and so of course he would want some acknowledgment,
- 9:56some apology about that, But I more importantly would want if I were
- 10:00in issues, do you understand that you have an overall issue? You know,
- 10:03if I wasn't a therapist, I didn't know about the stuff, I
- 10:07would say, I don't know what's going on, but there's something going on
- 10:11in you that causes you to see and believe things that just aren't even true,
- 10:16and then you get upset because you believe these false things like I was
- 10:20with Jess or that I don't love you. This has happened multiple times,
- 10:24and I don't know what that is. But until that mechanism is changed or
- 10:31managed or healed or something, then it might not be this particular manifestation.
- 10:37But it's going to happen again because it's happened multiple times. So what's that?
- 10:43You know? Again, I'm not. If I was therapist, I'd
- 10:45be like, well, here's what you do. But if I'm not,
- 10:46I'd be like, what do you think about that? How are you working
- 10:50on that? What's the plan with that? Do you acknowledge that that?
- 10:54Because that's the core, that's the foundation. This is just hard to hear.
- 11:03I apologize and the things that I said were things that were bothering me
- 11:07and really heavy on my heart. Was my delivery good? No? I
- 11:13thought it'd be better than that. Yeah, she's basically saying, I agree
- 11:20with everything I said. I just could have delivered it differently. What yikes?
- 11:30Right, that's all she said, I could have delivered it. And
- 11:35I'm guessing for him this is being comprehended that he's like, wait, what,
- 11:41Yeah, that is far. I mean, you'll hear people say that
- 11:46when they know they didn't even do anything wrong, right, I mean I've
- 11:50said that when I know I've done nothing wrong, like i'm I don't know,
- 11:54well, I'm talking to a client, and I you know, I
- 11:56do wrong things with clients, and I will apologize for it, you know,
- 12:00I guess when I'm mature or differentiate enough to recognize it. But there
- 12:05are times when there will be something that happened that I am. I'm,
- 12:09you know, ninety nine percent sure that it was some transference issue going on
- 12:15with the client, and I want to provide some level of reciprocity and the
- 12:20apology process, and so I might say, you know, I you know,
- 12:24and I apologize from my side as well. I stand by what I
- 12:28said, but I absolutely could have delivered it differently, even though I think
- 12:33that that isn't necessarily true, but there's you know, that's always basically true.
- 12:37I could have delivered it differently, or I could have maybe been more
- 12:39slow or patient or something. But that's what she's saying. She's basically saying,
- 12:46I agree when I said that someone told me that Jess was there last
- 12:52night, and I know she was there. I agree with what I said
- 12:56when I told you that I don't want to be with someone that out at
- 13:01all period. I agree that it was okay for me to scream in your
- 13:07face and say that you fucked that girl, even though you told me in
- 13:13confidence and told me even though you didn't have to tell me, and it
- 13:18was a long time ago and completely irrelevant to what we're talking about, and
- 13:22I did it in front of the cameras, so now the entire world knows
- 13:26not only about you, but about her. I agree with everything that I
- 13:31did. That I fought with you because last night I was tired and didn't
- 13:35want to go out, and you went out for an hour and a half
- 13:39or an hour and had one drink. I agree that the whole fight was
- 13:45and everything I said at all. Nothing she said in terms of the edit
- 13:50made any sense. The whole thing was based on her own invented lies in
- 13:54her head that she didn't volitionally cause. But he did nothing. I just
- 14:01want to emphasize he did nothing. So for her to say I agree with
- 14:09what I said, I could have delivered it differently. It was still a
- 14:11pile of shit for no reason. Sure, could you have delivered the pile
- 14:16of shit in a different way, Yeah, but it's still a pile of
- 14:18shit. She's not a pile of shit. I don't want to be clear.
- 14:22I think that's clear. But now as a therapist, when I treat
- 14:28people like her, at least what I think to be here. I don't
- 14:31know if it's similar, but I have all the patients of the world and
- 14:35all the understanding. And that's kind of a part of it, is that
- 14:37when I watch the show, I have no ability to help. I'm just
- 14:43watching helplessly. When the clients right in front of me. I don't feel
- 14:46that at all, and I take the long game. I might even be
- 14:50thinking, well, it's probably something to work on in a couple of years.
- 14:52I don't think they're ready for that yet. I don't have any of
- 14:56this frustration typically. I mean, certainly I can be to, but all
- 15:01I have is compassion and the long game, and it feels very gratifying to
- 15:07take each step down that road. Here I'm just watching, and it's so
- 15:13I get frustrated. But what she say, I apologize, and the things
- 15:18that I said were things that were bothering me and really heavy on my heart.
- 15:22Was my delivery good? No, not at all, And I am
- 15:28so sorry about that. And I can't apologize anymore now. Maybe in her
- 15:33heart she is really apologizing and feeling remorse. It has the look of that,
- 15:39but in terms of the edit, there's zero evidence of that. It's
- 15:43a non apology. She's saying, I apologize. I can't apologize more.
- 15:48You can't apologize a lot more. You can say, I'm sorry for saying
- 15:52that. I should never have outed that. I should never have accused you
- 15:56of that. I should never have even been upset that you went out front.
- 16:00I said to you that you lied to me repeatedly. I said you
- 16:04lied. I accused you of not responding when I told you I didn't want
- 16:10you to be friends with those women. I never asked you to do that,
- 16:12and I continue to double down and last night I never admitted any wrong
- 16:18last night, and I was wrong from beginning to end. Now, I
- 16:22don't know if that's true. There's a high chance that is true, but
- 16:26I don't know if that's true. We're seeing it at it. I don't
- 16:27know anything, but I've seen this happen in my office, and when I'm
- 16:32there, I have some ability to work on it. But here I just
- 16:36want to point out, you know, mainly because if you have a partner
- 16:40or even yourself that does this sort of thing. It needs to be understood
- 16:45because if you're being treated this way, you know, and I imagine it's
- 16:48true that for many of you, whether it's this video or another one,
- 16:53you are recalling events that you've been through or are going through, and it
- 16:59pulls you temporary out of the gaslighting and the crazy making situation. We're like,
- 17:02yeah, okay, that's right. You know, that's what it felt
- 17:03to me too. I felt like I didn't do anything wrong. But it's
- 17:08hard you go through it for so long and it looks so convincing. You
- 17:14know, she's crying, and again, she might be legitimately remorseful, but
- 17:18I'm hearing no evidence of that. What I think is possible is that she
- 17:22feels sad because she doesn't want to lose him. I don't think she's a
- 17:26psychopath. I don't think she is incapable of remorse. I think she's completely
- 17:32clouded by her trauma. So there's that, But in terms of having a
- 17:37mutual relationship that can grow and adjust, she's exhibiting behavior that shows that she
- 17:44has she doesn't have that ability. She can adjust, and she can have
- 17:48empathy, but given the cloud, it doesn't allow her to have that.
- 17:55So yeah, and that's important to know that when someone apologized to you and
- 18:00they're they're showing all the main sort of highlights, the tears, I apologize,
- 18:06the desperation, but if you really listen to what let's let's really listen
- 18:11to what she says here. It's edited, but really listen hard to hear
- 18:17I apologize and the things that I said were things that were bothering me in
- 18:21I apologize. Okay, that's a good start. When I talk about I
- 18:26have my different, you know, criteria for an effective apology. Often in
- 18:32those criteria of an apology, they will say you have to say you're sorry
- 18:37or I apologize. I don't include that. You certainly can say I apologize
- 18:41or I'm sorry, but I can apologize very effectively without ever uttering the word
- 18:47apology or sorry, like if I were in her shoes, let mean demonstrate
- 18:52last night, I made a lot of mistakes and I feel so bad for
- 18:59what I did to you, and I'm still sifting through it. And a
- 19:03part of me thinks that you're a jerkface. But from my experience and the
- 19:08therapy I've been through, there's a pretty good chance that I was the jerkface,
- 19:12and I just all night. I've been struggling, and there's a part,
- 19:18there's a side of me that just wants to believe that I was being
- 19:23mistreated. But when I think about it, all you did was go out
- 19:26with your friends for an hour, and I think you came back early,
- 19:30partially because you're working the next day, but also because I think you didn't
- 19:33want me to worry, which is, you know, it's a nice thing,
- 19:37and yeah, I was tired. I wouldn't have gone with you,
- 19:40and you should be able to do that, but I just got so hung
- 19:42up on it, and I just feel so bad about it. You notice
- 19:47I never said sorry, at least I don't think so. I never said
- 19:49apology, right, But that's an apology, God damn it, And just
- 19:53saying I apologize without anything in that direction is not a fucking apology. People,
- 20:02stop it. The world needs to know this. I'll shout it because
- 20:07public figures will say I apologize, I take full responsibility and then it ends
- 20:14or they follow it with a butt But you know you should know it's well,
- 20:18it's not an apology. Being sorry is to be sorrow full sorrow remorse,
- 20:27to have it and to show it and convince that you have it.
- 20:33She's crying. Maybe she does have remorse, she doesn't seem to. She
- 20:37says she stands by everything she says, except for the delivery. The delivery
- 20:41really heavy on my heart. Was my delivery good? No, not at
- 20:47all? And I am so sorry about that. And I can't apologize anymore.
- 20:52No, maybe I'll know that she apologizes more with actual remorse. We'll
- 20:56see. I also want to be clear, I'm not beating up on her.
- 21:00She is the last person that deserves to be beat up on the last
- 21:04person she is doing this if I understand what she's doing, or I'll just
- 21:11say everyone I know who does this and clinically has the worst childhoods and are
- 21:18constantly suffering. They are the most suffering people on the planet. And there's
- 21:22a lot of suffering on the planet because the suffering goes with them wherever they
- 21:27go. To you out there that have that suffering, and some of you
- 21:30know this, there is recovery and much less suffering. With awareness and corrective
- 21:37experiences with a specialist, it could happen and secure relationships, earn security.
- 21:45I'm not beating up on her. If I'm in his shoes, I'm frustrated,
- 21:48and I'm like, that's not an apology if I'm her shoes ugh,
- 21:53And I've said this before, but if they don't work out, he'll,
- 21:56I'm guessing, be okay her. On the other hand, because of I
- 22:03think what's happening for her, she won't be okay and the next relationship could
- 22:10be even worse. And what happens if she actually matches up with someone who
- 22:15actually is harmful to her? Right I don't know, maybe Jimmy is harmful
- 22:19to her, but clinically what I see is it's just so much suffer.
- 22:23So I'm not beating up on her. I'm just sort of shaking fists at
- 22:29internet apology. And she just reminded me of that. I forgive you for
- 22:33that. I don't hear me out. I know that I was horrible,
- 22:37but like for you to just throw in the towel if having a bad night
- 22:41is like that. Yeah, it's playing out pretty similar to how I predicted
- 22:45that he would have the walls up and then she would exhibit some softness.
- 22:53But it's not real soft It's not like the sort of softness that gives me
- 22:57optimism. And as soon as he exhibits some of the walls coming down.
- 23:03He says, I forgive you for that. Then she's starting right back in
- 23:07with the criticism. And maybe it's deserve and maybe I'm completely Often I'm terrified
- 23:12of that. I'm terrified that somehow the entire viewing audience is just like,
- 23:17what are you talking about, Kirk? He's a d bag, she's a
- 23:19victim. I don't know. I can only call him how I see it,
- 23:22and I could be wrong. I have no idea. I'm saying this
- 23:25because if you're seeing it as I'm seeing it, and you've been through it,
- 23:29or you will go through it, or you're going through it now,
- 23:32like having a perspective that can, at the very least in your mind tell
- 23:37you that you don't deserve this. I think is important. Just because we
- 23:45had a higo, things aren't going to be easy, and we did,
- 23:52we had so. I don't know about this, but with abusive people,
- 23:56we understand they minimize, and they will minimize at this phase of the cycle.
- 24:02They'll say, you're overreacting. It wasn't that big of a deal.
- 24:04All couples have this, you know, my friends have the exact same thing,
- 24:11and you're making too much of a big deal this. I don't understand
- 24:14why you're blowing this out of proportion? Why are you dwelling on the past
- 24:18now. For the psychopaths and the sadists, they're doing this relationally, they're
- 24:23consciously trying to manipulate for everyone else. For the vast majority of people,
- 24:27they're so desperate for the closeness, they will say anything and they will believe
- 24:33it to some extent, and they'll say, essentially, the message is,
- 24:37please don't leave me, And I will say anything to get you not to
- 24:41leave me because I need you so much. And that's a different kind of
- 24:45love. You know. I talked about in another video about how people that
- 24:48present like this can be very intoxicating at first because they appreciate so much of
- 24:52the love, and they also idealize you quite a bit because of the splitting,
- 24:56and they will say that they love you, and it feels like they
- 25:00do. But it's not the same love as the sort of love that at
- 25:07least people in my circle would want. It's a neediness love, it's a
- 25:14desperate love. It's a love that is kind of one directional. You know,
- 25:19and my wife, we love each each other and depend on each other.
- 25:23But for these people or people. I don't know about her, but
- 25:26people that present like this, they are loving from underneath. They feel like
- 25:30they don't matter in the world, and they're very desperate for a lot of
- 25:36They want love to shower down on them. And this is why therapy closeness
- 25:41and attachment is good for this, because it basically is kind of that right.
- 25:45The therapist doesn't ask the client to love them or to take care of
- 25:48them, hopefully, and so it's a good incubator, if you will,
- 25:53for this corrective experience, so that they can be fulfilled in that way,
- 25:56so that they don't need that from their partners and they can recover and have
- 26:00enough capacity to give. I mean that that's why you know, mostly securely
- 26:06attached people can give is because they've already received. The reason why I can
- 26:11give to my wife and to the internet, and to my clients and to
- 26:15my students is because I have been given so much by my parents and by
- 26:21people around me, by my siblings, my friends, mentors and teachers that
- 26:26I've had. I was needy and they gave to me, and I was
- 26:32filled, and now I can give. I still am being given to But
- 26:37I use a metaphor of a tank, like when I am being depleted,
- 26:41when I'm hurt or something, my tank goes down a little bit. But
- 26:44I don't need that much to get to full capacity of love and fulfillment.
- 26:49And when I'm at that level, I have the energy and the will power
- 26:55and the stability and the emotional regulation to be able to give. But if
- 27:00you never had your tank filled, or it's just we're always on empty and
- 27:04whenever you get a little bit, you know, you quickly lose it.
- 27:08Then you don't have the energy and the willpower to be able to give,
- 27:15to truly meet someone and really have a mutual taken care of. So it's
- 27:19a it's a it's a take. And so they're very needy in the way
- 27:26like a child would be needy of a parent. But and they'll come across
- 27:30and they'll say I love you, and they'll be very oriented towards you.
- 27:33But it's not really mutual peer to peer loves. It's more selfish in a
- 27:41way. It's not selfish, but it's more self centered, I suppose,
- 27:45And it'll have all the look of something like, wow, there's so much
- 27:48energy coming towards me, and I feel so secure in this relationship. Because
- 27:52they need me so much. And you can trick yourself into thinking that it's
- 27:57love, but it's not loving a vision of you an object. They're loving
- 28:03a projection. They're loving what they hope to be an all loving, all
- 28:11caring, all stable, God or parent or superior or something. And for
- 28:18people who worry about ever being loved themselves in a different way, this can
- 28:23be very appealing because they try to get love in other ways and it never
- 28:29seems to work or feel deep satisfying. To just be showered with this amount
- 28:34of love, it can feel very good. And so you know, I
- 28:37think there's a risk of that happening here. That was not that's not our
- 28:44character, it's not how we were drinking is not healthy. And talking about
- 28:48our feelings and that circumstance that was not okay. And I'm completely aware of
- 28:53that. Okay, So normally, if I heard that, I would stop
- 28:57done a weird frame there, and I would say, Okay, Well,
- 29:03maybe if you just limit your drinking, or when you drink you don't talk
- 29:07about your relationship, maybe that'll work. I don't think that would work anyway,
- 29:11but normally I might think let's give it a shot. That would mean
- 29:15that when she's sober, which presumably she is here, she would be able
- 29:22to look back and say I was completely out of my mind or I was
- 29:26completely off base. She has not said that at all. She just said
- 29:30delivery. She stands by everything she did, at least at this point.
- 29:34Maybe she apologized later, but she hasn't yet. So oh and another element
- 29:38of this is that they have a really hard time apologizing, even in their
- 29:44own well outwardly because you know, for narcissistic people, they have a hard
- 29:48time admitting they're wrong because their defensive structure is so dependent on them never being
- 29:55wrong and always being superior. Because underneath that defensive structure is a vast of
- 30:00nothingness and inferiority that they need to overcompensate by tricking themselves and other people,
- 30:07because you know, half of their energy is is trying to trick themselves that
- 30:11they're at the very least not inferior, you know, and they're they're constantly
- 30:17feeling inferior and wondering if they're nothing, and so they overcompensate by telling themselves,
- 30:23oh, no, I'm superior, I'm better than everybody, right,
- 30:26I'm better than I'm not only just average I'm better, I'm better, and
- 30:29then they're signaling it to others because it reassures them when other people see them
- 30:33that way. And then for people with borderline, what they have underneath,
- 30:38you know, typically is this fear that no one will ever love them and
- 30:42that they're worthless and unlovable. And sometimes people with borderline will describe themselves as
- 30:49like just inherently disgusting or or dirty or corrupted somehow. It'll they'll feel both
- 30:59empty and also just riddled with evilness or with disgusting stuff. It's just in
- 31:11their bones because that's the way they were treated and that was the conclusion they
- 31:15came to, and they might have literally even been told those things when they
- 31:18were being abused or given that message anyway. So for them, they have
- 31:22a defensive structure of a being hypervigilant and assuming that abandonment will happen around the
- 31:29corner, and being very critical of others. They're trying to shape others to
- 31:33be good partners for them. For narcissistic people, even when all the evidence
- 31:40is pointing the direction that they made a mistake, they cannot admit it even
- 31:44to themselves because that will just put a large hole in their defensive structure and
- 31:49they will fall straight into the nothingness. And I've seen it happen. It's
- 31:52a desperate act. It's not an act of people just being a jerk face
- 31:56deciding to do it. It is an act of desperation. It causes a
- 32:00lot of harm in the world. But they're not doing it because they just
- 32:05want to get away with something. They're constantly running on a treadmill away from
- 32:08the monster, and they're not getting anywhere, and the running is just narcissists
- 32:13supply. And as soon as they stop running and getting narcissistic supply, they
- 32:17fall on their ass and they're in the mouth of the monster. And so
- 32:22for people with borderline, what they're running from when the treadmill is away from
- 32:25abandonment and betrayal, and they're not getting really away from it, but all
- 32:31their effort of control and of criticism and hypervigilance and of pursuit pursue distancer kind
- 32:40of stuff is along those lines. And so when they are acknowledging to themselves,
- 32:47maybe I did something wrong, then what they're worried about is when they
- 32:52admit they did something wrong, it punches a hole in the defensive structure.
- 32:57And what they're worried about falling into is and therefore it's true that no one
- 33:01will love me. If I made a mistake, then why am I even
- 33:08running on this treadmill. I might as well just jump into the monster's mouth.
- 33:14Now that's black and white thinking. It's actually the opposite. If they
- 33:17were able to admit, at the very least of themselves, but at best
- 33:22to their partners, that they did something wrong, because of course she did
- 33:25something wrong, because everyone does wrong things, the irony is that their relationship
- 33:30would be stronger. But that's not how it feels. It feels like,
- 33:34you know, to the narcissistic person, if I have one flaw, then
- 33:37I am one hundred percent flawed and no one will love me, and everyone
- 33:40will be superior to me, and I'll be nothing to the border eye person.
- 33:45If I admit I have one flaw, if I did one thing wrong,
- 33:47then that will truly mean that the battle is over and no one will
- 33:52ever love me, because I will be revealed for the flawed, horrible person
- 33:58that I was told and that I know that I am. And so they
- 34:01will not admit before treatment, before recovery, before insight. They will not
- 34:07admit that they did something wrong. So it's not because they're a jerk face.
- 34:12It's desperation. But when things get tough, like I need to know
- 34:17that you're not just gonna walk away from me. Right, I'll stop you
- 34:22ammoring, But I just want to highlight it went faster than I realized it
- 34:27would or predicted it would. That we're right back to criticizing him. He
- 34:31said, if you think I don't love you, and you are talking about
- 34:37not wanting to be with me, I don't know if I want to be
- 34:39with you. He was only saying that in response to many things that she
- 34:45was saying and just straight up lying to him. Someone told me you were
- 34:51with Jess last night. I mean that's a discreet, just straight up lie,
- 34:57right, I mean, unless that's true, but it appeared to me
- 35:00not, so you know, he was responding to her. You didn't just
- 35:06come out of the blue and say like I don't want to be with you.
- 35:08Last week, I went home during the middle of an argument and I
- 35:15told myself I wasn't gonna do that again. Like I was proud of myself
- 35:17for not leaving. When you retreat me that way, I know it goes
- 35:24both. Yeah, I'm not bashing her, but I can. I can
- 35:34be in both shoes, and if I'm in his shoes, it's it's that
- 35:40nice voice, that tender voice, that vulnerable voice. But she has only
- 35:46defended herself and blamed him. The only thing she has said is that her
- 35:53delivery was bad. Maybe that's that's all she is admitted to. You could
- 36:00argue maybe she doesn't even really believe that. Maybe she was just saying that
- 36:02to be nice. So he's getting into the actual event, and then she
- 36:12says, yeah, but she interrupts him. What's reminding I'll do that again,
- 36:15Like I was proud of myself for not leaving when you will treat me
- 36:22that way, just me. I know it goes both ways, but like
- 36:25I felt, it doesn't go both ways. There are times when I will
- 36:30allow for that to be out there, even when it's like a twenty eighty
- 36:36percent thing. This is in the realm of abuse, and even if he
- 36:43did a few things wrong, it doesn't matter the pattern of coercive control.
- 36:50She literally said, you can't leave the house, you can't go out.
- 36:53Ever, that was how this whole thing started. You're not ever going to
- 36:59do that, even though you would have taken me with you if I wasn't
- 37:02tired or I wanted to go. I also, I mean, just all
- 37:08the things, I draw the line there. I'll give a lot of leeway
- 37:15for people if we're not in the abuse camp, but if we are,
- 37:21then no, Now I don't know what's happening here exactly, but in real
- 37:28life, no, Like when I have couples that are in my office and
- 37:31one person is abusive, and some of you might even there are even clinicians
- 37:35that will say it's unethical to treat a couple when there is an abusive partner.
- 37:38That's simply not true. It can be and it's not a matter of
- 37:43ethics per se. It's just a matter of the standard of practice or what's
- 37:45going to be helpful to the victim in particular. And if I take one
- 37:52case in which I would never see as a couple, you have an abusive
- 37:57partner who is not taking response ability, is dangerous, perhaps physically has threatened
- 38:04with a gun, has guns in the house, has already gone down a
- 38:08road of gas lighting and control, has separated the victim from a lot of
- 38:13other people. Yeah, I wouldn't have that couple in my office. But
- 38:19as I've been talking about through all of this is that there are many different
- 38:22types and gradations to abuse, contrary to what the Internet will say, like
- 38:29there's a binary. It's like you're either abusive or you're not, and there
- 38:32is a grey zone. But there's also, like a lot, there's a
- 38:35spectrum in different types. And I'm not saying that violence is more severe necessarily.
- 38:40You can definitely have abuse that looks like this that can be very very
- 38:44severe, if not more severe in a sense than violence, because it gets
- 38:47into your head. So the reason why I wouldn't see a couple like that
- 38:52in my office is because I couldn't guarantee that I would get a clear account
- 38:59from the victim because the perpetrator sitting right there. Even if I met with
- 39:02the victim alone at times, you know I alternated, I wouldn't necessarily know.
- 39:07Plus, the the imminent nature of the danger is perhaps so dangerous that
- 39:15because therapy will provoke things at times, you're not doing it on purpose.
- 39:19But you know that part of treatment for couples like this is that the victim
- 39:23is given a voice, a lot more of a voice than they've maybe ever
- 39:29had, but particularly in this relationship. But that is threatening to the perpetrator,
- 39:32And it also depends on the type of perpetrator. If it's like a
- 39:35psychopathic satist perpetrator, then yeah, that's it's not going to work. But
- 39:39most people that are abusive or not, we don't assess them as having that
- 39:45that disorder. So that's why we don't want to treat couples. But you
- 39:50know, the general public and a lot of clinicians, they'll just in a
- 39:52sweeping way, they'll just say treating a couple that has abuse in it is
- 39:57unethical. It's it depends. So in this couple at this phase is we
- 40:04don't know where it'd be in ten years. But with this couple, if
- 40:07what I'm seeing in the edit is accurate, I would characterize this as a
- 40:12form of abuse and it has an abusive cycle. And I would also ask
- 40:19the question, if I saw them as a couple, would I be worried
- 40:22that he was going to be killed or seriously harmed physically if he was to
- 40:30say something or the therapy were to challenge her some way that would trigger something
- 40:34in her and she would go after him. And based on what I'm seeing,
- 40:37which isn't enough information to make this decision, anyway, I'm guessing that
- 40:42I would find with more information than I would not conclude that he was in
- 40:45that sort of serious danger. Is he in danger of continuing with this sort
- 40:51of abuse? Yeah, but not with the kinds of things we'd be concerned
- 40:57for victims that would make it so that we would step one want the victim
- 41:01to actually be in a shelter or something. Okay, So with this couple,
- 41:06I imagine it's not hard to imagine for you that if I could work
- 41:12with both of them and slowly walk down the road, get a good enough
- 41:16relationship with her so that I can I wouldn't say she's abusive right off the
- 41:21bat, but I would one just build a relationship with her, And there's
- 41:24things I can do with people like her that aren't directly talking about abuse,
- 41:30Like I could say, let's work on both of your approach to apologies,
- 41:37for example, and then I would say, okay, let's start, what
- 41:42do you feel like you should be apologizing to your partner for or what would
- 41:45you like an apology for from your partner? And then I would walk through
- 41:49it. In my head, I'm thinking she's the one that needs more work
- 41:52with that, but everyone needs work on that and I could spend equal time
- 41:58and there's it's going to be more growth for her and there'll be some growth
- 42:02for him. But we're addressing the issue and we move down the road.
- 42:07So there's a lot of things I can do that isn't saying you are abusive
- 42:14and you are a victim. Once I get that rapport, I will say
- 42:17that. I use the word abuse with people in my office because I want
- 42:22them to know this isn't just this minor issue. It's weighty and the word
- 42:30abuse has weight, and I want them to feel that weight in the same
- 42:35way that I have treated couples, married couples who one person had raped their
- 42:40partner, and that word might not even be used by anyone in the couple,
- 42:50but I will use that word. Or maybe sexual assault depends, but
- 42:54I will use that word because I want the weight of it to be felt.
- 43:00I need to have a good enough relationship with them so that they don't
- 43:02blow out of therapy, and what good does that do? Right, But
- 43:06that's the primary thing in therapy is developing a relationship so that they trust me
- 43:10and feel that I I have love for them, so that when I bring
- 43:19this up, it is out of love and not a judgment but an observation.
- 43:27So with her, I would say that, and then you know,
- 43:30it'd be hard to swallow. Now the victims are appreciative of that, you
- 43:37know, like, oh, but they're also worried because you know, they
- 43:42don't they love their partner and they don't want them to feel bad. But
- 43:47then the journey begins. It's hard, you know. I've had clients and
- 43:51couples where one of the one of the individuals was abusive and it wouldn't be
- 43:54the topic every session, but you know, let's say there's a t transition
- 44:00period. Eventually they adjust to the term abuse, the label abuse for themselves
- 44:04and they go, yeah, I guess I guess I am that way,
- 44:07And you know what, my mom was that way too, and so I
- 44:09guess I've It doesn't sound an excuse, but oh, it's awful. I've
- 44:15had abusive clients, you know, who are abusive to their partners be some
- 44:19of the most moral, nicest, most self aware people I've ever met,
- 44:24so that stereotype has to go. Certainly, abusive people can be that way,
- 44:29but I've had abusive people who were in the moment they're not self aware,
- 44:34but in therapy, they'll say, oh, I did it again.
- 44:36I'm so sorry. You know that's they're capable of that, and if a
- 44:39therapist believes in them, then we can bring that out in them. We
- 44:43can emphasize that. And it takes a therapist that can believe in someone and
- 44:47loves someone to get them to that place because it's based on rejection anyway,
- 44:53and pain the whole reason why it exists. And so if they don't feel
- 44:59the opposite, which is acceptance and love, then how are they supposed to
- 45:01come out of their shell anyway? So she might get to that place.
- 45:07It can take a long time, but even in that phase, it takes
- 45:13a long time where they continue to have cycles and triggers and the victim continues
- 45:20to walk on eggshells. It's their choice, and I'll call it out and
- 45:24I'll say, are you sure this is what you want to do? And
- 45:29I'll meet individually and you know, make sure they're not being like torn down
- 45:31without agency anyway. And then we could be in that phase for years while
- 45:37they continue to do things that are abusive in nature and regret it later before
- 45:45they finally kick the habit. It can take a long time, but The
- 45:50reason why I do couple therapy, why I use that modality is that in
- 45:53my experience, for some situations, and of course, you know, each
- 45:55individual might have their own individual therapist. They might even be an individual domestic
- 46:00violence treatment or something. But even without that, depending on the scenario,
- 46:04the rapid pace of therapy is. You know that the speed is more rapid
- 46:10because the victim is right there. And if I'm effective at bringing everyone to
- 46:15the table and making it safe for the victim to talk, then the perpetrator
- 46:22can't get lost in their own justifications because if they do, the victim will
- 46:27say that's not what happened, or that's not how it felt, or I,
- 46:30yes, you've improved, but I still walk on eggshells. If I
- 46:34don't have access to that, then how am I supposed to know? Because
- 46:37unless you know, typically in domestic violence treatment programs, these programs are for
- 46:44convicted criminals, people who have been charged and convicted of an assault of some
- 46:50sort, you know, some domestic domestic violence crime, and those are only
- 46:58brought to our attention when you know, when I did that kind of work,
- 47:01we did talk with the victims, but not very often, but we
- 47:06did. But after they were done with the treatment program unless they got in
- 47:10trouble with the log again regarding domestic violence crime, then we didn't know,
- 47:16and so we might hope for the best, but you know, if the
- 47:21victim's right there. Plus, I can treat the victim because victims might not
- 47:25have just been victimized by their current partner. They might have been victimized several
- 47:30times in their life, and they have issues regarding their own self esteem and
- 47:34their own self worth, and their own boundaries and their own agency. So
- 47:40I can help with them with that. And I can do that in front
- 47:44of the perpetrator and watch the perpetrator watch us and go, oh, is
- 47:50that what's happening. I don't want that to happen because people care. Most
- 47:53abusers have empathy, they have the capacity for empathy. And then for the
- 47:59victim to watch me talk with the perpetrator about the traumas that they went through
- 48:04and the emotions that they feel that generate the abusive cycle, for them to
- 48:10see that, like, oh, that's way different than I thought. You
- 48:15just were a jerk face. I thought you were just controlling. I thought
- 48:19you just liked putting me down. You're still putting me down. And you're
- 48:22still controlling me at times, but it's something from your past. I feel
- 48:27bad about that. Now. We have to be careful because the victim shouldn't
- 48:30be sucked in to an abusive relationship that they would otherwise leave because they feel
- 48:36sorry for the perpetrator. That can happen sometimes, but I'm there to monitor
- 48:40it, and sometimes they do break up. Sometimes that's the best way for
- 48:45a victim to get out of a relationship is for this model to happen.
- 48:47In couple therapy, the victim does all this work. I'm working with them.
- 48:52They're watching me work with the perpetrator, working on communication. Things are
- 48:55shifting, you know. Typically at the very least, the abuse becomes heavily
- 49:00attenuated because they're coming to me every week, you know. And over time
- 49:04the victim grows and changes and learns and eventually says, you know what,
- 49:09I don't want to I don't want to be in this relationship anymore. And
- 49:13I don't know if I could have got here if I just went to individual
- 49:16therapy and I told the therapist what I was going through and the therapist just
- 49:21supported everything that I said. Now, maybe that is the model, and
- 49:24that certainly can work, for sure, and I've done that work too,
- 49:28But there's something kind of magical about having everyone in the room and they love
- 49:35each other. And what a wonderful thing if we could get the perpetrator to
- 49:37not perpetrate, and we could get the victim to no longer be a victim,
- 49:42and love will prevail, the original love can be, can be retained
- 49:45and enhanced. It's the best of all worlds. And my view, that's
- 49:50why I became a couple of family therapists. That's how it was sold to
- 49:52me. I didn't know about a couple of family therapy and I was just
- 49:55going to become a counselor. And Paul David my mentor, right, you
- 50:00know, I did an interview with Emmy was doing. He was at the
- 50:02open house thing and all of us are in the audience and he's talking about
- 50:07a couple of family therapists. They can work with individuals, and they can
- 50:09work with couples and families. And I thought, huh, I don't want
- 50:15to be you know, I was having fomo about couples and families. I
- 50:17was like, yeah, okay, individuals, but yeah, a couple.
- 50:20I want to work with individuals. That's but I can also work with couples
- 50:22of families. That sounds exciting, you know the thing that I because I
- 50:27eventually I was in his shoes talking to prospective students. And when I tell
- 50:31you that us, as a couple of family therapists, we work with individuals,
- 50:35couples and families, and if you join our program, you will be
- 50:37trained to do that. All of you will be terrified of that prospect,
- 50:42because you know, talking with one person seems easier, and it is so
- 50:49fear is rational. The difference is some of you will feel that fear and
- 50:54say no, no, no, no, no, I don't want that,
- 50:55But some of you will feel that fear and go ooh without me,
- 51:00it still is. I selled it so much from you yesterday. What else
- 51:12can I do to make you feel like, well, this could be a
- 51:15yes, Okay, we'll see what he says. I don't know. I
- 51:20don't have a good feeling about this at all. Now I've heard that she's
- 51:23in therapy and use using it well, So you know, maybe a year
- 51:29from now in terms of today, a year from the scene, everything works
- 51:31itself out. But you know, normally I'm like, oh, what's going
- 51:35to happen? Maybe there's a way to work things out. There isn't a
- 51:37way, you know, unless a lot changes in terms of her self awareness
- 51:43and her path to recovery, until there's even a hint of that that it's
- 51:47it's not I don't have any optimism. I need you never to cross the
- 51:53lawn on the things you cross the lown on the other night. Ever,
- 51:58like the same for you, I know, was never what line did he
- 52:02cross? Other than saying if you don't think I love you, and you
- 52:07think I have never loved you, and you don't want to be with me.
- 52:14If I'm going to go out for an hour to be with my friends
- 52:16and you're demanding I'm not friends with my three women friends, I said,
- 52:22I didn't want to be with you? What line? What line did he
- 52:25cross? Really, I'm trying to remember, I mean, and for her
- 52:30to get defense if you did it too, and that's I don't know about
- 52:34them, but abusive people will do that, so you know, the victim
- 52:37will say, hey, you know during the the country, I don't I
- 52:43don't use the main abuse wheel that everyone else uses. I agree with it,
- 52:46but it's you know, I just I just have a different set of
- 52:51words and concepts in my head. But it's the same cycle. But anyway,
- 52:54during the contrition or apology or repair or suck back in phase, the
- 53:01abusive person will you be nice at the very least, and maybe apology and
- 53:07sometimes abusive people will be fully apologetic and they will identify did this wrong,
- 53:12I did that wrong, and I did that wrong, and they might even
- 53:15mean it. But that doesn't necessarily mean that, you know, because until
- 53:19the the awareness and the repair and the systems in place to give the victim
- 53:24more power happen, like the expectation that whenever they want to, they can
- 53:30grab their bag and leave, and if there's any resistance from the abusive person,
- 53:37then the victim has the right to scream and scratch and claw and call
- 53:44the police, and the abusive person understands that while they are calm, so
- 53:49that they remember that in the moment, you know, just a lot of
- 53:52measures. I mean, that's kind of a severe one, but you know,
- 53:54stuff along those lines. Until that happens, the abuse cycle can just
- 53:59happen again. But anyway, so during the nice, apology contrition phase,
- 54:04the victim will be able sometimes to say, yeah, that was not okay,
- 54:10and the abusive person will often try to mitigate that because they either don't
- 54:17see it that way because of their traumas, or they don't want to be
- 54:22set up for a lack of power in the future. I don't know what
- 54:24that's happening here, but you could make an argument that she's setting up a
- 54:30narrative that they both did equally bad. I mean, that's what she's putting
- 54:36forth, and he's allowing that, which I don't know if that's how he
- 54:38sees it or that's how it is. I don't know. I'm only one
- 54:42person watching. I'm a fucking expert, but I'm only one fucking expert.
- 54:46There are other experts that would see it differently, undoubtedly, I guess.
- 54:51But anyway, so you could argue that what she's doing right now is she's
- 54:55sneaking that in you did things too, as a for look, I'm willing
- 55:01to pseudo apologize about nothing and basically say I stand by everything I did,
- 55:07but I just didn't like my delivery. What and you're saying that I did
- 55:12a lot of bad things, but you did bad things. So that when
- 55:14it comes time for me to get my clause in again and for me to
- 55:16control you and this isn't super volitional, you know, it's not like a
- 55:21Machiavelian plan typically, but the idea is that the place the person. So
- 55:28there's you could argue there's two main factors that contribute to abusive behavior. You
- 55:31have. One is I mean, unless we're talking about psychopaths and say this,
- 55:35it's a completely different topic. But for the vast majority of perpetrators,
- 55:38one is the relational trauma that distorts what they're seeing and exaggerates and makes them
- 55:46feel very intense, negative emotions that feel very justified to them. You know,
- 55:52last night she felt those feelings and they felt totally justified to her,
- 55:57and that fuels the justify vocation for going after your partner, because if your
- 56:02partner has made you feel these horrible, horrible feelings, then you deserve justice,
- 56:07you know, so those feelings are real. The other factor is the
- 56:15socialization, usually meaning the role models or something of And here's the answer to
- 56:22that feeling is through control. Because plenty of people have those feelings, but
- 56:28they don't resort to control. There's a lot of different controlling their partner.
- 56:31There's a lot of different responses to that, including a narcissistic response or a
- 56:36distance response, or a play cating response or something code pendant response. There's
- 56:39a lot of different responses, but her response exhibited in the edit is to
- 56:44control, to shut it down and do all those things, and that's what
- 56:49abusive people will do, right, So you have to have both. If
- 56:52you were just given the model of control and abuse, but you don't have
- 56:59the really traumas that result in you feeling deeply, deeply wounded over nothing or
- 57:04over very little things, then this is always available to you, but you
- 57:07don't ever call in it because you don't need it, because you have regular
- 57:10ways of dealing with your regular feelings. You don't need this now. I
- 57:14guess if you have a lot of it then maybe, But even then,
- 57:17and you know, truthfully, most people have that model because that's what most
- 57:23of us, particularly men, have been taught. So the fact that most
- 57:28men are abusive means that you need to have that second element. And if
- 57:32you have that first element, with that second So there's this deep feeling and
- 57:38worry of just like this could happen again from her in all likelihood, and
- 57:43I need to be able to engage in the same you know solution, And
- 57:47I'm still basically in that you know, when they talk about the cycle of
- 57:52abuse, I think sometimes people can think that the abusive person is a different
- 57:57person or something during the reconcilia, during the you know, as I was
- 58:00saying earlier, the contrition phase. And you know, maybe, but I
- 58:06think it's more important because if you really scrutinize as I've been doing, her
- 58:10behavior, it's not really a place of contricious She's not really apologizing. Her
- 58:16approach is differently is different. It's it looks softer. She's crying, she's
- 58:22not accusing or pointing fingers. Her body language is different, but it's the
- 58:28same message. If you just look at verbatim, you did things wrong,
- 58:31you amp that up to a different voice register. And that's what she was
- 58:36saying yesterday. It's so it looks like she's apologizing. It has the look.
- 58:42That's how it's so insidious. And if people aren't educated, as the
- 58:45vast majority of people aren't, because they've been given this one particular type of
- 58:51abusive person, then you would have no idea it's happening to you. You
- 58:54know, he could walk away and go, wow's she was really nice.
- 59:00I just love that she apologized, And you know, she said she was
- 59:02wrong. She has not said that. You could argue she kind of went
- 59:07along with things that he was saying, but not in my book, because
- 59:12as soon as he said every time she has followed up. You know him,
- 59:17no, nothing. He did nothing the first time with ad. Okay,
- 59:22on the scale of things, I wouldn't put it up there, but
- 59:25okay, you can complain about that. I could be triggering. You could
- 59:30ask him not to do that again. Okay, But the second fight was
- 59:34also nothing. From what she said that he had done or not done had
- 59:40been refuted some of it. And also what we saw on camera was he
- 59:44went to work, he came home, he was with her and her friends.
- 59:45He was lovely, everything was nice. They had a good time,
- 59:49they watched the TV show. They had sex, even though he was not
- 59:51really in the mood, but he went along with it because he could feel
- 59:53the pressure. And then and then she's like, I don't feel your love,
- 59:58you don't love me. There's a little bit of talk about how he
- 1:00:01doesn't always reply to her text while he's at work or something. I don't
- 1:00:05know. Certainly, not anything that you could say was anything close the transgressions
- 1:00:12that she has committed against him. Are completely eclipsed anything that he has done
- 1:00:15to her on camera and off according to their account, maybe he has been
- 1:00:22horrible behind the scenes. She has mentioned nothing about that, and you have
- 1:00:24to figure she would have the fact that she was screaming in his face and
- 1:00:28saying you fucked her. Do you think she had restraint last night regarding her
- 1:00:34ammunition against him, No, she would have said something. We have heard
- 1:00:37it all and a lot of fabrications that she's not. She doesn't wake up
- 1:00:43in the morning decided to do that. This is this is a This is
- 1:00:45a lot of suffering. She ironically is suffering more than him, which is
- 1:00:51kind of weird to think that abusive people are often suffering more than the abused
- 1:00:54person. Depends on the phase and the type, right, But at this
- 1:00:58phase, he's suffering. But typically when I treat people like this, her
- 1:01:02suffering is a hundred times worse. So I feel tremendously bad for both.
- 1:01:09I need you never to to cross the lawn on the things you cross the
- 1:01:15lan on the other night, ever like same for you, And I'll stop
- 1:01:21yammering. But they're doing what I predicted earlier, which is that it'll just
- 1:01:25be a commitment to never do it again, which won't work under any circumstances,
- 1:01:30whether it's a personality sort or abuse or not. Like you know,
- 1:01:35I've talked about that a lot, A commitment to like, oh I'm just
- 1:01:37gonna have willpower. It's not going to work. No, And I never
- 1:01:40ever, ever, ever want to argue like that ever again. Ever.
- 1:01:45Yeah me either. That wasn't fair for both of us. So where's your
- 1:01:52head at right now? I I signed up for the experiment, you know,
- 1:01:57I hardly know what that means. I mean, he might just be
- 1:02:00I'll see this through, which would be totally normal. But I don't know.
- 1:02:05I don't know. I don't know. I don't know anything. I
- 1:02:07don't know their future. I don't know anything. But yeah, I mean,
- 1:02:10that's what he's been saying this whole time. Is he isn't breaking up,
- 1:02:15which is fine. I worry about him, though, I worry about
- 1:02:21both of them. To get married too. Fine. A wife found a
- 1:02:23lot of my life. I'm still here for that reason. Do I want
- 1:02:29to give it a shot? Yeah? I do. And I should throw
- 1:02:35this out there that I don't know about them, But I've seen this many
- 1:02:38times where you have someone that presents like her, and you have someone that
- 1:02:43presents like him, and the Jimmies of the world will not realize it,
- 1:02:50you know, sort of like slowly raising the temperature on a frog, which
- 1:02:53apparently is apocryphal. The frog usually jumps out from miner stand. But anyway,
- 1:02:57using the metaphor that the jimi's over over time, they don't realize that
- 1:03:02they're slowly losing agency and making sacrifices. You know, they might feel a
- 1:03:07little bit, but they'll usually say, well, just as temporarily temporary,
- 1:03:10I don't really need that. Who cares. Fast forward in time and they're
- 1:03:14an abused, isolated, gas lit victim. The other thing that could happen
- 1:03:20that's very serious is that if there can well not if, but well,
- 1:03:25I don't know if their conflict continues even if they do get married, right,
- 1:03:29say, to get married and more triggers, more intense fighting, more
- 1:03:35frustration from him, because over time it's just going to pile up. Right,
- 1:03:39he has two choices. He either just completely gives in and becomes a
- 1:03:43victim or tries to reason with her, and in the middle of a fight,
- 1:03:47you know, as we saw, just there's no getting through, and
- 1:03:52so what can happen is there could be a huge blow up, and he
- 1:03:54could actually do things that are empirically problematic, like throwing a chair across the
- 1:04:03room or something not violent with her. You know, I guess that too,
- 1:04:08but you know, reasonably you could imagine something like that, or cheating
- 1:04:12on her or something or I don't know, something that she could point to
- 1:04:16and tell others about. And maybe even or he could just just go off
- 1:04:21verbally, just be like, I can't standy you just always and she records
- 1:04:26it and holds onto it, and then she never tells him about it,
- 1:04:30and then when they do break up, she like sends him a clip of
- 1:04:35the audio and says, hey, I'm just saying, you know, if
- 1:04:40you don't want to work on this relationship, I'm just gonna have to tell
- 1:04:44everyone who you are because I have a reputation to hold up or something,
- 1:04:46you know, that coercion, blackmail. And if he doesn't go back and
- 1:04:54she releases that and has a whole you just imagine she would believe what happened.
- 1:05:00She would write this whole post online, maybe even have an article in
- 1:05:03the newspaper and just ruin his life, even though he was the victim.
- 1:05:13It's a very serious thing. This is not just this reality TV thing.
- 1:05:15This The other serious outcome that can happen is a lot of people, says
- 1:05:18a little while back, the people I've treated who present like this, I
- 1:05:21don't know about her, no idea, but almost everyone I've treated like this,
- 1:05:27And as a well known association is suicidality is a desire to die because
- 1:05:33of the ongoing chronic suffering, especially when there's a transition like being dumped or
- 1:05:40broken up with, or a big fight or being fired from a job or
- 1:05:44something. You know, they're already in so much distress, and then their
- 1:05:48trigger is like, ah, just give up. You know it's again.
- 1:05:50Treatment that can absolutely go away the demoralization and the reason even fueling that.
- 1:05:58But you know, for those of you who have that, make sure you
- 1:06:00get treatment for that. And that's another serious outcome. Another serious outcome is
- 1:06:06murder. I'm not saying and I don't want anyone to say she's going to
- 1:06:13kill him or something, but you know, of the people who kill their
- 1:06:16spouses, it often comes from a presentation that is like this. Now,
- 1:06:21if I had a client like this, I wouldn't assume that would happen.
- 1:06:26It's a pretty rare event. It's much more likely that suicide would occur.
- 1:06:30Suicide is way more prevalent than murder. There's some very serious outcomes here.
- 1:06:33You know. This isn't just like is bartisk gonna marry Nancy? What's gonna
- 1:06:38happen? You know? This is when I watch these shows, I think
- 1:06:41these things. I don't usually mention it though, you know, because in
- 1:06:43the clinical world we deal with that side of things. You know, the
- 1:06:46reality TV is just like ah Chelsea's a I don't like her, Jimmy.
- 1:06:50You know, I'm not mocking people. I mean it's serious and some of
- 1:06:56you know it, and for those who might not, I want you to
- 1:06:59know it because it's important to know these things because and it maybe make connections.
- 1:07:06You know, when you hear a story in the news about something along
- 1:07:12these lines, and all you hear is the most reportable data, you might
- 1:07:16think, oh those are those are crazy people that'll never happen to me.
- 1:07:20When you watch this, I hope you see something that looks kind of familiar.
- 1:07:24It's not hard to mess you know, many of you have been here.
- 1:07:26But even if you haven't been in this exact thing it's relatable. It's
- 1:07:30conflict, it's love, it's trying to work things out, self awareness,
- 1:07:33that kind of stuff, you know, And and this, this is where
- 1:07:36it is. That's what I what I I've When I watch these shows,
- 1:07:43I am terrified, especially when they are attacked by everyone online, that someone
- 1:07:51is going to die. It happens. It happens all the time in my
- 1:07:57field, all the time. It's a very real thing. It's a very
- 1:08:01real thing. And so I guess if it's one thing I'm asking you to
- 1:08:05do is to take care when you are commenting online or or commenting on someone
- 1:08:13else's Instagram, participating in some Reddit conversation. It's it's real. It is
- 1:08:19it is real. This is real. We're watching reality TV. It's it's
- 1:08:28edited, it's you know, played up a little bit for the cameras maybe,
- 1:08:30but but it's real. I love you too. I really want to
- 1:08:36try with you, me too. The reason here, you too, or
- 1:08:41you can't come dressing like that when I'm mad at you, you look good.
- 1:08:47I really like those fants. It's hard not to consider it charming.
- 1:08:57Those pants. Yeah I predicted this in the beginning, and yeah, I'm
- 1:09:09not gonna say it all over again, I love you, and then he's
- 1:09:18the one that goes over to her. I would just feel so much better
- 1:09:24if she had some shred of actual remorse and apologize for at least one of
- 1:09:30the things that happened, or say I was overreacting even just that word.
- 1:09:42But there was nothing. There was none of that zero. In fact,
- 1:09:49most of the time of this conversation, she was the one saying he did
- 1:09:53a bunch of things wrong. One it doesn't give me any hope for the
- 1:09:58situation. And two it's just an injustice. It's just it's wrong. You
- 1:10:02know, we evolved. There's evidence to have an instinct, you know,
- 1:10:09and other primates as well. When we see an injustice for us to get
- 1:10:13upset for other people, it's like, hey, that's not the way the
- 1:10:16world's supposed to work. So I'm just a monkey watching injustice and shaking my
- 1:10:24cage, powerless, sitting in this office watching and you're watching me like some
- 1:10:30kind of lab coat research just took. Of course, I want to continue
- 1:10:34to travel with you. She's so damn hard not to forgive. The other
- 1:10:42night really hurt my feelings. But every conflict Selsea and I have had,
- 1:10:51I would love to just ask him, what are you forgiving her for?
- 1:10:56Exactly? I said, well, you know what happened? Well, what
- 1:11:00what happened? What happened? What exactly? What's one thing that she did
- 1:11:05last night that you are forgiving for? Well, when she was basically accusing
- 1:11:13me of I don't know, cheating on her when I went out the night
- 1:11:15before with my friends. Okay, it's nice of you that you're forgiving.
- 1:11:20Did she ask for your forgiveness for that? No? Did she apologize for
- 1:11:27that? No? Did she think it was wrong that she did that?
- 1:11:33Did she say she was wrong that she did that? No? Okay,
- 1:11:40And it's up to you, But you still want to forgive her? Am
- 1:11:44I hearing that right like that would be a conversation I would have with a
- 1:11:46client. It'd be a little less judge for a lot less judges. But
- 1:11:53I've had those conversations, you know, So I want to say that to
- 1:11:57him. We've been able to get through it. I love that about her.
- 1:12:00I almost took this off. I'd love to hear for you to see
- 1:12:05that would have been sad. I love you, love me too, and
- 1:12:15I hope you take this to heart for yourself the next time you forgive or
- 1:12:19move on, Ask yourself, did they actually apologize, did they admit the
- 1:12:26transgression? How much work did it take me to pride out of them?
- 1:12:30And did it work? Because you could have an interaction if you've never been
- 1:12:34really apologized to, and you don't really know what apologies are supposed to look
- 1:12:39like. You know the reason why I did. I said all this in
- 1:12:42the deep dive. But the primary function in my view, you know,
- 1:12:46it's just my philosophical or worldview, the primary function of an apology in most
- 1:12:53situations. You know, there are situations where apologies happens and it's less important.
- 1:12:57But the kind of apologies that would happen here is that the transgressor demonstrates
- 1:13:04to the transgressed that they have done a lot of work trying to put themselves
- 1:13:10in the other person's shoes and have explored why it even happened that they transgressed,
- 1:13:15and thus have a pathway to correct for those factors so that they're less
- 1:13:20likely likely to commit that transgression in the future. That's why you apologize.
- 1:13:26It's not just to move on or even take responsibility. You can take responsibility
- 1:13:30and not have any remorse, not put yourself in the other person's shoes,
- 1:13:34not do any work, even just thinking on your own, you know,
- 1:13:39like if she had said, I am sorry for getting on your case last
- 1:13:44night about having gone out with your friends. I feel terrible that I started
- 1:13:49and perpetuate the perpetuated the entire fight because you didn't do anything wrong and it
- 1:13:58was all my fault, and I feel so bad that I put you through
- 1:14:00that. It felt real the time, but I feel so terrible and so
- 1:14:04sad that I can't imagine what that must have felt like for you, that
- 1:14:09you're being accused of that, and the way I was talking to you and
- 1:14:13I wouldn't listen to you, and I must have just felt so hurtful and
- 1:14:16so frustrating. That's just one of the things I did. And so I've
- 1:14:21been thinking and going to a lot of therapy, and I figured out I'm
- 1:14:26I'm paranoid about you cheating on me, and I think you're cheating on me,
- 1:14:30or you're gonna cheat on me in situations where there's no evidence, and
- 1:14:33I don't know, maybe you are cheating, maybe you will cheat on me,
- 1:14:36but I don't have any reason to believe that. And I just assumed
- 1:14:41that it was happening, and it felt like it was happening. It felt
- 1:14:45like you had wronged me and betrayed me, or I felt like I was
- 1:14:49going to be betrayed. I was so sure of it. But when I
- 1:14:53look at it objectively and I talked with my therapist, there's there was no
- 1:14:56betrayal zero. I was also in embarrassed because you know, Mackenzie called and
- 1:15:01I didn't know what to say, and I have a problem with that too.
- 1:15:03This is not an excuse, but but I know what happened and I
- 1:15:08now have a path forward. I will probably get paranoid in the future.
- 1:15:13Again. I preapologize for that, but I am confident that I have a
- 1:15:20path forward and I'm dedicating myself to really working on this because I don't want
- 1:15:25to feel that way, and I definitely don't want to put you through that.
- 1:15:28That would be an Apollo's That's what I'm talking about. To the transgress
- 1:15:32they'd be like, Oh, that makes me feel good that you know what
- 1:15:38I went through and care about what I went through and have done a lot
- 1:15:43of work to figure out why you did that and are doing things to prevent
- 1:15:46it from happening again. I have said almost that exact thing to my wife.
- 1:15:53Not those words, but that format, because it's how I think.
- 1:15:57I'm not just following a format. I don't even have a format. I
- 1:16:01was just following my own nose as I went through that role play. Because
- 1:16:06I have all the elements felt to me, I let the apology gravitate me
- 1:16:13towards it. I'm not trying to follow steps, but I have said that
- 1:16:16one of the phrase I've said exactly I said, I have said probably every
- 1:16:21time I apologize to my wife, I say I can't guarantee I'm not going
- 1:16:24to do it again, and I preapologize for doing it. I'm so sorry,
- 1:16:29but I'm trying because it's irrational to assume that anybody can refrain from committing
- 1:16:36a transgression like this, because the same personality is there, the same tendency
- 1:16:44is there. You can't just will power that away. And it acknowledges that
- 1:16:48you acknowledge that it's not as simple as just having willpower. You're acknowledging to
- 1:16:54the transgress that you are very You're not delusional. You're not going to minimize
- 1:17:01it. You're not going to say it's never going to happen again. That's
- 1:17:04denial because to say it's never going to happen again means I don't really need
- 1:17:09to work on it because it's just never gonna happen again. We didn't hear
- 1:17:14anything close to that. Was it edited out? I doubt it? And
- 1:17:18so he forgives her. Is this the beginning of the brainwashing? Is this
- 1:17:27the begin Is this the beginning? Because this I don't know what's happening here,
- 1:17:30but if someone told me this on my couch or I saw this developing,
- 1:17:35I would characterize it as the beginning of the abusive style relationship and dynamic.
- 1:17:45All of the elements are in place that I've laid out, and his
- 1:17:53forgiveness, So where does that come from? On one hand, he could
- 1:18:00just be really nice and just really love her okay. On the other hand,
- 1:18:04he doesn't know he deserves better. He doesn't he doesn't really exhibit that.
- 1:18:08I don't. I don't know what it is, but it the fact
- 1:18:11that he's and maybe he plans on, but the fact that he's just completely
- 1:18:15okay with how this non apology went. And I I can't be mad at
- 1:18:21her. She's so easy to forgive. That's a red flag for his susceptibility
- 1:18:28to victimization. I don't know, but I'll say that to y'all so that
- 1:18:33he can know what that looks like. So you're gonna make me cookies or
- 1:18:39what night? Night? Why because you're in the freaking club, probably under
- 1:18:55normal circumstances, like well, that's funny, you're making it light of it.
- 1:18:58If she had already apologized for that, maybe, but there's a I
- 1:19:03am ninety percent sure that her brain literally went there in that moment, and
- 1:19:10because she is in the phase of where she's at, she didn't go after
- 1:19:15him. Think about that. He says he's tired because he didn't get sleep
- 1:19:19last night. Of course all of you thought because he was in massive emotional
- 1:19:25distress. The fact that it even just popped into her head it says something.
- 1:19:30But there's a pretty good chance she actually had a paranoid thought not It's
- 1:19:38not her fault. I'll say it again. I'm not bashing on her.
- 1:19:45It's not attack her. She It is a condition she has. If she
- 1:19:49has this condition, she has no control over it. No one does.
- 1:19:55But how interesting that she said that that that's that's scary me. Oh you
- 1:20:00didn't think I loved you. I'm happy that she knows where I'm at now,
- 1:20:10and I'm happy she feel the same way, and I'm happy to And
- 1:20:13I'm sure I don't need to do this. I hope I don't need to
- 1:20:15do this, but it just try in your mind by reversing the genders.
- 1:20:18It's not an exact replica, but just as a thought exercise, do that.
- 1:20:24Let's do that. Imagine if he was the one that said, where
- 1:20:29were you? I know you were with Trevor. I know it, someone
- 1:20:34told me, and you know you fucked that guy and you I don't want
- 1:20:42to be married to a woman that goes out with her friends for an hour.
- 1:20:45I don't. I that's not going to work for me. Right.
- 1:20:49If it's hard to feel, really go down that road. It's not the
- 1:20:55exact road, but worth thinking. If it's hard to feel, because he's
- 1:21:00a lot bigger, he's he fits none of the profiles the stereotypes of an
- 1:21:06abuse victim, but make no doubt about it. That has nothing to do
- 1:21:14with one's susceptibility to abuse and one's experience with abuse. I've been abused.
- 1:21:23I'm six foot one. I'm probably as similar. I don't know how tall
- 1:21:28he is, but I'm probably similar billed as him. I've been abused by
- 1:21:31people smaller than me. It has nothing to do with size gender. Men
- 1:21:38are more likely to be physically abusive, but in terms of emotional abuse,
- 1:21:42I don't know what the rate is. It might be slightly more men,
- 1:21:45I don't know. But what's the difference when you have a sixty to forty
- 1:21:50kind of a thing. And at the very least we're watching what resembles what
- 1:21:56I see? You know, even his body language as he's kissing her from
- 1:22:00underneath, you know he was the one who going to her. She even
- 1:22:03she even sexually objectifies him. And I mean just to draw just to sort
- 1:22:09of you know, imagine, well, you know, how am I supposed
- 1:22:13to be mad at you when you're wearing those pants in the midst of all
- 1:22:15the abuse? Right? If you're looking for ickiness, the same ickiness and
- 1:22:20the same hmm, if you feel that if he were a woman, the
- 1:22:27same ickiness is happening here. I feel the ickiness. Do you feel the
- 1:22:30yickiness? Work towards your marriage? That's that's what I came here for.
- 1:22:33And and I know Telsea is going to be a phenomenal wife. It's just
- 1:22:38working through the kinks of day to day and how we and victims will often
- 1:22:45be socialized prior to being in the relationship, and they're certainly socialized during the
- 1:22:48relationship. To to hope it'll get better. There's just a couple of if
- 1:22:55we just play our car every everything before, I'll just you know, I'll
- 1:22:58just sacrifice here and I'll be good and I'll you know, she says she's
- 1:23:01not gonna ever do it again, and she was nice and she apologized,
- 1:23:03and I need her and it must get better. It needs to get better.
- 1:23:09Everything. I'll be fine. It's just a couple of kinks. I
- 1:23:15will put my blood and sweat and tears into our relationship if I know that
- 1:23:18she's in it, and she's in it hundred percent. If she's in it,
- 1:23:21I'm in it and I won't let her go. Yeah, that's not
- 1:23:24a good metric, because an abusive person can be in it, at least
- 1:23:30in terms of I think how he defines that. That's not a good metric.
- 1:23:33Just because someone's in it or dedicated or putting effort does not mean that
- 1:23:39is a blind endorsement for the health of the relationship, nor nuts boy that
- 1:23:53she ends with you drive me nuts Boy said in a playful way, but
- 1:23:59it does not feel good to me. There's a lot of playful things that
- 1:24:03could have been uttered in that moment. I don't know what's happening here.
- 1:24:09I'm just saying this to the world so that you can see it when it
- 1:24:12happens in the real world. That's all. I have. No idea,
- 1:24:14no idea. All right, Well, that does it for that episode.
- 1:24:16I want to thank you if you have been watching all of these episodes.
- 1:24:19I know a number of you are. I see you, and I try
- 1:24:26to imagine. It feels better to imagine actual human beings, and I,
- 1:24:31you know, look at the comments and try to understand, you know,
- 1:24:35because when I'm a professor and I'm interacting with students, at least I can
- 1:24:39see their faces, and of course I interact with them a lot outside of
- 1:24:42lecturing, of course, but at the very least there's a there's a sense
- 1:24:45of that, and so it feels, I guess better for me to think
- 1:24:50about people following this for a while. You know that it's not just random
- 1:24:56people jumping in and watching one episode, so as a part of that,
- 1:25:00but I just want to thank you for doing that. I consider it a
- 1:25:05very important honor to me. I'm very honored by it. I consider it
- 1:25:12a responsibility that I have to you, particularly. I don't do this just
- 1:25:16because I feel like it. I do this because when you click on these
- 1:25:23videos, it says you get some value or entertainment from it, or both.
- 1:25:28And I want to be of service to you. So thank you,
- 1:25:31and take care of yourself because you deserve it. You really, really do