Latest / Film And Whiskey / Top Fives: Silent Movies for Beginners
Transcript
- 0:00So, here's the deal everybody. We just absolutely love
- 0:03producing as much content as possible for film and whiskey
- 0:07Nation. But if our regular episodes
- 0:09aren't enough for you, then you can head on over to patreon.com
- 0:13film whiskey sign up for one of our memberships and you will get
- 0:16a slew of extra content for your listening.
- 0:19Pleasure, check us out on patreon.com film, whiskey,
- 0:24welcome into the film whiskey podcasts, everybody.
- 0:27Today, we will be discussing the director cha Oral surgery.
- 0:31Carl's Chaplin and scoring him out as every single director
- 0:35loves for people to do. Then we're going to be trying
- 0:38five whiskies and throw it over to an interview with our friend,
- 0:42Mariah Gates. As she gives her top five,
- 0:45silent movies for beginners. This is the film and whiskey
- 0:51podcast. Hey everybody.
- 1:09Welcome into the film and whiskey podcast.
- 1:12I'm Bob book, I'm Brad G. And today Brad, it is time for
- 1:16us to score out. Charlie Chaplin on the four
- 1:20movies that we watched from him. If you're new to the podcast,
- 1:23we've been doing this thing for the bat, the past two seasons.
- 1:26We watch a number of movies by a given director and then we take
- 1:30those movies and we pass them through a five-point metric to
- 1:33figure out numerically mathematically.
- 1:36How good of a director are you Brad?
- 1:38If there's one thing I've learned about art, it's that
- 1:41passing it through a mathematical metric is the way
- 1:43to evaluate it easily. Yeah.
- 1:46It's by far the best way to do it.
- 1:48I don't know why. When you go to like art museums
- 1:51they don't have like scoring karna story.
- 1:54Yeah, scoring cards for you to fill out and then Unlike, you
- 1:57know, maybe like attached two or three professional critics cards
- 2:01like underneath each painting or sculpture so you can kind of
- 2:05compare and contrast, what how you think about it?
- 2:08Versus what they think? The thing is, as much as I'm
- 2:10saying, this is a joke, there's part of me that's like oh I
- 2:12would actually kind of enjoy that.
- 2:14Yeah, I would have waited till I saw like the Post-it note that
- 2:17someone wrote next to a Picasso. That's like it's too blue or
- 2:20something. You don't mean.
- 2:24All right Brad. Let's talk about this metric.
- 2:26So we established this. Five-point metric last season in
- 2:29a bonus episode. When we tried to establish, like
- 2:32what makes a good director? What are the things that when
- 2:35you talk about, somebody being good at directing movies that
- 2:39they're actually good at doing and we try to break these down
- 2:42into five distinct categories. Brad can you remind our
- 2:45listeners of what those categories are?
- 2:47And what they mean? Performances are how good at
- 2:51directing actors and actresses, is this director cinematography
- 2:55is, What do I see on the screen? And how much is it Pleasant and
- 3:00attractive and work with what he's trying to do editing is
- 3:04sound and visual. So the cutting of the film, you
- 3:09know, when you think about the Lord of the Rings, when you
- 3:13think about The Good, the Bad and the Ugly, like the the
- 3:16movement from scene to scene, is different in these movies like
- 3:19and who does it the best? Cohesion is how well does the
- 3:23film stick together. And this can be story-wise.
- 3:26It can be acting, it can be editing.
- 3:28But like all together, how much does the film have consistency?
- 3:33And then finally uniqueness and this is looking at the director
- 3:36and saying, you know, within the pantheon of all films and then
- 3:40also, like, within his contemporaries.
- 3:43How unique are you what, what ideas are you bringing to the
- 3:47table that are unique? What camera movements are you
- 3:50using? That are unique ha, how much can
- 3:52I say, you know, watch a scene from a film and immediately go.
- 3:56Oh, that's that's David Lynch or oh, that is Billy Wilder with,
- 4:01you know, just at the drop of a hat.
- 4:03How unique are they nicely? Done?
- 4:05Sir. Well thanks man.
- 4:07And I'm pretty happy with that. Without further Ado, folks,
- 4:10let's talk about Charles Spencer Chaplin Brad.
- 4:13I was a little bit taken aback at.
- 4:17I don't want to say the, the Met response that you had to
- 4:20chaplain because I think it was largely positive, but you were
- 4:23not as over the moon for chaplain, as I thought you might
- 4:26be I just find his movies to be an utter delight and they work
- 4:31from people from ages, you know, 32 103 and they did not work on
- 4:38you as effectively as I thought they would.
- 4:41I mean, what he is known for and like, famous for worked for me,
- 4:47like his true silent film era. The one movie that was filmed
- 4:53and directed in a time where all the movies were silent.
- 4:56Teams worked for me, 100%. I was in it was the movies that
- 5:01he made when silent films were into thing anymore and he was
- 5:05still sticking to it or, you know, the Great Dictator his
- 5:08first foray into talkies. That's what I just I just wasn't
- 5:13as impressed with him as a director so I don't know man.
- 5:17I'm going to put this back in the ball, back in your court and
- 5:19say maybe you should have picked better movies.
- 5:22I will say, I have gotten multiple people.
- 5:26Writing to me saying, I can't believe how wrong Brad was about
- 5:31The Great Dictator in particular.
- 5:32The great like not modern times, not City Lights, people really
- 5:36seem to like The Great Dictator and they really seem to not like
- 5:39you as a result. Well what was it?
- 5:42The Great Dictator or the fact that I don't like Ikea that
- 5:45really got people. I'm great that's all I'm really
- 5:48push people over the edge. Like I started them off there
- 5:52and just push them off the edge, with my take on the movie.
- 5:54And so they just lumped me in As a terrible person.
- 5:59All right man, let's talk about the performances in Chaplin's
- 6:02movies. I think that if there's anywhere
- 6:05well there's a couple other categories but I think if
- 6:07there's anywhere that he's really going to shine, it's
- 6:10going to be in directing actors including himself.
- 6:13We've talked about that iconic final shot of City Lights where
- 6:18it's just the close up on him at his most destitute as the Tramp,
- 6:22not knowing, if he's going to be accepted by the flower girl, we
- 6:25talked about Goddard in modern times and how good she was.
- 6:29We talked about her dad in The Great Dictator and how that
- 6:32guy's not funny at all. And chaplain did a great job of
- 6:35leveraging that I think that whether it is in choreographing
- 6:40people on screen to do these elaborate gags, or in drawing
- 6:46really good dramatic performances.
- 6:48Out of people, I think across the board, man, his, his
- 6:52direction of actors is top-notch.
- 6:55I'm going to give him a nine and a half here.
- 6:56Yeah. Yeah, I met a nine and a half as
- 6:58well. I think that Chaplin himself is
- 7:00an incredible actor. We talked a lot throughout the
- 7:03episodes about even just the way he his famous way, he walks and
- 7:09goes up and down stairs, and he keeps his feet open to the world
- 7:12and it just gives a Ark to his character that like, so few
- 7:17other characters in film history have.
- 7:20So, yeah, I think that the performances are Stellar here
- 7:23and, and easily will be His Highest category in my I think
- 7:27cinematography does kind of rival it though Brad.
- 7:29And in particular I'm thinking of when we watched the gold
- 7:32rush, we are talking about the special effects that he had on
- 7:35the screen and like an early version of green.
- 7:38Screening. Kind of, if you can call it that
- 7:40when they say, these people are out on this sort of like
- 7:43overhanging cliff and there's these big collapses.
- 7:46I think the way he uses the camera is really, really clever.
- 7:49I know you weren't a huge fan of modern times but the scene where
- 7:52they're in the department store and he's about to roller skate
- 7:55off into the abyss. This you should look up sometime
- 7:58how they pull that shot off because it was all done in
- 8:00camera, but it was done by layering matte paintings through
- 8:05like they painted onto a sheet of glass and then filmed through
- 8:10the glass. So that it looked like he was
- 8:11coming up against a big drop off when there was actually nothing
- 8:15there in real life. Really, really clever use of
- 8:18special effects and I think he's really good at using the camera
- 8:22to tell the story not to be showy.
- 8:25Like there's not a ton Of like oh my gosh, what a shot even
- 8:28though we had that one in the Gold Rush that we loved but just
- 8:33economical efficient, use of the camera.
- 8:35And I think that using the camera like that doesn't get
- 8:39high marks often enough and I'm going to give it to him here.
- 8:42I'm going to give him a 9 out of 10.
- 8:44Yeah. Honestly I was going to give him
- 8:46an 8 out of 10 here but the story about how he shot that
- 8:50roller skating scene is like, that's incredible.
- 8:54That's just really, really cool. I think that he does a great job
- 8:57with the camera and that shot you mentioned from Gold Rush
- 9:01when everybody takes to the dance floor.
- 9:02But him is probably like a top 5 favorite shots that I've ever
- 9:08seen in a film. So I'll give him an eight and a
- 9:10half here, alright? That takes us to editing and I
- 9:14think last time we did this with Kathryn Bigelow, Brad, I said
- 9:17that I finally figured out how to separate in my mind the
- 9:21editing and the cohesion categories, and editing is the
- 9:24rhythm of the movie, right? Does the movie drag is the movie
- 9:28cut? Well and then cohesion is like,
- 9:31does the director build a plausible world for these
- 9:36characters? That's kind of how I think about
- 9:38it. At least I think that I'm going
- 9:40to still give him very high marks in cohesion.
- 9:43But in editing I'm just going to give him an eight and a half.
- 9:46I really love these movies and so I'm probably scoring him
- 9:49higher than you will hear. But the Great Dictator is like
- 9:52at least ten minutes too long. I think that there are certain
- 9:56Moments in even modern times, my favorite movie of his, where it
- 9:59does get a little repetitive towards the end.
- 10:01It's like, all right, we're going back to the factory again,
- 10:04like we're going to do this, this whole feeding a guy, threw
- 10:06a chicken carcass thing again. So if there's anywhere that I
- 10:09think he suffers it is in editing but he still gets an 8
- 10:13and a half for me. Yeah, this is this is where I
- 10:16think he struggles the most is knowing when to stop a gag, even
- 10:21in the Gold Rush, there were certain gags that just went on
- 10:26Way too long. I think that this is by far his
- 10:30weakest category and it's the reason I struggled with his
- 10:33movies. So I'm going to give it a six
- 10:35out of ten, he man. Alright, so cohesion then on the
- 10:39other hand, even if the movies drag at certain points, I think
- 10:43that he really does build these fantastic worlds where it has
- 10:47one foot, in reality, one foot and kind of heightened comedy.
- 10:50I think about modern times where it's like they're living in a
- 10:54Shack on the edge of a lake. That is clearly.
- 10:56We being used for like dumping toxic waste, you know what I
- 10:58mean? Like it's just there's just
- 11:00little things where yeah this seems plausible but it's also
- 11:03like a place that it makes sense that the little Tramp would
- 11:05live. And I think he does such a great
- 11:07job of finding those worlds, and not making them to Fantastic
- 11:11goal. And also making it make sense
- 11:14that a character, like the Tramp could plausibly exist there.
- 11:18This might actually be his best category for me.
- 11:21I think I'm gonna give him a 10 here, Brad.
- 11:24That's interesting. I for me, I think the
- 11:26performances are easily the highest category.
- 11:29I'll give it an 8 out of 10 on cohesion.
- 11:31I think that he builds really interesting worlds and I think
- 11:35that he has interesting characters, I think that there's
- 11:40just enough of a hindrance for me and enjoying the world's that
- 11:45he builds that keep me from giving it a really high score
- 11:49here. So I'll give him an 8 out of 10
- 11:51here. I think that when it comes to
- 11:53you, Weakness. This is where I have no idea how
- 11:57to score him because compared to every other movie I've ever
- 12:01watched in my life. Yeah.
- 12:02This is very unique but I've not watched any other silent films
- 12:06Bob. So I'm going to let you take the
- 12:07lead here and give a uniqueness score.
- 12:10Well I don't mean I know that I'm really not going to sway
- 12:12your score but this is another area where it's like if it's not
- 12:15a 10 it's a 9 and a half because no one made movies like Chaplin.
- 12:19There were three major American comedians at this time.
- 12:23Time it was Chaplin Buster Keaton and Harold, Lloyd and
- 12:27Harold. Lloyd's movies are really sweet
- 12:29and really sincere, but the probably the least artistically
- 12:33accomplished Buster Keaton at just had a very different style
- 12:36of Comedy than Chaplin did and it was much more reliant on
- 12:38Stunt work. So they're like big Burly kind
- 12:42of action e movies with a lot of comedy in it, and, you know,
- 12:45some, some romance as well. Chaplin really wanted to reflect
- 12:50the plight of people in America and across the world.
- 12:53And whether or not that works for you.
- 12:55I think that it's kind of undeniable that no one was doing
- 12:58it the way he was doing it and also trying to make you laugh
- 13:02while he made you cry. They're really just is no
- 13:06parallel for him. And so for me this is another 10
- 13:08out of 10. I'll give him an 88 and a half
- 13:11out of ten here largely because of my ignorance.
- 13:14But also to say that like I really enjoyed his characters
- 13:18that he brought about and I think that that is a unique
- 13:22characteristic that not Tall directors have in them to give
- 13:26you characters that are fascinating and well, acted.
- 13:28So I'll give him an 8 and a half on uniqueness.
- 13:31Bob, I am coming out to a 40.5 out of 50 here, I am coming out
- 13:36to a very, very high 47 out of 50.
- 13:38I think Chaplin whatever you think of the flaws in his
- 13:41movies. I don't think there are very
- 13:42many but I think that our metric is really well suited to
- 13:48chaplain, when it just comes to things.
- 13:49Like, does he build a coherent world does is he unique among
- 13:53Pierce. Like, you're just going to get
- 13:55high marks for being the guy that made silent movies when no
- 13:58one else was making silent movies.
- 14:00Like that's unique in itself. So yeah, we're coming out to an
- 14:04average Brad of a forty, three point, seven five out of 50 or a
- 14:09an 87 and a half out of 100. Yeah I think that it's probably
- 14:15a good place for chaplain to fit and I know that I was not as
- 14:19high on his movies as most people are and To that.
- 14:24I say I don't give a rip. No, there it is.
- 14:27All right man. Listen we have to drink five
- 14:29Whiskey's before we throw over to our pre-recorded interview
- 14:32with Mariah Gates. I did want to Bob, we get to
- 14:35drink five, we get to. I was just going to say, I don't
- 14:39want to give the impression that we're going to drink.
- 14:40Five whiskies and then go interview Mariah Gates.
- 14:43That would be a recipe for disaster.
- 14:45But stick around for that at the back half of the show for now.
- 14:48Brad, let's dive into these whiskeys.
- 14:50What do you say? Let's get to it.
- 14:59All right. Brad, we have a gauntlet in
- 15:02front of us. My dude there are five Whiskey's
- 15:06that need to be drank. They meet, they must needs be
- 15:09drunk the to speak. It Old King James language,
- 15:13we've got five whiskies from very different distillers here.
- 15:17In front of us, two of the distillers are Old.
- 15:19Faithful old classics on the film and whiskey podcast.
- 15:22One of the distillers is brand-new to us, Brad.
- 15:26I don't know where to quite start here, but let me at least
- 15:29give the names of what we're drinking today.
- 15:31So we've got two whiskeys. From 10th Mountain, whiskey a
- 15:34rye and a bourbon. We've got two experimental
- 15:38Bourbons from Nur. If one is called the yellow
- 15:41leaning and one is called the Blue Claridge, and then we have
- 15:44the newest release from Bardstown bourbon company their
- 15:48Discovery series number 10, which has been picking up rave
- 15:51reviews, all over the place, including from our friend, Zack
- 15:54Johnston at up rocks, who just ranked it in his top 20 whiskies
- 15:59of the year so far. Yeah, and he's right.
- 16:04I've tried three of these five whiskeys.
- 16:06I will not say which ones I haven't tried until we get to
- 16:09them, but Brad, what order should we go in here?
- 16:13Um, let's let's just go ahead and start at the top.
- 16:17I would love to talk about this Bardstown Discovery.
- 16:20All right. Cool.
- 16:21So we're starting with the highest proof offering that we
- 16:24have here. This is a one hundred and
- 16:26fourteen point two for proof whiskey and I will say this is
- 16:32based on the fact that iíve already drank all five.
- 16:34So Bob if you want to start somewhere else because fun fact,
- 16:38if you don't drink whiskey consecutively, you should always
- 16:42start with the lower proof whiskey first, and then move
- 16:46your way up. Because if you start off with
- 16:48the 114, your palates going to be fried for the 86-90 proof
- 16:53something. So, if you want to start
- 16:56somewhere else, by all means my friends.
- 16:58Now, let's do it. I feel like I kind of like put
- 17:01my thumb on the scale a little bit.
- 17:03When I started talking about all the accolades as things one.
- 17:05So the discovery series from Bardstown is a blended whiskey
- 17:09from different products that they source.
- 17:11And it is just like a fantastic example of what blending whiskey
- 17:15can be. So this particular blend is made
- 17:18up. I'm going to throw a bunch of
- 17:19numbers that you guys, 62 % 9 year-old Kentucky, bourbon 18%,
- 17:2513-year Kentucky, bourbon 8% six-year, Kentucky, bourbon,
- 17:2910%, 10-year, Georgia, bourbon, And 2% 10-year, Tennessee,
- 17:35bourbon. So this thing has some age to it
- 17:37Brad it kind of shakes out to be about 75 percent corn 13, right?
- 17:42N barley and then point five percent of something else.
- 17:46I assume wheat. I'm not entirely sure.
- 17:49So it's funny like they listed out on the sell sheet of like,
- 17:53oh this is, this has a nine-year bourbon in it and it'll say
- 17:56like, 75 1510, but it won't say what the 75 1510 are, right?
- 18:01So I'm just guessing what the Rains are in this, in any case,
- 18:04it's gotten rave reviews. Let's try the thing.
- 18:07Yeah. So when I jumped into this on
- 18:10the nose, do you remember? I feel like this was around in
- 18:14our childhood cream. Savers.
- 18:17Oh yeah. The Lifesavers that had like the
- 18:20strawberry woven into him and stuff.
- 18:23There is strawberry and orange. Those were like, the only two
- 18:26flavors. This is an orange Cream Saver
- 18:29Bob. Wow.
- 18:31It's like I got just the A little bit of citrus to it, but
- 18:34it's creamy and delicious. There's caramel, there's
- 18:38vanilla. I got some like toasted almond
- 18:41nuttiness on the nose. This is friggin incredible,
- 18:44dude. You know what?
- 18:46It almost comes across on the nose, like a really solid weeded
- 18:50bourbon to me. It's not even more than just
- 18:53like, oh, it's a bourbon with wheat in it.
- 18:54It has that classic Cola. Note we get, but I almost had to
- 18:59remind myself that. I wasn't just drinking a
- 19:01Coca-Cola because Is it smells like a Coca-Cola in a glass to
- 19:05me, like, there's almost an effervescence to it.
- 19:08And when I went to taste it, it tastes Thin and Thick at the
- 19:12same time. I don't know how to explain it.
- 19:15Like, it has that sort of like thin mouthfeel, you get from
- 19:19like really high proof whiskey sometimes because of the alcohol
- 19:22content. But then the flavor is complex
- 19:25enough that it kind of comes in waves and it really coats your
- 19:29palate. For me.
- 19:31It was like spicy black A Coca-Cola and then like a hint
- 19:35of dark chocolate, ice cream. It was really creamy with some
- 19:39cacao to it, I really like that. Yeah, for me, I'm the flavor.
- 19:43You get the caramel, there's brown sugar, there's vanilla,
- 19:47but the, there's a ton of like a the orange move from a
- 19:51creaminess to like, have you ever had the little dark
- 19:54chocolate oranges that like, split off into little slices?
- 19:57Oh yeah. It reminded me of that.
- 20:00And then there was I didn't get quite black And pepper.
- 20:03But there is some, some sort of baking spices mixture in there,
- 20:07that had tons of complexity, and flavor, and like balanced out
- 20:11the sweetness really, really well.
- 20:13And then as I got into the finish, it moved back into the
- 20:16creaminess. There's vanilla, the nuttiness
- 20:20came back through Bob, this is a whiskey.
- 20:26I will say that I am slightly lower on it than I think.
- 20:29Both you and Zach are and it's because of the finish for me.
- 20:32The - got really herbal for me like huh?
- 20:36Yeah, like like almost vegetal kind of it.
- 20:39It took on like a really grassy character which is fine, but it
- 20:44just kind of turned a little bit bitter for me towards the end.
- 20:46Whereas the front of it was like Coca-Cola, like a really nice
- 20:49bright, you know, corn syrup e, kind of thing.
- 20:54It didn't finish that way, which is fine.
- 20:57But, you know, I just kind of expected it to kind of follow
- 21:00the trajectory that had had, it didn't quite finish. that way
- 21:03for me, but I think once again, Listen.
- 21:06Bardstown can do no wrong in our eyes.
- 21:08Like they never have, they never will, their products are all
- 21:11good. Like the worst Bardstown product
- 21:14I've had, is still like an eight and a half out of ten and this
- 21:17is probably better than that. Yeah, Bob, I know that like
- 21:21whiskey tasting is an opinion based Endeavor, but you're
- 21:25wrong. This is nearly a perfect whiskey
- 21:31Bob. This Bardstown Discovery 10
- 21:33series is one of the best. Bourbons that we have had in an
- 21:37extraordinarily long time. Wow, like it's at the perfect
- 21:41proof. Point the, perfect balance
- 21:43perfect flavors. I could drink bottle after
- 21:46bottle of this. Why don't you take this?
- 21:49Why did you pick this to start with?
- 21:50Have you ever heard of burying the lead?
- 21:52Like this is what we end with man.
- 21:55That's what this is. What do you say?
- 21:56This is the best thing I've had in Forever.
- 21:58Do you want to know the reality of the situation?
- 22:00Yeah, let's hear it. I knew that if we spent time
- 22:04talking about the other ones, we Would we would get to the end
- 22:06and be like, oh yeah we got to hurry up and like, finish this.
- 22:09That's and not take as much time to talk about how incredible
- 22:14this whiskey is. Well, let's get into the next to
- 22:17Brad and I think that we started off in such a high proof Point.
- 22:19Let's go to the lower proof ones and those are the 10th Mountain
- 22:23whiskeys. Now we've never had this brand
- 22:25before they, they were kind enough to send us each a full
- 22:28bottle of their rye and a full bottle of their Bourbon.
- 22:32And the thing that immediately stood out to me, Brad beyond the
- 22:3582 proof point is that it proudly states on the front that
- 22:39it is aged for one year we have not had a lot of one year
- 22:44Whiskey's on this Pond. Oh, oh it is kind of common
- 22:48knowledge among distillers that Rai ages, a little more rapidly
- 22:52in terms of tasting mature, then bourbon does.
- 22:56I don't think any distillers out there would say this is fully
- 23:00mature at one year, right? So what I'm thinking is that
- 23:0410th mountain is probably A newer brand.
- 23:06It seems like they are distilling their own stuff which
- 23:08I think is huge awesome, right? Yeah.
- 23:11Like they're not sourcing this, they're just coming out the gate
- 23:14and saying like Hey we're going to put out a really young
- 23:16whiskey. If you like where it's at at one
- 23:18year stick with us at to stick with us at three and four.
- 23:22Yeah. Like I hope they get to a point
- 23:23where they're doing friggin Boldon bond in a couple years.
- 23:25That would be awesome. Yeah that would be incredible.
- 23:29I I love when distilleries are willing to put their money where
- 23:34their mouth is and say. Like, we're distilling our own,
- 23:37our own juice and we want to get it out there for people to try.
- 23:41Now, what say, you Bob do you want to try the Rye or the
- 23:44bourbon first? Let's start with the bird.
- 23:45That's alright. Let's start with the ride just
- 23:47because it's on my left here. So, its first what I'm looking
- 23:49at, I really like the nose on this Brad, it is immediately
- 23:53apparent how young this is, because the color on it is just
- 23:56not what we normally get on a well-aged dry.
- 23:59It's very grain forward on the nose, but it doesn't smell like
- 24:03sour ride to me. There's a lot of really Ali
- 24:05bright fruit here. I get a lot of Peach on this.
- 24:09I'm actually really interested to see where this goes.
- 24:11The I know you've tasted both of them.
- 24:13These are the two that I have not tasted yet so I'm going to
- 24:15give it a sip while you describe your experience.
- 24:19Yeah. So I as I said, I love what
- 24:24they're doing here. I'm a fan of them, you know, for
- 24:29a young out into the world of whiskey and and trailblazing in
- 24:33their own path but I'm using a lot of big nice words to say
- 24:38that this smells like nail polish remover and it tastes
- 24:42like it too. Oh yeah.
- 24:44See I'm not getting that at all Brad.
- 24:47I'm having a vastly different experience than you actually.
- 24:51I'm really glad to hear that eyes.
- 24:53This is this there yet? No, but there's nothing
- 24:56offensive on the palate. It's I think honestly the worst
- 24:59thing I can say about it is that it has no complexity to it yet
- 25:02but it tastes like a really darn good, Rye Whiskey and I'm
- 25:06expecting that like the additional aging is going to
- 25:09bring that complexity and some of the mouthfeel to it as well.
- 25:12It's a little bit thin, but it's got the sweetness that I'm
- 25:15looking for in. In a like, a finished rye
- 25:18whiskey. It's got a little bit of that
- 25:21fruit note to it, as well at one year, I was expecting this to be
- 25:26a heck of a lot worse than it is.
- 25:28This is actually pretty good. I will leave it there and jump
- 25:33on over to the bourbon. I guess, I will say to you.
- 25:36You're the resident Rye person on this podcast, but I can see
- 25:43that this Rye is already like in my preferred.
- 25:47I will house. So that's why I think that's why
- 25:49I'm excited about it because I expected to stay in this flavor
- 25:52profile and just pick up some more character as it goes.
- 25:57Yeah, I'm with you. It will pick up more character
- 26:01as it goes. Alright, let's jump into the
- 26:04bourbon. This one has been sitting out
- 26:07for as long as the right house. I've had these both kind of
- 26:09airing out since we started this recording, the bourbon is more
- 26:13subtle on the nose than the Rye, but it does to its Credit have
- 26:17quite a bit of like a maple brown sugar nose to it.
- 26:23Yep. Dead it does.
- 26:25If you say it does Bob man you are not.
- 26:28You're not giving them any credit here, Brad.
- 26:30Like I know. Wow.
- 26:32I'll just I'll just get my thoughts out of the way.
- 26:35Bob this isn't good whiskey, the rise not good whiskey.
- 26:39They they need to put more time in.
- 26:41It needs more time in the barrel.
- 26:44Desperately, the bourbon has a A little bit more flavor to it
- 26:48than the Rye does. The, which is surprising because
- 26:52I was expecting the ride to be a little bit better at this age
- 26:55statement, but the bourbon actually has a tiny bit of a
- 26:59brown sugar e note to it. Actually I like your note, it
- 27:04has a hint of maple syrup but beyond that it is high in
- 27:13ethanol low in flavor. I like I've had a few white dogs
- 27:19that I like more than this and now, man, that's saying a lot.
- 27:23We have had it brands on this podcast.
- 27:25Before that we have really tiptoed around our thoughts on
- 27:28and a safe to say you have not done that.
- 27:30Today, you've got tipped with you, I appreciate that you
- 27:32haven't. But let me also say this I'm not
- 27:35tiptoeing here either I'm legitimately in the complete
- 27:39opposite place that you are on these Brad.
- 27:41Like I was expecting to not like these.
- 27:44I am very Only surprised with these because when I've tasted
- 27:48young whiskey or white dog, right?
- 27:50Like unaged, whiskey. The grain is the thing that you
- 27:53noticed the most and I will say that whatever they've done with
- 27:55this one year whiskey. It doesn't taste like
- 27:58aggressively grainy to me. It tastes like a whiskey that I
- 28:03don't know how to explain it. It's almost like where you're
- 28:08like, adjusting the color on a picture and you kind of
- 28:11desaturate it a little bit, you know, like Andy the Vibrance out
- 28:14of it, it has finished. And I when I say finished mature
- 28:19whiskey character to it but it's like they just kind of turn the
- 28:22dial down a little bit and I'm okay with that.
- 28:25It almost tastes just kind of like diluted whiskey a little
- 28:28bit. It's really good and I think
- 28:31that at two years at four years, this is going to be darn good
- 28:34stuff and I don't Minded at one year.
- 28:36In fact, I would say, like if you want to try a one-year
- 28:39whiskey, I don't know that you could do any better than this.
- 28:43How much does it cost? I have no idea.
- 28:46Hmm. That that would that would be
- 28:48interesting for me. It was, it was free 99 for us.
- 28:52Brad. That's daggone, right?
- 28:53It was, that is a great price to pay for whiskey pop.
- 28:57All right? Listen, we've got two more to
- 28:58try. Let's try these new riffs.
- 29:00These are both bottled and bond Expressions.
- 29:03They are well they're they're As a straight bourbon whiskey is at
- 29:06100 Proof. I'm not sure if they're
- 29:08technically bottled in bond. They are experimental runs from
- 29:12new riff using different kinds of corn.
- 29:15And in one corner in one experiment, they used what's
- 29:18called a yellow leaming corn. And in the other one they use
- 29:21what's called Blue Claridge. I think it's pronounced Claridge
- 29:24corn. And it's literally like just to
- 29:27see what the difference is by using two different varietals of
- 29:30corn. I think it's really, really cool
- 29:32idea. And I have to say I did Is a
- 29:35difference between these two products.
- 29:38Yeah, 100%. There is a huge difference here.
- 29:42Which one do you want to start with yellow or blue?
- 29:44Let's start with yellow. I'll give my notes real quick
- 29:47because the yellow is like a bob book, special.
- 29:51It's like, I knows this and it was like, I don't think I've
- 29:56ever smelled anything as strongly brown sugar, that isn't
- 29:59brown sugar, but it was just like brown sugar for days.
- 30:05As to the point where I started picking up a second note, and I
- 30:08was like, what is that, and the brown sugar kept overwhelming it
- 30:12that I couldn't pick out a second thing.
- 30:14I eventually settled, was it Browner sugar?
- 30:16I'd eventually settled on black pepper because I was like, I
- 30:19guess it's kinda spicy. But listen, this is not the most
- 30:22complex Whiskey in the world but Bob Books palette does not care.
- 30:27Like it is a super decadent super sweet almost like it
- 30:31almost had a we did a bourbon finish to me that I kind of had
- 30:35some of that cold. That we got on the Bardstown
- 30:37Maple vanilla brown sugar, it was just right in my wheelhouse.
- 30:42I was a huge fan of the yellow. Yeah I am mostly with you.
- 30:47I think for me the other note I got outside of the sweetness was
- 30:52kind of like a really nice light citrus lemon taste.
- 30:57Like there's just a little bit of a lemony feel to this.
- 31:00That gave it a little bit of character that transformed it
- 31:04from being a nice light. Into something that had a little
- 31:06bit of complexity and really took me in.
- 31:10I like the yellow Leeming a lot. On the other hand we have this
- 31:15blue Claridge. It sounds like maybe you didn't
- 31:16love this one as much. I as I drank it I thought I
- 31:20wonder if Brad's going to like this one better just because the
- 31:23yellow was so far up my alley that I was like okay this one is
- 31:27much more Okie much more spicy a little bit of ride for me on the
- 31:32pallet that the yellow definitely didn't have.
- 31:35What were your thoughts on the blue?
- 31:37Incredible. See, I knew it like yeah, I know
- 31:40this one was great. There's caramel there's oh,
- 31:43There's pepper. There's like not like an older
- 31:46let like a new leather feel to it on the palate.
- 31:50I had black pepper. There's a little bit of anise
- 31:53and it which normally I don't like as a flavor but it mixed
- 31:57just fine in here. Dude, this was a really
- 32:00interesting complex kind of dark feeling whiskey that I was
- 32:05totally down with this experience.
- 32:07I would take the blue Claridge any day of the week.
- 32:11This is why I love doing this. This podcast with you like and
- 32:15this is also why new riff like sending us stuff to try because
- 32:19now we get to promote both products and suggest that you go
- 32:22by both products. I really like these.
- 32:24Both the yellow is definitely my preference.
- 32:27The blue seems like it's definitely your preference.
- 32:29Mmm. Yeah.
- 32:30The the blue, the blue Claridge had a depth to it that I think
- 32:35was the missing on the yellow. But that being said, like, if I
- 32:39scored both of these out of 50, I'd probably land on like a 7:38
- 32:45for the yellow and like a 39 or 40 on the blue, like they're
- 32:48both really solid like D+ Whiskey's.
- 32:52Yep. Listen.
- 32:53Sometimes you just want to eat cake frosting, right out of the
- 32:56tub and and that's what the yellow leaving is like, I'm all
- 33:00for it. Sometimes I just don't want to
- 33:01have to think about how complex the whiskey is.
- 33:04I want it to be decadent. I want it to be sweet, and
- 33:07that's exactly what that is and it freaking check the boxes that
- 33:10I needed tonight. I remember one time Haley made.
- 33:13Like a homemade vanilla frosting and we had like the cinnamon,
- 33:19graham crackers in the house and I had like I've been in a little
- 33:23bit of an unhealthy period in my life.
- 33:25And I was gaining a little weight and I would just eat
- 33:28graham crackers with vanilla frosting on.
- 33:33It was the most incredible thing.
- 33:35When Haley found out that I was doing that, she was like, well,
- 33:38no wonder you're gaining weight like you just eating the worst
- 33:42possible? Evil thing in the world.
- 33:44Let me live my life, that's what I yeah, do that.
- 33:48Yeah, all right man, we have an interview to get to, we have
- 33:51brought back, our friend, Mariah gates to talk about the top 5
- 33:55movies. She would recommend for
- 33:57beginners who are new to silent movies.
- 34:00Super excited to talk to her. Let's get to it.
- 34:02Brad. Yeah, man.
- 34:03Excited for it. Let's get to it.
- 34:09All right, we are here with Mariah Gates.
- 34:11You might remember her from our episode, a few weeks ago on City
- 34:15Lights Mariah. Thank you for joining us again.
- 34:17Thanks for having me. I mean, you are the resident
- 34:20expert at silent films on film and whiskey and the competition
- 34:24was just me. So, like you pretty easily beat
- 34:26me out in that that capacity. But what we wanted to do is we
- 34:31know that most people that are listening to this episode, have
- 34:35either never seen a silent film or if they've watched A few on
- 34:37our account, it's just Chaplin and Mariah.
- 34:40I want to throw over real quick to a clip from before we started
- 34:44recording the episode Brad was telling you about how City
- 34:47Lights was the first silent movie he'd ever seen and you had
- 34:52such a great take on people seeing silent films for the
- 34:55first time I wanted to include that sound clip here.
- 34:58And then we'll get back into talking about what we're talking
- 35:00about now. I will say, I told Bob, I was
- 35:02like there's an element of. I, I know I Know what?
- 35:07I don't know. And so I don't totally know how
- 35:12to rate and and you know, the ranking is at the end of the day
- 35:17is somewhat meaningless. But like, you know, that doesn't
- 35:19know how to rate him Ivan's. A lot other side until that
- 35:23happens with silent. Not even just like a novice
- 35:27within the silent Community sound film fan Community because
- 35:31it was depending on who you talk to you.
- 35:33If you're like, talking about actual moving image or Talking
- 35:37about police Cinema you know like the the horse you know
- 35:41images you basically have 40 30 to 40 years worth of cinema,
- 35:45right? That's a long time and there's
- 35:48people who love the the later era stuff who like will give
- 35:52like a fragment one star or they'll give.
- 35:56I particularly love the nineteen teens.
- 35:58They'll give like films from the nineteen teens that maybe you
- 36:01know, maybe they're a little more archaic in the way that
- 36:03they the art. We I don't say archaic.
- 36:05The art is different. It's Different mode of
- 36:08expression, right? But they don't like it so
- 36:10they'll give it like one star. And I'm like, that's a
- 36:12masterpiece of 1911. What are you doing?
- 36:15And this is someone who was also seen thousands of silent films.
- 36:19So this is to say that I think there, this is an area that is.
- 36:23So like it's not really a genre. It is, it is a era of filmmaking
- 36:28and there's so much difference within that, you know.
- 36:31Like, I know some people who love the like 1902.
- 36:34That's their, that's their favorite era and it's Like what?
- 36:38But also a 1902 is great. I actually have a pink bike one
- 36:41of my films this from that era, but the point is we don't want
- 36:43to offend the 1902 Fanboys out. There is like, no wrong way to
- 36:48engage with silent. That's great to hear anything
- 36:51and watching us on it because there is so much there.
- 36:53Yeah, there's 90% loss. But the 10% that isn't the isn't
- 36:57losses, still thousands and thousands they were making you
- 37:00know like those Weber was making a film a week for like ten
- 37:04years. That's a that's a lot of mu p.
- 37:07So, you know, there's oh, my God, man.
- 37:10Doing is giving me permission to give this a 1 out of 10 just to
- 37:14mess with Bob. I mean, you could, but there's
- 37:16I'm just saying, there's no there's no judgment because it
- 37:18is its vast awesome. You made a really great point.
- 37:23The first time you were here, talking about how silent film is
- 37:26not really a genre. It's 40 Years of movies, they
- 37:29just didn't have sound, so it's really hard to lump them all
- 37:32together and yet, I feel like most people probably do lump
- 37:36them together in that way. And so we have a task ahead of
- 37:39us today. We ask Mariah to join us and
- 37:41give us her top five films for beginning, your silent film
- 37:46Journey and I'm really interested to see what Mariah
- 37:49has to say because like you know Brad we talked about the The
- 37:53Sight and Sound poll when that came out and how there's so many
- 37:56different ways of making your list.
- 37:58Is it just hey, I think these are the 10 best films ever made.
- 38:02Hey, these are my 10 favorite movies.
- 38:04Hey, I know what movies are going to get voted for and I
- 38:07want Shine a light on some other stuff and hopefully that can get
- 38:09included to. And I feel like Mariah, you
- 38:12could probably approach this like this.
- 38:14I had a fight in found ballet. Oh, hey, yes.
- 38:18And one of the films that I was going to mention.
- 38:19In this top five was on My Sight and Sound pilot, my strategy was
- 38:24exactly what you pointed out. I had one film that.
- 38:30Just barely didn't make the hundred last year.
- 38:32It still didn't make 100 this year mad about it, but oh no, it
- 38:35did it, did it maybe 100 this year.
- 38:36But the last time Ten years, it didn't.
- 38:38And so I, it's from a director of where this is not my favorite
- 38:41of her films, but I wanted it to get in the top hundred, so I had
- 38:44it on my ballot and then, most of the other films were.
- 38:48I'm assuming these are having this like don't have a Ice
- 38:53Cube's chance in hell to get on the hot top 100.
- 38:56But I know that when it came out 10 years ago, I looked at all
- 39:00the individual critics whose opinions, I find interesting,
- 39:03not that I agree with. But that I find interesting to
- 39:06see, like, what were their tent So I assumed there are enough
- 39:09people who might find me, interesting, they would click on
- 39:13it and then look at the 10 and then I would have nine films on
- 39:16there. That I felt I wanted at least
- 39:18the the 12 people who might click on my name, will watch
- 39:22these films. That was my strategies actually,
- 39:25I love that strategy and I feel like you could kind of apply
- 39:27that strategy here. It's got to be hard to just pick
- 39:29five movies to direct a silent film newbie to.
- 39:35Yeah, this was very stressed. Well, I was thinking I had a
- 39:39different, a couple different five films until I landed on
- 39:43what I decided to do. Was you know, like part of me is
- 39:47like I'm just going to give you five films that are my favorites
- 39:50right? But I tend to like a very
- 39:53distinct time within this period that I believe we would have
- 39:59about City Lights. There was some issue with like
- 40:03the voting of like this is the only sign of film I've given.
- 40:06I can't give it a ten, right? I don't want to throw people
- 40:09into the deep end so I threw that list out.
- 40:12I was like, this is a specific kind of film grammar.
- 40:15It's a specific art is a specific way of telling stories
- 40:19telling that you kind of got to work up to.
- 40:22So I didn't I didn't want to throw people and sci-fi films
- 40:25that are like, you know, physics 12 instead of the physics with
- 40:31no math. Kind of, I want to, I want to
- 40:33work them up to those films. So, I went with five films that
- 40:37But assuming you've never seen a silent film except the
- 40:39chaplains. So there's no chaplain on here.
- 40:42I'm assuming everyone, listening, watch the chaplains
- 40:44along with you guys. What would, what would get you a
- 40:47good film grammar. So that if you like these five
- 40:51films, you will then want to seek out more that ended up
- 40:54being my strategy. Well I mean, I don't think we
- 40:58should beat around the bush here.
- 40:59I made a list of five of mine as well and I assume that there
- 41:03will be some overlap especially hearing you like your strategy
- 41:06now. But There's any left over, I
- 41:08might give those as like, honorable mentions.
- 41:10After Mariah does hers, I would love for you to walk us through
- 41:13your top five Mariah sir. So I started with I just this is
- 41:18where you got to start. It's a trip to the moon, it's
- 41:21you you may be familiar with it if you seen Martin scorsese's
- 41:25Hugo or the Smashing Pumpkins music video, although I know
- 41:30that's the 90s now. And now that's 30 years old so I
- 41:32don't know how many people have seen that video anymore but for
- 41:35those of you who have You probably have seen the imagery
- 41:39from a trip to the moon. It's a rocket ship on like a
- 41:42cheese moon with a face. It's an interesting film because
- 41:47it is the first sci-fi film. It is melies.
- 41:50Doing a little bit of of his old school magician trickery with
- 41:58this new technology, but it's also a play on French fairy.
- 42:04Tales that was a Stage versions of fairy, tales was a big thing.
- 42:09That's why a lot of those early French silent films are like the
- 42:12Cabbage Berry and other weird magic related things.
- 42:17That was that was that's just part of French culture but this
- 42:21is such an influential film. It's hard to watch it and not
- 42:24see every single other science fiction space film ever
- 42:28referencing. Bits of it.
- 42:30It's a bit weird. It's also kind of
- 42:33Anti-Imperialist which is fun so you can watch it.
- 42:37Just for fun. You can watch it on a very deep
- 42:40philosophical level. You can watch it on a deep
- 42:42literary level or again, you can just watch it because it is very
- 42:46trippy, very lonely, and is only 13 minutes long, I recommend
- 42:52finding the lobster films transfer it is, there was a
- 42:57hand-painted - found in 1993 and I believe the lobster films
- 43:03edition of a trip. To the moon, is a digitized
- 43:05version of that. And so you At that beautiful
- 43:08early color as well. And I think it's really
- 43:11important. That is how it was supposed to
- 43:13be seen. They used to hand paint every
- 43:16frame, so it wouldn't be exactly the same everywhere, you know?
- 43:19Because they would send those those prints out everywhere.
- 43:21But that version is the closest to what Millie has wanted people
- 43:25to see. I love it.
- 43:27Alright, so number five is Georges méliès a trip to the
- 43:29moon. Let's let's hear number four.
- 43:32Okay. Number four was My Sight and
- 43:34Sound was on My Sight and Sound ballot. 1916, it is Louis
- 43:38Webber's. Shoes is a melodrama about a
- 43:44working. Not a working girl because that
- 43:47she's not a sex worker, a woman who works at a Five and Dime
- 43:50Store and she supports her parents and her dad is an
- 43:53alcoholic and he takes all her money and she just needs a new
- 43:57pair of shoes and she may find herself becoming the other kind
- 44:02of working girl in order to get a new pair of shoes.
- 44:04She's but it's really yes but it's a bit.
- 44:07Eek, it doesn't necessarily does not necessarily leave you
- 44:11thinking like the world is a great place.
- 44:14But what's interesting for me about it, is that lowest Weber
- 44:18was this filmmaker who saw film not just as a medium for
- 44:22entertainment, but a medium for social change.
- 44:24And so she made some of her films are not.
- 44:27Well, they did not age well, like she made some Eugenics
- 44:30films. You have to mention that because
- 44:32it's important to know that that's not good, but some of her
- 44:35other films that That aren't on that Line shoes has a movie.
- 44:40I think that has aged beautifully and really is about
- 44:44the exploitation of women in the workforce.
- 44:47And it's got a beautiful performance from Mary McLaren.
- 44:51And it's just, it's a gorgeous film.
- 44:53And I think a really important film sounds like a blast.
- 44:57Yeah, honestly, though, I'm not familiar with shoes.
- 44:59This is one that I am going to have to seek out.
- 45:01Like, I've never heard of this movie.
- 45:03I think it's on Criterion Channel.
- 45:05Still, okay, have Criterion channel.
- 45:06It's Definitely on Blu-ray was part of the quino's pioneers of
- 45:11our lie silent Cinema set. I believe and then I think
- 45:17Milestone may have put it out as well.
- 45:18So there's a few ways to watch it.
- 45:21Awesome. And I was not the only person
- 45:23who had it on my Sight and Sound Bala time.
- 45:25I think it was, oh, my God, she writes for New York Times Nola
- 45:30dargis. I think she I think she also had
- 45:32shoes on her science and Bella and I was like, just two of us
- 45:35here in Good Company. There you go.
- 45:37All right. What's coming in at number
- 45:38three? Okay.
- 45:40Now we 3i as much as I love the the teens I want us to get into
- 45:45like the meat of the silent era which is the 1920s.
- 45:49I also really love John Gilbert. So I have to have a John Gilbert
- 45:54film. This is flesh and the devil.
- 45:56It's Greta, Garbo, John Gilbert, Lars Hanson.
- 46:00I believe I mentioned Barbara Kent, previously.
- 46:03Also she's in Lonesome so this is the second part we can't
- 46:06film. It's probably the sexiest silent
- 46:09film. I'm at least in the top five
- 46:12sexiest, silent films, Greta Garbo.
- 46:14Literally will eat you alive with her face in this movie with
- 46:18her eyes. Like she's so sexy in this
- 46:20movie. It's hard to even think about
- 46:22it. John Gilbert also very sexy but
- 46:24basically, the plot is that Greta Garbo is so sexy.
- 46:26That two men almost died. That's the movie.
- 46:29Yeah, that's, I mean, it sounds plausible to me.
- 46:32That's the movie and it's shot by Clarence Brown.
- 46:36Who would go on to the in the 30s.
- 46:38Make some of the best, Garbo and Joan Crawford movies.
- 46:43So he was a great actress director and this movie is just
- 46:48is so So good man, I love these so far.
- 46:51All right, let's hear number two.
- 46:52Okay, number two, maybe the first silent film I ever saw my
- 46:57dad found a copy of it on VHS. We were out of town.
- 47:01One time he bought it and he was so excited because it didn't
- 47:05used to be on available and he was like oh my God I remember
- 47:07this movie from when I was a kid, not that he was alive when
- 47:09it came out but I think he saw it like it's a rerun on TV or
- 47:13something as a kid. He's so excited to show it to
- 47:15us. It's so good.
- 47:17It's Metropolis. Topless you can't, you can't go
- 47:22wrong with a strapless. Again, it's sci-fi.
- 47:24It is so influential, not just on all the music videos, so many
- 47:29music videos based on this movie, but you can see it in a
- 47:34lot of contemporary movies. The Styling of the city, you can
- 47:41see it in Blade Runner and so many other science fiction films
- 47:45in the last. Even last couple of years, have
- 47:48Rift on Metropolis, it has Brigitte Helm in it.
- 47:50Who's one of my favorite actresses?
- 47:52If you like her in this movie, you should just watch every
- 47:55single one of her movies that are available, because she truly
- 47:58was one of the great not just one of the great silent film
- 48:01actresses, she's one of the great actresses period and she
- 48:05was German, but not a Nazi as soon as Nazi.
- 48:08He's took over. She was like bye.
- 48:10So she's also unproblematic German.
- 48:14Yeah, which is it, which is there's a few where you're like,
- 48:17oh, you're terrible. But you're a good actor but he
- 48:19come good actor and said, you know, no to the Nazis.
- 48:23So that's great. It's just, it's a great film.
- 48:28I don't know what there is to say about Metropolis that you
- 48:30then it's so good. I just am looking at the sum of
- 48:34the the stills from it. And it reminds me of Batman from
- 48:39Tim Burton. Yeah definitely played on it,
- 48:43the Android in, it was Star Wars fans will be parallels there,
- 48:51what I will say is there are basically two versions of
- 48:54metropolis. There's a normal metropolis and
- 48:57there's Giorgio moroder's Metropolis.
- 48:59Now, I would suggest watching normal Metropolis, how Fritz
- 49:03Lang intended it to be but if you like it, It's worth watching
- 49:08the Giorgio moroder especially if you enjoy 80s like dumb 80s
- 49:13pop music because it is a different experience as a
- 49:17totally different movie, they had these pop songs like Queen
- 49:20wrote, some of the songs and Eurythmics I think is in the red
- 49:23next. Yeah.
- 49:23It's, if you like New Wave Music, it's like it's not
- 49:26Metropolis anymore, its own. There's a reason they call it
- 49:29Giorgio moroder's Metropolis. It is its own thing at that
- 49:34point, but I am a fan of it, but I wouldn't want it to To be your
- 49:38first way to watch Metropolis. That makes sense.
- 49:41So I had never seen Metropolis. You know.
- 49:43It's all about a decade ago, Kino lorber released a Blu-ray
- 49:48the complete Metropolis. They finally found like an
- 49:51existing print of the movie. Yeah.
- 49:53Like like like so many of these stories that it was just like
- 49:56deteriorating in a back room somewhere.
- 49:58They found a complete print of this movie and no one had ever
- 50:01seen it. Like the first time they were
- 50:03able to piece it all together and they released it's a
- 50:06two-and-a-half-hour silent. Brad.
- 50:08And like the, the best thing I can say about it to influence
- 50:11you, to go. Watch this movie.
- 50:12Is it flies by it? Is like it does.
- 50:15I can't believe this movie is is, is that long, incredibly
- 50:20influential movie. One of my favorite movies of all
- 50:23time, Metropolis. Another film, that's very anti,
- 50:26the man anti taking advantage of the working class.
- 50:30Very pro-union Pro like Workers Unite.
- 50:34It's really fascinating. So it's another film that I'll
- 50:37give you just watch it on the level of your, you want to watch
- 50:40a good Sci-Fi, you can do that. But then, if you want to go
- 50:43deeper, there's many, many, many levels to this movie.
- 50:47All right. We've got one more left.
- 50:48I'm anxious to see what your number one is Mariah.
- 50:52Taking it back to Comedy. I can't not mention Buster
- 50:56Keaton. I personally I think you should
- 50:58just watch every Buster Keaton movie and they are all on
- 51:01Criterion Channel right now. But the one that I particularly
- 51:05love is the cameraman only two. Yes, it's so sweet.
- 51:09It's one of the best romantic comedies.
- 51:11He's he's so like, you get everything in this movie where,
- 51:16you know, his other films, you get a little bit of this and a
- 51:18little bit of that. And, and they're all cohesive,
- 51:21because they're all Eaten. But this one, you really get all
- 51:23the different facades of what he does best, which is the physical
- 51:26comedy, the camera movements, and the romance, anything he
- 51:31does Shadow Ball in this too, which is really fun.
- 51:34So you get a little baseball if after thing and there's a cute
- 51:37monkey. Yeah.
- 51:39I mean, that's a selling point. There's, there's a cute monkey.
- 51:42It's like, what else do you need?
- 51:44So, it's Keaton in Marshall and day.
- 51:46And it's just this beautiful romantic comedy with a little,
- 51:51with them. Or chaos towards the end.
- 51:53Yeah, there's like a riot words and the monkey is amazing, and
- 51:56it's just really good. So, in my list, I wanted to pick
- 52:00a key and I picked the cameraman that's always been my favorite
- 52:02Keaton movie, and I'm so glad that like in the last 10 years
- 52:05or so, people have started to appreciate it on a level that
- 52:08they didn't. Before I think again that has a
- 52:11lot to do with the fact that it's finally become available
- 52:13like on Blu-ray. It's yeah.
- 52:15Put that one out as well 100%. Yeah.
- 52:18If I can add one to the list. If there's one movie that I
- 52:21would suggest, Just everyone on earth needs to watch at some
- 52:24point. I stayed up really late one
- 52:26night. Brad, I watched this movie
- 52:28because I knew that it was regarded as like a classic of
- 52:30world Cinema. It rocked my world to the extent
- 52:34that like, I couldn't sleep that night and it is the passion of
- 52:38Joan of Arc. Oh, yes, it is.
- 52:41Probably if I was making a list Brad of like the 10 greatest
- 52:44films ever made, this is like maybe in my top five.
- 52:47It is it features the greatest performance ever put on film.
- 52:50Yes. Eddie, she's she's a brilliant
- 52:53in this absolutely haunting movie.
- 52:56The time they had faces then. Yeah.
- 52:58Right. She has so many face.
- 53:00Yeah, I am. Like, I'm very sorry to end on a
- 53:02note where I'm talking about watching a film.
- 53:05That is literally like a Beat by beat re-creation of the trial
- 53:09and death of Joan of Arc. Damn it.
- 53:12If that isn't just a perfect movie, and I hope that that
- 53:16gives you Brad and like everyone listening a clearer picture on
- 53:22The breadth and the depth of silent film.
- 53:25We have everything from Harold, Lloyd and Buster Keaton and
- 53:29Charlie Chaplin to these incredible Classics of world
- 53:32Cinema like Metropolis, that their influence stretched for
- 53:36decades, you know, Mariah talked about Blade Runner and how that
- 53:41is like. So clearly based on Metropolis,
- 53:44I really hope Brad that we've given you a couple movies to add
- 53:47to your watch list today. Yeah, like I said, 11 One movie
- 53:52a week is not enough for me. I need to watch more and more
- 53:55films when Mariah we can't thank you enough for joining us again.
- 54:00I know you told us a few weeks ago when you were here but where
- 54:03can our listeners find you? The best place to find me these
- 54:07days is on sub, stack East, be very active on Twitter via
- 54:11Twitter is dying but on sub stack old film Slicker dotsub
- 54:15stack.com. I have my weekly directed by
- 54:18women viewing guide where I write about seven films.
- 54:22Each week to give you a film a day directed by a woman to
- 54:25watch. And I guarantee you I'll never
- 54:28run out of films. There are so many and then I
- 54:30also write a lot about silent silent film on there as well.
- 54:34And they're trying to be sort of a social thing, not just a
- 54:38newsletter. So there's like notes where I
- 54:41occasionally post random things like photos with quotes that
- 54:47I've read, while I'm researching a silent film that no one cares
- 54:50about. To try to get people to care.
- 54:54So that's, that's really the best, the best place to find
- 54:57everything. And I also share my writing
- 54:59there as well. Mostly not about silent films.
- 55:03I'm tend to be on the bad romantic comedy beat.
- 55:06So, I don't know when this airs. If I'll have watched another bad
- 55:08romantic comedy. But the thing is, I actually
- 55:12love romantic comedies and that's why I'm so critical on
- 55:15the ones coming out today because they're bad and they
- 55:18should be better, should be better.
- 55:21Just because they're out and we having something doesn't mean
- 55:25that it's good. And that is my that's going to
- 55:27be my window when you can watch the camera man like, you know,
- 55:34Zell that's that's the best place to find me.
- 55:36Is it? Bob and I watched way back in
- 55:39like, season one or two, When Harry Met Sally, that's the best
- 55:43romantic. And yes, that's all that needs.
- 55:46To be said, frankly, dad is the movie.
- 55:51For modern romantic comedies. Literally like using modern
- 55:55technique modern you know writing modern characterization
- 55:59modern, whatever. That's the that's the rubric and
- 56:02it's the reason it's so good. I'm sorry.
- 56:04I'm going to just this is something outside of home early
- 56:06but the reason it's so good. It's the characters feel like
- 56:09real people and what happens with romantic comedies today is
- 56:15they take the plastic beads but they don't craft characters and
- 56:20that is why most romantic, huh? These today are garbage.
- 56:23Mmm, that's the final word from Mariah games.
- 56:28All right, everybody, we will be back on Tuesday with another
- 56:31regularly scheduled episode. But until then I'm Bob book, I'm
- 56:35Reggie and we'll see you next time.