Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Remembering Civility During Client Interactions: A Guide for Personal Injury Lawyers
Transcript
- 0:03Welcome to Remembering Civility During Client
- 0:05Interactions, a guide for personal injury lawyers.
- 0:08I'm Neal Wall, vice chair of BHBA's barrister
- 0:11section, and I'm delighted to introduce our speaker,
- 0:14Eric Trout. Eric V. Trout is the founding partner
- 0:17of Trout Injury Law and one of the top trial
- 0:19attorneys in Southern California. He distinguished
- 0:23himself early in his career as the youngest recipient
- 0:26of the Orange County Trial Lawyer Association's
- 0:29Trial Lawyer of the Year Award in 2003. and received
- 0:32it again in 2023. Recently, he was selected by
- 0:36the nine chapters of Calabota as their trial
- 0:39lawyer of the year 2024, which is the highest
- 0:42honor for a trial lawyer to receive in California.
- 0:45In his 35 years of practicing law, Eric has successfully
- 0:48tried over 100 jury trials. Eric's reputation
- 0:52for civility, ethics, and fair play precedes
- 0:55him. Judges, arbitrators, and mediators alike
- 0:58have openly admired his integrity, compassion
- 1:01for his clients, impressive trial skills, and
- 1:03his gift of advocacy. And now let's get started.
- 1:09Well, good afternoon, everyone. Thank you for
- 1:11joining me, and especially in a very timely topic
- 1:16in today's world. We're going to be talking about
- 1:19civility during client interaction specifically,
- 1:22so sort of a real direct. content discussion
- 1:27today, but I will say it's timely in that our
- 1:31country is so divided. There's a lot of incivility
- 1:35that we see on a daily basis, not just in our
- 1:38own law practices, but across this nation. So
- 1:43talking about and getting a refresher on civility,
- 1:47I think, is a big deal. And that's why I decided
- 1:50to present this topic to all of you today. One
- 1:54of the things that we didn't learn in law school
- 1:57is the importance of being civil as a lawyer.
- 2:03And that includes obviously our conduct with
- 2:06the courts, opposing counsel, but even on a bigger
- 2:10scale with our clients, because our clients are
- 2:15the ones obviously we were representing and we
- 2:17want to do the best for. And so imparting our
- 2:22civility, often is helpful in their conduct and
- 2:26how they conduct themselves during litigation,
- 2:29during depositions. And so let's talk about remembering
- 2:35civility during client interactions and the importance
- 2:38of it. And I always like to provide some tips
- 2:41to folks that are helpful in their own practice,
- 2:44maybe things that they haven't thought about
- 2:46before that are helpful in preparing their clients
- 2:49for either depositions or trials. And because
- 2:53I've conducted over 100 civil jury trials all
- 2:57in wrongful death and injury cases and prepped
- 3:00many, many more clients for their depositions,
- 3:02I think I have a pretty good handle on what works
- 3:05and what doesn't, particularly when you have
- 3:08clients with varying personalities, varying characteristics
- 3:13that can play a role in how the jury, the judge,
- 3:16opposing counsel looks at them. But one of the
- 3:19most important things that they have to keep
- 3:22tamped down is their anger. They're upset with
- 3:28the situation. They're upset with being in litigation.
- 3:31And you have to help them in that regard. So
- 3:36let me give you some practical tips. First of
- 3:38all, we all know for those folks who are Involved
- 3:43in personal injury litigation that people especially
- 3:46catastrophic injuries are dealing with grief
- 3:49They're dealing with anger being put into that
- 3:52situation a lot of times financial strain So
- 3:57by the time they come to us As their lawyer They're
- 4:02not just looking for a lawyer to do a good job
- 4:04for them They're going to need somebody who can
- 4:07counsel them because of course we are considered
- 4:10counselors at law. And in these sorts of cases
- 4:13that I handle, it's a big part of your first
- 4:17interactions with your clients. Patience is a
- 4:21biggie. Compassion, having a civil tone in supporting
- 4:25them. The first meeting is very important. I'm
- 4:28not one of those lawyers who has an investigator
- 4:31go out and sign up a client or has a paralegal
- 4:34sign up a client. I want to get a feel for who
- 4:37they are, if it's the right type of case for
- 4:40me, and to set the tone when it comes to civility.
- 4:45Because when I meet with someone for the first
- 4:47time, as many of you have experienced, you may
- 4:50have a client who is one of those people who
- 4:53wants a pound of flesh. They come in asking for
- 4:56the bulldog. They come in wanting things other
- 5:01than the compensation that you're going to get
- 5:04them at the end of the case. Maybe they want
- 5:05that too, but they also want that pound of flesh.
- 5:09And I let them know from the outset, that is
- 5:12not my role. That is not what has worked for
- 5:15me for 35 years. I can be a strong advocate for
- 5:19you, and I will be. but I'm not going to sacrifice
- 5:23civility in the process and I explain to them
- 5:26why in 35 years acting civil with even claims
- 5:30adjusters not just lawyers has proven to be a
- 5:34big success and why I get things done and why
- 5:37I can help maximize the recovery for my clients.
- 5:39Obviously trying cases helps because you get
- 5:42that reputation but you also can garner a very
- 5:46good reputation with opposing counsel in what
- 5:48is a relatively small community, whether you're
- 5:51in LA or Orange County, you're likely going to
- 5:53see that defense counsel again in my situation.
- 5:57And so you want them to come back to the table
- 6:00knowing that you're going to deal with them in
- 6:02a nice manner. You're going to be a zealous advocate,
- 6:04but they're not going to have any troubles with
- 6:07you throwing up roadblocks or having personality
- 6:12conflicts with you. So I tell those clients in
- 6:14that first meeting, you have to remind them Also,
- 6:19if they're angry about their situation, be careful
- 6:22about what they post on social media. I tell
- 6:29them it's important that you know that the defense
- 6:33is going to see what you post and sometimes can
- 6:37use that. If it's impeachment, of course, they
- 6:40definitely could use it. But we've all seen the
- 6:43surveillance that's been done and the investigation
- 6:46that has been done by insurance companies on
- 6:48social media. I had a case last year that's since
- 6:51resolved that the defense lawyer gave me a report
- 6:55that a private investigation company that specializes
- 6:59in social media investigation gave them. And
- 7:02it was almost 1 ,000 pages. and super detailed
- 7:06and I was impressed with how deep they went.
- 7:10Nothing really significant that affected the
- 7:13case, but boy did they do a great job at researching
- 7:16everything this person had ever posted. So when
- 7:18you first meet with the client, of course you
- 7:20can't tell them to take down stuff that they've
- 7:23already put up on social media. It's an ethical
- 7:26violation to do that. But moving forward, you
- 7:29can tell them to be careful about what they post
- 7:32and particularly stuff that involves anger, if
- 7:35it's a drunk driving case or if it's an assault
- 7:39case or a sexual assault case, they have to be
- 7:42extremely careful and know that everything they
- 7:44post is going to be seen by the other side. I
- 7:48also remind them on the civility side of things
- 7:52that during their treatment that they make no
- 7:56inflammatory statements or send caustic emails
- 7:59to their health care providers or their employers.
- 8:03Because as you all know, that stuff is discoverable.
- 8:07And I don't want that medical record popping
- 8:10in to a deposition or a trial where they've attacked
- 8:15something that the doctor's done or they've argued
- 8:18about the type of treatment that's being rendered.
- 8:21So people are more apt, as we all know, to be
- 8:26more inflammatory in emails or during Zoom meetings
- 8:30than they are face -to -face or in person or
- 8:34on the phone. So they have to be very careful
- 8:37about sending things to their health care providers
- 8:40and to their employers. And I tell them right
- 8:42at the start. Let's move on and talk a little
- 8:50bit about preparation. several instances, you're
- 8:56going to be preparing those clients for statements
- 9:00under oath to be deposed. And as you can imagine,
- 9:06this is one of the most important times to spend
- 9:09a lot of time preparing a client. I know when
- 9:12I first started practicing law, I thought that
- 9:15a half hour to 45 minutes might be enough to
- 9:19prepare a client for their deposition. And I
- 9:22soon learned within a year or two that that was
- 9:24not the case, particularly with folks who have
- 9:29personality issues or come into the case very
- 9:33angry and that you're going to have to spend
- 9:34some of that time counseling them on how to conduct
- 9:37themselves, particularly now with Zoom depositions
- 9:41and a lot of videotaping being done of depositions.
- 9:45It's even more important that they maintain their
- 9:48civility during the deposition. So I spend a
- 9:53lot more time preparing them. You may also have
- 9:55a reason to prepare them if their testimony will
- 9:59relate to prior medical conditions that they
- 10:02have. And a lot of times either people forget
- 10:05or don't forget and just don't tell you about
- 10:07them and you see it in medical records. And if
- 10:09you do, you're gonna have to spend a lot of time
- 10:11with them. prior to the deposition so that when
- 10:14they get that medical record or whatever document
- 10:17it is that's thrown in front of them that they
- 10:19don't lose their composure because now they've
- 10:21already seen it and talked about it with you.
- 10:25But the same is true with police reports and
- 10:29statements made to police officers. Sometimes
- 10:31our clients say, well, I didn't say that, or
- 10:33I didn't say it that way. So you have to spend
- 10:35some time so they're not pit up against important
- 10:39witnesses in your case, a treating doctor or
- 10:43a police officer, and you can walk them through
- 10:47their testimony so that they're not attacking
- 10:51those folks on the record. Obviously, you want
- 10:55to instruct them to answer clearly, truthfully,
- 10:58but really, really important to tell them this
- 11:00deposition is not the time to tell their story.
- 11:05I don't want them vomiting up every fact he said,
- 11:08she said story about the collision, about every
- 11:12communication that they've had with the doctor
- 11:15and their whole zero to. to the beginning of
- 11:20their life until this point story about how it's
- 11:24affected their life. I tell them this is an important
- 11:26time to give a more of a reader's digest version
- 11:30of events and don't feel like you have to keep
- 11:33offering information to tell your whole story.
- 11:36Your whole story should be told at least by you
- 11:40and others at the time of trial and not in a
- 11:42four or five hour deposition. And I think the
- 11:45best way to tell them about not losing their
- 11:49composure, not telling their whole story, is
- 11:52to say, look, would you rather have a two hour
- 11:54deposition or a four or five hour deposition?
- 11:58And that will change their attitude and their
- 12:01approach much faster than just giving them. these
- 12:05ideas. If they know this is going to be less
- 12:07time on the hot seat, they're more apt to listen
- 12:10to you if they're one of these folks who's a
- 12:12rambler. But you're all going to know in a first
- 12:15meeting with somebody even 15, 20 minutes whether
- 12:18they're rambling type or not. And I will put
- 12:21that in my client interview notes if I realize
- 12:24that. If I've had a Zoom meeting with them or
- 12:26an in -person meeting where I know that they
- 12:28just want to spill their guts about everything,
- 12:30I put that in my notes so that when the time
- 12:32comes at a statement under oath or at a deposition,
- 12:36I review my notes and I know, OK, I got Susie
- 12:39Rambler here. I have to focus on that a little
- 12:42bit more than I would with most folks. The other
- 12:47thing that plaintiffs don't know in injury cases
- 12:51is that complaining, over complaining is a detriment
- 12:57to their case. Exaggerating is a detriment to
- 13:01their case. It's counterintuitive to some folks
- 13:05because they think, hey, the more I tell this
- 13:08other side that my life's been affected and turned
- 13:12upside down, and I really emphasize my pain was
- 13:15a 10 out of 10 every day for six months, that
- 13:18means the value of my case goes up. I'll get
- 13:20more compensation. And I know, particularly from
- 13:25trials, that that is not the case. The best results
- 13:28I've had, the best seven -figure results in trial
- 13:32up and down the state have been those clients
- 13:34who don't get on the stand and complain, those
- 13:37clients who don't get up on the stand and exhibit
- 13:40anger or animosity. I actually have them and
- 13:45really promote optimism. They can be realistic
- 13:50in their description of their injuries and how
- 13:52it's affected their life. Of course, I tell them
- 13:54you don't have to downplay things. But your general
- 13:59damages are generally going to come from other
- 14:01witnesses in your life. And so the last trial,
- 14:05I can just give you an example where someone
- 14:10who was very stoic but with a bad, bad injury
- 14:12did well. My last question to her on the stand
- 14:17was, how are you feeling about your future? Tell
- 14:21the jury how you're feeling. And her response
- 14:24was, I'm optimistic. My work is letting me work
- 14:29from home and I appreciate that my family lives
- 14:31nearby They come over we go out as much as we
- 14:36can they give me a lot of support So I'm I'm
- 14:39not letting this situation Get me down. I'm moving
- 14:44forward with my life and I'm optimistically about
- 14:48the future. That's generally what she said in
- 14:50about five minutes and the jury rewarded her
- 14:54with a very good result and it's because The
- 14:57other testimony about how bad this really was
- 14:59in limiting this injury came from other folks,
- 15:02came from the doctor, came from her daughter,
- 15:04came from her mom. So they need to know this
- 15:07at the deposition phase. They need to know that
- 15:10it's OK to be optimistic and to let the other
- 15:15side know, I don't like going to doctors. This
- 15:17has been a struggle for me. I'd rather just not
- 15:20do that. I'm dealing with the pain as best I
- 15:24can. I'm trying not to let it limit my activities.
- 15:28So that's a big area. And I know that that works
- 15:33because jurors don't want to feel like the plaintiff
- 15:38is tugging on their heartstrings as much as this
- 15:41plaintiff is trying to get back on their feet
- 15:44and do their best to get their life together.
- 15:48So make sure they don't exaggerate. Make sure
- 15:51that they don't guess. Make sure that they don't
- 15:54argue with opposing counsel. I'll give you one
- 15:57example that came up a few years ago in a case
- 16:00where I was sitting next to my client. I gave
- 16:03her the whole prep time that I needed to. And
- 16:06a question came up from the defense counsel,
- 16:08which was very generic in my opinion, which was,
- 16:10where did you graduate from high school? Seems
- 16:14pretty innocuous, right? Well, the client looks
- 16:16at me and says, do I have to answer that? Literally
- 16:19turns in her chair, do I have to answer that?
- 16:23So I said, let's take a break. Let's go outside
- 16:25and see what, I don't understand what's going
- 16:27on here. So what she, her perception was that
- 16:31because she had not graduated from high school,
- 16:35that the defense attorney was bringing this up
- 16:37to make her feel less. to make her feel bad that
- 16:42she never graduated from high school. She just
- 16:44read into the question. And I told her, he's
- 16:48not doing that. He's just trying to get some
- 16:50background out of the way. And don't let it affect
- 16:54you in that way. Most lawyers are not going to
- 16:57do that and try and make you feel less because
- 17:00you didn't go to high school. So you just never
- 17:02know where things are going to come from and
- 17:04what's going to cause some anger, but make sure
- 17:08that you stop the deposition. Obviously, in most
- 17:11instances, they're going to have to answer that
- 17:13question before you take a break. That's usually
- 17:16what the defense attorney is going to require.
- 17:18Sometimes they don't, but take them out, calm
- 17:20them down, and let them know. You just can't
- 17:24do that. Also, it's being videotaped, which a
- 17:27lot of times we're seeing now, of course. Tell
- 17:30them to be careful of their facial expressions.
- 17:34If they just start expressing sarcasm in their
- 17:38face or anger, that's going to show on the video.
- 17:41That good defense attorney is going to try and
- 17:43get some clips of that in at the time of trial
- 17:45on cross or an opening or closing. The other
- 17:49thing that's important in preparing them for
- 17:52deposition is if they have some anger towards
- 17:55one of their physicians for some reason, talk
- 17:58to them about that. See if you can tamp that
- 18:00down. Sometimes, as some of you have experienced,
- 18:05your client will be shown a medical document.
- 18:07that has an alleged statement made by the client,
- 18:10and we all know that doctors don't always get
- 18:12those right. They're not painstakingly making
- 18:15sure everything they write down about that history,
- 18:18every sentence, is perfectly accurate. They're
- 18:21just there to fix that client, treat them, make
- 18:25a diagnosis, and move on. Not so much worry about
- 18:27causation, and so they sometimes just don't get
- 18:30the facts right. So you got to make sure you
- 18:32let the client know, don't just agree with a
- 18:36statement in a medical record. If you don't remember
- 18:40saying that or you don't think you said it, that's
- 18:42okay to say. Don't object and angrily disagree
- 18:46with it in most instances because it's typically
- 18:48just a doctor who's just got it wrong. But let
- 18:52the defense attorney know that you don't agree
- 18:57with what it says. That you either didn't say
- 18:59it or you don't remember saying it. Eventually,
- 19:04at the end of a deposition, the civility that
- 19:06your client exhibits really assists them in their
- 19:10credibility and their claims. Ultimately, it
- 19:14helps jurors, too, and judges see them as reasonable,
- 19:18relatable, trustworthy, more likable, which is
- 19:22really what we need to have happen if we're going
- 19:24to end up trying this case. Let's go ahead and
- 19:31take a quick look at an unprepared client, and
- 19:36I'll just have a couple comments afterwards.
- 19:38This is the only video I'm going to be showing
- 19:39you today, but I think it's an extreme example,
- 19:42but it happens. Do you recall hiring a tenant
- 19:54from the Heartland Hotel to clean or do work
- 19:58at the sea captain? No. Sea captain? Why are
- 20:03you talking sea captain? She's asking about whether
- 20:06you... Just talk for Heartland Hotel. Don't go...
- 20:08Other property. She is. She is. She is. Careful.
- 20:13Must careful for my other property. You wanted
- 20:16to know about Heartland Hotel? That's all. Take
- 20:20it easy. If Raymond were... You don't pay the
- 20:23cost. They make copper sand for my property.
- 20:25What you talking about? She's captain. Raymond,
- 20:30you want to take a break? No, I don't want to
- 20:32take a break. She don't want to touch my other
- 20:34property or for my wife or my children or any
- 20:37other business. Who are you? Raymond, do you
- 20:40want to take a break? No, I don't want to break.
- 20:42Okay. She is... Are you ready? Start to brainwash
- 20:45me. No, she's not. Watch it. Why people kill
- 20:47people? Can I have that last piece of my bag?
- 20:53Go ahead. Raymond? Can I have that last part
- 20:56of my bag? Why she born over here to eat other
- 20:59people's head? What you want from Hotel Hotel?
- 21:02We're going to take a short break. She don't
- 21:04know your client yet. She liar. Number one liar
- 21:07in San Francisco. Never seen like you woman in
- 21:10this city. We're going to take a break. No, I
- 21:12don't want to break. I want to go home. You can't
- 21:15go home until we're done. She captain Raymond
- 21:16Hotel, industrial hotel. Come on. So that's an
- 21:34extreme example, obviously. But as you can see,
- 21:38that lawyer waited way too long to suspend that
- 21:42deposition to calm his client down, literally
- 21:44having to wheel him. Ultimately, I cut this off.
- 21:49at the point, but he eventually wheels him out
- 21:51of the room. And it should have happened a lot
- 21:55sooner than that. Obviously, his videotape, he
- 21:57was very caustic and mad, just about a couple
- 21:59words that were said. And the lawyer may or may
- 22:02not have seen that coming, but he obviously didn't
- 22:05prep him well about controlling his anger. So
- 22:08if that happens, He should have been taken outside
- 22:11and talked to 10, 15 seconds into it. As soon
- 22:14as you see that frustration and that anger coming
- 22:17out, it's time to suspend that deposition. All
- 22:25right. Let's switch gears here and talk about,
- 22:27we've talked a little bit about interacting with
- 22:29doctors and experts, but you're going to have
- 22:31your clients obviously involved with experts
- 22:35on both sides, doctors on both sides. But the
- 22:39medical experts and treating physicians, as we
- 22:42all know, are cornerstones to personal injury
- 22:45claims. And so the clients have to be reminded
- 22:48from day one to treat all the medical professionals,
- 22:51including the defense experts, with respect and
- 22:53civility, even though they're frustrated with
- 22:55the process. They often feel like their integrity
- 22:58is being impugned, particularly at trial, when
- 23:01you sit there and you hear what a defense doctor
- 23:04has to say. You can imagine how upsetting it
- 23:08can be to plaintiffs. I had a trial in Victorville
- 23:12a few years back where my client was extremely
- 23:17unlikable. And so we didn't sit her. I probably
- 23:20should have left her out of the entire trial
- 23:22and just had her come in and testify. But we
- 23:24sat her far enough back, sort of out of eye shot
- 23:27of the jurors in the audience section of that
- 23:30courtroom. And I was cross -examining the defense
- 23:33expert, defense doctor, on the stand. And about
- 23:36halfway through, the judge stopped me. And he
- 23:38said, Mr. Trout, I've got to stop this. Your
- 23:42client is gyrating, making faces, throwing her
- 23:46arms up in the air in the back of the courtroom.
- 23:48The juror's seeing it. I'm seeing it. The doctor's
- 23:52seeing it. This has to stop. So of course, I
- 23:55had to go outside, talk to her. Very embarrassing
- 23:58for all of us. and tell her to knock it off and
- 24:02just let me deal with the cross -examination
- 24:04of the doctor. I didn't need her help. So it's
- 24:07super important that they treat all the doctors
- 24:11with respect. You should always have an observer
- 24:14go to a defense medical exam. There are some
- 24:17great ones out there. I have about four or five
- 24:21that I've used over the years. I don't have any
- 24:23complaints about any of them. They're usually
- 24:26either registered nurses or chiropractors who
- 24:31do this for a living, and essentially you have
- 24:34them there to take notes, to time it, to tell
- 24:37you what examination methods were used, which
- 24:42ones were not used, which should have been used,
- 24:46but also an important part of having an observer
- 24:49there is to have your client meet with the observer
- 24:52beforehand. I actually went to a defense medical
- 24:55exam last week because I know the defense doctor
- 24:57and I feel like I'll get a more fair shake if
- 25:00I'm there face -to -face with him. I've used
- 25:02him in cases before and I think it will make
- 25:05a difference in the end that I was there, but
- 25:07most of the time I have an observer go who will
- 25:10meet with the client a half hour ahead of time
- 25:12and one of them is to control their conduct.
- 25:16because you have to let the client know that
- 25:19this doctor is likely going to be minimizing
- 25:21your complaints and your care and your treatment
- 25:26and trying to reduce the amount that the carrier
- 25:29has to pay out at the end of the case. That's
- 25:31their role. They'll object to that as their role,
- 25:33but that's really what it is. So you need to
- 25:36have someone there meet with them at least a
- 25:38half hour beforehand to give them the temperature
- 25:41of the room and what it's going to be like. and
- 25:45that you want the client to interact with the
- 25:49doctor in a cordial and nice way. Obviously,
- 25:52you've talked to them about what they can say
- 25:54and not say pursuant to the code. But their conduct
- 25:57is important because I have seen defense medical
- 25:59reports where they'll talk about how awful the
- 26:03plaintiff was and objected to this, objected
- 26:05to that. And then when they're on the stand,
- 26:07if they're a halfway decent witness, they'll
- 26:09bring that up in front of the jury. And it sometimes
- 26:13doesn't bode well for your client. As jurors,
- 26:15they'll listen to the doctor and go, hey, client
- 26:17wasn't very nice to this doctor. So it's very
- 26:20important. Have an observer there. Have the observer
- 26:23meet with the client beforehand. All right. Let's
- 26:29talk about The next area, civility in the courtroom.
- 26:39So we've seen a lot of incivility in recent times
- 26:44about our judiciary, about the justice system.
- 26:48We've heard about attacks on the Seventh Amendment
- 26:50and our jury system. I'm on a committee with
- 26:55a BOTA called Save Our Juries. had the opportunity
- 27:02to see statistical studies, surveys, federal
- 27:07court studies, the National Center for State
- 27:10Court Studies that prove how our jury system
- 27:14is dying, meaning that there are less and less,
- 27:18particularly in federal court. And there's a
- 27:21lot of reasons for it, but in recent times, it's
- 27:24been about the attack from our executive branch
- 27:27on our judiciary. honor judges, trying to control
- 27:32what they do, attacking them personally, creating
- 27:36an environment where others are attacking judges
- 27:40and their families at their homes. It's a serious,
- 27:44serious problem. And so I feel it's incumbent
- 27:48on us as lawyers who try cases in courtrooms,
- 27:52no matter what kind of case that you're trying,
- 27:56that on a grassroots level, We want jurors to
- 28:01appreciate and like the system because currently
- 28:04they're hearing so much bad about it. And as
- 28:07you probably know and have heard, one of the
- 28:11most tapped into resources on Google when somebody
- 28:16gets their jury service subpoena or notice are
- 28:20the websites that tell you how to get out of
- 28:23jury service. have a lot more Google hits on
- 28:27what is that than what is jury service like or
- 28:30what does the Seventh Amendment mean to our democracy.
- 28:34And so it's disturbing. And so I feel it's incumbent
- 28:36on us that when we walk in a courtroom that we
- 28:39act and our clients act and our witnesses act
- 28:43with civility and professionalism. because jurors
- 28:46walk into that courtroom thinking that the lawyers
- 28:48are gonna be at each other's throats. There's
- 28:51going to be name calling. I mean, we've all seen
- 28:54shows from LA Law to Boston Legal to Ally McBeal,
- 28:59the Lincoln Lawyer, there's another one. The
- 29:02list goes on and on of dramas where people think,
- 29:07hey, maybe this is how it goes, particularly
- 29:09those who have not served as a juror before or
- 29:12been in a courtroom before. And so they think
- 29:14there's going to be this high drama and expect
- 29:18it. And we already as lawyers walk into the courtroom
- 29:21as one of the least liked people or professions
- 29:25on the planet. So we got a couple strikes against
- 29:27us now. So it's so important that we walk in
- 29:30the courtroom with a client who's civil, who
- 29:32spends time out in the hallway being civil. That's
- 29:35the other thing you need to remind them is if
- 29:37they're out in the hallway, the jurors are watching
- 29:39every move that they make. The jurors are, if
- 29:42they're within earshot, they're listening to
- 29:44you. And to not talk about the case and not spend
- 29:48time trying to talk to jurors. There was a, just
- 29:51last week out in Fullerton Court, a defense lawyer
- 29:55friend of mine was telling me about a mistrial
- 29:58that she had because the plaintiff showed up
- 30:01to the courthouse. ended up talking to two jurors
- 30:05out in the hallway, talked about how one of her
- 30:09sons has a horrible disability. I mean, just
- 30:11stuff she should not have been talking about
- 30:13at all. I mean, at least it could have been,
- 30:15you know, it's a nice day or really light comments
- 30:19that probably would not have resulted in a mistrial,
- 30:22but this resulted in three days of wasted time
- 30:25and probably sanctions against the plaintiff
- 30:27lawyer. So remind your clients to conduct themselves
- 30:31civilly, don't get angry, don't get sarcastic
- 30:35out in front of jurors because they're watching.
- 30:37And even if you don't think they're watching,
- 30:39if you're in the cafeteria or the hallway or
- 30:41walking down the stairs or in an elevator, there
- 30:43may be a juror there and they have to be extremely
- 30:45careful. But once you get into that courtroom,
- 30:50I let them know you treat everybody with respect,
- 30:52whether it's the defense lawyer, whether it's
- 30:55the court clerk, the courtroom attendant, the
- 30:57judge, the jurors are all watching. And again,
- 31:00we want jurors to come back. We want them to
- 31:03like the system because they're hearing so much
- 31:05grumbling out there right now about, well, the
- 31:07system's rigged. And we know it's not. Those
- 31:10of us who are in trying cases, this is not. This
- 31:14is a group of folks with different life experiences.
- 31:19different people all coming to the courtroom
- 31:21to decide either a monetary or other fate of
- 31:25this litigant. And it's the best process on the
- 31:28planet. So we need to help preserve it. And civility
- 31:31is a big way to do that. The last case that I
- 31:35tried in January, which was my first medical
- 31:38malpractice case I've ever tried. And as those
- 31:42of you who are on this call probably know, they're
- 31:44very difficult cases. But the defense lawyer
- 31:47was so civil, so professional, I didn't have
- 31:50to worry about him trying any tricks, that in
- 31:54my closing argument, I gave him kudos in front
- 31:56of the jury. There's nothing wrong with doing
- 31:58that. Saying this lawyer, and I said, he's not
- 32:01in a boda, but if he asked me to recommend his
- 32:04application for his chapter in LA, I'd do it
- 32:06in a heartbeat. Because he respects the system.
- 32:10He did a good, zealous advocacy for his client.
- 32:14and I appreciated that, and so does the court,
- 32:16so does the court reporter, the clerk, and I
- 32:18hope all the jurors do. Just a little comment
- 32:20like that. It goes a long way. And you'll also
- 32:23find that when your client is civil and likable,
- 32:28whether they give them a lot of money or not,
- 32:30in my world, a lot of the jurors will stick around
- 32:33and talk because they like your client, they
- 32:37like the lawyers and how they conducted themselves.
- 32:40It's those caustic trials where there's a lot
- 32:46of incivility, sanctions being levied, all sorts
- 32:49of stuff, shenanigans going on, where those jurors
- 32:52run for the door as soon as they get out of there
- 32:54because they figure one side's going to be mad
- 32:56at me. Maybe both, we don't know, but we want
- 32:59to get the heck out of here. And I found that
- 33:01when the process goes the way it should, no matter
- 33:04what the outcome is, you will have jurors stick
- 33:06around and want to talk to you about the experience.
- 33:09And I think it's important that you do that.
- 33:12And it's also important for your client. If they've
- 33:14lost the case or if they haven't gotten as much
- 33:16money as they want, they can hear what happened
- 33:19and what the juror's process was of how they
- 33:23came up with it. So very important. logistical
- 33:29things about your client in trial that I think
- 33:32are helpful that I've had happen over the years
- 33:35that were not helpful. One we talked about, watch
- 33:40your facial expressions, eye rolls, whispering,
- 33:45handing me notes. I will tell them during jury
- 33:48selection, don't hand me notes or tug on my jacket
- 33:51if you have a particular problem with one juror
- 33:54or another or you want me to ask a certain question.
- 33:56We'll have a break. You can talk to me about
- 33:58it then, but I don't want my client appearing
- 34:02to be so interested in this case that they're
- 34:07trying to run it. And that's the way some jurors
- 34:09will think about watching them. handing me notes,
- 34:13pulling on my coat. So I tell them, don't do
- 34:15that. Just sit there. If something funny happens
- 34:18in the courtroom during jury selection or during
- 34:20the trial, it's okay to laugh. You don't have
- 34:21to sit there stone -faced the whole time, but
- 34:24watch the eye rolls, facial expressions, and
- 34:27passing notes around. The other thing that I
- 34:34think is important is don't look at me. before
- 34:41you answer the question. So you'll have witnesses
- 34:46on the stand at trial who are within eye shot
- 34:51of you, of course. And whether it's they want
- 34:54validation or whether they're unsure they're
- 34:56giving the right answer, I've oftentimes had,
- 35:01and I don't limit it just to clients, I've had
- 35:03experts do the same thing where they will, they'll
- 35:08look over at me as they're answering the question
- 35:10or at the end of the answer. And it looks like
- 35:13to the jury that they're taking cues from you,
- 35:16which is not good. Even if the jury likes it,
- 35:18you don't want them thinking that they're looking
- 35:21for assurances or looking to you to give them
- 35:25a good nod if they gave the right answer. So
- 35:28always tell your clients to don't look over at
- 35:32you when they're answering a question. Typically,
- 35:36a good cross -examining defense lawyer is going
- 35:38to move the podium away from the jury so that
- 35:43the witness is looking sort of away from the
- 35:46jury across at the defense lawyer. But oftentimes,
- 35:50you're right in that view as well, or you're
- 35:52close. And it's really hard unless you emphasize
- 35:56to the client to not do that. Don't keep looking
- 35:59over at me. And same thing during the trial.
- 36:03Don't try and be your own advocate by passing
- 36:06notes, frequently conferring with the lawyer
- 36:09in front of the jury, that sort of thing. The
- 36:14other thing that I think is important is that
- 36:18you recognize the fact if you have an unlikable
- 36:22client, you're going to have to own it. Some
- 36:27people are just not fixable, and I mean fixable
- 36:30from the standpoint of likeability, hopefully
- 36:33credibility you can fix a little bit, but even
- 36:37sometimes that's a problem. And so that case
- 36:41that I was telling you about in Victorville,
- 36:45where I had the client who was making faces and
- 36:50gestures with the defense attorney on the stand.
- 36:55The beginning of that trial was even more troubling.
- 36:59And I'll give you that story. This was one of
- 37:01those cases where I had not met the client other
- 37:07than in a phone call before trial. Because on
- 37:10occasion during my career, there have been cases
- 37:12where a lawyer who doesn't try cases contacts
- 37:15me right before trial and says, hey, can you
- 37:18try this case? This was one of those. And I've
- 37:21never made the mistake again of not meeting with
- 37:23the client first. I think you have to do that.
- 37:26And now that we have Zoom, we didn't have Zoom
- 37:28back then. I definitely would have met with her.
- 37:31She lived off of Highway 395, so she couldn't
- 37:35just come into my office in Santa Ana. So that
- 37:37was a problem. And I was brought into the case
- 37:40in the last couple of weeks. It was just too
- 37:43difficult to meet with her beforehand. And unfortunately,
- 37:46the plaintiff lawyer referred it to me, didn't
- 37:48tell me the whole story about how unlikable that
- 37:50she was. And it didn't come across so much in
- 37:53her deposition testimony. She did okay with her
- 37:56testimony, but her demeanor was a different story.
- 38:01So I would tell you. Make sure you meet with
- 38:05your clients. Meet with them for quite a while,
- 38:07particularly before trial, because most people
- 38:09have not been in a courtroom and know how to
- 38:13conduct themselves and how to act. They're nervous.
- 38:15They're going to hear things that people on the
- 38:18stand poke and holes in their case. It's really
- 38:20a tough situation. You really have to counsel
- 38:23them on how to deal with it. And I did that on
- 38:27the phone with this client. But I showed up on
- 38:31the day of trial and I was trying, I brought
- 38:32in a buddy of mine, Rob Gibson, some of you may
- 38:35know here in Orange County, and he's also tried
- 38:37over 100 trials. And I said, hey, Rob, I got
- 38:40this one out in Victorville. Here's the story.
- 38:42She's got a horrible leg fracture. Looks like
- 38:45a good liability case and the trial's in a couple
- 38:50weeks. And he said, sure, let's do it. So we
- 38:52planned to meet the client at the Victorville
- 38:54courthouse that morning about an hour and a half
- 38:57before trial starts. we haven't even started
- 39:00picking a jury yet. This is day one. So we walk
- 39:05in, we sit down. If anybody has ever been in
- 39:07that Victorville courthouse, it's mostly criminal
- 39:09cases. At that time, there was only maybe one
- 39:12civil courtroom and a lot of drug issues, a lot
- 39:16of criminal drug dealers are out in the Victorville
- 39:22area that are getting prosecuted. It was just
- 39:24a tough crowd. So we go in, and I heard the client
- 39:28had blonde hair, and she sort of walked with
- 39:31a limp. And that was about all I knew. I didn't
- 39:33even have a picture of her. So we see this woman
- 39:36at the end of the hallway walk in, and she's
- 39:38got a sort of short, white, form -fitting dress,
- 39:42blonde hair, and high heels. And that's her.
- 39:47the woman who has a horrible leg injury and who
- 39:51is there for her trial. So we walk up to her.
- 39:55I introduce myself and I said, we need to go
- 40:00shoe shopping because you can't wear these. There's
- 40:04just no way that somebody's going to give you
- 40:08fair compensation if you're walking around in
- 40:10high heels. And it just doesn't look appropriate.
- 40:14So we got in the car. Rob and I went in the car.
- 40:18She stayed in the courthouse. And we went over
- 40:19to a Payless shoe store, the only place open
- 40:22that morning at 10 a .m., probably the only shoe
- 40:25store in Victorville. And we find these slip
- 40:29-ons with a big yellow flower at the tip. It
- 40:33might have even been a big yellow sunflower.
- 40:36But it was the best we could do in a hurry. We
- 40:38really had to get kind of moving. So we had the
- 40:41right size. We got them. We bring them back.
- 40:43And so I see Rob go down the hall to give her
- 40:45her shoes. And at this time, there's jurors showing
- 40:50up, I'm sure. And I see her open the box, and
- 40:55I'm getting my suitcase or my briefcase open
- 40:57and getting stuff out. And I see her take the
- 41:00shoes and throw them, yes throw them, back at
- 41:03Rob. And see her saying something to him, and
- 41:07of course it was, I'm not wearing these, they're
- 41:09hideous. And so he comes back to me and he says,
- 41:13I can't do this trial with you. I could tell
- 41:17she's already a nightmare. She just threw her
- 41:19shoes at me. So this is where counselor Eric
- 41:22had to step in and now Rob's already the bad
- 41:25cop. So I had to be the good cop. So I grabbed
- 41:28the box and the shoes. I went down and I took
- 41:30her outside because I figured there were jurors
- 41:33that were showing up outside this hallway of
- 41:36this courtroom. I took her out and of course,
- 41:39expressed the importance of how she looks, how
- 41:45she acts, all of the things I just talked to
- 41:47all of you about on courtroom demeanor, knowing
- 41:50the whole time she's only half listening because
- 41:52she was so angry about how hideous the shoes
- 41:54were. And I talked her into wearing the slip
- 41:58-on flowery shoes. And so she puts them on and
- 42:03we go into the court. We pick the jury. And as
- 42:06I said, I counseled her on how to conduct herself.
- 42:11She didn't pass me notes. We actually didn't
- 42:13see her at council table anyway, so she'd have
- 42:15to run up if she wanted to pass me notes. And
- 42:18so really the only sort of inappropriate behavior
- 42:22was her in the courtroom sitting in the back
- 42:26and making all these gestures when the defense
- 42:29doctor was on the stand. And she did okay on
- 42:34the stand, got a little angry and snippety with
- 42:36the defense attorney a few times. But the one
- 42:39thing that was very clear by the time that she
- 42:42was done testifying is that she was very unlikable.
- 42:48There was 14 jurors, so we had 12 and two alternates,
- 42:52court reporter, court clerk, judge, me, Rob,
- 42:58defense lawyer, who's now chomping at the bit
- 43:00and loving this. all realizing she is very unlikable.
- 43:05So in my closing argument, I would have looked
- 43:09foolish and I would have lost all credibility
- 43:12if I tried to give a flowery closing argument
- 43:17about this client and her likability and credibility.
- 43:22There is no way. I would have been laughed out
- 43:25of that courtroom. So I owned it. And I said
- 43:28right out of the chute, I forget the exact words
- 43:30because it's been a long time, but something
- 43:32like, I understand how unlikable that Ms. So
- 43:36-and -so is. I get it. Look, I've been dealing
- 43:39with it. You've seen me for the last week and
- 43:42a half dealing with it. And I think I even told
- 43:44them I put her out of eye shot, you know, rose
- 43:48back in this courtroom because I didn't really
- 43:50know what to expect. But she's legitimately hurt.
- 43:56She's clearly upset about it and angry about
- 43:59it. She can't help herself. I've tried. I've
- 44:02tried to counsel her on how to conduct herself
- 44:06in front of all of you, but it's just not who
- 44:09she is. This is who she is. She's upset. She's
- 44:15not going to put up with a doctor minimizing
- 44:17her complaints on the stand. So I went through
- 44:19this for, I don't know, just a few minutes and
- 44:22I can tell you I had nods of ascension. Everybody
- 44:27nodding. Probably even the judge was nodding.
- 44:29I didn't look over. But if you have that ever
- 44:33happen where you haven't been able to control
- 44:35the conduct of a client or just have lost your
- 44:39inability, you've lost the ability to get up
- 44:42and argue that they're a super deserving, wonderful
- 44:45human being, then you have to own it. And in
- 44:49this case, it actually worked. They gave her,
- 44:51I mean, I think they would have given her double.
- 44:53they gave her a six -figure amount, but they
- 44:55would have given her double had she been super
- 44:57likable and somebody they felt like, you know,
- 44:59would use the money to help herself down the
- 45:02road. But they did give her a pretty decent amount,
- 45:05a lot more than the defense had offered. And
- 45:07I attribute that to owning the fact that she
- 45:12was not a good witness and not likable. I'll
- 45:15add one other one other little story that I think
- 45:19is important. It's not specifically directed
- 45:23at client conduct and civility in the courtroom,
- 45:25but it's conduct in the courtroom. And it was
- 45:28an experience I had in Riverside many years ago.
- 45:31And it was very well respected at that time by
- 45:35the defense in particular. It was a defense accident
- 45:37reconstructionist who was on the stand. And it
- 45:41was a case against the state of California, Caltrans,
- 45:44roadway design case. And so I had Harry Creeper.
- 45:49They had this guy. on the stand and he talked
- 45:56really fast and I remember during his deposition
- 45:58that he talked really fast and the court reporter
- 46:01was kind of going crazy trying to keep up with
- 46:03him and so again on cross -examination I have
- 46:09him on the stand and he's trying to explain his
- 46:12answers and explain himself even though I'm instructing,
- 46:17I'm making a motion to strike as non -responsive,
- 46:20that judge would let him go on a little bit.
- 46:22And he was talking really fast because that's
- 46:24what happens when you get nervous or you want
- 46:26to get something out, blurt something out. And
- 46:29so the court reporter stopped him and said, sir,
- 46:32could you please slow down? And this witness,
- 46:36who had testified many times in the past, here's
- 46:38what he did. He leaned into the microphone in
- 46:42front of the jury and he said, How is this? And
- 46:49then sat back. And you could have heard a pin
- 46:53drop. That was the end of his credibility. It
- 46:57was the end of the juror listening to anything
- 47:00that he had to say because he had just insulted
- 47:04and demeaned the court reporter for asking him
- 47:08a very simple and reasonable question to please
- 47:12slow. down. And that was his response. So again,
- 47:18in addition to talking with your clients and
- 47:23prepping them for their deposition, prepping
- 47:25them for trial, it's also just as important to
- 47:31prepare your witnesses, even those who are seasoned
- 47:35witnesses and have testified in the courtroom,
- 47:38even more so if it's a treating doctor because
- 47:40they're generally not familiar with the the rules
- 47:44of the road and what the burden is and they have
- 47:46to say with reasonable medical probability and
- 47:49those are other prepping things but you also
- 47:51have to talk about their demeanor and how important
- 47:54it is and not to get sarcastic or snippety or
- 47:57try and be cute which I've seen doctors often
- 48:00try and be and and most of the time it's going
- 48:03to fall flat and it's not going to help them
- 48:05and their credibility in the process so in addition
- 48:08to the clients boy you better really prep those
- 48:11expert witnesses for deposition and, most importantly,
- 48:15for trial because they're going to be up in front
- 48:17of those jurors and they've just got to conduct
- 48:21themselves in a civil way. Another thing, just
- 48:29sort of the final area of prepping your client,
- 48:35is in reacting to a verdict. And if you want
- 48:43to get feedback, and this is the way I express
- 48:45it to them, if we want to find out whether it's
- 48:47a win or a loss, if we want to find out what
- 48:50the jurors were thinking, how they came up with
- 48:53their decision, and I say to the client, you're
- 48:56going to want to know that down the road, because
- 48:59people are going to ask you, what happened in
- 49:01that courtroom? Good or bad? What happened? How'd
- 49:03they come up with that? So it's nice to be able
- 49:07to have a juror two three stick around and want
- 49:10to talk to you and So if the result is bad Don't
- 49:17guffaw don't get angry Don't throw your hands
- 49:20up in the air Don't make any exclamatory comments
- 49:24because that assures Them running out the room
- 49:28and the only way then of me ever getting any
- 49:30feedback is to track one of them down later and
- 49:32make a phone call so when that verdict comes
- 49:36out, stoic, no matter how bad it might be. And
- 49:40same is true if it's a very good verdict. Don't
- 49:44be jubilant, jumping up and down and clapping.
- 49:48I've never had a client do that, but the same
- 49:51is true. You don't want to rub it in the face
- 49:53of the defense lawyer and their client. I mean,
- 49:55you do, but you really don't want them to do
- 49:58that in front of that jury. So you have to counsel
- 50:02them on how to conduct themselves post -verdict.
- 50:07And also, sometimes jurors, I found, are concerned
- 50:13about being confronted by the defendant or the
- 50:17plaintiff. And so I generally tell clients to
- 50:21sit on the bench near where I'm going to be talking
- 50:25to the jurors if it's right outside the courtroom.
- 50:29At some point if I feel like it's worth the client
- 50:33hearing one -on -one, or if there's a couple
- 50:35jurors that really liked your client and had
- 50:38some nice things to say, then at that point it's
- 50:40okay and I have them, I waive them over. So I
- 50:42prep them on that. I let them know I'm going
- 50:44to have you sit on the bench, not because I'm
- 50:46trying to hide anything about what the jurors
- 50:49are going to say, but it sometimes leaves them
- 50:52open to talk more freely if you're not sitting
- 50:56standing right there, particularly if they have
- 50:58some criticisms about what you said or some area
- 51:02of testimony or some evidence that came in. And
- 51:06they don't want to make you feel bad if you're
- 51:08standing right there. So I generally have them
- 51:10hang out close by and just sit on the bench and
- 51:15then wait. Sometimes I bring them over. All right,
- 51:20let's take a look at another slide here. These
- 51:27are just quotes that I sort of lived by, and
- 51:32these are quotes that I talk to clients about
- 51:36because I think they're good ones, particularly
- 51:39that civility is not a sign of weakness. I would
- 51:42go as far as to say in my practice it's also
- 51:44a sign of strength, and civility costs nothing
- 51:48and buys everything. So when you have that talk
- 51:52with the client about, look, you're not going
- 51:54to get your pound of flesh. And even if you get
- 51:57a great result in this case, it may not be justice
- 51:59to you, because you would rather have your life
- 52:02back the way it was before you were seriously
- 52:05hurt. So you can't expect that this process is
- 52:11going to end in your perceived justice, because
- 52:16oftentimes it does not. it's not going to put
- 52:19you back into the position that you were. But
- 52:22one thing is true, and that is that this process
- 52:26can result in maximizing your compensation if
- 52:31you conduct yourself properly in all aspects
- 52:34and making your life easier, even with all that
- 52:38you have to live through. That's the goal of
- 52:41a personal injury lawyer is to maximize your
- 52:44recovery so that moving forward, that your life
- 52:48can be easier as you deal with the consequences
- 52:51of your injury. That's really it. So those are
- 52:55all the slides I have. I know that we have some,
- 52:58see some things in the chat. And if there's anybody
- 53:06with any questions, I think there's a way for
- 53:11you to send those to our moderator and I can
- 53:13answer those. I'd be happy to. Let me take a
- 53:16look in the chat, see if there's anything. Yeah.
- 53:18Okay. So, Eric, I don't see any questions in
- 53:20the Q &A right now, but we did receive one via
- 53:23email. Okay. This one is asking, what language
- 53:27or framing do you find most effective when a
- 53:29client says they want a bulldog or a fighter?
- 53:33Oh, good question. Sure. So, what I tell them
- 53:38first and foremost is that because I've been
- 53:40doing this now for 35 years, and seeing those
- 53:45lawyers who act out how their client wants them
- 53:48to act out as bulldogs or as attack dogs, whatever
- 53:52you want to call it, that that is not an effective
- 53:55way to maximize your recovery. And the reason
- 53:59is, is it can often make that person unlikable,
- 54:02whether it's in front of a judge or a jury. You
- 54:04don't want to reward somebody who's acting out
- 54:07and not treating people with respect. And that
- 54:11I can make all of the same arguments I otherwise
- 54:14would as an attack dog, but do them in a civil
- 54:17way and in a convincing way. And I will explain
- 54:20to them that acting with civility oftentimes
- 54:25causes the listener to listen more and for you
- 54:31as the lawyer to be more persuasive because lashing
- 54:35out and anger are things that people generally
- 54:37just in our day -to -day lives we push back on.
- 54:40and we may shut down, we may not want to hear
- 54:43that person who's acting out. So I tell them
- 54:46it's important, the civility side of things,
- 54:50because my plan here is to be more persuasive
- 54:55than the person opposite us. I want to be persuasive
- 54:58with the claims representative, just as much
- 55:02as I do with the defense lawyer to try and get
- 55:04the case settled. And when we're talking about
- 55:06trial motions or motions for summary judgment,
- 55:10civility is really key. There's nothing more
- 55:13that a judge hates more than a lawyer who's attacking
- 55:17someone either live in the courtroom or in their
- 55:21papers. There's nothing more. It doesn't help
- 55:24with winning that case. It makes you less persuasive.
- 55:29It makes judges think less of you. And so if
- 55:32you want a strong relationship with the judiciary
- 55:35in the county in which you practice, you do it
- 55:38with civility and you're going to go a long way
- 55:41to be persuasive in every aspect of your case.
- 55:44And I can tell you, I've never had, it doesn't
- 55:47happen a lot. I mean, literally once every couple
- 55:50of years, I'll have somebody come in and zoom
- 55:52with me or come in the office who says, I really
- 55:54want you to be an attack dog and I want to pound
- 55:56a flesh. I have never had anyone after I explained
- 56:00those things to them say, okay, I don't like
- 56:04what you just said. I still want the attack dog.
- 56:07thank you for your time and leave. Never. It's
- 56:11never happened. They understand it. They think
- 56:12about it. And it must be persuasive because I've
- 56:17never had anybody walk away from that. I also
- 56:20will counsel people who call me. I know all of
- 56:23us will get calls for referrals to lawyers in
- 56:27other disciplines. And I often get that phone
- 56:30call, particularly in family law. where I'll
- 56:33have a former client call me and say, hey, I'm
- 56:35going through this ugly divorce or child custody
- 56:37thing, and I really need a bulldog here. And
- 56:40I'll spend a few minutes telling them that that
- 56:42is not the way to go. Same thing in a family
- 56:45law setting. You don't want the incivility that
- 56:51can come from a bulldog in front of that court,
- 56:54particularly with not having a jury trial. And
- 56:57so I know from my family law, lawyers that I
- 57:00refer cases to. They are the epitome of civility
- 57:03and they treat the judge and the court and opposing
- 57:07counsel with respect. Those are the only folks
- 57:08I'll refer those cases to. So I try and talk
- 57:11that person on the phone out of the bulldog lawyer
- 57:14who's not even hiring me and explain to them
- 57:17why. All right. And then the next question from
- 57:20one of our attendees is, when do you decide to
- 57:23withdraw from a matter when the client is being
- 57:26abusive to their counsel? Or do you have a list
- 57:29of suggested steps to take before moving to withdraw?
- 57:33Sure. So I've only had that happen. I've made
- 57:36a motion to withdraw in 35 years, maybe four
- 57:39or five times. The last time was over 10 years
- 57:42ago. And it was a client who was demanding that
- 57:48I send certain discovery, that I ask certain
- 57:52questions at depositions that were just inappropriate.
- 57:56I think part of it had to do with the defendant's
- 58:01assets. It wasn't a punitive damages case. It
- 58:04was just things that were over the top and I
- 58:08had a really good offer on the table, wouldn't
- 58:10consider it. So I just knew I was not going to
- 58:12be trying that case. And the client did not do
- 58:15well at the deposition. I was that far down the
- 58:17road. So I brought the client in, said, look,
- 58:21seems to be we're not on the same page here.
- 58:23And you're not going to get there. So you're
- 58:26going to need to find new counsel. And of course,
- 58:28wouldn't sign a substitution. So I had to do
- 58:31a motion. And the court granted it. But it doesn't
- 58:34happen very often. Usually, I can talk them off
- 58:36the ledge. and get some consideration from them
- 58:41to let me do my job. I often give them the analogy
- 58:45of a plumber and I tell them, look, if I had
- 58:49a leaky pipe in my wall at my house and I tried
- 58:52to fix it, my house would be completely flooded
- 58:55within an hour, completely. So I want the plumber
- 58:58who's been doing this 10, 20, 30 years day in
- 59:01and day out to do my plumbing. Well, you hired
- 59:05me to handle your case. and do the best that
- 59:08I could for you and by the way I make more money
- 59:11if I get you more money so why wouldn't that
- 59:13be my incentive on top of everything else so
- 59:16it's really hard for them then to make that argument
- 59:19that my idea is better than yours or I'm going
- 59:22to do this my way that it does happen occasionally
- 59:24but I don't see it often and you know the courts
- 59:28are going to let you out of that case without
- 59:30any problem. Obviously, you can't set forth everything
- 59:33in a declaration that your client's doing, so
- 59:35the defense has it, but you can give them an
- 59:37inkling of it and get out of that case. Just
- 59:41not close to trial. You got to be careful to
- 59:43do that soon enough. Well, great. I believe that
- 59:49about wraps up Q &A. Great. Hopefully gave you
- 59:53all some some good food for thought and I appreciate
- 59:56you all of those who attended today and if you
- 59:59had any other questions feel free to call me
- 1:00:01or email me. I'm happy to answer them.