Latest / Yaron Brook Show / The Conservative Betray America’s Creed -- With Mohamed Ali | Yaron Brook Show
Transcript
- 0:03Speaker 1: A lot of them.
- 0:07Speaker 2: Widout self interest and an individual loss.
- 0:15Speaker 3: This is the show, all right, everybody, Welcome to your
- 0:22Speaker 3: on book show on this Monday March stood. Uh and uh,
- 0:28Speaker 3: I am really happy to have Muhammad Ali on our show.
- 0:34Speaker 3: Not the famous Muhammad Ali, but you know, yet to
- 0:37Speaker 3: be famous. We're gonna we're gonna help him along maybe
- 0:40Speaker 3: maybe one of these days. Who is a graduate student
- 0:44Speaker 3: in philosophy, a an objectivist And I'm gonna let I'm
- 0:49Speaker 3: gonna let Mohammad introduce himself, so he'll tell you a
- 0:51Speaker 3: little bit about his background, how he how he discovered
- 0:54Speaker 3: objectivism and everything else.
- 0:55Speaker 4: You, of course, I can ask questions.
- 0:58Speaker 2: Uh.
- 0:59Speaker 3: Now, I'll just mention that Muhammad wrote a a two
- 1:05Speaker 3: substack articles. I guess it's one, but in two parts,
- 1:08Speaker 3: why trad trad is traditional or trad con history is
- 1:13Speaker 3: bad history?
- 1:15Speaker 4: And the two parts. I've included the link to the.
- 1:18Speaker 3: Substack down below in the description Ales added here to
- 1:25Speaker 3: the chat. For those of you you'd like to check
- 1:26Speaker 3: it out, go check it out, subscribe and it's a
- 1:31Speaker 3: good article.
- 1:32Speaker 4: You'll definitely benefit from it from reading it.
- 1:34Speaker 3: And it's substance is called social dynamics. So I assume
- 1:39Speaker 3: that these are the first among many that he is
- 1:41Speaker 3: going to be writing. So let's when we start with
- 1:45Speaker 3: just tell us a little bit about your background, where
- 1:47Speaker 3: you found probably first time people have heard about you,
- 1:51Speaker 3: and suddenly hood from you.
- 1:55Speaker 1: Thank you for having me on. You're on.
- 1:56Speaker 5: I've this is so surreal. I've been watching for like
- 1:59Speaker 5: ten years. This is you know, just very different to
- 2:02Speaker 5: me on it from this end. But hello everyone. Yeah,
- 2:06Speaker 5: my name is Muhammad Ali. I am a graduate student
- 2:09Speaker 5: in philosophy at Washington University in Saint Louis. I've been
- 2:16Speaker 5: either reading about objectivism or in some way a part
- 2:19Speaker 5: of the objectivist sphere I like at this point until
- 2:24Speaker 5: like since like twenty sixteen when I went to my
- 2:26Speaker 5: first die.
- 2:27Speaker 1: In Rand conference. But I first read a nine Ran book.
- 2:31Speaker 5: I mean, I read The fountain Head when I was
- 2:34Speaker 5: still in high school, sophomore, and it was right at
- 2:39Speaker 5: a time when I was.
- 2:40Speaker 1: Two things were going on.
- 2:41Speaker 5: I was recently an atheist and was looking for some
- 2:45Speaker 5: kind of meaning, something to make sense of it all.
- 2:49Speaker 5: Like I knew what I didn't want, and I wanted
- 2:51Speaker 5: something else. And what drew me to objectivism, I think
- 2:56Speaker 5: was so halfway through reading the fountain head paused, and
- 3:01Speaker 5: then I like read the introduction, and because there was
- 3:04Speaker 5: I was getting a strange feeling that like, is this
- 3:08Speaker 5: author doing what I think she's doing? And so I
- 3:10Speaker 5: read the introduction and where she writes that, like her
- 3:14Speaker 5: goal is to like present the ideal man or the
- 3:17Speaker 5: ideal person, because young people usually.
- 3:19Speaker 1: Give up on their idealism.
- 3:20Speaker 5: And like I was, as will become clear the more
- 3:23Speaker 5: we talk about this, and the more we talk about
- 3:25Speaker 5: like particular American figures, like I like, a big part
- 3:28Speaker 5: of me, especially when I was younger, is like really
- 3:31Speaker 5: interested in like heroes and good guys, bad guys, and
- 3:34Speaker 5: there has been like a kind of and I was
- 3:37Speaker 5: seeking that like at that point.
- 3:39Speaker 1: In my life.
- 3:39Speaker 5: But like no one like that an author like took
- 3:41Speaker 5: that seriously and said, like that's her goal. Like I
- 3:46Speaker 5: knew whatever, whatever role whatever I ended up believing, and
- 3:51Speaker 5: I knew she had, you know, projectism has all these
- 3:54Speaker 5: interesting and controversial beliefs. But I knew once I read
- 3:57Speaker 5: that that like this was going to play a role
- 3:59Speaker 5: in my life just because she was the first author
- 4:03Speaker 5: to take that part of me seriously, and that was
- 4:06Speaker 5: that was.
- 4:06Speaker 1: Just very new, all right, since then, I've.
- 4:12Speaker 5: Learned more and just decided to pursue philosophy, and in
- 4:16Speaker 5: particular I'm interested in philosophical the role of ideas in history.
- 4:22Speaker 1: I have others too.
- 4:23Speaker 5: I'm also interested in science and the philosophy of science,
- 4:25Speaker 5: and you can ask him about how I relate the two.
- 4:28Speaker 5: But there's a sort of interest that I have in
- 4:33Speaker 5: how do we understand like why certain important civilizational events
- 4:39Speaker 5: took place? And like what's the role of the ideas?
- 4:42Speaker 5: And part of what objectivism gives you is a kind
- 4:44Speaker 5: of like story, right that starts like Aristotle and like
- 4:49Speaker 5: goes to the Declaration of Independence and then the industry
- 4:52Speaker 5: of loot, Like there's a whole story there, and like
- 4:54Speaker 5: that was like the second thing I read after I
- 4:56Speaker 5: finished The Mountain Head, like the intro to the for
- 4:59Speaker 5: the New Intellectual And that was like a weird kind
- 5:02Speaker 5: of like WHOA, here's this like holistic story, Like what
- 5:06Speaker 5: do I make of it? And I've been wrestling with
- 5:07Speaker 5: it like ever since, and I'll just leave it there
- 5:12Speaker 5: for now. That's like the kind of basic overview of
- 5:16Speaker 5: what I'm of, what I'm about, and how I started
- 5:19Speaker 5: hearing about.
- 5:19Speaker 4: This, and uh, just just to complete that.
- 5:23Speaker 3: Uh.
- 5:24Speaker 4: You undergraduate, you got.
- 5:26Speaker 3: In philosophy and physics, right, So like physics, I.
- 5:32Speaker 5: Wandered all sorts of like physics, philosophy, started with physics,
- 5:37Speaker 5: then I ended up going to philosophy and then grad
- 5:39Speaker 5: school in philosophy.
- 5:40Speaker 3: Okay, that's right. You had a master's, you had a
- 5:44Speaker 3: Virginia Tech right, yep, yep.
- 5:47Speaker 4: Good.
- 5:47Speaker 3: So so you interested in in in the role of
- 5:51Speaker 3: ideas in history, and you've witnessed essay on on kind
- 5:55Speaker 3: of the intellectual origins of the American founding, uh or
- 6:00Speaker 3: in particular a critique of of of the way a
- 6:04Speaker 3: lot of the conservatives look at at this period. And
- 6:07Speaker 3: before we get into the details of that, why should
- 6:11Speaker 3: anybody care about history that is, in particular American history?
- 6:14Speaker 3: What is it about history that is so important to
- 6:19Speaker 3: I don't know, the listeners here, the listeners to show
- 6:22Speaker 3: just people who might be, you know, interested in ideas
- 6:28Speaker 3: more broadly, what is unique about history and in particular
- 6:32Speaker 3: American history.
- 6:33Speaker 5: So, I mean, I'll that's the kind of question that's
- 6:37Speaker 5: just I think been asked and answered a thousand times.
- 6:40Speaker 5: I'm going to give it a little twist and like
- 6:43Speaker 5: ask if you're interested in objectivism or you think it's
- 6:47Speaker 5: something very important about it, why should you care about history?
- 6:51Speaker 5: And the question and like the answer is that if
- 6:53Speaker 5: you think you're a part of this, it's your self
- 6:57Speaker 5: fashion like revolutionary intellectual endeavor where there's all these radical
- 7:03Speaker 5: ideas that you're trying to persuade people of and you
- 7:07Speaker 5: think that it's going to have like this major shift,
- 7:10Speaker 5: like if you I mean, there's this Leonard quote where
- 7:13Speaker 5: he was asked, like what would the world look like
- 7:16Speaker 5: if you know we're objectivists, you know, or if the
- 7:20Speaker 5: ideas were taken very seriously and it was all sorts
- 7:23Speaker 5: of things and like from probably like technology to like
- 7:31Speaker 5: your soap operas would be better or something like that. So
- 7:33Speaker 5: like everyone has a sense that this is like a
- 7:35Speaker 5: revolutionary philosophy, and I was always interested in, like, well,
- 7:39Speaker 5: how okay, one, like, how does it look like? When
- 7:44Speaker 5: how could that? What how could we affect that kind
- 7:48Speaker 5: of change? What kind of groups, organizations, institutions.
- 7:51Speaker 1: Did it before? How they do it? Could we learn anything?
- 7:56Speaker 5: Like if you think that this is like the movement
- 8:00Speaker 5: that can have this dramatic and monumental impact in the world,
- 8:04Speaker 5: like what's the causal story there, right, because you don't
- 8:07Speaker 5: want to end up with a kind of like second
- 8:09Speaker 5: Coming of Christ where it just like happens, like it's
- 8:14Speaker 5: going to be through people, It's going to be through
- 8:16Speaker 5: certain organizations.
- 8:17Speaker 1: Like how does it? How could you do it?
- 8:19Speaker 5: And like what's the stories of similar advancements that were
- 8:23Speaker 5: made in the past, And like as far as like
- 8:26Speaker 5: dramatically good revolutionary movements go, they are unfortunately too few
- 8:30Speaker 5: of those. The overwhelming majority tended to be you know, terrible,
- 8:36Speaker 5: But there are some good ones, and the American Founders
- 8:38Speaker 5: are at least in large measure, one of them. And
- 8:42Speaker 5: it's ones that objectivists are more sympathetic too, and like
- 8:45Speaker 5: all know that they're they're a part of the lore,
- 8:47Speaker 5: so to speak. They're a part of that story that
- 8:50Speaker 5: you know, you get for the new intellectual that's like
- 8:55Speaker 5: my basic orientation is, like I'm trying to understand the
- 9:00Speaker 5: kind of dynamics so to speak, at play that inform
- 9:06Speaker 5: like how I think about what's good and bad and
- 9:09Speaker 5: like how we could make it, how we could bring
- 9:12Speaker 5: the world closer to our values and like shape it
- 9:15Speaker 5: in the image of the ones of the values that
- 9:17Speaker 5: we accept.
- 9:19Speaker 3: So you know, one of the things you talked about
- 9:21Speaker 3: in the early part in the essay is that in
- 9:24Speaker 3: kind of an American culture and America psyche to the
- 9:27Speaker 3: extent there is such a thing, you know, there's the
- 9:30Speaker 3: history of the founding is is really really important, and
- 9:34Speaker 3: that's why there seems to be constant battles about it.
- 9:36Speaker 3: We've got on the left, we've got the sixteen nineteen
- 9:40Speaker 3: kind of you know, pseudohistory project that is trying to
- 9:45Speaker 3: establish America as being founded in kind of original sin
- 9:49Speaker 3: and that it's always been bad. And historically Conservatives has
- 9:53Speaker 3: tried to defend against those kind of ideas and tried
- 9:56Speaker 3: to defend a certain you know, image of the found
- 10:00Speaker 3: is Is revolutionaries. But there's a kind of a twist
- 10:04Speaker 3: more recently in terms of how conservatives are dealing with
- 10:07Speaker 3: the founding.
- 10:11Speaker 4: You know, maybe maybe talk about that.
- 10:14Speaker 1: Right.
- 10:14Speaker 5: So, I mean, if you've been following you're on for
- 10:17Speaker 5: a while at this point, you know about national conservatism,
- 10:19Speaker 5: and you know about the kind of turn that the
- 10:23Speaker 5: right has taken. Like the way I think of it
- 10:25Speaker 5: as like Trump broke a lot of things and then
- 10:28Speaker 5: a bunch of people that wanted to give that meaning
- 10:30Speaker 5: just jump in and say this is how we should
- 10:35Speaker 5: understand what's going on, this is what it implies, this
- 10:39Speaker 5: is what we should do moving forward. There's sort of
- 10:41Speaker 5: he creates the kind of vacuum that like the national
- 10:44Speaker 5: Conservatives come in and try to like build something out of.
- 10:47Speaker 5: And I think, like what I've seen, like for a while,
- 10:50Speaker 5: a part of it was like so Rabbamari's that's like
- 10:53Speaker 5: a big part of the piece where he's.
- 10:57Speaker 1: Just out and out against.
- 10:58Speaker 5: Liberalism, liber like broadly understood, Like there's John Locke's philosophy
- 11:04Speaker 5: and not just like left wing campus bs. Like that's
- 11:09Speaker 5: that was I think really central culturally.
- 11:13Speaker 1: And since then.
- 11:14Speaker 5: I've seen a lot of different people in the conservative
- 11:18Speaker 5: space just gradually become not grad but like become a
- 11:26Speaker 5: lot more religious and more interested in religion than I
- 11:28Speaker 5: think they were even a generation.
- 11:30Speaker 1: Before, like kinds of.
- 11:35Speaker 5: Concerns that like Ali Beth Stuckey, who's a YouTube conservative.
- 11:40Speaker 1: She's just like.
- 11:42Speaker 5: If you just go on her YouTube channel and she's
- 11:44Speaker 5: like a you know, a youth conservative influencer, Like look
- 11:47Speaker 5: at how many of the videos are like about Calvinism
- 11:51Speaker 5: or about like and not just like religion, Like religion
- 11:53Speaker 5: is important but like, here are the five principles of Calvinism,
- 11:57Speaker 5: Like as though that's you know, supposed to inspire anyone,
- 11:59Speaker 5: Like the that's been a thing that I've noticed, and
- 12:03Speaker 5: I've noticed it also with respects to how they think
- 12:06Speaker 5: about America and about the West more broadly. So there's
- 12:11Speaker 5: the there's like a Michael Knowles interview or really a
- 12:15Speaker 5: debate with this YouTuber cosmic skeptic who's an atheist kind
- 12:20Speaker 5: of like the last of the you know, kind of
- 12:23Speaker 5: new age or rather new atheist movement types, younger though
- 12:27Speaker 5: also a philosophy student by the way, And it's Knowles
- 12:32Speaker 5: basically arguing that America is a Christian country. Now that's
- 12:36Speaker 5: not new, that's there's always been that kind of view.
- 12:40Speaker 5: But like a big part of him, a big part
- 12:42Speaker 5: of what he's argument, his argument is is like, yeah,
- 12:45Speaker 5: people like Thomas Jefferson and Thomas Paine were not that important,
- 12:49Speaker 5: and like there's a big issue, like you don't want
- 12:51Speaker 5: to think that everyone in the American Revolution was believed
- 12:54Speaker 5: the things that Pain did or Jefferson did, Like, but
- 12:57Speaker 5: isn't that strange? Like Michael Knowles is that this he
- 13:00Speaker 5: works for the Daily Wire, This is like the flagship conserved,
- 13:03Speaker 5: like Thomas Jefferson's not very representative of the Like that's bizarre,
- 13:07Speaker 5: that's so strange. And the reason is like he's the
- 13:10Speaker 5: most he's one of the more anti clerical ones, and
- 13:13Speaker 5: like just I mean they were all less religious than
- 13:15Speaker 5: he would grant them, of course, and like John Adams,
- 13:20Speaker 5: like you know, he the it was Knowles who published
- 13:26Speaker 5: or who tweeted that what was it that?
- 13:29Speaker 1: What was the year that he.
- 13:31Speaker 3: Twelve, twelve twelve or twelve twenty one something like that
- 13:34Speaker 3: was twelve it's thirteenth century, definitely thirteenth century.
- 13:37Speaker 1: Something like that. And I think what's important to realize,
- 13:39Speaker 1: like that's.
- 13:42Speaker 5: I want to express to people, like if that was
- 13:45Speaker 5: the year and you just took like the seven major founders,
- 13:49Speaker 5: like and you just dropped them in twelve twenty and
- 13:51Speaker 5: like they professed what they believed, like a bunch of
- 13:53Speaker 5: them would have been killed for Harrison.
- 13:54Speaker 1: Oh yeah, of course because.
- 13:56Speaker 5: At that time, like whatever the religious views were, no
- 13:59Speaker 5: one you really it was not intellectually respectable to talk
- 14:03Speaker 5: about the Trinity like that was just so clearly bs
- 14:07Speaker 5: and like just to go from that to the kind
- 14:09Speaker 5: of like Jordan Peterson mode, where it's like.
- 14:12Speaker 1: No, well, like it has like a kind of allegorical meaning,
- 14:16Speaker 1: and like even the more like sensitive or the more.
- 14:22Speaker 5: Sympathetic to religion, some of the founders were like Adams
- 14:26Speaker 5: and like he thought that was ridiculous.
- 14:30Speaker 1: Like there's a kind of.
- 14:33Speaker 5: Effort by these people to make America think of itself
- 14:37Speaker 5: as different than it actually was, in order to get
- 14:40Speaker 5: them to accept and swallow the kinds of ideas and
- 14:43Speaker 5: policies they're trying to push forward. And like a big
- 14:46Speaker 5: part of it's going to have to be you have
- 14:48Speaker 5: to tell Americans what they were was this kind of thing,
- 14:53Speaker 5: like this was we were always this religious? What do
- 14:56Speaker 5: you mean if this was with us from the very beginning,
- 15:00Speaker 5: Like you're gonna have to do that reinterpretation in order
- 15:02Speaker 5: to make the things that follow more palatable. And that's
- 15:06Speaker 5: just a very nefarious and despicable purpose, and I think it.
- 15:09Speaker 1: Should be called out.
- 15:10Speaker 4: Absolutely.
- 15:12Speaker 1: I do my best to do that.
- 15:14Speaker 4: So so there is a you know, there's a.
- 15:21Speaker 3: Strong effort for them to to elevate religion. And of course,
- 15:25Speaker 3: if they elevate religion as the source of the founding
- 15:29Speaker 3: of America, then they have to denigrate the Enlightenment. Uh so,
- 15:35Speaker 3: so to what extent do you see the Enlightenment as
- 15:38Speaker 3: causing the founding of America in a particular way that
- 15:43Speaker 3: it was, And in what way are they actively denigrating
- 15:47Speaker 3: the Enlightenment in finding other sources for it for the founding?
- 15:53Speaker 1: So then, okay, the.
- 15:59Speaker 5: I'll focus on one thing that I just thought about recently,
- 16:02Speaker 5: given a kind of philosophy class that I was in,
- 16:05Speaker 5: and like the it's been more fashionable recently for some
- 16:09Speaker 5: conservatives to be very to try to phrase what's wrong
- 16:17Speaker 5: with the Left in the following way. Well, they believe
- 16:20Speaker 5: people are born a blank slate, But no, there's really
- 16:24Speaker 5: there's like a deep human nature and there's something true
- 16:27Speaker 5: about that, But I think there's a problem in how
- 16:30Speaker 5: they phrase it. Like Victor Davis Hansen will sometimes talk about,
- 16:33Speaker 5: like the importance of history is that you learn that
- 16:35Speaker 5: people never really change and there is something obviously human
- 16:38Speaker 5: beings have a nature, but it's like really, but when
- 16:42Speaker 5: they talk like that, they kind of mean something a
- 16:44Speaker 5: little bit more narrow actually much narrower, like a real
- 16:47Speaker 5: concrete view of what human beings are like, and that
- 16:53Speaker 5: kind of view of human beings just really gets challenged
- 16:56Speaker 5: in the Enlightenment, and particularly like the English Enlightenment, and
- 16:59Speaker 5: there's and obviously the French Enlightenment too. But the one
- 17:04Speaker 5: thing that I think a lot of these people would
- 17:06Speaker 5: not be comfortable with is the extent to which a
- 17:10Speaker 5: lot of America's founders were calling things out as excuse
- 17:15Speaker 5: the term social constructs. Now that term is troubled, and
- 17:19Speaker 5: you know, I'm not trying to it, but in a
- 17:22Speaker 5: real sense, what it's trying to get at is the
- 17:23Speaker 5: difference between the metaphysical and the man made, just objective's terms,
- 17:28Speaker 5: And like, too much of the left today thinks like
- 17:31Speaker 5: everything's man made, right, but too many of the conservatives
- 17:34Speaker 5: think that just things are just natural, and that certain distinctions,
- 17:38Speaker 5: hierarchies they love talking about hierarchies, that those are just
- 17:41Speaker 5: like natural. And I think it would shock them the
- 17:46Speaker 5: extent to which the people that the founders of the
- 17:51Speaker 5: United States like, and the more intellectual ones I think,
- 17:53Speaker 5: like if you think of like Adams and Jefferson and
- 17:56Speaker 5: particularly more early atoms, the sense of like, no, like
- 18:01Speaker 5: people are like this because you like, society is set
- 18:04Speaker 5: up in such a way that people are restricted. They're
- 18:08Speaker 5: not free, they're not able to learn, but if they
- 18:10Speaker 5: if knowledge was available, there's a kind of utopian is
- 18:14Speaker 5: almost utopian, maybe a little bit too utopian, of the
- 18:19Speaker 5: kind of view that like since people and they took
- 18:22Speaker 5: their lock very seriously, like since people were blank slates,
- 18:25Speaker 5: and like it's like they learn from impressions, like you
- 18:29Speaker 5: can teach people to be good, like is it? I mean,
- 18:33Speaker 5: so as you'll see later, like as I'll say later.
- 18:36Speaker 5: I think part of the issue with.
- 18:38Speaker 1: Them is if anything, there was too there was too.
- 18:40Speaker 5: Much of a kind of almost naive optimism about how
- 18:44Speaker 5: things will turn out. But it's a kind of understandable,
- 18:48Speaker 5: excusable and sympathetic naive to given the time and given
- 18:52Speaker 5: like what they were up against. But there was a
- 18:54Speaker 5: real view that, like things could be very very different
- 18:57Speaker 5: if we build a whole new kind of society, and
- 19:00Speaker 5: they weren't. Yeah, So that's I think a very big
- 19:04Speaker 5: part of what for me characterizes like the spirit of
- 19:09Speaker 5: the Enlightenment that is under more than any like concrete
- 19:13Speaker 5: particular belief, but like this spirit of like human beings
- 19:16Speaker 5: could be different and like they could be better, and
- 19:18Speaker 5: like a big part of it is education and a
- 19:21Speaker 5: big part of it is the way society is set
- 19:23Speaker 5: up and late, like a lot of the Founding generation
- 19:25Speaker 5: took that very very seriously in.
- 19:27Speaker 1: A way that I think just doesn't feel.
- 19:29Speaker 5: Right for a lot of these conservatives, like it's it's
- 19:33Speaker 5: too optimistic, Like people like.
- 19:35Speaker 1: What do you mean, Like we're just gonna end up
- 19:37Speaker 1: doing the same kind of things. There will always still
- 19:40Speaker 1: be people in.
- 19:40Speaker 5: Charge, there's still going to be you know, widespread in justice,
- 19:45Speaker 5: Like there's.
- 19:45Speaker 4: A well, there's the traditional is right.
- 19:49Speaker 3: So so they expect the past to happen again, the
- 19:53Speaker 3: past is the standard, the standard of value. So the
- 19:57Speaker 3: Enlightenment said, no, we can change things things, the future
- 19:59Speaker 3: can be different from the past.
- 20:01Speaker 5: And people aren't good and like, again, it's not like
- 20:05Speaker 5: these I don't want to overexaggerate and think that like, oh, look,
- 20:09Speaker 5: all the Founders had this kind of like proto objectivist view,
- 20:12Speaker 5: but no they didn't. But they had like an Enlightenment
- 20:15Speaker 5: view and that had a lot going for it. And
- 20:19Speaker 5: why I say, like it's a little bit too much
- 20:21Speaker 5: or it's a little too utopian.
- 20:23Speaker 1: There's like.
- 20:25Speaker 5: Almost again a naivety, a little bit like the like
- 20:30Speaker 5: Jefferson thought that once religious freedom was established across the
- 20:35Speaker 5: country that like within a generation people would stop believing
- 20:40Speaker 5: in the trinity, like that that was like gonna happen,
- 20:43Speaker 5: like because that's because like true ideas.
- 20:46Speaker 1: Are going to win, right, That's just what's gonna happen.
- 20:49Speaker 5: Is it's they're gonna see that it's ridiculous and it's
- 20:51Speaker 5: gonna But in reality, and we can talk more about
- 20:54Speaker 5: this like the and this is a lesson I think
- 20:56Speaker 5: for like radicals.
- 20:58Speaker 1: In reality, a lot of different a lot of things they.
- 21:00Speaker 5: Did not expect to happen happen, like freedom ended up
- 21:03Speaker 5: looking a lot different than what they were prepared for,
- 21:06Speaker 5: and some of them were really unsettled by it. And
- 21:08Speaker 5: that's kind of interesting, like that you could be for
- 21:12Speaker 5: a kind of you could be for certain principles, you
- 21:15Speaker 5: can see them enacted, even if they're not enacted fully
- 21:18Speaker 5: the way you'd want, and then like the result could
- 21:21Speaker 5: be kind of a little bit unsettling or disturbing to
- 21:24Speaker 5: And there were certain things that they thought were that
- 21:27Speaker 5: unsettled them about early America, and part of it was
- 21:30Speaker 5: a lot of them became these evengelic the second grade
- 21:34Speaker 5: Awakening took place, and there's all sorts of like weird
- 21:37Speaker 5: religious fanaticism because the common folk, who were not particularly
- 21:42Speaker 5: educated now got to basically establish whatever church they wanted.
- 21:46Speaker 5: Like then they got to just go around and no
- 21:48Speaker 5: one stopped them, and like that's what they ended up doing.
- 21:51Speaker 5: And they and the people were also more commercially minded
- 21:55Speaker 5: in a way that did not sit well with them.
- 21:57Speaker 5: And they're more aristocratic conception of virtues and like too
- 22:01Speaker 5: many people interested in making money, and that was seen
- 22:03Speaker 5: as like being too gross and like that can't be
- 22:07Speaker 5: the kind of people that preserve a free society, Like
- 22:11Speaker 5: they're not. They're too concerned with the market in order
- 22:15Speaker 5: to sort of elevate themselves above it all, above their
- 22:18Speaker 5: own personal interests in order to secure the common good.
- 22:22Speaker 5: And they really did believe in the common good. And
- 22:23Speaker 5: it wasn't just like it didn't amount to just well,
- 22:27Speaker 5: the common good just meant protecting everyone's rights.
- 22:30Speaker 1: That was a part of it. But they had they
- 22:32Speaker 1: were still operating.
- 22:36Speaker 5: Under like a value system that is very different than
- 22:38Speaker 5: you know, what we think, and that's that has to
- 22:41Speaker 5: be engaged with and understood, and like there is merit
- 22:46Speaker 5: to getting to know them on their own terms, Like
- 22:48Speaker 5: that's how you'd have to do it.
- 22:50Speaker 4: Yep.
- 22:51Speaker 1: Yeah.
- 22:52Speaker 3: So you have a quote in the in the article
- 22:57Speaker 3: from JD. Vans saying that America is not an idea,
- 23:02Speaker 3: it's a nation. And you know, I've heard a lot
- 23:05Speaker 3: of people say that it's become quite popular these days,
- 23:08Speaker 3: again on the right, which is very different I think
- 23:11Speaker 3: than the old right, which very much thought America was
- 23:14Speaker 3: an idea.
- 23:14Speaker 4: And this is kind of a rebellion against that. Why
- 23:18Speaker 4: do you think it's.
- 23:18Speaker 3: Important for them to make this argument that America is
- 23:22Speaker 3: not an idea?
- 23:23Speaker 4: And what do they mean by it's a nation?
- 23:26Speaker 5: I think for what they mean by it's a nation
- 23:28Speaker 5: is they mean it's a people, And that just means
- 23:31Speaker 5: it's like a population and they're descendants like that group
- 23:35Speaker 5: of people, and.
- 23:36Speaker 3: It's in that sense, it's just like any other country, right,
- 23:38Speaker 3: It's just like any other nation.
- 23:40Speaker 5: And really and really, I think if you push them
- 23:44Speaker 5: on it, it's not the population that just happens to
- 23:46Speaker 5: have American citizenship. It's it's going to be among them,
- 23:48Speaker 5: and it's like and it's going to be, like I think,
- 23:52Speaker 5: gonna have a big racial element to it. Like that
- 23:54Speaker 5: that can't be. That has to be wrestled with it.
- 23:58Speaker 5: That's a big part of what's motivating that going on
- 24:01Speaker 5: the so like just personally right, Like, I So I
- 24:06Speaker 5: was I grew up by I was raised by immigrants,
- 24:10Speaker 5: I was raised to be a I was raised a Muslim,
- 24:13Speaker 5: and I had to sort of wrestle with like when
- 24:16Speaker 5: I was younger, like.
- 24:17Speaker 1: The extent to which like, well, what are my values? Right?
- 24:21Speaker 1: So like I grew up in.
- 24:22Speaker 5: The era post nine to eleven, and there was like
- 24:25Speaker 5: all this tension of like, well, am I a Muslim
- 24:30Speaker 5: who thinks that like what's happening in the Middle East
- 24:32Speaker 5: is bad because America messed it up the way everyone
- 24:34Speaker 5: around me believed it?
- 24:36Speaker 1: Or am I Like.
- 24:38Speaker 5: How do I wrestle with this? And I ended up
- 24:39Speaker 5: like thinking to myself, this is I mean, I I
- 24:47Speaker 5: became an atheist, but primarily because of less political reasons
- 24:51Speaker 5: and more like intellectual reasons.
- 24:53Speaker 1: I thought none of it made sense. But I had
- 24:55Speaker 1: to like think about.
- 24:56Speaker 5: What were my values after that for a while in
- 25:02Speaker 5: my more like everyone has like a more militant atheist phase,
- 25:05Speaker 5: like the I kept thinking of myself as like, well,
- 25:09Speaker 5: I'm for like Western ideals as opposed to you know,
- 25:15Speaker 5: Islamic ones or communists or whatever. But the I think
- 25:19Speaker 5: a big part of what I learned from that eventually
- 25:24Speaker 5: was that a lot of people that think of the
- 25:25Speaker 5: West and what they mean when they want to defend
- 25:29Speaker 5: the West is very different than the kind of thing
- 25:31Speaker 5: that drew me to objectivism, that drew me to America's founders.
- 25:36Speaker 5: And I realized that for a while in like the
- 25:39Speaker 5: kind of intellect, that intellectual dark web, kind of loose
- 25:44Speaker 5: association of people that's basically defunct now, there was too
- 25:48Speaker 5: much of like a package deal between.
- 25:52Speaker 1: What people meant.
- 25:53Speaker 5: By the West was like I don't know, the kind
- 25:55Speaker 5: of Stephen pinker Pole where it's like the Enlightenment is good,
- 25:59Speaker 5: and like, yeah, Stephen Pinker, Sam Harris, whatever their issues,
- 26:04Speaker 5: that's like the better side of the that. And then
- 26:08Speaker 5: there were like obviously the more religious ones Jordan Peterson,
- 26:12Speaker 5: and then there were like ones that weren't exactly clear
- 26:15Speaker 5: where they what they meant by the West exactly, Like
- 26:18Speaker 5: I think Douglas Murray is a little bit like this,
- 26:20Speaker 5: and like it's, well, do.
- 26:22Speaker 1: You mean like a population? I'm not That's not what
- 26:25Speaker 1: I signed up for.
- 26:26Speaker 5: First of all, I'm not like just on ancestral grounds
- 26:31Speaker 5: that wouldn't include me, And I like that's like I
- 26:35Speaker 5: think that like not to make too much of this
- 26:37Speaker 5: kind of like left wing lived experience thing. The I
- 26:42Speaker 5: think my experience has made me a lot more conscious
- 26:45Speaker 5: that I have to like choose what it is that
- 26:47Speaker 5: I think is good about the West, and I can't
- 26:49Speaker 5: like I can't afford to let them like be foggy
- 26:52Speaker 5: and murky and like.
- 26:54Speaker 1: Clustering around one another.
- 26:56Speaker 5: There's like no I have to like decide because like
- 26:59Speaker 5: some of them think that it's.
- 27:00Speaker 1: Just immigration in general is just bad and like or
- 27:03Speaker 1: at least suspect like Sargan of a cod Do you
- 27:05Speaker 1: remember how awesome you know he used to be.
- 27:08Speaker 5: I I used to love watching him and he's like
- 27:10Speaker 5: now become like you're just an out and out racist.
- 27:14Speaker 5: And like Richie Sunak who was the British Prime minister,
- 27:18Speaker 5: I mean he doesn't think he's like, look, he shouldn't
- 27:23Speaker 5: be prime minister, Like he doesn't have ancestors here all right.
- 27:27Speaker 1: When you start talking like that, like that's when I
- 27:30Speaker 1: have to get off board.
- 27:31Speaker 4: Like just you remember what's the name god? What was
- 27:36Speaker 4: there was the female conservative.
- 27:39Speaker 3: And culture and culture saying that to to h Vivic, Right,
- 27:45Speaker 3: you know I couldn't. I agree with a lot of
- 27:47Speaker 3: what you said. We could have never voted for you
- 27:49Speaker 3: because you're Indian, right.
- 27:51Speaker 5: That's so that's like alarm bells, Like what I mean
- 27:55Speaker 5: that was well after I've noticed this the problem. But
- 27:59Speaker 5: the the point is that there's a kind of like pressure,
- 28:02Speaker 5: like I have to like figure out out what I
- 28:04Speaker 5: think is good because I'm not gonna fall back on
- 28:08Speaker 5: this kind of like left going perspective that like everything
- 28:10Speaker 5: about the West is bad and like here's there's a
- 28:13Speaker 5: lot about American history that I just I think is
- 28:16Speaker 5: valuable and good. And like I also don't like merging
- 28:20Speaker 5: together the American immigration issue with the European one. Like
- 28:23Speaker 5: I really think there's even even with month immigration, I
- 28:26Speaker 5: think it's just a lot different in the US in Europe.
- 28:30Speaker 1: Part of that's numbers, but part of that is like.
- 28:35Speaker 5: Just as a matter of historical fact, the country has
- 28:38Speaker 5: had a more successful job assimilating immigrants. Put aside what
- 28:42Speaker 5: you think about what immigration policy should be or whatever,
- 28:45Speaker 5: Like just if we're just describing the history, I think
- 28:48Speaker 5: that has to be reckoned with absolutely, and I think, yeah,
- 28:53Speaker 5: just what's going on there is you have like a
- 28:55Speaker 5: population that just feels that they've been left behind for
- 29:00Speaker 5: partly legitimate reasons and partly illegitimate reasons that have to
- 29:03Speaker 5: do with just they've been too much grievance mongering. A
- 29:07Speaker 5: lot of those people, I think are fans as constituents.
- 29:10Speaker 3: Yeah, I think a big, a big part of assimilation.
- 29:13Speaker 3: A big part of what makes America good at assimilation
- 29:17Speaker 3: is that historically it to require people to work, and
- 29:20Speaker 3: I think the place in which people ultimately assimilate is
- 29:23Speaker 3: at work. Certain there's certain expectations at work that might
- 29:28Speaker 3: be different because the culture is different, language and a
- 29:31Speaker 3: lot of things. In Europe, immigrants not necessarily expected to work.
- 29:35Speaker 3: They immediately go on a kind of a welfare.
- 29:38Speaker 4: Or and and and they they're.
- 29:40Speaker 3: Separated from their main not population, and therefore I think
- 29:42Speaker 3: they never really assimilate.
- 29:44Speaker 1: Yeah.
- 29:44Speaker 5: There it's like they're a charity case. And like, so
- 29:47Speaker 5: if your charity case, then that's right. Then like the
- 29:51Speaker 5: emotions around you are weird because on the one hand,
- 29:53Speaker 5: there are people that resent you for taking charity, and
- 29:55Speaker 5: then on the other hand there are people who are
- 29:57Speaker 5: like just gonna stay quiet when you're doing things you
- 30:00Speaker 5: shouldn't do and not sort of feed you valuable information
- 30:04Speaker 5: about how you should conduct yourself socially because they're too
- 30:08Speaker 5: weirded out to say anything and they're just too ashamed
- 30:11Speaker 5: of it, and like like, hey, don't go hurtly. You
- 30:19Speaker 5: can't hit on women this way. Like the whole issue
- 30:21Speaker 5: with like migrant men in Europe, like.
- 30:25Speaker 4: Expect them to live up to certain standards. You can't.
- 30:27Speaker 4: You can't eliminate the standards because they're immigrants.
- 30:30Speaker 1: And I also don't know how so I have not
- 30:32Speaker 1: been to Europe.
- 30:33Speaker 5: I don't know how much of this is exaggerated, Like
- 30:37Speaker 5: I don't have a sense of the proportions there.
- 30:41Speaker 1: What I do have a sense of. I mean, I
- 30:42Speaker 1: grew up in.
- 30:43Speaker 5: Like Jersey City, which is one of the most you know,
- 30:45Speaker 5: ethnically diverse places in the country and therefore probably like
- 30:49Speaker 5: in the world.
- 30:50Speaker 1: But the the.
- 30:55Speaker 5: Yeah, and like the the people I knew growing up
- 30:58Speaker 5: growing up, like they you know, they made married across
- 31:00Speaker 5: different ethnic and religious line like there's it's it always
- 31:04Speaker 5: struck me as different, and like you're gonna lose that
- 31:07Speaker 5: kind of thing.
- 31:08Speaker 1: The less you think America is an.
- 31:10Speaker 5: Idea I've gotten news for you, Like there's not much else,
- 31:13Speaker 5: Like there's a real issue if you're really gonna go
- 31:16Speaker 5: down on this.
- 31:16Speaker 1: We're a people and by that we mean we're a bloodline.
- 31:19Speaker 3: And like, do you think that's the motivation? So is
- 31:23Speaker 3: jd Vance? I mean he's married to uh what to
- 31:26Speaker 3: to Indian?
- 31:27Speaker 4: Is Jade Vince?
- 31:29Speaker 3: You know, motivated by I want America to be a bloodline?
- 31:34Speaker 3: What motivates the It's not an idea.
- 31:40Speaker 5: I think, Like, so, look, I can't speak to what's
- 31:44Speaker 5: going on psychologically him, and sure like none of that.
- 31:51Speaker 5: I do think that a part of it is people
- 31:54Speaker 5: just feel on some level like these are my people and.
- 31:58Speaker 1: They're not doing to and we should focus on them first.
- 32:05Speaker 1: And like I think how much of that is racist?
- 32:08Speaker 5: How much of that is like, well, but my people
- 32:10Speaker 5: also include like the African Americans in Ohio or what like.
- 32:12Speaker 1: I don't I think that's a part of it, but
- 32:15Speaker 1: I but.
- 32:16Speaker 4: It's it seems to me that it's also.
- 32:21Speaker 3: Like if he acknowledged America's an idea, that idea is
- 32:24Speaker 3: very different than his ideas, and you know, so before
- 32:29Speaker 3: he can introduce the kind of Christian nationalism that he
- 32:32Speaker 3: wants to introduce, he has to destroy the existing idea.
- 32:36Speaker 3: So I think that the effort here is to get
- 32:39Speaker 3: rid of kind of the founding idea of America so
- 32:42Speaker 3: they can import into America the ideas that they would
- 32:48Speaker 3: like it to have.
- 32:50Speaker 5: The or like in the Hazony piece, which which is
- 32:53Speaker 5: the one I'm responding to, move there is something like, well,
- 32:57Speaker 5: it's really just like you're taking English tradition and you're
- 33:02Speaker 5: doing it. You're doing the same things that people did
- 33:05Speaker 5: in the Glorious Revolution but in seventeen eighty nine, and
- 33:08Speaker 5: like that's just how to think of it. As America
- 33:10Speaker 5: is just English traditionalism, and the founders were not particularly radical.
- 33:16Speaker 1: They were just like these English traditionalists.
- 33:18Speaker 5: And again I think what's important is to think about
- 33:21Speaker 5: like which ones and like as as any like cursory
- 33:27Speaker 5: investigation will show you a lot of these a lot
- 33:29Speaker 5: of them disagreed with one another, Like a lot of
- 33:31Speaker 5: them disagreed about all sorts of things, and in the
- 33:34Speaker 5: most vitriolic ways just oppose one another. There there is
- 33:39Speaker 5: a kind of what I find interesting is like how
- 33:41Speaker 5: do you like discuss this like the essence of a
- 33:44Speaker 5: period or like the essence of a movement when there's
- 33:45Speaker 5: a lot of disagreements and like which figures are more
- 33:49Speaker 5: central and which ones are more important. And I think
- 33:52Speaker 5: a big part of that is not something you can
- 33:55Speaker 5: tell as the thing's happening. It's like like after by
- 33:59Speaker 5: a period it like I think it really mattered.
- 34:04Speaker 1: That, And I don't think they knew.
- 34:07Speaker 5: This at the time, Like different states just had different
- 34:09Speaker 5: laws about establishing the establishment.
- 34:11Speaker 1: Of religion, and I don't think many of them realized.
- 34:18Speaker 5: That really it was all going to end up going
- 34:20Speaker 5: Virginia's way, and like that the that it's standard for
- 34:24Speaker 5: religious freedom is going to be accepted much much more
- 34:26Speaker 5: widely and therefore sort of like become part of the
- 34:30Speaker 5: American ethos in a way that it wasn't maybe even
- 34:32Speaker 5: intended to by many people. A lot of this stuff,
- 34:36Speaker 5: I think gets played out through time, and it like
- 34:38Speaker 5: depends on what choices are made, and it's not immediately
- 34:42Speaker 5: obvious to the people involved how the thing's going to
- 34:46Speaker 5: end up turning out, So there's a like and then
- 34:50Speaker 5: it's only then, when things turn out in retrospect that
- 34:52Speaker 5: you can go back and say, oh, now, I see
- 34:54Speaker 5: this person was much more central than I thought before.
- 34:58Speaker 5: And so there is like obviously the people involved cared
- 35:03Speaker 5: and had a concern with upholding what they thought was
- 35:06Speaker 5: good about English law and English liberty. But I think
- 35:10Speaker 5: what gets mistaken and what HAZONI I think it's a
- 35:13Speaker 5: purposeful mistake, is like you don't really think that there
- 35:16Speaker 5: is much more thinking that went on beyond that, Like
- 35:18Speaker 5: the hell he'll like gloss over relevant differences. They'll just say, yeah, well,
- 35:23Speaker 5: like the Senate is like the House of Lords, except
- 35:26Speaker 5: they're not lords. Like that's the whole thing. You've lost
- 35:30Speaker 5: the plot. You just like that was the big issues,
- 35:33Speaker 5: like do we have lords or not? And in the
- 35:35Speaker 5: article he writes, you know, yeah, but Americans never really
- 35:38Speaker 5: had an aristocracy. True, they didn't have like a land,
- 35:42Speaker 5: they didn't have like an established aristocracy the way Europe did.
- 35:47Speaker 1: But there were like, trust me, a lot of want
- 35:49Speaker 1: to be aristocrats.
- 35:50Speaker 4: And it was like he needs to Robinhood, doesn't Robinhood, and.
- 35:55Speaker 5: Like, but I mean in the US there were a
- 35:57Speaker 5: lot of want to be arist like in the beginning,
- 36:00Speaker 5: it was not heard like oh in that chance, yeah,
- 36:03Speaker 5: you know, like it was in the middle, like too
- 36:06Speaker 5: much of his what's interesting about the article, His article.
- 36:11Speaker 5: Is that the what's the one thing that he thinks
- 36:15Speaker 5: America does that's new and novel that's not English. It's slavery,
- 36:19Speaker 5: which which is you know, meant as a castigation of
- 36:23Speaker 5: the you know, of the founders. So everything else that's good.
- 36:26Speaker 1: It's like they just copied, you know, copied and pasted
- 36:29Speaker 1: from England.
- 36:30Speaker 4: So he's not a different than sixteen nineteen.
- 36:32Speaker 5: That's the yeah, So in effect it ends up being
- 36:35Speaker 5: the essence if that's the thing that makes it different. Yeah,
- 36:39Speaker 5: that's the Yeah, that's the irony there. But the and
- 36:43Speaker 5: by the way, like when he says it's English history,
- 36:46Speaker 5: well he thinks ultimately they get it from the Bible, right,
- 36:49Speaker 5: so he's trying to like it's all biblical. It's all
- 36:52Speaker 5: just you know, nothing new is there's nothing new under
- 36:56Speaker 5: the sun. You know, just everything important and useful is known.
- 36:59Speaker 5: I mean, there's that trigger you video of his where
- 37:02Speaker 5: he does talk about the Enlightenment more generally and he's like, yeah,
- 37:06Speaker 5: like you learned, we learned a lot of new stuff
- 37:08Speaker 5: about like how the eye works and like how light works,
- 37:10Speaker 5: and but it had all these problems with it too,
- 37:14Speaker 5: like it's such an out of scale kind of there
- 37:16Speaker 5: wasn't a sense that like there were these new things
- 37:19Speaker 5: being discovered, like like if you were Thomas Jefferson, your
- 37:23Speaker 5: friend Joseph Priestley just discovered oxygen, like that's weird, Like
- 37:28Speaker 5: they no one like.
- 37:29Speaker 1: And then there's a.
- 37:31Speaker 5: There's a cute story about like ben about Benjamin Rush
- 37:34Speaker 5: who a friend of the founders and signer of the
- 37:38Speaker 5: signatory to the Declaration, and he's he's the like he
- 37:42Speaker 5: goes on a ship and then he sees like a
- 37:44Speaker 5: mechanical pump that's you know, you know, meant to help,
- 37:48Speaker 5: you know, in case the ship got a leak and
- 37:52Speaker 5: prevent its sinking or at least FORESTALLID as much as possible.
- 37:55Speaker 5: And then he just like goes crazy, like he just
- 37:57Speaker 5: he just gets so excited about this and talks about
- 38:00Speaker 5: like how in the future there will be like an
- 38:02Speaker 5: end to all disease and like just.
- 38:04Speaker 1: This kind of like insane optimism. That's like whatever the
- 38:11Speaker 1: merits the.
- 38:12Speaker 5: Kind of arguments that these people have, Like it's it
- 38:15Speaker 5: has to be clear that they don't they don't capture
- 38:18Speaker 5: the spirit of the founding. They're just not those people.
- 38:21Speaker 5: If they were there at that time, they wouldn't. They
- 38:24Speaker 5: just wouldn't be for the country or like or if
- 38:26Speaker 5: they would, they wouldn't be in the faction that was
- 38:29Speaker 5: the most revolutionary, and they wouldn't be the ones that
- 38:31Speaker 5: ended up.
- 38:33Speaker 1: Changing the world for the better. Like they're just not
- 38:35Speaker 1: those kinds of people.
- 38:37Speaker 3: It reminds me of the of the book Dominion, where
- 38:42Speaker 3: everything is Christianity. Enlightenment is not a big deal. It's
- 38:45Speaker 3: just a spin on Christianity. Everything is christian So.
- 38:49Speaker 5: That book deserves like part of what I was thinking
- 38:52Speaker 5: of doing is like reviewing it, Like for Substack, here
- 38:56Speaker 5: is something that he that, like I've seen Tom Holland,
- 38:58Speaker 5: the author of that book, say that, Like I don't
- 39:02Speaker 5: know if that's I don't want to give the impression
- 39:05Speaker 5: that that's the best kind of perspective he has in
- 39:07Speaker 5: the book. But here's something he said, like at least
- 39:10Speaker 5: on two different occasions, so it wasn't misspoken. He gets
- 39:13Speaker 5: asked like what he thinks of the new atheists and
- 39:18Speaker 5: he thinks, well, they're deeply influenced by Christianity. Fair right,
- 39:21Speaker 5: because if they're altruists then fair Okay, so you already agree,
- 39:26Speaker 5: But then why why does he think they're influenced by Christianity. Well,
- 39:30Speaker 5: here's the argument he gives. Well, if you look through Christianity,
- 39:37Speaker 5: there was always like an iconoclastic element to it. So
- 39:41Speaker 5: like early Christian missionaries who tried to convert the Nordic
- 39:47Speaker 5: Pagans would chop down the trees that the Pagans thought
- 39:50Speaker 5: were holy, and so they would like attack superstition that way.
- 39:54Speaker 5: Martin Luther attacked some superstitions of the church and like
- 39:58Speaker 5: all the and so, but Dawkins and all these people
- 40:02Speaker 5: are doing well, they're just doing that kind of thing,
- 40:04Speaker 5: and so like really you see, it's because they're attacking superstition,
- 40:07Speaker 5: and so Carl like and he said this twice, so
- 40:09Speaker 5: like I don't know.
- 40:10Speaker 4: It's in the book. It's in the book, and it's
- 40:12Speaker 4: in the book.
- 40:13Speaker 5: And so like what's the So the argument there is
- 40:15Speaker 5: something like if you're iconoclastic, there is if like Christianity
- 40:22Speaker 5: has an iconoclastic streak, and so if therefore, if you
- 40:25Speaker 5: critique superstition of any kind, like you're working in that tradition,
- 40:28Speaker 5: Like that's that. That was an argument he presented twice.
- 40:32Speaker 5: Like it just makes me wonder about how worthwhile some
- 40:37Speaker 5: of the other stuff he says is also for what
- 40:39Speaker 5: it's worth. A lot of Muslim extremists are are iconoclasts,
- 40:44Speaker 5: but they would never dream Tom Holland would never dream
- 40:47Speaker 5: of thinking that, like when the Taliban blew up the
- 40:49Speaker 5: two Buddhas, that they were like these proto initiators of
- 40:53Speaker 5: like a kind of scientific revolution, Like there is such.
- 40:56Speaker 1: A weird like.
- 40:59Speaker 5: I mean a move that I think is worth doing,
- 41:01Speaker 5: is like see if you could replace some if you
- 41:04Speaker 5: could replace in a lot of their arguments, like Christianity
- 41:06Speaker 5: for Islam like that, I think that makes it.
- 41:08Speaker 1: More ridiculous, but in a way that you.
- 41:10Speaker 5: Could communicate to them, like like really, like this is
- 41:13Speaker 5: what you think, This is how you think ideas transmit,
- 41:17Speaker 5: This is how you think influences transmit. Like why would
- 41:20Speaker 5: you apply the same standard to a whole foreign religion
- 41:23Speaker 5: that you don't you know that's alien and different. You
- 41:26Speaker 5: probably wouldn't. There's a very like by the way, that
- 41:31Speaker 5: kind of thing where you're just like copy, like you
- 41:34Speaker 5: just pick some practice from the past that bears some
- 41:36Speaker 5: like superficial.
- 41:37Speaker 1: Resemblance to the thing that you're trying to explain.
- 41:41Speaker 5: Like I call that like tory history, Like it's a
- 41:44Speaker 5: kind of method of like like yeah, as a counter
- 41:47Speaker 5: like Whig history, where you think that the future is
- 41:50Speaker 5: just going to be automatically better and there's a line
- 41:52Speaker 5: of progress.
- 41:53Speaker 1: The opposite view is.
- 41:54Speaker 5: Like no, things just repeat and in a kind of
- 41:57Speaker 5: like naive way where you're not concerned with how are
- 42:01Speaker 5: they different? So like, there's definitely definitely connections between like
- 42:06Speaker 5: the scientific revolution and the Protestant Reformation, right, but it's
- 42:11Speaker 5: not just just like it's not as it's not this
- 42:14Speaker 5: straight line he's trying to draw, yep. It involves a
- 42:17Speaker 5: lot of conflicting values. So like it's one thing to
- 42:20Speaker 5: be if you're you know, if you think that science
- 42:27Speaker 5: will help you understand God's design, But then the more
- 42:30Speaker 5: you learn, the more scientific knowledge accumulates, it ends up
- 42:34Speaker 5: looking less and less plausible that this was something that
- 42:38Speaker 5: you know, that God made and that he was doing
- 42:41Speaker 5: it according to these pre planned principles. Like now there's
- 42:44Speaker 5: like a conflict between the values that you held before
- 42:47Speaker 5: and now you have to like choose, like, oh, it
- 42:51Speaker 5: turns out that like you probably can't think of living
- 42:55Speaker 5: things as designed by God.
- 42:56Speaker 1: Like what do I do?
- 42:57Speaker 5: Do I double down on the part of me that
- 42:59Speaker 5: was science Or do I push back or retreat now
- 43:04Speaker 5: that I see that this value that I thought was
- 43:06Speaker 5: cohering well with scientific knowledge, now that I see that
- 43:08Speaker 5: there's a conflict, do I like push back or do
- 43:12Speaker 5: I retreat back to that? Like that kind of conflict
- 43:16Speaker 5: I think doesn't play a big role in these sophistications,
- 43:20Speaker 5: in these unsophisticated versions of history. That like, even if
- 43:24Speaker 5: you have these like middle cases, what's interesting is what
- 43:27Speaker 5: happens when they're seen to be in conflict and what
- 43:29Speaker 5: do people do.
- 43:31Speaker 1: Then there's a kind of clash between values that they
- 43:34Speaker 1: thought went together.
- 43:35Speaker 5: That's like the kind of approach I tend to take,
- 43:39Speaker 5: which I do get from the Founders. So, like the
- 43:42Speaker 5: the interest in English liberties, right, so, like the view
- 43:48Speaker 5: is the Founders were very much pro English liberties and
- 43:52Speaker 5: that's why.
- 43:52Speaker 1: They rebelled against the King and Parliament.
- 43:55Speaker 5: Really what that kind of overlooks, though, is that a
- 44:01Speaker 5: lot of the precedents that were that people used for
- 44:04Speaker 5: establishing English liberties were also ambiguous because they also established
- 44:08Speaker 5: or seemed to establish that like Parliament had the final
- 44:11Speaker 5: authority because it was things like the Magna Carta and
- 44:13Speaker 5: the Glorious Revolution, and it was like, there are these
- 44:16Speaker 5: nobles and lords who get to basically stand up against
- 44:19Speaker 5: the king whenever they want, but they happen to stand
- 44:21Speaker 5: up for certain rights or for certain limitations on the crown.
- 44:25Speaker 5: What do you do when that body is the one
- 44:29Speaker 5: that you think are infringing on your rights and liberties.
- 44:32Speaker 5: So like that's new, Like it's not like you have
- 44:35Speaker 5: to make a choice.
- 44:35Speaker 1: You have to think.
- 44:36Speaker 5: And there are people on the other side who made
- 44:38Speaker 5: the other argument, and like those people end up getting
- 44:41Speaker 5: ignored by these people. They're they're just not taken into consideration.
- 44:45Speaker 5: Those people were the conservatives. Those peoples were the ones who.
- 44:48Speaker 1: Were like and like you.
- 44:50Speaker 5: And you can tell that they know that on some
- 44:52Speaker 5: level because they'll name their societies the Edmund Burke Society
- 44:56Speaker 5: and not the John Adams but like the I mean,
- 44:58Speaker 5: there's the Federalist Society, so counterpoint.
- 45:01Speaker 1: But on the other hand, they the.
- 45:03Speaker 3: Federalist Society at least think that they're consistent with the founders, right,
- 45:09Speaker 3: so they're not part of this new conservative movement at
- 45:12Speaker 3: least in the way they were founded, right.
- 45:16Speaker 1: Yeah, And the Edmund Burke said, he's more like national conservative.
- 45:19Speaker 3: So it's yes, it's explicitly right, they're explicitly that kind
- 45:24Speaker 3: of conservative versus the Federalist. It's still hawking back to
- 45:29Speaker 3: the founders, even if they don't really know that anymore.
- 45:33Speaker 4: At least the founders of the Federalist did.
- 45:36Speaker 1: Yuh so, like they know.
- 45:38Speaker 5: On some level like it because it's Edmund Burke who
- 45:40Speaker 5: gets a lot of the attention. And that's revealing, right, So,
- 45:44Speaker 5: I mean Edmund Burke had a lot going from he
- 45:47Speaker 5: you know, it's not like he was a terrible guy,
- 45:49Speaker 5: but he wasn't a radical by his own admission, he isn't.
- 45:54Speaker 1: Ye, he just he's not a John Adams, Like that's
- 45:57Speaker 1: just not who he is. He's not that guy. That's
- 46:01Speaker 1: and they wouldn't be that kind of guy either.
- 46:03Speaker 3: To say something about Adams, items is often considered the
- 46:07Speaker 3: more religious among the funny fathers. And maybe you know,
- 46:11Speaker 3: to what extent is that true? And to what extent
- 46:14Speaker 3: is he a real radical?
- 46:16Speaker 5: There's a I mean part of it's like he's a
- 46:18Speaker 5: man who lives until I forget how old he was
- 46:22Speaker 5: when he died, but he how the course of his life,
- 46:26Speaker 5: you're going to expect changes and like things developed and
- 46:29Speaker 5: I think a big part of.
- 46:32Speaker 1: The context is how much the French Revolution.
- 46:39Speaker 5: Kind of pushed people to different sides, and it kind
- 46:43Speaker 5: of did the same kind of thing I was telling
- 46:45Speaker 5: I was talking about earlier, where something, some event or
- 46:48Speaker 5: some kind of circumstance.
- 46:51Speaker 1: Occurs and you have to like become clearer about what
- 46:55Speaker 1: you're for.
- 46:57Speaker 5: I think the French Revolution, with it's excesses on which
- 47:01Speaker 5: like Adams was better than Jefferson on like he I
- 47:04Speaker 5: think that kind of I think helped cement that image
- 47:09Speaker 5: of him as being more conservative and much more defensive
- 47:14Speaker 5: of you know, institutions. And there is a lot to
- 47:17Speaker 5: say about that, right because it's not like the French
- 47:19Speaker 5: Revolution was terrible like it's it was a disaster, and
- 47:22Speaker 5: he ended up being right like he predicted, Yeah, what's
- 47:24Speaker 5: gonna happen is you're gona end up with a military dictatorship.
- 47:27Speaker 1: It's exactly ended up happening.
- 47:29Speaker 5: But the the what's interesting about Adams is like the
- 47:33Speaker 5: younger Adams, like the one who like was the bulldog
- 47:38Speaker 5: advocating for dissolution of the relationship from England, and and
- 47:43Speaker 5: like the and in particular like how intellectual he was.
- 47:49Speaker 1: The I mean, there's a at first, so like he
- 47:56Speaker 1: gets pushed almost almost by like force of logic, gets
- 47:59Speaker 1: pushed to certain kind of conclusion. So like there was.
- 48:02Speaker 5: At first like this issue of like, well, what exactly
- 48:05Speaker 5: are the balance of the parliament's.
- 48:08Speaker 1: Jurisdiction over the over the colonies.
- 48:13Speaker 5: And this is in Massachusetts, and so there is like
- 48:17Speaker 5: a view that people have and then the governor and
- 48:20Speaker 5: that it's that they have some but not like as
- 48:23Speaker 5: much as to be able to tax us in this way.
- 48:25Speaker 1: So the what.
- 48:26Speaker 5: Happens then is the governor of Massachusetts, the Royal Governor,
- 48:29Speaker 5: Thomas Hutchinson like rights, and really he presents the speech
- 48:33Speaker 5: in front of the legislators and he argues quite convincingly
- 48:39Speaker 5: that you can't you can't have that, and by force
- 48:43Speaker 5: of logic, you just look, either the parliament has completely
- 48:46Speaker 5: has no authority over these colonies, or they have enough
- 48:50Speaker 5: authority to be able to enforce these laws on us rightly,
- 48:54Speaker 5: and like it's it's like a it's not like bellicos
- 48:57Speaker 5: are threatening. It's just like this argument from well from
- 49:02Speaker 5: principles that were widely accepted about what sovereignty and just
- 49:08Speaker 5: terms that the lawyers and political thinkers of the time
- 49:12Speaker 5: would recognize just because and agree with because they were
- 49:14Speaker 5: just common at the time, and like Adams was kind
- 49:17Speaker 5: of like forced at that point after that him and
- 49:20Speaker 5: there's a he rights a or helps draft a response
- 49:24Speaker 5: to that that thinks, actually, yeah, you're right, like this
- 49:29Speaker 5: argument is correct, and I'm forced to conclude that, Yeah,
- 49:32Speaker 5: what's going on is the Parliament has no authority over
- 49:35Speaker 5: us because it can't be it can't be assumed or
- 49:39Speaker 5: something like, since it could not have been our intention
- 49:44Speaker 5: to forfeit the sortid rights that they're coming after now,
- 49:48Speaker 5: like that could not have like that was not a
- 49:50Speaker 5: part of the context of us signing. So yeah, I
- 49:52Speaker 5: guess I agree, Yeah, parliament has no jurisdiction over us.
- 49:56Speaker 3: And like.
- 49:58Speaker 5: That it was like this was a move that was
- 50:00Speaker 5: forced on him, but like through his thinking and not
- 50:03Speaker 5: just anger, Like as far as we can tell, like
- 50:07Speaker 5: it's a convincing argument that it convinced a lot of
- 50:09Speaker 5: people and like oh okay, yeah, actually.
- 50:14Speaker 1: I accept Like there's a real.
- 50:15Speaker 5: Intellectual battle there, and you just can't imagine anything like
- 50:19Speaker 5: that today, like where that's what's motivated Like there might
- 50:23Speaker 5: be like you might want to succee out of spite
- 50:26Speaker 5: or something like that, but like that you could engage
- 50:30Speaker 5: with your opponent and this sort of political, you know,
- 50:34Speaker 5: political philosophical battle where you're thinking about sovereignty in this
- 50:39Speaker 5: really deep way and then you arrive at a concludion
- 50:41Speaker 5: Like that's just very different than anything you would expect.
- 50:46Speaker 5: And I don't think it's the sort of thing that
- 50:48Speaker 5: the conservatives are comfortable with, or at least today's conservatives,
- 50:52Speaker 5: because I think what's a big part of the motivation
- 50:54Speaker 5: is they don't think there are principles that that that.
- 51:00Speaker 5: I don't think they think that there are principles that
- 51:02Speaker 5: you can discover in the way that you would discover
- 51:05Speaker 5: scientific principles about how to govern human beings.
- 51:08Speaker 3: Like it's a big issue for Zoni. He doesn't believe
- 51:11Speaker 3: in in universal values. He doesn't believe in there's any
- 51:14Speaker 3: such things as rights or a universal morality.
- 51:19Speaker 4: Even he rejects that whole concept.
- 51:22Speaker 2: So so it's gonna be yeah, so it's gonna you
- 51:25Speaker 2: have to like dig there's a kind of like one
- 51:29Speaker 2: it's under This is the kind of thing that I
- 51:32Speaker 2: think leaves.
- 51:32Speaker 5: People who are who are more liberal but in that
- 51:36Speaker 5: broader sense or more rights oriented or more pro freedom
- 51:40Speaker 5: in other societies that aren't in the West. I think
- 51:44Speaker 5: that's the kind of thing that would just like leave
- 51:46Speaker 5: them stranded. Like isn't that like if you're you know,
- 51:50Speaker 5: an Iranian girl and you're trying to think about how
- 51:54Speaker 5: to reorganize society, like the people here like aren't offering
- 51:58Speaker 5: you anything to think about. It's just dig through your
- 52:03Speaker 5: history and try to find something to justify it. And
- 52:05Speaker 5: like money, it's like money laundering, but for like good ideas.
- 52:09Speaker 1: It's the Yeah, and I have like a quote in
- 52:14Speaker 1: the article about.
- 52:16Speaker 5: Again this is too much, there's something wrong about this,
- 52:20Speaker 5: but I like its spirit. There's a quote we looked
- 52:24Speaker 5: for liberties and like musty old parchments and royal declarations,
- 52:28Speaker 5: but we found them like written in our hearts, which
- 52:31Speaker 5: is way too simplistic of.
- 52:33Speaker 1: Her like achievement.
- 52:34Speaker 5: They're not just written, But like I like that we
- 52:36Speaker 5: didn't have to look for them in musty parchments. Like
- 52:39Speaker 5: that's exactly the kind of thing that HAZONI would leave
- 52:42Speaker 5: someone in Iran who's trying to you know, possibly you know,
- 52:47Speaker 5: risk her life for you know, the cause of her freedom,
- 52:51Speaker 5: Like we have nothing to say to that person there's
- 52:53Speaker 5: no general principles we can say about how human beings
- 52:55Speaker 5: should live. But like why I think that like there
- 52:58Speaker 5: are there are principles that govern or at least that
- 53:02Speaker 5: we can understand about how life evolves, about how solar
- 53:07Speaker 5: systems are formed, like how syb atomic particles interact, like
- 53:10Speaker 5: and then, but when it comes to human beings, we
- 53:12Speaker 5: just can't say anything. That's for some somehow like that
- 53:16Speaker 5: just it turns off there, what's what's the motivation? Clearly
- 53:21Speaker 5: it's a kind of I don't know what pretext, Like
- 53:25Speaker 5: there's a he's just uncomfortable with what that kind of
- 53:30Speaker 5: inquiry is going to find and push and like.
- 53:32Speaker 3: Absolutely, I mean for HAZONI I think it's it's tribalism. Right,
- 53:35Speaker 3: it would imply that if there's a universal principle, then
- 53:40Speaker 3: his his particular tribes principles is Jewish you know, uh,
- 53:45Speaker 3: Jewish supremacy or Jewish tribalism is not an avoid because
- 53:51Speaker 3: there's something above and beyond that, right, there's something beyond
- 53:53Speaker 3: the Bible. There's something more universal than the Bible that's
- 53:57Speaker 3: unacceptable to them. It's it's why Domini and denies that
- 54:02Speaker 3: people can have new ideas and new integrations. Right, every
- 54:05Speaker 3: new idea and every new integration has to be hawking back.
- 54:08Speaker 4: To Christianity in one way or the other.
- 54:10Speaker 5: So what I think is like interesting is clearly human beings.
- 54:14Speaker 5: I mean, they read other people, they read things in
- 54:17Speaker 5: the past, like they should. Like the something I try
- 54:21Speaker 5: to point out in the article, and I think is
- 54:23Speaker 5: going to be a big like a central point of
- 54:25Speaker 5: my thinking is that like like a a new tradition,
- 54:29Speaker 5: practice or whatever, like could be continuous with an old
- 54:32Speaker 5: one in a certain sense.
- 54:33Speaker 1: They share some of the features. And like not just
- 54:35Speaker 1: they share features, but.
- 54:37Speaker 5: Like developmentally, maybe we ended up here because we started
- 54:41Speaker 5: here and then some people made certain choices and then
- 54:44Speaker 5: like and I use the example of like romantic love
- 54:46Speaker 5: and marriage, like monogamy is the big thing conservatives are
- 54:49Speaker 5: for what kind of monogamy? Right, So like what people
- 54:55Speaker 5: love about that idea is romantic love, Like that's what
- 54:59Speaker 5: matters to them. But that's again a new, more recent development.
- 55:02Speaker 5: But like, it's not the case that no one before
- 55:05Speaker 5: the nineteenth century or whatever, like had a loving relationship.
- 55:09Speaker 5: It happened sometimes, but oftentimes it was just family convenience,
- 55:12Speaker 5: and no one really expected that much out of their marriages.
- 55:15Speaker 5: Then like people started thinking about it differently, and there
- 55:17Speaker 5: were certain like cultural forces that like and people arguing
- 55:23Speaker 5: forcefully for like this is what should be valued in marriage,
- 55:26Speaker 5: and like you ended up with a practice that was
- 55:28Speaker 5: like still continuous, like it's still came out of the
- 55:33Speaker 5: previous one, but like it's still new. And that's the
- 55:35Speaker 5: thing that I think a lot of these people just
- 55:37Speaker 5: don't see that, Like things could be developmentally related, but
- 55:42Speaker 5: like the ideas motivating them are like different, and that's
- 55:46Speaker 5: that's like a thing that's just not registering.
- 55:49Speaker 3: I think, Yeah, I think yeah, I think a review
- 55:52Speaker 3: of Dominion would be fantastic. I think it definitely justifies
- 55:56Speaker 3: it and needs it. And there's a lot I think
- 55:59Speaker 3: that he there's a lot wrong in that book.
- 56:01Speaker 4: So there's a lot to cover. Good.
- 56:07Speaker 3: Let's see anything else you want to cover on the article.
- 56:10Speaker 3: We've been going in an hour, so we should probably
- 56:12Speaker 3: turn to some questions from the audience.
- 56:18Speaker 4: Let me think the.
- 56:21Speaker 5: I mean, I just want to say more personally, like
- 56:22Speaker 5: the the I mean, I had an interest in American
- 56:27Speaker 5: history and particularly the founders, like even before objectivism, like
- 56:34Speaker 5: I mean, there was a and I think looking back
- 56:36Speaker 5: on it now, Like I was reading like the Ben
- 56:39Speaker 5: Franklin's autobiography, you know that's everyone reads that and like
- 56:42Speaker 5: the but it had a more what I what I
- 56:45Speaker 5: thought I liked and I and I say thought because
- 56:47Speaker 5: I don't think I put it into words at the time, but.
- 56:50Speaker 1: It was like there is something like dramatic. I'm just very.
- 56:58Speaker 5: They're like action hero, but their action was intellectual, Like
- 57:03Speaker 5: there's and whatever, like that's my content, like whatever issues
- 57:07Speaker 5: I have with them, and there's all sorts of issues,
- 57:09Speaker 5: like I'm not gonna I'm not trying to whitewash maybe
- 57:14Speaker 5: the compromises that they did over slavery, and like there's
- 57:17Speaker 5: real evasions.
- 57:18Speaker 1: I think on some of their parts there.
- 57:20Speaker 5: But like if you're like if you think the world
- 57:24Speaker 5: could be made better, and like that's a real belief
- 57:28Speaker 5: you hold and it's not like floating and it's not
- 57:31Speaker 5: just you accept it because you know objectivesm totally you
- 57:34Speaker 5: or like the and you don't recognize it like these
- 57:37Speaker 5: were like some of the people that help do that,
- 57:40Speaker 5: and whatever shortcomings and failings that they had, I just
- 57:46Speaker 5: don't think we're doing the same thing. Like I'm genuinely
- 57:51Speaker 5: invested in the kind of project that these people were
- 57:54Speaker 5: for in a way that's really feels really acute now
- 57:57Speaker 5: because I think we're in a perilous time and I
- 58:00Speaker 5: think Donald Trump is exactly the kind of man that
- 58:04Speaker 5: would discuss all of them like the and I mean
- 58:06Speaker 5: discussed like the kind of contempt that he is resentful,
- 58:10Speaker 5: Like he's very resentful about how like the liberal elites
- 58:12Speaker 5: think of him. And I think that is nothing compared
- 58:16Speaker 5: to the kind of utter, guttural disgust that someone like
- 58:22Speaker 5: James Madison would have over him, Like that's just they're
- 58:26Speaker 5: just not in the same universe.
- 58:27Speaker 4: That's a yeah, I agree with it completely. I don't.
- 58:30Speaker 3: I don't think we can imagine how horrified the Founders
- 58:33Speaker 3: would be of the of Trump in particular. But then
- 58:37Speaker 3: in this new conservative political tradition, I think you're right.
- 58:41Speaker 3: I think they're filling in the vacuum that Trump has created.
- 58:45Speaker 3: The Hanzoni's and jd Vance's and the and the Patrick
- 58:50Speaker 3: Denise and whatever. They're filling in a vacuum that's created
- 58:54Speaker 3: Christian Conservatism, national conservatism, integralism all ways, in which to
- 59:00Speaker 3: come in and fill that vacuum. But I think the
- 59:03Speaker 3: Founders would be horrified by the whole project.
- 59:05Speaker 5: But also one one final thought like that it's a
- 59:08Speaker 5: part of it's also that the the way I think
- 59:12Speaker 5: of it as the But what John Adams did when
- 59:16Speaker 5: he was looking and thinking about the what was good
- 59:18Speaker 5: about the English Constitution, and it was like, I'm going
- 59:22Speaker 5: to choose to prioritize protection of liberty over a sovereignty
- 59:25Speaker 5: of parliament. Like those two things were part of the
- 59:28Speaker 5: same tradition or like at least muddled or unclear object
- 59:31Speaker 5: like I think of the objectivist movement.
- 59:33Speaker 1: We're trying to do the same thing. But with America.
- 59:35Speaker 5: Yep, we're trying to think of like, all right, there
- 59:40Speaker 5: is way too much sympathy to religion, there's way too
- 59:42Speaker 5: much the moral views were all too influenced by Christianity.
- 59:47Speaker 1: But here are some central ideas.
- 59:49Speaker 5: And we're going to focus on those, and we're going
- 59:51Speaker 5: to like and that's what we're gonna make sense. We're
- 59:53Speaker 5: gonna make those central, and we're gonna need to bring
- 59:57Speaker 5: in a whole new philosophy to undergirden and do all that.
- 59:59Speaker 5: But we're doing the same kind of historical project they
- 1:00:04Speaker 5: were doing when they were looking at English history. And
- 1:00:06Speaker 5: like deciding what from it to keep and how to
- 1:00:08Speaker 5: reconceptualize and like how to like we need something like
- 1:00:12Speaker 5: the House of Lords, but it can't be Lords.
- 1:00:14Speaker 1: So like we're doing the same thing. But I think.
- 1:00:20Speaker 5: Right the way because it's philosophical, So the the way
- 1:00:23Speaker 5: I think of it as like the it's not like
- 1:00:26Speaker 5: we're going to go back to the founder. Like the
- 1:00:28Speaker 5: point is you take what's good about them and you
- 1:00:30Speaker 5: make it more central, and you try to understand them
- 1:00:33Speaker 5: and try to understand what's good about it, and like
- 1:00:36Speaker 5: you double down on that and then you fight against
- 1:00:40Speaker 5: the people that want to undermine that. And the Conservatives
- 1:00:44Speaker 5: are doing the same thing in a sense, like what
- 1:00:47Speaker 5: Michael Knowles knows. Even when he argues that America was
- 1:00:50Speaker 5: a Christian country, if you watch that interview with him,
- 1:00:54Speaker 5: he's like, yeah, but it also had this too much
- 1:00:58Speaker 5: too pro enlightenment view and like ultimately it's going to
- 1:01:02Speaker 5: collapse into one of two directions, and he says it
- 1:01:04Speaker 5: and either that and his words were like, either you know,
- 1:01:07Speaker 5: it becomes like an atheist secular hellhole, or it's like
- 1:01:11Speaker 5: a Catholic country, and he's he doesn't say related. He
- 1:01:14Speaker 5: says a Catholic country. That's his take on it. But
- 1:01:18Speaker 5: even he knows that there's a kind of something similar
- 1:01:20Speaker 5: going on, like there's a we're each choosing what it
- 1:01:24Speaker 5: is we care about.
- 1:01:25Speaker 1: In the country, and we're like fighting for that.
- 1:01:31Speaker 3: Yeah, and there's a sense in which as objectives, we're
- 1:01:34Speaker 3: doing that with the whole Enlightenment project, right, we're saying
- 1:01:37Speaker 3: what was good about it?
- 1:01:39Speaker 4: What do we and how do you take it to
- 1:01:41Speaker 4: the next level? How do we? How do we?
- 1:01:43Speaker 3: And that's what you know, Rand of course is a
- 1:01:46Speaker 3: powerful force in that direction. Right, Good, let's see, let's
- 1:01:52Speaker 3: see what we have here. Let me just think, uh
- 1:01:58Speaker 3: we got some stick. Just let me thank Clay and
- 1:02:02Speaker 3: Gail and Wes and Mary, Elene and Scott and Jonathan.
- 1:02:12Speaker 4: And show us what he has A question, all.
- 1:02:14Speaker 3: Right, have you encountered anyone in academic in academic realm
- 1:02:18Speaker 3: of philosophy who is more or less aimless?
- 1:02:27Speaker 1: Are they gonna read, they're gonna are they gonna see this?
- 1:02:29Speaker 1: But the answer is yes, a lot? Yeah. Uh how
- 1:02:34Speaker 1: does that?
- 1:02:34Speaker 4: How does that manifest itself?
- 1:02:37Speaker 1: Listeners?
- 1:02:38Speaker 5: I mean, the first of all, like I don't it's
- 1:02:42Speaker 5: I don't know if it's just unique to philosophy, I think.
- 1:02:47Speaker 5: So first of all, just college, just university.
- 1:02:49Speaker 1: People end up there aimlessly.
- 1:02:51Speaker 5: Like it's because you just get especially if you're intelligent, ironically,
- 1:02:54Speaker 5: because you just get so much pressure to just go.
- 1:02:58Speaker 5: So I take it the question was people are they aimless?
- 1:03:01Speaker 4: Yeah?
- 1:03:01Speaker 1: Is that?
- 1:03:01Speaker 4: Yeah?
- 1:03:02Speaker 1: Yeah? Right? And then grad school is not is a
- 1:03:05Speaker 1: little bit better, but not that different. There's just like.
- 1:03:10Speaker 4: They don't know why they're there, They're just there.
- 1:03:13Speaker 3: Uh.
- 1:03:13Speaker 5: And then what happens is you just like kind of
- 1:03:15Speaker 5: pick up on what people are doing.
- 1:03:17Speaker 1: So the.
- 1:03:19Speaker 5: You end up going maybe because you're just like intellectually
- 1:03:23Speaker 5: curious because you did really well on a philosophy course
- 1:03:27Speaker 5: when you were an undergrad, and then you.
- 1:03:29Speaker 1: Just end up.
- 1:03:31Speaker 5: You get told, yeah, why don't like I like this?
- 1:03:33Speaker 5: Why don't I do this more professionally? But then you
- 1:03:35Speaker 5: go and it's like now you have to like have projects,
- 1:03:38Speaker 5: you have to have like things you care about, well,
- 1:03:40Speaker 5: like what is that?
- 1:03:41Speaker 1: And the it's very hard. I'm trying to do that.
- 1:03:44Speaker 5: So I'm trying to translate like this kind of more
- 1:03:46Speaker 5: inco a kind of broad interest in all these different
- 1:03:49Speaker 5: things into like actual projects. And I think that's one
- 1:03:52Speaker 5: that's just very difficult to do. And one thing that
- 1:03:57Speaker 5: can end up happening is you just like see people
- 1:04:01Speaker 5: do things and they're just like use certain terms or
- 1:04:05Speaker 5: they this one particular area is important and everyone thinks
- 1:04:10Speaker 5: it's important, and like you just sometimes just find yourself
- 1:04:15Speaker 5: adopting it and like defining like and it's just basically
- 1:04:20Speaker 5: kind of an accident that like it's you're not interested
- 1:04:23Speaker 5: in this particular subfield and ethics and like that's because
- 1:04:26Speaker 5: a bit for often a lot of people, that's just
- 1:04:28Speaker 5: what's around and like they just see everyone talking like
- 1:04:31Speaker 5: and there's like technical vocabulary that goes with it too,
- 1:04:34Speaker 5: like oh, we care about reasons not reason the faculty
- 1:04:39Speaker 5: like there's a certain kind of focus on just like
- 1:04:43Speaker 5: mini commandments that's plaguing philosophy today, or I don't know,
- 1:04:51Speaker 5: like you catch on a certain terms like in cognitive
- 1:04:55Speaker 5: science like multiple realizability and you're functionalism functionalists this functionalists
- 1:04:59Speaker 5: that a functionalist account of whatever, Like the there's a
- 1:05:04Speaker 5: you can just like pick things up by it's almost osmosis,
- 1:05:08Speaker 5: but sometimes it's also like more intentional, like this is
- 1:05:11Speaker 5: what people like you know broadly you want to do philosophy,
- 1:05:14Speaker 5: but you don't know what you want to do, and
- 1:05:15Speaker 5: it's again hard to have projects. And like philosophy is
- 1:05:18Speaker 5: what philosophers do is the perspective people end up having.
- 1:05:21Speaker 5: And what philosophers do is like this thing as it
- 1:05:25Speaker 5: happens in the and like you don't really think too
- 1:05:28Speaker 5: deeply about why they're doing it or whether it's going
- 1:05:30Speaker 5: to exist in the same form in like half a
- 1:05:33Speaker 5: century or even a decade, and like it's just aimless.
- 1:05:36Speaker 1: But I don't know if.
- 1:05:37Speaker 5: It's how special it is to philosophy. I think like
- 1:05:42Speaker 5: young adulthood is filled with a lot of this.
- 1:05:43Speaker 1: Kind of thing.
- 1:05:45Speaker 4: Yeah, I think that's right.
- 1:05:47Speaker 3: Uh, let's see us what else asks What would happen
- 1:05:51Speaker 3: to America if the Conservatives got their way by eliminating
- 1:05:53Speaker 3: the barrier between church and state.
- 1:05:57Speaker 5: Oh I love this, so all right, this is good.
- 1:06:01Speaker 5: First of all, they would all hate each other.
- 1:06:05Speaker 1: So like this is the thing.
- 1:06:06Speaker 5: Like I had a teacher in high school who I
- 1:06:09Speaker 5: still follow on Facebook who is a Mormon and is
- 1:06:12Speaker 5: now like very pro Trump and like kind of pro this,
- 1:06:16Speaker 5: And I'm like, you're a dude. I mean, Trump is
- 1:06:19Speaker 5: not a national He's not a Christian nationalist is that
- 1:06:21Speaker 5: on anything?
- 1:06:22Speaker 1: But like if you're Mormon and you're.
- 1:06:24Speaker 5: Like pro Christian nationalism, you're you're not bright, Like you're
- 1:06:30Speaker 5: ruining yourself. Like there's a So what would happen is
- 1:06:33Speaker 5: like the moment this stuff starts becoming an actual matter
- 1:06:37Speaker 5: of legislation, Uh, they're all going to turn on each
- 1:06:41Speaker 5: other and they're.
- 1:06:42Speaker 1: Gonna fight it out.
- 1:06:43Speaker 5: And it's only it's only because of the of the
- 1:06:48Speaker 5: foresight of the honestly of like Jefferson and Madison, who
- 1:06:54Speaker 5: unlike in particularly Madison, whose reason for it was like
- 1:06:58Speaker 5: the way he ended up getting it passed, it was
- 1:07:00Speaker 5: and who got the Virginia Statute passed, and it.
- 1:07:02Speaker 1: Was through like a kind of political shrewdness.
- 1:07:04Speaker 5: Like so Jefferson's view was like, ah, people will accept
- 1:07:08Speaker 5: religious freedom because they're more enlightened now. And Madison persuaded
- 1:07:12Speaker 5: them by saying, Hey, now that the Anglicans are gone,
- 1:07:16Speaker 5: do you want like the Quakers to get the No, no,
- 1:07:20Speaker 5: we don't. So like what happened is they knew that
- 1:07:23Speaker 5: like this kind of conflict, like the same kind of
- 1:07:26Speaker 5: conflict do you get in schools overwoke imagine like doing
- 1:07:30Speaker 5: all that again, but with religion, like like as though
- 1:07:33Speaker 5: we were living past in the you know, four hundred
- 1:07:35Speaker 5: years ago and you could tell that now Like there's
- 1:07:38Speaker 5: like Michael Knowles and Charlie Kirk were in a taking
- 1:07:42Speaker 5: questions from an audience and they just have like a
- 1:07:44Speaker 5: digression on like the pope and they're like arguing back
- 1:07:48Speaker 5: and forth. Like twenty years ago, thirty years ago, maybe
- 1:07:50Speaker 5: they would only they could unite because they're like pro religion.
- 1:07:55Speaker 5: But now like Charlie Kirk's an evangelical and he's like,
- 1:07:58Speaker 5: well I don't. I just believe in Sola scripture and man,
- 1:08:01Speaker 5: like I'm just and like there are all these like
- 1:08:04Speaker 5: Reformation era debates that are like happening, like who gives
- 1:08:08Speaker 5: a ship? Like you don't And if you're Hazzoni, like
- 1:08:12Speaker 5: you're not being very prudent like that is that.
- 1:08:15Speaker 1: Is not like.
- 1:08:18Speaker 3: Now kaus Shandy is never ever no branch of Shanny
- 1:08:21Speaker 3: as ever be nice to the Jews. I mean that
- 1:08:23Speaker 3: is just a reality and Hazzoni is evading that completely.
- 1:08:28Speaker 5: Yeah, I mean the yeah, I mean I did have
- 1:08:31Speaker 5: like a small interaction with him on Twitter.
- 1:08:35Speaker 1: He like the I mean he so.
- 1:08:38Speaker 5: He didn't like that I called them blood and soil
- 1:08:40Speaker 5: conservative their blood and soil nationalists.
- 1:08:42Speaker 1: Forget the term that I used, because he thought that
- 1:08:45Speaker 1: meant Nazis.
- 1:08:46Speaker 5: Yeah, well, uh, all right, so you don't like blood
- 1:08:52Speaker 5: and soil, but like even the phrase there, but like
- 1:08:55Speaker 5: you do you know that, like what does Victor Orbon
- 1:08:58Speaker 5: say about that?
- 1:08:58Speaker 1: Like you like Victor Orbon?
- 1:09:00Speaker 5: Like would you think he would be so disgusted with
- 1:09:02Speaker 5: the phrase blood and soil? Like the the irony of
- 1:09:06Speaker 5: the people that like first things and they love to
- 1:09:10Speaker 5: like they just love this kind of like ecumenical.
- 1:09:15Speaker 4: Did he answer you?
- 1:09:17Speaker 1: No, he he just it was just it was Ben.
- 1:09:20Speaker 5: He was talking to Ben Behar, and I think he
- 1:09:21Speaker 5: thought I was beneath like responds there, But I at
- 1:09:26Speaker 5: least know he read up until the point where he's
- 1:09:28Speaker 5: citing from. Yeah, and I got a couple jabs in
- 1:09:31Speaker 5: at that point in the article.
- 1:09:32Speaker 1: So I'm just happy with it. I mean, at some
- 1:09:34Speaker 1: point I just say that like they're betraying Lincoln, Like
- 1:09:37Speaker 1: there's a I like that.
- 1:09:38Speaker 3: Yeah, he's uh yeah, I mean he's he's red ran.
- 1:09:43Speaker 3: You know, he said he knows where where can I
- 1:09:47Speaker 3: coming from? It's he's an interesting and he took this
- 1:09:51Speaker 3: turn to conservatism because I knew him before he became
- 1:09:54Speaker 3: this big national conservative and he took this turn to
- 1:09:57Speaker 3: national conservatism more recently, and it is it is interesting,
- 1:10:03Speaker 3: but he's of course, he's always been super religious, and
- 1:10:06Speaker 3: it was inevitable that it would come to this. He
- 1:10:08Speaker 3: has to justifies nationalism somewhow.
- 1:10:10Speaker 1: A similar point that I was making earlier, like the.
- 1:10:19Speaker 5: Do you if you had to guess, I mean you
- 1:10:21Speaker 5: probably you know the actual history, so it wouldn't be
- 1:10:23Speaker 5: a guest for you.
- 1:10:24Speaker 1: But if you take the Middle East and.
- 1:10:28Speaker 5: You ask yourself the relationship between the Sunnis and Shias
- 1:10:33Speaker 5: get better or worse when Islamism, like when Islamism became
- 1:10:40Speaker 5: the dominant or the predominant ideology, and like.
- 1:10:44Speaker 1: It got worse really quickly. Yep.
- 1:10:46Speaker 5: And that's kind of a fact that gets obscured in
- 1:10:49Speaker 5: history almost so like so one of the things that
- 1:10:52Speaker 5: like Aari is big on is like the nineteen seventy
- 1:10:56Speaker 5: nine revolutions, like the pinnacle of Islam asn't and like
- 1:11:01Speaker 5: it's responsible ultimately for like al Qaeda, which is a
- 1:11:04Speaker 5: you know, Sunni, right, And that was like I always
- 1:11:09Speaker 5: found that puzzling and I was like, wow, I need
- 1:11:10Speaker 5: to look into that because like I grew up in
- 1:11:13Speaker 5: like the Sunnis and she is hated each other. Like
- 1:11:16Speaker 5: but if you look at the actual history, like Saudi
- 1:11:20Speaker 5: could who was a Sunni was being translated by he
- 1:11:24Speaker 5: translated and like they oh, so it turns out that
- 1:11:27Speaker 5: like that like real deep patriot it was always there,
- 1:11:30Speaker 5: like it never gone.
- 1:11:31Speaker 1: But like the it's isn't that like weird?
- 1:11:35Speaker 5: Like there they were allied together and like in really
- 1:11:39Speaker 5: close ways like the until they got power and then
- 1:11:42Speaker 5: they and then they start hating each other, right, and
- 1:11:45Speaker 5: like do you do they like if you're a national conservative,
- 1:11:48Speaker 5: I know we're on the pretense that like well, like
- 1:11:50Speaker 5: Christianity's a different religion, it's this way.
- 1:11:53Speaker 1: I don't buy it. I never I never bought that.
- 1:11:55Speaker 1: But the I think the difference is between the people
- 1:11:59Speaker 1: and like how religious they are.
- 1:12:00Speaker 4: But like the.
- 1:12:02Speaker 5: If you think that's not gonna happen to you, guys,
- 1:12:04Speaker 5: like just pay attention to conservative media, like just watch
- 1:12:08Speaker 5: like before Candice Owens was like you know, she still
- 1:12:13Speaker 5: had a show on the Daily Wire. She had like
- 1:12:16Speaker 5: her husband on and debating like another conservative commentation like
- 1:12:21Speaker 5: where it's like Calvinism versus Catholicism, Like why is that
- 1:12:24Speaker 5: a thing being litigated now more than before? Like, it's
- 1:12:28Speaker 5: because you guys are taking it more seriously. And if
- 1:12:30Speaker 5: you think you're not gonna end up fighting with each other,
- 1:12:33Speaker 5: you're gonna hate each other more than you've hated anyone else.
- 1:12:35Speaker 4: Because it's about power now, it's about power.
- 1:12:38Speaker 3: And and it is interesting you know that most of
- 1:12:43Speaker 3: not all of them, but most of the intellectuals on
- 1:12:45Speaker 3: the on this new right, uh converts to Catholicism.
- 1:12:50Speaker 1: Many of them. Yeah, so like the many of them are.
- 1:12:52Speaker 3: I mean, Jadie Vance is a good example, the Mule
- 1:12:55Speaker 3: in Harvid and and Deneen.
- 1:12:57Speaker 5: But they're still like they're there's still the more the
- 1:13:00Speaker 5: I forget what's his name, but the one that's Orthodox Christian,
- 1:13:04Speaker 5: the the and then.
- 1:13:05Speaker 4: Like he's an ol fan. The Orthodox Christian is like
- 1:13:08Speaker 4: an old bunt fan.
- 1:13:10Speaker 1: You get his name.
- 1:13:13Speaker 4: Something with a D, yeah, yeah.
- 1:13:15Speaker 1: Yeahrere yeah.
- 1:13:16Speaker 5: I mean he has like a book with a title
- 1:13:18Speaker 5: the if you're talking about the Enlightenment, like the it's
- 1:13:23Speaker 5: called I think that his title is something like re
- 1:13:25Speaker 5: enchanting the World or something like the and what that
- 1:13:28Speaker 5: alludes to is this period in history where we got
- 1:13:32Speaker 5: rid of magic basically, and it's it ends up getting
- 1:13:34Speaker 5: called the Great Disenchantment because now we don't believe in
- 1:13:36Speaker 5: demons and we don't believe.
- 1:13:37Speaker 1: In this or like it's more natural causes.
- 1:13:40Speaker 5: But like enchantment sounds lovely and magical, so like we're
- 1:13:44Speaker 5: gonna pretend that was a great time, even though like
- 1:13:47Speaker 5: what the Disenchantment did was it made the world less capricious,
- 1:13:53Speaker 5: like like Martin Luther like fell on his knees when
- 1:13:56Speaker 5: there was thunder when there was a thunderstorm, and just
- 1:13:59Speaker 5: to see a contrast between that and the Founders, and
- 1:14:01Speaker 5: like Ben Franklin's fame partly came from like taming lightning, yeah,
- 1:14:07Speaker 5: and showing you that like it's harmless.
- 1:14:09Speaker 1: It's just lightning.
- 1:14:10Speaker 5: Like you think of that sentence when like a kid
- 1:14:13Speaker 5: gets startled or something when they hear a thunderstorm and
- 1:14:15Speaker 5: it's just lightning. Like so much went into that statement
- 1:14:18Speaker 5: to make it like so benign, but like you could
- 1:14:23Speaker 5: just always talk about how lovely things were when.
- 1:14:25Speaker 1: Things were enchanted, the world was magical.
- 1:14:27Speaker 5: It was when what that really means is like nothing
- 1:14:30Speaker 5: made sense and everyone was scared of everything, all.
- 1:14:34Speaker 3: Right, Chelesbuch says, have you eaten at the Left Bank
- 1:14:39Speaker 3: Burger bar in Josie City, one of my favorites.
- 1:14:42Speaker 4: If there was bad of pawking.
- 1:14:45Speaker 1: What's weird about that? So?
- 1:14:46Speaker 5: No, But what's weird about that is there's a I
- 1:14:49Speaker 5: thought he was gonna say the Left Bank bookstore here
- 1:14:53Speaker 5: in Saint Louis, But.
- 1:14:56Speaker 3: Oh, when you go home to Jersey City, I have
- 1:14:59Speaker 3: to try the Left Bank bog a bah m hmm.
- 1:15:03Speaker 3: Mary Aleen, have you read Principles of Nature by Ethu Palma?
- 1:15:15Speaker 1: He did not, but I just know of him in general,
- 1:15:19Speaker 1: and he was so the issue with him is he.
- 1:15:22Speaker 5: Was more of like, ah, right, So Palmer was more
- 1:15:27Speaker 5: like a lot more on this more radical Enlightenment side,
- 1:15:32Speaker 5: And I just know that that's the side like if
- 1:15:35Speaker 5: I have like an error and I'm gonna be unobjective,
- 1:15:38Speaker 5: like it's gonna I'm gonna be too I'm gonna be
- 1:15:41Speaker 5: too much on that faction. So I like, I'm trying
- 1:15:43Speaker 5: to like correct by too.
- 1:15:47Speaker 1: Much in the other direction.
- 1:15:48Speaker 3: He was a radical Enlightenment essense of soul secular. She
- 1:15:51Speaker 3: says he thought religion was destructive to man. And then
- 1:15:54Speaker 3: man had unlimited capacity to make model and scientific improvements.
- 1:15:58Speaker 3: Was born in seventeen sixty four, Connecticut. Yeah, and this
- 1:16:02Speaker 3: whole idea of radical enlightenment, which Jonathan Israel uh writes
- 1:16:09Speaker 3: a lot about.
- 1:16:12Speaker 1: I don't have an opinion on his work, Like I
- 1:16:14Speaker 1: know it's that the.
- 1:16:17Speaker 5: The so there's gonna be issues of like which So
- 1:16:22Speaker 5: Jonathan Israel like places a lot of emphasis on Spinoza,
- 1:16:24Speaker 5: So I don't. I don't know enough to know how
- 1:16:26Speaker 5: much he's overemphasizing him.
- 1:16:28Speaker 1: Or or not. But like here's what I know for sure.
- 1:16:33Speaker 5: If you don't think that kind of thing that Merrilyn
- 1:16:36Speaker 5: just said in the text, where like you're capable of
- 1:16:39Speaker 5: improvements and all these different dimensions, like you wouldn't care
- 1:16:42Speaker 5: about freedom, Like it's not the sort of thing you
- 1:16:44Speaker 5: would care about, Like if you really thought that, like
- 1:16:47Speaker 5: all the great truths were known and like they were
- 1:16:50Speaker 5: discovered before and like that's it. Like that's not the
- 1:16:54Speaker 5: kind of person that like cares about building a new society.
- 1:16:57Speaker 5: Like that's just not who would do it.
- 1:16:59Speaker 1: It just doesn't fit.
- 1:17:02Speaker 3: Yep, all right, Jackson, thank you Jackson. Fifty dollars, he says,
- 1:17:10Speaker 3: grad school question follow up, I'm thirty two in a
- 1:17:13Speaker 3: lawyer for the last six years considering grad school. Any
- 1:17:17Speaker 3: advice to someone who has been out of school that
- 1:17:20Speaker 3: long realistic? Or should I consider other avenues? Interested in
- 1:17:24Speaker 3: history and international relations?
- 1:17:27Speaker 5: Those are not departments I'm in. But there's no what
- 1:17:31Speaker 5: was the did he say lost?
- 1:17:32Speaker 1: Cause it's certainly not a lost cause.
- 1:17:35Speaker 3: I forget he thinks he's too old because he's thirty two,
- 1:17:37Speaker 3: which makes you know, I don't know what it makes me.
- 1:17:40Speaker 5: I mean, the only thing I would think of is like,
- 1:17:43Speaker 5: do you would you be comfortable with the kind of
- 1:17:45Speaker 5: pay you'd be getting, because if you're like thirty two,
- 1:17:47Speaker 5: you might be used to like just a higher income.
- 1:17:49Speaker 5: But there's certainly there are people in their thirties in
- 1:17:52Speaker 5: grad school. There's there's a previous question about aimlessness. I mean,
- 1:17:59Speaker 5: what do you if you're in your thirties, you're probably
- 1:18:01Speaker 5: less likely to have that problem.
- 1:18:02Speaker 1: Yeah, like the twenty years, Well.
- 1:18:04Speaker 4: He's motivated to go, so he's not going to be aimless.
- 1:18:07Speaker 1: Like it's not.
- 1:18:09Speaker 5: I would not give up on it just because you
- 1:18:11Speaker 5: think you've like aged out, Like that's not worth doing it.
- 1:18:14Speaker 1: Like that's if you take your life seriously, don't do that.
- 1:18:18Speaker 3: Yeah, I agree, Bryan says, what is your take on
- 1:18:22Speaker 3: the nasty political split between Jefferson and Adams.
- 1:18:29Speaker 1: The So, I like.
- 1:18:34Speaker 5: My first iin ran Con uh, you know, I asked,
- 1:18:38Speaker 5: like I was talking with Greg so Omri and I
- 1:18:41Speaker 5: asked him, like why, like our objective is so fighty
- 1:18:44Speaker 5: with one another?
- 1:18:47Speaker 1: Like his poet was like, when you.
- 1:18:48Speaker 5: Like take ideas very seriously, this is the kind of content,
- 1:18:51Speaker 5: Like this is the kind of issue that you think,
- 1:18:54Speaker 5: and he used the example of the Founders like like this, yeah,
- 1:18:58Speaker 5: but like more concretely, why was it?
- 1:19:02Speaker 3: So?
- 1:19:02Speaker 5: I mean, there's just a very good book on this
- 1:19:04Speaker 5: and it's called Friends Divided, and it's like it just
- 1:19:08Speaker 5: goes through it by Gordon Wood's it goes through the
- 1:19:12Speaker 5: their relationship and like you do get like a real
- 1:19:15Speaker 5: colorful sense of who they were as people from that book.
- 1:19:19Speaker 5: And I think the real big thing, the first thing
- 1:19:21Speaker 5: really was the French Revolution and like Jefferson had too
- 1:19:26Speaker 5: much of.
- 1:19:26Speaker 1: Like a.
- 1:19:30Speaker 5: One of his issues was like I think he was
- 1:19:32Speaker 5: too much of a Democrat and in a real sense
- 1:19:34Speaker 5: he was too much of a.
- 1:19:34Speaker 4: Democrat like demica meaning democracy or.
- 1:19:39Speaker 5: Yeah, like compared to his other like way too much
- 1:19:44Speaker 5: like in ways that would make us uncomfortable. But the
- 1:19:47Speaker 5: and I think the reason is I think he was
- 1:19:48Speaker 5: way too like. I don't think he realized how much effort.
- 1:19:57Speaker 1: It actually takes to.
- 1:20:01Speaker 5: So in some sense he's he's like the more utopian one.
- 1:20:04Speaker 5: But I think he thinks these things happened too easily
- 1:20:07Speaker 5: and that people are like already basically good. They already
- 1:20:09Speaker 5: have like an innate sense that tells them what the
- 1:20:11Speaker 5: rights are, and so you can trust the people to
- 1:20:15Speaker 5: even like ideas he's floated around like electing judges, which
- 1:20:20Speaker 5: now would be terrible for us, like they and he
- 1:20:23Speaker 5: there's real issue of like what the world the judiciary
- 1:20:25Speaker 5: would be when he was president because he didn't like
- 1:20:29Speaker 5: the idea that the Supreme Court could be the last
- 1:20:31Speaker 5: kind of UH had the last say as the matters
- 1:20:36Speaker 5: of constitutional interpretability, and that was a big issue back then.
- 1:20:39Speaker 1: But if you think about like how that would have
- 1:20:41Speaker 1: turned out historically, like when FDR was and and now
- 1:20:46Speaker 1: like now, the Supreme Court might be the sort of
- 1:20:47Speaker 1: thing that like saves us from the issue you know,
- 1:20:50Speaker 1: issues with the Trump administration.
- 1:20:52Speaker 5: So Jefferson was more of a democrat he was, but
- 1:20:57Speaker 5: also for the same reasons, I think, just a lot
- 1:21:00Speaker 5: more interested in like thinking of America as like it
- 1:21:05Speaker 5: could be a radically new place, and that like Adams
- 1:21:10Speaker 5: and his real deep knowledge of history, like part of
- 1:21:13Speaker 5: that is like he's too much like, yeah, human beings
- 1:21:18Speaker 5: never change. It's the same kind of base, especially later
- 1:21:21Speaker 5: on when he gets a little bit more hardened and
- 1:21:25Speaker 5: a little cynical. There's that kind of like that foundational
- 1:21:29Speaker 5: like ideological split.
- 1:21:31Speaker 1: But then that gets turned into a political one too,
- 1:21:34Speaker 1: because they're just on opposite sides.
- 1:21:36Speaker 5: Of And Jefferson was like really worried about these what
- 1:21:41Speaker 5: he took to be people in the in the North
- 1:21:44Speaker 5: in particular, who wanted to bring back or really wanted
- 1:21:47Speaker 5: to establish an aristocracy. And he thought the Federalists were
- 1:21:50Speaker 5: like part of this giant plot to like turn America
- 1:21:54Speaker 5: into a state just like Europe, and that was a
- 1:21:58Speaker 5: big no no for him. And he thought Adams at
- 1:22:01Speaker 5: best was like a useful.
- 1:22:02Speaker 1: Idiot for them. This is this is when their relationship
- 1:22:05Speaker 1: was at the lowest.
- 1:22:06Speaker 5: Yeah, they he was being used by them, or that
- 1:22:09Speaker 5: he was complicit in it, whereas earlier in their lives
- 1:22:12Speaker 5: they had just a much more amicable, much closer relationship,
- 1:22:16Speaker 5: a relationship which they then reconcile later on in life
- 1:22:21Speaker 5: and they just it and always that's like really heartwarming.
- 1:22:25Speaker 5: If you read the book that I just recommended, there's
- 1:22:28Speaker 5: like a passage where like John Adams is just reminiscing
- 1:22:34Speaker 5: and he just goes like, but I love Thomas Jefferson,
- 1:22:37Speaker 5: Like there was a real like there. While he comes
- 1:22:41Speaker 5: off as like cynical and a bit like he was
- 1:22:44Speaker 5: like a real exuberant, loving person, Like there's a like
- 1:22:49Speaker 5: he liked to read romances. Wal Scott was one of
- 1:22:52Speaker 5: his faith Like that's a and his love letters with
- 1:22:55Speaker 5: Abigo just as on a side were like like just
- 1:22:58Speaker 5: great and awesome, and like the it's a very aspirational
- 1:23:03Speaker 5: relationship there. But that's the short answer, Like the.
- 1:23:06Speaker 1: There's a real.
- 1:23:09Speaker 5: Difference in kind of like temperament and basic ideology that
- 1:23:12Speaker 5: then gets even.
- 1:23:18Speaker 1: It just gets heightened and worse through political issues.
- 1:23:20Speaker 5: And then Adams turns a signs into law several.
- 1:23:28Speaker 1: Several pieces of law that.
- 1:23:30Speaker 5: The Alien and Sedition Acts, and then like Jefferson and
- 1:23:33Speaker 5: Madison basically say that those laws don't apply in the
- 1:23:39Speaker 5: respect in Virginia or Kentucky and like that's a big
- 1:23:42Speaker 5: constitutional crisis, and like it's you needed like George Washington
- 1:23:47Speaker 5: coming out of retirement and like begging Patrick Henry, who
- 1:23:51Speaker 5: was against the Constitution in general, to say, hey, could
- 1:23:55Speaker 5: you jump in here and calm things down, and like
- 1:23:57Speaker 5: Patrick Henry's like, yeah, look, guy, is I was not
- 1:24:01Speaker 5: for the Constitution, but god damn it, we signed it
- 1:24:03Speaker 5: and it turned out we adopted it and it turned
- 1:24:06Speaker 5: out to be much better than I thought, and so
- 1:24:07Speaker 5: we shouldn't give up on it now.
- 1:24:09Speaker 1: And there's like a real like there's something like the story.
- 1:24:15Speaker 5: Shows that there's an inelimitable element of like character in
- 1:24:21Speaker 5: why the country didn't break apart the way most new
- 1:24:24Speaker 5: countries do. Like there's like this kind of like they're ideas, yes,
- 1:24:29Speaker 5: and they're important, but they're also like people that are
- 1:24:37Speaker 5: willing to take certain stands and willing to like put
- 1:24:42Speaker 5: their character on the line, and like there's also just
- 1:24:46Speaker 5: a lot of respect for certain figures that that plays
- 1:24:49Speaker 5: a big role in keeping a country together. More so
- 1:24:52Speaker 5: than I that I would have thought just a priori
- 1:24:55Speaker 5: like this, because I would have thought it's just like
- 1:24:56Speaker 5: ideas and obviously it's ideas, but that.
- 1:24:59Speaker 4: There's somebody has to take them seriously.
- 1:25:02Speaker 5: Yeah, and you have to like respect them and you
- 1:25:04Speaker 5: have to like think they're good. And like you needed
- 1:25:06Speaker 5: like a Washington. You needed someone that was like this
- 1:25:09Speaker 5: person is honorable and like and also like he's like
- 1:25:14Speaker 5: dashing and kind of like.
- 1:25:18Speaker 4: Gent.
- 1:25:19Speaker 5: There's a that's inelimitable. Okay, you need you need people
- 1:25:22Speaker 5: like that. If you're trying to do something like this,
- 1:25:26Speaker 5: you need something someone like that.
- 1:25:29Speaker 4: All right?
- 1:25:30Speaker 3: Jackson asks, is it fair to say that a primary
- 1:25:34Speaker 3: difference between the French Revolution and the American Revolution is
- 1:25:37Speaker 3: emotional action without reason versus rational action?
- 1:25:41Speaker 4: Also weak institutions and.
- 1:25:43Speaker 3: Bad ideas, wanting the effect of the America without knowing
- 1:25:47Speaker 3: the cause.
- 1:25:48Speaker 5: I'm gonna rif so the I want to give the
- 1:25:53Speaker 5: French Revolution much more thought before I give a answer here,
- 1:25:57Speaker 5: And I don't think. I I think all I know
- 1:26:00Speaker 5: for sure is that it turned out worse on that.
- 1:26:04Speaker 5: But I don't know if I could isolate what the
- 1:26:07Speaker 5: root difference is. I mean, one thing to notice though,
- 1:26:10Speaker 5: is that, like the American Revolution is like a secession,
- 1:26:14Speaker 5: so it mattered that like it was bodies of government
- 1:26:19Speaker 5: that were like intact leaving as opposed to like you're
- 1:26:23Speaker 5: gonna disband the government and build something in its place,
- 1:26:27Speaker 5: Like at the very least, that ladder is much more difficult,
- 1:26:30Speaker 5: and like there are much more opportunity for things to
- 1:26:33Speaker 5: go bad in that than than than to go well.
- 1:26:37Speaker 5: So like that's my first approximation of like what I
- 1:26:41Speaker 5: think is going on. But I think I need to
- 1:26:43Speaker 5: look more into it, because the conservatives love to bring
- 1:26:46Speaker 5: it up.
- 1:26:46Speaker 1: It's the and it's just worth knowing on its own terms,
- 1:26:49Speaker 1: Like it's just worth getting the cause.
- 1:26:51Speaker 3: Yeah, I mean it From the little I've read, it
- 1:26:53Speaker 3: seems like, first of all, there were I mean, ifent
- 1:26:55Speaker 3: your revolution went through phases, and the original phase might
- 1:26:58Speaker 3: not have been that bad, it was probably mostly inspired
- 1:27:01Speaker 3: by good Enlightenment thinkers.
- 1:27:04Speaker 4: But the second phase was clearly USSO phase and inspired
- 1:27:09Speaker 4: by Rousseau.
- 1:27:09Speaker 3: And that's rubersphere and and and that's when they get
- 1:27:14Speaker 3: brutal and uh and bloody. But it is it needs
- 1:27:18Speaker 3: real examination to see the intellectual roots of of each
- 1:27:22Speaker 3: phase and who inspired whom and But but I don't
- 1:27:25Speaker 3: think it was I don't think I don't think it's
- 1:27:28Speaker 3: one inevitable sequence. I think there are many choices that
- 1:27:32Speaker 3: have happened that leaded in a particularly bloody, horrific direction.
- 1:27:37Speaker 5: Are in junctures of which certain things choices were made,
- 1:27:39Speaker 5: and like the that's important, it's it's the but yeah, yeah,
- 1:27:49Speaker 5: so it's important to know just to understand the causes
- 1:27:51Speaker 5: and just to understand the principles of what went on
- 1:27:55Speaker 5: the and just more practically, it is the thing that
- 1:28:01Speaker 5: gets brought up if you're talking about, well, I'm gonna
- 1:28:06Speaker 5: let's think about what the rights of human of man are,
- 1:28:09Speaker 5: like what that's that's associated with the kind of Jacobinism,
- 1:28:13Speaker 5: even though it's not, that's not really what the Jacobins
- 1:28:15Speaker 5: are about.
- 1:28:15Speaker 1: But that's.
- 1:28:18Speaker 5: Why the kind of endeavors that I was talking about,
- 1:28:21Speaker 5: Like why does his Oni think there aren't rely principles
- 1:28:24Speaker 5: for human government when there are for all these He's.
- 1:28:27Speaker 1: Like, well, look at this.
- 1:28:29Speaker 5: You need you do need to explain it, like somebody
- 1:28:31Speaker 5: needs to come in and say this is where it
- 1:28:33Speaker 5: went wrong, so why it was bad and what so
- 1:28:38Speaker 5: far that hasn't I don't think adequately like been done.
- 1:28:41Speaker 4: Yep, No, I think it's important. I agree.
- 1:28:45Speaker 3: Adam asks Muhammad, how did you find a pH d
- 1:28:48Speaker 3: advisor who is willing to take your idea seriously enough
- 1:28:51Speaker 3: to spend significant time working with you on your ideas.
- 1:28:54Speaker 1: I'm still in my second year and I'm trying to
- 1:28:56Speaker 1: do just that.
- 1:28:57Speaker 5: So that's the that's the big issue, right, Like they're
- 1:29:01Speaker 5: still part of it, is.
- 1:29:06Speaker 1: I mean so so part of it is I have
- 1:29:07Speaker 1: liked to.
- 1:29:10Speaker 5: So I can't go in and just do the thing
- 1:29:12Speaker 5: where I pick up the language and like choose something
- 1:29:15Speaker 5: like by pick up the language, I mean pick up
- 1:29:17Speaker 5: the current conceptualization of the issue. Like there's a there's
- 1:29:21Speaker 5: a kind of like an extra thing that I need
- 1:29:23Speaker 5: to do, which is like how do I integrate this
- 1:29:25Speaker 5: with how what I already know? And like that, And
- 1:29:28Speaker 5: so the process is a lot, like I think slower
- 1:29:30Speaker 5: if you're if you're trying to particularly if it's like
- 1:29:32Speaker 5: philosophy and you're trying to do a PhD in philosophy
- 1:29:34Speaker 5: and you're from a background and objectivism, Like there's a
- 1:29:37Speaker 5: lot of like the first thing you'll notice is the
- 1:29:42Speaker 5: issues are like carved out differently, and like that's the
- 1:29:45Speaker 5: first thing you notice, is like that, huh funny, Like
- 1:29:48Speaker 5: they think these two things go together, and I didn't
- 1:29:50Speaker 5: think like and I didn't even expect somebody to give
- 1:29:52Speaker 5: me that response to this question, Like there's a and
- 1:29:55Speaker 5: that's like really difficult in a learning curve. But my
- 1:29:58Speaker 5: view is that if I can do that well enough,
- 1:30:04Speaker 5: then I can find someone who uh at that point,
- 1:30:08Speaker 5: I can communicate what my ideas are, but like translation
- 1:30:12Speaker 5: and then like you know, I'm still working it out.
- 1:30:15Speaker 5: So it's not like I have a full answer there.
- 1:30:17Speaker 5: But a big part of it is like I'm trying
- 1:30:20Speaker 5: to learn why the people are.
- 1:30:22Speaker 1: Thinking the way that they do think.
- 1:30:23Speaker 5: And a big part of that is like historical for
- 1:30:26Speaker 5: what it's worth, because it's like who came up with
- 1:30:28Speaker 5: this and when? And but so far, like the the best,
- 1:30:33Speaker 5: the biggest influence I've had hasn't been like a PhD advisor.
- 1:30:36Speaker 5: It's been like Greg saw Mary so far. I think
- 1:30:39Speaker 5: it's partly because he had to do the same thing
- 1:30:40Speaker 5: when he was in grad school.
- 1:30:44Speaker 3: That's the big right, Bunny asks, respect for reason was
- 1:30:48Speaker 3: a huge fact. And the funding Father's thinking, have we
- 1:30:50Speaker 3: completely lost that?
- 1:30:55Speaker 1: That's that's not like your that sounds like a you question.
- 1:31:01Speaker 3: Well, certainly the political realm we seem to have lost it.
- 1:31:03Speaker 3: I mean I think there has to be some respect
- 1:31:05Speaker 3: for reasons still in the culture. Otherwise we wouldn't be
- 1:31:10Speaker 3: doing technologically and economically as well as we do. Somebody's
- 1:31:14Speaker 3: respecting reason out there. That's why we keep moving forward.
- 1:31:18Speaker 5: But also it's it's so disheartening when those people like
- 1:31:24Speaker 5: end up misconceptualizing what's going on, and so you end
- 1:31:27Speaker 5: up with like a Mark and Recent celebrating Trump's victory,
- 1:31:31Speaker 5: and it's like, and it's.
- 1:31:34Speaker 3: But that's Kurtis Jovin's I mean, Curtis Yovin is an
- 1:31:37Speaker 3: influential I don't know what you call him, a reactionary
- 1:31:43Speaker 3: in the heart of Silicon Valley who has managed to
- 1:31:47Speaker 3: market his ideas exceptionally well to that crowd. And it's like,
- 1:31:52Speaker 3: which is amazing to me, how that that's happened.
- 1:31:55Speaker 5: You're not even like this is so stupid, Like there's
- 1:31:57Speaker 5: there's so many different things where it's like we're dumpster diving.
- 1:32:02Speaker 5: There's the there's that Rand quote, which is the you know,
- 1:32:05Speaker 5: I'm for capitalism or separation of state in economics the
- 1:32:10Speaker 5: same way I'm for separation of church and state for
- 1:32:13Speaker 5: the same exact reasons. And like it sucks to that
- 1:32:16Speaker 5: like you, it's already difficult to argue for state and
- 1:32:21Speaker 5: economics to be separate, but now we have to like
- 1:32:23Speaker 5: re litigate some things that are like one already it's
- 1:32:26Speaker 5: like and so courtesy, like the church and state like
- 1:32:28Speaker 5: that you can't for some.
- 1:32:30Speaker 1: Wings, you just can't assume that anymore.
- 1:32:32Speaker 5: And for like now we're talking about monarchy again, like
- 1:32:34Speaker 5: what is this weird dumpster die, Like this is the
- 1:32:38Speaker 5: best we've got, Like this is like an intellectual that
- 1:32:40Speaker 5: we're supposed to take seriously.
- 1:32:42Speaker 1: And oh, he's got like new idea. If you watch
- 1:32:44Speaker 1: Curtis Jarvin, he like he he just.
- 1:32:48Speaker 5: Doesn't sound like he's that knowledgeable, like he he can
- 1:32:51Speaker 5: pick there's a kind of like purposefully obscure way of
- 1:32:55Speaker 5: framing things, like I don't think that's like a feature
- 1:32:58Speaker 5: of a clear, good mind. Like that is less bad
- 1:33:01Speaker 5: than Jordan Peterson, but there's it's so disgusting that they
- 1:33:04Speaker 5: have to like relitigate these kind of like things that
- 1:33:06Speaker 5: should have been long dead and buried now.
- 1:33:10Speaker 3: But this is what happens, I think when the intellectuals
- 1:33:13Speaker 3: are so bankrupt and have been for so long that
- 1:33:17Speaker 3: successful people are looking for everything's crap. When it comes
- 1:33:21Speaker 3: to politics and culture and they're just looking for something.
- 1:33:25Speaker 3: And yeah, these dumps, the divers, you know, come out
- 1:33:30Speaker 3: of nowhere.
- 1:33:31Speaker 4: They and they dominate because.
- 1:33:35Speaker 3: Clearly and the more outside of the mainstream. But hearkening
- 1:33:40Speaker 3: back to some past, it seems romantic. You are the
- 1:33:44Speaker 3: more acceptable, it seems to be because the current environment
- 1:33:48Speaker 3: is perceived to be so negative, so bad.
- 1:33:51Speaker 1: Yeah, I mean one of the things that I think is.
- 1:33:55Speaker 5: And objective is and you just get a sense of like, well,
- 1:33:57Speaker 5: how bad the philosophy departments are. But like the worst
- 1:34:01Speaker 5: thing about the philosophy departments I've been in is that
- 1:34:04Speaker 5: like they're just on They're like less interesting the you know,
- 1:34:11Speaker 5: however badly.
- 1:34:11Speaker 4: Yeah, what answers, I mean cuts you. Ovin has at
- 1:34:14Speaker 4: least something to say.
- 1:34:15Speaker 3: What would professor, a philosophy professor at a standard university
- 1:34:19Speaker 3: you have to say about the state of the culture
- 1:34:21Speaker 3: and the way we should go.
- 1:34:23Speaker 5: It would be like Ralls, But that's already like fifty
- 1:34:26Speaker 5: fifty years.
- 1:34:27Speaker 3: It's like the and probably not even as clear. And
- 1:34:30Speaker 3: as you know, Walls is not clear. But you know,
- 1:34:34Speaker 3: since then, they've just convoluted it made it more even
- 1:34:37Speaker 3: convoluted and you're not going to convince an indrease.
- 1:34:40Speaker 4: Of egalitarianism, right, So that's out.
- 1:34:43Speaker 3: So it has to be something that has the semblance
- 1:34:47Speaker 3: of merit and monarchy, particularly the way Curtis you Ovin
- 1:34:51Speaker 3: talks about it. You know, a merit based monarchy. It's weird, right,
- 1:34:56Speaker 3: And the CEO of Apple is and is a king.
- 1:34:59Speaker 4: Did you know that?
- 1:35:00Speaker 1: Uh?
- 1:35:01Speaker 3: You know he twists it in ways that superficially appeal
- 1:35:05Speaker 3: to these guys.
- 1:35:06Speaker 1: A dictator like this is what I don't like.
- 1:35:08Speaker 5: There's a lot of this bullshit like the a monarch
- 1:35:14Speaker 5: a ceo, but like a dictator like this, that's what
- 1:35:18Speaker 5: you want.
- 1:35:19Speaker 1: It's it's kind of the same thing with like a
- 1:35:21Speaker 1: I mean this is better.
- 1:35:22Speaker 5: But the critique of like the woke right, like calling
- 1:35:27Speaker 5: them the woke right, like it's such a small like
- 1:35:30Speaker 5: why are we.
- 1:35:30Speaker 1: Reinventing the wheel here?
- 1:35:31Speaker 5: Like that they're like racists and theocrats, and like, like
- 1:35:36Speaker 5: I get that, You're part of what you want to
- 1:35:37Speaker 5: do is you want to like say that they're like
- 1:35:39Speaker 5: the woke in that they are racists, but it's also
- 1:35:41Speaker 5: like small minded, like you're trying to appeal to people
- 1:35:43Speaker 5: that their paradigm of badness is just woke and so
- 1:35:47Speaker 5: you they don't have any broader abstraction than that, and.
- 1:35:49Speaker 1: So you're just trying to like recycle it.
- 1:35:52Speaker 3: Well, it's just it's the same people who call every
- 1:35:55Speaker 3: leftist they know Amoxist, right, because they left. There's only
- 1:35:59Speaker 3: one type of left and that's Marx.
- 1:36:01Speaker 4: He's bad.
- 1:36:02Speaker 3: So every other woe has to be Marxist, even though
- 1:36:05Speaker 3: woken Marxism are not related directly. Certainly you have to
- 1:36:09Speaker 3: call the neo Marxist so cultural Marxist or something, because
- 1:36:13Speaker 3: the anything they can relate.
- 1:36:14Speaker 5: To, there's like and there's the deeper sense in which
- 1:36:18Speaker 5: they're the same, Like they they effectively like carve people
- 1:36:23Speaker 5: out into these like groups that can only win.
- 1:36:27Speaker 3: But that's unique to marx That's that's you know, like
- 1:36:29Speaker 3: respect hundreds of years.
- 1:36:31Speaker 5: People see themselves as they saw themselves like anti Marxists,
- 1:36:34Speaker 5: and the Marxians don't like them. Like the a lot
- 1:36:37Speaker 5: of the right is just not very right.
- 1:36:41Speaker 1: The there's.
- 1:36:44Speaker 5: Yeah, I mean there there's the Richard Hanania point about them,
- 1:36:47Speaker 5: just less. I don't like the kind of focus on
- 1:36:51Speaker 5: i Q and intelligence and the way that he does
- 1:36:54Speaker 5: it because I think it like it's one thing to
- 1:36:57Speaker 5: have a culture. Like one thing that you like about
- 1:36:59Speaker 5: the founders that yeah, they don't. They definitely don't think
- 1:37:02Speaker 5: that like everyone's equally intelligent, Like that's.
- 1:37:04Speaker 1: Never a view that they've had.
- 1:37:06Speaker 5: But what the view that they did have was that
- 1:37:07Speaker 5: you can expect people to value intelligence.
- 1:37:10Speaker 1: Yep, that's different, like and it.
- 1:37:14Speaker 5: Doesn't follow that like if you think most people you
- 1:37:16Speaker 5: know are below a certain level of intelligence that like
- 1:37:19Speaker 5: you don't, you can't expect them to value intelligence the
- 1:37:22Speaker 5: way the Senate was supposed to work, Like you're supposed
- 1:37:24Speaker 5: to like vote for a legislator a state legislature who
- 1:37:29Speaker 5: you think is outstanding in your community, and then those
- 1:37:33Speaker 5: people pick someone and like by each person being trust
- 1:37:37Speaker 5: and trusted to like choose someone that's intelligent and virtuously
- 1:37:40Speaker 5: you end up with better people at the top. And
- 1:37:42Speaker 5: that didn't really work out, but like the it kind
- 1:37:46Speaker 5: of showed that, like they had an expectation that people
- 1:37:48Speaker 5: could value intelligence, even if overwhelmingly you know, not everyone
- 1:37:53Speaker 5: is an Einstein or whatever.
- 1:37:54Speaker 1: But more than that, they care about virtue actually for
- 1:37:57Speaker 1: what it's worth.
- 1:37:57Speaker 5: But the yeah, yeah, there's there's all these.
- 1:38:06Speaker 3: Well I don't think Kanani views the you know, the
- 1:38:11Speaker 3: right is lack of intelligence, is genetic. I think he've
- 1:38:15Speaker 3: used the I think he've used the dumb people have
- 1:38:19Speaker 3: gravitated to the right because the right is so anti intellectual.
- 1:38:24Speaker 3: But he is ambiguse about it because he comes, you know,
- 1:38:27Speaker 3: he was a racist, so he's somehow attracted to these ideas.
- 1:38:32Speaker 4: And one or another and worries.
- 1:38:35Speaker 1: I'm a little dubious there too, like the.
- 1:38:38Speaker 3: Yeah, I don't think he quite realizes how bad it
- 1:38:40Speaker 3: was to be a racist. He kind of makes fun
- 1:38:43Speaker 3: of himself, but he doesn't really acknowledge the evil that's involved.
- 1:38:49Speaker 5: Yeah, I mean in so far as like that kind
- 1:38:51Speaker 5: of view is coloring the elite human capital.
- 1:38:54Speaker 3: Yes, but I like that he applies it to the
- 1:38:57Speaker 3: right because I think in essense he's right.
- 1:38:59Speaker 4: Right, they're not they're not smart.
- 1:39:02Speaker 1: And and one thing about them like being less sophisticated.
- 1:39:05Speaker 5: Like if you if you look at like left wing conspiracies,
- 1:39:08Speaker 5: like they're like systems, they're like, you know, it's really
- 1:39:13Speaker 5: complicated and abstract, like in a way that's like bullshit
- 1:39:17Speaker 5: and religious, Like it's almost like.
- 1:39:18Speaker 1: You can't escape it. It's like a force in the universe.
- 1:39:21Speaker 5: It's like gravity, like you like for the right whenever
- 1:39:24Speaker 5: something bad happens, it's it's like a particular person.
- 1:39:27Speaker 3: It's like it's the Jews controlling those ladies beams.
- 1:39:31Speaker 1: Sometimes it's often times the Jews.
- 1:39:33Speaker 5: But like that, like they can't think that, like bad
- 1:39:36Speaker 5: things can happen struck like because of like incentives or
- 1:39:40Speaker 5: stru like it's no like who set La on fire?
- 1:39:43Speaker 3: Like it has to be a concrete Yeah, Jackson again,
- 1:39:47Speaker 3: thank you Jackson.
- 1:39:49Speaker 4: Uh, it's what is it?
- 1:39:50Speaker 3: What is a good reference for understanding Enlightenment is a
- 1:39:54Speaker 3: cause in history? It seems like a traditional view is
- 1:39:56Speaker 3: glorious evolution to Victorian. But I I think the event
- 1:40:00Speaker 3: that best civilizes as death is World War One.
- 1:40:06Speaker 5: For the Enlightenment, I mean people generally think it ended
- 1:40:08Speaker 5: well before World War One. The thing that people tend
- 1:40:12Speaker 5: to think of is ending in World War One. And
- 1:40:14Speaker 5: this is like given our shared context, like Ran talks
- 1:40:18Speaker 5: about this, but like other people have too. That's the
- 1:40:22Speaker 5: the la bellypoc or the beautiful age that's well after.
- 1:40:29Speaker 3: Just a sense of lightful the Enlightenment. But the intellectual
- 1:40:34Speaker 3: aspect of the Enlightenment is long gone.
- 1:40:36Speaker 5: But even like yeah, but even if you weren't like you,
- 1:40:41Speaker 5: like there's the era of Romanticism, which is seen as
- 1:40:43Speaker 5: like just and by the people who are to spit
- 1:40:46Speaker 5: in it.
- 1:40:46Speaker 1: It's just like very very anti.
- 1:40:48Speaker 5: The Enlightenment, and partly for good reasons and partly for
- 1:40:53Speaker 5: like bad reasons. Like if you look at like early
- 1:40:54Speaker 5: American art, it was all this like neo classical, super
- 1:41:01Speaker 5: moralistic like pedagogy, like it was all the kind of
- 1:41:08Speaker 5: things that like objectives and the things was bad art
- 1:41:11Speaker 5: and like but that's for a lot of people, the
- 1:41:14Speaker 5: way they can septualize it, like that's part.
- 1:41:16Speaker 1: Of being free, like this is this is what again,
- 1:41:19Speaker 1: it's like a kind of naivety or like just they're
- 1:41:25Speaker 1: still figuring this stuff out.
- 1:41:26Speaker 5: And the way that they thought art would work is
- 1:41:29Speaker 5: it would just like make you a better person, and
- 1:41:32Speaker 5: we you need to cultivate certain virtues in order to
- 1:41:34Speaker 5: be free, and so like the purpose of art should
- 1:41:36Speaker 5: be to teach you to be a good citizen. And
- 1:41:38Speaker 5: you ended up with these like very boring ish morality
- 1:41:44Speaker 5: tales that people often read because they were about sex
- 1:41:47Speaker 5: and like that's what.
- 1:41:48Speaker 1: They liked about it. But that was rebelled against in
- 1:41:52Speaker 1: this kind of like Romantic era that came later in
- 1:41:54Speaker 1: America but earlier in Europe, and that like you pick
- 1:41:59Speaker 1: you standard of you is that that's while like the
- 1:42:02Speaker 1: Enlightenment's done by then, like by the time you that.
- 1:42:05Speaker 3: Seems the Enlightenment is done in the French Revolution? And
- 1:42:08Speaker 3: when when would you say? It's thoughts, I don't know.
- 1:42:12Speaker 1: The periodization is difficult.
- 1:42:14Speaker 5: So here's an issue like that that you need, like
- 1:42:18Speaker 5: a philosopher to work with the historians to figure out,
- 1:42:21Speaker 5: like how do you be objective about periodization?
- 1:42:24Speaker 1: Like you want to pick a period, you want to
- 1:42:26Speaker 1: say like this.
- 1:42:27Speaker 5: Is these are like the bounds that I'm interested in,
- 1:42:32Speaker 5: Like how do you make that choice objectively? And I like,
- 1:42:35Speaker 5: there's going to be considerations I think that depend on
- 1:42:38Speaker 5: your purpose, but I haven't. This is one of the
- 1:42:42Speaker 5: things that I think I, as a philosopher interested in
- 1:42:46Speaker 5: like historical method have to think more about. It's like
- 1:42:49Speaker 5: thinking about how do you like come up with beginning
- 1:42:55Speaker 5: end dates in a way that's objective, not to say
- 1:42:56Speaker 5: if there's one for each one, but like, uh, there's
- 1:42:59Speaker 5: many clause ones, but how do you like do that
- 1:43:03Speaker 5: in a way that's thoughtful?
- 1:43:06Speaker 1: And interests.
- 1:43:10Speaker 3: Yeah, I mean generally I think it's the eighteenth century,
- 1:43:13Speaker 3: but it's like.
- 1:43:15Speaker 5: When in the eighteenth century, Like is it so like
- 1:43:17Speaker 5: some people might think it's Newton's Principia.
- 1:43:19Speaker 3: Like Newton's Penticipia, and it's lock Second Treaties. It's somewhere
- 1:43:23Speaker 3: around there in the seventeenth century. Then at the end
- 1:43:27Speaker 3: of the seventeenth century, and then you know it runs
- 1:43:30Speaker 3: through the Revolution probably, but exactly when hot, Yeah, I
- 1:43:36Speaker 3: mean it.
- 1:43:37Speaker 1: Yeah, it's funny answers, Like these things like fade into.
- 1:43:41Speaker 4: Each other, right, but they have to. Yeah, that's why.
- 1:43:44Speaker 5: Any good account of things is going to like yeah,
- 1:43:48Speaker 5: and acknowledge that there are different ways to doing it
- 1:43:51Speaker 5: and like tell you a little bit about things that
- 1:43:54Speaker 5: were squarely outside of the period in order to like
- 1:43:56Speaker 5: help set the context.
- 1:43:58Speaker 3: Yeah, and it's Jonathan Israel would probably date it earlier
- 1:44:00Speaker 3: because he would he viewed Spinoza as the as the
- 1:44:03Speaker 3: guy kicks it all off, so he would date it
- 1:44:05Speaker 3: back to Spinoza.
- 1:44:06Speaker 4: So it really depends on.
- 1:44:08Speaker 3: How you do who you decide are the key figures
- 1:44:11Speaker 3: within the within the movement, and what istorical events actually
- 1:44:14Speaker 3: affected by it. But that's where there's a lot of
- 1:44:18Speaker 3: work to be done in history. It's it's it's interesting,
- 1:44:22Speaker 3: all right, Islam, A Lee asks relative my brother, Yeah,
- 1:44:27Speaker 3: what evidence is the right used to claim America is
- 1:44:29Speaker 3: founded on Christian values?
- 1:44:31Speaker 1: You should read my article.
- 1:44:33Speaker 4: But that's you should be Islam. What's up?
- 1:44:36Speaker 1: Definitely did but the.
- 1:44:39Speaker 5: A So, there have been like several things in this area.
- 1:44:47Speaker 5: So one that I've recently come up or come into
- 1:44:50Speaker 5: contact with is.
- 1:44:53Speaker 1: This idea by.
- 1:44:55Speaker 5: I don't know if it's by him, but it's at
- 1:44:57Speaker 5: least promoted by like Donald Lutz.
- 1:44:59Speaker 1: And it's the.
- 1:45:00Speaker 5: Idea that like the way that a lot of these uh,
- 1:45:05Speaker 5: a lot of the people from the colonial era and
- 1:45:06Speaker 5: the founder's era thought about what they were doing was
- 1:45:09Speaker 5: like framed and shaped by Biblical covenants, by the view
- 1:45:13Speaker 5: that like you're making a covenant with God, and so
- 1:45:17Speaker 5: like that kind of like compact is what you're that's
- 1:45:22Speaker 5: that's giving you a kind of like frame of reference
- 1:45:25Speaker 5: for how you do things like set up society. So
- 1:45:28Speaker 5: like a society with other people is the same thing
- 1:45:30Speaker 5: as a kind of covenant. Like that reeks to me
- 1:45:33Speaker 5: too much like the kind of Tory history I was
- 1:45:35Speaker 5: talking about, where like there are way too many differences
- 1:45:41Speaker 5: and way too many more plausible explanations for like how
- 1:45:44Speaker 5: you think of how they ended up thinking about their
- 1:45:46Speaker 5: society that had more to do with social contract theory
- 1:45:48Speaker 5: and like those ideas like the the the So that's
- 1:45:54Speaker 5: one thing like you that they think of. The bands
- 1:45:58Speaker 5: uh together is somehow alluding to this tradition of like
- 1:46:04Speaker 5: covenant with God, even though it's not a covenant with God,
- 1:46:07Speaker 5: it's like a social compact with other human beings. But
- 1:46:10Speaker 5: supposedly if that's like it's developmental origins, then like then
- 1:46:14Speaker 5: you've done it. But there's a difference between like the
- 1:46:17Speaker 5: orig the developmental origins of something and like what I
- 1:46:23Speaker 5: would put as like it's essence, like what's actually important
- 1:46:26Speaker 5: about it? Then there are like other issues of like
- 1:46:29Speaker 5: they definitely thought that you needed, like their conception of
- 1:46:34Speaker 5: morality was just shaped by Christianity.
- 1:46:36Speaker 1: And as any like.
- 1:46:39Speaker 5: As as would be expected, like and even the more
- 1:46:42Speaker 5: anti clerical ones. Yeah, like obviously they thought that like
- 1:46:47Speaker 5: some kind of sacrifice is good. Like it's not as
- 1:46:49Speaker 5: much as they they might want to do, but the
- 1:46:53Speaker 5: conservatives won't want to say, but there is, and that
- 1:46:57Speaker 5: is something that they verbalize and they say like they
- 1:47:01Speaker 5: expect like sometimes they'll say things like they want like
- 1:47:03Speaker 5: a pious people. But depending on which ones talking, like
- 1:47:07Speaker 5: that's something more of an Atoms would say than unless
- 1:47:09Speaker 5: than a Jefferson. But the it's it tends to come
- 1:47:13Speaker 5: in I think when they talk about the kind of
- 1:47:17Speaker 5: moral quality that the founders expected a successful and a
- 1:47:23Speaker 5: free people to have and like, because their morality was
- 1:47:26Speaker 5: like shape by Christianity, you're gonna end up with a
- 1:47:28Speaker 5: lot of like actual.
- 1:47:32Speaker 1: It's it's non accidentally related to Christianity. It's ye, right,
- 1:47:36Speaker 1: So there there's that point there.
- 1:47:38Speaker 5: But the question is, like, if they had that but
- 1:47:42Speaker 5: didn't have this idea of like and just that they
- 1:47:44Speaker 5: didn't have this idea of like, you could make the
- 1:47:46Speaker 5: world a lot better. You could learn more. You could
- 1:47:48Speaker 5: learn more than our ancestors ever knew. We could build
- 1:47:50Speaker 5: things they could never imagine. We could be much happier
- 1:47:52Speaker 5: than they ever were. Like that, if you didn't have that,
- 1:47:55Speaker 5: you would never build the United States of America. That
- 1:47:58Speaker 5: would just not have happened.
- 1:47:59Speaker 3: Yep, cook says sagon Avakad read The Ominous Plows but
- 1:48:06Speaker 3: ended up getting inspired by the bad guys. Yeah, it
- 1:48:11Speaker 3: is interesting. Let's see, Justin said Muhammad, what is your
- 1:48:16Speaker 3: assessment of Trump's first forty days.
- 1:48:27Speaker 5: I think he thinks he can get away with a
- 1:48:29Speaker 5: lot more than he or than he thought in his
- 1:48:34Speaker 5: first term. But I don't know, Like the the big
- 1:48:40Speaker 5: thing for about Trump for me, and like it's almost
- 1:48:44Speaker 5: like my clock stopped at that point was January sixth,
- 1:48:48Speaker 5: and like I think that's the thing about him, that's
- 1:48:51Speaker 5: the most important thing ever And I don't really care
- 1:48:54Speaker 5: that much about It's not so that he can't do anything.
- 1:48:57Speaker 1: Worse than that, but like American.
- 1:49:01Speaker 5: History should, there's a pre January sixth, I mean, there's
- 1:49:04Speaker 5: a post January sixth. Like before, like on January fifth
- 1:49:07Speaker 5: of that year, we were a country that didn't have
- 1:49:10Speaker 5: this kind of trouble with passing down political power. Now
- 1:49:15Speaker 5: we are, like we're at least blemished in that one respect.
- 1:49:18Speaker 5: We were blemished in other respects, but now we're blemished
- 1:49:21Speaker 5: in this whole new way, and like that undermines the
- 1:49:24Speaker 5: fabric of the country in a way that like nothing
- 1:49:27Speaker 5: that he's done so far in the past forty days
- 1:49:29Speaker 5: has come close to He'll try, probably, he'll try, but
- 1:49:35Speaker 5: like the I don't like this kind of like, well
- 1:49:38Speaker 5: what did he do this week?
- 1:49:39Speaker 1: And like the.
- 1:49:43Speaker 5: The main thing about him is he's someone who's trying
- 1:49:45Speaker 5: to who try to whip up an angry mob to
- 1:49:51Speaker 5: desecrate the sort of institution that like people like him
- 1:49:55Speaker 5: could have never built.
- 1:49:59Speaker 3: Yep, all right, Justin says Hannania is a race realist
- 1:50:04Speaker 3: as far as I know, he just doesn't think it
- 1:50:06Speaker 3: matters from a public policy perspective anymore.
- 1:50:10Speaker 4: That is possible. All right, this has been fun.
- 1:50:15Speaker 1: Thank you for having me on shore.
- 1:50:17Speaker 4: My pleasure. Thanks for being on. Thanks.
- 1:50:19Speaker 3: Muhammad oh Ian has a question, He says, no question,
- 1:50:22Speaker 3: just praise for the January sixth answer. So Ian throo
- 1:50:27Speaker 3: in twenty dollars invest the twenty dollars for the answer,
- 1:50:31Speaker 3: So thank you. All right, this was great. Looking forward
- 1:50:36Speaker 3: to seeing how the substack develops. You guys should check
- 1:50:40Speaker 3: it out. Society societ tell Dynamics dot subseack dot com.
- 1:50:48Speaker 5: Social dynamics would have sounded too much like I'm giving
- 1:50:50Speaker 5: like dating advice like that would be societal is like.
- 1:50:53Speaker 4: You would have gotten more people have signed up.
- 1:50:55Speaker 1: Though it's true I would have gotten more people out.
- 1:50:57Speaker 4: The societal dynamics, that's dot com.
- 1:51:02Speaker 3: Go subscribe to the substack, support what Muhammad is doing,
- 1:51:07Speaker 3: and I definitely recommend reading White trad History is Bad
- 1:51:11Speaker 3: History Part one and part two and look forward to.
- 1:51:14Speaker 4: Reading more on the substack. Thanks Mohammed, thank.
- 1:51:18Speaker 3: You, bye bye bye everybody, and thanks to all the superchatters.
- 1:51:22Speaker 4: You guys were great.