Latest / The Team House / Israel\Hamas Negotiations: Are They Going Anywhere? | EYES ON | Ep. 22
Transcript
- 0:00Hey, guys, it's Jack. I just wanted to talk to you today
- 0:02about a way that you can help support the podcast. If you're not already,
- 0:06we would really appreciate it if you guys went and reviewed us on Apple
- 0:10or Spotify. Those reviews really help people find the podcast and help it get
- 0:15recognized, and you know, if you've been enjoying the show, we really
- 0:18appreciate your support. Another thing that you can do to support the channel is
- 0:23to become a Patreon member. So we have Patreon memberships that started just five
- 0:28dollars a month, and when you sign up, you get access to all
- 0:32of our episodes add free. That's the big bonus for that. I mean,
- 0:36we also do some Patreon bonus episodes for our subscribers, but this is
- 0:41the biggest and best way that you can support the Teamhouse channel and podcast if
- 0:47you'd like to, and we really appreciate that, So go and check us
- 0:51out at patreon dot com slash the Teamhouse. Hello, everyone, welcome to
- 0:56another episode of I so On, and I'm going to announce my interrot and
- 1:00the host introduction first because we never rehearsed this so and then we'll get around
- 1:03to the guest I'm Andy Milburn, I'm Jason Lyons, I'm Dimitrik on Tacos
- 1:10and today as a guest, we have Alex Pleisis. He's a non resident
- 1:15Senior Fellow with the Atlantic Council. Very interestingly, I think, I mean,
- 1:19his whole resume is interesting, but of particular interest especially to our listeners.
- 1:23He's just taken over the the Terrorism Studies Group. Is that right?
- 1:26Alex at the Atlantic Council. You know, he's a and perhaps unlike some
- 1:37of the think tank think tank crowd, Alex has plenty of practical experience.
- 1:42He was Chief of Special Programs in the under the Assistant Secretary of Defense for
- 1:49special operations some low intensity conflict. It's so much easier saying, ASD sold
- 1:53that I get beating. Anyway, kudos to you. That's one part of
- 1:57the Pentagon that I think, honestly, any anyone in soft probably does want
- 2:05to work, even if they don't know it. Alex, I am turning
- 2:10it absolutely over to you and to guide the discussion as you wish, topics
- 2:15of your choice. It is. Thank you. That was a kind of
- 2:17introduction. I'd like to think of myself as like the forest gump of the
- 2:21g Wat era, stumbling my way through historical events. I have no business
- 2:23being involved with that's no way all like Iraq, Yes, exactly, yeah,
- 2:29along those lines I mean of late. Yes, the terrorism studies program
- 2:32of the Council has been revamped obviously in light of what has transpired, as
- 2:37we all know from guests and colleagues in the community. You know, after
- 2:39the airport fell on Cobble, the agency was basically told to take the Afghan
- 2:43maps off the wall. We've all moved on. We're going to you know,
- 2:46pivot to the Pacific was the famous phrase. We're going to look to
- 2:49the threats coming you know from China and East China see and then South Chines
- 2:52see. And then all of a sudden the terrorist said, hey, you
- 2:53may be done with us, but we're not done with you globally and regionally.
- 2:57Right. So we spent better part of twenty years going out after Sunni
- 3:00Cellfist. You know, Jihadis groups across the region, you know, from
- 3:04Alkaita to Isis et cetera, who were seen as a geostrategic threat, particularly
- 3:07with the existence of the caliphate under Isis that you know, then dissipated due
- 3:13to combat operations. But then we've seen a not a resurgence, but one
- 3:17that's been there the entire time under you know, boiling right there under the
- 3:21surface, the boiling frog syndrome, which was really the threat posed by Iranian
- 3:24state sponsorship of terrorist groups in the region. And for the purpose of discussion,
- 3:29right the definition for terrorism we use is politically motivated violence against civilians.
- 3:32So somebody is using acts of violence against those civilians and the hopes that they
- 3:37can get them either as voters or a you know, dictatorial regime, to
- 3:39get the regime itself to change its behavior in line with whatever the group wants,
- 3:44is what we're talking about. So for Iran in many cases that you
- 3:46know happens to be in Israel or in other places, or against US forces
- 3:51to try to get us out of the region where they don't want US based
- 3:53sort of nearby. So that's been a focus on the counter terrorism side,
- 3:58and obviously immediate short term then being Amas, which we you know kind of
- 4:00talked about and October seventh, so my role at the Council in addition to
- 4:04the terrorism program, so part of the N seven initiative or the Negev Forum,
- 4:09which is where the Abraham Accords were sort of born, and so that's
- 4:12building on the work that the Abraham Accords hadn't done. I was in Abu
- 4:16Dhabi last March, Bahrain last July, and I was supposed to land in
- 4:19Israel and October seventh, actually the rest of my teammates in landed from the
- 4:23Council. We had about thirty members of Congress that were that were coming,
- 4:27many of them we saw on television immediately afterwards saying I was in Israel,
- 4:30and I was there under rocket attack, and they were there for our conference.
- 4:32What they were doing there, Ministers from a number of Arab countries were
- 4:36coming, Billionaire financiers from New York and from the States were coming in to
- 4:40talk about financial investment in the in the region, improve the lives about Israelis
- 4:45and Palestinians. And then October seventh happens and twelve hundred people are slaughtered,
- 4:49and probably the most sim the most heinous fashion of scene. We'll kind of
- 4:54get into all that a little bit. I took two hundred hostages at that
- 4:57point, and I have to tell you, having done began analysis on the
- 5:00fly at the Pentagon and senior leader spaces and then you know, through the
- 5:02course of my career and sigh out here or there, seeing the ISIS videos,
- 5:08seeing the al Qaeda videos, they were very business like, for lack
- 5:11of a better term, black shadowy figures. Remember you know Gihati John who
- 5:15was part of the Beatles, you know, with the ISIS videos and some
- 5:16of the others, they would make very serious policy statements, right. Their
- 5:19acts of violence were grotesque and what they were doing to intimidate people, but
- 5:23it was policy base, right. We want X, you know, we
- 5:27want you out of our lands. The caliphit's going to take over. And
- 5:29even though we don't agree with what they're doing or how they're pursuing it,
- 5:31it was seen as business with serious business in the videos and meant to intimidate.
- 5:35I went to the Atlanta Council because the Israeli Embassy provided the forty seven
- 5:40minutes of footage of the attack that transpired in October seventh, and I have
- 5:43to tell you it was among the most heinous things I've seen, not only
- 5:46for what had transpired and the callous disregard for human life, even you know,
- 5:49women and children, but the maniacal laughter. The phone calls back to
- 5:54mom and dad bragging about the fact that they had just I just killed Jews.
- 5:58Mom, your son's a hero, and you know, high fiving each
- 6:00other, giggling about what was going on as they're you know, killing people
- 6:03in some pretty awful torturing folks. Basically, there's no way to describe it.
- 6:05In some pretty awful ways. It was almost indescribable. And if you
- 6:10think about the problem that we had there, it was twenty five hundred people
- 6:14across the border from Gaza into Israel to contemit these atrocities. This was not
- 6:18a cell of five to ten deranged individual it's even a couple of cells.
- 6:23Twenty five hundred is a massive sample size the population there that came across the
- 6:27border an unfortunately indicative of the indoctrination into the terrorist ideology that Hamas has pursued
- 6:32for quite some time, and it resulted in the deaths of the twelve hundred
- 6:36people in Israel. And what I also, you know, you derived from
- 6:40looking at the situation is yeah, I mean dealt with hostage cases. As
- 6:43part of my that was the other part of my portfolio at Salek was hostage
- 6:46rescue. I was on the twenty fifteen hostage Policy Review, where we created
- 6:48the Hostage Recovery Fusion Cell, We created the Special Envoy for Hostage Affairs,
- 6:53which is currently Rodner Carston's his position. And you know, we wrote the
- 6:56Presidential Executive Order and the strategy for responding to hostage events. Still deal with
- 7:00hostage cases, still helping hostage cases in Afghanistan, I few other places around
- 7:03the world. And what the situation told me when looking at is a couple
- 7:06of things off the bat. First of all, there were some debates about
- 7:10whether or not Hamas truly knew the scope of what it was doing. The
- 7:14hostages weren't taken from one kibbutz or one small village. They were taken from
- 7:17all across southern Israel, from a number of different cells that were operating right
- 7:21out of twenty five hundred people. So it was clear from the onset that
- 7:25they were given instructions to take hostages and bring them back to Gaza. And
- 7:30why would you take hostages in that number. The only reason you would need
- 7:33that many hostages to bring back to Gaza is if you were aware that what
- 7:38you were planning to do was so incredibly big and spectacular. For lack of
- 7:44a better term, in terms of the attack itself and the carnage it was
- 7:47going to cause. That you need to mitigate the gap and military capabilities between
- 7:51the IDF and whatever Hamas has, between rockets and fighters on the ground,
- 7:55and the way you do that is by hostages. That's your negotiating chip,
- 7:59bargaining chip. Israel has to participated in lopsided deals for years, releasing thousands
- 8:03of people and even you know, murderers for dead bodies of Israeli citizens to
- 8:07bring them back. So Hamas knew what it was doing and what it created
- 8:13is this nightmare scenario where you have essentially Gaza eight by twenty five miles controlled
- 8:18by a terrorist organization that's effectively walled and blocked off. It's often described as
- 8:22the most densely populator, and it's not the most densely popular. I don't
- 8:24even think it makes top twenty five. But it is extremely densely populated.
- 8:28Out of two million people in that small space, with an underground tunnel network
- 8:31five hundred kilometers or so, if not more. It's basically a giant ant
- 8:35farm. I mean there's stuff all over the place, and so you've got
- 8:37this densely populated environment that is non permissive. With a hostile population there towards
- 8:43the Israelis, and with two hundred hostages dispersed across a tunnel system and in
- 8:48buildings across the area, it makes trying to conduct simultaneous hostage rescue operations virtually
- 8:52impossible. You've got small arms fired RPGs and potentially shoulder fired missiles, manpads,
- 8:58et cetera. Make helicopter missions, you know, and they're extremely difficult,
- 9:01right for any aerial insertion, you know, trying to come over the
- 9:05beach is obviously difficult too, is you're going to be seen coming, So
- 9:07you're really basically limited. That point to a large scale ground incursion that we
- 9:11saw along with special operations for US is trying to conduct limited raids and so
- 9:15you're really it puts you in a shitty position, for lack of a better
- 9:18term, it really forces you into a primary stance of negotiation to try to
- 9:22get the hostages released, because there really isn't a good viable means. So
- 9:26Hamas really set themselves up in this case to get what it is that they
- 9:30were looking for. Now, whether they're going to get it, it doesn't
- 9:31look like that's going to happen here at the end based on negotiations. But
- 9:35this was well planned, this was well thought out. Yes, certainly,
- 9:41I mean no argument there. I think you know, that's the you know,
- 9:46having spent a good deal of time in this round the last six months
- 9:52up set on this program. The sad thing is, you know, as
- 9:54as someone who really loves this, is that I don't think that country will
- 9:58ever be the same again. I can't. I just can't see it.
- 10:01I don't think that people outside the country understand that. I think you know,
- 10:07and and I think at the same time and this this may not be
- 10:11neither there here nor there, but it's but I think it's an interesting aspect
- 10:16and I think I'm not sure what the comment is on this, but you
- 10:22know, as masks whether or not, you know, as they try and
- 10:24distance themselves from some of the worst random atrocities and yet claim clean you know,
- 10:31responsibility for others, you know, it almost becomes irrelevant. But an
- 10:35interesting point I think is and worth pointing out with no agenda, is that
- 10:41a lot of those people who got out of regards who were common criminals or
- 10:45opportunists, sadly, and that is what now the idea I thinks. I
- 10:50mean, I'm sorry the you know, the IDF thinks occurred in some of
- 10:54the kabutz is that weren't on the map but were nevertheless act right, you
- 11:00hear the same thing, and I think, you know, do you right
- 11:01your point? If you look at the polling data coming out, they're ninety
- 11:03percent support for the war on Gaza, ninety percent for you know, eradicating
- 11:07Hamas for lack of a better term, fifteen percent you know, support for
- 11:11Prime Minister Notatan Yahoo, which is which you think is rare, right,
- 11:13I mean, after nine eleven we saw rally around the frost. That's not
- 11:16high, you know what I mean? Yeah, no, I mean having
- 11:20been there on surprise that it's not hi. I didn't need anyone who liked
- 11:22them, you know, that's what they're furious. But like you said,
- 11:24but but yeah, they've rallied. That's absolutely the point. So so I
- 11:31wanted to now kind of jump forward in and I know, you know,
- 11:33every time, no one can talk about this discussion without getting angry calls,
- 11:39you know, and so on our listeners know hopefully hey listen, this is
- 11:43we're going to go down this pop because we need to just arguing either way
- 11:50as we get you know, fast forward to where we are now, right
- 11:54and I believe and tell me if this is you know, incorrect summer and
- 12:00then and then absolutely want to hear your filth. So so you know,
- 12:03the things over the weekend, especially in the Arab media, there was there
- 12:09were kind of optimistic rumors that her Maas was going to and accept the latest
- 12:13proposal, which happened to be an Egyptian broken one. Right and then and
- 12:18then sometimes Sunday morning, Israeli time, har Maas targeted an assembly era in
- 12:26there coron Chuan killing or Israeli soldiers wounding, wounding nine right after that.
- 12:33So so that that in in in you know, as far as the Israelis
- 12:37were concerned, Hey, that's all bets are off right, sure, and
- 12:41that's it went into session and not then that said, I'm sorry. The
- 12:43cabinet went into session, came out by unanus unanimous vote, decided to go
- 12:48ahead with invasion of Rafa, her mask her Mass's claim at the time,
- 12:52so us, hey, this was self defense, so we're going to take
- 12:56Rafa anyway. That's why they were there in that assembly area and the whole
- 13:00useless borrow of arguments. But as the as the you know, kind of
- 13:03the initial shaping action start in a phase that was estimated to take two to
- 13:07three weeks, you know, evacuation of personnel, insertion of special operations forces,
- 13:13gathering an assembly, as all those steps are taking place. Arguably William
- 13:16Burns was able to say, hey, look all this stuff is happening,
- 13:20you know, kind of the veiled stake behind the carrot, and the carrot
- 13:24being potentially survival of Hamas leadership. And that's and at that point Hamas counterproposed,
- 13:33but it wasn't the Egyptian proposal. It had changed in at least two
- 13:37points that the Israelis regard is critical. And that's kind of where we are
- 13:41now agree. And I think, you know, as you mentioned for listeners
- 13:43who are in there, you know, history starts for people on either side
- 13:48of this argument, either after Palestinians or after Jews were killed and people argue
- 13:50to the death that were Who's if you got the moral right here we're largely
- 13:54talking about here is the military tactics and situation that on the ground that's going
- 13:58on. You can draw your own conclusion about who's correct and who's not.
- 14:01And that's not. I'm not really interested in getting into the moral rights and
- 14:05wrongs here so much as like we're having a discussion about what's happening from a
- 14:07tactical perspective, from a strategy perspective, what's going well and what's not,
- 14:13and we and we talk, you know, we talk about politics here too.
- 14:16Yeah, absolutely, I think, you know, I think our listeners
- 14:20count on us to be as bipartisant as we can, or at least if
- 14:22we present one view, can we argue back. And we've got pretty good
- 14:26at that. That's fair. Yeah, feel free to express your views at
- 14:30all. Okay, I I think so. I wrote on October eleventh that
- 14:33wrote a piece for the Atlantic Council basically detailing exactly what's happening now, the
- 14:37military strategy, how it was going to work. So from the beginning Prime
- 14:41Minister Nataniell who laid out what he declared was his goal for the operation,
- 14:45which would be the demilitarization of a moss Right. We know from twenty years
- 14:48of counter terrorism ourselves, you can't kill an ideology with bombs and bullets.
- 14:50That's simply not going to fly, right, But you can degrade and disrupt
- 14:54a terrorist organization such as isis right in the caliphate or so called caliphate to
- 14:58the point where it's rendered and effective and and operate the way that it was.
- 15:01But in order to do that in an area that they control, you
- 15:03basically have to conduct a giant cort on in search of Gaza, which are
- 15:07then going to break up into chunks, which is what they did. So
- 15:09if you you know, at the beginning of the operation, they basically,
- 15:11I mean and as your well ware, you know, midway down Gaza is
- 15:15Wadi Gaza, like a wadi that kind of goes across the little valley,
- 15:18and they declared that to be the basically the line of advance, and they
- 15:20told everybody in northern Gaza to get south, so they included the ect evacuation
- 15:24of Gaza city. Roughly a million residents then fled south and Israel began conducting
- 15:28clearing operations inside the city. Hamas remnants were they are the battalions, and
- 15:31they fought on. Hundreds of Israeli soldiers have been killed. This was a
- 15:35real battle that's been going on. You know, Hamas did stay and fight
- 15:39and the goal is to get the strategic weapons and the fighters. But when
- 15:41I looked at the forty seven minute video of what transpired that day, and
- 15:43that's again where some of the analysis comes from. There were no strategic weapons.
- 15:48There weren't even really many technicals being used. This was AK forty seven's
- 15:52pistols, knives and grenades, That's what I saw. So the fighters themselves
- 15:56are what conducted that attack, that threat to Israel, right, So for
- 16:00them it's the act of battalions on the ground. So if your goal is
- 16:03to demilitarize Hamas and also ensure that that type of attack doesn't happen again,
- 16:06and I don't mean from a radicalization perspective, the people turn around say,
- 16:08well, gright, you're creating another generation of radicalized individuals because they've been now
- 16:11subjected to total lost their families, their homes, their livelihoods, and this
- 16:15is just going to be a perpetual cycle of violence. That is one counter
- 16:18argument to go from a strictly military perspective and achieving the objectives that were laid
- 16:22out in front of them. You know, the only way you can really
- 16:25do that is you got to go in and search, and so that would
- 16:26include remaining areas or raw fund everywhere else. Because the second you pull out
- 16:30and all of a sudden, IMS still has strategic stockpiles of rockets and everything
- 16:33else, and rockets are flying across the border. The chiefs, the government
- 16:37who is responsible for ensuring this type of tactics to happen again, look like
- 16:41utter in complete clowns. So that's the political problem, never mind the actual
- 16:45military problem itself of not getting the remaining fighters and the stockbillus. You're never
- 16:48going to get every AK forty seven, You're not going to get every single
- 16:51fighter. But again, it's about disruption and degrading the institution to where it
- 16:55doesn't function, and you've got to deal with the remnants sort of afterwards.
- 16:57And so the problem is when everybody pushed south again. If you look at
- 17:00if you picture Gaza as a giant rectangle for lack of a better term,
- 17:03and starting up the top and moving south, everybody's essentially wedged between what's a
- 17:08wall on the right hand side or the east side, and on the north
- 17:11side south side is a wall with Egypt, and on the left is the
- 17:15Mediterranean Sea that Egypt that Israel has basically a naval blockade. So it's a
- 17:18giant rectangle where everybody's stuck in the center, and so everybody's now pushed south
- 17:22close to that wall with Egypt nearly two million people. Infrastructure has been destroyed,
- 17:26so difficult in many cass sewage, water are those types of things.
- 17:30Humanitarian conditions are extremely difficult on the ground. I mean the Sidney McCain ahead
- 17:34the World Food Program has talked about famine and other issues that are on the
- 17:37ground there which are very real. I mean, we've been running rescue operations
- 17:41in Gaza since October, helping to evacuate American citizens and allies, and it's
- 17:45the same thing you get from our folks on the ground. You know,
- 17:47in terms of the conditions, they're right. So the question then became,
- 17:49what the hell do you do with the two million people trapped south and around
- 17:52the wall, and the Israeli answer as well, we're gonna have to shuffle
- 17:55them around the battlespace literally like in a circle, and as we move in,
- 17:57we'll push them one way or the other and try to send people back
- 18:00north, although you don't want people behind your rear flank. And so it
- 18:03became this, my god, this humanitarian disaster. You know, we need
- 18:06to stop this operation. They're going to have to go into rawling. You
- 18:08cannot achieve the military objective of demilitarization and leave strategic areas where you've got known
- 18:14Hamas fighters and stockpiles of weapons intact and expect to achieve your objective. It's
- 18:18simply not going to happen. So when everybody's arging against them, looking from
- 18:22a military and security perspective, they're going to have to do it. And
- 18:25then Hamas is like, well, you know, we don't want this,
- 18:26We want to be fairly troops with it all from Gaza. Yeah, you
- 18:29also opened a giant hole in the fence and opened up hell for lack of
- 18:32a better term, with twenty five hundred people coming across the border and slaughtering
- 18:34twelve hundred Israelis and probably the most heinous way they've seen and relative decides their
- 18:38population. It's a very significant number of people and there was not. And
- 18:44again the arguments are, well, you know, we've been trapped like you
- 18:47know, caged animals in Gaza, and this is you know, resistance fighting
- 18:49back against an oppressor who is unoccupied territory and they have no business being here
- 18:52in the first place. The justifications will go back and forth in terms of
- 18:56whether people should or shouldn't, whether you believe it was the right thing to
- 18:59do or not. Five hundred people across the border. They blew a hole
- 19:00and a billion dollar front system that was out there, and they murdered twelve
- 19:03hundred people. Alex can I can I just not, you know, certainly
- 19:07not argue that point. But to talk about U the you know, the
- 19:12the operation itself, and and I think, you know, I think it's
- 19:15fair to for me to share I think at this stage a pessimistic assumption about
- 19:21the hostages. And sure it's not easy for me to do that. I
- 19:25actually know you know, one of the hostage families and have met, you
- 19:27know, But I I just it's got to always be front and center as
- 19:33a strategic goal for the Israelis. I understand that. But in practical terms,
- 19:37although it's importance remains great, I think in practical terms, we you
- 19:41know, we we're looking at a very long shot, right, you know,
- 19:45for for even getting the forty LT. But that's anyway, that's that's
- 19:51kind of that's something we can can say here clear ye. But I understand
- 19:56in Israel, no, you know, that's a you cannot talk about that.
- 20:00But but from the from the perspective military operation. Then as far as
- 20:04goals, as far as objectives, you know, it's almost an opening.
- 20:08And it's not a secret. I mean, there have been rumblings among IDF
- 20:14leadership about kind of lack of strategic objectives. They have no problem. In
- 20:18fact, they insist that many of them, I mean that Rafa has to
- 20:22be cleared. But they they're needing kind of just like they're needing some kind
- 20:26of overall goal. Who takes over from her mask? That's that's number one.
- 20:30How do you see that evolving? Number two? Is you mentioned and
- 20:36we're all aware of this problem to include of course the Israelis, the you
- 20:38know this whole clear and hold. They just don't have demand power to hold
- 20:44Gaza. They haven't made an attempt to do so. That isn't for tapical
- 20:48reasons. It's simply because they can't keep three hundred thousand reservers tied down.
- 20:53So they've had to move out of areas of Gaza. They have tried to,
- 20:59they have retained, you know, they've kept solve in that they've they've
- 21:03got far better visibility of what goes on. But the plain fact is,
- 21:07as they know at Hamas's backfield those areas and retaken control, and that is
- 21:11always going to be a problem. So those kind of questions are linked how
- 21:15how to solve that problem? Never mind, you know, let's not even
- 21:18worry about well, let's not talk about the hostages at this point, but
- 21:22those goals. So, I mean, I think it's it's actually probably the
- 21:26most point of question and the one that needs to be answered the most.
- 21:29Quite frankly, there's an obsession with RAFA right now because it's been the thing
- 21:30in the news, and you know, with a progressive administration on the US
- 21:36side and around the world, with seeing a lot of sympathy for the Palestinians.
- 21:38It's my god, the humanitarian situation we need to focus on. RAFA
- 21:41is going to be done, and not that long. This is not going
- 21:44to be a very long operation. As you mentioned, it pivots to the
- 21:47longer term question and it's one that has actually probably I think the worst moan
- 21:52Israeli security perspective. Like you mentioned, who is going to take over security
- 21:56afterwards? Inside because you need to, like we talked about clear bill and
- 21:57holds, somebody has to provide security. Who is going to govern that space?
- 22:03Right? And then we talk about reconstruction. If we look at the
- 22:04damage that we've seen, fifty percent of buildings are damaged or destroyed in one
- 22:07capacity or another. It's going to be a decade to rebuild, at least
- 22:11on most estimates. If the people there don't accept the governing institution that is
- 22:15put on top of them, right, they may rise up against it.
- 22:18So if it's not a if the Pelstony authority doesn't come in and they're not
- 22:22accepted, or somebody else outside of Hamas right now, knowledge you have Hamas
- 22:26remnants that are going to rise up, but you may have the population that's
- 22:29going to rise up. And then for security, if that security force ends
- 22:30up being the IDF and there's not an outside force of contractors or a coalition
- 22:37of Arab states or whatever or else has been proposed, you essentially end up
- 22:40with the Iractionnario and I hate using these comparisons generalize ones to other conflicts,
- 22:44but if we think about it, it's essentially where we are, right all
- 22:45right, We've taken Bagdad, and we've we've beaten the Iraqi army in two
- 22:49thousand and three, fantastic. We're a uniformed military force whose mission is to
- 22:55conduct military operations and defeat an adversary. Now you're telling me, I got
- 22:59a whole display. We could do the security mission. Sure, Okay,
- 23:02who does governance? Anybody in here do governance? Nation and state building?
- 23:04Who the hell is responsible for that? So and that's again when we had
- 23:08a population and an ingenious decision to send the Iraqi army home without their weapons
- 23:12and have a bunch of military age males without jobs or income who are now
- 23:15pissed off at what's going on. Right, and at least there there was
- 23:18at least a democratic election of local candidates who were not selected by the US.
- 23:23Eventually, right, there's a democracy where you have a Shia majority government
- 23:26for the first time after Saddam was removed. Right in Gaza, we're not
- 23:30even talking about that. So we're talking about potentially these Raelies from what we're
- 23:33hearing of these so far, because there's been no announcements to what the hell
- 23:34of plan is. Right again, Rafa is the big thing. Great,
- 23:37what happens in two three weeks a month when this is done? If the
- 23:41plan is for the IDF to remain there at the security posture, also administer
- 23:47temporary governance and then start the reconstruction process and try to find some alternative government
- 23:51against there hasn't been elections in the Palestinia, a decision, by the way,
- 23:53which has tremendous economic and social implications throughout Israelis society much. It's not
- 24:00an operation. It's not like deciding to surge the military to Iron one hundred
- 24:04percent, as you mentioned, because it's just simply not there from a size
- 24:07perspective, and the economic impact to israel effort from the limited. You know,
- 24:11the war went only on for a few months. We've been at war
- 24:12for twenty years in the US. There was a pretty sizable impact the Israeli
- 24:15economy with people that we're missing. We're seeing it Ukraine another small country as
- 24:18well. You know, thirty percent of factories or thirty percent of production capacities
- 24:22down in many cases for Ukrainian factories where people are off to work. So
- 24:26the impacts are real, as you mentioned, from an economic perspective as well
- 24:27as societal. So even if that wasn't the case, but it is,
- 24:32you have to worry about that. You don't have the numbers, and you
- 24:36end up with that point. So for folks that are listening right, the
- 24:37definition of what we're talking about here is an insurgency where you have a group
- 24:40of people who are going to rise up against the governing authority that they don't
- 24:42recognize as legitimate and against the security apparatus in that case being the idea that
- 24:47they don't see is legitimate either. And it only takes me. I mean,
- 24:49we did this in Iraq for a long time. I gave two years
- 24:52of my life almost in a country that I'll never get back over weapons of
- 24:55mass destruction that didn't exist, fighting in a counterinsurgency right and against an insert
- 25:00an insurgent force. And in this case what happened hamas fighter's sticking their you
- 25:03know, rifle out of windows again. Like I said, you're not going
- 25:06to get every aka, every pistol taking pot shots. That is rarely soldiers
- 25:10killed two, three, four today, five tomorrow. It doesn't take that
- 25:12much where that adds up over time and you end up in the sustain It's
- 25:15actually Amasa's best case scenario. No longer do they have to break through a
- 25:19fence to attack his fahlya soldiers. They can do it in their own backyard,
- 25:23you know, And I and I just you know one other comment,
- 25:29I guess just the kind of context. But the term occupation itself carries an
- 25:33incredible emotional historical weight in discussions with the IDF, and I just turn them
- 25:41insout it now. I think one hundred percent, right, is a very
- 25:45emotional term. I mean even the way that you know, areas of gaz
- 25:48are described as you know, the refugee camp, and people are thinking there's
- 25:52pitch tens, you know, somewhere because they're used to seeing that elsewhere.
- 25:53And refugees are people who flee their own homeland to go to another country,
- 25:56right, Otherwise they're internally displaced persons by Definitely, if you're inside your own
- 26:00country, you're an IDP. If you flee to a neighboring country orn outside
- 26:03country, you're a refugee. They're not refugee gamps. People have been living
- 26:07there since nineteen forty eight, right. And the terminology is important because it's
- 26:11for them to evoke some emotion and you know, a reflection of what they
- 26:14see as an occupation by the Israelis of land that doesn't belong to them.
- 26:17Whereas this is the sovereign state of Israel, and we've got people in our
- 26:19country or neighbors, they was like preferred as a dangerous neighborhood, who want
- 26:22to kill us. So you're right, it's a very very different mindset.
- 26:26It does evoke a lot of emotion, and we're talking about it, and
- 26:29you know, there's a question of whether or not there should be a two
- 26:30state solution or a one state solution, and unfortunately, this is the other
- 26:34conundrum that we need to talk about as well as part of this. It's
- 26:37blatantly clear, based on the messaging from the Arab States, Russia, hiling
- 26:41on, China, other major players in the world, that they believe the
- 26:44solution to this is a Palestinian state based on the sixty seven borders before that
- 26:48war, which a large squapth of land in the West Bank with some land
- 26:52swaps as they'll call it, whatever the hell that looks like. And then
- 26:53the guy's a strip. From an Israeli perspective, forget the thinness of the
- 26:59state of Israel at those borders, whether or not it's militarily defensible, eleven
- 27:02to nine miles wide, and it's thin this point, right, you can
- 27:03cut the country in half. Put that, just put that aside for a
- 27:07second. This is question of now of whether a two state solutions possible.
- 27:11Is there somebody they can trust to govern a neighboring state to give up that
- 27:15territory? Right these are? And then are you rewarding terrorism by agreeing to
- 27:18a two state solution even if it's not with Hamas after twelve hundred people were
- 27:22killed? And is that now going to be seen as a forcing function for
- 27:25future policy? Ask on behalf of other people? And politically inside and that's
- 27:29the other thing. Politically inside Israel, there isn't the appetite if you're looking
- 27:32at the polling data for a two state solution right now, So you have
- 27:34that as just the general background for what's going on, then there's the political
- 27:37reality. So for those of you who are not following Israeli politics because it's
- 27:41not something most people would do. So it's not you know, just it
- 27:44is what it is, Prime Minister NATANYAHUO. It's a parliamentary style system.
- 27:48So it's a majority of the members of parliament get together for a majority and
- 27:52then they elect their leader who becomes the prime minister. In this case,
- 27:56due to a history of you know, then you always been one of the
- 27:59longest serving premiers in Israeli history. He's got a couple of stints in and
- 28:02out of the job. There. The coalition he had to put together to
- 28:04get the job includes you know, what's described as the far right inside the
- 28:07Kanesset, which are groups of people who are adamantly against a Palestinian state.
- 28:11You know, you know, Ben Gavie's one who's very famous for being outspoken.
- 28:15I mean, he was so outspoken and outlandish in his behavior. The
- 28:17Idea wouldn't let him join. He actually didn't serve, which is rare in
- 28:21a country work service and mandatory conscription and getting in not only just to serve,
- 28:25but which he is now Minister for Security right, national security, right,
- 28:30and that touches on a couple of things, like you're right, it's
- 28:32Minister for national security. And so for folks who are looking at this problem
- 28:33set, you've got a guy who's basically who's feelings towards the Palestinians was so
- 28:37great. He's now the Minister for internal security, like like you mentioned Nation
- 28:41Security, guy who's made some outlandish statements publicly, you know, like who
- 28:45cares about this? This is be Israelis and the Palestinian rights don't matter,
- 28:48which has been not received well so Natanyahu even if he wanted to make some
- 28:53more of these, you know what would be seen as progressive gestures towards you
- 28:59know, in our state or what not, Palestinian state. There's members of
- 29:03his cabinet who are adamantly opposed to this. And when you have a razor
- 29:06thin majority like we're seeing in the US right We've seen the shit show in
- 29:08the House of Representatives over the last six months where it's like a game of
- 29:11musical chairs to forgere o that hol the speaker is going to be every six
- 29:12weeks. It's basically the same thing for the Israelis. Know who you know
- 29:18does something that's considered too brash or too far is a concession. His government
- 29:22could literally collapse in terms of these folks who pull out of the coalition and
- 29:26yeah, there's a war cabinet, but at the end of the day,
- 29:26they could say, you know, we're not doing this, and there's not
- 29:29a requirement to call for elections, and he wants to remain in power.
- 29:32So you have this domestic political problem with a razor thin majority and a group
- 29:36of people who are opposed to an Arab state, and then you have a
- 29:38global community who is saying that we're going to pay for this, will help
- 29:41with reconstruction, will recognize the state of Israel, you know, in terms
- 29:45of the potential Saudi deal on the table, but it all hinges upon the
- 29:48acceptance of a Palestinian state on the sixty seven borders. And so the global
- 29:52community's viewpoint on this in many states, their desires and outcome for Palestinians is
- 29:59at stark contrast and odds to domestic Israeli politics and the realities of the governing
- 30:03situation inside Israel. And so that is probably one of the biggest problems that
- 30:07people aren't seeing. That's driving a lot of the inability to get to get
- 30:11some of it's done, because you got people saying you need to do this.
- 30:15People are in power, like I can't do that. My government will
- 30:18collapse, and I want to remain in power. And that's essentially what we're
- 30:19looking at. Sorry, yeah, ahead to me real quick. You said
- 30:25something a while back. Sorry it took me so long, but you had
- 30:29mentioned in the in the after you know, the I don't know, but
- 30:34the possibility but you know, like an Arab led uh not I guess occupation,
- 30:41but temporary governance perhaps or security or something like that. Is there in
- 30:48whether officially or not, Is there are there any Arab states that would be
- 30:53willing to raise your hand that you know of and say, hey, we'll
- 30:56hold on to things, hold things together until you get it. And my
- 31:00second part of that question would be how long would the Palaestatan people be willing
- 31:04to put up with that? Because that is another I could turn it to
- 31:07another occupation. So I will asge that with yes. But so yes,
- 31:11there are, but with some conditions. You know, Gaza was administered by
- 31:17Egypt for quite some time. People forget that, you know, historically,
- 31:18it's not the first time they've had an outside the country that's helped to administer
- 31:22the situation there. Egypt also has the highest anti Israeli sentiment in the entire
- 31:25Arab world. I think I think a third of all Arabs live within six
- 31:27miles of then out river between Egypt and Sudan. When you look at it,
- 31:30it's the epicenter of our culture and language, one of the longest standing
- 31:33peace deals of Israel. But the highest anti is really sentiment that's kind of
- 31:37around and there's no desire I think for the Egyptians to do that. They're
- 31:40broke at this point they needed the IMF loans. You know, Ceci's been
- 31:42trying to God to country the best that he can, and they were worried
- 31:45about a permanent displacement the Palestinians. And the reason that I mentioned this is
- 31:48tied directly to your question. For an Arab forced to go into Gaza to
- 31:52provide security potentially have to shoot terrorists that are trying to come out from a
- 31:56killing fellow Arabs, fellow Muslims, and also pay for reconstruction without a commitment
- 32:02to a two state solution based on the sixty seven borders or something that the
- 32:06Palestinian people would find acceptable for a lot of the Arab states, and again
- 32:10the Egyptians with opening the gate to the Sinai, the biggest concern that they
- 32:14have there is if this is a permanent displacement and I open the gate,
- 32:16am I complicit in the end of a Palestinian state that includes Gaza. Am
- 32:21I doing Israel's dirty work for me? And the same thing is kind of
- 32:23thought and spoken in the background, but not publicly amongst the Arab states as
- 32:27they're looking the situation. If I provide the security force here and I do
- 32:30the reconstruction and there's no Palestinian state. I essentially am green lighting the Israelis
- 32:37coming in conducting their actions in Gaza, all the death and destruction that took
- 32:40place. Whether you agree with Israel's justification for doing so or not, it's
- 32:44the Raaly situation what's transpired. Am I complicit now in that because I'm providing
- 32:49these services on the back end and the Palestinians get nothing for it. So
- 32:52I think, yes, there are states who are willing to do so,
- 32:53but it's going to require that to be part of a comprehensive plan that includes
- 32:58a two state solution. And right now, there's nothing for them to gain.
- 33:01There's absolutely nothing for them to gain to come in and offer to do
- 33:05this. They're vilified, you know, by half the world, and they're
- 33:09not really achieving anything and that great cost. And you know, honestly,
- 33:14the impetus behind normalization has nothing to do with ideology. It's everything to do
- 33:19with the economies, right and so and so why why in order to achieve
- 33:28that would any country volunteer to take on a massive, unending, indefinite economic
- 33:32cost, not to mention all the political baggage that comes with it. But
- 33:38I'm not sure that. You know, when I say we collectively us,
- 33:43I'm not sure that our State Department always understands that. I think sometimes again,
- 33:46whether we're dealing with the Arab or the Israeli side, we tend to
- 33:50mirror image our own goals and objectives rather than you know, be able to
- 33:54see it through their eyes. You mean not everybody's warrantogy goals are aligning,
- 34:00fix it and yeah, but I mean inside and inside every Middle East,
- 34:04and it's just an American Texan struggling to be waiting get his or even worse
- 34:09than New York helping the world. That's the case, was that life from
- 34:15Block is like I would advise you that there's certain areas of New York not
- 34:19to invade if you ever make it to America. When he's talking to the
- 34:22the whole true, the reconstruction alone is just a bad show. Can we
- 34:31can we touch on like what's going on with the hostage negotiation? He's fire
- 34:37negotiation because there was like some back and forth yesterday every you know, one
- 34:40side was saying yeah, we yeah, we agreed. The other side is
- 34:44like no, no, no, we didn't. Yeah, So I think
- 34:46that's a great place to start. So they originally started with two hundred hostages.
- 34:51Let me just make something equivalently clear as far as I'm concerned from a
- 34:52policy perspective on these works. You take hostages, you're holding them against their
- 34:57will. You were holding them inside Gaza. The Israelis are telling you we
- 35:01are going to conduct military operations here as a result of the attack that took
- 35:06place. It is your responsibility as the hostage taker and you take your happy
- 35:10ass and the hostages with you out of the combat area that's there. And
- 35:14if you can't to basically rodrop and say hey, I can't do that.
- 35:15I realized we're talking in an idealistic world, right that this is what's supposed
- 35:19to happen. But from a responsibility standpoint, that is the truth. A
- 35:22mosto people is holding them against their will. So out of those two hundred
- 35:25people, we did see that early group of releases, right that the initial
- 35:29deal that saw you know, a ceasefire that took place, and we saw
- 35:31the hostages being released, So we saw that population dwindle. Since then,
- 35:36we've seen a number of bodies that have been recovered either by as rarely special
- 35:38forces or by you know hamas videos and announcing these people have died and then
- 35:43telling them it was Israel's fault as means of propaganda. Whether it's true or
- 35:45not irrelevant because they were using it for propaganda purposes. So, because how
- 35:50many people are actually left now Israel knows in the literal sense, there are
- 35:52people who are missing who were assumed taken on October seventh, who've either been
- 35:57seen on videos or whatever else, so we know what kind of with that
- 36:00looks like, and most at least state that they were taken alive. Right,
- 36:04because there's another category of people who are missing though we don't know.
- 36:08Yeah, live for dead bodies and people forget. The state of Israel was
- 36:13founded in the modern State of Israel was founded in nineteen forty eight, right,
- 36:15So everybody had come from somewhere else Zionism as they called it, starting
- 36:19the Zionis Congress starting the late eighteen hundreds, right, started bringing people into
- 36:22the war of independence. The modern state founded. The reason I mentioned it
- 36:25is there were waves of refugees and immigrants that came to Israel, Jews from
- 36:29around the world and the after about the World War two and where they're being
- 36:31oppressed in other places to come into Israel to find the Jewish state, as
- 36:36you know, their rightful places as a as a Jew in the world,
- 36:38that you are authorized to come to Israel and become a citizen if you if
- 36:42you are a Jew, both in terms of religium and also I forget the
- 36:45connection is one grand parent. I forget what the bloodline requirement is. But
- 36:49everybody, the point is it became somewhere else. So a lot of these
- 36:51hostages are dual citizens. They're dual nationals because it's such a young country in
- 36:54terms of the modern state, that the people hold dual citizenship from wherever their
- 36:58parents are. In some cases they themselves were born if they're not first generation
- 37:00immigrants. I believe there's still five Americans that are part of that that pool
- 37:04that's there. You've got a couple of other problems. There was heinous sexual
- 37:07violence that took place on October seventh. You know there you've seen the videos
- 37:12of the Israeli female soldier in the gray sweatpants with the trail of blood you
- 37:15know, from her the back to the backside as she's being forced into a
- 37:19vehicle. While the sexual violence was not in the forty seven minute video.
- 37:22I've seen enough. And then myself outside of that video itself, and then
- 37:25also spoken enough people and survivors, et cetera to know that it was real.
- 37:30I fear that there are a number of female hostages or soldiers who may
- 37:34not come back as a result of not wanting them, not wanting to tell
- 37:37that story. It is a real rim fear that I have that I don't
- 37:39have anything other than a suspicion based on the way things have gone down.
- 37:43But then more important that you mentioned in recent days they've been negotating last couple
- 37:46of weeks. The asked was for forty women, children and elderly as part
- 37:51of that deal, and Amas basically came back and said, we don't have
- 37:54that many that we can find. Right, Well, you took them,
- 37:59so when you're saying can't find them, it's not like you know, you
- 38:00put somebody somewhere like you're responsible for them. And I asked, is it
- 38:04just Hamas that's holding the hostages or is it like Islamichi Hoad Are there other
- 38:07groups? There were multiple, So to start out with, you had Hamas
- 38:12Palestinian, Islamichi had and then as Andy rightfully noted, you had a bunch
- 38:15of local criminal shitbags who also broke through the hole in the fence that well
- 38:19Hamas sold the responsible and they created the whole. They let they let these
- 38:21you know, pat but multiple groups that were holding them, which was part
- 38:24of the problem. And again in the hostage situation, the first thing you
- 38:27want to do is you want to establish who's holding them as much you could
- 38:30figure out who these people are, who's the decision maker on the release,
- 38:32get to them, figure out what the hell they want? Can you actually
- 38:35give them something that's not a policy concession, it's a terrorist and can you
- 38:37get these people released? That's what you're looking to do in these situations,
- 38:39right, part of the problem. That was part of the reason they were
- 38:43asking for those initial members tool ladies. I think the first ones they let
- 38:45out in the very beginning, and that was I think proof that they were
- 38:46negotiating with the right people. Do you have kind of command and control to
- 38:50actually release hostages? And that was part of the establishment of that that,
- 38:52Okay, these people are real, but you're right, does PIJ have some
- 38:57folks to other people? Yeah? And I think that that may be part
- 38:59of it. There still should be forty people that Hamas has alone to be
- 39:01able to get their hands on. Some of it could be a means of
- 39:04communication issues. But yes, Israel was bombing and they're conducting military average.
- 39:07But they told you they were conducting military options. They told you where they
- 39:10were conducting military operations, So all of those hostages should be safe in southern
- 39:14Gaza, somewhere out and away from remain military operations were conducted. If Hamas
- 39:19actually did what they were supposed to do, my fear is that either due
- 39:22to military activity, you know, the combat up north, or you know,
- 39:27over time, not being able to sustain these people whatever else, that
- 39:30people died during that. So I don't believe that all of the remaining hostages
- 39:34are alive. I don't know how many. I don't have numbers. I'm
- 39:37certainly not going to speculate and play with people's emotions and toys. But when
- 39:39you've got a terrorist organization who is asking for things that they want is the
- 39:44reason they took the hostages in the first place, and they can't produce them
- 39:47the hostages that they're supposed to in order to get what they want, that's
- 39:51a problem because again, if they weren't asking for things, who gives a
- 39:53shit, you know, whether we keep them alive or kill them or whatever
- 39:57else. And then from a terrorist perspective, it doesn't matter. You took
- 39:59the hostages because you knew you were going to need them. You knew the
- 40:02only way this situation was going to end in your favor was through a negotiated
- 40:06settlement, because the IDF has overwhelming military superior and advantage over you. So
- 40:10going into that and knowing that's what how Mass's intentions were. If they can't
- 40:14produce the hostages, the only conclusion you can draw from at that point is
- 40:16they're either in community or they're out of communication, which is unlikely given the
- 40:21way Kasa functions and where everything is, and more likely, unfortunately, that
- 40:23there's more deceased than I think that people are willing to admit at this point.
- 40:27I mean, that's the conclusion that one has to draw logically. So
- 40:30my background on hostage negotiation is dealing with my granddaughter and trying to get her
- 40:37to go to the bathroom. So let me ask a simple Hollywood question.
- 40:40I'm sure people asking and these sorts of things. Are the families involved or
- 40:46is it kind of like, okay, we'll take it from here. We'll
- 40:49let you know. It depends, right, so in this particular case,
- 40:52the families are unlikely to be involved, and that's due to the fact that
- 40:55hostage takers are not looking for concessions from the family through the family or they
- 41:00trying to communicate with the Israeli government through the family. Right, they've taken
- 41:04into very public fashion and their negotiates taking place and cutter, you know,
- 41:08with the representatives of different The people on the ground are unlikely to be in
- 41:17communication. It's open. This is open. It's not something I'm you know,
- 41:20sharing, I'm out a government, I have a clearance anymore. I'm
- 41:22not revealing classified. Their signals intelligence is good. I mean they understand what's
- 41:25going on inside there, which I know sounds insane in the aftermath of October
- 41:29seventh, but they surge capabilities and they've got a pretty good feel for what
- 41:30the hell's going on the ground. So if they were making phone calls out
- 41:36with housages, talking to families, et cetera, would be be a big
- 41:37problem. Which the reason they ran hard phone lines under the ground is a
- 41:40means of evasion from the Israelis because they know what that looks like. So
- 41:44communication is extremely unlikely. If they need to put pressure on the Israeli governments,
- 41:50or they'll try to activate the families by releasing these videos of people showing
- 41:52that they're still alive, to get them fired up and go protest and try
- 41:54to agree. That's all means to pressure a deal that Hamas believes is in
- 41:58its favor. That's the reason all that shenanigans has kind of taken place.
- 42:01So I don't die. The families are not that involved here, and the
- 42:05role of third parties, which normally get like folks like me and whatever else.
- 42:07It's not an appropriate time for me or someone else like me to try
- 42:10to insert myself in that situation where it's very delicate ongoing negotiations at the governmental
- 42:15level, and unless they need help, where you have some sort of unique
- 42:16thing you can bring the table, you end up meddling and causing problems.
- 42:20Right, that's perfect, thank you. It's not one of those situations I've
- 42:25observed myself. In your opinion, Alex, do you think hostages will be
- 42:30released? Because I can't see how MAS going for hostages being released without a
- 42:37deal on a ceasefire, and it doesn't seem like Israel is interested in that
- 42:40at all. So I think the big problem and the biggest disconnect in all
- 42:45of this is Moss wants a complete ceasefire and a complete withdrawal of Israeli forces
- 42:51from Gaza. And it's like the guy who beats the shit out of you,
- 42:53and you show up with a gun and point out, well, you
- 42:55know, I actually didn't mean to beat the shit out of you. I'm
- 42:58really sorry about that. I promise not to do it again, even though
- 43:00I've been spewing nothing but genocid wal you know, rhetoric. If I ever
- 43:02got my hands on you again, you know, snap your neck. I
- 43:06mean, it's the center stud of these Raelis feel going at it right.
- 43:07And like I said, if the military objective is to you know, demilitarized
- 43:10Moss, they have to go into Rafa and the battle therefore is not over.
- 43:14And they're not going to withdraw because who the hell is going to provide
- 43:15security. They're not going to allow a Hamas to reform in the vacuum,
- 43:20you know, to the extent possible. Again, that's yet to be seen.
- 43:22Over time. As Andy mentioned, people you know creeping back up north
- 43:24and you know, and you know, reoccupying areas so that that ship show
- 43:28is already coming We're already going to see that that battle line coming. Hamas
- 43:31continued existence in the form of governance and a governing structure inside Gaza is a
- 43:36non starter for anybody in the West. It's a non starter for most Arab
- 43:37states. They don't like Hamas. This is not like buying closed doors folks
- 43:40like I hate those guys. I wish the war wasn't being prosecuted this ways,
- 43:44but I'm really not. You know, all that upset about Hamas no
- 43:45longer existing as institution. They're not exactly a well liked group amongst most of
- 43:50the arb states. So the the issue is, then, is there a
- 43:52willingness to accept reality. You picked the fight you can't win. You can
- 43:57have a respite for a while. You could, perhaps, you know,
- 44:00ease the conditions for folks on the ground that are there, perhaps even negotiate
- 44:04your own exit, like you mentioned, to save your own ass and go
- 44:06to some other country and try to live to fight another day. All those
- 44:07fucking guys are dead men walking, every last one of them. The Mosada
- 44:10is going to get their hands on them and they are going to die.
- 44:13I don't care where they are on the face of this earth. That is
- 44:15one prediction I will make. I will not make a lot of military predictions.
- 44:17Those men will not survive. They will eventually say Israel's going to get
- 44:21them. So since Sinwar who's in charge, who, by the way,
- 44:23is a sociopath. The guy is a psycho, the one who's elected to
- 44:27take over Hamas. He was the internal security enforcer for Hamas. At one
- 44:31point he went to prison for only almost twenty years inside Israel. He was
- 44:37one of the ones that was released for a Gilliat Shalit back in six At
- 44:38that point he had brain cancer and was and survived because an Israeli neurosurgeon removed
- 44:44the tumor from his brain. So he had murdered Palestinians and I think plans
- 44:47to kill Israeli soldiers back then, and that's why he ended up going to
- 44:50jail and he got out. He's run on the show now from the tunnels
- 44:52under Gaza. He's the one that everybody's basically waiting on to say yes or
- 44:57no on this Teal And so far it seems like Micheal and some of the
- 45:00others who were in you know, in different plays in do Hard and Negotiating
- 45:02or wherever they happened to be hiding. It sounds like there's more favor from
- 45:07those outside to try to negotiate a deal, and he's basically like, no,
- 45:10it's not going to happen. So the question of whether or not there's
- 45:13a deal and hostages is going to get out is depend upon Hamas accepting the
- 45:16fact this war will continue at some point. You pick the fight that you
- 45:22know you can't win, and the Israelis are going to finish it one way
- 45:23or the other, right, And it's whether or not you're willing to give
- 45:27some reprieve to the Palestindian people and release some you know, innocent civilians and
- 45:30everything else if they're interested in doing that, and so far, you know
- 45:34what came back yesterday was that they significantly produced the number of postages to be
- 45:37released and also extended the timeframe in which they would be released, like three
- 45:40a week or something like that, as opposed to three a day, which
- 45:44is a non starter for the Israelis. So it would take Hamas getting serious
- 45:47on releasing the hostage as well as accepting the long term fate that Israel's going
- 45:51to continue to fight. Look, if you don't want fight, you shouldn't
- 45:52start in the first place, right, and their argument's going to be,
- 45:54well, then we'll continue to hold the hostages and at some point Israel's going
- 45:58to have to go in and try to recover the to themselves and take the
- 46:00territory, or there's going to have to be a deal settlement. But the
- 46:04terms that were put on the table yesterday, from a security perspective and politically
- 46:07in Israel, non starter, not gonna happen. And then and then,
- 46:10and Alex stick correct me if I'm wrong. Then you've got this really convoluted
- 46:15kind of chain of communication for the negotiations, right, So not even the
- 46:19US are in the room. The israelis not so, and the parties are
- 46:22not And then the parties that Hamas sends to Doha can't make decisions for Hamas,
- 46:29right, They've got to And as you said, Alex, for some
- 46:32somehow they're connecting with Sindjah beneath you know, beneath Kaza to get his final
- 46:37say so on things. And it's like what's real Taliban, And in Doha
- 46:42as well, it's the light of misfit. Everybody there's a mouthpiece, but
- 46:45we can make any decision. They go go back to Kanda Arkabo to get
- 46:47a decision render. So yeah, you have that problem, and then it
- 46:51sounds like yesterday. Another shit show is the fact that this you know,
- 46:53negotiation allegedly was taking place without the Israeli's dollars that there changing to the terms
- 47:00saying yeah, and the way I read that was Hamaskan O I like this,
- 47:04this I could deal with. Everybody's been saying that it's Hamasa's fault for
- 47:07saying no. So I'm going to come out publicly and I'm now going to
- 47:09say yes, I've accepted the terms of this deal. At the same time,
- 47:13political pressures bounting in Israel for a deal to be accepted and basically trying
- 47:16to throw the ball over the Israeli car. Well, we accept the terms
- 47:19of the deal. It's like Congress plays the game, right, we passed
- 47:21the law, We're going home on break. Yeah, but your law coming
- 47:23out of one chamber of the other is completely unacceptable to the other side.
- 47:27So I don't even fun if you pass it and you're going back home from
- 47:29wherever you're from, it's it's that's not gonna fly. And that's essentially what
- 47:32we landed on yesterday. As it's like, I'm glad you negotiate with yourself
- 47:35and came up with a deal that you thought is feasible. Doesn't work for
- 47:37us. We're going into rafa until you guys get serious. So the Israelis
- 47:42are basically saying, hey, that deal is in a fucking sushi menu.
- 47:45Yeah, exactly. Yeah, there will be hostages released, there will yeah,
- 47:50yeah, I mean it's in business, business too. You're a businessman
- 47:52as well, in addition to having time and service. When you you know,
- 47:54forget Donald the r of the deal, there's only so many levers of
- 47:58power you can pull inside of deal structure. Right, you've got terms,
- 48:00you know, payment terms net thirty, net forty five, net sixty.
- 48:04Right, you know how much profit margin you're going to have, what other
- 48:07conditions you can have or terms on the sale that's going to be beneficial to
- 48:09somebody else. Right, you can tweak those levers, but it deal's got
- 48:13to be good for both sides unless some of these backs. And at the
- 48:15end of the day, Hamas is trying to pull all those levers in its
- 48:19favor and Israel is never going to accept that. But Alex, I don't
- 48:22see any shaded air in the then diagram at all, you know. So,
- 48:25so you know, as far as organizations, possibly there's some wiggle room,
- 48:30you know, Israel Hamas maybe some wiggle room, maybe kind of a
- 48:36Tunisian type exit for the leadership. As you said that the Israeli snow will
- 48:40only be temporary, right, you know, I mean it took them,
- 48:44It took them twenty four years, but they got air faed in the end.
- 48:46Right. Well, it's actually but actually fascinating story. If we got
- 48:52time for that. When you're done, I want to hit that piece because
- 48:54actually, yeah, yeah, you're going to steal to stop talking. I
- 48:59would love to hear that. So Arafat. So I got to meet one
- 49:02of the agency doctors at one point and kind of told us the story about
- 49:05what had happened with Arafat because it kind of came up as a means because
- 49:07his job was to assess the health of foreigners and see how they're doing right,
- 49:12and so everybody I was looking for antidote anecdotes are cool stories when you
- 49:15go to training classes in the community and said, well, you know,
- 49:17Arafat, he actually died, and you know he's like the Israelis didn't didn't
- 49:22actually get him and I said, what do you means? He said,
- 49:23but they kind of did. I said, can you explain what you mean?
- 49:27And he said, well, he got sick. He ended up with
- 49:30septis semia where he had you know, the infection had gotten so bad I
- 49:31got in bloodstream and when he was septi scemic and required surgery, he was
- 49:36in France, right, so he was supposed to have surgery. I believe
- 49:37he was in Paris where they were going to conduct the surgery, and supposed
- 49:39the French doctors got together, like with the septi seemia that's here and the
- 49:43conditions and his age and everything else, there's a good chance he's going to
- 49:45die in the operating table. I'm not fucking touching him. I'm going to
- 49:47be the one labeled as responsible for killing Arafat on the table. And he
- 49:52was so paranoid that the Israelis would get him, you know, in a
- 49:53medical situation, they would get to him, like in a hospital somewhere,
- 49:58that he held off on medical treatment till the very end, until it was
- 50:00too late. So he's like, well, the Israelis didn't get him.
- 50:02It was the paranoia that they had induced in him after years of assassination attempts
- 50:07that actually caused him not to seek medical treatment until it was too late,
- 50:09and for the French to go, fuck this, I'm not touching him.
- 50:13That is such a great no. I mean, that's such a great story.
- 50:16I mean the irony because how many times did Marsat try to kill him?
- 50:21I Meangman, you know in that book Rise and Kill First. If
- 50:24you look up assassination attempts on Arafat, it's like, I mean, asan
- 50:31barrock at one point when he was prime minister, because he had been there
- 50:35and dealt the force equivalent commander in terms of uh Syria. McCall right.
- 50:38I think at one point in his book he talked about standing there with like
- 50:42a I don't know if it was an RPG or like a shoulder fired rocket
- 50:45that he was in a field that was supposed to be aimed at killing Arafat.
- 50:47And then then Arafat's in charge. Eight years later, he's the prime
- 50:50minister and the two of them were trying to negotiate a peacedale. I mean
- 50:52exactly that. It's just give you an illusture of example of how fucked up
- 50:57the politics are there at that point. But there's some symmetry there when Malacham.
- 51:02When Bagan wanted to visit the UK in nineteen seventy seven, the British
- 51:07had to remove a a an arrest warrant for murder for for connection with the
- 51:17blowing up the hotel. David back in when does that forty five forty one
- 51:23there in the forties? Absolutely insane? I mean one day you were fighting
- 51:28one next to your that's right, yeah, and they found out almost at
- 51:31the last minute. It was a hilarious story. Special Branch is that's awesome,
- 51:37but we need to be there for the arrival summit ceremony because we've that
- 51:44is insane. I got one more question about the whole What does Egypt do
- 51:50because like there's been some talk about Egypt kind of spinning up and is not
- 51:53interested in like like you said, like you know, a million refugees coming
- 51:57through there, you know that border. See does the Egyptian military do anything?
- 52:01Do they spin up I don't see it now, spin up perhaps on
- 52:06the other side of a fence to make sure that people escape, because there
- 52:08were some reports yesterday that you know it must be blow try to blow a
- 52:12whole the fence to cause chaos and let the palestin the in start of escape
- 52:15the situation. The reality is, if you talk to the vest majority of
- 52:16Pealestinians, yes they would, they would like humanitarian assistants. They don't want
- 52:21to leave. They want their own country. So by them leaving, right,
- 52:22they're not going to get they want. I think there's people be happy
- 52:24refugees and get the hell out of Gaza. Don't get me wrong, given
- 52:27the circumstances. But for the Egyptians, they're not going to start a war
- 52:30with these railies. They're not going to There won't be military you know,
- 52:32you know, uh clashes between the two so to speak. It would be
- 52:37the situation's sort of unforeseeable. They do have one of the oldest I mean,
- 52:39let's not forget look how far we are into this war and the conditions
- 52:43that you see in Gaza and what the you know people are talking about.
- 52:46They still have diplomatic relations, you know, with a number of countries,
- 52:50they have peace treaties with it. Right, they haven't suspended, they haven't
- 52:52pulled thembasters. So we haven't even gotten to the point where we start,
- 52:55like the diplomatic dictance that starts before that the combat starts where it's like,
- 53:00Okay, I'm going to recall this guy for consultations. Now I'm going to
- 53:02pull the ambassador from here. We're going to degrade, you know, our
- 53:06status here in this country. We haven't even started executing through those diplomatic steps
- 53:09yet, never mind getting down to a military conflict between the two states.
- 53:13So I think of anything, it's potentially we see them, you know,
- 53:16providing security around around Gos and to make sure people don't come into Egypt.
- 53:21But I don't I don't see them them going inside. They don't want touch
- 53:23it, as we're mentioned earlier, as any mentioned too, for political reasons,
- 53:27for economic reasons. They don't want to do it. It's they would
- 53:29like this is a they don't want to touch this with a ten foot pole,
- 53:31nless they have to. And and also to be clear, for the
- 53:37Israelis, having CC and control in Egypt is the best of a number of
- 53:40bad options. You know, they have delighted that it's not more sea still
- 53:45on the Muslim Brotherhood, but who you know, the Cross is an offshoot
- 53:50of the Muslim Brotherhood. So and there is and there's more collaboration and cooperation
- 53:55behind the scenes than people realize is the Egyptian government is sensitive to its own
- 54:01public, who as wait, so hates Csraeli's but that the pragmatists, you
- 54:07know at the desert they are are. So what happens now? What's your
- 54:14best prediction? I know that's horribly unfair, but we've got we've got nothing
- 54:20closer to an expert. I know you don't like been cool an expert.
- 54:22God help you wait, I can't imagine anyone closer to an expert. So,
- 54:30I mean, how I see it going. The key decision that still
- 54:35has to be rendered is by sin More and whether or not he's willing to
- 54:37accept reality on some of these major points in the deal. So far it
- 54:40seems to be a bridge too far that they're unwilling to do that. Israel
- 54:45will go into Rafa. It's going to happen sooner, or it's going to
- 54:49happen later. I believe that the IDF will be asked to provide security inside
- 54:53of Gaza, at least initially while they're there there is I mean, we
- 54:57are too close to the end of an operation of with no mobilization of forces
- 55:01from an Arab country to expect them to be the day after scenario to take
- 55:05over security. So the short term and the midterm is becoming increasingly clear.
- 55:09What is still unclear this point is a long term solution for governance post war,
- 55:14reconstruction and security, and that is where I think we're going to attempt
- 55:17to see some more US broker deals in the background and trying to see this
- 55:22normalization go on. The sticking point I mentioned on one side more he's willing
- 55:28to accept reality there. The other sticking point then for the longer term solution
- 55:32is whether or not Israel is going to move towards the state Tuesday, Alex,
- 55:38you're breaking up a little bit there towards the sixty seven middle. Yeah,
- 55:45Alex, Sorry we lost you there. You got a little choppy just
- 55:50from the lost pomp. Yeah. As you're telling you about the state solution,
- 55:54it was, you know, a sense it that the whole thing.
- 55:59So for the folks or you know, pro two state solution, there isn't
- 56:02the domestic support inside of Israel for that. So again, if I mentioned
- 56:06sin war being the short term issue in terms of his willingness to accept reality
- 56:10and what's not going to happen as the result of the negotiated settlement to the
- 56:15war. There's a long term issue that has to be addressed, which is
- 56:19on the Israeli side, which is the you know, a two state solution,
- 56:22and there isn't the domestic will Ford right now. And for folks again
- 56:24not following Israeli politics, well, nen Yah who just gets out of office,
- 56:29this is all going to get solved. You know, he's a conservative
- 56:30loan and you know he doesn't want a two state solutions never going to happen
- 56:34if you look at the polling data. First of all, he's really left,
- 56:36has been decimated. He's really left in politics, but relatively doesn't really
- 56:37exist in terms of a functioning entity right now. Those days are long gone,
- 56:42and who knows what happens in the future. But you know Benny Gantz
- 56:45is likely going to come in afterwards. And while he comes with a lot
- 56:47less the political legal baggage that Netanyahu does, if you look at his stances
- 56:52on the war and the other people in the wark Habin, their stances are
- 56:54just as firm as that who is on a lot of these issues, and
- 56:58they're subject to the same public opinion poll and votes as Netanyahuz. And so
- 57:02there's two things that in order for this really to get moved. There's two
- 57:06things that have to get solved. Sinmar has to accept reality for this war
- 57:10is not going to end on his terms, and the fact that he wants
- 57:13these Raelies out in a permanent ceasefire. That's great. I want a golden
- 57:15Ferrari. No one's parking one of my driveway next weekening it to happen.
- 57:19And the long term, there needs to be some sort of willingness to move
- 57:22towards a two state solution but not make it look like it's rewarding terrorism,
- 57:27which is a difficult balancing act in order for us to see a realistic foreign
- 57:30security force and investment in reconstruction to take place. So unfortunately, we are
- 57:35coming close to the end of the end for the end of becoming shortly for
- 57:38Rafick. It's a small area that needs to get cleared. We are getting
- 57:42very close to where the day after scenario is supposed to start, where the
- 57:45day after scenario is completely undefined. And so that is the biggest concern that
- 57:49I see in front of us right now is the coming insurgency that I believe
- 57:52is coming. Yikes, Alex, I'm not going to make a flippant come
- 57:58in at the end about you wassend on a on a high note because you
- 58:01know, I think sadly you are right on tugget. I'm a Mets fan.
- 58:08There's always next season. Oh god, yeah, you know if I
- 58:13always a sports fan. I think it's something pathetic to say, you know,
- 58:16to try and raise our spirits right at the end. But instead I'm
- 58:20gonna turn over to d all Right, Alex, everybody can find you on
- 58:22Twitter and LinkedIn obviously, right, Alex plezis what's your Twitter handle? I'm
- 58:29gonna put it all in the description anyway, so if anyone love it,
- 58:31fellow Greek has to stop to try to get that last name correct. You
- 58:35know, it's that because you try to pronounce it the other time. And
- 58:37I was just gonna say, pleizzis. I mean I heard, I think,
- 58:39probably the most insulting comment, which you can't even you know, say
- 58:43in this environment anymore. Boot camp twenty years ago, I had a drill
- 58:45sergeant and looked at me and goes, do you know what pleza is?
- 58:47I was like, what, you know those moments where you're like, oh
- 58:50God, what's coming? Because that's the one part of the buffalo the natives
- 58:52would need. I didn't even know how. I sat there utterly stuck.
- 58:55I didn't even had to respond to that. It's so for Twitter, it's
- 59:00at A L e x P L I T s A s so at Alex
- 59:05bleitzis and linkedin' the same subs Alex Bleitzas. All right, I'm gonna leave
- 59:07all the links in the description, of course Andy's award winning book. Congratulations
- 59:12Andy, congratulations. Maybe yeah, the link will be in the description.
- 59:16That's the last episode. You need to do that, But I appreciate it,
- 59:20all right, higl buying a copy of you guys having a Bandy's book.
- 59:23Yeah, it's incredible, it is good. Yeah, well, thank
- 59:27you? What else? Okay, if you're listening to us, rate and
- 59:30review. If you're watching us, like and subscribe, check out our Patreon,
- 59:35Patreon dot com slash the Teamhouse. We have a really important guest tomorrow
- 59:38on the Teamhouse. Adam Gamal. He wrote the unit. Uh yeah,
- 59:44he's in studio too, but I'm gonna be blocking his face out live,
- 59:46so hopefully I don't screw that up and show his identity. There's another Team
- 59:50House podcast. Yeah, can you imagine the actually yeah, you audacity you
- 59:55know what they see me and Jason. Everyone wants to be us. Huh
- 59:59exactly. It's not that, it's not that fucking Jack Jack Something Murphy,
- 1:00:04Jack Murphy, that Green Beret rabble rouser, another musclehead, Dave popped it,
- 1:00:10said warrior scollar right to one of these. Thanks als, We really
- 1:00:16appreciate that. Yeah, you guys awesome. That was guys. You do