Latest / Chatter that Matters / Dr. Brian Goldman - The Care in Health Care
Transcript
- 0:01Health is a subject that matters to each of us. I mean, those in good
- 0:04health, we wanna stay that way. Those battling their health issues want the best
- 0:09care. Those who advocate for others are looking for answers
- 0:13and the best path to follow in a complex system.
- 0:17Each time I brought a health professional on the show, I realized
- 0:20that they internalize how failing health can rip away all we
- 0:24know and value, and even our time on this planet, and how
- 0:27dedicated they are to trying to make us feel and ideally
- 0:36patient. I mean, David Fagenbaum. You haven't listened to that episode.
- 0:40He was given his last rights twice. Dying from an
- 0:44incurable disease, he had to find his own cure. Stephanie
- 0:47Strathy, an infectious disease specialist. Ironically, her husband
- 0:51gets infected by an antibiotic resistant superbug that's
- 0:55absolutely taking away his life, and through her dedication, they
- 0:58uncover a century old cure that saves his life. Other times, they
- 1:02try to move health care in the future. Doctor Jean Marmario, in her
- 1:0670, signs up to be a maid doctor to help people in extreme pain,
- 1:09end their life with dignity. Emmanuel Taban came from
- 1:13extreme poverty in the Sudan. He was captured by rebels and tortured.
- 1:17He finds a way to become a doctor, and he becomes world
- 1:20renowned as a pulmonologist with his groundbreaking cures for COVID-nineteen.
- 1:24Doctor. Alika Lafontaine, first indigenous doctor to be president of the Canadian
- 1:28Medical Association, takes what he learns on from working with his
- 1:32people and with limited resources, in doing so, tries to
- 1:35encourage all of us to do more health care with less. Well,
- 1:39my guest today is doctor Brian Goldman. I came out of medical
- 1:42school with the impression that if I memorized everything
- 1:46and knew everything or as much as possible, as close to everything as
- 1:50possible, that it would immunize me against making
- 1:53mistakes. And it worked for a
- 1:57while until I met missus Drucker. A wife,
- 2:01a mother, and a grandmother. They say you
- 2:05never forget the names of those who die, and that was my first time to
- 2:09be acquainted with that. To one of those rare individuals
- 2:12who who's found success in not one, but several adrenaline pumping careers,
- 2:16highly regarded emergency physician at Mount Sinai Hospital, one of
- 2:20Canada's top medical commentators. He's a host of CBC's award winning
- 2:24radio show, White Coat Black Art, who takes listeners behind the scenes of
- 2:28hospitals and doctors' offices, and he's a host of the podcast, The
- 2:31Dose, on current affairs in health care.
- 2:36This is chatter that matters with Tony Chapman
- 2:40presented by RBC.
- 2:46Brian, welcome to Chatter That Matters. Hi, Tony. Glad to be
- 2:50speaking with you. So in our pre interview, I asked you
- 2:54the best way to describe yourself, and I have to say, of all the
- 2:58answers I've received to date, and it's over 200 episodes, yours is
- 3:01among the best, if not the best. So give us a sense of how you,
- 3:05how you like to be thought of and known. A wise person, once told
- 3:09me a long time ago that if you can't be the best, be different.
- 3:13So so one thing I strive for is to be different because because
- 3:17I can't compete with the best. I also hate competing,
- 3:21even though I'm a very competitive person. In the work that
- 3:24I do, whether I'm speaking to somebody in the emergency
- 3:28department, often they have mental health challenges, or I'm doing
- 3:32an interview for White Coat Black Art, I I want them to say something different.
- 3:36I wanna get them off their prepared script. I, you know, I think a lot
- 3:38of a lot of, journalists would feel you know, would say, well, that's what I
- 3:41do too. One of the ways that I do it is by listening carefully,
- 3:46because I think that people do wanna talk about themselves and they wanna they
- 3:50wanna reveal themselves. They wanna be seen. And if you if you
- 3:53follow the bread crumbs, you'll get to to the place
- 3:57where they feel comfortable. Like, you know, that look in somebody's
- 4:01eyes when somebody says is it there's a look that says, I've been waiting
- 4:04for somebody to ask me that question for 30 years, and
- 4:08you finally asked it. Now I get to talk
- 4:13about it. What advice because I think today we're so frantic to get to the
- 4:14next bit and bite, the snackable content. And I see
- 4:17people just scrolling like mad on Instagram. What advice
- 4:21can you offer to people in terms of the magic that can
- 4:25be found when you just pause and dive a little
- 4:28deeper? Go beneath the surface, as you say, that to follow those
- 4:32bread crumbs. What I'm sharing is not me leading and and telling
- 4:36people what to do, but reflecting on my own struggles.
- 4:40And and, you know, you you said something really penetrating there. You
- 4:43said get to the next. If you're getting to the next, that means you're
- 4:47constantly anticipating what's next, what's next, what's next. And
- 4:51what are you missing out on? You're missing out on what is at the moment.
- 4:55That's directly connected to to my own personal struggles
- 4:59of either living in the regretful past, what I woulda, coulda, shoulda
- 5:03done, or living in the worried future. You can't you
- 5:06can't dwell in either place. You have to live in the
- 5:10moment. That's the only moment you have, and yet I and that's
- 5:14my struggle. That's my eternal life struggle. So just as I've learned to
- 5:18breathe, you know, I, you know, I I I'm hoping I'm gonna write a book
- 5:21on my personal struggle with insomnia, you know, because I've had a multi
- 5:25decade struggle with insomnia. And we'll get to
- 5:29to the implications of that insomnia on my on a on a major career
- 5:32shift. But the point is, you one of the things I've learned
- 5:36in in in in helping my my my problems with
- 5:40insomnia is that when I'm lying in bed, I just
- 5:43breathe and concentrate on my breathing. You know, I
- 5:47I will reach a count of 6 or 7 and then out 6 or
- 5:517. And and when you concentrate on your breathing, you're not you're no
- 5:54longer concentrating on on, you know, hearing a bit of music and having
- 5:58it play in your brain as an earworm, or worrying about something that you didn't
- 6:01do, thinking you gotta do something, and that
- 6:05ties directly into your question, you know, to to what you're asking me
- 6:09about about waiting to hear what somebody's gonna say.
- 6:13You don't know what they're about to say unless they're heavily scripted and you're heavily
- 6:17scripted. You know, just yesterday, I was planning
- 6:21my one of my producers and I are gonna be are gonna be going off
- 6:24to Hamilton to interview a young man with with colon cancer,
- 6:28And the whole focus of the show is that young men and women can get
- 6:31colon cancer despite what doctors believe,
- 6:34and and I've I've found that his script was some a bit more
- 6:38heavily scripted than it needed to be. Like like, he was
- 6:42asking questions expecting a certain answer to be spat out.
- 6:45And I said to him, let's make the questions a bit more vague,
- 6:49a bit more open, and leave a little room for mystery.
- 6:53That delicious thing that somebody tells you something that they didn't think they were gonna
- 6:57tell you, and you didn't think you were gonna hear, and and now you
- 7:01have to deal with it. And that's the best part of interviewing. You remind me
- 7:04in some ways of Larry David, and I and I'll tell you why.
- 7:08Because Larry David is really one of the most insightful
- 7:12human beings in the moment. He created a show with Jerry Seinfeld, the
- 7:16show about nothing, which was about everything. It was about life. But at the same
- 7:19time, when you listen to Larry David talk about his life,
- 7:23he's often talking about overcoming his insecurities
- 7:27or the things that he felt held him back. I'm wondering if there's a
- 7:31parallel there that when you when you do take the time to reflect on
- 7:35your journey and to recognize that these are obstacles
- 7:38to overcome, does that make you more equipped to
- 7:42be in the moment and in the present? You know, he's wicked.
- 7:46He's arch. You know, some people think he's mean,
- 7:50but and and and that's the risk. That's the risk that goes with with
- 7:54going for authenticity. But he's, you know, in his own inimitable
- 7:58way, he's going for moments of authenticity where people actually
- 8:01drop the drop the mask and just reveal themselves. I
- 8:05didn't start out my career striving for that, but it
- 8:09became obvious that that was that was my shtick. That's what I like to do.
- 8:13That's when I feel like I'm alive. I I
- 8:16need to feel when I'm when I'm doing an interview
- 8:20that I have gotten something that my
- 8:24that the producers who are working with me, who are very talented, would
- 8:28not necessarily have gotten. And then sometimes their jaws drop
- 8:31because they didn't think that that somebody would go to a place and talk
- 8:35about and talk about something so intimate. I interviewed a nurse
- 8:39practitioner who works in a library, the
- 8:43the main the Stanley Milner Public Library in Edmonton, and and this is in
- 8:46the downtown core surrounded by homeless people, people who
- 8:50use, Fentanyl, who are dying of Fentanyl overdoses, who live in
- 8:53precarious housing. A pilot project, always a pilot project.
- 8:57They, got some funding to put nurse practitioners
- 9:01and social workers in the library because that's, you know,
- 9:05the library is the last place where
- 9:08homeless people, people who use drugs, you know, people
- 9:12who have severe mental health issues can feel they have a right to be there.
- 9:16You know, you can get kicked out of almost any other place, including the emergency
- 9:19department at some point. If they think you're using the ER for, you know, if
- 9:23the staff there think you're using the ER for a, you know, a sandwich and
- 9:26a and a and a warm place, to stay on a cold night. You
- 9:30know, perish the thought. Anyway, I'm talking to the nurse
- 9:34practitioner, and, you know, it's gonna be a standard interview about what she does,
- 9:37and she we we I'm gonna make rounds with her. She's gonna run around the
- 9:41the the library. She's gonna be seeking out people in
- 9:44crisis. She's gonna be called, you know, to the stacks or, you know, to the
- 9:48to the reference desk because there's somebody who's sitting by themselves and they're beginning
- 9:51to talk to themselves and maybe there's a mental health issue with them. All magnificent
- 9:55stuff. But when it came to interviewing her, there's why does she
- 9:59do what she does? It turns out that
- 10:02her father had had substance
- 10:06use and died in an intensive care unit. We went there. We
- 10:10went to her talking about that, and her voice started to quiver, and she was
- 10:13talk and and this was her mission. Nobody knew until
- 10:17she said, and she just muttered something, and I just picked up on what
- 10:21she muttered and we went there. And it became a really important part of the
- 10:24show because not only do I want to to
- 10:28hear people's exploits, what they do to make health care better, their
- 10:32their hopes, their dreams, their frustrations, whatever, and patients too,
- 10:35but I wanna know what makes them tick because what makes them tick
- 10:39tells you why they do what they do. That's the engine of their life just
- 10:43as it's the engine of my life. So let's talk about that because my show
- 10:46is all about human journeys, you know, and I always call it the hero's journey
- 10:49that people have to go through life. They have to battle headwinds. Sometimes, you
- 10:53have to overcome the most horrific circumstances, but at times,
- 10:57they defy all odds. They get to reclaim or chase their dreams. They
- 11:00find a new mission in life. Where did yours come from? I mean, I was
- 11:04looking back at a couple of the defining moments of your life, and
- 11:07maybe just wind the clock back to
- 11:11how did this empathetic Brian
- 11:14Goldman get there? Because from what I understand at the beginning,
- 11:18you weren't necessarily you had a intellectual firepower,
- 11:22but I don't think your heart had quite caught up yet. No. I and I
- 11:25think that's fair. You know, I I think that if you'd asked me
- 11:29why I went into medical school, for instance, I I I would've said that's
- 11:33where that's where my cohort of smart kids went. I remember
- 11:36in in either, you know, grade 12, we had grade 13 at the
- 11:40time, One of my classmates, Sherry Yaffe, said,
- 11:44in the middle of the class, that Brian Goldman would study for a blood
- 11:47test. Yeah. Like, I was known I was the the the
- 11:51expression was a browner. Yeah. Yeah. A geek, a nerd, or
- 11:55something like that, but I I was a browner, and that was all I was
- 11:57known for. I was known for studying hard. One of the reasons why I studied
- 12:00hard was because I was a social misfit.
- 12:04I I was the youngest and the shortest, and,
- 12:08I you know, now I'm not the youngest anymore. I'm I'm the oldest in my
- 12:12one of the oldest of my cohort in the emergency department and at CBC.
- 12:17It reinforced this inferiority complex that I had, and and I was
- 12:20lonely. And, you know, in many respects, I still am, you know. I I accept
- 12:24now I know I'm lonely, and instead of acting out my loneliness, I
- 12:27I I feel it. Because if you feel it, then you feel better. And then
- 12:31you begin to discover and if you breathe and, you know, if you if you're
- 12:35living the moment, you discover the other people who are lonely too, and you discover
- 12:38who your friends are and who your true friends are. And I'm just
- 12:42you know, and I'm dealing with that for a couple of reasons. You know, my
- 12:44sister my sister died, 4 almost
- 12:4814 months ago. She was one of my best friends. And and then I
- 12:52found out out of the blue just just recently in the last 6 weeks or
- 12:55so that one of my oldest friends had who had moved
- 12:59away and, you know, we had infrequent contact over the last 5 years. He'd
- 13:03become a bit of a recluse. He died suddenly of,
- 13:06glioblastoma, the same thing that that struck Gord Downey,
- 13:10the tragically hip. He had a he had a brain tumor and he died 6
- 13:13weeks later. And and it leaves you feeling bereft, but but that, you know, just,
- 13:17you know, that's a digression. To get back to your question. You know, I
- 13:21was a guy who studied hard because I was lonely. You know, I was gonna
- 13:24do what smart people did. I knew I wasn't gonna be a surgeon. I didn't
- 13:26have the manual dexterity. I certainly wasn't gonna be an orthopedic surgeon,
- 13:30so I was probably gonna be an internist, and then I thought I'm gonna be
- 13:33a neurologist, and then it was gonna be a pediatric neurologist. And I was planning
- 13:37my career from the top down. Boy, what a
- 13:40ridiculous piece of advice because that doesn't give you any room
- 13:44to to kinda smell smell the roses or or the coffee or
- 13:48or whatever. And but I had planned it to the point that
- 13:51I was gonna go to Johns Hopkins and do a 2 month elective in neurology,
- 13:56a 1 month of adult neurology, and 1 month of pediatric neurology, and
- 13:59impress, my would be mentors there and, you know,
- 14:03have them want wanna say yes to me if I applied to their residency
- 14:06program. And and, you know, I I eventually, I did go on a residency tour
- 14:10in the United States, and that's what I was gonna do because that's smart kids
- 14:13went to the United States. You know? There, you can make it big. You can
- 14:16make it big anywhere. So I was at Johns Hopkins, and I hated every
- 14:20almost every minute of it. And why's that? Oh, you know, it it was
- 14:24I had finally met my match in a cohort of smarty pants
- 14:27people who, you know, if I spend all of my time studying, you
- 14:31know, they you know, know, if I used 18% of my brain,
- 14:35they used 19 or 20% of their brains, and they they were
- 14:39just they could outdo me in memorizing facts and
- 14:43and and figures. And I and I just felt like I I didn't
- 14:46belong in their culture. That was one of my first exposures
- 14:51to a strong medical culture where where doctors are
- 14:54superheroes and they have no problems with sleep
- 14:58deprivation and food deprivation and and
- 15:01bathroom deprivation. They just, you know, they save lives and all, and
- 15:05they only do good stuff. And the flip side of that is that they are
- 15:08ultra, ultra, ultra defensive and ultra sensitive to criticism. To
- 15:12me, one of my salvations is that is that I discovered that I can be
- 15:15criticized and live and and and and actually grow stronger from
- 15:19it, but my colleagues don't don't know. They still don't know that. It's I mean,
- 15:23it's just incredible how prickly and how brittle they are
- 15:26in the face of criticism. And I had
- 15:30insomnia at that time, which said medicine wasn't for me, but I
- 15:33persisted because one of the one of the things I cannot do is let go
- 15:37of things. It's one of it's my Achilles' heel. You know, like Diana
- 15:41and the golden apples, I keep, you know, I keep collecting things I'm supposed to
- 15:44be doing, and I have a really hard time letting go of them.
- 15:48Instead of waking up at 5 o'clock in the morning, I was waking up at
- 15:514 every morning and getting more and more sleep deprived and more and more
- 15:55depressed and more grumpy until the day when I was supposed to
- 15:58present grand rounds in the department of neurology. Guy McCann
- 16:02is the is the hotshot neurologist. He's in charge. I'm gonna impress
- 16:06him. I got up at about 3:30 or 4, had
- 16:10a quick pee, went back to bed, and fell into the
- 16:13deepest sleep that I had had in months. I
- 16:17woke up just as rounds were supposed to be beginning, the
- 16:21ones that I was supposed to present. And so I'm a no show at the
- 16:24rounds I was supposed to present. I got up. I got dressed as fast as
- 16:27I could. I ran across the street to, Johns Hopkins Hospital,
- 16:31climbed the flights of stairs as fast as I could out of breath, and stood
- 16:34at the back of the room like Dustin Hoffman in The
- 16:37Graduate. Elaine. Elaine. Like, it's too late.
- 16:41And then that's your that is that's a medical student's nightmare. That's a
- 16:45that's a dream, a recurring dream that I have. And
- 16:49my nemesis, the senior resident who was there, who hated
- 16:52me, probably because I reminded him of himself, but
- 16:56he didn't know why he hated me. He looked and had this malevolent grin on
- 17:00his face and he said, I still remember him. I can remember how he said
- 17:03it and the words he used. It's okay, Brian. You're
- 17:07too late. Everybody broke out in laughter. It
- 17:10was the worst moment of my life, right up there with
- 17:14the humiliation of the the day that I got the strap, you know,
- 17:18corporal punishment from a principal, a public school principal.
- 17:22Soon after, you know, the the elective was finished, I went back to Toronto
- 17:26and had to rethink my entire life. I sank into a depression.
- 17:30It took several years for me to come out of it. I was signed up
- 17:33to do an elect to do an internship in Sick Kids at Sick
- 17:37Kids in Pediatrics. First step in becoming a pediatric neurologist.
- 17:40That was gone. After the first few months of doing
- 17:44pediatrics, I did pediatric neonatal intensive care unit, and I was
- 17:48ready to quit medicine at that point. I certainly didn't wanna continue the residency.
- 17:52And so I switched over back to internal medicine, which was like reaching back
- 17:55to something that I was good at, but I didn't wanna be doing a
- 17:59I didn't wanna be an internist. Not at all. I mean, this is incredible.
- 18:03Like, all the time I put into this, the lifeline for
- 18:07me, the ticket out was that in
- 18:10my internship year, I started to write a novel that I never finished.
- 18:14But I discovered that I loved writing. And it was a solitary
- 18:18pursuit. I could be inside my own head. And then as I
- 18:22switched from pediatrics to to to doing a year of internal medicine,
- 18:26I took a a continuing ed weekend course
- 18:30in how to get your writing published. And I turned that course
- 18:34into my first, sale for The Globe and Mail.
- 18:38I decided I since I didn't know what I wanna do what I wanted to
- 18:41do with my postgraduate medical career, you know,
- 18:45somebody suggested to me you know, I had friends who were moonlighting in the
- 18:48emergency department, and and, they said you should give it a try,
- 18:52and I did. And I discovered that it suited me and I
- 18:56suited it. I left residency at the end of that second
- 18:59year. This is 1982. It's a long, long time ago. I
- 19:03started to do 2 things. I worked shifts in the emergency department
- 19:07in a hospital in suburban North North of Toronto in in a
- 19:11suburb called Richmond Hill. And, eventually, 2 years later, I I started
- 19:14working at Mount Sinai Hospital where I just celebrated 40 years.
- 19:19In parallel, I wrote one article after another, you
- 19:22know, newspapers, then magazines. I became a contributing editor to the
- 19:26Canadian Medical Association Journal. And then 1987, I took or
- 19:301986, in the fall, I took a course in radio documentary writing
- 19:34at what is now Toronto Metropolitan University and turned
- 19:37that into my first sale for the CBC. And, really, in many
- 19:41respects, I've never looked back, and radio has been my medium since then.
- 19:45So a couple of things I wanna unpack on what you said is that a
- 19:48lot of times when you get hit with a sledgehammer, in this case,
- 19:52obviously, as you said, it took years to recover. I fell into a
- 19:56depression. A lot of people are battling some horrific
- 19:59headwinds right now. And I'm my hypothesis and why I do this show is
- 20:03that this overpowering negativity that
- 20:07we're inhaling every day is is manifesting this growing sense
- 20:10of impossibility. And people are just feel like they're the cement's
- 20:14just pouring up their legs and there's just no point going forward.
- 20:18How did you turn around what to me would be one of the
- 20:22crisis moments of your life, sleeping in and
- 20:25missing your shot, that one shot that Eminem talks about, what advice
- 20:29can you give to others who are going, there's no point going forward? I I
- 20:32I had my hand on that rung and I fell off the ladder, and I
- 20:35just don't have the I don't have it in me anymore to reach.
- 20:39I I say this with a bit of trepidation because I I
- 20:42have abilities, and I have and I have privilege, and
- 20:46I had privilege back then that made it that made it easier,
- 20:50that cushioned the blow, and and made it easier for me to
- 20:54contemplate doing other stuff. I'm also, a very
- 20:58practical person. It's not either
- 21:02or, and you should never think in terms of,
- 21:06the whole dream is gone or the or or the whole dream is
- 21:10is alive and well. It could be something in
- 21:13between. And my survival instinct said,
- 21:17as I left residency to to, you know,
- 21:20pursue this fledgling dream to write, I'm gonna
- 21:24hang in medicine long enough to have just to
- 21:28be able to earn a living doing it so that I could subsidize
- 21:32myself writing. And, you know, I think I think some of
- 21:35my emergency colleagues would be well, some of them would say, yeah. We knew it
- 21:39all the time, Brian. You just dabbled in emergency medicine so that you could
- 21:42write about it. But the point is that it's not all or
- 21:46nothing. It's not that the dream is is is alive or the dream is dead.
- 21:50Maybe the like, in the same way that, you know, some
- 21:53of the employment experts or retirement specialists who teach you,
- 21:57try to counsel you on how to have a good retirement, which is also an
- 22:00important transition, that that you cultivate interests,
- 22:05multiple interests, just as you have multiple sides of yourself.
- 22:09And what those can do, you know, they they may
- 22:12become a job. They may become your primary occupation. Or
- 22:16the job that you train for may become an avocation instead of instead
- 22:20of your primary source of income. And you have to be flexible
- 22:24in that way, and I've always been flexible. And one of the things I, you
- 22:26know, one of the things I learned, you know, I I I summarized my freelance
- 22:30career very, very quickly. You know, one of the important survival
- 22:34tactics that I've used over the years is to have multiple streams of income
- 22:38and to not ever be dependent on one thing. You know? So I I
- 22:41promised myself I would early on, I would never be an employee. I don't wanna
- 22:46be, you know, alive or dead professionally on at the behest
- 22:50of a company or at the whim of a company. There's a core thing that
- 22:53I that I wanna say for people who feel stuck.
- 22:57The first thing you have to do when something horrible
- 23:00happens in your life, and I hate to say this, but it's
- 23:04true, is to feel the pain. You have to feel the
- 23:08pain. You cannot make excuses for
- 23:12it. You know, they were lousy or, you know, they didn't they didn't appreciate the
- 23:15true me. You at some point, you have to feel it in
- 23:19your bones, in your heart and in your soul. The disappointment, the deep
- 23:23disappointment that you feel, You know, an Olympic athlete who
- 23:26trains for years years years and then has a terrible injury just
- 23:30before the Olympics or has their shot at it and it's gone.
- 23:34You cannot explain it away. You have to cope.
- 23:38You have to rise above it, and some of that may be kind of chasing
- 23:42some of the negative thoughts, but you do have to experience the disappointment if
- 23:46that's what you feel. And not try to the more you block it, the more
- 23:49you push it away, the harder it comes at you and inhabits your dreams, your
- 23:52nightmares. And the other question that I I wanted to ask because it really
- 23:56bridges your medical profession and your gift
- 24:00as a storyteller, is this TED Talk you did, Doctors
- 24:04Make Mistakes, and at least one of your episodes in the dose calling
- 24:07for more whistleblowers to come out. Yep. And I'm curious
- 24:11as to why you decide to openly talk
- 24:15when you're obviously working alongside other professionals.
- 24:19Did you ever feel blowback from them that sort of said, he's
- 24:22not really here to practice medicine or have my back. He's
- 24:26really here to expose the flaws in the healthcare system. Those were
- 24:302 of many courageous statements you've made to say, hey, we're not
- 24:33perfect. We're not like the guy that sits in the front of the room with
- 24:37the the grin saying you're too late, Brian. We're we're human beings, and
- 24:40and you can expect all the warts to come with being
- 24:44human. Yeah. You know, I I think that,
- 24:48you know, have I had have I had people who've objected? Yeah. You know, from
- 24:52time to time. Individuals don't do that. Occasionally,
- 24:56you know, I had I had one I had one colleague who
- 25:00thought that, you know, my self confessional about my mistakes in the
- 25:04TED Talk was was well suited to the age of Oprah Winfrey, you know,
- 25:07to the the age of people sitting on a couch and talking to a,
- 25:11you know, to a famous interviewer about about their flaws and about about their
- 25:15foibles and their mistakes. But that person I'm thinking of is a
- 25:19bit of an exception. I, you know, I I found over the years
- 25:22that more people, appreciated
- 25:26it, appreciated the open invitation to reflect on their own mistakes
- 25:30in a less self crucifying way,
- 25:34like I'm a terrible person because I make mistakes. I didn't know
- 25:37it at the time, Tony. I became interested
- 25:41subsequent to that TED Talk, in the
- 25:44phenomenon of toxic shame, you know, the Brene Brown kind
- 25:48of toxic shame, this this this primordial fear that
- 25:52if anyone discovered how flawed you were, the mistake you just made,
- 25:56they would ask you to leave, exclude you from the group.
- 25:59That is a preeminent fear of a lot of
- 26:03health care providers, so they don't want people to learn about their
- 26:07mistakes. You know, they're not dishonest people. They just they're just
- 26:10terrified of being outed and discovered. If they were, they think they would be
- 26:14kicked out. That's obviously a cousin of the famous imposter syndrome
- 26:18that people feel like they're just waiting for to be the tap on the shoulder.
- 26:21You know, the finger that says, you don't belong here. It's time for you to
- 26:25leave. For me, why did I, you know, why did I do that? I did
- 26:28it because, you know, it what started as a TED talk, what
- 26:32ended as a TED talk started as a series of of speeches that I
- 26:36gave, and they all began in exactly the same way. I don't know how you're
- 26:39going to react to this Because it was novel. Because people didn't talk about
- 26:43their mistakes. It left you the impression that doctors never make mistakes. For
- 26:46me, you know, I talk about being a kind of
- 26:50a brazen medical resident, you know, that in that year of internal
- 26:54medicine in which I sent a patient home. I treated their heart failure, sent
- 26:58them home. It was it was at a time when we didn't have some of
- 27:01the tools for quickly diagnosing and and and the method
- 27:05for quickly diagnosing, whether somebody was having a a heart attack
- 27:09without the obvious signs of a heart attack on the electrocardiogram.
- 27:13And and I sent the patient home. I did so
- 27:16without talking to my attending cardiologist,
- 27:20who would have had a completely different view. He would have said, no. You shouldn't
- 27:23do that. And I know that, because he said so.
- 27:27And after the fact, also, I the
- 27:31other mistake that I made was not listening to a little voice in my in
- 27:34my head, in my heart, which was which is trying to tell me that's not
- 27:37a good idea. So I did both. I went
- 27:41back to to my the rest of my cardiology duties. That was the rotation I
- 27:44was doing. And on the way home, I did something that I that I would
- 27:47that I never did. So, obviously, I had a foreboding sense. Instead of walking out
- 27:51taking the most direct route to the parking lot to my car, I walked through
- 27:54the emergency department. And I and I heard the words
- 27:58that that are, you know, the 3 worst words that an emergency physician
- 28:02will ever hear, and they are, do you remember? Do
- 28:06you remember that patient you sent home a few hours ago? You know,
- 28:09occasionally but not usually, it isn't followed by, well, that person is donating
- 28:13a $1,000,000 in your name and thinks you're wonderful. It's usually something really bad
- 28:17happened. And in this case, the patient was brought back moribund,
- 28:21like nearly dead. You know, had a severe,
- 28:24hypertensive episode, heart failure, and died about 10
- 28:28days later. You know, she might have died 10 days later anyway, but the
- 28:32fact is that that my mistakes were clear. That was the
- 28:36first time that I was aware that my
- 28:39that this work is tough and that my mistakes had
- 28:43consequences. If I sank into a depression
- 28:47following, you know, sleeping in, this was this was
- 28:50altogether different. And and it took me many years to realize that it
- 28:54was a shame response that I was feeling. As I listened to you,
- 28:58in situations where success or failure,
- 29:02life or death are ones that
- 29:05really impact you. They're not a transaction. They're not a
- 29:09moment. They can send you into these spirals. But you continue to come
- 29:13back and put yourself in those situations because anytime you walk into
- 29:16ER, you've gotta make decisions and judgment
- 29:20Right. That are a matter of life and death. Right. I'm curious
- 29:24why you kept coming back and drawing from that well
- 29:28knowing that you it has such an impact on you
- 29:32mentally. What would your advice be? I'm
- 29:35asking rhetorically, that that you that you not
- 29:39do it anymore or that that, you know, if you see yourself,
- 29:43if if if that alternative is running away from challenges,
- 29:47shirking from challenges, just or flinching and and just saying, nah. That's
- 29:51too much for me. I think that I saw my parents do that
- 29:54for many years. This is terrible now. I mean, you know, the it it
- 29:58was part of the, you know, the litany that you that, you know, the messages
- 30:01that parents feed their children. My mom kept saying, don't be like your father. Like,
- 30:05you know, come on. You know? Like, he had no good qualities. Come
- 30:09on. You know, that took me a long time to get you know? But
- 30:12but my mom, I, you know, I did I ran a race when when I
- 30:16was, like, 6 or 7 years old. Their social club,
- 30:20had a picnic. And, you know, if they had their kids, they had events for
- 30:23their kids. And and in this race, I took 3 or 4
- 30:27strides. You know, on your mark, it's let go. I start to run. I realize
- 30:30I'm not going to win because I'm not the fastest, and I stopped. And and
- 30:34my mom never let me forget that. She called me a
- 30:37quitter. She said, don't be a quitter. The pathology of that, like, it's not
- 30:41all good. The pathology of that is that you you don't know how to quit
- 30:44things that you should quit. I can tell you, Tony, that I have, you
- 30:48know, I'm thinking of a colleague right now. I've been thinking about who are the
- 30:51people I worked with 40 years ago when I first started at Mount Sinai Hospital.
- 30:54And one of them, within 9 months to a year or
- 30:58so, was so beaten down by the very things that
- 31:02you've talked about, you know, the patience that go south, that that go
- 31:06sour, you know, the person you send home who comes back way worse or dead
- 31:09because it happens because that's real life. She quit and
- 31:13she she did something else, and God love her for that. One of the things
- 31:16I had to learn how to do, 2 things. You know, I you know, for
- 31:20for my head, I had to figure out what I did wrong and not do
- 31:22it the next time. And and and as I said in the TED Talk, the
- 31:25TED talk is not just a litany of my mistakes. It's it's a
- 31:29triumph. It's it because because I I can't tell you how many
- 31:33people I've saved know, because of the mistakes that I made. And that other
- 31:36that famous person that told me if he not famous. He was he was former
- 31:40father-in-law of mine, late father-in-law of mine, said if, you know, the one
- 31:44who said if you can't be the best, be different. He was one of the
- 31:47first people to tell me that, you know, he liked to quote aphorisms,
- 31:51that good judgment comes from experience and experience comes
- 31:54from bad judgment. You have to make mistakes and you have to
- 31:58rebound from your mistakes. If you don't, you're going nowhere. It's it's
- 32:02the concept of failing forward. Certainly, the
- 32:05business world has embraced failing forward. But if you live in a
- 32:09shame, if you work in a operate in a shame, culture,
- 32:14you don't learn from mistakes because because the
- 32:18revelation of those mistakes are, by definition, shameful. Because they're
- 32:21shameful, you don't wanna learn from them because because you think the inevitable result
- 32:25of revealing those is that you'll be asked to to disband and
- 32:29shame you know, I think a lot of health professionals become
- 32:32health frontline health care workers because they are riddled with internal shame,
- 32:36internalized shame. It's like a bulletproof vest against
- 32:40criticism that, you know, you sacrifice so much and you're such a
- 32:43hardworking you work hard. Look, you know, you were you were
- 32:47halfway to the parking lot and you realize that you hadn't checked the sodium. So
- 32:50you turn around and you go back. And and then a family pulls you in
- 32:53to the emergency department and says, please help my son. And you, you know,
- 32:57even though you're supposed to be going home to your to your family and you're
- 33:00supposed to have dinner and you're tired, you go and you stop and you help
- 33:03them. And instead of going home at 9 o'clock in the evening and missing dinner,
- 33:06you go home at 1 o'clock in the morning and you miss sleep because you're
- 33:09and everybody says, what a great job. You know, you're a martyr. That's a great
- 33:13you know? And it all sounds wonderful until you realize how sick
- 33:17it is. It's sick because if you don't take care of yourself, you will
- 33:21not take care of your patients. Most people don't spend a
- 33:24lot of time thinking about, you know, their final chapter, where they might be
- 33:28living, what their caregiving requirements might be,
- 33:31and personal planning, their financial planning, and then ultimately,
- 33:35their estate planning to make sure that they're setting their loved ones that they're
- 33:39leaving behind up for success. That was Leanne Kaufman speaking.
- 33:43Join me later as she shares what RBC Wealth is doing with their healthy
- 33:47aging initiatives. Stick around because what she has to say
- 33:50matters because it's about you living longer and
- 33:54healthier. Hi. This is Tony Chapman.
- 33:58I wanna talk to you about what RBC Wealth Management is doing to support healthy
- 34:02aging. Old age is becoming old news. We're living longer,
- 34:06and planning for our future means we need to integrate health, wellness,
- 34:10and our financial matters. RBC Wealth Management is partnering with
- 34:13leading experts and organizations like the MIT AgeLab, the
- 34:17National Institute on Aging, the Women's Brain Health Initiative, Elder
- 34:21Caring, and the Woman's Age Lab. Why? To provide you with
- 34:25comprehensive resources covering every aspect of you aging
- 34:28well. This includes support for your physical and mental health, caregiving,
- 34:33maintaining financial stability, and preparing for later life health
- 34:36issues, ensuring you can age safely and comfortably, and ideally
- 34:40in your own home. With RBC Wealth Management, you create a personalized
- 34:44plan that adapts as your needs change, giving you peace of mind and
- 34:47security. Visit rbcwealthmanagement.com
- 34:51and learn more about healthy aging and start planning for your
- 34:55future. Healthy aging? Well, that matters to you, to
- 34:58me, and to RBC.
- 35:03I've discovered the antidote to my shame and my
- 35:07path to empathy. It began with me talking about my medical
- 35:10mistakes openly and being a beacon for those
- 35:14who felt ashamed of their of their mistakes to say you are not alone, I
- 35:17have done it and maybe I've done worse. You're listening to Chatter That
- 35:21Matters with Tony Chapman presented by RBC. My guest
- 35:25today is doctor Brian Goldman, one of Canada's top medical commentators.
- 35:29He's a host of CBC's award winning radio show, White Coat, Blackguard,
- 35:33and he's a host of the podcast, The Dose, Current Affairs in Health
- 35:36Care. I want to talk about, care
- 35:40and your book, The Power of Kindness, and it really
- 35:44came about, I guess, from this gentleman, Ruben Rosenblatt. Yep. So he
- 35:48brought his wife into ER. So just tell us about what happened and
- 35:51why and how that manifested into a book. So Reuben's,
- 35:56late wife was in the end stages of multiple sclerosis, and
- 35:59and she could not speak for herself. She couldn't ambulate. She was
- 36:03receiving, know, pretty much 247 care at home.
- 36:06And her family had reached the point, you know, where they were
- 36:10they felt they couldn't care for her properly at home, like, as as most families
- 36:14do. In fact, even today, especially today, now that we have so many
- 36:18so many people who have loved ones who require 247 care, we don't have great
- 36:22home care, we don't have a lot of long term care facilities. One of the
- 36:25reasons why, you know, we, you know, we have them transferred to a long
- 36:28term care facility is that we don't have the support and competence
- 36:32and knowledge and skill necessary to care for them. 1, you know, one of the
- 36:36solutions to that is to teach people how to do it. This is we're talking
- 36:391992. Like, you know, at a at a time when, you know,
- 36:43Reuben did what what every family or what most what most
- 36:46families do. They bring their loved one to the emergency department saying, we've we've reached
- 36:50the end of the road on this. And and, you know, I
- 36:53was a youngish, smart, but very defensive emergency
- 36:57physician. When they asked, when they said this is the situation, I
- 37:01sized it up. My assessment was that was that,
- 37:05my patient was not suffering from severe respiratory distress,
- 37:08wasn't wasn't dehydrated, had a loving family. I
- 37:12had already cultivated in my self or had had decided
- 37:16that I was never going to be an emergency physician who, you
- 37:20know, kinda puts my hands on my hips and says no to people's requests.
- 37:23If I can if I can make it happen, I I'll make it happen. And
- 37:27so I referred her almost immediately to the internal medicine
- 37:31team. Because of triage, because the most
- 37:34urgent patient gets whatever whatever order in whatever order they
- 37:38arrive, the most urgent patient gets treated first.
- 37:42You know, I I I made that referral early in my shift, and, like,
- 37:465, 6, 7 hours later, she still hadn't been seen by internal medicine. And
- 37:50every time I walked by the room, somebody from the family,
- 37:53Ruben or his kids, would ask, when's my mom
- 37:57getting a bed? I don't know. Can you estimate when my mom's getting a bed,
- 38:02when she sees the internal medicine team? And and I left. And I'd come back
- 38:05an hour later, or I'd walk by and they'd pull me in and they'd say,
- 38:08when's my mom gonna see the internal medicine team? I don't know. Can you
- 38:12estimate when she'll see it? And this went on and on and on. And at
- 38:15one point, I you know, when one of the family members
- 38:19asked if I had actually made the referral, like,
- 38:23skeptical. I did something that that, again, I
- 38:26broke one of my rules. I snapped at her. I said, I did what you
- 38:30asked, and I walked away. And she got
- 38:34seen eventually by internal medicine. She got admitted. She died several
- 38:37weeks later, about 3 weeks later, not unexpectedly. And then a
- 38:41while, a few months after that, I received this beautifully handwritten note from Rubin Rosenblatt,
- 38:45a letter. Like, who writes a letter these days? And the words that
- 38:49burned that that made me kind of burn with kind of shame,
- 38:53there's that word again, was that she he he invited me to
- 38:56meet with his family to to talk about what happened,
- 39:00to see if there was any residual kindness
- 39:04lurking under all that brusque ness that I
- 39:08demonstrated that day. So they weren't talking about my confidence. They were talking about
- 39:11my demeanor and my kindness.
- 39:15First of all, if if if somebody accuses you of incompetence or
- 39:19negligence, that's actually arguable. That's almost always
- 39:23arguable. But when a family accuses you of
- 39:26unkindness, they've got you busted.
- 39:30They know. Because everybody knows kindness and unkindness. You know,
- 39:33eventually, I met with the family. And, you know, my chief,
- 39:37offered to come with me. I was appreciative of that, but I, you know, I
- 39:40I thought they don't wanna see the Pollak Bureau. They don't wanna be told we
- 39:44did the best we could and, you know, we have competing priorities and I where
- 39:48people walk away feeling more damaged than than, you
- 39:51know, feeling as if whatever they said landed. So I met
- 39:55with them alone. I remember the room. I remember the time and place.
- 39:59They told me all the things that I wish I'd known had I been present
- 40:02on that day with them instead of being you know, I I
- 40:06reckon as I look back, I was defensive. I didn't like saying I don't
- 40:10know. I didn't like being power you know, to their questions. I didn't like
- 40:13being powerless, not being able to snap my fingers and make things
- 40:17happen, which, you know, emergency physicians are almost by
- 40:21definition powerless. You know, we have to beg people
- 40:24sometimes to see patients and, you know, the the residents get younger and younger
- 40:28and they get more and more condescending over the years. Although, you know, there is
- 40:31power in being an older attending physician. You know, when when
- 40:35all of the, you know, when all the attendings know you very well, you know
- 40:37that if you pick up the phone and call them, they're not gonna defend the
- 40:40resident. They're gonna go to the resident and say, hey. How come you're not seeing
- 40:44Goldman's patient? But, you know, we had you know, the family cried.
- 40:47I cried. We had a really good session. And it's really interesting.
- 40:51I didn't remember this, but one of the sons remembered,
- 40:56that I said to them, I'll never forget this conversation.
- 40:59Verbally, I empathized with them. Emotionally, I had no idea what
- 41:03they were going through. It was so far beyond my experience
- 41:07of having a mother with end stage, you know, end stage,
- 41:11multiple sclerosis and and maybe providing care and not being able to
- 41:14talk to her. It was only about 10 years later
- 41:18with my mother having dementia and my father spending the
- 41:22best 15 years of his retirement life looking after her, that I
- 41:26could finally, finally empathize with that family and
- 41:30especially on the night my dad died. He died at a
- 41:33hospital in Toronto. He took care of my mother,
- 41:37until until she was removed from the home at at you know,
- 41:41because it was either it was either stay at home or die or go
- 41:44to long term care and live. And it broke my father's heart, and 6 months
- 41:48later, he had his first heart attack and he developed heart failure and and
- 41:52the last 2 or 3 years of his life were not kind. And and on
- 41:56the last day of his life, I had worked all night in
- 41:59the emergency department the night before. He was he
- 42:03was brought to the emergency department. I'd had a difficult conversation
- 42:07with somebody not related to medicine, related to my broadcasting.
- 42:11And and so it was not a good day. It was a really, really bad
- 42:14week for a whole bunch of personal reasons. And I stayed with him. And
- 42:18at 10:30 at night, my dad wanted us to all go home. We
- 42:22were gathered around his bedside. You know, he still had smoldering angina, and I should
- 42:25have realized that was the end of it. But I, you know, my judgment was
- 42:28off because I was so I was more sleep deprived than I'd ever been in
- 42:31my life. And and I remember walking out the
- 42:35door with a foreboding sense and then kinda stepping
- 42:39back and and kissing him on the cheek and saying, I love you. And
- 42:42it was the only time in my life that I said I love you. He
- 42:45never said it to me. I went to bed. I don't I don't remember my
- 42:49my head hitting the pillow. And the next thing I know, I I'm
- 42:53being shaken awake. I can hear my name being called 2 or 3 times.
- 42:57And it's it's my wife, Tamara. And she's got a stricken look on her face.
- 43:00And I said, he's gone, isn't he? And I remember going
- 43:04back to the hospital with my sister and brother-in-law.
- 43:09Actually, the first look on my dad's face, you know, it
- 43:12was a placid look like the struggle was over, and it had been a horrible
- 43:16time for him. And then the cardiologist comes in
- 43:20with a nurse. I recognized myself in him.
- 43:24That I, how I was with that other family was how he
- 43:28was with me at that moment. He was defensive. He
- 43:31was thinking I got I got Goldman's dad as my
- 43:35patient, and I couldn't keep him alive for 1 night. I
- 43:38remember not wanting that
- 43:42cardiologist to be in the room with me anymore. I was done.
- 43:46My father was gone. Nothing was going to change that. And I remember saying to
- 43:49him, Thank you. Thank you for looking after him.
- 43:53That was the first time that I understood what the other family was going
- 43:57through, and that's what set me on the journey to write the book. That was
- 44:00the engine that that set me on the world to meet kind people, to ask
- 44:04myself the question, am I a kind soul or or am I a I don't
- 44:08know if I can say this. Am I an asshole? Is that is that what
- 44:10I've become? At that and and I realized that the answer was more
- 44:14nuanced, that that I was so shame riddled and
- 44:17defensive that that, you know, I I couldn't get outside of, outside
- 44:21of my own head. My own head was in the way of of of being
- 44:25in the moment and kind. But you have to purge yourself of that. You have
- 44:27to and and one way to do it is to, first of all, say, you
- 44:31know, live with your mistakes and accept that you make mistakes.
- 44:35One of the things I discovered early on is that when is if you tell
- 44:38a family what actually happened, 9 times out of 10,
- 44:42they will like you better. You know, it's interesting. I I had,
- 44:46Miles Nadell on my show, and
- 44:50he's of the same age you are and I am. And
- 44:54asking him kind of, you know, in terms of how he wants to be remembered
- 44:58and thought of. And it's interesting, you know, for a guy that has done so
- 45:01much. He said, I just wanna be known as a kind person. Yeah. I
- 45:05wanna talk a little bit about Joanne because your sister, who
- 45:08you were very close with earlier in the show, she said, you know, she was
- 45:11your best friend. And you wrote this incredible
- 45:15article that really moved me titled, I'm the last surviving
- 45:19member of my family. And within it, you included some pictures
- 45:23of the 2 of you that I thought were just beautiful. You could tell that
- 45:26you were siblings and soulmates. And talk to me about
- 45:30because it seems like all every time your throughout your journey, these
- 45:33experiences have truly changed you, moved you,
- 45:37sharpened the way you're thinking, opened up your heart, opened up your mind. And
- 45:41I'm just curious to what what did Joanne's, when she
- 45:45was here with you, bring to your life, and
- 45:49what did her passing give to you? My sister,
- 45:54was in many respects an opposite to me, but she also showed
- 45:57remarkable capacity for growth and development. She
- 46:01found some of the subjects at school harder than I
- 46:04did. You know, I was probably better at math and and and science
- 46:08than she was. Certainly, you know, one of the things that she did
- 46:12that that, you know, I said I was lonely and she had a million friends.
- 46:16She had a great facility for nurturing
- 46:20friendships and remembering everybody's names. She had a
- 46:24kind of a problematic relationship with our father. My
- 46:27sister, who could be argumentative, had a lot of arguments with my dad that, you
- 46:31know, they seem to be the the the entertainment of our house
- 46:35arguments, like knock down, drag out arguments, yelling and screaming
- 46:38matches. You know, my sister absorbed a lot of negative messages
- 46:42when she was growing up that you're no good at this, you're no good at
- 46:46that. She started off as a confident girl and
- 46:49got beaten down in her teenage years, I thought. I can't change
- 46:53that. 1 of, you know, one of one of her enduring wonderful qualities,
- 46:58she had a capacity for loyalty, which was amazing. You know, she would see she
- 47:01could see the best in everybody, including me. That and the
- 47:05shared experience that she and I had from growing up, it's something
- 47:09that I think is often underrated. You know,
- 47:13that the relationship with the sibling is so
- 47:16important to affirming who you are and reflecting on who you are and
- 47:20how you've changed over the years. She was always there at my, you know,
- 47:24at our at our at the good in the good times and in the bad
- 47:26times. Like, she didn't tell me enough about the struggles that
- 47:30she had raising raising a son who lived the first 17 months of his
- 47:34life in an orphanage in Romania at the tail end of the
- 47:38Ceausescu regime, where they were they were brutal and
- 47:41abusive and horrible to babies at that at that
- 47:45time. She was always the person who
- 47:49knew what resources to try to tap into, whether it was
- 47:52psychologists or or other kind of play therapists,
- 47:56art therapists, that that that kind of thing. So when we asked her for advice,
- 47:59she was always an encyclopedia of of suggestions. And and, you
- 48:03know, I talk about her in my talks these days, and and I have a
- 48:06photo of her. I went I went to to her work on one of her
- 48:10last days at work. Maybe it was the last day. I don't know. I don't
- 48:12think it was the last day. She wasn't cleaning out her desk. And and I
- 48:15saw how well she was received. She was a counselor at a shelter for for
- 48:19women who had experienced domestic violence that in downtown Toronto, Robertson
- 48:22House. And she was well liked and she and she was a counselor's counselor. She
- 48:26was she was very good at juggling commitments and, you know, you could see
- 48:30her walking through the the the facility, which is residential as well
- 48:34as a treatment facility, and and having to kind of put
- 48:38out fires from, you know, from one end of the hallway to to another. And
- 48:41she hated, you know, that the root of the work that she did
- 48:45was relationships with women who had experienced domestic violence, helping them through a
- 48:49very difficult transition of their lives. And and,
- 48:53you know, it had morphed into outcomes. Treat them and street them. You
- 48:57know? Get them get them out in the street. Get them housing and get them
- 48:59out of here and get the next one in. And and she hated that, and
- 49:03and she she retired. And no sooner did she
- 49:07retire than she started showing signs of dementia, symptoms and signs of dementia.
- 49:10There was no time for me to feel how I felt, which was utter
- 49:14despair. Like this person who you think is going to be with you for the
- 49:18next 20 or 25 years, and you're going to raise your kids together
- 49:22and you're going to go you're going to go to to happy events
- 49:25together. You know, we had just buried our parents one after the
- 49:29other 2013, 2014. And by 2016, 2017,
- 49:32she just wasn't right. And, you know, her life after that was
- 49:36horrible. She lived in long term care for the last 14
- 49:40or 13 months of her life and last the last 7 months in a long
- 49:43term care facility. She lost her capacity for
- 49:47words, for speech. For a while, she had fluent aphasia where she
- 49:50would she would say sentences that made sense to her
- 49:54but made no sense to us. It was very hard to know what was on
- 49:58her mind. The last 4 syllable
- 50:01word that she uttered, I remember. She had a beloved caregiver who, you know,
- 50:05an outside caregiver who, was a PSW but was a nurse
- 50:09in the Philippines, became qualified as a nurse in Canada, and and we kept her
- 50:13on. You have this sense of accomplishment that you get
- 50:17a meal into into your loved one, which is ridiculous because if
- 50:20they're don't if they don't wanna be fed, then then the accomplishment is
- 50:24not the feeding, which is your way of making them live
- 50:28another day when they may not wanna live another she
- 50:31hated being fed by me. She actually didn't like being fed by Christine. So I
- 50:35was talking to her and I was empathizing with her. I said, you know, you
- 50:38don't like this. And I said, you're angry about this.
- 50:42And she mustered up the will to give a 4 syllable word to describe
- 50:46the predicament of being fed by 2 adults. The word was
- 50:50embarrassing. This this woman who used to be able to
- 50:54speak who could no longer speak 3 weeks before she died referred to
- 50:58being fed by me, by us, as embarrassing. In
- 51:02the last couple years of her life as I took over her affairs and became
- 51:05her power of attorney, I had to become the Joanne
- 51:09Whisperer. I had to be able to
- 51:14to try to provide emotional support for her. It was a
- 51:18really hard time. And it was only after she died that
- 51:22I first I mourned her her death and her absence,
- 51:25and then I realized I had never mourned her
- 51:29dying. You think that somebody with dementia might live another 2 or
- 51:333 years. You know, we got her into a long term care facility and then
- 51:362 months later, she was admitted to hospital with with aspiration
- 51:39pneumonia. And that was that's the beginning of the end. When you
- 51:43aspirate, it means you can no longer control food from going prevent
- 51:47it from going into your lungs. If that happens, you're at risk of
- 51:51choking to death at any time. You're at risk of aspiration pneumonia and
- 51:54fever and respiratory distress. She had all of that. We you know, the
- 51:58hospital treated her well enough that she eventually got back to the long term
- 52:01care, And we went through a number of episodes of
- 52:05aspiration. Then she got COVID
- 52:08and that was the end. And and I I didn't realize how
- 52:12much I was. I I how much despair I felt at
- 52:16being unable to stop this freight train, that this train was going to go over
- 52:20over the canyon, was going to fall into the canyon. You know, I
- 52:24guess as a physician, as an emergency physician, you know, I'm not
- 52:28I'm not a palliative care doc, that I'm always thinking there's a there's a there's
- 52:31always another solution. There's always another fix. And accepting the fact that there
- 52:35wasn't was really hard on me on that time. I'm better than I
- 52:39was when I wrote the article, but but I was despairing at being the last
- 52:42surviving member of my family and feeling that there was no more
- 52:46that that I no longer had somebody who knew what it was like when
- 52:50we grew up with our parents, what our relationship was really like, not
- 52:54the you know, not the projected image of our family that
- 52:57that's out there, but what how as we really are. Such a
- 53:01powerful story. And then I but I do wanna also get to I know I
- 53:05described you earlier as, Larry David, but I'm this new one is
- 53:09now Superman and Clark Kent. And, you know, there's this sort of
- 53:12Superman ER doctor at night compartmentalizing, and
- 53:16then Clark Kent, the journalist, the radio
- 53:19host of White Coat Black Art, CBC Radio 1,
- 53:23Podcaster. How important is it for you to have
- 53:27that left brain and right brain? Because the way you described yourself
- 53:30earlier on in life is, you know, science and mathematics and I think
- 53:34what the quote was, you know, he'd study for a blood test. And
- 53:38the emotive side of you that comes out when you're talking about
- 53:42the health care system and you're talking about, you know, even the
- 53:45changes, and why are we still handwritten notes and file cabinets that
- 53:49overflow. So tell me how both of these
- 53:53things happen inside one person because to
- 53:56me, the it really is 2 different very different
- 54:00careers. Yeah. And well, I, you know, I guess I guess the simplistic
- 54:04answer is that I made one feed into the other. I'm not complete
- 54:07without both. I don't want to leave the impression that that I just
- 54:11I'm just a fortunate person who can can dabble in a whole bunch of
- 54:15things, can can dabble in math and sciences and dabble in in in
- 54:18English and history and politics and and and all that and and all
- 54:22that kind of stuff. For too long, medicine has encompassed
- 54:26the left brain and not enough of the right brain. Although, remember, the right brain
- 54:30also is involved with visualization. And, you know, there are there are
- 54:34specialties and subspecialties of medicine, like radiology, that
- 54:37depend on the on the on the right brain. It's
- 54:41never all or nothing. I would
- 54:44say, you know, medicine should not only be
- 54:48practiced with the head, but with the heart. And that means empathizing.
- 54:52You know, we we have as as if you read the power of kindness,
- 54:57we are all, you know, evolution has gifted us with with
- 55:00the genetic heritage of being able to empathize with others. And that's how we
- 55:04build civilizations. That's how we take care of our families. That's how we take
- 55:08care of other people's kids. And without which we'd have
- 55:11killed each other. And and, you know, we have these giant frontal
- 55:15lobes that that are well equipped with the
- 55:19capacity for kindness and empathy, except when
- 55:22we are under unbelievable stress. The more
- 55:26we have stress torqued up in our society, the
- 55:30more that takes our frontal lobes offline, and
- 55:34we resort to our primitive reflexes. And in our primitive
- 55:37reflexes, we have, an uncanny ability to divide the world
- 55:41into us and them, into the self and the other,
- 55:45my friends and my enemies. And we and if you look around,
- 55:48that's what we're doing. That's what American politics is doing. That, you know, Canadian
- 55:52politics has not been that like that. We could be heading in the same direction,
- 55:56you know, where we fear the barbarians at the gate. We fear the we fear
- 55:59the immigrant because the immigrant's gonna come and take over and destroy our
- 56:03lives. You know, the stress that we're under, we're under
- 56:07security stress, we're under housing stress, economic
- 56:10stress. The answer to to to reviving
- 56:14our our natural tendency to empathy, to to be empathic and kind
- 56:18to others, is to address the stresses. And so societies
- 56:22that that that do a better job of taking care of people, redistributing wealth.
- 56:26It's not rocket science. That's the way to do it. That's what a kind society
- 56:29does. And the more you leave every person for themselves and
- 56:33speak disparagingly of people who are disadvantaged, the more
- 56:36that society is in trouble. For me, it why
- 56:40do I do it? Because it makes sense. Because it's the only way. It's the
- 56:44way that that I think I've become a better person. And
- 56:48by listening to that inner voice, by and and that inner voice isn't coming
- 56:51from isn't coming from my left brain. That, you know, that voice, I've often said
- 56:55that it was a guardian angel that made me sleep in that morning and miss
- 56:59rounds. You could also argue that it finally became
- 57:02evident to me and that I needed a dramatic gesture as an
- 57:06exit, as an exit from from from a
- 57:10plan that was would have been disastrous. I I just think you're not a you're
- 57:13not a complete person if you don't have both. I always wrap up my
- 57:17show with my 3 takeaways. And you've
- 57:21offered so many gems. But I think the first one
- 57:24is just something you just talked about and something we should all be paying
- 57:28more attention to that the more stress we are
- 57:31under or we feel the world is under, the less
- 57:35empathetic we are. We become much more of a divide and conquer
- 57:39society. And I think that's just a powerful insight, and
- 57:43I think those insights come from my second takeaway from you, which is was at
- 57:46the beginning of the show where you said, I like to follow the bread
- 57:49crumbs. I like to go deeper than the surface.
- 57:54I like to listen generously. I like to observe. And
- 57:57I think that's another powerful lesson for us because if we just get caught up
- 58:01in this snackable content and these these these roar of
- 58:05negativity coming at us, we are just gonna continue to hide with what
- 58:08we think is our within our comfort zone and attack those
- 58:12that we feel don't belong there. And then the the final one is just
- 58:16the the importance of feeling the pain, whether it's
- 58:19mistakes you make, people that you lose along the way,
- 58:24situations that happen to you that, you know, when people just say, you
- 58:28know, buckle up, slap you in the back and say, get over it, it it's
- 58:31the wrong advice. The more most important thing you need to do is to
- 58:35feel that pain, embrace it,
- 58:39maybe even learn from it. You've offered so much today,
- 58:43in the show, and I can certainly understand why you are
- 58:47as talented you are with your show White Coat, Black Art, what did your
- 58:51podcast to dose. I'll put links to both. I'm gonna put links to the TED
- 58:54Talk, which I listened to every word of it. I haven't read Power of Kindness
- 58:57yet, Kindness yet, but I'm gonna now. And, I just wanna thank you for being
- 59:01part of Chatter That Matters. Well, thank you, Tony. You know, you've had you
- 59:04you've conducted some great conversations, and, you know, certainly, you've
- 59:08interviewed some people who've had even more dramatic stories than I have.
- 59:11And, thank you for doing what you're doing. My name is Brian Goldman.
- 59:17I am a redefined physician. I'm human.
- 59:21I make mistakes. I'm sorry about that. But I strive to learn
- 59:24one thing that I can pass on to other people.
- 59:28I do remember.
- 59:35Joining me now is Leanne Kaufmann, the president and CEO of RBC
- 59:39Royal Trust. Leanne's made several appearances on my
- 59:42show, and I often go to her when it comes to
- 59:46matters of life and money. Leanne, welcome back to Chatter That Matters.
- 59:50It's great to be back, Tony. Thanks for having me. Now, you've got a big
- 59:54title, and it's obviously attached to RBC Royal Trust. But what
- 59:58I I'm most fascinated about is some of your posts
- 1:00:01in recent weeks and some of your adventures in recent
- 1:00:05months, all about aging well. So talk to me
- 1:00:09about why is that a passion of yours, and what does that have to
- 1:00:13do with RBC Royal Trust? Well, I mean, on a personal note, of course,
- 1:00:17we should all be concerned about aging well. And I'm
- 1:00:20over 50, so I've got a selfish vested interest in this.
- 1:00:24But from a from a business perspective, Royal Trust, given
- 1:00:28that we act as corporate executor, corporate power of attorney, we
- 1:00:32we've always dealt with people in in later stages of
- 1:00:35life and end of life. You know, it's a natural
- 1:00:39fit, especially with the demographics that we're seeing.
- 1:00:43People are living longer. There's more and more people living to a
- 1:00:46100 and beyond, but it doesn't necessarily mean that they're living
- 1:00:49well. And, we just wanted to start bringing
- 1:00:53attention to this issue for people my age and
- 1:00:57older to really, you know, make sure they're able
- 1:01:01to maximize. You know, and selfishly, I actually benefit from it on
- 1:01:04Chatter That Matters because you're always meeting these really interesting people
- 1:01:08and suggesting that they would make great guests. And one of them, obviously, is my
- 1:01:12guest on this episode, Brian Goldman. Why do you feel
- 1:01:16what he's doing is is of importance to
- 1:01:20Canadians as we look through the passing of time? Generally, of
- 1:01:24course, doctor Goldman's, you know, had a public voice for a long
- 1:01:27time around all things related to health and medicine and
- 1:01:32and making it really accessible for the general public.
- 1:01:35But he's also been very public about his own caregiving
- 1:01:39journey, looking after his sister. He's been focused on
- 1:01:43issues related to powers of attorney and the legal
- 1:01:47side of and and caregiving side of,
- 1:01:50of these journeys as well. So I know that he is just
- 1:01:54an advocate. He's he's a great, speaker when it comes
- 1:01:59to all things medical, makes them very consumable, but also speaks
- 1:02:02from a place of personal experience and lived experience. A lot of
- 1:02:06this is about matters at the heart, caring for others, caring for
- 1:02:10ourselves. You also talked a little bit about money
- 1:02:13matters. And I just wanna close this part of the show with
- 1:02:17any advice you can give to people, because we tend to think
- 1:02:21that we're immortal. We tend to put off a lot of the dotting
- 1:02:24i's and crossing t's. But if there's 1 or 2 thoughts you can leave
- 1:02:28my audience with in terms of getting your money matters in
- 1:02:32order so that you can focus on what really matters, your health. What would
- 1:02:36those thoughts be? Well, it all comes back to planning and whether that's
- 1:02:39planning for your your health, planning for how
- 1:02:43you're going to live your life in your later years, wealth
- 1:02:47is part of that because, you know, your your finances are
- 1:02:50inextricably linked to some of the choices and and goals that
- 1:02:54you'll have. And so most people don't spend a lot of time thinking
- 1:02:58about, you know, their final chapter, where they might be living,
- 1:03:02what their caregiving requirements might be. And but they you know,
- 1:03:06we we really want people to do that and to factor this in as part
- 1:03:09of their personal planning, their financial planning, and then ultimately,
- 1:03:14their estate planning to make sure that they're setting their loved ones that they're
- 1:03:18leaving behind up for success. You know, Leanne, I can be
- 1:03:21personal testament to that because someone very close to
- 1:03:25me did leave us sooner than we imagined. You know, as you're dealing with
- 1:03:29personal grief, having to deal with these money matters was something that
- 1:03:33no one asked for, nobody wanted. And quite honestly, no one had any idea
- 1:03:37what to do about it. So sage advice for all, and I appreciate you joining
- 1:03:40me in Chatter That Matters. It's always a pleasure. Thanks for having me.
- 1:03:44Chatter That Matters has been a presentation of RBC. It's Tony
- 1:03:47Chapman. Thanks for listening. Let's chat soon.