Latest / eMotors: Electric Revolution / Powertrain Costs: EV Advantage and the Repair Gap
Transcript
- 0:09Welcome to The Deep Dive, the place where we take your complex
- 0:12source material, boil it down, and deliver the insights you
- 0:16really need. Today we've got a great topic.
- 0:18We really do. Our mission today is, well, it's
- 0:21pretty sharp. We are cutting through all the
- 0:24noise, all the anxiety around the cost of electric vehicles.
- 0:27That's the big question, isn't it?
- 0:29I mean, for any new vehicle tech over the last, what, 20 years,
- 0:33the number one hurdle for people is always that upfront price
- 0:36tag. Always people love the idea but
- 0:38they see the sticker price and just walk away.
- 0:40They balk at the cost. Exactly.
- 0:42So we dug into the fantastic research you sent over to answer
- 0:452, I think really critical questions.
- 0:48First, when do EVs actually become, you know, economically
- 0:52competitive, both at the dealership and, maybe more
- 0:55importantly, over their lifetime?
- 0:56And the second question. And second, what's next?
- 0:59What is the future of batteries look like beyond lithium?
- 1:02Are we sort of stuck here? And the sources you found are
- 1:05perfect for this because they give us this complete picture
- 1:08from the past all the way to the future.
- 1:10We're starting way back in 2003 looking at the first hybrid
- 1:13electric vehicles, the HUV. Then we jump to today with these
- 1:17big 2022 projections for pure battery electric vehicles or
- 1:21Bevs that go all the way out to 2035.
- 1:24And then the really cool part. And then and yeah, the really
- 1:26cool part, a glimpse at brand new research on cutting edge
- 1:30sodium solid-state batteries. It's it's the whole story in one
- 1:34package. OK.
- 1:35Let's start where the sources do then in the past, I mean, to
- 1:39understand the price hurdles for today's Bevs, we kind of have to
- 1:43look at how the industry handled that first big wave of
- 1:47electrification. The hybrid wave.
- 1:48The hybrid wave, yeah, we're using a really detailed 2003
- 1:52report that compared those Hevs to your standard internal
- 1:55combustion engine vehicles. And that analysis really gives
- 1:58us the original blueprint for this whole challenge.
- 2:00The data showed what they called the HEV price effect.
- 2:03The HEV price effect. Yeah, it basically just means
- 2:06hybrids were always more expensive at retail than the gas
- 2:08only cars, and sometimes substantially more expensive.
- 2:13So give us a sense of that difference back in the day.
- 2:16Well, in year 2000 dollars mind you, for a smaller car like a
- 2:21Cavalier with a let's say lock complex hybrid design, the
- 2:26premium was maybe around $2500. OK, that's not nothing, but it's
- 2:30manageable. Right.
- 2:32But if you were looking at a big truck like a Silverado with a
- 2:35more a more advanced hybrid package, that price difference
- 2:39shot up. We're talking almost $6700.
- 2:41Wow, $6000 is a huge deal, especially 2 decades ago that
- 2:45had to be a major barrier for buyers.
- 2:47It was, and that's where the analysis got really smart about
- 2:50optimization. The key finding wasn't just, you
- 2:53know, let's slap a battery on it.
- 2:54Right, it's more. Complicated.
- 2:55It was about pairing systems. Yeah, the analyst figured out
- 2:58that if you combined a whole package of improvements like
- 3:01making the car lighter, more aerodynamic, a more efficient
- 3:04engine with the simplest form of hybridization.
- 3:07The mild. The mild hybrid exactly.
- 3:09That was generally the least cost solution.
- 3:11So the secret sauce was realizing that complexity just
- 3:14adds cost, and that the small gains really matter.
- 3:17It was about efficiency, not necessarily like all electric
- 3:21range. Precisely.
- 3:22It was the smartest hybrid, not the most powerful one that won
- 3:25on cost. But even with that focus, the
- 3:28sticker price was still higher. Which brings us to the real
- 3:32measure of value. The real measure?
- 3:34Yeah, the difference between sticker price and life cycle
- 3:36cost. Exactly.
- 3:38And what's so fascinating is that even with that higher price
- 3:40upfront, the total life cycle cost, so maintenance, fuel, all
- 3:45of it was often really similar to the gas car, especially for
- 3:50those super efficient designs. Because you were saving so much
- 3:52on gas. The fuel savings just shrank
- 3:55that gap over the vehicle's life.
- 3:56And your sources had a specific number for that breaking vidden
- 4:00point, didn't they? Based just on the price of gas.
- 4:02They did, and it's a brilliant little data point.
- 4:04They calculated that for those Hevs to be competitive, gas
- 4:08prices needed to be somewhere between $1.49 and 265 a gallon.
- 4:12Now, what's amazing about that low number?
- 4:14The dollar 49. The studies assumed national
- 4:18average for gas was $1.46. Oh wow, so they were right on
- 4:22the edge. Right on the edge.
- 4:24It told the industry even back then that the right kind of
- 4:28hybrid was already floating with parity.
- 4:30You just needed gas prices to nudge up a tiny bit.
- 4:33That's a perfect foundation. The principle is the same.
- 4:36New tech costs more upfront, but operating costs can save the
- 4:40day. So let's jump to now the pure
- 4:43battery electric vehicle, the Bev.
- 4:45And it's the same initial hurdle.
- 4:47The 2022 analysis confirms that initial price gap was still,
- 4:51frankly, pretty intimidating. How big of a gap are we?
- 4:54Talking well, depending on the car and the battery, Bevs were
- 4:57priced anywhere from 3000 to a massive $25,000 higher than a
- 5:01similar gas car. 25,000 I mean how does anyone get past that?
- 5:05That feels like a total non starter.
- 5:07It does, and that's why the narrative has been so tough for
- 5:09the industry, right? But the the solution now is
- 5:12fundamentally different, and it's moving much, much faster
- 5:15than it did with hybrids. Back then, all you could really
- 5:18do is tune the engine and maybe make the car a bit lighter.
- 5:22Today the key isn't tuning, it's chemistry.
- 5:25It's manufacturing scale. It's the cost of the battery
- 5:28itself. And those battery costs are just
- 5:30dropping like a stone. Absolutely.
- 5:33It is the single most important factor in this whole transition.
- 5:36The projection show battery pack costs are just falling
- 5:39dramatically. They're expected to hit about
- 5:41$105 per kWh by 2025. Which is a huge milestone for
- 5:48Mass. Adoption it is, but it keeps
- 5:49going down to around $74 per kWh by 2030.
- 5:54That's what lets you build a competitive car without needing
- 5:56huge subsidies. OK, this is where it gets really
- 5:59tangible for anyone listening. Let's break down the timeline.
- 6:02When can you walk into a dealership and see a Bev with
- 6:05the same sticker price as a gas car?
- 6:07We can map it out pretty clearly for shorter range Bev, so 1:50
- 6:11to 200 miles, perfect for city driving.
- 6:14We're looking at upfront price parity happening well right now
- 6:17basically between 2024 and 2026. That's not the future, that's
- 6:20current events. It is then for mid range, the
- 6:24sweet spot 250 to 300 miles. Parity is expected between 2027
- 6:29and 2029. And the really long range ones.
- 6:31Those will take a bit longer naturally, 350 to 400 miles of
- 6:35range. You're looking at parity between
- 6:362029 and 2033. And pickups, which are such a
- 6:40huge market they lag a bit behind I assume.
- 6:43Corrects pickups are generally running about one to three years
- 6:45slower. They're just so big and heavy.
- 6:47The physics of it demands a much larger, more expensive battery
- 6:50pack. Now it's really important to
- 6:52talk about plug in hybrids, the PHEVS, because the sources have
- 6:56a pretty grim outlook for them cost wise.
- 6:58This is a critical point that I think gets missed a lot.
- 7:01PHEVS are just they're not declining in cost at the same
- 7:05rate, and the sources project they do not reach purchase price
- 7:09parity with gas cars at all in the time frame, not even by
- 7:122035. Why not?
- 7:13What makes them a financial dead end?
- 7:15It all comes back to complexity. A PHEV has to carry the cost and
- 7:19weight of two complete powertrains.
- 7:21You've got the gas engine, the fuel tank, the exhaust, and you
- 7:24have the electric motor, the battery, the power electronics.
- 7:27You're paying for everything twice.
- 7:29You are, and that combined cost is just too high.
- 7:32You can't offset it with battery price reductions alone.
- 7:35That makes perfect sense. So OK, BV sticker price parity
- 7:38is coming soon, but let's shift the whole metric for someone
- 7:41thinking of buying a car today. Let's talk about the cost of
- 7:44ownership. This is where the whole story
- 7:46flips. This is where the benefits
- 7:48become immediate and undeniable, because when you factor in
- 7:53operating costs, Bevs hit parity years, literally years, before
- 7:58the sticker price does. So let's nail down those
- 8:00savings. Where do they come from?
- 8:022 main places. First, fuel for electricity.
- 8:06The analysis from 20/22 showed that over six years, the fuel
- 8:09savings were huge. We're talking $4800 for a car up
- 8:13to $8400 for a pickup. $8400 just on energy.
- 8:17Just on energy and the second part is maintenance.
- 8:19Fewer moving parts. Way fewer.
- 8:21No oil changes, no complex transmissions, less brakeware
- 8:24because of regenerative braking. Over that same six years,
- 8:28maintenance costs are about $26150 lower for a Bev.
- 8:32So for a truck buyer, you add that up and that's nearly
- 8:34$11,000 in savings in the first six years Exactly.
- 8:37So when do you actually break even?
- 8:39When does the six year ownership parity actually hit the?
- 8:42Modeling is very clear on this. For B VS with up to 300 miles of
- 8:47range, you hit that six year ownership parity by 2025 in
- 8:51every single class of light duty vehicle.
- 8:53So next year. Next year even the biggest
- 8:56longest range pickups get there by 2027.
- 8:59It means if you buy a typical EV in 2025, even if you pay more
- 9:03upfront, you are saving money over the life of that car
- 9:06compared to the gas version. That's the pivot point.
- 9:09It's not a future calculation anymore.
- 9:10It's a current reality. And if you wait just a bit
- 9:13longer, it gets even better. It becomes instantaneous for a
- 9:16Bev bought in 20-30. Basically all models show
- 9:20immediate ownership cost parity the day you buy it.
- 9:23The upfront cost plus the projected running costs are
- 9:26equal to or lower than the gas car from day one.
- 9:29That's a monumental shift and the total impact when you look
- 9:32at the entire fleet is just staggering.
- 9:34The societal savings are massive, all driven by those
- 9:37fuel and maintenance savings. The net consumer benefits are
- 9:40expected to start outweighing the costs this year in 2024, and
- 9:44they rise to about $70 billion annually by 2030. $70 billion a
- 9:50year flowing back into consumers pockets.
- 9:52That's the projection every single year.
- 9:54OK, that's the economic case. Let's look further ahead.
- 9:56The conversation is always about lithium.
- 9:59What's on the horizon? We are seeing some extremely
- 10:02promising work in next Gen. batteries, specifically
- 10:05solid-state sodium batteries. Using sodium like salt.
- 10:10Exactly, using abundant materials like sodium to try and
- 10:13break that dependency on lithium or cobalt.
- 10:15So what are the big advantages of solid-state sodium?
- 10:18How is it better than what we have?
- 10:19Now, well, first and foremost, safety and longevity.
- 10:23They are inherently less slammable because there's no
- 10:25volatile liquid inside and they can handle way more charge
- 10:28cycles. Plus they work much better in
- 10:30the cold and some current lithium tech like LFP batteries.
- 10:33So safer, longer lasting, better in the winter.
- 10:35But the problem with sodium has always been energy density,
- 10:38right? It has been, but that's
- 10:40changing. This new generation is reaching
- 10:43energy densities that are comparable to some lithium
- 10:46batteries on the market right now.
- 10:48That's a huge leap. What was the technical
- 10:50breakthrough that allowed that? The key was solving what's
- 10:53called ionic conductivity, basically how the electricity
- 10:56moves inside. Researchers developed these new
- 10:59solid electrolytes made of sulfur and chlorine.
- 11:03Think of the electrolyte as a highway for the ions.
- 11:06This new solid material is like building a brand new, super
- 11:09fast, super stable highway for the sodium ions to travel on.
- 11:13That makes it really clear. So when could we actually see
- 11:16this safer, cheaper sodium tech in a real car?
- 11:21The predictions are cautiously optimistic.
- 11:23They're putting the potential market debut somewhere in the
- 11:25next 5 to 9 years. It points to a feature where
- 11:28batteries are even cheaper and safer than the ones we have
- 11:31today, which are already improving so fast.
- 11:33This really gives us the complete picture from the
- 11:35lessons of 2003 all the way to the breakthroughs of the 20
- 11:38thirties. Let's try and synthesize the
- 11:40main takeaways. I think the big take away is
- 11:42that the old idea that EVs are just too expensive is, well,
- 11:46it's being dismantled by the data purchase price parities
- 11:49coming fast between now and 2029 for most vehicles.
- 11:53But. That's not even the real story.
- 11:54It's not. The key insight is that
- 11:57ownership parity, the true measure of savings, is already
- 12:00here for a lot of models. You can unlock significant
- 12:03savings right now. And here's a final thought
- 12:06drawing from the policy side of the analysis.
- 12:08Realizing those billions of dollars in savings, that $70
- 12:12billion annual benefit, it's all contingent on the market
- 12:16continuing to grow. Right, it doesn't just happen on
- 12:19its own. It means we need sustained
- 12:20investment in the technology and supportive regulations to keep
- 12:23the momentum going. The economic payoff is there
- 12:27waiting for us, but only if we maintain that momentum.
- 12:30Indeed, innovation and the framework to support it have to
- 12:33move together. That's the only way those
- 12:35massive savings get fully realized by everyone.
- 12:38A truly compelling picture of the future.
- 12:41Thank you for sharing your sources and letting us dive into
- 12:43this with you. Thank you for having me.
- 12:45If you enjoyed this analysis, be sure to follow the channel or
- 12:48show wherever you're listening now for your next deep dive.
- 12:51We'll see you next time.