Latest / Saigalseatrade Podcast / Weekly Tanker Overview Week 35 of 2025
Transcript
- 0:11Welcome back to the Segal Sea Trade Podcast.
- 0:14I'm research analyst Trisha, and I'll be your host for today's
- 0:17episode. And with me today, we have our
- 0:20resident shipping expert, Mr. Sandesh Ghannat.
- 0:22So welcome back to the episode Sandesh.
- 0:25Thanks Trisha. Thanks for welcoming me once
- 0:27again. We have a lot to discuss today.
- 0:29So Sandesh, let's kick off with the big guns that is the VLCCS.
- 0:34From the Middle East Gulf to West Africa and to the US Gulf,
- 0:38it seems like each basin, it's telling its own story, you know,
- 0:43from owners that are disciplined but charters that are also
- 0:46cautious. And there are rates as well that
- 0:49are holding but somewhere without a dramatic spike.
- 0:52So Sandesh, could you walk us through what's really happening
- 0:55in the VLCC market right now? Well, Trisha, the VLCC market
- 1:00right now, you know, it's a classic case of steady but
- 1:03cautious momentum. You know, it is a market that
- 1:06wants to push higher, but it's constantly checking itself.
- 1:10Let's start with the Middle East Gulf first.
- 1:12At the beginning of the last week, we saw kind of a real
- 1:15strength because fixing activity was steady and what really
- 1:19supported owners was, you know, the short haul demand.
- 1:23So those regional runs into India or East Africa that help
- 1:26to soak up the prompt and it quickly.
- 1:28We have a benchmark route, TD2 and TD3C where you know, rates
- 1:32kind of a pushed higher and not dramatically, but enough to give
- 1:36owners of confidence. Now midweek is where things got
- 1:39kind of interesting because the charters, they kind of slowed
- 1:43down. And that's why always a tactic
- 1:45when they feel owners are pushing too hard, they pull
- 1:48back, let a few ships accumulate on the list and see if that
- 1:52softens the sentiment. But here is the key.
- 1:55We have a vessel supply that stayed tight and enough that
- 1:59rates didn't sleep and owners kind of a shoulder discipline.
- 2:03So they weren't, you know, rushing to fix at a lower levels
- 2:07and that created this Talmet kind of a market holding firm,
- 2:11not shooting up and not collapsing either.
- 2:14If we swing West to the West Africa, the story is slightly
- 2:18different but connected because fixing volumes were lower last
- 2:21week and let's be honest, not much fresh activity either.
- 2:25But the demand that was there specifically to the West Coast
- 2:29of India and you know to the Far East was enough to provide a
- 2:32flow. We have a benchmark TD15.
- 2:35It held a steady and you may ask why because the tonnage list was
- 2:39relatively very tight and owners didn't have to panic plus a
- 2:43cross basin support it kind of a help relatively the Middle East
- 2:49Gulf was holding, the US Gulf was forming and that sentiment
- 2:53carries over even if you are basin is quiet, if you are
- 2:56neighboring basins are strong, you don't want to give the
- 2:59ground you know too easily. And then of course the US Gulf,
- 3:03this is where VLCCS rallies found their footing here also we
- 3:07have seen the TD 22 benchmark US Gulf to China.
- 3:10It formed as you know, the Asian refiners, they kind of came in
- 3:14for a coverage and early fixtures set higher levels and
- 3:17that give owners the confidence to test upwards sentiments was
- 3:22kind of a positive because, you know, the cargo flows was
- 3:24healthy, though it's not booming, but you know, steady
- 3:27enough to keep the list tight. Forward tenders, they added more
- 3:31weight and modern tonnage was able to command the premiums.
- 3:35So by the week's end, you could feel it, the US Gulf market had
- 3:39closed on an owners favored footing.
- 3:42If we have a TD 22, another bench market reflected the gains
- 3:45and the outlook was skewed towards more upside if the pace
- 3:49continued. Now why does this matter you
- 3:51have asked? So VLCC are kind of a
- 3:53bellwether. They are the barometer for the
- 3:56entire dirty tanker market. So if VLCC holds steady as they
- 4:00did last week, Suez Maxes and AFRA Maxes tend to stay in the
- 4:05balance. So if VLCC surge, they pull the
- 4:07smaller classes with them. Conversely, if VLCC falter, you
- 4:11often see a ripple of weakness. So if I have to compare and if I
- 4:15have to step back, think about the, you know, fourth quarter of
- 4:202023 or even the post COVID rebound in 2020 here.
- 4:24You know, when we see the VLCC rates, they spiked more than
- 4:28$100,000 a day and that was a pure supply shock.
- 4:31And you know, it's an alignment of stars that you know, send
- 4:35owners to the moon. So today, today's market isn't
- 4:38like that. And today's market is kind of a
- 4:41more disciplined, more majored and owners aren't chasing heavy
- 4:45fixtures and even the charters, they aren't rushing the cargoes
- 4:49either. So I think it's a poker game.
- 4:51And right now, both sides are waiting for the other to the
- 4:54blink. All right, Sandesh, now let's
- 4:57narrow the lenses a bit. And by that I mean let's also
- 5:01have a look at Suez Maxis. So they are often the swing
- 5:05players between the VLCCS and Afrimaxis.
- 5:08You know, for example, last week we saw firmness in the Meg, then
- 5:11we saw mixed picture in West Africa and we also saw cross
- 5:15basin demand from CPC and Brazil, which was playing a key
- 5:19role. So according to you, Sandesh,
- 5:21what would you say you know would be the read on the Suezmax
- 5:24story right now? Well, the Swazmax market is
- 5:28always a fascinating because it sits right in between too small
- 5:32for the big crude flows but too big for the purely regional
- 5:34trade. So it becomes this swing player
- 5:37adjusting to whatever gaps VLCCS and Apramaxis live open.
- 5:41So in the Middle East Gulf last week the tone was firm, but it
- 5:46was kind of early in the week September programs or the
- 5:50September stems were active and Indian demand which is you know
- 5:53usually strong driver for the Swiss access was kind of a
- 5:56supportive. Then we have seen the prompt
- 5:58tennage. It was a tight and owners they
- 6:01naturally pushed for higher rate specifically on the westbound
- 6:05routes and for a while they got it eastbound, however, started
- 6:10to wobble midweek. As you know, the fresh inquiries
- 6:13kind of a slowed and charters weren't chasing the ship.
- 6:17So sentiments then soften and by the weak sand, the region was
- 6:20more balanced, not weak, not bullies, just a steady one.
- 6:24And then coming back to the West Africa market, it told a
- 6:27slightly different story because you know, the early in the week
- 6:30things kind of a look good and there was a Titanic list plus
- 6:35competition from the CPC Brazil that you have mentioned and even
- 6:38some pull from the US Gulf all gave Swiss Max owners kind of a
- 6:43leverage. But at targos thin out when the
- 6:46week started progressing ahead, statement turned cautious and
- 6:50charters then pulled back and you know, testing just how much
- 6:53owners willing to hold the owners advantage was moderated.
- 6:57Still, the fundamental didn't collapse because the cross basin
- 7:01activity kept the floor intact. And you know, that's why I would
- 7:04describe the web market as a sideways with, you know, a very
- 7:08slight lean to the softer side if the inquiry doesn't return
- 7:12soon. So what's important here is the
- 7:14economics of choice and economics of scale because
- 7:18charters, they look at Swiss Max versus Opera Max or VLCS.
- 7:22So sometime it's purely about cost per ton, sometime it's
- 7:25about timing and availability. And you know, that kind of
- 7:28interplace, you know, kind of a decides whether the Swiss Max
- 7:31catch a premium or, you know, it may get squeezed.
- 7:35So for example, on the benchmark TD 20, the VAF UKC, you can
- 7:40track how quickly Swiss Max react to the VLC CC changes.
- 7:43So if VLCC are tight, Swiss Maxes suddenly looks attractive
- 7:47and if opera maxes are from charters may upsize to Swiss Max
- 7:51for efficiency. So it's it's you know, the
- 7:53constant push and pull in the moment and that, you know,
- 7:57drives the owners momentum. Historically speaking, Swiss Max
- 8:01can be explosive because think of the volatility we saw in the
- 8:042022, you know, when the Black Sea disruptions are spiked the
- 8:08demand. But today the volatility kind of
- 8:11feels muted and owners are still holding the cards.
- 8:15But charters aren't overexposed. And you know, that's the balance
- 8:18is what gives this market in a steady headband rather than
- 8:21swinging wildly. Well, Sandesh, now that we've
- 8:24talked about VLCC and Suez Maxis, let's also have a look at
- 8:28Afromaxis. You know, they are the
- 8:30workhouses especially for the shorter haul crude and we saw
- 8:34that the Meg, it saw some tightening.
- 8:37Then on the other side, Southeast Asia also spiked on
- 8:40full oil stems. When we also saw TD 14, it
- 8:43jumped to almost world scale 112.
- 8:46So Sandesh, there's a lot happening here.
- 8:48So how would you say are the AFRAMAC dynamics playing out and
- 8:52you know, especially given the tug of war with the Suezmaxis?
- 8:55Well, you know to Trisha, the Aframaxis are always interesting
- 8:59because you know they are the workhorses like you said,
- 9:02because they're mainly driven by the utility players, because
- 9:06they drive on the short haul. Crude specifically other other
- 9:10than crude is fuel oil and regional arbitrage.
- 9:13And last week we saw two very different Afromax stories.
- 9:17So first in the Middle East Gulf sentiments improved gradually
- 9:22because here TDA benchmark it formed and you know, we have to
- 9:26thank to the title list and then Asian activity absorbed some
- 9:30tonnage, but it wasn't, you know, a kind of a flood of
- 9:33demand. So owners felt more balanced,
- 9:36which gave them a cautious optimism.
- 9:38But you know, let's be clear here.
- 9:40You know the charter they still prefer so as maxes when the
- 9:44economics work because you know, a bigger ship often means lower
- 9:49cost per ton. So AFRA Max upside was you know
- 9:52indirectly capped and that said Aframaxis got some indirect
- 9:57support from the strength of the VLCCS and you know the the
- 10:00elevator ceiling on Australia's Maxis.
- 10:02Now the second thing or the second story is from the
- 10:06Southeast Asia where you know market was more dynamic.
- 10:09So the last week started on a balance note with you know the
- 10:12modest Indonesia, Australia coverage.
- 10:14And when we started moving around midweek we saw demand it
- 10:20cooled slightly and then also least didn't really clear.
- 10:24But then the rally come because we have seen a flurry of second
- 10:28decade stems for the next month and specifically the fuel oil
- 10:32cargos, they kind of hit the market and you know the relative
- 10:36impact was that suddenly TD 14 benchmark it jumped to world
- 10:40scale 112 like you have mentioned.
- 10:42So the rally was you know, kind of underpinned by the short term
- 10:46tennis scarcity and I will say that very targeted demand
- 10:50because the specifically fuel oil was the trigger and not the
- 10:53crude. And when the replacement cargoes
- 10:56came in, owners had a leverage because they simply weren't in a
- 11:00prompt ships. And you know what, this is a
- 11:02classic Aframex behavior because when demand lines up, rates
- 11:06jumps quickly, but just as fast they can soften if inquiry
- 11:11fades. So there are volatile because
- 11:13you know they rely on short all time sensitive cargoes.
- 11:16So what's fascinating is how Aframax is so as the pressure
- 11:21valve. So when the VLCC's are tight,
- 11:23some cargo split down, when the sewage Max are busy, Afromax get
- 11:27the overflow and when the product demand for fuel oil
- 11:30spikes, they become the first choice.
- 11:32So that's why even in today's fleet structure where bigger
- 11:36ships dominates and Afromax remains critical, they provide
- 11:39that flexibility. And I have seen this, you know,
- 11:43kind of a momentum before, one week, quite balanced list.
- 11:46The next week owners are getting, you know, around world
- 11:49scale 120 plus because of the scramble for prompt replacement.
- 11:53And that's the Afframex story. If I have to shorten it in a
- 11:57single line, it's always a roller coaster, always a
- 12:00regional, but never irrelevant. Well, Sandesh, there was indeed
- 12:04and very precise overview on the entire crude market.
- 12:07But now let's switch gears to the product markets.
- 12:10That is the clean side wherein the story is quite different
- 12:13because LR twos, they look quite strong wherein the LR ones, they
- 12:18are struggling to keep pace And Mrs. well, they are buzzing both
- 12:22east and West of Soez. So really, can you unpack this
- 12:25for us and especially focus on why are, you know, Mrs. so
- 12:29resilient right now? Well, Trisha, the Clean Tango
- 12:33market last week was, you know, kind of a tale of three very
- 12:36different ships. Let's take a example first about
- 12:39LR Twos. So LR twos were stand out last
- 12:42week because on the AJ Japan TC-1 route we saw rates pushed
- 12:47higher by nearly three points and they closed around 100 and
- 12:51150 world scale. And you know what that translate
- 12:54into the TC earnings also because we have seen that around
- 12:57$34,661.00 per day earning which was you know solid 3% jump week
- 13:03on week. So what's important here is the
- 13:05narrowing spread with the LR ones.
- 13:07LR twos now hold just you know world scale 2.5 premium over LR
- 13:12ones, which is a small considering their economies of
- 13:15scale. So the charters usually prefer a
- 13:17bigger ships when the spread is narrow and that's the exactly
- 13:20what we are seeing. So the LR twos are outperforming
- 13:23with the prompt probability and then the you know, tightening in
- 13:26the Tunnage list and in the Middle East Gulf and you know
- 13:31the healthy demand into the North Asia now coming back to LR
- 13:34ones. So LR ones by contrast are kind
- 13:37of a lagging on ATC5 benchmark that is AG Japan, their rates
- 13:42they aged up marginally to world scale 150 and TCS were stuck
- 13:47around 1691 per day. So the forward curve is in a
- 13:51slight backwardation and we don't expect LR one strain to
- 13:54the last into Q4 unless the demand improves.
- 13:57So LR1S are struggling to replace the LR two-story and
- 14:01that's been the case for the months now.
- 14:03And then the we have the third type of tanker that is Mr. So
- 14:06now Mr. This is where the action really is because in the East of
- 14:09Suez AG, East Africa, this particular momentum is
- 14:14significant because it you know jumped and reached to the world
- 14:18scale 220.71 and AJ Japan again rose almost five points to world
- 14:23scale 168.69. And with that it even leave the
- 14:27earnings to you know by 5% week on week.
- 14:31In the Northeast Asia, the market turned kind of a bullish
- 14:35because we have seen the early September stems had to be
- 14:38covered least towards or the tennis list was the short, so
- 14:42just five shifts for more than 10 cargoes and that tightness
- 14:46gave owners a huge leverage. And then in the Southeast Asia,
- 14:50Singapore, Australia, so these particular flows they were
- 14:54steady for last week and which helped to keep tonnage kind of a
- 14:59balance. Now coming back to the West of
- 15:01sewage market, you know it was even a busier because here we
- 15:05see UKCUS A/C it kind of a rebound to world scale 120 after
- 15:10a flurry of you know the transatlantic cargoes and with
- 15:14that they cleared the availability of some of the
- 15:17tonnage. So in the US Gulf activity was
- 15:21red hot because the roughly 40 Mrs. were expected to lift
- 15:25almost 2 million tons of product in a single week.
- 15:28We hope that some of them will be also translated into the next
- 15:33week. And then if that happens, then
- 15:35rates kind of a followed the suit because USG Continent ECO,
- 15:41you know, it averaged around $37,767 per day.
- 15:47You know, the increase was significant.
- 15:49It was around 32% increase in a single week.
- 15:53And then US Gulf Brazil, the TC was around 40,377 per day and
- 16:01then USD carries again rows by rows and closed at around
- 16:06$61,812 per day. So now put all of these together
- 16:11and you then get a bifurcated clean market because LR twos are
- 16:16you know consolidating their strength and LR ones are kind of
- 16:21a stagnant. And then the Mr. twos, they are
- 16:23kind of a buzzing everywhere because they were absorbing
- 16:26demand and providing flexibility.
- 16:29And if you, you know, ask me specifically, the near term
- 16:33outlook is clear because LR twos and Mrs. They kind of stay firm
- 16:40in the coming weeks while LR ones you know they may or wobble
- 16:45until something sparse fresh demand.
- 16:48Well, finally, Sandesh, let's touch on the LPG segment as
- 16:52well. So it looks like the east of
- 16:54Suez is kind of weak and on the other hand, the West of Suez is
- 16:58quite, but Indian demand is indeed buzzing.
- 17:02And if we were to talk about the freights, the freights, it
- 17:04actually softened from, you know, the Panama highs and the
- 17:07congestion's easing, but the volumes, they are still there.
- 17:11So, Sandesh, according to you, what's really driving in this
- 17:15VLGC sentiment right now? Well, you know Trisha, the LPG
- 17:19is such a unique market. You know why?
- 17:22Because it never behaves like crude oil products.
- 17:25So it has its own drivers and last week was, you know, a kind
- 17:30of a perfect example of East versus, you know, the West that
- 17:35divergent that we always discussed.
- 17:38So in the West activity was weaker because we have seen only
- 17:42three fixtures last week which was reported and there was even
- 17:46A1 rare requirement for mid-october lake and which you
- 17:50know is itself unusual at this point since September lake has
- 17:55isn't fully covered yet. So on the Houston Chiba route
- 17:59via you know Panama, the freight they held in the highs of east
- 18:04per ton down about dollar 10 per ton from the highest just a few
- 18:09weeks ago. So the easing of Panama Canal
- 18:12surcharges, you know, which had been up near $1,000,000 just a
- 18:18weeks earlier, really cooled sentiments.
- 18:21We have seen the congestion. It also, you know, receded
- 18:24significantly because rates are still more than double what we
- 18:28saw back in the mid-april or, you know, the second week of
- 18:31April. But the trend is kind of a
- 18:34softer because owners are cautious because, you know, the
- 18:38US Gulf fixing activity for the early October is lagging
- 18:42compared with, you know, the recent months moving back to the
- 18:45east of Suez Basin. So here the market was more
- 18:49active. Over 10 fixtures were done for
- 18:52the September AG loadings and mostly in the first two decades.
- 18:56Yet even with, you know that activity, Ras Tanura Chiba
- 19:01freight rates, they held a steady win, the low to mid
- 19:05Spartan and that tells you how the tonnage list is balanced.
- 19:10And with that we have seen the demand was, you know kind of
- 19:15strong enough to clear the cargoes but not so strong that
- 19:19owners could push rates higher. So India was the real driver in
- 19:22the LPG market because we have a state buyers came in with the
- 19:26multiple tenders and August imports are kind of already
- 19:31exceeded 2.05 million in tons. With the festive season is
- 19:35approaching, I think demand is expected to stay firm.
- 19:38On top of that Chinese PDH coming back online after the
- 19:42maintenance which will lift the propane consumption in the
- 19:45region. So if you have got to push and
- 19:48pull on paper, the market looks you know kind of a very bearish
- 19:52and turnage heavy in the West with Rajas close.
- 19:56But on the ground in the east, women from India and China is
- 19:59putting a floor under the rates. And we have seen this before
- 20:03because LPG can swing overnight one week, the number six week
- 20:07the next week, a surge of tenders or a plant, you know the
- 20:11restart flip sentiments. So if I had to summit up, the
- 20:15West looks heavy and the east looks stable and the real?
- 20:22Will be how demand plays out in the late September and early
- 20:25October. Well, Sandesh, I have to say it
- 20:28was indeed an incredibly insightful discussion with you.
- 20:32We've covered the big picture, the regional quirks, and the
- 20:35numbers that matters. And for our listeners, thank you
- 20:39so much for tuning in and listening to the Segal Sea Trade
- 20:41Podcast. Until next time, navigate safely
- 20:44and stay informed.