Latest / Onramp Bitcoin Media / Liquidity Begets Liquidity: $123K Bitcoin and the Incoming Supply Shock
Transcript
- 0:02It all comes down to computers. Communicating the information
- 0:07superhighway can be a confusing mix of on ramps and off ramps.
- 0:11Bitcoin is worthless, artificial.
- 0:14Gold. Is it still rat poison?
- 0:17Probably rat poison squared. We need to get into the world of
- 0:21OK, this is actually foundational technology.
- 0:24What the Internet of Money does is it creates a single network
- 0:29which can do a microtransaction to a giga transaction.
- 0:36The Internet is going to be one of the major forces for reducing
- 0:41the role of gun. The one thing that's missing
- 0:44that will soon be developed is a reliable E cash.
- 0:51Welcome back to another episode of Final Settlement.
- 0:55Today is Monday, July 14th. I'm joined as always by my Co
- 1:01hosts Liam Nelson, Michael Tanguma.
- 1:04Michael, you were just saying the worst part about new all
- 1:06time highs is what as Bitcoin crosses 121.
- 1:10I think it hit 123 earlier this morning.
- 1:13But what's the worst part about all time highs?
- 1:14Mike, I think if you're. Outside the industry, it's it's
- 1:20fun to sit back, but when you're in the middle of it, there's
- 1:22just so much going on that there's just a lot of stress and
- 1:26anxiety. And I genuinely appreciate when
- 1:29the awareness from the world isn't on this asset class.
- 1:32So that's what I was referring to.
- 1:34I will also share that I feel a little bad for Jackson because
- 1:38we had the the great BPI RIP early in the week.
- 1:41So we kind of missed a lot of this, this all time high and
- 1:43Jackson was really hurting because he he loves to just talk
- 1:47about price. And so we almost did an
- 1:50emergency plot on Friday. We didn't.
- 1:51And and then we got to record first to talk about what the
- 1:54hell is happening in Bitcoin. I think like overnight maybe got
- 1:57up to close to 123. Is that right?
- 2:00Yeah, I think 120, a little over 123 on some exchanges is what I
- 2:04saw. But yeah, to last week, I think
- 2:08we'd recorded, as you mentioned earlier in the week and then we
- 2:12were kind of just watching the price on Thursday being like,
- 2:15should we do an emergency pod? And Jackson had put the level
- 2:17out there of 115 and it eventually did cross 1:15 that
- 2:21evening, but it was already a little late in the evening to,
- 2:24to jump on an emergency pod. So we get the honor of, of
- 2:28speaking to new all time highs. We're at 121 seven right now.
- 2:33What do we what do we think's happening here, boys?
- 2:34Any, any notable catalysts? I think partly some people are
- 2:39trying to attribute this to some some words and thoughts and
- 2:44rumors around Powell either resigning or having necessary
- 2:48cause to fire him that that could be part of this.
- 2:52As I like to say, this is this is just more buyers than
- 2:54sellers. If you just want to boil it down
- 2:57to sellers getting exhausted at these levels, which we've been
- 2:59talking about for weeks, sort of the coiled spring, which I
- 3:02actually wrote about in last week's newsletter that came out
- 3:06around noon on Thursday right before it kind of started taking
- 3:10off. So some prescient commentary
- 3:12there. But any any thoughts around what
- 3:14could be driving this? Yeah, I think it's the same as
- 3:18always. It's just price goes up, it
- 3:20educates more people in the market and there's a ton of new
- 3:23vehicles to get exposure, whether it's the ETFs, which
- 3:26we're going to go into, all the new treasury companies, there's
- 3:29options on the ETFs. And so everybody's kind of been
- 3:33seeing this arbitrage strategy both on the publicly traded
- 3:37company side as well as just, you know, the, the good old
- 3:40arbitrage strategy of buying Bitcoin waiting until the price
- 3:44goes up. And, you know, some people end
- 3:47up selling at, you know, price XY and Z.
- 3:50But really the, the big arbitrage strategy is just
- 3:52Bitcoin has only some amount of units and dollars and Fiat is,
- 3:57you know, not constrained by any math or anything.
- 4:00And so people are just being more educated on what Bitcoin
- 4:05is, the different vehicles out there.
- 4:07They're educating the rest of their teams if they are on an
- 4:11investment team or whatever else it is on the value proposition,
- 4:16either you know, if they're completely neutral to Bitcoin or
- 4:19if they want to be long the asset class and it's just
- 4:22bringing in more liquidity, which brings in more liquidity.
- 4:25And the the two big value drivers of Bitcoin are its
- 4:29ability to transact and store value throughout time.
- 4:33And it only gets better at storing value and and
- 4:36transacting as more liquidity comes into the asset class.
- 4:41So it's doing a fantastic job. Doing a fantastic job at storing
- 4:46value right now Mike. Any thoughts?
- 4:49Yeah, I think, I think, I think there's a confluence of things
- 4:54happening. One is naturally like more
- 4:57buyers and sellers. It ate we chewed through the
- 4:59$100,000 kind of hundred 110 just like price point.
- 5:05Think we kind of maybe missed the mark.
- 5:07There are a lot of individuals thought 100K was that price
- 5:09point. Think long term it'll be that
- 5:11price point to show people can get to 1,000,000.
- 5:13But in the short term, there was a lot of downward pressure from
- 5:16O GS and people just needing to sell.
- 5:20I think there's something completely outside of Bitcoin,
- 5:24which is just what Brian referred to as like more the
- 5:26macro landscape, whether it's almost everything at all time
- 5:30highs in the public markets, coupled with what's happening
- 5:32with pal. I think what's what's
- 5:34interesting about this time is we've already seen Bitcoin
- 5:37behave as like a true risk off asset or almost a true risk off.
- 5:40But it has been super, it's been resilient and off the face of
- 5:47like what happened with the tariffs in Iran.
- 5:50Like so we've kind of seen glimpses of, you know, it can
- 5:52play in both directions, but I think right now the direction is
- 5:55risk on. And then yeah, of course the pub
- 5:58Co stuff is a lot of downward pressure.
- 6:01The thing that's the most interesting for me or upward
- 6:04pressure. The thing that's most
- 6:05interesting to me is the, that there's no retail like, and, and
- 6:12I don't know if it's a mix because retail's eating up the
- 6:15pub Co stuff. I, I don't think that's the case
- 6:17because it's just, nobody's talking about Bitcoin.
- 6:19Like it's very outside of the traditional squawk box CNBC in a
- 6:23couple of the corners, like nobody cares that the Bitcoin
- 6:26price is $123,000. And it's fascinating.
- 6:30And I don't know what like if it's FTX just kind of like
- 6:33pushed everyone, it's like, screw it.
- 6:34This thing's all a Ponzi. Or if it feels like there's
- 6:37something that happened between 22 and 25 that has put people
- 6:42like blinders on to certain, like mimetic.
- 6:46I don't know. There's something here right now
- 6:47that is going to take a while before the masses really come
- 6:49back. And I'm not really sure what it
- 6:51is yet, but it's going to be exciting.
- 6:52It's going to come out of left field probably.
- 6:54I think that's definitely true. But I, I do think that there is
- 6:56a caveat there of like the, a lot of the ETF flows over the
- 7:00past, you know, 12 months have been what you would typically
- 7:05call like a retail buyer that's just buying the ETF through
- 7:08their brokerage account. And so I think retail just looks
- 7:10a little different. But I would agree generally
- 7:13speaking, that in in terms of like the broader zeitgeist, like
- 7:16the normie brain, it's still very sort of off the radar, like
- 7:19no one's talking about Bitcoin on 21.
- 7:22I agree, but I think that that's like a good barometer for me is
- 7:24if you go to the grocery store, you go get your hair cut and you
- 7:26ask somebody what Bitcoin about Bitcoin, They're they crypto and
- 7:29then they'll also when you tell them what do you think the price
- 7:32is? And then they go, holy shit.
- 7:34And that's the proxy of retail that will get everyone else to
- 7:37ape in or like that analogy will like get the traditional
- 7:41advisors and people that are off the street that had never heard
- 7:43about Bitcoin. I think the demand that this is
- 7:46was like pent up demand from people wanting to get exposure
- 7:49and their financial advisor. Because a lot of financial
- 7:51advisors historically have told their people like, look, don't
- 7:54go into it or wait for it to come on platform or it's risky
- 7:58on these other ways. And so this was kind of like the
- 8:01the demand that had existed previous that was also locked up
- 8:04in traditional like tax advantage accounts or off like
- 8:08personal account. So it is retail, but it's a
- 8:10different kind of like net new marginal buyer that is I guess
- 8:14what I'm referring to it like retail when we generally see all
- 8:17time highs hit in these markets. Yeah, no, that's totally fair.
- 8:21It's not necessarily like net new people who are learning
- 8:24about Bitcoin for the first time.
- 8:26It's it's more so other pools of capital that were, you know,
- 8:30trapped in, in various accounts that can now get exposure.
- 8:34But Liam, you had referenced the ETF flows.
- 8:36This is a pretty remarkable chart just showing I bit and
- 8:41just, you know, clearly demonstrating these are the most
- 8:44successful financial products ever launched.
- 8:47I bit alone is over 80 billion. I think the entire spot ETF,
- 8:53Bitcoin ETF complex is closer to 150 billion now, but we have any
- 9:00thoughts on on what we're looking at here.
- 9:02Yeah, I mean, two things. One, the unit bias is extremely
- 9:05real. Seeing 120 and so $1000 on on a
- 9:10Bitcoin seems completely out of reach for most people.
- 9:14They don't even know that there are Satoshi's or you can buy a
- 9:18part of a Bitcoin, but they do see Bitcoin ETF and so they'll
- 9:23just buy that. And then #2 to the FDX point
- 9:27earlier, that is certainly something that's real.
- 9:29They just think that all of the industry is primarily a scam.
- 9:33For the most part, if you're out from the outside looking in and
- 9:36it does either end up in a landfill or you know that it
- 9:40just they, they just take your Bitcoin and run away with it.
- 9:43And so, you know, just having the name of Fidelity, BlackRock,
- 9:47etcetera on your investment account is just going to drive
- 9:50significant flows. The options on IVIT I think are,
- 9:54are really underrated how much demand they've driven and that
- 10:00chart is just like absolutely vertical.
- 10:04It's it's really like people are say we're saying this is priced
- 10:09in. You know, I don't, I don't know
- 10:12what to say to that. This is going to be a continued
- 10:15bid for a very long time. I think it's just, you know,
- 10:18people continue to want more exposure and it's increasingly
- 10:22available. Yeah.
- 10:24The it's, it's an interesting thing you bring up about, about
- 10:32UNIBIAS, because I never thought about that in terms of like the
- 10:36ETF stuff and the flows. And it kind of further
- 10:41underpins. I was thinking about the other
- 10:42day, like how do we put out a call like for like, I wonder if
- 10:46there's like a bounty we can do of it was I was thinking about
- 10:50financial literacy and unit bias, right, Because we all know
- 10:53and it's really sad, but like somebody can really pull
- 10:55themselves out of, you know, some deep stuff if they just
- 10:58realize if they've stacked 510, whatever it is.
- 11:01And I was thinking about it because my wife just jokes
- 11:02around, she's a cash app and there's like significant money
- 11:04and she hasn't put a lot of money there.
- 11:05She's just been doing it one off like for the past five years.
- 11:09And I was like, that actually is material for most Americans and
- 11:13but there's no like financial literacy that's really tied into
- 11:16that from exchanges. So I'll make this short like
- 11:18there, there just needs to be and I don't think it costs a
- 11:20lot. It can probably built off a lot
- 11:21of like the rails we've created, but it's just a SAT space
- 11:24exchange. And then it just focuses on like
- 11:26financial literacy and like how you save and preserve wealth.
- 11:30Like nobody does that and it's such a no brainer anyway.
- 11:35So that ties into the to the. Yeah, I was listening to Bill
- 11:40Gurley's pod over the weekend and and he was talking about, I
- 11:43guess an initiative that he's been very close to is
- 11:47effectively trying to have all high schools, I guess, have some
- 11:51sort of financial literacy education.
- 11:54But I think there's a massive gap there still because I think
- 11:56what he's talking about is like, you know, how to how to use a
- 11:59checkbook, how to have like, you know, checking your savings
- 12:02account. It's like, you know, you
- 12:03actually need to go a little bit deeper than that and like
- 12:05understand what money is to have like true financial literacy.
- 12:09So I think it's a noble effort, but I think there's still
- 12:11massive gaps in terms of how people perceive like what you
- 12:14know, what is what do people need to be learning about in
- 12:17terms of personal finances? It's like there's, there's the
- 12:20first layer of just like, you know how, how credit card debt
- 12:23kill you, but then you take it a step further and like
- 12:26understand, well, how do you actually save in a form of money
- 12:29that can't be debased? And so I think there's still
- 12:32some some additional learning that that needs to go on there,
- 12:34but a noble effort nevertheless. That was, yeah.
- 12:37It's the pod that made me think of it.
- 12:39Like, again, I was listening to the same thing.
- 12:41Sorry though. Yeah, I did this well, but it's
- 12:45it's completely disconnected or like you can't teach that
- 12:48financial literacy because people will naturally ask like,
- 12:52OK, well, I just made money. Like, why can't I just save it
- 12:55in dollars? And the answer is it goes down
- 12:57in value over time. And, you know, the natural
- 12:59answer is, you know, we need to put that money to work into
- 13:02something else. And the reasons for that are
- 13:06essentially just speculating on, you know, the S&P 500 will
- 13:10continue to go up over time through monetary debasement.
- 13:14And I, I think that's completely at odds with, you know, public
- 13:18government education of financial literacy.
- 13:22And so I, I'm just like not very optimistic that that will happen
- 13:26in a meaningful way, unfortunately.
- 13:28There was the other related initiative, I forget, I'm
- 13:32blanking on what they called it, but they were originally
- 13:34referring to it as like the Trump accounts.
- 13:35But it's like these saving accounts for all kids in
- 13:38America. They'll have access to at least,
- 13:40you know, a starting amount of like $1000 that's put into the
- 13:43S&P. It's like, OK, that's a step in
- 13:45the right direction, but like you should have the option to
- 13:47put that in Bitcoin, not the S and.
- 13:49Pi think to Liam's point, I think to Liam's point is we were
- 13:53this is like way off topic. If we got to figure out the the
- 13:56but like this is, it's just effectively like socialism, like
- 14:02what he's which we're describing.
- 14:04And because it's making the case that we can't actually make the
- 14:08money and then like give back and deliver better serve like we
- 14:12can than the government. Because like what Brian's
- 14:15pointing to is whatever that Gerstner and Dell did is like,
- 14:18it's like when you're born, you get $1000 and then it compounds
- 14:22and you get access to the equity market.
- 14:24It's like that sounds good at face value until you realize,
- 14:27well, that's coming from somewhere.
- 14:28It's not free. And then, well, why am I giving
- 14:30it to you versus I'll figure out how to give it to you.
- 14:32And I, I anyway, I'll bring it up later because there's a,
- 14:36there's a deep rabbit hole I went into like, you know, the
- 14:40Great Depression, Roosevelt and like all this stuff has just
- 14:43been this long game of socialism to mask kind of like the debt.
- 14:47And they make up these reasons like, Oh, it's OK, It's a little
- 14:49debt for the kid. But then like there's all this
- 14:51other, you know, stuff. But going back to the ETF, the
- 14:55volatility and options, I think that's something that has been
- 14:58under discussed is the institutional capital and
- 15:03products that have come into this space.
- 15:05It will probably material dampen the volatility and we've kind of
- 15:10seen that more like recently and I think it's been pushed over to
- 15:15it won't be forever. Like I do still think we'll see
- 15:18substantial volatility, but it won't be like what we
- 15:20historically saw with these headlines where Bitcoin would
- 15:24move in 10 to 20% in a day. We're seeing this in the like
- 15:27equity markets now with the OR specifically with the Bitcoin
- 15:30treasury markets where the volatility has moved over.
- 15:34And I thought that was just like an interesting aspect.
- 15:37Like this has been a pretty steady climb to 123.
- 15:41I've never seen it like this from, you call it beginning of
- 15:44last year to now. There hasn't really been wild
- 15:47moves outside of, you know, 5 to 10% over the course of a couple
- 15:50weeks. Yeah, also we're sharing we
- 15:53haven't made a new new all time high in gold terms, which I
- 15:56think is is just worthy of, of pointing out.
- 15:58You can see there's sort of a, I'm not a, I'm not ATA guy by
- 16:01any means, but there is some resistance at these levels here
- 16:05in terms of Bitcoin Express in gold.
- 16:07So something else to to take note of as well.
- 16:12Where do we, where do we want to go from here, boys?
- 16:14We had we had a few few things on the list to get to we
- 16:18Michael, I was going to go to your tweet, but.
- 16:24Let's do it. I don't even know what we put do
- 16:27these things and then I love when they get to come back.
- 16:30You you wanted to share a tweet from yourself?
- 16:33Oh, well, it's not really from me.
- 16:35I just I just post this stuff because we need it somewhere
- 16:38that's concise. So the the quote is allocation
- 16:41as an art. It's a beautiful, impressive
- 16:42thing, though unfortunately it increasingly it is increasingly
- 16:45less applicable a term to what venture capitalists do.
- 16:50This was from Kyle Harrison, who I think is probably one of the
- 16:53best kind of writers thought leaders in the traditional
- 16:57venture space. He's at contrary research.
- 16:59He's been a number of venture firms before.
- 17:01They write really great memos, but he put out a piece this
- 17:05Sunday and it was referencing that, you know, again,
- 17:08allocation is a beautiful thing, but he's he refers to it.
- 17:10It's not what venture capitalists do.
- 17:12And at face value, you'd be like, well, that doesn't make
- 17:14sense because they're allocating capital.
- 17:15And then he kind of further goes to say, don't get me wrong,
- 17:18venture capitalists have capital.
- 17:19They allocate in that sense that they have it and then they
- 17:22don't. But what makes allocation such a
- 17:24magical concept is the strategic implications of how the capital
- 17:27is allocated. And I think this is really kind
- 17:29of, maybe it sounds pedantic, but it's really fundamentally
- 17:33different than somebody just deploying dollars because true
- 17:37allocation has to have the context of not only where the
- 17:39capital goes, but whether it's timing or synergy gets thrown
- 17:43around a lot, but how it compounds with others.
- 17:45And I think that people often forget how amazing allocators
- 17:50like Jeff Bezos and Mark Zuckerberg and Jeff Bezos in
- 17:54particular, because I think people don't know that he owned
- 17:57at one time like 5 to 7 1/2%. He was one of the earliest
- 18:00investors. I think he invested it was so 5
- 18:03million. I I think it was $5,000,000
- 18:05valuation into Google. And but then post that he then
- 18:12this right here that in O six, he did this pivot for taking the
- 18:16warehouse infrastructure and moving into AWS.
- 18:18And this was a big investment and everyone looked at it,
- 18:21including Wall Street, like it was crazy.
- 18:23And then similarly, they, they look back at Zuckerberg and
- 18:26Instagram. And I just thought this was an
- 18:28important thing to call out because it's one thing to
- 18:32allocate capital and and try to go back into dollar terms.
- 18:35It's another thing when you kind of look at a business and an
- 18:38opportunity from the vantage point of where the market sits,
- 18:42the unique opportunity that we understand the money is
- 18:44changing. But then also as you're building
- 18:46businesses, you can kind of spot the angles on it, how
- 18:49compounding forces will occur that most people don't because
- 18:52they're looking in almost like a 2D fashion of how do I like get
- 18:55my return profile versus a long game that these guys are
- 18:58ultimately playing long games. And it's no question these the
- 19:01Jobs, the Zuckerberg, the Basil Rolls are Co founder like CEO.
- 19:05They're not people that were managers that got put into these
- 19:07positions because they just can't help but only see the
- 19:10world in a certain like transactional view versus people
- 19:13like this. You know, it's super
- 19:15interesting. I mean, in that context, what do
- 19:17you make of Zuckerberg's latest sort of capital allocation
- 19:24decision to basically Aqua hire folks from Open AI and other
- 19:27places for, you know, hundreds of millions of dollars in in
- 19:31salary? Is that a logical use of, of
- 19:35capital in this, in sort of this, you know, this race that
- 19:39we've talked about past few weeks in terms of just throwing
- 19:42piles of cash at AI in particular, do you see a shift
- 19:47in his mindset in terms of like how he's how he's thinking about
- 19:50allocating capital if he's willing to do that?
- 19:53It's a great question because I think we're like in a transition
- 19:57phase and I haven't heard this. If you curious you guys thoughts
- 19:59like there's the traditional sense in the Fiat tratify world
- 20:02that the dollar is your return. And then these guys are playing
- 20:06for something else that I don't know what it is.
- 20:07I don't know if it's IPAGI, there's something else.
- 20:09And at the end of the day, they're all going to realize
- 20:11they're all playing for Bitcoin and we're in a transition phase.
- 20:14And so like they're not like thinking in dollar terms.
- 20:16I don't think they're thinking in dollar terms or in Bitcoin
- 20:19terms. They're thinking in like total
- 20:22addressable market ownership stake in like global commerce.
- 20:26I don't think they're looking at this because these numbers keep
- 20:29changing, but if you had to like do a return on investment, I
- 20:33think that the total allocation, I saw it written somewhere that
- 20:37was like 1% of Facebook's total market cap for this bet to win
- 20:43AI. So it's pretty that's like that
- 20:46was the most straightforward that I saw.
- 20:47It's like, so it's 1% of its total business to win
- 20:49potentially AGI or win whatever they're competing for.
- 20:54It's pretty good, right? You know ROI.
- 20:57It's one aspect that I thought was interesting too is
- 21:03essentially there was somebody who was thinking about this a
- 21:06little bit differently and would be curious if you guys thought
- 21:08it's like if essentially 1% of all venture investments drive
- 21:12all the returns. It's not that illogical to think
- 21:15about it from an employee standpoint of there are
- 21:19significant people who can make outsize contributions to a
- 21:23company and the direction of it. I do think that they need to
- 21:26have a, a massive stake in the vision of where things are
- 21:31going, like the, the Jobs, the Zuckerberg, the basis of the
- 21:34world. But I can understand from that
- 21:37perspective why they would be willing to pay that much money.
- 21:41I, I don't know. I don't have a strong view yet
- 21:45because I don't know what they're playing for.
- 21:47And, and I'm not that deep in the space, but it's interesting
- 21:49for sure. The other interesting just just
- 21:53about this, this tweet that we still have up.
- 21:56If you think about the the Instagram acquisition, one of
- 21:59you know, I think most would perceive as one of the greatest
- 22:02acquisitions of all time in terms of its IRR, 65% IRR over
- 22:0613 years. I don't have the exact numbers
- 22:09in front of me, but I think Bitcoin's IRR over 13 years is
- 22:12probably closer to 100%. I know it's 65 around the past
- 22:15five years or so. So even even if you know one of
- 22:19the greatest acquisitions of all time would have underperformed,
- 22:22just buying Bitcoin worth pointing out.
- 22:28With that said, but I think that's where the allocation
- 22:31decision comes in because you can make the case that Instagram
- 22:35delivered more enterprise value than that return, I guess if
- 22:41I've read that. And well, that's revenue per
- 22:44year, but we don't know like the creative value.
- 22:47Like that's the thing with money is it's just money.
- 22:49So it's not it gives you optionality if you didn't have
- 22:51any. But this would potentially be
- 22:52more Bitcoin terms if there would have like spit out more
- 22:54capital to buy more Bitcoin. Right.
- 22:59Yeah. Hey, guys.
- 23:01Thanks again for tuning in to another episode of Final
- 23:04Settlement. We had a awesome pod talking
- 23:06about all the things happening in the current market landscape.
- 23:10Just this morning, I believe DCG filed for IPO as well as the
- 23:15price. I think last night top ticked
- 23:17close to $123,000. It's a very exciting time in the
- 23:20industry and no better time to learn about multi institution
- 23:24custody and everything that we're doing at on Ramp.
- 23:27Folks may be interested. I've heard of us would encourage
- 23:30you to schedule some time or look at what we're building in
- 23:33the institutional, kind of private institutional across the
- 23:36board custody landscape. But if you're not ready and you
- 23:40just want to follow along closer, we just recently put out
- 23:43a really great report with the Bitcoin Policy Institute.
- 23:46We worked on it with them and had them on the podcast last
- 23:50week. Zach Shapiro, Zach Cohen
- 23:52specifically talking about the strategic Bitcoin Reserve
- 23:54playbook, the toolkit for adoption for all states,
- 23:58including the United States, and multi institution custody was a
- 24:02big component of it. We like in and joke.
- 24:05If multi institution custody is good enough for a sovereign, it
- 24:07should probably good be good enough for a few individuals.
- 24:10And so we'd love to talk with you if you're interested,
- 24:12schedule a time with us via our website.
- 24:14You can book a time directly on the web page or you can just
- 24:18sign up and go through our onboarding flow.
- 24:21All right, on to the rest of the show.
- 24:24Next one on the list, Michael, I think this is one of yours, but
- 24:28VCs on which crypto companies could IPO next any anything
- 24:31worth pulling out of here? So I'll wrap, I'll wrap two
- 24:36parts to this. So the first one is this is a
- 24:37block article referencing the crypto VCs.
- 24:43They were pontificating on what companies are going public next.
- 24:46It was funny because this came out, we were going to talk about
- 24:48it and then it came out this morning that I believe DCG is
- 24:50going to be filing for an IPO. If you Scroll down, I think it's
- 24:56talking about the multi year multi.
- 25:00I think we paused right there. Yeah, if you go up, so I forget
- 25:07who it was quoted, but it was explaining basically we're in a
- 25:09multi year kind of market for IP OS, which I think is true.
- 25:12I think it's going to be very fascinating to see what happens
- 25:15just given what we see behind the scenes.
- 25:18I feel like we this, this is an extended.
- 25:20Can you keep it there though? Because I wanted to go and we're
- 25:22an extended. There's just BC it'll be
- 25:25interesting to see how far this market runs with Bitcoin.
- 25:28And then I think the market as Bitcoin runs, everything else
- 25:31follows, including the amount of companies that'll be able to
- 25:33IPO. They reference OK X Uphold,
- 25:36Falcon X Ledger, chain analysis, fire blocks consensus and then
- 25:41DCG as another one. So I think it's going to be
- 25:44interesting. I think this extends not just a
- 25:47crypto, these are just a crypto piece.
- 25:48But I think in general, the amount of, I think Circle is a
- 25:53great proxy for interested in this digital asset space.
- 25:56The thing that I think most of these firms are missing and it's
- 25:58going to be very interesting, like we got to figure out a
- 26:01piece on this. But I'm confident the way people
- 26:04miss Bitcoin and they're still not woken up is going to be how
- 26:07these people like in this world missed underlying custody.
- 26:11Because right now everyone's talking about stable coins.
- 26:14Everyone's trying to figure out their stable coin game plan and
- 26:16the securitization. And they're all going to like
- 26:19net settle or end up trading like the real anchor pair is
- 26:23BTC. And then you want to get closer
- 26:24to that. And none of them are actually
- 26:26focused on underlying. Like how do you get a position
- 26:28of the 21 million? And that's like the biggest
- 26:30asymmetry once you understand Bitcoin if you're building
- 26:33infrastructure and none of them care about it.
- 26:35And so that's another just like unique opportunity that we're
- 26:37really kind of focusing on right now.
- 26:40I I love that you brought that up because I have kind of two
- 26:44things that come from it. One, yeah, the, the first people
- 26:47who came through the door in these in the crypto space, they
- 26:52naturally got distracted with everything else.
- 26:55And so at the same time, I think there are new entrants that are,
- 27:01you know, coming in now. I think, you know, Bitcoin
- 27:03dominance is 65%. All of the, there's a lot of
- 27:08noise in the market, but you can tell by the Bitcoin ETFs versus
- 27:11everything else that Bitcoin is completely different than, you
- 27:14know, institutional demand for Ethereum, et cetera.
- 27:18And you know, from a personal anecdotal side of things like
- 27:22the retail interest isn't there. I'm not sure how many texts you
- 27:24guys get from, from friends and those who are just interested in
- 27:28Bitcoin, but it's probably not a lot.
- 27:30What I have seen is my friend who's, you know, VP at a private
- 27:35equity firm, he's, you know, looking for a new job and he's
- 27:39like, OK, here's an investment firm that they that I applied
- 27:43to, but they have a corporate development role.
- 27:45And the corporate development role is just buying AI
- 27:48companies. And they're also going to
- 27:50implement a Bitcoin treasury strategy.
- 27:53And so he went out to me and was like trying to understand what
- 27:57is the arbitrage play that they're doing?
- 27:59And and obviously happy to explain that to him.
- 28:02But I think the some of what we've been talking about of the
- 28:07illiquidity of private equity investments and them staying
- 28:11private for longer will change as some of them, you know, as
- 28:15we've seen with Figma just buying Bitcoin and you know,
- 28:18keeping that as a small amount as well as some of them going
- 28:21public. And most of I think there will
- 28:24be more than we anticipate or more than most people anticipate
- 28:29in terms of returns driven through portfolio companies of
- 28:33venture and private equity firms buying Bitcoin as well as
- 28:36selling some going public because they have not given
- 28:40money back to investors yet. And so naturally when you do
- 28:44that, the investors will ask the question of well, why are you
- 28:51having the company buy Bitcoin? Like why can't I just do it
- 28:53myself? And not as especially because
- 28:57many of these publicly traded companies, their main KPI is
- 29:01just like, how much more Bitcoin am I getting?
- 29:03Over time, the LP's will naturally ask that same question
- 29:07and that's kind of why. And then that will be something
- 29:12that the general partners have to naturally change as well.
- 29:15They're going to have to change their carry and hurdle rate to
- 29:19be higher than Bitcoin. Otherwise, people can just buy
- 29:21it themselves. And I just thought it was super
- 29:25interesting that the early rider's thesis that we've
- 29:27started to talk about like a year ago is coming out to not
- 29:32just Bitcoin companies, but pretty much there are early
- 29:36signs that it's going to transition to the rest of the
- 29:40private equity and venture world as well.
- 29:44Yeah, that's super fascinating and yeah, something that I think
- 29:49we would all expect to see continue head that way.
- 29:52But it's it's interesting to see that sort of specific anecdote
- 29:55from someone in more of the traditional PE space kind of
- 29:59realizing like, you know, this is, you know, obviously becoming
- 30:05potentially an overcrowded saturated trade of just like,
- 30:08you know, spinning out public Bitcoin treasury company type
- 30:12deal. But I think you're going to, you
- 30:15know, we might still be in the very early innings of it is, is
- 30:18really the take away. It could extend a lot farther.
- 30:21Than we think well every company is going to buy Bitcoin too.
- 30:25I mean the the premium may or or may not be saturated, but the
- 30:30owning Bitcoin itself is is still very early in the trade
- 30:33for every company A. 100. Percent yeah, I think I think
- 30:36the big question for me on the the Pub Co stuff is it if it
- 30:39ends up in a it's going to burnout.
- 30:44I can make any bet it'll burnout.
- 30:45It's just does it burnout like with a bang or does it like with
- 30:48a whimper? And what I mean by that is does
- 30:51the market naturally de lever because there's some kind of
- 30:54like understanding if somebody gets rugged with counterparty
- 30:57risk or they all start to play a trade because this is what
- 31:00happened in 22 with everyone in the three AC and that's what
- 31:02caused the systemic risk problem.
- 31:05And so does it all just like de lever at once.
- 31:07It probably ends up like that because that's just how this
- 31:09industry works is as quick as it goes up, it goes down.
- 31:12But the alternative of way, and it's not to say they're mutually
- 31:15exclusive, but the the alternative whimper is what Liam
- 31:19saying is like, it's just going to be understood that whether
- 31:21it's in bonds, whether it's in insurance and specifically pub
- 31:26public equities and private equity, you just have to hold
- 31:29Bitcoin and you just have to hold it.
- 31:31And they'll just make up all those BS reasons why it'll be
- 31:33like AI and you got to like preserve and like it'll make all
- 31:36these reasons. But I think the day they'll come
- 31:37around to like, oh, this is just like a savings account.
- 31:40And then you'll just have some premium on, we'll make up new
- 31:43numbers like on, you know, you know, whether it's DCF or
- 31:49multiples, like we'll just come up with new numbers on what the
- 31:52underlying business coupled with their Bitcoin treasury and then
- 31:54how much Bitcoin they're creating.
- 31:55And then that'll be like what the equity market will absorb.
- 31:59But again, you can see how it goes that way.
- 32:00But between now and there, there's going to be a lot of
- 32:03education on who's actually delivering value and and who's
- 32:07not. Yeah.
- 32:09It's just going to be multiples on how much Bitcoin you can
- 32:12deliver per year and if that is sustainable or if you think it
- 32:19increases or decreases over time.
- 32:23Yeah. And to to Mike's point, like the
- 32:25the big thing that nobody's even talking about is just
- 32:27counterparty risk. And like that, that probably if
- 32:30there is some sort of deleveraging event in my mind,
- 32:32it's probably related to that where some custodian fails and
- 32:36some some way shape or form. And then there's a a recognition
- 32:40from everyone who's invested in these proxy exposures of, well,
- 32:44who's my underlying counterparty layers to need the surface.
- 32:48My bet is it is it's, it's probably, it could be custodian.
- 32:52I, I think it ends up being just somebody gets on the risk curve,
- 32:57like you can always know it's suspect if somebody doesn't want
- 32:59to show you their balance, if they're a public shareholder or
- 33:02they have shareholders, because you know, that just inspires and
- 33:06invokes confidence, especially in a world where this does
- 33:08happen. And the reason why they don't is
- 33:10because they naturally are going to want to extend leverage and
- 33:12not want you to see or have optionality for leverage.
- 33:15And so that optionality is ultimately going to end up in a
- 33:19rugging because that's what happens in that's exactly what's
- 33:21happening for 15 years is when people are naked with the
- 33:24Bitcoin, you end up losing it all.
- 33:27And so that'll happen. And then that'll be when the
- 33:30people start waking up to like, where does the assets sit?
- 33:32And then we'll probably end up for a longer run because then
- 33:34it'll be like, oh, they have it here, but then like who's
- 33:36auditing? Where is it on chain?
- 33:38And then somebody else will rugby, they'll say it was there,
- 33:40but it wasn't there. And then you all kind of end up
- 33:42until like a more transparent way.
- 33:43And we've all talked about the custody with what we do.
- 33:46So we don't have to probably go deep.
- 33:49Well, slight transition. We had referenced some noise.
- 33:52Generally speaking, I, I would, I would categorize this as as
- 33:56some noise in the market, but pumped up fund raised 500
- 33:59million in a matter of minutes in a, in a token sale.
- 34:07Any thoughts around it? We've sort of talked around this
- 34:09of like the, you know, broader crypto X Bitcoin is sort of out
- 34:13of narratives and it's either stable coins or literal casino
- 34:17gambling a la pump fun type websites.
- 34:22And so yeah, I I think this is just an indicator that that is
- 34:26the case. You know, outside of Bitcoin
- 34:30stable coins, really the the use case for all these crypto
- 34:34networks is, is predominantly gambling.
- 34:37And as we've discussed, the sort of expected value on this form
- 34:41of gambling is actually worse than stepping foot in a casino.
- 34:44And so it is very representative of sort of broader financial
- 34:48nihilism, which we've spoken about.
- 34:50And people feeling like this is their their only way out, their
- 34:53only way to accumulate some Bitcoin is to to gamble on
- 34:57pumped up fun. Any thoughts on this?
- 35:00I think it's all kind of gambling and nihilism.
- 35:04I kind of like the, the, the like the pump fund versus the,
- 35:09the treasury just because it's so shady and like quick and and
- 35:11fast. Like it's just like get in and
- 35:13get out. I think, I think it's all, I
- 35:16think what's fascinating to talk about this is just how the
- 35:18market structure around venture capital in the digital asset
- 35:22space is, is kind of not transitioning, but like
- 35:26morphine. So you got like VCs that are
- 35:28going into these pipes, right, because there's no real
- 35:30opportunity. So now, like venture capitals
- 35:32are going into the pre funding of these treasury companies to
- 35:36return. They're now called digital
- 35:38asset, they're called Dats, just in case anybody's curious, if
- 35:41you're listening. So the digital asset treasury
- 35:43companies, because they're not, you know, just a Bitcoin now.
- 35:45So you have I think this week or this past week there was Solana
- 35:49theory, I guess hyper liquid, another couple, but there's
- 35:52these are will continue to grow. I think I think we'll see more
- 35:59of this, which we're describing with a pump the because I know
- 36:02we've had this discussion on like the, the dominance level
- 36:08with Bitcoin. And I think ultimately we'll see
- 36:10the dominance top out at whatever point that actually, I
- 36:17can't pick the point outside of we'll start to like see it flow
- 36:20into the crypto market, start to speculate more outside of the
- 36:25traditional equity markets. And I don't know what that looks
- 36:30like, but you're going to see the transition of like there'll
- 36:32be the Bitcoin equities and then the crypto equities.
- 36:34And then you'll see like different layer block chains.
- 36:37And then they'll start to like absorb them into these.
- 36:40They'll be like a recursive loop.
- 36:41And then we'll start to see that transition.
- 36:45Where is it at right now? I see you pulling it up.
- 36:47What's the number? This is this is X stable coins
- 36:51and it's around Look it looks like 76%.
- 36:54It was as high as close to 80 couple weeks ago.
- 36:58Let's come down a little bit, but I remain bullish Bitcoin
- 37:02dominance. I think, you know, I, I
- 37:06understand the arguments around these other treasury companies
- 37:09being spun up with other assets. I think they're de minimis in
- 37:12scales relative to what MSTR and others are doing.
- 37:17I also think like, you know, as we've talked about in the past,
- 37:19people are expressing their views in different ways and it's
- 37:22not necessarily accruing to the native tokens.
- 37:26Ethereum, Solana, you know, Ethereum is, is languishing at
- 37:32at this point. And you know, I think around
- 37:35like 3K and the last time, you know, it was at 3K, Bitcoin was
- 37:39at half this price. So that is, you know, reflected
- 37:41in this sort of slow grind upward in terms of dominance.
- 37:44And in order for this to top out, as you're sort of alluding
- 37:47to, like you would need a massive shift in terms of
- 37:51institutional appetite for Ethereum effectively, which I
- 37:54just don't necessarily see on the horizon.
- 37:56You've got the Tom Lee's of the world showing what they're doing
- 38:00in terms of, you know, trying to do an MSTR strategy with
- 38:03Ethereum. I just don't think that that's
- 38:04going to have the same appetite because it's just, you know,
- 38:09what we've seen with the ETF flows.
- 38:11There's there's been almost no. Yeah, one thing to say is I can
- 38:17see a world where that's right, like where there's a top five,
- 38:23you know, basket of crypto and then they it ends up playing
- 38:28into dats or whatever. And then people are really the
- 38:31volatility, like we talked about ends up going into private and
- 38:33public equity businesses that are traded on, you know, whether
- 38:37it's on the stock market or, you know, these other block chains
- 38:40that are going to be trading. I, I still hold out that that's
- 38:45not the case simply because like I kind of want that to be true.
- 38:53I just don't think it'll be true because if we're all set and we
- 38:57agreed no retail is in like this is just smart money, then, then
- 39:03then of course they're not in like this garbage.
- 39:07But if we are going to come back to a crypto bull market where
- 39:13everyone comes in and everyone's cab driver, Uber drivers is
- 39:17they're not going to understand any of this shit.
- 39:19That's always, and that's been my case this whole time is the
- 39:21price is going to RIP. And then naturally people in the
- 39:23crypto market cycle into these other assets.
- 39:25Other things get spun up, other means get spun up and vibes and
- 39:29then you naturally end up in that like reversion back to it.
- 39:33That's the case that I've made and I still make his retails.
- 39:36Not here. If we were at like $550,000 and
- 39:39this thing was at the same place or moving up, then I'd like say
- 39:41OK, but we just all admitted like nobody in retails here.
- 39:44So why would? Here's the here's the
- 39:47counterpoint that I think is going to happen is, you know, if
- 39:52you're not one of those dats, I guess then then no companies are
- 39:59going to buy like Ethereum or or Solana or any of this stuff.
- 40:02Like I think that the bid from privately held companies with no
- 40:06plans of going public as well as just investment firms that want
- 40:11exposure to Bitcoin is going to be larger than retail demand for
- 40:15all coins because you know, retail will will gamble.
- 40:18But I think that the long sovereign private company bid
- 40:23and investment bid for Bitcoin. Well, it's just like too big and
- 40:28and larger than retail interest that will inevitably go into all
- 40:32coins and I think that's just kind of a maturation of the
- 40:36market today. Yeah, that's it.
- 40:38Yeah, that's a good take. I mean that that's kind of been
- 40:41my thinking is like, even if you do see that retail bid for all
- 40:45coins, it's going to be just magnitude smaller than the pools
- 40:49of capital bidding Bitcoin going forward.
- 40:51Like if we get to 500 K per Bitcoin like that, that is going
- 40:54to be in part due to a sovereign bid in my mind.
- 40:57And like sovereigns are just not going to be bidding all coins.
- 41:00So it's just totally different pools of capital and the sort of
- 41:02magnitude and size of them. I think it'll be very difficult
- 41:06for the altcoin space to actually eat into Bitcoin
- 41:10dominance going forward. Yeah, I, I just, I, I think that
- 41:18it's, it's, it seemed right. I just can't help but feel that
- 41:24the institutional capital that will make up stories to sell
- 41:28like the what was the recent stuff that JPM, I think it was
- 41:31JP Morgan did. It's like an internal Ledger,
- 41:33like there's just going to be so many.
- 41:35Yeah, they came out with something either yesterday or
- 41:38the day before saying like something about bullish about
- 41:40Ethereum. So I I hear that side of it.
- 41:43I just don't think I don't think enough capital is going to
- 41:45actually buy the story this time.
- 41:47Because if you look at Ethereum like it's actually losing it
- 41:52sort of protocol wars to Solana or hyper liquid, like it's not
- 41:56even it's not even the best bet if you're looking for a bet on
- 41:59those protocol networks. And because it's still the
- 42:03second biggest, like that's where the big delta is, because
- 42:06in order for Bitcoin dominance to actually come down
- 42:08materially, like it actually has to come from Ethereum, because
- 42:12if Ethereum is just losing ground, then you would need like
- 42:14massive, massive adoption of Salon or it's one of these other
- 42:17networks to actually eat into dominance.
- 42:20And if this ends up playing out, then my instincts would tell me
- 42:25that the capital that's all on the sidelines or supposed to be
- 42:28allocated to the space, it ends up merging.
- 42:31We're like crypto because we agree like a theory of Salon and
- 42:34some of these others aren't going to go away.
- 42:36No, probably others merged. You end up having them be baked
- 42:39into like equities and that's what gets the volatility in
- 42:43trading. And so this is just going to
- 42:44turn into like this other thing of like because you don't know
- 42:47it's you're moving. It's much easier to bet on Robin
- 42:50Hood, Coinbase or Circle than it is to like, oh, I'm going to.
- 42:54I'm going to pick which one of these protocols is going to win.
- 42:57That makes them. It makes a lot of sense.
- 43:00It's also very scary for a lot of people.
- 43:04Everyone, hope you're enjoying the podcast.
- 43:06We had an exciting discussion talking about all things related
- 43:09to digital assets, Bitcoin and market infrastructure and
- 43:12capital markets. It was an interesting
- 43:15conversation around the amount of hours worked per Bitcoin.
- 43:19It's a it's a trend. I think we'll increasingly see
- 43:21those metrics as discussed on the pod.
- 43:24It's something we've looked at very heavily as far as early
- 43:26riders and the way we look at the world when it comes to
- 43:29investing, building and how do you effectively return more
- 43:32Bitcoin than Bitcoin invested. And and that's a proxy for how
- 43:36do you return more value than time invested.
- 43:40And so if you're interested in learning about anything we're
- 43:43doing on the early writers side, we want to check out our
- 43:45research. I'd encourage you to go to
- 43:47earlywriters.com. We have no shortage of materials
- 43:50as well as newsletter that comes out every week, and we're
- 43:54consistently looking for entrepreneurs building in the
- 43:57space as well as folks looking to get involved in other ways.
- 44:00So you can reach out at earlywriters.com.
- 44:01You can shoot me a note at michaelearlywriters.com as well.
- 44:04On to the rest of the show. Yeah, yeah.
- 44:11All right, switching gears a little bit, Michael, you shared
- 44:14this tweet from our boy Matt Pines.
- 44:17What is he talking about here? Yeah, so Matt Pines retweeted.
- 44:24I don't know who Pippa Pippa Mulmagrin is, but whoever he was
- 44:30retweeting, she had tweeted about AI outsmarted 30 of the
- 44:35world's top mathematicians at a secret meeting.
- 44:38If you go back to the Pines tweet in the In This Long Form
- 44:41article we can link to, it said the mathematicians who
- 44:44participated had assigned on disclosure agreements requiring
- 44:47them to communicate solely via the messaging app Signal.
- 44:50Other forms of contacts, such as traditional e-mail, could
- 44:52potentially be scanned by an LLM and inadvertently train it,
- 44:55thereby contaminating the data set.
- 44:58And so Pines is effectively saying that he or he says
- 45:03exactly there's an underappreciated near future
- 45:05dynamic is 1 where human surveillance, the capital
- 45:08capitalism is replaced by AJI panopticon, where every packet
- 45:12is sniffed out by networks of autonomous LMS hungry for every
- 45:15digital morsel, where the Internet becomes a dark forest.
- 45:19And I thought this is important to call out because I think that
- 45:22we we talk internally and externally a lot about the
- 45:27underlying asset as a store of value.
- 45:29But I think we all agree and know that the Internet in its
- 45:32first version wasn't really built out and baked out
- 45:35correctly. And we've seen the
- 45:36centralization of these large, you know, behemoths like a
- 45:39Twitter or X or Facebook, among others.
- 45:43And there's a number of reasons why.
- 45:46And over time, there's going to be an encroachment on privacy
- 45:53and just, and we've seen this in other states or other countries
- 45:56specifically, we all know about China, but then even in the EU,
- 45:59it's increasingly becoming harder to, you know, with a
- 46:01censorship among other things. And this notion of privacy
- 46:06leveraging the Bitcoin protocol, I think will naturally emerge.
- 46:11And so I just thought it was a fascinating thing.
- 46:13I don't think it really plays out until we get more like
- 46:16things will get worse. And then also as things get
- 46:18worse, a lot of the people that built these existing worlds will
- 46:22also be adopting Bitcoin. And I think Jack is the the
- 46:25perfect example of this. And that's what you know, Pines
- 46:27references is Jack who recently put something out which was like
- 46:31an encrypted chat. I don't even know exactly how it
- 46:34works, but maybe Brian you've looked into it could share.
- 46:37Yeah, he's what? What Pines alludes to in that
- 46:40tweet is Jack came out, I guess over the weekend with a
- 46:45messaging app called Bit Chat that doesn't need Internet or
- 46:49cell service. It works over Bluetooth
- 46:51networks. And so this is sort of along
- 46:54those lines of, you know, broadening and thinking through
- 46:58ways of enhancing peer-to-peer networks that don't necessarily
- 47:02rely on centralized servers. So this is this I thought was
- 47:06pretty interesting and basically allows people to communicate via
- 47:11Bluetooth networks. Now there's some obvious like
- 47:14constraints around that, like you need to be near people, but
- 47:17the overarching idea is that similar to sort of how the
- 47:20Lightning network works, you could have basically hops that
- 47:24allow you to spread out this sort of mesh network of
- 47:29Bluetooths and, and any phones that are connected to it.
- 47:32And so sort of just interesting along some of the lines of like
- 47:36as this digital panopticon and, you know, the perhaps perverse
- 47:43incentives of of AI start to take hold, there's going to be
- 47:46sort of a, a, you know, work that needs to be done counter to
- 47:50that to preserve people's privacy and preserve
- 47:53decentralized networks that work in peer-to-peer fashion.
- 47:56And so this is, I think a step in that direction, but expect to
- 47:59see more things like this as sort of those risks materialize.
- 48:08All right, let's see what else we got on the list here.
- 48:13This was an interesting chart we're sharing sort of, you know,
- 48:17similar to the previous we were talking about earlier in the
- 48:20conversation. Just hours of work to buy one
- 48:22Bitcoin is ripping. And this is, you know, really
- 48:26indicative of just wages, you know, not keeping up with
- 48:29inflation generally speaking. And just that will make it
- 48:33harder and harder for people to accumulate one Bitcoin based on
- 48:37what they're earning in Fiat terms.
- 48:41Any. Thoughts on this?
- 48:43Yeah, this one stood out. I think there was 2 reasons.
- 48:46The first one was like, I think the version you hit on, which is
- 48:51just the measurement of amount of output for one Bitcoin.
- 48:55So we've talked about it, which is the measurement amount of
- 48:59investment into early riders versus amount of Bitcoin return.
- 49:01Like that just makes sense, right?
- 49:02But how much Bitcoin can I get if I put my Bitcoin at risk
- 49:05amount of time of your personal time at risk amount of number of
- 49:09employees to make one of those Bitcoin, right?
- 49:12Like there's a lot of like versions that I think that will
- 49:14just grow over time. The other one that is a little
- 49:18bit more of like A, and I don't want to say meta abstract is
- 49:21this notion of as it starts to increase the number of hours,
- 49:27like there's going to be a natural push pull between hours
- 49:30of Bitcoin to work and it'll go up and then it's going to go
- 49:33down and it's going to go up. And that's how the world gets
- 49:35more efficient because what's going to happen is people are
- 49:38inefficient today. This is a product of like too
- 49:41many, too many dollars. And this again, it sounds like
- 49:44theoretical until you kind of are inside an organization
- 49:46building it and you kind of think through, OK, how can one
- 49:48person produce more? And how can they do the work of
- 49:5010? And then they naturally would
- 49:52take less number of hours to produce that Bitcoin.
- 49:56So the idea is today it takes a number of hours to produce that
- 49:59Bitcoin because the price is rising and they're inefficient.
- 50:03And they'll try to get that Bitcoin at reduce work.
- 50:05So they'll be higher, more efficient to produce the same
- 50:08amount of output. And then that'll like start to
- 50:11drift because now you're, you're, you're basically
- 50:15becoming more efficient as the price is going up.
- 50:17So it commands more hours. And that's just basically like
- 50:20this edging all the way out into how we end up like in a
- 50:23different universe, if that makes sense.
- 50:26It does, It does. I think what what you're sort of
- 50:29describing is that this chart at current is not reflecting
- 50:34necessarily the go forward efficiency of a single person
- 50:39and their ability to leverage deflationary tools in order to
- 50:43you know, buy one Bitcoin faster than they currently can today.
- 50:47And so, yeah, to your point, this will be a very interesting
- 50:49chart to monitor going forward because I think if you see dips
- 50:53in this chart, it's not necessarily that Bitcoin prices
- 50:55going down, it's that we're all overall becoming more efficient
- 51:00as workers doing more with less excetera.
- 51:04Yeah. And then which causes more,
- 51:06you're doing more with less. And then then it gets harder to
- 51:11buy the Bitcoin because the bitcoins price is rising because
- 51:13they can purchase more. And this is like, this is the
- 51:16whole beauty of a finite supply. It's a really like heady thing
- 51:20to think about. But that's what I really thought
- 51:23of when I see this is because it won't always go up into the
- 51:26right like this. It will until, yeah, it's, it's
- 51:32one we got to like work on because I could see like in
- 51:34dollar terms, it'll go up into the right.
- 51:36But then eventually it'll be like a different metric.
- 51:40Or maybe it'll always be hours because hours are hours.
- 51:49But. Yeah, very interesting.
- 51:54One more deal that I thought was worth referencing was Core Weave
- 52:03to buy Core Scientific, the Bitcoin miner.
- 52:06This was a deal that was initially proposed last year
- 52:09actually I think for evaluation around 1 billion that got
- 52:14rejected. It's now they're now buying Core
- 52:18for around 9 billion, I believe. And I, I found this interesting
- 52:22just in the from the perspective of I think there was a lot of
- 52:27talk around basically miners on both, you know, on the Bitcoin
- 52:34side, diversifying to service various forms of AI compute.
- 52:40And this is sort of that, but in the other direction.
- 52:42So, you know, an AI focus company acquiring the
- 52:47infrastructure of a Bitcoin miner.
- 52:50This is also interesting because Core Scientific went bankrupt,
- 52:53then restructured. I think they emerge from that
- 52:55restructuring in the beginning of 2024 and that's when they
- 52:58sort of started their own internal pivot more to the AI
- 53:01side of things. And so you could see that as
- 53:04sort of, you know, the initial stages of moving towards this
- 53:08type of deal where they would just get acquired by an AI
- 53:11company. And so that is now occurring.
- 53:14I think the other take away from this to me is sort of just
- 53:17points to the ruthless competitive nature of Bitcoin
- 53:21mining space where I think you're going to start to see
- 53:26less super large Bitcoin mining companies like core was.
- 53:33And basically, you know, see over time Bitcoin mining pushed
- 53:38to smaller scale operations more on the the edges.
- 53:42And part of that is also just from the competitive perspective
- 53:47of the largest variable in Bitcoin mining being your, your
- 53:50energy cost. And as nation states get more
- 53:53involved in Bitcoin mining, they will in all likelihood, you
- 53:57know, have access to energy sources which are 0 cost to
- 54:01them. And so that just makes it harder
- 54:03for a, you know, public miner, whether in the US or otherwise
- 54:07to compete if they are, you know, have some amount of cost
- 54:10relative to their, you know, to their infrastructure, to their
- 54:13electricity costs, I should say. And so I think All in all could
- 54:18be a positive sort of trajectory in terms of the decentralization
- 54:21of mining, not having it as concentrated with these super
- 54:24large sort of mega farms. Any thoughts on on this deal or
- 54:29or sort of how the mining space is evolving?
- 54:32Yeah, I completely agree with it will decentralized over time.
- 54:38I think this is this is kind of a Trojan horse for all these AI
- 54:43companies starting to learn about Bitcoin and the importance
- 54:47of it as a strategic treasury asset.
- 54:50Because naturally if you buy a Bitcoin miner, they drive all of
- 54:55their revenues in Bitcoin. So they have to make a conscious
- 54:57decision, do I sell my Bitcoin or do I keep it in Bitcoin?
- 55:02And they will naturally do the analysis as part of the due
- 55:04diligence. Has that Bitcoin gone up over
- 55:07time and performed better than cash?
- 55:10Or like how do we think about selling Bitcoin as a treasury
- 55:16asset in order to cover expenses?
- 55:18Because, you know, their expenses are still dollar
- 55:20denominated. And once they do that analysis,
- 55:23they're going to realize that over a long period of time,
- 55:27holding the Bitcoin is better than selling it for dollars,
- 55:30especially if you don't have expenses that you need to pay
- 55:33right away. And I think this is one of the
- 55:35Trojan horse ways in that the AI industry understands that having
- 55:41Bitcoin is is very important as a corporate.
- 55:47Yeah. I don't have much else to add
- 55:50other than I think it's going to be extremely fascinating the
- 55:53confluence of sovereigns, AI data centers and then Bitcoin
- 55:59and how they just naturally integrate together.
- 56:03Because to your point, like it makes zero sense for any AI data
- 56:09center company to not have any like R&D or understanding of how
- 56:12Bitcoin mining works because it's pure optionality.
- 56:14If you need to basically like move over for whatever reason,
- 56:18whether the the Bitcoin price rises to a point where it makes
- 56:21it economical to switch that to giving you opportunity to just
- 56:25even negotiating. And so, and that's just one
- 56:29aspect that's like not even talking about the intersection
- 56:31between AI and Bitcoin. A few things before jumping.
- 56:38It's just like a crypto crypto corner over here that I thought
- 56:42was interesting and it just relates to Bitcoin that I guess
- 56:46this is crypto week. So they're supposed to be the
- 56:48genius act, clarity Act and then the anti CBDC and my
- 56:52understanding, curse your understanding is genius looks
- 56:55good, which is a stable coin bill clarity, which is more
- 56:58market structures, probably not anywhere near on the table to be
- 57:03done. And then the anti CBDC I don't
- 57:05actually know. And then the other thing was
- 57:08related to I don't know his exact.
- 57:10I got to look it up, but it's his name is Jonathan.
- 57:14I want to say gold maybe, but he's the new OCC head of the
- 57:19OCC. He was a proponent put together
- 57:23a piece about halting choke point 2.0 and then he was
- 57:26actually the last person, I forgot what his role was
- 57:29previously at the OCC that approved Anchorage for the
- 57:31banking side. And I think those are all super
- 57:34just fascinating when you think about the growth in maturation
- 57:36of the industry because you've seen what is it bit go Coinbase
- 57:41and maybe one other circle looking for bank charters.
- 57:44I think we're going to naturally start to see this convergence
- 57:47between digital asset firms and bank trust and what does it look
- 57:52like to hold deposits, lend against them.
- 57:54And, and it's kind of like it goes under the underlying thesis
- 57:57of we just like end up in an extended bull market into
- 58:00probably like late next year, if not even further.
- 58:03Because there's just a lot of things getting executed and
- 58:07delivered to the market that still aren't priced in or the
- 58:10flows haven't been brought in yet.
- 58:11And there's not much leverage is the last piece.
- 58:14Like I don't think we've seen a lot.
- 58:15There's not much leverage in the system yet.
- 58:18Yeah, so you're saying super cycle?
- 58:20No. I think that there's.
- 58:24Probably a lot of leverage. Outside of the system, on the
- 58:26Bitcoin treasury companies, etc. Possible.
- 58:30Not not even that the Bitcoin treasury companies are too
- 58:33leveraged. It's the people that are buying
- 58:36shares of the Bitcoin treasury company are too leveraged.
- 58:39Yeah, I mean, there's that and there's definitely a lot of, you
- 58:41know, dear, dear diligence, but a lot of treasury companies that
- 58:44have Bitcoin that's not their Bitcoin.
- 58:46They have some, yeah, 33 different levels of Bitcoin lent
- 58:49to them and how it's structured. Even private companies that say
- 58:52they have a bunch of Bitcoin, that's not their Bitcoin.
- 58:54So that that's a component, but it's what we call it healthy
- 58:58leverage right now. Intelligent.
- 59:01Is it intelligent? Leverage is the real question.
- 59:06But no, I'm glad you brought up crypto week.
- 59:08That is another thing that people are pointing to around
- 59:10like what's driving price? Just general bullishness,
- 59:13optimism around crypto week in DCI.
- 59:17Think there's also should be some form of a report that's due
- 59:21at the end of the week. So maybe we get an audit, maybe
- 59:24we get an audit of how many, how many Bitcoin the United States
- 59:27government owns all I'll believe it when I see it on that, on
- 59:33that front. But I think that was part of the
- 59:35original sort of timeline that end of July ish, we would get
- 59:41some sort of reporting so there. There, we'll see on that, on
- 59:45that. There's a there's a fantastic
- 59:48book that Prince recommended. There's two, but the one that I
- 59:52started reading was The Secret to the Federal Reserve and super
- 59:57fascinating, like the way that it was written, researched and
- 1:00:01the guy that like wrote it was like locked up and it like Ward
- 1:00:05and he was like a guy that helped Ernest Hemingway and like
- 1:00:08all these people, right. It's a very like interesting
- 1:00:11reason. It's really it's all research,
- 1:00:12but point being is they breakdown how crazy for first
- 1:00:18since like the Jekyll Island meeting to the inaction of it in
- 1:00:221913. And it made me feel very crazy
- 1:00:25or like not crazy, but like even sitting here because I usually
- 1:00:28don't jump into the conversation about Musk and and the what is
- 1:00:31it called the the debt doge and all of it because it just didn't
- 1:00:35feel like earnest. It just it feels like like WWE
- 1:00:38or wrestling. And I feel very vindicated.
- 1:00:42Like I encourage you guys to read it because the amount of
- 1:00:45like manipulation of how they like took out at the time, I
- 1:00:49forgot who the president was and they inserted, I believe it was
- 1:00:52Woodrow Wilson who came out of nowhere.
- 1:00:54And like Roosevelt came in for a bit just to steal the votes, the
- 1:00:57votes. And then the both bills were
- 1:00:58basically the same but called different names.
- 1:01:00And then how they just like moved it.
- 1:01:01And then they did it on Christmas.
- 1:01:03There's a lot of these things that you get you hear about.
- 1:01:05They did it literally on the Christmas week.
- 1:01:06They were all supposed to go home and they like rushed it
- 1:01:08past and it just reminded like they were doing this thing 100
- 1:01:12years ago. And it also really ties into the
- 1:01:15capital because when you go how deep, like owning the, the, the
- 1:01:19ultimately the cost of capital. I think we kind of joke around
- 1:01:22and like we talk about interest rates and all this stuff, but
- 1:01:24it's like we would laugh if somebody said you're going to
- 1:01:27put a price on bananas or the laptop, like versus the free
- 1:01:30market deciding. And that's effectively what's
- 1:01:31happening with money. And when you do that, you
- 1:01:33basically can control the world. And if you understand the amount
- 1:01:36of time it went through, then it kind of makes your sense that
- 1:01:38it'd just be fine with it going to Bitcoin.
- 1:01:41And then that's when you start to go into the pub coast stuff
- 1:01:42because you're like, well, there's obviously something.
- 1:01:44But so anyway, there's your weekly book, book reading
- 1:01:49secrets of the Federal Reserve. It's it's really fascinating,
- 1:01:51but it's also just kind of a it's just crazy because it's all
- 1:01:55like out there, but nobody ever looked in.
- 1:01:57And then we won't, we'll won't say anything.
- 1:02:00But you know, the, the the Titanic happened previous to
- 1:02:03this to 1913, and that was always something that was
- 1:02:06floated around and they kind of like break it down to that, that
- 1:02:08book. We will look at a new show
- 1:02:12notice and maybe we have a a final settlement book club.
- 1:02:15I think we I think we should all read this one and and bring back
- 1:02:18thoughts for the audience. You should get print.
- 1:02:21In the financial literacy course too.
- 1:02:23Yeah. That they teach in schools.
- 1:02:25You. Can just give them a Thomas Sell
- 1:02:27book for that and we'll think what's what's his good one?
- 1:02:31There's like a very basic, basic.
- 1:02:33It's like basics of economics. Have your or you know, that's
- 1:02:36Henry Haslett. It's a that's a good book.
- 1:02:39We should we should recommend. It's like the window.
- 1:02:42The window theory right off the bat is like an economist will
- 1:02:44say a window productivity. If you break the window and fix
- 1:02:47it, it's like, well, let's let's get back to the basics here.
- 1:02:49That's there's nothing anyway. All right, boys, that's a good
- 1:02:53place to rabbit. Thanks for joining us.
- 1:02:55We'll see you next week. Thanks.
- 1:03:00It all comes down to computers. Communicating the information
- 1:03:05superhighway can be a confusing mix of on ramps and off ramps.
- 1:03:10Bitcoin is worthless artificial gold.
- 1:03:14Is it still rat poison? Probably rat poison squared.
- 1:03:18We need to get into. The world of OK this is actually
- 1:03:21foundational technology. What the Internet of Money does
- 1:03:25is it creates a single network which can do a microtransaction
- 1:03:30to a giga transaction. The Internet is going to be one
- 1:03:36of the major forces for reducing the role of gun.
- 1:03:41The one thing that's missing that that will soon be developed
- 1:03:45is a reliable E cash.