Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / The 16 Trillion Dollar Alphabet Valuation Myth Explained
Transcript
- 0:00Imagine someone telling you that a single company, just one
- 0:03single company, is going to be worth $16 trillion in 10 years.
- 0:08I mean, 16 trillion, right? That is just a massive number.
- 0:13Right. For context, that is roughly the
- 0:15gross domestic product of the entire Eurozone.
- 0:19Now imagine they told you that this investment is like so
- 0:22incredibly safe it is basically mathematically guaranteed to
- 0:26make you money. Yeah, a guaranteed tech stock.
- 0:29Exactly. Even if half of the company
- 0:31completely fails and goes bankrupt.
- 0:33So does that sound like magic? Or maybe just, you know, the
- 0:38Wild West of Internet finance. I think we both know the answer
- 0:41to that. Yeah, I mean, if you have ever
- 0:44watched a video that promises A guaranteed minimum return on a
- 0:47stock and you know how comforting it can feel, the
- 0:50point to a chart. They lay out a few growth rates
- 0:53and suddenly tell you that you are mathematically shielded from
- 0:57loss. Do you just plug in the numbers
- 0:59and the machine outputs a pile of cash?
- 1:01It feels clean, you know, It borrows the language of
- 1:05engineering. We love things that seem neatly
- 1:07categorized and predictable and risk free.
- 1:10We really do. But the reality of valuing a
- 1:13massive complex corporation is it's anything but clean.
- 1:19Once you get past the surface level arithmetic, you are
- 1:21swimming in some really diagnostic Muddy Waters.
- 1:25Which brings us to the two sources driving our mission for
- 1:27you today. The 1st is a viral YouTube video
- 1:30from a channel called rule #1 Investing, and this was
- 1:33published back in October 2026. The host of the video
- 1:37enthusiastically breaks down Warren Buffett's massive $37.7
- 1:41billion position in Alphabet, which is, you know, the parent
- 1:44company of Google. And this video claims to have a
- 1:47foolproof valuation model, proving this investment is
- 1:50essentially a sure thing. Yeah.
- 1:52A total sure thing. And then our second source is
- 1:55this rigorous line by line alphabet valuation audit.
- 1:59The reality check? Exactly.
- 2:01This audit does exactly what you should do when you're presented
- 2:03with a sure thing. It stress tests the video's
- 2:06exact claims, checking the actual corporate disclosures,
- 2:09recalculating the projections, and just, you know, pulling
- 2:12apart every single underlying assumption to see if the
- 2:15structure holds up. And so our mission for this deep
- 2:17dive is to navigate this exact clash of perspectives.
- 2:21We are going to separate the hard financial facts from the
- 2:25overly optimistic assumptions. Because there are a lot of them.
- 2:28Oh, tons. Think of this as a master class
- 2:31in how to critically analyze a stock valuation so you do not
- 2:34get swept away by a really good story.
- 2:36OK, let's unpack this, because this video makes a trillion
- 2:39dollar tech giant look like the easiest bet in human history.
- 2:43It really does. And to understand why the audit
- 2:45pushes back so hard, we first need to lay out the pitch the
- 2:48video is actually making to you, the viewer.
- 2:51We need to look at the machinery of their $16 trillion
- 2:54prediction. Right, so let's get into that
- 2:56setup. The setup for the video is that
- 2:59Wall Street thinks Warren Buffett is completely crazy for
- 3:02buying Alphabet at a $4 trillion market cap.
- 3:05Which was around $350.00 a share at the time.
- 3:08Yeah, exactly. And a $4 trillion market cap
- 3:11means the market is already pricing in a staggering amount
- 3:15of future flawless success. Right, a lot of pressure.
- 3:18But the video argues that you can ignore the noise, you can
- 3:22ignore the daunting price tag. You just need to focus on
- 3:25Alphabets 2 core profitable businesses.
- 3:28So that's Google Services, which is search and YouTube and Google
- 3:32Cloud, which the video just broadly labels as GCP.
- 3:36And this is where the video starts doing some very heavy
- 3:38math. We need to follow its logic
- 3:40closely. Yeah.
- 3:41Lay it out for us. So let's start with Google
- 3:43Services. The video's host takes the
- 3:45second quarter operating income for that division, which was
- 3:48roughly $39.5 billion. OK, solid chunk of change,
- 3:53right? And he annualizes that, meaning
- 3:55he multiplies it out for a full year, factors in a 21% corporate
- 3:59tax rate, and he arrives at about $125 billion in pure net
- 4:04income for the year. I mean, $125 billion in profit
- 4:08for just one division, That is an astronomical number.
- 4:11But how does he leap from that to a multi trillion dollar
- 4:15valuation? Like what's the next step?
- 4:17Well, by projecting a very, very optimistic future, he assumes
- 4:21that services is going to grow that net income at 12% a year,
- 4:25every single year for the next 10 years.
- 4:27Wow, OK. 12% every year, right? Then in the year 2037, he
- 4:33applies a price to earnings ratio AP/E ratio of 24 to that
- 4:37future earnings number. Let's pause on the jargon for a
- 4:41second. Just explain to the listener
- 4:43what applying AP/E ratio of 24 actually means in real world
- 4:49terms. Yeah, of course, AP/E ratio is
- 4:52simply what the market is willing to pay today for $1.00
- 4:55of a company's profit. So a P/E of 24 means investors
- 5:00in 2037 would be willing to pay $24.00 for every $1.00 the
- 5:05services division makes in profit that year.
- 5:08Got it. So it's basically a measure of
- 5:09confidence. Exactly.
- 5:11It implies that even 10 years from now, the market believes
- 5:14the company has a long, highly profitable runway ahead of it.
- 5:18So by multiplying those inflated future earnings by that 24
- 5:22multiple, he concludes that Google services alone will be
- 5:26valued at $9.3 trillion. 9.3 trillion just for services and
- 5:33then I assume he runs the exact same playbook for the cloud
- 5:35division. He does.
- 5:36He takes their $8.8 billion quarter.
- 5:39He annualizes it to about 27 billion in net income and then
- 5:43assumes a 20% annual growth rate for a straight decade. 20% a
- 5:47year for 10 years. Yeah.
- 5:48And he justifies this by pointing out they just had 1/4
- 5:51with an 82% surge in revenue. So he just projects that out.
- 5:55OK. But a surge is different from
- 5:57sustained decade long growth. Completely.
- 6:00And then finally, he applies a 40 * P slash E ratio to cloud in
- 6:052037. Wow.
- 6:06A 40 multiple is massive. It means the market expects
- 6:11explosive, flawless growth for years to come.
- 6:14So you do that math and cloud becomes a $7 trillion company.
- 6:19OK, so let me do the math here. 9 trillion for services, 7
- 6:24trillion for cloud. You put them together and he is
- 6:26projecting a $16 trillion valuation for Alphabet by 2037.
- 6:32That's the dream. But the biggest hook of the
- 6:35video, like the part that is really designed to make you feel
- 6:38completely safe putting your money in, is his claim about a
- 6:41guaranteed floor. Oh yeah, the worst case
- 6:44scenario. Right, The host claims that even
- 6:47if Cloud entirely fails, even if all the artificial intelligence
- 6:51initiatives just burn up, and the way MO self driving cars go
- 6:55to 0 Google services alone provides a worst case absolute
- 6:59minimum return of 8% annually over 10 years.
- 7:03He explicitly says this is better and safer than a Treasury
- 7:06bill. Which is an incredibly audacious
- 7:09claim, right? I mean, AUS Treasury bill is the
- 7:12global benchmark for a risk free investment.
- 7:15It's backed by the US government claiming a tech stock is safer
- 7:18than AT Bill is completely designed to disarm your
- 7:21skepticism. It's a huge red flag.
- 7:24The video actually calls it a heads I win Tails I Win
- 7:27scenario. It treats the company like a
- 7:30sundae. A sundae.
- 7:32Yeah, like the core businesses search and YouTube are the ice
- 7:35cream. Everything else like AI and the
- 7:38experimental tech is just the cherry on top.
- 7:41If the cherry goes sour, you just toss it away and enjoy the
- 7:44ice cream. And see, that metaphor is
- 7:46exactly where my alarm bell started ringing.
- 7:49Because treating AI is a cherry on top that you can just throw
- 7:52away if it gets too expensive. It makes no structural sense,
- 7:55no. Not at all.
- 7:56It's like looking at a Formula One car and saying, well, if the
- 7:59engine development gets too pricey, we'll just cut that
- 8:01budget and let the chassis coast to the finish line.
- 8:03Right. Good luck with that.
- 8:04Exactly. The AI isn't an optional Cherry.
- 8:07It's the engine powering the cloud services and the search
- 8:10algorithms. You cut the engine, the car
- 8:12stops. Can the rest of Alphabet fail
- 8:15without dragging down the core business?
- 8:17I mean, probably not. What's fascinating here is how
- 8:20the video evaluates these business segments in a complete
- 8:23vacuum. Like they're totally separate
- 8:25companies. Yeah, as if they don't share
- 8:27resources or personnel or infrastructure.
- 8:29It just ignores the structural reality of how a modern tech
- 8:32behemoth operates. And that is exactly where the
- 8:35Alphabet valuation audit steps in to apply a magnifying glass
- 8:38to this 8% minimum floor. Because an 8% guaranteed floor
- 8:42on a tech stock just sounds too good to be true.
- 8:45So when the audit stress tested this claim, did the math
- 8:49actually hold up? Well, the audit score finding is
- 8:52critical for anyone who evaluates stocks.
- 8:55The arithmetic in the video is completely sound. 2 + 2 does
- 8:59indeed equal 4 OK, but the inputs driving that math are
- 9:02purely hypothetical assumptions. So the calculator is working
- 9:07fine, but the numbers being punched in are just fantasies.
- 9:11Pretty much. Let's look at how he constructs
- 9:14that worst case downside scenario.
- 9:17The video claims that if everything else fails, you still
- 9:19make 8% a year. How?
- 9:23Yeah, how? By assuming that Google services
- 9:27will comfortably grow its earnings by 12% annually for a
- 9:30straight decade. With 12% a year compounding for
- 9:3410 years, that means they have to more than triple their
- 9:37current earnings. Exactly.
- 9:39They would have to grow from 125 billion to over $388 billion in
- 9:44net income, and on top of that, the market would still need to
- 9:48be willing to pay a premium 24 * P slash E ratio for the stock at
- 9:53the end of that decade. But that is not a worst case
- 9:56scenario. That is a wildly successful
- 9:59super bullish scenario. It is a highly optimistic
- 10:02projection masquerading as a baseline guarantee.
- 10:05Growth does not mechanically entitle a business to AP/E
- 10:09multiple equal to twice its growth rate.
- 10:11Right, that's not how the market works.
- 10:13No, the market dictates the multiple based on future
- 10:16expectations, interest rates, competition, all sorts of
- 10:19things. The audit provides some
- 10:21alternative math to show how incredibly sensitive this
- 10:24supposed floor really is. Here's where it gets really
- 10:27interesting for me, because I want to know what happens when
- 10:29we tweak those perfect assumptions just a little bit.
- 10:32Like what does the audit show? Well, if you adjust the
- 10:35assumptions slightly, say services, growth slows down to a
- 10:39respectable 6% instead of 12% and the market gives it an 18 *
- 10:44P slash E ratio, which by the way is historically very normal.
- 10:47OK. A normal market environment.
- 10:49Right, in that scenario, that 8% guarantee completely vanishes.
- 10:53Your annual return drops to a measly 0.07%.
- 10:58Basically 0, so 10 years of holding the stock for zero
- 11:02return, yeah. And if earnings simply stay
- 11:05flat, like 0% growth with a 15 * P slash E ratio, the investor
- 11:10actually loses 7.3% a year. Wow.
- 11:13The audit proves that massive, painful losses are entirely
- 11:17compatible with the video's own mathematical model.
- 11:19It's like someone saying hey, my absolute worst case scenario for
- 11:23my marathon time is 3 hours right?
- 11:25Assuming I comfortably run a 6 minute mile the whole way.
- 11:28The weather is perfect and I never get.
- 11:30That is so true you. Haven't defined a floor, you've
- 11:33just defined a slightly less optimistic perfect race.
- 11:36You're hitting on the exact flaw the audit exposes, and this
- 11:40actually brings up a vital distinction, one that the video
- 11:42gets completely tangled up in. Oh, what's that?
- 11:45The video leans really heavily on a quote from Warren Buffett
- 11:48where Buffett says the investment is likely to give a
- 11:51return better than AT Bill. The video takes that to mean the
- 11:54investor's stock price will go up by 8% a year.
- 11:57And the audit argues that is a misinterpretation of Buffett's
- 12:01philosophy. Completely, the audit clarifies
- 12:04that Buffett was talking about the business returns on invested
- 12:07capital. Oh, OK.
- 12:09He means that the money Alphabet reinvests internally into its
- 12:12own data centers, and engineers will generate a higher yield
- 12:15than a government bond. But internal business returns
- 12:19and your external stock returns are two entirely different
- 12:22things. Right, because of the stock
- 12:23price. Exactly.
- 12:25A company can generate fantastic internal returns while its stock
- 12:29price stays flat or even falls, depending on the valuation
- 12:32premium you paid to buy the stock in the first place.
- 12:34Which means the price you paid today matters immensely.
- 12:38You can't just plug in a 12% growth rate for a decade, ignore
- 12:41the $4 trillion starting price, and call it a worst case
- 12:44scenario. No, you really can't.
- 12:46Assuming perfect perpetual growth is exactly how investors
- 12:50get trapped in bubbles. And that stress testing reveals
- 12:52the video's biggest operational blind spot.
- 12:55Because, you know, if we accept that the 12 and 20% growth
- 12:58assumptions are actually best case scenarios, we have to ask a
- 13:01fundamental question. Which is.
- 13:04What exactly is fueling that massive growth?
- 13:07Right. And this goes right back to my
- 13:09Formula One engine analogy. The video claimed Alphabet could
- 13:12just abandoned its money losing businesses like AI if they don't
- 13:16pan out and still keep that 12% growth in search and YouTube.
- 13:20The audit absolutely dismantles this idea.
- 13:23The analysis points out that the videos math completely ignores
- 13:26$5.8 billion in quarterly Alphabet level expenses. 5.8
- 13:32billion. 5.8 billion. 1/4 That equates to about $18.3 billion
- 13:38annually after tax that just vanishes from the video
- 13:41spreadsheet. I mean, $18 billion a year is a
- 13:43lot of money to sweep under the rug.
- 13:45What is that money actually being spent on?
- 13:47A massive chunk of it is shared artificial intelligence research
- 13:51and development. The engine of the car.
- 13:53Yep, and this exposes A fatal double counting flaw in the
- 13:56video's logic. You cannot assign the cloud and
- 13:58services divisions a decade of massive, uninterrupted growth
- 14:02while simultaneously pretending the AI research driving that
- 14:05growth can just be casually cut to save money.
- 14:08Because they're connected. Exactly.
- 14:11The video treats AI and the custom chips Alphabet makes
- 14:14called TP use as optional upside.
- 14:16But Alphabet themselves explicitly state in their
- 14:19disclosures that AI models like Gemini are the very things
- 14:23currently driving growth across their cloud products.
- 14:26Let me make sure I am grasping the scale of this error because
- 14:29this is huge. The video is treating AI as a
- 14:32free bonus price you can throw away if times get tough, when in
- 14:36reality it's the incredibly expensive multibillion dollar
- 14:40engine keeping the core businesses alive and
- 14:42competitive. Yes, you cannot have the revenue
- 14:45growth without paying for the engine that creates it.
- 14:48It just doesn't work. And that brings us to the final,
- 14:51perhaps most crucial piece of the audits analysis, which has
- 14:54to do with the difference between accounting earnings and
- 14:57actual cash flow. OK, this is where a lot of
- 15:00people can get lost in the financial weeds, myself
- 15:03included. I need the Eli 5 version here.
- 15:06Explain it like I'm five. What is the difference between
- 15:09cash flow and accounting earnings in this specific
- 15:12context? Sure.
- 15:13So the video relies on metrics called operating income and net
- 15:16income. These are accounting figures.
- 15:19Let's say Google buys a billion dollar AI supercomputer today.
- 15:23In accounting, they don't subtract a billion dollars from
- 15:25their profits this year. They slice that cost up and
- 15:28spread it out. They depreciate it over, say,
- 15:30five years. On paper, this makes their
- 15:32profit margins look incredibly stable and smooth.
- 15:35But accounting earnings do not equal distributable cash.
- 15:39The reality is that full billion dollars in cash left their bank
- 15:42account today. So the accounting makes them
- 15:44look highly profitable on paper, even while massive amounts of
- 15:47cash are flying out the door in real time.
- 15:49Exactly. That is the perfect way to put
- 15:51it. If you look at Alphabets actual
- 15:53bank account, in that second quarter they generated $39
- 15:56billion in operating cash, but they spent a staggering $44.9
- 16:01billion in capital expenditures. 44.9 billion.
- 16:05In one single quarter. What does that even buy?
- 16:08Like how do you spend that much cash?
- 16:09Physical infrastructure, Real estate, millions of miles of
- 16:13copper and fiber optics, massive data centers out in the desert,
- 16:17cooling systems, and just hundreds of thousands of
- 16:20specialized AI servers. Because they spent so heavily on
- 16:24all that physical equipment, their free cash flow, which is
- 16:27the actual cash leftover at the end of the quarter that could
- 16:30theoretically be given to shareholders, was negative $5.8
- 16:33billion. Oh wow.
- 16:35So while the video is enthusiastically saying they
- 16:38made 40 billion in profit, they actually bled almost 6 billion
- 16:42in real, tangible cash because they had to buy so much physical
- 16:45equipment just to keep up. Yeah, that's the reality.
- 16:48Now, to be fair, negative free cash flow doesn't inherently
- 16:51mean it's a bad investment. Right, because they're building
- 16:54for the future. Exactly.
- 16:55Spending 10s of billions on data centers today could create
- 16:58massive value and dominance tomorrow.
- 17:01But. But convincing valuation model
- 17:04cannot simply ignore this reality.
- 17:06If you assume Google is going to grow its cloud division by 20% A
- 17:10year, you have to factor in the 10s of billions of dollars in
- 17:13cash they have to spend every single quarter to build the data
- 17:16centers required to support that growth.
- 17:18The video's model ignores capital expenditures entirely.
- 17:21It just assumes the growth happens by magic.
- 17:23Which is a pretty big oversight for a guaranteed floor.
- 17:27Are there any other hidden costs the video glosses over?
- 17:31Yes, the audit notes. It also ignores future share
- 17:34issuance. Oh right, stock compensation.
- 17:37Exactly. Alphabet frequently issues new
- 17:40stock to compensate its engineers and executives.
- 17:43And if a company issues more shares, your individual slice of
- 17:46the pie gets smaller. That dilution drags down your
- 17:49personal return, even if the company's overall market cap
- 17:52goes up. You know, if we step back, this
- 17:57raises a huge warning flag for anyone watching these kinds of
- 18:00finance breakdowns on YouTube or wherever.
- 18:03The host of that video is incredibly energetic.
- 18:06You read the transcript and he's saying things like, let that
- 18:09sink in. You know, framing this is a
- 18:12foolproof Warren Buffett secret. Right.
- 18:15It's very persuasive. He promotes his workshop by
- 18:18saying his mathematical process removes all the guessing.
- 18:22If we connect this to the bigger picture, it shows why a
- 18:24structured valuation process is a double edged sword.
- 18:28A mathematical formula is only as good as the human judgement
- 18:31picking the numbers. Yeah, garbage in, garbage out.
- 18:34Exactly. A spreadsheet can brilliantly
- 18:37organize your thoughts, but it cannot magically force an
- 18:40uncertain, highly volatile future.
- 18:42To be perfectly exact, recognizing that a plausible
- 18:46bullish scenario is just that. A scenario is how you survive in
- 18:50the market. A best case scenario is not a
- 18:53floor. So what does this all mean?
- 18:56If you are taking all this in trying to figure out what to do
- 18:59with your own portfolio, what is the ultimate take away here?
- 19:02Well, the Berkshire Hathaway investment in Alphabet is very
- 19:05real and Alphabets profits, at least on an accounting basis,
- 19:09are objectively massive, right? But whenever someone pitches you
- 19:13a mathematical worst case return, you must inspect the
- 19:16underlying assumptions. If a model tells you that a
- 19:19stock is guaranteed to beat a risk free treasury bill, you
- 19:23really have to look for the hidden costs they left.
- 19:25Outlook for the $18 billion in shared R&D.
- 19:28Exactly. Or the $45 billion in server
- 19:31costs that mysteriously vanished from the spreadsheet.
- 19:34You have to look past the smooth accounting numbers and ask where
- 19:37the actual cash is going. And that actually leaves me with
- 19:41a final thought. I want you, the listener, to
- 19:43ponder on your own. We talked about that staggering
- 19:46capital expenditure, $44.9 billion in a single quarter.
- 19:50Just massive. Consider how this new AI arms
- 19:53race is forcing even the most profitable monopolies in human
- 19:56history to spend cash faster than they can actually generate
- 19:59it. Yeah, think about that.
- 20:02If the ultimate corporate modes of tomorrow require $50 billion
- 20:06a quarter in physical infrastructure just to maintain
- 20:09today's competitive edge, are we entering a new era?
- 20:14An era where traditional P/E ratios and paper accounting
- 20:17earnings completely failed to capture the true risk of
- 20:19technological obsolescence. It's a great question.
- 20:23Are you really paying for a perfectly safe first floor, or
- 20:27are you financing an astronomically expensive rocket
- 20:29ship just to keep the house from falling down?
- 20:32Ponder that the next time you look at the safe tech bets in
- 20:35your portfolio.