Latest / Manager Mondays with Fexingo: People Management, Team Leadership, and First-Time Managers / How to Give Feedback That Actually Lands
Transcript
- Lucas: So on this show we spend a lot of time on the tricky employee, the one who overcommits or hoards credit or always has an idea. But there's a quieter problem that I think shows up in every team, every week, and we almost never talk about it. Luna: Which is? Lucas: Feedback that just... evaporates. You give it, the person nods, they say sure, and then nothing changes. And you walk away thinking, did I even say anything? Because the words left your mouth, but they clearly didn't land. Luna: That is painfully relatable. And I think we've all been on the receiving end too, where you genuinely don't know what your manager wanted you to do differently. Lucas: Exactly. And look, if someone can't repeat back what you just told them, then you didn't give them feedback. You gave them a noise. So today we're going to look at why feedback fails, and what to do so it actually sticks. Luna: And if you've ever gotten something out of this show, whether that's a new way to handle a tough conversation or just the reminder that you're not alone in this, a couple of dollars a month is genuinely what keeps these going. You can support us at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. Lucas: And it does make a real difference. No big production costs here, but it means we can keep making this show ad-free and focused on the stuff that actually matters in your day-to-day. Luna: And every bit helps, honestly. Now let's get back to feedback. Lucas: So let me set the scene. It's Monday morning, you're in your one-on-one, and you tell your report, 'Great job on the presentation yesterday.' What happens next? Luna: They say thanks, and then you move on to the next item. And a week later they do the same thing again, and you're like, didn't I already tell you that was good? Lucas: Right. Because 'great job' is not feedback. It's a compliment. And compliments are nice, but they don't tell someone what to repeat. So the first fix is to get specific. Instead of 'great job on the presentation,' try 'when you summarized the client's objections and then proposed a next step, that moved us forward. Do more of that.' Luna: And the difference is huge. Because now they know exactly which part of their behavior you want them to keep. Lucas: Exactly. And the same goes for constructive feedback. 'You need to be more proactive' means nothing. But 'In the last two meetings, you didn't speak up until I asked you directly. I want you to share your opinion before I call on you' — that's something they can actually act on. Luna: So specificity is the first key. What's the second? Because I feel like there's a trap a lot of us fall into. Lucas: The compliment sandwich. You know, the 'here's something good, here's the bad, here's something good' structure. And I know it's well-intentioned, but research shows it actually dilutes the message. People remember the good stuff and forget the critique entirely. Luna: So you end up with an employee who thinks they're doing great, when you actually had a specific issue you wanted them to work on. Lucas: Right. So my advice is to drop the sandwich. If the feedback is constructive, just lead with it. Be direct. 'I want to talk about how you handled the client call yesterday. When you interrupted me, it undercut the point I was making.' Then pause. Let them respond. Luna: And that pause is so important. Because if you've given them a specific behavior and a specific impact, you've given them something to work with. They might even explain their side, which is the start of a real conversation. Lucas: And that's the third key: make it a dialogue, not a monologue. After you give feedback, ask a question. 'What's your read on that?' or 'How did you see it?' That invites them to engage, rather than just absorb. Luna: And it also stops you from talking at them. Which, let's be honest, is easy to do when you're the manager and you've got a point to make. Lucas: Totally. And this is where timing comes in. The best feedback is given close to the event, when the memory is fresh. Not saving it up for the quarterly review. That's a vault, not feedback. Luna: So if something happens on a Tuesday, you talk about it on Tuesday. Not three weeks later when you're filling out the performance form. Lucas: Exactly. And I want to be clear, this isn't about never having a formal review. It's about using those moments for the big picture, not for the first time you're mentioning a problem. Luna: That makes sense. And I think what you're saying is that feedback should be a habit, not an event. Lucas: Yes. And that's the real shift. When you give feedback regularly, it takes the sting out of the difficult conversations. Because you've built trust, and the person knows you're not just piling on. You're trying to help them grow. Luna: And that's the thing, right? If you only ever talk to someone when they've messed up, they're going to dread talking to you. But if feedback is a constant part of your one-on-ones, it becomes normal. Lucas: So to recap: be specific, drop the sandwich, make it a dialogue, and do it often. Four things that sound simple but take practice. Luna: And I think the trick is to start small. Pick one conversation this week and try to be more specific than you usually are. See what happens. Lucas: And that's the thing — one small change can completely change how your team hears you. Because they'll start to actually listen, instead of just nodding along. Luna: And you'll know it's working when they can repeat back what you said. That's the test. Lucas: Exactly. So next time you're in a one-on-one, try it. And if you're on the receiving end, you can also ask for specifics. 'Can you give me an example of what I did well?' That's a great question to ask your own manager. Luna: Because feedback's a two-way street. And the more you practice asking for it, the more you'll get it. Lucas: So that's our take on making feedback actually land. We'd love to hear from you — what's your go-to way to give feedback that sticks? Send us a note, and we might feature it in a future episode. Luna: And if this episode helped you think about your own management style, consider supporting the show at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. It really does keep us going. Lucas: Alright, that's a wrap for this Manager Monday. Thanks for listening, and we'll see you next week.