Latest / TheThinkingAtheist / When Religion Hurts You: with Dr. Laura E. Anderson
Transcript
- 0:01Understand the thinking atheist. It's not a person, it's a symbol, an
- 0:09idea. The population of atheists in this country is going through the rule,
- 0:14rejecting faith, pursuing knowledge, challenging the sacred. If I tell the truth,
- 0:20it's because I tell the truth, not because I put my hand on
- 0:24a book and made a wish and working together for a more rational world.
- 0:29Take the risk of thinking. Feel so much more happiness. Truth, Fusian
- 0:33wisdom will come to you that way. Assume nothing, question everything, and
- 0:40start thinking. This is the Thinking Atheist podcast hosted by Seth Andrews doctor Laura
- 0:57E. Anderson. She is a psychotherapist and a trauma resolution coach. She
- 1:03helps to bring people out or at least help them navigate some very difficult journeys.
- 1:10I stumbled across her work online, some articles that she had written.
- 1:15She also is author of a book called When Religion Hurts You. This fascinated
- 1:21me. I reached out. Doctor Laura Anderson has been kind enough to join
- 1:26me here. Welcome, Hello, Thank you so much for having me.
- 1:30It's wonderful. What do be here with the name doctor Laura. I almost
- 1:34feel bad for you, I know, I know. On the other doctor
- 1:38Laura, the good one. Yeah, yeah, Okay, Well, let's
- 1:42start with something that you say on the services page of your website, and
- 1:46I'm just going to read it. It says, I believe that trauma is
- 1:49stored in the body, not the mind, and therefore requires a nervous system
- 1:55and body centered approach that is tailored to the unique needs of the individual.
- 2:01I don't want to get too pedantic, too far out in the weeds,
- 2:04but is this like body mind dualism, because I'm one of those guys who
- 2:07says the brain is the mind. So are you talking about the mind as
- 2:12a spirit or a soul? Help me understand that. Yeah. So,
- 2:16when we talk about trauma, trauma is anything that is too much, too
- 2:21fast, too soon, that overwhelms our ability to cope and come back to
- 2:23a place of safety. So essentially, that means that trauma is not necessarily
- 2:29the thing that happens to us, but the way that our physiology in our
- 2:32body responds to the thing that happens to us. It means that we can't
- 2:37simply think trauma away, Oh that thing is in the past. The way
- 2:40our that it is stored in our nervous system, our physiology means that we
- 2:46have to resolve it in our physiology. We can't. Our brain doesn't just
- 2:50like time and date, stamp it and say, Okay, that's in the
- 2:53past. Now we're here, so we're good. If that was the case,
- 2:57we wouldn't have things like a diagnosis of PTSD. That's not the way
- 3:01our body stores it, and so we have to take a more full bodied
- 3:07approach. I like the mind body approach. I don't believe either should be
- 3:12elevated over the other. I think that we have to take both into context.
- 3:16I'm a big fan of a body up and mind down approach. We
- 3:21have to hold both with each other. So maybe a holistic approach would be
- 3:24a better way to say it. But in the past, there has been
- 3:30a lot of therapeutic modalities, clinical people in the clinical fields and research that
- 3:36would say, yeah, you just kind of think your way through things.
- 3:39And what research would suggest now is that that isn't necessarily a complete way to
- 3:47navigate trauma. We still see that there are embodied responses. Even if your
- 3:53brain knows that thing is in the past and I'm in the present, we
- 3:59still have embodied or physiological responses to things that happen in the past, so
- 4:03we have to take a more embodied approach, or a physiological approach to trauma
- 4:08resolution. So I'm thinking about something that happened to me, and my heart
- 4:14starts to race, and my palms start to sweat, and I feel a
- 4:16sense of panic and anxiety. It's the effect of the mind on the rest
- 4:20of the body. Is that close close? Yeah, And it's something that
- 4:25you might not have conscious control over. So you go, hey, my
- 4:28heart is racing, my face is flushing. You might tell yourself calm down,
- 4:32or you might shame yourself and say, what the hell is wrong with
- 4:35me? And no matter how much you tell yourself like I'm fine, get
- 4:40over it, your heart is still racing, your face is still flushing.
- 4:45Things are happening beneath your conscious control. Your body is doing that, and
- 4:49so that's where we go, Okay, there's something else that's happening. Your
- 4:54nervous system is operating beneath your conscious control, which means that it is alarmed.
- 5:00It is operating on a system that you're not necessarily having conscious control.
- 5:04And that's what we're trying to target in the body based trauma resolution modalities,
- 5:10is that the same as fight or flight. Yes, it is, Yes,
- 5:14absolutely, and that's part of it. I mean, when we look
- 5:16at fight or flight, we're looking at the sympathetic nervous system, which of
- 5:19course fight or flight is a part of. And there's many other things that
- 5:24are incorporated in the sympathetic nervous system. That's just part of it. Okay,
- 5:30So let's talk a little bit about cult tactics. You've done a lot
- 5:35of reading and writing and teaching and counseling about it, and this I think
- 5:41can be a home environment, certainly a church environment, or some other group.
- 5:45Cults come in many forms, and I want to start with the tactic
- 5:48that we have talked about but not in depth, love bombing. It sounds
- 5:56so wonderful. Who wouldn't want to be like showered literally bombed with love?
- 6:00Can you describe what this is and how it is used? Please? Yeah?
- 6:05So I want to for people that have probably heard the term love bombing
- 6:10before, they've heard it in the context of a relationship with another human being.
- 6:14We often hear it when we're talking about domestically violent relationship, intimate partner
- 6:18violence, or even narcissistic relationships. It's this period of time in a relationship
- 6:25that is categorized by this kind of over the top behavior where somebody's coming in
- 6:30and really endearing themselves to you. Maybe they really are giving you like lots
- 6:35of gifts, lots of comments, where they're showing up and they're being kind
- 6:40of the person that you've always dreamed for them to be, or in the
- 6:44context of a group or a cult, this vision of what you have always
- 6:47hoped life could be like, and it's often painted in this way that feels
- 6:53very enticing, very appealing, very alluring. They're kind of speaking to your
- 6:58heart's desire. They're often promising that you'll have the things that usually are very
- 7:02core or central to your humanity, connection, higher purpose, and value.
- 7:09In a one on one relationship, when we're looking at maybe a relationship with
- 7:12a narcissist, the person on the other end is going, oh my gosh,
- 7:15this is the person that I've been waiting for my whole entire life.
- 7:19This is the night in shining armor. This is why I've kissed all the
- 7:23frogs like this is my prince. When we're talking about a group, whether
- 7:27it's a cult or a high control religion, we're going I've been looking for
- 7:30my life's purpose I've been looking for something where I can find meaning or identity
- 7:35or value. They're speaking to a core part of me, and there is
- 7:40this promise of connection. There's this promise of maybe even needs getting met.
- 7:45Housing, there can be food, there can be childcare, and especially people
- 7:48that may not have some of those things on the outside world that can be
- 7:53very alluring, and so they kind of get caught in this idea of like,
- 7:58wow, if I join this group, I'm going to have access to
- 8:01these things that are not only meeting these identity things within myself, but also
- 8:07some very practical things, and wow, like why wouldn't I want to do
- 8:11this? Like this meets exactly what my purpose here on earth is. And
- 8:16so we joined that thinking I've kind of hit the jackpot, like this is
- 8:20what I've always been looking for and it feels really really good until it doesn't.
- 8:28But we have that as a period of time, kind of as like
- 8:31something as an anchor to always look back on and go, remember this period
- 8:35of time that we had, and even if times get bad, we always
- 8:39have this to look back and hold this and say, well, if I
- 8:41can just get back to this, then everything will be fine. And we
- 8:46do this in one on one relationships. We do this in cults, we
- 8:48do this in high control religions. We always have this to look back on
- 8:52and say, remember when, So, if I can just get my shit
- 8:56together, if I can just go to therapy, if I can just comply
- 8:58more, I can submit more, if I can follow the rules more,
- 9:01then maybe we'll go back to this because this was such a good time.
- 9:05It's a very very important time in a relationship or in a system. It's
- 9:11why we put up with other behaviors and even consequences, because it was never
- 9:16all bad. If we didn't have this period of time in a relationship,
- 9:20whether that's with a person or a system, we probably wouldn't stay. This
- 9:26is part of the reason that we stay in high control religions, relationships,
- 9:30systems, culleds, things like that. I was having a conversation with a
- 9:33friend, a business owner, the other day and we were talking about employees.
- 9:35I don't know if this is applicable, I'll let you speak to it,
- 9:39but we were talking about when you hire someone, they always have their
- 9:41best face forward, the resume is perfect, and they're going to give you
- 9:46the good stuff, and then once you work with them, you find out
- 9:50what they are really like, And sometimes I think we resist making a change
- 9:56or removing someone from the workplace who may not be pulling their wage or maybe
- 10:01causing problems because we fell in love with a resume. And then the question
- 10:07is, well, if I knew then what I know now about that person,
- 10:11would I hire them today? And I tend to think maybe that fits
- 10:16with relationships. If I knew then what I knew now, maybe I wouldn't
- 10:22make the same choice. Is that valid, Laura? I think so.
- 10:26One of the things I talk about I work with a lot of people coming
- 10:28out of high control religions, and it's funny because there's a lot of things
- 10:35that they take for granted of just like quote unquote the normal things they do
- 10:39in that system. But I always say, you know, like if they
- 10:41led with this idea of like, hey, you come to our church and
- 10:46oh, by the way, you're you're going to need to give us ten
- 10:48percent of your income. Here's what you can wear, here's what you can't
- 10:52wear, here's the people that you can be in relationship with, here's the
- 10:56information that you are allowed to have, and here's all this information that you're
- 10:58not going to be allowed to have. Here's the people that you must cut
- 11:03out of your life. Here's the only people you can listen to. Here's
- 11:07the jobs you can have, here's the music you can listen to, the
- 11:11books that you can read, the movies you can watch, and everything that
- 11:13you can Right. If they lead with that, nobody's going to that church,
- 11:18Right, nobody's going to be a part of that group. The same
- 11:22thing would be, you know, if you were in a relationship with somebody
- 11:26where on the first date they flip over the table, they cuss out the
- 11:31server, they throw you into a wall, they demand that you do all
- 11:37these things. You're not going on a second date. If they lead with
- 11:39those things, You're like, there's not going to be an established relationship.
- 11:45You're not going to go on a second date or third date, or have
- 11:48a two year long, ten year long, twenty year long relationship. If
- 11:52we are leading with the truth of that, it's very unlikely that there's going
- 11:58to be established relationship that's with one person or with a system or organization,
- 12:03whether that's a religion, a cult, anything like that. And so I
- 12:07think that's part of where people can feel a little bit crazy is because they
- 12:11go, yeah, but when I started It wasn't like that they promise these
- 12:16relationships, these connections, this community, My needs were going to be met.
- 12:20We were going to be, you know, kind of working towards this
- 12:24higher good, this purpose, this you know, my identity, and that's
- 12:28the bill of goods that they were sold. They weren't. They didn't tell
- 12:31me I was going to have to give all my time, energy and resources,
- 12:35that I wasn't going to be able to speak to my family outside of
- 12:37the church. But it's slowly, over time, those things are chipped away
- 12:41at, and they do it in such a way where they a either make
- 12:45you feel like it's your idea, or b they do it in such a
- 12:50way where they don't make it feel like it's that big of a deal,
- 12:52where it's just it's slowly like, oh, you know, your shirt's just
- 12:56a little bit too low. You don't want your brothers in Christ to stumble
- 13:00like, oh yeah, no, no, I don't want that, right,
- 13:03and so if you pull it up just a little bit. They're not
- 13:07doing it in an overt way. Necessarily, they're doing it in a very
- 13:11subtle way. But you're getting the message and you slowly start to change yourself,
- 13:16and so I think that's really important because then you slowly, over time,
- 13:20become a shell of yourself and they gain more control. It's never usually
- 13:24this big kind of like you know, like the hammer comes down in one
- 13:30day you're this very, very different person. The same is true in abusive
- 13:33relationships. And I think in your analogy, like with the employee, over
- 13:39time, it's not that one day they're one way and the next day they're
- 13:41this totally different person. It's it's over time, and then you look back
- 13:46and you're like, wow, I don't know that I would have hired that
- 13:48person, or I don't know that I would have started dating that person or
- 13:52going to that church or joining that cult had I known that this is what
- 13:56it would have turned out to be. Oh, there were people watching and
- 14:00listening right now who were nodding and going, oh my god, I know
- 14:03exactly. It's kind of the frog in boiling water. Yes, So I
- 14:09mean, is love bombing not to be labored, but is love bombing grooming
- 14:15in a way? Yes? I think I think you could absolutely use those
- 14:18interchangeably. Yes. Good. You posted on Instagram a message for trauma survivors.
- 14:26You said you are not what happened to you so the trauma becomes what
- 14:33an identity for some people. I think oftentimes, I think a lot of
- 14:39times trauma survivors hold a lot of shame the things that happen to them.
- 14:43They hold as their identity. They say, I must have caused this thing.
- 14:48And oftentimes, especially when we're talking about religious trauma or trauma from colts,
- 14:54we are made to believe that we caused and or deserved the things that
- 14:58happen to us. And so, yeah, we do take it on as
- 15:03an identity. And so I think it's very important for people to know that
- 15:07that's not you. Like, not only did you not deserve that, you
- 15:11did not cause that. That's not you. You don't have to wear that.
- 15:15And I think it's very easy to think that because that thing happened to
- 15:18me, that's just who I am now for the rest of my life.
- 15:22On the flip side of it, I think after we come out of those
- 15:24systems, it's also very easy to just make that our whole identity. I'm
- 15:30an ex Vangelical, I'm an ex Mormon, I'm an ex JW, I'm
- 15:35an ex this, or I'm fill in the blank, and make that your
- 15:39entire identity as well. And that can be really helpful for an amount of
- 15:43time. It helps us to organize what it is that happened to us.
- 15:48But it also doesn't have to be the totality of who we are either.
- 15:52Isn't the concern the difference between reflecting and ruminating as well? I mean to
- 15:58be able to say I came out of this, I acknowledge this, I'm
- 16:02going to own it and help others to overcome as well. And then all
- 16:06of a sudden it drifts into a kind of crutch where you walk into the
- 16:08room and you lead with I know I'm an alcoholic addict. I mean,
- 16:12at some point, does it become an albatross around your neck? And I
- 16:17know that's a very tough line to draw, right, It certainly can't.
- 16:21Yeah, where it becomes everything about you and it always leads back to that
- 16:26thing where you can't speak about anything else unless it goes back to that one
- 16:30hundred percent. Yeah. Coming up next with my guest, if you have
- 16:36an abusive father, are you then destined cursed to choose an abusive life partner.
- 16:45I'm going to ask doctor Laura E. Anderson that question and more.
- 16:48Next, your patronage is so critical these days, and I'm so thankful for
- 17:00your support. Long story short is that the podcasting world is just weird.
- 17:07They've been changing a lot of how revenue is done with Apple, podcast etc.
- 17:12And podcasts pretty much across the board have been taking a hit, and
- 17:17mine is not excluded from that. So we've been taking up the slack with
- 17:22patronage, and if you want to be a part of that, I would
- 17:26so welcome your support. Patreon dot com slash Seth Andrews speaking here with doctor
- 17:36Laura E. Anderson. Do you like the E? Is there another Laura
- 17:41Anderson out there? I want to make sure that I'm not sending people to,
- 17:42like, you know, some wooy site. You know, somebody's selling
- 17:45chakra oil or something like that. You know. So whenever I went to
- 17:51buy the website domain, there is a doctor Laura Anderson, which is why
- 17:53I had to put my middle initial in there. So doctor Laura E.
- 17:56Anderson. That's why it is the way it is. But yeah, leave
- 18:00the E in there. I'm gonna do. I'm going to call you Laura
- 18:02since we just met and now we're apparently really good Friends's let's uh, there's
- 18:08a I guess it's a conception misconception that people who end up in high control,
- 18:17even abusive situations, are sometimes primed by family and culture. It's the
- 18:22whole My father was abusive to me, Now I'm going to end up in
- 18:27the arms of an abusive husband. Is there any truth to that? Yes,
- 18:33there is truth to that. It's not unequivocal, though. I think
- 18:37when we're talking about religion, one thing that's really important to recognize is that
- 18:42there's many people who are in high control religion that simply were born into it,
- 18:48that never had a choice. I can speak from my own experience.
- 18:52I was born into it. There was never a day where I grew up
- 18:56like not knowing all of this, Like this was my norm. I mean,
- 19:00I think the story went like I was three days old and I was
- 19:03at church, you know, and sitting there with my parents. Of course,
- 19:07I obviously don't have cognitive memories of that, but like that was that
- 19:10was part of my growing up, and so there was never a point where
- 19:12like I didn't have that indoctrinated into me, and that absolutely shaped then the
- 19:18way that I grew up in my identity and how I learned to not only
- 19:23formulate my identity, but how I learned to relate to others, and that
- 19:26absolutely played into my adult relationships, which did include abusive relationships later on in
- 19:33life, like a domestically violent relationship. Is it unequivocal that if you are
- 19:38in an abusive relationship or witness to an abusive relationship in your childhood years,
- 19:44that you will end up in that in your adult years. No, is
- 19:48a likelihood greater. Yes. And the reason why is not because you're out
- 19:52there looking for it, but it is the way that our brains are wired,
- 19:57because it's what we consider normal we are. We go, I see
- 20:03that as normal, I see my brain takes that information in. We know
- 20:07how to deal with that. That is something that becomes what we would call
- 20:11like familiar, and my brain is set up to deal with that, and
- 20:17so I can tolerate that. I have capacity within me to tolerate that,
- 20:22and I gravitate towards that. Our brains register what is familiar as safe,
- 20:27even if it's not necessarily what we might consider healthy, and our brains register
- 20:34what is unfamiliar as unsafe, even if it's healthy. So we might go,
- 20:41wow, say, here's like a healthy relationship, But if that's unfamiliar
- 20:45to me if my brain has never witnessed or experienced that, that would be
- 20:49considered unfamiliar, and my brain actually might resist that, which might look like
- 20:53sabotage. I might actually try to end that relationship or do things that might
- 20:59end that relationship. Does that answer that question? Like the devil? You
- 21:03know? Is often how I've little had that phrased, yeah a little.
- 21:07I'm going to hurt them before they hurt me, or I will leave them
- 21:11before they can hurt me, even if they haven't hurt me. I don't
- 21:15know. I don't want to drift too far into cliche, but I know
- 21:17many people see these things flying. Yeah, I mean, yeah, it's
- 21:21a little bit. Yes, it's like a colloquial explanation for why people sometimes
- 21:26do that. Yes, this is what armchair psychologists like myself who have no
- 21:30training do. I sit around and try to sound deep and profound, and
- 21:33then I let you correct me on these things. Okay, the technical terms.
- 21:38So when you were talking about the cultures where they tell you who you
- 21:42can hang with and what to where, and who you can love, I'm
- 21:47thinking about pretty much the first third of your book When Religion Hurts You,
- 21:52and you were telling the story of a youth leader named Trey. And of
- 21:56course the more I read, I'm over here going that's wonderful. Bit like
- 22:00I'm literally getting irritated. Okay, can you just real fast tell me about
- 22:04the tray experience this guy and the and the experiences that you had as a
- 22:10woman in a high control church. Yeah, well, what would you like
- 22:15to know more of? Because there's a specifically I am interested in how you,
- 22:19as a woman were placed under the authority of a male. They're banging
- 22:22the Bible the whole time. To excuse it, I find it convenient because
- 22:26I wonder if men wrote the Bible. But you know, you were at
- 22:30a point when it was dictated to you who you could fall in love with.
- 22:36Right, You found someone and you're like, I'm attracted to them,
- 22:38and I want to I want to make this choice, and yet you felt
- 22:41like that choice was being taken from you. And I think that's where I'm
- 22:45going. Yeah, yeah, So it's sometimes I still to this day will
- 22:52pick up little nuggets and put them together. I'm like, oh, I
- 22:55see something a little bit more clear. But yeah, So for people who
- 23:00haven't read the book, I tell the story in there of a person that
- 23:03I became interested in so in that in the culture that I grew up in,
- 23:08it's called we call it now purity culture, which back then we didn't
- 23:12So we're talking about early two thousands, and it was this culture where you
- 23:18essentially don't date, you court, and which means you're kind of supposed to
- 23:22know if you're going to marry the person before you even go on a date
- 23:26with them. But you're also supposed to involve like the church leaders and parents
- 23:30and elders, and they're supposed to guide you in pray and like basically tell
- 23:34you like, yeah, we think you're supposed to marry this person as well.
- 23:38And I had met somebody I was young. I think at the time
- 23:41I was twenty one, and I had met somebody and he was also a
- 23:45leader in the youth group. I was on paid staff at the time.
- 23:48He was a leader in the youth group. He was almost eighteen. And
- 23:52I need to just preface that had the roles been reversed, if I had
- 23:56been almost eighteen and he was twenty one, this would not have been a
- 24:00problem. He could have been thirty and that still would not have been a
- 24:06problem. It was I think only because I was a little bit older that
- 24:10this even caused anybody some pause, but he was almost eighteen, and I
- 24:15did this the right way. I this person expressed interest in me. I
- 24:18went to the leadership and said, hey, this person is interested in me.
- 24:22I'm interested in him. We realized that we shouldn't be dating right now,
- 24:26so we're not going to and we just wanted to make sure that everything
- 24:32is good, and we're letting you know that we're going to wait until this
- 24:36person has graduated from high school in like two months or something like this,
- 24:40and then we'll kind of like wait for the guidance to happen. And I
- 24:44was just torn to shreds for this. Trey, who was my boss at
- 24:48the time, was absolutely livid and was like, well, you can't date
- 24:52him, and I was like, literally, that's fine. I said,
- 24:53I was not going to date him. I said that, you know,
- 24:57we would wait until this person was, you know, graduated, and until
- 25:03like we were given the go ahead to do this. I just wanted to
- 25:06be above approach. And he immediately cracked down and started stripping me of like
- 25:11my job duties because he decided instantly that I was somebody that was not trustworthy,
- 25:18that I couldn't be trusted with people. As well as other tasks.
- 25:21He started having people spy on me and report back to him. He started
- 25:25telling people that they couldn't spend time with me, and this also started to
- 25:30include family members of mine. This included young women that I was mentoring.
- 25:33It eventually ended up being that I was not allowed to spend time with any
- 25:37high school students, anybody over the age of like eighth grade, because I
- 25:42was deemed to not have any control over myself. Mind you, Like I
- 25:47was not doing anything. I was really keeping to myself because the person you
- 25:52were interested in from kind of an outside you know, you're right here on
- 25:56the periphery saying we're going to take it slow. Because he was eighteen,
- 26:00they're thinking you're going to go trolling junior highs and high schools something like that.
- 26:06I still to this day have no idea what they actually thought was going
- 26:08to happen. Yeah, and mind you, so in this purity culture,
- 26:15there was such a huge emphasis on sexual purity. So at this point,
- 26:19like I said, I think I'm twenty one. At this point, I've
- 26:22never kissed anybody. I think I'd held hands with somebody. At this point,
- 26:26I've certainly never had sex. I've never done anything whatsoever sexual, physical,
- 26:33anything like that. In fact, I have a commitment to not kiss
- 26:36anybody until I'm married. So I'm like living above reproach at this point,
- 26:41and so I've never been alone with a man anything like that. I was
- 26:47really trying as hard as I could, and I just no matter how hard
- 26:52I tried, it was like I just kept getting more punishments bestowed upon me.
- 27:00Actually, what started happening is people would figure out that if they would
- 27:03tell Trey information, they would kind of get rewarded for it. It was
- 27:08like they would earn his favor. And so people started making up information and
- 27:15because Trey had decided that I was lying to him, then he would believe
- 27:19them and I would get punished for whatever it was that they were telling him.
- 27:25And so again I'm losing then friends, I'm losing like anybody that I
- 27:30was mentoring, that I was seeing in a small group capacity, and even
- 27:33my family. There was only one family member that had my back at that
- 27:37point, and it was just incredibly lonely and isolating. And finally it was
- 27:42so bad that I decided to quit my job. And I was like this
- 27:45is just this is just ridiculous. Like I feel like completely alone. So
- 27:49I decided to quit my job, and I thought, I will just I
- 27:53will move. By this point, he's obviously graduated. He's moved two and
- 27:57a half three hours away, and I thought, you know what, I'll
- 28:00just move. It's fine. And all of this has continued. So even
- 28:03though like he's over eighteen at this point, he's moved away, he's at
- 28:07college. I decide I will quit my job. They are still exercising their
- 28:14control. I was trying to get accepted into a master's degree program and get
- 28:18jobs elsewhere. They went and contacted the schools that I was trying to go
- 28:23to and the jobs that I was applying to to. I don't even know
- 28:27what the stories were the that that they were telling about me, but essentially
- 28:32blacklisted me. So I would go in. I'd have these great interviews where
- 28:36they're really promising. They're like, yeah, we'll call you, and they
- 28:38were telling me like we're going to offer you the job. You know,
- 28:41it's just basically formality, and then i'd get calls back they're like we're sorry,
- 28:45like we received information we're not going to be offering you the job.
- 28:48Anymore, and so basically trapped me to continue having to live in the community.
- 28:53And the long story short is, at some point I was like,
- 28:57I just have to break up with this guy because I can't. I can't
- 29:02continue dating him. My life is like to shit, essentially, like and
- 29:07I and I knew that I wasn't going to be with him, And mind
- 29:10you, I still didn't kiss him. We still didn't, like, do
- 29:12any I think you like kissed the palm of my hand. You know,
- 29:15come on, what in your twenties? Really that's wild. I mean I
- 29:21thought we were Puritans because we did the whole We had true love weights and
- 29:26the girls wore the purity rings and we you know, we promised to God
- 29:29and then we would fail, and then would they. We'd have the whole
- 29:33sin repent, sin repent cycle going on, wrestling with our around innate desires.
- 29:38I did a whole speech about this about purity culture. By the way,
- 29:41you were talking about sexuality and a little thumbs up I kind of appeared
- 29:45on your screen and it freaked me out a little bit. So I was
- 29:48like, I don't know what that is. It is. It's like it's
- 29:51some weird, weird things within the computer like I was watching on YouTube.
- 29:55You know, apparently if you say that word, the thumbs up will appear.
- 29:57So we'll wait and kind of see what happens. You went to Liberty
- 30:03University? Is this true? It is true? Okay, Liberties For those
- 30:08who don't know, I have a lot of people who may not be familiar,
- 30:11sir, real fast, let me do my due diligence. Liberty is
- 30:15a private Christian university in Lynchburg, Virginia, made famous by Jerry Folwell senior
- 30:22than his son, who apparently was a total freak. And there's a documentary
- 30:26about his sexual exploits and threesomes and whatever. He knows a voyeur and he
- 30:30was doing all the stuff that he told everybody else not to do. I'll
- 30:33let you go watch that. It's one of the biggest Christian universities in the
- 30:37world. They've got like fifteen thousand in person students, eighty thousand online students,
- 30:44and they have a very strict quote unquote moral code they call the Liberty
- 30:49Way. Doctor Laura E. Anderson, did you walk the Liberty Way when
- 30:56you were there? I did not. So here's the fun part. I
- 31:03did their hybrid program, so I did not have to. Well, I
- 31:07only had to walk the Liberty Way when I was on campus, which I
- 31:12was still like in fundamentalism at the time, so it was not difficult.
- 31:17But I technically walked it because I was so scared that somehow they would figure
- 31:22out even when I was like at home, that they would like have spies
- 31:27and they would see if I was drinking or something like that. But I
- 31:32did not have to sign like the big like moral policy Code of ethics whatever
- 31:37it is that it was. But well, if I can jump in,
- 31:41forgive me, Laura, what would be in that requirement. Yeah, a
- 31:45lot of things about drinking, no sex before marriage. They did have a
- 31:48dress code that was the I didn't have to sign anything with the dress code.
- 31:52When I was on campus, I wasn't obviously was not allowed to drink
- 31:56because I was older. I went there for my master's degree, so since
- 32:00I was older, I was legally allowed to drink, but not allowed to
- 32:02drink on campus. Of course, not allowed to have sex on campus if
- 32:07I wasn't married, which I wasn't and I still was keeping my purity promises.
- 32:13So we were good there and I'm trying to think modesty stuff. We
- 32:16still had to abide by all of those rules when we were on campus.
- 32:21Certainly non hetero relationships were totally forbidden. Yeah, yeah, yeah. And
- 32:24like I said, when I was at Liberty, I was still heavily entrenched
- 32:30in the fundamentalism that I grew up in. But that was really where I
- 32:36started untangling my faith. In fact, it was the very first day of
- 32:39classes, and so I was asking a lot of questions and really trying to
- 32:45grapple with how do I make sense of this. So it's interesting about the
- 32:50master's degree programs at Liberty is that they are technically Christian, but they're not
- 32:55super enforcing it if you're not in the legal or past storal programs. So
- 33:01there was an interesting mix there. They technically have to abide by the Liberty
- 33:06way, but there's also not as much enforcement of biblical perspectives. Really stuck
- 33:12by high control churches and their obsession with sex. They're just obsessed. They
- 33:19are more I tried to repress it. The more you realize that we're always
- 33:22talking about it, we're always thinking about it, they're always preaching about it.
- 33:27I've said this, This is another statement that I've made that you can
- 33:30correct me on because it may be wrong, but I've often said that if
- 33:36someone can get your sexual identity under control, if they can control your sexual
- 33:42identity, they've got the whole person. I think sex is the church's biggest
- 33:47competition. Do you think most of the Puritans wrestle with the stuff they preach
- 33:52about? Because usually whenever I see somebody who's behind the pulpit and they're like,
- 33:57don't do this, don't do that, I can't help but suspect that
- 34:00this is what they're wrestling with in their own mind, or or they're just
- 34:02lying. I don't know, what do you think? Yeah, So I
- 34:07don't necessarily want to like always bring something back to myself. But I had
- 34:09this experience. I talk about it a little bit in the book My First
- 34:13sexual Experience. I expected to feel an immense amount of guilt and shame,
- 34:17because that's what I had been told for almost thirty years, you're going to
- 34:22feel this way. And not only did I not feel that, I felt
- 34:25the exact opposite. And I had this moment and I didn't have words to
- 34:30articulate what it was, but now I can. But I felt like I
- 34:37was so connected to myself, to the universe, to God, whatever that
- 34:40even was And in that moment, I was like, Oh my gosh,
- 34:45I am so powerful, and I know why the church never wanted me to
- 34:51have this, because I don't need God anymore. Because this, like,
- 34:57I am so fully and holy myself that I don't need anything. I'm complete,
- 35:04I don't need what they taught me that I needed. And I was
- 35:07like, oh, I get it, I get it. You ever fantasize
- 35:09about looking tray up and grabbing them by the shoulders and going that was none
- 35:15of your goddamn business. See I mean, do you ever fantasize about it,
- 35:20Lauren? Uh? Not with Drey. I'm sorry, we're probing deep
- 35:30into your psyche. That's not my role here. But I do like personal
- 35:32stories. I really feel like, you know, lived experiences are shared experiences,
- 35:37you know, the human condition. We all have walked so many of
- 35:40these similar paths. And you know, I'm fascinated by about you know,
- 35:47high control organizations, churches, families, people. They rob you of your
- 35:53identity and so you are supposed to take on the identity of the group or
- 36:00the master. I think I came out of high control Christianity right, not
- 36:05me, but Christ lives in me. There is no one worthy. Blah
- 36:08blah blah. This is common right, you need me to have value is
- 36:15a common message from abusers. Correct one thousand percent. Yes, whether we're
- 36:20talking in a relationship or we're talking about in a church or cult, yes,
- 36:24absolutely, it's it is how they gain control over you. They prescribe
- 36:30a problem that they are the solution for. If I look at the biblical
- 36:34model, I see a domestic abuse model. Yeah, I made you,
- 36:39I rule over you. You get your worth from me. There was no
- 36:43one else that is worthy. Let me do all the thinking, let me
- 36:45do the talking. If you get hurt, even by my hand, it's
- 36:50either your own fault or you straight from my protection, or it's a teaching
- 36:54moment to make you stronger. By the way, I'm jealous, I have
- 36:58a temper. You better be loyal because if you leave me, you're going
- 37:02to get it. I mean this sounds like straight up abuse, right,
- 37:06one thousand percent. That is how I figured so much of this out.
- 37:09Before. I really specialized, like professionally in religious trauma and high control religion,
- 37:17and till this day, I really specialized in domestic violence. Kind of
- 37:22by accident, I just like clients started landing in my office, and oddly
- 37:27enough, because I was in a domestically violent relationship and I understood it on
- 37:31a personal level as well as a professional level. And there was a day
- 37:35I sat down with my journals and I was like, I don't know who
- 37:38said what. I don't know if that was my abusive ex partner or I
- 37:43don't know if that was God and or like the pastors or the church that
- 37:46I came out of, And that was deeply concerning to me, and I
- 37:51thought, well, that's something I need to start researching and exploring that more.
- 37:55And I did. I sat with that for years in terms of just
- 37:59like untangling why is that, like why like that that's so wrong? Because
- 38:05we can I think, as humans, we can so easily identify these abusive
- 38:09patterns and statements and behaviors that we go, but like, that's wrong.
- 38:15Once we see it, we see it like we we and we can't unsee
- 38:17it, and we go, that's that's not okay to do that to your
- 38:20child or to another human being. And yet we so readily accept it from
- 38:24this higher power that's perfect or his ways are are higher than our ways,
- 38:29and we can like placate or spiritually bypass and it just no longer makes sense.
- 38:34And there's you know, I know some people like don't buy that answer,
- 38:37and they're like, well again, God's ways are higher than our ways.
- 38:39I'm sorry, that just does not make sense to me anymore. Yeah,
- 38:43we're like antswer in his aunt farm. He can do what he wants
- 38:45to. Is you know, who are we to question God's ways kind of
- 38:49thing? Yeah? Right, not an okay enough answer, And that's a
- 38:52whole other conversation. But I think we have to look at it through that
- 38:55lens because the other piece of it is like if we do not accept that
- 39:00from other humans, if that is an inhumane way for other humans to treat
- 39:05each other, then surely the creatures that God created, Like why would we
- 39:10accept that from the creator? Like that does not make sense to me.
- 39:15I think if we look at it through the domestic violence lens, how do
- 39:19we not see God as the ultimate perpetrator of that? Manipulators tell us not
- 39:25to trust ourselves. In fact, they shame us for taking care of ourselves.
- 39:31I want to get a mental health professional's opinion on that, plus some
- 39:36resources for us coming up. I got a bunch of speaking dates coming up.
- 39:47I'd love to see you on the road La Little Rock, Denvers,
- 39:52Saint Louis, Fort Worth, Houston, Sarnia, Ontario, Toronto, Lexington,
- 39:58Kentucky, Bentonville, Arkansas. You can see all the details with links
- 40:04at seth Andrews dot com slash events more Right Now with psychotherapist and trauma resolution
- 40:14coach doctor Laura Anderson. It's interesting how high controlled cultures have all these built
- 40:21in protective mechanisms excuses. If I start to think for myself, how arrogant
- 40:27are you? It's all about you, isn't it. Mister man? You
- 40:30know why would you fight? This is just you wanting to be a god.
- 40:34There's all these reasons that I shouldn't focus on me self care, those
- 40:38types of things, And I bought that lie for a long time, and
- 40:43I felt guilty about focusing on my own needs and who am I? What's
- 40:46my identity? And carving a path of my own because me, me me.
- 40:51If you frame it in that way, it's it really does. They
- 40:53make me feel guilty for being an arrogant sob right, but how convenient right?
- 41:00That's part of the cycle that we're talking about. It's part of how
- 41:04an abusive cycle works is that the reason that they can get you in that
- 41:08abusive cycle is that they make you believe that any time that you question or
- 41:14have a doubt or go against them, that it's a sin or wrong or
- 41:17proof that you are actually the bad person that they say that you are,
- 41:22or that you're doubting, and so therefore there is something wrong with you,
- 41:27because certainly to question them or to go against them, or to doubt them
- 41:31or to say they're wrong is just further proof for evidence that you are who
- 41:37they say they are. So they've created this system where they have insulated themselves.
- 41:45That's quite convenient. You just want to sin, Laura, You just
- 41:51want to sin, so fun. Yeah, And you know the thing is
- 41:57like again, that's a very convenient way for people to bypass uncomfortable conversations in
- 42:04kind of like the spiritual Christian circles. They try to figure out like why
- 42:07are all these people coming out of churches? Why are they doing this like
- 42:10deconstruction thing. Well, they just want to sin, They just want to
- 42:14have sex. Like those are convenient excuses because they don't actually want to think
- 42:20about like what are we doing, what is the church doing? What are
- 42:23these spiritual institutions actually doing that are driving people out of these buildings. They're
- 42:30not willing to ask the hard questions, and so they're like, well,
- 42:34they just want to sin, they just want to have sex, They just
- 42:37you know, they were just never true believers in the first place. Those
- 42:38are convenient spiritually bypassing statements, because if you were to actually talk to the
- 42:45people that are coming out of those spaces, these are people that are deeply
- 42:50committed, that gave their entire lives, their time, their energy, their
- 42:53resources, that were some of the most committed people. That are the people
- 42:58that were in so many cases agonizing over walking out those doors, that did
- 43:02not leave lightly, that tried to make it work. I remember when I
- 43:08finally gave up my faith. I still remember the day, the moment everything.
- 43:15I sat in my living room and it wasn't a spectacular moment. And
- 43:19this is so often how it is for domestically violent clients of mine that I've
- 43:23worked with, where the moment that they realize it's over, it's usually like
- 43:27a teeny tiny moment as compared to all the big things that have happened in
- 43:31their relationship, and this it was just this like not benign. It was
- 43:36something that happened, but it was relatively small as compared and I realized,
- 43:40like the goalpost always kept moving, I was no matter what I did,
- 43:45no matter how small I tried to make myself, no matter how much I
- 43:49tried to contort myself or make this fit or that fit or whatever, it
- 43:53was never going to be enough. And I felt like Taylor Swift's song like
- 43:57we are never ever getting back together? That was like me and God,
- 44:00I was like, We're just it's not happening, like you know. And
- 44:07this was years after trying to make it work and trying to make theologies fit
- 44:10and whatever, and I'm like, that is no small thing. I tried
- 44:15to make it work for years, and finally I got to a day where
- 44:20I was like, I cannot do it anymore because I am losing myself entirely.
- 44:25And I think that that's probably a lot more common than the people that
- 44:30are making these comments of like you just want to go, sin like to
- 44:34think, because I think the people that are coming out are doing so usually
- 44:37very thoughtfully and with a lot of grief, and usually it's not carelessly that
- 44:44they're coming out. That's just my personal opinion here. It's a touchy one.
- 44:49Since I'm monopolizing your time, you're good, Why don't they just leave?
- 44:54I mean, you'll see somebody who's in a domestic abuse model and you're
- 44:59like, they're smart, they're strong, they've got a good job, they
- 45:02should know better. Why would they put up with it? You know,
- 45:05he beats the shit out of her, or he's verbally abusive, or she's
- 45:07not getting anything. It's totally one sided. I mean, just pack your
- 45:10stuff and get out. What's the problem. It's so simple, it's right
- 45:14in front of you. We tend to be reductive, sometimes dismissive in that
- 45:17way. How would you address that attitude? When I have the opportunity to
- 45:22really sit with people who are asking that question, I gently try to tell
- 45:27them that is the wrong question to ask, because it usually indicates that they
- 45:34don't understand what that relationship is, not from a place of maliciousness, and
- 45:40almost from a place of you should be happy that you don't understand what this
- 45:44is, because it's not a situation where you can just leave. Whether we're
- 45:49talking about a one on one domestically violent relationship or a high control religion,
- 45:53a cult, anything like that, you don't get to just leave. When
- 45:59your entire identity and life is connected to that person, that system, that
- 46:05church, that group, you don't get to just leave. There's usually six
- 46:09reasons why you don't leave, and it's one. You're usually choosing one to
- 46:15six of them. There's hope streams and possibilities. You've built a life together,
- 46:19and you go, oh, well, if we could just get back
- 46:21to that where we were at that love bombing stage. If I could just
- 46:23do this, If we could just go to therapy, if we could just
- 46:27get enough money so things aren't so tight, if we could if I could
- 46:30just do more of this, less of this, If he could do that.
- 46:31If if I could you know, pray more. If I could go
- 46:35to more Bible studies, volunteer more of my time, this or that,
- 46:37If I could hoe the church, could just reach more people and get more
- 46:42you know, money in the offering place, whatever, then we would be
- 46:45back to this place, and we have all these hope streams and possibilities.
- 46:49We stay because we fear what would happen if we left. There's so many
- 46:54high control groups that we see what happens when people leave. I think about
- 47:00like scientology, there's a concept called fair gaming where when somebody leaves, they're
- 47:06fair game. Literally anything can happen to them, everything from literal like physical
- 47:10assault, to people call their jobs. People will go on, They'll be
- 47:15like a social media smear campaign. People will be harassed, you know,
- 47:21like anything can happen. There's sometimes with kids type stuff like maybe their kids
- 47:25are still in the organization, or there's one parent that stays, like you
- 47:30can have your your kids held against you. There's a lot of fears like
- 47:34what will I do, Like maybe I don't have any skills to work to
- 47:37make money, I don't know anybody on the outside. How am I going
- 47:40to provide for my family? And so we stay because we fear. We
- 47:45have an immense amount of fear of how we would even survive on the outside.
- 47:50Of that. You told a little bit of your story. I'm going
- 47:52to tell you a little bit of mine because I think people can relate the
- 47:58rational set and the irrational seth wrestle all the time. I came out of
- 48:02a very high control religious family with the best of intentions. My mother and
- 48:07father wanted us to be Bible literalists Sunday go to meet and church going Jesus
- 48:13loving Christians who would take this country back for God, the Christian nation,
- 48:19and we would be world changers. Blah blah blah. And for decades of
- 48:22my life I was in that mold, but it was a mold fashioned for
- 48:24me by them, and I finally started to do my own thinking and everything
- 48:32just sort of went south. And so it's been you know, it's been
- 48:35fifteen years and a point not too far off, not long ago. It
- 48:42was one of those things like you were talking about. It wasn't a big
- 48:45deal, but it was a big enough deal that I thought, no,
- 48:47that's a boundary violation. It is just the latest example that a pattern in
- 48:53And I had to luck my mother out, not because I want to disrespect
- 48:59a mother, but because I have to respect myself. Right, How can
- 49:01someone with self respect allow someone to step into their life and name and blame
- 49:06and shame. And I remember it had been so long and so bad when
- 49:09I hit the block button on my phone, I've had people say, well,
- 49:13how did that feel? Yes, And I said, you know,
- 49:16at that moment, I felt so beat up that it was kind of like
- 49:20blocking spam? Is that weird? And then even now, the rational brain
- 49:25said this was necessary, and the you know, my brain says that,
- 49:30my heart says, you're a bad son, and I just go. I
- 49:34still wrestle with it, and everybody's like, just get over it. And
- 49:37it's just it must be a common thing that you hear, right, And
- 49:39you can bill me Laura if you want, but I mean, you hear
- 49:43this kind of thing all the time, right. Yeah. I was at
- 49:45a speaking gig last week and that was a question that was asked, you
- 49:49know, like what do you do with the whole family thing and blocking them?
- 49:52And what I said is, I think when we get to the point
- 49:55for some people, we have to get to the point where we do have
- 49:59to block or go to contact with a family member, maybe even several.
- 50:02And what I say to people is that it usually takes a very brave person
- 50:07to get to that point, because that means there's been a lot that's happened.
- 50:14It is not easy to get to that point, and it's usually with
- 50:17great pain and agony. It's not usually something that is done callously or quickly,
- 50:23because I think that what we have to remember is like we're always the
- 50:28child of our parent, and with that comes a lot. Oh there's like
- 50:32a weight that comes with that, and I think there's always that child part
- 50:37of us that really desperately wants our parents to love us, to connect with
- 50:42us, to have some sort of a relationship where they get us and can
- 50:47have communication with us, you know. And I always like to think about
- 50:52boundaries as they can change, Like we're in a season right now where they
- 50:57have to be blocked, and maybe that's forever. Maybe it's for a year,
- 51:00maybe it's ten years, maybe it's ten months. I don't know.
- 51:05We can always renegotiate those, but I think it's like so worth knowing that.
- 51:10I'm sure that it took a lot to get to that point, and
- 51:14to not beat yourself up for how hard that must have been and how hard
- 51:20it still is every day to know that a that's what you had to do,
- 51:24and b that it still causes pain to know that you had to do
- 51:29that. It would make sense that it still hurts because it's a parent,
- 51:32Like we want our parents. There's just always going to be that child part
- 51:37of us that wants our parents to be in our lives. Well, it's
- 51:42funny too, when you're raised with the you know, honor thy father and
- 51:45thy mother honored right in some cultures apparently to some people means that you have
- 51:51to abide everything they say and do and pat them on their head, or
- 51:54just endure because setting boundaries is a kind of dishonor or disrespect after all the
- 52:01sacrifices they've made for you, and this is the thanks they get again.
- 52:06I think we're back to these sort of protective mechanisms for people doing and seeing
- 52:10inappropriate things. I've had to kind of continue to navigate through that. I'll
- 52:14venmoil you for that counseling cabarsion doc. I'll just give me your venmo and
- 52:19I'm going to send that to you straight away. Okay, as we draw
- 52:23to a close, so many people watching and listening, they've been through it,
- 52:28maybe they're going through it. I know it's a broad umbrella here that
- 52:32we're under right now. But what would you say to someone who was still
- 52:37navigating trauma abuse. Maybe they've escaped, maybe they want to escape. Can
- 52:42you just sort of speak some words of constructive words of encouragement and help for
- 52:45them? Please? Yeah. The first thing I want to say is that
- 52:51you're incredibly brave leaving systems like this is not for the faint of heart,
- 52:57and it really is that bad. I think that back to Seth's question of
- 53:00like, why don't you just leave? It is one of the hardest things
- 53:05ever to leave. It's not just walking away from church. It's your entire
- 53:09identity. In so many cases, it's your family, it's your relationships,
- 53:14it's sometimes your job, your livelihood, it's everything that you know. And
- 53:19it takes an incredibly brave and courageous person to do that. And I don't
- 53:22think that that can be understated. And so please know that if you are
- 53:27leaving, if you have left, you're incredibly brave for doing so. And
- 53:31I also just want you to know that there are people who are available to
- 53:36help you and to support you and to walk that path. You are not
- 53:38alone. I'm happy to share resources if you need that. But yeah,
- 53:44you're not alone, and there are people who can be there for you.
- 53:46This is real. You don't have to pretend that it didn't happen. Trauma
- 53:52is a real thing. Religious trauma is trauma. You don't have to pretend
- 53:55that it isn't real. And that sounds clicheous is trauma, But like knowing
- 54:00that what happened to you was not okay, should not have happened that Yes,
- 54:06these messages can stick in your body and have physiological impact. It's worth
- 54:10knowing that and that there are people that can help you through that. I
- 54:15think it's just so important for people to know that so you can get the
- 54:17help that you need. And if you ever want to find the tray in
- 54:21your own life, grab them by the shoulders and say that was none of
- 54:24your business. You know, whatever whatever serves you you. I know you
- 54:29offer counseling remotely or or online. I don't know if that's something I should
- 54:34or can pitch here is that appropriate people can actually like bring you in and
- 54:37have you counsel one on one. Go ahead and tell me about that,
- 54:40or you would Yeah. I actually I have a company, the Center for
- 54:45Trauma Resolution and Recovery. We do online coaching, and we use that modality
- 54:50because just for like license like state lines and licensing purposes. Everybody does have
- 54:55a clinical background. We all have our degrees in mental health field, but
- 55:00I've chosen to practice as coaches and then we have Advanced Trauma Training certifications and
- 55:05stuff like that. But it's the Center for Trauma Resolution and Recovery. We
- 55:08do online coaching. You can go to Trauma Resolution and Recovery Dot com everybody
- 55:13has free inquiry calls, so you can sign up for that today and start
- 55:19working with a practitioner of your choice and get the support that you need.
- 55:23Doctor Laura E. Anderson, who is not doctor Laura, who has been
- 55:28a great guest, and it's a pleasure to talk to you. What a
- 55:31fun conversation and a constructive one. I think if I wanted this. Whenever
- 55:37people ask me the purpose of our channel, I think it's we want to
- 55:39learn stuff and help people right and along taking the ride too. I'm no
- 55:44great mind. I'm a guy who's trying to figure it out with everybody else.
- 55:46I want to learn something and try to help and encourage people, and
- 55:50I know you've certainly been a big part of that equation. Today I will
- 55:53link to your site in the description box of this show, and for your
- 55:59time and expertise. Thank you so very much, Thank you so much for
- 56:01having me. Follow The Thinking Atheist on Facebook and Twitter for a complete archive
- 56:07of podcasts and videos, products like mugs and t shirts featuring the Thinking Atheist
- 56:12logo, links to atheist pages and resources, and details on upcoming free thought
- 56:16events and conventions. Log onto our website, The Thinkingatheist dot com