Latest / eMotors: Electric Revolution / Electric Vehicle Performance in Wet Conditions
Transcript
- 0:09Welcome back to the Deep Dive. So if you've spent any time
- 0:13online recently, I'm sure you've seen the footage.
- 0:15Oh. Absolutely.
- 0:15It's everywhere. These unpredictable flash
- 0:18floods, you know, streets just turning into rivers, and you see
- 0:21these agonizing clips of cars trying to get through water that
- 0:25is clearly way too deep. And it brings up this huge
- 0:29pressing question, especially as electric vehicles are becoming
- 0:33so mainstream. It's a question everyone's
- 0:35asking. Are EVs with these massive
- 0:38batteries, are they fundamentally safer or are they
- 0:41actually more susceptible to water damage than, you know, a
- 0:45traditional gas powered car? That is the crucial question.
- 0:48And today, we're going to do a deep dive into the source
- 0:51material you sent over, specifically comparing the
- 0:53performance and the safety risks of EVs versus internal
- 0:58combustion engine or ICE vehicles.
- 1:00Right ICE equals. And we're looking at 2 very
- 1:02distinct wet conditions. First, you have rapid driving
- 1:05over wet roads where you risk hydroplaning OK.
- 1:08And 2nd, driving through actual deep flood water, the submersion
- 1:11hazard. And I think before we get into
- 1:13any of the physics or the engineering side of things, we
- 1:16have to start with the single most critical safety fact.
- 1:20This applies to everything we're about to discuss.
- 1:22It's non negotiable. Avoid flood water entirely.
- 1:25It doesn't matter what you drive.
- 1:26Exactly. The National Weather Service
- 1:29confirms that half of all flood related deaths involve vehicles.
- 1:34So if the water is rising, you turn around.
- 1:36That has to be the baseline for this whole conversation.
- 1:39Absolutely. So with that essential warning
- 1:41out of the way, let's unpack the difference between losing tire
- 1:44traction and, you know, full vehicle submersion.
- 1:48And we're starting at the surface level aquaplaning, where
- 1:52the sources layout a pretty surprising and quantifiable
- 1:55safety advantage for EVs. So we're talking about
- 1:58hydroplaning, which is that scary situation where your tire
- 2:01just lifts off the road surface because there's a layer of water
- 2:04underneath. It your tire is essentially
- 2:05floating speeding on the water. Yeah, exactly.
- 2:08And our sources say this is responsible for about 20% of all
- 2:11wet weather accidents. And here's where the design of
- 2:14an EV really flips the script. The primary difference between
- 2:19an EV and an equivalent ICE vehicle is just mass the.
- 2:23Weight. The weight That huge battery
- 2:26pack means EVs are significantly heavier.
- 2:29We're talking often 200 and 450 kilograms more than their gas
- 2:33counterparts. So all that extra battery weight
- 2:36that we often hear criticizing, you know, for range or for
- 2:38infrastructure impact, it's actually giving us a hidden
- 2:41superpower in a rainstorm. That's a perfect way to put it.
- 2:43The physics of it are really straightforward.
- 2:46That increased vehicle mass acts as a greater load, a downforce
- 2:50on the tire, pushing it down, pushing it down, and that load
- 2:54helps the tire display place water more effectively, pushing
- 2:57that water film away so it can maintain critical contact with
- 3:00the actual Rd. It directly counteracts the lift
- 3:03that causes the hydroplaning in the first place.
- 3:05And the computational data, it's, it's just stunning.
- 3:08They ran analysis using this complex fluid dynamics modeling.
- 3:11And what did they find? OK, get this.
- 3:14They found that the added weight of the Ed batteries inherently
- 3:17decreases the chance of hydroplaning by an average of
- 3:2054.4% compared to IC vehicles. Wait 54%?
- 3:2554.4% To put that in context, the data shows that adding 400
- 3:30kilograms of mass, which is like a 1000 Newton load increase per
- 3:34tire, you decrease the chance of hydroplaning by 58.25%.
- 3:39That is a massive safety dividend, and it's rooted
- 3:42entirely in physics. It's huge.
- 3:44So if this holds true across the board, the percentage of wet
- 3:48weather accidents from hydroplaning could potentially
- 3:50be cutting fast if the whole fleet just shifts to electric.
- 3:53But hang on, if we're seeing this huge safety benefit benefit
- 3:55from added mass, doesn't that extra weight come with
- 3:58trade-offs and other safety areas like increased wear and
- 4:01tear or maybe longer braking distances?
- 4:03It absolutely does. Every single design decision is
- 4:06a trade off. While the mass helps
- 4:08significantly with hydroplaning, we do have to consider the
- 4:11secondary impacts of that increased load, and that's
- 4:15something we'll circle back to at the end.
- 4:16But for this specific phenomenon, the sources show the
- 4:19weight is a definitive positive. OK, that makes sense.
- 4:23So managing a slick surface is one thing.
- 4:25What happens when the water is deep enough to actually reach
- 4:28the engine or the battery pack? Let's pivot to the catastrophic
- 4:32risks of deep water submersion, because this is where the
- 4:35challenges for EVs and IC cars really diverge dramatically.
- 4:39For the ICE vehicle, the risk is immediate and it's potentially
- 4:43terminal. If the water level gets high
- 4:45enough, it gets sucked into the air intakes.
- 4:47The engine then tries to compress water instead of air,
- 4:50and since water is incompressible, you get what's
- 4:53known as hydro lock. And how catastrophic is that
- 4:55failure usually? Oh, it's usually terminal.
- 4:57It results in severe, often irreparable mechanical damage.
- 5:01You talk about the engine block, Pistons, connecting rods.
- 5:04It's an immediate, devastating and very expensive failure mode
- 5:08unique to combustion engines. So EVs face a different but an
- 5:13equally severe hazard. We know the battery packs are
- 5:16sealed for normal weather, but deep flood water, especially
- 5:19flowing water or water with debris in it, can compromise
- 5:23those seals. And if water breaches that high
- 5:25voltage system, you get a short circuit and complete battery
- 5:28failure. And the most crucial severe
- 5:30public safety risk here is fire. Fire and this is especially true
- 5:34if the water is salt water, like from a coastal storm surge.
- 5:37We saw a specific thermal incidents following Hurricane
- 5:41Idalia in 2023 and then again during Hurricane Aline in 2024.
- 5:45So. Why is saltwater uniquely
- 5:48hazardous to lithium ion batteries compared to
- 5:50freshwater? This is where it gets really
- 5:52interested. Right.
- 5:52So saltwater dramatically increases the ionic conductivity
- 5:55of the water around the battery cell.
- 5:57If a seal is compromised, this highly conductive saltwater
- 6:00rushes in, causing rapid and severe short circuits across any
- 6:03exposed terminals or cell casings.
- 6:05So the. Reaction is just way faster, way
- 6:07more violent. Way faster, much more heat, far
- 6:10more quickly, which accelerates the chance of thermal runaway
- 6:13and fire compared to just say, rainwater.
- 6:16That mechanism explains the urgency behind those public
- 6:19warnings we saw. I remember the Pinellas County
- 6:22Emergency Management Director Kathy Perkins.
- 6:24She specifically warned that lithium ion batteries need to be
- 6:28moved out of saltwater surge zones.
- 6:30She said they've seen them explode and cause fires.
- 6:33Which brings us to manufacturer waiting depths.
- 6:36And these are essentially tests of engineering tolerance.
- 6:39They're not operating instructions.
- 6:41Yeah, they're not a recommendation.
- 6:42Not at all, and the sheer disparity in these limits just
- 6:45highlights how varied the design approaches are.
- 6:48Indeed. I mean we see these limits
- 6:49listed all over the map. The rugged Tesla Cyber Truck
- 6:53lists awaiting depth of 32.5 inches.
- 6:57The Ford F-150 Lightning is up to 24 inches.
- 7:00Which is pretty high. But then you have a vehicle like
- 7:02the Nissan Leaf listed at up to 27.5 inches, while the Audi Q8
- 7:07is only listed at 11.8 inches. That enormous difference over 20
- 7:12inches between them? It reflects crucial design
- 7:14choices. Primarily, it's about battery
- 7:16location and the robustness of the ceiling system.
- 7:19So a lower slung EV like the Audi Q8, it's battery pack is
- 7:23just way closer to the road. Exactly, making it vulnerable
- 7:26much sooner. Light weighting limits reflect
- 7:28an architecture designed to keep that battery pack high and dry.
- 7:32But again, these are absolute limits.
- 7:33Yeah, the AA still advises against driving through water
- 7:37deeper than 4 inches for any vehicle. 4 inches?
- 7:39That's not very deep at all. Not at all.
- 7:42Beyond the powertrain itself, other factors play a role too.
- 7:45We have to consider tire choice. Some eco tires, which are
- 7:49designed specifically to maximize EV range, they might
- 7:53actually offer inferior adhesion on wet surfaces compared to
- 7:56standard performance tires. So that choice could partially
- 7:59cancel out the hydroplaning advantage we just talked about.
- 8:02It sounds like a constant negotiation of priorities, but
- 8:05there is a structural advantage, right?
- 8:07The EV motor itself is generally completely sealed.
- 8:09It is, and it has far fewer exposed mechanical parts than a
- 8:13sprawling IC engine, So that sealed architecture does give it
- 8:17better protection against general water ingress.
- 8:20Provided the water level stays below those critical battery and
- 8:23connection points, it's all about that water level at the
- 8:26end of the day. Safety in wet conditions is
- 8:28dictated by driver prudence. Whether you drive an EV or an IC
- 8:32car, the universal safe driving practices apply.
- 8:35Drive with caution. Maintain greater safety
- 8:37distances. Avoid sudden breaking in the
- 8:39wet. It's the same for everyone.
- 8:41So what does this all mean? It seems like we've extracted a
- 8:44kind of dual conclusion from the source material.
- 8:47We found this powerful, quantifiable, and frankly
- 8:51unexpected advantage for EVs in preventing hydroplaning.
- 8:54Right, about 54.4% better on average just due to mass, which
- 8:58is. Incredible.
- 9:00But conversely, we confirm that deep flood water presents a
- 9:03severe, unique danger to EVs, the fire and short circuits,
- 9:07especially with salt water, and an equally catastrophic danger
- 9:10to ICE vehicles which risk that terminal hydro lock.
- 9:14So the core take away really remains driver awareness is your
- 9:17first and best defense always. OK.
- 9:19So as we look forward to the widespread adoption of EVs, this
- 9:22added vehicle mass, it provides a clear safety benefit against
- 9:27hydroplaning, but this benefit comes with a trade off.
- 9:31We've established that the weight decreases the risk of one
- 9:33specific type of accident by over 50%, Which.
- 9:36Is a huge win a. Huge win, but we have to ask how
- 9:40should our infrastructure planning evolve to handle the
- 9:43secondary impacts of this significantly increased mass on
- 9:46things like, you know, Rd. where parking garage weight limits and
- 9:50just overall Rd. safety considerations?
- 9:53And that tension between safety benefits in one area and
- 9:58engineering challenges in another, that's really the
- 10:00defining feature of any major technology adoption.
- 10:03It really is. Thank you so much for providing
- 10:05the sources for this fascinating deep dive.
- 10:07Yeah, we really hope this comparison helps you stay safer
- 10:10and better informed the next time the weather turns
- 10:12unpredictable. Absolutely.
- 10:13And be sure to follow our channel for more curated
- 10:15knowledge and insights on the biggest topics in tech and
- 10:17beyond.