Latest / Epic Fury: The US-Iran War Podcast / Iran War Day 44: No Deal After 21-Hour Talks, Hormuz Crisis and Vance Warning
Transcript
- 0:1621 hours. That is how long the Islamabad
- 0:20talks lasted. From Saturday morning through
- 0:22the night and into Sunday's early hours.
- 0:24American and Iranian negotiators sat in the Serena Hotel while
- 0:28Pakistani officials shuttle between them and eventually
- 0:31beside them as the proximity format gave way to direct face
- 0:35to face contact. The highest level US Iran
- 0:38engagement in 47 years. Technical papers were exchanged
- 0:42and reviewed repeatedly. 5 major issue areas were discussed.
- 0:46The sun went down and came up again.
- 0:49And then just after 7:00 in the morning local time on Sunday, JD
- 0:52Vance walked out, held a brief press conference and boarded Air
- 0:56Force 2 for Washington. No deal, final offer left on the
- 1:00table, The two week ceasefire technically still in place and
- 1:05the question of what comes next with no clear answer.
- 1:09It is Sunday, April 12th, 2026, day 44 of Operation Epic Fury.
- 1:16The Islamabad talks are over. The war has not ended.
- 1:20The ceasefire continues for now with 9 days left on the clock.
- 1:25And Vance said departing Pakistan with Kushner and
- 1:27Witkoff at his side. I think that is bad news for
- 1:30Iran much more than it is bad news for the United States of
- 1:33America. We left the final offer on the
- 1:36table. We will see what they do with
- 1:38it. This is episode 44 of Epic Fury,
- 1:42the US Iran War podcast. Follow on Spotify and Apple
- 1:47Podcast to stay with this story as it develops.
- 1:50Let's get into it. Start with what the 21 hours
- 1:53actually produced because something did happen in that
- 1:56hotel, even if a deal did not emerge from it.
- 1:59The talks began as proximity talks, 2 delegations in separate
- 2:03rooms, Pakistani officials carrying messages between them.
- 2:07Within hours, according to Al Jazeera sources close to the
- 2:10mediation, that format shifted. The two teams moved to direct
- 2:14negotiations with Pakistani mediators present in the room
- 2:18alongside both delegations. That transition from indirect to
- 2:23direct is significant in itself. The US and Iran have spent 47
- 2:28years not sitting in the same room.
- 2:30The last time American and Iranian officials of comparable
- 2:33seniority were in direct diplomatic contact was during
- 2:36the Carter administration, in the earliest stages of the 1979
- 2:40hostage crisis, before those channels collapsed entirely.
- 2:44The fact that Vance and Arachi were in the same space,
- 2:47exchanging positions directly for hours across the full range
- 2:51of substantive issues is the first such encounter at that
- 2:54level since the 1979 Islamic Revolution.
- 2:58It did not produce a deal. It produced something rarer in
- 3:02US Iran diplomacy. The direct conversation.
- 3:05That conversation has now happened.
- 3:08It cannot be undone. And whatever comes next, renewed
- 3:11bombing, ceasefire extension or a revised Iranian response to
- 3:15the US final offer will be built on the precedent that direct
- 3:18engagement at this level is possible.
- 3:21During those 21 hours, both sides exchanged technical papers
- 3:24and reviewed them repeatedly, according to CNN's reporters on
- 3:28the ground who watched the sun go down in Islamabad and then
- 3:31come up again as the marathon talks continued.
- 3:34The Iranian Foreign Ministry confirmed that intensive
- 3:37negotiations continued uninterrupted until the early
- 3:39hours, covering the Strait of Hormuz, the nuclear issue, war
- 3:43reparations, lifting of sanctions and what Iran
- 3:46described as the complete end to the war against Iran and in the
- 3:49region. The breadth of that list, five
- 3:52major issue areas discussed in a single session, suggest that the
- 3:55talks were substantive rather than merely procedural.
- 3:59The two sides were not arguing about whether to talk.
- 4:03They were arguing about the substance of what a deal would
- 4:05contain. The substance is where the talks
- 4:08collapsed. Vance was direct about the
- 4:10central sticking point. He said he would not get into
- 4:14the full details, but that the US needed a firm commitment from
- 4:17Iran that it would not seek a nuclear weapon.
- 4:20Iran was unwilling to give that commitment.
- 4:23Iranian state media, through Tiznim News Agency, blamed the
- 4:26failure on what it described as US overreach and excessive
- 4:30demands, specifically citing the removal of nuclear materials
- 4:33from the country and the reopening of the Strait of
- 4:35Hormuz as the two points that Iran could not accept on
- 4:38American terms. Iran's position on the nuclear
- 4:41question is rooted in a strategic calculation that
- 4:44predates this war and will outlast it.
- 4:47Iran's nuclear program is not simply a weapons development
- 4:50project. It is the foundational deterrent
- 4:52that Iran's leadership believes is the only reliable guarantee
- 4:55against future military action by the United States and Israel.
- 4:59The logic is the specific lesson that Iran's leadership draws
- 5:02from the fates of Muammar Gaddafi and Saddam Hussein,
- 5:05leaders who gave up their weapons programs and were
- 5:08subsequently removed from power by Western military force.
- 5:12From that perspective, agreeing to permanently abandoned all
- 5:15nuclear capability is not a concession that ends a war.
- 5:18It is a concession that makes the next war easier for the
- 5:21other side. Whether that strategic logic is
- 5:24correct in the current context, given that Iran's military has
- 5:28just been devastated by 44 days of the most intensive American
- 5:31air campaign since 2003, is debatable.
- 5:35But it is the logic that the Iranian delegation carried into
- 5:38Islamabad. Those two issues, give up your
- 5:41nuclear program entirely and reopen the waterway you have
- 5:44been using as your primary strategic leverage are precisely
- 5:48the two things the United States defined as non negotiable from
- 5:51the beginning. The gap that existed before the
- 5:54Islamabad talks began still exists after they ended.
- 5:57Vance called the US offer quite flexible and described it as the
- 6:01final and best offer the United States would make.
- 6:04He said he was leaving the proposal on the table for Iran
- 6:07to accept. He said Iran had chosen not to
- 6:10accept US terms. He said the US team had been at
- 6:14it for 21 hours and had a number of substantive discussions.
- 6:18And then he said, so we go back to the United States, having not
- 6:21come to an agreement. It was a measured professional
- 6:24statement of failure or of deferred success, depending on
- 6:28how the next 9 days unfold. Delivered at a press conference
- 6:31in the early morning light in Islamabad, with Kushner and
- 6:34Witkoff flanking him before he climbed the stairs of Air Force
- 6:372 and departed, Iran's Foreign Ministry said it was studying
- 6:41the US position and that its response would come through
- 6:44appropriate channels. That is not a rejection, that is
- 6:48a delay. And in the 9 remaining days of
- 6:51the ceasefire window, delays may be the most significant form of
- 6:55diplomacy still available. There is a further dimension to
- 6:58what the 21 hours produced that goes beyond the negotiating
- 7:02deadlock. two US Navy guided missile destroyers, the USS
- 7:06Frank E Peterson and the USS Michael Murphy, transited the
- 7:10Strait of Hormuz on Saturday while the Islamabad talks were
- 7:13underway. CENTCOM confirmed they were
- 7:15conducting operations as part of broader mission to clear sea
- 7:18mines previously laid by Iran's Islamic Revolutionary Guard
- 7:22Corps. This is the first transit of
- 7:24American warships through the Strait of Hormuz since the war
- 7:27began 44 days ago. The significance extends beyond
- 7:32the symbolic Iran laid mines in the Strait during the conflict
- 7:36as a physical enforcement mechanism for its blockade.
- 7:39Those mines represent an ongoing threat to commercial shipping.
- 7:42Even after the ceasefire, tankers cannot transit a
- 7:45waterway that may be mined, regardless of whether the IRGC
- 7:48is actively attacking them. the US mine clearing operation,
- 7:52conducted simultaneously with a diplomacy in Islamabad, is doing
- 7:56two things at once. It is physically restoring the
- 8:00conditions under which commercial shipping can operate,
- 8:03and it is establishing the American position that the
- 8:05Strait is an international waterway that the US Navy will
- 8:08clear and open regardless of what Iran says about its
- 8:11sovereignty over transit protocols.
- 8:13That is coercive diplomacy and military positioning executed in
- 8:17parallel, which is how the Trump administration has conducted
- 8:20this entire conflict from its first day.
- 8:23Trump, speaking to reporters before departing from Miami on
- 8:26Saturday, was characteristically emphatic about the outcome.
- 8:31He said regardless what happens, we win.
- 8:33He said the US had totally defeated Iran.
- 8:36He said whether we make a deal or not makes no difference to
- 8:40me. And when asked if he was hopeful
- 8:42about the talks, he replied whatever, otherwise we'll reset.
- 8:47We're ready to go. That commentary, whatever,
- 8:50otherwise we'll reset. Is Trump setting the domestic
- 8:53political table for what comes next with the specific
- 8:56architecture of a president who cannot lose?
- 8:59If Iran accepts the final offer, Trump announces A historic deal
- 9:03and takes full credit. If the ceasefire expires without
- 9:06a deal and bombing restarts, Trump can point to 21 hours of
- 9:10good faith negotiation, a flexible final offer that Iran
- 9:14refused. In Iran that chose war over the
- 9:16reasonable terms. Washington put on the table the
- 9:19framing of Iranian obstinacy. They had their chance. the US
- 9:23was more than accommodating. Iran chose not to is politically
- 9:26available to Trump regardless of what actually happened in those
- 9:29rooms. Reset is not the language of
- 9:32escalation. It is the language of
- 9:34restarting. The specific framing that allows
- 9:37the war to restart without Trump having to describe it as a
- 9:40failure of diplomacy. Whether that framing is accurate
- 9:43to the facts of the Islamabad talks is a separate question
- 9:47from whether it will be effective as a political
- 9:49narrative based on the 1st 44 days of this conflict.
- 9:53The answer to the second question is almost certainly
- 9:55yes. The ceasefire's technical status
- 9:58as a Sunday morning is that it remains in place.
- 10:01Vance did not announce that the ceasefire was over.
- 10:05He did not announce that bombing would restart.
- 10:08He announced that no deal had been reached and that the US
- 10:11team was going home. The two week window that began
- 10:14on Tuesday, April 7th expires on Tuesday, April 21st.
- 10:19There are 9 days remaining. Those nine days will unfold in a
- 10:23specific political context that shapes what is possible.
- 10:27Trump is heading to Miami and has publicly declared
- 10:30indifference to the outcome of the talks.
- 10:32The Iranian supreme leader must decide whether the written US
- 10:35final offer contains anything worth responding to, and whether
- 10:39responding to it publicly constitutes a capitulation that
- 10:42his domestic narrative, a victory, cannot absorb.
- 10:45The IRGC must decide whether to continue its drone operations
- 10:48against Gulf states in ways that further erode the ceasefire's
- 10:51credibility. The Strait must be progressively
- 10:54cleared of mines and reopened to commercial traffic before the
- 10:57ceasefire expires or the economic rationale for the
- 11:01ceasefire evaporates. And the world's oil markets must
- 11:04decide, in the absence of a deal, how to price the
- 11:07probability that the ceasefire expires without renewal and the
- 11:11bombing restarts on April 21st. Whether those nine days produce
- 11:15a revised Iranian response to the US final offer, an extension
- 11:18of the ceasefire under a new framework or a return to
- 11:21military operations is the question that defines what this
- 11:24war's next phase looks like. Galabaf, for his part, had
- 11:28signaled before the talks began that Iran's experience with
- 11:31American negotiations had always been met with failure and broken
- 11:34promises. That framing, setting up the
- 11:37expectation of failure before entering the room, is the
- 11:40standard Iranian posture in high stakes diplomacy with the United
- 11:44States, designed to lower domestic expectations and
- 11:47preserve political space for walking away without being
- 11:50blamed. Whether the Iranian delegation
- 11:52went to Islamabad genuinely prepared to make concessions on
- 11:55the nuclear question that their public framing made impossible
- 11:57to acknowledge, or whether the talks were always destined to
- 12:00end as they did, is a question that will be debated by Iran
- 12:04analysts for years. There are reasons to believe the
- 12:07Iranian side was not simply performing for domestic
- 12:10consumption. Arachi told reporters in
- 12:12Islamabad that he wanted to speak with European counterparts
- 12:15in Berlin, Paris and London, suggesting he is thinking beyond
- 12:19this round of talks to a broader diplomatic architecture that
- 12:22involves the European parties to the original JCPOA.
- 12:26Iran has also indicated that it will accept an extension of the
- 12:29ceasefire if the US makes movement on the issues that
- 12:32matter to Tehran. The Iranian rial slightly gained
- 12:35on Saturday and the Tehran Stock Exchange rose 2.16%.
- 12:40Small market signals that Iranian investors believe some
- 12:43kind of agreement is still possible.
- 12:45Pro government newspaper Kahan claimed Iran had the upper hand
- 12:49and that nuclear disarmament was impossible, which is the hard
- 12:52line position. But the fact that Common A
- 12:54specifically told the supporters not to protest or insult the
- 12:58talks is notable. It suggests the Supreme leader
- 13:00was giving the diplomatic process space rather than
- 13:03mobilizing domestic opposition to it.
- 13:05What is observable is that the Iranian delegation of 70 people
- 13:09with technical experts in nuclear, economic and security
- 13:12fields spent 21 hours in detailed, substantive
- 13:16discussions. That does not look like a side
- 13:18that came to Islamabad to perform failure.
- 13:21The talks moved from proximity to direct engagement, suggesting
- 13:25that at some point both sides concluded the mediated format
- 13:28was insufficient for the complexity of what they were
- 13:30trying to negotiate. That is progress of a kind to
- 13:34countries that have not spoken directly in 47 years, deciding
- 13:37they need to speak directly to get anything done.
- 13:40The problem is that direct engagement revealed the gap more
- 13:43clearly, not less. In a proximity format, Pakistan
- 13:47can smooth over the sharpest edges of each side's position
- 13:50before delivering it to the other room.
- 13:53In a direct session, Vance and Arachi hear each other's
- 13:56positions unmediated, and what they heard apparently, was
- 14:00irreconcilable. CN NS reporters described the
- 14:04two sides as too far apart, not just in substance but in style
- 14:08and temperament. the US delegation was looking for a
- 14:10relatively quick solution, a framework that could be
- 14:13finalized in the two week ceasefire window.
- 14:16Iran typically negotiates over the long term, building position
- 14:20and precedent across multiple sessions, refusing to be rushed,
- 14:24treating every concession as a strategic decision requiring
- 14:27internal consultation and supreme leader approval.
- 14:31Those two negotiating cultures, the American instinct for
- 14:34transactional closure and the Iranian instinct for protracted
- 14:37process, have been the source of failure in every US Iran
- 14:41diplomatic encounter of the past quarter century.
- 14:44Where that leaves the ceasefire and what the next 9 days will
- 14:47produce is genuinely uncertain. Vance left a written final
- 14:52offer. Iran has it.
- 14:54The ceasefire is still in place. The Strait is still partly
- 14:58closed, but the US mine clearing operation is underway.
- 15:02Trump says he does not care whether a deal happens.
- 15:05The IRGC is still conducting drone operations against Gulf
- 15:09states in ways that contradict the ceasefire's terms.
- 15:12And somewhere in Tehran, Common A and the Supreme National
- 15:16Security Council are deciding whether to accept, reject or
- 15:19counter propose to whatever Vance left on the table in the
- 15:22Serena Hotel. The one thing that did not
- 15:25happen in Islamabad is the thing that defines what the Islamabad
- 15:28talks ultimately mean. A deal did not happen, but a
- 15:32direct conversation between American and Iranian officials
- 15:36at the vice presidential level for 21 hours on the full range
- 15:40of issues that divide the two countries is something that has
- 15:42not happened since 1979. Whether that conversation plants
- 15:46the seeds of something that grows in the 9 remaining
- 15:49ceasefire days, or whether it's simply demonstrates that the
- 15:52seeds cannot grow in the current political soil is a question
- 15:55that only the next 9 days can answer. the US left a written
- 15:59final offer on the table in Islamabad.
- 16:02The offer is there. Iran has it.
- 16:05Whatever common 8 decides to do with it in the next 9 days is
- 16:08now the hinge of this war. If he accepts, the deal happens.
- 16:13If he rejects, the ceasefire expires and the bombs return.
- 16:17If he counter proposes, a new round of diplomacy begins in
- 16:20whatever time and venue is available before April 21st.
- 16:25Those are the three pass. All of them remained open this
- 16:28Sunday morning and this podcast will be here to cover whichever
- 16:33one Iran chooses. The international reaction to
- 16:36the Islamabad outcome was swift and measured.
- 16:39Russia called for restraint from all parties and urged a
- 16:42responsible approach, expressing hope for the success of the
- 16:45talks even as they ended without agreement.
- 16:48France's Macron said he had urged Iranian President
- 16:51Poseskian to use the negotiations to achieve lasting
- 16:54de escalation and work toward broader regional security.
- 16:57The European framing, both Russia's and France's, is
- 17:01notable for what it does not say.
- 17:03Neither characterized the outcome as a failure, both left
- 17:07open in the possibility of continue process.
- 17:10The diplomatic language of hope and continued engagement is the
- 17:14international community's way of keeping a door open that Vance
- 17:17walked out of on Sunday morning. For the Gulf States, Saudi
- 17:21Arabia, the UAE, Kuwait, Qatar and Bahrain, the outcome of
- 17:25Islamabad is alarming in a specific way. 9 days remain on
- 17:29the ceasefire clock. If the ceasefire expires on
- 17:32April 21st without renewal and if US bombing of Iran restarts,
- 17:37Iranian strikes against Gulf infrastructure will begin again
- 17:40alongside it. The Gulf states have been
- 17:43absorbing Iranian attacks for 44 days.
- 17:46They did not start this war. They cannot end it and the
- 17:50prospect of another cycle of escalation, this time without
- 17:54the 12 day shock of the opening campaign but with the
- 17:57accumulated damage of 44 days of prior strikes already in the
- 18:00infrastructure, is not a prospect that any Gulf
- 18:03government is welcoming. For global energy markets, the
- 18:06outcome of Islamabad means the Strait of Hormuz remains a
- 18:09geopolitical risk asset rather than a cleared waterway.
- 18:13The mine clearing operation by the two US destroyers is a
- 18:16beginning, not an end. Full commercial restart requires
- 18:20weeks of clearing operations, insurance market stabilization
- 18:24and the kind of Iranian cooperation on transit protocols
- 18:27that Islamabad did not produce. The 13% oil price drop on
- 18:31Tuesday night was built on the expectation of a ceasefire that
- 18:34produced a deal. The reality of a ceasefire that
- 18:37produced no deal and a final offer that is sitting unanswered
- 18:41in a Serena hotel room in Islamabad is a different
- 18:43economic picture. Oil markets on Monday morning
- 18:47will price that difference. If this podcast is helping you
- 18:50make sense of what is happening, please take 30 seconds to leave
- 18:53a review on Spotify or Apple Podcasts.
- 18:56It makes an enormous difference to how many people find a shell.
- 19:00For Vance personally, the outcome of Islamabad is more
- 19:03complex than a simple failure. He spent 21 hours in the most
- 19:07consequential diplomatic engagement of his career.
- 19:11He led the United States into direct talks with Iran for the
- 19:14first time in 47 years. He left a written final offer, a
- 19:18concrete document that defines the American position and that
- 19:21Iran must now respond to. He said the US was quite
- 19:25accommodating and made its best effort in good faith.
- 19:29Whether that narrative holds, whether the Islamabad talks are
- 19:32remembered as a good faith American effort that Iran
- 19:34refused, or as an American overcorrection that demanded too
- 19:37much and got nothing, depends on what Iran does with the offer
- 19:41over the next 9 days and on how the war's next phase unfolds if
- 19:44the ceasefire expires. This has been episode 44 of Epic
- 19:48Fury, the US Iran War Podcast Day 4421.
- 19:54Hours of talks. The sun went down and came up in
- 19:57Islamabad and still no deal emerged.
- 20:00A final written offer is on the table.
- 20:03A mind clearing operation is underway in the Strait, Trump
- 20:07says. Whatever we reset 9 days left on
- 20:10the ceasefire clock. Common A has the document.
- 20:14We will be back very soon.