Latest / Film And Whiskey / Hanksgiving, Vol. 4: Saving Mr. Banks
Transcript
- 0:00Today on the Film and Whiskey Podcast, it is Hanks giving
- 0:03Thanksgiving. We're looking at the life and
- 0:06career of our favorite actor of all time not named Cruz I.
- 0:12Was about to say with the 2013 film Saving Mr. Banks.
- 0:17This is the Film and Whiskey Podcast.
- 0:40Welcome to the Film and Whiskey Podcast, where each week we
- 0:42review a classic movie and a glass of whiskey.
- 0:45I'm Bob Book. I'm Brad G and things already
- 0:49feel off today. Brad, I don't think I've ever
- 0:51said this is. You haven't.
- 0:54How do I feel? I feel I feel naked.
- 0:56I don't know. I don't like it do.
- 0:59You Do you feel ashamed, though I do.
- 1:01I feel like hiding now. Yeah, yeah.
- 1:03I mean, I wasn't going to say anything, but it was a little
- 1:06subpar and especially on such a special day as Thanksgiving.
- 1:09I know, man. I.
- 1:10I think our audience deserves better, Bob.
- 1:12Oh, it was so tentative because I didn't know if I should.
- 1:15It felt it felt forbidden, you know.
- 1:18Well, folks, after that shaky start, welcome to Hanksgiving.
- 1:23Thanksgiving, baby. The most beautiful day of the
- 1:25year is this Hanksgiving 4 or Hanksgiving 5?
- 1:28Brad Bob, this is Hanksgiving #4.
- 1:31Wow, I for some reason I feel like Hanksgiving was a recent
- 1:36invention, but I think we did it in our second year of the
- 1:40podcast. We we started Hanksgiving back
- 1:42when the pilgrims did. Yes.
- 1:44It's not, this is not recent at all, man.
- 1:47I really like this bonus episode that we do every year on
- 1:51Thanksgiving, watching one film from the career of Tom Hanks,
- 1:54because it gives us a little bit of an opportunity A to talk
- 1:57about, you know, America's dad, Tom Hanks, but also to look at
- 2:02some films that may not make our regular list of 32 movies.
- 2:05You know, we're trying to knock out some stone cold classics of
- 2:09cinema and like, you know, Big is a great movie, but like, is
- 2:14it a Top 100? Probably not The Terminal, a
- 2:16movie that I like. But you know, let's be honest
- 2:19here, folks like this is not on the sight and sound list.
- 2:22And so today we're looking at perhaps like the perfect Tom
- 2:26Hanks movie to look at on Hanks Giving, and it is 2013's Saving
- 2:31Mr. Banks. Bob, this movie wrecked my soul,
- 2:36man. I was not expecting what I got.
- 2:39I'll tell you what. So I will say this, first of
- 2:42all, for saving Mr. Banks, it is very effective at what it tries
- 2:46to do. It is manipulative.
- 2:48And I I I don't like that about it.
- 2:51But Dang it, it works. I went to see this movie at a
- 2:56midnight premiere, Brad, you know, as as you do when you line
- 3:00up for midnight premieres because my wife's favorite movie
- 3:04of all time is Mary Poppins. And so we knew this movie was
- 3:06coming out and we were, you know, engaged and childless at
- 3:10the time. And so we had plenty of free
- 3:11time and energy to stay up late, and we went to see this movie
- 3:14The very first opportunity we could Thursday night at
- 3:18midnight. And it's a good movie, Brad.
- 3:21I don't know if I would nowadays go see it at midnight, but like,
- 3:25I I feel like my history with this movie is I saw it at the
- 3:29earliest possible convenience that anyone on Earth could have
- 3:33seen it. So I go back a long way with
- 3:35this movie. You sure do, Bob.
- 3:37I for me, I am as far on the opposite side as you can get.
- 3:42I knew. That Walt Disney was was a
- 3:45character in this film. I had zero idea that this was
- 3:49even about Mary Poppins. Like it.
- 3:52What do you think it was about? I have no idea.
- 3:57I like. I was like doing stuff.
- 4:00It was, yeah, you know, you see the Netflix preview for like 3
- 4:03seconds as you're like. Scrolling through, you know this
- 4:06is back before Disney Plus I'm pretty sure it was on Netflix
- 4:09and so you you see like a four second preview and I saw a woman
- 4:12walking with Walt Disney and and it looked pleasant and I just
- 4:16figured it was kind of a a schmoozy biopic about Walt
- 4:20Disney. No it's not.
- 4:23So to your point, this is, this is what I was going to say when
- 4:25I got off on my tangent about midnight screenings.
- 4:27But every time I return to this movie, and this is probably like
- 4:31my, I don't know, my 4th time seeing it, maybe fifth time
- 4:34seeing it, I always remember it being like a golden hued, you
- 4:39know, touchy, feely uplifting movie that would be perfect for
- 4:43Thanksgiving. And then I watch it and I'm
- 4:45like, this is a deeply sad film. Like, like it ends on a positive
- 4:50note. But even the positive note is
- 4:52like, tinged with it gets pretty dark, man.
- 4:55You know, like, and and so I come out of it wondering, like,
- 4:59I I almost feel like we should evaluate it.
- 5:01A, on the Hanks side of things, like how does this work as a
- 5:04Hanks movie? But B, does this actually work
- 5:08as a Thanksgiving movie? Because like I I thought, oh,
- 5:11this would be a great one to throw on with your family.
- 5:13And then after watching it, I'm like, yeah, I don't know, man,
- 5:15like. I mean, I know that Walt Disney
- 5:17was thankful for all the money that he made off of Mary
- 5:19Poppins. So 100% multiple Times Now.
- 5:22Yeah, many times over. There's also the fact that we
- 5:25can all be thankful for Colin Farrell as just.
- 5:30A stellar actor. I really love Colin Farrell and
- 5:33I'm so glad that things have come back around for him.
- 5:36Yeah, he spent so many years toiling away in in indie films
- 5:40and taking smaller roles like this before, you know, the
- 5:43banshees of Ennis. Sheeran has put him back on the
- 5:46top of the mountain and I am. I'm so glad for him.
- 5:49I don't know if I can ever watch that movie again, but man, I
- 5:53really want to watch that movie so good.
- 5:55Even Brendan Gleeson are are like.
- 5:58Probably one of the best duos in a film I've ever seen.
- 6:03Well, if you can tell how much we like saving Mr. Banks, we're
- 6:06already talking about other movies instead.
- 6:09I do have to reiterate, I like this movie, Brad.
- 6:11I think it's a well made film. I have many complicated thoughts
- 6:14on it though. But before we get into talking
- 6:16about that, I think it's time that we throw over to, Brad
- 6:19explains. Brad's going to give us the
- 6:21movie plots with only 60 seconds ticking on the clock, so let's
- 6:24go ahead and hear your take with this little segment that we
- 6:28call. Brad explains.
- 6:30Now because this is a Hanksgiving episode and not a
- 6:32full regular episode, Brad, I almost want to implement a 30
- 6:35second time limit. But let's just let's just say
- 6:39like. I mean, you already started,
- 6:41started us off today. This should be just a Bob
- 6:43explains concisely as possible. Brad, can you spoil this movie
- 6:48and fill our listeners in on the plot of Saving Mr. Banks?
- 6:53I sure can. Bob Saving Mr. Banks is a film
- 6:56about PL. Travers, a author in the 1960s
- 7:00who wrote the wildly popular Mary Poppins series.
- 7:04She has a terrifically, horrifyingly sad childhood.
- 7:09With an alcoholic father and a overwhelmed mother that sets her
- 7:14on the trajectory to writing Mary Poppins because her
- 7:17mother's sister comes and is essentially Mary Poppins in her
- 7:20life. The latter half of the film is
- 7:24about her and Walt Disney's relationship and how she
- 7:28bitterly tries to derail his project to bring Mary Poppins to
- 7:33life. The end.
- 7:36I I mean, did you see anything else in the movie?
- 7:39No, no. Like some?
- 7:40Hidden hidden scenes that I didn't see.
- 7:44All right. So I'm trying to decide how to
- 7:46approach this movie, Brad. Because again, this is
- 7:48Hanksgiving. We're here to talk about Tom
- 7:50Hanks and Turkey. I mean and.
- 7:52You could approach it from the Tom Hanks, Walt Disney side of
- 7:55things and just be bright and optimistic, sure.
- 7:57Or you could approach it from the Colin Farrell side of things
- 7:59and just drink as much alcohol as you can.
- 8:01It really does fit with the theme of our show, doesn't it?
- 8:04It sure does. All right, so let's start with
- 8:07Hanks. I want to start with Emma
- 8:09Thompson because she is clearly the lead of this movie.
- 8:11This might be the first. I guess it is the first
- 8:14supporting Hanks performance that we've done for Hanks
- 8:17Giving. Right.
- 8:19Yeah. And I, as I said before, I did
- 8:21not know that when I picked this, Yeah, it's interesting.
- 8:24I thought that this was a Tom Hanks movie.
- 8:26Yeah, I mean, it is a Tom Hanks movie.
- 8:28I feel like this movie doesn't really get made if you don't
- 8:31have someone like Tom Hanks as Walt Disney.
- 8:34And I think that's a good place to start, Brad.
- 8:35Because aside from the performance itself, which we can
- 8:38talk about, the fact that Disney makes this movie right, like
- 8:41they have complete control of how the movie gets made and how
- 8:45they depict Walt Disney. There are just tons and tons of
- 8:48historical inaccuracies like the actual the actual trip from PL.
- 8:53Travers to California. Walt Disney went on vacation for
- 8:56most of it, so that he didn't have to deal with her like they
- 8:58they truly hated each other. They never had a good
- 9:01relationship. She never liked the final movie
- 9:03of Mary Poppins. Like, everything's made-up.
- 9:05Everything's controlled by the Disney corporation.
- 9:08But there's something about Disney.
- 9:11I guess the most insidious thing about it is that Disney is
- 9:14leveraging the Tom Hanks persona.
- 9:17Because by casting Tom Hanks as Walt Disney, you're
- 9:22automatically smoothing over any rough edges that this person
- 9:25could have had, right? Like, whatever actual problems
- 9:29he may have, whatever personality flaws he might have,
- 9:33the audience is ultimately always going to come out on his
- 9:35side. Because he's Tom Hanks, right?
- 9:37Like you're always you're always viewing him as ultimately the
- 9:41good guy here. And as you know at Peel, Travers
- 9:44is the one who has to change because of course, Tom Hanks
- 9:46wouldn't have to change. When it also doesn't help that
- 9:49like six years later, he plays, you know, Mr. Rogers.
- 9:52Yes. And so now if you watch Saving
- 9:54Mr. Banks, there's moments where Walt is talking to like, his
- 9:57staff or to to Pamela. And 100%, I'm like, Oh no, that
- 10:03there's Mr. Rogers. He's not waltz anymore.
- 10:05He's just comforting her. What a nice guy.
- 10:09Yeah, this was the beginning of his tour to play every respected
- 10:12figure like it's going to be like Walter Cronkite next.
- 10:16Like, it's got to be somebody else that's trusted by all of
- 10:18America. He's just going to be commenting
- 10:21on Vietnam for like 2 1/2 hours straight.
- 10:27Here's the thing, man. I feel like this movie kind of
- 10:32falls into the vein of a kind of like an Aaron Sorkin Social
- 10:39Network type of movie where. It's not accurate to what
- 10:45happened in real life, but it tells a compelling story and I
- 10:50think I'm kind of OK with it because of that.
- 10:53And and it's such an interesting, like meta
- 10:55commentary on itself though. Like the Disney corporation took
- 10:59this woman's book, took the source material and changed it
- 11:03to their liking to make the Mary Poppins movie and ultimately
- 11:07said like, look, we did it like we made a great movie out of it.
- 11:10And then they made a movie about the making of that movie where
- 11:12they completely changed the source material and they were
- 11:15like, doesn't matter, we're going to make a great movie out
- 11:17of it. It's like, well, I guess you
- 11:19know, if it ain't broke, don't fix it.
- 11:21Like keep using that formula, Disney.
- 11:24Yeah, well, and there is absolutely no love lost between
- 11:29Disney and I here. I think Disney is a shisty
- 11:33organization that does shisty things constantly with with
- 11:37their IPS, with their characters, with their movies.
- 11:40But I will give them credit, man.
- 11:42I really liked this film. I did too.
- 11:44Like at the end of the day, here's the thing about this
- 11:47movie. It's like the script for this
- 11:50movie is like the the epitome of a 6 1/2 out of 10 script.
- 11:54It's like a 2.5 stars out of four script and then they just
- 11:58stacked the cast with legitimate Hollywood A listers.
- 12:03And then even the most supporting roles are like
- 12:06seasoned veteran. Paul Giamatti.
- 12:09Yeah, right. That's what I'm saying.
- 12:10Like, but even below that, like the lady that plays Disney's
- 12:13secretary, her name's Kathy Baker.
- 12:16I feel like we've had her in a movie or two before.
- 12:18I mean, she's like a well known character actress and she's
- 12:21playing the 12th lead of the movie, you know what I mean?
- 12:25Yeah, yeah. And.
- 12:26And you have, like Paul Giamatti playing a Mickey Mouse
- 12:30character. There's just so much going on
- 12:33here that fits. To elevate this script beyond
- 12:38what it should be. Well, OK, let's go ahead and do
- 12:41this, 'cause I I want to talk Hanks, I want to talk the movie
- 12:44itself, but let's kind of knock out all of the other actors in
- 12:47the movie. And I guess we've already talked
- 12:50about Colin Farrell. Let's kind of go down the
- 12:52supporting cast list here. Giamatti is really, really great
- 12:56in this movie and I just went and saw a movie with him in it
- 12:59the other day called The Holdovers, which if I can just
- 13:02plug a Thanksgiving movie, folks, go see The Holdovers.
- 13:05It is like the perfect old school.
- 13:08Take your family to the movies on Christmas or Thanksgiving
- 13:12movie. It's so freaking good.
- 13:14But seeing him just the other day in that movie and then
- 13:17seeing him here, I'm reminded of like just how great his range is
- 13:22because he's playing the most, like, optimistic, sincere,
- 13:27authentic person ever. He's like a puppy dog in human
- 13:30form in this movie. And it's it's believable because
- 13:34it's Paul Giamatti. Like you've got an Academy Award
- 13:37nominated guy playing the 7th lead of this movie and he's not
- 13:42even a real person. Like this character is just
- 13:44made-up. And of course they make up the
- 13:47character that has the most compelling back story, right?
- 13:49Like the handicapped daughter and like.
- 13:52But Giamatti once again, like he, takes the source material
- 13:55and and absolutely elevates it. Yeah, he he really does.
- 14:00The line that killed me with him is when Travers is talking about
- 14:05how the rain brings life and he just looks at her and he goes,
- 14:10yeah, but the sun does too. And it's just so.
- 14:14Optimistic. It's It was so optimistic.
- 14:17But here's what sells it 95% of actors would deliver that line
- 14:23way too bright and sunny. And Giamatti does it with a
- 14:27sadness that this movie doesn't deserve, where you can tell that
- 14:32he has been through some garbage in his life.
- 14:35And he is still choosing to believe that the sun brings life
- 14:40and and it's all conveyed with this, this tonality of his voice
- 14:44and this look in his eye. And I'm like, why did they pay
- 14:47Giamatti like, you know, probably like 5 million, four
- 14:50million to to be this? To deliver that line perfectly.
- 14:55That's why I do love the moment, like towards the end where he
- 14:59drops her off at the airport and she says you're the only
- 15:02American I've ever liked and he goes up.
- 15:04Well, can I ask why she goes? No.
- 15:07Of course. And they cut back.
- 15:08And he's like, all right, cool. It's just a great reaction.
- 15:11I'll take what I can get. You've got BJ Novak and Jason
- 15:14Schwartzman as the Sherman Brothers, and there's a great
- 15:17documentary on Disney Plus about the Sherman Brothers and all the
- 15:21songs they wrote for all the Disney movies.
- 15:23I I really love them in this movie.
- 15:25I feel like they definitely make them more simplistic as people
- 15:29than they need to be, but they serve the purpose of the film.
- 15:32You know, BJ Novak is the guy who doesn't like Travers, and
- 15:35then you've got Jason Schwartzman as the one who's
- 15:37more sympathetic. And again, for having these big
- 15:40name actors playing these tiny, tiny roles, I think Schwartzman
- 15:45is responsible for my favorite scene in the whole movie, which
- 15:47is when he does Feed the birds and he just plays it for Tom
- 15:50Hanks. And Hanks gets that great line,
- 15:53because Feed the Birds is famously Walt Disney's favorite
- 15:55song that was ever written by the Shermans, and he's playing
- 15:59it for Disney for the first time.
- 16:00And he he finishes it and it's a real tearjerker.
- 16:03And Hanks just goes, Yep, that'll work.
- 16:06And then they move on to the next thing.
- 16:07And I just. I love that scene so much, man.
- 16:11I personally love the scene when BJ Novak is walking around with
- 16:15his cane. You mean every, every scene?
- 16:19With DJ, the first time when Travers sees him and she goes,
- 16:22what's wrong with him? The I think it's the secretary
- 16:25goes, oh, he was shot in the leg.
- 16:28And she she basically goes like, why do you go and do a thing
- 16:31like that? You have to make her the most
- 16:35British, British person, right? Oh, just the worst.
- 16:39Like I think I texted you like. 20 minutes into the movie was
- 16:43like, well, I understand why I had the take I did on on Mary
- 16:47Poppins when we reviewed that. OK, just a few more supporting
- 16:52characters. I don't even know that we really
- 16:53need to talk about them in depth, but like, you've got
- 16:55Bradley Whitford alongside the Sherman brothers kind of helping
- 16:58to coax Travers into accepting this whole movie.
- 17:02I think Bradley Whitford is one of those guys that you're always
- 17:05like, Oh yeah, he was in this too, Yep.
- 17:09And he's great in everything. Yeah, Yep.
- 17:12I really like the the Mary Poppins stand in.
- 17:15What's her name? Rachel Griffiths.
- 17:16I think she was on 6 Feet under. I like the mom, you know, for
- 17:20that Colin Farrell's wife in the movie.
- 17:22I just, it's crazy how many people they got to be in this
- 17:26movie, Brad, because as I think about the type of movie this is,
- 17:31this is the type of movie that nowadays Disney would make this
- 17:34movie and release it exclusively on Disney.
- 17:37Plus, it would not get a theatrical run.
- 17:39They would not be making a big Oscar push push for it for
- 17:42anybody except maybe Hanks. And the fact that this movie
- 17:44comes out and makes I I think a couple $100 million at the box
- 17:48office just ten years ago, it really is an example of how much
- 17:52the industry has changed really, really rapidly.
- 17:55Yeah, the This movie definitely feels like a relic of the
- 18:00majority of film history that no longer exists and we should just
- 18:05burn it all down. Bob.
- 18:08I love it, man. I'm thankful.
- 18:09This is what I love on Thanksgiving talking about
- 18:11burning down the establishment. Yeah.
- 18:15All right, man. What do you see?
- 18:16We take a break here. We'll come back after the break
- 18:18and we'll talk a little bit about Tom Hanks and our overall
- 18:22thoughts on this movie. What do you say?
- 18:25Let's get to it. All right, we're back talking
- 18:28about saving Mr. Banks. Brad, we're not drinking a
- 18:31whiskey today, at least not for review.
- 18:33But I do have one poured out here and our our operative thing
- 18:37today was pour yourself a whiskey for this recording that
- 18:40you are thankful for. What's your whiskey today, man?
- 18:44Bob, I have poured out in front of me amroot fusion because by
- 18:50golly, this is the best thing I think I've drank all year.
- 18:56Especially in terms of being surprised, like like when I
- 18:59looked up amroot fusion, I was like, oh, Indian whiskey.
- 19:02I didn't know they made Indian whiskey.
- 19:05And I drank it and I said I didn't know India made whiskey
- 19:07better than almost every other country in the world.
- 19:12Surprise, surprise. Yeah, man, in front of me is an
- 19:15old standby. And it's funny because, you
- 19:17know, we talk about certain whiskeys all the time on this
- 19:21podcast that that really stuck in our brains.
- 19:23But that doesn't mean I drink them all the time.
- 19:26And about, oh, I'd say 3 weeks ago I was.
- 19:29I was feeling like a single malt.
- 19:31I didn't really know what to pull down off my shelf.
- 19:33And I was like, you know what I haven't had in a long time?
- 19:36Glenmorangie Quinta Ruben, 14. Dude, dude, let's freaking go.
- 19:41And I tried it. I tried it again.
- 19:42And I was like, Oh my gosh, like I have hyped this to death for
- 19:47seven seasons of this podcast and it still delivers every
- 19:51single time I drink it for a $50 whiskey like you, just you will
- 19:56never get a better $50 whiskey than this.
- 19:58Brad. Yeah, no dude, I I had it again.
- 20:02I think I finally bought myself a bottle.
- 20:04Just I was like, you know what, I'm buying a bottle and I drink
- 20:09it again and I was like, I might have come down a point or two
- 20:13from my first appraisal, but by golly, man, for $50.00, I think
- 20:18it might be like around 55 nowadays in Ohio.
- 20:21You it is so so good. Well, we are thankful for Amrut
- 20:26Fusion and Glenmore and G Quinta Ruben and Tom Hanks I.
- 20:30Give a I give an honorable mention in the whiskey category.
- 20:32Please do. I was having a steak the other
- 20:35week and I drank Lagavulin 16 with it.
- 20:40You are a big Lagavulin guy. You really love that stuff, man
- 20:43it. Is incredible and I and I have
- 20:46to say for anybody out there who cannot approach the peated
- 20:51scotches, drink them with a steak.
- 20:54There is something about the savouriness of the meat that I
- 21:00thought that that log of 1/16 was like rich and and caramel Y
- 21:05and almost like cheesecake richness and sweetness.
- 21:10It was truly incredible. And I think I'm after, you know,
- 21:14like 4 years of drinking whiskey.
- 21:16Seriously, I think I'm going to start being more specific about
- 21:19drinking whiskey with foods as opposed to on an empty stomach.
- 21:25As opposed to on an empty stomach at 8:00 AM recording
- 21:28with my best friend. That's right.
- 21:29You know, I know you how much you like Lagavulin because, like
- 21:32you, unprompted sent me a text about it.
- 21:35It is so hard to pin you down via text.
- 21:37I'll be like, texting you about important things of scheduling.
- 21:40No response. And then out of nowhere, I just
- 21:42get Lagavulin 16 is so rich and creamy when you drink it with a
- 21:46nice medium steak. And it was.
- 21:48It was like a response to you saying like.
- 21:50Brad, I'm in the hospital, My wife is in a different hospital.
- 21:54My children, I don't even know where they are.
- 21:56And I'm like, dude, lagable in 16.
- 21:58Incredible. All right, let's get back into
- 22:01talking about this Hanks giving movie and it's time to talk
- 22:04about the man himself. I think this is a really good
- 22:06performance. I also think this is, I would
- 22:09like pinpoint this as the performance where Hanks, oh I'm
- 22:13going to tread lightly here, where Hanks stops trying to be
- 22:20the best possible actor and starts trying to use the Tom
- 22:26Hanks aura in every movie he makes.
- 22:30And I feel like every movie since this has been like it's
- 22:33not Tom Hanks as Mr. Rogers, it's Tom Hanks as Tom Hanks as
- 22:39Mr. Rogers. Like he can't shed the Tom Hanks
- 22:42Ness of it all. And like, is this a great
- 22:44imitation of Walt Disney? Nope.
- 22:47And he knows that. And that's the thing when you
- 22:49get that scene when he's sitting down with Travers at the end of
- 22:52the movie and talking about when I was 8 years old, my old man
- 22:55beat me with a belt and it's like, oh, this is horrible.
- 22:58It's also like, very clearly his Oscar moment, like this is going
- 23:02to be his Oscar highlight. And it works.
- 23:05It's not a good impersonation. It's a good performance.
- 23:09And Tom Hanks knows I can just be Tom Hanks.
- 23:12And that is enough to at least get me in the Oscar conversation
- 23:15every year. Yeah, it it is.
- 23:17And he's put in the work to become that beloved.
- 23:20So I'll give him credit where it's due.
- 23:23I think the interesting thing for me is I don't think I've
- 23:27really ever seen many videos of Walt Disney.
- 23:30So I I don't have like a great reference point on whether or
- 23:34not this is a good impersonation.
- 23:38You know, like when you look at at biopics, you know, a lot of
- 23:42people would point to like Jamie Foxx as, Ray Charles as like.
- 23:46One of the best imitations of a person and I I just can't
- 23:52honestly say if I know if this is a good one or not.
- 23:54I've seen enough pictures of Walt Disney to know that they, I
- 23:58think they did a really stellar job with his makeup.
- 24:01Agreed to to bring his eyes in a little bit smaller to make his
- 24:04nose look more like waltz. His his mouth felt smaller than
- 24:08it normally is. I noticed it in the scene where
- 24:10they're walking through Disneyland because it's not even
- 24:13the focus of the shot, but like on the side of his head.
- 24:15They had added like some age spots to look like the way
- 24:17Walt's skin looked. It was real, like really subtle
- 24:20stuff in the makeup. I'm with you, man.
- 24:22They did a great job making him up.
- 24:24So that that was the one thing for me where I was like, oh, he,
- 24:27I think he looks like Walt Disney.
- 24:29But I am with you in that a lot of the little mannerisms and and
- 24:35the nuances of his voice and the tone that he uses, I was like,
- 24:38Oh yeah, it's, it's Tom Hanks doing his like warm and fuzzy.
- 24:43You know, I I'm the king of the world.
- 24:45Like I I want to want to bring people into this nice place
- 24:49called Disneyland. And it was good.
- 24:52It was charming. It was.
- 24:53It was warm and fuzzy. I mean, I think that he also
- 24:56clearly, like he knows his limitations enough to as an
- 24:59actor that like he's never going to be Meryl Streep in Sophie's
- 25:03Choice. Like, he's never going to be the
- 25:05most believably like Polish person.
- 25:08Do you know what I mean? Where is, like, you can watch
- 25:10Meryl Streep in that movie and be like, I'm not watching an
- 25:13actress, I'm watching a real person.
- 25:14She's so good. Yeah, but he's like.
- 25:17Compare it for me then to the terminal.
- 25:21OK, well, he's not playing a specific person, but yeah, well,
- 25:24and I I was going to compare it to the Mr. Rogers performance
- 25:26because I think they're like the same.
- 25:27I think he took the same mindset of like it's it's meant to evoke
- 25:32Mr. Rogers, it's meant to evoke Walt Disney.
- 25:34It's not meant to be an impersonation, and I appreciate
- 25:38that so much more than if he had tried to like get every
- 25:40mannerism down and be like Daniel Day Lewis, like doing
- 25:43Lincoln, you know what I mean? Like there's a slightly
- 25:46Midwestern sounding wilt to his voice and so there's like some
- 25:51cadence things and some inflection things.
- 25:53But overall, it's just Tom Hanks with a little bit of an an
- 25:58accent. And I'm cool with that.
- 26:00And I think that that's like, that's where he's at as an actor
- 26:03now. He's like, I'm not going to
- 26:04disappear into a role. I'm going to be Tom Hanks with a
- 26:08tinge of this guy. And I honestly think that's
- 26:10probably the best choice. Well, and opposite of him you
- 26:13have Emma Thompson, and we haven't talked about her at all.
- 26:17I think that she does an incredible job with the script
- 26:20that she's been given. Oh, she's excellent in this
- 26:22movie, man. Like, she and and what I noticed
- 26:25about her too is like the moments where her performance
- 26:28really shines is in between all the lines of the script.
- 26:32Like that scene where she's just listening to Tom Hanks talk
- 26:35about his childhood. And, you know, he finally kind
- 26:38of turns the tables and says, I know that you took your dad's
- 26:41name. You know, I know that this isn't
- 26:44that Mary Poppins didn't come to Save the Children.
- 26:46She came to save the father and it's your father and like
- 26:49watching her start to tear up and and feel upset at being
- 26:53found out but feeling ashamed and feel like all these emotions
- 26:57crawling across her face. She is just so, so good in this
- 27:01movie. In those areas where the script
- 27:04is kind of bare bones, she fills in the blanks really well.
- 27:07Where where the script gets out of the way.
- 27:09Yeah, for sure. Yeah, and I I think that that's
- 27:12what I appreciated most about the acting in this movie was the
- 27:16fact. That I think that Hanks and
- 27:19Thompson have great chemistry and I think that they elevate
- 27:24this movie beyond what anyone else could have done.
- 27:28And it's because as much as you know, you talked to the start
- 27:33about how in real life Disney absolutely just despised
- 27:38Travers, you get just enough of that conflict that by the end of
- 27:44the film you are still not convinced that.
- 27:47Disney likes Travers at all. I like you.
- 27:51You definitely get the vibe that he is not on team team Pamela by
- 27:56the end of it, and that he has been putting on this persona as
- 28:00a businessman throughout. And I think that that is a a
- 28:03little teeny, tiny bit of honest self reflection from Disney on
- 28:07their founder. I would have really liked to see
- 28:09the version of this movie that is more of like the Social
- 28:11Network version where, yeah, Disney just ends up being the
- 28:15villain and not like a straight villain but like a more
- 28:18complicated figure, You know, in real life.
- 28:20She was so stubborn about it that like, even at the premiere
- 28:23of the movie, she walked up to him afterwards and said, like,
- 28:26you have to cut the Penguin scene, you have to cut this.
- 28:29And he just looked at her and said Missus Travers, the ship
- 28:31has sailed and walked away. And I'm like, that would be
- 28:35really cool because that would make the emotional punch of like
- 28:37she has turned over her baby to this man and he just did what he
- 28:41wanted with it. Like, I want to see that movie.
- 28:45Yeah. Now the movie we got is really
- 28:46good and warm and fuzzy and hopeful.
- 28:49But like, I kind of want to watch the more realistic
- 28:52version. I I just want to see your
- 28:55version where there's a after credits scene of Walt Disney
- 29:00sitting in in front of like a giant like desk and he's just
- 29:04like lining up all of his royalty checks.
- 29:07Like you're, you know, whatever the the theaters pay him to the
- 29:11movie in it, just lining up check after check after check on
- 29:14this giant desk and he's just laughing as the flames rise
- 29:20around him. Yes.
- 29:23So Tom Hanks not nominated for this movie.
- 29:26And this was a big shock at the time because he made two movies
- 29:29this year, saving Mr. Banks and Captain Phillips, which is also
- 29:32a great movie. And word around town in
- 29:35Hollywood was that he was campaigning hard to get
- 29:38nominations in both lead performance and supporting
- 29:41performance categories. And now this has happened on a
- 29:44number of occasions. Kate Winslet did it back in
- 29:482008. I think at least at the Golden
- 29:51Globes, she won both awards and they were like, Oh my gosh,
- 29:53she's going to do it. The Academy Awards does not like
- 29:55doing that. I think the last time, the most
- 29:58recent time that happened I think was Scar Jo.
- 30:01She she was nominated for Marriage Story and JoJo Rabbit
- 30:03in the same year in different categories.
- 30:06And then Tom Hanks doesn't get nominated for either category,
- 30:09which is freaking crazy because they think these are two of his
- 30:12best performances of this century for sure.
- 30:14Like it's Have you seen Captain Phillips?
- 30:17I have not. Oh dude.
- 30:19Oh man, you gotta watch that. Thanksgiving Year 5 Thanksgiving
- 30:23What's what? What's Thanksgiving without a
- 30:25little hostage situation? That's what I'm talking about.
- 30:29So when you hear the news that Tom Hanks not nominated, does it
- 30:34surprise you or is it kind of like, yeah, I can see why he
- 30:36wasn't nominated? Like where do you land on this?
- 30:39I think he just didn't have quite big enough of a role in
- 30:43this film to land as even as supporting actor cause and maybe
- 30:49this comes back to what you said earlier.
- 30:51There are so many great supporting actors in this movie.
- 30:54I think Colin Farrell could have been nominated for a Best
- 30:57Supporting Actor in this film. So there there were enough other
- 31:02performances that were really solid that I don't know if Hanks
- 31:05really deserved A nomination here.
- 31:08Let's see Supporting Actor 2014 awards.
- 31:11We had Jared Leto winning for Dallas Buyers Club.
- 31:16Obviously Barkhad Abdi from Captain Phillips.
- 31:19So the the guy that plays like the lead hijacker in that movie,
- 31:22Bradley Cooper in American Hustle, Michael Fassbender in 12
- 31:26Years a Slave, and Jonah Hill and Wolf of Wall Street.
- 31:30Now like, I think Hanks probably could have been in one of those
- 31:34five positions, but like, I actually don't hate this
- 31:37category. This is a pretty good lineup of
- 31:39supporting roles. I was going to say Bradley
- 31:41Cooper in American Hustle is really solid.
- 31:43What? What was the final one you said
- 31:45Jonah Hill in Wolf of Wall Street?
- 31:47Yeah, Jonah Hill was incredible. Yeah.
- 31:49So yeah, I mean, this is a tough line up to crack for him this
- 31:52year. Wolf of Wall Street Thanksgiving
- 31:55number six you want to do? Obviously.
- 31:58Obviously, I don't think Tom Hanks would ever come near a
- 32:02movie like that. Oh, my gosh, man.
- 32:04All right, let's wrap, Let's wrap things up.
- 32:06I want to get to my Thanksgiving meal at some point.
- 32:08Brad, I hope people are listening to this as they, you
- 32:10know, trim their Turkey and everything else.
- 32:12So, all right, so let's let's score this movie out as a movie,
- 32:17Let's score it out as a Tom Hanks movie and let's score it
- 32:20out as a Thanksgiving movie. And let's start with the
- 32:22Thanksgiving aspect. Is this a good movie for
- 32:25Thanksgiving, Brad. Yes.
- 32:29Spicy take. So here's the thing about this
- 32:31film, and I'll kind of get here with, like, my final score.
- 32:36I think that what sells me on this movie is literally nothing
- 32:39that we talked about so far. All the things we've talked
- 32:42about, you know, are solid parts of the film.
- 32:44But the messaging of the movie is what really, like captured my
- 32:48attention. And it's this idea that as we
- 32:52engage in imagination, as we engage in storytelling, it can
- 32:58heal the UN viewed traumas of our past.
- 33:04That as we've shoved away the bad stuff that's happened to us
- 33:08into the dark corners of our mind, when we revisit those
- 33:12experiences through storytelling and through imagination, there's
- 33:17a genuine healing effect on our soul, on our body, on our mind.
- 33:21And that just completely, I I thought that they knocked it out
- 33:26of the park on that forefront of this story that this idea that
- 33:30as she. RE crafts the story of Mary
- 33:33Poppins. It is re crafting her
- 33:36understanding of herself in light of the trauma she's been
- 33:39through. And I I got to, I got to say
- 33:41Bob, I'm thankful for that. I think we need more movies like
- 33:44this. I think the core of this movie
- 33:47is a good Thanksgiving like message.
- 33:50But I also think that if you put this on for your family, like
- 33:53after everyone has eaten stuffing and like, you're going
- 33:56to bump some people out. It's a terrible movie to watch
- 33:58on. That's, that's what I mean here.
- 34:01Like, I don't know that my family would forgive me for
- 34:05being, you know, for making them watch this young girl's mom,
- 34:08Trey, commit suicide in a river and like, you know, not the warm
- 34:12fuzzies that you're looking for. Not quite as a Hanks movie.
- 34:17How does this fall for you? I think this is a mid level
- 34:22Hanks movie. I'd put it in like upper middle
- 34:25class if if I was doing it economically.
- 34:28What's your like criteria like as a movie that has Tom Hanks or
- 34:32like as a Hanks movie? I would say as a Hanks movie
- 34:37with with a Hanks performance, you know, kind of rating high
- 34:41there, I'm with you there. Like it's if there's like 4
- 34:44tiers of Hanks movies, this is like a solid Tier 2 Hanks movie.
- 34:48Yes, you're not putting it on with like Castaway and Saving
- 34:50Kravit, Ryan, but it's it's a good Hanks movie.
- 34:53Yeah, I mean, I I would put it similar to like the the five
- 34:56Hitchcock films that we watched this year.
- 34:59You know, they're all B tier Hitchcock films.
- 35:02And then you go and watch, you know, Vertigo and you're like,
- 35:05oh, oh, this is Hitchcock we're talking about.
- 35:09All right. As we get to final scores, I'm
- 35:12going to compare this movie to one of our least favorite movies
- 35:14ever. Brad.
- 35:15Oh, that movie is Bohemian Rhapsody, Because this is how
- 35:20you do Bohemian Rhapsody the right way.
- 35:23Like nothing about this movie that I know is is like
- 35:28realistic. None of this happened in
- 35:29reality. But if you're going to
- 35:31editorialize, make it good. And this movie really with worse
- 35:36actors, I feel like could have been an absolute disaster 'cause
- 35:38it. It teeters on the edge of being
- 35:40overly cheesy the whole film and it teeters on the edge of
- 35:44feeling like when a late night comedy show makes a spoof of,
- 35:48like an Oscar bait movie. You know every year they're like
- 35:51they they they do a spoof of like they were, they were
- 35:55forbidden lovers and but you like it's it seems like one of
- 35:57those movies and yet it's so sincere and so to use your word,
- 36:04Brad Earnest. And it's it's acted in such good
- 36:07faith, like no one's winking at the camera.
- 36:09Everyone's taking the material seriously.
- 36:11It elevates this movie way higher than it needs to be.
- 36:15Like I said, this is a 6.5 like across the board that is
- 36:19elevated. Like when I watch it, I'm like
- 36:21oh this must be like an 8 out of 10 movie, you know what I mean?
- 36:24And I think I am going to fall out somewhere in like the 7.5
- 36:26range on this movie, but it's like it's in the upper tier of
- 36:307.5 movies and like on IMDb it's got a 7.5.
- 36:36Everyone on Earth agrees that this movie is a three star
- 36:39movie, and I think that makes it a really good movie.
- 36:43Yeah, I I think it's one that anybody should come back to and
- 36:47revisit. If you haven't seen it, it is
- 36:49well worth your watch. I think I would land at like an
- 36:538 1/2 out of 10 here Bob. Wow, dude, I.
- 36:55I think it's a 7 1/2 to an 8 movie, but the messaging speaks
- 36:59so directly to me that I just. I really enjoyed this film.
- 37:05Yeah. I have always considered you a
- 37:07curmudgeonly old British person, so like it it does.
- 37:11The messaging is directly spoken to you.
- 37:13Yeah, it fits, man. I'm just angry that anybody
- 37:16would think would Dane to speak to me.
- 37:20Well, Bradley, as we wrap up this Thanksgiving, first of all,
- 37:23I'm thankful for you, man. Happy Thanksgiving to you.
- 37:25Dude, thanks. I appreciate that.
- 37:28You're thankful for me. Yeah, that's what I thought.
- 37:30I knew it set myself up for that one didn't.
- 37:33I You sure did. We are also thankful for you
- 37:35film and Whiskey Nation. We can't thank you guys enough
- 37:38for riding with us on season 7 starting next week.
- 37:41Just a reminder, our feed is going to be taken over by our
- 37:44friend Zach Johnston as he does a whiskey tour of America.
- 37:48I cannot wait to check out those episodes, Brad.
- 37:51So we're actually signing off for a few weeks here.
- 37:54I I will not talk to you again purposely until mid-december.
- 37:59Thank the good Lord. All right.
- 38:02So space. So join us for Zach Johnson next
- 38:05week. But until then, I'm Bob Book.
- 38:07I'm Brad G and we'll see you next time.