Latest / Psychology In Seattle Podcast / The Psychology of Severus Snape (2018 Rerun)
Transcript
- 0:07So Berto, why do people love Snape? Severus Snape? Why do they?
- 0:12He's supposed to be kind of a secondary character, and at times he's
- 0:17almost like a villain. But for many people, Severas Snape is their favorite
- 0:23character from the Harry Potter books in the movie Oo Bly to Lover. Why
- 0:29did people? It's because he is the ultimate tragic character, and yet initially
- 0:36we all felt he was a very good villain. And yeah, it's just
- 0:40like there's so many good archetypes wrapped up and demonstrated via that character. He's
- 0:46also I think the as it was portrayed in the movies was done so well
- 0:52by Rickman, and so I think the people that read the books probably felt
- 0:58like myself felt, fell in love with the complexity of that character and just
- 1:02how much we didn't like him, and then how much we grew to understand
- 1:06the all the things we didn't understand, And then the people that saw the
- 1:08movies probably loved also the performance that he gave and yeah, it's it's great.
- 1:15I love it. Yeah, it's interesting. People love Vader and Kylo
- 1:19and and Loki and Ramsey Bolton and Ye Theon, Gray Joy and Hannibal Lecter,
- 1:26Patrick Bateman. But in all those examples, all those were real monsters.
- 1:32Yeah, and Snape defies those expectations, right, And I think that
- 1:38we love these characters, or some people do, because they hold a lot
- 1:42of power. You know, all these characters have tremendous power. They almost
- 1:47seem untouchable, and Snape had a lot of power. And also at some
- 1:53point they give off a vibe or it's revealed that they've been bullied as children.
- 1:57They're very misunderstood, and they they tend school shooters. They don't need
- 2:01people. They I don't need people. I'm not here to make friends,
- 2:05that kind of thing. And so I think that it is an attractive persona
- 2:12that we would that some people wish they could adopt, you know, to
- 2:15be powerful, to get revenge on people who don't understand us, and to
- 2:20not need anyone around. And by the way, initially, by the way,
- 2:23spoiler alert and all these things, but initially he was a very good
- 2:28way for us to have something to root against without fully showing all our cards.
- 2:32Yeah, you know, I looked up some Snape memes online and there's
- 2:38one where a bunch of Alan Rickman's are on a plane and they say Snape's
- 2:42on a plane, and then another one where Snape is looking kind of sad
- 2:47and there and he's or he's angry, and he's like, stop whining.
- 2:52You know nothing about the friend zone. So that's what I want to talk
- 2:55about today. I want to talk about the psychology of ever Snape. What
- 3:00do you say, bird, Let's do it. This is the Psychology in
- 3:02Seattle podcast. I'm your host, doctor Kirkhanda. I'm a therapist and a
- 3:07professor. Who are you, Burtle? My name is Umberto Casa and I
- 3:09own a small apothecary shop in downtown Seattle. So a little caveat at the
- 3:15beginning, as I always say whenever we go into stuff like this, is
- 3:19there are super nerds, Harry Potter nerds out there, and there are you
- 3:23know, seven books with lots of words in it and lots of details,
- 3:29and we might get some of those things wrong. And if, as I
- 3:32always say, if you come to a psychology podcast to get your definitive details
- 3:38on Harry Potter, there's something wrong with you and you know, so don't
- 3:45worry if we get a couple of things wrong. That's not the point.
- 3:46The point is for us to chat about this and also to provide some analysis
- 3:53on the character and maybe maybe help people understand how people can end up in
- 4:00situations like this. Yeah, look, it's it's ultimately about also remembering,
- 4:03finally the memory of Cerberus Nape. Yeah, and so uh so burrow what's
- 4:10your experience with these books? Like what, how did you grow up with
- 4:13these? Well, that's a great thing. So at the time I was
- 4:16I had a different job. Back then. I was cleaning and detailing expensive
- 4:21automobiles. And my boss came to me and said, hey, we may
- 4:27need to do a deal with JK. Rowling and her people because these books,
- 4:33these this series for kids is doing really well. And at the time
- 4:38we would license famous things to put on our cars, like decals, and
- 4:42so I thought, okay. So I was given the first three books to
- 4:45read as homework assignment by my boss, and I took them home and I
- 4:49looked at these books and I did not want to read them because the covers
- 4:55looked so childish. So he hadn't he hadn't heard of them. I hadn't
- 4:59heard of it. And I looked it is like this little awkward kid in
- 5:01a broom with glasses flying around, and I don't know if you remember the
- 5:06art of the original books, but it wasn't that inspiring. It was sort
- 5:10of clunky, you know. Yeah, the art for all seven books were
- 5:13by the same Yeah, but I felt like once I got to love it.
- 5:15I bet when I first saw it, I was like, Okay,
- 5:17I don't like this. Well it made it look like a very second rate
- 5:23child's book. Yeah, totally. So I was totally against it, but
- 5:26I sort of had no choice. So I sat down and I read that
- 5:30first book and I was hooked. Man. Then I couldn't stop. I
- 5:34read the second one. By the time when I started, only the first
- 5:38three had been out, so that's why I had those three. I read
- 5:40the first one, the second one, and the third one like back to
- 5:43back. I was sewing engrossed in them. And because I read them,
- 5:46did you end up doing work with them? No? Unfortunately we didn't,
- 5:50but it was that was the research we were doing that we would potentially have
- 5:54led to putting decals on rolls royces. But anyways, I loved the books,
- 6:00and I love those first three books so much because I read them right
- 6:02one after. It's like binge watching on Netflix or something, so I knew
- 6:05all the little details, and I saw the little recalls from book two and
- 6:10book three that harkened back to things she'd laid down in book one. And
- 6:14you're not excited, and you're not a big book reader, Well not anymore.
- 6:18When I was a kid, I read a lot more, and nowadays
- 6:20I read a lot of graphic novels. Yeah, and then what and then?
- 6:25So then I every time a new book was coming out, I was
- 6:29right there waiting in line getting my book. I didn't get him signed or
- 6:31anything, but I was always trying to get the book right away. And
- 6:33I would often stay up all night. So you would have been in like
- 6:38your mid twenties up to your thirties reading. It's embarrassing to admit, but
- 6:43I was certainly not a two year old. But I think I think a
- 6:46lot of people were, you know, of adult age who liked it.
- 6:53And you really liked the books. I really liked the books, and you
- 6:57really liked the movies. Yes, now I didn't. I didn't like the
- 7:00books evenly. I felt to me the best books were three and six and
- 7:05seven, like those were the best. But I also I also liked some
- 7:11things about four and then one and two, especially one one for me has
- 7:15a lot of problems, but at the same time it laid out the universe,
- 7:18and so it's so good when the movie started coming out, Oh my
- 7:23gosh, especially that first movie. Like I actually I remembered feeling mixed feelings
- 7:29about the first movie, but I rewatched it recently, and Columbus got so
- 7:34much right with that movie. Yeah, totally. Oh my god. Well,
- 7:39the first book, I remember when I was reading it, I remember
- 7:43thinking, man, this would be a great movie. Yeah. It's almost
- 7:47like rolling or rallying, rallying, rallying. It's almost like she knew it
- 7:51was going to be made into a movie because the books are written in a
- 7:57screenplay kind of way, so much so that when I saw the first movie,
- 8:01I was like, well, yeah, of course that's what it looks
- 8:03like. Everything looked exactly the way I had it in my head, except
- 8:09for Harry Potter himself. Oh really Yeah, oh okay, I actually what
- 8:13was different about Harry Potter? The real Harry Potter in my head? The
- 8:18Harry Potter I had in my head looked like the guy in the front of
- 8:22the book. Yeah, thinner and bushier hair. If you look at Radcliffe's
- 8:30hair, throughout the seven movies. It's like every movie they tried because his
- 8:35hair changed drastically, and there was one hair where it was like puffy out
- 8:41on the sides, and it was like they kept trying to make it right
- 8:45and it never looked right. His hair looked ridiculous in every Hermione was spot
- 8:52on, but they changed their hair a lot too, but it was always
- 8:56within the realm of my imagination. Ron Weasley surf spot On, McGonagall spot
- 9:03on. You know, everyone was like exactly how I imagine them to be.
- 9:07Dumbledore was a little like in my head. Doubledore was much more epic.
- 9:11I guess well, I felt that the first dumble Dore was like that.
- 9:13Yeah, but then unfortunately not the what's his name ed or something like
- 9:18the new Dumbledore, great actor and he he really did pull it off.
- 9:22Yeah, but that first one was well, he died. He died,
- 9:26yeah, yeah, die. So my experience was that I was doing in
- 9:31home Richard, I was doing in home therapy for in the late nineties.
- 9:37I'd just become a therapist. I'm twenty six, twenty seven, twenty eight,
- 9:41and the books came out when I was around that age, and I
- 9:45remember, and I would do in home therapy, and I would I would
- 9:48go into the rooms of these kids and they all had this book called Harry
- 9:54Potter. That's how you saw the pattern. And they all loved it,
- 9:58and they and all the kids talked about it. It was a phenomenon among
- 10:01children, you know, as each book came out, and and I remember
- 10:05thinking, oh, it must you know, but I've heard about a lot
- 10:07of books like that, like what's the Goosebumps and like Animorphs or something.
- 10:13There's always been some kind of kid book that's been popular. But and it
- 10:18never occurred to me that I would read them, you know, especially when
- 10:22you look at the cover. It's like, oh, it's great that kids
- 10:24are reading. I remember thinking that and everything, like, oh, it's
- 10:26great, it's great that some book is appealing to kids, and blah blah
- 10:31blah. But I would never read it. It's just great that it's Yeah.
- 10:33And then my mom had talked about it and she had them all on
- 10:39cassette because this is before CDs. I mean, it was during the time
- 10:43when CDs were around, but CDs were kind of new actually and for whatever
- 10:50new well like late eight and late nineties. Yeah, ten years old.
- 10:56I mean my first the first CD I got was like the first CD I
- 11:00bought was probably like ninety one. Like I was still buying records and cassettes
- 11:03up until and it was your mom, so I could see what well.
- 11:05And people didn't have CD players in their car. Oh, because they didn't
- 11:09have CD players. That didn't sketch, that's true. And so everyone still
- 11:13and plus everyone still had their old stereos with cassettes and so you mainly listen
- 11:18to audiobooks in cars. And so so she had she had all she had
- 11:22all four of the first the first four books on cassette. Wow. And
- 11:26it was like several cassettes, you know, like twenty cassettes or something,
- 11:33and and I just said, hey, could I maybe you know, borrow
- 11:37that because I'm I was getting into audio books, And so I borrowed the
- 11:39first one. And the actor who reads it is just fantastic, you know
- 11:46that, the way he reads it, and and and that first book is
- 11:50just so great and so great on audio too, because it's just so easy
- 11:54to follow and and the story in the world building and everything was just so
- 11:58amazing. And so I listened to all four books like straight on cassette in
- 12:07the span of like a couple months in my Accura that literally had three hundred
- 12:11thousand miles on it. And and because you know, there weren't podcasts back
- 12:18then, so it was either like NPR or that. So that that was
- 12:22my experience. So yeah, for me, and then eventually as each as
- 12:28each book came out, I would listen to the audiobook and I never actually
- 12:31read the books, but yeah, listening is equivalent because you got the extended
- 12:37story, not just the movie. But I think one of the problems with
- 12:41audiobook is that with more complicated stories is as the books, you know as
- 12:48four, five, six, seven, it gets a little bit more complicated.
- 12:52Oh there's more characters, there's more things to follow, and I got
- 12:56lost. Oh and you can't quickly rewind the pages and yeah right, yeah,
- 13:01so whereas book one through three are so simple that you don't really it's
- 13:07you can listen. That's a that's a really good point because if you have
- 13:09all the books at your disposal, you can like, wait, where did
- 13:13I first read about? You could go book back to book three, look
- 13:15at the chapter in question. With audio, especially with tapes, yeah,
- 13:18there's it's just not convenient Now, I I loved Book one, I loved
- 13:24Book three, Book two was like not great, Book four was entertaining,
- 13:31and then after that I lost interest for the most part. Now, in
- 13:37researching for this episode, I have a new appreciation for Harry Potter because I
- 13:43finally understand the story. Because like I would, I would, I listen
- 13:48to the books on audio and then I would go to the movies. But
- 13:50there's a lot of characters, you know, every book introduces like brand new
- 13:56people and new ideas like the whore Cruxes didn't show up till eighty do you
- 14:00know what I mean? And I'll say Book five and Movie five for me,
- 14:07were that to me, it was a little bit of a low point
- 14:11because it did get quite convoluted it it had a lot less fluidity in the
- 14:16in the storytelling. This is how I experienced it anyways, Whereas I felt
- 14:22that like to me, Book three and movie three were great, like we're
- 14:28just really strong, and I felt that Book six, Book six, oh
- 14:31my god, so and then of course the finale. But yeah, book
- 14:35five and so if you're trying to slog your way through and you hit book
- 14:39five, it's sort of and I can only imagine with audio, it'd be
- 14:43even harder because it's so many names, so many new concepts, like you're
- 14:46saying, and yet you're still not given the picture to give you the context
- 14:52of why all this is being introduced in the first place. So a lot
- 14:54of stuff is being disrupted from this pattern you had gotten sort of used to.
- 14:58It definitely starts in book four, where all of a sudden they got
- 15:01the Goblet of Fire. You got a new thing. So it's already like,
- 15:05oh, it's not a normal year anymore, but then five everything really
- 15:07starts falling apart. Yeah. Yeah. And it also bothered me that she
- 15:13had to follow a certain format for every book, right, she she had
- 15:16to follow a school year, and she had to have certain themes like Snape's
- 15:20always a dick to Harry and Draco Malfoy and Harry always have a fight,
- 15:26and you know Hermione is always doing this, and everyone always hates Harry even
- 15:33though he fucking saves it. It's Jack Bauer, Yeah, even though at
- 15:37the end of every book he literally saves the universe. Yeah, and and
- 15:43yet start right back up next year. Everyone hates him. Petunia hates it
- 15:46like it just I get it, you know, because it's a it's a
- 15:50children's book. You have to follow the format. You can't like, and
- 15:54that's what kids want, and that is, in fact what made it feel
- 15:58familiar, because you remember, that was the school year when I was,
- 16:02when we were growing up, right, the school year would start the same
- 16:04way every year, and you'd sort of start a little bit of a stranger,
- 16:07even if you had a little few friends, and the year would progress
- 16:11and at the end of the year you'd have resolved the year and you'd go
- 16:15into summer break and the next summer fall it'd all start over. Yeah.
- 16:19Now, upon doing research for this episode, I have a new appreciation for
- 16:23it, but just a couple otherative negatives. And I think most of it
- 16:27is because I didn't really pay attention closely as I was listening to the books.
- 16:33So one of the things that and a lot of the negatives came out
- 16:37for me. For example, in most of the books, there would be
- 16:41all these wacky mysteries and then at the very end, Dumbledore would come in
- 16:45and explain the whole thing, and sometimes and a lot of times, the
- 16:49explanation just didn't feel right, except for books one in three that the explanations
- 16:56at the end of one in three actually felt like, oh, and and
- 17:00Hermione had the time travel thing, like it all makes sense. I agree
- 17:04on three on one, even though I love it. The traps they set
- 17:11and then they perfectly made sure that Harry and Hermione and Ron had just the
- 17:15right combination of skills to get through the trap. Yeah, and it was
- 17:18such a weird thing, like a chess game. Well that Voldemort is on
- 17:25the back side of Quarrel's head, like what like, it's so weird,
- 17:29you know what I mean. But anyway, so it's like a Scooby Doo
- 17:33episode right. The other Yeah, that's a great way to put it.
- 17:37Yeah. The other negative was the lack of diversity, which is very apparent
- 17:44when you actually look at the situation today. But I actually looked up the
- 17:48demographics of England and of Britain and it is vast majority of white people.
- 17:55Yeah. Although the I mean the books they'd have and then the movies at
- 17:57it, like they had they had Hindi people and a couple of black people,
- 18:04but they had Cho Chang, who I have mixed feelings about. On
- 18:08one hand, it's like, oh, you know, an Asian love interest
- 18:12who wasn't like just there because she was Asian, like she was she was
- 18:17Scottish or whatever. And but on the other hand, it's like cho chang,
- 18:22like that's not even a name. That's that's like that's two last names.
- 18:25You know. It's it's like calling someone you know, yeah caa Hernandez
- 18:30or something. You know, it's like how more stamen you laugh. But
- 18:33whenever I give my first name, people are like, is that your first
- 18:37name? But at the same time, you have like all these very strange
- 18:41names everyone you know, dumb, Dumbledore and several Snape like everyone has a
- 18:47funny name, so you know. But anyway, Albus yeah so so.
- 18:53But I will say that doing research for this episode, I'm like, I
- 18:57kind of want to go back and read the books again because I think I
- 19:02was so lost that I couldn't enjoy some of the like severe emotional sings that
- 19:11it's particularly Snape story toys. You know. I think you'll have a big
- 19:15can of apologies to miss rolling or rolling or whatever. So let's talk about
- 19:19JK. Rowling. English writer Harry Potter. The series is the best selling
- 19:25book series in all of all time. Wow. She produced the films.
- 19:32She's apparently a Rags to Richest story. She was almost homeless or was homeless
- 19:37or something, and then then she became a billionaire. Isn't she other than
- 19:44the Queen the richest woman in England? No, but she's in the top
- 19:48you know, group of or women. I don't know. I think she
- 19:52is. Well, she's the first billionaire author, which is interesting. But
- 19:56she gave away much of her money to charity, which is nice. And
- 20:02she also said that Snape was one of the most important characters in the books,
- 20:06portrayed by Alan Rickman. What movies can you name of Alan Rickman?
- 20:11Diehard, that's his first Tons Gruber Love actually, yeah, Galaxy Quest,
- 20:19Galaxy Quest, Yes, Sense and Sensibility A Dogma, Oh, of course.
- 20:26I've been rewatching clips on YouTube of Dogma. Yeah, it's a good
- 20:30movie. It's got a lot of good stuff too. Robin Hood, the
- 20:33one with Kevin Cosser. But why a spoon because it hurts moll A little
- 20:40bit about his personal life is he met a woman when he was nineteen and
- 20:44was with her his entire life. Wow. He died in twenty fifteen.
- 20:48He suffered from a minor stroke which led which led to the diagnosis of pancreatic
- 20:53cancer or he no, sorry, he died in sixteen at the age of
- 20:59sixty nine. All right, several Snape, let's get into it now.
- 21:03His story is given to us bits and pieces throughout the seven books, and
- 21:10most of his story is given in the final like few chapters of the final
- 21:15book, which is just like what I was talking about in terms of the
- 21:18Scooby Doo thing and it and it's but it kind of pays off when it
- 21:23has to be like that, right, because it because the whole conceit is
- 21:27like is Snape good? Is he bad? Harry? We're in Harry's shoes,
- 21:33and Harry is like, you know, is Snape good? Is Snape
- 21:37bad? And you know Harry has arguments with people. They're like, you
- 21:42gotta trust Dumbledore. If Dumbledore trusts Snape, then you got it. And
- 21:45he's like, but you don't understand the things I've seen and like, and
- 21:48they're like, you're you're blinded by your hate, you know, and all
- 21:52this kind of stuff, and it's it's a it's so I get it.
- 21:55Yeah, And they laid it all out then it would have ruined it,
- 21:57right, and they gave plausible deny ability all along because there were there were
- 22:03clearly things he did early on to save Harry or to prevent But then they're
- 22:07like, well, yeah, he was paying back a debt, you know
- 22:11he was, or they were always you know he respects stumbled door too much
- 22:15or any number of Okay, okay, I see why, And so they
- 22:18always she always left the door open for for the but is he really where's
- 22:23his real alliance? Allegiance? Sorry? And then and then when in uh,
- 22:29when they he does the unbreakable vow with Bellatrix. I remember reading that
- 22:34and being like, wait a minute, unless they're lying to me in the
- 22:38description of what an unbreakable vow is, he's he's got no out, So
- 22:44either this means he's really evil or what is he doing? Yeah? You
- 22:48know right? That was such a good scene to write in because it puts
- 22:53the reader up to a decision, now what, because you know, the
- 22:57whole time you could be, especially with really written storylines that try to do
- 23:00this, you'd be like, well, yeah, but there was this one
- 23:03scene where clearly you gave it away here. It's like it's sort of impossible
- 23:07as a reader to not be like, wait a minute, I thought I
- 23:10knew what was up because I remember at that moment I still thought, now
- 23:12Snape is good, Snape is good Snape, And then I was like,
- 23:15wait, what Yeah, how are they going to get out of this?
- 23:18Right? And you could make a case. Yeah, so well, we'll
- 23:23get into it. So I looked into his history from the books, not
- 23:29from the movies, and at some point we learned that his parents might have
- 23:33fought quite a bit. Did you do you remember reading about that. I
- 23:37don't remember reading that his parents fought, but it might make sense since he
- 23:40was a half blood and his dad was a Muggle and his father apparently was
- 23:45not a nice guy. He did not like his father. No, yeah,
- 23:48his father was mean and critical and while he was a kid living in
- 23:53the Muggle world, it's like, yeah, there's not much my father liked
- 23:57or something along this line, right, So, uh, we don't know
- 24:02much, but it sounds like things weren't so great and as a kid,
- 24:06he we we see him. He's trying to make this is all like through
- 24:11the pensive and all that Harry is. Harry is seeing the memories of what
- 24:15Snape's past was. Snape doesn't tell Harry directly at this, but yeah,
- 24:21Stumbledore is giving him insight, right, or he took the tears of of
- 24:26of Stape in the oh right, right right? Yeah, Snape was as
- 24:32a kid was awkward. He was kind of nerdy and he didn't really understand
- 24:36how to make friends. But he tries to make friends and it doesn't really
- 24:40work. Oh oh sorry sorry. Part of it is when he's training in
- 24:44acclemency and like like like a lemons, is that remember he accidentally or you
- 24:51know, he gets into Snape's head and then at one point, while Snape's
- 24:55not there, he goes into the pensive and all these things and and he
- 24:57gets in trouble for it. But yeah, that was part of it too
- 25:00anyways. Sorry, yeah, yeah, So as a kid he is rejected
- 25:04by other Muggle people and called a freak. But then Harry's mother, Lily
- 25:11is nice to him, and it seems that Lily is his only friend.
- 25:17And so as a kid, your Snape Zebrus and your parents are fighting.
- 25:22Your dad's critical, You're you're a mud blood yourself, you're awkward, everyone
- 25:27hates you. You're being bullied, rejected by people. And then there's this
- 25:32one girl who is also a bug mud blood and who is you know,
- 25:40It's funny. I never knew if it was mud blood or mug blood because
- 25:44because because I never read it. Oh, and you didn't know how they
- 25:47were pronounced. Yeah, but the way he pronounced it in the in the
- 25:51in the in the audio books, I could never really because he's a mug
- 25:53bud like the way he said anyway, but I read it today, it's
- 25:57it's was Lily Potter a mud blud? Or was she? Uh full?
- 26:03I think? No? No, I think isn't it that her parents weren't
- 26:07neither of them were wizards or witches? But she had magic? Oh,
- 26:11I don't know. And because I thought Harry's dad was was magic, like
- 26:15was a sorry, Yeah, I thought she was a muggle and his dad
- 26:21was. But maybe I'm not remembering this right. All I know is that
- 26:23her sister Petunia, Petunia was not magical and really hated and resented what Lily
- 26:33Lily. Right, there was a whole Lily Petunia severisk issue that was going
- 26:38on, which sort of set up Petunia resenting Lily and then raising Harry in
- 26:44a shitty way. So then they go to Hogwarts to learn, you know,
- 26:49the ways of magic as kids, and they continue to be friends,
- 26:53and Lily is put in Gryffindor with James, with James Potter, and Severus
- 27:00is put in Slythering. And and this is when Snape is sort of sad
- 27:04because he's like, oh my one friend. Yeah, and and Lily is
- 27:10not really she doesn't care that much because she is more she has, she's
- 27:14more popular and this stuff, and she and he already doesn't like James because
- 27:18he had already been teasing him, like James was a bully on the Yeah
- 27:22no, no, yeah, yeah, James was an asshole. Yeah,
- 27:26exactly like Harry Potter's dad was a true, true sadistic, sadist bully asshole.
- 27:33Like there they do not right, I mean they don't. They don't
- 27:38paint James in a positive way at all. They do this weird thing where
- 27:42they say, well, by the such and such seventh year or whatever,
- 27:47he had started maturing or whatever. But they didn't. I didn't feel they
- 27:51really sold his how he could come back from being such a jerk. Yeah,
- 27:55I mean it wasn't like one incidence. He was. He bullied Snape
- 28:00for years. Him in Syria, the little gang there Marauders. Yeah,
- 28:04him and Sirius Black and Loomus Pedigrew were basically like Malfoy and yeah and tweedled
- 28:14the and tweedledum, which was the poetic, you know, beauty of it.
- 28:18But at the same time, that was one flaw if I don't know,
- 28:22I actually I don't remember how it was in the books. Maybe in
- 28:23the books it was better, but from what I remember now in the movies,
- 28:27that was one flaw I felt was that they showed how bad he was
- 28:32and yet they didn't sell me on. But well, then why did she
- 28:36end up with him because he well I'll get into that a second. But
- 28:38but they but in the end, uh again at researching this topic, I
- 28:45you know, from from the books, they don't actually redeem him at all,
- 28:49That's what I'm saying. Yeah, they don't. They don't, And
- 28:52they don't explain why Lily would be with They said something like, you know,
- 28:55he he matured later and he did technically save Snape. So it makes
- 29:00total sense why Snape was such a busted up person because the one person who
- 29:07had been for years. So you have your you have your best friend.
- 29:11So so Lily is friends with Snape throughout Hogwarts time. You know, from
- 29:15the from the time they enter at age ten or eleven through yeah, through
- 29:18for several years and so so Snape his only friend is Lily, and he's
- 29:25in love with her, infatuated in love, it's his life. Lily,
- 29:30meanwhile, has other friends, but Lily really likes Snape, and Snape is
- 29:33trying his hardest that online dating and family. Yeah, and so uh,
- 29:40meanwhile, James and his and his other bullies are tormenting him, humiliating him
- 29:47in front of people, hanging up upside down to show his underwear, making
- 29:51fun. And then and then and then this one thing happens where uh James
- 29:57is, you know, doing this thing to Snape, and then Snape doesn't
- 30:04know what to do, and Lily kind of gets a little smirk, like
- 30:10she gets a little she's Lily's trying to defend Snape. She's like James,
- 30:14back off. And then something kind of funny happens, and then Lily gets
- 30:18a little kick out of it. But then she tries to defend Snape.
- 30:19Yeah, basically what happens is they're they're torturing him. He Snape gets really
- 30:25pissed and to defend himself, he uses his spell that he created that can
- 30:29slash and so he slashes at uh at Potter and actually cuts him a bit,
- 30:34and that's when Potter casts a spell to hang him up and upside down,
- 30:38and then everyone sees his his dirty gray underwear or whatever, and Lily,
- 30:45against her better judgment, smirks but then kind of stops smirking as soon
- 30:48as she starts. But he sees this and this is like betrayal, yeah,
- 30:53and then he attacks her, calls her a mud blood, and then
- 30:57she kind of fine. So, so imagine that you're Lily and you're you're
- 31:06you're you know, this guy who you know has a crush on you for
- 31:10years is being completely bullied and lashes out at you. Kind of yes,
- 31:15and then you're just like fuck that guy, and not only fuck Snape,
- 31:21like screw him. I'm not gonna She completely rejects him. Snape goes to
- 31:25her, begs her to be friends again. She's like, no, late,
- 31:27too late, and you're sort of involved with this dark Arts people like,
- 31:30so I don't really like you. Yeah, that's the one thing.
- 31:33Snape was not doing himself any favors with that, Yeah, but still like
- 31:37so, but imagine your Snape, you know again, you're attracted the Dark
- 31:41Arts because the cool kids are not attracted the dark arts. And you're looking
- 31:45for some power in the world. I want to belong, You want to
- 31:48belong, and you also are looking for some power to like strike back at
- 31:51this guy who physically man handles you with his fucking wand every now and then
- 31:55and you have your grandfather's broken helmet, right, Yeah, it's like,
- 31:59you know, earning kung fu or something, you know, to defend yourself
- 32:02and so and then one day you you lash out at Lily while you're being
- 32:07hung upside down, upside down with your underwear showing, and she just completely
- 32:10just drops you like a sack of potatoes. Yeah, not only that,
- 32:14but then she she marries that guy. Yes, she for years is witnessing
- 32:20this bully being an asshole. And then and they and they both talk,
- 32:23you know, Lily and Snape would talk shit about James and be like,
- 32:27oh, yeah, he's a she's she called him a toe rag. She
- 32:30called him a toe rag. And then lo and behold there and so imagine.
- 32:37So that's the beginning of Snape's psychology. You have a dad who's super
- 32:40critical, parents who are fighting society that hates you. You finally go to
- 32:45a place where wizards. You finally feel like you're accepted. You're still being
- 32:50bullied. You have this one girl who pays it, who's nice to you,
- 32:53You're you're in love with her. She's beautiful, she's nice, and
- 32:57she's strong. And then one bad bullying incident, you lash out at her,
- 33:01she drops you. You beg her to come back, she won't,
- 33:05and she marries your enemy. Yeah, that's got to screw you up.
- 33:09That's got to give you a complex. Absolutely. Okay, So let's take
- 33:14a break and then we'll go into his adulthood. What do you say,
- 33:15Burrow? Ye, all right, we're back from the break. If you
- 33:24haven't become a patron of the podcast, do so. Now go to Patreon
- 33:28dot com become a patron of the podcast. When do you become a patron
- 33:30of the podcast? You get access to all of our premium episodes that are
- 33:36only available to patrons of the podcast. You also don't have to listen to
- 33:39ads for the most part. All right, let's get back into this,
- 33:44Burrow, So you should add yourself as a patron. So Snape is now
- 33:47an adult, and he's got a lot of baggage. He's got dad baggage.
- 33:52He's got Lily baggage, he's got James baggage, he's got society baggage,
- 34:00Voldemort baggage, Voldemort baggage. So he is he becomes a death theater
- 34:07under Voldemort as an adult. By the way, do you know that his
- 34:12bogart I just found this out today because I was also reading up his bogart
- 34:16is Voldemort, meaning the bogart is the thing. Do you remember where they
- 34:22had the closet in the second movie, sorry, in the in the third
- 34:28movie, Yeah, where they opened the closet and this bogart takes the shape
- 34:32of the thing you're most afraid of, and like for for Neville it was
- 34:37Snape, and for Harry it was it was a de mentor and and so
- 34:45forth. For Lupin it was the Moon. Right. Well, they don't
- 34:51show us this, but so I don't know how we found out or maybe
- 34:54it's somewhere, but it sounds like for Snape it's Voldemort. It's for Snape,
- 35:00it's Voldemort. Yes, that's the thing he's most afraid of. Why
- 35:02would he be afraid of Voldemort? No, because it's think about it this
- 35:08way. For the entire time, we know Snape, he is having to
- 35:14play double and then triple agent. Oh and including his thoughts from Voldemort at
- 35:21all, you're sort of skipping for in the story. Like I'm talking to
- 35:23he just enters adulthood, so you know, but I'm saying that, like
- 35:28at this time, Voldemort had already been a thing, right, So,
- 35:34so Voldemort Voltemore has been around a long time, correct, So he's sort
- 35:38of like hundreds of years old or something. Yeah, and so well not
- 35:43hundreds because Dumbledore he was a kid when Dumbledore was younger. Okay, but
- 35:49the point is that the main thing had already happened. So that's why they
- 35:52had death eaters, right, Like that was there was already a cult of
- 35:55Voldemort, right, so he was already developing this obsess with that stuff.
- 36:00Voldemort. Snape was so explain to me. Was, so Snape is an
- 36:06adult and he wants to become a death eater. Is Voldemort alive at this
- 36:10point? Yeah, because he's gaining power and Voldemort has he ever died at
- 36:15this point? No, he's never died because remember he dies when he trusts
- 36:17to kill Harry, right, So so he's just sort of living his first
- 36:22life, yes, as an older power, and he's gaining power okay,
- 36:27and he is older than Snape in them because here he already went through school
- 36:30before that. But he's not as old as dumbled Dumbledore. He's not as
- 36:32old as so he's probably like fifty or something. Yeah, I don't know,
- 36:37forty years I lost Okay. So Voldemort tells Snape to go to Hogwarts
- 36:44and spy on Dumbledore. So that's why, uh Stape becomes a teacher at
- 36:49Hogwarts. He wouldn't have done that normally. Why would he want to go
- 36:52back to the place that he was bullied so often? Right? But he
- 36:57goes back and he tries to become the dark arts person he's rejected did and
- 37:00he becomes the potion Master. Perhaps Dumbledore knew about something like I wonder if
- 37:05it's like Yoda with or you know, like the like I send some darkness
- 37:09in you. So yeah, right, because it seems like Dumbledore would have
- 37:15detected something was up with Snake, you know. And Snape learns the prophecy
- 37:21about Harry and or about Longboten coming to destroy Voldemort, and he tells Baltimore
- 37:29about the prophecy, which causes Voldemort to figure out who it was and Voldemort
- 37:36goes, oh, it must be must be Lily Potter's kid. And then
- 37:39Voldemort is like, okay, Snape, thank you, I'm gonna go kill
- 37:43Lily Potter and and her family now and and and and Snape is like,
- 37:47holy crap, what like, right the prophet I you know, I'm trying
- 37:52to serve you as the master. I tell you this prophecy. I had
- 37:55no idea it was going to be about Lily Potter, like the one person
- 38:00on this planet that I actually like, you know, And he begs Voldemort
- 38:04to not do it, right if Voldemort is like, don't be stupid.
- 38:07You know, I'm gonna of course I'm gonna do it this this this kid
- 38:10is going to kill me or you know, you know the prophecy blah blah
- 38:15blah. So Snape is in this decision right now. Snape is like,
- 38:19well, I could come, I could become full evil right now and just
- 38:22be like, well, I guess that's the way it's going to be.
- 38:25Breaks and you know, but and he would have except for one person,
- 38:31well, right, if it was just uh Potter or the Sun the child,
- 38:37he would have right. And so it's interesting to look at rallying's story
- 38:43in these like moments, right, like what if you know, what if
- 38:46Snape had just let go and just said, okay, fine, I guess
- 38:50that's what's going to happen, this whole story would have gone a different way,
- 38:53right in all likelihood? Right, Dumbledore what a or Voldemort? What
- 38:59a rule of the world? What was that? Voldemort's mission was at least
- 39:04the wizarding world? Right? Yeah, I mean he he wants irrational power
- 39:07and to live forever, right, and so he he's basically like what he
- 39:15appreciates the most is the power itself, and he has no understanding of love,
- 39:21so he wants to live forever. So part of it is like,
- 39:24you know, making sure that he can do all sorts of dark magic so
- 39:28he can live forever. And then the other one is consolidating his power and
- 39:30having everyone be subserving to him. So if there's a prophecy that says that
- 39:35something or someone's gonna take him down, you could bet he would stop at
- 39:38nothing to undo that prophecy. So now Snape is in a conundrum because he's
- 39:45begged with Voldemort. He's not going to change his mind, and Snape can't
- 39:49stand up to Voldemort because Boldemort is too powerful. And this is what you
- 39:52know. He fears Voldemort above anything else, and so it's like, what
- 39:58is to do. Well, he he does something that he never would have
- 40:01done in another situation. He goes to Dumbledore and he's you know, he
- 40:06says, please save save Lily. And this is the beginning of his double
- 40:13agency. He when he first went to Dumbledore, he was an agent.
- 40:17He was an agent. Now he's a double agent. Well, and then
- 40:20Dumbledore says, okay, fine, I'll do what I can to fix the
- 40:23situation, but what are you willing to do for it? And Snape is
- 40:30like, He's like, I'll do anything. I'll do anything. I'll be
- 40:32your slave, I'll die, I'll do anything you want me to. I
- 40:37just want Lily to live because he's in love with her after all this time,
- 40:42always, And so Dumbledore says, okay, fine, I will do
- 40:47what I can, but you will be a double agent. Now you're gonna
- 40:52work under Voldemort, secret agent Snape. So then Voldemort arrives at the house.
- 41:00Now this is where maybe you can film me it because I don't really
- 41:02get it. What did Dumbledore do to protect Lily at this? So he
- 41:07was hiding. He was. They formed a little network of people and they
- 41:12were like hiding the location of where they were and all these things. It's
- 41:16just that Peter Pettigrew betrayed them. Oh so Dumbledore did try, but unfortunately
- 41:22they didn't realize that one of their best friends was going to betray them.
- 41:27Okay, so Voldemort figures it out, arrives at the house of Harry Potter
- 41:31and his parents, and James the father tries to stall Voldemort, and Voldemort
- 41:37kills him like very easily. Voldemort then tries to kill Harry, but Lily
- 41:44stands in the way, and Voldemort says, Lily, get out of the
- 41:50way. I got to kill your son. And then Lily's like, so
- 41:53this is another sort of interesting question, like why doesn't Woldemort just kill her
- 41:58like he killed James. I mean he was he was trying. I feel
- 42:04like he was trying to do what Snape had asked him to do, because
- 42:08that's what I was thinking. It's like, it's like, well, I
- 42:10one of my most loyal servants will be had. All I need to do
- 42:15is kill the kid, and if I keep Lily alive and you know.
- 42:17So so that was but they didn't really explicitly see And and it's interesting because
- 42:22at the time he wasn't yet as monstrous as he was to become Voldemort.
- 42:30Yeah, and he hadn't actually yet. In fact, if I'm not wrong,
- 42:35I believe Harry was only like the second hork Crux or third like he
- 42:40was. He was not yet the Voldemort that was the full beast. So
- 42:47then Lily casts some spell that says that if she sacrifices her life, then
- 42:54it'll She didn't cast a spell, she just gave her life up to a
- 43:00her son, and that magic of love made it so that it put a
- 43:06charm of charm on Harry. And then Voldemort tries to kill Harry, and
- 43:09that, yeah, that backfires and almost kills Voldemort, and as far as
- 43:14anyone knows, kills Voldemort. But he lived. And by the way,
- 43:17the reason he lived is because of the hork Crux stuff. Like if he
- 43:22didn't have hork cruxes, and if in fact Harry had a hork crux,
- 43:27can you explain the hork cruck. Yeah. So there's this super super super
- 43:30super dark magic, which is that if you kill someone in just the right
- 43:35way and with a very important object around or something like this, part of
- 43:39your essence can go into that object. So it requires that you murder someone
- 43:46part of your essence, part of your essence the person doing the killing.
- 43:51Why would you want to do that? Because when you do it, it
- 43:54has one very very big side effect, negative side effect, which is that
- 43:59your essence starts getting diluted and you become more and more monstrous. But the
- 44:02positive is that if they kill your body, they still haven't fully killed you,
- 44:08because you still have part of you in these other objects. This is
- 44:12just him living forever. That's part of how he wanted to live forever.
- 44:15So I listened to all the audio books, and this is the first time
- 44:21that I've understood and watched the movies. By the way, is there something
- 44:24wrong with me that I don't know? If the movies make it clear enough?
- 44:28But I remember, I mean, I read those two books twice,
- 44:31I think. And is it possible that I was paying, you know,
- 44:37close enough attention to the books and the movies and have the whole hor Crux
- 44:40thing go over my head? Yes? And yet the horre Crux thing was
- 44:45the whole six and seven book. Yes, But I think that the way
- 44:49the movies play out there's a lot of detail you don't have to understand in
- 44:52order to enjoy those movies. I still but the whole they're searching for the
- 44:58horror cruxes and blah blah, and and I just remember being like, what
- 45:01are the what the fuck are the horse cruxes? And like and like midway
- 45:06through books seven, they still don't even know where they still don't even know
- 45:09what all the horse cruxes were, and I'd be like, well, how
- 45:12are they going to wrap this up anyway? Well, and then but that's
- 45:15just it that I if you're trying to eliminate, you know, imagine it's
- 45:17Hitler, right, and we're like got to get rid of Hitler. And
- 45:21and you're told, here's the catch. He's put part of his essence in
- 45:25six other or seven other objects around the world. And if even if you
- 45:29kill three of them, there's still the other four, which is great,
- 45:32But why seven? It's so cumbersome like he was. It would have been
- 45:37a bet I think a better plot if it was like one or two or
- 45:42three, but seven, because because like, can you name the seven horse
- 45:45cruxes? Uh? No? But Nagini, Harry, uh, the oh
- 45:52Man, the one of the uh the items from the house. I think
- 45:57the slitherin but do you know what I mean, It's like it's like it
- 46:00it got not only did the Hoore crux concept go over my head, but
- 46:05then I lost track of all anyway. Yeah, no, you're right.
- 46:07But the reason there were seven is because I don't think anyone in history had
- 46:10ever done that. All the stories he had read, It's like people had
- 46:14done it like once, and he was trying to go for broke. Okay,
- 46:19so then so so Lily dies, James is dead, and Harry lives.
- 46:23Voldemort is gone and dead as far as anyone knows. Diary the diary
- 46:29was one of them two in Chamber of Secrets, okay, the Tom Yeah,
- 46:35Tom Riddle Riddle. Snape is first on the scene to save Lily.
- 46:40Did he Is that why he arrived at the house or just to see what
- 46:45happened or something? Wait? When what are you talking about? So after
- 46:47the dust settles, Harry is still alive, the parents are dead, Snape
- 46:52is the first one to enter the house. Oh is he? I didn't
- 46:54remember that? Yeah, or at least in the movies anyway, I don't
- 46:57know. I'm pretty sure in the books, and he finds Lily dead.
- 47:00Yeah, and he is devastated and he holds her and he's crying and oh
- 47:05now I remember this, You're right, just a massive amount of grief for
- 47:08the snapester. Okay, well, and I think in that moment that is
- 47:16the irre irreversible turning point in which he will never be able to be loyal
- 47:22to Voldemort. If he was ever on the tetering edge of it, that
- 47:27was it, Like, he would have never been able to be loyal to
- 47:30Voldemort. So he had to for then on the rest of his life became
- 47:35essentially like, well, I will be a triple or you know, I
- 47:37will be against Voldemort till my nine days. Yeah. So now we have
- 47:42another psychological incident where you're in snape shoes. Okay, right again, You've
- 47:50grown up aloner. No one has liked you, You've tried to get people
- 47:52like you. The only person that's liked you is Lily. She dumped you
- 47:58and married and have a kid with your mortal enemy, someone who was legitimately
- 48:04a bad person. Yep, and that's pretty messed up. But you still
- 48:08have just a you know, a place in your heart because you don't have
- 48:12anyone else for this person Lily. Then you go to the dark side,
- 48:19and you have to be a little conflicted, right, because he's not evil,
- 48:21he's you know, he's only going there partially because he's just trying to
- 48:25find a group of friends, right, and also people who appreciate him,
- 48:30and also maybe to get some power so he can so he can protect himself
- 48:34against bullies like James and his crew. And then that sort of leads down
- 48:38a road and then you're like, Okay, I told I told Woldemart about
- 48:43this prophecy. You know, Snape's not a murderer, but he's like kind
- 48:46of an accessory to murder at this point, and he's so he's not I'm
- 48:51sure he's not quite so happy about that. And then he finds out that
- 48:54the murder, the murderer victim is going to be Lily herself. Yeah,
- 49:00and then he does everything he can to completely uh you know, prostrate himself
- 49:07for Voldemort. That doesn't work. Then he goes to his moral enemy,
- 49:09Dumbledore, you know, another person that's on James side. He's you know,
- 49:14Dumbledore's on the on that other side. Yeah, and completely humiliates himself
- 49:17and and begs and does you know, and hands himself over in a in
- 49:22a very humiliating and masculating way, and and all of that doesn't do anything.
- 49:29Lily still dies. And not only is Lily dead, but Voldemort's now
- 49:32gone and like your entire you know, like side of the fence is now
- 49:37falling apart. Oh and by the way, Voldemort or sorry Snape, thinks
- 49:44it was Serious Black who betrayed them, which explains why he hated Serious interesting
- 49:51and so he is now the reason why Lily not so not only did Lily,
- 50:00so he's blaming himself for everything. Not only did Lily leave him in
- 50:02the first place, because he struck out in anger against her. So he's
- 50:07beating himself up about that. Why did I call her a mud blood?
- 50:10Why did I do that? You know, there's something why you know,
- 50:14it's my fault. If I hadn't have said that, I might have married
- 50:19her, you know. And not only is he torn up about that,
- 50:23but now she's dead because he fed Voldemort the information. It's his fault that
- 50:31she is dead, and wonder he lived with himself and he's standing over and
- 50:37then well then he goes to Dumbledore and he's just like, well, I
- 50:40guess that's it for me. I'll kill myself and Dumbledore's like, no,
- 50:45you won't. If you really loved Lily. You know what your job is
- 50:49now, you have to protect Harry well, which sucks because that's one thing
- 50:54that Dumbledore didn't tell his name, is why he had to protect Harry.
- 51:00He sort of sold it as like, that's that's Lily's child, right,
- 51:04So then it because because because Dumbledore knows that he's a a horse crux,
- 51:09right, he suspects he doesn't know for sure, but his The long con
- 51:14plan that Dumbledore's playing is that he believes Voldemort split himself up into these various
- 51:20things. He thinks the snake is one of them. He thinks if if
- 51:24Voldemort really believes this prophecy, he's gonna come back. He's going to try
- 51:28to finish the job. All these things, blah blah blah, and anyways,
- 51:30the point is that he is in fact sort of using Harry as part
- 51:34of the pawn in his game. He doesn't tell Snape all of this,
- 51:37but he sort of sells it as like, hey, this is Lily's child,
- 51:42we must protect them because Voldemort is going to try to kill him.
- 51:45Right, So the third betrayal is or the third horrible thing that happens to
- 51:49Snape is when Dumbledore tells Snape about this in the end, and he's like,
- 51:54so I need you. We need to set up a situation so that
- 52:00Voldemort kills Harry because that will actually help us. And then Snape's like,
- 52:06wait a second, So I was only trying to protect Harry this whole time,
- 52:09so that you kill him, so that you would eventually kill him,
- 52:13like, and you never told me, like, you're just but you're tu,
- 52:16You're just another bully who lies. And I I legitimately love this kid
- 52:23because he's because he has Lily's eyes and you know, blah blah blah blah.
- 52:28Well, no he doesn't, to be fair, he doesn't love Harry.
- 52:31Well, he part of him, but part of him has a attachment
- 52:37to keeping Harry alive. Yeah. Well, and one of the things that
- 52:39and I don't know if this was in the books or the movie or both,
- 52:43but because you wonder, for most of the books, I assumed that
- 52:46the reason Snape hated Harry so much was sort of a writing convenience. Why
- 52:53does Snape hate him so much? And then you find out, oh,
- 52:55he got bullied by his dad. But even then You're like, all right,
- 53:00yeah, I could see, but but it's a kid. I mean,
- 53:00at some point, don't you go like, well, yeah, he
- 53:04looks he reminds me of that asshole. But okay, whatever. But the
- 53:07the thing is Lily died to save Harry, right, and so in some
- 53:14extent, Snape's like, she's saved you. This is what she died for.
- 53:19And he looked at Harry with disappointment, right right, So well every
- 53:22time, so Harry comes to Hogwarts later on, and it's like the amount
- 53:27of emotion that Snape feels when he sees Harry. Yes, and he's a
- 53:32celebrity, right, and just everything about this is just so. And it's
- 53:37he's like Griffindor, he looks like his dad. Lily died to save him.
- 53:43He doesn't do well in classes. He seems a little bit bratty.
- 53:46Well, right, So that's another thing is that Harry, you know,
- 53:52Snape is tasked by Dumbledore and also for his love for Lily, about keep
- 54:00Harry alive. And one of the ways that Harry is gonna stay alive is
- 54:04if he pays attention in class and learns things. And Harry isn't as good
- 54:08as Hermione right, and so he gets upset sometimes because he wants Harry to
- 54:15be more studious because he's because he cares, but Snape, because he's never
- 54:20had social skills. It comes out all wrong the way it always has,
- 54:24and so so he is. So this is another part of complicated grief in
- 54:34that when we have someone who dies that's close to us, and you know,
- 54:42everyone's ran into this is like someone close to you dies and you're devastated,
- 54:46you know, so you're Snape. You're devastated, and then at some
- 54:52point something will happen where you'll either not be thinking about the grief anymore,
- 54:59like it won't won't be the first thing that enters your head when you have
- 55:01time to think and and or something funny happens and you laugh. Most people
- 55:09will be like, oh, I'm laughing, Like like, I'm not supposed
- 55:14to be laughing. I don't deserve to laugh? Does laughing? Is that?
- 55:20Is that demeaning of the memory of the of the loved one? Am
- 55:24I being disrespectful? Do I? Do I deserve to be happy? Okay,
- 55:29so your Snape you're like, I don't deserve to be happy. It's
- 55:31like being at a funeral of a loved one or relative and just laughing,
- 55:35laughing, right, if it's particularly difficult, And and Snape has no one
- 55:40to talk to, he can't talk to anybody. I guess he can only
- 55:45talk to Dumbledore, and Dumbledore isn't I was available, And and he has
- 55:47a policy about keeping things right close and by the way, then this I
- 55:52actually didn't realize, or I don't remember having thought of this angle. But
- 55:57today when I was catching up a little bit on the just to remind myself,
- 56:01someone had pointed this out. Snape also had to pretend the whole time,
- 56:09because what happens is, imagine Voldemort comes back and any one of his
- 56:14spies, including Malfoy because Lucia's is super influential amongst the death theaters, and
- 56:20his son is at Hogwarts. Right, Imagine the word gets back that like
- 56:23I think Snape's actually on dumbledore side, because he tends to be nice to
- 56:29Harry, tends to It's over. The whole effort is done, so he,
- 56:34on top of everything else, he actually has to pretend whether he really
- 56:38feels I'm sure he does have all these receptions. On top of everything else,
- 56:43he actually has to pretend to be evil, right, And this is
- 56:46something that maybe she didn't intend fully to write it this way, because I
- 56:51do think even though she actually had the arc pretty well written out, and
- 56:53she actually did a lot of back work before she even wrote the first book.
- 56:58At the same time, the first book, there's a lot of things
- 57:00in there that you that are written conveniently so that the first book works.
- 57:06But so whether it was intentional or unintentional, in the end, it's got
- 57:08a plausible explanation, right. That's why after researching for this episode, I
- 57:14finally like totally appreciate Rallyings writing, because like, if you just pay attention,
- 57:20if you're nerdy about it enough, then there are some very poetic things
- 57:25that happen very early on, you know, from the from the first class
- 57:31of the Potions that Harry goes to and Snape is a total dick to Harry.
- 57:36You're like, you know, I now want to read the books again
- 57:38because I want to, like, if you understand the backstory, it all
- 57:43makes total sense. And by the way, it's not the kind of thing
- 57:45like in Lord of the Rings where well, of course they couldn't use the
- 57:49eagles this other time, because if you read Silmarillion, page six and fifty,
- 57:53I'm like, come on, man. So so there's throughout the books
- 58:00Snape protects Harry and his friends, like from Loopin when he turns into a
- 58:05werewolf, and you know, but he also, like there's other times where
- 58:08he's super he's pretty much mean to Harry. Throughout all the books, Snape
- 58:14helps the good guys. He's in the Order of the Phoenix. But then
- 58:17you know, some red herrings happen where it's like, wait, he has
- 58:22the mark of the death of the Mark and you know, and you know,
- 58:25and and then he attacked one of the one of the Weasley brothers when
- 58:30they were trying to get in to Hogwarts here. Yeah, but that was
- 58:34an accident apparently. And then you have like this Snape Serious Black, you
- 58:39know, feud going on. But again, all that makes sense because Serious
- 58:43Black was a total asshole the Snape and Serious Black thought that, and Snape
- 58:50thought that Sirius was the one who betrayed to find out where the Potterhouse was.
- 58:57So basically, other than Voldemort, Serious Black was probably the second person
- 59:04in Snape's kill list, right, and James too, you know, well,
- 59:08but James, James had even you know, like I feel like Snape
- 59:14had had gotten to the point where he would hate James forever. But it's
- 59:17not someone he would have wanted to kill, no versus, he would have
- 59:21wanted to kill Sious because he it was his betrayal that led to Lili's.
- 59:24Right, you know, then as you talked about Narcissa, Malfoy gives Snape
- 59:30the unbreakable vow that says narciss or Bellatrix isn't Narcissa narciss Okay, okay,
- 59:36oh right, right right, because it's right. She's related to Draco and
- 59:39she wants Draco protected. She is Narcissa Draco's mom. I don't know.
- 59:43I think it's Draco's mom. Yeah, so she's like, yeah, I
- 59:46want my son protected. So you got to make this unbreak o vowel.
- 59:50Right. So so now you're Snape, and you're like, well, if
- 59:52I refuse, then I look like I'm like, I'm right, like I'm
- 59:57a double agent or a triple agent. And and so I guess I gotta
- 1:00:00do it. And and and this is when Harry witnesses it. I think,
- 1:00:05right, and I want to reread these now, and this is getting
- 1:00:07me excited. Right, So the and the vow is to protect Draco to
- 1:00:12help him complete uh Voldemort's task, which is to kill uh, you know,
- 1:00:17Dumbledore. And if Draco can't do it, then Snape has to complete
- 1:00:23it himself. And if you break an unbreakable vow, you die, right,
- 1:00:28And so Snap becomes the Dark Arts Professor, and he uses the Dark
- 1:00:32Arts to save Dumbledore from the Gaunt Ring and it and this is when it's
- 1:00:36revealed that Dumbledore is going to die soon anyway, right, and and so
- 1:00:40it doesn't really matter. Well, we don't find that out till later,
- 1:00:46till later, maybe even the very end of the seventh but but there was
- 1:00:51some hint because his hand was withering away, right, So it's it's interesting.
- 1:00:55It's like Dumbledore would have died anyway, Snape needed to kill you know,
- 1:01:06either Draco had to kill Dumbledore or Snape had to kill him. Yea.
- 1:01:12And and Snape's like, well, it'll look better if I do it,
- 1:01:15because then then Voldemort will really trust me. I think, I think
- 1:01:20Gandal, I think uh Dumbledore uh says something about Draco's soul like he doesn't
- 1:01:25want and then Dumbledore is like, dude, you got to kill me,
- 1:01:29Like Draco he's a kid. Yeah, he's still a kid, and he's
- 1:01:32salvageable, and he's got to finish his finals because he hasn't graduated yet.
- 1:01:37Right, that was a whole other thing. It's like throughout the books,
- 1:01:40even up till like book six, there's they're still playing fucking quidditch, you
- 1:01:45know, and like and like Snape gives Harry detention so he can't play on
- 1:01:52the quidditch and you're just like, really, like, after book four,
- 1:01:55I feel like they should have just completely done away with it, dude.
- 1:01:59It's it's too risky to be at school, and they sort of do,
- 1:02:01right, Like in book five, he like he's not at school all year,
- 1:02:06right, Like, I mean he's and in book six he goes on
- 1:02:09these long quests with Dumbledore. But but but there's still like it's total normal
- 1:02:15thing and everyone still thinks Harry is a dick. You know. The other
- 1:02:19funny thing is that they often say, like, you know, Hogwarts is
- 1:02:22like the safest place, but all of that shit happens at Hogwarts. So
- 1:02:30Harry hurts Draco in a fight using the half Blood Prince spells that he's reading,
- 1:02:35which is really Snape's book, right, Yeah, and Snape gives Harry
- 1:02:39detention during the final Quiddits match. It's the what's the slashing spell? I
- 1:02:46don't remember. Dumbledore tells Snape that we've already gone over that. Draco tries
- 1:02:52to kill Dumbledore, Snape kills Dumbledore himself. Harry attacks Snape, And this
- 1:02:58is an interesting scene here too, because at this point you're like, oh,
- 1:03:00Snape is evil because he just killed Dumbledore. I mean, is that
- 1:03:04what you thought? No? I mean, but it was Remember at this
- 1:03:09point, I've already been the whole time second guessing everything, and I'm realizing,
- 1:03:14well, look, he had no choice because of the unbreakable vow.
- 1:03:19So yeah, the way that Rally writes, it's like, well, who
- 1:03:22knows. At the end of book seven, there's there could be a twist,
- 1:03:25and there was, and I was certainly I was certainly in shock,
- 1:03:29like did they really kill Dumbledore? Yeah? And then I was like,
- 1:03:34well, I remember after book six, good Snape has got to be good.
- 1:03:37I remember after book six everyone was like, oh my god. You
- 1:03:40know, yeah, because book six comes out, everyone's in line for overnight,
- 1:03:45right, and then everyone runs home and instantly reads the book, right,
- 1:03:50Yeah, And within like eight hours, people are tweeting about it and
- 1:03:54facebooking about it and stuff or whatever. We had back in well, I
- 1:03:58guess it would have been like two thous and five. I don't think we
- 1:04:00had any of that stuff. We had tweets maybe, well anyway we had,
- 1:04:05but people talked about it whatever. However, people communicated in two tho
- 1:04:11my space, my space. They were my Space. They were friends stirring,
- 1:04:15they were khazaing it and people were like, oh my god. And
- 1:04:19I remember there's all this talk about like about like John Snow, is he
- 1:04:26really dead? Right? Maybe he'll come back? Right? Yeah? Yeah,
- 1:04:30No, I mean people are like, well no, Gandal, I
- 1:04:31keep wanting to he's not really dead, like because of this, And there
- 1:04:35were tons of theories I remember, But me, I I was convinced he
- 1:04:40was dead. It's just that I both held hope Slash had my little theories
- 1:04:46that's that Snape was good and that this was somehow like on purpose. Let's
- 1:04:53take a break and we get back. Let's talk about the end of Snape's
- 1:04:55life. All right, we're back from the break. Let's let's continue the
- 1:05:03story here. So then Voldemort kills Snape because he thinks he will He thinks
- 1:05:11he needs to. Well, so he believes that Snape controls the Elder One,
- 1:05:15and Voldemort's trying to get control of the Elder One because it's the most
- 1:05:18powerful wand right this, why does he think Snape because he thought that Snape
- 1:05:25killed Dumbledore and Dumbled well, sorry, Snape did kill Dumbledore. He thought
- 1:05:30Dumbledore controlled the Elder wand when Snape killed Dumbledore, and therefore Snape now controls
- 1:05:35the Older One. But what he doesn't know is that I think Harry did
- 1:05:40an expoiliarmus on Snape, and because he did that, Harry now controls the
- 1:05:45Elder One. Something along those lines. Interesting. Yeah, So the point
- 1:05:49is Voldemort thinks Snape controls the other one. If I kill him, I
- 1:05:54will control the Elder One. See that was a whole other thing that went
- 1:05:57over my head. So the Elder One isn't an actual wand it is a
- 1:06:00one. Yeah, so he took Snape's wand he so the Elder One belonged.
- 1:06:06It was part of the whole. There was this whole story I remember,
- 1:06:11with the little circle and the triangle and the stuff. But it was
- 1:06:15given to Dumbledore by what's his name. Starts with the ge Grinda Wald.
- 1:06:23So the Elder One was Grindawald's one, I believe, and he gave it
- 1:06:28to to Dumbledore. Okay, so now Dumbledore is in possession of the elder
- 1:06:31One. Okay, but Snape kills Dumbledore. And when you kill someone,
- 1:06:36you can take possession of their wand apparently also if you explain the armis someone,
- 1:06:42you can take possession of their Wand apparently if I remember this right or
- 1:06:45someone along those lines. So so, so Aldemort be able to just look
- 1:06:48at the one and go like, well, that's not the older one,
- 1:06:50that's that's your rusty old wind you always have. I don't remember that part
- 1:06:55of the scene. I don't know if he's holding it. I don't know.
- 1:06:57If it doesn't matter if he's holding it or not holding it, I
- 1:06:59don't remember. But what I do know is Harry was the one that really
- 1:07:02controlled the older one. Why doesn't he just ask for the older one from
- 1:07:06Snape? Because you can ask for it, but if you if you don't
- 1:07:10control it, you can't use it, and you have to kill them too.
- 1:07:13You have to do either kill or expel the Army. I can't remember,
- 1:07:15you know what I mean? I know I know, but listen,
- 1:07:18So while we're on this line, it makes sense when you read it.
- 1:07:23I just don't remember the details. But what I do know is Voldemort thinks
- 1:07:26that Snape's got it. So this is just another convoluted thing about the story.
- 1:07:30It's just like it's too complicated, you know, case to extend this,
- 1:07:34to extend this, like why did Harry beat Voldemort in the end?
- 1:07:41So Voldemort kills Harry? Killing Harry removed the last bit of Voldemort that was
- 1:07:48protected by horcruxes. So now the only thing left of Voldemort was his body,
- 1:07:56and that made it possible to kill that one and be done with it.
- 1:08:00Now, why Harry was brought back is because of love. But it's
- 1:08:05a little bit of they did a little bit of doosic smocky no there,
- 1:08:09but they they she explains it. It's just, you know, maybe a
- 1:08:14braver story would have had Harry fully die, you know, but whatever,
- 1:08:17I liked that he came back personally because it was nice. And then who
- 1:08:21actually killed Voldemore in the end? Well, I think Harry kills him by
- 1:08:28or yeah, doesn't isn't it? Like do you know what he's been a
- 1:08:31long time? Look, it's been a long time. Yeah, but who
- 1:08:34cut off Luke Skywalker's hand, Princess Leah? And and who killed the Emperor?
- 1:08:42This is not fair. Listen, these are only three movies, and
- 1:08:45I saw them a billion times each. But do you know what I'm saying,
- 1:08:47Like, No, these are not fair. Who killed Valdemore? You've
- 1:08:51only seen movie the seventh movie. I'm just saying, like, I think
- 1:08:55I've only seen it in the theaters once. Look, maybe if we looked
- 1:08:59into it it would make sets, But the question of who killed Voldemort Sterry,
- 1:09:03I'm pretty sure it's Harry. Okay, you're right, it should be
- 1:09:08obvious. But also realized that the fact that we can't answer it is going
- 1:09:11to be used against us in a court of internet. Yeah, but I
- 1:09:15feel like we've been pretty good up to this point. Well yeah, but
- 1:09:16look, look, look what I'm trying to say is the reason I can't
- 1:09:19quite remember is because and I guess this goes to your point. There's a
- 1:09:24lot that happens in that last battle, but that one question should be pretty
- 1:09:30easy to see. Like, so, so Voldemort kills Harry and Harry goes
- 1:09:35to like Harry goes to his limbo place, and his parents are his parents
- 1:09:40are there, but Love brings him back because of the thing that they had
- 1:09:43caught. Remember there was a little ball with the the thingy that Dumbledore with
- 1:09:47the quitted the snitchy thing. There's all this stuff that magic. It's magic.
- 1:09:51Yeah. And then and then then Harry walks wakes up and kills him.
- 1:10:00Anyway, so Voldemort, So Voldemort before this point kills Snape because he
- 1:10:05wants to be, you know, the older He wants the elder one,
- 1:10:09and he has his snake bite Snape through the neck, which is pretty gnarly.
- 1:10:14And well, Harry sees the whole thing. Harry runs the Snape side
- 1:10:18as he's dying, and this is when Harry, you know, really realizes,
- 1:10:23Wait, Snape's been good this whole time or so, or Snape's a
- 1:10:27good guy, the bravest soul. Well. Then then Snape tells Harry to
- 1:10:31look in the book. Harry says, or Snape says, look at me,
- 1:10:35look at me, because he wants to see green eyes, the green
- 1:10:40lily eyes, which in the movie does he does he do that? Yeah,
- 1:10:43and Snape cries and then Harry he collects his tears. And then after
- 1:10:48Snape dies, he goes and sees the memories and he learns the whole backstory.
- 1:10:56And this is when we learn the whole backstory of Snape, and and
- 1:11:00we learned that he was plagued with mixed feelings about Harry and his father,
- 1:11:04and that he's it is the epic Scooby Doo of all Scooby Doos, and
- 1:11:09he's jealous and anger and you know, and we learn finally that Snape is
- 1:11:16an incredibly vulnerable, suffering, grieving, lonely, guilty, low self esteemed
- 1:11:27human being. And when you see it from that perspective, it all makes
- 1:11:30sense. I mean, the way that Alan Rickman pulls it off, and
- 1:11:33I guess the vision in your mind that rallying sort of portrays is that it's
- 1:11:39right on the line between is he a sadistic, unfeeling asshole or is he
- 1:11:47so is he suffering so much that he's just holding it all in? And
- 1:11:55I think what we realize in the end is it's the latter. You know,
- 1:11:59Snape was so so greatly and he was so racked with guilt and to
- 1:12:04some extent suicidal because of how bad he felt about everything, and so put
- 1:12:12upon by bullies and society, and you know, he was bullied by the
- 1:12:16Muggle world, he was bullied by the Wizarding world, falls in love with
- 1:12:20this girl. She dumps him for the bully. Then you know, he's
- 1:12:27trying his best, and he causes Lily's death and then Dumbledore uses him as
- 1:12:31a pawn in his you know, and Dumbledore, by you know, by
- 1:12:35the end of the books, is like his mentor his his you know,
- 1:12:41maybe the only other person. You know, he went from maybe I have
- 1:12:45my mom, and then he goes to Lily, and then he goes to
- 1:12:47Dumbledore, and then Dumbledore also kind of betrays him, and then he makes
- 1:12:51Snape kill him. I mean, imagine what we haven't even talked about that.
- 1:12:55Yeah, imagine if I told you you have to shoot me in the
- 1:12:59head with a gun. Yeah, and you're and you have no choice,
- 1:13:02right, and there's no money involved. Yeah, And and you know that's
- 1:13:06gotta screw you up, right, And even because even if you're like,
- 1:13:10dude, I'm dying, I've got some terminal disease that's not that only makes
- 1:13:14it I'm not. I don't know if it makes it harder, but it's
- 1:13:16like, wait, first of all, I'm trying to process the fact that
- 1:13:18you just told me that you're gonna die. Yeah, now you're asking me
- 1:13:20to kill you. Yeah, in a violent like oh my god, yeah,
- 1:13:27I'm gonna be awake and I'm gonna see it now I just remembered sort
- 1:13:33of. So, so Harry gets killed by Boltimore, eliminating the last horcrucks
- 1:13:39he could have held on to. Right, did Harry know he was a
- 1:13:42horre crucks at that point? I think he had figured it out. So
- 1:13:45Harry knows he has to die, I think so. Yeah. So then
- 1:13:47but he's got that little I forget what it is. It's like a little
- 1:13:50golden anything. There's something that protects him. So he dies, goes to
- 1:13:54a little funny place, but he comes back and then they don't. They
- 1:13:57do the thing with the wands where he attacks, and then the ones are
- 1:14:00the thing, and then all the people that Voldemort killed come back and overwhelm
- 1:14:03him and that's how he dies. Oh yeah, yeah right, that's because
- 1:14:08love. Ultimately, this was the thing that Voldemore never understood, is the
- 1:14:12power of love and blah blah blah. So something along those lines, I
- 1:14:15think you're right. Yeah, Okay. Years later, Harry names his second
- 1:14:18son, Albus Severus after Dumbledore and Snape, and he the kid grows up
- 1:14:27and is about to enter Hogwarts, Harry's kid and this and Albus Severus Potter
- 1:14:33is worried that he's going to be sorted into Slytherin. He's like, oh,
- 1:14:38no, am I gonna get into Slytherin. I want to be And
- 1:14:41Harry tells his son, you were named for two headmasters of Hogwarts. One
- 1:14:47of them was a Slytherin, and he was probably the bravest man I ever
- 1:14:51knew. Yeah, by the way, one gripe I did have was that
- 1:14:59they always kept Slytherin House around and they all pretended, I meaning the head
- 1:15:02master. Everyone pretended like it's fair. It's a fair system, right,
- 1:15:09but it was so not fair. You have one mean house and the other
- 1:15:14three houses having to deal with this one mean house at all times. The
- 1:15:18Slytherin headmaster was always mean to everyone else and unfair to everyone else. Yeah,
- 1:15:24I mean I while going down this research rabbit hole today, there's a
- 1:15:28YouTube video that explains the origin story of the different how of Hogwarts itself.
- 1:15:34And you know, there were two guys and two women. You know,
- 1:15:39the two and one of the Alasar Slytherin. Yeah, and he was a
- 1:15:44horrible human beings see Salastar Slytherin, Rowena, Raven Claw, Griffin, Godrick
- 1:15:48Gryffindor and something huffabuff. Yeah. And and the Snape guy was kind of
- 1:15:58like the first Voldemort in some ways, right as Salasar Slytherin, you mean,
- 1:16:02yeah, or the first Slither Salad sly Yeah. First it wasn't evil
- 1:16:06though. No, The thing is he wasn't He was a purity. He
- 1:16:11was about pure. But you know what it feels like to me sort of
- 1:16:15like our current you know situation a little bit where we have to keep up
- 1:16:18appearances that like, well today the President said something a little disturbing, or
- 1:16:24like, in a similar way, you have this situation where it's like,
- 1:16:28I can imagine they should do a Rosenkrans and Gildernstern type thing behind the scenes
- 1:16:32where we see it from different from like head mass or like different professors perspective,
- 1:16:36where they're in the break room and they're like, Okay, how long
- 1:16:40are we going to sit here and pretend that this is normal? Slytherin house
- 1:16:44is just insulting everyone. Their little brat kids in that house are always bullying
- 1:16:47everyone, right, everyone pretends this is balanced. Was there was there any
- 1:16:51nice person in Slytherin? Not the way that we looked at it. I
- 1:16:56mean there there was a there were a couple of grays on one, but
- 1:17:00for the most part they were the bullies. They were the main ones.
- 1:17:02Well, the thing, the thing that I always sort of got was Dumbledore's
- 1:17:06perspective on that, which was a kind of meta wise perspective around the big
- 1:17:12picture, which was like, if you ask Dumbledore like, why is Slythering
- 1:17:16still a thing? He'd be like, well, you know, you need
- 1:17:18all types of people. But but no, right, but I can and
- 1:17:21they're not They're not evil, They're just they're just, you know, they're
- 1:17:26I I So here's what what I'm what I'm saying is if it were written
- 1:17:31a little more subtly, like it was just an adult movie with these themes,
- 1:17:36I could see And I don't mean that in that way. I'm sure
- 1:17:40there is a porn what I mean Hogwarts Harry, but what it would be
- 1:17:44called Harry Potter and the and the Chamber of Dildo's Harry Plopper. And listen,
- 1:17:50what I'm trying to say, is that I could definitely see the perspective
- 1:17:54of the Yin Yang thing where they say, look, in fact, I
- 1:17:56think Dumbledore says this, right, he says, look what happens is Slytherin
- 1:18:00are are reckless, and but they are also they are all so brave and
- 1:18:05they do these things. So they say, great, so was it they
- 1:18:09break rules a bit, but they so snape. For example, was Slytherin
- 1:18:14and he was the key to the whole, and Harry Potter was partially he
- 1:18:18was inclined towards that side as well because of his Voldemort part of him innards.
- 1:18:24Yeah, but so that's fine. But the way it plays out is
- 1:18:28a kid's story, meaning Slytherin is pretty much the bad guys. Right,
- 1:18:31That's that's the whole thing. Like we always have to remember that these kids,
- 1:18:34these are kids stories that are and we're not talking like like you could
- 1:18:40argue Star Wars is a kid's story. No, No, Harry. The
- 1:18:43first Harry Potter book is is a kids is written for ten year olds,
- 1:18:47and it was so to its credit, how amazing it could inspire so many
- 1:18:53adults having been written for kids that were really kids, right, yeah,
- 1:18:59yeah, yeah, exactly, so in that way, I mean, you
- 1:19:02know, Rallying really pulled something off. And again, doing research for this
- 1:19:08episode, I have I have a total new appreciation for the whole story because
- 1:19:14not only did it make sense to me, but I really have an appreciation
- 1:19:17for the way that she wrote Snape's character. Yeah, dude, what a
- 1:19:21classic character in literature. Now, because such an arc and so many strong
- 1:19:29reasons to explain why and how and everything and everything kind of comes back to
- 1:19:33us now. I will say, I'm thinking back to if people are listening
- 1:19:40to this episode and they're true fans, can you imagine we should almost ship
- 1:19:45like medicine of some sort, penicillin or something, because their heads are gonna
- 1:19:49explode when we got to the point in this podcast where we didn't know how
- 1:19:53the hell Voldemort died or who killed them. They're gonna be like, unsubscribe,
- 1:19:59unpaid, and you're done. Luckily they won't hear this part because I'll
- 1:20:03tell them a Levy gash No. But in all fairness, it's we do
- 1:20:10this because we love the material. We're not experts in the material, and
- 1:20:14I just love this stuff. I mean I will Yeah, I can totally
- 1:20:17empathize with that. I listened to podcasts where they talk about pop culture,
- 1:20:23and it's really hard for me to listen to people when they're talking about things
- 1:20:28that I love and not only do they not really understand it, but they're
- 1:20:31also trashing on it. Like if what was I listening to recently? I
- 1:20:38can't remember. It was some listening to something. They were talking about some
- 1:20:43movie that came out recently, and it was a it was a movie that
- 1:20:45I liked. I mean, I remember thinking I didn't love the movie,
- 1:20:48but I remember and maybe it was the new the New Star Wars. I
- 1:20:51don't know, but they were talking about it like they barely understood it.
- 1:20:58They're like, so, how many Star Wars you know, for Examity stars
- 1:21:01are there? Yeah? How many? How many Star Wars movies were there?
- 1:21:03And like how you know? And yeah, who you know? Wasn't
- 1:21:10there a Darth Vader character in another movie? I don't get it? And
- 1:21:13it's like it's really hard to listen to that. It'd be one thing if
- 1:21:17they're just like, yeah, I really liked it, and but I don't
- 1:21:20really you know. But it's another thing when they're when they trash on something
- 1:21:25and they don't because they they haven't spent enough time with you many years ago.
- 1:21:30I think I told this one before. But I have a friend who
- 1:21:33we went to watch Heat, the movie Heat. Remember Heat? I love
- 1:21:38that movie? Yeah, and that that holds up? And we're leaving the
- 1:21:40theater and what'd you think? That's sorry? I didn't like it so much.
- 1:21:45I'm like, what, how did you? Why did you? And
- 1:21:49then it's like, well, this, this didn't this didn't make sense.
- 1:21:54Why did val Kilmer say such and such? And I'm like, oh,
- 1:21:57what do you mean because of this other thing that they clearly said? And
- 1:22:00then the other thing happened. Oh, I was asleep during that part.
- 1:22:03What So they were blaming plot holes and things they didn't understand because they had
- 1:22:11fallen asleep, right, which is essentially what I was doing because I wasn't
- 1:22:14really paying attention. It's fair to the audio. But I'm saying like,
- 1:22:17and if you want to claim it was boring so I fell asleep, that's
- 1:22:20fine, but don't poke holes at things you weren't watching, right, Like,
- 1:22:24that's not but I think it is a legitimate. I still think it's
- 1:22:28I mean, because you're you've been super into the books and of the movies,
- 1:22:31and for me to just throw out a question, which, you know,
- 1:22:36how how did it fair? How did Baltimore die? And now,
- 1:22:41granted you're not as a super nerd as people perhaps listen, or it's not
- 1:22:45recent like at the time, I probably would have listed out the whole scene,
- 1:22:47but it didn't stick with you. You make a really good point,
- 1:22:51which is that? And partially it's because it is a seven book series and
- 1:22:57those last books are massive. Think about that kids' books, and they're massive
- 1:23:02and way more readable, got like a thousand pages or something, and yet
- 1:23:06way more readable than the Lord of the Rings ones. So I will say,
- 1:23:11God, the Lord of the Rings books, I will say, you
- 1:23:13make a great point in that. If you ask me, or if you
- 1:23:15ask anyone that's seen Star Wars once or twice about major plot points or Lord
- 1:23:19of the Rings, I mean, like, you know, they're like the
- 1:23:24climax of the of the movie, like how does Saurrondi Burdo? How does
- 1:23:30Sarn die? The Ring? The Ring burns in the fire right, the
- 1:23:32Ring goes into the no no no, but see I but I I was
- 1:23:35thinking you were going to use Lord of the Rings as also another example of
- 1:23:40complicated. There there are, but of the key moments, how does sarrond
- 1:23:45the ring burns in the fire Ring goes into the you know, you know,
- 1:23:48I see what you're saying. It wasn't the Sword of Griffin or stab
- 1:23:53Voldemort through the heart, which, by the way, it might have been.
- 1:23:56Yeah. Well, and I remember when I remember when I read the
- 1:23:59books and saw the movies. I remember being like, man, you know,
- 1:24:01that was such a I remember being disappointed by the ending because I was
- 1:24:05like, it would have been so much cooler. It would have been so
- 1:24:10much cooler and so much simpler if they had had if I was if I
- 1:24:15was writing the books, I would have had maybe either three horn Cruxes or
- 1:24:21maybe just one horre Crux. And the only horse Cruckx was Harry Potter,
- 1:24:27and Voldemort doesn't know that. And somehow Harry Potter and his crew trick Voldemort
- 1:24:33into believing the horse Cruckx as something else. Okay, yeah, and then
- 1:24:36and forget about the Elder One, like that whole thing is just a ret
- 1:24:40Like who cares about the Elder One? You know, that doesn't really matter,
- 1:24:43right, And you just sort of make it so that Voldemort is dead
- 1:24:46set on getting this one item, and he's and he hates Harry Potter and
- 1:24:51wants to kill him. Yeah. Yeah, listen, you would have had
- 1:24:56a few less billion dollars as a result, I know. And right now
- 1:25:00you just finally nailed the nails in the coffin of this episode because you basically
- 1:25:06but but but because I remember, well, because I was into it enough
- 1:25:10in two thousand and six, just before the fourth the subventh book came out.
- 1:25:14I remember being enough into it at the time where I would speculate with
- 1:25:17you, probably in other people about like how this was going to end.
- 1:25:20And I remember really hoping that the way it was going to end was that
- 1:25:26Harry was going to die. And and I remember everyone's saying like, well,
- 1:25:30Harry has to die like that. That just has to because you know,
- 1:25:33that has that just has to be the way it's ending. And then
- 1:25:36you know, he kills Harry or Harry sacrifices himself to save someone else,
- 1:25:43save everyone. Yeah, yeah, and and Harry dies boom, you know,
- 1:25:47Voldemort explodes and every and then everyone cries, and then they do a
- 1:25:53memorial and then Hermione teaches at the school and and they remember Harry fondly.
- 1:25:59But they but they did more of the Jesus arc. Right, Harry had
- 1:26:02the worst everything, and then he dies and came back. Now, I
- 1:26:06will say so, I don't disagree with you that in the end it is
- 1:26:11a complex puzzle, right, But it was that kind of story, right,
- 1:26:16It was that kind of story. Now, you're right. It was
- 1:26:19very consistent of Rally to have a very complicated ending to a book in a
- 1:26:27series of books, was very complicated end. And so you are right to
- 1:26:30point that, like, and it's funny because I would have thought of Lord
- 1:26:33of the Rings in the opposite way. But you're right that when it came
- 1:26:35to how did the bad guy get defeated? Oh, they dropped a little
- 1:26:40piece of gold ring into a lava pit. That's simple, which they established
- 1:26:45from the beginning, yes, like in chapter three, yeah, of the
- 1:26:48first book. And that's fair, and so they Gandalf says this ring has
- 1:26:53to be destroyed. So like for example, again this wouldn't have made so
- 1:26:56many billions, but for example, in book two or book three, we
- 1:26:59would have found out the only thing that can defeat Voldemort is the sort of
- 1:27:03griffindor driven through his heart. But that cannot happen until we find out how
- 1:27:09he's staying alive, and then we find out it's Harry. Then Harry dies
- 1:27:13and then stab and then he died. Okay, something simple, less billion
- 1:27:15dollars, but simple would it have been less billings? She made a lot
- 1:27:20of money with She's a complicated story. But but to me, I wonder
- 1:27:25how much how much of the billion dollars was made by the world, because
- 1:27:31like, there's a lot of things that go into making something popular, sure,
- 1:27:35and story is one of them. But I don't think if my evaluation
- 1:27:40of the because I enjoyed the books, I enjoyed the things that I the
- 1:27:45things that I think made the product that because I spent money, you know,
- 1:27:48for the audiobooks and the movies. I think the thing that made the
- 1:27:54product was the world, the look, the mythology, the humor, I
- 1:28:00guess, the interplay between Hermione and Ron and Harry, the fact that it
- 1:28:08was both for kids and adults, the fact that you could kind of nerd
- 1:28:11out on it. Fact it had a lot of things in it that I
- 1:28:15think everyone kind of wants. I think everyone wants to go to a Hogwarts
- 1:28:20and be, you know, put in a house and have an instant a
- 1:28:25bunch of friends that you can play totally games with. And I agree with
- 1:28:30you in similar way how Star Wars established a universe that we could all get
- 1:28:34behind. What I will say though, is she was she put herself into
- 1:28:40an impossible situation on how to end that thing, and yet she did pull
- 1:28:44it off right. Because think about it, if she had killed Harry like
- 1:28:47many of us thought Slash maybe secretly hoped or maybe not so secretly hoped,
- 1:28:53there would have been a whole other wave of disappointment and anger and betrayal because
- 1:28:59many people might have wanted Harry to live right. Another thing is if someone
- 1:29:03had avada could because remember they're the only ways that we know that people die
- 1:29:06in the story. Magically, the big way is by the unforgivable avada kadabra
- 1:29:13a curse. If someone, if one of our heroes would have had to
- 1:29:16do that on Voldemort, it would have compromised that one's soul, So it
- 1:29:21would have to have been like Snape doing it, but Snape was dead,
- 1:29:24or it would have had to be Lucious but Lucia's That would have been so
- 1:29:27anti climactic. Malfoy but then Malfoy is a kid, he also would have
- 1:29:30compromised his soul. In fact, that's why Dumbledore didn't want him to have
- 1:29:32be the one to kill mean Draco. Yeah. So so the problem is
- 1:29:38they had to She had to find a way for for Voldemort to die that
- 1:29:41didn't have one of our heroes actually using the Unforgivable curse on Baltimore. And
- 1:29:45that's why I love had to be the way to triumph and blah blah.
- 1:29:47But it is complex. I don't disagree. It is complex, right,
- 1:29:51but I I totally agree, and and I and that, and that has
- 1:29:56bumped it up in my head that every book in the series had a very
- 1:30:02convoluted ending and and gave you a sense, you know, like you said,
- 1:30:10it wasn't like when you're reading the book or saw the movie you were
- 1:30:14like what like you you were? It transported you along, right, you
- 1:30:18know, and it led you to those moments and then and it made sense
- 1:30:24in the moment. It was hard to describe later, but the way she
- 1:30:28wrote it it it it carried you along. But to me it I was
- 1:30:33again, after after book four, I was kind of a reluctant enjoyer of
- 1:30:38the stories and so it just it made it hard for me to enjoy,
- 1:30:43to be fair, like, think of Star Wars, right, it didn't,
- 1:30:46in fact end with Luke Skywalker stabbing the Emperor through the heart with his
- 1:30:49light saying that's that's right, right. There was more complexity to not nearly
- 1:30:54as much, not nearly as much. But you know, darth Vader just
- 1:30:58threw him into a hole. But if I asked someone, look, so
- 1:31:00how did darth Vader die? Okay, well he he was depleted from the
- 1:31:08exertion and the lightning powers. But you see what I'm saying, like,
- 1:31:12no, I don't know the Emperor killed darth Vader, not as darth Vader
- 1:31:16was throwing him into a hole, not directly, and he didn't die right
- 1:31:18away and then but he died redeemed that like, there's more to the story
- 1:31:21right there. So even something as simple as the Star Wars arc didn't just
- 1:31:29end. It's pretty really, it's pretty simple. It's pretty soon. I
- 1:31:31remember Luke Skywalker was a horkruck, so if he had stuff, I'm just
- 1:31:38saying like, and you know, that's why I didn't like book two,
- 1:31:43you know, because the book two, the ending, the whole story of
- 1:31:45book two was convoluted. You know. The other thing no one talks about
- 1:31:48is Anna Luke. Like people don't like to admit that there was a romance
- 1:31:53between Darth Vader and Luke Skywalker and it was bringing all the movies. People
- 1:31:58don't like it. You're a Luke Vader shipper. I'm a little leadership yeah,
- 1:32:01I will say again, especially and you know, looking at Stape's character
- 1:32:08that it really makes me want to read the books again with this understanding.
- 1:32:13You know, it's like seeing him like a movie like Inception again or you
- 1:32:18know movies you watch it again and or Arrival for example, and it's like
- 1:32:26it's it's more enjoyable the second time because you know, you know the whole
- 1:32:29story and you're like, oh, I can see why that's dropped in there,
- 1:32:31and that all makes sense. And imagine if someone did make a movie
- 1:32:34from Snape's perspective, done in sort of a stylistic way where you know,
- 1:32:40you don't get a whole seven other movies. You get like one movie,
- 1:32:43but it's it's watching the whole storyline but from Snape's perspective in a condensed way,
- 1:32:48because you get these moments where he's not even in the main scene,
- 1:32:51but he's like, what the hell are they doing now? Like I'm trying
- 1:32:55to keep this kid, and he's talking to himself like I just want to
- 1:32:58save this kid. Oh god, damn it, right, and then he's
- 1:33:00like talking to Dumbledore like, listen, man, I don't know how much
- 1:33:03longer I can do this, Like I have to act like I'm upset the
- 1:33:06whole time. I'm not this upset. I'm not this depressed. I bet
- 1:33:11you someone's done this. But if they haven't, they should is someone should
- 1:33:14write a diary of Snape. Yeah, like you know, different diary entries
- 1:33:19throughout his entire life, and it turns out he was never that depressed.
- 1:33:24He was like, well, yeah, I liked her, but listen,
- 1:33:27I'm not obsessed with her. But you know what I mean. It'd be
- 1:33:29so interesting because because to have these entries of just like, yeah, so
- 1:33:34you know, Harry showed up today at school, and but that's pretty tough
- 1:33:39because you know, she he looks like James and he also kind of looks
- 1:33:43like Lily. So boy, I got a lot of feelings on the inside,
- 1:33:45you know, dear diary complicated grief. Today Harry showed up. You
- 1:33:53know I think it'd be. And then he's like, and I had to
- 1:33:56cry these fake tears as I was dying so that Harry would think I was
- 1:33:59a hero old time. But I'm really Voldemort. I was Voldemort the whole
- 1:34:03time. Is what you don't know is I'm a fifteenth or coarse crux.
- 1:34:09All right, Well that does it for that episode of psychology and Seattle,
- 1:34:12thanks for joining us out there. Please take care of yourself because you deserve
- 1:34:16it. Can you can you say it like in a snape way or something?
- 1:34:20I could say it in a dumble doorway, because you deserve it always.
- 1:34:30Isn't there a better sort of way? You could say? I wanna
- 1:34:33Harry Potter must not return to Hotwoods this year? Do it like Bobby?
- 1:34:38Yeah? Do it like yeah, okay, yodas And I can't. That
- 1:34:43doesn't even work. Hey, Harry, you deserve it. It's a hagred.
- 1:34:49How does snape talk snapes like attention? And I can't do his voice.
- 1:34:55It's such an Alan Rickman so good at this. It's like you will
- 1:34:58find my class is very difficult. But that's not even right, because because
- 1:35:05you deserve it,