Latest / Creative Women: Artists, Writers, Musicians & Makers / The Music in the Dust: Playing Piano on a Broken Upright in an Abandoned School | Creative Women
Transcript
- There is a specific kind of silence that only exists in rooms where time has stopped moving forward. It’s not empty, though; it’s waiting. I want you to picture this with me. You are standing at the edge of a room that hasn’t seen sunlight in years. The air smells like wet paper and old glue. It’s that heavy, dusty scent that sticks to the back of your throat. And there, in the corner, half-swallowed by shadows and peeling wallpaper, sits a piano. It’s not a grand. It’s not even a decent upright anymore. It’s broken. One leg is missing, so it leans slightly to the left, as if bowing to someone who isn’t there. The keys are yellowed, some missing entirely, leaving jagged holes in the row like teeth lost to time. Most people would walk past it. They’d see neglect. They’d see decay. But you… you stop. You feel that pull in your chest, don’t you? That quiet, irresistible urge to sit down and press one key just to hear what sound still lives inside. Let’s sit with that for a second. Why do we feel drawn to broken things? Especially when those things were once vessels for joy. This piano wasn’t always abandoned. It belonged to a school, maybe in the seventies or eightens. It was played during assembly lines, during talent shows, during rainy afternoons when children needed a place to be loud without being told to be quiet. Now, the wood has warped. The felt hammers have hardened into stone. When you finally lift the lid, it doesn’t open smoothly; it resists. It groans. And when you press middle C, it doesn’t ring out clear and bright. It thuds. It coughs. It sounds like a ghost trying to remember how to speak. But it’s still music. It’s imperfect, distorted, and utterly alive. There is something deeply human about that. We spend so much of our lives chasing perfect tone, perfect execution, perfect presentation. But here, in this abandoned classroom, perfection is impossible. And yet, the act of playing becomes more honest because of it. I remember sitting at one of these pianos last autumn. My hands hovered over the keys, trembling slightly, not from cold, but from reverence. I thought about all the little fingers that had pressed these same ivory squares decades ago. Did they practice scales? Did they play songs they loved? Did they cry over difficult passages? I closed my eyes and let my fingers find their way through a simple melody. I didn’t try to make it sound good. I just let it happen. The notes were off-key, some deadened, others ringing too long. But the rhythm remained. The structure held. And in that messiness, I found a strange comfort. It reminded me that creation doesn’t require pristine conditions. It requires presence. You don’t need a Steinway to make art. You just need to show up and engage with the instrument exactly as it is, flaws and all. That’s the lesson the abandoned school is whispering to us. We often forget that instruments are labor. They are built by hands, tuned by ears, maintained by patience. When a piano breaks, it’s not just an object failing; it’s a relationship ending. But even in its end, it retains dignity. It asks nothing of us except to acknowledge it. To listen to what it can still offer. I think about the teachers who once sat at this bench. They weren’t professionals. They were likely tired, underpaid, overwhelmed by administrative burdens and behavioral challenges. Yet, they showed up every day to teach these kids that beauty could be made from vibration and tension. That’s a radical act. In a world that demands instant gratification and flawless output, showing up imperfectly is revolutionary. It’s okay if your work is cracked. It’s okay if your voice shakes. The music is still happening. The effort is still valid. Tell me more about that moment when you first realized your own imperfections were not failures, but invitations. How did it change the way you create? For me, playing that broken piano was a surrender. I stopped trying to control the outcome. I stopped worrying about whether the neighbor would complain or whether the recording would capture the nuance. I just listened. And listening changed everything. I heard the creak of the bench. I heard the wind rattling the windowpane. I heard the silence between the notes. Those silences were not empty; they were full of history. They were filled with the echoes of everyone who had ever sat in that chair. By acknowledging the breakage, I opened myself to a deeper connection with the material. It wasn’t about fixing the piano. It was about letting the piano fix me, or at least, remind me of what matters. What remains when the polish wears away? Back in my twenties, chasing gallery openings and one-act plays, I thought the magic was in the premiere. I wanted the applause, the critique, the validation. But I’ve learned since then that the real magic happens in the quiet hours before the curtain rises. Or in the dusty corners of abandoned schools after the bell has rung for the last time. It’s in those unobserved moments that we connect most deeply with our craft. There is no audience to perform for. No algorithm to please. Just you and the work. And sometimes, the work is broken. Sometimes, the tools are insufficient. But that’s where the intimacy lives. That’s where the truth hides. When you strip away the spectacle, you’re left with the core of why you started making things in the first place. Not for fame, not for money, but because you have to. Because the song inside you needs a body, even if that body is cracked and leaning to the left. Thank you for sitting in the dust with me today. Keep playing, even if the keys are sticky. Even if the sound is rough. Especially then. Until next time, keep creating beautifully. Bye for now.